55min · about 8,000 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Foreign.
0:09Welcome welcome. Hello. Please let me know if you're able to hear us loud and clearly. Welcome.
0:18If you are able to hear us loud and clearly, can you please let us know where are you logging in from on June 15, 2026? So I am logging in from South Carolina by way of California. So this is just a test for us to see if you're with us loud and clear from New Jersey. Hello. What city in New Jersey? Kc Kansas City, Missouri I have a speaking engagement coming up in Kansas City with the University of so welcome. New Jersey St. Louis fantastic. Missouri Philly, D.C. badminister, New Jersey. Is that anywhere near Cherry Hill, New Jersey Arlington, Virginia New Jersey Virginia Colorado Springs welcome beautiful state Overland Park, Kansas Albany, New York I went to law school at Syracuse, so welcome upstate.
1:22So you all are here. I am so pleased that you've joined us. From lexfib cle we're going to discuss attorney wellness, mental health and ethical compliance. Today we're going to discuss competence, client protection, and professional responsibility. A little bit About Me My name is attorney Tracy Sanders Rucker. I've been practicing law for about 20 years. Yes, I'm aging myself here, but graduated from Syracuse University College of Law, went to practice in areas such as employment law, immigration law, clerked for a judge, and now I am teaching cles and writing full time. The reason why I'd like for us to discuss attorney wellness is first. As you all may know, it's a big deal in terms of having a healthy mind and ethical compliance because we need attorney wellness, mental health and ethical compliance capability to provide competent client protection and to meet our professional responsibility.
2:31So the CLE program today will provide you for an attorney audience with a structured compliance focused framework for addressing mental health, wellness and professional responsibility within legal practice. As attorneys navigate increasing workloads, technological disruption, and evolving client expectations, mental health is no longer solely a personal concern. It is directly tied to ethical obligations under the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct. So let's stop here and go back to the chat. In addition to the ABA rules, most states have their own model rules. So if you will share where you're admitted. So for example, I'm admitted to practice law in the state of Connecticut and Connecticut also has model rules which are similar to but are separate from, of course, the ABA rules. So we have to follow our ABA rules as well as our State Bar association rules. And then are are any of you admitted to the Federal Bar Association? So the Federal Bar or some practice bar associations might also have ethical canons? Yes. Thank you so much Sarandos mentioned court. So it is important for us to keep in mind that while we often see ABA Model Rules, we also have to think about state rules. We also have to think about federal rules. And what about local rules? I don't know if you all are aware, but a law firm, Ropes and Gray, has created a wonderful publication about AI and local rules. So in addition to our ABA Model Rules, we also want to be cognizant of local rules. And those local rules could be state court, local rules,
4:31or even, even go a step lower than state court. It could be local jurisdiction or tribunal. So whatever space we're in, if it's civilian or military, ABA or state, we want to follow the rules of professional conduct. So the CLE program examines how attorney wellness intersects with the duties of competence, diligence, communication, and supervision. So I like to do a quick quiz with you all. I'd like to poll you all in terms of competence, diligence, communication and supervision. What resonates with you more in terms of all of these terms? When you think about attorney wellness and protecting clients or competence, what would you say? Diligence, communication, or supervision?
5:29So, for example, for me, I think it is definitely going to be diligent because we have to do the work and test ourselves before we can manage anyone else. What do you all think? Communication. We have to have excellent verbal written as well as netiquit, which is email or Internet communication. And then in terms of supervision, remember, as attorneys, we are not only responsible for our own conduct, but if you have some associates that you're working with, or if you have paralegals, or even to a lesser extent, if you're using software tools or AI. So there are various components of supervision, communication and diligence. But all of this is leading back to our need for competence. When you think about the term competence, do you all think it is merely a matter of having great mental health, or do you think that mental health and wellness are the same term or separate terms?
6:36What do you all think about attorney wellness? And we will go over these terms in a moment, but I want you to think about attorney wellness. I want you to think about mental health, and I also want us to be cognizant of the quality of life because lawyering can be very stressful. So these are terms that might be synonymous in terms of attorney wellness, mental health, quality of life, and also impairment, which can come from substances or prescriptions or illness. Right? And it doesn't have to be a vice all the time. We have human bodies and they don't always feel well. So there are various components of wellness. Now in terms of a definition, a multidimensional foundation of professional practice should start with the definition of wellness. Wellness is a proactive approach to promoting general well being and health health rather than merely treating or managing symptoms of health problems. Now, when I started law school in the early 2000s, a lawyer would not dare mention mental health problems or emotional well being. But I think we're at a point now in society where there is still a stigma somewhat attached to mental illness or the lack of great mental health. But we understand that there is a multi dimensional approach to wellness and health, including mental and physical health, that might also include emotional well being, coping effectively with life changes, creating satisfying relationships, managing stress, and maintaining psychological resilience. So that is super loaded
8:35when we think about emotional wellness. Let's think about some life challenges. So even if we are attorneys or lawyers, you can use the words interchangeably, life will still happen, right? People get married, people get divorced, people get separated, people lose family members, people might have to deal with sickness or financial issues even if these things occur. And sometimes life challenges could be happy challenges. You could receive a large inheritance, you could reach retirement, you could get married, you could adopt a child, you could become a parent or a grandparent, your kid could graduate from college.
9:19So there also happy surprises as well as negative surprises. And sometimes happy surprises can also affect emotional well being because think about it, if you win the lottery overnight and become a millionaire, that's a happy surprise. But it still could affect your emotional well being or health because it still would involve managing stress. Psychological resilience is the ability to face those challenges, whether it's good or bad. Happy surprises, negative surprises, great life challenges are not so great. But are you able to bounce back and maintain your physical well being and your mental well being in spite of these life challenges? Physical well being means recognizing and meeting the need for regular physical activity.
10:12I don't want to age myself or become overly personal with you all, but the way I approached being a lawyer and attorney wellness in my 20s or 30s, when I became a lawyer, is not the same as it is now that I'm approaching middle age. So a lot of that physical well being is being very honest with ourselves as lawyers and thinking about what decade in life, what life phase we're in, and then adjusting in terms of our health and well being, the need for physical activity, the need for nutritious food, the need for adequate sleep as our foundation to overall health and wellness. And if we are healthy and well, then we can become or maintain our roles as healthy or well, attorneys. And then the dimensions of wellness might encompass multiple interconnected dimensions, such as feeling great about ourselves.
11:12Right. First and foremost, the battle begins within. We want to be our best selves and then we present our best selves. In the workplace, or if you are solo practitioners or you have your own company, the best you is going to be the best supervisor or the best employee or the best entrepreneur. And this is going to be involved with the importance of maintaining healthy practices in terms of physical health, mental health, resilience and personal and professional life. Personal and professional life is going to be important to have boundaries. So I will ask you all this. How many of you agree that in the workplace you believe it is important to have professional and personal boundaries? What about with your clients as well? Say if you're meeting with a client and you're having a bad day, do you all fill your clients in on how you're feeling or are you resilient enough to go through the rough times? Maybe you're not having such a great day, but your client deserves the best representation.
12:24And if the client asks, how are you today? You will smile and you will get through the case without filling the client in on my dog died, my cat got run over, my kid lost his homework. Whatever is happening, you can still go to court, face your client, face your co workers, and you are resilient and you're doing a great job. Now this will require a lot of practice and support. And research shows that individuals who participate proactively engage in wellness practices such as eating well, exercise, adequate sleep, even physicals once a year or twice a year, dental care. Whatever your health practices are, those are going to be the professionals that have a better overall lifestyle health outcomes, higher rates of physical activity, improve self well being, and then you can only give to others what you have for yourself.
13:26That's going to make for a better attorney. So why attorney wellness matters? Well, first and foremost, physical and mental health are connected. I am not at all a psychologist. This is for lawyers. But we do know that there is a psychosomatic connection between mind, body, health, soul, spirit, however far you want to take it. But there is a component that drives ethical performance. We make better decisions when we have better physical health, when we have better mental health. So the prevalence of mental health has a correlation in our legal profession with ethical breaches. So for example, 71% of lawyers or attorneys might experience anxiety that could take the form of general anxiety disorder, or it could be certain phobias or it could just simply having panic attacks or feeling as if you are not in control of your emotions.
14:30So unfortunately, lawyers suffer from anxiety, about 71%, 5% increase from 2022. We don't know if that is because lawyers now feel a little more comfortable post Covid disclosing mental health challenges or if we have technology and screening tools that are able to capture data and provide metrics that are better than what we had before. And then 38% of attorneys unfortunately experience depression. That could be mood disorder, that could be not feeling well, that could be not being able to function. But overall, 38%, that is an increase from 2022 as well. And then 31% struggle with other mental health issues. That could be OCD, that could be anything from ADHD or whatever other mental health ailments attorneys are suffering from. And the source of this data is the 2023 almandlaw.com Compass of Mental Health survey. And this is reported in the American bar Association Journal, May 19, 2023. So Attorney Wellness and mental health issues are real. So what are we going to do about it? Let's consider environment as primary stressors.
15:59Now, you don't have to tell me in what environment, but how many of you during the course of your legal career. And please do not breach confidence or share personal information, but have any of you felt stressed out at work? Did you find your work environment to be stressful? So I will start us off if you'd like to share for me, yes. And what did I find most stressful? Because it says here 76% of lawyers attribute problems to their work environment. 68% billable hours, 67% inability to disconnect work from home. Then there's sleep issues and all other sorts of crises. For me, I agreed Diane deadlines.
16:44One time I had to file a deadline. And this is an immigration law where there's so much at stake. I could not sleep for days. I wanted to make sure that I got everything in, but I missed a deadline. And you all know that if you're working for a law firm, if you miss a deadline, that's pretty much your job, right? Deadlines are lifeblood of the legal profession, so I can relate to deadlines. What about bullying at work? When I initially graduated from law school, my voice wasn't as passionate and pronounced and powerful as it was initially. But I will say the biggest hurdle for me initially was bullying.
17:29I don't know if any of you have had problems with co workers or supervisors, but for me it was a whole issue of Bullying because Southern girl going to Northeastern Law School, then ending up working in New York City, that was a nightmare. So for me, I had to learn how to find my own voice, stand up for myself, and, and to really feel great and confident about myself. So I shared a little bit of my stress and anxiety right out of law school. In terms of what were some issues that could have affected my mental health. How did I take it back? Well, I avoided burnout. Burnout symptoms and cognitive impact can affect our ability to perform. So if you can't perform, you can't stay employed. I don't care if it's public sector employment, meaning working for the government, federal, state, or local, or.
18:26I went to a large law firm right out of law school, and that's even more demanding. But rather it's private practice in a large law firm or public practice, or teaching or a nonprofit. We have to maintain our cognitive health because our cognitive impact is going to determine how we perform, how we service our clients, and the decisions that we make in terms of professional responsibility. So over 60% of lawyers report feeling at some point during their careers overwhelmed, irritable, exhausted and unable to concentrate. Over 50% experience feelings of failure, self doubt. You all have probably heard about the imposter syndrome. I did not suffer from the imposter syndrome. I suffered from kind of being delusional, thinking that I could just graduate from law school and everybody would like me and practice, and then I had to learn how to like myself. But whatever your issue is, we have to maintain control of ourselves. We have to feel that we can win, we won't fail. We can't focus too much on our weaknesses and engage in self doubt. We need confidence. We can't fall prey to cynicism and other issues that may affect our cognitive ability to practice law, which could lead to burnout. Now, if you had any of those issues, let's focus on some solutions.
19:56Anyone can pout about the problems, right? So let's focus on some solutions. So I mentioned growing up in the south, going to a Northeastern law school, suffering from some bullying. What did I do about it? I. I found a mentor. First and foremost. Do you all think mentorship helped? So I found a mentor. I enrolled in yoga, and back then we didn't have mental health apps or we couldn't find a coach or therapy. But I also found a business coach or a life coach. So these are some solutions that worked for me. If you have some solutions that might help your fellow attorneys logged in today, what are some solutions that you found?
20:41Religion That's a very good solution soon because yes, for me, religion and going to church also help having faith. Whatever your source of support, you're going to need it. Whether you're first year out meeting new attorney mid level where I am now, or if you're in the golden age of your career, you will need support and wellness solutions. So inadequate support and wellness solutions will possibly lead to cognitive impairment burnout and possibly making bad choices which could lead to ethical breaches. So only 33% of attorneys believe that they could take leave for mental health issues. Most of the time attorneys believe that we have to suffer in silence. I think that is changing now because mental health is being destigmatized and you don't have to always see a therapist. Now there are mental health apps or you can see a life coach or a business coach or you could read a great book. For example, have any of you heard of Mel Robbins? Mel Robbins is, I call her a self help guru, but she's also a lawyer and she wrote a lot of great books about this very topic. And one book I recently read by her is called the Let Them Theory.
22:07So for me, finding sources of support and great books, especially from lawyers who understand our profession was also another great source of support for me. Now, are any of you second generation lawyers or you have lawyers in your family? Are any of you in a family of lawyers second generation? Fantastic. So if you have a parent that's a lawyer, or a grandparent that's a lawyer, or neighbors or church members, community members, I find that if you. Wonderful. James. James is second generation. His mom, uncle, rely on family members and friends in the profession, I think that is a great source of support. Now for those of you who might be like me, I am first generation. Any other first generation lawyers? For first generation lawyers, I think it would be great to look at ergs in the workplace. Do you all know what ergs are? Employee resource groups. Employee resource groups in 2026 cannot be based on race. They should be open to everyone, right? So if you have a first generation employee group and your law school, in your workplace, in your community, that is also a great source of support. Now if you are legacy attorney, kudos. But if you're first generation such as myself and many others, we can seek out other sources of support in terms of other first generation lawyer groups in the community, in schools, in the workplace. So substance abuse and alcohol disorders might result when lawyers are not doing what we are doing now, engaging in CLE conversations.
24:05And I perceive this to be more of a conversation than a monologue because I think we learn from each other. So even if it's not as interactive. Join other cles about attorney wellness and mental health and ethical canons. The more we know about professional responsibility and how to meet our professional responsibility obligations, the better attorneys we will become. And this might also help prevent substance abuse and alcohol disorders which are the hidden crisis barrier that undermine attorney wellness. So for example, 21 to 36% of attorneys have cited to problem drinking. This is three to five times more than a general population. Why do you all think that drinking might be an issue in our profession? I will say because of happy hours and networking and because it is expected in certain environments. If you go out to a client meeting or you go out with friends after work, you don't have to drink. And for some people it is against their personal values, religious values or their upbringing. But for many people they might feel that it's peer pressure and then it can become a problem and then depression symptoms. 28% of attorneys have reported anxiety depression, 11% suicidal ideation.
25:36This is very scary. So I will say be nice to a lawyer. There's a national be nice to you lawyer day. But why don't we plan to be nice to each other every day? I will tell you the reason why lawyer shows in my opinion are so highly watched and rated. Everything from Ally McBeal, if you can remember that far back to LA law to some of the new modern shows is because of the idea that you see these wonderful attorneys. They're beautiful, they're well dressed, they're dealing with this work related stress and are pushing back against some of the issues that we are discussing now. But I think what people generally like to see in the practice or in some of these other legal shows is how we get along with each other. When you are in a legal environment where you like your co workers and everybody won't like everybody, but when you enjoy going to work, when you enjoy working with your clients, when you enjoy the work that you do, it is probably one of the most fulfilling feelings I've ever felt in my lifetime. I worked at a law firm in Los Angeles and I enjoyed going to work. The lawyers and I in that firm as well as paralegals liked each other so much. We worked together 10 hours a day.
27:05We'd probably go have dinner together. We call each other after work over the weekends to the point where I'm married now but significant other than said, do you all ever take a break from each other? So I think when we work together well, we really do work together well, and it prevents burnout because you have that source of support in terms of preventing chronic occupational stress, which can cause exhaustion and cynicism. When lawyers are stressed, we can be very type A and mean. We're cynical, we're critical. We are cat fighting and dog fighting. And this can impede productivity, it can reduce efficacy, it can interfere with our client obligations and also affect professional responsibility. It can lead to impairment, cognitive overload. But when you are in that legal environment where you enjoy your work, you enjoy your co workers, you enjoy even working with the judges that you might see in court, it gives you that extra oomph, as I will call it, in terms of the ability to have resilience, which is the ability or the capacity to recover from adversity and maintain performance. Because even when I worked in a magical law firm that I liked so much, I still had bad days.
28:31Clients didn't always bring their documents to court. Judges yelled at me, my paralegal called out sick. But when I had a team that I could depend on and we supported each other, it made it that much better. And then this will also affect your competence. How many of you know that it's a great work environment where you can bounce ideas off of other attorneys? This is why I really like working in person more than remotely. Because sometimes when you're reading over statutes in case law, you're not always sure, am I reading this properly? Do I understand what I'm doing? What about case strategy? How should I deal with this client? It's great in terms of competence that we can fulfill our individual duty to provide representation with necessary knowledge and skill as an individual. But it's even better when we have a supportive team.
29:27And then diligence is the duty to pursue matters with reasonable promptness. And then when we can communicate well in terms of keeping our clients informed and responding promptly, whether it's by sent text messages. In one firm that I worked in, we were able to correspond with a company issued a cell phone, and we could text our clients. We could use RingCentral to send messages to clients. I had my paralegal to call clients. However you're going to do it, we have an obligation to communicate. But when you have a successful team working together, you can easily communicate with clients and possibly prevent withdrawal, which is the duty or obligation to terminate representation when you are not meeting these goals of competence, diligence, communication because of possible burnout, impairment, or cognitive overload.
30:29So it really does require a village, in my opinion, to practice law well, and what is a possible village model? So let's look at ABA Model Rule 1.1. You need to have individual competence, so your paralegals can't be competent for you. AI cannot be competent for you. Your fellow co workers and lawyers can't be competent for you. We need individual competence. And when we have cognitive capability and we are effective, then we are making the team that much better when we understand the legal rules regarding knowledge, skill, thoroughness and preparation. Of those words, I would say preparation is probably most important because we can research the rules and we can gain skills and thoroughness will come in time.
31:25But the number one rule is to always, always be prepared. And then understanding our key risk factors for burnout, things that we want to avoid, substance abuse if we're not feeling well, we need to get our physical mental health health back together. We want to do whatever we can to avoid burnout and cognitive overload which will lead to ethical exposure. We want to make sure that we understand the ethical canons and how it is that we are to fulfill these ethical canons and our best strategies for professional responsibility safeguards. So what are some of those professional responsibility safeguards?
32:05Workload adjustment. If you have a calendar in the workplace, have that calendar scheduled out for months, you know your caseload, you know what is expected of you, you know which paralegals or legal assistants are helping you. You have peer consultation available even if you're not in person, you can still consult remotely. But you need professional support to preserve your competence. So I will stop here. Before we go on to diligence, how many of you agree that it feels a whole lot better going to work when you work well with your team, when there's collaboration, when there is cooperation
32:52and when there's excellent communication. I think that's what most of us want. I mean, I don't think people go to work, most people with the intent of making other people miserable. But usually if we're not happy with ourselves, then it is that much easier to make other people miserable. So if we focus on some of these ideas of collaboration, competence, communication, and not always being so accusatory or quick to accuse people of, you know, awful things in society that happens, bias, discrimination, being ill willed and ugly towards each other. I think if we replace some of these terms with communication, collaboration, cooperation, it will help in terms of, for example, diligence, preventing burnout, having good intentions in terms of meeting our ethical obligations. If you are in fact being discriminated against or you feel biased, or you feel you're not giving your fair shake Then that's not a good point.
34:02Place you want to look at the onset of what is causing you stress, Is it chronic? Is it causing burnout? Is it accumulating? And then that could lead to slippage, meaning you don't feel well, you don't want to go to work, you don't want to get out of bed. This could lead to procrastination, which could lead to missing deadlines, which could lead to violations in terms of following deadlines, missed clients complaining, and then the consequence, possibly disciplinary exposure, possibly being fired, malpractice liability. And now we're down this negative rabbit hole. So before we go there, let's assess first and foremost, how do we feel about ourselves?
34:50Is this the right workplace for me? Do I fit in with this organizational culture? If there are some naughty habits and behaviors that are being discussed displayed, are they going to interfere with my ability to provide excellent legal services to my clients? Can I delegate? Can I adjust my workload? Can I initiate withdrawal before it leads to disciplinary action? So the other ethical canon that we want to consider is communication. A lot of times what I think we call being ugly towards each other in terms of discrimination or bullying or just outright bias, hate and envy, a lot of it starts with communication.
35:38So I will tell you this. I'm going to confess sometimes in the morning, I am not a morning person. I have gone to work early in the mornings and before I have my green tea, if someone says hello to me, maybe I'm a little bit snappy. If you snap now, that's going to lead to a parade of horribles. You could snap at the wrong person in the law firm and your career there is over. And you're thinking, oh my God, this person doesn't like me because I'm navy blue or I'm purple or I'm green or I'm red or I'm orange or I'm white or I'm black. No, it could be our communication. Now sometimes people are mean and they may be biased and they might not like us for whatever reason.
36:23But as I have grown in my career, I've learned to watch my communication. Because a lot of missteps start with communication. When I am not fully awake, when I'm stressed out, when I am sleepy, when I am angry, when I am whatever I am. It could lead to stress driven communication that's going to lead to a prompt response or being gnarly or delayed or ignored emails that's going to lead to a complaint. And it could be a complaint from co workers, supervisor paralegal client. Do you see how we're going down this rabbit hole? That's going to lead to at risk behavior, that's going to lead to possible discipline. Emails could go unanswered, emails could be snappy, and then there's a whole parade of horribles.
37:15So I would say in terms of communication, the very best rule I have learned, and this is me taking personal responsibility for myself, is I've learned to understand that my intent does not always meet my impact and to focus very carefully on myself before I start blaming others. So if we engage in the self assessment, it can help us to be proactive, to maybe be silent instead of being snappy with a co worker or maybe to have a clear strategy in terms of how to deal with an annoying client before we send that email and then the client is now reporting us to a higher up or how to deal with a paralegal that is constantly making mistakes and making you look bad in court. These things happen. So I think communication is very important in terms of a self communication, interpersonal communication and then communication with clients. Now sometimes it's not us, sometimes we are in horrible situations.
38:22It could be a toxic workplace, it could be a horrible client, it could be a client that did not pay us, we're not feeling well. If it is a situation where you have self assessed, you have done everything that you can do to your best ability and it is still not working out, perhaps you need to consider withdrawal. So Aba Model Rule 1.16, withdrawal is sometimes the only viable solution. When is withdrawal a solution? When we have completed our self assessment. If it's a toxic work environment or a client is not playing, paying or a toxic client and there's just no way out, or if we have some type of cognitive impairment, we're not feeling well, we're physically sick, we're mentally sick, we're on prescription drugs, life has happened. When impairment reaches a threshold, withdrawal becomes a duty. There is first mandatory withdrawal triggers such as physical or mental condition, mental impairment, ability to represent client has been affected. So you first want to consider if it's mandatory withdrawal. And second layer of consideration is permissive withdrawal. Representation becomes unreasonably difficult due to client actions, changed circumstances or evolving conflicts. If you can't get along with your client, the client isn't paying, the client isn't providing the documents or following your instructions to adequately represent the client. Perhaps that is the case for permissive withdrawal.
40:03Now remember I mentioned that self assessment, self assessment obligation. The attorney must honestly evaluate first and foremost ourselves Our character, our attitudes, do we really want to represent this client? That should have been considered during the intake. But sometimes if you're working for a law firm, you can't always pick and choose your clients. So if you can't pick and choose, you have to do the self assessment. Attorney must honestly evaluate whether materially threshold has been introduced into this case, meaning representation of the client. And has it crossed the level where this will not go well for the client in terms of representation and what can I do about it? If it's self assessment and you can adjust your attitude, you can adjust your diligence, your communication, if there are things that we can control, yes, by all means do so. But sometimes it might require transition responsibility to protect the client's interest, to provide adequate notice, we need to return all the files and property. We need to ensure a smooth transition to someone else, meaning successor counsel or co counsel.
41:20Because withdrawal is the only option. Withdrawal is not failure contingent upon why you are withdrawing and the timeline. Okay? If you're doing it in a manner where the client will not be adversely affected and you have professional responsibility, duty and justification for doing so, don't always perceive withdrawal as a failure. Now, sometimes we can't withdraw. I have actually tried to withdraw from a case and I am not reaching attorney client priv because I'm not giving you details, but I tried to withdraw in open court because the case scared me. Immigration court, you could probably think about some scenarios where that might happen. And I politely tried to withdraw and a judge said to me, this is San Diego immigration court, we don't do it the way you do it in la. This is your client. So sometimes you cannot withdraw. And then what is our ethical obligation when we cannot withdraw? We still have to represent our client with our best skill, knowledge, ability and zealously advocate for his or her own behalf. So I thought I'd want to share a personal testimony in terms of we can't always withdraw and when we can't, we still have to do a great job. So professional responsibility when impairment involves not necessarily withdrawal, but substance abuse, that's another time when a lawyer must withdraw.
42:54If a lawyer is possibly taking prescription drugs or it could be alcohol or drugs, you probably want to think about releasing yourself from representation before 4. It is an issue where there is a complaint and disciplinary action. So if there is a substance issue, it could be alcohol, it could be prescriptions, it could be mental or physical illness, and now you're taking meds. The attorney should begin to understand at the beginning or the onset of any possible substance abuse or substance misuse, will this affect my client? And then in terms of competence erosion, Rule 1.1, the lawyer has a duty to think, okay, I am not able to competently represent this client because of prescription drugs or alcohol or whatever the situation might be. In terms of impairment, then it might lead to material impairment.
43:59If you're not stopping before it gets out of hand, if it's material impairment, this is when impairment crosses into materially affecting representation and the lawyer must consider withdrawal. So under Rule 1.16, mandatory withdrawal obligations are triggered if your ability to represent the client has been cognitively impaired and your representation might affect the client outcome negatively. What about supervisory responsibility? Are you responsible if you're supervising other attorneys and you sent notice, observe or suspect cognitive impairment? Now, I need to stop for a moment here to say be very careful because of the Americans with Disabilities act and other issues related to mental impairment, if you perceive someone to be impaired, merely perceiving someone to be mentally impaired or mentally disabled could lead to a discrimination lawsuit.
45:09So don't forge ahead too quickly. If you're supervising another attorney or any supervisor role in terms of paralegals or legal assistance, we don't want to go around diagnosing and proclaiming that people are mentally disabled or mentally ill or have some type of disability. The best that we can do is to make observations based on what we see, what we hear, corroborating evidence, and then you're sharing this with HR or your supervisor so you can make an informed decision. But the last thing you want to do is accuse someone of being mentally disabled or impaired or mentally ill. And it could possibly lead to some type of that could be disability discrimination. And if the person is in more than one protected category, it could be multiple discrimination lawsuits. So we want to be very careful in our supervisory role.
46:11Now in terms of remediation or discipline, we can also suggest legal assistance programs. If we have in house hr, we do have an ethical duty to take care of ourselves. But if you're supervising others, you also want to possibly provide resources for the attorney that might be impaired. So litigation risk factors and demographics include younger attorneys are possibly more susceptible to problems with respect to attorney wellness women. And this is not at all being negative or stereotypical or sex discrimination. I can attest as a person born female at birth that the legal profession is male dominated.
46:56And it can be type A. And sometimes it can feel overwhelming as a person of the female gender, if you're the only woman in this room full of men and they are very decisive and they're strong and are great attorneys. And you feel this need to prove yourself that in and of itself, itself can lead to stress and attorney unwellness. So what are we going to do about it? If you find yourself in one of these categories in terms of younger attorney or a woman, or disproportionately not fitting in an organization? First hypothetical to consider is you want to avoid burnout. So the burnout associate cannot help himself, cannot help clients, and certainly cannot bring profit to the firm. Or if you're working for a government agency, you can't help the common good if you cannot help yourself.
47:54So the first thing we want to do is avoid burnout. So we want to identify the issue, what is causing the stress. So the attorney must address the root cause, notify a supervisor of the risk, and then correct the action promptly. The ethical canons that are tied to avoiding burnout are Rule 1.3, diligence. Diligence is directly implicated by the pattern of missed deadlines. If you're burned out, maybe you're not paying attention to your performance, you're not returning client calls, you're not responding to emails, you're missing deadlines. So we want to avoid all of that. We want to analyze the root cause, we want to assess the impact in terms of attorney wellness, and we want to remedy the situation. What about hypothetical 2? The unreachable counselor we all work with know, or you may be an attorney that is hard to reach, especially if it's a rainmaker, right?
48:56The attorney that's out meeting with clients and making money. Well, great. But you still have an ethical duty to avoid stress for your clients by keeping in touch with your clients, communicating with your clients. So what are some solutions in terms of the unreachable counselor? The attorney fails to return calls or emails. The client feels overwhelmed. Paralegals feel overwhelmed. The other attorneys feel overwhelmed. The ethical risk is you risk being reported to the bar, you risk being fired from your law firm, you risk reputational damage. So how can we prevent this communication breakdown? Erodes trust and exposes risk of bar complaints. You want to establish a coverage system, electronic, maybe send out email responses, have your paralegals or legal assistance to call. Maybe you can delegate communication. Remember I mentioned my magical law firm enlargement Los Angeles? That I enjoyed working there.
50:02And the attorneys and I were basically always together. We always did work. Sometimes we would cover for each other. So if you can't call your client back or you can't make a meeting in court, whatever the Situation is you can have a coverage system to delegate to someone else so the entire firm is covered and your professional reputation is not as stake either way to avoid behaviors driven by any type of impairment or driven by simply forgetting sometimes you want to have a coverage team. Now, hypothetical three as we're winding down the impaired advocate. If you are working with an attorney that is possibly impaired due to mental health impairment, physical impairment meaning sick, not feeling feeling well, or there's some type of substance abuse issues first, the attorney should first and foremost alert his or her supervisor. Now sometimes attorneys don't always self disclose. So if you're noticing those behaviors, you want to inform a supervisor or other co workers to keep a lookout. If it's more than one person reporting or observing the same behavior, that almost becomes corroborating evidence in and of itself.
51:25So it's not you as one person singling a person out. This will also possibly help prevent claims of discrimination or bias or harassment. So you want to take a team approach to observe behavior. You want to document it, you want to journal it, and we should not be in the business is out to destroy anyone. You should offer support and help by possibly having team wide trainings or team wide sessions or employee benefits programs to remain known to all. If this is still not helping, there might be a Rule 1.1 breach. There could be cognitive impairment. You don't want to make those allegations. You want to alert HR and other members in the workplace to take a team approach to get to the bottom of this before a trigger occur which could lead to material impairment of representation, which could lead to a whole host of problems in terms of client complaints, ethical violations or problems for the entire firm. So anytime there is an issue in the law firm with an attorney, please do consider taking a team approach. As we wind down, rest assured that the mental health stigma is still there, but it's not at the same rate that it was Pre, Covid or 10 or 20 years ago. The stigma, licensure, fear and confidentiality concerns that attorneys had in the past about wellness, they're still there, but they're eroding.
53:01So feel free to do research and if you feel that you would like to share information in terms of how you're feeling, your wellness, the need for support, know that other attorneys in your workplace might feel the same. So perhaps you could suggest employee benefits such as attorney wellness programs or LAP legal assistance programs. This will help to prevent the primary barrier to attorney wellness, which is 44% of stigma, fear of discovery, loss of perfectionism in terms of culture and how other people see us. If we're in it together, that can help decrease that fear and stigma of needing help. In terms of attorney wellness, bar licensure concerns are real, but attorneys can reach out to their local bar association and confidence for assistance if clients have not been adversely affected. And you want to do this before clients are adversely affected.
54:07There are also self reliance tools. There are mental health apps. Now there are life coaches, there are attorney coaches. So there are a whole host of self help and self reliance tools. And we want to do this to prevent the financial cost associated with attorneys unwellness because this could cost our careers, it could cost our license, it could cost our law firms, it could cost our clients. So there are financial cost and also it interrupts or affects the workplace culture because remember everything that we do in life could have a direct effect or consequence in terms of how we are affecting others.
54:52So as we wrap up, remember that attorney will Wellness is not a personal luxury, it is an ethical obligation. Mental health is the foundation of competence, diligence and communication. There will possibly possibly have a part two to this because I have a little more to share, but for now let's wrap up with five stages of wellness. 1. Know the ethical rules. 2. Monitor your state bar rules in addition to the ABA rules. 3. If you're starting to feel unwell physically or mentally, take proactive steps to become well. You want to prevent cognitive impairment which could lead to a material breach in terms of client representation. And the fourth step is sustainable practice.
55:45An attorney who invests in Attorney Wellness will protect him or herself, protect the clients, protect licenses, protect careers and protect your attorney workplace. With that, I am attorney Tracy Sanders Rucker. It has been my pleasure to present Attorney Wellness to you today and I would like to congratulate you all for completing the course. Your Lex BID completion code for today is N as A Nancy C. U as in Umbrella, B as in Brian, R as in Robert, W as in William. And I will keep the LexID completion code up for about three more minutes, but I'll repeat it again for accuracy. It's N U B rw and thank you so much for joining me and I hope to see you on another let's fit cle.
57:01Goodbye everyone. You're welcome. You have a great day as well.
57:17The lex fit completion code is n as in nancy, u as in umbrella, b as in brian, r as in robert, and w as in will.
57:47The code is n and I'll type it u b r w n u b r w. You are welcome.
58:23It.
58:52One more minute and we will log out. The completion code for today is nubrw.
59:16Last call for the completion code. That is going to be N U B R W.
59:28And with that, thank you all for joining me and have a nice day.
59:42Goodbye everyone. Have a great week.