1h 31min · about 11,200 wordsDownload Transcript
0:02Hi, everyone. This is Mike DeBliss. Today's program is the Fifth Amendment's essential role in offshore audits. This is one of my favorite topics because we get to talk about the intersection of law with tax. Those are basically the two topics that I'm really passionate about. I started this series with, with presenting these for basically, for lexvid to basically share a little bit of knowledge that I've gained in the last eight years or some doing practicing tax law. Basically, I got into this by accident. It was not intended. It was one of those things where I happened to be at the right place at the right time. I was in my third year of law school and I did an internship, or I guess technically an externship for a white collar criminal defense firm. I joined the firm just as they were going to start the trial of a white collar defendant. They were defending him on charges of money laundering. And as I'm sure many of you are aware, there are a number of collateral offenses that are charged with money laundering, such as structuring, as well as tax crimes.
1:35I was asked to do some research on the tax evasion count as well as some of the other tax counts in the indictment to see if there were grounds for a motion to dismiss. And I realized very quickly that tax law was a minefield. And while I had taken an elective in white collar crimes when I was in law school, this was a whole different ball game. I found myself researching the statutes and trying to discern what all these definitions were and what all of it meant. Because I had no background in tax. I didn't come from an accounting background. I wasn't a cpa. I wasn't an enrolled agent like everybody else. I was just somebody who had done my taxes, you know, from the time I had to start filing. And that was as much knowledge as I had in the area of tax.
2:32But I learned a lot from that experience. And as a side note, we did file a motion to dismiss the tax counts and it got denied. But I pretty much tucked that away, knowing that at some point I wanted to come back to tax law because I was very eager to learn more about it and specifically to carve a niche for myself in the area of tax crimes. I thought that specifically that area was very appealing. About six or seven years later, I'm a public defender in New Jersey, and I decide at that point that I want to go back to school, earn my master's in tax law. I did it at night while I was working, and, you know, I two and a half years later graduated and then decided to go into private practice. My first project was actually something that I would have never expected when I first began my LLM courses.
3:36And that was a call from an enrolled agent, not an accountant, but an enrolled agent for advice on compliance for a US Expat who was living abroad and was out of compliance with filing their international tax returns, specifically an fbar. I didn't know anything about it. I did some research and the next thing I knew I was on the phone with the client providing them with advice on coming into compliance and the rest is all history. I really got into the area of international tax compliance and launched a full scale practice catering to US Expats as well as any US Persons that were looking to find answers insofar as what their international tax obligations were. This is one of those presentations that came about as a result of my years of working in this area and I'm very eager to share it with you because once again, it's at the intersection of tax law compliance and the law.
4:52And we're going to be talking a little bit about everything here. So let us jump right in. So let's set the stage. There is an inherent tension between the government and the taxpayer when it comes to information gathering. This is no more apparent than in the case of an offshore audit where revenue agents are often armed with incomplete and potentially inaccurate information provided by foreign banks, and they need information that only the taxpayer or his accountant can provide in order to supply the missing link. If the government cannot get the requested documents, it often cannot make a case.
5:36So I want to preface everything that I'm saying here with this. Just because a person, a U.S. citizen or resident, is living in another country, doesn't mean that they are absolved from US Tax obligations. I want to start with that baseline requirement. Every U.S. person, regardless of where they are living, and it does not need to be on US soil. They have an obligation to file their 1040, just like every other US citizen living in the United States does. They also have a plethora of international tax reporting forms that they are obligated to complete. And that is what gives life to the Fifth Amendment in the context of an offshore audit. The other thing that is very important to know is that US Persons, and by US Persons, I'm not just referring to US Citizens.
6:55US Persons is a very specific, specific label that encompasses more than just US Citizens. I've already referenced US Residents. But person in the context of the Internal Revenue Code is not just limited to a human being, it also includes partnerships. It also includes corporations, LLCs, and a number of other legal entities. US persons have an obligation to report their income and pay taxes on their worldwide income, regardless of where it is derived. So you can have a person who is, you know, just give you a very straightforward example. It can be a US citizen who has lived for the last eight years, years in Brazil. And let's say that that US person owns a company in Brazil and that 100% of the clients of that Brazilian company are international, meaning that they are non US.
8:10Notwithstanding all of that, the US citizen who owns the Brazilian company and generates revenue and cash flow and profit from that Brazilian company is liable and is responsible to paying taxes on the income derived in Brazil from that Brazilian company, as unfair as that might seem. So the US Stands alone. I think there might be one other country in the world that taxes its citizens on worldwide income. This is a very controversial issue. However, it was brought to life by a very small US Supreme Court case called Cook vs Tate that I believe came out back in the 70s. And so that has been the law of the country ever since that any individuals, wherever US Persons, wherever they reside, must pay taxes on their worldwide income. And in this case, the U.S. citizen operating the Brazilian company, where there are zero U.S. customers of that Brazilian company, must pay taxes on the profit generated by the Brazilian company to the US Government in an effort to mitigate the, what we might refer to as double trouble international overlapping tax systems. Because of course, double trouble taxation in the form of overlapping tax jurisdiction. Of course, if the US Government is taxing the profits of the Brazilian company, we know that the Brazilian government is also taxing the profits from that company because the the company was formed in Brazil and it is a functional business on Brazilian soil.
10:19So the US Government basically has treaties with these foreign companies, foreign governments, that allow for mitigation of this harsh double taxation regime. When a tax treaty between the US and the foreign country doesn't exist, there's a credit system which I'm not going to get into in this presentation, but I just want to give you some background information so you understand why there might even be a challenge or a contest when it comes to an offshore audit. This is because again, US persons have international tax reporting obligations to the US Government and they also have responsibilities to pay taxes on their worldwide income to the US Government.
11:12So make no mistake about it, offshore audits, which are typically based on third party information received under fatca. So I'm going to introduce to you what is called the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act, FATCA for Short. Before we go any further, let me give you a little bit of background about FATCA. In the wake of 9 11, the government was looking for any low hanging fruit to begin to as enforcement tools to root out terrorism and terrorist organizations funneling money through our legitimate banking system.
11:55They discovered that there was what was called an fbar, the Foreign Bank Account Report. On the books from the 70s. It was a creature of the Bank Secrecy act, but it hadn't been enforced with the gusto that they felt it could be enforced with and that it could be a useful government enforcement tool and information gathering tool to help discover illicit, illicit and what we might refer to as criminal workings of the underworld as far as funneling money through our legitimate banking systems. So the FBAR was one of the tools. FACA was a new tool. As we all know, it's very difficult for the government to get new legislation passed. The U.S. patriot act is one that comes to mind in the aftermath of the US Patriot act being passed. You might remember the firestorm that erupted in, in Washington and throughout the country regarding privacy rights and how the government was really deemed to be very invasive and intrusive as far as the information that they were allowed to eavesdrop on as well as uncover from that was very benign information and violation of privacy, of basic privacy rights of US persons.
13:29FATCA deals with banking and when I say banking, it's not necessarily limited to foreign banks. It is broad enough to include government structures as well. But specifically FATCA wanted to clamp down. The Foreign Account Tax Compliance act wanted to clamp down on bank secrecy in foreign jurisdictions. So for example, consider Switzerland, which was like the, it was like the poster child of bank secrecy. Look no further than James Bond movies or those, those movies where you would see, you know, you would see suspicious looking people walk into a bank and provide like a code or a bank number and be able to access money from a secret bank account that was real, that wasn't fictional. It was actually, it was very real, this idea of bank secrecy. The government was looking for a way to clamp down on it and they realized that there was a dilemma that had to be that was going on, at least so far as the international banks were concerned.
14:56On the one hand, there was bank secrecy that was law in a country like Switzerland. And on the other hand, the US Government was very concerned about US persons taking advantage of the veil of bank secrecy in foreign countries like Switzerland to avoid or evade paying taxes to the US Government and evade disclosing disclosure of the foreign bank account altogether so the government attacked it like they attacked the drug problem during the Reagan era, if you remember. You know, there was a lot of emphasis on the bottom feeders going after the bottom feeders, which were like the low level drug dealers. And the government began to work its way like a funnel up to the top to get to the drug dealers and then the drug lords. And they would, they would not, you know, stop altogether the bottom feeders and the small time drug dealers, but they would also pursue all of those to the top, including the drug lords and the drug cartels and what have you. Similarly with FATCA looks, the FATCA act was what came about as a result of the government getting very frustrated with the challenges that existed for them to get taxpayers and U.S.
16:29persons to disclose their foreign bank accounts so that the income generated by those foreign bank accounts could be reported and that the US Persons would pay their tax bill on that income. And the government recognized that it was widespread, it was so widespread. So the government took a two prong approach through fatca. They began to say, okay, we're going to target the banks who are complicit almost in this idea of not disclosing of the US person, not disclosing their foreign bank accounts. How did the government do this? They realized that they had to put teeth in the threats that they were making to the foreign banks about prosecuting them if they didn't turn over US account holder information to the US government.
17:26And so the US government essentially strong armed the foreign banks into signing non prosecution agreements with the US government. In so doing, the US Government was able to force these banks to turn over U.S. account holder information. Now, interestingly enough, whenever a new bank would announce that it signed an NPA and is now part of FATCA with the US government, there would be huge press releases that DOJ would release. And ironically enough, taxpayers began to find this out. And in the aftermath of widespread press releases being disseminated all over the Internet about this bank, you know, signing on to the non prosecution agreement and fatca, so many US persons that had accounts with those foreign banks and hadn't already begun to disclose their foreign bank accounts to the US government would quickly close the account at that bank because they knew the inevitable was going to happen and that it was just a matter of time before the bank disclosed their personal information to the US government. And once the US Government learned about US person that had foreign bank accounts with the bank and saw that that U.S. person didn't disclose the foreign bank account on their 1040 or file an FBAR the government had every right, not just to audit them and to assert civil FBAR penalties, but they could also refer the case for criminal prosecution to DOJ Tax. And it would start with CI Criminal Investigation Division of the irs.
19:21So the stakes were ramped up exponentially when these press releases came out. And floods of US persons that had undisclosed foreign bank accounts with the US Government that banked with these foreign banks that had just signed on to FATCA would like swarm away from the bank, close their account and then transfer money to other bank accounts. And that is what was happening in the early days of fat gum. As time went on, taxpayers began probably with all the press releases and all the anxiety that was percolating over this issue and realizing that it was a dangerous proposition to stay in the shadows regarding not disclosing their foreign banks, they would become proactive and start to disclose their non compliant foreign bank accounts. Now there's just so much information to talk about, so much to talk about in this area because it was just a domino effect of things that were going on here.
20:30But that's enough information now about fatca. Once again, offshore audits, which are typically based on third party information received under FATCA Tax Information Agreements or as a result of the Swiss bank program, are ripe for referral to CI. For better or for worse, the third party information usually supports the conclusion that the taxpayer violated one or more federal criminal statutes. One thing to know is that there were programs in place for taxpayers who were ambushed by this whole world of international tax enforcement by the US Government. What the US Government did essentially was extend an olive branch to US persons recognizing that that not everybody who failed to disclose their foreign bank accounts was an Al Capone of the tax world or a terrorist. There were legitimate reasons why a US person may not have disclosed their foreign bank account. And one reason that was very basic was that the taxpayer didn't know about an FBAR reporting requirement. And so the US Government wanted to give individuals who were naive, just outright naive about this reporting obligation the opportunity to come into compliance without losing the shirt right off their back, or even worse, having a referral made to CI and perhaps escalated to doj. So there were a series of voluntary programs, disclosure programs that the IRS announced. The big one was the offshore voluntary disclosure program. It was the 800 pound gorilla. It allowed individuals that were very non compliant, and when I say very
22:38non compliant, I mean to the extent that they had multiple undisclosed foreign bank accounts to the tune of maybe 6, 7 figures of high watermark balance, they gave those individuals the opportunity to jump into the offshore voluntary disclosure program bunker. And if they did, and if they took advantage of that program, not only would they essentially obtain amnesty from any possibility of a criminal prosecution, but, but the penalties would be reduced to 27.5% of the highest watermark balance in their foreign bank account over an eight year look back period. So before you can jump up and down and get excited about it, 27.5% of seven figures is a lot of money. And so a lot of US persons were loathe and reluctant to jump into that program. They would really do it only if the risk, if the, if the risk o meter was vacillating ever so close to the willfulness side of the meter.
23:55Because willfulness in the tax world for tax crimes is the operative element. It's the mens rea element. And it's a difference between whether there, whether the person has engaged in lawful tax avoidance. Tax avoidance is lawful or illegal tax evasion. That one word, willfulness. So a lot of times we would look at the non compliance and determine based on the actions that were undertaken by the taxpayer as well as the substance of the accounts themselves, we would make a determination of where that needle was hovering on the willfulness o meter, you know, like a spectrum. On one far end it was non willful. On the other end of the spectrum it was willful. And sometimes it was the, you know, it was a slam dunk, of course, when the, when the needle was vacillating towards an extreme end. Because when it was vacillating on an extreme end such as willfulness, right away slam dunk, it's going to be an offshore voluntary disclosure submission. But if we're on, if the media was vacillating to non willfulness, then maybe it was as simple as filing a reasonable cause letter with the delinquent FBARs and doing a mea coppa with an explanation as to why this person was delinquent in filing the FBARs. And a lot of times the interest income is generated on the foreign bank account was still negligible enough that it would be hard for the IRS to make the argument out that this taxpayer was willfully trying to attempt to violate the Internal Revenue laws when they would have owed only an extra maybe $300 in
25:46taxes if they had actually disclosed that foreign bank account. The tough ones are when the needle is vacillating in the middle and you know, the taxpayer, you know, there's badges of fraud that might weigh, that might, you know, look like there's Willfulness at play. And then there are benign and legal aspects to the conduct and the action and the maintaining of the bank accounts that could just as easily cause things to tip in the non willful direction. With voluntary disclosure. The whole spirit of the program is that the taxpayer has to disclose, has to come forward and disclose the undisclosed foreign bank accounts before the IRS has already found out about them. If the IRS has already found out about them, it's too late. So, yeah, FATCA was an information gathering tool for the U.S.
26:43government to learned about those individuals, those U.S. persons who had foreign bank accounts with foreign banks and weren't compliant with their US Tax obligations.
27:00So it should come as no surprise that few, if any taxpayers are willing to assist the IRS in its fishing expedition. If you think about it, whenever the irs, you know, sends, for example, an information document request to a taxpayer, if it's the information that the taxpayer is supplying, the government could very well provide them with the ammunition that they need to launch an investigation and ultimately a prosecution to the taxpayer. So it's very important, especially with IDRs, because they're very common. IDRs are information document requests. You might have seen them before. Whenever a taxpayer is being audited or examined, they'll receive an IDR and the IDR will list like a, like a shopping list. It's an itemized list of items that documents and records, if you will, that the IRS is demanding the taxpayer supply. Of course, you have to look to see if it's overbroad and if it's a fishing expedition. Many times more.
28:15More so than not, it's usually the law. The law will support what they're asking for. The thing with IDRs is that you need to really sit down with the client and make sure that there aren't going to be any bombshells in there that are going to reveal something that, you know, might be a smoking gun as far as direct evidence goes. And by that I mean, for example, if the taxpayer had not disclosed a foreign bank account to, on a prior year's return, and you know, the IDR is asking for all records and an itemization of every bank account, both domestic and international, that the taxpayers maintain for the last two years, and you know that that foreign bank account is in there. Wow. You know, we've got some damage control, we've got some things we've got to do because it's not a matter of if the revenue agent is going to discover that foreign bank account. It's a matter of when Surrendering such information is the modern day Equivalent of an old fashioned western duel where one cowboy, the taxpayer gives the other cowboy, an IRS revenue agent, the bullets and ammunition needed to load the empty barrel. In a very real sense, it's a silver bullet that the government needs to successfully prosecute the taxpayer. Because of how devastating the information could be to the client's liberty, great care should be taken to assert all applicable privileges, including the Fifth Amendment privilege against self incrimination.
29:51So let us talk a little bit about the list of privileges as they relate not just to the fifth Amendment, but we'll also just talk a little bit about immunity as well as the attorney client privilege, the fifth Amendment privilege against self incrimination. The most, the most, the most well known aspect. Whoops. Of the fifth Amendment privilege against self incrimination is as it applies to testimony. We are all very familiar with the Miranda rules and you know, having studied in criminal procedure the Miranda rules and all of the other law that was spawned by law enforcement taking liberties with, with, with suspects in the interrogation room. So that is one of the most well known aspects of the, of the Fifth Amendment.
31:03But don't forget that the Fifth Amendment also applies to, to document production. There is immunity, which we all know about. If you do any work in the criminal arena,
31:22you may have represented a client that was offered immunity in exchange for disclosing information
31:33that would be helpful to law enforcement to uncover perhaps more information about a drug operation. The attorney client privilege and work product privileges. We all know very much about the attorney client privilege and work product privileges.
31:54So let's start with some background information. Tax cases, like any white collar case, are document intensive cases. As we previously discussed. If the government cannot get the requested documents, it often cannot make a case. And a good part of the time the seminal evidence in a tax case is going to come from the taxpayer himself. It's for this reason that a critical issue in document production cases is whether the taxpayer has a fifth Amendment privilege with respect to the documents that he possesses. Because those documents could be, as we've already talked about damning enough, and they could become governments. Exhibit one in the criminal prosecution of the taxpayer.
32:54Let's just roughly go back to the fifth Amendment and what it says. It says that no person shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself. Ordinarily, the Fifth Amendment applies to the live testimony of a witness at a judicial proceeding, in a criminal trial, or during custodial interrogation of a suspect by law enforcement. Yeah, I'm sorry, before, I forgot to mention in a trial as well, it may also be asserted with the Fifth Amendment in a trial. Of course, we know that the defendant has no obligation to take the stand. And to the extent that they decline and decide not to testify on their own behalf, their silence will not be used against them. And the judge specifically has to give instructions to the jury to that effect. It may also be asserted during a congressional hearing before a House Oversight Committee, such as that involving Mark McGuire during the committee's open hearings on steroid use in Major League Baseball going back to 2005.
34:14But live testimony is not all that the Fifth Amendment protects. It also protects something just as sacrosanct, the compelled production of business records in certain situations. And there is a trio of cases that flesh out this concept. And I'm going to highlight some of the important parts of those cases. Again, I just want to go back to something that we talked about before. When it comes to documents in white collar cases and when it to comes to this body of compelled production, this body of law surrounding the compelled production of business records, we are not talking about the substance of the records. We are talking about. We're actually stepping back and taking a look at the view from the top of the mountain. We are just talking about the, the actual, the actual turning over of a document from a taxpayer to the government and what that act of turning over a document to the government establishes. So we're not getting into the slight substance or the content of that record itself. It might very well be that the substance or content of that record is a smoking gun. But what we're focused on here is the act of producing it, the act of the taxpayer handing it, if you will, to the government. What does that prove?
36:05And we're going to learn that there are three main things that that act of turning a record over to the government proves.
36:16The Fifth Amendment privilege is fairly straightforward in cases involving testimony, but has proven to be confounding just as the curse in Harry Potter when it comes to applying it in document production cases. And this is why I've taken some time to explain the distinction here so that we don't get lost, because half of the battle here is understanding that we are specifically referring to the act of turning over a record, and we are not talking about the substance of that record itself during the government's information gathering stage. Fifth Amendment concerns arise when the taxpayer is asked to produce records or other documents.
37:06So the question is one of who bears the burden of proving that the privilege exists? There's two people basically here. Is it the taxpayer or is it the court? The taxpayer has the burden. The taxpayer must make at least a prima facie showing that responding to the information request would criminally implicate him either in this crime or in another crime. Now, federal jurisprudence is attempting to balance here two specific interests. First, the desire to protect individual citizens from excessive governmental intrusion. And second, the government's need to properly enforce the laws by using evidence independently obtained through skillful investigation. Those are the two interests.
38:05In order for the privilege to apply, statements must be compelled. So what we're really doing right now is we are putting a magnifying glass on some operative terms in the Fifth Amendment. In the Fifth Amendment language, and as we might remember from criminal procedure, compelled is a loaded, loaded term. So for a second, please dispense with what you, with what you might remember. You know, the definition of compelled to be, because we are getting very narrow and very specific here as these terms apply to document production for tax crimes. So, and this comes out of the case law that I'm going to reference in these three, in the bot. In these three cases, a witness who voluntarily testifies or willingly produces documents in response to a summons or a subpoena cannot later claim the privilege. Why? Because they voluntarily surrendered the document. So compelled is something that is greater than a voluntary acquiescence, if you will, of information to the government. The act of producing documents in response to a subpoena may be subject to the Fifth Amendment privilege against self incrimination. Once again,
39:49the act of producing documents or records in response to a subpoena issued by the IRS may be subject to the Fifth Amendment privilege against self incrimination. We get that out of the case of Fisher versus the US
40:09let's talk a little bit about the facts of the Fisher case. In Fisher, the government issued summonses for the records of two taxpayers, which were created by the taxpayer's accountant, but later transferred to and held by attorneys for tax preparation. So it's not a bad idea in the tax world to draw diagrams, especially in corporate taxation, because of how you could have an individual that owns a corporation, that owns foreign bank accounts, or. And you could have so many different iterations of that. But here the vertical diagram might look something like this. You have the accountant who might, you know, you might diagram the accountant as a circle, and the accountant basically created records for two taxpayers and later transferred those records to attorneys for tax preparation.
41:26So that's what's going on. We have the accountant who has prepared records for two taxpayers. They did the legwork. This is their work product, essentially, and they transferred those records to the attorneys for tax preparation, the court held that enforcement of the summonses did not violate the Fifth Amendment privilege. So here's the square off. Here is the contest. The contest is won where the IRS was looking to via a subpoena to get the. And I just want to make sure that I've got the right. Okay, I just want to make sure I know who's doing what to whom. The IRS is definitely involved here. But let me just go a little bit further. So I remember in my mind the fact that facts. Because I believe that the government was looking to elicit via a subpoena the records. And I want to just make sure that I don't confuse us, because I want to make sure that I know which party the IRS had issued the summons to. This was a summons, I'm sorry, not a subpoena. In a unanimous opinion, the court refused to cut the Fifth Amendment completely loose from the moorings of its language and make it serve as a general protector of privacy.
43:01The decision left the door open for future Fifth Amendment application in tax cases. So it's very refreshing if you're a defense attorney and a taxpayer. It's very refreshing to hear the court, in a unanimous opinion, state that they were unwilling to do dispense with the Fifth Amendment completely in this context. So here are some takeaways from Fisher. Even if the documents themselves aren't privileged, the act of producing them in response to a subpoena nevertheless has communicative aspects of its own, wholly independent of the contents of the paper produced. By contents, I'm referring to the substance of the papers, meaning what is there when you read it.
43:55We're referring here not to the content, but to the act of producing the records to the irs. That act of producing the records to the IRS has communicative aspects of its own. And if this testimony and admission that the requested documents exist, that's one of the things it proves. And if this testimony is critical to the prosecutor's case and not merely a foregone conclusion, that adds little or nothing to the sum total of the government's information. The privilege, the Fifth Amendment privilege may attach, but this is all language from the court. But if the existence and location of the papers are a foregone conclusion and the taxpayer adds little or nothing to the sum total of the government's information by conceding that he in fact has the papers, then the act of production privilege does not apply.
44:53It's benign at that point. It's completely trivial and benign. The plot thickens with us versus Hubble. This is an infamous Whitewater case. Back in 1996, independent prosecutor Kenneth Starr served a subpoena duce tecumseh on former Arkansas lawyer Webb Hubbell. In that subpoena, Mr. Hubbell was ordered to bring documents before a Little Rock grand jury. He subsequently refused to testify about the documents or even acknowledge whether or not they existed. Citing his Fifth Amendment rights, the district court threw out the subpoena as a quintessential fishing expedition, however, an appeals court. Because of course, the government wasn't going to just lie silent and not appeal that ruling. They appealed it to the appeals court. The appeals court later reinstated.
45:54Reinstated it. So what were the arguments? The defense's argument, the only way that the government was able to bring this prosecution was through the information that I produced. The court held that the indictment should be dismissed. The Supreme Court of the United States held that where a document communicates information about the document's existence, custody and authenticity, those are terms that are worth committing to memory. Existence, custody and authenticity. Existence, custody and authenticity. Then the mere act of production is incriminating and the Fifth Amendment privilege applies.
46:40This slide is probably the most important slide of the entire presentation because it's telling you what the act of turning over documents and records in response to a government summons or subpoena establishes, and it is the existence of the document. Right? Because the act of turning it over, if the document was not in existence, there would have been nothing to turn over. So by producing it in response to a government subpoena, the first thing that is established is the existence of that very document. Second, what is being established by the act of producing it is custody. That the taxpayer had custody over this document and had control, if you will, over the document. And it was in their possession and authenticity that it's legitimate and that it bears the hallmarks of authenticity.
47:47In a near unanimous opinion, Justice Stevens essentially extended Fisher. Once again, he focused on the production aspect as akin to testimony, likening it to a prisoner forced to try on a shirt in order to link him with a prior criminal act. It's like, for example, armed robbery, where the individual or actor who walks into the 711 or the bank has a mask concealing their face. But they have a very distinctive jacket. Maybe it's a bright colored jacket, or maybe it's even something more subtle. Maybe it's something as subtle as an earring, you know, in their left ear, and they get arrested. An individual is suspected of being involved.
48:41The law enforcement doesn't know for sure, and they pick the person up and arrest them and book them. And you know, lo and behold, the government at some point during the investigation was able to find or uncover this article of clothing that was prominent on the actor at the time. And let's say just to keep it simple, it was the jacket. It was a bright yellow colored jacket. And the law enforcement and the detective interrogating the suspect asks the suspect to turn it on, to try it on. Okay, that's what we're talking about here. And that's what Justice Stevens was looking what was drawing a comparison to the compelled testimony that is relevant in this case is not to be found in the contents of the documents produced in response to the subpoena. It is rather the testimony inherent in the act of producing those documents. He explained.
49:44What is the testimony inherent in the act of producing those documents? They are its existence, its custody and its authenticity.
49:56Unlike the facts in Fisher, prosecutor would have had absolutely no case against Hubbell unless he had access to the withheld documents. In sum, the court held, we have no doubt that the constitutional privilege against self incrimination protects the target of a grand jury investigation from being compelled to answer questions designed to elicit information about the existence of sources of potential incriminating evidence. He concluded, so the information. This was the court's analysis in the Hubble case. The information was so voluminous that the prosecutor needed the defendant's assistance both to identify potential sources of information and to produce those sources.
50:46Given the breadth of the categories of documents called for by the subpoena, the collection and production of the materials demanded was tantamount to answering a series of detailed interrogatories or a series of deposition questions. Providing a catalog of existing documents fitting within any one of 11 broadly worded categories could surely provide a prosecutor with leads to incriminating evidence.
51:20All right, again, what does the act of producing documents concede? First, the existence of the documents demanded. Second, their possession or control by the taxpayer. Third, the taxpayer's belief that the documents produced are those described in the subpoena, a fact that the government may use to authenticate them. So that's how we get to authentication the fact that in exchange the fact that in response to a subpoena, these documents were the ones that the taxpayer turned over to the government that can be used by the government at trial to authenticate them. Because again, it establishes the taxpayers belief that that these were the documents the government was looking for in the subpoena or else they wouldn't have been the ones that the taxpayer turned over to the IRS in response to the subpoena.
52:22I want to make a note of something here, very specific. Compelled in this area of Fifth Amendment document production is satisfied. And we're going to take a look a little bit at the case law. But whenever the government is forced to issue a subpoena or a summons, there is in effect, compulsion involved. Because otherwise, if it was something where they picked up a phone or wrote an informal letter and the taxpayer responded, that is going to be deemed more voluntary. But when the government has to resort to a subpoena or summons, that will suffice for the element of compulsion or compelling as per the Fifth Amendment.
53:22All right. The privilege applies only to compelled testimony. And that comes from the case of US vs. Couch. Voluntarily prepared documents are not privileged because no compulsion is present. Okay, so I actually have to catch myself here and correct myself on something because I misstated how compulsion exists in document production cases. We are not looking. It doesn't rise and fall on whether the government has to resort to issuing a summons or subpoena. I sincerely apologize for the confusion. The issue of whether it's compelled does not fall on whether the government has to resort to a subpoena or a summons. It looks, it takes it a step forward to determine whether it was whether the documents were voluntarily turned over or compelled.
54:37The courts must look to see whether the documents have been voluntarily prepared, meaning the records and documents that the government is requesting in the subpoena or the summons. Were those documents voluntarily prepared? If so, they're not privileged because no compulsion is present. All right. And I don't want to say it and beat you over the head with it, but another way of saying it is that a taxpayer who voluntarily produces documents in response to a summons or subpoena cannot later claim the privilege. All right, so it's. It's basically looking. The light is on. The taxpayer does the tax it Has a taxpayer turned documents over in response to the summons or subpoena willingly? If so, then they cannot later on claim the privilege.
55:45The privilege protects a person only against being incriminated by his own compelled testimonial communications. Documents prepared by individuals other than the taxpayer are not protected. Now, this raises an interesting issue because tax records are not always prepared by the taxpayer himself. In many instances, the taxpayer employs a CPA or an enrolled agent to prepare tax documents, if not the return itself, on the taxpayer's behalf. So let's explore this issue of whether the privilege applies to individuals other than the taxpayer. This comes from the case of Fisher vs United States as well.
56:47The issue as it relates to whether the privilege applies to someone other than the taxpayer. Is. Are the tax records of a taxpayer. Sorry, Are the tax records of a taxpayer created by the taxpayer's accountant but then transferred to and held by attorneys for tax preparation subject to the fifth Amendment privilege against self incrimination? This is where we need to look at that vertical chart that I was telling you about. We have tax records that were created by the accountant, by the taxpayer's accountant. It's very likely here that because we're talking about taxpayers, plural, that it might be two spouses, or of course, it could be individuals who are in the same partnership that have filed. But regardless, we have tax records that were prepared by the accountant and then transferred to and held by attorneys for tax preparation. It's a little bit of, it's a little upside down because one would think, why was the accountant engaged by the taxpayer just to do the records and then the attorneys engaged to do the preparation? Wouldn't the taxpayer just rely on the accountant to do the records and the tax preparation for whatever reason here, you know, this is just how the taxpayers structured the preparation of their returns.
58:33They had an accountant handle the records creating the records, and then they had an attorney handle the actual preparation.
58:45The attorney's handling the preparation needed, of course, the records of the taxpayer in order to prepare the return. So it's not out of the ordinary for the attorney to. Or for the accountant to forward all of the records to the attorney for that purpose. The tax records in Fisher were, were the accountant's own work papers. They were the accountant's own work papers. And what we know here from this rule is that documents prepared by individuals other than the taxpayer are not protected. So let's go look at the holding. The court held that the taxpayer's tax records obtained through a summons on the taxpayer's attorney are not protected by the fifth Amendment privilege against self incrimination. Why?
59:40Because they were not prepared by the taxpayer himself. They were prepared by the accountant, who is someone other than the taxpayer.
59:54We have here some analysis that I'll share with you.
1:00:03The court reasoned that the summons and the order of the court enforcing it were directed against the accountant, not the taxpayer. The accountants work papers are not the taxpayers. They were not prepared by the taxpayer, nor did they contain any testimonial declarations by him. Therefore, the essential ingredient of personal compulsion against accused is lacking. So you might want to, if you're, you know, if you're listing these elements and, you know, jotting down notes, you might want to list Next to the compulsion element, that it has to be personal compulsion. And the reasoning here, of course, is that they were not prepared by the taxpayers.
1:00:55And the court was able to obviate this concern of a testimonial declaration made by the taxpayer by laying out their reasoning that because the records were prepared by the accountant, there was no testimonial declaration contained. There was no tech testimonial declaration made by the taxpayer. And so we need to focus on personal compulsion now in order to see whether the privilege applies.
1:01:35What if the tax records were still in the taxpayer's possession? Now, that's an interesting question. So the records. We would keep the same facts and assume as in the hypothetical, that the records themselves were prepared by the accountant, but instead of the government issuing the summons on the attorneys, on the attorney who was doing the actual preparation, we're going to assume for purposes of this hypo that the tax records remained in the taxpayer's possession. So essentially they were transferred from the accountant directly to the taxpayer. Would that alter the result? I think that that's a good hypo to explore.
1:02:23And basically we're looking at, you know, two possibilities. Yes, it would or B it wouldn't.
1:02:31No, it would not alter the results. Any ideas why it wouldn't alter the result? This was kind of like a red herring that I threw out to throw you off a little bit. The reason why it doesn't alter the result is because the rule specifically focuses on who the one was, who the person or individual was that prepared the documents. And once again, they were prepared by the accountant and not the individual taxpayer. So it doesn't matter that the tax records wound up in the taxpayer's possession. We're not examining that. That's not relevant for purposes of this analysis. It is instead, who was the person that created the. That did the work, and that here was the accountant.
1:03:34However, the court acknowledged two important things here. First, that a subpoena served on a taxpayer requiring him to produce an accountant's work papers in his possession still involves substantial compulsion. All right, Very important, the court did not. Did not dispense altogether with this idea that there was still an element of compulsion involved with an accountant's work papers that were in the possession of the taxpayer, where the IRS targeted the taxpayer with a subpoena to elicit those records. And second, that the contents of the account was work papers might well be incriminating.
1:04:28Incriminating. All right, but. But the act of producing the work papers is all that the taxpayer is being compelled to do. It does not compel oral testimony. In other words, it does not compel the taxpayer to restate, repeat, affirm the truth of the contents of the documents sought. That gives us a clue as to what the court would find to be offensive in this act of production. The fact that the taxpayer is not compelled to restate, repeat, or affirm the truth of the contents of the the of those tax records obviates any type of compulsion against the taxpayer.
1:05:25What does Fisher stand for? Well, it stands for the proposition that the privilege against self incrimination protects only the act of producing subpoenaed evidence and not the tacit averments within the documents themselves.
1:05:48What if the taxpayer is a corporation?
1:05:54Does the privilege apply if the corporation receives a summons or a subpoena? The answer is no, the privilege would not apply. The taxpayer was a corporation and the IRS issued the summons or subpoena to the corporation.
1:06:15There is what's called a collective entity doctrine and what I'll add a little bit of flesh to the bones on this. It says that corporations and entities have no fifth amendment privilege. Only the individual who responds on behalf of the corporation, who is the custodian of records, could potentially assert the privilege. So it's not a blanket rule stating that the custodian of records could under any circumstances assert the privilege. It's saying that they could potentially only potentially assert the privilege. So let's see if we have any cases on this to explore this Timeliness. Timeliness. Timeliness. When.
1:07:07When there is a grounds for objecting to a summons or subpoena. The the most prevalent grounds for objecting to a summons or subpoena is that it's over broad. But there are other others as well. To the extent that an objection exists, it must be asserted at the right time. There are both legal and ethical questions wrapped up in this, in this rule. First, it's a matter of professional responsibility. Defense counsel cannot instruct his client to disregard a summons because even if it's overbroad, unless there is at least a good faith basis to challenge it. Good faith basis to challenge. If no such basis exists, defense counsel cannot advise his client to ignore it.
1:08:07Now, if there is a good faith basis to challenge the summons, when should the privilege be asserted? And I give you two choices here. @ the earliest stage possible so that it is preserved during the summons enforcement process or B at a contempt proceeding after the taxpayer defies a court order enforcing compliance of the summons and the court is considering imposing sanctions. A little bit of background information. When it comes to summonses, a summons Is not self enforcing. What do I mean by that? What I mean by that is that if the target of a summons does not respond, the government cannot just send law enforcement to the home or to the office and have them, you know, walk in and obtain it.
1:09:08There is an intermediate step that must be taken. The government must go before a judge, and that is what's known as a contempt proceeding, to argue to the judge that the summons was being disregarded and to ask the court to enforce complaints compliance of the summons.
1:09:36It's a low standard. I talk about the criteria that must be proved by the government in order for the judge to enforce compliance of the summons. And again, it's a very low threshold, but we'll leave it at that. If there is a good faith basis to challenge the summons, it goes without saying that it must be challenged at the earliest stage possible so that it is preserved. That would be during the summons enforcement process. I'm sorry, I mentioned contempt proceeding in its incorrect context. The government, when, in order to enforce a summons that has not been responded to, would go before a judge for a summons enforcement hearing. I'm sorry, Contempt proceeding is if it is willful and if the government is looking to get the judge to impose sanctions. Contempt proceedings, you know, are part and parcel of the summons enforcement process because it's, you know, it's, it's a, it's possible that the judge might also impose sanctions after he or she orders enforcement of the summons.
1:11:10The prosecutor has the ability to confer active production immunity. So let's set the scene here. The government really wants the documents and the records, but under Fisher, the very act of turning them over is incriminating. The government could grant the taxpayer immunity with respect to the act of production. What does that mean? Well, that means if the government were to confer immunity, act of production immunity on a person, the government is basically saying to the, the taxpayer that they will not use the fact that the taxpayer turned the documents over in response to a subpoena or summons to authenticate them. They will not turn that act of producing the documents on the part of the taxpayer around and around on the taxpayer and use it against them and at a criminal trial to authenticate those documents.
1:12:20Yeah, that's pretty much that the government's representing. They won't use. They can't use a defendant to vouch for the fact that the information is authentic and that it's responsive. If the government grants the taxpayer act of production immunity, how would it then authenticate the documents at trial? Well, that's interesting. And it's a valid question. Authentication is, once again made up of possession and production. So let's suppose that the taxpayer owns a corporation and that the government wants to introduce documents that it obtained from the corporation in response to. To a subpoena.
1:13:07How would the government show that the corporation possessed the documents requested by the subpoena and that they produced them in response to the subpoena?
1:13:20I'm not sure here if we even need to talk about this in the context of a taxpayer who has been issued active production immunity. The concept is still parallel to what we're talking about in the sense that if there is no individual to authenticate the documents, as in the case of a corporation, how would the government, in this hypothetical involving the corporation, show that the corporation possessed the documents that the government was requesting in the subpoena and that the corporation produced them in response to the subpoena? You want to think chain of custody. How could the government establish chain of custody?
1:14:15Well, the government could call two essential witnesses into court to testify. First, the process server who delivered the subpoena to the corporation, and second, the custodian of records, namely the individual within the corporation who received the subpoena, the custodian of records. So between those two individuals, the process server who delivered the subpoena to the corporation, and secondly, the custodian of record who was the recipient of the subpoena, that should be sufficient for the government to establish production on the part of the corporation without the government having to. Without the government having to say the corporation produced it.
1:15:19The jury would have to infer from this testimony that the corporation possessed the records and that it produced them in response to the subpoena. I think that it's a very.
1:15:31From there. Once you establish those two things that we talked about.
1:15:49Yeah, once you.
1:15:52Once you establish those two things that we just talked about, the process server delivering the subpoena and the custodian records being the one who received it, that should be enough for the jury to infer that the corporation possessed the records and that it produced them in response to the subpoena. Roswell versus United States. This is a very interesting case. The issue in this case was could the custodian of records claim the privilege under the act of production doctrine on the ground that his act of production would be personally incriminating? Oh, so that's interesting. So it looks like the government attempted to prove active production through the way we just talked about, through the process server and through the custodian of records, and then the custodian of Records wanted to claim the privilege under the active production doctrine by arguing that if you. He was made a party to this case by the government being able to introduce evidence that he was the one who received the summons, he had concerns that he would be personally liable because his act of producing the documents and records in response to that subpoena would be personally incriminating to him.
1:17:37So what if the taxpayer, for example, in that scenario is the sole shareholder of the corporation and that he wears all hats in the company, from marketing to product development to public relations to custodian of records? Now we are getting very close to the custodian of records. We are moving from the custodian of records as a W2 employee of a corporation who has nothing to do with being a shareholder or an owner of the company to somebody
1:18:25that is the owner, for all intents and purposes, the sole shareholder of the corporation is in fact the owner of the corporation. So what if the sole shareholder, perhaps of an S corporation is wearing all these hats and is the custodian of records and the government is trying to introduce into evidence to establish production that John, the owner of the corporation, was also the custodian of records. Is that bringing this now too close to home? That it's as if now. It's as if now this person is the act, is the very one who produced them? Well, the argument is any production by the corporation would surely be viewed by the jury as having been done by me, the company's alter ego, because, you know, I'm the sole shareholder of the company.
1:19:32The answer is no. Actually, the answer is an emphatic no. That this argument being asserted by the sole shareholder, that, you know, he's essentially the company's. That the jury is going to infer that he is essentially the company's alter ego, you know, because he wears all these hats, including the custodian of records. The court ruled against that. So essentially, even in a small corporation where the sole shareholder is wearing all these hats, including that of custodian of records, and the government is establishing. Is attempting to establish active production by arguing that the custodian of records was the sole shareholder and they, in fact, were the ones that turned the documents over in response to the. In response to the.
1:20:30To the subpoena, that's fair game. That's fair game. That's going to be admissible in the chain of custody. How does all this apply to foreign bank account records? Good question. So we talked about the Bank Secrecy Act. The Bank Secrecy act, and we talked about it in one respect Already in the beginning of the presentation, it was what gave life to to the foreign bank account report. The FBAR and the Bank Secrecy act has been on the books since the 70s. There is another obscure element to the Bank Secrecy Act. It didn't just give life to the foreign bank account report, but it also has some again, very obscure requirements as far as how long taxpayers must hold on to documents in addition to their annual reporting of financial accounts.
1:21:34That really falls under the umbrella of fbar. So let's first talk about the Bank Secrecy act and foreign bank account reporting. The Bank Secrecy act requires taxpayers to annually report to the IRS foreign financial accounts in which the taxpayer had a financial interest or signatory authority. This information is reported to the IRS on FinCEN form 114. This is the foreign Bank Account Report form. It is not a creature of the irs. It is a creature of financial crimes and enforcement network. It is however, enforced by the IRS. So it's a little bit, little confusing. FinCEN is the form. The enforcement arm for the FBAR is the irs.
1:22:25In addition to the reporting requirement, the Bank Secrecy act also requires taxpayers to maintain for five years records for each foreign account, including the following. The name in which each account is maintained. Second, the number of other or other designation of such account. Third, the name and address of the foreign bank or other person with whom the account is maintained. Fourth, the type of such account. Is it a savings, is it a checking, is it a high yielding investment account, etc. Etc. Is it a retirement account? And finally, the maximum value of such account during the reporting period. The reason why the maximum value of the account is relevant is because only foreign bank accounts that have a watermark balance, high watermark balance at any given point during the year of 10,000 or more would trigger an FBAR filing requirement. So even if for one hour in the course of the tax year the foreign bank account had a $10,000 balance and all the other times, or every other day plus 23 hours and 58 minutes, the bank account 364 days, 23 hours and 58 minutes. All that other time the bank account had a $5,000 high watermark balance, the bank account still must be reported on an F bar, even just for one minute.
1:24:09Even because just for one minute it had a balance that exceeded $10,000. What you would do is because these are foreign bank accounts that are in foreign currency, you of course would have to take the high watermark balance and in the account and convert it from foreign currency to US Currency using the exchange rate that was in effect as of the last day of the tax year. And that would be the amount from which you extrapolate the high watermark balance in that year. The regulations do not articulate how to compute the five year retention period, but it is generally agreed that the five year period is calculated by reference to the current year, not by reference to the year under audit. So, for example, if the IRS issued a summons back on November 1st of 2016, the Bank Secrecy act requires the taxpayer to only maintain records concerning the foreign bank accounts retroactively from November 1st of 2011.
1:25:14So again, we would extrapolate the five year period from the date that the IRS had issued the summons for. And that's what gets us back to 2011. And then the retention period is calculated by reference to that current year, not by reference to the year under audit. The required records doctrine, as informed by Fisher and Hubble, has been extended to documents required to be maintained under the Bank Secrecy Act. But hold on. The Fifth Amendment only protects individuals from compelled testimony, so there's a required records exception. The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit was the first appellate court to weigh in here. It decided that the Fifth Amendment privilege against self incrimination could be raised in response to a subpoena demanding the production of offshore bank account records.
1:26:14That's very favorable to the taxpayer. That ruling in 2011 in the case of Inray MH the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that the records sought through the subpoena fell under the required records exception and the Fifth Amendment privilege did not apply. So we have an opinion here that comes out of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals that is definitely against the taxpayer because it's holding that the records sought through the subpoena fell under the required records exception of the Bank Secrecy act and at the Fifth Amendment privilege did not apply. So essentially what the court was saying in this context was that turnover taxpayer, those records that you have had that you were obligated to maintain for a five year period as per the Bank Secrecy
1:27:30Okay. So in other words,
1:27:34the Ninth Circuit held that the required records exceptions rendered the Fifth Amendment defense useless in Bank Secrecy act cases. So far, the courts of Appeals for the first, second, third, fourth, fifth, seventh, ninth and 11th circuits have agreed that the records required records exception requires taxpayers to produce foreign bank account information required to be kept under the Bank Secrecy Act. The IRS and the U.S. department of Justice Tax have issued summonses and grand jury subpoenas seeking information required to be kept under the Bank Secrecy Act. There has been an inordinate amount of litigation surrounding whether and the extent to which in these documents must be produced.
1:28:19We have actually a very taxpayer friendly opinion that came out some years ago and it was the second Circuit case of United States versus Greenfield. I'm going to probably wrap up this section before we jump off and I'll do it quickly because I know that we're a minute over time in Greenfield. The Court of appeals for the 2nd Circuit narrowed the scope of the required records exception as it applied to the alleged Bank Secrecy act violations in Greenfield. The IRS learned that Stephen Greenfield had been involved with certain nefarious offshore entities used to evade, not avoid evade, which connotes intention willfulness to evade US taxes. 2005 was a bad year for Greenfield. The IRS selected his 2005 federal income tax return for audit. In 2013, the IRS issued an information document request along with a summons directing him to produce documents relating to both his domestic and foreign bank accounts, including quote, unquote, every account over which Stephen Greenfield had signature authority and or over which Stephen Greenfield exercised control during the years 2001 through 2011 over a 10 year period.
1:29:47Even mathematically and linguistically challenged readers could surmise that such a request was too broad. Why? Because it went well beyond the five year foreign account Bank Secrecy act records request, which is five. To add insult to injury, the summons further requested Greenfield to produce all documents in his possession for each bank account. Incensed, Greenfield refused to comply with the summons. Objecting on the grounds that the summons was overbroad. The government brought an enforcement action in 2014. Greenfield responded with a motion to quash. Essentially, that is the next power move in this dance of the government seeking to enforce a summons because once again, a summons is not self executing.
1:30:35So what we have here is an enforcement brought by the government in 2014. We have greenfield responding with a motion to quash. Super. So you should be all set. Thank you, thank you. Thank you so much. I'm sorry to keep you guys over, but we are through and look for more because there will be more tax programs coming up in concert with LexVid and hope you enjoyed it and got something out of it and I wish you the very best. Take care. Bye now.