58min · about 7,000 wordsDownload Transcript
0:05Running in.
0:10Hello everyone. Hello. Hello. Hello.
0:16Hello. Welcome. Welcome to our continuation today. Can you all hear me? Let's do a sound check. Can you all hear me? If you can hear, please post a note in the chat. So the way I teach cles are probably non traditional. This is definitely a teaching CLE course but I like to make it interactive because the one hour course goes by quickly. If you are engaged and involved and because most of you are probably either military, JAG or military family members, that means you are definitely probably go getters a personality so you have no problems with involvement and leadership. Before we begin, I'd like to let you know who I am. I am Tracy Sanders Rucker.
1:13I'm pleased to present on behalf of LexBid Military Grooming Standards and workplace law. We will discuss religious accommodation, race and legal compliance with respect to military grooming standards and the that will include hair, that will include beards, that will include mustaches and tattoos. Before we move on to why we are here today, a little bit about myself to let you know why I am qualified to teach this CLE on behalf of LexFID. My military affiliation is as a military spouse. My husband is retired military officer and I am definitely in support of the United States Armed Forces and here is an example of the US Military armed forces.
2:07So before we go on, I'd like to ask if you all have military affiliation. Are you a part of a military family? Did you serve in jag? Are you a military officer? So what is your military affiliation? Did you serve military family or. You're like the most of us in America. You believe it is important to understand military culture and believe in thinking military members for your service. I'd like to remind you all that today this legal education seminar is for legal education purposes only. This is not to provide any type of legal or medical advice. If you need legal education for CLE credit, you're in the right place. If you are seeking legal or medical advice, please contact a professional in your area.
3:07The information provided today is subject to change. As you know, under the current federal administration, we are currently seeing a lot of changes with respect to the executive, legislative as well as to certain degree the judiciary. So please constantly check for regulatory citations, policy references as well as case law changes. The independent research required to conduct the CLE has been performed. I will provide cases, but in order to make sure the information is accurate, I'd like for you to also check for accuracy. Now, before we move on, I want you all to post as well the branches of military service. So if you Joined me yesterday. You know, I asked what are the five branches of the US Armed Forces? So if you all could post that in the chat. And then while you're doing that, let's see if we have US Armed Forces members on with us today. None so far. None so far. Here for CLE credit, Richard Sokoloff, Esquire. Brother joined at age 49 as a medical professional. So thank your brother for his service. I do know that there is a military, I think it's like naval boat that goes around on the sea to provide medical services as well as providing medicine to service members.
4:48So fantastic. Mary's husband has serve. So Mary, salute to a fellow military spouse here to learn more about military grooming and dress codes. Wonderful. Brother was in the military. Raymond has also provided information for us and Stephen has posted the military branches. Army, Navy, Air Force, Coast Guard. And Andy mentioned the Space Force. Lexid Jama, thank you so much. Military family. Her father was in the Navy. Now before we move on, in terms of our slides, previously the U.S. department of Defense as we know it, the Name of the U.S. department of Defense has changed. What is the current Name of the U.S. department of Defense under our current federal administration? So it is the. Yes, U.S. department of War. So if you see in the regs or in the news, the Department of War, it is now synonymous with the U.S.
6:02department of Defense. So why are we here today? We will discuss one legal foundation. We'll go over a glossary. We know that all constitutional power in terms of the Department of Defense, now known as Department of War is from our U.S. constitution. There is not any mention of grooming codes in our Constitution. That is per the individual branches. However, as you will see in our CLE today, these administrative changes may come from the top, from the Department of War as policy. And then the individual branches of the US Armed Forces will have discretion in terms of how they might carry out policy. When we speak of the military branch specific standards, we're speaking of Army, Navy, Marines, Air Force, Space Force. Now do know there is a difference between military law and civilian law. When I speak about the difference between military law and civilian law, do you all know what I mean by that? So if you're speaking about military law and JAG officers are Army, Navy, Air Force, military lawyers. That is military law, which is separate from civilian law.
7:29Today this presentation or CLE is based on U.S. civilian law, which is not military law. We will also discuss religious accommodation as well as PFB analysis. There's a significant controversy right now about PFB which is also known as razorbumps that some service members develop, primarily African, American, Latin or some men of Middle Eastern origin. If they shave, they might develop skin irritation. And so there's been an order handed down from the Department of War that if they cannot shave, then they might be eliminated from military service. That's one controversy right now in terms of grooming standards.
8:21Another controversy is within the Sikh community or from the Indian American community about religious accommodation if they can still serve and not be able to wear headpieces. There's also a case that I pulled from you that came from the U.S. department of Air Force where a military member of Jewish faith wore a yarmulke. Do you all know what I mean, in terms of a yarmulke? So it's the Jewish headpiece. And he wanted to be able to serve and in the Air Force and not have to wear the uniform, but wear his yarmulke. And so there's case law about that that we will discuss. And with respect to different headpieces or religious garb, we will go over what the case law states about that in terms of individual rights and religious rights and understanding the reconciliation with the need for uniformity in the U.S. armed forces with respect to civil, federal and state law, employment law. We're not going to focus so much on civil rights. This is more an issue of military and grooming standards. But do know that if you are advising clients or if you are serving as a military officer, you already know that even if an officer is serving in the military, they still have rights with respect to Title vii or title 6 or title 9 or, or if it's state laws such as the Crown act or any type of state individual rights. I pulled for you case law, as well as legal compliance policy, as well as practice tips.
10:09And you will leave with a whole lot of information, including a case that you can use by comparison. And we have hypothetical. So let's go over some glossary terms. PFB is a medical condition that is defined as chronic inflammatory skin condition caused by shaved hairs. And this is primarily affecting military service members that have shaved hair that curls back into the skin when they shave. So why is this relevant to the US Military? So if you see this photo, usually the US Military, regardless if it's Army, Navy, Air Force, space Force, and you know that we recently had a successful space mission and the goal is to work in uniformity and usually is clean shaven. So if you see this photo, regardless if it's black, white, Latin, Arabian, Asian, usually the policy is clean Shaven. Here lies the problem for some military officers. If they shave, the skin is going to produce papules, pustules or potential permanent scarring which disproportionately affects individuals with tightly curled hair. Now recently from the Department of War there was a memo sent down that regardless if the service members cannot shave, they might be eliminated from the US military.
11:52Why is this controversial? Because under the previous federal administration, these same officers primarily if we're talking about statistics, it would have affected the officers of color, received a medical accommodation. The medical accommodation would have stated yes, we understand the clean shaven policy, but because of this medical condition I can't shave, so I'm still allowed to serve. Under the current administration the medical accommodation might not hold. So we will see what happens but wanted to take time to explain. So if you are following military law or serving or representing military service members, that's what the military controversy is all about. There is also controversy about military transgender members if they can serve or being able to use military benefits to perform transgender assignment and by hormones. So there are a whole lot of issues around appearance and military grooming standards and appearance policies that have changed under the current, current federal administration. CBRN stands for chemical, biological and radiological and nuclear threat environment requiring airtight respiratory protective equipment that is incompatible with facial hair. So do you all see now the balance?
13:34So it's not in some instances all about race, it is about safety, performance, military operation. If a person's face is not clean shaven, the military policy is how can you be deployed if you can't pull the equipment all the way down on your face? Right. So that's the military operational concern. The soldiers on the other hand who cannot shave or saying I want to serve but if I shave then I'm going to have a medical issue. So we will see how this is possibly going to play out if it goes all the way to court. ASIMS is an administrative aeromedical service information management system. This electronic platform is used to record and track Air Force, Space Force medical profiles. So each branch has its own medical profiling system. And when a service member is reporting issues such as I can't shave or I'm told I have to lose the tattoos or lose the mustache or I previously could have gender assignment hormones. Whatever the issue might be, every branch has its own way of tracking medical profiling request or issues through a medical profile. Officer, for example chief of aerospace medicine at an installations military treatment facility serves as a senior reviewer of shaving profiles exceeding 30 days. And this example comes from DAF. So, for example, that's the Department of Air Force, but the Air Force might be different from the Marines. And a quick quiz from you all. The Marines is connected to which part of the US Military.
15:38So I just mentioned the Air Force. Correct. So CC just mentioned respiratory fit tests will not work with many beards. So you're understanding the conflict. It's an issue of military operation. But the appearance standard is about military operation. But the concern is if I comply, there is a medical condition. And then the social justice backdrop is disproportionately affecting a certain racial group. In this particular case, it would be people of color. So there are a lot of different issues that we certainly cannot sort out in 45 minutes. If you would like an additional CLE on this topic, because there's a whole lot to sort out, I'd be happy to continue with a part two. So, yes, Dennis, the Marines and the Navy are within the same branch.
16:41I believe the Navy would be the parent branch and the Marines is a subset of the Navy. Now, also daf, which is the Air Force. The Air Force also is a parent branch of what is the subset of the Air Force in terms of the five branches that we mentioned, do you all know what is another branch that is connected to the Air Force? Remember I mentioned a recent huge media blurb about a successful mission out in space? Yes, the Space Force. And why is this important? Because the grooming standards from the Air Force would possibly have a connection to the Space Force. So they would come down from the Air Force with a connection to the Space Force. And then Navy and Marines might be connected, but each branch is able to make its own specifics, but they must comply with the overall Department of War. Now, with respect to the medical evaluation board, that has both legal and medical implications. So this is the board that will evaluate whether a service member's medical condition constitutes a disability. So this will affect whether the service member can continue to serve, but it's also going to affect when the service member can deploy, as well as during separation from service, determine the amount of disability benefits as well as possible honorable or dishonorable discharge. And it could also affect retirement.
18:28So there is a lot at stake here. So, for example, the Marine Corps requires MEB endorsement before separation for grooming related conditions. And then there is re3p code. So this is Reenlistment Eligibility Code assigned to members separated from medical physical standards. So think about people who possibly served for four years. They might leave military life and decide, I want to use my GI Bill, go to college for four years, possibly work as a civilian and reenlist. Well, what if they separated due to medical or physical standards? It could heavily depend on how the military member departed.
19:15If it is in good standing, maybe that means the person can reenlist. But if it's not, then there's a lot at stake. So it's not just hair or beards or mustaches or whatever else may be related to grooming standard. It's a whole lot more at stake. Now with respect to, to religion, this is a very sensitive topic. And someone recently stated in 2026, religion is even more of a hot topic in America and abroad than race. What's going on right now in the military that you all think or you might possibly understand? If it's an opinion that religion is much more of a hot topic than race, what's going on right now in our nation in terms of the Department of War, are we at war or peace? And we're not getting into the politics because this is legal education, not political commentary, but are we at a time of war or peace? And you don't have to make any political comments. You can simply write the word war or peace.
20:34And the comment for most would probably, I'll type it war. And what part of the country, Middle East. Right. And that part of the country is heavily known for religion or religious issues? Because this is not a time of peace, because of the region in terms of conflict, because it is in large part based on religious conflict. There is a lot of tension around religion right now in terms of social, economic and political sectors in the United States and abroad. That's going to affect not only the military workplace, but the civilian workplace. So be on high alert right now. Religion is a hot legal topic.
21:29For example, RFRA stands for the Religious Freedom Restoration act, codified in 42 USC Section 2000 BB. Now, the problem with RFRA, it was overruled at the state level by the US Supreme Court. The US Supreme Court held it does not apply to the states because Congress overreached. The states have rights. It does apply to the federal government at the federal government level because the Department of War is a federal agency. RFRA does apply to military service members and it requires compelling governmental interests and least restrictive means for a substantial burden on religious exercise. What does that mean in terms of military members and asking for religious accommodation? With respect to military grooming standard, it means in most instances, military members should receive religious accommodation. However, most of the cases that I've read and the cases that I'm providing to you the courts are holding that because the U.S. armed forces is so central to national interests, protecting our homeland, protecting the welfare and security of our nation, and because the very tenets of military service are based on uniformity, based on common goals of protecting the national interests and keeping our nation safe, it is in the best interest of the military service to have uniformity.
23:14If you are in the Navy, it is expected for Navy service members to wear the same uniform, to wear the same headpiece, to wear the same workplace clothing, which would be the uniform, to wear the same footwear. So the courts are constantly holding that the army uniform, including the headpiece, should be the same. The Navy uniform, including the headpiece, should be the same. The Marines, Space Corps, Coast Guard, etc. Even if a person has religious rights with respect to military grooming standards and religious rights, the military need for uniformity is weighing out. Does that mean that a person does not have religious rights? No, it means there's a compelling government interest. Now, with respect to disparate impact, the legal doctrine under civil rights law, where a facially neutral policy disproportionately affects a protected class without sufficient business justification, there's still a slippery slope. For example, with the facial hair or mustaches or tattoos, or women being able to wear braids because they feel is culturally appropriate, there is some pushback. But for the most part, again, in the interest of uniformity, common goal, which is national interest. The Army Navy, Marines has a lot of discretion.
24:54DODI stands for Department of Defense Instruction. That's a regulatory document implementing DoD or Department of War policy across the military service. The key word here is instruction. Military is not the place for most people who do not want to follow instructions. Military is not the place for a person who is big on individuality. If you do not follow instructions or if you are big on individuality and you are in the field, you are given an instruction. Pull your headpiece down, go out and put on this uniform. If you're not able to follow instructions and do it quickly, the person next to you could end up dead, or you could end up dead, or the entire country or your military company could be blown to smithereens.
25:52So we as lawyers understand the need for following instructions in terms of the military stance, in terms of this is why it is important. But we also understand the importance of individual rights, civil rights and respecting human beings. It's always this constant battle of going back and forth in terms of individual rights, group rights, civil rights, military law, and of course, constitutional rights. Administrative separation is non punitive separation from Military service initiated by command for failure to meet service standards. And we're finishing up here because we have a lot to discussed. But this is laying a perfect foundation for going forward.
26:45Maradmin is an acronym for Marine Administrative Message. And this is the official Marine Corps Administrative communication used to implement an update policy. And finally pcm. So in the military, if you are a military family member, you probably know about tricare, which is the primary military health care system or plan. So in the military instead of primary care provider, it would be a primary care manager within a tricare health care system. And this is the military health care provider responsible for managing a service member's routine medical care. Now that we went through the important glossary terms, understand the legal foundation for grooming standards in terms of military service is always the Constitution of the United States. That's the statutory authority and it is derived from Article 1, Section 8, which is constitutional congressional power and authority. You know, we have the executive branch which is the US President. We have the legislative branch, which is Congress, and then the judicial branch which is the Supreme Court and federal courts.
28:10And then we have the Department of Defense or Department of War which is providing policy. And then we have the US Armed Forces and the individual branch and branches. And then we have commander discretion in terms of the individual branches of service. Now in terms of individual rights, because remember, we will not have branches of service without service members. So we have to protect and show gratitude towards service members who are risking their lives to protect our country. And that means they deserve individual protection from the Constitution, federal statute, state statute, as well as local statutes. So I provided some examples for you here to Review after our CLE today you will receive a copy of the PowerPoint from LexBID as well as case law and practical hypotheticals.
29:15So I provided for you various statutes that you can review after our time together today, there is a lot of focus on not only military members, but military families who often travel with military members. Because remember, the soldier is only as good as his support system. And when you think about first of all, we will back up and think about the support system. We know that when we think about Congressional foundation, it's going to be the First Amendment one through ten. First Amendment one through ten. A quick quiz for you all you know about the Bill of Rights. And then we have the First Amendment, Fifth Amendment, due process, fourth 14th Amendment and equal Protection Clause. But then we have these various administrative federal agencies.
30:16When you think about the U.S. armed forces and federal administrative agencies, could you all list some federal agencies that come to Mind, when you think about the US Military, what are some federal agencies that you think are involved with. Right. Not officially at war, not officially at peace. Why don't we say we're somewhere in between? And because we don't want to get into a political quagmire, we will focus on legal education. But what are some. So Veterans Administration, what are some other federal administrative agencies that are involved with military service? Military life, Veterans Administration, what are some other agencies?
31:14What about the Department of Labor?
31:18Any other federal agencies that might be involved? What about the Department of Defense? What agencies might be involved? The Federal Retirement System, possibly. There is an agency and it's called the Merit Systems Protection Board. So Charmaine, you are definitely on it. It's the Merit System
31:46Protection Board.
31:50That's another agency that is involved with military life, the Department of State. So when military members are serving abroad, that is the Department of State. And as you know, we have our Secretary of State that is heavily involved with military service members abroad. And what about the security agencies in terms of national security interests? Does any of those agencies come to mind? What about doj, Department of Justice? Any involvement in terms of Department of Justice? So these are some agencies we want to constantly think about when we think about military service. So we want to keep these agencies in mind. Now when we think about involvement, as you know the Supremacy Clause rules, and with the Supremacy Clause, we know that this is all federal jurisdiction for the most part. Some of the cases show conflict between state law and federal law.
33:02But whenever there is a conflict between state law and federal law, particularly with usera and military member service, this is all federal law. So just an overview in terms of jurisdiction, federal administrative agencies, and who is ruling here. Now, in terms of military service members and their families and grooming codes, not only are military members serving on base, many of them are also serving and going to school. So think about military members not only receiving an education for themselves, but they're receiving an education for their families and a lot of them are living dual lives.
33:54So thought I would mention that as well. In terms of grooming standards in the military, primarily the rules are coming from the Department of War and this is secretary level directives. So I am so happy that Steven is keeping us on task because he mentioned not exactly at war, but we have. So that's cece. So I'm going to go back to Stephen's comment, which I thought was very good. Steven La C. Esquire So we have to be very, very careful with the words that are used, especially in our current Political climate not officially at war. And then we have from cece some comments earlier about not exactly at war, but we have deployments and conflagration.
34:54Let's think of being cautious in terms of how we describe the conflict that I'm about to mention with respect to grooming standards. On August 20, 2025 from the Department of War there was a memorandum that established uniform grooming standard. Clean shaven face mandatory. This included beards, goatees prohibited unless specifically authorized. Mustaches permitted if neatly trimmed. Then a month later there was a memo it states provides branch specific implementing instructions, ascension standards and service compliance requirements. Special operations forces exception. Could someone please give us some guidance in terms of what exactly when you hear the term special operations forces? What comes to mind when you hear special operations forces? Because that was a part of the memo with respect to grooming standards via mission essential validated requests then under Secretary authority. And this is pulled right from the memo. USW pnr empowered to establish policy assign responsibility grant exceptions.
36:25Military departments required to submit implementation plans within 90 days. So now it's going down to the branch level. So it came from the Department of War. Clean shaven face mandatory. What has to go, beards, goatees unless specifically authorized. Mustaches permitted if neatly trimmed. And now it's going down to the branch level. Army, Navy, Air Force, etc. Each service publishes implementing directive no later than 30 days after submission. Now it's going down one level further. Unit commander, enforcement commander serve as a final approval authority for medical shaving profiles. Non compliant personnel.
37:14Flag is non deployable. Repeated non compliance may result in administrative separation. And remember in our glossary, remember here, administrative separation, it means non punitive separation from military service initiated by command for failure to meet service standards. So you see how this works together. So let's go back to our memo from 2025 and let's see what happens after the memo was sent around. So it went to the unit commander and then the US army military branch specific standards. So for example, the army had its own standards. There was governing regulations and then key 2025, 2026 action policy eliminating permanent waivers. Before there was a clean shaven policy waiver under the previous administration.
38:25Now under the army elimination of that all clean shaven. And then there's a profile duration period. Then there was a, there was a separation trigger after 12 month waiver period. Wow, this is incredibly interesting. All of this around grooming standard unique provision, nail hairstyle, I guess earring makeup Revision also issued September 2025. The Navy Marine Corps. Remember we mentioned Early Navy Marine Corps under one branch also issued key administrative action profile duration, separation trigger, unique provision and then Air Force remember Air Force and space force under one branch shaving policy memo December 15, 2025. The key 2025, 2026 action profile duration limit separation trigger provided and then the unique provision under the Air Force Space Force is that the commander has final ASIMS approval authority within seven days. Now let's go back up to our glossary and refresh our memory in terms of what does asims, what does that stand for? And this is within the Air Force Aeromedical Service Information Management System is an electronic platform used to record and track Air Force and Space Force medical profiles. So after this came down, meaning the new policy regarding clean shaven from the Department of War to the Air Force and Space Force medical profiles are going to be tracked. Record it for service members and then based on the new directives, go back here to the Air Force and Space Force commander has final ASIMS approval authority within seven days. And then specifically for the Space Force
40:46Space Force instruction vandenberg S F FB guidance December 16, 2025. All of this again is lifted from an official Department of War memo and it goes through the key 2025, 2026 action profile duration date, same separation trigger as Air Force Space Force, but for the Space Force there's a unique provision Guardian subject to Aug 20 US Space Force specific memo on grooming standards. So you all will have this PowerPoint to go back and do the research and review it if you're interested in this topic further. Now, in terms of disparate impact and where this might lead to additional lawsuits, is this clean shaven policy is going to have a civil rights disparate impact on males of color, particularly black males who cannot shave due to the medical condition pfb. So PFB is a chronic inflammatory skin condition caused by shaved hairs curling back into the skin, producing painful papules, pustules and potential permanent scarring. So the epidemiology and disparate impact. Epidemiology is the study of diseases or medical conditions. But here's what's interesting in terms of the epidemiology with pfb.
42:28There is a National Institute of Health study that is coining PFB as a disease, but the military is coining it as a condition. So we might see further controversy about is it a disease, Is it a condition? But for our purposes today, pfb affects approximately 45% of black male service members. Disproportionate prevalence in individuals with tightly Curled hair. Documented cases increase from 2000 to 2022. Severity is mild response to improve shaving techniques. Topical steroids Moderate may require temporary profiles. Severe may require laser treatment. But how many can afford laser treatment? And will the military pay for laser treatment?
43:30Legal significance is 2021 Military Medicine Study found shaving wavers Remember, shaving waivers were provided under the previous administration. So do you see here where under the current federal administration it's specifically stating that eliminating permanent waivers for any type of clean shaven policy exceptions. This is per the army, but each branch can make its own decision. But the army is stating eliminating waivers and soldiers held waivers. So that is to be decided. But a previous study stated shaving waivers correlated with slower career progression and promotion delays for service members of color, creating documented disparate impact. So here are the treatment options. We know the problem, let's focus on the solution. Right? So the treatment options are proper single blade shaving techniques Education because the grooming standards and there is a PBS documentary I will post this for you all. There is a PBS documentary about military grooming standards and in this PBS documentary it stated that the military grooming standards are based on European European beauty standards as well as European biology. So if the standards are based on European biology, then education should be diversified to help understand what type of shaving techniques, what type of topical creams or dermatology laser treatments might help service members and possibly avoid elimination from service. Now let's focus on some other issues. In addition to clean shaven policies, you might see issues regarding tattoos, you might see
45:49issues regarding transgender service members. You're probably going to hear issues in the military about women service because women have other needs that I don't want to make you all feel uncomfortable about. But there was an issue in the news about women serving when it's that sensitive time of the month. And I don't want to make anyone feel uncomfortable, but women have different needs. There are also issues about when women go through a different phase in life, such as menopause. Right. What happens when women are menopausal and they're retiring out and their hormones change? What all of this means is as biology changes and gender differences are apparent, then perhaps there should be diversification and education and this can be included in terms of a person's military career. Also included in terms of dermatologist expert opinion.
46:58So right now we are facing some challenges in the military as never seen before. And we're not getting into the politics, but there are challenges for many who are perceived to not fit a certain mode. So for example, PFB clean shave face policy and disparate impact is one issue that is in the news. Current grooming enforcement policy may create measurable, documented adverse disparate impact warranting legal scrutiny. So I always like to stop before we go through some of these solutions around this problem and ask you all if you have any comments concerns. Do you think grooming standards should consider different groups, not only men, but like us, like I mentioned, men of color have different concerns than maybe Euro men in terms of shaving.
48:09But what about women? Do you think grooming standards for women should be considered with respect to policies and memos? As lawyers do we help create legislation and policy in terms of military standards to consider differences? So these are some things to think about, women, men, people of color in terms of differences. And of course you know, there are all these different issues that we cannot solve now. But one way we do solve these problems is through legal education. So medical waiver process There's a three gate system where a commander holds military authority. It starts with the primary care manager PCM recommendation. The PCM can evaluate the service member, for example for pfb. And PFB is not only black males. It could be a multicultural male, it could be a white male. Anyone can have pfb. It's just that it seems to appear more in people with melanated skin or with curled hair. And they can apply a clinical treatment algorithm and a branch equivalent and go through the documentation and a treatment plan. And then the profile officer review can profile and provide the number of days and do the check ins to make sure everything is documented. And then there's a commander final approval authority to make sure the ASIMS is within the seven days and then may request evaluation and then commander approval.
49:52And then there are also administrative constraints to consider. No SANGER profile may exceed six months. Approved profile must include individualized treatment plan. Non compliant members flagged as non deployable. Now good news. After Ames v. Ohio we know we do not have racial preferences. Ames v. Ohio is going to apply to the military as well. Ames v. Ohio State Just because a person is majority race, white or male, white males can sue or have the same level of protection as a minority person or a person that is claiming minority status. So this is not to provide any type of preference or affirmative action. It is stating if a person has a medical condition, they should go through the medical waiver process.
50:47If the medical waiver process is being eliminated, as it is being eliminated in the army, the next best solution is documentation and appeals. What a military service member should also do is medical research. This is medical just as much as it is legal. For example, is it a medical condition? Is it a disease? Because if it is a disease it's going to affect outsource out processing. How did you leave? Why did you leave? How much disability are you entitled to? What are your retirement benefits? So if it's not a waiver and you have to be separated, is it a condition of separation or did you separate per a disease?
51:37And now you are appealing so there's always a solution to everything. I am not in favor of always fighting. I think sometimes instead of jumping to fight, perhaps it's a better move to research and read and find a settlement. So I would say if a person is facing issues regarding elimination and waiver, there is a way to work around an exit without fighting. Just find a way to appeal and possibly exit and move on to civilian life. Understanding your rights so religious accommodations is another issue as we wrap up so reverted to pre2010 standards legal tension with RFRA and first amendment protection. So there are a lot of religious accommodation issues, particularly around people from When I say Indian we have to be politically correct.
52:40So I again I really like Steven's comment and cece's comment in chat with being careful with wording right. Are we at war? Are we at peace? If we are at war, how is it stated? So same concept with religion. When we speak to Indian conflict, understanding religious accommodations requests Indian can have several connotations. When we speak about Indian Americans, we are not speaking about Native Americans who are also enlisted and they may have their own issues with religious accommodations. Those were primarily around the ability to smoke peyote, but we're not focusing on that today. Today we're speaking about Indian Americans from the country India and concerns about being able to wear religious head guards. A lot of those cases were filed around First Amendment protections and rfra. So if you see cases around RFRA you might be confused because there are cases that are stating that RFRA is not the law of the land anymore because it was overturned by the Supreme Court.
53:59It was overturned by the Supreme Court meaning it does not apply to the state, but it still applies to the federal government. So it does still protect federal government employees such as Department of War. There's still religious accommodation requests reviewed on a case by Case Spaces. Some long term waivers for beers issued based on sincerely held religious beliefs. So we don't want to paint a broad brush. The Department of Air Force DAF 5 year waivers issued from 2020 accommodation more broadly available across roles and then for example the current policy post2025 under the current Federal Administration directive reverted to pre2010 standards. Religious waivers for facial hair generally not authorized because some religions require that men cannot shave. So it's not always based on biologics or race or individuals that can't shave because if they do it's a medical condition.
55:07It could be religious reasons. So the Religious Liberty and Military Service 09-01-2020 documentation of sincerely sincerity required and must support good faith determination by approving authority approvals limited to non deployable roles with low CBRN firefighting risk Religious shaving waivers explicitly excluded from the 12 month medical waiver separation mandate. I would strongly suggest checking in with the Department of War asking about the Directives related to DoDI 1300.17 Religious Liberty and Military Service 9-1-2020 specifically asking if the Department of War is still using the pre2010 standards that could have changed. This is only legal education to provide guidance.
56:10Now in terms of rfra, RFRA requires compelling interest and least restrictive means. However, there is a case called Goldman v. Weinberger where the Court deferred to military judgment on uniform standards and practitioners must evaluate sincerity and in this case the Air Force won because the court held that it is more important to have not more important in terms of not understanding or acknowledging religious rights but for national security interests to have uniformity in terms of the uniform as we wrap up, you will have here a case study for your review about grooming standards and religious accommodation. You can review after our time today I provided for you Bradley v. Pizzico. It's going to be a comparative analysis of desperate impact in civilian world comparing it to military grooming standards and I've also provided for you practice tips in terms of military grooming standards quickly initial assessment, accommodation strategy, procedural audit, administrative remedies, separation defense and imposed separation remedies.
57:38Primarily appeals if possible and always documentation for your own purposes and to make sure the information is correct. Please use the appendix to source the information and with that I am attorney Tracy Sanders Rucker. It has been my pleasure to present to you today and the CLE completion code is 97 you as in uniform 62. 97 you as in uniform 62 thank you all and I hope to present on behalf of LEXFIT again in the future.
58:26It.
58:57The lexeded completion code is 97U as in uniform 62.
1:01:03One last time the LexVid completion code is 97U62. Thank you all and have a wonderful day.
1:01:25It.
1:02:01Goodbye everyone.