robert K.TX
Key takeaway is that this is a very technical and complex area. Discussion on Charitable Co-Venturers was more than worth the price of admission. Valuable presentation, but very densely packed.
1h 0min · about 8,200 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, everybody, my name is Kent Seaton. And I am excited to be here this morning to talk about tips and tricks in establishing your own charitable 501 C three, organization, I'm going to cover all the legalities in connection with this process. There are quite a few, this is a very well regulated area of law. There's both state and federal law that applies, as well as law relating to solicitations corporate law at the state level. And then at the federal level, we have a 501, C three, section 501, C, three of the Internal Revenue Code 509, A, and some other relevant provisions in the Internal Revenue Code that sort of applied to these wonderful organizations that are trying to change the world. If you ever have any questions during this presentation, because this is a live recording, you won't be able to actually to ask me them, you could always reach out to me at 31055719233105571923. That's my office line, call me any time happy to be of help.
1:19Alright, so let's get going here. On the presentation. Charities, I want to start little bit with some distinctions there different than for profit organizations, and how are they different, and I'll go to sort of one through a variety of distinctions. These aren't an exhaustive list, but these are definitely some representative list. But first off, um, charities don't have any owners. Okay, unlike a for profit organization, which has shareholders who are owners of stock, and therefore own, the company, and it also exert control by reason of their ownership shares don't have ownership. In fact, I will posit a question to you, of course, I'm going to answer it because we can't interact with each other, but who owns the assets of a charity? Because if they don't have owners, somebody's got to own it. Right? Or maybe not. And the reality is the latter, nobody owns the assets of the charity. However, charitable assets are irrevocably dedicated to the benefit of the public, okay? Again, irrevocably dedicated the benefit of the public, right. So that implies that they're held in trust, in essence, by whatever charitable entity holds the assets for the benefit of the public. So even though somebody may have control of the assets, they don't own the assets. And they're holding the assets for the benefit of the public, right? The charitable class of people that are going to benefit from these assets. So that's a very, very important distinction. Because, quite frankly, almost every rule of charity law stems from this
3:15basic concept of ownership, right? Private Ownership, which doesn't exist versus public benefit. Okay. So if you've understood this very simple distinction at the beginning of this conversation, I can assure you that you are learning a tremendous amount that will be applicable to a lot of different sorts of legal concepts that I chat about today. And that you learn potentially in the future regarding these lovely in wonderful charitable vehicles. Okay. Now, the second thing once like a little bit about the human capital, that is involved with a charity that can Who are they who is the human capital, that ultimately helps charities one, there's something called the board of directors.
4:06Okay. Right. Most of you have probably heard of the board of directors, terminology at least, and it was a for profit organization. Yes, you have a board of directors with a nonprofit, you also have a board of directors. But unlike the for profit, the shareholders and for profit elect the directors, but not with the nonprofit. In fact, the board of directors are initially appointed by the incorporator. And then thereafter, when elections occur, the board elects the subsequent board members. Okay. The very different in terms of the way board members get elected right. Now, who reports to the board or staff, paid staff. Okay. So I also want to illuminate one time, a time to see titles here that I think are particularly important because, especially practically speaking, they come come up regularly within the charity world, which are officers of the organization. Now there's two types of officers can sound very, very confusing, but it's not one or officers of the board of directors and the other officers of the corporation. Okay, I see can't this is doesn't really make a lot of sense. And you kind of said the same thing? And the answer is actually no, I did it. So offices of the board, traditional titles include President or chairperson or chairman or chairwoman, vice president, secretary and treasurer, very sort of the old school terms for officers, their offices of the board of directors, very different from being an office of the corporation. Now, in addition to the office of the board, a nonprofit corporation
5:53couldn't have officers of the corporation titles like Chief Executive Officer, Chief Financial Officer, Chief Operating Officer, they are officers of the corporation, okay. Now, there are no hard and fast rules here. But I want you to understand the distinction. So just because somebody is the president of the board does not mean that you could not have a CEO. In typically offices, the corporation in almost all cases are paid. Okay, and not volunteers. And for the most part, almost without exception, board members have a charitable structure, our volunteer board members, okay, so now you're beginning to flesh out the humans that work for support, and help execute on the vision of your charity in the different titles within right. So to be incredibly powerful as a lawyer, you know, helping advise these charitable structures, you probably need to know who's running the operations, and how does it run the officers of the corporation report to the Board of Directors, including the offices of the board, okay, so that's the hierarchy offices of the board up here, offices, the corporation paid staff underneath the opposite of corporation, and it sort of goes up vertically reporting to the board of directors, right. The board of directors is the ultimate governing body, they have something called fiduciary duties, they have a duty of loyalty, they have a duty to act in the best interests of the corporation. And so that is why your board of directors is so very, very important. Okay, so now we've talked a little bit about that,
7:47I may come back to some of these topics down the road, but currently, we're going to move a little bit. Okay. Now, I'm going to continue on this sort of the differences of distinctions between a public charity and a profit making enterprise. And quite frankly, there's some similarities. Okay, both types of enterprise can engage in good, in other words, a for profit, and he could do good too. Okay. It doesn't have to do good, but it could a charity must act charitably. Okay, another one's doing good. Okay. So sometimes you may see a for profit, do good. And you may see a charity do good in the same sort of industry. And it's absolutely nothing wrong legally with us. Okay. Now, another thing, I think to understand is that both entities can do something called earn revenue. There's a lot of misconception out there that nonprofits cannot earn revenue, because they're nonprofits. And the reality is, it's exactly untrue is long as the revenue that you're earning, okay, is as important rule is related to the charitable purpose. It's completely copacetic. Okay, and not taxable. Okay. So in other words, let's take a case in point, a university, okay. And most universities are charitable structures, and they charge for education. Right. And that certainly sounds like a fee for service model, right, just like many for profits are. But interestingly, because the earned revenue in other words, the tuition and the cost involved with students paying for education is related to their exempt purpose, which this purpose is
9:45the very purpose related to education. It's completely acceptable that a university earns revenue and they're not taxed on the income which is very, very important. Now I'm going to make a quick note, if the earn revenue activity is unrelated to the charitable purpose of the enterprise, it's taxable. So for example, a university that sells its merchandise in a gift or bookstore, like coffee mugs or beer glasses that have its logo. Well, the selling of merchandise is unrelated to education. Therefore, any income from those activities that earn revenue is taxable. Okay? It's taxable. And so that's something important for you to be cognizant of, and appreciate the distinctions between a nonprofit and the for profit, okay? Now, so more differences, okay, between a public charity and a for profit business. The for profit businesses tax, the charity is exempt from tax. In addition, charities, also, when they receive charitable donations are able to give the donor individual donors a charitable deduction for the value of the gift. Okay, for profits, if they receive a gift or a charitable gift. They don't get a deduction to the donor. They can give up to whatever the current ceiling amount is, that's exempt from gift tax. But there's a shareable deduction. Okay, so clearly a for profit entity could do all the same things, from an activity standpoint that a nonprofit could do, but they definitely do not enjoy the same benefits of the tax exempt status, or this charitable deduction. In gift deduction, it's allowed to public charities. There are over a
12:10million charities in the US, there's only 290,000 that have more than $25,000 in gross revenue, there are 50,000 New charities being formed every year in the US. So the charity business is quite frothy, it's quite busy, there's a lot of activity within charities. So it's very interesting. Okay. Now, the more charities that are formed, that generally would probably be a good thing, but there are some issues that develop. One is that the more chairs they have, the harder it is to regulate them. Okay, when it's harder to regulate, that means there's more opportunity for abuse. Okay, so just be conscious that juries are a highly regulated, structured, because they are endowed with an incredible gift, which is their tax exams. Okay. And because of this tax exempt status, which is a privilege, not a right. The government, both federally, the IRS, and also on a state level, are very diligent about ensuring that charities act in a legal manner. Okay, so this is going to become a big theme as we sort of continue. Be mindful, generally speaking, that in the state of California, for example, these are relevant agencies that have some sort of jurisdiction over charities, the Attorney General of California, when you set up a state entity, you have to file articles of incorporation, you file with the Secretary of State, when you apply to become a 501, c three public charity, you actually apply to the Internal Revenue Service, on a state level, you have potentially an application to send to the state tax authority to become exempt from
14:10tax. And then on a local level, if you throw fundraising events, for example, the city of Los Angeles, the fundraising event, you're required to get a permit in advance of following the fundraising event with the Los Angeles Police Commission. So there's all these agencies, and that is, by the way, not an exhaustive list, but a representative list of some of the basics ones that you want to be aware of, as you're hopefully setting up these legal structures for either yourself or for your client. Now, why do they have so much oversight over charities? Well, it's unfortunately the history of our forefathers bear relevance on the current state of matters today, which is that what our forefathers did the rich games that were happening, where families were faking, that they had family charities or family foundations. And ultimately, it was a sham, they were trying to pay family members who weren't doing anything's compensation for working for the charitable entity itself. And, and there was enough abuse that it became obvious that if you let family members become board members, and you allow them to compensate each other, a lot of potential facility and it could occur. Okay. So that's one of the things that sort of fuels some of the oversight of past abuse another example there, telemarketers that are sort of predatory. They call a variety of individuals to Icom sales calls and literally request charitable donations for the police department for the fires, fires. And the reality is there not endorsed fundraisers.
15:58And in addition, the level of actual support that they provide to the charitable beneficiaries is sometimes fractions of what they raise. And they found that sometimes up to 70, or 80% of the funds raised, were staying in the pockets of the telemarketer, right? Clearly, that's not something that we want, nor to something that we're looking for. And we're also very, very diligent that most of the money that's getting raised gets hopefully going to the charity, right, and it seems pretty practical. So that's something important understand that. That's why there's so much regulation, because of the abuses that have occurred in the charity sector, as sad as it is to say. So let's talk a little bit about solicitation and fundraising rules, because I'm a little bit sort of counterintuitive to, you know, unfortunately, you know, the world of doing good. One of the activities that all charity, for the most part engage in is soliciting funds, really, because without money, how could one actually do anything, so in other words, you need charitable donations, and the only way to get them typically is to solicit them to ask for them. Interestingly, every state, this is just not going to be that exciting for you to hear has its own set of solicitation rules, and requirements that people comply with when they solicit funds for charitable purposes. Okay, so suffices to say that if you are a charity, or you represent one that is going to be soliciting funds, both in you know, the home state in which you're located, and if it's California, as an example, and or
17:49multiple states, you're going to want to do your homework about what obligations you have in advance of soliciting. Okay, I'm not gonna go to all the details. But in California, you have to register with the Attorney General, you have to provide financial notices, if you engage in what they call commercial venture campaigns. And you're supposed to any type of campaign that you do supposed to give advance notice. And also, if this campaign is a national campaign, you may have to do this with a variety of attorney generals. Okay. So be very cognizant of the fact that these rules, sorry, rules are state by state. But also, if you don't know what you don't know, you want to reach out and say, Hey, you guys handle this now. So you asked me do but you know, other organizations that might as well, what do we need to do before we do this fundraising campaign? Okay, so hopefully you find the right people to check in with before you do stuff like this.
18:49Pursuant to code I'm asked every charity in the state of California as an example has to register, the Attorney General requires that you give within 30 days of receiving your first shareable property, you have to give them notice that you received it, you have to file periodic reports with the Attorney General and a lot of states are very similar in terms of the modality. Okay. Also be aware, this is a more fun stuff that like many states require audits, okay. In some, for example, California and they require an audit when she received 2 million or more in gross revenue in any fiscal year in gross revenue is very broadly defined, or there are a couple of exceptions like grant monies received from governmental contracts. But overall, all the money that you take in if it's 2 million or more, you need to get an audit, it needs to be by the third party. And there's some governance obligations as well in terms of having an audit committee and who signs off on the audit and yada yada yada. Okay. So be aware, though, that at 2 million there's an audit requirement in the state California and there are other states, if you do business in states, that may also require an audit as well.
20:17Now, let's talk a little bit about the power of the attorney general. And again, some of these seven may be talking specifically in California, but most attorney general sort of function in sort of a similar way, I think it's important to sort of remember like what powers sort of governmental agencies have and just be reminded of it. But when the Attorney General typically has broad powers in terms of overseeing charitable structures, they can investigate transactions, they can require reporting, when funds are solicited, which is we just had about the power to subpoena documents from any but all citizens of the state legal entities, they can require you to attend a hearing. They can even institute a legal action, up to 10 years after the cause of action accrued in the name of the people, they are also entitled to be a party to any action, any legal action that relates to the general property. They're also entitled to receive notice of legal instruments that have been filed relating to charitable property that's going to be donated to the beneficiary charity. So, in reality, you know, for a lot of people, this sort of Attorney General Power doesn't come up, you know, with a great amount of sort of frequency, but at the end of the end of the day, yes, the Attorney General has broad powers, and you should be very aware of what those powers are. Okay. Now, you know, they also have the power to punish, which we all know is sort of the reverse, sort of the other side to compliance
22:04is the failure to comply sometimes results and punishment. potential liabilities can you know, result in California up to $10,000 per offense, and you could have multiple offenses, okay, so, at the end of the end of the day, without powers to punish, the rules of the attorney general would be pretty emasculated. So it makes a lot of sense, why there's the ability to punish as well. Let's talk about something that I chatted a little about, that the people the human capital is involved in a charitable structure and how and who kind of keeps these things going and subtitles. But I specifically want to talk about a class or category of human capital that's related to helping charities raise funds. These are not internal employees, these are external companies or individuals that professionally raise funds for charities, okay, they're called commercial fundraisers. That's the legal terminology, they also can be referred to as professional fundraisers. And these are folks that are in the business of raising charitable funds for charitable entities in return for compensation. Many states have rules requiring registration and or other regulations related to commercial fundraisers and operating in their state. To the extent that you utilize a commercial fundraiser a client does you want to be very familiar with these rules, want to make sure that a written contract has been prepared, although there's some very specific provisions that need to be in this particular contract are statutorily defined. But you want to make sure you know,
23:44just saying it, you know, in a more layperson way that like if you hire a charity, that charity hires a commercial fundraiser, your client has a commercial fundraiser for their charity. Are they registered? Are they required to be registered in California they are in other states, they also have affirmed the registration requirements and know whether there are or not is a big knock against the commercial fundraiser, who is not registered. Because at the end of the day, they're avoiding the rules and regulations of charity law and you know, chairs need to be careful if they're celebrities involved, they could get in trouble as well. But really important thing to be talking about.
24:24Employees are not commercial fundraisers. Okay, so another charity that raises funds, that's not a commercial fundraiser. Okay. So don't get confused, but just be aware of that these rules exist. Okay. Commercial fundraisers have to register B prior to making the solicitations on behalf of the charity. They have to do renewal registrations, they have a filing fee they have to prepare the typically in California as an example. They have to post a bond I mean, there's all these rules and regulations to make sure like it said they're scared. Government is scared because it's been former abuse. So now we have to regulate not only entities, they're doing business in the charity world, but we also have to regulate the individual's okay. And that's what's really kind of going on. Right here was another another title called fundraising Council. The best way to explain fundraising Council is that sort of they're like, a less supercharged commercial fundraiser, they don't go out and solicit sort of funds directly. But what they do do is they help advise you, your charity, or your client charity on how to solicit So an interesting distinction. There's rules and regulations about fundraising Council, as it's called, again, they need to register and California has this designation and several other students. So be aware of this. Commercial core ventures, it's a wonderful topic, because this is something that quite a few charities get involved with. Because it's exciting in a way, which is also known as
26:12cause marketing, where you sell a product or service to the public, and you tell the public, if you buy this product or service will donate a portion to charity. Okay, one of the great examples that was massively successful was TOMS Shoes. For those who don't know TOMS Shoes is when it was a for profit business selling shoes. And its promise to the customer is if you buy a pair of shoes, from TOMS Shoes, we will donate a pair of shoes to a person in need. Okay, that is a picture perfect cause marketing campaign otherwise known legally as a commercial co venture, there are a bunch of rules that are triggered when you have a commercial co venture. These are, a lot of times these are the national campaigns. So when it gets national offsetting really gotta be on your game, if there's celebrities involved helping sell these products or services, then you really want to be even more on your game, because you don't want to knee trigger some rules and not be in compliance. And now it affects the charity affects a celebrity. So this is a very big, big thing. There are a lot of entities out there trying to do cause marketing campaigns. They are wonderful, no question about it. However, there are a lot of rules around it, because again, they're scared of abuse. And there's been some past abuse. Okay, so this, I may end up coming to that and deeper kind of explanation and description. But I wanted to cover it from a big picture perspective, because I think it's so important. I think this is something that's happening a lot these days. Probably a
27:55lot of the entities out there that are doing it are unfamiliar with the rules, because quite frankly, unless you're a lawyer like myself for the last 25 years in the sector, certain charities and Federation, why would you know about these rules, you wouldn't know, okay, even other lawyers, if they have not been in the sector, they may not know. Okay, so this will sort of mark a midpoint in this chat that we will take up and we will begin with solicitation and fundraising rules. And we'll go ultimately to Section 1751 0.3. And talking about solicitations a little bit more. And then we'll kind of move on from there. And we'll go into some more things. And I'll cover some board governance stuff. And I'll give you some tips and tricks and some resources. But anyway, thank you all for the first half of this little juncture. And we will be right back. All right. We're back. And we can go ahead and get started with transitioning into solicitation and fundraising rules related to charitable structures.
29:18This is an interesting topic. Charities are subject to a lot of regulation. But it's interestingly, the topic of regulation when it comes to soliciting charitable funds is also a pretty pretty tight set of statutes that apply both here in California as well as in other states states. There's two main types of solicitations. One is a solicitation for charitable funds, where it's a donation. So in other words, I'm asking you to donate to the Girl Scouts of America and to give $100 That's a straight charitable solicitation, the rules regarding the manner in which you solicit these charitable funds.
30:14The second type is a solicitation that involves the sale of something. So, again, Girl Scouts are very good example. If I sell you a box of Girl Scout cookies, that's in I say that the funds are the proceeds of which will go to the benefit of the Girl Scouts of America because of your purchase of these cookies. That's called a sale solicitation. Okay, as opposed to just a regular solicitation. Both types of solicitations are, are regulated. The basic rules are that transparency, sort of a ongoing theme, always in the charity world always wants to be very clear with the potential donors, how much money is going to go for the terrible purposes of, you know, to the organization itself. So, these are two things that will sort of come back to but I just want you to be clear that solicitations and sales solicitations are regulated activities, your charity structure needs to be aware of them as you move forward in trying to generate charitable funds. Also, I think something that's very important is that every state has its own set of rules in regards to soliciting charitable funds. So you may say, Hey, I'm seeing shareable funds in California, but the minute you go outside of the state of California, there may be a different set of rules, for example, in the state of Nevada, or the state of Delaware, or the state of New York or the state of Florida, right. So from a practitioner standpoint, you would want to know, where are your clients eliciting shareable funds? In other words, which jurisdictions and then also become fluent in
32:18the laws connected to those jurisdictions, if that makes sense to you? Okay, so the 41 jurisdictions that require an affirmative registration with the Attorney General, prior to engaging in either a sale solicitation or a regular solicitation of charitable funds. So this is, again, a very highly regulated industry. You know, the knowledge that these laws exists, is quite important, both here, you know, in California, but also if you engage in a national campaign, you want to be aware of that, okay. Now, I'm under Section 1258 1.2. A solicitation is defined as any type of request for money or anything of value, that is made for charitable purposes in the name of a charity, or implies that the, the gift will be used for a charitable purpose in and of itself. This would also include like, agencies that sort of help with public safety, like fire departments, police departments, etc. But in the event that you are making a charitable solicitation and sort of the rules underneath, section 1258 1.2, and related sections will apply. So just be aware of the fact that these rules exist. And then of course, what are some of the requirements for that? One thing to be aware of in California, every charity must file within 30 days of receiving its first charitable property, a document called the CT one to register with the attorney general. And then thereafter, provided he continues to do business in California, will file something called RF RF one, and that will be filed annually within four months and 15 days of the close of the accounting year of the
34:32organization. Okay. Now, California, in 2006. This sort of coincided with the Exxon Valdez
34:49incident in the county disaster, California State Legislature enacted something called the nonprofit Integrity Act 2006 in that act among a variety of provisions, the state legislature added some very specific requirements for charities that received 2 million or more in gross revenue in any fiscal year. And what the state legislature mandates in California now is that, to the extent that you do receive 2 million or more in gross revenue, and this is sort of gross revenue is fairly broadly defined, then you're required to engage in an audit, okay, of the organization's financials, by an independent third party firms require to have an audit committee. And there's sort of a bunch of other sort of requirements under the section that you got to sort of comply with.
35:57Obviously, the height responsibility is that once you have 2 million or more in a given year, there's more opportunity for negligence with the funds, there's more assets under management, if you will. And then there's more reason to make sure that we have some oversight in the collection and the maintenance of these charitable assets. And therefore, we now have a rule that, again, requires more oversight for these these terrible authorizations that have more and more money. gross revenue does not include just for the sake of this particular definition, grant monies received from governmental contracts, or contracts for services with any governmental entity as well. But examples of gross revenue that that is included in the gross revenue calculation formula all forms a gift grants and contributions monies received in connection with providing services to the general public. So for example, if you're a university, you charge tuition that's included in your gross revenue calculation to determine whether or not you meet this to that $2 million charitable benchmark, unrelated business income, revenue would also be included investment returns, royalties, and rents. So pretty, pretty broad in terms of the revenue calculation, but also very important, because the Attorney General of California, when you file this annual renewal filing, which you're required to do, will ask whether or not you have had the audit, a lot of times, they'll require that you provide the audit to the attorney general as well. If
37:41you don't, you'll, you know, you'll you'll you'll not be in good standing with the Attorney General of California, which clearly is not something that you want to be. So you want to make sure you do this also on the 990 IRS Form, they also have a checkbox, whether you've been audited or not. And of course, you would have to check your you're required to get an audit and of course, you know, inform the IRS that you have had the audit as well. The audit committee is prescribed by statute who needs to be on it? The audit committee cannot be members of the staff for the charity cannot be the president of the CEO. However, it can be the treasurer or CFO. You can also have a finance committee which can be separate. And ultimately, though, I think the key thing here is that you do have an audit committee requirement and make sure that you comply with that as well.
38:52In terms of the Attorney General of California, the Attorney General is really the governmental body that oversees charitable solicitations in whether or not there's there's been unethical or unlawful solicitations for charitable purposes. Any complaints by donors or funders, against individuals or organizations that have sort of wrongfully made requests for charitable solicitations or use funds for odd, you know, non charitable purposes or anything of that is really within the domain in in jurisdiction of the attorney general. So the Attorney General has broad powers to make and enforce rules concerning charities and the parties involved in fundraising and soliciting for charities. So you know, I guess another way to look at it is that you know, there's some deep public policy The interest in ensuring that funds for charities in the solicitation of those funds are done in a ethical, responsible and legal manner.
40:13And to the extent that they're not, then the people involved should, of course be held accountable. Okay. And the Attorney General is is really the mean state governmental body that sort of would investigate any claims for any any sort of infractions. Okay. But that being said, it's important, be aware of the rules. Just to briefly go over the powers of the Attorney General as relates to these charitable snake tation activities. They have broad powers to investigate transactions, subpoenaed documents, they can require prior attendance of persons involved at hearings and proceedings, it has 10 years to bring legal action. It literally can bring an action on behalf of people. These are all things that are very important. We're gonna get into a little bit about not just your organization's themselves with the people that are helping these organizations in in sort of actually going out and soliciting funds or some professionals that work in the industry of charity, and they have some additional sort of requirements of registration with the attorney general. And those professionals are called commercial fundraisers, which are really professional fundraisers that raise money professionally for charities and they take a fee for their services, something called fundraising Council. And then the final category in California is called the commercial convention, explain each one and go into them to some degree of depth. To give you a sense of their their their meaning their the requirements of these individuals as it
42:09relates to charitable entities. but be mindful that if you fail to comply, any of these professionals fail to comply with the rules. He has the power to assess costs and attorneys fees for non compliance. The potential liability for violating any of these fundraising rules is up to $10,000 per offense. So there's there's significant ramifications for improper dealings. Okay. We'll start with the first category professional which is called the commercial fundraiser defined under Section 12599 of the governmental code. The commercial fundraiser any person or entity or unincorporated entity who for compensation, cannot solicit funds assets or property in California for charitable purposes, or as a result of solicitation of funds for show purposes receives or controls the funds assets or property. Or employees procures or engages any compensated persons solicit, receive or control funds. Okay. I said a lot right there. I want to stop for a second and just kind of dial into more of what that means.
43:24But again, it's any person for compensation. So if you're paid to go out and raise charitable funds, and you're not an employee of the organization, you now maybe a commercial fundraiser, okay? And if you get paid and you solicit funds, then you are triggering the definition and you have some affirmative obligations in terms of registration with the Attorney General. In addition, this is very important, it says or as a result of solicitation of funds, you control funds, assets or property. Well, this is interesting, because a lot of people and I would call these a lot of the sort of platforms out there that receive charitable funds that are for profit entities. They are.
44:23They're receiving funds on behalf of charities and they're holding them, okay, they're controlling them. And while he didn't expressly solicit the funds, they're holding the funds for charitable purposes, and therefore, they would actually trigger the definition. So I'm not gonna get too far into this, right, the second but you can imagine, there are a lot of entities likely that don't understand that they actually trigger the definition of a commercial fundraiser here on this to California, therefore, in non compliance
45:04and we'll get into that a little bit more. Okay. Now I mentioned this a little bit, but let's cover who is not a commercial fundraiser. The charitable corporation itself is not a commercial fundraiser. So going back to the Girl Scouts of America, they are a charity. They're the charitable Corporation so to speak. In this example, they are not a commercial fundraiser, even though they're going out raising charitable funds, okay. An employee of the Girl Scouts of America also would not be a commercial fundraiser, even if they're paid by the chair of a corporation, because they're an employee
45:48and so forth and so on. Okay, now. Commercial fundraiser must register with the Attorney General prior to soliciting charitable funds must file renewal registration by January 15 of each calendar year the filing fee is $200. must file an error report. The county for all funds solicited no no later than 30 days from the close the preceding year. You cannot solicit funds until you've complied with all the rules of being a commercial fundraiser. Okay. Remember, a commercial fundraiser is considered to be a constructive trustee of collected funds, therefore has a fiduciary responsibility, okay, for the handling of such funds. Commercial fundraiser must have a written contract between the commercial fundraiser and the charity itself. And there are statutory provisions that must be contained set forward in Section 12599. I have the government code which actually literally specifically asked to be in the contract itself. Typically, there's a bond that needs to be posted as well for this affirmative registration by the professional fundraiser. In addition to commercial fundraising must disclose the total percentage of funds and the fundraising expenses that were incurred related to its fundraising activities. So there's a lot of regulation right? In, if you're advising a charity that hires someone to solicit funds, you better be aware of these rules. And you better make sure that that third party is aware of these rules and is registered if they're not, you might have a problem. Okay.
47:38Now. The second category of sort of fundraising professional in the charity world is called a fundraising Council. In they don't solicit charitable funds on behalf of charities, but the advice charities about soliciting funds, they prepare materials to assist, they don't control funds. Or they don't employ anybody that is compensated to solicit funds either, but they're advising, here's how to do it. If that makes sense to you. These are called fundraising Council, the set of professionals. And they have rules. All fundraising counsel, much registered with the Attorney General was filing renewals by January 15. As a $200 filing fee, they must include the filing of all charities and performing services for on their filing. Not less than 10 days before they commence, they have to submit a form to the Attorney General California, detailing their their details of their engagement. And under Section once you find that 9.1 E of the government code, they must have a written agreement, okay with the charity. So you can see, as you're listening to this, it's been about 20 minutes on this particular second half of the discussion, that there are a lot of rules and regulations in terms of soliciting just soliciting funds that you would want to know on behalf of your clients, right as you're doing things and it should be your attendance should go up and go wow, this is this is a lot. And I want to be very careful, you know, not only for my client, but for me as a petitioner. The third category
49:38of professional fundraiser is the commercial co venture. And this is a really interesting category. Most of you have not heard of the terminology. And some of you may have heard of the word cause marketing. And really, it's sort of a fancy Word for your marketing a product or service, and there's a cost surrounding it. Okay. Again, it could be, you know, breast cancer to support breast cancer, Susan G. Komen. And you're selling a product in the proceeds of which will benefit that charitable initiative or that charitable cause. That's called cause marketing or commercial co ventures, commercial co ventures are regulated in California. definition is any person or entity that's engaged in business and represents to the public that the purchase of any good or service of anything of value will benefit a charitable cause or charitable entity. Okay?
50:50Now, I'll give you an example. If you buy this cup of coffee, at Starbucks, we will donate 20 cents to the Girl Scouts of America. Okay, so I'm engaged in business meaning Starbucks is a business, it's engaged in a business of selling coffee, right? It represents to the public, it's something good will be done. It's we there literally advertising promoting it, the 20 cents will be donated to the Girl Scouts of America. And if you buy the coffee that will trigger the gift, okay. All the elements of the rules of commercial venture exists. Therefore, Starbucks in this example, is a commercial co venture. Okay, now, let's juxtapose that, that let's say Starbucks, instead of everything's the same, except they don't tell you. They don't advertise to the public, they make no statement, the public that they're donating 20 cents for every cup of coffee, they just go out and do it. The question is, would Starbucks in this example be a commercial co venture? And the answer is no. Okay. So the key fact is the fact that you have to market this to the public, okay. And it has to be conditioned upon the purchase of a product or service. So again, small distinction here, but important. If Starbucks said, We will give, we support Girl Scouts of America, and we will give them $20,000. They didn't condition the gift upon the purchase a coffee. Okay. So therefore, it doesn't trigger the commercial co venture rules. Okay. So these are the nuances to be aware of, if you're advising clients. If this is a national campaign, commercial conventions
52:49that a lot of responsibilities may have to register with, you know, the charity may be need to be registered with 41 Attorney General's. The for profit, in this case, the Starbucks example may also have, I think, 11 or 12, states that had asked to register as a commercial co venture, California, you need to have a written agreement for Section 1259 9.2. Within 90 days, you have to transfer funds. Starbucks does, for example, to the charity. Okay, and so there's all these requirements for the commercial code ventures as well. So again, in advising clients, you know, the biggest thing is to know what you don't know, if they come in and say, Oh, because it was great opportunity working with this for profit business, they want to raise money. Well, that's great. And there's no reason sort of be discouraging, but on the other hand, there may be a set of rules that apply here and you want to be aware of that because obviously, you don't want to advise the client and not give them proper advice. prior to engaging in these activities, okay.
54:00We talked about the different kinds of solicitations to to the sales in the in the regular solicitations. What kind of solicitation as a commercial co venture involved in it really is a sale solicitation. You know, and of course you want to, you know, comply what we call the transparency rules. I think some interesting things for commercial fundraisers. There are some guardrails, no more than 50% of the net proceeds can go to a commercial fundraiser in the form of compensation or fees. So, you know, there are, you know, this is sort of rule stems from some past abuse, where, you know, very limited percentage was actually going to the charity and the commercial fundraiser was making a lot of the money. This is illegal activity. You In the charity world, and also you have to disclose to the donors how much is going to the charity versus how much is going to the commercial fundraiser. So failure to disclose may create a potential infraction in liability. Volunteers, if you're wondering out loud, do these rules apply? Well, no, they're not paid. Professionals so to speak, they still have some rules of disclosure, but they don't have the registration requirements of their volunteer, they're not being compensated, okay. So these rules are really applying to people that are compensated typically. There's a, if you do a national campaign, and you're complying. There's now 41 states, I believe, that have affirmative registration that you have to do, there's a uniform form that they created, which, you know, attempts
55:58to simplify it, it's still quite complicated, unfortunately, called multi state, it's located at www dot multistream. state filing.org. Tries to standardize the form, you know, honestly, if it was going to be a lot easier for making charities comply with these sort of multi state registrations one form and one agency to sort of comply with would make it a lot easier. Unfortunately, that's not happened. And so you have to deal with individual states. And so these are things that are quite important. I think that I want to slightly shift gears right now, to board governance and board responsibility.
56:47Always an important topic for the board members to be aware of their fiduciary responsibilities. In California under Section 5210 of the California corporations code, the board has the ultimate authority over all activities of the organization, ultimate authority, okay, under Section 5212, California corporations code the board meet create committees, a committee must can consist of at least two or more bed member board members. And the board can rely upon professionals under 5231 B. It cannot, going back to committees for for a second cannot delegate certain things to committees, but can delegate a fair amount, they can rely upon professionals like CPAs, and lawyers and other folks that are in the industries that they need help with. The Lions should be reasonable and not negligence. Okay.
57:50And so, you know, the board has a lot of responsibility. They're supposed to report to each other, so to speak, the charities that, you know, have some obligations to be transparent, as I mentioned, under 6104 of the Internal Revenue Code. organizational documents, including the form 1023 990 should be made available to the general public. There's a lot of rules and regulations, we're going to finish up right now that apply to these charitable organizations, for different activities and things that they're involved with. So you really got to be aware of all these things. Again, knowing what you don't know just but knowing that, oh, they have there's some rules that affect boards, and let's be careful those rules and then you can always look them up. But this will sort of round out. What I call some of the tips and tricks for charitable organizations as it relates to the rules and regulations and things to sort of watch out for are the traps for the unwary. You know, for me, I very much enjoy advising charitable organizations and the board members and the professionals in the industry on the rules and regulations to help you help them avoid breaking some rules that they unknowingly are breaking, so that they can really just do more good without sort of the fear of repercussion. Thank you again, for LexVid for you know, having me be a speaker. I'm at WWW dot Seton law group.com.
59:39If you want to reach out, I've got a lot of information and education that I'm involved with. I put on regular, you know, talks and discussions and conferences bringing Changemaker people together in the charity world. I have a whole accelerator course taking A lot of charity folks through to learn how to build social capital tell inspiring stories generate funders and donors that are aligned with their charitable interests. I can be reached at any time at K Seton at SPL services.com. Thank you again
robert K.TX
Key takeaway is that this is a very technical and complex area. Discussion on Charitable Co-Venturers was more than worth the price of admission. Valuable presentation, but very densely packed.