1h 25min · about 13,600 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, and welcome to LexVid presentation on a legal guide through the adoption process and applicable federal laws. I'm calling Quinn, I'll be your host for this program. And I run the adoption surrogacy Law Center at my law firm of the Quinn Law Centers in Richmond, Virginia, just by way of a little bit of background. So you know, that I'm actually experienced in this area. And know what I'm talking about in terms of what we're going to cover today. I've been practicing adoption law now for almost 35 years, and am a member of the Academy of adoption and assisted reproduction attorneys actually had been on the Board of Trustees and served as president of that very esteemed organization.
0:47I also have written the last five versions, I've co authored the last five versions of the Virginia CLE book on adoption procedures and forms. I'm also a member of a number of different organizations that are applicable to this area of practice, that would include the LGBT bar, it also would include the American Bar Association, Family Law Section, those are just two of the organizations that also touch upon adoption laws. So without going into a lot more details about some of my accolades, hopefully, that'll make you comfortable enough to know that I indeed, am experienced in this area, as we walk through the next about hour and 15 minutes to maybe hour and a half. For this program. I do have about 90 slides to cover and the area of adoption law is pretty intricate. So we will need to devote sufficient time to make sure we cover everything. All right. So when we do an overview on different types of adoptions, and it can be very confusing for clients when they go to the internet. And they plug in the word adoption, it's very confusing to try to figure out what are the different entities and how does adoption law work. And there's so many different types of adoptions out there. So when we look at the different types of adoptions, I normally like to tell my clients that I break it down into two hemispheres. Basically, there's to two worlds of adoption. And I try to tell them that most of adoption law can be broken down into the all inclusive agency world, or the non agency world. That's how I like to separate it. The all inclusive agency world would include your
2:48international adoptions, which are commonly agency placements. Also, your foster care placements are agency placements, it's just that they're done by the public agencies Department of Social Services or Department of Children and Family Services in some states. And then there are also the all inclusive domestic agency placements, where that domestic agency will quarterback and do the entire adoption, we're going to go into a little bit more detail on that as we go through these slides. And then over here are the non agency adoptions. And they're often often called different things, which makes it even more exceedingly confusing. So in Virginia, they're called parental placements.
3:32But in other states, they're called independent or direct or private. Throughout this program, I'm going to generally call them direct point rental placements. And this is where typically, a lawyer will quarterback the adoption process. So if we kind of divide the world of adoption into these two hemispheres, it makes it a little bit easier to understand. And then there are a lot of ancillary folks that are associated with adoptions, such as consultants and websites where people can post their adoption profiles. And there are facilitators and even licensed facilitators out in California. And these are all kind of ancillary folks that operate to support these two different hemispheres. So if we break it down that way, then hopefully it'll be a little bit easier to understand the different types of adoptions. So international adoptions, foster care, adoptions, domestic agency, adoptions fall into this all inclusive agency category, and then the direct or parental placement, private, independent and fall into the non agency category. All right, so let's talk first about international adoptions. They're generally done by experienced agencies and just a handful of qualified attorneys, most of whom have to On behave accredited, and in some countries a full adoption will happen.
5:06Whereas in other countries, the adoptive parents may only be given guardianship and may not have been permitted to fully adopt the child. Different countries have different requirements or restrictions in terms of the characteristics of the adoptive family, there might be age restrictions, if it's an adoptive couple, it may be that there are two ages combined cannot exceed a certain number. In some countries, single parents in same sex parents are not permitted to adopt. There may also be medical restrictions. So it's important when folks are looking to adopt from an international from another country and do an international adoption, that they know what that country is going to permit or not permit. Prior to COVID, the number of international adoptions already were dropping. And then of course, with COVID, when travel was banned, etc. The international adoptions just dramatically dropped in number. These adoptions typically will take a year and longer to accomplish in some cases, it can take many years, it's very hard to get a newborn given the amount of time that it takes for a child from another country to be cleared to adopt. And then medical prenatal care and background information oftentimes are difficult to obtain. Many of these infants have just been abandoned. They've they've been left at the hospital, they've been left at a farmhouse door. And so oftentimes, it's even difficult to know the date of birth or the age of the child. And then of course, international adoptions can be pretty risky with with
6:51volatile countries. We've all read stories about countries opening and closing their doors to adoption. So the Hague Convention on the Protection of Children, and cooperation in respect of inter country adoption, is an international agreement to safeguard international adoptions. It was originally enacted in 1993 in The Hague in the Netherlands, and it established international standards of practice for inter country adoptions. The United States signed on to the convention in 1994. But the convention didn't enter into full force in the United States until 2008. So what does it mean to be part of The Hague? Well, the Hague conference has at least 82 members. And basically, if you're a member of The Hague, then you agree that you're going to follow the head walls for doing any sort of international adoption. And certain countries took different amounts of time to embrace the Hague on there are still countries out there that have not signed off on the Hague. So for countries that do belong to the Hague, the adoptions follow a more uniform and safeguarded process, and only Hague accredited providers, that is agencies and attorneys can be utilized. I am not a Hague accredited attorney that takes
8:19paying a fair amount of money and it takes going through a lot of hoops. And it takes a lot of expertise to stay Hague accredited. And so there are only a handful of 100 credit lawyers. Typically, the Hague accredited organizations are adoption agencies that are well heeled and working with that particular country. So if someone comes to me to do an international adoption, and they want to pick a particular country, then typically what I will do is I will network through the Academy of adoption and assisted reproduction attorneys to locate an attorney that has been working with an agency that has is well heeled has a good track record with that particular country. In 2014, the UAA was passed that is the intercountry adoption, universal accreditation act of 2012. That got signed into law on January 14 2013. And then it went into effect 18 months later on July 14 2014. So what does the UAA do? Well, basically, under the EU a adoption service providers working with prospective adoptive parents in non Hague Convention adoption cases, still need to comply with the same accreditation requirements and standards that apply to Hague Convention adoption cases. So basically, the USDA said, look at you head countries that have decided not to join. We're still going to hold you the same accreditation standards. We're still going to make sure we're safeguarding these adoptions, and that The same standards are being met. So it requires the Hague accreditation of all adoption service providers. And it basically has eliminated independent or private
10:09international adoptions entirely, and requires that this compliance, that this uniformity be followed with regard to the safeguards that the Hague put into place. What has that done? Well, it is actually continued to cause international adoptions to plummet in numbers. So we are not seeing a lot of international adoption activity. Right now, although international adoptions still are happening and can happen, they just need to be with countries that have a good track record and that haven't opened and then shut their doors. And so we can still guide folks to do international adoptions, and there still are plenty of needy children to be adopted. But they just have become a little bit more difficult couple of federal laws that apply to international adoptions, of course, the Immigration and Nationality Act, any international adoption, is going to have to address the citizenship of the child. And then there's also the inter country adoption Act, which implemented the Hague Convention, which is kind of a sister convention to the Hague Convention. Also, when we're looking at international adoptions, we want to be familiar with the child Citizenship Act, that basically gives you a citizenship to children adopted by American citizens who meet the requirements that are listed out on that slide. And I'm not going to go through the full list. But we can see what those requirements are for citizenship. The accuracy for adoptees Act is a really neat at the Academy was integrally involved in getting this Act passed when I was on the
12:01board. And it basically allows adoptees from other countries to have their names and ages changed. Remember, I said some of these kids are abandoned on the, you know, at the hospital at the farmhouse step at the orphanage. And they don't come with a birth certificate, or a note that says, you know, I my date of birth was this. So and then also, we have countries that have given children on purpose of lower ages in order to try to get them placed for adoption. So what the accuracy for adoptees Act does is it allows us to go ahead and change the child's on name and date of birth, as indicated on a state court order or a state vital records document and fix what might be the wrong date of birth, in particular for that child, when they came from the other country? And how do we how do we know like what is the accurate age of a child? It's mainly through the dentist. When the it's not just a pediatrician, the pediatrician can do an exam and kind of be able to determine based on the growth of the child age, but actually, the dentists and dental records on tend to be able to best pinpoint so when I'm doing real adoption, or an adoption out of a guardianship from another country. And there's a question about the child's age. A lot of times I will I will be using a dentist affidavit in support of correcting that child's age. All right. So what is the role of a local attorney if you're not hitting accredited, like I'm not hitting accredited, I can guide adoptive parents to the right country and try to get them using the right
13:44agency. For that country, I can stress the importance of getting certified translations of all the paperwork. We have folks come in with boxes of stuff from their international adoption, and sometimes it's just a mess and they haven't gotten all the right translations. So we want to make sure they get the right documents and the right translations. We can give them kind of an overview and then we'll handle the real adoption or what's called the finalization or domestication of a foreign adoption, or it might be an adaption out of a guardianship. The timeframes for joinery adoption can vary from state to state in Virginia, for example, it can be six months to a year with regard to if post placement visits are going to be needed. And then a lot of countries and agencies have their own requirements in terms of the number and timing of post placement visits. Just be aware that us birth certificate from a re adoption is not evidence of citizenship. That's a separate process with regard to the citizenship of the child. Some states have a simple route to obtain a US birth certificate, but that is not a real adoption. Virginia has that route but it requires almost as much paperwork as doing the real adoption. But the reasons for joining Adoption include that it might be necessary if only guardianship was attained. The RE adoption, the United States will negate any underlying procedural irregularities in the foreign adoption. So it's kind of like if that country failed to notify or properly notify a biological parent
15:18or something, it will negate that irregularity. The RE adoption puts the foreign born child on equal footing with the US born child, the reduction will result in a US issued birth certificate, which post 911 became really important for kids to have us issued birth certificates. And of course, the RE adoption can be used to change the child's name on the date of birth, or the age of the child as well. You just have to make sure that you watch out for visa and passport irregularities and make sure the clients go back and fix any prior passports or pieces that were issued for the child with a new date of birth. Alright, if you're doing any international adoptions or working in this area, you need to watch out for immigration issues, I oftentimes will have folks in the United States say, Oh, my niece is over here from India, I'd like to adopt her, we have to be really careful that we're not violating international adoption laws and also that adoption, that relative adoption that nice is not going to get that child citizenship. So I always refer these to immigration counselor, because I don't do immigration work. And I want to make sure that we're not messing anything up in terms of that child's citizenship. In many cases, the child may have to do a real adoption in order to get a certificate of citizenship, especially if they only came in on a guardianship. Alright, so now we're gonna switch gears and we're gonna step away from international adoptions, and we're going to talk about domestic adoptions. And we're going to go back to this
16:50two worlds that I talked about those two hemisphere hemispheres. And we're going to talk about the legal difference between all inclusive agency adoptions versus the non agency adoptions. The biggest legal distinction is that an all inclusive agency adoption, the placing parent is placing legal, physical custody with the agency in a foster care case, the placing parent, they're not really placing the child, they're getting their rights terminated. And the foster care agency has stepped down due to abuse, neglect, or abandonment, as basically taking the child from their home giving them every opportunity to take measures to get the child back. But in that case, it's still the agency that's taking that legal and physical custody, even if it's not voluntary. Versus the non agency placements, the direct current and potential placements and those placements, the placing parents are placing physical and legal custody directly with the adoptive parents.
17:55So in the agency world, there's an intermediary that is the agency that's holding that legal and physical custody, versus in the non agency direct parental placement world, there is no intermediary, it seems a little bit strange, because a lot of domestic agency adoptions, the family will go to the hospital and they will take the baby from the hospital. But what is happening there and that all inclusive agency arrangement is that the placing parent is signing a documents over to the agency. And the agency takes physical and legal custody, and then then they're turning around and directly giving temporary physical custody to the adoptive parents. So that's the biggest legal distinction. With the all with the agency adoption, I call it the all inclusive resort. Because normally, if a family is doing a domestic agency adoption, they're going to pay one big ticket price to have the agency do everything they're going to other agents who agency is going to locate that placement situation. They're going to gather the information on the placing parents, they're going to handle any expenses needed by the placing parents. They're going to handle taking on treatments or relinquishment. And they may do everything except finalize the adoption. So I call the finalization the airline ticket to the all inclusive resort, because sometimes the finalization will be included in the package and sometimes not. If it's not included, then it really doesn't cost that much. We typically charge about 1200 for fee plus
19:31costs to finalize agency adoption. And when we talk about agency adoption cost though the cost of the all inclusive agency adoptions are running, generally about 35 to $70,000. So it's not a huge amount. That airline ticket remember in an agency adoption agency does not represent the adoptive parents or the placing parents. So the role of the adoptive parents attorney would be to provide legal oversight during the adoption process. As I might review the agencies contract, I might review on whether the agency is complying with applicable state laws and doing the adoption, I might ask a lot of questions about has adequate information been obtained. Regarding the placing parents, medical history and whatnot? Do we have adequate information about the birth father or potential birth fathers. And then the attorney also might finalize that agency adoption. So when we look at the non agency adoptions, that is direct parental placements, I call those ala carte they're not all inclusive. On typically the adoptive family is going to pay separately for the adoptive families attorney, the placing parents attorney, they are going to pay the agency to do their home study, birth parent counseling, and they're going to pay typically, in many states for a guardian ad litem for the baby, that's an attorney for the baby. They're gonna pay living expenses and medical bills and other lawful expenses, either directly or through their attorney.
21:00And believe it or not, when we look at when we go to an all inclusive resort, we think that that typically is a better deal. But in the adoption world, the all inclusive, agency route tends to be more expensive than the ala carte a direct funnel placement route. So not the same thing as going and getting a fixed pre meal at a at a restaurant where you think you're getting a better deal on the ala carte world in the adoption world tends to be less expensive to pay everybody separately. So in the direct parental placement, the role of the adoption agency is to be a it's kind of a support role. And so in this ala carte, direct parental placement role, they're going to do various support services, but they're not going to quarterback the adoption. Instead, in this terminal placement world, it's going to be the attorney that quarterbacks the adoption. And typically, that's the adoptive parents attorney. I have quarterback the adoption before as the placing parents attorney in Virginia, but it typically works best to be representing the adoptive parents attorney. Alright, so in this non agency world, the adoption agency and playing that support role, they might be preparing the home study doing birth parent counseling, and then in many cases, they might be preparing reports to court. In Virginia, we have two levels of reports. One is a report of investigation. Another one is a report of visitation. And then typically, at the fundamental level, they might be taking the home study report and supplementing it with information for the
22:40court. And then a lot of times, as part of the report of visitation, the home study agency might be doing post placement visits. So when we are looking at the direct final placement over here, typically the eight adoption agency is not doing the match over here and the all inclusive world. That's why they're getting paid those big bucks is because they're actually locating the placement situation and doing the match up. So over here in this direct funnel placement world, usually the adoptive parents and placing parents find each other directly. And we're going to talk about some of the networking processes that are used. So why is there such a big price difference between the all inclusive world and the ala carte world? Well, this all inclusive agency is incurring a lot of marketing and administrative costs to try to drive placing parents to that agency to do that placement on and so that represents a lot of the cost savings between the all inclusive agency and the parental placement. So in these parental placements on how do these adoptive parents and birth parents find each other it's normally by networking on that is world of word of mouth, that's really important. They might be using social media, they might be networking on Facebook, they might be doing eblasts I do training sessions for my clients on all the different ways that they can potentially connect up with a a placing parents. There are some agencies that provide a match only service fee like Abby's one true gift, will they'll just do the match and charge a match
24:22only fee. There are a lot of websites out there where adoptive parents can post their profiles. We've got a list of maybe 15 different websites including adoption.com parent profiles adoptive miss, parent finder, etc. Sometimes attorneys can do a match I periodically will be approached recently was approached by grandparents who had suddenly been charged with taking care of their 18 month Special Needs granddaughter and their approximate about six month grand son The birth father didn't want to have anything to do with the children and the daughter, what had drug issues. And so, in that case, the grandparents just found that the kids were too much to handle. And so we're looking for an adoptive family family and approached me as an attorney to do that. So sometimes attorneys will assist with that, that matching that might take place. Attorneys have to be careful about whether or not they can charge for that I do not charge for that because of certain restrictions under Virginia law. So if I do match placing parents and adoptive parents than we do that at no charge, because Virginia has got very strict restrictions on what can be paid and adoption as the most states. A lot of folks will connect to through distant family, third cousins, through neighbors to church through work through medical providers through OB GYN, and the direct parental placements have been tending to go up in numbers. While the all inclusive agency placements have been tending to drop in numbers over the past few years. Of course, all placements of any
26:11healthy newborns were dropped dramatically, with COVID. Alright, so what is a facilitator? A facilitator is not a licensed child placement agency or adoption agency. It's it's a broker, basically facilitators, a broker. And in California, they actually recognize licensed facilitators, and that's legal, but many states. In fact, most states, including Virginia, prohibit payments to facilitators. So it's really important to advise our clients in Virginia to make an unlawful payment is actually a it's a crime. And so we want to make sure that we're advising our clients not to be committing a crime in this adoption process.
26:56So when we talk about consents, and consent, in an all inclusive agency placement versus in a direct parental placement, they get called different things which gets a little confusing. For the most part, when a placing parent is placing with an all inclusive agency member, she's giving legal and physical custody to that agency. She typically signs in entrustment or entrustment agreement. It's often in some states, it's also called a relinquishment. And they're normally taken outside of court. It can be in front of two witnesses, it might be in front of a notary, it might be in front of an attorney, and a social worker varies from state to state. And in, in very rare instances, it might be called a consent but for the most part, it's called an interest in our relinquishment. On the other hand, in the direct parental placements, the placement parent typically signs the consent. However, in a couple of states, it is called the relinquishment. And so that can get a little confusing, but for the most part, you signed consents in direct control placements, and interest payments or relinquishment in agency placements. So when these documents get signed, there's something called a wait period, and then a revocation period. So in some states, there might be a 48 hour wait period after birth, such as in Kansas, for example. And then upon signing, there is no revocation period in Kansas. So when I placed in parents signs her consent, 48 hours after birth in Kansas, her consent at that point is irrevocable, she cannot revoke it, how,
28:37however, many states have not only have a mandatory wait period, but they also have a revocation period, Virginia gets a little confusing, because it's different for all inclusive agency adoptions versus our direct parental placements. And so that can make it a little bit more confusing when you're talking to clients to try to explain the differences between weight and and revocation periods. So remember, the weight period is how long do they have to wait? Normally, it's good practice for the placing mom who's just given birth to wait at least 48 hours because she has just given birth. And there might be medications in her system still. But everybody's just gone through a traumatic event. So I typically as a matter of practice, even if there's not a 48 hour wait period, I still, if I'm representing a placing parent that just given birth, I will not allow her to sign anything until at least 48 hours after birth, and I also want to make sure she's got no heavy duty medications in her system. So that's the wait period. The revocation period is how long you have to undo your signature Once you have signed and that can vary from state to state. Some states even have up to 30 days to change your mind. And then some states have the have For up to 30 days, but then they have a you can waive the 30 days. So it's in any of these situations. So it's just really important to make sure that before that placing parent goes to sign anything that they are truly ready to sign that document. And nobody is, is placing any undue influence on them, and
30:22they've had adequate time to think about their decision. So termination of parental rights in adoptions can be done by the voluntary relinquishment, and trust mints or consents, sometimes they're signed in court. Sometimes they're signed, as I mentioned before, a notary or two witnesses or a lawyer or social worker or combination thereof. Also, in many states, a birth father can sign a denial of paternity or a waiver. And in many states like Virginia, he can do that prior to the birth. Sometimes a birth parents rights will be terminated just by giving them notice and they fail to object or appear.
31:01Also in in a number of states such as Virginia, if a putative father will talk about that fails to register with a registry that might be grounds to terminate. In some states, a placing mom may have a constitutional right to refuse to name or disclose the birth father's identity. But that varies greatly from state to state in Virginia, we don't really have that option. So in some states, the placing mom may be able to affirm that the identity of the birth father's not reasonably ascertainable, or that his whereabouts are unknown. And that might be sufficient, along with perhaps checking that state's birth father registry, birth, parent rights, in some instances can be shown via abandonment. Virginia does not have prenatal abandonment, but some states do have a concept of prenatal abandonment where the birth father was not supporting the child during the pregnancy. And then most states have us some way to terminate parental rights by finding that the objecting parent is unfit or that they're objecting contrary to the best interests of the child. Okay, so we're going to switch gears, we're going to talk about the cost of adoptions. The most inexpensive adoption is from the foster care system, of course, where the child oftentimes comes with subsidy monies. And these adoptions typically result in the adoptive parents getting their legal fees paid their home study costs covered by both state and federal funds. And then oftentimes, the child will have a continuing subsidy after the adoption and also generally can stay on
32:40Medicare or excuse me, Medicaid, or the state equivalent of Medicaid. So the downside about the adoptions out of foster care, although they might be the most inexpensive, or the least expensive, or the folks may not have to come out of pocket at all. The downside is that typically you don't see children freed up to be adopted out of foster care until about age six or up. Sometimes there might be an aberration, there might be a sibling set that's younger than that. But it just takes so long for those parental rights to be terminated and the children to be freed up for adoption that we typically don't see children out of foster care freed up to adopt until that age six or higher, that does not include the children who might be in a foster home. And those foster parents might be lucky enough to have cared for that infant since birth, and then end up adopting that child. I always tell folks don't go into being a foster parent thinking you're going to adopt because foster parents their primary role is to take care of that child and then work with the Department of Social Services to return the child to their family of original origin.
33:55If those birth parents, you know, have rectified their issues with neglect, abandonment, etc. Or alternatively, the foster parents are to help support DSS find relatives or kin. That is people like relatives to take the child. And so I tell folks don't go into being a foster parent thinking you're gonna be able to adopt that child, because you're signing an agreement that your role is to take good care of that child and to support the family attorney, excuse me, the child returning to the family of origin. All right. Well, we look at the comparative cost of adoptions. The most expensive adoptions tend to be international generally ranging from 40,000 to 60,000.
34:43Although some impoverished countries like Haiti might be less than that. The domestic agency adoptions really have gone up in price since COVID. And since we've seen a drop in the available number of healthy newborns, so domestic agencies options can run about 35 to 70,000. I'm seeing a lot of agencies with their pricing at around the 50 to 60,000 Mark. And then the least expensive adoptions tend to be an in state direct parental placement, where no living expenses or medical bills need to be paid, they can generally be done for about $20,000 or less. If we look at the breakdown of that $20,000, sometimes even under $15,000, if it's an in state rental placement, the adoptive parents attorney typically will run about three to $6,000 on especially if the adoptive parents attorney is located close to the court that's involved. If a court appearance is needed, the placing parents attorneys oftentimes 1000 to 3000, The Guardian Ad Litem that's the baby's attorney around 500. And then of course, the adoption agency support services, including home study, post placement visits, etc, might run about 4000 to 6000. Some of those numbers might be a little bit higher in other states and areas, including in certain more populated cities. But still, even if you bump those numbers up, you can still see that these in state direct placement adoptions oftentimes can still be done under that $20,000 mark.
36:23When we look at Interstate adoptions, that does add to the price tag, but the direct parental placements still tend to be much less expensive than the all inclusive agency placements, they still can be done around 20 to $30,000. For an interstate direct parental placement, why is there an added cost, it's mainly because of the interstate approval process that we'll talk about, which requires more legal work for the sending state to give permission and then the receiving state to get permission for those adoptive parents to leave with that little baby citizen and cross state lines and go from the sending state to the receiving state. The National electronic interstate compact system has really helped bring cost down for that interstate approval process by allowing for electronic filings and transmissions. But not all the states have signed up to be on the national electronic nice system. And so in some cases, we're still doing these paper filings. And of course, in any situation if substantial living expenses or medical bills have to be paid. And that's going to drive up the cost of the adoption as well. So I've got this cute little cartoon here, where costs and high demand can be barriers to some adoptions, and you've got the social worker saying, congratulations, Mr. Smith, your new adopted child is here, if you can reach them before the buzzer. And the Minister Mr. Smith has to go through the alligators through the boiling acid to the marshmallows that are now packed and ammonia, before he can finally get to the to the baby. And so, yes, the costs
38:03and also the high demand, especially for newborn infants can be barriers to folks trying to adopt a real myth, they'll have clients come to me and think it's just, you know, some child out there is in need. And they're, you know, they're available to adopt that healthy newborn, like, not so easy. There is a limited supply and high demand. And then with COVID with kids not in college and high school, and folks not going out to bars and beaches and whatnot. And we saw a big drop in the UPS factor. We also saw, you know, the government assisting folks financially. And so we saw a huge drop, we did see an increase in some of the relatives and grandparent adoptions, especially with the opiate crisis. But a lot of folks thinks that they think that there are just these, you know, babies that are available. And that's not the case. adoptions do cost a lot.
39:00And there is typically a pretty long wait period for folks to be able to adopt at least a newborn. There are a lot of children available in foster care, but they're gonna be those older children. So when folks do go to adopt, sometimes they get sticker shock. I have clients be like, Whoa, even the clients that have had this situation fall right into their lap, and they're like, Oh, we just got this call and this woman wants us to adopt her child. They're flabbergasted how much the cost of a home study is going to be etc. So I do try to give resources to folks, I tell him about the adoption tax credit, or they can look to Employer Assistance, including the military, they can take out a loan against retirement and then pay it back when the adoption tax credit gets. They get the adoption tax credit after they finalize their adoption. Or there might be family gifts.
39:54They can do fundraising church, GoFundMe. There's a great website WW fertility within reach.org That includes a lot of grant organizations. The Academy has a family formation Charitable Trust, which gives out grants on folks who do equity lines of credit. Or there's another fellow how Kauffman that has my adoption advisor that has a lot of good ideas on it on garage sales, etc, for people to be able to help fund their adoption. Alright, we're going to switch gears again now, we're talking about special types of adoptions. And in this situation, we're going to break out parental placements and break them down into the special types of adoptions. So, direct parental placements, which are over in this world. This hemisphere here include close relative adoptions, adult adoptions, step parent or second parent, second parent adoptions and also non relative placements. And some of these special types of adoptions can be streamlined in many states and not quite as complicated as a non relative parental placement. So a step parent adoption is normally when one spouse is the biological adoptive parent of the child and the other spouse is not step parent adoptions are typically where you have a married couple on there's gets to be some confusion between second parent and step parent step parent is when they're married. Second parent is when they're not married. And second parent may just may not be a committed couple, it could be like a mother and a daughter adopt together or two unrelated foster parents that
41:41have been co fostering can adopt together. So the step parent and second parent adoption, they're very similar, but one typically step parent has the marriage component and second parent does not have the marriage component. All right. When we look at step parent or second parent adoptions, a lot of my LGBT families, especially my same sex, female, parents, will wonder whether they should do an adoption. And the answer is yes, that's the National Center for Lesbian Rights. The LGBT bar equality Council all recommend that the adoption order is obtained to back up the birth certificate even if they're already both listed on the birth certificate. Also, in many of these cases, the ladies will have used a sperm donor from a cryobank and that sperm donor will have signed a release or you know, some sort of document with the with the cryobank and in most states or at least statute that supports or backs up that release, but not in all states. So by doing that adoption, it will help definitively terminate that those donor rights, which is another reason to do that adoption. In those cases, typically, you'll need to get the clients get a copy of the sperm donor release or an affidavit or letter from the cryobank saying that the donor did in fact, sign a release. Just be aware that contested step parent and second parent adoptions oftentimes can be pretty contentious, and oftentimes unsuccessful if the other parent has been involved in the child's life and is not unfit. So oftentimes, I'll have clients come to me, they want to do a stepparent a second
43:40parent adoption. And I'll have to tell them that if that parent that they're trying to cut out of the picture is a decent guy or gal, that we're not going to really be successful and getting that done. Of course, the standard varies from state to state. And you might be able to get these adoptions done being an open adoption or continued contact type agreement. It might be that the one parents willing to sign off and consent to the adoption, because they no longer want to have a child support obligation. But if they have an ongoing contact agreement, they'll still be able to have some contact with the child. So in these second parent adoption cases, you've got to be able to convince the judge that the two parents that are co parenting truly have established an enough of a joint connection to the child that it's going to be as successful adoption. So whenever I do these consults, I try to get as much information as I can from the clients and pack that into my petition. I want to get information about their education, their background, what they do for a living, how long you know, the the second parent that is seeking to adopt who has been involved with the child, I wouldn't really want to be able to convince the court that this is a good thing for the child. And then note that California and some other states that have adopted the current uniform parentage Act actually allow for more than two parents did not prevent permit multiple parent adoptions.
45:13I did a law review article for the International Association of matrimonial lawyers International Academy of matrimonial lawyers a few years ago, called Mom, mommy and daddy and dad, daddy, and Mommy. And if you want a copy, you can just email me but I tried to capture at that time, the states and countries that did recognize three and four parents for a child. All right, so moving on about special types of adoption. Another one are the relative adoptions and many states have streamlined procedures where the adoptions among relatives, but that can vary again from state to state. In Virginia, if the child's not been in the home for more than two years, our folks still have to go through a home study process. That is not the case. In a lot of states. In many states, a relative adoption will be more streamlined and not require the home study. Be careful if it's a relative adoption going across state lines, because the definition of relative under the entered state compact on the placement of children is typically narrower or more narrow than the definition of relative and a lot of state statutes. So while an adoption might be considered a relative adoption, under Virginia statute, which is pretty broad, the definition of relative under the Interstate Compact is, is more narrow. So if you are doing a relative adoption across state lines, you may still have to comply with the interstate compact and get approval for that child's across state lines. I've given you the interstate compact exception. Here is an example from the Virginia statute. And you
46:59can see that if it's a narrow relative placement, and you're sending or bringing a child that has been done by the child's parents, that parent, grandparent adult brother or sister or adult uncle or aunt or guardian that is exempt from the interstate compact. But if you compare that definition to Virginia's statute on close relatives, you'll see that our definition of close relatives is much broader and includes an adoption by the child's grandparent great grandparent adult nephew or niece adult brother or sister adult uncle or aunt, great uncle or great on step parent adult stepbrother, stepsisters or other adult relatives of the child by marriage or adoption. So you'll note there that adult great uncle or great aunt might fall under Virginia's definition of close relative, but that is not exempt from the interstate compacts definition. So just be careful there if you're doing a relative adoption across state lines. And then you always want to check the law of the other state. For example, I was doing a relative adoption several years ago, which we thought was going to be really simple. Because my clients in Virginia, had the child in their home for a long period of time, and we just had to get the birth mother's consent from Colorado. But when I checked with the Colorado colleague, I discovered that birth mother in Colorado was not allowed to sign a valid consent without having an adoption agency involved and doing counseling. So it became a much more involved adoption than I originally anticipated. But
48:40it's so it's really important to check with an attorney in that other state and make sure you're not about to violate that other state's law by having that person sign a consent. All right. Adult adoptions, typically the adoptee is over 18 They're pretty simple. The consent of the birth parents is not required. Typically no court hearing is required. In some states, you need a 15 year age difference. Sometimes they can be really closely scrutinized, especially if the child is young. If it's an adult, that's 1819 20. The judges oftentimes will scrutinize what's going on in that situation. So I like to pack a lot of information into my petition about why this this child at such a young age child is actually now an adult but this young adult at this young age, is now wanting to essentially have new parents and no longer have the biological parents be the legal parents anymore. Right the home study, when is that required? Well, the home study is going to be the anchor to almost any adoption, except for the step parents second parent adult adoptions, most relative adoptions, or adoption by a person named in a will where that's applicable. So what is the home study? A lot of times clients will ask skew, you know, what is it what's involved, it's usually done by a local licensed child placement agency or social worker on the prospective adoptive parents. It's usually about 2500 to 3500. Although I have seen that creeping up a little bit. It's usually done on a sliding scale basis. So it's normally based on the income of the adoptive parents
50:22with lower income parents having to pay less. And it usually requires criminal background checks, child protective service checks, medical clearances, a history of the medical, educational, vocational mental health history taken, the financial wherewithal of the adoptive parents is going to be reviewed, and then recommendations from non relatives that indicate that yes, these folks will be good parents. The agency then has to certify that those folks are suitable to adopt. And they're going to certify them as suitable to adopt a particular type of child like it might say that they are clear to adopt or certified to adopt a Caucasian child under the age of two, or a biracial child under the age of two, or a sibling set under the age of five. So there'll be a certain training on adoption issues and cultural competency issues that'll be provided that will then allow that family to be certified for a particular type and age of child. Passing the home study can be a little bit intimidating. It does involve intrusion into past medical, mental health, financial and criminal histories, certain crimes or barrier crimes that might prevent the person from being approved. And typically, it needs to be updated in Virginia, it's good for three years, but in most states, it's only good for one or two years, it needs to be updated. I did have an interesting story about a couple who were adopting. And the gentleman had a history of one criminal item in his background. And what he had done was he had gotten into a road rage where somebody cut
52:04him off. So we took the coins out of his little cop in his car, and he threw them out the window. And he was charged with attempted manslaughter by a flying missile or something like that, unfortunately, didn't use a lawyer to get the it all pled down, it was a misdemeanor. And it was nine and a half years old, we had to wait another six months for him to get home study approved for it to be more than 10 years. And at that point, he was able to get home study approved. So watch your road rage, don't throw your coins out the window. Alright. So one role of the adoption agency or the adoptive parents attorney is to make sure we gather accurate background information in these cases. In many instances, there might be an ongoing contact agreement. So the adoptive parents can still contact the biological parents and get additional information. But in some cases, the biological parents are going to place the child and disappear and in so we're the one opportunity we have to really capture the necessary information for this child is while we're in the adoption process, so we want to make sure that we get the full medical history and prenatal care history, social educational, religion, nationality history, including Indian heritage, we want to get as much information on the biological father, even if the placing mom says that she really doesn't have much information, she met the guy at the back of a bar, and it was a one night stand. And All she knows is His name is Joe, for the benefit of that child. This child still gonna want to know well,
53:38what did Joe look like? And was Joe, you know, athletic? Or was Joe thin or did Joe wear glasses, so we want to capture as much information. We also want to lay out what the hospital and adoption plan arm is going to look like. If the child hasn't been born yet, we want to map that out as well. All right, I'm going to switch gears now we're going to talk about special federal laws that are applicable to adoption. And they include the Indian Child Welfare Act, the adoption tax credit, and the servicemembers civil Relief Act. And so I'm going to zip through these I'm not going to read every slide on at this point, because there's a lot of information on these slides that don't just take me too long to dive into. But just be aware with the Indian Child Welfare Act, that if there is an issue of Native American Indian heritage by either birth parent, then there's the possibility that Iqua might be implicated. So we do want to check in and get more information about what is that Native American history. Um, some folks will romanticize their Native American Indian heritage, but not even really know which tribe and it has to also be a federally recognized tribe, unless we're dealing with a state many ICWA So some states have have their own little miniature it was. But if we're talking about the federal Indian Child Welfare Act, then we need to know whether the child could potentially be an Indian child or qualify as an Indian child with a federally recognized tribe that is on the national register.
55:21So, if you do have a situation where you may potentially have a child that qualifies as an Indian child under ICWA, we've got to explore that further. That includes gathering more history, um, from those biological parents about who was their parents that might have the heritage, who's the grandparent? What are the names of those folks, possibly contacting the tribe finding out what their requirements are for a membership is the parent is the grandparent on their rosters, gather a little bit more information to find out if it will, might be implicated. Also, whether the tribe needs to be notified depends on whether the placement is voluntary or involuntary. And the tribe should not be volunteers should not be notified if it's a voluntary placement. Even if the tribe is not involved. If the Indian Child Welfare Act does apply, then we've got to go through some additional hoops. And that is both birth parents have to sign their consents before a judge and they have to wait at least 10 days after the bars to be able to sign they also have expanded replication rights. So I'll tell you just a really quick war story I had a case through there was the placement was done through an agency. And the agency notified the potential prospective tribe that was out in the Midwest, over the birth mothers objection, they did not get her permission. And the tribe tried to intervene in that adoption, I was representing the adoptive parents in that placement. And when we went for the Consent Hearing where the placing mom was going to give her consent, the tribal representative
57:08and their lawyers showed up, we had already briefed the whole thing for the judge that the tribe did not have standing. And then we had the placing mom testify as to why the child was not an Indian child. The the placing mom did have American Indian heritage and it was within nationally recognized tribe. But she had tried to apply for membership twice in order to get the casino benefits that the tribe offered. So and twice she had been rejected by the tribe as a member. Um, so she was pretty ticked off that these people were trying to interfere with her adoption. And after we had her testify that she had tried to get membership twice and been rejected, the judge agreed that the child did not qualify as an Indian child and ask the tribal representative and the lawyer to please exit the courtroom. So in that case, the agency made the mistake of notifying the tribe in the first place. But these cases can get a little bit sticky. And I just tell you that worst story, if you are not super familiar and experienced ICWA, then you may want to consult with or bring in somebody as CO counsel that has that experience. A good point to start to study, it was the baby Veronica on the United States Supreme Court decision and then be aware of the Bureau of Indian Affairs guidelines and the pending lawsuits that are out there challenging the guidelines, because these cases can get pretty complex, if equal does apply. And then remember, I did mention that some states have those many it was like Oklahoma, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Arizona, that
58:48have more restrictive requirements than the federal ICWA. So if you operate in any of those states, or you're doing an adoption that implicates one of those states and interstate adoption, you've got to be familiar with those many it was real quickly the federal tax credit, it's basically a one time tax credit for qualified adoption expenses. And you can read they're also about some income exclusion for employer provided adoption assistance on whether or not if your employer assist you to what extent you can still take the adoption tax credit. The adoption tax credit does allow for reasonable and necessary adoption fees port costs attorney fees traveling expenses, including meals and lodging while away from home and other expenses directly related to the adoption, all to be bundled into that one time and credit. It is not available for step parent or adult adoptions unless the adult adoption has special needs. We do want to tell our clients from the very beginning to make sure that they keep track of all their expenses etc. So that they can take advantage of the adoption tax credit at the end of their case. Right now, the adoption tax credit for 2023 is a maximum of 15,009 50 per child. So almost 16,000, it changes from year to year. And if the modified adjusted gross income of the adoptive parents is underneath $239,230, they can take the full credit. And then that credit starts to phase out with a partial credit between income levels of $239,230, up to $279,230, after $279,230, at least for 2023. At that point, the adoptive
1:00:36parents will not be eligible for the credit. But I do tell folks that you never know if you're going to take time off from work once you bring this baby home or this child home. And so your income may drop even if they are above the maximum amount. special needs children are treated differently and adoptive parents can take the full credit even they have not incurred the full expense amount. So that's a whole different ball of wax. And I've got a article on that if it folks want me to email it to them. Alright, let's talk about the servicemembers civil Relief Act. This is really important if you are doing an adoption and either birth parent is in the military. Basically, this act prevents taking any legal action against somebody that is an active duty military. The purpose of the act is so that our service men and women can focus on doing their job and serving the country and not have to worry about defending against lawsuits or notices. Recognize that it's not just members of the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps and coast guard that are on active duty that fall under the act. Also National Guard members called to active duty and commission members of the Public Health Service and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration also fall under the act. So the Act provides special protections and we need to make sure we adhere to procedural safeguards under the Act, I can't send a notice letter to a birth father and basically tell him that he's got, you know a certain period of time to either register with the Virginia birthfather
1:02:19Registry, or that he's got a certain period of time to file an objection with the court with regard to this adoption. If he is under if he falls under that act. I can't proceed with that sort of legal action against him. So I've got to make sure I gather adequate information to find out whether a birth parent is in active duty military or false, somehow under the Act, otherwise, it's going to be my actions against them are going to be invalid. So we do want to be aware of the service members and sellers Relief Act. Alright, so let's just talk real quickly about interstate adoptions and the interstate compact. It doesn't matter whether it's an agency placement over here, or it's a direct rental placement over here, we still have to comply with the interstate compact. So agencies have to comply and attorneys have to comply. If we're crossing state lines, we've got to figure out conflict and choice of law issues. And we need to consult attorneys in both states. And the adoptive parents have to remain in the sending state and cannot go home to their home state, which is the receiving state until they get interstate approval from both states. So we typically want to look at the conflict, the choice of laws, and those states and decide under which status is adoption going to be happening. And it can happen in one of three ways. So let's say for example, we're doing interstate placement from Maryland to Virginia, on the entire adoption can either be done under Maryland law, if the adoptive parent if Maryland allows for Virginia residents to
1:04:00finalize in Maryland, or it can be done entirely under Virginia law, or we can do a hybrid that is we can do termination of parental rights and transfer custody in Maryland, and then do the adoption itself in Virginia. So we always want to do an analysis. And then we also want to determine what rules what procedures does each state have, if Virginia allows for an enforceable ongoing contact agreement, but the other state does not. And that's an that's important to that placing parent, well, then we may want to do the adoption under Virginia law so that we've got the ability to have that enforceable ongoing contact agreement. We may need to look at those state laws and determine under which state law is it going to be easier to terminate and objecting birth father's rights or to address the situation where there might be an unknown birth father or a birth father that can won't be found. In Virginia, we've just have to have the birth moms sign a statement saying that his identity is unknown or his whereabouts are unknown, and then we check our birth father registry. But in other states, the court actually will require the appointment of a guardian ad litem. So we do want to do that assessment and figure out what's going to be more advantageous.
1:05:20Typically, unless that relative exception that we reviewed earlier applies, we're going to need to get interstate approval, it normally starts with a 100, a form that signed by the sending parent on you want to make sure you know what each interstate office is going to require before you file the packet. And if you don't file the right documents, it can result in adoptive parents being stuck in that other state for a long period of time. So you always want to consult with an experienced adoption attorney in both states, you want to check with the ICPC office and the other state, you want to make sure that you don't mess up the ICPC. For example, I had a situation where the attorney completely terminated the horse mom's rights in Washington state before she signed the 100 a permission slip. She then signed the 100. A and Virginia ICPC took the position that her rights have been terminated, she no longer had standing to sign that document. And it just created a real mess in that situation. If if that attorney in Washington State had just checked with the Virginia Attorney, and he or she had signed the 100, a and that the ICPC package was signed before her rights were terminated it would fix that situation.
1:06:29So we want to make sure that we do that full assessment and these interstate placements, I want to look at the choice of law issues and the conflict of law issues. And you can read the additional slides in that regard. All right. I've got some examples there with regard to Kansas and Florida that you're welcome to read. But let's jump forward on to foster care placements. So these are typically publicly eight public agency placements that involve the involuntary termination of parental rights. And the role of the attorney in these placements is generally to oversee the adoptive placement agreement, the adoption assistance agreement, and make sure we get all the right documents to finalize the adoption, you've got to make sure that the subsidies have been addressed before you finalize that adoption and that the adoption assistance agreement is in place before you finalize that adoption. So be very careful in foster care placements. Be aware of the Adoption and Safe Families Act that was one of Bill Clinton's babies. And basically, it was intended to force states to streamline and expedite termination proceedings to try to move kids faster out of foster care. It's been very helpful, but still on we do have kids that tend to be in foster care for longer periods of time than they should be. Alright, so we're going to switch gears again and talk about when placing parents make an adoption plan. It's really critical for those placing parents to get adoption options counseling in person and not just by phone and to give them continued
1:08:08counseling. We want to make sure that you complete those exhaustive and comprehensive background forms and somebody goes over those with them to make sure we capture that information. We want to make sure that a placing mom who's pregnant gets prenatal care, and that we get her medical records. And it's always their plan. We want to make sure it's that they take ownership of that plan and that we respect the fact that it's their plan. We want to determine whether there's going to be ongoing contact, we want to make sure that they meet the adoptive parents, we will explore issues of drug and alcohol use, we want to figure out who's opposed to the adoption, who's supportive of the adoption. In situations where I've identified that the there are a number of people opposed to the adoption. I've been able to warn the adoptive parents, hey, this placing parent may want to do this adoption plan. But at the hospital, I have a feeling her parents are going to come in or sister's gonna come in birth Father's gonna come in and they're all going to get her to change her mind. So we do want to identify folks that support the adoption versus are opposed. And we also want to make sure adoptive parents make sure that we never have a crystal ball even though it looks like this placing parents gonna definitely place this child know placing parent 100% know they're going to go through with their plan, especially if they haven't actually seen that child come into existence. Real quickly. What is closed versus open mean in the adoption
1:09:37world. In past days closed was one of my best friend from high school. Her parents at age 17 her biological mother was whisked off to stay with an aunt and she was placed through Catholic Charities and she never knew who her biological parents were until her two full fledged siblings contacted her through Facebook when she was 35 years old. That was your traditional closed adoption, the placing parent never knew where that child went, had no ongoing contact. And while that's some closed adoptions can still happen. They're pretty rare at this point. Now most adoptions are considered open, open can mean a number of things, it can mean that the placing parents selects the adoptive parents, it also can mean that there's ongoing contact. So it does mean different things. I do have some examples in your materials about prior to 2007. Our agency placements were closed, and in 2007, that changed now at birth, mom can go to an adoption agency in Virginia and select the family. And she has the option of doing it as an agency placement or a direct parental placement. And then also in 2007, our open or direct placement adoptions changed to allow for the placing parent to select the adoptive parents, but decide that she doesn't want their full background information she doesn't want their last name, it makes it a little tricky when we go to court to try to prevent her from learning their last name. But we do have that option. And so the agency world and the direct placement world in the early 2000s became kind of blended in most states so that in
1:11:18either cut case, now the placing parent can pick the adoptive parents directly, but also has choices in terms of how much information she may want to share or have. Most states in terms of ongoing contact have what we call Pacus post adoption, continued contact agreements, they can range from everything from just the change of picture and letters to actual visits. Some states allow them to be enforceable in Virginia, they are enforceable, and we incorporate them into the final order of adoption. And these cases where we do have these enforceable ongoing contract agreements, failure to comply with the ongoing contract agreement is not going to be a basis to undo the adoption. Instead, the placing parent would have to go to court to basically enforce the ongoing contract agreement. And these agreements typically are worded so they have to be in the child's best interest. And so it could be that that placing parent is actively using drugs or alcohol. And so doing an actual visit with a child may not be in the child's best interest. We do try to craft these agreements really carefully. And if there is a history of the placing parent having a drug or alcohol issues, it may be that they actually have to do a drug or alcohol test before they're allowed to have a supervised visit with the child. Like maybe that the adoptive parents will just meet with them for a good 15 minutes to just kind of absorb their behavior before they'll actually be able to do that supervised visit. It's where for ongoing contact agreements to have supervised
1:13:04visits and ongoing actual in person visits. However, there are a good number of ongoing contract agreements that that do provide for that. So we do want to just put safeguards in if there are going to be actual supervised visits with the child. adoption has embraced a new psychology of openness. I think that's in large part on why we're seeing so many more direct parental placements, it's no longer, you know, nearly as taboo to be an unwed woman who has an unplanned pregnancy. Many times folks in her family will know. And then folks in her family will know someone from work or they'll know neighbors. And so with just kind of the new embracing of adoptions and the level of openness, we are seeing more of these direct parental placements happenings through such means as networking. And as part of that new psychology of openness. It's important if you are representing adoptive parents, to give them tools with regard to the child's psyche and making sure that that that that child is going to embrace the fact that they are an adopted child. So most families will develop a my birth story book. They'll even do a little actual soft bound book on Snapfish or Shutterfly, in which it'll be a storybook that shows who the biological parents are, might even show they might have half siblings out there. The biological parents may have other children. They'll show extended family, the biological parents show the hospital where the child was born. Sometimes a picture of the judge of a judge was involved. I've even had my photo in some of these my birth story books that have been
1:14:53put together by my clients. There are also lots of children's books out there now on adoption and it's really important for that A child from a very early age to be introduced to the concept of being adopted. And so that we don't have these awkward situations like my 35 year old best friend, having her two full siblings contact her on Facebook and suddenly finding out that she's adopted. And now there's this 35 year old secrets that her parents had kept. Although she and her two brothers all look so dramatically different that some of us suspected they might have been adopted. But really, what happened was her 217 year old parents went on, got married, had two more children. And now at age 35, out of the blue, she's contacted by her two full siblings. So in order to prevent against that sort of deep, dark family secret, making sure our clients embrace the concept of openness, and know to start reading that my birth story book to their child from a very early age, I went for an eye exam and the nurse. Once she found that I was an adoption attorney, she told me that she had a little my birth story book for her son. And he felt really special because he was the only kid in the class that had two mommies, or two daddies. And he actually wanted her to come to his kindergarten class and read his my birth story book on storybook day to the rest of his class. So I thought that was that was pretty cool and a pretty well adjusted child as well. Okay, a couple of things before we wrap up, and the remaining few minutes, recognize that if you
1:16:33are doing a interstate placement across state lines, some states like Virginia have protective statutes that protect state residents from signing and trust mints or relinquishment, or consents to other states that limit their rights. If the rights in that other state are more restrictive than Virginia, then we want to make sure that they know what they're doing. So by way of example, if I have a Virginia placing mom, who is going to sign a Kansas irrevocable consent 48 hours after birth, well, in order for her to sign that Virginia statute requires that she have her own lawyer, that her lawyer explained to her here are your rights under Virginia law, and you would have a longer period of time to wait on you would have three days to wait, you would have to go sign before a judge instead of a notary. And you would have seven more days to change your mind versus signing before a notary 48 hours after birth. And it being an absolute done deal. Are you sure you want to do that? And then it needs to be done an affidavit format, and the waiver needs to include even my phone number, my address, etc, in order to be a proper effective waiver. So if you are doing an adoption across state lines, and you're asking a placing parent in another state to sign a consent, you got to make sure you check with a lawyer in that state and find out you know, do they have a special statute like Virginia has, that's going to require you to do more? Because it could be that if you don't do more than that consent can be in it will be invalid or it can be negated. All
1:18:18right. And this requirement that Virginia has of this having separate legal counsel and signing a proper waiver. It applies not just to the direct parental placements, but it also applies to the all inclusive agency placements. So if they're sending an adjustment or relinquishment to an adoption agency in another state, they've got to have separate legal counsel and sign that proper waiver. So just whether it's agency adoption, or non agency adoption, we want to make sure we follow those requirements. In our few remaining minutes, we're going to just briefly talk about putative not punitive, but putative or birthfather registries. I can't tell you how many times people call them punitive. And they're not supposed to be punitive. The paternity registries actually are supposed to be helpful to adoptions and also protects the placing mother's privacy rights. So the US Supreme Court held these registers constitutional in 1983. In the case of Leia versus Robertson, some 35 or more states have paternity registries. Um, yesterday, I was on my independent adoption committee call with the Academy. And we were talking about the difficulty we have with the states that don't have registries because they make it more difficult for us to be able to accomplish our adoptions. So the concept of the registry is, is that if a birth if the birth father has sex, he's on notice of the fact that he could have sired a child and that child could be placed for adoption. And the reason for the registry in large part is to protect the placing mom against having to
1:20:00do orders of publication, these orders of publication or public notices in the newspaper that put her name out there, the fact she's given birth to the child and the fact that she's going to be placing that child for adoption, that's pretty intrusive stuff. So the idea of a pure registry is that she doesn't even have to name the guy or notify the guy. And many states have variations on that. In Virginia, if we know who he is, and where he is, we have to give them notice and his right to register. So there is something called the there's a proposed national registry that's been proposed for many years, it's not passed. But if we did have a federal registry, that we'll be able to link all states, and we could just check one national registry that might be introduced again, this year as the Papa act. It was originally drafted in 2006, as the proud father act, but it has yet to get past. The key thing when we're looking at the type of birth father is we need to categorize that guy. If he is an adjudicated dad via the court order. If he's acknowledged that he's he's been placed on the birth certificate, if he's presumed the dad, because he's married to the placing mother, if he's registered with a registry, then those types of fathers tend to get treated differently, then a non registered putative father that doesn't fall into any of those categories. So whatever I'm taking a case in, I'm trying to identify which category does this guy fall into. So if he falls into one of these categories on that gives him more rights. And typically, he's
1:21:40going to be entitled to notice that the adoption proceedings, and if he falls into the category of an unregistered putative birthfather, he may or may not be entitled to notice of his right to register, that is going to vary from state to state. And I just included Virginia's information on that. So if in Virginia, if he falls into the one of the categories, that makes him more of a dad, so to speak, he actually gets actual 15 days notice of adoption proceedings, if he falls into the category of a putative father, and we know who he is, and where he is, we have to give him notice of his right to register with the registry. And if we serve him personally, he has 10 days to register. If we send it by certified mail, and he's got 13 days to register, I do like to, if I'm doing it by certified mail, I like to back that up with Federal Express with proof of delivery, because a lot of times, they will not go pick up the certified mail card. So I do want to be able to show the judge that the guy actually got the packet, a couple of practice tips. If you are working with putative birth fathers or really birth fathers, generally, you want to try to contact them before you put something in the mail. Some of them can be they might not even know that the woman was pregnant and they'll feel left out. Also, you have to watch out for who they live with. If they live with a mother or a wife or a girlfriend, you live at the same address. Who doesn't know that they've had this extramarital affair, that could create some chaos. I typically will include the consent
1:23:20and denial forms along with a notice letters on giving them the option of signing a denial or consent or registering, I will include the actual registration form, I will include background forms with the hope that maybe they'll fill them out. And you want to make sure your instructions are very clear, because this is going to be an exhibit with the court. And then if we send it by Federal Express with proof of service, in addition to that certified mail, we'll have that as backup. So that closes out my presentation for the day. I know it's a lot of stuff to take in. But hopefully this gives you a really good overview of the whole adoption process the applicable federal laws. And on the final reflection, if you can look at these lovely characters here of folks holding hands with their children. We do want to protect the integrity of the adoption by knowing what we're doing. If you are just starting to venture into this area, please be sure to co counsel with more experienced counsel, purchase whatever books might be available. If you're in Virginia, the Virginia CLE book has forms in it. It's clear as clearly spells out the Virginia procedures. But we do want to protect the integrity of the adoption. I've been an expert witness in several legal malpractice cases. And one was a really egregious case where the attorney had the placing mom sign an out of court consent when she needed to sign it before a judge and the family in that case after having the child in their home for two years, thinking their
1:24:52attorney had done the adoption properly had to return the child to the to the birth family. So we've got to protect the integrity of Adoption and make sure that we do these right to protect these families thank you so much thank you LexVid for allowing me to do this program and you've got my email address if you need anything further thanks