Richard O.NY
Excellent program and excellent presenter.
1h 1min · about 9,800 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, I'm Jeff Cunningham from Goldberg Sagala. Today we're going to be discussing a deep dive into legal malpractice with ethical considerations. I am told that you're able to unmute yourself if you want, and you can also drop questions into the text. If anybody wants to get interactive, feel free. You can interrupt, you can ask questions at the end. And before I start, I'd be a pretty sorry ethics guy if I didn't read my claimers at the bottom. Prior results do not guarantee a future or similar outcome, and no attorney client relationship is formed. And this material does not constitute and should not be considered legal advice. All right, so you'll notice the fish theme. We're going to keep that throughout the deep dive into legal malpractice. A little bit about me my name is Jeff Cunningham. I'm a partner at Goldberg Sagala, and I consider myself the law firm GC. I used to be your law firm GC, but another guy down in Atlanta, John Hawkins, actually has that trademarked, and he's a great law firm general counsel as well. So I deferred and took the law firm GC. I defend lawyers and law firms sued for legal malpractice and facing ethics issues. I also serve as outside general counsel to solo to mid sized law firms providing simple systems before there are problems. I spent most of my early career defending lawyers sued for legal malpractice and then transitioned into doing grievance, attorney discipline issues.
1:23And for the past five years or so, I've really been trying to get ahead of problems before they turn into a lawsuit or a grievance and working on simple ways that law firms can protect themselves, really using attorney statistics, which we'll go through some of the major statistics and looking at your biggest source of risk and sort of attempting to get ahead of that risk. I'm an attorney admitted in New York and Connecticut. All right, again, here's the fish theme. It will follow us throughout. We're going to talk about the big picture, legal mal generally, ethics generally. And then, as I said, the RIT statistics and sort of a lot of my approach is based off of my experience in defending lawyers, but I also like to use the ABA's available statistics and other statistics to the extent they're out there. But the ABA and some insurers are the primary source of our data on attorney discipline and legal malpractice.
2:18Then I want to talk about ethics, the elements of legal Mao, the common defenses to legal Mao, some specific scenarios to work through the four elements of legal malpractice the common defenses of legal malpractice claims, and those ethics issues we're talking about. And we'll be discussing the ABA model rules. So obviously, you have to look at your state analogs to see what the actual rules in your jurisdictions are. And then we'll wrap up with I always like to close out with some action steps, some simple things you could do today to make your law firm safer and your practice better. And again, I really try to strive for simple approaches that are actually going to be used by your people with the biggest return on investment.
3:03I've found that a perfect risk management system doesn't exist, but even if it did, if it was too complicated, people wouldn't be able to use it, or they wouldn't bother using it. And it's almost better not to have something if you're not going to have something that's actually employed. So an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Ben Franklin said that, and he did it in the insurance context. Creating a insurance and firefighting policy in Pennsylvania a very long time ago. I think it's really a great idea for law firms to consider that getting ahead of problems before they become disasters is absolutely key. And the cost savings of addressing your risk early on versus making an insurance claim, dealing with a lawsuit, or, God forbid, dealing with an attorney.
3:53Grievance and discipline really can't be overstated. We'll get to the statistics in a bit, but the most shocking statistic out there, according to the ABA, 80% of lawyers will be sued for legal malpractice over the course of their career. That's lawyers in private practice, 80%. So four out of five of us will face a legal malpractice claim. That's a shocking statistic. I'm in this world. I think that number is high, but I don't think it's excessively high. Probably not as excessively high as most of you listening would think. So that's the ABA stat, 80%. According to the ABA, we have a four to 17% chance of a legal malclaim per year. Again, that's lawyers in private practice. And that four to 17% range depends on your practice area. Unfortunately, they don't publish which practice areas at the 17%.
4:45But I have some guesses that we'll talk about when we get to the other ABA statistics. The big picture here, your primary source of risk is your clients. I often say your clients are your enemy. And I say that because it's a little shocking. I think it helps jar lawyers into a risk management mindset. And your clients can certainly be great clients. They are obviously those that we owe our primary duties to. They're the whole reason we practice law. They're also our source of financial success. And many times, clients can become friends. They can be wonderful people no matter what, even if they're relatives of yours, no matter what. At the end of the day, your client is your enemy.
5:27Your client is your primary source of risk. It's like 99% of your risk stems from your clients. So keeping that in mind, while we love our clients, we want to use that as sort of the big picture lens to look at risk to law firms, and specifically here, legal malpractice risks and the corresponding ethical compliance that's required. My approach is to use sort of a four pronged big picture approach. And these aren't hard and fast categories or anything. It's just the way I like to break down risk into four different ways of looking at the risk. And then that way it sort of gives me a more holistic approach. Education, admitting and understanding the risk, figuring out what your biggest areas of risk are based on your practice, your firm size, your jurisdiction, and your client base, and thinking about where you can get the biggest return on investment for incorporating systems. That's the second part of my method, using the ethics rules in your jurisdiction as a basis to create systems based on your prior experience. My prior experience, the ABA and state Bar Association's prior experience, creating systems, simple systems, hopefully, that address, mitigate and transfer that risk to the extent you can. Plans incorporating the defenses, we'll discuss the defenses to legal malpractice are a great basis for planning purposes, for defending your law firm and really considering what happens if your systems fail. And thinking about your risk and each piece of risk you can identify and
6:57then coming up with a response plan for that risk. And that includes not only steps to be taken, but also people to be included. One of the biggest mistakes I see law firms make is not having an action plan or a legal malpractice claim or other very foreseeable risk. You should. If you don't, that can be your takeaway for the day, is you should have a simple file made up with your response plan, the steps you take, the order you're going to go in, counsel, you're going to contact your insurer, how you're going to protect any internal communications, things like that. So planning is absolutely key, and then that bleeds into teams, and that's how you take the action and who you take the action with. And I like to remind lawyers that your team isn't just the equity partners. It isn't just your leadership committee or whoever runs your law firm.
7:50It's not even just your firm. You want to look from the bottom of your firm to the top, front office to back. You want to think about your vendors that are involved, your insurers. They're a great resource, a really underutilized resource. And even your clients, to some extent, think about your team in the broadest possible context you can, and incorporate that team into your systems and your planning. All right, so that's our big picture method. And again, just to hammer home the idea that the client is the enemy, I really like this fable. I guess it is. It's an iranian, ancient iranian fable. Persian, I suppose.
8:26But every culture on the planet seems to have some version of it. There's a scorpion, and there's a turtle, and they're buddies. And the scorpion can't swim. Of course the turtle can swim. And the scorpion says to the turtle, hey, I need to get to the other side of the river. Can you swim me over there? And the turtle says, sure, hop on my back. So they swim out into the middle of the river, and then the scorpion tries to sting the turtle, and of course, the turtle shell protects him. The turtle gets to the other side, the scorpion gets off, and the turtle says, why would you do that? I'm your friend. I'm helping you.
8:55You would have killed me, but you would have also killed yourself because you can't swim. So if you stung me in the river, you would have drowned. And the scorpion answers, it's nothing more than this that my nature instigates me to sting. And so here, the scorpion is our clients. The turtle is the lawyer. The turtle shell is all of the various risk management systems we can employ to protect ourselves from our good friends, clients who, in their nature, will inevitably sting us. And again, you have an 80% chance over the course of your career of facing a legal malpractice claim. So while clients are wonderful, clients can be your friends, clients can be your relatives, clients are your primary source of risk. And it's absolutely key that you keep that in mind. All right? In addition to liking old persian fables, I like darts a lot. And so I like to think about the interaction between ethics and malpractice risks in the dartboard. And if you aren't familiar with the dartboard, this is a pretty straightforward illustration. The black and white spaces will use. The white are our ethical obligations.
9:59The black is our malpractice risk. The red and green areas, not the bullseye, but those two rings you see are your double and triple point areas. Those red and green areas are the overlap where things like conflicts of interest come up. Those can be both an ethical issue and a malpractice risk. In the black and white, you're really dealing with just an ethics concern or just a malpractice concern. They don't always overlap, but where they do, those are the danger zones. And the bullseye, of course, is the lawyer. The lawyer is the target of a legal malpractice claim. The lawyer is the target of ethical grievances.
10:35And here, of course, this will be the last time I think that I'll beat up on our clients. But the darts are the clients, right? And they're aiming for the bullseye. They're coming after the lawyers. There's a host of reasons why lawyers are particularly tempting targets. But we don't need to go into that. We just need to accept that lawyers are tempting targets. Clients are our primary source of risk, and we want to look at the ethical and legal ways we can insulate and protect our firm while providing the best possible service to our clients. Don't hold me. They're not beating up on the clients. I think I might complain about them a little more later, but we'll see. I'll try to keep myself in check. So, going through some of the ABA statistics I discussed, these primarily come from the profile of legal malpractice claims. The ABA puts out every four years, and the next one's coming out next year, probably next October.
11:23So it'll be interesting to see what COVID did to risk to law firms. But the general idea here is the smaller the firm, the more risky the firm. And as you can see, law firms of ten lawyers or less make up 72% of all legal malpractice claims. Keep in mind that 80% of lawyers will face illegal malpractice claim. 72% of all claims are against firms of ten lawyers or less. About a third are against solo practitioners. And it's assumed that the ethics stats track the legal malstats, although they're just not as readily available. But a third of lawyers make up in the US make up solo practitioners, and about 60% of attorney discipline is brought against. Public discipline is brought against solo practitioners.
12:18So the attorney discipline stats might actually even be worse. But the stats aren't as available. The ABA doesn't track it in the same way. And I think the reason for that is the insurance companies participate in the ABA profile of legal malpractice claims. While you can't generally have insurance for attorney discipline, they don't have the partner in the same way and maybe the financing in the same way. So the big takeaway here, the smaller the firm, the bigger the risk. There's tons and tons of reasons for that. I think one of the biggest reasons is large firms. Every Amlaw 100 firm, most firms of more than 100 lawyers have general counsel, and small firms typically do not. That's one of the reasons I got into the practice area I did of providing outside general counsel services to law firms.
13:05I think it's a huge area of need, and there's just not many people providing that service to small firms. But regardless of the reasons, we want to really think about what we can do based on this reality that small firms are riskier in the same way. Practice type. And this also comes from the ABA's profile of legal malpractice. But your practice area really does dictate a lot of your risk. As you'll see, 22% of all legal malpractice claims stem from personal injuries. And that's mainly plaintiff side personal injury. Family law, real estate, trust and estates sort of business. Commercial and bankruptcy are kind of the other big areas.
13:49Criminal. We'll talk about the nuances of criminal defense work. Criminal makes up a pretty sizable amount when you consider how small of a population of criminal defense attorneys we have compared to general civil practice. And then all other practice areas make up 15%. That's not to say all other practice areas are really safe, but these major practice areas are huge sources of risk. And I think this also sort of ties into why small firms are riskier. These tend to be small firm practice areas. Personal injury, especially plaintiff side, family law, real estate, trust in estates, they tend to be smaller firms dealing with these types of practice areas.
14:35So our erisk, and here we have the law firm size at the bottom on the. I guess that's the x axis. I think I shouldn't dive into math, but the bottom is law firm size and then the percent of reported incidents. Now, this is cyber issues. And as you'll see, as firms grow, their risk increases, the percent of reported claims increases, and then as firm size gets larger, they start to get better. And I think this is really illustrative of risk in general, because once firms get to a certain size, they have the resources to devote to deal with ethics issues, to deal with cyber and technology issues, to deal with financial issues that they might not have, and the danger zone.
15:23The incline of this graph really also demonstrates that while small firms are particularly risky, growth is also a real risk. And as law firms grow and expand in new practice areas, new geographic locations and jurisdictions, new practice groups folding in lots of other lawyers, that adds a ton of more risk. And on top of all that, you're also typically folding in lots of new clients. And since clients are a primary source of risk, that makes things riskier and riskier. And then the last of our statistics, I hope, is really jarring. Approximately 55% of all disciplinary proceedings and legal malpractice claims involve attorney mental health and or substance abuse issues. I think that percentage is probably extremely low. Anecdotally, I think in my experience, it's probably closer to, like 90% of all the issues I see, especially when it comes to disciplinary proceedings, there's almost always an attorney wellness component. And one of the big areas I preach to law firms is that attorney wellness is risk management. And so whatever you're doing to support your attorneys and staff from mental health, substance abuse issues, wellness as a whole, find ways to do more. There's a lot of resources. The bar associations are finally starting to really provide resources. There's a lot of free resources that are available, no matter that your firm size, no matter your practice area. I hope a takeaway today, especially in the very challenging holiday season, is that you think of more ways you can support your people. Whether it's more
16:58paid time off, whether it's monitoring paid time off, seeing who isn't taking vacation, and maybe finding out why they're not taking vacation to just asking people if they're doing okay to actual programs through the bar association or other events. I did a virtual forest bathing meditation. A friend is running it. Not something I ever thought I would do. And it was not even in the forest. It was literally a Zoom call, and it was incredibly relaxing. It was shockingly effective. And if anybody's interested, reach out. I can connect you with that program. It was really surprisingly effective, and I'm still shocked that it actually worked, and I felt better after doing it, and it was a lot of fun. So broaden your horizons a little bit, but realize that over half of all your problems are going to stem from attorney wellness in some way.
17:55And of course, don't neglect your non lawyer staff. Everybody on your team has to deal with issues, and you want to be as supportive as possible again before there's a problem. It's good business, it's good risk management, and it's the right thing to do. So it's kind of win, win, win. All right, so that's enough for the scary statistics. Diving into ethics a little deeper, as I mentioned, today we'll be discussing the ABA model rules of professional conduct. The other sources of ethics are lawyer codes, like the restatement of law governing lawyers, your jurisdictional rules, or even rules outside of your jurisdiction that could potentially be persuasive, and in the same way, ethics opinions every jurisdiction has now adopted the ABA model rules, but no jurisdiction has done it completely. Even in jurisdictions that have adopted most of the model rules, they haven't always adopted the comments. And then each jurisdiction's ethics opinions are going to interpret the rules, whether or not they're copies of the model rules, differently. And then you have court decisions, which ultimately, in most jurisdictions, ultimately decides on attorney discipline and ethical issues.
19:06And the courts will be deciding based on the jurisdiction's rules and the jurisdiction's law. And so we have real, competing sources of ethics jumping back up to the ethics opinions as well. Unlike the courts, you'll often have state bar associations providing ethics opinions. You'll have county city affinity bar associations, whether they're religious, demographic, ethnic, whatever, or industry specific. So there's lots of ethics opinions running around. And if your rule in your state is the same or similar to a neighboring state or another state, then you could even look to those opinions if you don't have an opinion on point. Most attorney discipline is private, so there's not available court decisions.
19:49But the more drastic attorney discipline decisions are published, are public and available. And then finally you right. We each have our own set of ethical obligations, commitments and understanding based on our professional conduct. And I don't think we do that justice. I don't think we take a moment and recognize that it's not just the model rules, it's not just the risk of being disbarred. Right. We're all professionals, and there is something personal about our commitment to ethics. So all of the rules are involved in legal malpractice and in risk management to law firms. Today, we'll be talking about a few of them, and it's quite a few of them, but it is a few of them just rattling off the list. 1.1 competence, 1.2 scope 1.4 Communication 1.5. And fees 1.6. And confidentiality 1.8 to 1.14 your conflicts rules 1.16 declining terminating the representation 2.1 attorneys as advisors. 5.1 to 5.3 the supervisory rules 6.1 pro bono and 8.4 misconduct. We'll talk about each of these rules when we get to the various elements, and sort of digging into the elements of legal malpractice and connecting which rules show up at which element, but this is our working list.
21:22Then the elements of legal malpractice. And I got the periodic table in the background, privity, a breach, and then some jurisdictions combine three and four, but most break it out into four elements. I like to break it out when thinking about them, approximate cause and then damage and taking it back from the top. There has to be an attorney client relationship. Again, clients are your primary source of risk, except in very rare circumstances, a non client cannot sue you for legal malpractice. We'll talk about it a little bit more, but there are instances of near privity, especially in the trust and estate context, but where the lawyer is aware of the client's reliance on the attorney and the non client's reliance on the attorney, and the non client is reasonably relying on the lawyer. In those instances, courts can find near privity enough to allow a professional liability claim against an attorney that is not the attorney for the plaintiff.
22:26The privity element and the creation of that attorney client relationship is absolutely key, and most jurisdictions find it to be the subjective, reasonable belief of the client. And so I think lawyers often do not appreciate the risk in that if a client considers you their lawyer and that's reasonable, then you may be their lawyer, whether or not you think you are, it's not necessarily a mutual understanding in all jurisdictions, and so documenting the relationship or lack of relationship is absolutely key. The breach element is typically along the lines of a reasonable attorney in similar circumstances.
23:12And I like to think about the breach element, and we'll talk about this in more detail. But I like to think about the breach element. Comparing a Manhattan real estate attorney who handles million billion dollar deals versus a solar practitioner up in Plattsburg, New York, which is a small town up right before you get to the, you know, a solo practitioner who handles any kind of work and happens to be doing a first time homebuyer's, home purchase, residential home purchase, those attorneys are going to be held to different standards. It's a reasonable standard based on the reasonable attorney in similar circumstances, same law, just a different breach standard. Proximate cause.
23:53Typically that has to be, but for causation, not the sole proximate cause. And this is the case within a case that most people have heard about. When dealing with legal malpractice, the legal malpractice plaintiff has a tough burden, has to prove that. But for the breach, the act or omission of the attorney, the plaintiff would have succeeded in the underlying action, done better at settlement, or done better in the deal if the underlying issue was a transaction and not a litigation. It's very challenging, and it's very hard to successfully sue your attorney, which is generally good for us. The proximate cause element almost always requires a legal malpractice expert, and some jurisdictions treat it a little differently. But except in very straightforward cases, like missing the statute of limitations, the law requires an expert and the fact finder to determine the breach and proximate cause and then the damage element.
24:50And again, this is sometimes combined with the proximate cause element, but as a standalone element, the damages typically have to be actual damages, so not hypothetical. And dollar damages, pecuniary loss only, so not emotional damage or loss of liberty, things like that. It has to be dollar damages. Typically, there are a few jurisdictions that are sort of opening the door there, but those are pretty rare circumstances. So using those four elements, we're going to talk about the common defenses. There are other defenses, of course, but the common defenses to legal malpractice claims, and then go through some scenarios that we can discuss the elements and attach the model rules and the various defenses to those scenarios to really try to understand the elements. And while we discuss all of these, try to think about ways you can incorporate this into your firm's daily practice, and think of these defenses, think of the ethical obligations we have, and think about how you can better protect your firm and in the process, better serve your clients. So the statute of limitations, like all claims, it's very important, but understanding the statute of limitations defenses and how your jurisdiction treats whether there's a discovery rule or whether there's the continuous representation doctrine, which extends the statute until the attorney client relationship ends, really understanding how the statute of limitations comes into play and whether you can shorten the statute of limitations, typically, you can, in most jurisdictions,
26:25in your engagement agreement. So that's something to consider as well. The absolute privity requirement. As I discussed, there are instances where near privity can allow non clients to sue lawyers, but those are rare. And most jurisdictions have a very strong presumption of absolute privity that's required to sue your lawyer. The sophisticated client doctrine, this is called a bunch of different names and a bunch of different jurisdictions. But the basic idea is, much like the breach and the proximate cause elements, the courts will look to the sophistication level of the client, and like the lawyer, it'll be a reasonable lawyer.
27:05In similar circumstances, courts will often look to the reasonable client in a similar circumstance. So, going back to the idea of the Manhattan real estate attorney and the first time home buyers up in Plattsburg, New York, the client of the Manhattan real estate attorney, assuming they've done millions of dollars of deals and they're a big time real estate developer, they're going to be held to a different standard than a first time home buyer. It's just the reality judgment call doctrine. This also is called the attorney judgment rule, the professional judgment rule. There's a lot of names for this one as well, but the basic idea is that the courts don't look back with perfect hindsight to say, well, your strategy, your trial strategy, your analysis of the case, your reading of the case law, whatever, it turned out not to work, so it was negligent. The standard remains the reasonable practitioner in similar circumstances. So courts won't just look back and say, well, you lost the trial, so your trial prep was inadequate. It's an understanding that attorneys need to be able to employ their professional judgment without the fear of repercussions.
28:18Collectibility. This can sometimes be a defense. Sometimes it's actually incorporated into the damages or other elements of the legal malpractice claim. But the basic idea is, even if everything the lawyer did was 100% negligent, and they just completely botched the representation, and all the other elements are there, if the underlying case was worthless, say the underlying defendant was judgment proof, or if the underlying deal was worthless, say Bertie Madoff had been running a huge scam and there actually wasn't any money once the deal was done. If the underlying issue was not collectible, if it was worth $0, then the legal malpractice plaintiff has no damages because they don't have the actual and ascertainable dollar damages that are required.
29:07And then finally, the innocence requirement, which is generally limited to criminal, legal malpractice claims. So, legal malpractice claims stemming from criminal defense, not legal malpractice that crosses over into criminal activity, but legal mal stemming from criminal defense matters. The innocence requirement, and it varies by state, but it requires the legal mal plaintiff to show that they were innocent of the crime, either actually innocent, factually innocent, legally innocent, or a combination. And the innocence requirements are really helpful, as we'll discuss in thinking about proximate cause, approximate cause element. All right, so each element, privity, the breach, proximate cause, and damages, really provides an opportunity to think about legal malpractice, to incorporate ethics and the defenses, and then focused in on your practice and how your practice can be made safer.
30:06And your client services can be better. So keep that in mind. All right, diving into the elements a bit more. The first element, privity. The attorney client relationship creates all of our legal malpractice risk. And again, there is the near privity requirement, the near privity exception. We'll talk about that. But the privity element and the attorney client relationship are going to be absolutely key. And it's so important to have a bespoke custom engagement agreement with every client for every single matter. So even if it's a long standing client, you've represented them for years or decades. Even if you've handled dozens or hundreds of matters, you want to make sure every single matter has a specific engagement agreement for that matter, detailing the scope of their relationship and trying to anticipate any issues and getting ahead of it.
30:58Remember our scorpion and turtle story and your engagement agreement? That's part of the turtle shell. Your other systems are going to be part of the turtle shell, protecting your law firm from the inevitable claims that you're going to face. And then near privity in the Wild west, just a warning to any practitioners in the western states, they're much more likely to accept the near privity concept. The further east you go, the stronger the absolute privity requirement is. Again, in the trust in a state's context, if it's known beneficiaries and the lawyer is aware of the beneficiaries reliance, and the beneficiaries reliance is reasonable. That is really the only place in the absolute privity states where you could see near privity creep in.
31:41But even then, in the absolute privity states, it's generally challenging for plaintiffs. Once you go to the western states that are a little more open to the idea of near privity, your risk goes up in the trust and estates context, but in other practice areas as well, the rules for the privity element, again, all of the rules sort of are captured in legal malpractice, but the ones to really think about here are 1.2 and the scope of representation. Even if you're a general practitioner, you're providing limited scope. You are, and many lawyers don't think of their representation that way. But it's so important that your engagement agreement captures the actual scope of the representation and that you update your engagement agreement periodically when that scope changes.
32:29Scope creep is common. What starts out as the client bringing issue X to the lawyer based on the client's understanding can quickly change to issue, I don't know, y. Once the lawyer sits down and actually looks at the problem and starts to analyze the problem. Just because you're a landlord tenant attorney doesn't mean that the client understands necessarily that they have more than a landlord tenant issue, and so they may very well bring you two or more problems without understanding that you're only going to be dealing with one of those problems. You want to get all of that captured in the engagement agreement and make sure the client really understands that as well as getting a document communication Rule 1.4 Lack of communication remains I think over 30 years the ABA has been tracking the top ten or top five complaints against lawyers, and a lack of communication remains the number one complaint. It's clients number one complaint about attorneys. It's a huge source of risk. It's also an ethical problem and figuring out a way to respond to clients proactively, quickly, effectively, and documenting and memorializing that you're doing that is absolutely key. And the attorney client relationship really hinges on 1.4 and communicating the status of the matter to the client. Declining terminating representation 1.16 is just as important as that initial engagement agreement detailing the scope and communicating the status of the matter, the end of the matter and how you document the end of the matter. How the client understands the end of
34:06the matter is absolutely key and will typically start the clock on statute of limitations to potentially defend against claims. And then rule 8.4 and attorney misconduct and the definition of what misconduct is and how that overlaps with legal malpractice. Again, because clients are the primary source of risk, you want to look at your particular clients and not just your practice areas, not just your landlord tenant clients or your criminal defense clients, but really your specific criminal defense clients. Where are they coming from geographically, economically, the demographics, what community are they a part of? What communities are they a part of? What sort of criminal defense work are you doing? White collar is different from traffic, is different from petty crimes.
34:52So really trying to drill down and think about the common denominators of your specific set of clients to understand the risk and then thinking about 8.4 and how the definition of misconduct, how that creeps in to your specific practice areas, really can be beneficial. So the defenses, again, we talked about all six generally, but the defenses that come up in the privity element are the statute of limitations and absolute privity, the statute of limitations. In many jurisdictions, there's the continuous representation doctrine, or rule, which holds the statute of limitations until the attorney client relationship is terminated, which highlights how important it is to have that end of representation letter. Whether you're withdrawing, whether you've been fired, whether the job is done, the case is over. Whatever it is, you want to have a writing that details the exact specific date that the attorney client relationship ended. You don't need to have everything done right. The client doesn't have to have a copy of their file. The client doesn't have to have paid in full. You can continue communicating with the client to mop up the engagement after the attorney client relationship has been terminated. And so I see many lawyers chasing money that don't actually document the end of their relationship and extend the relationship on for months or even years while they try to collect. Another problem is, if work product is provided and then continuing advice is contemplated, what you really want to do is document
36:28the end of the relationship to start the statute of limitations for that particular representation, and then as additional invite is provided or additional work product is provided, open a new file, get a new engagement agreement signed, and then start the clock on that discrete work. The continuous representation doctrine is for discrete matters. So if you're providing general representation to a client, it doesn't toll the statute for all of your advice. It is for specific deals, specific litigations, specific matters. And so again, that's why it's so important to have a bespoke retainer agreement for each individual matter, even if it's a long term client, even if it's your only client. And then the absolute privity requirement, as we talked about, only your client can sue you for malpractice with very limited exceptions. You want to take a look and see what your know, whether it falls into the Wild west, where near privity is more common, and then your practice area, and think about, okay, we represent clients in these three practice areas. What situations would allow for erosion of the absolute privity requirement in our jurisdictions?
37:41What clients are riskier than others? And it could be in the trust and estates context that you have to add additional steps and systems to deal with the beneficiaries, known beneficiaries. In the near privity context, it could be an instance where if you're dealing with spouses, you need to document that you represent one or the other or both. So, as I said, for each element, we'll talk through scenarios and sort of discuss the ethics rules and common defenses. So this scenario was a pretty terrible personal injury. The plaintiff was really terribly injured and happened to speak a foreign language. And so the attorneys represented the injured worker.
38:34Ultimately, they were unsuccessful. They didn't sue the proper party. It was particularly shady, I think, what the defendant entity did and had this web of sort of fronts, and the court, unfortunately, was not very supportive, and ultimately, the statute ran on the proper entity. Now, there was other issues going on in this case, but for our purposes here, the law firm was sued not only by the injured plaintiff, the client, but also by the client's wife. And the retainer agreement between the law firm and the client was absolutely key because it definitively limited the relationship to the injured plaintiff. Specifically noted that spouses and relatives were not clients, and the scope of the representation was specifically limited to the litigation. And the firm did a nice job of including the actual details of the litigation, including the case number.
39:36Once the case was filed, they plugged it into the engagement agreement and sent the updated engagement agreement to the client. So the retainer agreement was absolutely key. Now, this didn't help the law firm dealing with the client, the injured client. And again, it was a substantial injury, and the damages were in the millions. Ultimately, we settled the case, and the plaintiff client had a good case, but the client's spouse did not. She simply was not being represented by the law firm. So any act or omission on the part of the law firm had nothing to do with her and didn't damage her in any way. Here, the spouse acted as a translator for her husband because they spoke a foreign language and her English was way better. And the spouse even took solo phone calls with the lawyer.
40:27Now, those phone calls may not have been privileged. They may still have fallen under the umbrella of privilege. We didn't have to deal with that. But even here, taking solo phone calls with the law firm wasn't enough to push her into near privy. Now, this happened to be in New York, which has a very strong absolute privity. And before we jump into the next scenario here, the scope of services, the engagement agreement and communication with the client, those ethics rules were absolutely key in protecting the firm. The next scenario involved a law firm made up of two partners. It was just two partners. One handled sort of the transactional work, and one handled the litigation. They had the transactional guy, the litigation guy made sense. Again here. The retainer agreement was absolutely key. So the firm had a client they had dealt with on many other occasions, and client was getting into hard money lending and brought a deal to the firm.
41:34The transactional guy drafted the instrument, and the loan was made. They had an engagement agreement for that work, and they had a nice termination letter. When that was done, everybody was happy. Ultimately, the borrower defaulted, and the client came back to the firm and said, I need to sue this guy. He defaulted on the loan so that the litigation guy then takes over, there's a new engagement agreement, and the litigation guy sues. Ultimately, the rate used on the loan was usurious and illegal and unenforceable. And so that was bad. The client turns around and sues the law firm for negligently drafting this instrument. No complaints about the litigation. The litigation was handled perfectly well. It was simply a fact that the instrument was unenforceable. And here having the two retainer agreements for the distinct services was absolutely key.
42:32So even though it was the law firm's client both times, they were limited in scope to the specific work that was being performed. If the law firm had not done such a nice job of really delineating between the two specific discrete services, then this would have been much more challenging to defend the firm against. I mean, here it was nice that they had such a distinction between their two practice areas, even though they were small and just two lawyers. Oftentimes firms aren't quite that clear, and I think that really helped them. But even if it had been the same lawyer drafting the document and then bringing the litigation, having two distinct engagement agreements, and the termination letter that said, thanks so much, this ends our relationship. Here's your work product. I think that probably would have been enough in this particular jurisdiction to protect the law firm. All right, the next element, breach. Again, it's a reasonably similarly situated attorney, and this element usually requires expert opinion.
43:41The rules here are 1.1, competence, of course, 1.2, and scope. And again, I harp on this, but the scope of services defined in your engagement agreement. Lawyers are very bad at it, and I often find that lawyers don't want to limit potential work. And by defining the scope, you're not limiting work at all. One, you can and should update the engagement agreement as the scope of work changes. But two, no client is going to look back to the engagement agreement before they contact you with a problem and say, oh, they were only representing me in X, this is y, I'll bring it to some other lawyer. It's not going to happen. So I really encourage you to look at your scope in your engagement agreements. See that it actually captures the work that you're being paid to do and the risk you're being paid to accept. Because at the end of the day, the attorney client relationship is just risk transfer for the client. The client is paying the lawyer to accept risk 1.8 to one, and 114 conflicts comes up a lot in the breach element, and conflicts are particularly tricky cases to get rid of.
44:45And then the supervisory rule 5.1 to 5.3, which essentially provides for supervisory attorneys, law firm owners, partners to be on the hook for attorney staff and non attorney staff, and even non staff like vendors, for example. And so thinking about the supervisory role now, it doesn't get other junior lawyers off the hook by any means. It actually keeps them on the hook too. But thinking about 5.1 to 5.3 and how that impacts risk is key. And then, of course, 8.4 again. And the definition of misconduct in your jurisdiction. The defense is here, really one defense that we're going to talk about is the judgment call doctrine, professional judgment rule.
45:29It's known by many names, but the idea is that the reasonable professional judgment of the attorney is protected. Courts are not going to look back with perfect hindsight and say, well, what you did didn't work. So it was not reasonable scenario. There's a landlord tenant war in Manhattan and there were six lawsuits. The FBI was involved. It was just an absolute mess. It lasted eleven years. It was a very high end luxury apartment, and at the end of the day, millions, I think hundreds of millions of dollars were being withheld. The whole building was on a strike. But the attorney represented one of the leaders of the tenant strike, and the landlord was particularly aggressive in attacking the leaders of the tenant strike.
46:24And so there were six lawsuits that the attorney was trying to defend against in an effective and cost effective way, and ultimately came up with a novel approach to settlement that the court determined was ineffective. There was a specific statutory tool that the attorney tried to use to settle all of the cases. It did not work, and ultimately the client turned around and sued the attorney. Now, it worked out nicely that this particular client was extremely sophisticated and had, through his business dealings, had in house counsel, really an in house counsel's office that was also involved, while not representing him personally in any of the lawsuits, was extremely involved in the defense of these claims and in this novel settlement attempt.
47:21And ultimately we were able to use the professional judgment rule to show that while this settlement approach didn't ultimately work and using the statutory vehicle proved not to be effective, I sort of disagree with the judge's decision on that one, but nobody asked me. But even though the court found that the statutory vehicle was ineffective the way it was used, we were able to demonstrate that this was a reasonable approach, given the circumstances, and a reasonable attorney could have used that same approach. And in fact, the client's business attorney agreed with the approach and was on board, and the client was really involved as well.
48:02Again, very sophisticated. And the defendant attorney did a really nice job of documenting their meetings and calls, following up in writing, and really explaining every step of the way, the pros and cons, what the attorney was trying to do, how the attorney was using the statutory vehicle a little differently, and that it might not work. And so the defendant lawyer did a nice job there. Third element, proximate cause. You'll look for anything to sever that but for causal causation change. And the rules here, 1.1, competence. Again, 1.2, scope. Scope, absolutely. Key. 5.1 to 5.3, the supervisory rules, and 8.4, the definitions of misconduct in your jurisdiction. So those are the rules to think about. In the proximate cause element, the supervisory rules will really become important.
48:55The two defenses to discuss in our scenarios are the sophisticated client doctrine. Again, it's not education, it's not intelligence. It's just how experienced the clients are with that particular subject matter. So, again, thinking about the real estate mogul in Manhattan dealing with millions of dollars of deals with, say, an in house legal team versus the first time home buyer up in rural Plattsburg, New York, they're just going to be held to different standards, like the lawyers are going to be held to different standards, and then the innocence requirement, which we talked about in the criminal context. So the criminal defendant in illegal malpractice, criminal defendant turned plaintiff in a legal malpractice claim has to show that they were innocent of the crime, either factually or actually innocent.
49:42All right, so our first scenario is the real estate mogul. So we had a case where it was over $100 million in exposure. The plaintiff had done dozens of deals with this law firm and was doing a deal in another estate, and it was worth over $100 million. Everything went south, and it was an absolute disaster. We were able to show that this sophisticated client claims that they didn't understand the transaction when they had a team of in house attorneys representing the client. The client was the entity. So a team of in house attorneys and the client themselves was this very experienced real estate mogul with millions, maybe billions of dollars in experience, decades of experience, to argue that they didn't understand the transactional documents that were prepared by this attorney in a different state really could not be argued to establish the proximate cause element. The court agreed with us, and we were able to get the case disposed of summary judgment.
50:53I think this really demonstrates how you have to look at your client community and decide what sorts of clients do we typically represent, and where does that generate potential exposure to us, and where does that kind of give us heightened ethical obligations. And where can we provide better service while providing safer service? The other scenario and the proximate cause element is the innocence requirement. And, you know, here we had a defendant who was convicted of kidnapping and spent 15 years in jail. Ultimately, he was able to get himself. He tried many, many times to get out of jail. Ultimately, he was successful.
51:44The court had miscalculated his speedy trial time, and so he got his conviction vacated. And in this instance, the plaintiff had to show actual and legal innocence. Now, some jurisdictions treat those differently. There's actual, actual and legal innocence. Some use all, some use some. Here he was required to show actual and legal innocence. Now he had the legal innocence because he was able to get his conviction quashed. The speedy trial time had been miscalculated. Had been miscalculated, admittedly by the attorney. The court also messed up. The rule had changed like a week before the calculation was done, and nobody seemed to have been aware of the change. Now, this guy had spent a decade and a half in jail, so it was extremely challenging to defend anyway.
52:35But it was the actual innocence that really helped the lawyer out here, because we were able to track down the person who was kidnapped and get an affidavit from that person. And the person was actually kidnapped. There was virtually no doubt about it. While the procedural, constitutional speedy trial time wasn't calculated properly and the conviction was appropriately quashed, this person had committed the crime. And the idea there, and I think it's really instructive about proximate cause in the legal mal world, is that even assuming that everything the attorney did was negligent, and here the attorney miscalculated the speedy trial time, but assume every single step of the way, the lawyer was negligent and fell short of the standard of care, it didn't matter. This person actually committed the crime. So they spent 15 years in jail because they kidnapped a person.
53:27And so the idea is, if someone is convicted, if someone pleads guilty, or if they provide an allocation that will bar a legal malpractice claim because of the concept that they were convicted because they committed the crime, not because of anything the lawyer did or did not do.
53:49This rule doesn't extend to civil claims, although in the fraud and some other intentional worlds, it can be used. But I think it really highlights proximate cause and how to think about proximate cause. And then the last element, damages. And for those of you looking, the attendance code is in the chat. I'll also read it at the end. Damages have to be pecuniary loss, dollar damages. They have to be actual and ascertainable. The rules to focus on are 1.5 and fees 2.1. And the advisor thinking of the attorney is more than just providing advice on the law, right? In every jurisdiction, it's a little nuanced, but we're supposed to think about sort of the big picture. And then again, 8.4 and how your jurisdictions define and capture attorney misconduct. The defense to discuss here is collectibility.
54:38And again, if the underlying transaction or litigation was actually worth zero, then the client has no damages and the legal malpractice claim can't stand. So the scenario here is there was a pretty nasty personal injury claim from a gate on some property. The workers comp law in that jurisdiction barred claims against the employer. The property owner had at least complete control to the employer. And in this jurisdiction, that got the property owner off, and there was some negligence or a breach of the standard of care in prosecuting the property owner. We were able to show that because of this jurisdiction's law, the property owner was exempt, essentially carried on to the employer's workers comp protection because the property owner had turned over 100% of control to the employer who was insulated by the workers comp bar. So the lost case, the case that was botched against the property owner was actually worthless. And that zero value case then didn't have any damages, and we were able to get the case dismissed. All right, so a recap of the defenses as we're wrapping up. Statute of limitations is absolutely key. Again, consider shortening your statute of limitations. You want to have outside counsel for the client.
56:00You want to have informed written consent. You want to make sure the client understands what they're giving up and why. And you want to keep it all reasonable. But that's something that I think lawyers don't do enough. I don't do it enough with my attorney clients. I think it's a really valuable tool. Absolute privity and understanding what your jurisdiction's rules are on privity and where your potential non client risks creep up in your particular practice areas. The sophisticated client doctrine, really thinking about your client base, your common client, your ideal client, and your outlier clients, think about them, their level of sophistication and understanding with your subject matter practice areas, and how you can use that to provide better service to the clients, and in the same vein, protect your firm.
56:45The judgment call doctrine. And thinking about our scenario, the best way to develop the judgment call doctrine, whatever it's called in your jurisdictions protections, is to document document document. That CYA email is so valuable at this point to demonstrate that the client was completely on board with the approach that the lawyer explained there's no guarantees in this business, and that in the lawyer's professional opinion, this was the right way to go. Now, that's not always going to insulate the lawyer, right? That doesn't necessarily mean the lawyer is out, but it really does help if there is a professional judgment rule, judgment call doctrine, defense, available collectibility, understanding whether the underlying transaction or litigation had any value and tying that back into the damages component and then the innocence requirement in the criminal context, and how that can really illustrate approximate costs. As I said, I always like to provide some easy action steps, and here's four things that I think you want to think about doing adding to your practice today, at least one of the four to make yourself safer and provide better service for 2024.
57:54Retainer agreements. They're your first line of defense. You want to make sure your engagement agreement is bespoke for each client, even if you only have one client, even if you have a client that's been around for five decades, even if you handle thousands of matters for the client, every single matter has to have its own specific retainer agreements. My contact information is at the end. I am providing free retainer agreement reviews. It's all educational and it's been great. I'm trying to get to 1000 so that I can come up with all this LinkedIn stuff, but feel free to reach out and let me know if you're interested. If I'm still doing the once I get to 1000, I'm going to stop doing it, but I still have about 150 to go, so hit me up if you're interested in a free retainer agreement review.
58:37Even if you're not, look at your retainer agreements. Look at your past retainer agreements and see how you can improve those and protect yourself. Client screening intake is a great area to add some friction. Lawyers typically want to get rid of friction because you want the clients to come in. But look at problem clients you've had in the past and figure out how you could have screened them and didn't, and build that into your intake. Use the defenses we discussed and defenses unique to your practice and jurisdiction, and build that into your intake screening. Try the best client is the one that you turn down in writing and say, hey, we can't help you. Here's the bar association contact info they can get you. Oh, thank you so much, Pete. That's nice to see that comment.
59:19I appreciate that turn down letters. That's going to start the statute of limitations, and it's going to sever the attorney client relationship. If you don't use turn down letters 100% of the time, you should start and hit me up if you'd like a sample. It doesn't have to be anything dramatic, and it can just be emailed, but you definitely want to use turn down letters 100% of the time. And then client communications, contemporaneous written communications. I like to use a dual approach of periodic every three months, six months, whatever the time in your practice. That makes sense, but also triggered by milestones. Again, depending on the subject matter, whether that's litigation milestones or a deal or whatever, having some system to make sure you're communicating with the client before they reach out is absolutely key. All right, so recap. Education system plans and teams, four ways to attack your risk and ethical obligations. All right, thank you so much. This is me and how to get in touch with me, Jeff Cunningham from Goldberg, Sagala. I'm very active on LinkedIn. I'm also on Twitter, Instagram, and threads. I'd love to connect with any of you. And I'm just going to be the ethics man that I am. And read my disclaimer is, again, prior results do not guarantee a future or similar outcome, and no attorney client relationship is formed. And this material does not constitute and should not be considered legal advice. Thank you guys so much and have a great day.
1:00:37Bye.
Richard O.NY
Excellent program and excellent presenter.