0:00Hi everybody, this is Mike DeBliss, and today's program is on opening statements and closing arguments. Thank you so much for joining me. This is an exciting presentation that is chock full of information, and so I do want to delve right in.
0:24So the way I broke this presentation down is I really like to start with the. With elemental things as building blocks and then kind of from there work our way up. So I had this revelation as I was, you know, preparing my last trial, and I really began to see a lot of comparisons between what I was doing as an actor learning, learning the playwrights text, and what I was doing in my very own opening and closings. Essentially, I realized that I was doing the very same thing. Even though the words were my words, I essentially was writing an opening and a closing and committing it to memory so that I could deliver it without the need for a notepad.
1:26So virtually every performance coach will agree that memorized text should be spoken in a way that makes the listener feel that the thoughts are coming to the speaker in the moment and that he is speaking them for the first time as if they are fresh. This is how we speak in real life. So we aim for spontaneity, as opposed to a monotone or pre planned delivery that brings the meaning out of the words and makes them sound as if they are being recited verbatim off of a page. Maybe an example of that would be a flight attendant making the obligatory evacuation speech before takeoff.
2:11We want to mint our words with the feeling that we want the jury to experience. And so we tend to speak the words as if they are all the same, but every word has a different meaning and deserves a different type of emphasis. And this is not to say that we want to be robotic about how we recite text,
2:43and we don't want to be that way. We want to aim, of course, for spontaneity. But we also have to be aware of some hidden traps when it comes to reciting memorized text. So the earliest acting instructors observed a phenomenon that would happen whenever their students were instructed to memorize a monologue. Despite being warned not to memorize it in one set way, almost inevitably, every student would. The danger this presented is that the actor got locked into speaking their monologue in one set way, such that it became virtually impossible to break the pattern and deliver it any differently, even when the instructor was side coaching the student. Through research, we now know that it's very difficult for the brain to break a pattern that emerges during the memorization stage.
3:38So for example, if I am Memorizing my opening in a way that sounds like this, where I'm going through it very methodically and I am enunciating virtually every syllable. There's a very good chance that in the live presentation it's going to be recited just like that. And again, it is a psychological process that social research has uncovered that's responsible for that. So subconsciously we hold onto the exact rhythm, pace, tone, voice, inflection that we relied upon when memorizing it. For actors and public speakers such as attorneys, this is fatal. Why? Well, unlike written words, the spoken word is fresh, dynamic and alive. It's like a heart rate monitor which ebbs and flows and has hills and valleys.
4:40There are hard stops, long pauses, quick transitions, rapid, unbroken chains of thoughts that come out of stream of consciousness. Laughter, excitement, sadness, longing, hesitation, uncertainty, gloating, silence, shamefulness, regret, flirtation, the list goes on and on and on. And all of these are in play in our everyday encounters with other people. As actors, we want to mirror real life. And the closer we come to that ideal, the more apt an audience will be to suspend their disbelief and to be drawn into the story. It's no different for lawyers. We're storytelling through storytelling. Lawyers need to draw the jury into a reconstructed reality of past events so that the jury can see, hear and feel what it was like for the client to, if it's a personal injury case, suffer a paralyzing injury. Or if it's a criminal case for the defendant and a self defense case for the defendant to be ambushed from behind by the victim.
5:52Second, there are a myriad of ways to say the same thing. The example that most coaches give is this line, I love you. Well, if you think about it, I love you can be uttered in so many different ways. And I'll give you extremes. It can be uttered in the most passionate of ways. Look no further than Romeo and Juliet. It can be uttered in a begrudging way. Think of a teenage boy yelling back to his mom before boarding a bus to go to summer camp. It can be uttered in a pleading way. And that might be in the form of a response of one partner to the other upon learning that the other wants to break up.
6:35In other words, getting locked into speaking text one way makes you a Johnny onenote and removes the possibility of discovering other ways that might be richer than the original way. And a good practice here is that we are always changing when we are in conversation with other people. And I always look at a presentation to the jury as a conversation because even though they don't speak back to us verbally, they are speaking back to us in terms of their body language. And if we envision this connection between the attorney and the jury as an electric current, it's a two way street. What comes from the jury can influence and impact what the attorney is saying, and vice versa. The words and speech of the attorney will influence and impact the jury. So again, the vision or the metaphor that I have for that is like an electric current. It's alive. It's not a one way ambush of the attorney speaking to the jury and being completely, completely in a bubble. It's always a two way street, just like it is in a conversation.
8:09Why is this relevant for trial attorneys and for anybody? I always bring this back to the courtroom, but it's not just for the courtroom. This work is. This work is about being human. And that's really the thrust behind all of my presentations. We connect with people who show us their humanity. This is what draws us to the theater. This is what draws us to movies. We want to see the human experience as it is experienced by a rich character. Now, that's not to say that we would be content to see a film of a normal, everyday life in the life of the character. No, we want something that is a little bit above that, that's, you know, not so off the mark, but is something that the character is experiencing that we perhaps would never experience in our life.
9:15So it has to be heightened, no doubt. And this is what makes it come alive. So I get the question all the time from attorneys, you know, about how strong their opening and closing is, but how it doesn't land as well as they anticipated it would in their preparation or in the real thing. And so we need to make distinction between the written word, which we as lawyers do so well, and the spoken word, which we as lawyers do quite well, but which I feel can be enhanced, in which there is a lot of room for improvement. So keep in mind that nobody would go to see a movie or to see a theatrical performance if the actors mailed it in and were merely speaking words in a monotone tone. For that matter, all the audience would need to do is get a copy of the play and read it, and it would be right there in black and white.
10:30But you have to ask yourself the question, why do theater enthusiasts, such as classical theater enthusiasts that love Shakespeare, how come they go to see so many adaptations of Hamlet played by different characters? Well, the answer is obvious. No two Hamlets are going to be alike. What, what one actor brings to the role is going to be different than what another actor brings to the role, the role, for the same reason, you might have been drawn to Jack Nicholson's portrayal of the Joker and then gone back to see Joaquin Phoenix's adaptation of the Joker and been equally surprised. So we are always in search of something that has deep meaning to us and that will resonate with us and. And the human condition. So we have to recognize that we might have the most incredible opening and closing on paper, but the next level is how do we lift these words off of the paper and make our performance of it? And I hate to use performance because that automatically infers that there is some type of rating system going on and that we have to be good. And then we have all these others, all this other psychological baggage that we attach to that. But if we just, in this context, refer to it as a performance, we want to be as compelling as the rich speakers that have come before us and that have been able to galvanize crowds such as Martin Luther King.
12:27So reading off of the page is not an option for trial lawyers. Instead, we must memorize our opening statements and closing arguments in the same way that actors memorize their lines so that the jury becomes the entire focus of our attention. The danger posed by a notepad, or worse yet, an electronic device, and I have seen that, believe it or not, is that they are distracting to the jury, and they continuously beckon for the attorney's eyes. The attorney who so obliges will begin to look down instead of into the eyes of the jury, thus breaking eye contact during the most formidable stage of the trial and losing the human connection that is so vital for building rapport with the jury.
13:13In this way, these objects create a barrier or a wedge between you and the jury in the overall scheme of things. You risk squandering one of the few opportunities that you have during a trial to what I call break the fourth wall and to address a jury directly. Breaking the fourth wall is a term that was introduced back in Shakespeare's time and in his plays. Essentially, whenever a character had a monologue where they were alone on stage, they would break the fourth wall and turn to contact the audience, and they would speak to the audience their inner thoughts. And audiences back in Shakespeare's day loved this. I mean, who could resist someone like Iago explaining his plan to, you know, to turn Othello against Desdemona and ultimately kill her? I mean, hatching all of that and giving the jury a glimpse into the inner thoughts and the plan that is being contrived by this Notable villain gave them, made them feel like they were a fly on the wall in a cabinet meeting on Capitol Hill. It was so enticing and so seductive that they couldn't resist it. So I feel that there are many opportunities for us as attorneys to do this with a jury.
14:53I mean, most obvious is when we stand up in opening and closing and speak directly to the jury. Another opportunity is if it is. If you have attorney conducted voir dire in your state, you can begin to build rapport with the jury even before they've been sworn in. As many an actor knows, breaking the fourth wall allows you to speak heart to heart with the audience and to reveal your innermost thoughts and feelings in the same way that a close friend may confide a deep secret in you. Shakespeare used this device so brilliantly that even his darkest and most vile villains were able to score points with the audience, no matter how much blood they shed.
15:37Of course, the one big difference is that the actor must memorize the words of someone other than himself, that being the playwright, while the lawyer must memorize his own words, since he himself is the one who wrote them. And that's the beauty of it. Because, you know, if you think about it, you know, it's one thing to have to learn another person's words, that of a playwright. It's another thing to have to learn your own words. It tends to be easier, at least in my experience, to memorize my own words than to memorize the words of a playwright. In order to undo this psychological bias towards reciting text the way it was originally memorized, which can lock you into patterns that are limiting, we need to trick the mind. How do we do this?
16:26By reimagining the way in which we memorize text in the first place so that we don't get locked into one way of doing it. The most basic way of doing this is through movement. This is what a lot of people don't recognize. Actors are very athletic, and we undergo a lot of training in movement. And movement is a very general term and can be perceived in many different ways by many different people. But essentially, what we mean when we talk about movement in a performative aspect is the type of readiness that the body needs to be able to take on the life of a character. And because, because we are physical beings, there is always some type of gate or some type of physical impediment that the character has that you will need to embody physically, and that will cure or will solve a lot of problems for finding the character. Because a lot of Times once you find the physicality of the character, you begin, your voice begins to drop right in. And so we always start in this outside in way of working.
17:53And so movement again is making our bodies as prepared for the demands of taking on a character other than ourselves. So, for example, these are some things that you can begin to implement almost immediately. You can memorize your text while bouncing a tennis ball. I do this all the time when I'm memorizing text, especially heightened text, that of Shakespeare, in an effort to avoid getting locked into one way of memorizing it, which for me, because I am so. I need to be so word perfect when I'm memorizing classical text. Because if you, if you lose a word, then you lose a syllable in the line and then the iambic pentameter is off and it can be recognized very easily by an audience. So when we memorize Shakespeare, there's so much need to be so perfect that I oftentimes find myself resorting into over enunciating syllables so that I don't leave any single word out. And that locks me into a pattern where I tend to be very sustained in my presentation of a monologue if I don't change rhythms. And so what I'll do is bounce a tennis ball off a wall, bounce a tennis ball off the ground, I will do dishes and begin reciting my monologue. I also do this with my opening and my closings or the time I will stand on my head. I've been known to stand on my head while I do this. Of course, I do not endorse others to do this for obvious reasons.
19:42This will all allow the text to spring out of you in a multitude of different ways, which will keep you open to the shifts that happen in the audience so that you can react to the audience in, you know, lively and be able to let the text spring out of you in different ways. But it can be scary if you haven't. If you haven't stretched yourself in those other ways. So this is. This is to get you out of those patterns. But that's not the only way in. What follows is a more expansive investigation into discovering the hidden treasures that lie within your speech. This is what I have learned from many different instructors that I've worked with over the years and that I continue to rely upon when I am in the rehearsal stage of a new play or when I am preparing for a trial. These concrete tools are designed specifically to enhance the delivery of your opening statement and closing argument.
20:42I've also included a number of exercises. So here's my approach. I used to think that once I had memorized my opening statement and closing argument, all the hard work was done. And I can now turn my attention to another vital aspect of trial preparation, such as cross examination. Nothing could be farther from the truth. Memorization of text is but the first of many steps required to bring your speech to life in a way that inspires a jury and leaves them thinking that the only just result is one in your favor. You can have the best written speech, as I was talking about earlier, but if you deliver it in a bland, stale, or monotone way, it'll fall flat. As my instructor once said, mike, don't wring the meaning out of the words. And he didn't say this to be nasty or to be mean. He said it because I was wringing the meaning out of the words. And he knew that what the audience wanted to hear was the rich inner life that I had going on inside me.
21:46And I didn't have the confidence back then to know that I had a rich inner life brewing inside me. So it took a little bit of confidence in getting there. But we all have this. We all have unique experiences that we can bring to our work as attorneys and that we can rely upon to persuade. We all know this from having gone to the theater to see a popular classical play of the likes of Dickens, Shaw, Williams, or Beckett, and leaving feeling completely empty and upset by the play, falling short of our expectations. So even professional actors that are, you know, that have had tons of training will wring the meaning out of the words. And who, you know, who hasn't seen a Shakespeare play where, you know, the actors, you know, sounded, you know, as any other Shakespearean actor, they have to, you know, put on this aura of, you know, some type of highfalutin, you know, aristocrat before they start reciting Shakespeare's words. But I'd argue that that's not how Shakespeare wrote his verse. He wanted the actors to bring themselves to the role and to reveal what was going on inside them within the context of the text. So I've seen my share of inferior productions of Shakespeare plays.
23:28To know the feeling in my approach, after the opening or closing has been written, I turn to memorizing it and then working on its delivery. The latter takes a lot of work, and it's not for the faint of heart. But if you want to make an unforgettable impression on the jury, there are no shortcuts. A great stage actor can silence an audience, but they must make use of Their voice. There is no avoiding it. Lawyers have that same ability in a courtroom. So let's talk about the power of thought. As you know, I talk about thought all the time because it's not something that gets a lot of attention in trial lawyers programs, but that we talk about a lot when we gather for Shakespeare workshops.
24:18On the most primitive level, we must be able to understand and hold a thought. Closing argument is not like a Starbucks conversation. Legal reasoning, like Shakespeare's verse, is heightened for a reason. There's magic in it. It's precise and vast. Shakespeare's words, just like an attorney's closing argument, are received by the brain like music. It's like an invocation or sending someone to the moon. It's crucial to know where thoughts begin and end so that your argument has organization, emboldens the jury, flows and keeps them on the edge of their seats. Similarly, you need to know where to pause or snatch a breath without breaking up the thought. All of this is necessary to do what my Shakespeare instructors dub drive the thought. And then of course, there is the rhythm of speech, which gets very little attention in trial lawyers programs, but which is of utmost importance. We have a vigorous vocal warm up that we go through before we even begin to speak any Shakespeare. We focus on consonants, then we go to vowels, then we do tongue twisters.
25:34In the second part of this program, I'm going to introduce you to some of those same exercises. And by the way, I use them to this day, not only when I am getting ready to go on stage, but also before the morning, before I have an opening or a closing to do. I will always warm my voice up and make it as resonant as I possibly can before I stand before a jury. Rhetoric. We must understand rhetoric and how to, I dare say, manipulate people with speech. That is what we're doing when we talk about rhetoric as lawyers. Our secret weapon, it's all in how we present the argument. Great leaders know how to do this exceptionally well. They know how to connect with an audience and get them to fight for them. An example that I'm going to use here is Mark Antony's famous Friends, Romans, countrymen speech. Ironically, I've never played Antony, but I have played Brutus.
26:41So I can tell you the feeling of having done the Brutus speech and then had Mark Antony come out on stage to do the friends, Romans, countrymen speech. And if you know the play well, you know that Brutus was one of Caesar's assassins. Julius Caesar's famous phrase was a, a two Brutus, meaning even You, Brutus, you. And now at least four other people are stabbing me to death. And it was Brutus himself who allowed Mark Antony to speak at Caesar's funeral. How ironic, right, that now Mark Antony is going to stand up and is going to rally the crowd against Brutus and the other assassins of Julius Caesar. So let's set the scene. A crowd is gathered for Julius Caesar's funeral.
27:41Brutus, one of Caesar's assassins. And by the way, I'm storytelling right now. So this is like a lesson within a lesson. I love to teach using the narrative form and using story because whatever it is, I think it's really something that's been, that's innate in us from the time of our ancestors. We would always gather around the fire to hear elder members of the tribe talk about stories of great hunts or great conquests. And so we are programmed, we are mapped for our antenna to go up as soon as someone begins the story. Looking at this from a very purely simple level, consider a comedian that you like. We don't even need to go to the big screen or to Shakespeare to experience this, but a comedian that you like. And when they start off by telling a story, and it might be one involving a little bit of self humor, where they're going to poke fun at themselves, but they set things up so brilliantly with a story. And immediately, immediately we're hooked in.
28:54We're not looking at our phones, we're not thinking about what we did 20 minutes ago. We're not thinking about our commute to the theater. We are automatically brought right in to this reality of this comedian who is now going to entertain us. And they usually live up to the expectations if they're good. So let's hearken back to Caesar's funeral. Brutus, one of Caesar's assassins, has allowed Antony to speak, provided that he would not blame him and the others for Caesar's death. A hushed silence descends upon the crowd. They know that Caesar was killed, but they want to know how Antony is dealing with it.
29:40In the same way that a close friend would want to know how you are coping with the death of a parent. I remember after I lost my father, I had so many well intentioned friends want to know. And you'd hear it from the grapevine. They wouldn't always say it directly to you, but you would hear it from other people that so and so was worried about you. Wants to know how you're doing, you know, please give them a call. And so that's really what, you know, good friends, you know the concern that they have when they know that a close friend has lost a parent. So what follows here is a revenge speech. And the stakes could not be higher. Why? If the crowd turns on him, Antony might not live to see the light of another day.
30:26But Antony is clever. He cuts out the fake news and goes straight to the facts. He knows how to inflame the crowd and to arrest their attention. His intention is to destroy Caesar's killers, and he's an invincible force. How is he able to do this? By answering the question, who is Caesar to me? It's incredible what Caesar has done for Antony. He was like a father who rescued his son when he was wandering around aimlessly and trying to find himself. It's painful to feel this lost. You know how there are people who come into your life and literally save you? I can think of at least five people like that in my life.
31:09And Caesar was just that to Antony. Can you imagine now what it must have been like for Antony to have seen his role model and the person who he loved beyond anything else in the world, Caesar be slaughtered right in front of his eyes? And the culprits doing it? It's as if his father is dead and the roof is king, caving in on him. Every fiber of Anthony's being wanted to break their necks. Despite this natural instinct, Anthony wouldn't have been able to win because there were several of them and only one of him. So what does he do? Despite the inner rage, Anthony creates a veneer of stability that allows him to create a plan. His plan is to get them slaughtered, the assassins he unleashes his secret weapon.
32:02Not only is Anthony a fierce warrior, but he can speak rhetoric under immense pressure, and that is exactly what he does. We call this process bringing yourself to the text and personalizing it. How is this like what you might be called to do in a courtroom? Well, you have, of course, a cause that you're fighting for. Your cause, of course, is not going to be as heightened as that of Antony to rally the jury to kill another human being. Thank God we live in a very different age than the Romans, than the Roman age. However, you have a cause that you're fighting for. It might be your client who was seriously maimed in a car accident. And you are trying to get justice for your client by getting a recovery that is going to help in some way make things a little bit better for them. You know, if they can no longer work, if they have these mounting medical bills.
33:13You know, obviously money doesn't bring back what life Once was like for people who have been seriously injured. However, it's the only way, it's the only compensation that we have available to help a person who has gone through a traumatic life altering event like one of serious injury, not to mention the post traumatic stress come and all of the psychological trauma that comes about as a result. So Antony refers to the crowd as friends and then as Romans. He does this strategically. He knows that it means something to be a Roman. He then says, lend me your ears to soften them. Essentially he's saying, would you mind letting me talk? Antony needs to take the wind out of the propaganda. That brute is spun. He has to make the people in the crowd, who have their weapons drawn and pointing at him, stand down. Slowly, he begins to pry open the ground and make the crowd doubt the line they were given. And it's all in how Antony presents his argument.
34:27He drives. Each thought, each new idea separates the crowd from the fake propaganda. It's like a snowball picking up speed as it rolls down a mountaintop, getting bigger and bigger by the second. At one point, Antony tells the crowd that they have food on the table because Caesar made the economy good. Like a tsunami, Antony turns the crowd against Brutus to crush them. He knows exactly what he's doing on each line. With laser like precision, he asks, how do I want to make them feel? Our job as attorneys is no different. He wants, and he has an action. So he answers that question. It's not a rhetorical question, how do I want to make them feel? And then cogitates on it for another two days. No, he knows he's figured that out ahead of time, how he wants to make them feel and how does he want to make them feel? He wants to devastate them in order to arouse, ignite, or inflict them to action. If you've ever been a criminal defense attorney, chances are you've tried cases where the prosecutor's objective was identical to that of Anthony. On the inside, he's enraged and screaming, but on the outside he's logical.
35:43Few people would be able to stir up the passions of a crowd in this way. Antony is exceptionally intelligent in how he goes about it because he can do that. You can get clear about who he is. And that adds insight and a glimmer into his personality, which allows the crowd to connect to him. It always comes down to intention, with the key questions being what am I doing on each line? How do I want to make the audience or the jury feel? That is how precise we have to be with Our words. This, I'm afraid to say, is pick and shovel work. It's very tedious work, but I can tell you that when it is done, the presentation will be one that is unforgettable.
36:37I have videos that I played for you in the past and I'll try to pick some more out for part two of this presentation that will show you actors that work in this way. Yes, the time investment is enormous. However, the feeling that the audience gets from this type of precise preparation and this type of figuring out what emotional response you want the audience to have on virtually every line, the specificity that that creates will make your speech unforgettable. And that, my friends, is how it goes a long way towards winning your case. So again, you can have the most brilliant written out speech, but if you haven't done the work that needs to be done in order to prepare it for presentation, then you are losing out on a big piece. And that same beautifully written speech isn't going to have the impact that you want it to have because again, this is about oration.
37:58If it was only about how beautiful and eloquent your written words were, you could merely stand up and give each member of the jury a written copy of your speech and have them read it to themselves. But that's not how it works in a trial.
38:18You are the instrument that brings it to life. And that's why there are some Hamlets that will go into the history books as being incredible and of having moved heaven and earth while other hamlets, people can't stay past the first act because it is, it makes them feel like they need to take a bath. It's, you know, just heightened, somebody speaking heightened language in a way that they don't, they themselves don't know what they're saying. Now we go. Now we turn to the vitality of the breath. Yes, breath again, these are things that don't get any play. They don't get talked about in traditional training for trial attorneys, but that we get tons of training in.
39:15We do voice and breath work all the time. We break things down to their most basic ingredients. We spend time just learning how to control our breathing. And yes, when it comes to speaking heightened text and being able to get through a full line of verse, our breath capacity as actors has to be optimal because if it isn't, we are not going to be able to get through the thought in the, in a, in one breath. And if we have to start taking catch breaths in between, it's going to break things up and we're going to lose our audience. So what I see happening is that, and these are the problems that I have and I continue to have when I speak classical text first, it might be not filling up with enough air.
40:16So I would argue that we don't take in the full capacity that our lungs have for breathing. We simply fill up probably 50% if at most. And again, if you're speaking heightened text or if you're engaging in legal reasoning in a closing argument, in order for your thoughts not to disconnected and to flow seamlessly, you have to have the breath capacity to speak the entire thought on one breath. Now, that's not to say that you can't take catch breaths, but when you do, they need to happen at strategic points so that you're not breaking up thought and confusing and making it difficult for the jury to follow along. So some of the, some of the culprits for this is again not filling up with enough breath. The second culprit is filling up with breath. And then, and the way the voice works. And so I have to give a quick little lesson on the voice. We take breath in and when we are full with breath, our voice comes, comes out on the exhale. So the incoming breath comes in, the diaphragm drops. So it's actually counterintuitive.
41:42I don't have a picture of this, but if we plan some type of voice warm up, which I really want to do in an upcoming program, I'll have my voice instructor explain to you a little bit about the anatomy so that you can appreciate what's happening on an anatomy level. But the breath comes in, it fills the lungs, and as it does, the diaphragm actually drops. It doesn't go up. So it is counterintuitive. And that's because we don't have a lot of nerves in the diaphragm. And so it's difficult to clock what that parachute essentially or jellyfish is doing. But we bring the breath in and then we exhale it. And ironically, in daily life, when we're speaking and we get a thought in our mind subconsciously,
42:36our breath or our anatomical breathing system knows just the right amount of air to take in in order to support the thought. And so it's just so fascinating because we as actors struggle, struggle with this process so much about taking in breath and having enough to sustain the thought. But in everyday life, like I'm doing right now, my body just automatically knows how to take in enough breath in order to express the thought that is going on in my head even now as I Have Covid and I am still, you know, have a little bit of shortness of breath. My body is still filling with an enough breath to support the thoughts. Now what happens? And these are some of the very same things that happen to lawyers as well when they're doing their opening or closing. We hold the breath when we fill with it, and then we try to speak. And so you can see what's happening to my voice right now. I'm holding my breath and I'm trying to speak without exhaling.
43:43And so you see that now the voice is a little bit higher pitched and I'm not getting the same vocal resonance as I otherwise would if I spoke on the exhale. The second thing, that happens a lot, and this has a lot to do with anxiety and stage fright, which we all experience in high stake trials. We will take an incoming breath and then accept, exhale it fully before we speak the first word. So in the first example that I gave, we take in the breath and then we hold because we've got so much tension in our upper body. We hold and then we try to speak. And the other example, we take in the breath, we exhale before we speak the words. And now on an empty machine, we want to speak a full line of text. And you can imagine the pitfalls that come with that.
44:43So over time, we've learned to hold our breath, especially when we're anxious or frightened, which is not uncommon when it comes to public speaking. A lot of people talk about this, this feeling of fight, flight or freeze. And I have had my share of stage fright and I've talked a little bit about that in some of the programs. Completely normal. The good news is that when you acknowledge it, it tends to recede. And in acknowledging it, you can acknowledge that fear is energy. And when it is acknowledged and it is not fought, meaning you accept the fact that you're human and that your body is doing the thing that it knows how to do and that it's supposed to be doing. It is quote, unquote, protecting you. And it's gotten you to this point in life. So how beautiful of a thing it is.
45:38All we need to do, however, is to tell it that we can now channel that energy into a more productive, more productive avenue. And a lot of us know that, that it sometimes takes about a few minutes to drop in to our openings or closing, because those first few minutes are full of a lot of butterflies and a lot of anxiety. But after a couple of minutes, we usually are in it. And at that moment, you know, we are now free with our words. Some people, however, will have lingering and we'll have bursts of anxiety come out throughout. And there are ways of dealing with that, not the least of which is the confession of fear, which Jerry Spence encourages. And the theory behind the confession of fear is that when you acknowledge the fear and why you are having it in a public way, such that the jury knows that you know you're experiencing some fear and the reason behind it, because you care so much about your client and you are afraid that you might fall short of what, of the type of defense that he or she deserves in this most critical hour.
47:05Voicing that for some people helps them to drop right in. And it also helps jury to see the humanity in you and how caring of a person you are. And they can connect to that in a more visceral way than they can connect to, you know, a standard invocation that we as lawyers might use like, you know, you must do this or you must do that, or, you know, keeping it on a distant level of just legal jargon. When we really can delve into the humanity and what's going on in the case and how high stakes of a case it is, the jury then will begin to appreciate the very same. So everything comes back to the breath. When I mention speaking, I mean speaking on full support from an always open position that is fully forward in the mouth and without mumbling. Mumbling is a habit which does not release any power in a text. Most of us, I would say, think too much before we speak. The process of thinking too self consciously censors our connection to a spoken text. But words contain emotional and physical properties which lawyers can work with and expose.
48:25When speaking to the jury today, we tend to wring the meaning out of words them in a monotone way, like we are reading a grocery list. And I want to say this, and I want to be very clear, it is not our fault. It is the training which we've been through in law school. I would dare say that if any, if any, of us had gotten up in a contracts class and tried to make the facts of the case emotional by making an emotional appeal, we would be admonished by our contracts professor and probably be made an example of what not to do in the class. Why? Because it's very formal and we are being taught a very precise way of thinking, and that is to. To remove the feeling and the emotion from the words and to focus on just those facts that are essential in order to conduct our legal reasoning.
49:34So emotion has no place in that aspect of law school because we are being trained very clinically in the same way that a doctor would be to focus exclusively on those things that we need. The other parts, such as the emotion, are those parts of like an erector set. I'm dating myself now when I say erector set that you don't need in order to assemble. In order to assemble it. So yet what we need now in a courtroom or when we're doing a deposition is, is that very same. Are those very same ingredients that we were told not to bring. And so we cannot be faulted because this was our formal training in law school unless we have embarked or had a background in the theater arts.
50:34This is going to feel a little uncomfortable at first. Yet it is this emotional, physical and sensual cogn content in a text that I am trying to release alongside its thought Instead of controlling words and dominating them intellectually, which I think we do quite well. I would like to see the lawyer painted by the words as though he or she were a canvas gradually taking shape from outside stimuli. We're not looking for the speech to be grammatically correct and word perfect. As Jerry Spence said, when a person speaks from the heart, words come out mispronounced, sentences run on, thoughts get interrupted, the perfect word gets replaced by multiple inferior words. While this might make your 4th grade English teacher roll over in her grave, the fact remains that, that this version bears more hallmarks of trustworthiness and authenticity than a grammatically correct and perfectly recited speech. After all, we're humans, not robots.
51:47We are inherently flawed. This is why it is easier for an audience to relate to a character who falls woefully short of an ideal than it is for an audience to relate to A person who is squeaky clean, has all the answers, and claims to be the poster child of success. I don't know about you, but I have to be honest with you. There are very few social media influencers that I have that I revere. Why? Because so many of them are talking to us from this, from the ivory tower, and from a heightened level where they've made it and they've made their millions or what have you, and now they're going to teach us how to do it. I appreciate that they want to spread the wealth, if you will, but there's something that always leaves me a little feeling like, oh, a little like I need a shower after I listen to them. You know, there's just something that it just doesn't feel real that this 20 something person, you know, has made all this money, you know, Publishing self published books or you know, making self videos or you know, figuring out the algorithm for Facebook.
53:18I mean, you know, obviously I, you know, everyone is different, you know, and there are some that, you know, tend to, tend to be a little bit more honest and you know, speak from a more real place. But this, you know, these, this generation of, you know, self made millionaires that are, you know, that are, that are, you know, that are speaking things from the place of having killed just leaves a lot to be desired. So say for example, no longer mourn for me when I am dead. In saying this line, you should be able to experience the mournful qualities of the words. And so we would probably speak a line like this. No longer mourn for me when I am dead.
54:10And yet, you know, so that's one way of doing it, infusing it without any meaning. Another way of reciting this is to take your time and really experience what is going on here. We are talking about life and death. Every human being who has to confront life or death experiencing, you know, something that is above and beyond anything else. So we're not speaking, we don't want to speak a line like this as if we are in a Starbucks ordering a cappuccino. You know, we want to feel these words in a very visceral way. And the way I back myself into something like this is to slow down and not rush through a line and take anything for granted.
55:08A line like this, when you really let it seep in, will have more meaning. And you don't even have to put conscious attention on what words you might want to emphasize above others. It will automatically, a lot will take care of itself when you really understand the context and what you're saying. No longer mourn for me when I am dead. You know, so there we're making a little bit more progress towards what meaning the author might or the playwright might be getting at from those words. So on the most simplistic level, breath and voice work in the following way. I breathe in, I speak out in a more complicated way.
55:52The breath is linked to the length and quality of thought and feeling. These experiences hopefully will unlock that simple, natural breath. Every human has a different breath pattern which will change according to different circumstances. As you change, your breath changes. Our physical and emotional transformations are reflected in transformations of breath. If you had a startling experience and you're breathing and your breathing gets rapid, all of a sudden your voice and your tone and the words are going to start coming out a lot faster. I'm breathing at a very low or very sedentary level right now. So my words are coming out a lot slower, A lot more thought is involved, a lot more intention. But once we break the breath pattern and experience an emotional state, those words are going to come out a lot differently. And you can sense the difference between how my words were coming out before I increased the speed of them and then after.
56:59And you were probably able to get a sense in your own mind of some different feeling as a result. And the jury will experience similarly a similar different feeling. And so imagine if you can imbue your text with differences that are so nuanced that that will increase your storytelling and that will allow for more texture into the story. Freely wrought text will have these changes and rhythm shifts built into it. Different styles of text have varying lengths of thought and content, consequently will demand different lengths of breath. Today, most of us tend to speak in shorter thoughts with a fractured rhythm, using faster and shorter breaths.
57:50A lot of my work is about breaking and extending the short breath pattern of a lawyer in order to release the thought and emotion behind their text. The traditional view of the breath when it comes to verse speaking was that an actor ought to be able to speak. Speak eight lines on one breath. That's impossible. Impossible. And to expect something like that even out of an actor that from the Royal Shakespeare Company would be impossible. I don't think it's practical for many actors without appearing artificial. Most people aiming for eight lines contort themselves, squeezing the text out and not sounding real. So if you can do eight lines without squeezing or losing connection to the words, that's a fine feat. But if you cannot achieve this, don't despair. Stretch as far as you can without constriction. A lot of what we're talking about right now, you know, it's difficult to speak about without giving you an experiential experience and without throwing you into a voice class led by a trained and seasoned professional who will help you to develop more breath capacity and a more resonant voice. And that's where I want to take these programs, these future programs, because there's only so much I can do as far as lecturing goes.
59:14It's good to have the theory behind this, but it's a whole other thing, and it will take this to a whole other level in your work as a practicing attorney, if you can get some real work on your voice in a group setting. And so, again, that's what my goal is as we continue in this journey, in this series. I have reached time right now. There will be a Part two to this program. So if you do have any interest in continuing, please do sign up. If not, no worries. There are other some other programs that will, if they haven't been announced already, will be announced shortly through LexVid. Once again, thank you so much for joining. If you have any questions, always feel free to shoot me an email. I do try to respond as quickly as I can and I do appreciate the feedback that I've been getting because the feedback has lent itself to the creation of some of these new programs. So I'm forever grateful on what you would like to see in future workshops.
1:00:27And again, my plan, my overall plan, is to somehow get us into a group setting with the instructors that have profoundly impacted my life, not just as a performing artist, but as a person. I would really like to get them in the Zoom Room with all of you teaching some of the voice work that I steadfastly rely upon in my work as a trial attorney. So I hope to see you in a future program and thank you so much for joining. Take care.