0:01We start page 128, valuation discounts, leveling the playing field that has to do, again with the differences between the interests that that our data sources and what we're applying it to, which are the usually privately held firms. So slide 129 The data, the value must be consistent with the data source. When when they are comparable, then there's no discount or premium. So for example, if someone is a real estate appraiser gets values of develops value estimate of real estate, say, fee simple interest in a building versus another building or a house versus another house, everything's comparable. It's apples to apples comparison, no discounts or premiums necessary.
1:01If we're applying, let's say the IBA database, or the press stats database to the valuation of a controlling interest in another firm, also, that's generally going to be an apples to apples comparison, and no no adjustments necessary. However, if we were applying it to say a minority interest, then then it's no longer apples to apples. And if it's apples to oranges, we need to develop some estimate of the the difference the economic difference between those two types of values, we call them levels of value. Okay, the valuation discounts are the flip side of premiums. So one could apply a control premium to a minority interest to get a control interest or a discount for lack of control from a control interest to come down to a minority interest. Same thing, generally, we can apply a discount for lack of marketability from from publicly traded data down to privately traded data. Historically, these were poorly supported by appraisers. We've gotten a lot better at it in the last, let's say 10 years or so 10 to 15 years.
2:21Slide 131 We're going to go over some different levels of value charts. There's Mercer's chart, there's my chart. Copeland, sarin and Shapiro and now
2:40slide 132 is Mercer's modified level of value chart from 1998. So, Mercer's concept of levels of value is a single dimension, you're either somewhere up here or somewhere down here or somewhere in between. At the top of the, at the top of the pyramid is a strategic level of value. Next level down is a control value, but not a strategic value. Next level down is a marketable minority value. And the final bottom level is the private minority level. Before that, we didn't even distinguish between marketable and private minorities. So it used to be only three levels in the value chart. But as of 1998, Mercer still conceives it today as a four level chart with a single column.
3:54So if we're going from the bottom to the top, going from a private minority now in the middle column, to a marketable minority, we would reverse out the discount for lack of marketability that exists in the private minority. If we want to go up one more level two control value, we would have to apply a control premium. And if for some reason we wanted strategic value, which would probably be not for fair market value, then we're talking about investment value, possibly for let's say, a merger or an acquisition, we would add the value of synergy. And if we're going from somewhere up here to somewhere down there, we would take the various discounts so they go down from strategic value to control value, we would eliminate the synergy from control to a marketable minority we would reverse out the discount for lack of control.
4:50Are we would take a discount for lack of control. And to go from a marketable to a private minority, we would discount it take a discount for lack of marketability you
5:02Next slide 133. Eric Now, levels of value from 1990 and mine from 2000.
5:13I can't take most of the credit this goes to Eric Now, which was to conceive of a two column chart. You're either a public firm or a private firm. Okay? And you're either a strategic level of control level, my distinction is to add in mind, a well treated minority to distinguish between a well treated and an exploited minority. And today's well treated minority potentially is tomorrow's exploited minority. So there is a risk even even if the exploitation never occurs, there is a risk of always being an exploited minority Mercer does the difference is that Mercer does not believe in a discount for lack of marketability for a control interest. He believes if you have control, you control the cash flows and therefore there's no discount for lack of marketability.
6:19I disagreed with that. I disagreed with him publicly. In an article that I published in business valuation review in 1994. And in the year 2000, some academics, Copeland sarin and Shapiro found that the prices were 20 to 30%, lower in acquisitions by public firms of private firms compared to acquiring public firms. So their academic work supported my contention.
6:56Slide 134. So minority interests are worth less than control interest, they have no power to get cash out of the business. They cannot set salaries, declare dividends or force a sale of the firm, the control owner can fire the minority owner and that actually happened to a friend of mine
7:18adjust for level of control slide 135.
7:23contractual arrangements arrangements are very important here and they can vastly change the discounts and values. So salary if the control shareholder upon inception of the business. In the original contracts, if the control shareholder agrees to accept salary limitations. If there are piggyback and drag along rights for the minority shareholders, that that reduces. I don't know if it eliminates usually not, but it definitely reduces those valuation discounts. So attorneys can protect their clients at the inception of the investment later on is usually too late.
8:14Slide 136 We're adjusting for law level of control laws and legal procedures can be very important. For example, to dissolve the entity. In California, there's a requisite quorum of 1/3 of interest to initiate a corporate dissolution suit. Also, the cost of the suit matters probability of success, and the amount of time to cut to accomplish and that can vary from one state to the next depending on their judicial load.
8:51So we may consider all of those in the discount for lack of control as well as discount for lack of marketability. The amount of time to accomplish it is very important in discount for lack of marketability, but we'll get to that later. How to Measure discount for lack of control is murky and controversial. The traditional measure is using control premiums.
9:16Slide 138 shows murky waters. I will say that, in my opinion.
9:25adjustments for control are the least well understood adjustments have an entire valuation process. We're we still don't have an entirely satisfying
9:41theory and body of evidence that that I find to be compelling. So we use what we can use. So slide 139 I show a typical calculation of of control values and minority prices. So if we look at a publicly traded stock that's trading at $100 A share at a minority price that's in cell B four. And it actually sold in an acquisition for 140. A share in cell B three to $40 premium per share in cell B five, or 40% and B seven. The discount for lack of control would be equal to the $40 control premium divided by the $140. Control price, or 40 over 140 is 28.6. So if we start from $140 a share and be 12, we subtract 28.6% of the 140. That's $40 In B 14, and that comes to the minority pricing