0:00Hello, and thank you all for joining us for best cybersecurity practices. For boards. I'm Jennifer Deutsch, Director of cyber security and privacy and with me is my esteemed colleague, Daniel, Gary. Daniel, if you'd want to introduce yourself, yeah, I just got upgraded to a steam I found in forensics house. I'm a professor at Harvard, where I teach cybersecurity law and forensics, I often am involved in advising large, multinational corporations and their boards on complex cybersecurity issues. And with the changing landscape for the SEC and other regulators, this has become a lot more of a focus topic. And Jennifer, turn it back to you.
0:50Thank you, Danielle. I am the director of privacy services at lon forensics and I'm a member of the cybersecurity practice group at lon forensics working with Daniel. And before we begin, I just want to go over the disclaimer that today and our opinions are not legal advice, nor should it be considered legal advice. This presentation the comments contained there and represent only the personal views of the participants as spoken and do not reflect those of their employers or clients. This presentation is offered for educational and informational uses only soliciting speakers is strictly prohibited.
1:33So today, we're going to be speaking about cyber risk landscape, the attorney role in cyber risk management and incident response, regulatory guidance and requirements and prevention over cure cyber risk assessment. So to begin, we're just going to be seeing a cyber risk landscape. And, you know, to start us off, what is a data breach.
2:01So there's a difference between a data breach and a cybersecurity issue or incident. And I think it's important for people that are working at the board level to appreciate the distinction, because lawyers often conflate the two and it becomes problematic. So you can have a cybersecurity incident that doesn't resolve a data breach because the database is where sensitive or basically the information, you know, is stolen or misappropriated by someone that's not authorized. This could be an internal employee or it could be a third party. But the point being is that that's a form of a cyber attack. But you also have, you know, other cyber attacks that don't involve data breaches like ransomware, spearfishing and others. And so it's very important at board level, you understand the distinction and difference and making sure, certainly as lawyers that your clients that are on the board are involved with the board at the board level, appreciate the distinction, because when the seaso, or chief security officers discussing these topics with you, this is a nuance that sometimes, board members conflate data breach cybersecurity, it's all one in the same, but it's truly not.
3:11But anything back to you, Jennifer. I would also say that the classification and we can go on this to the next slide about cyber attacks, is really the distinction and the classification getting it right, because failure to classify it as a data breach may result in not reporting it to the proper regulatory authorities that it's required to as opposed to a cyber attack, you know, which may opens up to different responses. So make sure when you are in that initial phase for the board for that you understand what this terminology is, and also what it means to classify an incident as such. So Dana spoke on in a little bit about us, what is the cyber attack, right? It's any kind of malicious activity that attempts to collect, disrupt, deny, you know, degrade the information systems and information. The actors, you know, it can be criminal, political, it can be personal. You can have it in a multitude of ways. Daniel, how have you seen really in your work? What is the most the most kind of common cyber attack that you've seen against corporations? So there's not one most common I think that you know, you know, when you're operating at this sort of board level, right, there's a distinction between a state actors or we'll call highly sophisticated cyber attackers and less sophisticated or, or better way to look at as material or non material cyber risks that you know, generally fall into those dumb by a much more sophisticated bad actors and those that are run of the mill, and I think it's
5:07really important to realize that cyber attacks take all forms and shapes, whether it's spear phishing business email compromise, where they're misappropriating money, or there's ransomware, where they're encrypting all of your data and shutting down your business. There's, you know, using your, your hack, entering your company's environment to then enter a competitor or someone else's environment. So it really does vary quite a bit. So, I don't know, hopefully, that so but I think there's some questions that people need to consider. Jennifer, if you want to walk through them the story of three board members that they should be asking the seaso in an engaging conversation, right, when the chief security officer is presenting to the board about an attack or these things, these are some great questions, but I'll let you sort of walk us through them.
6:01Right. So you know, in an event that there is a data breach some type of incident, right? The board needs to have a full 360 understanding of what's going on. Right. And here we have on this slide is threats, vulnerabilities, impacts, values, all of those things they need to understand because the response to those questions can impact legal regulatory your clients, you know, and everything even relevant or related to, you know, for your threats. Who is attacking? Is it coming from an internal source and external? Is it an issue of a state sponsored attack? Right? Do you even know who is attacking at this point in the investigation? vulnerabilities? What weaknesses can be attacked? You need to assess? What were the weaknesses in your system? Was it an employee that clicked a link? Was there an actual, you know, bug in your system or anything like that, and that may, and most likely will require you having the technical people in the room on the board, tasked sometimes being the seaso, you know, the seaso? Making sure that you have all the relevant people in those meetings when the board does have conversations. Daniel, the impacts that, you know, when assessing a data breach, I mean, in my experience, it's the everyone jumps to financial impacts, you know, but it's really much broader than that. And the impacts go much more into reputational, you know, I client based what have you seen as the scope of the consequences of data breaches? Well, you know, at the board level, we're seeing a shift, right, there's the monetary, there's
8:01the brand and pack, there's the cost of the cleanup, but there's also just about adopting appropriate data governance, and being able to demonstrate that to regulators, right. I mean, when you have, you know, the chief security officer saying we have lots of vulnerabilities, the regulator's expecting somebody or a committee on the board, or somebody at that level, to engage in sort of drill down to the next level, how are what are the weaknesses? How are you addressing them? What are the severity of, you know, not, not, per se, the technical nuances of it, but from the business risk side of the house, and we're seeing a lot of evolution at the board level, on how to address and mitigate and manage those risks. Often, there's been a desire, you know, a lot of chief security officers, unfortunately, are very technical and AR aren't familiar with, you know, bore the cadence of being a board member of financials and metrics and risk and, you know, risk governance and these sorts of things, you know, and so often we're seeing this, you know, coming to the board, and there's a, the regulator comes and asks, so what kind of oversight are you giving of the cybersecurity program? And one of the more interesting trends we've been observing is that when the chief security officer is actually briefed the board about a security threat or a data breach issue, they are looking at how did the board engage on this and what was how did the board actually participate in the conversation and to work to understand the risk in those tool sets?
9:44You know, the other interesting thing is that a lot of organizations don't fully grasp at the, you know, where all their information is, and the board isn't really focused on that. But at the board level, there's a material risk if you're going to addition isn't aware of all of the data they have. Obviously, if there is an incident and there's a bunch of data, you weren't aware of this misappropriated that, you know, results in obvious litigation, and so on and so forth. But also, that a creates a, there's a lot of legacy information that has no real value, but the company's keeping it creating a lot of additional costs and risks that come out of this. So long winded answer, but hopefully that got the point across but I'll turn it back to you.
10:34Yeah, I think you brought up a good point about having the board understand what information it's vital that the board understands the type of information right, and, you know, does it contain PII, which is personally identifiable information. The understanding the flow of information, where it comes from how it goes through your corporation, is vital to understanding the impacts of a data breach. And then just moving on to really what is cybersecurity? Daniel, this is your wheelhouse is, you know, where you excel? Just, you know, generally what is cybersecurity?
11:20technical level, it's protecting information systems, and more application, you know, in corporate America today, record corporations actually, globally, it's the right controls are proud, you know, controls procedures, risk quantification matrices, understanding of these things, right. And it's, you know, technically very clear, right, securing technology systems that support and operate a business as well, you know, involving third parties and vendors. But you know, the reality is, is that it's a lot more than that today. It's people, technology, processes, risks, you know, business management, partner, relationships, vendors, and all these things. So cybersecurity wall has a technical definition and organizational setting, it has a broader reach. I know you do some work here, too, Jennifer, I don't know, if you want to add anything, you brought up a great point about it being throughout the entire company, incorporation structure, if your marketing department is lacks with their how they protect the data and their interactions with third party vendors, right, that is a vulnerability to your entire corporation. Even though it's outside the it or technology department, you need to make sure as a board that your cybersecurity posture is not only vertical, but also horizontal in and how it covers. And that how you go about it is understood by the key and relevant people. I would say cybersecurity just as like, even a concept is fluid. It's it's, it can be as broader and as narrow as how you want to interpret it. But it is a
13:13practice that is you know, I think becoming like the key word. You know, it's the the new thing for these corporations to really make a concerted effort to focus on because the repercussions could be extensive. And then just the weapons that, you know, malicious actors are using and I know Daniel, we've touched on this a little bit earlier. Some of them, you know, we've got viruses and Trojan horses. Phishing, in my experience has been the most common of what I've seen, especially because that really involves, you know, a person in marketing getting an email about they got an extra day and PTO click here to, you know, accept it, right or log into using your credentials to the internal software.
14:09And it ends up revealing the passwords or confidential information to this malicious actor. Trojan horses are it's a type of malware that seems to be legitimate, it's disguised as illegitimate, it's software and ends up you know, or like harmless files and you download it and ends up being a malware Daniel, any of weapons or any of these that stick out to you or you want to explore a little further?
14:48One of the more interesting things I think that I think boards are just at an executive level around understanding so you're seeing this this shift because The executive orders and the new cybersecurity roadmap provided by the White House earlier this year, as well as from the SEC, sort of saying, I think it's this week next month as track that, you know, if you're in the technology space, you have to make basically, lack of just in the interest of time, reps and warranties about the security posture of software and technology system. So what you're seeing is the shifting of liability and risk back to the technology providers. But and in the cloud space, particularly, when we're watching this operate with artists are AI and machine learning and these other things, we're seeing their application and to developing more advanced fishings, developing more advanced malware and ransomware. And it's very interesting, because while used to have this one push by the government to sort of work to compel companies to become better data stewards, and managing themselves, the risk also pushed for the technology companies to develop and deliver better technology solutions. However, with the cloud solutions, what's happened at the board level, and on down, frankly, is that they've adopted these integrated board technology systems, but they don't have access necessarily, you know, the cybersecurity attackers will attack the larger entity, the cloud service provider, and that the tag will cascade down. So even though the organization may have appropriate
16:37cybersecurity, controls the, once they hit the cloud service provider, unfortunately, there's not a whole lot that the technology companies can do, except making sure that their agreements, and the other things are appropriately structured. So we're seeing a definite evolution, we're also seeing a lot more attacks through IoT, and OT devices that weren't previously there, right attack, you know, using, where there's not a lot of security, but they're widely used within the environment. And again, at a board level, the real question is asking, you know, how are you determining what are the cyber, you know, because cyber threats and attack vehicles, because truthfully, a lot, you know, all but a handful of corporations in the glow can actually stop a cyber attack by a sophisticated state actor. So it's very interesting balancing act that needs to be considered later on. But I'll turn it back to you, Jennifer, I know we have some more to cover. I was actually you're right, you know, it's stopping is one thing, but identifying it is also I would say just as important, right, having that employee that accidentally clicks, you know, a suspicious link, being able to have the proper channels to report it and go through and have policies in place to make sure that is if there is an incident such as activity, that it goes to the it can be addressed, once identified. So that our next session section about legal business, and technical issues to consider at the board level. So at the board level, you know, just generally, there's the seven categories of
18:24board duties, governance, strategy, risk, talent, compliance, culture and insurance. But within these seven categories, the board's duties, play critical roles in the oversight. The next few slides go a little bit deeper into this, really the mitigation models for the boards and directors, HR and compliance, it's important that you're providing training education. Speaking on this, and where I see in my experience, that companies are beginning to make headway and really make training, by push of regulation or by understanding of the environment is training and education. Your greatest vulnerability could be your employees, and having them understand what, you know, cyber attacks and data breaches. And all these terms look like what it looks like in the real world. And practicing phishing campaigns, and educating on them. And then also educating them on the policies and procedures is so important for a board to make sure that they have that in place. And, you know, throughout your corporation, that's a requirement.
19:52And so one of the interesting things for boards, particularly when I'm advising and working with them is that there's often a focus on The seaso and that's where it stops. And I often tell them that, you know, cybersecurity is a, you know, concerted effort across all the different stakeholders that are coming to the table. So it's important when you're talking to the cybersecurity, lead of your organization that you're asking the HR compliance, how are you working with them and engage in and the board to ask the compliance leadership team? How are you working on cybersecurity and HR? What about onboarding and training and making sure that it's not just a technical ownership?
20:36Because cybers you know, clearly being reaching across all the different key business functions, whether your business units as well? What are your contracts and agreements look like? How are you managing the risk with your key vendors, obviously, government and communications making sure that they're properly involved in and messaging and responding and working with legal as well, and finance, you know, understanding what the impact would be, and incident response and insurance and all of these things. And they're all, they all sort of work together. And often we see boards that just focus on the chief security officer or the cyber team to answer these questions.
21:21But it's really a function of these different business, you know, these business stakeholders to really help deliver a robust and complete cybersecurity program, that the CISOs responsible for driving, but the board really needs to push and make sure that they're getting adoption and buy in, across the entirety of the enterprise to ensure that the program that the seaso is being asked to deliver is indeed effective. But back to you, Jennifer. Yeah, I think you adequately covered it, you know, in the various areas that need to be addressed. You know, I would say, making sure also the legals involved, right, you need to make sure that your efforts and mitigation are in compliance with the laws and regulations. And especially as in the trend, that there are new and developing cybersecurity really opinions coming out, and regulations coming out, that you have someone with board, you know, on the board, or in the meetings, that can actually explain and understand what these new regulations are, and the impact of that on your company.
22:47So, just to touch a little bit more, you know, boards, it's important that General Counsel, internal audits give cybersecurity a high priority, right, they need to board's need to be proactive in their discussion with these department heads leader, there's, and understand that cyber risk is dynamic, it's not a once a year meeting, let's just check in, they need to have a firm understanding of how your company posture is played out. And
23:25the end really just is a continuous effort that needs to be a priority amongst all members and all stakeholders. The consequence of really not having that. You know, it the cyber risks are really just one of the most important risks that a company can face at this point. Daniel, how do you see boards reacting to this changing environment? And the compliance issue?
24:06What I'm seeing a lot of you know, is there's no question there's an increased focus on making sure that, you know, with the SEC regulations that there's appropriate and competent board members with cybersecurity expertise and understanding, one of the things that is somewhat unnerving to me is a lot of cybersecurity executives aren't aware of how to be a board member. And so there's a need for a lot of companies that are looking to add these individuals to make sure that they're adding people that you know, they get the certifications qualified technology board advisor, I don't know they make them up or they have them. And that, you know, having sat on several boards myself, that doesn't certify suffice. Boards are adding in folks that may not be the best fit or skilled or understand their vertical or how their business works or how financial modeling works and these other things, but one thing where I'm encouraging boards to do is to create a committee or are usually an audit or a different subcommittee to undertake and manage proactive discussions with this cybersecurity and other members of the leadership team to make sure that the cyber risk because cyber is really a risk. And it's a quantification exercise. Both tech, you know, remediation may be technical, you know, business HR legal, but making sure that it's properly done, and in a way that the board is exercising that and then that committee reports back to the larger board, that the committee will meet on a monthly basis, and then report back quarterly or something like
25:51that. Hopefully that answers your question. It doesn't actually brings up a great segue into our next section of regulatory guidance and requirements, sec and FTC. So the SEC, EA, has stated that directors are expected to act in the best interest of the company maintain the sound understanding of the company's strategies. And that goes, I think, in line perfectly with what you were just saying, of the board becoming knowledgeable and understanding and having an active enrollment, getting the people that do understand this right, and possibly making the committee a separate committee in order to educate and give them that information. I think that's what I would say it was in line with the SEC on board responsibility.
26:48I mean, the board is the SEC has made it very clear about its expectations at the board level of for what they're expecting. I mean, Jennifer, I know you do some work here as well, you know, that, you know, best interest of the company and managing the risk. And, you know, there's a lot of things as a board member that, you know, I have nothing to do with cyber, but, you know, there's a lot of respond, you know, if you jump to the next slide, I believe, you'll see that the there's a lot of observations and 2020, recapping 2018, where the SEC is, you know, stated this, and you'll see 2023 is really created more functional rule sets around this, but you know, that that is the appropriate floor, there's a risk assessment, there's tabletops, and all of these things, and a lot of boards, you know, we're doing for fun Dettori tabletop, get a PowerPoint, but there'll be no follow on, you know, my company where we work, we built a whole product and practice helping boards, you know, test the cybersecurity program, independently evaluate it, outside of the chief security officer and cyber security officers perform an independent evaluation, and then come up with a workstream, an action item list to help the board, manage and provide demonstrate appropriate oversight, you know, but Paul, the SEC was pretty detailed about policies and procedures and these other things, but I'll turn it back to you, Jennifer.
28:23Absolutely, more in line with what you were saying, you know, the testing and monitoring that continuous evaluating and adapting changes, communication SEC has been firmed in what they are expecting boards to do, and what they are saying are best in good practices. You know, how I see, one of the biggest hurdles I see with boards today is that they said, you know, the con is, oh, well, I think we addressed or we did that test, or we did our risk evaluation 2021, two years ago, a year ago, right, as opposed to it being a continuous effort that they need to monitor that they need to actively review that they need to have a hand in and also then, you know, continuously testing and monitoring and communicating with all necessary parties. What were the results of those tests were those assessments are those policies, you know, of anything that and with and also to third parties, internal parties, employees and any other participants that are relevant and necessary, as the board has, you know, needs to be committed to cybersecurity and in their actions and how they face really going about business ventures. I Daniel, I know you spoke about then the 2023 I suppose The 2020. And so this is pretty recent, just two months ago that the SEC published, proposed cybersecurity and consumer information protection rules. Do you want to speak about what you see as that, before we jump into the maybe walk us through what they are and how they work and the details there before we jump more into general? Sure.
30:26So for just a little bit background, market entities are really broker dealers. Figuring agencies, you know, I swap participants, that's what they mean by kind of market entities. And with these, this three, this new proposal is really threefold. The amendment to regulation SP. And currently, the regulation SP only requires card firms to notify customers about how they use their financial information. But these firms have no requirement to notify customers about breaches. So with the structure of the 2023, proposed cybersecurity rules, that would change. Additionally, what they're asking they're proposing in this new regulation, would be that they need to adopt written policies and procedures for incident response. And that's what you'll see throughout the three new proposals. This requirement that they must be written policies and procedures to address data breaches incident response. I see that in my experience across the board, that is not enough to say we can handle it, that regulators want to see the piece of paper they want to see the you know, that the piece of paper the policy, their procedure, is not only written, but the parties understand it.
32:03And in line with what we just talked about with testing, is that that has been tested against possibly with a tabletop exercise. I did not do want to speak as to propose rule 10.
32:18I don't have to touch on it. But I think the proposal is, you know, modifying the SP and the SEI are all focused on making sure that companies are properly. And I believe that 60 day periods actually finished running. And we're we're now at a period where it's just a matter than issuing and from negating those rules, but have you jumped to the next slide, you'll see this more of the details? Or maybe it's a couple. Okay. I mean, one of the things with the proposed rule 10 Is that, in addition to the written policies and procedures, they would require then that sorry, over a nice screaming the background, but that provide immediate written notice to the SEC of significant cybersecurity incidents. So there's reporting requirements, that is now going to be certain standards, as opposed to the reg sei amendment, which is that also has adapted notification requirements as well. And with the regulation SB for them, it's that they need to provide notice to individuals reasonably likely to be impacted within 30 days after becoming aware of this incident. So in addition to written policies and procedures, you see that there's also now a requirement across the board these proposed rules that you also give notice. Sorry, go ahead. One of the things under the proposal 10 is not only they have written policies and procedures to address their cyber and periodically review, their effectiveness, one of the unknowns today that is currently causing concern among companies that are, you know, subject to sec oversight is what exactly, you know, is appropriate. How do you
34:27demonstrate this and what is the SEC going to be looking for? But, I mean, it's really they're looking to dig in to understand how covered, you know, companies are dressing these policies and procedures. And they're the interesting part is the board will be responsible for demonstrating this oversight. So it's this interplay that will be really dynamic. I think with policies and procedures as well. If your company doesn't have their resources to draft these, I highly, you know, recommend seeking external experts, counsel that is qualified, that has an understanding of the technical and the legal. It's one thing to be able to write a policy. The other thing to understand the technology. And the other thing is that it has this new and immediate reporting requirement in the event of a significant cybersecurity incident. So this is where it gets really tricky, because at a board level, you know, I can't tell you the number of times we've been involved in US incident and get, you know, response helping either technical or strategy or even in a legal side, helping companies figure it out. And, you know, it starts with the sky is falling, then a couple days later, oh, it's not falling. It's not so bad, then, couple days after that, no, no, it's really that bad. And then we end up with Oh, not all not no important data was exfiltrated. So now, given that the timeline of that town, an event may unfold, the reality is, is, you know, you know, a significant cybersecurity event. Well, I started thinking it's a significant cybersecurity event, but it ended
36:17up being and nothing burger. So one of the things the board's going to need to come up with as a framework to evaluate these, you know, events in an effective and timely fashion, because failure to do it, you know, and this ties in, I think, to the White House's National Cybersecurity strategy that are released in March of 2023. And time and tying it all together, because if you think about it, you know, the financial services sector is really leading the charge there, especially for covered entities, but, you know, firms are going to effectively, you know, you know, it will turn only applies to, obviously, the covered entities and some small broker dealers. But, you know, there's the broader implications of rule 10 Being a standard set for, you know, all, you know, all publicly traded companies, and, you know, there's also this third party oversight piece. I mean, so you're gonna have to oversee your service providers as well, that receive and maintain or process information. And covered entities will be responsible for the cybersecurity mitigation, even when the information sitting with third parties. So it seems really interesting sort of shifting of obligations, so to speak, that will be really telling and same thing with the SCI issues as well. But I'll turn it back to you, Jennifer. Thanks. And an interest of time, I'd like to just move on to the FTCs health Breach Notification Rule. In short, this notification rule requires that companies that have had a security breach, must notify everyone whose information was
38:11breached, notify the FTC and in some cases also notified the media. And in FTC, excuse me in recently, in 2021, FTC issued a policy statement to broaden the scope of entities and information that we subject to this rule by clarifying that the developer of a health app or connected device is in fact a healthcare provider under definitely this definition. So really, what I've seen is just this is a really broadening of companies that are going to fall under this. And now are they do they know of their requirements? Do they know of their notification, I think is harkens back to that cyber, the cyber attack data breach that classification. If the data breach, if it involves personal health records, there are reporting and notification requirements, and understanding that is vital for boards success and for companies. Hi, Daniel, how have you seen companies handle this FTC Breach Notification Rule?
39:37I'm not sure. How, both. If it's been fully adopted yet. I think it's it but I think, you know, it's puts a burden on people. I mean, it makes sense. So I mean, there people are doing their best to comply with it at the board level. It's another regulation There's not unlike the SEC. You know, when a data breach, it's the board members in the company that's generally sued, that doesn't really have the same impact or import, as the SEC guidance that's coming down the pike or even the DFS, if you're licensed and financial sector in New York, but I mean, this is an indication of what is to come. Actually, I think just recently, good RX, was charged by the FTC for violating this very rule for failing to notify appropriate parties of the breach of unsecured personal health records. And they were also charged with participating in deceptive and unfair acts and practices. So ultimately, they did settle under a stipulated order, and good RX admitted to no wrongdoing, but at the consequence is that they also had to pay 1.5 in civil penalty, civil penalties, excuse me. So we do see that there are real consequences and FTC is enforcing or notification requirements. 1.5 million is not, you know, pennies on the dollar? Yeah, I think, again, from a big picture perspective, it's more about managing that risk and the board's level of helping manage that risk. I think the reason why boards cares, because when the FTC sort of comes down like this, and make opens up the board, and the company to plaintiff, you know, adversarial litigation from third parties are
41:41impacted parties. And so, you know, the guidance they provided is fix vulnerabilities, notify, you know, and so on, so forth. But in the interest of time, we may want to just jump to the section here, essential questions to the board. So what to ask fellow board members, you know, these are general questions about your insurance policy, does your insurance cover the board? If there's a cyber attack? Is your insurance cover the C suite? If there's a breach? These are things that need to be asked. And is there a board committee assigned to address cybersecurity? Those are talking points that need to be asked. And also there needs to be answers to.
42:32One thing I want to lay out that I think is important, on the board, one of the most productive things that happens in any board meeting is a conversation between board members. And you know, the one other thing is, you know, obviously the questions about insurance and DNO coverages is something at a personal level board members should be, you know, obviously having conversation at the board level to make sure it's being addressed. But one of the questions is, you know, operational management of the I T, you know, and is that the same as the information security? Do they report in as the same function? And are you You know, what's your confidence level that your organization has identified and looked at these risks? And I think talking with your board members engaging with a think and feel will prove to be insightful. And while sometimes a dynamic conversation is a really necessary conversation, because that will then allow you to either bring in a third party to assess that and provide guidance or talk to your chief security officer, your chief information officer to help develop and formulate answers to these questions so that you can answer them in the affirmative by going back to slide, Jennifer. One of the other things about cyber is a risk, right?
43:53It's an operational risks. And one of the things that's often overlooked is how you providers and contractors that are key to your company, that providing critical services, has legal on these other folks actually considered these issues and risks and presented them to you right, as a board member, the question is operational cyber risks, the contracts the agreements, policies and employees and training. Its ask the questions and then process the answers but speak with your fellow colleagues as well as to the senior executive team for which you have ultimately response the you the roll up to you as the board members something you should really be focused on. Back to Jennifer just jumping to the next slide.
44:44This is regarding just CISOs and CEO be geared towards them right? How confident are you? They can withstand cyber attacks from internal external actors does your it adequately flex Cyber Risk Board A few should feel free to ask hard questions to these individuals. And then also challenge them in having them explain it to you, you should be able to understand it's that board responsibility having an understanding of what's going on within the company. You know, what is your confidence level with your the level of protection for your company for your information systems? And
45:33one of the things as board members you should be asking yourself is, you know, what each other is, you know, when you look at it, and you look at your IT strategy, is it accounting for cyber risks? Do you feel it's being properly addressed in HR and these other things, and as we go to the next set of questions? So looking at that, you know, the General Counsel asking them, how is legal involved? What is legal doing? How are they participating or not participating? You know, PR firm law firms retains all of these things, and a law firm, maybe to advise the board and a law firm to advise the company.
46:24Sometimes they're one in the same, sometimes they're different. Sometimes they need to be different from privilege and attorney work product. So it's just important to give these questions, some thought and also ask the legal and your chief financial officer these questions, and also the financial impact and operational risk, as well. So, Jennifer, if you want to keep a move in there? Yeah, absolutely. So prevention over cure, cyber risk assessment, oh, temperature and water detected. So the National Institute of Standards and Technology, NIST as its well known, issued framework for improving critical infrastructure, cybersecurity, and there's three parts the framework Core implementation tiers and framework profiles.
47:21Now, this cybersecurity framework was supposed to be to improve cybersecurity risk management, the three parts the core, what the core is, is, within that it has three parts to function categories, subcategories, and then with under that, there are five functions, identity, protect, detect, respond and recover. Well on to the next slide, Jennifer? Yes. So, you know, with with all of those frameworks, the real key takeaway is that this provided a standard that's become somewhat widely adopted, a lot of board members, you would benefit by getting at least an overview of what this risk assessment looks like, a risk assessment is a broad construct. That often is much more varied than, you know, but usually, you have to make sure that the risk assessment you're getting is mapping against the things you're focusing on, and getting that done properly. So I would just, in your experience, is there a standard form of risk assessments? Is there a blue book of you know, this is how it's to be done?
48:42I mean, there's no magic wand here. It varies based on the organization and the players and their commitments. So I think it really varies, but I think once you have that assessment, running a tabletop, at the board level, usually what we suggest is an audit of your program, your procedures and policies, do some workshops. And then and or then run a tabletop that's tailored to organization and simulate this the TAC at the board level, which was different questions at the C suite level, which will have different questions on the operational people that are executing. And so running tabletops across different stakeholders, from the board on down is something the board can really drive and then have those results fed back up to the board. And it's a great tool to help that and table you know, and my organization we built a whole practice around this as well some software, you know, web platform to help provide visibility and other things for an organization to see and manage those risks. Back to you, Jennifer.
49:54What I find valuable and tabletops is not only can it be done with the stakeholders, the department it can also be tailored to the different departments, right? You can change your fact pattern, you can change how you're being tested to meet the individual risks of each department, you know, your HR risks may be different than your legal and having these real world scenarios you will test your company and your posture in a way that I find to be most effective. There is an incident, how are we going that? Well? How are we reading the policies and procedures that we have? What is our response, and what I find boards are most impressed by that is, then it's becomes much more apparent where the gaps and holes are. And that is, then the benefit of having usually than an outside vendor conduct these tabletops is because they're coming in with no information of or, you know, no ability to hide, right, they're giving you an assessment, usually on the regulatory legal and technical basis. I know through Lnf, that's what our assessments and tabletops are comprehensive in that and we divide that a memo and we work with companies to then fill those gaps and holes to then become more in compliance. But tabletops as a whole, is just a phenomenal type of assessment that and in terms of regulations are requiring that companies conduct audits or assessments. This is to have the documentation that you are doing a tabletop can then also show that you are actively trying to be in compliance with these regulations. By now even just from a privacy
51:50perspective, the California Privacy Rights Act are now requiring cyber audits and privacy assessments can to be done and those reports to be then submitted to the regulatory authority in California. A tabletop is a great example of doing that.
52:14So just to touch on a really what your company should do. I know we've kind of just spoke about timestamps and like we're in the interest of time just making the we should jump into some case law. I agree. So you want to walk us through those cases? Sure. So this Blackbaud Inc, customer breach litigation. In short, Blackbaud was hacked and their clients data was exfiltrated and then held for ransom. Blackbaud paid in exchange for the commitment that the hackers then would destroy the data, the vendors notified the clients months later. So the issue was did Blackbaud have a duty to the customers of the clients against this hack? Right, did they have a duty to disclose? And the court then ruled that there was a duty based off black bots alleged creation of the risk that because they got hacked. Now, what's interesting as well, is that this was the court ruled that despite the security decisions made the need in South Carolina, the injury occurred where the servers were attacking Massachusetts. So organizations store data in multiple jurisdictions and data, the different locations can subject companies to state laws. It's important that I think beyond this, that companies and corporations understand that with this the injury, it was where the servers were, which would open them up to jurisdiction in a different state. And are there policies, procedures, contracts and practices then in compliance with that other state? Data? Do you have anything to add to this? No, not so much. And we're coming right up on that hour this and as long as the
54:32actually our last case, and this is pretty quick case. So the plaintiff in this case was seeking compensation from T Mobile data breach that compromised personal data, more than 50 million people pretty large data breach that was well known. And the issue became that in T mobile's terms and services in terms of conditions, there was a mandatory clause to arbitrate disputes come hanging from the terms and conditions. And the issue became, should the court support T mobile's forced arbitration mandatory arbitration.
55:16And really, the result was that the plaintiffs is should they have opted out of the arbitration clause, it is possible for a settlement case to proceed. And I think that what's important for that is, you know, with this matter is for the board and going big picture. With data breaches, and with an arbitration clauses, it's important to understand the jurisdiction where you are. And it's important that are where your choice of law is, with class actions with these broader cases, is important than to also get counsel that understands the implications of doing forced arbitration for terms of settlements. And just in an interest of time, Daniel, as we wrap up, do you have any takeaways or things that, you know, you want to leave the webinar presentation with the audience understanding? I think the one key thing is to recognize at the board level, cybersecurity is at a constant ongoing thing, and that you're watching the courts evaluate how companies are responding, and it will become more and more important for the board to appropriately show that they're exercising oversight and, and managing that risk. Otherwise, they're going to risk, you know, the experiencing, what we're seeing play out now. And, and today. So I think that would be the key thing I would recommend to anybody that's advising board members today to have that and keep it in mind.
57:24I would say what's important for the audience to understand is that the board has under if the board doesn't understand thing, if they lack the people internally, finding external vendors that specialize in the area where you have a gap is important. And it's critical, whether that means you're doing outside counsel, an external third party that runs your independent cyber audit, if that is it coming from a different source, you know,
58:03simply just not having the tools and infrastructure is not a general is not an excuse anymore. There are sources, even educational sources that can provide the board with knowledge.
58:18i That's an excellent, you know, key takeaway for folks to remember and keep in mind as the marketplace and as things start to evolve and change. But it'll be constantly changing. But I think boards are going to be held more and more accountable on it's something that folks need to be focusing on and keeping in mind. I agree, I think there is an the personal liability or the criminal, you know, liability is now in recent cases, going to the CISOs and going to the board level. So it's important that the board protect themselves and protect the board as an entity in their actions, making sure that how they respond to cybersecurity and cyber incidents is in compliance. By Daniel, I appreciate you taking the time and speaking with us today, and I look forward to speaking with you again soon. Thank you very much.