1h 1min · about 8,400 wordsDownload Transcript
0:01Hello everybody. Welcome Back to part two of Demystifying the FBAR. I'm Mike DeBliss. If you don't know me, I've been doing some of these webinars for LexFid now for, oh my gosh, it's going on about a year and we are slightly transitioning into the world of tax. This is actually a practice area of mine as well. And the way I got into it was actually by accident. I was in last term of law school and I did an externship for a white collar criminal defense firm here in New Jersey. As luck would have it, when I joined the firm, it was just when they were getting ready to start the trial of a white collar crime defendant that they were representing in a large money laundering case.
0:59And it was in the Federal District Court of Newark. I came on board when there was a lot of pretrial motion practice going on. So it was about a few weeks before the start of jury selection. And I was given the task of researching many of the issues that came up around the collateral offenses that the senior partners were drafting a motion to dismiss on. And there were counts of tax evasion, failure to file a tax return, etc. Etc. And nobody really wanted to touch that with a ten foot pole. And so being low on the totem pole, I was delegated that task. I got very interested in the tax code and in particular in tax crimes during my research. And I kind of, I put that in the back of my head and I said, I'd love to come back to that later on at some point to study tax in depth and perhaps marry that with my interest in criminal defense. And I did just that. It took me about four or five years after law school, but I circled back and I matriculated in an LLM program and I earned my LLM in tax while working at the public defender's office. It was no easy feat, but like they say, when you put your head down and you're determined to do something, you'll accomplish it. It took a little longer than normal because I was going to school at nights. But slowly but surely I did get my degree. And when I got out and I decided to go into private practice to join my dad's law firm, it was my intention to expand the practice into tax crimes. But I didn't realize at the time that my very first call
2:54would be from an accountant who needed assistance with a client who was out of compliance with their FBAR filing requirements. To be honest with you, I didn't know what that MNEMONIC stood for back then, despite two and a half years of intense tax studies, I had to research it, and I realized that I was in the area of what was called US International tax compliance, and that there were a number of US Expats that lived abroad and perhaps lived in the United States, that resided still in the United states and were U.S. nationals or Green card holders that had not. That were not in compliance with what's called a foreign bank account report. It's essentially a report that's required by the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network if you are a US Person and if you have ownership or a possessory interest in a foreign bank account with a high watermark balance at any point during the year that exceeds or eclipses $10,000.
4:09So basically, that's the threshold. $10,000 or more will trigger what's called an FBAR filing requirement. And if that's the case, then you must disclose that foreign bank account on an F bar form. Most of the time, the interest generated by the offshore account is negligible. And so when an account is left off of a 1040, it usually does not impact the gross income and the corresponding tax liability. So a lot of clients would look at this as, you know, if. If they didn't file an fbar, no harm, no foul. It wasn't like the corresponding tax liability, if it had been disclosed, would have been so substantial that it would have increased their overall tax burden for that tax year. However, as you can imagine, the IRS viewed that very differently. So in so much as the fact that this is a Financial Crimes Enforcement Network form, this fbar, it's enforced by the good old irs, and the IRS enforces it with abandon. Why? Because the penalties for failing to comply with F bars are astronomical.
5:29And they are not just limited to civil penalties. They expand into the world of criminal tax as well. So, yes, you can be criminally charged for failing to file an FBAR if it is willful. So we will talk a little bit about willfulness in the context of transitioning out of the civil penalty structure of FBARs and into the criminal structure of FBARs. So that's a little overview. How did the FBAR come to be? Well, it is a creature of the Bank Secrecy Act. The Bank Secrecy act has been on the book since the mid to late 70s. I believe it was passed by Congress around that time period. And the FBAR filing requirement was one of those parts of the Bank Secrecy Act. It had not been enforced, though, with the level of abandon that it's been enforced with today. Until post 2001 for reasons that you might imagine. So let's bring these slides, got spruced up, by the way, if they don't look familiar to the ones that you saw in part one. I was doing this for an accounting organization a couple weeks ago and they were kind enough to spruce them up a little bit and bring them out of my very limited graphic and technological abilities over PowerPoint.
7:05We talked about this in part one. There's just too much information for me to have to go back and cover it again. So we're going to pick up where we ended last time. But yes, I do want to talk a little bit about why of all times, why in all of history the FBAR started to be enforced with the abandon that it did and in the wake of 2001 terrorist attacks. So the FBAR is a tool used by the government to identify persons who may be using foreign financial accounts to break US law. In the aftermath of 911 terrorist attacks, the government was faced with the harsh reality that the financing for most of these attacks came from terrorist organizations using our very own banking system.
7:59And of course, the government wanted to clamp down on the use of our banking system and our financial systems to finance terrorist activities. And so they began to look for the low hanging fruit, what tools were already existing and in place that they could start to enforce to, to push back on this, on the use of our banking system by terrorist organizations to fund these activities. And lo and behold, they came upon the fbar. And seeing the FBAR as an information, as a wealth or treasure trove of information that can be learned about individuals who have foreign bank accounts, and recognizing that if the FBAR had been enforced more strenuously pre 2001, that they could have uncovered some of this terrorist financing well in advance of 9 11, the government turned to the FBAR as one of its chief enforcement tools to clamp down on terrorist financing.
9:17And so basically, the information contained in FBARs can be used to identify or trace funds used for illegal purposes or to identify unreported income maintained or generated abroad. It's a wide net. And so not only is it an information gathering tool for illicit purposes, but also for those individuals like illicit on the scale of terrorism, it's also, you know, designed and its breadth is vast enough to, and to ensnare, if you will, individuals like the ones I've described at the very beginning who have offshore bank accounts and have not declared them based on perhaps the fact that they didn't even know about the FBAR since it was such a little known information reporting form. And because the corresponding interest income generated by the accounts was negligible and would not have really increased the overall tax liability. However, the IRS though, saw this as an opportunity to replenish the coffers, if you will, of the treasury in the aftermath of 2001 with the financial crisis that it created because the civil tax penalty scheme around the F bar was very lucrative. The fact was very simply that despite the fact that an offshore bank account, the interest generated by that account might have been so negligible that it would not have increased the taxpayers corresponding tax liability that much. The civil penalties for failing to file the FBAR were so substantial that the government was going to, it was going to be a win win for them to start enforcing it. Because even though the interest
11:10might have amounted to, I don't know, $501,000 on these bank accounts, the amount that they could recoup on civil FBAR penalties was far too, how can I say, was far too,
11:26was far too luring and attractive to the government to turn a blind eye to FBAR enforcement even for those who weren't doing it for nefarious and terrorist activities, but because they, you know, they had these offshore bank accounts that perhaps they didn't even know about the FBAR about. So the government saw it as a win win. It would help to combat terrorist financing being funneled into our financial system and at the same time it would help them to replenish the treasury for, you know, in the aftermath of 911 by ensnaring those US expats that hadn't disclosed their foreign bank accounts even though the interest income generated was negligible.
12:23So again, it's not a creature of the tax code, it's a creature of the Bank Secrecy Act. The IRS breathed new life into the FBAR as a tax enforcement and revenue raising tool. The IRS has administered and enforced the FBAR since 2003, just two years after 9 11. This was the rule itself. As we pointed out in part one of this presentation, every term is a legal term of art. So resist the temptation to impose your understanding of what these terms mean onto these terms. Just like with the stat, just like with a statute in constitutional law, when you are reading it, you need to have your Webster's Dictionary handy or electronically the app handy, because these terms have very precise meanings and that's why I've highlighted them by putting them in italics for you. So, so we can analyze each one, define it, and then give you an example.
13:28A US Person must file an fbar if that person has a financial interest in or signature authority over any financial account outside of the U.S. and the aggregate maximum value of the account exceeds 10,000 in U.S. currency at any time during the calendar year. Anybody who meets that definition, who is again a US Person, which has its own very specific definition, must file an F bar for that tax year. These are polling questions that they put in. We don't have to worry about them. These are the elements. I basically reduced them to a grocery list for you. You can see them. There's six primary U.S.
14:17person. We talked about this already. Just a quick refresher. It's a citizen or resident of the U.S. it's an entity created or organized in the U.S. or under the laws of the U.S. an entity includes, but is not limited to corporations, partnerships and LLCs. So don't be lulled into believing that person is a live human being. Only it's a live human being, but it also is as broad as to include entities. It could be a trust formed under the laws of the US it could be an estate formed under the laws of the U.S. these were some examples that I gave you of a U.S. person. So U.S. citizen, of course is going to be a U.S. person. But how about U.S. resident? To determine if the filer is a resident of the US you would apply the residency test in 7701B. They are very ambiguous.
15:13Even the accountants that I lecture to about this have trouble wrapping their head around 7701B. I don't really go there unless I have to go there. And it's a perplexing question that a new client has brought to me. But this is a threshold question determining whether the person is a US Person, because if not, then the rule doesn't apply and there's no FBAR filing requirement. In example one, we have Matt. He's a citizen of Argentina. He, he's lived in the US Every day for the last three years. Because Matt is considered a resident by application of the rules under 7701, he must file an FBAR. Essentially. Not to get into the nitty gritty of 7701, but there's a look back period of three years. And basically if the individual has resided, meaning lived in the United States a certain number or stayed in the United States over a certain number of days during a three year period, they would automatically trigger residency for purposes of being a US Person. So that's what we're talking about here.
16:23There are tax treaties between the US and between foreign countries. And Most countries that are part of the United nations we have treaties with. We have tax treaties with. So for example, we have Kyle, who's a permanent resident of the United States. He's a citizen of the uk Under a tax treaty between the US and the UK Kyle is a tax resident of the UK and elects to be taxed as a resident of the UK Notwithstanding, he must still file an fbar. Tax treaties with the US do not affect FBAR filing obligations. They do offset the tax liability that the individual is responsible for. Because the United States stands alone, I think there might be one other country in the world, but we stand alone as being the country that taxes its citizens and residents on their worldwide income, regardless of where it is derived.
17:27We talked about that in part one. So, for example, you can be a US Citizen and own a company in Brazil, spend no time in the United States, and your Brazilian company, 100% of the clientele of that Brazilian company could all be from Latin America, with not one, not one person on your customer list being a US Person, citizen or resident. And yet the US Will tax your Brazilian company on the profits. You will have to report the profits from the Argentina company on your 1040. And it's a firestorm. This has been raging, this debate since time immemorial. Essentially what gave the US the chutzpah, if you will, to tax its citizens and residents on their worldwide income? It's a very little case. It's a very small case called Cook vs Tate that was decided back in, I want to say, 1940. Essentially, the Supreme Court gave the US government the power to tax its citizens and residents on their worldwide income tax. And of course, the government is enforcing that with abandon. What we do have available, though tax treaties, mitigate the responsibility that taxpayers would have to both taxing authorities. Because think about it. In the example I gave you, the person who's doing business in Argentina, the Argentina government is going to tax the profits on that Argentina company.
19:18And it's within their jurisdiction to do so because the company is based in Argentina. And if the government, for example, doesn't have a tax treaty with the Argentina government to blunt the impact of double taxation, theoretically the individual. Hold on one second. I'm sorry, I've got a dog that's barking crazy right now.
19:54Sorry everybody. I have a puppy and she gets a little crazy. So every so often. So just getting back to this. In an effort to mitigate or blunt the impact of double taxation, if there is no treaty in place between US and Argentina, and I do believe there is a treaty in place. So that would supersede anything else. But to the extent that the US doesn't have a treaty with that foreign government, what would happen is that the government, the US Government would still attempt to blunt the harshness of double taxation by giving the taxpayer a credit. So if they are in say a 20% tax bracket in the United States, but they're only in a 10% tax bracket in Argentina, the US government would give the taxpayer a credit in the amount of 10%, meaning in the amount of what they pay to the Argentina taxing authority and the difference of between 20 and 10%. 10% that is, would go, would be owed and paid to the U.S. treasury. That essentially would become the taxpayer's responsibility to the US treasury for his Argentina profits on the Argentina business.
21:18That's how the US Would blunt the impact of double taxation. If there were no tax treaty in place. If there is a tax treaty in place, the tax treaty would govern the way that the tax liability would be apportioned.
21:38Yeah. So what does a financial account include? This is probably a good question for us.
21:45First option is bank accounts such as savings accounts, checking accounts and time deposits. Second would be security accounts such as brokerage accounts and security derivatives or other financial instrument account. I'm sorry, this is actually the list of what a financial account includes. So again, we go from the very basic and general and then we get specific. So very basic in general are the run of the mill bank accounts that you have with a bank, a foreign bank. And these include just like we have here in the United States with TD bank, with Wells Fargo. We, you know, we have, we have regular checking accounts, we have savings accounts, we have time deposits. Those are included in the definition of financial account. But then we get broader.
22:33We also talk about securities accounts like brokerage accounts, securities derivatives, other financial instruments accounts. Third, we have commodity futures or options. And fourth, we have insurance policies with a cash value.
22:48We also have mutual funds or similar pooled funds. We have, finally, any other accounts maintained in a foreign financial institution or with a person performing the services of a financial institution. This is an issue that we talked about last time. Gold or currency cash notes maintained in a foreign financial institution. There is no, how can I say, there is no black and white black letter rule, if you will, that the IRS has passed regarding gold or currency stored in a vault, if you will, in a foreign country. However, we do have guidance in the form of a case. So the way things work in the tax world, and it's a little counterintuitive Unless you've done some work, you've dabbled a little bit in tax.
23:44When we are looking for guidance in the tax world, we will look to a number of secondary sources. Those include the treasury regulations. Those tend to have higher precedential value than the other items I'm going to list for you, but yeah, other sources I'm going to list for you. But we would start with treasury regulations. We would then look at what are called the Internal Revenue. Internal Revenue Code. So actually in the hierarchy you're going to have Internal Revenue Code, which is at the top. You'll have treasury regulations which are up at the top with the Internal Revenue Code. And then we have what are called revenue rulings, which are administered by the IRS commissioner. Those have high value as well. We will also look at the instructions.
24:43So every form, including the FBAR has corresponding instructions. Keep in mind that because it's a FinCEN form and not an IRS form, the instructions are going to be published by FinCEN. But they're very thorough and they will answer a lot of questions that you might get with a first time filer of an fbar. At the same time, you know, it doesn't, they don't always answer all the questions. So, so you might default into the Internal Revenue. There are what are called Internal Revenue Manual
25:21information, like they call them IRMs and you can find them on the IRS website. They are guidance, if you will, on certain aspects of the filing and what triggers filing requirements that may not have been covered in an instruction bulletin, if you will, that corresponds to that form. So those are the sources. And then we turn to case law, of course, because there are, you know, tax cases do make their way into federal court. More often than not, however, they make their way into the US Tax Court, which is a very specific court that is designed to hear tax related issues. And the difference between tax court and federal court is that you don't have to post the amount that's in dispute as what we might call collateral in order to have your case heard. The other benefit of Tax Court is that the judges in tax Court have a very solid background in tax. They've got their LLMs and they might even at some point in their life have had pursued accounting and so have an accounting background. They might have even been accountants or worked for the government in the IRS before they went to law school.
26:41So everybody comes from different backgrounds as the judges, but they all have a very heavy background in tax, unlike federal court judges who don't. However, in federal court you do get a jury trial Even on civil matters. And you don't get that in tax court the judge is a trier of fact. So nonetheless, there are rulings that come out of tax court that can be precedent as well. And if they're published. And then of course you have circuit courts that people will go to if they're not satisfied at the lower courts and there are circuit court rulings. And here we don't have any specific guidance, any black and white guidance on whether gold or currency cash notes stored in a foreign financial institution outside of US Soil is reportable. So we've been issued some guidance by an opinion called US Versus Haam. And basically they have us apply what's called the duck test.
27:44They call it the duck test. The more it looks like a brick and mortar and bank client relationship, that is the relationship between the client and the and the gold storage company, the more it will be reportable, the more it will look like a traditional bank client relationship. And thus the more it looks like it will need to be reported the currency and cash notes or gold on an fbar. So contrary to popular belief, not all foreign assets owned by U.S. taxpayers must be reported. According to FinCEN, a financial account does not include IRA owners and beneficiaries, participants in and beneficiaries of tax qualified retirement plans.
28:32It doesn't however, mean that if the individual has an ownership interest in these, that there is no reporting. It just means that these investments vehicles are not reported on an fbar. But I can tell you right now that the second one, like retirement plans, would fall in another category for being reported on a separate international reporting form. And that reporting form is actually called a pfec. We call it a passive foreign investment company. So even though these, the list of these would not trigger an FBAR filing requirement, it doesn't mean that they would not require did not trigger another international reporting form requirement. So this is why you got to really know not just the FBAR but all the international reporting forms.
29:28Because you don't want the client to leave your office thinking, oh, that's great, I don't have to file an FBAR because I have this tax qualified retirement plan and I'm safe. No. If they don't file a PFIC for their retirement, for a mutual fund or for a retirement plan, then they will face very large civil penalties just as if they had a bank account that they didn't report on an FBAR. Then we have consolidated FBARs. This is where a US person that is an entity and is named in a consolidated F bar filed by a greater than 50% owner is not required to file a separate FBAR. There are some basic relationships that would trigger a consolidated fbar, which we're going to talk about shortly. Trust beneficiaries.
30:25A trust beneficiary with a direct or indirect financial interest in greater than 50% of the trust assets or income is not required to report the trust's foreign financial accounts on an fbar if the trust trustee of the trust or agent of the trust meets two conditions. First, they are a US Person, and second, they file an FBAR disclosing the trust's foreign financial accounts. How about signature authority? There are individuals who have signature authority over accounts, but they don't have a financial interest in or a possessory interest in the financial account itself. Those individuals are not required to report the account in certain situations. So we don't have a catch all blanket rule that excludes individuals with signature authority over financial accounts from having to disclose it. It's basically
31:21on a circumstance by circumstance situation, and we'll look at some of those situations. The ninth Circuit held that a taxpayer's accounts with two foreign based online poker sites were not bank accounts that a taxpayer had to report on an fbar. This is the Hamm case. In that case, John Hamm gambled online through Internet accounts and pokerstars.com and party poker.com and used an account@firepay.com, an online financial organization that received, held and paid funds. I should have italicized received, held and paid funds because essentially that's the duck test that the courts have laid out for the government to apply in determining whether a relationship analogous to a bank, a traditional brick and mortar bank relationship, triggers an fbar.
32:15However, we're not dealing with gold and cash notes right now. We're dealing with Internet accounts. But there is a very strong connection between the two. And that's why the duck test that the courts applied in this circuit court holding is applied when determining whether gold stored in a foreign country, in a vault or in a bank itself triggers an FBAR filing requirement. That's yet another reason why I cite this case. So at some point in 2006 and 2007, so just keep in mind received, held and paid. When you go to a bank and you open up an account, isn't that what the brick and mortar bank is doing for you? Of course we bank online these days, but you have to show up in person to open up the account, show proof of, you know, that you are who you hold yourself out to be, and of course you have to transfer the funds into the account.
33:16So the relationship of a bank and to a client is that of someone who receives the money, holds it and pays funds on behalf of its customer. So that's what we're looking for when we look at non bank relationships to determine whether how close they come to receiving, holding and paying funds on behalf of the customer. To the extent that they are doing exactly that, that they're receiving, holding and paying funds over, chances are a court is going to view them as a bank for all intents and purposes. And therefore the funds that have been parked and held by these, these businesses would have to be disclosed on an fbar, assuming of course that they meet all the other requirements. At some points in 06 and 07, the aggregate amount of funds in John's Firepay, Poker Stars and Party Poker accounts exceeded 10,000 in US currency. It went over the threshold. After conducting an fbar exam of hom for 06 and 07, the IRS assigned assessed penalties against him for failing to file FBARs for his interest in his fire pay Poker Stars and party poker accounts for 06 and a penalty for failing to file an FBAR for the Poker stars account for 07. Now one thing you should know about is that the word assessed is a term of art.
34:53Assessed doesn't mean. See, there's a difference here. So we want to be very, very careful to distinguish the term assessed between as opposed to the term asserted. There is a big, big, big difference. When the IRS has conducted an examination and they've determined that there is a difference between what the taxpayer has reported as their gross income on their return versus what in the IRS's opinion is the actual amount of tax due and owing, that difference is the amount that the IRS is asserting the taxpayer owes to them. When the IRS asserts makes an assertion, the taxpayer is afforded a number of due process rights.
35:44Just as in the case of a situation when there is a due process challenge for a constitutional law issue, the person is able to challenge or contest it. At this stage, when there is an assertion of penalties by the irs, the taxpayer has the right to challenge the underlying deficiency. That's what we call this. The deficiency is very simply the difference between what the taxpayer self declared on their 1040 versus what the IRS revenue agent determined their tax liability to be after conducting an examination, that's known as the deficiency. When the IRS makes an assertion that taxpayer reserves the right to challenge or dispute the underlying tax deficiency by a filing a protest to IRS appeals which is the mediation Department of the irs.
36:48Or, and, or because they could, the taxpayer could actually have this matter mediated by an irs, an IRS appeals officer, that's what they call them, or bypass IRS appeals altogether for fear that the IRS appeals officer is going to be biased towards, towards the revenue agent, which in many ways they are, and go right to Tax Court. In doing so, they would file what is called a petition in US Tax Court. And again, the petition, the notice of deficiency,
37:26is the ticket to getting into Tax Court. So essentially the taxpayer would have to wait for a deficiency notice from the IRS before they could file the petition in U.S. tax Court. But all of that to say, when an assertion is made, the taxpayer has the absolute right to challenge the underlying tax deficiency. But when an assessment is made, it's too late. The train has left the station. The train for the taxpayer to have challenged the underlying deficiency has left the station. Now we are on to the last and final stage, and that is collection due process. So at the assessment level, the amount of tax due and owing is a liability against the taxpayer. And really all it comes down to now is whether the IRS has honored all of the collection due process requirements that they must honor in order for the amount, in order for the judge to order the taxpayer to pay the amount, or in order for the IRS to get to use liens, levies and other collection action. But I want to make it very clear that once an assessment has been made, it is too late for the taxpayer to challenge the underlying tax deficiency.
38:51Hamm failed to pay the tax penalties and the IRS filed suit against him in federal court. The IRS claimed that FirePay, PokerStars, and Party Poker were all financial institutions because they functioned as commercial banks. The district court agreed with the IRS reasoning that Hom opened up the accounts with all three entities, controlled access to the accounts, deposited money into the accounts, withdrew or transferred money from the accounts to other entities at will, and could carry a balance on the accounts. So for all intents and purposes, this relationship was analogous to that of a traditional brick and mortar bank client relationship.
39:32The court also found that because all three entities were licensed and regulated in foreign countries, they were foreign financial institutions. That's usually the easiest element to satisfy. As a result, the court held that Ham's online accounts with them were reportable. And that's a citation you can go to to learn more about the case. Hamm wasn't happy. And so what did he do? Well, he appealed the district court's decision by going to the Ninth Circuit. As you can imagine, this was probably not A decision that he made in a bubble. He obviously sat down with his attorneys and had them look at 9th 9th Circuit case law precedent to determine how it was likely, how the 9th Circuit was likely to review the district Court's holding. Because Hamm had a lot at stake here. Having lost at the District Court level, he now owed the IRS a substantial amount of money. Because, like I said, these civil FBAR penalties are nothing to shake a stick at. They are very, very high penalties and oftentimes can leave the taxpayer with nothing more than the shirt on their back after the taxpayer is done paying them. So he made a very strategic decision here to keep his defence team intact and to pay them to undertake an appeal to the Ninth Circuit. So he must have had held out some hope and been given some reassurance by his attorneys that the 9th Circuit was apt to look at this case differently than the District Court, the Northern District Court of California did. The Ninth Circuit, what did they do? Well, the Ninth Circuit affirmed
41:31the District court's decision with respect to fire pay because Fire pay, in their opinion, qualified as a foreign financial institution. However, the Ninth Circuit reversed the Federal Court's decision with respect to Poker stars and party Poker accounts, reasoning that they did not fall within the definition of a bank securities or other financial account. So the 9th Circuit split the baby. The court reasoned that Ham's Firepay account fell within the definition of financial institutions institution for purposes of FBAR filing requirements because Firepay was a money transmitter. Under 5312R, the court viewed Firepay as an intermediary between Hum's Wells Fargo account and the online poker sites. Humm could carry a balance.
42:22Here's the reasoning and here are those key terms that are coming up again in the court's reasoning. Hamm could carry a balance in his Firepay account. He could transfer his Firepay funds to either his Wells Fargo account or his online poker accounts. Firepay also charged fees to transfer funds. So Firepay acted as a licensed sender of money or any other person who engages as a business in the transmission of funds and therefore qualified as a financial institution. The court held that Firepay was a foreign financial institution because it was located in and regulated by the uk. In stark contrast, the court held that Hom's Poker stars and Party Poker accounts were not reportable because they did not fall within the definition of a bank securities or other financial account. The IRS argued that the two entities were functioning as banks because neither the statute nor the regulations defined banking. The Court used that term's ordinary and common meaning. The court looked to the Webster Dictionary, which defined a bank as an establishment for the custody, loan, exchange or issue of money, for the extension of credit, and for facilitating the transmission of funds. Since there was no evidence to suggest that party poker and poker stars were established for any of these purposes, the court held that they were not banks and Hum's accounts with them were not reportable bank accounts. And again, this is still a gray area, but I will tell you that from experience, what you would do in a situation where a client comes in to
43:57consult with you and perhaps request an opinion letter on whether their gold stored in a vault in a foreign bank is reportable, you would of course begin by looking at the agreement that is in place between the client and the vault company, the storage company. And to the extent that the relationship mirrors that of a traditional bank, where the bank is essentially holding, maintaining and issuing or transmitting funds based on instructions from the client, it's going to appear more and more like a traditional brick and mortar client relationship. And thus the account would have to be disclosed on an fbar. I can tell you that there have been situations where when the gold, so when the individual purchases the gold, sometimes the gold retail agent is, is also the storage agent, and sometimes the storage company,
45:17gold ownership company that sold the gold to the person. Sometimes what they'll do is they will lease out space in a foreign bank account to store the gold. And the reason they do that is for obvious reasons, a bank has already a tremendous amount of security in place with respect to safes and security and things like that. And so it's more financially feasible for the gold company to lease out space, vault space in an existing bank. However, that will usually tip the scales in favor of the gold being like cash that is deposited into a bank account for the basic reason that it's stored in a bank that's leased by the gold company. So to the extent that the gold is again is stored in a bank, in a traditional brick and mortar bank on foreign soil that's leased by the gold storage company, it's going to look more and more as if this gold is like cash that's been deposited into a brick and mortar bank. However, it gets really gray when the private vault company is leasing space out of like a warehouse that they've had like converted into a fortress, if you will. That is, you know, that's got all the safety precautions and vaults and things like that. But as you can imagine, that cost the vault, the private vault company, a Lot of money to deck out a warehouse like that to be like a bank for all intents and purposes. But that would, would make it even a grayer area. And that's when you're really scrutinizing that vault, vault storage client relationship by looking at the actual written agreement that's in place and seeing whether
47:38it looks more and more like a traditional brick and mortar client relationship. When is a financial account a foreign financial account? Very simply, when it's located outside of the U.S. the U.S. includes all 50 states and D.C. all U.S. territories and possessions.
47:57Continuing, what does it mean for the taxpayer to have a financial interest in a financial account? Well, a US Person has a financial interest in the following situations when the US person is the owner of record or holder of legal title, regardless of whether the account is maintained for the benefit of the US person or for the benefit of another person, including non US Persons. So in another instance, the owner of record or holder of legal title is a person acting as an agent, nominee, attorney, or a person acting on behalf of the US Person with respect to the account. In order to really grasp this, some hypotheticals are necessary.
48:38John's a US Citizen. His brother Paul maintains bank accounts in Mexico, a foreign country, on John's behalf. Now, we don't know Paul's residency status here. That's been left out. But we know that John, we have a clue here that John is the owner of these bank accounts because it says in the second sentence that Paul is maintaining them on John's behalf. So what I can glean from those two sentences is that John is directing Paul on when and where to send and transfer money from his accounts to. The accounts are held in Paul's name, but Paul only accesses the accounts pursuant to John's instructions. So John is very much like the puppeteer, you remember, like Pinocchio. You have like the, you know, the puppet and then you have the strings and you have the puppeteer who controls, you know, the puppet from, you know, up top and from, you know, the, I don't know, the gadget that they hold. John is the puppeteer, the puppet is Paul.
50:00And Paul doesn't do anything until. Unless or until John moves him to do something. So the equivalent of that here is John calling Paul up and saying, hey Paul, please make a transfer to this utility company to pay this bill on my behalf. Paul only reacts according to John's instructions. He's not going to arbitrarily go to the bank or do a deposit or withdrawal unless he has been instructed to do so. By John. He won't be doing it by his own volition. Does John have a financial interest in the Mexican bank accounts for FBAR reporting purposes? Yes, because he is the owner. If Paul is a US Citizen or resident, he would also have an FBAR reporting requirement with respect to the accounts. And that's because of this rule. A person acting as an agent, nominee, attorney, or person acting on behalf of the US Person with respect to the account has a financial interest in the foreign account. If of course, that person is a US Citizen or resident. So that's the threshold question. Is Paul a US Citizen or resident? Is he a US Person?
51:19Second scenario where we're triggering a financial interest in a financial account. The owner of record or holder of legal title is a corporation in which a U.S. person owns, directly or indirectly, greater than 50% of the total value of stock or greater than 50% of the voting power of all shares of stock. This is interesting. This was always something that was a very vague concept for me to understand until I finally did something that the professor was advocating for US students to do in corporation and partnership tax. You need to map it out, you need to draw things out. Because these issues, these hypotheticals can get very, very complicated very, very fast.
52:09I liken some of the hypotheticals that are going to follow to secure transactions. There's a lot of crossover and similarities in the sense that in order to understand whether something was prospective or retrospective and when you know, and the look back periods that were in place in secure transactions, I'd have to write things down and diagram them in like pictures so that I would put things down on a continuum and like a spectrum of light, if you will. This is going to be no different. This first example, we can probably get by with just visualizing it in our head. But the second one's going to require a visual aid.
52:56A Minnesota corporation. Minnesota is like a neon sign blinking to me. Us. Us person. Us person. Us person. A Minnesota corporation owns 100% of a Spanish company. So far there is no FBAR filing requirement because we haven't discussed or gotten into anything beyond the fact that the Minnesota Corporation owns 100% of a Spanish company. However, if you're one step ahead of me, you're probably already suspecting that that Minnesota corporation or that that Spanish company is going to have some ownership, some type of ownership interest in a foreign bank, because otherwise how the heck is it going to be able to do business and function as a function as a business if it doesn't have a foreign, doesn't have A financial interest in a foreign bank account.
53:58So in the second sentence, we get more information. The Spanish company maintains several foreign bank accounts. So right away, foreign is blinking out at me as a neon sign. The question becomes, this is. Basically, the client is going to come to you. The client is the Minnesota Corporation. Maybe it's their CEO. It depends, of course, on whether, you know, it is a closely held corporation with one owner or whether there are, you know, several owners. But nonetheless, at least one person is going to be walking into your office representing the Minnesota Corporation with this question. You know, Mr. Attorney or Ms. Attorney, must my corporation. Must I, on behalf of the corporation, file an FBAR? Your answer is 100%.
54:55Yes. Why? Well, the Minnesota corporation is a U.S. person because as we defined a U.S. person at the top, a U.S. person is not limited to a human being. A U.S. person is broad enough to include entities such as corporations and LLCs. The Minnesota Corporation, as an incorporated corporation in the state of Minnesota, meets that definition of a U.S. person. And we know that it owns 100% of a Spanish company, and that that Spanish company, in turn maintain several foreign bank accounts. So the Minnesota Corporation has a direct ownership in the Spanish company of greater than 50%. And the Spanish company basically has legal title of several foreign financial accounts. So the Minnesota Corporation, directly, indirectly, I'm sorry, has an interest in foreign bank accounts by virtue of the fact that it owns greater than 50% of the total value of stock of the Spanish company. Now, assume that Jack, a US person, owns 75% of the Minnesota Corporation in that previous example. So keep in mind, in that last example, we had the Minnesota Corporation at the top of our. What do you call these diagrams? Oh, gosh,
56:34it's okay. So basically, we have the Minnesota Corporation. Let's define that, or let's draw it as a square. And in the first example, it owned 100%. So I would draw a vertical line from that square that represents the Minnesota Corporation into the Spanish company, which might be a circle. Right? And the Spanish company has ownership in foreign bank accounts. That's how my diagram would look in example 1. In this example, we're going up one level. So instead of the square, Minnesota Corporation being at the top and the Spanish company being directly below, we're now going to insert Jack in the position where the Minnesota Corporation previously was. And so we're dropping the Minnesota Corporation, that square down one bit, and Jack might be a triangle so that we delineate or distinguish between all three entities. Jack being one, Minnesota being two, Spanish company being three.
57:44So Jack is a U.S. person. And the line would be drawn vertically down to the Minnesota Corporation. I would put 75% in the margin, recognizing that he has a 75% ownership interest in the Minnesota Corporation. The Minnesota Corporation now is going to have that vertical line going down to the Spanish company. And the Spanish company, I think, was a circle that we drew it as before. In the side, in the margin, I'm going to write 100%, because that's the ownership interest that the Minnesota Corporation has in the Spanish company. And then we are going to put in parentheses by the Spanish company in that circle that the Spanish company has several foreign bank accounts. And so the issue becomes one of whether Jack has to file an fbar.
58:40And we can look at this visually and say, of course he must. Why must Jack file an FBAR? Because he has greater than 50% of the total value of the stock. It's an indirect relationship between Jack and the foreign company that owns the bank accounts. Right. Because there's an intermediary. Now, the intermediary is the Minnesota Corporation. So it's not direct that Jack owns foreign bank accounts as if Jack inherited them from a relative in Spain or something like that. It's indirectly that Jack has this interest in the Spanish bank accounts. And again, the Minnesota Corporation is the intermediary. And through that Minnesota Corporation, Jack owns the Spanish.
59:31Has a possessory interest in the Spanish bank accounts. But the issue, the trigger, is that he owns greater than 50% of the stock in the Minnesota Corporation. And so that basically, that explains why he would have to file an fbar. Oh, we're over time already. So, yeah, it gets very tedious at times, but the more you use visual aids and diagrams, the easier it is to conceptualize what's going on. And, you know, I can remember doing this for some of my classes in law school, and it was a good practice as well. I'm visual. I'm a visually oriented learner. So seeing it like that on paper is so useful for me because when I see it enough on paper, I begin to see it in my head with clarity that I would have never had if I didn't take the time to draw it out the first few times.
1:00:33So thank you so much for joining me today. Look forward to seeing you in a couple weeks when we come back on this series. And I think a few new ones around tax. Take care. And again, stay safe.