59min · about 6,000 wordsDownload Transcript
0:01Hello, I'm Alex Charance. I've practiced criminal defense and freedom of information law in Durham, North Carolina for 43 years. I'm the author of FBI Snitches, Blackmail and Obscene Ethics at the Supreme Court and Cloak and Gavel. FBI Wiretaps, Bugs, Informers and the Supreme Court. My articles about the Supreme Court in the FBI have appeared in the New York Times, Washington Post and other publications. This CLE is designed to teach you to file your own FOIA requests and followed up with my tricks and tips that I've learned over the last four decades so you can get the maximum results. I will also use a case study of my voluminous FOIA requests to the FBI about the Supreme Court, including my three lawsuits to uncover previous bureau secrets.
1:11Let's get started.
1:15So the last piece of the puzzle. What if you have a client and you need highway crash data? The FOIA might be helpful to you. Or what if you need Justice Department policies on the use of facial recognition technology? The same you might use the foia,
1:42that smoking gun in government mandated auto parts, recalls of airbags, you might find that smoking gun or the recall of child safety seats,
2:01explosive evidence.
2:04Maybe in an Occupational Safety and Health Administration OSHA report, you may find that explosive evidence about dangerous working conditions or for your criminal practitioners, sentencing mitigation evidence. And something that is very helpful I found is the honorable discharge papers. And for example, if you have a veteran who has lost their papers, for example, you're representing a homeless veteran who doesn't have any, any papers to their name, you request a true copy from the source. The FOIA could be helpful to you. So there are X files out there to help your clients cases and you're not always going to be fought by the government agency.
3:09Oftentimes they're incredibly helpful.
3:16So the Jeffrey Epstein files, I went to the pre processed files at the FBI. They have something called the Vault and that includes a lot of pre processed, pre released records about celebrities and public figures. And what I found is nothing but exemptions. Pages of exemptions, no, nothing else. And hopefully folks are taking care of that. And next time you go to the Vault you might actually find something. But we're going to learn about what all These exemptions mean. B1, B2.
4:09And what have other folks gotten? That was pretty impressive. The C CIA Operation Condor, the National Security Archive received this document about that secret program and it was declassified. Some of the pages are redacted or blacked out.
4:38And they also received documents under the FOIA about the CIA's MK Ultra program. And this was a program where unsuspecting military personnel and folks in college were subjected to secret LSD testing by our government. So sounds like something that was out of a science fiction novel, but it actually happened. So what we're going to learn about is exclusions, exemptions, redactions do not file files. And here's an FBI memo from 1967 that has exemption B2 and there looks like a B7C. And we're going to learn what those mean. So the truth is out there.
5:45And to get to the truth, often we can use the Freedom of Information Act. It was passed in 1966, it's been amended seven times.
6:00But warning, if the records you seek are held by a state entity, a state agency, the FOIA isn't going to help you. The federal FOIA that is. And in North Carolina, what our public records law is called is the North Carolina Public Records Act. Each state has its own public records or state FOIA law. But you need to know what agency you're requesting records from, because if you want state records, you're not going to get it using the federal Freedom of Information Act. So to make a FOIA request we're using five United States code 552. We have to identify our federal executive agency. And there are hundreds of them. Ice, Veterans Administration, the U. S. Department of justice, the FBI, Department of Defense, the State Department, etc, not Congress.
7:07You can't do a FOIA request to a congressional office, you can't do it to the federal courts. And the White House is exempt except for the executive office of the president.
7:27So the time for the agency to respond to a FOIA request, the law says 20 business days and that sounds pretty good. But their definition of response is we've received your FOIA request. That's all they have to do, touch base. And They've met the 20 business days requirement. And that is pretty common for them to be able to keep up with that they can get another 10 business days. But the actual time to release records depends on the first in and first out queue and the complexity of your request. So one way to get around being put in the complex queue or the heavy requester queue is to do break your request into pieces, which often is the best thing to do. Don't do around the world request for everything you want, break it into topics that make sense.
8:35At one point I was considered the FBI's number one FOIA requester. And the FBI, when we were in court, they said that to the federal judge, like it was a bad thing. I took it as a badge of honor until I learned that for a simple request for say 100 pages, there was the fast queue and then I was in the slow queue. The in molasses or amber Q that could take months or years. The complex Q because I was a heavy requester.
9:24Oh, do does. You would think that the liberal Democratic administration, one might think, oh, they comply with the FOIA better than the Republicans do. Well, here, here's an article from the News Media alliance showing that the Obama administration spent $36.2 million fighting FOIA requests. Fighting it. So they were fighting lawsuits, they were denying requests that shouldn't have been denied. They were claiming records were non existent when they weren't. And it made it harder for journalists and members of the public to get their hands on records that should have been accessible. Shame on them.
10:19Sometimes we might get what's called a glomar response. That is, we can neither confirm nor deny whether we have the records. And there's a picture of the glomar explorer and the glomar response means no. It means yes or no. You can't tell what it means because they're not confirming or denying anything. So where does the glomar response come from? In 1968, a Soviet Union submarine known as K129 sank in the Pacific. On board were 98 sailors who all perished. On board also were nuclear missiles. The Soviet Navy attempted for months to find the ship, which was three miles below the surface, but wasn't able to locate it.
11:30At the same time, the US recognized there might be a lot of valuable intelligence data on that ship if it could be raised. And once the Soviets gave up
11:45the US the CIA and Department of Defense began searching. And six long years they had a covert operation to raise the ship under the code name Project Jennifer, later to be revealed as Project Azorian. And that's according to the National Archives. And where you get this glomar response is when there's a FOIA exclusion. An exclusion is where the agency decides that the Freedom of Information Act, FOIA doesn't apply to your request. So when doesn't it apply? Whenever records that are described in B7A, where investigation or proceeding involves the possible violation of criminal law, and there is reason to believe that the subject of the investigation or proceeding is not aware of the pendency of that investigation and disclosure of the records might reasonably be expected to interfere with law enforcement proceedings.
13:07And the agency can, during that time, treat the records as not subject to the FOIA. That's the C1 exclusion. You might get the glomar response. We can't confirm or deny that we have any records. The C2 exclusion that applies to a narrower situation involving threatened identification of confidential informants and criminal proceedings.
13:41So when informant records are maintained by a criminal law enforcement agency under the informant's name or personal identifier and are requested by a third party, the agency may treat the records as not subject to the requirements of the FOIA unless the informant status as an informant has been officially confirmed.
14:08And exclusion C3, this exclusion pertains only to certain law enforcement records that are maintained by the FBI pertaining to foreign intelligence or counterintelligence or international terrorism. And the existence of the records is classified under exemption.
14:36As long as the records remain classified, they can treat the records as not subject to the requirements of foia. And if you ask for something like that, you'll get the glomar response. They can't confirm or deny. So when the FOIA does apply, according to the agency, there are nine FOIA exemptions. And by exemption, if part of the record can be reasonably separated from the exempt portion, the agency is supposed to make maximum disclosure and give you part of the record. For example, here is exemption one, information that is classified to protect national security. And at the red arrow to the left you see an X,
15:40black X, and that's xing out the classification marking showing this had been declassified. I found this in my massive Freedom of Information Privacy act file that's thousands of pages long. And it is a record of the electronic surveillances that Abe Fortis had been picked up in in 1965 and then when he was on the court in 1967. And you see Beast 6 exemption, which we haven't gotten to yet. Up the top right, they block something out for privacy reasons. And in near the middle, There's a number 190 dash 37, 116, and that is my personal FBI file number. After it, there's a dash 53. This is the 53rd document in my file. A 190 file is a FOIA PA file. So freedom of Information Act Privacy act file. And you can find in the Federal Register the prefixes like the 190 file that describes what type of file it is. Because sometimes all you're going to get is the file number. But it can give you valuable information.
17:18In Exemption 2 rules, information related solely to the internal personnel rules and practices of an agency, they can redact or blackout, or in these days, it's white out anything related to those Personnel rules and practices.
17:41Exemption 3 Information prohibited from disclosure by another federal law. And many laws can be cited by the agency, but the one most cited is going to be the Privacy act. And the picture is of the Privacy act data cover sheet.
18:08And for third party files that you ask for under the foia, you should get a declaration signed under penalty of perjury that your client or whatever person you're requesting the files about gives you permission and waives their privacy rights. So that isn't raised as a bar to you obtaining those records. And at the agency websites they'll give you example of a declaration in waiver forms. But simply saying Alex Charnes gives permission to Lawyer Smith under the Privacy act and under penalty of perjury. This is true and correct. That would probably work.
19:08Exemption 4 is trade secrets or commercial or financial information that is confidential or privileged.
19:29Exemption 5 privileged communications within or between agencies, including those protected by the deliberative process. Privilege provided the records were created less than 25 years before the date on which they were requested. So records older than 25 years, they can't raise this privilege. So depending on what you're looking for, they may not be able to deny you access.
20:05Exemption 6 Information that if disclosed would would invade another individual's personal privacy. This exemption is often used with other exemptions like the one about that you could it's it's protected by the Privacy Act. Also there other exemptions that apply and they'll often use each exemption. They'll use multiple exemptions because if you get into court you may win on one and lose on another.
20:50Exemption 7 Information compiled for law enforcement purposes that under 7A could reasonably be expected to interfere with enforcement proceedings.
21:097B would deprive a person of a right to a fair trial or impartial adjudication.
21:217C could reasonably be expected to constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy.
21:367d could reasonably be expected to disclose the identity of a confidential source. So again this could be used with other exemptions and maybe even the exclusion.
21:547e would disclose techniques and procedures for law enforcement investigations or prosecutions or would disclose guidelines for law enforcement investigations or prosecutions if such disclosure could reasonably be expected to risk circumvention of the law and 7F could reasonably be expected to endanger the life or physical safety of an individual. You're not we and you are not going to get that. Exemption 8 Information that concerns the supervision of financial institutions. Exempt. And finally, exemption nine geological information on Wells. In 43 years, I've never requested information that was about geological information on wells or deceased subjects, provide proof of death certificate, Social Security data, a newspaper account of the death or obituary. And when I requested the files on individual justices, I provided their obituary from the New York Times or Washington Post, like this one involving Abe Fortis.
23:30When a person is deceased, the case law is that their privacy rights extinguish wish except in circumstances the privacy rights of their family to gory photographs.
23:52In that case, there's some case law that shields the the survivors from having to go through the public release of gory crime scene photographs and the like. But in general death extinguishes the privacy rights of the person deceased.
24:23So find your federal agency. And we have the insignias, emblems of Department of War, Department of Defense and where do we go? The starting point is www. FOIA.gov and on that site we have the lofty language. The basic function of the Freedom of Information act is to ensure informed citizens vital to the functioning of a democratic society. And what we hope and expect is that our agencies live up to those lofty
25:18And you search for the agency. So let's use Department of Defense. Imagine we type that in here and what are we going to get? 37 results. US Strategic Command, US Special Operations Command, European Command, Southern Command, Department of The Air Force, U.S. space Command and many, many others.
25:46So let's imagine that we're interested in Armed Services, Board of Contract Appeals and there's the agency mission to provide a lethal joint force to defend the security of our country and sustain American influence abroad.
26:13And on the agency website like here they have that, they cite the average processing time and this is quite amazing. This was, this is very quick work if it's true, three working days for simple requests that is amazingly speedy and 12 working days for complex requests. And what they suggest is what you're looking for may already be public. And if so you can go to their FOIA library online and look for it. If it's already been released, that makes it very easy and you may be able to download it from the site. Just like the FBI has their online vault of pre processed files,
27:10other agencies do that as well. One note of caution with the FBI, if you go to the vaults and they ask if they, for example,
27:25say here's here are the files that were released about Abe Fortis. What I found is they are not complete. So if you're really interested in every single document, which we often are as lawyers or researchers or historians or reporters, the pre process results may not include everything you're looking for. And we'll talk about that a little later in the program. So there's a form. You make your request, and here for the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals, you would put in the information you're looking for. But FOIA requests can be made on the portal that the agency has by email, by snail mail. So if you're using an email form, you cite the Freedom of Information act, you detail what you're looking for, and you should do that as specifically as possible. But understanding if you're, if you limit your request, they're not going to broaden it. So do multiple requests that encompass everything you're looking for. And then I'm going to talk about some tricks to make sure you get everything,
29:06everything that you're looking for. You need to determine what your status is. Your status being, are you a commercial requester? Are you a personal requester? Are you requesting for an educational institution, public interest group or journalist? Or you could be freelance. Are you affiliated with the media?
29:37And the reason to determine what your status is is because there may be fees. So request a fee waiver of search fees and copy costs if you're a member of the media, representing the media, representing educational institution, publishing one's findings or the information you seek is in the public interest. And the code of Federal Register will define this public interest as any person or entity that gathers information of potential interest to a segment of the public, uses his editorial skills to turn the raw materials into a distinct work, and distributes that work to an audience. I always including when I was a baby lawyer and just starting out as a freelance journalist and researcher, I requested a fee waiver that I'm requesting this in the public interest. I'm going to publish my findings and donate the FBI records to a public library.
30:58And I always got a fee waiver. Sometimes I appealed in order to get that status. So fees a typical requester. The agency can charge for the time it takes to search for the records and for the duplication of those records. There's usually no charge for the first two hours of search time or for the first hundred pages of duplication. Some of my requests were tens of thousands of pages. So that fee waiver was pretty important to me.
31:41Appeal every denial, Every denial. An appeal is easy. And you can do it online these days to obtain more information. Appeal to challenge the adequacy of their search. Appeal to preserve the right to sue in federal court. Appeal, appeal, appeal, appeal. And you can file suit after your appeal in the city your office is in, where you live, where the Documents are located or Washington D.C. i chose to litigate in the Middle District of North Carolina, Greensboro, because my office was in Durham, which is in the Middle District of North Carolina. I chose not to travel to D.C. to litigate.
32:48And there is a letter in response to a FOIA appeal. What you'll get when you give notice of appeal. And again when if you're denied records or the records are claimed to be excluded and you appeal, you get an appeal number a dash in the year and in your number. It's also citing your Freedom of Information request number, which is important to keep in use every time you're communicating with the agency.
33:26So now to the case study FOIA request to the FBI. These days it's very easy. You can go to the portal forms.FBI.gov FBI-e FOIA-request-form
33:52the FBI. I learned reading the FBI and Martin Luther King Jr by David Garrow used wiretapping, bugging, threats, poison pen letters and disinformation against the Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Did the FBI do the same against the liberal Earl Warren Court?
34:17That was the question I had. And being a suspicious sort, I believe the FBI spied on the Court and did any other untoward things. Here's a picture of the brethren with Earl Warren in the front and center in 1966.
34:45So my 1983 FOIA request requested all files about the High Court. And I did what you shouldn't do is around the world request. I just threw everything in, everything I believed about what the FBI had done in the past. And I asked for any files or documents relating to present or past FBI surveillance of the United States Supreme Court, including attempts to influence its decision making, attempts to gain copies of Court opinions prior to public release, the use of informants or sources within the Court, including Justices, clerks, clerical, administrative or other persons involved in carrying out the Court's day to day functioning to allow the Bureau access to the inner workings of the Court in addition to any other FBI programs directed at the Supreme Court from January 1, 1924 to the present time.
36:01So that original request was made on October 26, 1983. Got no response. No response. Should have appealed. Then I made Follow up Letters 2-6-1984 4/13-1984. Wow, this was taking a long time. I was getting no response.
36:29Finally the FBI wrote to me, we have no file called Supreme Court. I didn't believe it. I consulted with an expert, Professor David Garrow, winner of the Pulitzer Prize for his Martin Luther King biography Bearing the Cross. He was at UNC Chapel Hill, where I had just graduated from law school. And he recommended asking for the FBI files on each and every deceased justice going back to the 1930s. That's how I became the number one requester under the FOIA to the FBI.
37:19And a trick you can use with any agency. Request your own file in a separate follow up FOIA request.
37:33Request all search slips. This allows you to see how the agency is processing your FOIA request. It's like pretrial discovery. But it's important not to ask for your own file in the same letter you're asking for the subject you're interested in. Because they haven't created your file until a certain time has elapsed for them to search for the documents and create your file. So wait, but do it. And here's why.
38:16After I was told no records existed, I got my own file. It was more than 3,000 pages.
38:27And what it I've got in it is a search slip. This is an FBI search slip. And there is the subject United States Supreme Court.
38:41And there's some exemptions but notice at the bottom it says other variations not listed. They found seven files about the Supreme Court. One including United States Supreme Court law clerks. And remember in my around the world request I asked for information about law clerks. And here's a file number. It's a 62 file. 62-27-5585.
39:18And what I would learn is that file which I requested by exact file numbers. 62 file is a miscellaneous file. What I learned by going through my own file was that despite the fact the FBI told me they had no file in the Supreme Court and they filed found seven files about the Supreme Court. A fee waiver committee considering my fee waiver granted me a fee waiver that it was in the public interest to release files on the Supreme Court.
40:04Yet they told me the files didn't exist. So is that just gross incompetence or a grand conspiracy? I will let you decide. Over the years I've had my own opinions.
40:27So I use that search slip to request the file called Supreme Court by its exact file number. I didn't realize that's what I was requesting. I just knew the search slip talked about law clerks and the Supreme Court and I wanted that file. Jackpot. More than 2,000 pages of records about FBI spying on the court were released. And one of those pages is shown with me as a younger lawyer. And there's some redactions, but most of that page is readable. And about spying on the court.
41:21And what I did is I Vowed when I did the first request to get the fee waiver, I published my findings. And there's an article that I wrote called FBI kept a file on the Supreme Court and notice the date 1988. It took me five years from the request for files on the Supreme Court to be told they didn't exist, to get my own file, to get the release of the file called Supreme Court. And I did an op ed for the Washington Post how the FBI spied on the high court. Thirty years of wiretaps and over 2,000 pages of private files on the justices. That was 1989.
42:14So let's go to 1966.
42:20Lyndon Baines Johnson was President. Earl Warren was Chief Justice. Nicholas Katzenbach was Attorney General. Thurgood Marshall was Solicitor General.
42:35And of concern to the FBI was Senator Edward V. Long. A Democrat from Missouri was threatening to investigate FBI electronic surveillances in 66. So Hoover sent the FBI third in command, Arthur Deke Deloach to have a little talk talkie to, to the Senator to avoid this result. And deloach was successful. And Long never investigated the Bureau of Surveillance Practices. But of note, that same year, Senator Long wrote a final draft of the FOIA before its passage in 1966. So thank you, Senator Long.
43:30So the biggest threat ever to J. Edgar Hoover's power up to that point was a warrantless bugging case before the high court which could expose decades of illegal FBI surveillance. And the case was fred B. Black Jr. Versus the United States. He had been convicted of tax evasion.
43:59And.
44:05The goal of the FBI in that case was to blame former Attorney General Robert Kennedy, who was a rival and adversary of LBJ in the Democratic Party. They needed a mole on the Supreme Court to help out because this was a crucial point in the FBI's history. And the FBI knew that Fortas was an advisor and confidant of lbj. Even more. Fortas, while he was on the court would go over to the White House and advise the President something that violates separation of powers. It arguably was unethical, it was untoward. He shouldn't have been doing it.
44:55The bugging cases that were going up to the court there we have lobbyist fred B. Black Jr. With ties to the Democrats. He's top left. We have the case of Boxer and activist Muhammad Ali, top right and Teamster leader Jimmy Hoffa bottom right. And there's Bobby Kennedy to the left. All those illegal bugging cases were making their way up to the court. And first was fred B. Black Jr. S case. And what the FBI had Done. They used a spike microphone. There is a picture of one and you see a box at the top, it's black. And that big spike. And that gets pounded into the wall, which is an incursion into property.
45:57And we have the microphone on the far left. And that is at that time was considered a Fourth Amendment violation. It would be a Fourth Amendment violation today. And often the placement of that spike microphone was done by what's called a black bag job, which is a burglary. So we have another Fourth Amendment violation. So we have all sorts of crimes going on.
46:36So we're going to spend some time on this memo.
46:44And what I learned by challenging the scope of the search in my litigation was that in that Supreme Court file, it didn't have everything. It didn't have all the goodies, the really bad things that the Bureau was doing towards the Court. It was bad enough what was in the 2,000 pages in the file called Supreme Court. But the FBI had a bifurcated, a two tiered program of keeping records. They had what's called Do Not File files. They also called them June Mail. And one set of these Do Not File files was Hoover's official and confidential files. What some people refer as the blackmail files. He kept them under lock and key in his own office. They were so sensitive, no one else could access them. And when I asked for all the files on Justice Fortis, I actually also asked for all cross references. And a cross reference is a mention of someone in the main file of another person.
48:13So, for example, you see on this memo it says fred B. Black Jr. On the left. The file is about Fortis acting as an informant against his brethren for the FBI. But this file was considered a cross reference. So had I not asked for cross references, I wouldn't have received this file. And what this file shows is that assistant to the Director deloach is telling.
48:55Hoover and Tolson, Tolson's number two in command, Clyde Tolson, about his morning meeting with Justice Fortis. Where Justice Fortas was telling DeLoach about what the Supreme Court intended to do on the Fred Black case. And that he would assist the FBI in blaming Bobby Kennedy for the illegal bugging in the Fred Black case. That he would lobby his brethren.
49:34What he received from DeLoach were FBI memos that were signed by Bobby Kennedy.
49:45And he recused himself in the Fred Black case. But he continued to attend conference at the Supreme Court about the Black case. He continued to lobby his brethren about the Black case. And he created a blind memo that he passed around to the other Justices, this was the greatest ethical violation in the history of the court. But when I got this memo,
50:26I wasn't sure I could believe it. Would the man who argued and won the Clarence Earl Gideon case, the case that requires states to pay court appointed lawyers to represent folks who might get prison time, Would this man, Abe Fortis, super lawyer, snitch for the FBI against his brethren? Would the brilliant liberal justice who wrote Tinker vs. Des Moines, the freedom of speech case for students, violate his judicial ethics in this way? I found it hard to believe.
51:04So I reached out to Carolyn Ager, Justice Fortas widow, and got special permission to examine sealed Fortis papers at Yale. They're now unsealed, but when I asked they were had been sealed. And I found five folders that contained FBI memos that DeLoach had given Fortis at a time when he had recused himself on the case. And the blind memo to lobby the Justices to blame Bobby Kennedy. So.
51:46Again, in my opinion, this was the biggest ethical violation ever of a Supreme Court justice acting as an informant. And it was something that was hard for me to fathom. But in the end I found that it was indeed true. Hoover survived the ruling in the Black case. The FBI was mentioned, but Hoover was not. And Hoover wasn't mentioned. Thanks to the unethical machinations of Justice A. Fortis and again my promise to publish. In 1992 I published Cloak and Gavel. FBI wiretaps, bugs, informers and the Supreme Court.
52:37And.
52:44It wasn't over. The litigation isn't over. There's more to find. There's a picture of the courthouse in Greensboro. And this is the Wheel of Fortune segment of the litigation.
53:01We wanted to index of the Hoover's official and confidential files. The FBI said it didn't exist. But one of my mentors, Professor Ethan Theo Harris, the foremost authority in the Bureau, had an index that the FBI had released to him years ago. It was alphabetized, it was numbered in number 70. Foreign influence in the black extremist movement was followed by 71 which was redacted, and 72. Foxworth, P.E. my lawyer, the brilliant Paul Green, figured it out. F, O, R, t, a s comma space, a, b, e. 11 spaces, letters comma. So we did a motion.
53:57Filed in federal court. And in this hallway an FBI employee handed me six pages of blackmail memos about Abe Fortas. Prior to the hearing, attached memorandum from the Washington Field Office reflects possible homosexual activities on the part of Justice Abe Fortis. Colson and DeLoach recommend that a memorandum be prepared forwarding this information to the Attorney General.
54:28There is Hoover's initials at the bottom,
54:34J E H. And he writes, no, DeLoach should see Fortis. And here's a memo that I received in that hallway in federal court showing that DeLoach went to Fortis's home at 5:10pm on 724 67. He handed him the memo accusing him of having sex with a teenage boy. Foris denied it and Foris was told that the FBI was not going to investigate and nothing further would be done on the FBI's end. It wouldn't be reported to the Attorney General. No one would look into it. Essentially that his secret was safe. There's deloach and a Vortis below. So this sexual blackmail, a Supreme Court justice was compromised. He's told his secret is safe.
55:42It was locked away, hidden in Hoover's private office. And and then after Hoover's death, in a special file room under lock and key. No investigation was ever done of this allegation of having sex with a teenage boy. Despite the fact that here's the Homosexuals in Government program required investigation and removal from office. Though Justice Forrest continued to rule on FBI cases after 1967, after he had been blackmailed, mailed after he had been compromised, his secret was safe for over three decades. The Senate didn't learn of it when Fortas was nominated to be Chief Justice. They didn't learn of it when he resigned in disgrace due to unrelated financial scandal. And the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence didn't learn of it. The Church Committee after Watergate.
56:42So again, back to my tips. Request searches of special indices if you want them. Elser is electronic surveillance index. Otherwise you won't get things like this mentioning that a justice of the Supreme Court was picked up in a wiretap. Again, ask for C references, everything, get everything. Appeal the denials, litigate, ask for the search slips. My decades long FOIA journey, you don't have to go through decades of requests and litigation because you've learned a couple tips and use them. So my 42 years of FOIA requests, 13 years of litigation and I got published. Re redid my cloak and gavel book to update it with the blackmail information and wrote FBI snitches, Blackmail and Obscene Ethics at the Supreme Court. My tens of thousands of FBI records are housed at UNC Chapel Hill and the Villanova Law School. 20,000 items, 60 linear feet are UNC Chapel Hill. And at Villanova, the more recent Supreme Court justices who died after my litigation, Chief Justice Rehnquist thurgood Marshall. Those records are at Villanova. If you need more help, check out the National Security Archive or the aclu. They have detailed manuals for doing your requests. Or email me at hrnsarnslaw.hutch.com so play offense, keep requesting appeal, sue if need be. And I wish you good luck. Good hunting. And don't be dissuaded from using the foia. Based on my case study.
58:50That was a unique situation. It was an agency that was trying to protect its reputation against my efforts to to reveal some very dirty secrets that they had. So thank you very much and be well.