Karalenne G.NY
Pointing out the preconditions (mediation, waiver of a jury trial) was important to learn; as was the fact that retaliation claims are not addressed in the statute.
1h 5min · about 5,800 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hi out there. I'm Bob Fitzpatrick, and today we're going to talk about a brand new as of March 3 2022. Federal statute, and its full title is the ending forced arbitration of sexual assault and sexual harassment. And why theme throughout? is going to be this is one of the worst written statutes I have ever, ever seen. It is a mess. As you'll see, as we work through it, all I have is questions. And this is supposed to be the me to answer to sex harassment cases, being forced into arbitration. I beg to differ. This is the manna from heaven for lawyers. Because all we're gonna be doing is writing brief after brief after brief as to what the heck this statute means. Just say you got an idea. Two pages, that's it. And two pages, they managed to create an enormous mess for all of us. So let me go back to the beginning. For those of you who don't know me, I'm Bob Fitzpatrick.
2:09I've been practicing for a lot of decades, I only put a number after it today. Trust me, I've been around the bend and around the bend, and then around the bend again. I have concentrated my practice for all these years in employment law, I love the area, I still get great enjoyment out of representing the clients that I currently represent. my bio, you know, you can look on line it goes on endlessly. Suffice it to say, I've been everywhere. I spent 17 years as one of the external councils for one of our largest employers here in the DC metropolitan area. But I am principally known as the lawyer for employees, typically, executives have represented in the last few years, a lot of lawyers. Trust me, that's a ton of fun. And but from the janitor to the CEO, I've been a lawyer for employees for many, many years. Okay, enough about myself. One last housekeeping matter. And then we'll get into the new statute, a disclaimer. And typically, they'd be a paper or a PowerPoint with the presentation. I don't believe there isn't one currently, there will be one written fairly soon. And maybe you'll get that as a part of your package. And it will have the entire Google the GOC of its Patrick's disclaimer.
4:30Suffice it to say in simple terms, I'm human, just like the rest of you. I am not the product of artificial intelligence. I make mistakes we all do. I undoubtedly will say something during this program that is just dead wrong. If you rely upon anything that I say Any opinions that I expressed during this program? That's your problem, not mine. I disclaim all liability for anything that I say during this program. And today's program is going to be, as I said at the outset, mostly questions, because I've read this statute. Now it's two pages. You can see all my chicken scratch. All right. I've probably read it 50 times. Every time I read it. I don't see an answer. I see yet another question. This is an awful statute. Congress of the United States, and President United States who signed this should be in balanced by putting something like this in the statute books. And Hey, folks, they got another one come. The Senate. Okay, has already passed it. So it's gonna pass the House in a New York second. There is a no more nondisclosure. No more non disparagement clauses in sexual assault sexual harassment cases, if it was as simple as that. Okay, as I just expressed it. Okay. We could, but I've read the statute that was passed by the Senate, and will undoubtedly now be passed by the House. And I gotta tell you, I'm scratching my head almost as much as I am about this statute or about talk about with questions of what in God's name? Do they mean, they cannot write an English sentence. They simply can't write an English sentence.
7:21If it was 450 pages, you know, as some of their legislation is, okay. If there's a couple of sentences buried in there, then you just kind of have one constant Ingress. I mean, I can kind of understand that. What a two page statute. You can't express yourself incomprehensible English. And you can't anticipate you got lawyers galore, climbing all over Capitol Hill on this statute. You couldn't anticipate some of the problems you were creating when you wrote this statute. A pox on your house. Okay. I guess I got that off my chest. Let me read for you a quick summary of statute. The Act amends the Federal Arbitration Act. And that is critical. Seems to me to your understanding, this is now chapter four of the FA of the Federal Arbitration. So when you're trying, as undoubtedly you will, if you get one of these cases, and you will take your US Code out of the FAA probably hadn't been updated yet. And insert in the right places, all of this language. That's very important, but understand the FAA.
9:15Forgive the diversion here. I'll go back to the summary that said the FAA is not a as I understand it is not a jurisdictional statute. And the court, in fact, reaffirm that notion. In one of the arbitration cases, they looked through, are we going to apply a look and forgive me for being a wonky? Are we going to apply to look through doctrine of Vaden VAD in two SEC's sections nine and 10 of the FAA and doing that. I think they emphasize in any jurisdictional statute It is merely a procedural statute which will be of some benefit to you in trying to parse this law. And as we'll get to it, and then determining whether with respect to the states, it is constitutional. And I think there is a serious question as to whether the Congress of federalism question whether the Congress of the United States can dictate, as this statute does, proceed to the States or leave aside. Native American tribes. I just don't know, that law backwards and forwards.
11:00Certainly, we're getting an education from Justice Gorsuch, who does know that law. But I assume there may be similar constitutional or conflicting statutory issues with respect to the application of this statute, to tribal courts, but we'll put that aside, I know nothing about that area of law. Okay. This statute amends the FAA. And the The Act defines I'm gonna read here a bit, forgive me, defines a pre dispute arbitration agreement as any agreement to arbitrate a dispute that had not yet arisen. Okay, I'm gonna stop the use the verbs rise arise and accrue. The Maryland highest court in Maryland, has said, accrue and arise or rise have different meanings. But they just, you know, and you'll see for the effective date is when the claim rises or accrues? Well? No, I think they probably think they meant the same thing. But maybe not. And this court really takes its dictionaries out to parse textually statutes like this one. So defines a pre dispute arbitration agreement is any agreement to arbitrate disputes that have not yet arisen at the time of the making of the agreement, and a pre dispute. Hold your hand on this one joint action waiver? Ever heard of a joint action waiver? I've written a lot of waivers of the right to file or participate in a class or collective action.
13:32But I don't think I've ever used the phraseology, a joint action waiver. That's hearing this statute and a pre dispute joint action waiver as an agreement, whether or not part of the pre dispute arbitration agreement that would prohibit or waive the right of one of the parties to the agreement to participate in a joint class or collective action concerning a dispute that has not yet arisen at the time in the making of the agreement. Okay. A sexual assault dispute means a dispute involving a non consensual so can be a big issue, sexual act or sexual contact. And a sexual harassment dispute means a dispute relating to contact, cont conduct, excuse me, that is get this alleged to constitute sexual harassment under applicable federal tribal, or state law. The Act provides that the election of a party alleging the conduct constituting a sexual harassment dispute or sexual Salt dispute get this or the named representative of a class orient a collective action alleging such conduct may pre dispute arbitration agreement or pre dispute joint action waiver shall be valid or enforceable with respect to a case which is filed. Okay. Very important. There are a lot of words and two pages. But watch the words, findable seems to me to be very under federal tribal or state law. So, in its simple terms, if I can make anything of this mess simple, it is that they man or woman who is alleging, okay, sexual, hostile, you know, what? I hear from clients all the time now, a hostile work environment based upon a sex. Okay, that paren where there is, let's assume
16:23a valid enforceable arbitration agreement. That person now in only sex harassment or sex assault cases, the sexual assault cases are defined with reference to the Federal Criminal Code consent. To the extent it constitutionally applies to the States, I think consent is left up to the states. And there are many different versions of consent under various state halls. So A, he or she alleging sexual harassment or a sex assault, where there's a valid enforceable arbitration agreement. Now has the election the option to say, I want to proceed in court. Now remember that word filed, and it may be they can exercise that election or option until a lawsuit has been filed. Okay. There is no requirement in this statute that any notice be given in any form whatsoever to job applicants or your employees, or for that matter, anyone else. And understand this is not limited to employment. This could be doctor patient. This could be an equity partner and a law firm who was not considered under that Supreme Court decision. name escapes me right this moment, but an equity partner is not considered to be an employee under Title Seven, but nonetheless, this would apply to such person, doctor patient, a retailer and retailers customer.
18:58And basically, any situation where there is alleged sexual assault, sexual harassment, and there is Ottawa otherwise, the claim would go to arbitration because the doctor has an arbitration agreement for all of his or her patients, et cetera. So keep that in mind. So there's no notice need be given to anyone under this statute. A lot of the advice that's being given out there right now. And I am not given much advice. I'm just raising questions, or Hawaii advice that's been given out there right now is to amend your arbitration agreement to have a carve out for sex harassment and sexual assault allegations, allegations, which is in effect, giving notice that nowhere in this statute does it say you have to do that. So, query Do you want to give notice or not? I have seen a suggestion. And it is nothing but a suggestion. It's one of the many, many questions that this statue make someone think about. I've seen this suggestion that it would be unethical not to give notice to people? Well, yeah, it says, Just an observation. It's an adversarial system. If the sex harassment the individual who's made the allegations as counsel, why isn't unethical of me, if I'm representing the other side, that I'm silent that I just don't tell them what their rights are? Good, godly thing, I'm a lawyer. And why should I be putting myself at risk of misrepresentation malpractice? whatever label you want to put on it, by giving advice to the other side when I'm not required to do so. But there has been a suggestion that there is an ethical
21:51issue there. So I will leave that to you. I don't have an answer to these questions. Okay. Okay.
22:08puts yourself in the shoes of someone who has to decide whether they're going to go to arbitration or whether they're going to exercise their option election under this statute, and litigate. One of the reasons who wants to litigate, is that, you know, arbitration is not good for employees, and they roll out statistics saying, you know, that more people lose in arbitration than they would in court. And of course, you have an arbitrator, you have no jury, and the judicial review, at least on the federal side. Okay, don't forget the state. judicial review on the federal side, in most instances is extremely limited. Okay. So what if the individual can proceed anonymously in court, because that's the push to arbitrate is it's private, it's confidential. And you're not out in the public domain. If you are in a jurisdiction, where your client can proceed with litigation, anonymously as a Jane Doe, and that is the first circuit don't have the site decision in the last week. I think that sets up of four part test for under the federal rules can you proceed as a jazz a doe is Jane typically in sex harassment case? It would be his agenda. If you can proceed as a doe anonymous plaintiff and litigation seems to mean you've gotten your cake and can eat it too. You got the one benefit, big benefit of arbitration, which is private this thing and unlimited and your before a federal court hearings before a federal judge. Now. statute doesn't speak to this. Can the employer or whoever is the other end of the doctor, for example, the other end of the arbitration
25:20agreement? Can the let's just take the example of an employer, can the employer and the employee enter into a valid enforceable? Okay. And, you know, you know, that's a whole other kettle of fish as to whether the arbitration agreement is a valid agreement under typically state law. Okay. But let's assume that it is otherwise a valid enforceable agreement. Can there be preconditions? In that agreement, for example? And, you know, you know, there's been a huge controversy about shortening the statute of limitations. Courts are deeply split. Almost every day, we're getting a decision down on this question. I think the trend is against employers who are arguing that they can by agreement, shorten the statute of limitations. What can you establish preconditions to, we now know, doing it the right way? The person alleging sex assault, sexual harassment can elect to go to court. But can the employer say whoa, wait a minute, there are preconditions, you're not excluded from making your choice, you can go to court. And we're not going to use these preconditions as you know, the clock still running and try to run a statute of limitations on you. But a precondition to litigation is you got to go to mediation. So you are, you know, by agreement, compelling people before this goes to litigation, it goes to mediation. And then if you do mediate, to get the right choice of mediator, you know, somebody who knows how to settle cases may not to me is a good mediator. And quite frankly, I got a strong bias against
28:07most X federal and state court for that matter, judges. There are some who know how to settle cases. But I'm sure I'll take flak over this. I think it depends on how long they've been retired, how long they've been away from wearing the black robe. So they can tell you. Here's my feeling about the law. Here's my feeling about the trend. Here's what I've seen jurors do. But I'm not going to come down on you hard and say, you know, your judges going to rule against you. And that's bad media. So anyways, can you apply preconditions and require mediation? Oh, a lot of case law out there that says you can you okay. Then the Corker and California just went against employers on this issue. And that is, can you require, you know, you litigate. Okay, you got your option to litigate despite arbitration agreement under this new statute, but you have entered into an agreement with us to waive jury trial. And question is, is a waiver of jury trial? Going to be enforceable? And suffice it to say, that's going to be, I think, a much litigated issue. Then the issue that everybody has spotted in this statute is what if the individual alleging sex harassment sex assault files a multi count complaint? And some of those counts have been, they might pass the supplemental, I think it's rule 15 test. And that, you know, the judge will keep them, but they, you know, they're Wage and Hour claims, let's say that have anything to do with the claim of sex harassment. And there's some claims in this multicam complaint that are part of somehow intertwine
31:21related to AI typically, it would be a state court assault claim, may have some constitutional issues there. Or it may be a flaw. In every case, you get now you get a one a retaliation claim. So it may be a retaliation claim under 704. A, but it is so Title Seven, and person says I'm being retaliated against. Because I complained internally, whatever the OC, whatever it may be, about my boss sexually harassing me, this statute does not anywhere. Address retaliation. Okay, nothing. golfing. But now we got our example, we got a multi count complaint. We got a sex harassment claim. We got a retaliation claim that is kind of related to this ex harassment. And we have a wage and hour claim that doesn't have anything at all to do with sex harassment. And I've now as lawyer for this individual, I've now filed this suit in court, put aside practicalities, you know, what do you as defense want to do? Do you just hold? Okay. I know, this person's got me in court on sex harassment claim. So what the heck, we'll just litigate all this mess, you know, dollar the sense wise, that makes more sense for my client than having the sex harassment, and then their retaliation Wage and Hour over in arbitration. And, you know, does one of them, shouldn't one of them be stayed or is kind of a race between the two, which is probably won by the arbitrator, and is the arbitrators decision have any impact on the federal court's decision, sexual harassment? You know, but all that. Yeah, the defense lawyer has to think through the put
34:04all that aside. And just the issue is, what does the individual have the right under this statute to take to court? Is it only the sex harassment? Or is it the sex harassment and any claim related to it? Or is it the whole Migaila even though there are claims that bear no relationship whatsoever to the sex harassment claim? There is language in the statute, one place where they use the word case, which opens up that mess as to Oh, Okay, I've filed a case that has sex harassment claim. Does that sweep in everything that I've alleged in my complaint? They do not answer that question for us. One.
35:22Professor, who I think she's adeleye, Ole in New Orleans, brilliant. Professor teaches arbitration down there. She has suggested that the best answer to this is that the sex or in multi count, complaint example, is that the sex harassment and the related claims, got to litigation, and the unrelated does not, and then raises all practical issues that are referred to do I really want to be litigating in two forms. If I am in both go, I try to get the arbiter to quickly make some findings of fact that maybe somehow undercut the claims in federal court, etc. That's a lot of thinking that one has to go through.
36:29And, and we're gonna see a lot of this because it's a rare day, and you know, where that there is a complaint that is just HW II hostile work environment, sex harassment, and that's it. You know, we see mold hotel complaints all the time. Okay. Does this statute apply to collective bargaining agreements? Not touched in the statute? I am told there was a version of the statute that didn't address the issue. And then that language was then deleted. So that even it seems to me even those the Scalia, Thomas, wing of the court, who are opposed to, for the most part, using legislative history as a guide to interpreting a statute. It seems to me that there is case law out there, that even those judges would embrace that where the Congress, wrote a state, you know, knew how to do it, and then dropped it is a strong suggestion that now in this statute, the one that actually passed, they meant to do it, and that is that the statute, arguably, okay, because there's going to be a big fight over this. You know, the unions, I think, are not going to like this. But the argument is going to be made that sex harassment, sexual assault allegations, under a union contract, don't go to collective bargaining arbitration. One can exercise their option to go to court. Now, they still have to grieve.
39:11Because that's not arbitration. They still have to grieve under the collective bargaining agreement. Who knows? Just one of the many unanswered questions. There's language in the statute that says that whether the law applies to a particular matter shall be determined, quote, under close quote, federal law. I know one's natural reaction is All it means it's supposed to be decided by federal law. But here, you know if we're saying federal substantive law covers a state or tribal court claim of sex harassment, where the state statute may be very different than the federal statute and in terms of the definition of what a hostile work environment may be, and what the case law is under state law. Do they mean that? Did they mean to as a matter of substantive now, we're not talking procedural? We're talking about substantive law. Are we saying that the fence is this the anti commandeering cases Forgive me here been wonkish? Do they apply in this? Is this constitutional? Or do I avoid the constitutional issue by focusing on the word under and does under just being that you cannot deviate from the Federal arbitration agreement?
41:41Individual who alleges such claim file suit under state law? And this may make sense? I'm not sure. Um, there are now a number of state laws that are from the grievance, the person claiming sex harassment. From that person's point of view, there are now some state laws that are better than the federal statute. And there been a lot of issues about and or severity, and so on and so forth. So there are some state statutes out there that are better. So if I sue under state law, do I have the option to do that? And I don't I then have to argue that the federal statute is unconstant unconstitutional. And therefore, I now the management lawyer, have to argue that because it is unconstitutional because of because it is unconstitutional, the arbitration agreement that I have is still valid, enforceable, you don't have an election. And then I argue that my state arbitration statute is the applicable statute. I have a valid enforceable one. So is this where I think about amending my current document and amending it to put in some language, and I'm not going to try to spit out the right language, but basically the language that says either if you proceed in state court, or maybe you have to proceed in state court with a state claim. And if you do, state law will apply the here and then you pick your choice of law, and you got to be careful on that you all know this. Because if you pick a choice of state law, just don't marry up with your company in a sensible way.
44:55You got a problem. Okay. The effect Give date of this statute. And you know, it says that the end the effective date is March 320 22. Any claim arose or accrued prior to that date. And the first thought I had was, well, ex harassment is a cumulative tort claim. And the first bad act, excuse me, may not constitute sex harassment yet. Too bad acts. Maybe you got sex harassment, maybe not. Now, at some point in that continuum of events in that accumulation of events, finger it sex harassment, okay. And the claim has been this is kind of the argument, the claim only then has arisen or accrued. Therefore, if the cumulative harassment the first act, second act of third, but still I haven't got there yet, it ain't enough with my judges to get them to say it is ex harassment, then if those happen before March three, but the act that finally makes me able and my judge able to say, bango, it's now sex harassment happened after Mars three, then maybe you're timely under the statute, you know, the defense is going to argue, oh, come on, you know, the first act occurred long before March three, blah, blah, blah. And it's just another question. Another issue that's going to be litigated folks. Here's one that was called to my attention by a lawyer in Florida. And I gotta tell you, I don't know the answer. The lawyer has a legitimate point. And here is the point, right? What if I have filed with the EEOC and the sexual harassment occur clearly, before March 320 22. But my ability to file a lawsuit under Title Seven is contingent upon EEOC
48:17spending a requisite amount of time with my charge charge was timely filed and issuing to me and notice the right to sue where I have 90 days to file suit. Is the 90 day notice the right to sue letter? Is that the accrual? Is it out when the claim arises? I don't really but I think it is a I think it's all legit. question raised by the individual. Um
49:05you know, I said, you know, it's the standard employment statute could be a landlord. Students got a lot of sex harassment under Title nine cases. Colleges schools, presumably now. This statute will apply in Title retailers, doctors, priests, sexual assault cases against typically, it's against some Catholic Diocese. And if they have an arbitration agreement, presumably is statute applies under retaliation. Maybe just raise it as something for you to think about. Maybe section 42 USC Section 1985. I think I've got the right section. Maybe that and that I'm hearing is being used a lot. In some cases, could that be used now to make a retaliation claim arising out of misrepresentations wrongdoing? Not recognizing one's election rights under this statute. possibility I can take a look at. The statute uses the word alleged. And that really had me scratching my head. What the heck are they getting at? Can anybody go into federal court and file a sex assault, sex harassment, claim and a legend and then make the election now remember, I emphasize that the statute uses the word filed. So in my mind, I could be wrong. I've said that over and over the election. You know, by filing suit, if your lawyer knows what he or she is doing, by virtue of filing suit in the face of a valid enforceable arbitration agreement, I am in effect, making the election to litigate. Now, what if I allege sex harassment, but like skeletons of cases? On the face of the complaint? It simply does not allege the preconditions for
52:51a sex harassment claim. And I say, okay, Judge Oh, man, and you know, here's my proposed amended complaint, and it's no better few. Okay. There's simply is not there is alleged a sex harassment claim, but it doesn't meet it bollocks. wombling. It is not plausible. Under the law do you get to stay in court? No, you can't go you've lost your sex harassment. It's dismissed. But you got your other and let's say you got a related claim. The retaliation? Let's say you got an unrelated claim the Wage and Hour I alleged sex harassment was it enough to get this myth into court or not? And we're gonna see that, you know, Judge, you know, yeah, they have a legend. But they don't have a leg to stand on. They got nothing. When it comes to, you know, the, the the test for a hostile work environment case based upon gender, that's going to be dismissed in a New York second judge. You and I both know it. And this case should be you know, my motion to compel arbitration should now be granted. Okay. I kind of made a lot of fun at the start about this joint waiver deal. And you know, I've read that over and over and over just like the rest of the statute, but I don't have a clue what they're really trying to Do an A talking about a class representative. Okay. So what does this do to our class to management's class action waivers in arbitration agreements that say you cannot proceed as a class representative? Can I now proceed in court? And do I have to be the named class representative? Which is referred to in the statute? What if somebody else as
55:46initiated a class does that person is a total stranger to me? nationwide company, somebody out in Seattle has filed a class action. Can they do the election? I don't make any sense at all to me. So to me, the only thing it makes sense is, you know, now I have, you know, otherwise I would have had to go to arbitration. But now I have filed. And I've filed this case as a class action or joint collective action and under the FLSA originalen case. And I'm the named rep and I make the election. Okay. I guess I've gotten that far. And then who's my class? Nobody else, let's just say, to my knowledge has made an election. I propound, some discovery, which my judge grants to the defense and says, Yeah, give me the name and address, buddy, who has made an election under the statute? And the answer is nobody. Well, what's my class? Can I represent people who I allege our subject or maybe subject to sexual harassment in the same working environment that I've been, and that they can be members of my class, because I've made an election, even though they haven't complained? Even internally, much less exercise the option much less in any way join this lawsuit. Can I judge send a notice to these people telling them of this case and what their rights are and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah? Just the the joint action waiver language to me, just doesn't make a heck of a lot of sense. And may lead to yet further litigation.
58:41timeliness, and I think I'll close with this last term of the Supreme Court, as you probably know, there was a case where the defense arced around for about I think it was eight months in court. And then, I think I think it was when mediation failed. They then eight months into the litigation, filed a motion to compel arbitration. And the issue that he was the Sundance case, and the issue that goes up to the Supreme Court is, is there a special rule in arbitration cases where you have to show prejudice and the court if if I've got a right of Sundance whatever case it is, it's a great case for the plaintiffs. side, because basically what, for our view account five arbitration cases, last term, if anything came out of all those cases it is that there is no policy favoring arbitration. And in Sundance whatever case was got sent back to the lower court saying, no special rules for arbitration, you just apply whatever federal common law, whatever it may be. Okay. So now let's take that to this new statute. And the parties are in mediation, let's say we've got a pre dispute condition preceding mediation. And the plaintiff then decides to exercise the option to litigate the matter. And what if the plaintiff knowing his or her rights, under the statute, had counsel had sharp counts and didn't in any way exercise the option to litigate? But mediation is probably not a good example. But delayed and delayed and delayed, you know, let's say went into arbitration. That's the better exam, forget to buy mediation. So went into arbitration.
1:02:17For let's take last term's case for let's say, eight months. And then says tengo, I've had enough of arbitration, I make by election now to lead. Can you do that? Can you delay the election that long? Does prejudice count. Somebody's paid some money to jams or triple A or whoever the form providing the arbiter. Somebody spent time and money on arbitration. Hello. Once again, nothing about any of that is addressed in this statute. Okay. I could go on and on and on beating up on this statue of an office is enough. I hope I have been of some help to you today on trying to piece together many, many issues in this statute.
1:03:40And my guess is that you will now go out and read this two pager, and you'll go Oh, my God, what about blah, blah, what am I blah, blah, issues that I haven't seen yet, or issues that I haven't addressed here today. Please email me at our Fitzpatrick at Robert B. Fitzpatrick. That's our Fitzpatrick at Robert Beatty. Don't leave the B out or won't get to me, Robert B. fitzpatrick.com. Please email me. Hey, if you got comments about today, this program, if you see other issues, if you see some maybe some answers to some of the many, many questions that the statute raises, please email me. Thanks again for attending. I appreciate your time and attention. I hope I have been of some help, at least in focusing you in on. There are a lot of unresolved issues under this new law.
1:04:58Have a great day. Take care Bye bye
Karalenne G.NY
Pointing out the preconditions (mediation, waiver of a jury trial) was important to learn; as was the fact that retaliation claims are not addressed in the statute.