53min · about 9,000 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's seminar. This is our third lecture in a series when we're talking about the attorney client relationship. We've gone through communication, we've gone through diligence, we've gone for, we've gone through forming that attorney client relationship in the first two in this series. And today we are going to talk about confidentiality and conflicts of interest because these are two of the biggest areas where attorneys tend to get in trouble for malpractice. And it all comes from just understanding, again, that attorney, attorney client relationship and how as attorneys, we have to interact with our clients and the duties of loyalty we have from them and the duties to be free of conflicts of interest that we have. And we just have to understand that dynamic. For those of you who don't know me, my name is Carrie Sheehan. I'm an assistant general counsel with Taft Law Firm in Indianapolis, Indiana. I'm also a professor of ethics. I teach at The Robert H. McKinney School of Law, and I teach professional responsibility. So I teach a lot of the subjects that we are talking about here today and throughout this series and throughout a lot of the videos that you may find of mine on LexFit as well. But let's get started here today because confidentiality and conflicts of interest are very big topics, and we could consume hours just talking about each of them individually, but we are going to try to all fit it in here in the next hour of our time. So confidentiality is
1:27the biggest hallmark of the attorney client relationship because anything a client tells us is protected. It's confidential. Now, this is also known as the attorney client privilege. Attorney client privilege includes those communications directly between the attorney and the client. Confidentiality is way broader than the attorney client privilege. It's part of it, but it's broader. Confidentiality not only includes those communications directly between the attorney and the client. So a little tiny circle. Confidentiality includes a big circle around that little circle. And it's everything that we learn, everything that we consume or that we get into evidence as part of the representation of a client. So if we talk to witnesses, if we take depositions, if the client gives us documents, if we go out and get witness statements or we have an investigator, that's all part of confidentiality.
2:26Attorney client privilege is that small subsection in the middle of confidentiality, which are just the communications between the attorney and the client without any outside third parties present. Now, that's the key to it. Now you will think, well, wait a second, wait a second. There's exceptions to that, and there is exceptions to that. I mean, lawyers love their exceptions. One of the exceptions is that you can still maintain the attorney client privilege, those communications structure between the attorney and the client. If the third party present is there to aid and assist in the representation. And their presence or their ability to aid and assist has to be necessary.
3:10Now, this is a kind of a high standard to meet just to have someone in the room with you when you're talking to your lawyer. If you're a client, just for emotional support is not a necessity that has been determined. A necessity is more like you cannot communicate with your client or excuse me, communicate with your attorney efficiently. Say you have an incapacity or you have something, you know that's not allowing you a fear or something not allowing you to communicate. Maybe you're a minor child. And the person, the third party there is necessary another type of necessary participant could be an investigator, could be the legal assistant of the attorney there to take notes. Those people are necessary to aid in the furtherance of the representation. If you don't meet that standard and you're not necessary to aid in the furtherance of the representation, then your presence can break that attorney client privilege and then break confidentiality with an inadvertent waiver. Now, that means that the opposing counsel, if they know that that third party was present and that the privilege and confidentiality is broken, even if inadvertently, they can request those communications or call people to testify regarding the substance of whatever communication was taking place between the attorney and the client.
4:34So if you don't protect that attorney client privilege or you don't protect that broader confidentiality and it's inadvertently waived, then opposing counsel can request that in discovery or call the witnesses to testify about what happens. Now, you can always claim that it's privileged or claim that third party was necessary. But again, you're going to have to meet that high standard that they're necessary for the furtherance of the representation. So we really want to keep those attorney client communications just between the attorney and the client without any outside third parties present to keep that secret.
5:11And then confidentiality, everything else that you learn in the course of the representation, we also have to keep and not give out to outside third parties. Once we give it out, that's considered a waiver. So we need to keep it within the bounds of the attorney client communications and that privilege and that confidentiality. Otherwise it can be discoverable. Now, there are other ways besides just inadvertent waivers in which we can break confidentiality. But first, let's look at Rule 1.6. 1.6 is our confidentiality rule. It says a lawyer shall not reveal client information unless the client gives informed consent or the disclosure is impliedly authorized.
5:57Now, let's break that apart. This is the other way that we can give out confidential information and not get in trouble. It can be inadvertent, like we talked about, or we have to go to the client and say, hey, I want to use this information and disclose it to a third party. Here's a document stating that. Here's the risk, here's the benefits. Please sign this and allow me to go talk about your confidential information. That's informed consent confirmed in writing with the client. The client. Remember, the client is the Boss under Rule 1.2, and the client holds the key to confidentiality. That means the client is the only person who can waive confidentiality.
6:42You, as the attorney, cannot pick and choose what you think should go out to the public or pick and choose what should be told to a third party or, you know, what is ever the hot topic at that cocktail party you're going to. You can only talk about client information and client matters if you have the client's informed consent confirmed in writing. Otherwise, you will break Rule 1.6 confidentiality. And it's called an inadvertent disclosure, meaning you didn't purposely do it, but you can still get in trouble for it. So we need to have that informed consent confirmed in writing. Now, the other way that we can talk about client confidence is if it's impliedly authorized under under the law, or the disclosure is impliedly authorized.
7:29This means things like if you go to court, obviously you have to say certain things to the judge to argue a motion or defend the client. And you can't always sit there and say, okay, I want to say this. Do I have your informed consent? Okay, great. And go for it. It's just impliedly authorized like it's in that course or furtherance of moving the client's case forward. Now, a lot of attorneys take this a little too broadly. This implied the authorized. It does not include making media statements. It does not include talking about anything that's on a public record or public docket. Impliedly authorized is just those situations where you're arguing something in court, drafting a motion, or you're in some type of situation like a deposition or something where you have to use client information and confidential information to further the representation. Now, let's go back to where I said it's not. That's not impliedly authorized. The first one was Talking to the media. We see all these lawyers out in the media and posting stuff on social media or giving press conferences about the client's case, their client's case, and they're talking about some details, some defenses, just things going on. And in the back of my mind, I'm always like, oh, my gosh, I hope they got the client's consent confirmed in writing. And normally the client's standing beside them. But there's a lot of times where attorneys just will give a statement about a case in a newspaper or article because a journalist calls
8:55them and asks them for a quote without first going back to the client, getting the client's consent to talk about the case, and then giving the statement if they can get that consent because the client holds the key to the consent. If the client doesn't give you permission to talk to the media, permission to make that quote in the article, then you cannot give it. And so we always have to remember, yes, we're flattered and want to see our name in print and be part of these articles, but we have to stop and think of our duties of confidence, confidentiality to our client, and that we cannot comment until we get their permission to do so.
9:32Now, the other thing, too, which is a misconception under Rule 1.6, is the fact that we cannot talk about publicly available information. So some attorneys think that if it's filed on a public docket or it's a public record that anyone can access, if they go to, you know, the certain websites and pull it down and get the information themselves, then they're free to talk about it without the client's consent. And that is a misconception. There is no exception under Rule 1.6B, which is our exceptions to confidentiality, where it states that our attorneys are allowed to freely talk about information regarding their client that is of public record. That's not an exception.
10:13The comments even say that's not an exception and not allowed. There's an ABA formal opinion saying that we cannot talk about publicly available information without the client's consent confirmed in writing. So even if the information is publicly available, filed on the public docket, or something else, we still cannot talk about it to third parties unless we have our client's consent or impliedly authorized by law or by what is happening. So by nature of this, you're not even supposed to disclose the name of your client, what you're doing for the client, what cases you're working on to third parties. And with the holidays coming up, or, you know, every year when they come around. This is a huge deal because when you go to cocktail parties or you meet up with the old law school friends or family, one of the first questions they always ask you is, what are you working on? That's the last thing you want to answer. If you get the question, what are you working on?
11:12You can say, well, I need my client's consent before I can answer that. Now, that's kind of the smart, eloquent remark to make. But again, that's what you need to do because we should not be talking about our clients. We should not be talking about what we're working on or what we do without our clients consent confirmed in writing. So we need to make sure we get that before we move forward. Or we can have breaches and violations of Rule 1.6. And we are going to talk about a case here today. And it's a case called in re Anonymous. And we'll get to it in a few slides where an attorney did just what I was describing. He took his clients or prospective clients private information, talked about it, like at a cocktail party or gathering with friends, and got sued for malpractice and lost. So we cannot do those things, even if it's public record, even if it's public knowledge, if it is our client, we cannot talk about it without the client's consent confirmed in writing. Now, this is just a slide to really show you that distinction.
12:13I was talking about between the attorney client privilege, or just, you know, the definition of it for your notes. The attorney client privilege are the communications directly between the attorney and the client for the purposes of obtaining or providing legal assistance. So anything that the client and you talk about regarding your representation, regarding getting that legal assistance is what is protected by the attorney client privilege. And so we need to really think about that because that is what's important. It says attorney client privilege representation. Small, very circle inside that big circle of confidentiality. The visual kind of helps you see those circles. I was talking about attorney client privilege, small confidentiality, huge. Everything else that touches and concerns the representation, always remember that even if you need to break it down to, you know, what is included in, you know, communications regarding the representation, it's where the client is seeking legal advice from a professional, you, the attorney, and the communications or the conversation you're having are made with that idea that they're going to remain like confidential.
13:29And the client expects that and you're giving legal advice on that particular situation. If those factors are met, then the communication is protected by attorney client privilege. And you've probably created that attorney client relationship, even if you didn't want to, because now we're giving legal advice, persons relying on it. We have an attorney client relationship, we have attorney client privilege. So we need to think about those things too. Attorney client privilege means it is protected under the big auspice of confidentiality, which means we can't disclose it to someone else. So when we get to the case of NRA Anonymous, we can see we're talking to friends or not having a formal engagement.
14:12We're thinking that those one off conversations where family members ask you, hey, you're a lawyer, I need legal advice on this. And then you go ahead and answer it can really come back to harm you. Because if you answer it, you've created the attorney client relationship. That communication is now protected by the attorney client privilege. And if you go tell it to your other co friends or friends, mutual friends or anyone else, you've breached confidentiality and can be sued even without a formal engagement letter. We've really got to stop and think when that attorney client privilege relationship attaches and how it works because otherwise it gets breached and it get breached a lot.
14:56So again, that relationship and when it starts, when it exists, like we talked about in the first seminar in this series, it's vitally important. We have to know if someone's asking for legal advice, you're giving that advice. Even if there's no formal engagement letter, even if in your mind you're just helping out a friend or a family member, you still have that attorney client relationship. Starting privilege attaches. Confidentiality attaches if you now disclose, sued for malpractice and potentially a disciplinary complaint. So we've really got to think about what we're saying and what we're doing in these different scenarios that can pop up all the time. Now, confidentiality also includes work product, which is a work product is a little different than obviously attorney client privilege. Those are the communications.
15:48Confidentiality is in that big red circle to this work product. Work products are the materials that a lawyer prepares in reasonable anticipation of litigation or of a transaction or in furtherance of that representation. So say I'm the lawyer, I'm taking notes, I'm preparing drafts, I'm sending out letters. Those are all my work product, all my drafts, all my notes, all my, you know, legal thoughts of, you know, how do we maneuver this? Like what is our strategy? That's all work product and that's all confidential. That's all in that big red circle. So those things can be protected too. But a lot of attorneys get Confused when they hear the different terms. They hear confidentiality, they hear attorney client privilege, they hear work product doctrine, and they think they're all separate from each other, but they're not. Attorney client privilege, work product doctrine, all go under the big umbrella.
16:42This is confidential information. All under Rule 1.6. It's just the different specifics of what's in that big umbrella. And that's what we have to start thinking about when you hear those different terms. Now with confidentiality, it attaches to our prospective clients. As I was saying, under Rule 1.18, those are those ones where we give the advice. We, it's about something, you know, they're asking for legal advice, we give them that legal advice. But we never sit down to do a formal relationship. Those are those prospective clients. So confidentiality attaches. Their attorney client communications attached, their privilege. It also goes under current clients, which is the rule 1.6. And then it goes to former clients, which is Rule 1.9, meaning confidentiality never stops.
17:34If the client no longer is a client, their communications, the information that gave us everything in that anticipation of litigation, the work product, our mental impressions, everything is still confidential. We cannot now say, okay, the client's gone, it's former client, we're going to go do a CNN report or we're going to go out there and tell it to the world or our friends. Confidentiality never ends. It doesn't end at the termination of the relationship. It doesn't end at the death of the client. It doesn't even end when you're on your deathbed. As lawyers, we have to take our clients confidences with us to the grave and beyond. And I know that sounds morbid, but we just have to do that because that is how sound it is and that is how solid it is. And there is actually a case where I call it the dead body case. Again, I know, morbid, but it's a case out of New York. And this case is an interesting case and a really good representation of how solid the attorney client privilege is. And the, the lawyers in this case, I'm trying to find the case right now is why I'm looking to the side. But the lawyers in this case were criminal defense lawyers. One was hand picked by the criminal defendant and the other one was, you know, appointed by the court in a roundabout way. And they had the client or the defendant was charged with murder.
18:59Now in the course of the representation, they were obviously talking to the client, talking about different things, you know, about their defense, about what they're doing and the client tells them, I've murdered other people. And he tells the attorneys where those other people's buried bodies are buried. Now, the other murders and the other bodies where they're buried had been in the news in this state. It was in New York for months. The families were looking for these victims. No one knew where they were. They were asking for any evidence. The lawyers confirmed that their client was being honest about this. Now, obviously, the client told him that kind of as a bargaining chip, probably for if he was going to get a plea agreement.
19:40But he told the attorneys they couldn't say anything. And the attorneys were bound by confidentiality because they learned this information and furtherance of their representation of the one charge he was charged with. He wasn't charged with these other murders because no one knew he committed them, just the one that they thought he committed a new one. And so the lawyers couldn't say anything. And they didn't say anything. They didn't use it really as a plea because the client wouldn't let him. Client never gave him permission to tell anyone. So they had to keep it confidential. Because if you look at Rule 1 6B, there's no exception to disclose where dead bodies are located.
20:17There's an exception to confidentiality for to stop the furtherance of a crime or, you know, violent act. So this is something where, you know, client sitting in your office, they say they're going to go kill someone. They have the weapon, they have the aggression, they go out the door. You have the discretion to say, wait a second, I need to tell someone. I got to stop this crime or this murder from happening. I got to stop this imminent bodily harm. The bodies are. The people are dead. There's no imminent bodily harm that's already passed. This is just the location of dead bodies. So that exception doesn't apply. Going down into 1 6B, other exceptions that don't apply is not going to hurt anyone's financial interest. It's not. You're not helping them commit a crime. You're not helping them cover it up. They've already done it.
21:03It's done. You haven't touched the grave sites. You haven't touched the scene. You haven't moved the evidence. You're not committing a crime, or they're not using you in furtherance of a crime. So that doesn't apply. You're not trying to defend yourself in a malpractice suit or a lawsuit from your client. Do you know they're claiming you did something wrong? That doesn't apply. You're not Doing anything where an exception applies to where you don't have to get your client's consent. So what do the lawyers do? They have to keep it secret. But what the case really came about and why it's studied in textbooks is because when the defendant took the stand, the defendant shared this information, or he shared in a statement that his attorneys, he told his attorneys where these bodies were buried, but he didn't give his attorneys permission to disclose the location of the bodies. So the families, the victims families, put pressure on those attorneys. They said, we want to know.
22:04We want to know where they are. They filed a lawsuit against the attorneys. Those attorneys were threatened by the public. They had to move their families out of state. They had to quit the practice of law because it got so bad for them. And they held fast on their duty of confidentiality. They never gave up where their client told them those bodies were buried. And that is huge. It went all the way to the Supreme Court highest authority, who vindicated the lawyer, saying, no, rule 1.6 is strict. They did what they were supposed to do professionally. That is how strict confidentiality is. Could you last through people hounding you, threatening you and your family, having to quit the practice of law even though you didn't do anything wrong, you're not being disciplined. You know, it's all in these appeals and litigations and different stuff. And can you hold steadfast on that Rule 1.6, confidentiality, just so you did not disclose where the bodies were buried or where that confidential information came from.
23:13So, again, that is a huge, huge thing. And if you do Google the buried bodies case, I can't find this citation. I was looking through my notes right beside on me right now. It is one to really study, and it is studied in law school textbooks. It's studied in multiple different facets across multiple jurisdictions, too, just to show how strict this confidentiality is. And this applies to our prospective clients, our former clients, and our current clients. And we need to keep that in mind. Now, again, just to reiterate some of those things, even if it's not, there's no exception for public information. It applies to social media, applies to giving interviews and statements.
23:56It never ends. Now, the one thing that you can do, because, I mean, I've given some examples on the seminars that I've given for lexfin and different things, we can give hypotheticals so we can talk about our clients and hypotheticals, so long as no one listening or taking in that information is going to be able to ascertain the identity of your client. Or the situation of your client. So if I gave a hypothetical where it was blatantly clear who my client was and what the situation was, you know, what their facts were, you know, all this confidential secret stuff, then that's not a hypothetical. If I give a hypothetical like this once I had a client who would call me every day, yell at me, hang up and fire me. You have no idea who that was.
24:44There's no really way to find out who that was. That's a hypothetical and it shows you can deal with uncivil clients. And you, you know, I use it as an example for incivility and that kind of stuff. But it's a hypothetical to where you can't ascertain the identity or situation or any confidential information on my client. And so we have to really remember that that confidentiality stays through the client relationship post client relationship post death, biggest thing ever. It never ever ends. And we have to know that identity of the client in order to know whose confidences we have to keep. That is a must do. So one of the other cases, this is a case too when since we are coming up more on the holiday season, this is a case where we had a prospective client relationship and it was one of those where a friend reached out to their friend who was an attorney, asked for some advice. The attorney gave that advice. No formal relationship was ever created, but they got some confidential information. So we have that perspective rule 1.18 scenario where we have that exchange of confidential information. So this is the case of Inray or excuse me, matter of anonymous. If you want the citation, it's 932-Northeast-2nd 671 Indiana 2010. So it is a real case. So just give you a little more brief overview of the facts here. This is the respondent represented an organization that employed ab. So we use the person's initials.
26:14Respondents became acquainted with AB through this connection. In December of 2007, AB, which is the prospective client, and her husband were involved in an altercation in which the police were called during which AB's husband asserted she threatened to harm him. In January 2008, AB phoned respondent, which is the attorney, and told her about her husband's allegation and that she and her husband had separated in a second phone call. A.B. ask respondent for a referral to a family law firm. So we have AB calling an attorney who they have a prior relationship because the attorney had represent the organization that AB worked for.
26:57And we have AB telling the attorney what had happened in the scenario asking for a referral kind of asking what she should do. Respondent gave AB the name of the attorney and the respondent's firm. Respondent then called this attorney to inform her of the referral and gave her AB's phone number. So he referred her to attorney in the firm. So he didn't have an existing formal relationship. He referred her to someone else, but had got confidential information because I had to take in that legal information to assess, and then referred her to someone else. The attorney called AB that same day and arranged a meeting the following day when AB retained the attorney.
27:36So the other attorney that was referred to AB told the attorney that in December 2007, Instant and directed her to follow divorce petition, respondent was aware that AB had retained the attorney and that had the divorce petition been requested to be drafted and filed, because again, they're the same firm. So he. So the. So the respondent, the attorney has access to that information. And if one person in your firm has the confidential information, that confidence is attached to you because clients of a law firm are treated as one. If my partners have a client, it's my client to you. I have to keep that confidentiality here.
28:14Respondents, Excuse me. A.B. and her husband, however, reconciled, and AB stopped the petition from being filed, told the attorney she didn't want to do it. Everything you know was dismissed, gone, over, done with. But now you think, okay, now what comes into play here is that the respondent, the attorney who AB was friends with or had known through the work and talked to, was talking to other mutual friends of theirs. So other people who knew AB and knew the attorney and told them that she was divorcing from her husband, she reconciled with her husband. She never went through with the petition.
28:50Her husband didn't know anything about it, and so he gave over that confidential information to their mutual friends, who then said something back to ab. And then AB obviously got mad because then her husband found out that she had gone to see a lawyer, and she sued the attorney for breach of confidentiality and for other malpractice things. The court found that it was a breach and that under the circumstances, AB was a prospective client, even though no formal petition was ever filed, even though she stopped it, even after she got the advice of the two attorneys in the same firm, and the information was subject to confidentiality and protection of the rules. So we had a breach of confidentiality just by having those talks at get togethers, having mutual friends, not thinking of when that attorney client relationship starts. We need to really watch out for those things.
29:49This is another case kind of similar fact patterns. This is a case out of Texas Appellate court. So if you're in Texas, you may want to look this one up. This is 822-Southwest-2261 Texas, Texas Appellate Court 19.
30:06In this case, we have Perez, and it arises out of a school bus accident that occurred on September 21, 1989 in Texas. Reuben Perez was employed at Valley Coca Cola Bottling as a truck driver. On the morning of the accident that occurred, Perez attempted to stop his truck at a stop sign along his route, but the truck's brakes failed to stop and collided with the school bus. The loaded school bus knocked into a pond and 21 children died. Perez suffered injuries from the collision and was taken to a local hospital to be treated. The day after the accident, the attorneys at Kirk and Kerrigan hired. Were hired to represent Valley Coca Cola Bottling company and visited Perez in the hospital, who was an employee of Valley Bottling company.
30:57Perez claims that the lawyers told him that they were his lawyers and that they were going to keep everything confidential. So he gave them a statement. He thought his employer had hired him an attorney. After they talked to him, instead of, you know, helping him out and keeping those confidences, Kirk and Kerrigan made arrangements for another criminal defense attorney to represent Perez and not them represent him. But then Kirk and Kerrigan cooperated and gave over Perez's statement to the district attorney's office for prosecution of Perez. So we have a law firm going into the hospital room of someone who'd just been injured in an accident, claiming to be his attorneys because they were hired by his employer, then saying, okay, well, we're not going to do it. We're going to refer you to someone else. But they already had his statement because he thought Perez thought they were his attorneys. They had stated they were his attorneys, and then they took his statement, which was given in confidence, that attorney client privilege, that perspective relationship, even if they didn't continue, and then gave it over to the district attorney for his use to prosecute Perez.
32:10Blatant breach of confidentiality. They defended, saying that it wasn't an attorney client relationship and that they had never stated those things. Obviously, there's testimony and stuff to kind of defect that they had a lawsuit settlement was $462,619 against the former employer and against. There was another lawsuit against the Kirk and Kerrigan as well. So again, violations of confidentiality all over the place. How do we solve this? If we want to give over something that the client told us or talk about it, we get their Informed consent, that's what the rule tells us. We get the informed consent confirmed in writing. And so we have to make sure we make those communications to get it. But in order to do that, we have to know, going back to that session one of this series, who is the client? If you can't answer that question, you're probably going to violate the rules at some point. We need to know who our client is. We need to know, is it a prospective, current, former client?
33:13If it's any of those confidentiality attaches. Attorney client privilege can attach, which is that small subsection of confidentiality if you have any work product that's also confidential under that big red circle. But we have to first know that attorney client relationship, who is the client, that is who we owe the duties of confidentiality to. If we can't answer that question, like I said, we're probably going to violate the rules. So we have to keep thinking about that. Once we know who that client is, we seek that informed consent. Some consents are not consentable, meaning some things we can't get consent for. We obviously don't want to be plaintiff and defendant in the same litigation. That's not really consentable because we can't, you know, properly defend or properly prosecute or use, you know, something like that in the same type. Also too, the something that may not be consensible would be a scenario where you are on both sides of a contract. One person is trying to get the best deal over here, another person is trying to get a better deal over here. And if you're on both sides of that, that may not be consentable either. It might be if you can get the informed consent confirmed in writing, but it's really hard.
34:28That could not be a non consentable situation. Another one which can be consensible but very risky to do is that, well, excuse me, husband, wife scenario, different things that we have to look at in those things as well. But we've got to watch, you know, our confidence is what we can do and when we can disclose stuff. Because obviously if you represent both sides of the V, this side's not going to tell this side and this side is not going to want you to tell this side. Well, how can you properly do that? And then that gets into conflicts of interest too. Any consent though, whether it's in consent to give over confidential information, when we get to conflicts here in a second resolve conflicts of interest, has to be informed, must be written or highly recommended to be written. Both of those are your responsibility as the attorney to make sure, you get them. And then you have to advise the client too that they have the right to seek independent outside counsel before they sign any informed consent.
35:27Meaning you can't just put a document in front of them and say, hey, sign this. Trust me, I'm your lawyer, but this benefits me. No, you have to give them the opportunity to seek independent counsel. Do most clients seek outside independent counsel? No, they do not. But you have to give them that opportunity to not to be able to seek independent outside counsel. And so just remember that and what you do and make sure you do that for your informed consent confirmed in writing. One of the other cases we're going to look at here is in Ray Presley. In Ray Presley is a Vermont case and this citation is 6 to 8 A.2d 927 Vermont 1993.
36:18So you can write that down if you were looking at it. So in Ray Presley, 628 A.2d 927 Vermont 1993. The facts of this case include in 1989, respondent A member of the Vermont Bar since 1975, representing complainant in connection with relief from abuse and divorce proceedings. Complainant informed respondent her husband had a history of alcoholism, battering and abuse. After a hearing at which she was represented by respondent, complainant was granted a temporary order requiring her husband to refrain from abusing her and by stipulation the party's temporary custody of the couple's two children, which, excuse me, with supervised visitation by the father. After a month later, respondent filed a divorce complaint on his client's behalf. The parties negotiated an agreement under which complainant had would retain temporary custody of the children and her husband would be allowed unsupervised visitation. Complainant on respondents advice, reluctantly agreed to the provision.
37:29At that time she told the respondent that her husband had her, that she had been harassed by her husband, the alcoholism and different things like that. Of course, respondent advised her that there were no legal grounds to get out of, you know, the situation that they were in at this time. And so with these different things, the respondent took this information, used it out without getting the client's consent, he told different things and revealed this information out to third parties. And so it was without getting the informed consent. If he would have just got the informed consent or use the statements in that way to help her with her consent, then he wouldn't have violated those confidences.
38:12So we have to really protect, get our informed consent where we need to, but definitely take a look at that if that's something you're in a situation with where you have to get informed consent. Some other things too that could make us be able to give over clients confidence is court orders. But again, we can claim privilege, we can claim confidentiality, but sometimes we could be ordered by a subpoena or by the court to give our client confidences. And so if it's a situation where, you know, it's the Supreme Court telling us in the state or wherever we have to do it, then obviously we have to in some circumstances. But you can still hold fast to your confidentiality or go to your client and get that consent. Just say, hey, we have this subpoena, we're being ordered to do this. Are you okay with me releasing this?
39:01If they say yes and you're good to go? If they say no, then you need to fight to maintain that confidential confidentiality and that privilege. It is our duty to maintain it. It is a hard duty. We always just want to obey what the court tells us or obey the subpoenas that come in and kind of freak out. But we cannot just open our books and our client files willy nilly to anything that comes in. We have to maintain confidentiality. Sometimes this means that you could be held in contempt, especially if you lose, or you could be held in contempt for, you know, not fulfilling it. And you just got to continue to fight it and fight it. Kind of like those lawyers in that dead body case. They knew they were right.
39:42They knew they would eventually, hopefully be vindicated. And they just kept saying, no, I'm not telling, no, this is confidential. No, we're not doing this. And kept holding steadfast. And it went all the way up for them to get that vindication. We're not going to go through this case in detail, but it's just another one I wanted to mention. If you really wanted to learn more about the confidentiality, more about how steadfast it is, especially when it comes to court orders and content. And then, you know, the duties we owe to the client, the duties we owe candor to the court and finding that balance. This case of Dean versus Dean would be a great one to read. The citation for it is 607 S. Second 494 Florida Appellate Court, 1992. Again that is 607 S. Second 494 Florida Appellate Court 1992. That is just one where it really talks about that, you know, holding contempt confidence in that fine line between them, contempt, confidentiality, court orders, just really going through those different details to really take a look at that too.
40:53If you are in House at a company or corporation, you do have to hold the client's confidences. Your client is organization. If you do have to report them, you need to report up and out, meaning try to resolve stuff internally by going to the highest authority if they still don't correct what's going on or if there's something bad going on that's going to harm the corporation. If you report up and nothing is done to fix it and it's still going to harm the corporation, then you can report out to third parties and still be protected. Meaning not give over client confidences or not have a breach of your ethics, but you try to go in the house first, all the way to the top and then out. That's that up John standard, those up John warnings at the bottom of the screen.
41:38The page reference is just for me because I have a book that has these cases in it. But again up and out because if you represent an organization, you still have to keep the confidences of that organization. So but, and to do that you report all the way up as far as you can go if they've done something wrong or someone in the company has done something wrong that's harming the company and then you go out to authorities if you cannot resolve it at that point. Just something to really consider other concerns. We do have concerns sometimes with diminished capacity. Diminished capacity can come in different forms. It can be a minor child, it can be in the instance of say someone with Alzheimer's or dementia or some other mentally or on the spectrum type of diagnosis.
42:30But diminished capacity is something that can be a problem. And one of the things with this is we still have to treat them as a normal attorney client relationship. We still have to treat it as something where, you know, we are going to try to communicate with them like we talked about last seminar or we're going to still try to keep that bond together. Now the scenario that's referenced here, I know again the page numbers are from my reference, not yours. The problem is now that I'm selling my business, an 85 year old patriarch tells Fox, I want you to make arrangements to give half of the proceeds to dear Margaret. I don't know what I'd do without her.
43:10Margaret is patriarch's 30 year old companion. What may or must Fox do? So Fox is a lawyer. This 85 year old patriarch comes to the attorney and says I I want you to give half of my business or to my companion, 85, selling business. No true signs of diminished capacity. But is age enough to get there? If it is Enough to get there. Then what are your duties? Can you go to the companion or go tell people what the 85 year old wants you to do? Well, that's giving over confidences. Can you. Should you just do it blindly and follow the direction of the client? We kind of talked about this last time. That could be a violation too, because if it's a diminished capacity, then they may not be in the right mind to make their own decisions. But then you think for yourself. Is that my call to make? Well, part of that comes with our duties of communication and warming that attorney client relationship and following the wishes. So here, maybe we need to get a guardian ad litem. Maybe we need to get an evaluation to see if she's competent or. And then if she's not, then seek the guardian ad litem and then follow the client's wishes.
44:27But we can't just automatically assume all the time that someone with an age, an older age, like 85 or higher is diminished capacity. They may not be. Some of the sharpest people I know are not. Are older and don't have diminished capacity or any of those on the spectrum or Alzheimer's or dementia. So we still have to treat them like our client. But you do have the right to test out their competency. You have to keep their competences though. But you can test their competency to see if they have it. But you still. All those duties we've talked about through the series, you still owe them that in those different realms.
45:04Confidentiality exceptions. We've already kind of briefly talked about these, but I did want to give you a slide that shows them. To prevent reasonably certain deaths, substantially bodily harm to prevent a crime from occurring where they're using our services. We cannot allow people to use our services in furtherance of a crime, to permit to prevent or mitigate, rectify substantial injury or secure compliance with the rules or establish a defense. So again, very limited exceptions. Dead bodies case fits nowhere in here. It does not. We have to look at the exceptions and see if they apply. If they don't apply, what do we need? Inform consent confirmed in writing from the client. Otherwise we violate potentially attorney client privilege, probably confidentiality, but we have to make sure we have those.
45:56Another case here, just talking about the different exceptions, talking about how it comes into play with confidentiality is going to be Spalding versus Zimmerman. This was an interesting case because in this case it was. What had happened was there was a plaintiff who had been involved in an accident and the attorneys, the defense attorney had a full evaluation done. Plaintiff's Attorney didn't have that same evaluation done. But then they came to a mutual settlement prior to formal discovery. And the problem was, when the defense attorney got back the report from the expert of the evaluation, it showed that the plaintiff had an aneurysm. Now, when they went to settle, the settlement was only $6,500.
46:45The defense attorney never disclosed that they knew the plaintiff had an aneurysm. And the plaintiff's attorney didn't get the same evaluation or they hadn't done discovery yet. So plaintiff's attorney and plaintiff did not know about the aneurysm that the plaintiff had. Defense attorney did. Defense attorney did not disclose it. They disclosed it to their client, but not to the plaintiff. And even in the settlement negotiations, the settlement agreement said that it is in furtherance or encompasses all known and unknown injury or all known injuries, you know, including different things. His injuries at the time of the settlement were described as severe crushing of the chest with multiple rib fractures, severe cerebral concussion, patial hemorrhages of the brain, bilateral fractures of the clavicles, but nothing in there about an aneurysm. And the settlement was only for 6,500.
47:41Later on, plaintiff did get an evaluation himself when he was continuing to having problems, and they found the aneurysm, went back and said, you know, hey, this wasn't, you know, as part of my settlement. And that's when it was figured out that the defense knew about it all along, lied at the settlement conference saying that no, this includes everything we. No, well, it didn't. It didn't include the aneurysms, and the description of the injuries didn't include the aneurysm. So it wasn't everything that the defense attorney knew. So we have cander issues too. But at this case also talked about just does the defense attorney do they have fallen or one of the exceptions to be able to disclose this to the other side without their client's consent. And the court said, yeah, they should have disclosed it, which is kind of in my mind maybe a borderline decision, because where they went with was to prevent substantial bodily harm in that. But again, now we have defense doing plaintiff shot for them. So this case can cut both ways. If you want to read it more in depth, I know we're winding down here. It's 116 Northwest Second 704, Minnesota, 1962. Is that citation.
48:52Make sure you take a look at it. Some other cases to look at here. We are not going to go through them in detail. Hawkins versus King. This is regarding mental health Concerns, violence, different things like that when it comes to confidentiality and if we can release it without the client's consent. So kind of that imminent bodily harm standard. 602 Pacific 2nd 6 excuse me. 602 Pacific 2nd 361 Washington Appellate Court 1979 so our things as lawyers, sometimes we are faced with decisions like the 85 year old. The different things we find out plaintiff has an aneurysm. Our ethics and morals may tell us disclose, disclose, disclose. But sometimes our confidentiality is telling us no, we can't.
49:39So finding that balance and really is hard. And sometimes as a lawyer, our duties of confidentiality can really test our morals and ethics. And that is a really hard thing to understand. But half of our job as a lawyer is telling our clients to stop doing stuff stupid and follow our ethics, follow what we know. And if we can do that, then we've won half the battle. But definitely take a look at these exceptions. I know I'm kind of going a little faster because we're winding down and for confidentiality now where it comes into play more with conflicts of interest. Conflicts of interest and confidentiality. Conflicts of interest. Obviously we can't represent one client against another. Otherwise we're going to break those confidence or is going to do those things. We're not going to go in depth on that. That'll be for some seminars in October and November, so come back for those.
50:32But they do play hand in hand. So you, if you know confidentiality, then you know why you have a conflict of interest. Because we can't disclose confidence of one client to another client and we can't use them against each other. And if that's going to be the case, then we have a conflict of interest. So that's kind of how they play in together, but kind of just going back here. Sorry, I digressed for a minute. These exceptions too. We can't let the client commit fraud or use our services and fraud. So we must disclose in that scenario too. That's one of those exceptions to confidentiality. We can't turn a blind eye to fraud. We're there to prevent it, not help or assist our client in it. We don't want to be sitting in jail with our client.
51:11We want to be helping the client get out of jail, but just kind of knowing that we can't turn a blind eye either. We can't say don't tell me kind of like that I don't want to know type of thing. We have to reasonably believe or you know, have some intuition then investigate a Little further to really stop fraud and those things from happening. And we do have a duty to disclose certain things. Our duty of candor to the court trumps confidentiality. So if our client lies to the court and we know they lied, we have to try to have them correct it. If they won't correct it, we have to correct it. And if they're using our services and furtherance in that line, then we should fire them as a client.
51:49So we need to make sure our duties of candor are upheld in all these scenarios. And then those last exceptions of Rule 1.6B, obviously if we get sued, we can use our client information to defend ourselves. We can use it to establish a defense, comply with a court order. But again, we can assert those privileges and confidentiality if we want. Some other cases here too. Purcell versus District Attorney. Don't think I have a citation with that one right in front of me. But again, you can just google it and it will come up, I promise it will. Just the name of it. United States versus Chen. Same thing.
52:25And they are just talking about these duties and how we can have not have to get client consent. So there's exceptions to Rule 1.6B. But we do need to think about our services. And if we take all these, these theories we had the first one about the training client relationship, second about communication and clients, the boss and now this about predominantly confidentiality, a little bit of conflicts in here. But again we'll have more predominant ones of conflicts coming up in October, November. We have to really get think about it. We can't be used as an instrumentality to commit crime or fraud. We have to be business savvy.
53:01Remember the client's the boss though and kind of have that balance, communicate, watch for those red flags and just know not every client is the best client and we can fire our clients. With that we have come to the end of the seminar. Thank you for everyone attending today and look for more upcoming series potentially on conflicts of interest, more going in depth and other ethical topics. Thank you.