Aaron L.CA
Very informative and well prepared. Was enjoyable to follow and learn.
1h 7min · about 11,000 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Welcome to ethics and professionalism, the art of graceful disagreement. My name is Wendy Patrick, and I've been a trial lawyer for about 27 years, almost all of them have also involved teaching ethics and professionalism. It's what we do as lawyers. It's what makes our profession a worthy calling. And it's also what tends to get lawyers into trouble. And over the years, I've seen trends, and let's just say a trajectory as to how courts view ethics and professionalism. And I'm going to be talking to you during this program, about how those two concepts really do blend when it comes to how we look at the way in which we do our jobs, dealing with clients dealing with opposing counsel, court, staff, judges, juries, and everybody else in the process, ethics and professionalism has really become front and center in the legal profession, as well as many others. But typically, it remains a bit misunderstood by even very seasoned lawyers who are used to thinking about these two concepts separately, we shouldn't, and I'll explain to you why that is.
1:14In our American Bar Association's preamble, okay, raise your hand if you've read the preamble to the ABA. Well, I read preambles all the time, because in giving presentations, it is very helpful to know that much of what we discuss around board tables at meetings and in the hallways during court really is actually written down. Sometimes it's even codified in existing state's ethics codes. Now, this presentation is geared for you no matter which state you practice in, because all states at this point, have adopted a version of the ABA model rules. So that's why I like to start with the preamble. Let's just start right from the top. That's the place we get all of our ethics rules from to begin with. Comment five, listen to the way it's phrased, a lawyer's conduct should conform to the requirements of the law, both in professional service to clients, and in the lawyers, business and personal affairs. How do you like that? There's another program, I give the talks about how you're off the clock conduct can have professional consequences. But suffice it to say that concept applies here as well, that there is an element of civility and professionalism that we as lawyers when we raise our hands and took the oath to follow the law, that we also embrace that higher responsibility to ourselves to our clients and to society in general. It's also why we care collectively about professionalism. Because when one lawyer is either filmed by the media or goes viral on social media, doing something that makes the
2:56rest of us look bad that reflects on everybody else, it reflects on the really our ability to get quality clients, it reflects on the confidence that clients have in us as the lawyers and it just as a profession demeans the reputation that otherwise should be so high because the vast majority, the vast majority of lawyers are professionals. Now I know this because I've been watching it for 27 years. I've also done a lot of research into this issue. And this issue of what gleans what, what how do you determine whether or not somebody is worthy of that type of competence? And professionalism is always at the top of the list. So business and personal affairs now, that shouldn't be a frightening concept, because there shouldn't be this anxiety about well, gosh, what if the State Bar knows what I do on my own time that really shouldn't characterize the flavor of the lifestyle? Shall we say, that you bring to the profession? Let me say that our individual states also have codified ethics and professionalism, ideals that really make it clear that we are never off the clock. Our clients don't expect us to ever be off the clock. If there's an emergency motion that needs to be filed or court need something by Monday, and it's important, we're expected to do what we need to do to get the job done.
4:23It's kind of like always being on call, but many lawyers would probably make the argument that they're always on call because it's been a 24/7 lifestyle since law school. But however you want to frame that thought the reality professionalism and ethics wise, is that we do have a higher duty to be ethical and professional in and out of court and on and off the clock. I will also say on and off line, by the way, because so many lawyers spend so much of their personal time blogging and tweeting and posting. So the intersection and blending between civility and ethics that there's really probably a lot more time than I can devote to the topic today, because there are just so many areas within the practice of law where this comes up. I mean, you could think of the the lifecycle of a case. I mean, from the very beginning, when two parties lawyer up from that point forward, there was so much that goes into the Civility aspect of things. I mean, think about the interaction you have to have with other players in the game, right from the get go. I mean, you're gonna have to file a claim, you are going to have to cooperate to some extent with opposing counsel in deciding court dates. And when the judge gets involved and trial dates are set or settlement conference dates are set, you have to comply to comply with Discovery obligations. And all along the way, there's so much opportunity for error, but not if not, if you forge those civil relationships right from the beginning.
5:53Setting the tone early and often in as litigation progresses, will save you so much time and heartache. So speaking of trajectories of professionalism, one other trajectory I've seen during the course of my career is lawyers that believe they have to play hardball to show off for their clients to show off for their clients that the clients are earning their heart the money they paid to the lawyer. And we can think Hollywood for this stereotype. Though, sometimes we call this a script in the psychological world. In other words, people believe that this is why they are this is what this kind of a relationship should look like. The court should really be that adversarial. Those of us that have been in court for our entire careers know that's not true. We know anecdotally, we can get farther with honey than vinegar, but we don't always act that way when tensions are high, and emotions get the better of us in the courtroom. And that sometimes translates into the way we treat other people outside the courtroom, opposing counsel, sometimes our own clients, court staff, I mean, the list goes on. But if you think about civility as something that should permeate every bit of litigation from beginning to end, your life can be so much easier not to mention, you'll probably be able to save your license as well. There has been a tendency that courts have found more and more frequently to blend ethics and civility. Now, we don't have binding civility codes, really phrase like that, but I'm gonna show you a couple that I
7:26believe arguably might fit that bill. But first we go to Benjamin Franklin, it takes many good deeds to build a good reputation, and only one bad one to lose it. Who doesn't know that, logically. But how many of you think this through in the heat of passion on the spur of the moment when you've been unjustly accused? Or when you're really getting into it with an expert witness that won't answer any of your questions in deposition or on the stand? Remember, the golden rule of repetition, nobody's going to care in a week, or maybe even in a couple of hours, they were kind of a tip you got into with a witness or something happened in the courtroom. But reputation precedes you. So make sure we always remember this. So on the Civility side of things, as we sort of began to expand our examination of how ethics and civility are just a match made in heaven, I should say, you know, they really do go so well together. Part of the common ground is respect for others. One of the ways in which we respect others is by respecting their time. So you wouldn't file a motion on Good Friday, would you when maybe you know your opposing counsel is not going to get it or doing a Jewish holiday if you so same thing, no, your opposing counsel is not going to get it in time. And if they do, you just ruin their weekend, they're gonna have to respond to your motion, or if you plan to, you tell them beforehand. And I know lots of lawyers that send courtesy copies, because the downside of jamming up a lawyer or right before a three day weekend or a holiday or
9:08vacation is also the ramifications to you as the lawyer that did it. Now sometimes we do it by accident. You know, sometimes, you know, you give something to a courier to file your E file something or you give something to somebody else to E file and it sits somewhere it doesn't get delivered. Well, that's not on you. The respect for others, it's inherent in the Rules of Civility mean that we are attuned to somebody else's time. And that's just not with respect to motion practice. That also is with respect to life in general, including family, health, children, other obligations, case loads, you know, post pandemic backlog was something that was felt quite evenly by lots of different types of lawyers. In other words, we were all in it together, and there was a great deal of graciousness, at least word time that was extended to our brothers and sisters in law who were feeling the squeeze just like we were. And that should continue.
10:08And in fact, some courts have actually weighed in and, and held that, you know, unless there's a really good reason, ie some get significant prejudice to a client, or impossibility. If it's a reasonable request for a continuance or reasonable request for resetting new dates, that that shouldn't be something that we automatically object to. And it goes further than making the observation. You know, it's your opposing counsel, today, it's you tomorrow. I mean, you never know when you're going to need a continuance, it goes farther than that it goes to this element of civility. So respect for others time. Respect for other space. As a very practical matter, if you work in a busy courthouse, you may not have a lot of space to talk to your client without everybody overhearing you, including other members of opposing counsels team, we always and we know we do what we can, the judge turns on the white noise in the courthouse and every jurisdiction has different methods and ways to try to give everybody the space they need to be able to talk to clients before going back into court. But that's one of the other things that we can really do just as a interpersonal favor, you know, Respect for others time respect for space, that makes it easier to litigate with us. And guess what that makes it easier on everyone. Now, I don't know that I would be giving this presentation in exactly the same way. If I told you I had been a lawyer for seven years versus 27. Because I do believe that mellowing out occurs with age and experience.
11:40And I don't just mean you've been knocked down so many times, you know, you're just used to it. That's not it, there becomes a greater respect for the process for the jobs that the other lawyers have to do for the job that the judge and the clerk and the bailiff and everybody else involved in the procedure, what they really do, you know, some offices, and some law firms, when they hire new associates, they actually take them around and introduce them to a lot of the other people that they'll be working with to get a feel for what other people's jobs entail. What does it mean to serve a witness? What's involved in that? How do you go and file paperwork at the courthouse? Who do you have to deal with when you're there are there lines you have to wait in sometimes we just don't have any concept of what others that we work with and for have to deal with on a daily basis. And that includes our opposition. So this respect for others is something that really goes to almost every civility guideline that exists in every one of our states. So we also look at respect in terms of opinions. Okay, we've talked about time, space, personal issues, privacy, respecting others opinions, and I don't just mean political opinions, although that's what a lot of people talk about, especially online opinions about the case. You know, sometimes I've seen lawyers just become so emotional, they would say passionate, but whatever they call it is clouding judgment. And that's, that's very apparent, not only in the way they express their arguments, but in their
13:09inability to be as articulate and polished as they otherwise could be, if cooler heads prevailed. So this idea of being opinionated is okay, if it can be kept under wraps, and certainly not foisted on others. To the extent that it creates division, I'd probably be giving the same mantra if I were you talking at a business forum or at your child's school, I mean, this is the kind of environment that could potentially become toxic. There's a lot of opinions out there, that they have no place in litigation litigation is to win your case, and to win your case, ethically, legally, and with civility and respect for others in the process, even if those others don't share every opinion that you have.
13:55Now, what does that mean, translated into an online forum? We are still in many jurisdictions doing court online, at least some of the hearings, maybe not jury trials, but settlement conferences continuances. I mean, there's so many times that it's just easier for everyone to free up some of that time that we otherwise would spend walking to court. Now I know we all wear a pedometer is in our eye watches, and we're tracking our steps, you know, maybe we go outside and get some healthy exercise instead of walking back and forth to the same court department. Every time there's something to do. So zoom matters, Zoom manners matter, team, manners matter, whatever the virtual platform is that your jurisdiction is using it, we're not less inclined to necessarily be less civil. Just because we're online. We're just very distracted and sometimes multitasking. And that really detracts from the focus and the respect to the process. Our clients certainly wouldn't want us to behave any less properly, simply because we're on a tiny little square on a zoom screen. So the fact that We take this into account when we are even looking at the smaller hearings should also be remembered in cases where everything is recorded. It's kind of like recording fireworks at a deposition. And then you think that's a snippet that's going to be shown at trial because that was just so sensational.
15:17Well, it might also be shown at a contempt proceeding because of human behavior. Now, if you have a guest, you just Google it, you can go on YouTube. And you can find some horrifying examples of lawyers misbehavior at depositions, including leading up to fistfights in the deposition room yet, when there's a camera running. Not that I think any of you would resort to that type of misbehavior. But let's just say it illustrates the fact that even a camera in our face doesn't necessarily deter disrespectful behavior. Remember that next time you go on Zoom, I'll give you an interesting psychological study. You may see the PhD after my name. So I went back to earn a PhD when I had been a prosecutor for already about 15 years, wanting to know more about the why the rationale behind why people behave the way they do. And one very interesting study, and this actually just was recent, that they looked at how people behave differently on Zoom versus in person. And in a civility context, they were looking at whether or not the treatment was better or worse, or whether people felt almost unaccountable behind the Zoom screen. And sure enough, without the ability to lock eyes with somebody else, the researchers found that we are less inclined to behave as well as we would in person. How do you like that, they did an experiment where they actually installed the camera on computers that did afford the opportunity to make eye contact, participants in that category treated each other a lot better. When we're in court. When
16:51we're right there next to our client, when we're looking at the people in the eye, we behave better. Go figure. But remember that in terms of civility and ethics on virtual platforms, everyone can have a bad day. That is one of the things we have to remember, before we react to something our opposing counsel did or said, sometimes people apologize, oftentimes they don't. But it's oftentimes people don't even apologize in their personal lives. I mean, we all know somebody in that category. But that doesn't necessarily mean it has to change the dynamics of the case, you know, we can just choose to move on, move through it focus more on our case, the elements we have to prove or disprove our clients and everything else. You know, being this trained advocate also means understanding human nature, because that's what we deal with, in and out of the courtroom. And in that arena, I'm going to bring in one of the very first ethical rules that not only is first on the chart, in terms of numerically, that also is one of the most important ethics rules that comes up no matter what kind of law you practice. And that's competence. It's 1.1. It's 1.1 in every one of our states. But let me tell you a little bit about why competence is so important when it comes to ethics and civility. So first, let's see what it says a lawyer shall provide competent representation to a client. And competence, of course, is defined in a little more detail. It says competent representation requires the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and
18:29preparation reasonably necessary for the representation. Now what that means is, whatever kind of case you have, you have to make sure you know that law inside and out, you have to know the case law, you have to know the ways in which those cases are typically decided. So it's almost more than just knowing black letter law. I mean, any member of the general public could do that. They don't need to have gone to law school to be able to read what any particular law says that you have to do that analysis and competence requires you to be able to do legal analysis in the kinds of cases that you undertake, if you can't either get up to speed or associate in somebody that can help you. But that's what competence requires. Now, let me add something to all of that.
19:15Some of our states, including my home state of California, go farther. They talk about mental, emotional, and even physical competence. In other words, they recognize the reality that a lawyer may be unfit to try a particular type of case or maybe any case depending on the circumstance, if they are not at their best cognitively, mentally, emotionally or physically. It's a very important concept to to work into almost everything else we do in terms of ethics and civility, because it just goes to show you how broad based some of these rules are. I mean, you wouldn't want an airline pilot to be compromised cognitively mentally. emotionally or physically or anybody else for that matter that's doing a job that requires them to be at their best. Now, I don't mean ADA impairments that are very easily accommodated or rectified or that don't, don't jeopardize a client's case, I'm talking about the states that often come and go, You know, sometimes somebody is going through a really emotional time personally, or they may be nursing an injury and on their own painkillers. I've heard lawyers in open court talk about how many painkillers they took before coming to court. Again, YouTube has some video footage of things like this. So these are some of the competence issues to keep in mind. Also, when it comes to civility, if lawyers really don't know or recognize the Civility guidelines in their in their state, or recognize the ways in which civility intersects with ethics rules, that could become a competence issue, especially
20:51in states where there is case law, where judges have ruled that it's bad faith to oppose a continuance just to oppose it, or it's bad faith to intentionally file motions when you know your opposing counsel will have time to respond to them. Now let's look at another ethical rule 1.3. Right next door diligence. Now, the way this rule, this phrase is as follows. A lawyer shall act with reasonable diligence and promptness in representing a client. Well, if a lawyer gets served with emotion on a Friday afternoon, when it's either the beginning of Easter weekend, or it's a Jewish holiday, or it is a day that everybody knows this lawyer is leaving on vacation, they're not going to be able to meet a deadline. And then they worry about 1.3 diligence, acting with diligence and promptness in representing a client. Now it is true, you have the word reasonable in there, thank God that word appears in so many of our ethics rules. But in nonetheless, this is one of those rules that we have to remember, everybody has to comply with this, not just us, but our opposing counsel is going to be held to the standard to and when you look at the comments to 1.3, please read the comments. By the way to all these rules.
22:03They contain very practical scenarios that bring the rules to life. Listen to what comment one says again, well, one point we diligence. A lawyer is not bound to press for every advantage that might be realized for a client that had it like that I'm going to go on in a second. But many lawyers that may be watching a lot of crime dramas on television and seeing these wild antics that take place in the courthouse, think that that's their duty is to just be bulldogs in the courtroom. And they certainly don't want to be a lap dog. But there's no reason to go all out with a spiked collar and just attack everybody else. Because that's not the way we do the best in our cases. So ABA comment, one 1.3 says that, but then it goes on, says for example, a lawyer may have authority to exercise professional discretion in determining the means by which a matter should be pursued. And that cross references rule 1.2, which deals with the allocation of authority between lawyer and client? The other good thing about the comments to some of these rules is they refer you to other rules that complement the rule that you're reading. I mean, it's almost hard not to be ethically informed, if you read these rules and the comments and all of our states have comment sections as well. So what is the end of this comment, say it's basically saying you may have a client that loves the idea of you just you know, circling like a shark in just eating a witness alive when the ethical and professional rules don't normally don't
23:42require you to do that, but prohibit you from using tactics that would be harassing demeaning invasive of privacy. In other words, this rule recognizes that it's up to you as a lawyer to exercise professional discretion in determining the means by which a matter is pursued. I mean, a client, you know, they tell you their objectives and what they hope to accomplish. But they can't dictate the means by which you do that. The communication rule says something very similar, that you have to not only communicate the important parts of the case progression with the client, but also the reality that you can't just do or say anything in pursuit of zealous advocacy.
24:21Again, sometimes new lawyers are brutally treated in a court decisions, if they do otherwise. I say treated because obviously it's in writing, but sometimes courts don't publish the names of tortfeasors in the courtroom will call them. Sometimes they do. Sometimes there's behavior that's so bad. You'll see judges actually, at the very end of the opinion, say we order this opinion be turned over to the state bar for potential referral to determine whether there's enough to prosecute and they phrase that all different ways but the bottom line is, that's probably a case the State Bar is going to look at I've read So many state bar opinions, I have to tell you that they bars do look at this kind of behavior and they weighed against all possible violations, you know, something may come in as a 1.3 diligence potential violation. But there may be so many other rules that are also potentially violated, like 1.1 competence, 1.2 1.4 communication. So all of these things work together better just be civil, and ethical to begin with. Now, here's another little asterisk. If you are civil, if you are honest, if you're trustworthy, if you gain the respect of every one you practice with an appear before, what do you think that's going to do to you getting the benefit of the doubt? If you exercise poor judgment on occasion, if you forget, if you accidentally get into it with a witness and then apologize, that's gonna go a long way, in you saving that reputation as Benjamin Franklin points out, you may have spent years
26:01cultivating, you don't want one incident to ruin it. So all that goes into play here. Now let's let's stay on 1.3 for a minute, because comment one goes on and here's what it says in the next paragraph. It says the lawyer's duty to act with reasonable diligence. Okay, this is an ethics rule diligence, does not require the use of offensive tactics, or preclude the treating of all persons involved in the legal process with courtesy and respect. You know, I could do a one hour M CLE. program just on ABA rule 1.3 comment, one, because look at everything that's in just this one sentence, the lawyer's duty to act with reasonable diligence. Okay, so first, we're establishing that this is a duty, this isn't an aspirational guideline, like some of the Civility codes are, this is a duty to act with reasonable diligence. But it says it doesn't require the use of offensive tactics. Now, you may say, Well, you know, offensive is in the eye of the beholder? Well, it's probably in the eye other in the experience of the receiver as well. And maybe even in the eyes of the court, there's been so many instances where courts have held lawyers in contempt for obscene gestures for off color comments, for demeaning comments. And there's just so much involved in the way that we do our jobs in the courtroom. And this rule is in and out of the courtroom, because listen to the way it's phrased in that respect, it says or preclude the treating of all persons involved in the legal process, with courtesy and respect, that is open ended all persons involved
27:45involved in any capacity, I suppose Don't be the test case, it is one of those things that, you know, we can look in rules that we wouldn't think would necessarily include treatment and respect for others, and they do. So lest there be any doubt, the extent to which civility is swept up and included within so many of these ethics rules. Okay, so I mentioned rule 1.21 of my favorite rules, let's take a look at that one in a little more detail. So 1.2, as I mentioned, is scope of representation and allocation of authority. That means authority between what you get to make the calls on and what your client makes the calls on. So it says a lawyer shall abide by a client's decision regarding the objectives of representation. And per 1.4, that's the communication rule shall consult with the client regarding the means by which they are pursued. That is a distinction with a difference, because the first sentence says abide. The second part of that says, consult very different, you want to, you know, invite the opinion of your clients. But you don't have to abide by the means by which they would like their matter pursued, that's going to save you in some cases where you have a client that wants you to do something unethical that you already know you can't do or what you do exploit the vulnerability, for example, of an opposing counsel who's compromised, who is less than in terms of the their court performance due to maybe an issue that you happen to know about. I mean, there's so many different ways in which you have to do the right thing
29:32ethically, if you have a client that wants you to do something that's ethically impermissible. So keep that in line with one point to some lawyers, especially if they haven't read this thing. Well, the client wants me to do to have to do it. You don't. It depends on what it is that your client wants you to do. Obviously, this will goes on to clarify some of what we already know. If it's a criminal case, we must of course, abide by a client's decision regarding whether to take a plea whether waive jury trial and whether the client wants to testify. Now, we do advise and I would also direct you to rule 2.1. Lawyer as advisor, we are entitled if we so choose to advise on a variety of different areas, not just law, by the way, everything from politics, social issues, morality, I mean, there's a lot that goes into the equation as to how much we can tell our clients and how much we can advise our clients and really give our opinions in a lot of different areas. So 1.2 2.1, remember to read those two in tandem as well.
30:38But on the issue of ethics and civility, let's take a closer look at yet another rule that's been teased in the last two rules we've looked at. And that's one point for communication. That rule says that a lawyer shall promptly inform the client of any decision or circumstance that requires informed consent, reasonably consult with the client about the means by which the client's objectives are to be accomplished. So there's a lot there, let's take a look at it promptly inform the client of any decision or circumstance. And then subdivision two says, reasonably consult with the client about the means this same distinction that we just saw in 1.2. Now make sure you look at your state's version of all these rules in the off chance. There's something that's phrased differently, because there are states that phrase some of these rules differently. Just as an example, one of the rules that's often phrased differently in different states, I gave you the competence example 1.6 confidentiality, often is wildly different in different states regarding some of the subdivisions and the way that they're phrased. So or other rules, though, you know, it's true that we look to the ABA for guidance if we don't have something specifically on point. But because most of our states have adopted in whole or in part, the ABA rules on almost every subject, that's where we look first, ABA rule 1.4, it goes on. And in the third subdivision, it says keep the client reasonably informed about the status of the matter, promptly comply with
32:25reasonable requests for information. But when you look at the way it's phrased with regard to the consult language, it says consult with the client, this is so important. If there's nothing else you remember about 1.4 With reference to ethics and civility, remember this consult with the client about any relevant limitation on the lawyer's conduct when the lawyer knows that the client expects assistance not permitted by the rules of professional conduct or other law. Now, this goes to everything that's not only been codified, but thinking about case law. You know, there's an increasing amount of cases in all of our states that recognizes bad lawyering and bad lawyering on a number of different fronts, both substantively and socially the way in which lawyers treat other people. This is the kind of rule that often shouldn't be taught in connection with client control. And we hate to say the word control, it's just say, client conduct the bonding with clients, the way in which we gain the trust of our clients, and also the way in which we gain the respect of our clients and looking to us to make the decisions that are ours to make, like the the decisions that are referenced in rules, 1.2 and 1.4. And to some extent, in 2.1, although that's more aspirational in terms of the things you can talk to a client about. But this is the kind of thing where a client will thank you in the end for doing what you need to do to win the case, or make it at least far more likely to get a positive outcome, rather than resorting to tactics that are simply more likely not
34:06only to get you into trouble, but also to to impair you really get the powerful persuasiveness that you otherwise might have in presenting the client's case. So professional dealings within the court system. There are even rules on this. That's right. The one that comes up most often is 3.4. Listen to the way this is phrased. fairness to opposing party and counsel. That doesn't even sound like it has some elements of civility. I mean, isn't civility at least in part about your playground conduct being fair, playing fair in all aspects of the way in which you put on a case, prepare a case and litigate a case? So here's what that rule says. It says a lawyer shall not unlawfully obstruct another party's access to evidence or unlawfully altered or destroy or conceal a document or other material having potential evidentiary value, or counsel or assist another person to do any such act. Okay, let's break that down for a minute. A lawyer shall not unlawfully obstruct another party's access to evidence. So your client may have come, there may be confidential information that nobody gets that's for you that there's so much that falls into categories like that. This is talking more about discovery. So legal obligations to produce evidence have to be followed. Obviously, we don't probably need to be told we can't be destroying evidence. And this rule talks about destroying or concealing document or something else of potential evidentiary value, that word potential that gets everybody well, how am I supposed to know
35:48what will or won't become relevant or what might be of interest to my opposing party, usually, we can infer knowledge from circumstances. That's a famous phrase that you hear all the time, because everybody understands why that's true. You can't get into somebody's head and read their mind. But you can look at what they did, and determine why you think they did it. Don't just do this all the time when it comes to, you know, extending the benefit of the doubt. But back to the issue of, you're more likely to get the benefit of the doubt, if you are respected and trusted by your adversary by the judge, by your client, by the court staff by remember the way that other was phrased, all persons involved in the legal proceeding. So you see, I can work civility into every single one of these rules. This one, it's already there fairness to opposing party and counsel. Now, also risk, respect the fact that adversaries in court are often also covered by some of the more vague ethics rules that talk about how you treat anybody.
36:48So it's not just, you know, the witnesses or the judge or your client, it could in fact, include an adversary could include anybody in the process. And I haven't even gone into the bias and discrimination rules, the ways in which you cannot use anything that's bias or discriminatory in or out of the courtroom. But there's something else that covers potentially what you say to your adversaries, and that's ABA model will 4.1. But it's 4.1, by the way, in all of our states now as well. Truthfulness in statements. Here's what that one says, In the course of representing a client, a lawyer shall not knowingly okay, there's the there's the word, we'll come back to make a statement, a false statement of material fact or law to a third person. Let's just stop there and talk about this for a minute. This is not just in the courtroom, that's 3.3 candor in the courtroom. This is a broader duty of candor, that involves everything everybody you talk to in the course of representing a client. Now, most of our states have other rules, and sometimes case law that says lawyers can ever be dishonest about anything, anytime, anywhere, doesn't matter whether or not you're practicing law. But for purposes of the ABA model rules 4.1 talks about in the course of representing a client, so let's go back to working in our civility rules that would include negotiating with opposing counsel.
38:13And in fact, there are ABA Ethics opinions that deal with truth in negotiations, specifically with doing things like puffing, overestimating the strength of your case, those kinds of tactics, when can you use them when Can't you and the bottom line is usually a matter of you can't mistake facts, you can't mistake material facts. But 4.1 is the rule that's often analyzed in those ethics opinions. By the way, if you don't know how to find ethics, opinions, this is something that you really shouldn't be doing and reading, you just Google them. You put in your state's, you know, Nebraska, lawyer, client relations, ethics, committee, ethics, opinion, whatever the terminology you choose.
38:53And by the way, you're able to look at all the kinds of opinions from other states as well, because if you don't have anything on point, most of our rules invite us to look to other jurisdictions for guidance. You know, the state boards want you to know how to do things right. And part of my career in ethics, was chairing our California State Bar ethics committee. What we did was write opinions, write ethics, opinions, we did research we put together presentations, but the goal was educating practitioners on ethics and civility, teaching lawyers how to well represent their clients, as well as themselves protecting their own licenses. So with all that in mind, truthfulness and statements is paramount. You know that we have a bad reputation as lawyers for being dishonest. If the public only knew Oh, the ethics rules we have to follow many of which deal with dishonesty like 4.1 does, they'd be amazed. Okay, so false statement of material fact with third person and then the second part of 4.1 says this I fail to disclose a material fact with third person when disclosure is necessary to avoid assisting a criminal or fraudulent act by a client, unless disclosure is prohibited by 1.6 1.6.
40:15At the confidentiality will, that I said varies very differently between states. So if that ever comes up client confidentiality, what you can and can't reveal, for example, based on what a client told you, make sure you look and see exactly how your state's version of 1.6 is raised. So we moved from 4.1 truthfulness and statements to 4.4 Respect for rights of third person. Now, what do you suppose this relates to listen to the way this is phrased, again, civility, ethics, broad based language that are designed to apply to a broad swath of people in the process, including opposing counsel, including victims witnesses, the judge or client, it doesn't really say anybody's excluded. Listen to the the inclusive language here. It says in representing a client, a lawyer shall not use means that have no substantial purpose, other than to embarrass, delay, or burden a third person or use methods of obtaining evidence that violate the legal rights of such a person. What do you think about that? That would mean you need to have very good motions and eliminate if you're in trial, and you have information you intend to impeach a witness with. Because God forbid, I should say God save you. If it is explosive, sensational, and runs afoul of 4.4. A and you haven't sought leave to introduce it. Because that analysis, that balancing test is something that's going to be on the record.
41:52It won't be you know, you going rogue out of the gate, seeking to embarrass delay burden, the witness or third person, it'll be you seeking to impeach in a proper fashion by using evidence, for example that detracts from the perceived credibility of the witness. I mean, that's what we do as adversaries on cross examination. But it can't be the kind of evidence that violates 4.4. A. Now you may have evidence that is embarrassing, detrimental, prejudicial. That's what impeachment is for as well. The reason that this is phrased the way it does, the way it is, is listen to what it says means that have no substantial purpose, other than to embarrass, delay or burden a third person, your substantial purpose is to impeach a witness to detract from the credibility in front of the jury to then be able to argue you shouldn't believe what that witness said. That's very different than sort of the uninvited solicitous recitation or presentation of embarrassing or sensitive facts that doesn't get you anywhere. If it's not an issue in the case. There have been lots of high profile cases that have been compromised by one of the lawyers admitting seeking to admit asking about irrelevant, but very salacious evidence that you know, that's all the jury is going to remember, you don't want a case reversed or have to try it twice or, and be held in contempt or be in violation of your state's version of 4.4. Because you didn't clear all of this with the judge ahead of time, not to mention the fact that it really doesn't you talk about
43:26reputation, not only does it not make you look good in front of that jury, it might be a reputation you carry with you in your legal career. How do I know this? Because within those 27 years of practice, I've gone up against adversaries, where colleagues, both on the criminal side and the civil side, have said, Let me tell you something about that lawyer, and then shared really horrible examples of the ways in which that lawyer had behaved and trials pass. Sometimes these lawyers had been sanctioned by the State Bar, but they were suspended. They were put on probation, they got their license back. But does that necessarily mean they learned their lesson? That's what we worry about. That's why civility codes exist in all of our states to try to make as as best we can. This type of connection between ethics and civility, because it really endures to everyone's benefit to follow these rules. I'll give you a couple of specific examples. First, is what I call the traveling witness hypo. Now, we know that one of the ways in which we are expected to treat each other with civility is to be fair, to be fair in terms of not sandbagging with evidence but also not obscuring access to evidence. Remember, we talked about that, when we looked at 3.41 way in which this often comes up with a traveling witness, for example, is a lawyer that would make statements to a witness such that knowing the witnesses the other side is trying to subpoena the witness. Well, I mean, can't serve you if you're not home. I can't tell you not to take a vacation can't be
45:05called to testify if you're not subpoenaed. How many of those kinds of statements do you suppose it would take for the witness to get the idea that the lawyer is insinuating or directing the witness to take a hike, take a vacation be unavailable, don't accept Service of a subpoena. Oftentimes, witnesses not knowing any better are very transparent and forthcoming about the things that a lawyer said to them. Along those lines, that's gonna very much jeopardize a case because it sure looks like trying to prohibit or interfere with access to evidence. Now, some state ethical codes, also talk about the courtroom behavior of lawyer. So it's more than just behaving badly and obscuring or preventing access to evidence. It's also the way in which an adversary is treated in the courtroom. So for example, interrupting momentum is always one. Well, I've been a criminal trial lawyer for years. So in criminal law, everything goes to trial, or at least far more goes to trial. And then in the civil world, my colleagues tell me, the example I often give here is, you know, you have an opposing counsel that might be in the middle of an engaging, compelling opening statement. And you might have a lawyer that will make an objection, that, you know, the judge is going to overrule. And you know, that it's, you know, probably not your place to be objecting, but you want to interrupt the momentum, because the lawyers doing really good. Many states civility codes, frown on unnecessary, often meritless objections, we see that happening. Also, when
46:48you have a particularly good cross examination, for example, maybe you have an opposing counsel, that is really scoring points, just destroying your expert on cross examination, maybe the expert or any, whoever the witnesses is becoming even visibly flustered. You feel like you want to give your witness a break. So you object, and you cite several different grounds in order to try to give your witness and even more of a break to compose themselves. Well, many states civility code, say, again, meritless objections are not the way to practice law. Now, many people listen to this guidance, the Civility guidance and say, Yeah, but that's not mandatory. But then the question I suppose would become, how many times would a judge entertain, or or tolerate this kind of behavior, when everybody knows what's going on? It goes back to the trust factor, it goes back to the reality that you'll get a break everywhere, if you treat everybody with courtesy and respect. And it also goes to sort of what we learned from experience, you may think your case is just crumbling into a heap of ashes. When your jurors might be more focused on where they're gonna stop for dinner after courts out for the day or what kind of shoes you're wearing it and they aren't necessarily as emotionally tied to the emotional dynamics that you are. Now that's good and bad. Obviously, we want them to be paying attention when we're scoring points, don't we? But it just sort of brings us back to the reality that there's never an opportunity that you want to take to
48:24compromise ethics, integrity, or civility simply because evidence isn't going or coming out exactly the way you want to. So with that in mind that let's go to the next rule, professional misconduct. This is rule 8.4. professional misconduct includes anything you do that violates any of the other rules of professional conduct. That's the way this will start is by spelling that out for us. It also includes committing a criminal act that affects honesty or fitness as a lawyer or engaging in conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice. Now, that last prong is very broad. But why wouldn't it encompass some of your very uncivil actions that do exactly that are prejudicial to the administration of justice?
49:18I mean, if you are in the habit of always being late to court, I've springing continuous requests on everyone without giving prior notice serving witnesses and serving motions at the 11th hour, that is going to very much impact the progression of that case, often in a manner that adversely impacts the administration of justice, or at least a court could find that and courts have found that lawyers that unnecessarily prolong cases object to continuances or pull other kinds of disruptive tactics are doing exactly that. They're they're interfering with the administration of justice. So listen to comment, one Again, comments are minefields of guidance to rule 8.4. Aba, it says lawyers are subjected to discipline when they violate or attempt to violate the rules of professional conduct, knowingly assist or induce another to do so, or do so through the acts of another as when they request or instruct an agent to do so on the lawyers the half. Now, that is very important, because it recognizes that we don't always do all of our own litigation practice, we don't always file our own motions, we don't always do our own online research. You know, when you look at the fact that we can't invade the privacy of other people or do anything that might embarrass them. Remember, we talked about the you're not supposed to even obtain evidence in a fashion that disrupts the privacy rights of others, you might imagine there that would imply that you can't then direct investigators to do what you can't. And in so many different cases, you know, sometimes
51:00it's just an issue of communication. The guidelines from the lawyer are vague or misunderstood by paralegals secretaries, investigators, process servers, you can't direct anybody on your team or your staff to do something that you know, you can't because you know what these rules say? Now, I also want to draw your attention to a set of standards. We've talked about the ABA rules, we've looked at the comments, I've alluded to the reality that all the states have adopted a little bit different version of these rules. Now, let's turn to the ABA criminal justice standards for the defense function.
51:33Now the prosecution has its own function, but the ABA has these criminal justice standards. So if you're a criminal practitioner, or if you practice primarily civil law, but occasionally you get a criminal case, please take the advantage to read these take the opportunity to have a look at the kind of guidance that these standards give you. I'll just give you an example. I mean, standard four dash 7.2 is entitled, civility with courts, prosecutors and others. And it says in written filings, defense counsel should respectfully evaluate and respond as appropriate to opposing counsels, arguments and representations and avoid unnecessary personalized disparagement. Most, if not, all, of our civility codes around the nation include language just like this, that training case is personal. It's not about your opponent. It's about the law, the analysis, your theory of the case. And rules like this, really emphasize what we've been saying since slide one, that this applies to everything you do, in trying a case or handling a case I understand many of you don't go to trial per se, but you handle cases where they settle along the road doesn't matter. There's bound to be written filings, there is bound to be communication with opposing counsel. And when you are responding to arguments, there is nothing that your opponent could argue that should lead you to unnecessary personalized disparagement. I love that it's phrased that way, because it really encapsulates what we seek not to do, even when we're angry, even
53:25in the heat of passion. Now, there was a great scene in the movie Liar Liar with Jim Carrey, when he really really needed a continuance, but he couldn't lie. So he was very passionate about really, really needing one liking one, I think, is the way he phrased it. And then when the judge asked if he had grounds or not, he had to say not many times, maybe that's us, we would love to have a continuance. But we don't have any grounds for seeking one, which means that you have to explore your options. But there may also be times that your opponent really wants a continuance. I mean, maybe they have a child that just sprained ankle, or they have some other personal circumstance that requires them to ask for this accommodation. There may be times that it doesn't prejudice, prejudice you or the case of your client, or the case in general. And a lot of case law has come out that basically says, you know, your opposing counsel today, you tomorrow, unless there's a real reason to not accommodate and if it's a reasonable request, but that word reasonable was all over these court decisions. Maybe you ought to think about whether or not it would really be a hardship to agree. So one more ABA, criminal justice standard for the defense function I'm going to give you here that's also very, very much in in tune with what our ethics rules say, standard for national point nine Dilijan Since promptness and punctuality, you will find this sentiment in every state's ethics code. It's about being on time. It's about notifying people, if you're not going to be
55:09there on time, it's calendar control. It's everything about remember going back to respecting the fact that all of us have busy case loads. All of us are multitasking. We have lots of irons in the fire, lots of cases that are going forward and are time consuming. If there's a reason you already know in advance, you're either going to ask for a continuance, you need a continuance, you're gonna be late to court. Listen, the way this is phrased. Defense Counsel should not unreasonably oppose requests for continuances from the prosecutor. And we know that we should not unreasonably ask for continuances if we don't need one, if we know it'd be disruptive to the case, these are basically civility codes packaged as best practices. And disability codes are themselves best practices. And by the way, you can find them on your state bar's website, no doubt there. There's a great deal of overlap almost a substantial degree of overlap within the different states. But I was telling you about some of this case law that has specifically looked at whether or not opposing counsel should have granted a continuance asked for a continuance accommodated, that kind of a request, and almost give you you know, one example and this is from 2010. I want to give it to you for 2010 and show you that even back then, as a long time ago, but even back then, courts were recognizing the inappropriateness of just objecting because you can. And that was a case that held that the district court abused discretion in not granting a
56:47plaintiff's counsels modest extension to file an opposition to summary judgment motion. That's a pretty big deal. And here's part of the rationale. They said Where as here, there is no indication of bad faith, prejudice, or undue delay. attorneys should not oppose reasonable requests for extensions of time brought by their adversaries. How do you like that? And by the way, what did they say to in addition to obviously, there's always Watson prior case law that's often used by courts, but they also cited to the California Attorney guidelines of civility and professionalism. So court rulings, incorporate civility guidelines in reversing decisions of lower courts. And this is a case you'll have in your materials, Xenon pictures, Ninth Circuit case, why is this important for us, it's important to really observe the reality that we live in a day and age that civility is a part not only of ethics rules and codes, but of court decisions. So it impacts the success or failure of our cases. So it's much more than reputation, although that's obviously very important, too. It's much more than the respect you get from your client and the trust you get from the court and opposing counsel. It's even in all wrapped up in the way in which you have the chance of winning your case or doing the best you can for your client. That's how important civility is. Now think about this. Also, when you're sending emails, I mean, you know, I read your psychology today. And there's a great title I plan to use regarding the how much you can
58:36tell about somebody by the subject line of their email. We look at that first. That's how we determine whether or not it's spam or whether we're even going to take the time to flick it open. But I'll say the E and email stands for evidence. And that's because oftentimes emails are discoverable. Oftentimes, they have to be produced. We see that happens politically, socially, and legally in a courtroom. So a couple of tips here, strategize that subject line, you know, watch things like capitalizations ASAP. I mean, sometimes less is more when you're crafting an email, be formal, be cordial. Be respectful, everything that you would want to do or say an open court make sure that characterizes your electronic communication, because all of that might come into question.
59:24Depending on whether or not your case takes a turn. Be careful with humor and emoticons. Not everybody interprets those the same way. Now also in your materials, I'm giving you standards of courtroom professionalism, ABA standard three dash 5.2 and the corresponding for Dash 7.1. We have to support the authority of the court. We have to have a professional attitude towards court and opposing counsel witnesses, defendants jurors, and you know, it's true that sometimes witnesses are very difficult. Some judges make wrong rulings, but and many of our states including California Has codified this, we have an ethical duty to respect the court. Certainly it's a professional duty.
1:00:05Certainly it's a duty of civility. But some of our states have actually codified it as a potential violation of a code section. So make sure that we treat everybody with that kind of respect. And that's true. Also, when you talk about privacy rights, I mean, anything that intersects with some of these rules, because also remember, judges have the power to enforce on civility. Aba rule 3.5 is actually entitled impartiality and decorum of the tribunal. And it says a lawyer shall not engage in conduct intended to disrupt a tribunal. It has lots of other subsections but that's one of them. Conduct intended to disrupt a tribunal could be completely uncivil behavior. And in fact, in comment for of ABA rule 3.5. It says this, the advocates function is to present evidence and arguments so that the cause may be decided according to law. Refraining from abusive, or obstreperous conduct is a corollary of the advocates right to speak on behalf of litigants.
1:01:22obstreperous, that's a word you don't hear very often say that 10 times fast. But this is a recognition that bad behavior in the courtroom is part of our duty as an adversary to refrain from that kind of behavior. Our function, as noted in the first part of comment four is to present evidence and arguments of the cause may be decided according to law period. And I would even add to present it in a fashion that is respectful, that's persuasive, that's polished, but that's endearing enough to bring the case to life. I mean, that's how we win cases in front of jurors, isn't it? Jurors aren't necessarily looking for an advocate that's totally polish, they may not trust an advocate that they can't relate to, but they're looking for somebody that treats everybody with respect. So not only is ABA rule 3.5 designed to prevent uncivil conduct.
1:02:12It's also designed probably to encourage, inspire and promote good behavior, at least I hope it is, because we can definitely read it that way. The very last thing I'll touch upon is that there are rules regarding responding to judicial misconduct. And in rule 3.5 comment for it even touches on that I'm going to also talk briefly about 8.2. But in rule 3.5, comment four, it says a lawyer may stand firm against abuse by a judge, but should avoid reciprocation. It says the judges default is no justification for similar dereliction by an advocate. You gotta love this language. Doesn't that make the point?
1:03:03You may have a judge behaving badly after all, anybody can have a bad day, but it's not a license for a lawyer to then begin behaving badly also. And that's right there in 3.5, which is entitled impartial impartiality and decorum of the tribunal. It goes on and says an advocate can present the cause, protect the record for subsequent review and preserve professional integrity by patient firmness no less effectively than by belligerence theatrics. We don't need a definition of this. We know it when we see it. We've seen very colorful behavior from lawyers in a courtroom. And we wonder to ourselves is that really in the best interest of the client? Probably not. Part of 3.5 scope by the way, extends beyond the courtroom. Comment five says the duty to refrain from disruptive conduct applies to any proceedings of a tribunal including a deposition. How do you like that? It then cross references rule 1.0 M, great cross reference and some of these ethical rules. And you know, the duty of candor goes beyond candor in the courtroom as well. So there's lots of reasons to read both the rules and comments, because they really give you great guidance as to how to, to how to behave, how to present your case and how not to present your case. There's lots that you can look at in terms of different court decisions. There's lots you can look at in terms of the power that judges have to enforce the Civility codes, what their contempt power looks like. And of course, that looks different in different cases. But it even
1:04:47relates to the ways in which judges can regulate the manner of presentation beyond the words rolling of the eyes, tone of voice, there's lots of ways that uncivil behavior might ensue. Fact The integrity of a proceeding or might adversely impact the administration of justice. So also look at rule 8.2, which talks about what you can and can't say about judges. And I'm just briefly going to read you what 8.2 says. It says a lawyer shall not make a statement that the lawyer knows to be false, or with reckless disregard as to its truth or falsity concerning the qualifications or integrity of a judge adjudicatory officer, public legal officer and the list goes on. So that's important as well, because we have a duty a point to comment three says to maintain the fair and independent administration of justice. But the way this comment is phrased, it says lawyers are encouraged to continue traditional efforts to defend judges and courts on justly criticized. So that's very different than you know, filing a brief or taking an appeal to a higher court that's very different than that. Remember that 8.2 talks about making a statement, you know, is false, or with reckless disregard to truth or falsity. So there's a lot here, there's a lot to ethics and civility and the blend that we now have with respect to the two areas. But it all goes to our higher calling. We have a higher calling as lawyers than we might have had it would perhaps gone into other professions. So it is with ethics and professionalism in mind that we engage in the
1:06:32art of graceful disagreement. I hope you've enjoyed this session. I hope you found it both informative and maybe even a bit entertaining. And I want to wish you all the best of luck. Again, my name is Wendy Patrick, and it's been a pleasure to spend some time with you here today.
Aaron L.CA
Very informative and well prepared. Was enjoyable to follow and learn.
Suzanne F.PA
An important reminder for new and more experienced practitioners. I was admitted the PA Bar in 1980. I know from personal experience that a lawyer's reputation for civility, reasonableness, and preparedness over time inures to one's client's benefit.
Matthew M.NJ
Very experienced instructor who knew the subject matter so well she spoke extemporaneously for 67 minutes while weaving between ethics rules. Impressive. Thank you.
David S.CA
Excellent presentation, thoughtful, well-organized, and informative. Exactly what a CLE should be.