Dennis S.IL
interesting point that attorney client duty of confidentiality exists as long as the attorney possesses the info, even beyond the death of the client.
56min · about 9,600 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello everyone, and welcome to today's presentation on relationships are complicated for the attorney client relationship, that is, other relationships are complicated too. But we are just going to focus on attorney and client relationship here today. First, my name is Carrie Shan. I'm a conflicts and ethics attorney with Scopolitas, Garvin, Light Hansen and Feary in Indianapolis, Indiana. So I do practice ethics and internal ethics and compliance for law firms and attorneys all day, every day. In addition to practicing attorney, I'm also a professor. I work as an adjunct professor at The Robert H. McKinney School of Law in Indianapolis, Indiana. And I've also taught courses at the Kelly School of Business as part of the IU Kelly School and at the Lacy School of Business at Butler University. And those courses I teach there are business ethics. So again, ethics has kind of been my forte, what I do and practice regularly.
1:01So let's get started here today on relationships, that attorney client relationship which is paramount. If you think about it, everything we do as attorneys revolves around the attorney client relationship. We would not have a book of business, we would not have a job if we didn't have clients. And so clients are paramount to our profession. Now, how many of you and like, I can't see your hands, but just think to yourself, have ever had a client you just do not like or do not even want to talk to? I know I have. When I was practicing law as a litigator, there were several of my clients who would call, they would yell at me, then they would threaten to fire me if I didn't do what they say. And then half the time they would hang up the phone and call back again.
1:53And so depending on your clientele, depending on what area of law you're in may depend on what you have to deal with from the client perspective. But as for ethics, there are a few ethical considerations when you are dealing with clients that you need to keep in mind. And we're going to go over some of those here today. And it's not just things like be nice to your clients or pretend to listen. We should actively listen, not just pretend. But there are also things too that we need to consider when it really does come to clients. And so let's talk about some of those rules today. Now, before we get to the main rules, though, I do want to remind everyone that we do have a sense of professionalism. Those clients that we find unruly, that we really don't like to handle, that we find very difficult to handle, the ones that call yell at us and hang up or Just that really make our blood boil.
2:50How many of you have had some of those calls today? And what do you want to do? You want to lash back out? You want to respond in kind? Sometimes you want to set the record straight that the boss or you're in charge or be just as much of an offensive personality as the client is to you. Now, the thing we have to remember, too, remember those rules of professional conduct that I talked about? Well, we also had something called our oath as an attorney. And here in Indiana, our attorney oath is stated in Rule 22 of our, you know, rules of conduct. And in the middle of our oath, this is the oath that we took here in Indiana as attorneys, we raised our right hand. You will see there in the yellow font that it says, I will abstain from offensive personality. Now, this is very interesting because when I ask attorneys if they remember raising their right hand, taking the oath of everything we swore to uphold, becoming attorneys, no one ever remembers that they swore to abstain from offensive personality. And then if you read the comments and you read the rest of the rules, because they all should be read in conjunction with each other, it says that this applies personally and professionally 24 hours a day, seven days a week. So then I asked the question, how many of you have abstained from offensive personality in your personal and professional lives, not just dealing with the attorney client relationship, but also dealing with every relationship and every circumstance in your life? Some people raise their hand,
4:28and then I ask if I should poll their significant others and spouses, and then we see hands go down. So just remember that we do have this sense of professionalism that not only applies to the attorney client relationship, which we're talking about here today, but also applies across the board. And Indiana is not the only one with this type of rule in really comes in in a lot of jurisdictions in their preambles and in their oath. South Carolina has one. North Carolina, if you go back and look at your jurisdiction, there is going to be something in there regarding professionalism, your personality abstaining from a fist of personality, acting with professionalism. These are all those buzzwords or code words that we need to be civil with each other, that we need to be professional. And I offer professional service to our colleagues, to our clients, and to third parties, personally and professionally.
5:27Because we as lawyers play that vital in society. We're supposed to be the gatekeepers of justice. We're preserving a civilized society, as some people say, in some jurisdictions. So we really need to look at our conduct. And it all starts with that attorney client relationship. So when we look at the attorney client relationship, we need to look at kind of who's the boss? Do we take directions from the client? Does the client take directions from us? How much do we need to communicate with the client? What can we tell outside parties? What do we need to keep confidential? And how do we determine that type of information? And then also too, how do we collect fees?
6:08And can we fire clients? And the answer to that last question, yes, you fire clients. So we'll see how to do that ethically and professionally. And then two, just think of all the clients you may want to fire, you may want to get off this call and go fire once we're done. But again, we need to think about these things in a reasonable manner. But let's answer that first question. Who is the boss? Well, the golden rules of the law are the client is the boss. That's rule number one. And rule number two is never forget rule number one, the client is the boss. How many of you thought going to law school that you would be graduate and then not even be your own boss, that your clients are your boss? It is sometimes a hard pill to swallow or a realization because 90% of the time your clients have not been to law school.
7:02Now my clients have been to law school, but I'm an internal ethics counsel. But most of our clients have not been to law school. So they don't know the law, they don't know always the legalese or how to do stuff they think they do because they use that great Google function or ChatGPT or something, told them something, but they didn't go to law school. So you would think that we were more the boss on kind of telling them what to do within the bounds of the law, telling them what to do within their case or how to move forward. But that is not in reality how it works. We are actually just advisors.
7:38Under Rule 1.2, the Rules of Professional conduct, the client controls the objectives to the representation. So they tell you what they want the ultimate outcome to be. Your this is what they're wanting, this is what their hopes are of getting. And then you tell them or consult with them, be that advisor on how to pursue that objective. So they tell you, this is my end goal, is that client to win this case, to not go to jail, to be whatever it is. And then you say, okay, let's look at the facts, the evidence, how do we get to this objective or somewhere near it. Now also in that advising consulting role, you really have to temper their expectations. I will say as A plaintiff's attorney.
8:26When I was practicing plaintiff's law, there was clients that would come in and in their mind, their case was worth a million dollars. They'd already bought that boat in their mind, or bought that, you know, $20,000 vacation package and that, you know, they were going to get this windfall. And when did they want the windfall? In a month, two months, next week, you know, before you even got the complaint on file. And so part of that consulting with the client to reach their objectives, whether their objectives are reasonable or unreasonable, is tempering down their expectations and guiding them along the way, saying, okay, if we want to get to Z, then we need to go through ABCD and all these, and along the way communicating if that objective should change, be altered, or if it's even going to be a reality or a possibility. Because the last thing you want to do is have a client with unreasonable expectations, unreasonable objectives, and then you foster that, and then at the end, they're going to be so upset with you, they may even file a grievance. So, yes, the client does control those objectives, but you need to consult with them and control the means of how to get to those objectives.
9:43The means need to be legal, they need to be lawful, and they need to be ethical. Now, some things other to think about here, too, in pursuing those objectives, any point along the way, you could recommend something. Say you want to hire an expert, and you say, this expert will help us get to that objective. If the client says no, then the answer is no, no. They still get a kind of like a veto power if you get to move forward on a path to get to that objective or have to detour off of it. And they say, I don't want you to hire that $10,000 expert. You don't get to hire the $10,000 expert. You have to go find a cheaper one or a different one.
10:26Now, you can obviously consult with them, try to convince them otherwise, but in the end, it's the client's decision. This is the same thing with any settlement offer that comes in. You can counsel them that this is the best they're ever going to get. The client could still say no. And you can't override that same thing with a plea agreement or something. When it comes to the criminal defense role, if they don't want to accept the plea, if they don't want to do those things, then the answer is no. They get to choose those objectives. You can tell them how to get there, what's good and bad, advise and consult.
11:02But in the end, they get that yes or no veto power. So we really need to think about these things when we are talking with our clients. And part of, you know, working with a client and having that good attorney client relationship and for the client listening to you and following your advice is having good communication. And rule of Professional Conduct 1.4 is our communication rule. We need to be prompt in our communications to our client. We need to give them enough information for them to participate intelligently with us so that we can, they can choose yes or no in the means to pursue those objectives. And two, we also need to tailor our communications down to the sophistication of our clients. So when we think about this, if you have a client who's educated, maybe has a graduate degree or master's degree, then how you talk to them and how you break step down may be different than someone who does not have those degrees or those things. Maybe your client is someone who's never been involved in the legal System, has an 8th grade education, is an older person, and they just don't understand certain terms. So you wouldn't go to them and say, I'm filing a motion for summary judgment.
12:24They are not going to know what that means. You would have to say, you know, we need to request the court. Xyz, you've got to get out of using the big legal terms, the big phraseology, those different things when you are tailoring communications down to fit sophistication of clients. Now obviously, if you deal more in the corporate world or deal with corporate clients more often, CEOs, general counsels, in house counsels, your communications can be more sophisticated. And that is because they're used to the terms, they know what you're talking about and they have a higher level of understanding of the legal process. Maybe they have you on retainer, maybe they work with outside counsel all the time. And so that's going to be a little different. In an easier conversation, you could maybe go to them and say, hey, we need to file a motion to get this suppressed and they're going to know what those words mean. You go to someone else who's not sophisticated, they're not going to know what those words mean.
13:21So not only are we the advisors, like identifying how to get to those objectives of the client, we also have to think and taper down our communications for the sophistication of our clients so they can be reasonably included and give their opinions and tell us what objectives that they want to pursue forward. And so this is kind of a hard for attorneys, you May not think it is, but think of all the attorneys you know. Are all the attorneys you know great communicators? Are they ones that are the life of the party? Or do you have attorneys out there and you can think of some maybe you know too, who are more like recluses.
14:00They like to do their paperwork, write their contracts, do their IP key work, do whatever it is that they do best, maybe tax lawyer too. Sit in their office, do the work, get paid, not talk to anyone, and go home. Now, how are they going to communicate with client and be good communicators? And it doesn't matter what area of law you're in or what practice, or you know, what your personality is. These rules apply to every single lawyer. So whether you're that big boisterous litigation lawyer, or the one who just wants to be left alone, do the paperwork, and never really see clients, you still have to communicate. So understanding how to do it in the best way and be most effective at it is going to be paramount to any practice. Another thing to remember too, to help foster this communication, clients are the only people who really want to talk to attorneys. Now think about that for a second.
14:53Clients are the only people who want to talk to attorneys. Now, your family probably does too, and your loved ones and friends. But otherwise, unless they need us, people just don't seek out attorneys. Attorneys, we're not the life of the party all the time. We're the butt end of a lot of jokes if you really think about it. But your clients want to talk to you, so you should want to talk to them or at least make the efforts under the rules to talk to them. Some best practices to kind of implore in your practice, maybe return client calls or messages within 24 hours or at a minimum, acknowledge the call. Say, for instance, you're in trial or on vacation, you get in an email, you get in a voicemail from a client. Now you don't have to respond in substance, but you can just say to them, or shoot an email back or even have your assistant email them back and say, we've received your phone call. Attorney so and so will get back to you at X date, by X date in time. This gives the client an expectation.
16:00Now they know you've acknowledged it, they're not being ignored, and they have a time of reference from when they're going to hear from you. So you kind of put them at bay, gave them that, hey, we care about your case. I know I need to call you back. I'm just otherwise engaged now on the flip side of this, you need to return the call by that X date and time you gave them. Otherwise you're going to have a whole nother problem with the client. But you can really favor and, you know, control this attorney relationship with communications like that. And it helps because clients just want to be heard. They think their case is the most important.
16:38It's the center of their universe. They don't really understand that we may have hundreds of cases going on at the same time, but we still have to make them believe and think that theirs is the most important case on our desk, even if it's not at the time. And so sending back that communication, returning calls within 24 hours or at least acknowledging the call and giving them a time frame can go do wonders for the attorney client relationship. Also too, another practice, I know this is done a lot in kind of the insurance defense world. Insurance companies, they usually have procedures or policies where their outside attorneys have to give them status updates, whether it be 30 days, 60 days, every 90 days, whatever it may be.
17:23So you can employ that too, even if your client does not have that procedure mandate in place. Maybe every 30 days or 60 days, have your assistant send them a letter with the status of their case. That's a communication. So then you're going to keep a constant communication to where if they ever claim a disciplinary complaint against you for failure to communicate, you can pull those letters out and say, no, I communicate every 30, 60, 90 days with interim calls. This stuff arise and you have a defense, some type of communication, we need to show that we're actively, you know, working with the client and assisting in the case. You can also, if you have a more sophisticated client, maybe send them drafts of your significant documents before you file them, send them out there, do those things. And a lot of times corporate attorneys, if you're working with a lot of corporations and that they enjoy more than hands on, they can see your work product, they can see what you're doing, and they can really help in that realm as well.
18:25Another thing we have to worry about when it comes to client training client relationship is confidentiality. Rule 1.66 tells us that a lawyer shall not reveal client information unless the client gives informed consent or the disclosure is impliedly authorized. So informed consent means consent from the client. The client holds the key to the information. Without the client's consent, we cannot disclose anything confidential about the client. Now you may think that the attorney, excuse me, that confidentiality only includes stuff protected by the attorney client privilege, the attorney client privilege are those communications directly between the attorney and the client. But you would be wrong on that. And we will see here in the next slide or show a chart that will show you why you are wrong. And that confidentiality is way broader than the attorney client privilege. If we do not have that client's consent though, then we cannot disclose anything unless impliedly authorized. Meaning this could be by court order or, you know, it's necessary to, you know, litigate the case or respond to a motion, something like that. But we're also constantly communicating with the client to ensure that they know what's going on.
19:39And here is that graph. I promise that attorney client privilege is very small. The communications directly between the attorney and the client without any presence of outside third parties, with limited exceptions to that confidentiality is everything around the attorney client privilege. So everything in red, including the attorney client privilege there in blue. Confidentiality can include the name of the client, anything you learn within the course and scope of your representation of the client, anything at all, witness statements, outside investigations, anything at all you learn in representing that client is protected by confidentiality. And this is huge.
20:21A lot of people forget this, especially attorneys, because what do they do? They go disclose, I'm representing so and so that name of your client is confidential. Then I always get the rebut or the person coming back to me and saying, but it's part of the public record. It's on the docket that I represent them, so I can go talk about it. The answer to that is no. The comments to rule 1.6 and a lot of literature and ABA formal opinions say that there is no exception to confidentiality for publicly available information. This means just because you filed appearance and that everyone that goes onto the docket or looks up that case can see that you're the attorney of record, does not give you the right to talk about that case or even disclose the client's name to outside third parties without the client's consent confirmed in writing.
21:19This is a hard rule to swallow for a lot of practitioners, because if you think about it, what do you want to do if you get a big client or a big win? Because wins, yeah, they're public records or verdicts, different things. But you cannot talk about it unless you get client consent confirmed in writing. So those wins that you want to post on your social media page, those wins that you want to post on your LinkedIn account or your website's page, or give a client, you know, representation of a client list to like someone else to try to get their business, you cannot use any client information on any of those sources without getting each and every client's consent confirmed in writing. So for example, if I win a big case for Google and I want to post about it on my webpage, I have to get Google's consent to post about it. Even though the win may be public record on the docket. If I want to tell people that I represent, you know, Google and Yahoo and all these big name companies, then I have to get their consent to use their names on my website. As clients of mine. I cannot just do it sometimes the all the time the client's name is confidential and anything touching the representation is confidential without the client's consent confirmed in writing. Way broader than that attorney client privilege and we have to preserve our confidences. Aba formal opinion 4, 80 there in the middle of your screen really talks about, you know, social media and the mishaps that can happen on social media
22:57regarding this confidentiality and breach of that attorney client privilege and confidentiality in General under Rule 1.6. I highly recommend you take a look at that. If you have a very high social media presence or you like to use social media a lot in your practice, that's some opinion you would probably want to read. Now there are some exceptions under Rule 1.6B that we can disclose confidences without our client's consent. None of these include if we want to post it on social media. None of them include using it in an AI artificial intelligence program. None of it includes talking to other people at a cocktail party about what work we're working on or who we're representing.
23:42None of those are exceptions to confidentiality as we see here. The only exceptions are that we may disclose and it's discretionary to prevent substantial injury, financial or physical, and we shall not assist in a client's fraud, meaning we have to disclose if a client is using our services to commit a crime or to commit fraud. So if we know, say we represent someone and they're asking us all these questions like how do you launder money? Can you put this money in your hold it in your trust account? If we know they're using our services to commit fraud or to commit to commit a crime, then we have to cease representation.
24:25It's a shall standard, not a may standard. Just keep the old adage, you don't want to be sitting next to your client in the jail sale. You want to be on the outside of the bars helping them get out of jail. So if you're assisting them in their illegal conduct and activity, then you're going to be Sitting beside them. We don't want to be sitting beside them. We want to be on the opposite side of the table, on the opposite side of the bar, jail sale cells. So keep that in mind. Other exceptions are that we can use confidential information only to the point necessary to defend ourselves if they find trial malpractice against us. So we can mount that defense, but we can only use what is necessary to mount a defense in any formal malpractice claim against us, and that we can also disclose it by court order if the parameters are met and we're not challenging it in some way. Those are the exceptions.
25:21Nothing else applies within the exceptions. And that is a lot of times people think, well, it's just this or it's, you know, innocent. But that's still a breach. Now you may think, well, I've never done any of that. Why would I ever, you know, post on social media, tell people at a cocktail party? So my next scenario to you is this. You come home from work, you sit down at the dinner table with your spouse, your significant other, your family, your friends, whoever you're sitting down with that evening. Maybe it's just, you know, if you're by yourself, that's fine too. But you're sitting down with someone this evening and you're talking about it, and they ask you the question, what did you work on today? Who are you representing?
26:04You can't answer those questions. That's confidential information. Your spouse, significant other, friends, family, whoever it is, if they are not part of your law firm and under the attorney client privilege with you, then you cannot disclose to them who you represent or what you're doing on cases. Now that's the mind blowing thing to a lot of people because what do we want to do to have that human connection when we come home? We want to talk about our days. We want to share with our spouses and significant others. We want to tell them our frustrations, our highs, our lows. And sometimes we can't as lawyers. And that is too, why this is an isolating profession or can be a very isolating profession.
26:49And we just, just have to understand that going into it now, if you want to talk about your cases, talk about them with colleagues or other people. But we have to remember that confidentiality and this confidentiality is the hallmark of our profession. And sometimes you may be faced with a situation in this attorney client relationship keeping those confidences, that is terrible for you. I mean, absolutely terrible in this case. The buried bodies is what I call it and what textbooks and law schools call it too. This is a case studied still in law schools. We have a client, Robert Francis Garo attacked four campers in July of 1973, stabbing Philip DeBlinsky to death while the other three escaped and summoned help. After a massive manhunt, he was captured. Immediately after his capture, Garrow requested Frank Armani, a general practice attorney in Syracuse, New York represent him. And Mr. Armani had represented in previous other minor matters, criminal matters that he'd had pending.
28:00And with him too. The court also. The court named Armani, but also named Francis Blage as a local council to assist as well. So now Mr. Garo has two attorneys, Armani and Blade. During the preparation, Garrow admitted to the attorneys that he had murdered Dublinski. But he also admitted to other crimes. Now these attorneys are learning this within the attorney client relationship. Remember, confidentiality is huge. So he, their client admitted to murdering two females, 16 year old and 20 year old. He described the locations of where these females were buried, the description of it and Blade curiosity.
28:43He went out to this location to see if his client was telling the truth. Didn't touch, didn't disturb the burial sites, didn't move anything, didn't do anything, but verified that the women were there and took photos. He didn't touch anything, didn't disrupt the grave sites, didn't tamper with evidence. His attorney just wanted to verify the client's information. So Armani and Valage told no one. A Giro's confession. If we think about Rule 1.6B to stop imminent threat of bodily harm or financial injury, it's over. There's no imminent threat. He's already killed them. No exceptions apply under Rule 1 6B.
29:24These two attorneys cannot release this information. They cannot tell anyone. And they do know too. In the news at this time, the families of these two young victims, these two girls were still looking for the bodies. They were still there looking for them. And it was actually after, while Garo was testifying, that he mentioned this and that his attorneys knew where the bodies were located. But he had never gave his attorneys permission to disclose where they're located. So the attorneys still could not disclose. They were crucified in the media for this. The families of these two girls came after them.
30:09Widespread public outrage, including vandalism, death threats. Were forced to relocate their families. To protect their safety, they insisted. These attorneys insisted that their duties under Rule 1.6 bound them. Without their client's consent, they could not disclose the location of the bodies and the client would not consent. Consent. If he consented, then that gave the police More evidence to tie two more murders on him. So there was no consent. They never ever disclosed they were charged. They even tried to get at them with charges for failing to report a dead body, failing to provide decent burial.
30:47Charges were later dismissed by the judges. My courts praising these two attorneys for holding up their ethical obligations as lawyers. Lawyers. But to hold up these ethical obligations, they had to relocate their families. They eventually stopped practicing law. They couldn't, you know, get a job. They couldn't, you know, practice because they were, you know, being attacked by public all the time. But this requirement of the attorney client privilege is so embodied and so ingrained and so paramount to what we do that they found that it to be the utmost importance. And it is. They could have lost their license if they would have told.
31:27Now you could sit there all day and say, it's worth losing your license. I'll fight that fact. You know, I'll do all these things and that's your choice to make. But this 1.6, in our confidentiality with our clients, especially in criminal proceedings like this, when you do criminal defense, you need to take very, very seriously. The committee of Professional ethics also got a complaint with them. Obviously it was dismissed. You know, and they even said this requirement of attorney client and confidentiality is so embodied in that, you know, we cannot reveal stuff unless we are granted that right in one of our exceptions.
32:07How many of you, and you can just think to yourself, again, I can't see your hands or anything, could have held out and kept that with the public coming at you being the backlash, having criminal charges brought against you, having to fight those and get them dismissed, having disciplinary complaints come against you, having to fight those and get them dismissed all the time. Standing by Rule 1.6. That's it. Just Rule 1.6. Knowing you had to relocate your family for death threats, knowing you couldn't practice law right now in that jurisdiction because of the backlash you were receiving, you basically lost your license, even though you didn't officially lose it just because, you know, your whole life was overturned. That is how important Rule 1.6 is.
32:53And that's why that case is still studied in law schools to really impress upon students and incoming lawyers that this is important, that social media doesn't override it, that our own self interest can't override will. 1.66 that is the hallmark of this attorney client relationship and that we need to take it very seriously when we practice law, and that the only person who can waive confidentiality affirmatively is the client without informed consent. Confirmed in writing. So if their client would have waived it, they could have disclosed, but their client didn't waive it. Now, there are ways that the attorney can inadvertently waive the attorney client privilege, but if you inadvertently waive it, you could be subject to discipline or malpractice. So this is not something you want to do. You really need that client consent confirmed in writing. But there are things such as inadvertent disclosures.
33:47Inadvertent disclosures, again, are things that happen when we don't intend it to. And we really could be sued for malpractice or for breach of confidentiality or even a disciplinary complaint for doing any of those things and waiving the privilege. Judge, when it's really the client's province to waive it, we do not get to choose. We can do it inadvertently, but we're going to be subject to discipline. Some of those inadvertent disclosures where it can happen, speaking in a public place. Say, for instance, you're working in a coffee shop or public place doctor's office, you take a phone call, you have a conversation where someone else can hear all the details about your client's case, your client's name.
34:28You just inadvertently weighed the attorney client privilege and confidentiality. And so you've got to really have conversations with your clients in spaces which are private, which are contained, and which are, you know, useful in that context. You also have to watch too. If you're at a seminar somewhere and you have your laptop up working on client matters, can someone see your screen? Can the person sitting behind you at that coffee shop, at that conference on the airplane, can they see what you're working on? And if they can, that's a potential inadvertent breach too. So you've got to be very careful with who can see your materials, who could overhear your conversations when you're in public and guard against those scenarios. Also, I would caution too, using public WI fi in places like coffee shops and different areas like that, because public WI fi usually gives you that warning that other people on this network may be able to see your content. That's a potential breach.
35:25So you say, well, what do I use? Well, most cell phones nowadays have hot hotspots on them. Log into your own personal hotspot on your phone, password protected, only you can use it. Really taking those reasonable measures to protect confidentiality. And these are easy steps we can take. They're not hard to take. They're easy steps. And so looking at those different areas too, if you do represent or talk to Anyone in jail, if you represent a defendant, remember those jailhouse conversations by telephone are not, not confidential. They are usually recorded. So you would want to advise your client if they're going to call, like either spouse, parents, kids, someone else, friend, that those jailhouse conversations are recorded and are not confidential. If you want to talk to your client in jail, obviously, please go visit them, but keep that in mind too.
36:16And make sure you advise your client regarding the same inviting other people to a meeting that if you are talking with your client, client, just you and the client, the attorney client privilege attaches if there are other third parties present. The attorney client privilege doesn't attach and confidentiality may not attach either, unless the third parties that are present are necessary to conduct the representation. So like a legal assistant, a paralegal, another attorney, or if you have someone with dementia, Alzheimer's, someone to assist you in talking with your clients, client, the third parties that are present have to be essential to the representation. And you have to prove that they're essential to providing that legal advice and the representation. If you cannot prove those things, then you've waved and breached confidentiality. And now that third person that was present can be called as a witness to testify to everything that was said in that conversation. So you've got to be careful with inviting third parties to meetings. This happens a lot because again, family is not always essential.
37:23Having moral support is not essential to the representation normally, unless you can make that argument. So if someone just says, well, I drove him here, so I was just going to sit in and listen. No, sit in the waiting room. I'll talk to the client. Well, I'm their spouse. I want to sit in, sit in the waiting room. I'll talk to the client. If both spouses are not your client, we have to really look at who's essential to the representation. And if they're not essential, then we need them to sit outside. Now, that's not always an easy conversation to have, but it's good to tell them, you need to sit outside.
37:58I need to talk to them separately or by themselves. So inviting others to that meeting, then too, if you tell these people to sit outside or your client goes and shares all the material and all the conversations you have with them, your clients in essence, inadvertently waiving the privilege as well. So if they go share with a neighbor, they go home and share with friends about their conversation. Now, those people can be testified or called to testify to what your client told them. So we also need to counsel our clients to not talk about anything confidential with outside Third parties either, because that's another way we can inadvertently breach confidentiality. A few examples here.
38:39Benny Wilson is charged with possession of stolen merchandise. The day after discussing a case with his lawyer, Benny discusses it with a name neighbor. As long as Benny does not say something to his neighbor like, here's what I told my lawyer yesterday. The attorney client communications remain confidential. Of course, this is not true. Benny's conversation with the neighbor is not confidential. Benny just inadvertently breached confidentiality or waived it because Benny has the key to that waiver. And now the prosecutor can call the neighbor and ask him to testify to what Benny told him. So this is kind of that if we go back back that last example of sharing conversations with others, we want to counsel our clients not to do that.
39:24So other places where we have confidentiality, confidentiality is not only with just our communications, our evidence, things we gather, but it's also in client files. So current and closed client files can also be confidential. And they are confidential through eternity. It doesn't end with the matter being done. And so we have to use reasonable means to protect our files. This means any and every document. And then once the case is closed, we have to know that our confidentiality extends beyond the representation. It just does not die with the case. It does not die if the defense or the client passes away or no longer with us. We have to take reasonable steps through all paths, all phases of the case, from beginning to end to closure, to infinity and beyond, to keep the documents and information we learned during that representation confidential. And so one of the biggest mishaps when it comes to client files is improper disposal or improper storage of our client files.
40:30Now, you may think, how does this happen? Well, a lot of times it happens without you even realizing it. Say, for instance, you task your assistant or someone with shredding documents. Say, hey, hey, throw these drafts away. We don't need them in the file. They're just cluttering it up. And so they throw them in the general trash. Well, those drafts had client confidential information that are now just put in a trash bag, thrown in the dumpster out back, and can be rifled through by anyone who goes dumpster diving. And so that's not improper disposal. So now you tell your assistant, hey, properly dispose of these. Shred these. Your assistant says, okay, I will, Will. But the shred box, the main shred box, we all know what I'm talking about. When you throw the documents in, to have the big shredder company come and take them.
41:17It's only located on the third floor. And your assistance on the first floor. To your assistance, like, man, I've already got my 10,000 steps today. I don't want to walk or take the elevator up two flights of stairs. And plus, I don't like, you know, so. And so who sits down there. So I'm not gonna. I'm only going to do it one a month or once a week. And so what your assistant does then is she gets a big box, puts it under her desk. Every time she has papers to shred or you tell her to shred stuff, she just throws them in this box, accumulates them until she's ready to take, you know, the steps on her Fitbit or her Apple Watch up to the third floor. So in the interim, though, you know, your assistant's not there every day or your assistant does go home at night, you do let her go home and sleep.
42:01And so during the night, the cleaning crew comes, they're cleaning up stuff. This shredder box, makeshift shred box, is underneath your assistant's desk, just wide open. Cleaning staff is new. They mistake those documents in that box for trash because she knows right by the trash can, we know, under her desk. So they pick them up, put them in the file, put them out back in the dumpster. Joe comes along, does some dumpster diving, finds them. Breach of client confidences. We need to use proper, reasonable means to protect client information. Leaving in there for a week, two weeks, month only, taking them up during that time to be shredded is not reasonable. We need to get that Apple Watch working.
42:41We need to take those extra steps and we need to counsel and teach and train our employees to do the same. Because if our assistant there breached or, you know, breach the confidential, the client, they don't have a license. Who's going to get sued for malpractice? You are going to get sued for malpractice. Who's going to get the disciplinary complaint? You are going to get the disciplinary complaint. So again, we have to take those reasonable means and train our staff to take them as well. So always remember that. And the thing too, with confidentiality and attorney client privilege and all these different things we've talked about is when does it attach? Because we've talked about, you know, how we breach it. You know, we have a client. But when do we have a client? That's a good question, because most of us would sit here and think we have a client when they sign an engagement letter and I agree to represent them. That's normally the traditional route of when we have a client. However, there can be inadvertent. Attorney client relationships formed without even realizing it. So how do we get an attorney client relationship or how do we know when we're in one?
43:52Well, obviously if there's express, express acknowledgement or agreement between the attorney and client through the traditional means, you know, the engagement letter, you know, and that then we have an attorney client relationship. It can also be from the appearance. Say someone comes up to you at a party, a friend, or, you know, you see someone on the street, or they just randomly call you and say you're a lawyer, right, Let me ask you a question. And then they go on to tell you about their legal woes and ask you for your advice and what they should do. Do you wanting to help this friend because you've been friends with them since high school, junior high, college, whatever long it may be, give them legal advice on their specific situation and you know that's what they're asking for. Now you, they say thanks, you say, you're welcome. If you have any other questions or anything, just let me know or, you know, I'll talk to you next year. You've already formed the attorney client relationship. There does not have to be a formal meeting, there does not have to be an engagement letter.
44:50There does not have to be any of those bells and whistles that we traditionally think of when forming an attorney client relationship. It can be as simple as answering a legal question, someone relying on the advice and they sought that advice from you because they know you're an attorney and they wanted legal advice and that's all it takes. Now the problem is you now owe confidences to this person. You can't go tell your other friends, family, social media, whoever. Hey, I talked to so and so, yeah, they asked me legal question or having some trouble on XYZ, you just breach 1.6. It attaches even when you least expect it. So creating those inadvertent attorney client relationships can cause a problem when it comes to confidentiality and protecting the attorney client privilege.
45:38So you really have to evaluate each situation and encounter with a client or potential client by thinking where legal advice of any kind is sought. So the person asking the question is seeking legal advice from you, the professional legal advisor in your capacity as an attorney. The communications are being made in confidence by the client to you and therefore are protected from disclosure, except if waived. So if someone comes to you, even if it's off the cuff or off the wall, and ask for that legal advice, particular situation, all these bells and whistles, all these eight things are present, then we have an attorney client relationship and Rule 1.6 comes into play and all the other protections of the attorney client relationship as well. So sometimes we are going to create these relationships without realizing it and that's going to be kind of sometimes a problem when it comes to it. Let's look at an example here. Suppose Sally Smith contacted David Jones, an attorney by telephone. During the conversation, Smith explained to Jones that she is involved in a dispute with the Internal Revenue Service concerning a tax savings arrangement devised for certain business objectives. She discloses important facts and highly sensitive information during the conversation, then asked Jones for his legal opinion.
47:04Is the content of this conversation privilege? Yeah. She contacted him involving a dispute seeking legal advice. ICE were meeting those bells and whistles, so we would just evaluate it. So it does depend though too, the history is there, right? Do we have this relationship, the reasonable belief that it's creating. And the answer is probably yes. Another example. Heidi Hemp is charged with possession of illegal drugs. At the request of Heidi's mother, attorney Joe Lawless talks with Heidi in jail and offers to represent her. Heidi decides not to hire Lawless and instead retains Haynesville Mutual for her lawyer.
47:44After she bails out at trial, the prosecutor tries to call Lawless as a witness and ask him to reveal what Heidi told him in their jail conversation. Lawless cannot testify why she meets those criteria. She came to him. Doesn't matter if the mother hired him or not. She told him confidential information to seek legal advice. And the privilege, the confid, the communication was perceived as being confidential even if she hired a different attorney. We all know that the client is the only one that has the right to waive the privilege like we've been talking about. And that waiver needs to be in writing, communicated and, you know, put there too. Presence of a third party, is that inadvertent disclosure?
48:27We don't really want those there, but again, it could happen. Just another example here. Heidi tells her lawyer that certain drugs belong to her her if she bought them for the first time during a period of great stress in her life, just after she lost her job, Heidi authorizes her lawyer to reveal this information to the district attorney, hoping to achieve a favorable plea bargain. However, the district attorney refuses to reduce the charges and the case goes to trial. Cross examining, hiding. The district attorney asks, isn't it true that you admitted to your lawyer that the drugs were yours? This is probably not a proper question. Heidi authorized her lawyer to reveal the information and to the statement of DA just to get a plea bargain. This is one of the exceptions here.
49:12So here they were trying to work out a plea. So if you're trying to negotiate a plea or like in a mediation setting, those settlement negotiations are normally confidential and you can't use them later at trial because otherwise how are we going to foster settlement? If the stuff we say during settlement can be used against us later, then we're not going to say it during settlement and then we're never going to have anything. Settlements. So settlements and plea bargaining are its own personal bubble. You can authorize it just for means of settlement to disclose something, but then it can't be used later against you as well. So that's another kind of one of those nuanced exceptions there too.
49:48Just the rule two we've been talking about third parties being present the communication. It's a harsh rule. Those only exceptions if the person is there, like I was saying earlier, is essential. Necessary. Necessary highly useful to the representation. Then we can still maintain the privilege around that. But otherwise third party's presence breaks or breaches that confidentiality in the attorney client privilege. And we talked about that earlier. But just information on the slides if you wanted to see it in print. An example of this. Soon after her arrest, Heidi speaks to her mother in jail. Heidi's case goes to trial. Trial and the prosecutor calls Heidi's mother as a witness and asks her to reveal what Heidi told her.
50:31Heidi's mother would likely have to answer questions under oath about what Heidi said to her. Why there's no real privilege between mother and child unless it's a minor relationship. Potentially because we have to have that essential to aid in the communication. That presence of the third parties and an adult child and adult mother really don't meet those standards. Standards. But it's all going to turn on in if Heidi's mother is essential. Parents of witness who face criminal charges sat in on conversations with the lawyer, provided advice and guidance to their son who was the minor child. The parents hired the lawyer and pay the lawyer.
51:09This could potentially be there because a minor child may the parents may be more essential. But the adult adult maybe not minor adult. You could argue that essentially that necessity or the essentialness of the parent to be present to where the third party present does not breach the confidentiality. Here defendant was charged with second degree murder. During a prior divorce case. The defendant brought his daughter to a meeting with her family law attorney. Could the family law lawyer be called to testify at the murder trial or was the daughter's presence essential? It all depends on why they were there. We have to answer Those questions. Same thing with like, you know, a civil case.
51:51If a daughter is here, we get more into easing the communication, transportation, you know, memory loss stuff. We really have to look at a case by case factor system almost to see who's essential, why they're essential, and then decide if it attaches in that attorney client relationship too is we're winding down here in the last five minutes of our seminar. We have to remember rule 1.5 tells us that fees must be reasonable. Reasonable based on locality. There's guidance from a 1.5 location area of law. You're doing what you normally charge. If you have a specialty in a certain area, I would recommend getting everything in writing.
52:31Only contingency fees and most jurisdictions are have to be in writing. Everything else can be just agreed verbally. But it's always great to get any fee in writing with the client because otherwise you may have a dispute. Dispute, we don't want any disputes when it comes to who gets paid what. So unless it's a contingency fee, which is normally required to be in writing under Rule 1.5, fees just must be reasonable based on different factors set out in Rule 1.5. And each jurisdiction is a little different. So I, I encourage you to go take a look. But always, always recommended to have fee agreements in writing.
53:08Like I said, contingency fee agreements are the ones that must be in writing. And you must provide a client with a written statement of how the proceeds are divided at the end. Like that accounting of it when it does come to payment of the contingency fee. The contingency fees are the only ones that are generally required. But it is those best practices to have any fee in writing, put it in the engagement letter, specify who the client is, specify the details, specify how you're going to get paid. Then that is part of that communication with the client that is essential to that relationship too. And making sure you're not frustrated if you're doing some alternative fee arrangements.
53:47Again, put it in writing, get the scope, get what you're doing, get how you're going to get paid. Just so there's no question, because six months, 10 months, two years down the road, it could be foggy what you agreed to, you know, two years prior, sometime prior. Getting everything in writing will help you exponentially if it comes to any dispute. Always monitor collections, retainers, provide drafts, documents, scope, oversee things clearly, set clear boundaries and costs for the service. Do everything up front and clearly just so there's no problems when it comes to the end of it too when are you required to stop terminating representation? Obviously, if you're impaired, you can get fired by the clients or you can fire you know the person too. So you can fire the client, the client can fire you. If you become impaired or there's something else stopping you from doing sellist representation, then that's when you should stop representing the client. We also want to make sure if we do get fired or we do fire the client that we don't do anything to materially harm them. We still have to clean the client's best interests at heart and we can do not hold the file. Sabotage. Meaning saying, I'm not going to give you your file unless you pay me. You're going to get sued for malpractice for that. Even in jurisdictions where that is allowed in some circumstances, generally is not because we cannot materially adversely affect the client.
55:16Holding the client's file hostage for payment is materially adversely affecting them. Submit your lien to the new lawyer. Submit your lien to the court, the client, client, go about it the proper way. But just know we can fire the client almost at any time, just depending. Sometimes you do have to seek court permission or order though, so keep that in mind. But we need to avoid prejudice to the client, facilitate transfer if they have a new council, and then obviously send anything to them. And I thank everyone for joining and you are free to go.
Dennis S.IL
interesting point that attorney client duty of confidentiality exists as long as the attorney possesses the info, even beyond the death of the client.