1h 3min · about 9,500 wordsDownload Transcript
0:01Hello, I'm welcome to LexVid production of LGBTQ family formation, law and reproductive rights. I'm calling Quinn. I'm going to walk you through an hour regarding this topic, and it's one of my favorite topics. And I have written a couple of different law review articles of that play into this topic. One is mama, mommy, and daddy, dad, daddy and mommy. Try parenting article. And then I also have another one on riding the storm out after the Stonewall court riots. And if you like either one of those law review articles emailed to you just let me know. My email is on the second slide right after the title page. So who am I? I am calling Quinn I run the Quinn Law Centers out of Richmond, Virginia. And I've been doing adoption surrogacy family formation law for almost 35 years, and a past president of the Academy of adoption and assisted reproduction. Reproduction attorneys also belong to the LGBT bar, have worked closely with equality council with the quality Virginia with the National Center for Lesbian Rights. I'm just trying to build more awareness and also assist a lot of my LGBTQI families with their their family formation and family building. So kind of launching into the first part of our program, we're going to talk about some of the historical issues confronting LGBT Q clients in the areas of family law, reproductive rights, and then we're going to talk about recognizing the added measures necessary to protect and safeguard our LGBTQ families. Alright, so this first part of the presentation comes from my University of Richmond Law Review
2:00article on writing the storm out after the Stonewall court riots. And what I did was I kind of identified four waves of LGBTQ family formation up until probably pre COVID. And so the first wave wave one which was prior to the Stonewall court riots, pre 1970s. And basically in that timeframe, LGBTQ individuals primarily had children through heterosexual marriage, or other means, and families often lived in secret or kind of hid those relationships. Um, that evolved into Wave Two in the 1970s and 1980s, when a lot of LGBTQ families would adopt children in foster care, and gay marriage and adoption were intertwined some people because gay marriage was not valid, they would actually adopt their spouse to enable to have a legal relationship with each other joint adoptions by same sex couples were pretty rare and most adoptions were by a single LGBT parent. There was some second parent adoption, but it was not really widespread. And the legal landscape was kind of Uncharted and messy and the state laws varied pretty widely. And so key events during wave two, and I go into a lot more detail about a lot of these key events in my law review article. But some of the key events that happened during wave to 1977, we had the formation of the National Center for Lesbian Rights. In 1978, the Washington State Supreme Court issued the county's first custody rule in favor of a lesbian couple that case was Schuester versus Schuster. In 1979, a gay couple in California became the first to jointly adopt a child. So we're starting to see a little bit of
3:51momentum. And then we go into wave three, the 1980s to the 1990s. And this is when assisted reproductive technology starts to become more popular. We do have a self insemination a lot of our same sex female couples were using eyedropper her strictly based hers, that book our bodies ourselves came out. As gay men were also often the source of storm for these same sex female couples who were using just various means of trying to self inseminate and get pregnant. We did start to see the development of sperm banks, we started to see the ability to freeze sperm. And then the growth of sperm banks and fertility options and clinics became more advanced and available on but primarily for straight couples and not for the LGBT community. So some of the key events that we see happening during wave three on 1982 The sperm bank of California opens 1985 There's a second parent adoption case in Alaska. 1986. The National Center for Lesbian Rights wins a high profile second parent adoption case In 1986, though, we also had some regression because we have the SCOTUS ruling and Bowers versus Hardwick that says sodomy laws can be enforced by the states. In 1988, we have the RT Wallace case where National Center for Lesbian Rights wins a custody fight by an AIDS infected parent in California. And in 1988, we have the formation of a collage the children of lesbians and gays everywhere, which was formed as an independent national organization. Um, so we just we've seen positive movement other than that SCOTUS decision and Bowers versus Hardwick so then
5:38we're moving on into wave four, which I kind of characterizes the 1990 to 2016 timeframe. And LGBTQ families are, that are being formed start to garner a little more publicity, but this also creates some backlash. We start to see child welfare organizations beginning to study the fitness of LGBTQ families, I remember a very contentious at the time, it was the American Academy of adoption attorneys, and then we over time have morphed into the Academy of adoption and assisted reproduction attorneys. But at the time, I remember a very contentious debate at one of our conferences, where it was point counterpoint. And once I was arguing that children are raised by same sex couples flourish did fine. And then the other side was arguing, no, that there that, you know, that children of same sex couples, you know, we're not turning out to be normal. And it was, it was very alarming, it was kind of a disturbing point counterpoint at that time.
6:52So that this is when we are seeing these that was probably in the, I would say mid 1990s, to just late 1990s. And that's when we were seeing these child welfare organizations beginning to study the fitness of LGBTQ families and coming out with these unscientific studies with with with not very positive conclusions. So a lot of lot of questioning their gay marriage was banned by DOMA, but then it was overturned in 2013 and legally recognized. And then in 2015, after a bearish or foul, it became easier, of course for LGBT couples to adopt jointly now that marriage equality was recognized at that point. So what were some of the key events during wave four? In 1996, we had the Romer versus Evans case where SCOTUS strikes down a Colorado law in 1997. On New Jersey becomes the first state to allow same sex couples to jointly adopt after a class action lawsuit.
7:57In 2003. We have the Lawrence vs. Texas case where SCOTUS now overturns the Hardwick case and rules that sodomy laws are unconstitutional. And in 2008, the California Supreme Court rules for marriage equality. So we're starting to see some of this positive momentum, especially as we're moving into the early 2000 to 2010 timeframe. And in fact, October 10 2009, at the Human Rights Campaign dinner, President Obama makes the first explicit mention of same sex parents and a presidential proclamation. And this is really important and moving. And so I'm going to quote it from the slotless slide, quote, you will see a time in which we as a nation finally recognize relationships between two men or two women, as just as real and admirable as relationships between a man and a woman, you will see a nation that's valuing and cherishing these families as we build a more perfect union, a union in which gay Americans are an important part, very important statement by President Obama in 2009. So what are some of these additional events we start to see from after President Obama makes that statement from 2010 to 2017 and 2010, Florida's the last state overturn an explicit statutory ban on adoption by gays and lesbians in 2013. We have the US versus Windsor SCOTUS ruling which strikes down section three of DOMA in 2014. We have the Boston vs. Schaefer decision, and that's the case that came out of Virginia where I am where the Fourth Circuit basically
9:46struck down Virginia law banning same sex marriage and then SCOTUS denied cert on that. So we actually had same sex marriage in Virginia and 2014 sooner than the Obergefell case. In 2015, though a year later, we have the very fell versus Hodges case and now the United States Supreme Court rules that there's a fundamental right to marry for same sex couples granted under the equal protection and due process clauses. In 2016. We have a federal judge striking down a Mississippi law banning same sex adoptions. In 2016. We have the veal versus el decision. I'm going to talk more about that decision, where SCOTUS rules that adoption orders must be given full faith and credit by all states.
10:31And then in 2017, just a year later and the payment versus Smith case. The United States Supreme Court, loosely referred to them as SCOTUS. SCOTUS rules that marriage equality means children of same sex marriage have the right to be legal parents. They have the right to have both parents be legal parents that have both put on their birth certificate. So lots of good stuff happening during that time period. Of course, before we had marriage equality, adoption by both same sex parents was a little bit more limited. And we would actually have home studies listing spouses as roommates. In Virginia, like many states, only one parent would adopt, and the other parent would, we would get a joint custody order for them. If we couldn't accomplish an adoption. That became sometimes a court to court judge to judge dependent on whether something could be accomplished in the lines of an adoption. And of course, these home studies that listed spouses as roommates were really not kind of coming straight out and telling the court what was going on. But then we had judges that just kind of turned the blinders on, we're fine with it. It was difficult for some LGBT families to become foster parents. And like I said, joint custody was a huge, usually used alternative to actually accomplishing a full legal adoption for some of these these families. All right. So before we had marriage equality in the world of assisted reproductive technology, we did have gay men using surrogates. But oftentimes, we could only get the genetic or biological dad
12:23declare the legal dad, and then we'd have to do joint custody order as to the other Dad, we had lesbian couples using donor sperm. But oftentimes, the non gestating parent that is the parent that didn't carry the child would not be recognized. And again, we'd have to resort to a joint custody order. In the marriage recognition states, step parent adoption oftentimes could be accomplished. But in the nonrecognition states, like Virginia, we could only get a joint custody order at that time. So a lot of creative lawyering was required, especially in the nonrecognition states. I'm going to talk about the case that I had with my clients who use reciprocal IVF. Basically, one mom was the gestational mama and the other mom was the genetic mom. And I was able to use Equal Protection Clause and due process clause arguments in Virginia to get both recognized on an order of parentage. And that was prior to marriage equality. Of course, I had a sympathetic judge. And I was able to use those argued the arguments that under the equal protection clause under our parentage statutes that if a man could establish his paternity by using DNA testing, that a woman likewise should be able to establish her maternity by using DNA testing. And that basically, my genetic mom, under the due process causes deserve to be recognized as equally as the gestational mom. And so we were able to get both moms on that birth certificate. We also had to use similar arguments by headed single dad using a gestational carrier. And I'll talk about that
14:11case in a minute, but I just want to show you a picture of the Haman family and their twins and this was gestational mom and genetic mom. And the great thing too, is that the Haman family also freely allowed me to use the brief to publicize the decision so that we could use it to get parentage for other parents and also use it in other states. And so that's one thing I've always tried to talk about with my clients is, hey, are you comfortable with us using this to help other LGBT families and almost uniformly the answer's yes. So I also had a case. single dad, not like LGBT, but still a lot of the same issues and also single dad facing some of the bias of being a single dad. But in this case, my client was willing to go forward with attempting an order of parentage. At that time, if I had a single dad that used a surrogate, the dad had to actually adopt their own genetic child. Um, so what we did was we argued again, that if a, if a woman could basically be removed from a birth certificate by establishing that she was not the parent with a heterosexual couple that it made sense for why can't a single dad also be able to leave that gestational carrier from being on the birth certificate.
15:56So we used equal protection arguments on saying that that gestational carrier who attended only to be a carrier, you know, shouldn't have the burden of having to carry for a heterosexual couple as opposed to a single dad. We, so we got we argued that she should be entitled to an order of non parentage. And then we are also argued that dad should be able to establish himself under an order of parentage as the genetic father and be able to use the surrogate like a heterosexual couple could. And the court agreed with all of our arguments, and we were able to then start doing these arrangements with just an order of parentage rather than having these poor single dads using gestational carriers having to do an adoption. So creative lawyering was was certainly necessary and still actually is necessary in today's current environment, which we'll talk about later. Alright, so moving right along, I've got this wonderful cartoon where the officiant is marrying two guys, and she says, You may now kiss the Supreme Court. And of course, everybody was thrilled when the Obergefell decision came out, declaring that same sex marriage was to be recognized. So after we had marriage equality and 2015, now we have the ability for same sex married couples to be able to adopt together and also do stepparent adoptions. So they could either adopt together jointly a newborn or we could do a step parent adoption, if that was needed. We also had children that were born to married same sex couples through egg or sperm
17:39donation, or by using a gestational carrier or surrogate, we now are able to declare them those children that children have both of those parents. But we still had some ongoing issues and some unconstitutional gendered statutory language. And that remained at that time and that actually still remain. So we have some state what I call unconstitutional on marriage, and unfortunately, Virginia is one of them. We still have a number of state constitutions that refer to marriage as between only as between a man and a woman. And examples include Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, but I don't know whether it's for a state of Florida and also of Virginia. And actually, Virginia even had a Marshall Newman amendment in November 2006. Re declaring marriages only between a man and a woman. So of course, we have the state constitutions that are in conflict with the SCOTUS ruling on marriage equality. And that's troublesome, and we'll talk about the concerns there, including the concerns with the more recent jobs rolling. All right. We still also have in many states faith based licensed adoption agencies that can still legally discriminate against LGBTQ families. Again, Virginia, unfortunately, is one of them. In Virginia, we have a conscious clause, where a private agency is not required to do any adoptive placement in violation of its its written religious or moral convictions or policies. And other states with similar type statutes include Alabama, Kansas, Mississippi, North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, and
19:24Texas. So I've given you the Virginia code section there, I'm not going to read it, but you can just see what it says. And so basically, if it's a private adoption agency, and it's not part of their religious tenants to serve same sex families, then they don't have to, and that is an existing code section in Virginia and there are similar ones as I mentioned in a number of other states. We also have a lot of state statutes that still are not all gender neutral, including Virginia. I was on part of the Virginia code committed commission to gender neutralize all of Virginia statutes. And as we worked through that process, it became clear that we were not going to get that job done. And there were a couple of areas that that were concerning to me on when I was working on the Pregnancy Assistance provisions where a pregnant woman could get state funding. As part of the pregnancy, there was concern that if that funding was applied to a trans man with reproductive parts, that we were substantively changing the intent of the statutes. And so that's when it became clear that we weren't going to get the project done. Um, I don't know if you've ever heard of a nibbling. But that was the term for the gender neutral term for a niece or a nephew. It sounds like a cracker or something that you should eat. We did not get things changed to adopt the term nibbling. We still have fixes in our statutes to make this year I'm working on trying to fix there's one remaining area in Virginia is adoptions statutes that still refer to mother and
21:21father and that's where previously married but now divorced, folks can still do an adoption if they failed to do like a stepparent adoption during the marriage. And we still have the terms mother, father, and also man woman in that statute. So I'm hoping that we can get that change. And slowly but surely, we've been working away to try to gender neutralize pieces of Virginia's code bit by bit. So of course, the law of the land sense of NFL versus Hodges is that all married couples are entitled to have their marriages recognized. However, we're, we still even after that decision, we're seeing issues. And one of them was in the Stankiewicz versus Millie Ron Michigan case in 2015, where the couple was married, and they had a child with each other by agreement. But upon the split, the biological mom tried to say that the non biological mom was not a parent. And then we had the the BL versus el decision. And what happened in that case was that the same sex female couple had done a an adoption in Georgia, so they had done a step parent adoption where the non biological mom had adopted the child and then the biological mom moved to Alabama with the child and tried to say that because Alabama didn't recognize same sex adoption that the Georgia adoption order should not be recognized. And that went up to the about Alabama Supreme Court and they agreed and they said, Yep, we're not going to recognize that Georgia adoption order. Then that went up to SCOTUS, and in 2016, SCOTUS issued a ruling saying, no, no, no, you can't do that
23:02you just can't move from one state to the other, that adoption orders need to give me be given full faith and credit in all states. So it's critical for same sex couples to accomplish an adoption to make sure that they have that weight of being able to travel from state to state and having the ability to have full faith and credit, recognize that adoption order. We also want to look at the Pavan versus Smith case in 2017. What happened in that case is you have two sets of same sex female couples that had children through in vitro fertilization with Anonymous sperm donors. The non biological parents sought their name sought to have their names put on the birth certificates. And the Department of Public Health and Arkansas said no, the Circuit Court said it was unconstitutional enough to put you know the non biological moms down and the Department of Public Health appealed. It ended up going up to SCOTUS and SCOTUS said that Obergefell only applied to marriage, not parenting. But that if you had a court order ordering both spouses and unmarried, same sex relationship, and that court ordered both to be put on the birth certificate, then the Department of Health needed to go ahead and follow that court order. So what that decision did was it established that that reestablished what we already saw in the VL versus el decision that same sex couples need it to go get that order of adoption, ideally an adoption order. In most cases, an order of parentage also will suffice. But the given the VL versus el decision, the adoption order we know we have
24:57a SCOTUS ruling right on point for that on So but the payment versus Smith kind of reaffirmed that same sex couples needed to get an adoption order, securing their legal parentage and also to make sure that they both got on the birth certificate as they needed to do in Arkansas. But also, we just don't want same sex couples to be relying solely on a birth certificate. I had a case down in Chesterfield County Circuit Court, where I was doing a step parent adoption for same sex female couple. And actually, the judge refused to enter the adoption order, and I couldn't understand it. And the judge was like, Well, you know, since we have a supreme United States Supreme Court ruling saying that same sex marriage is valid throughout the land, I just don't feel this adoption is necessary. And I was like, Judge, you don't understand the adoption is necessary so that we can best secure their legal parentage. And I argued a bunch of different scenarios, including the case I had where it was a heterosexual couple. And the little boy was 10 years old. And the client called me and said that her her husband thought he was the father of this child that he really wasn't and that it was another guy that the husband was on the birth certificate. The other guy had been making noises about being concerned that her husband died that he would then be on the hook for child support. So the one was asked me what did she need to do? And I said you need to do as a stepparent adoption. And she said, Well, does my husband need to know and I was like,
26:35I need to consent to it. And she then called me back a month later asking if I did divorce work, and then she called me again three months after that and said her husband had come around to the realization that he did want to secure his legal parentage with the stepparent adoption order. So I argued before this judge, you know, hey, this applies not just to same sex couples, it applies to heterosexual couples, sometimes we need an order to backup the birth certificate. Eventually, he entered the order. But I did work with the quality of Virginia and Virginia family law coalition after that case to get our stepparent adoption statute modified to say that even if both parents were already listed on the birth certificate that the court had to go ahead and grant their adoption order. And I couldn't balk at that. So when we look at these cases, it's not always obvious sometimes to judges as to why an order is needed when you have the both parents already listed on the birth certificate. There is a really good case that I've attached to some of my briefs out of New York, that's the matter of L out of the Family Court in Kings County. And that court decision, the court issued a decision saying that married lesbian couples are entitled to two second parent adoption and for the security of their own children. So if you confront a judge that is like, wow, I don't understand why this is necessary. We've got marriage equality, that's a great case to use. Alright, and so why can't same sex couples rely on just a birth certificate
28:16alone, a birth certificates an administrative document that's issued through an administrative process and does not carry the weight of a court order. Birth certificates based on the relationship between the spouses only and not the relationship between each parent and the child. The parentage that is solely dependent on the birth certificate can be challenged, just like that case with that 10 year old child that biological dad could have stepped in and challenge that birth certificate under our our parentage act. parentage based solely on birth certificates may not be recognized by all judges and courts, whereas we have the El vs. VL SCOTUS ruling that says adoption orders have to be given full faith and credit throughout the land. We don't have a SCOTUS ruling that says all of our certificates have to be given full faith and credit throughout the land. Birth Certificate. Just both parents being on the birth certificate like those moms be on a birth certificate. That does not ensure that any underlying sperm donor rights are terminated by a court order that court order on that adoption order or that parentage order is going to definitively terminate any sperm donor rights. And that's a problem, because I've got some clients who have gotten their sperm from a sperm bank in Georgia. And my colleagues in Georgia tell me they don't have a statute right on point that says a donor is not a parent like we do in Virginia. So making sure that underlying sperm donor rights get terminated becomes even more important when a sperm donor was donated in a
29:47state where there's not a clear donor statute. So and their parentage based solely on a birth certificate is generally not sufficient to adequately give a basis for passing and inheritance by intestate laws for the child to qualify. Social Security benefits are for claiming the child as a dependent on apartments, tax codes. So we do want to make sure that all same sex couples have that court order backing up, even if they're both on the birth certificate we want to have that court order and that can be done by a pre birth order, step parent or second parent adoption order order of parentage, or an order of parentage as to one parent along with this step parent, a second parent adoption for the other parents. So everybody needs to clinic should be referring folks to legal counsel. And it's really important for us to educate our families on the importance of the court order. And I love this cartoon, it's this gentleman down in hell talking to the devil. And the devil says if you don't have an attorney, we've got millions of them.
30:47So there are plenty of lawyers out there that can accomplish getting these court orders. Alright, so we're gonna talk just real quickly about family planning. Before marriage equality of same sex couples were advised to have their Advanced Medical Directive or living wills in place, their general durable power of attorney, their burial designation, their last will and testament, oftentimes a pourover, willing to a trust. And they were advised to make sure their real estate vehicles and accounts were all jointly titled. And then, even with marriage equality, same sex couples still should have all of those documents in place. So while hospitals and medical providers are required now to recognize the knowledge, same sex spouses and making medical decisions, rather than the spouse having to rely on Advanced Medical Directive, we still want for folks to have those documents in place, just as we would advise heterosexual couples to have those documents in place. And what I tell people is what happens if you're both in the car crash your kids in the backseat. And both of you are in a coma? Who's going to make medical decisions for both of you, if you have an Advanced Medical Directive, then you've identified that person and in Virginia, we actually have a registry so the hospital can look up and find who those folks are supposed to be. Who's going to take care of your kid, you know, naming a joint guardian, that's just as important for our LGBT cute families as it is for heterosexual families. All right, I'm going to talk real
32:21quickly about the jobs ruling, because that's of concern, and it should be of concern. What happened in the Dobbs versus Jackson Woman's Health Organization case in 2022. Was SCOTUS overturned the federal constitutional abortion protections that we had in Roe vs. Wade, and basically left it up to the individual states to determine whether a woman was legally able to get an abortion or not. And this has alarmed the LGBT community especially because of Judge Thomas's concurrence and that decision. So it's also a concern, because we're talking about reproductive rights. And I've given you a link to a really good article there, which has a fact sheet that shows how the LGBTQ plus community is disproportionately affected in terms of access to reproductive health care. And then also LGBTQ q plus families are also potentially affected by the Dobbs decision, because of the shared constitutional basis between reproductive rights and many LGBTQ rights. It's a slippery slope. So the concern regarding the dogs ruling was that the 14th amendment's Due Process Clause creates a legal concept known as substantive due process which protects the right to liberty, or the right to privacy, which is the bedrock for abortion rights, and also for same sex, sexual intimacy and also same sex marriage. So that right that Liberty right that right, to privacy that's embedded in our liberties that people are entitled to under our US Constitution, and for nearly 50 years, the right to privacy, that is the right to an abortion safeguarded people's
34:15autonomous decision making over their personal life choices. However, that rolling in Dobbs is now threatening that 14th amendment substantive due process protection of liberty and privacy. And that's kind of scary. And what's a little bit more scary is the justice Thomas's concurrence, because in his concurrence, he basically specifically references overturning other precedents, such as Obergefell. And so he suggests revisiting Obergefell, and same sex marriage. And what's really ironic about that is in the line of precedent as we look at the cases that Justice Thomas mentioned, revisiting like Obergefell? Well, if we go down that line of cases, we also have the Loving versus Virginia case, which recognizes biracial or interracial marriage and Justice Thomas is in an interracial marriage. So it's a slippery, slippery slope. And but it is concerning, and rightly so. And hopefully, the United States Supreme Court will not go in that direction and go down that slope. If they did, Justice Thomas's own marriage, arguably could be in jeopardy. Alright, so where does this leave our LGBTQI families and family formation?
35:37Well, now we're back to adhering to all the same safeguards that we basically were doing prior to Obergefell out of the concern that same sex marriage could potentially be challenged. So we still want to have the wills and trusts in place, we want to accomplish those orders of parentage or adoption, we want to make sure that we're safeguarding these families. I'm going to flip to part two now of our program, and that's using the law to creatively represent your clients and advocate for continued changes and protections in the area of LGBT Q family building, give you a couple of scenarios of cases that I've been involved in or that are happening in Virginia or did happen in Virginia. So we have this borderline case out of Roanoke that went up to our Virginia Court of Appeals. And what happened in that case was, first of all, the woman that carried the child did not have a sperm donor agreement with the gentleman that she felt was a sperm donor. In addition to that, she also used a turkey baster and not an A not any sort of like a drugstore insemination kit. So the court came out and said a turkey baster is a kitchen instrument and it's not an intervening medical technology. And so we just have to make sure that our families, you know, follow our statutes and definitely have a sperm donor agreement in place. And then we want to define the use of whole at home insemination kit as an intervening medical technology. We do still have some not very LGBTQ friendly fertility clinics. However, the American
37:21Society for Reproductive Medicine has strongly addressed this issue. They, prior to COVID. Probably been quite some time now. They've formed the LGBT Q. Committee of our professional group of ASRM and they've come out with a lot of good guidance and everything to force clinics to become more LGBTQ friendly. That said, I still see some clinic documents that don't cater to the LGBTQ community. So we have made some inroads in Virginia and also in other states. I had two clients that I worked with
38:09the the tenants old Timmons Olson case and Jacobs law. So I worked with, with my clients and also with Delegate Rip Sullivan in 2019, to get our surrogacy statutes gender neutralized but not only that, but the guys also worked to get Virginia law so that intended parents could use donor embryo along with a gestational carrier. And there's a picture of Jay Timmons and Rick Olson and their little guy, Jacob, and Jacob was born from donor embryo, he actually was carried by a carrier in Wisconsin. And if you just Google their story, it's an macing. Just but horrific story that these guys went through with a very homophobic judge in Wisconsin, who basically call them human traffickers because they were using a gestational carrier with a donor embryo. I have done the donor embryo embryo donation agreement for them in Virginia. Everything was on the up and up Wisconsin had good wall law recognizing gestational surrogacy. But anyway, these poor guys spent 1000s and 1000s in lawyer fees, to finally get everything rectified. So they were recognized as the dads to Jacob. And so back in Virginia, we worked with each other on we actually pitched the legislation as pro life because of so many embryos that are in storage, that should be brought to life. And so we were able to get this legislation passed. But that took some creative thinking, especially to get some of the Republicans on board to come around to the idea of a same sex couple using a surrogate With the or gestational carrier with a donated embryo and for that to be all, you know, legit. So those
40:08changes that we made on them under Jacobs law in 2019, included making our surrogacy statute gender neutral, making sure that the spouse of a child born through assisted reproductive technology was the presumed other legal parent that was really important, especially to our same sex female couples to make sure, because prior to that, it basically said that the husband of the gestational mother is the other presumed legal parents. So we got that change, we got the use of a donor embryo permit it, we got it clear that a single intended parent could use a carrier. Prior to that we were doing our single intended parents outside of our statute, we were able to get changes made to clarify that only a traditional or true or genetic surrogate could void the contract.
40:59The only downside is we didn't get changes to our statute, providing for a court order. But we do have the ability under parentage statutes to get a court order. And so when I'm whenever I'm doing, for example, an arrangement for a same sex male couple using a gestational carrier, the contract part and the birth certificate amendment issuance part will fall under our surrogacy statutes, but I will also use our parentage statutes to get them a court order as well. And this is similar to what folks are doing in other states is making kind of mixing and matching laws etc, doing whatever we need to do to make sure that we're safeguarding our same sex couples. So if we look at LGBT patients using assisted reproductive technologies, we've got a lot of different combinations. We do have, you know, the same sex male couple us or an individual using a gestational carrier. And we've got female couples that are doing artificial insemination or embryo transfers are sometimes reciprocal, carrying where one's gestational mom and one's genetic mom. Um, but we also have to think about we have transgender females that are biologically still have their male parts contributing sperm and undergoing embryo formation and transfer with the partner. And we also have transgender males who still have their biological female parts serving as a gestational carrier for a couple, or carrying the pregnancy, himself. And so being open to all these different arrangements, and knowing how to address them with their fertility clinics becomes important. So when I talk
42:44about some clinic documents, there are some clinic documents that still have words like mother and father and husband and wife versus parent and parent, we still have issues with a lesbian mom who's contributing her egg to the relationship being given a donor form to sign and we also have the issues of like the lesbian mother who's just dating the child, the vn given gestational carrier forms, we still have the issue of same sex male couples, be given, you know, release forms that are written for heterosexual couples. Um, so we do want to try to make sure that our clinics are putting gender neutral and appropriate documents out there and helping them in that regard, too. So if you have, I always ask my clients to see their clinic documents, because I want to make sure they haven't signed anything that might get them into trouble. So when you have like a situation with a gestational mom and a genetic Mom, it's really important to get those clinic documents and look at them, and make sure that the genetic mom is not making a donation of her egg, but it's just having a retrieval of her eggs, it's important to make sure that she's not deemed to be a donor, but instead she's deemed to be a genetic mother.
44:03It's important that the carrying mom is deemed to be is not called a gestational carrier or gestational mother, but instead is called an intended mother or the gestational mother. So we don't want the carrion mom deemed to be a carrier. We want her to be a mom. And so we want to make sure that these consent forms are consistent with the intention of the parties. So some additional examples of forms that I've had to revise an ovum donation recipient consent form, I've had their hand right through that and say, No, this is a genetic and gestational mother consent form a consent to act as a gestational carrier form, I've had to change that and say it's good sense to act as a gestational mother. The consent to utilize a gestational carrier form I've had to revise that to say that's a consent to serve as an utiliza gestational mother. So we just want to double check this language. To make sure it's consistent with the party's intentions, I've got this cute little cartoon. It's these two little babies. And the two babies are talking to each other and looking at enviously at this other baby. And he says, I hear he's IVF like way want it on. It's true. I mean, folks that have to go to the fertility clinics are spending more and paying more. And they will prevail, despite non user friendly documents. But we do want to try to make sure that our clinics, update their documents and change them. There are two problem cases out there that arose out of the clinic documents not being proper. There's the two cases I've mentioned, they're
45:39out of California in 2005, and Florida and 2013. And both cases involve moms who split up. And the gestational mom then claimed the genetic mom was a donor and not a parent. And in both cases, the genetic mom's hadn't given donor consents to signed by the clinic. So that those two cases just kind of reinforce the need to make sure our clients are not signing inappropriate forms. Right. So I've included some language there to strike out if you see it, in the next slide for you to be able to recognize that kind of language. And the other thing is to make sure that when you have a gestational mom and genetic mom situation, that you have a non donor agreement in place, I actually call them parenting and non donor agreements, so that the genetic mom is clearly not a donor, and that both are equal legal parents. So that's something I try to educate the clinics to just send folks my way to make sure that we have this in place. In the interest of time, I'm not going to go into great detail. But there is a case out of England, in that case, where because of the mismanagement by the clinic and their forms, again, the one of the moms was not recognized as the other legal parent. And you could read the slides on that, and just how, how upsetting that was, for her in that situation. Of course, with same sex marriage also come same sex divorce, and more and more couples are arguing over the ownership of eggs, sperm and embryos. And so I'll have situations where I will have a partner who has had her eggs retrieved. And she and her ex appointed, purchase the sperm
47:29jointly. So purchasing it together makes it marital property or joint property. Now they've combined their marital property that is the sperm with her eggs, well, now those embryos become marital property. And so basically, now her ex has to donate her interest in that embryo to the spouse that contributed the eggs in order for that clinic to go forward on allowing the the woman who's the spouse whose eggs have been retrieved, to go forward if she wants to carry a pregnancy. And that poses problems, especially if they're they're fighting. And we can't get that donor consent from the spouse that that is did not contribute the eggs. So in these cases, we really want to insist on our clients having a prenuptial or even a post nuptial agreement, we want to make sure that the clinics send these folks to lawyers to make sure that there is a disposition agreement as to if they split up, if they die, we want to know who is going to own the embryos, who's going to own the egg who's going to own the sperm.
48:43And the clinic should want to send folks to us so that they don't get caught up in the legalities. I've got this cute little cartoon there about donated embryos and the one son saying to his brother on their real child, and you're just a frozen embryo thingy they bought from some laboratory. But we do want to make sure that we have property proper property disposition agreements between these folks and that they do it at the beginning when they are acquiring the eggs or the sperm or forming the embryos. So I've got a slide there, again, saying that the clinic release is not enough that we do need to have agreements between the parties that that basically establish what's going to happen if they separate what's going to happen if they divorce, who's going to own who's going to own these gametes and who's going to own these embryos. The clinic agreement does not bind those two parties. And there's a lot of good case law out there. So, on the next slide, I've just mentioned a Texas case to be aware of, we want to make sure that we have clear sperm donor and egg donor releases and this case the man verbally agreed to provide firm sperm to a friend. And it was used for artificial insemination because they didn't follow proper law. He didn't qualify as a donor, so he became a parent. And so we've we've got to just make sure that folks are educated and know to seek out legal counsel and have proper agreements. I'm also telling clients to keep their eggs and sperm separate if, if they can, um, this keeps the ownership clean. The viability of egg freezing is now
50:30excellent, and the doctors can easily form embryos from separate egg and sperm. So if I have a mom who is having her eggs retrieved, and she and her partner or spouse are buying sperm jointly, if she can keep her eggs separate, and make it clear that they are only hers, and we don't form the embryos, yet, it makes it cleaner. If they separate, she can, she can better claim ownership to her own eggs, once they're combined with a sperm that they've both jointly purchased. Now it becomes sticky. Alright, so co Parent Adoption without marriage is still an issue in some states. Fortunately, in 2022, after several years of working on this equality, Virginia, and also the Virginia family law coalition, and I worked on getting second parent adoption passed in Virginia. So now on folks don't have to be married in order to do a second parent adoption in Virginia. We also have a lot of states and countries that are recognizing three or more parents by statute.
51:44And I do have that law review article Mom, mommy and daddy and dad, daddy, and Mommy, which goes into a lot more detail, including a lot of the states that have case law. So I've listed here for you on this slide. Those states and countries that recognize three or more parents by statute, and then my law review article goes into more of the states that have case law on point. And in the law review article, I talk about multi parenting by design versus default. And so by design is where folks actually go into the arrangement choosing to be three or four parents, for the child, by default tends to be more cases where somebody might have had an extramarital affair. That tends to be more where you have the cases by default. So now you have a husband and wife and then the wife has an extramarital affair. And so now we've got a biological father outside the marriage who wants to be declared a dad as well. But the husband still also wants to be a dad. So those are more than the cases by default. So I've given you an example, from New Jersey, have a multi parenting case by design. And that's where these folks went into a tri parenting agreement with two men that were a gay couple. And they use one man sperm, the woman's egg, and they gave the other man's last name to the child, and they all agreed to co parent and be active. But then, of course, a couple years later, the woman wants to move with the child to California, and the two men protested on that. And I've given you the ruling in that case, out of New Jersey, that basically the New Jersey court was
53:36sympathetic to the non biological father but ultimately believe that changing ways to get legal parentage was something best loved left to the legislature. And so the court did not go to the extent of recognizing three legal parents, but did award all three parties joint legal and residential custody and equal parenting time, which is about as close as you can get to declaring them all legal parents. And then I've included another case to compare out of Delaware, which is multi parents by default. And in that case, the first male Petitioner who was the ex husband of the child's mother, and the second male petitioner, which was a man whom the mom started to have an affair with. Around the time of conception, they both sought custody and a paternity adjudication in Delaware. And the court found that recognition of the both of the male petitioners as fathers was in the child's best interest, as a child consider both male petitioners to be her fathers and both have been deeply involved. So that was a case where it was by default, but the court did recognize all three parents. So and I've included more information from that case on the next slide that you can read. Alright, so I'm going to quickly jump forward in the interest of time as we close out our hour. And I just want to switch gears a little bit because I Do you want to talk about sexual identity and gender identity discrimination being protected in the employment setting, but we don't have the same safeguards outside of the employment setting. So, um, we had the Bostick versus Clayton County, Georgia ruling
55:17that went up to the United States Supreme Court and was decided in 2020. It actually was a combination of three different cases on appeal. I've got more information and a deeper dive, if anyone's interested in those cases, but Jerry Bostick, who was the lead plaintiff, he had started to come out in the workplace, he played on a gay sports team. And it started to become more obvious that he, you know, that he was gay. And then suddenly, he started getting faulted for his performance at work. And he went from being a rock star to not a rock star. So he was the lead plaintiff that came forward with regard to sexual orientation, discrimination. And then the other two cases one was a sexual orientation discrimination case. And then the other one was a gender identity case. And so basically, out of those cases, the United States Supreme Court said that that Title Seven or 1964 Civil Rights Act, Title Seven protected gay, lesbian and transgender employees from discrimination based on on sex. And the opinion was written by Chief Justice John Roberts and the courts for liberal justices. And in that case, gorse, Gorsuch said, quote, We must decide whether an employer can fire someone simply for being homosexual or transgender. The answer is clear. And he found such discrimination was barred by the language in the 1964 law that banned discrimination and employment based on race, religion, national origin or sex. So that was a great ruling that came out in 2020. But it only applies in the employment setting. Since then, poor Ruth Bader Ginsburg
57:25is probably just turning in her grave at this point. But since then, we had the masterpiece cake shop decision, and we also had the creative LLC decisions. And so now as we're weighing five, we talked about the four waves. And some of those waves we saw, both going forward and we saw going backward in terms of LGBT protections. Here, we're seeing the same thing. We're seeing some forward movement with the Bostik case, but now we're seeing backwards movement. So in the masterpiece cake shop case, that was decided in 2018. That was before the Bostik ruling, but basically, SCOTUS held that owners of public accommodations can refuse certain services based on the First Amendment clause.
58:11And so that, given that the First Amendment protects free speech and free exercise of religion, that it was okay for Masterpiece cake shop to refuse to provide creative services such as making a custom wedding cake for the marriage of a gay couple on given the the owners own religious beliefs. And along similar lines, just this past, just just past several months. 2023 SCOTUS ruling, we have a sixth justice majority ruling saying that Colorado cannot enforce a state anti discrimination law against a Christian website designer who did not want to create a wedding website for a same sex couple, because doing so would violate her first amendment right to free speech and arguably, her her right to her own religious beliefs. So basically, we see another ruling, which is allowing private industry to discriminate on the basis of free speech and based on the their religious beliefs. So, but at least we can say that United States is much further ahead than a lot of other countries. Because when we look, as of October 2013, we had a 30 countries and territories allowing same sex marriage, but Mexico only allowed gay marriage in certain territories. I haven't been able to really update where we are around the world. But we are way better off in the United States and and Canada. And we still have issues in Italy, as well. And we have a number of countries that still do not really recognize and honor marriage as between same sex couples, and also that don't recognize same sex parent adoption or step parent adoption. So when I'm doing
1:00:11international surrogacy, and we have folks from overseas that are using a surrogate, we're still seeing some countries where we can get those dads, a court order and a birth certificate here in the United States, that back in their home country, both dads can be declared to be the parents. So I'm still seeing issues around the world. And of course, we still have concerns with the dogs decision and the creative LLC decision and the masterpiece cake shop decisions, which again, just reiterate that, as practitioners in this area, we just kept to continue to make sure we are looking out for our LGBTQ clients in this area of family formation and reproduction, reproductive law, and we need to understand client's anxieties. It's important to be creative and to advocate. And to understand that there is anxiousness out there, especially with adopts decision and make sure we put our clients at ease. I always tell my clients that are doing I call it a confirmatory adoption. I don't like calling it a step parent adoption or second parent adoption. I call it a confirmatory adoption. And I reaffirmed for them that the El versus VL decision which says that doctor's orders have to be given full faith and credit throughout the land, Full Faith and Credit law is really, really pretty established. And it's that is not something that the dobs decision. Even if we go down the line of precedent of cases that Justice Thomas mentions in the in the jobs decision having to revisit the full faith and credit law, though is just so steeped, that I just
1:01:58let my clients know that it you know that that adoption order is in that email versus BL decision is something that you know, they can take some solace in and feel protected in that regard. So as we close out, I love these slides. These two rainbow banners on the one side and we are all the same inside. And then the other one saying I'm gay, I'm lesbian, I'm bisexual. I'm transgender. I'm like you, I'm human. I appreciate you spending this time with me today and I hope you've learned something. Thanks