55min · about 9,300 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's presentation on conflicts of interest, former perspective, imputed and government clients. We are going to be talking all things conflicts, really focusing on government conflicts and our imputed conflicts, you know, lateral attorneys moving from firm to firm or government service to private practice, or private practice to government service. So that is what we will be discussing today. Let's get started here today. If you have not had a seminar with me, my name is Carrie Sheehan. I'm assistant general counsel at CAP Law firm in Indianapolis, Indiana. In that role, I help with internal compliance and ethics for the firm and for all of the firm attorneys.
0:44So anything that touches the rules of professional conduct is what I deal with on a daily basis. In addition to that, I do teach professional responsibility at The Robert H. McKinney School of Law here in Indianapolis, as well as have two of those classes going on this semester for students who they end here in one week, which is going to be fabulous. But again, I teach these rules. I practice these rules. You know, I help other lawyers and our law firm practice the rules. So if you have any questions, please do not hesitate to ask. Now, the first thing I want to remind everyone is that while conflicts may seem really simple and a very simple concept, you know, we can't be adverse to a client or we can't be across the V. Like, we can't be plaintiff and defendant at the same time. There's a lot of nuances to conflicts and there's a lot of places of gray areas like, what do we do in this situation? Or what do we do in this situation?
1:43So you start to see a lot of nuanced examples. Some of those can come into play when you talk about affiliates of companies or, you know, owners of smaller companies, because, say, if you represent a company and the company says, wait a second, you're adverse to one of our affiliates, you're like, well, yeah, I don't do work for them. They're not my client. And the main company says, no, they're related to us, so they're your client, too. That's the situation where, okay, what do the rules say? Well, in that scenario, if you go under the rules, Rule 1.7, which is a current conflict, or 1.13, dealing with more corporations and corporate conflicts, the rules tell us that we do not just by nature representing a parent company, represent all the affiliates, too. Now, that's going to come into play and be important when we start to talk about government conflicts and who is the client for the government, because again, a government can be one Entity, it can be, you know, you represent the state of Indiana.
2:47Well, the state of Indiana has subdivisions, it has departments, it has, you know, things that are related to it. So in, in. So in taking on the representation, say for the state of Indiana, are you now also representing all the subparts, subdivisions and different and different affiliates of it? It's a great question how, what does that look like? Most states say that yes you do. If you represent the state, they have their own terms and conditions and they say that if you represent the main entity, the state, as a government lawyer for the state or an outside counselor for the state, then you also represent all the subarms, affiliates or different departments. But again, it can be state by state because the rules tell us that's not the case unless we agree to it. Otherwise. That otherwise agreement is normally through outside counsel guidelines. If you've never heard of outside counsel guidelines, consider yourself very lucky. But they are terms and conditions that the clients send to us, the lawyers, and then we have to abide by those terms and conditions and we have to agree to them normally or we have to try to negotiate them. Most states, political subdivisions, government entities that you could undertake to represent or be an in house counsel or government attorney for have terms and conditions or outside council guidelines. I think the most onerous ones I've seen come from say the state of California, maybe the state of Minnesota, they come from, you know, bigger states,
4:26you see more onerous terms sometimes, but it can be anywhere. They can be from any state and they're not all the same. Each state can write and devise their own and then obviously you as outside counsel can agree to them. Or if you want to negotiate them, you can try to negotiate them. But at the same time, sometimes if you don't disagree to them, they're going to find another attorney to agree to them without having the negotiation process. So while you may think conflicts are simple, just in the scenarios I brought up, it's not a straightforward reading of the rules. We're piecing together multiple rules and our former client perspective, client imputed conflicts and government conflicts are no different than the current conflicts, you know, piecing together for the more complicated situations.
5:16So sometimes that gray area is going to come up. And sometimes you may ask yourself, oh my gosh, what do I do here? And you may not know the answer. And that's okay. That's why we have the rules, that's why we have comments to the rules, and that's why we have people like myself and probably in most of your jurisdictions, you may Know someone who practices ethics or is known as an ethics attorney or an in house counsel somewhere that can maybe hopefully give guidance or direct you in the right path to find guidance yourself. Now, in one of the textbooks I teach out of, again, the page numbers on the screens are always for my reference, not for yours. And it's for my reference just so I kind of know. I bring up different cases, different things, and so I just know where to find those in case, you know, my memory goes as I'm speaking. But on this page reference that's here on the screen in front of you, I just want to kind of give a summary or just an overview of, you know, kind of confidentiality and conflicts as to, you know, former clients, current clients and even perspective clients and government clients. Now, a lot of them are the same. If we think about current clients and government clients, they're the same. We know we owe our current clients confidentiality.
6:33And if it's the government, then obviously we owe the government confidentiality. If it's our client and if we've agreed to those outside terms and conditions, then any affiliate that's listed in those or any term that makes any other entity or subdivision as our client, we owe them confidentiality too. That is just how it works. If we consider an entity, a sub entity or an affiliate, a client, then we have to owe them confidentiality. Now for former clients, prospective clients, it's about the same. A lot of people think that confidentiality may end up at the conclusion of the representation or once the client has passed away or the entity has dissolved. If it's a company corporation or maybe just the government has changed hands or something and that is not the case. Confidentiality never ends, just kind of a brief overview on it, and it extends past the representation, so into the entity, company corporation or government affiliate, becoming a former client. And what is a former client? By definition, it means that you no longer do work for an entity or person or, you know, government entity, that there's nothing pending, there's probably nothing on the horizon. All the matters and all the things you've done for them have concluded have come to an end and the relationship in all aspects is done. The attorney client relationship, it doesn't mean it can't come back up again. But everything current that you have is done, you're done with it.
8:10Now a lot of people like to leave these types of matters open in their conflict system, open in their firm. And that's a little scary because technically if it's open, it's going to read as a Current client. And it may not have been billed for five years, 10 years, or maybe even three or two years, but as long as it's reading as a current client, then it's going to pop up when someone runs a conflict report, and then it's going to have to be cleared either by reaching out to you, reaching out to the client. If you say, yes, I don't have any work for them, but I'm hoping to get more. Great, let's close it out.
8:47If you get more, we reopen it. Because if we leave it open in the conflict system and you say, well, I don't want to work for them right now, the other attorney who has the conflict says, okay, that's fine, you know, I'm just going ahead and do this work. You say, great, well, next week you get something in. You already have a current client number open, so maybe your conflicts team thinks everything's been resolved with adversity now in the books, and you never get waivers. So it is a recipe for disaster. If you do not close out former clients within the system itself. And former clients, you still owe all the same duties. Confidentiality, freedom from conflicts.
9:25But with former clients, if you've attended any of my other seminars that we've talked about with former clients, the analysis is a little different than our current clients. Current clients, under Rule 1.7, we know we cannot be adverse to any current client in anything, even if it's unrelated, without our consents confirmed in writing. So you can't represent Yahoo in a real estate matter adverse to Google. When you represent Google and IP work over here, yes, they're unrelated. Yes, they may both give cons, you know, maybe like, yeah, they're unrelated. We don't care. But we still can't do it. We still can't be averse to Google for Yahoo until we get the two consents confirmed in writing. Two consents meaning one from Google and one from Yahoo. Because we have a current conflict, we cannot be adverse to a client in anything, even if unrelated, unless we get consents confirmed in writing. Consents come in two from both affected clients.
10:22Former clients are a little different when it comes to conflicts. Former clients, once we close that out, we still know confidentiality extends, but we close out the client files like we're supposed to as good attorney citizens of our law firm. We close them out. And now if someone hits on it, the analysis is easier. They look and say, okay, I want to be adverse to Google. Well, it's a former client. We have nothing current. Everything's closed out. Everything's done. You know, we were a good corporate lawyer citizen over here and you say, okay, well there's nothing current, so I can be adverse to them. Well, normally you can. The only way you cannot is if you're going to be adverse to Google in a matter that is the same or substantially related to what you did for Google in the past.
11:14And so you have to go down to the nature of the matter. What is the description? What confidential information did we get from Google when we were actively, excuse me, representing them? If any of that information can be used adversely against Google now, then we can't undertake to be adverse to them. So we really have to look at, you know, what we did for the client, what that looks like. So we cannot be adverse to a former client in anything that is the same or substantially related for what we did for that former client when they were a current client. That's the conflict analysis. But confidentiality still continues. It always continues. So we can't, and that's why we can't be adverse to them and saying we're standally related because we have to keep up their confidences. We cannot use what we learned in that representation to, to adversely affect them now in a new representation of someone else. So again, confidentiality and conflicts go hand in hand when really making that analysis. Kind of the same.
12:21For our perspective clients, prospective clients are the ones that come in, they ask us, you know, here's my scenario, can you help me? You say yes or no or, and if you say no, they stay a prospective client. But anything they told you in that initial consultation, in that time period where they're trying to find an attorney and you're trying to decide if you want to represent them, that is also confidential. If it's confidential, it creates a conflict of interest. See how they go hand in hand. So now we cannot be adverse to any prospective client without the prospective client's consent. If we can use that confidential information that we learned in that prospective client meeting, or even if we say, well, we're not going to use it if we know it, if we know it's there and harmful, we can't be adverse to that prospective client. This famous scenario, this is, you know, two people are getting divorced and one of them, just to be ruthless, goes around and has initial consultations with like 10 divorce lawyers in town. In those 10 initial consultations, they give just enough information to basically conflict out that attorney so that their soon to be ex spouse can't represent them. Because once they've had that consultation Got the confidential information from the one perspective client, if the other spouse comes in and wants to hire them, they have to say no because they're conflicted out, because now they have information that could adversely affect the spouse that didn't hire them. And I don't think they're going to get consent
14:00there. So again, you have to be very careful. But confidentiality is what we are trying to protect. And when that confidentiality is at risk of being disclosed to adversely hurt the client that gave us that confidential information is when we have a conflict of interest with current clients, no matter what, we cannot be adverse to a current client without consents confirmed in writing. Even in unrelated matters. Former client, we look at what confidential information do we have, same or substantially related matter, where now we're going to be on the opposite side. We can't do it without consent. Prospective clients, again, what information did you gain during that initial consultation or that prospective relationship, and can it now be adversely used against that prospective client? If so, the answer is no. We need our consent. So we do have to look at that because confidentiality is maintained forever, even past the client's death, the prospective client's death, the former client's death, dissolution of the corporation, it extends for all eternity. Even past your own death, it extends for all eternity, the confidentiality. So now kind of looking at these a little more, just the rules I've gone through, I think a pretty decent overview there of how they kind of work intertwined. First one here with former clients, if you remember, I said we can't represent someone adverse to a former client in the same or substantially related matter. You see that here with the rule itself. A lawyer who has formerly represented a
15:37client in a matter shall not thereafter represent another person in the same or substantially related matter in which the person's interests are materially adverse to to the interest of the former client, unless the former client gives consent confirmed in writing. That is exactly what I was saying in that overview. You have to look to that same or substantially related context and we can't be adverse. We're looking at what confidential information do we have, did we gain? And now even if we choose not to, but could it be used adversely against that client? And if so, we need our consent. And it just goes on to really reiterate that, going into a little more detail about interest being adverse and what that looks like and how we cannot use the information to disadvantage the client there in that part C.
16:29And so just keep that in mind. Confidentiality and conflicts of interest really do go hand in hand when we're trying to make an analysis on whether we have a conflict with a former client client. One of the cases that is good to study, and law students study this as well. This is one that's just kind of been in textbooks. And part of the hallmark of, you know, just learning this rule, the former client rule. There is also some imputation here under row 110, which we have not got to yet. I'll just kind of read you some of the facts of the case. We'll discuss the issue and then how the court decided, especially with, you know, rule 1.9 looming for us in the background here. So in this case several years ago, an inquiring attorney represented a wife who was a foreign national and the husband was a United States citizen.
17:22The representation was for the application of the husband for an immigrant visa and an adjustment of status for the permanent residence for the wife. So we have an immigration visa that we're getting here for the wife's permanent residence. The husband subsequently withdrew the application after he and his wife had a disagreement. The husband, if you remember, was a United States citizen. The couple reconciled and engaged in inquiring the attorney a second time to foot forth a se second application. So we have an application. Husband and wife get in a fight. Husband withdraws it, probably to punish the wife, and then now we have reconciliation. Attorney gets hired a second time to file a se application for the wife. However, again, history repeats itself. The husband and wife had another disagreement and the husband withdrew the second application.
18:15The inquiring attorney stated that the wife is presently in a position though, to obtain a lawful permanent residency without the husband through a petition with the Violence Against Women Act. So now the attorney has figured out that the husband here, who keeps withdrawing the applications of his wife to get her immigration, her visa of status, that the wife's being beaten and that the wife may have a vehicle in without the husband to get her status or get her immigration visa. The problem is this is the attorney who jointly represented the husband or represented the husband, an application for the wife. And now he's advising the wife that she can get a visa, but she has to claim or state that her husband is abusive to her Violence Against Women Act.
19:09And with this, though based on the claim, she would have to state that she was subjected to extreme cruelty by the husband. Wife even asked inquiring attorney to represent her in this application, where she has to claim the husband had extreme cruelty against her. And the wife asserted and offered even evidence to the attorney that the Husband subjected her to this extreme cruelty. Cruelty. The inquiring attorney stated that she had. That the attorney heard, had no knowledge of this cruelty during the prior representations of the husband and the wife for the joint applications, and now wants to represent the wife. But the question is, is there a conflict of interest? So when we get down to it, initially the inquiring attorney represented the husband and the wife for the application for the wife's visa. The husband was the sponsoring because he was a United States citizen. The wife, you know, was a citizen of a different country, so was getting the immigrant visa to withdraw on applications, but the husband still engaged in both times. Now the wife wants to engage the attorney by herself and now claim that the husband was abusive. Extreme cruelty. Does the attorney have a conflict of interest and can the attorney represent the wife?
20:25Hopefully, most of you in your heads right now, since we're not, you know, speaking or it's not a live seminar, would say there is a conflict of interest here. Why is there a conflict? The husband is a former client of the inquiring attorney. In order for the inquiring attorney to now represent the wife, he's going to have to assert a position adverse to that husband. And if you don't think claiming that someone is cruel to their wife or that they abused their wife in some way is an adverse position, it's an adverse position in the eyes of the law. And so he's going to have to. To basically set forth this adverse position against the husband, his former client. And the rules really do not allow us to do that. And it is, if you even look at Rule 1.9, former client, and the same or substantially related text in there, the same or substantially related, you know, wordage, and the standard we have to meet, these are both immigration visa statuses is the same or substantially related. The wife's just now trying to go at it a different way by throwing the husband under the bus since he keeps applying, withdrawing, applying, withdrawing. Obviously, there probably is some abuse there, but going forth with that, this attorney has a conflict. Is it a curable conflict? That is the question. Can we get consent?
21:48Do you think it's consentable? Would you love to go to that husband who's your former client and say, hey, your wife or, you know, separated wife now has come to me and we're going to file our own application and claim you abused her. Think of how that consent's going to look. The court saw that, and the court here said the panel must resolve whether the conflict of interest under these facts is consensible and the panel, meaning the court believes it is not just because of the allegations that would come out and the assertion of, of, you know, what the wife would have to claim to get that visa that immigration under, claiming that the husband was an abuser. So it doesn't mean the wife can't file under that status. It just means that this inquiring attorney who represented the husband in the prior two applications cannot do the work. It needs to go to another law firm. It needs to go to another attorney. So it is not consensible.
22:46We have a former client conflict issue under Rule 1.9 and we really look to that same or substantially related context. This is just another case example that's often studied as well. And this one, the underlying facts include the case arises from false advertising claims relating to marketing of high fructose corn syrup. We've all seen those claims before pitting the sugar industry against the corn refining industry. So we have sugar versus corn. Plaintiffs are sugar industry manufacturers, trade groups and associations and defendants are manufacturers and trade groups and associations of the corn industry. So we have sugar as our plaintiff, corn as our defense. Plaintiffs represented by a legacy law firm called Squire Sanders and Dempsey LLP filed an instant lawsuit on April 22, 2011, asserting a cause of action for false advertising under the Lantham act, alleging that the defendants misled consumers by using the word corn sugar.
23:52So we have sugar versus corn and we're arguing over the worst of the use of the word corn sugar in advertisement. On June 1, 2014, the law firm of Patton Boggs LLP and Squire Sanders. Squire Sanders represented the plaintiffs combined. There was a merger and the merger, when they combined, you know, Patton Boggs and Squire Sanders combined to one law firm. Squire Patton remained as the sugar plaintiff's council record. The defense, which included an entity called ingredion, moved to disqualify the sugar plaintiff's lawyer. So the Squire Boggs or Squire Patton Boggs law firm from representing the sugar plaintiffs because Squire was now adverse to Ingredient, who was a long standing choir. Excuse me, client of Patent bog. So what do we have here is we have Patent Boggs and we have Squire Sanders merge. Squire Sanders over here represented sugar plaintiffs.
25:00Patton, excuse me, Patton Boggs over here represented Ingredient, which was a defendant in sugar lawsuit. So it was a corn manufacturer when the two firms merged. We have a conflict. This is called imputation. This is called. This should have been resolved before that merger occurred is what this is called. So this is kind of looking at this too. Do we have a former conflict? Are we now going to get into our imputed conflicts, our rule 1.10 conflicts. Well, when this came up and then Ingredient moved to disqualify the firm for being against it, Patent Bog said that Ingredient was a former client of theirs. So we're getting into that former client analysis now because they're Patent box said, no, wait a second. Ingredient, you're not a current client, you're a former client. Different analysis. And they went through an analysis that Patent Boggs had first retained, been retained by ingredient in 2004, and continued to do work for them ever since.
26:04And they paid probably about 230,000 in legal fees. Shortly after that, you know, the work kind of slowed down, subsided. There wasn't a lot of ongoing work at the time. But it came down to. Is the work that Pat and Boggs did for Ingredient the same or substantially related to the sugar case that Squire was representing all those plaintiffs in? And we have to look again about the confidences. What confidences did Patent Boggs learn when it was represented? Ingredient, what is Squire now learning? A supply plane of sugars. And can what we learned over here adversely affect them if we allow them to continue represent them since they're now one firm? So we have to look at that same or substantially related.
26:51Keep in mind, too, and this court reiterated it, that screens or those ethical walls that we think about, you know, just say, erect a scre. The two, you know, merge firms. That doesn't resolve a conflict. If there's a conflict, then we need consents. If we can't get consents, then we're out of representing the entities. So we have to get our consents. And when they really looked at what the patent box did for Ingredient in the prior work, it did include things like the usefulness of names for the high fructose corn syrups, labeling, and different things. So they were touching on some of the stuff that is part of this litigation. So we probably have a conflict that we're going to need consents for here.
27:34And so with this, they said, you know, you have to be able to get the consents. You have to, you know, get those in order to proceed. And unfortunately here. Do you think Ingredient was, at this point, after filing a motion to disqualify, going to give a consent? Absolutely not. And they didn't. And the court granted Ingredients motions to disqualify. The Squire firm now merged with Patent Boggs. So it became Squire Patent Boggs from representing the sugar plaintiffs because they didn't resolve the conflict or flag that former conflict. Former Client conflict when they merged as firms. I can see how it was missed because usually during a merger, you're looking more for current client conflicts, Rule 1.7.
28:21But we can never forget about our Rule 1.9, former client conflicts, because it was the former client scenario here that really hurt Squire Patent Boggs in the end when those two firms merged and the conflict bubbled up. So we have to be very careful and really get down to what did we do for the client, what confidences? And there was like three or four whole paragraphs on how Patent Boggs for ingredient did stuff with the high fructose corn syrup, the labeling, you know, what that looked like, which were the issues in the case at hand, where we needed the consent. And so, again, we have to be very careful when it comes to finding conflicts and resolving conflicts with this, too. We can get these in our prospective client conflicts or prospective clients. This is the rule.
29:13We kind of talked about it a little earlier too, where, you know, a person who consults with a lawyer, possibility of forming that attorney client relationship, the confidentiality attaches, which means freedom from conflicts attaches to. At the same time, when that prospective client comes in, starts to confide in the lawyer, starts to give details about the case, that information is confidential, which means we have to be clear of conflicts, and we can't do anything to adversely affect that prospective client or use the information they gave us to benefit someone else adverse to them. So we have to be very careful when people come in for consultations and who we talk to, because a consultation is not always paying a fee. Coming into a formal law firm, sitting down in an office.
30:01A consultation can be at a holiday party over Thanksgiving. It can be at a family gathering. It can be online, it could be through text message, it could be through Instagram, MySpace, that's really dating me. It can be through TikTok, anything where you are giving legal advice in response to someone's specific scenario and they are seeking that advice, they intend for it to be confidential, and usually they rely on your advice. That is a perspective client situation, whether you like to think of it as that or not. Because it's not always about what you believe. It's about what the person you're talking to believes, the lay person, the potential client.
30:40So we've got to really be careful, especially over the holidays, having those conversations with family members, friends, where they say, hey, you're a lawyer. Let me ask you this. No, we don't want that question. We want to take that question and run as far away from it as we can because we may be creating a prospective client relationship. And how many of you, when you have those conversations, then go back to your firm and say, hey, I talked to five people this weekend, gave them advice on their specific legal scenarios. Here are their names. Put them in my conflict system. How many of you do that? Absolutely no one. So again, we have to be very careful of those prospective client relationships because they can really get us in trouble when it comes to conflicts and analysis.
31:30And people tend to forget that prospective clients can create conflicts too. Just like former or current clients. People tend to forget about prospective client relationships and our duty to keep it confidential and free from conflicts. One of the cases more often studied than others is Kiefer versus of Mossberg and Sons. Again, I'll just read you a few of the facts. We'll go through kind of what you think of the facts and what the court's going to decide. Again, I'm just talking to myself, but if you'd like to participate, please do in the chat section. On October 2008, Luke Keefer and his wife Stephanie Kiefer were hunting outside White Sulphur Springs, Montana. Stephanie was hunting with a 0.308.
32:13I know I said that wrong. Mossberg model 800 rifle. The Kiefers alleged the Mossberg rifle fell and struck Luke's rifle and discharged and shot Luke in the face. Terrible situation causing serious impairment injury. On August 10, 2010, Luke called Tarlow and Stofizzer PLLC and spoke to an attorney, Margaret Wiemer, regarding Luke's possible claim against the gun manufacturer for the injuries sustained in the hunting accident. Because the rifle went off, no one dropped. Weimer's time record indicates that she spoke to Luke for six to 12 minutes. After discussing the case with Luke, Weimer advised him that her law firm was would not be interested in taking the case. Those six to 12 minutes is enough for a prospective client relationship. One minute is enough.
33:05Thirty seconds is enough. The conversation, however long it is, is enough. So we have a prospective client here. Even though this law firm turned it down, they still owe duties of confidences and freedom of conflicts to Luke. When because of the consultation, Luke and Stephanie then retained another counsel. In June 2011, filed a personal injury action against Mossberg or the law firm. Later agreed in the excuse me, filed a personal injury action and the firm they had first consulted with Mossberg and Sons or Mossberg agreed to represent the gun manufacturer in the case. That seem a little weird? We had Luke during the consultation and now they are on the Other side, that firm he talked to first, now they're on the other side and representing Mossberg. So I think I confused some of those facts for you. But again, so Luke went to talk to the first law firm. They said no. Luke hired another attorney, filed a personal injury action. The first law firm Luke, look, excuse me, Luke worked for is now going to represent the gun manufacturer.
34:13Crazy. That's a conflict. It's a perspective client conflict. Now, the attorney that had talked to Luke hadn't put it in the system, said that when they ran checks, there was nothing there revealed about this phone conversation, the 6 to 12 minute conversation, so that there's no way they could have caught it. Is that enough of defense to now be able to represent the other side and violate confidentiality of Luke or conflicts of interest, freedom of conflicts? Absolutely not. Just because you forget to record it, fail to find it, you are still subject to disqualification and potential discipline under the rules for violating conflicts. And so here that is the issue is this. Counsel who had gained information from Luke as a prospective client should be, should they be disqualified for conflict of interest under Rule 1.18?
35:06And that's what the court was deciding. They went through the prospective client analysis about how they're there to protect certain consequences or, excuse me, certain confidential information. And those conversations that we have with our prospective attorneys, because if we don't give honest, accurate, detailed information, how does that prospective attorney know if we have a valid claim and if they want to represent us? So Luke was very forthright and honest. Sanctions and disqualification were put up as being potential ways to, for them to resolve this situation because defense counsel is operating under conflict of interest. And think to yourself, what would you do? Looking back at that rule 1.18 and just looking at, you know, what it says and what we've talked about, would you disqualify this law firm as a prospective client, you know, conflict? The answer is yes. The law firm was disqualified. The court held that it was a conflict of interest of a prospective client and they were taken off the case. So we have to be aware not only of our current conflicts, which I know is not really as much in this seminar, but our former client conflicts and our prospective client conflicts.
36:19We also have to watch out for imputed conflicts of interest under Rule 1.10. Imputed conflicts normally come up in situations where we have lateral attorneys moving firm to firm or government service to private practice, which is more 111, which we'll get to after Rule 110, but this is where we have them Moving firm to firm or different areas like that. But that's the biggest. And here for an imputed conflict too, under this rule, we have to remember that a law firm is treated as one person. So my conflicts are all of my 900 fellow colleague attorneys. Conflicts. All my fellow 900 attorney colleagues, their conflicts are my conflicts. So if they are disqualified or they are conflicted out, I am conflicted out. There's not a lot of conflicts where you can just say, okay, well that particular attorney can't do it, but let me go to the office next door, you know, right next door in their same, you know, law firm and have them do it. Only personal conflicts work that way. Every other other conflict, if one attorney's conflicted out, all the attorneys are conflicted out.
37:29Now with this, two imputed conflicts, the lateral situation, which I've been mentioning, if you're a lateral attorney going to a different firm, you're bringing your book of business. Most likely, when that book of business comes over, all your conflicts now become conflicts of that new firm. Even if you decide to leave some of those cases behind, your brain still comes over to the new firm. What does your brain have? Confidential information about all those physical files you left behind, meaning you weren't going to take with you to the new firm. That means all your former client physical files, maybe your current clients who decided to stay with your former firm.
38:10But you can't leave your brain behind. So the confidential information, while it may not be in physical paper form, comes with you to your new law firm. And if you're a new law firm, kind of like going back to that merger situation is on the other side of one of your current or former clients or prospective clients, there's a conflict that needs resolved the minute you walk in those doors to your new law firm. Otherwise you're going to be in the Squire Patent Boggs situation with disqualification. So to rectify those situations, a lot of times if you move firms, and if you move firms, you may know this. If you haven't, this may be new information for you. But when you new firms, usually the firm you're going into, ask you for your current clients and your former clients for the past five years, including adverse parties on each of their matters. Why do you think they do that? They do that so that they can take your book of business, run it through their law firm so that they know the minute you walk in those doors, the minute HR says welcome to the new firm, they know what you need screened off from. This is where screens come into play. So Say, for instance, it was the Patent Bog situation. We knew we represented in Integr Integrin back at our former firm. We now know we have the sugar plaintiffs here. There's a potential former client conflict. Well, when that Patent bogs merged, the day of the merger, a screen should have gone up. That's where we lock out patent bog's attorneys from Squire
39:47attorneys on those files. Now, we can't bring those files with us. If it's, you know, the other side, we leave them behind, or, you know, the former client, but we screen it off, meaning, yes, your brain's coming, you're leaving it behind. We put a wall. You can't talk about it, we can't talk about it. We can't share information. We don't need consents because we left it behind. If we would have brought it with us, we would have had a current conflict and we would have needed consent. But so long as it doesn't reach the standard of same or substantially related and we leave it behind, we can screen. When that lateral attorney comes over, that's the time a screen is appropriate. If there is an active conflict, a screen is not appropriate for that lateral situation.
40:33The screen is appropriate because we're just screening off the brain. We're just screening off your ability as the lateral to talk to anyone about the case, inquire into it. You're probably locked out of the H drive or the files, whatever your shared file databases. You can't access it, you can't talk about it. You can't, you know, provoke conversation. And if people ask you, you have to say, no, no, no, no, no, I can't talk about it because you're screened off. That's what a screen does. And it is only appropriate in that situation where a lateral is coming. And we ran that list, they're leaving those files behind. So we're more in that former client scenario.
41:11It's not the same matter. We don't have a current conflict, but we have a conflict and we screen it off. So you do need certain things to find these things. You need certain things to find current conflicts, prospective conflicts, and former client conflicts and know when imputation is there and know when you have to screen. You have to have some type of database. And usually it's a firm wide database where you run a search in it and you can just say, okay, I want to represent, you know, bank of America. So you search bank of America and see if there's any hits in it. If there is, it'll tell you, well, bank of America Is a client bank of America's adverse. Whatever the relationship, it should be kept in that database. Now how robust of a database you have depends on the size of your law firm, your clients, how many clients you have, how many offices, how many attorneys. If you're a one or two person shop, you're probably not going to have a robust conflict database. It may be a yell down the hall or spreadsheet situation or where you just check it and do a word find to see if the name pops up.
42:18If you're a huge or big law type of law firm, like Taft, like Barnes and Thornburg, Ice, Miller, Frost, Brown, Todd, or any of the big, big law firms, McGuire, woods, any of them, you probably have a more robust database. The robust database probably allows you to do bullion searches or you kind of like our Westlaw LexisNexis term searches and then it gives you a report of all the hits. Then you have to decipher through the report or look through the report to find out if there is any conflicts and then resolve them. But you do need some type of system. Now systems are not foolproof. They won't catch personal conflicts which you know, takes out that one attorney and not the whole firm if it's personal to that attorney, meaning they have a belief or own a company themselves or something personal to them.
43:09It's also really hard in databases to catch former client conflicts and prospective client conflicts because usually the databases don't contain enough information and they're hard to search where you're not going to catch those things. So while conflict databases are fantastic for our current conflicts, they are harder to catch our former and perspective client conflicts. And same thing with government conflicts, which we'll see here in just a second too. The conflict databases are not great for them, but they do kind of help us obviously identify when other conflicts are going to be imputed upon us and imputed upon, you know, different areas like that. And catching those current climb conflicts, once we catch them, we have to identify them, figure out is the rules invoked which rule, and then get our consent if we can. Sometimes having a conflict attorney or someone neutral review those results within the firm can be good because the lawyer wanting to take on the new case and the lawyer not wanting you to take on or representing another side or a former client give a little jaded view and interest. So having a neutral party in the firm, usually known as a conflict attorney, review those reports is a great idea too, especially if you're a larger or mid sized firm and takes a lot of that administrative Burden off the attorneys themselves so they can get back to their billable time. And then the complex attorneys do it. At that point, once you find the conflict, you got to decide, is it consensus or not? Can we. Do we need two
44:45consents? Do we can't get consent at all? Like, what do we need? Or is a wall or screen the proper route? Screens never cure conflicts. Screens are usually only there for that lateral attorney moving situation, like I talked about. So just know that they never, excuse me, resolve a conflict. So we have to be very careful. Lawyers should have knowledge of the conflict rules. Even if you feel like I don't deal with them every day, you need to have them even if you have conflicts. Attorneys having knowledge of the conflict rules is vitally important to the success of a lawyer. Excuse me, in any law firm. And just knowing what it is, because imputation, disqualification, and all those things can happen when you least expect it.
45:35This case is one. When I said, you know, screens and that imputation, it needs to be timely, like when the lawyer steps into the firm. This is one where it was not timely. This is apprentice versus Office Max North America. In this one we have here, Office Max filed a motion to disqualify counsel for the plaintiffs because the Roan firm hired an attorney named Talbot after Ellison left his employment with counsel for Office Max Ogletree Deacons was the firm. And so we had one attorney leaving, going to another firm. We. They didn't bring it with them. But we have this imputation coming. We have their brain coming.
46:15And they didn't catch the conflict in the initial onboarding process, the lateral. They finally did, and they put up a screen like they should have to begin with that lateral situation. But the screen was not timely. The screen was after the fact. It took a couple of weeks to get in place, which was way too long. It was not prompt when that person entered the firm. So we had an issue when it came up to that. The rule that came out of this case is what I've been telling you, but I'll read it to you verbatim here. To be timely, screening should have been performed at the time of hiring. Thus, the Roan law firm did not provide prompt notice that would enable them to be compliant with Rule 110.
46:57So if you have a lateral situation, you need to assess conflicts before that lateral comes over, not after. And that screen needs to be in place at the time that lateral enters the door, or you can get disqualified. Something to think about. We should not switch sides too. This is a good story. And it is. You can actually Google it. It's listed in Legal Tender. It's a publication, but it's My Lawyer Switched Slides. Don't worry, There's a screen. It's kind of a parody on the fact that some lawyers think that screens can cure conflicts like replace a consent, and that's just not the case. And this just kind of takes it to that ridiculous extreme of why that shouldn't be the case and why we can't do that, and that screens are really only there for those lateral situations. And so if you really don't believe me on that, reading, this parody will really open your eyes if you just Google the name of it. My Lawyer Switched Sides. Don't worry, There's a screen. You should find it. It was published in a publication called Legal Tender, A Lawyer's Guide to Handling Professional Dilemmas. But it is a good story or parody to read there as well. The last topic we're going to talk about today as we wind down here in our Last minutes or so, 10 minutes or so, is rule 1.11 our government client conflicts. There's a special rule for conflicts when someone moves from government service in house to private practice. And that is because being a government lawyer, you have a unique client. Your client's the government, and you're going to interact with a lot of different
48:33companies, people you know, on the other sides of things, but you're not going to touch every case, obviously. And there's a lot of government lawyers and there's a lot of, you know, different departments and stuff. And so there's a rule devised to kind of allow for the movement of counsel from government to private practice, because if we didn't have this rule, that would be a very hard move, and you'd be precluded maybe out of a lot of work just because of that government service and how much government touches different types of cases. So this rule broken down says, except as law may otherwise expressly permit, a lawyer who has formerly served as a public officer or employee of the government shall not otherwise represent a client in connection with a matter in which the lawyer participated personally or substantially as a public officer, unless the appropriate government agency gives informed consent confirmed in writing to the representation. So breaking that down, this is going to be on the person moving from government service to private practice to catch these conflicts, because only that person is going to know what cases they participated in personally and substantially while they were a government services lawyer. And how are they going to know when something pops up in private practice? Say a case pops up and they say, hey, we need you to work on this case. Here's the parties, or here's, you know, the government's on the other side. Here's the party. That lawyer is going to say, no,
50:00no, no, wait a second. I did work for that, you know, on a case with that entity before. I have personal knowledge, I participated substantially. I cannot do that case unless the private firm, the private attorney now gives notice to the government agency they work for that they're going to be working on that case and that government agency consents to it. So that attorney that's moving from government service to private practice has to always be on and thinking, did I participate with this entity or person involved in anything while I was in government services? And that's because usually when you move from government service to private practice, you're moving into private practice in the same area of law that you did in government. Now you're just doing it for more money in private practice. So you've got to be very careful there and know and what happens when that comes up.
50:52That doesn't mean the whole firm's disqualified. This is one of those unique situations. It just means that government services or former government services attorney is disqualified. And we put a screen up. We put that invisible wall barrier. So a screen can also cure these types of conflicts, but we have to catch them first. And it really does come down to that lawyer that was moving from government to private practice stepping up, speaking up, and knowing what they worked on and knowing that it is a conflict. Normally when government lawyers come into a firm, the firm advises them of this duty, gives them a copy of Rule 1.11, because Lo and behold, some of them have never read it and that it's on them and that they could be disciplined for violating it, and that they have to speak up so that internally we can put procedures in place like this screen and that to protect them when it does arise. But we have to know about it. And it all boils down to, as we talked about the beginning, that confidential information, confidential government information that they've obtained representing or the government, and something the same or, you know, personally or substantially related.
52:03Now, they can't do the opposite in private practice. So really something to think about. And this is just a chart just again to remind myself, but kind of going back through everything we've talked about here today, you know, that prior representation, the former client scenario, we have to say we're substantially related. We have government employees we have to look at. You know, when you're moving, when you were a government employee, did you per, did you participate personally and substantially in something related to the same party or parties? If so, we have a conflict. We need to, you get either informed consent from the agency and a screen or a screen or something, depending on how you want to go forward.
52:43So you really do have to think about what is the scenario, which rule applies, Is it former client, is it current client, is it prospective, you know, client, is it government, you know, government employee to private practice employee, what is involved? And then on top of that, especially if you're a government employee or corporations involved, who is the client? What does that mean? How do we know what confidence is we held? How do we know if we're now going to be adverse to a client? If it's an agency or, you know, a department or governmental entity we were representing? And for government, it boils down to the client is usually that official that's over the agency or body or that branch of government. So like the mayor or someone like that county attorney represents the county, not the individual commissioners. So you kind of treat government like we do corporations.
53:35So when you're thinking of that analysis under Rule 1.11, you know, who did I represent? Who are the parties involved? Your client is normally the agency, the entity, the county, not the commissioners, not the individuals. So you have to think in that context. That's who you owe confidentiality to. That's who you owe your duties of loyalty to. And that's why when we have to get consent, you know, that lateral moving from government service to over to private practice, we have to notify the agency, we have to notify the entity. It's not the individual people. We have to maintain that competence. You have the same duties as a government lawyer as you do as an in house lawyer of reporting up if something's affecting or adversely affecting the agency reporting up and out.
54:18So you have all of those same duties. And we have to keep that in mind for conflicts resolution. For government lawyers. Always just remember that participated personally, if substantially, in a matter if. So you need to raise your hand and say, hey, hey, hey, hey, we need a screen. I have a conflict. So making sure that you do that because again, we need to make sure that we maintain our ethics. And I hope everyone has a great evening and thank you for joining me for this seminar today.