Sharon R.NJ
Very informative and current.
1h 6min · about 10,700 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, everyone. My name is Joe korsmeyer. As you went well know, I am a practicing lawyer in the state of Florida. I'm actually in Palm Harbor, which is in the west on the west middle part of the state. I am I primarily well not primarily represent lawyers who have difficulties with the Florida Bar. I also represent individuals who wish to become admitted to add to practice in the state of Florida. I also represent every buddy that need wants to be licensed in the state of Florida when they have a license issue or trying to get a license. And I give ethics advice to many law firms and lawyers around the country, actually, mostly in Florida. But I do do multi jurisdictional ethics advice for lawyers, law firms that wanted to become multi jurisdictional law firms in the state of Florida. And finally, I am hired to provide expert opinions in matters involving lawyer ethics, such as legal malpractice, motions to disqualify and things of that nature. So I've been doing this for a while I worked for the Florida Bar from 1990 to 98, as a bar prosecutor, and then I moved to private practice before that I was a criminal prosecutor for almost four years from 86 to 90. And then I became a was with a firm for a while then became a sole practitioner. I've been doing that since. So let's get get started. This webinar is going to discuss and I'll be talking about ethical issues related to technology, and specifically to lawyers and also to paralegals, because you know, and also non lawyers who work for lawyers, because those issues are important to them as
1:42well. So if we have non lawyers listening, I'll be giving information that should be helpful to use well as well, that we'll be talking about, or I'll be talking about lawyer, technology competence, right? Actually technology competence, the rules related to competence and how they have changed somewhat, and also how the risks have increased with regard to technology. And the fact that we are living in a very highly technical technical age, including the recent remote practice situation with COVID, which is, as I speak, increasing around the country, again, toggle, I'm going to talk about zoom, which is a platform, as you all well know, there are a few others around but Zoom is was the one that got the most attention. And I'll be talking about zoom and other other ways to get on the internet and have remote communications. Also Alexa, smart smart devices are it's important for lawyers and those involved in the legal profession to know about those also disclaimers with regard to technology that may be put in a fee agreement to protect the lawyer. Also e portal filing, which is a now a not only a common thing, but but I believe it's essentially all the only thing with regard to filing around the country, there may be some areas or states that maybe don't have E filing, I would be very surprised if they do in Florida. We've had remote e filing for a long time. The federal courts have had it for probably 30 years. I don't know how long it's been but they've had it for much longer than most states. How about this, we'll talk about
3:30remote online access decline in foreign files, which is very important because it involves technology. Also, electronic file storage in cloud computing is important and a topic we'll talk about outsourcing and protection of client confidentiality digital storage devices, which are pretty interesting. And I'll talk more about that social media emails and reply all which is actually a an ethics slash, practical consideration. And also providing unsolicited, or receiving unsolicited information through a website from individuals who may send that information. So we're gonna talk about those things. So let's get started. The first topic is technology competence. I'm going to move through these slides so you can review the slide as I speak. There's a comment that's that was added to the model rules of professional conduct which are promulgated by the American Bar Association and are put out there for the states to evaluate and potentially use not all use them not all in many states, including Florida modify them some in some some rules have been modified substantially.
4:48And the model rules have been out there since the 70s 80s. And California in 2018, was the last state to act right actually implement a version of the ABA model rules, believe it or not in 2018, California joined the rest of the 49 states and district Columbia to modify their rules as a version of ABA model rules. However, theirs are substantially different from the actual model rules. With that in mind, the model rules are revised by the ADEA. As conditions warrant, there have been substantive some substantial changes to the rules throughout the years. Most recently, model rule 1.1, which is a competence rule.
5:38Added to that rule, dealers should keep up with changes in the law and its practices during the benefits and risks associated with relevant technology, engage in continuing, continuing stay in education and comply with all CLE requirements related to technology. It requires learners to understand the model rule to understand the benefits and risks associated with relevant technology. However, there is no definition of what that is, or in it's somewhat of a moving target. And the question is, where do lawyers go to obtain hands on knowledge technology? You know, for instance, in mobile devices, computers, social media platforms and dozens of apps and software? Well, lawyers obviously, are not IT people we lawyers are. And same with non lawyer, non lawyers who work for lawyers, unless the person is tired, specifically for it purposes, they're not going to be familiar or we're not going to be familiar with those nuances. You know, what's the best practice or their best practices for mobile devices, computers, social media platforms? However, there is there are resources out there, you know, we have the ubiquitous Google and other research engines. The bar in Florida has guide has a frequently resources I should say in their, on their website. It's called they have a section called legal fuel, which provides information also answers questions related to technology. However, it's the lawyers responsibility. And the lawyer we held responsibility if there's a problem with the use of technology, and if for instance, the information is obtained improperly
7:23confidential information, so lawyers must be very careful to ensure compliance with technology, new best practices for technology. Lawyers can depend on third party software and also technology vendors. However, I caution lawyers and anyone who's dealing with this issue that many times these third parties and the platforms aren't specifically designed for lawyers, and even if they are, they may not be specifically designed for the lawyer in a specific state. And they aren't designed specifically many times with to comply with the relevant bar rules. So it's important for the lawyer to dig a little deeper than or at least have someone dig deeper to get to report on this to determine whether the technology is appropriate. And whether it will protect client and primarily client confidentiality is what we're talking about here. But also, your hacking and losing documents and having documents held hostage, you know, by a hacker is a horrible thing. And it's happened and it'll continue to happen. As we move forward in the 21st century and further on. The lawyer is required to supervise any third party vendor to make sure that the the relevant rules are complied with. I've said this for many years with regard to advertising lawyers, are responsible for advertisements, even though the third party vendor who's going to produce those advertisements may be really good at creating them. The lawyers are ultimately responsible to comply with Florida. In this case, in my case, my in my state, the Florida Bar rules,
9:00but also in your state, whatever rules apply. It's very important to understand the lawyers to understand that number one lawyers are responsible to comply with whatever the best practices are for to protect client confidentiality and protect documents. But that can be outsourced with the proper supervision. All right, what about zoom? So I'm on zoom as I speak, in this that's how we're recording here. Zoom has some it's very, a very good platform. And so are the other ones. There's a mic I use Microsoft Teams sometimes and there's some there are certainly others. All of them have their their benefits and their and their downsides. Use zoom and other platforms there can be problems such as hacking of the there was a hearing in Tampa in near where I live, where I practice, where a A person was being arraigned for a hacking charge criminal hacking charge and someone hacked that hearing, and did some bad stuff.
10:09So that happened in I believe that hearing was held on Zoom. So a couple of points. One is be very careful, if you're going to an audit times we're on hearings, they're being, you know, if they're a hearing before the court and the courts, you know, making or sending this zoom link, not us. But if we're preparing and sending zoom length link, we need to be very careful. I believe there should always be if it's if it's a hearing or some other. For instance, a current client Zoom meeting, there should be a passcode on the invitation so that someone can't just randomly obtain the link and use it improperly to listen in that way, the the lawyer in this case, or the person running the meeting can ensure that access is limited to those that have that are permitted to know what's going on. There should be a waiting room created and zoom allows a waiting room and I teach a class at a local college St. Pete college, I teach a paralegal at this class, and I teach it on Zoom and I have a waiting room and I wait to it, let the individuals in confirm that they are who they are. That way you can limit the access to the only the appropriate the appropriate attendees. What if it's a large group of attendees? Well, that's that's a problem, that can be a problem. But generally, that's not going to be a confidential client, Attorney type of a situation. So it's just a matter of vetting the individuals if they if they're allowed in and they turn out to not maybe there could be a requirement that that that those individuals identify themselves,
11:43but it's actually not, that's not perfect, as far as having the waiting room as far as far as if you have a giant group, but the smaller groups can be can be bedded. The meeting should be locked after it begins so that no one can can obtain access to its or access to, to the meeting itself, limit this screen sharing to one person at a time or to the host. And that's generally what's gonna happen with the Zoom call anyways, the screen sharing will won't be it'll have to be authorized by the host for anyone else to use it, but the host can can use it automatically. And then also, my my recommendation and many others is to remove an authorized participants if they do get involved in the in the meeting. So that's important to know. All right, so entering of Zoom meeting, always be on mute. And I would recommend that you're always on the video, it would be hidden at the beginning and open it up after you get on to ensure you're in the right meeting. And all for all the reasons that you can think of as to why that should be done. That virtual backgrounds are good. As you can see, I'm in my office, I have my bookshelves behind me in my door and another desk. So virtual backgrounds are fine.
12:55They're actually good because they they then limit the limit the you know, the the access to comp, what could be confidential information. Also, that, as I said, the screen sharing, it's important to be careful about that. Also, it's important to know whether you're being recorded because recording if a person and here's what I'll say, I would always assume, I always assume I should say that I'm being recorded, because recording is certainly something that is, you know, that is if I am being recorded, I'm I'm never saying anything that I shouldn't be saying but, but if I shouldn't be recorded that I need, I'll ask the stop. And you can always tell on the on the corner of the screen, it'll say whether you're being being recorded that the left hand top part of the screen and zoom will show whether you're being recorded. So that's important to know, as well. So that's a that's a brief, you know, obviously I can tend to speak a longer period of time as far as technology and the Zoom slash, you know, those types of platforms. But that's, that's in the period of time that we have now. That's the information I've wanted to provide to you about Alexa and other other devices mobile home, the typical use in home devices, smart devices, they are a security concern. They can record they can be hacked and people can listen to the Alexa. Now I don't know I don't agree with the you know, the conspiracy theorists who say that we're being recorded by Alexa and data as being you know, a really, but it's always better to be safe and
14:39as far as any hacking is concerned if someone's hacking so as far as Alexa is concerned if we're if we're working from home remotely, that Alexa should not be on in my humble opinion ever. When if we're doing if we're dealing with Attorney, work, discussions, telephone conversations, that kind of thing of working at the office and we have an Alexa it's the same thing or or A device such as that it's the same thing. We need to be aware of our surroundings and the fact that that could happen. So confidential communications must be kept confidential. That's one of the highest ethical duties of a lawyer, probably second only to don't steal trust other people's money and clients money.
15:20So my recommendation is turn the turn the device off until it needs to be used or should be has to be used. That's fine. You know, maybe that's not practical. But if that's not being done, then the discussions need to be limited to nonconfidential. If the lawyers working from home or if the devices is in the office, there is a structured instructions on how to set up a delete by voice, which you can look look up on the web. On those, those devices. You can ask Alexa, you know, to answer questions related to that, I don't know how effective that is. But it's, it's certainly something that I've seen recommended. No, there should be no recordings, but if there are they should be deleted, I would say unplugged the device, don't just turn it off on plug in, if you don't want to hear people hear it. It's the same issues are created with cell phones, smartphones, computers and iPad microphones. They can be hacked, you know, and people can listen to our discussion. So it's pretty much the same issue. Although we can control Alexa a little bit more, you know, we could turn off our cell phone, we can turn off our computer. So those are ways to handle that as well. So it's important for all of us to note that we have always be aware or cognizant of the fact that we this, this could happen, it may never happen to us. Or we never may never know what's happened to us. But it's important to realize that that could be an issue, in my opinion.
16:52Okay. And the next topic is E portal filing. It's been around for a very long time, as I just said, in Florida, it's been around since I think the 2000s. You know, before 2010. There's some ethics opinions, ones from 2012. On some 2014 related to E filing in Florida e portal filing is called the E portal which many other states called that. So as we all know, I'm sure the portal is designed to allow the electronic filing of court documents and the that filing it's it's permitted in at least in Florida that electronic signatures be used of the lawyers signature. And also there's a button that's pushed to file it in the in Florida, the portal says you have you made sure that there's no confidential information in the filing, it actually is a little pop up if you go into the portal. So it's important for lawyers and non lawyers who work for lawyers to understand that that convenience is fine. But there's some very important downsides potentially to it. Number one, if we have a paralegal or trusted, if a lawyer has a paralegal or a trusted non lawyer, do the filing, then that individual needs to be trusted, and individuals can you know, do things that we don't like. So there's an ethics opinion in from 2012 that it's in Florida ethics PD 20 dash or 12 dash two, she's a new test some good information. So for all for those of you that are maybe Florida Bar members, there may be an ethics opinion in your jurisdiction. As I say in these webinars. I'm talking in general about ethics issues, ethics rules, however, always check your own jurisdiction where you're
18:37admitted to if you have a specific question related to ethics, and also if there's specific ethics opinion that may be available, but 12 dash two states that the lawyer can give the login credentials of a truck to afford the portal to trusted non lawyer employees to file court documents that have been reviewed and approved by the lawyer. However, the lawyer remains responsible for the filing and there's you know, there could be confidential information inadvertently sent in an exhibit, or even in the motion or in the document itself. So the lawyer is ultimately responsible for the content of that document. The lawyer must properly supervise the lawyer monitor the use of the portal and immediately change the lawyer's password if the non lawyer employer employee leaves the lawyers employment, or shows on trust worthiness and use of the portal. So that's important for lawyers. And that that then works or that is appropriate in I believe, are appropriate guidance in all jurisdictions. So I'd recommend I'd recommend that you consider that All right, so how about E Porter filing the there's a case from 2012 That's been around now for 10 years, but there are some other others. I just have this one in my in my PowerPoint, an individual named John Googe JG OUDGE I think that I don't know how he pronounces that way. But that's how I pronounce it. He was a lawyer in a Chicago law firm, who was responsible for filing complaints. Suing non paying student loan borrowers, and that was through the United States Department of Justice. So it's
20:24a deck debt collection matter. And that firm was signed a contract to do that for DOJ, this lawyer was supervising and also involved in that. Under that lawyers supervision, a non lawyer assistant prepared complaints and exhibits and they were filed by the by the non lawyer using the what's what the federal courts used to call the CM ECF e filing system. And it was it was filed in the Northern District of Illinois. And there's a box that the non lawyer, the person who's filing a check saying they're in compliance with the rule, and that all personal identifying information was redacted. Unfortunately, for this lawyer, there were not the complaints were fine, but the documents included law, your loan documents that had social security numbers, personal information, such as phone numbers and addresses, that was not redacted. So the individuals who were sued, complained and fight and the lawyer had to deal with a complaint with the Illinois disciplinary authority. And he had he admitted that he failed to make reasonable efforts to supervise a non the non lawyer expressed remorse and received a reprimand. So that lawyer, unfortunately, you know, and the, the, what we need to learn from this is not only is the actual court document, does, not only does that have to be not have to be better to not include that type of information, but also any exhibits, to the complaint or to the dock or whatever the document it document is it's the lawyers responsibility to redact that type of information. And if the lawyer doesn't below, you're maybe responsible, held responsible
22:12under under the relevant bar rules. So it's important to consider that. All right, how about providing remote access to electronic client files. So for instance, in today's world, and it's went on, it's been going on since especially since COVID, and a bit has been accelerated where lawyers and non lawyer employees have access to the law firms files remotely. And that's provided because they're not going into the office. It's important, and there's actually some ethics opinions. I have one posted here from 2014, the new New York State bar's ethics opinion 1019, which I believe it gives important information, a law firm may give its lawyers remote access to client files, so that lawyers may work from home, as long as the law firm determines that the particular technology used provides reasonable protection to client confidential information, or in the absence of such reasonable protection as a law firm and obtains informed consent from the client after informing the client of the risk. So hopefully, there's going to be reasonable protection. All right. That is it's important to have rock solid, remote communications with you know, with connections that are privates, and and protected. But also, you know, the lawyers shouldn't be using some method of remote access. That's not appropriators isn't practically isn't isn't appropriate for the protection of the of the client's confidential information. You know, hacks can happen, and they do. But if we've done all we can to protect the client's confidential information and documents,
23:51including even when providing remote access, then we've done all we can and sometimes stuff happens. But if the lawyer hasn't taken those steps, then the lawyer is going to be held responsible for ultimately be held responsible for a hack of the of the that information and and after the only consequence. So it's important and I cite in one ethics opinion there there definitely more that you can review in your jurisdiction. Again, I'd urge you to check your jurisdiction on that issue. But the main thing is to ensure in this this may be contacting the appropriate information technology person who has a lot of experience with this the strongest protection that can be provided within reason needs to be done, especially if something is important is confidential client information. Okay, how about electronic file storage? So that is that that means storing documents, client documents, file documents in the cloud, on on a server outside of the lawyer's office. Essentially what that is, some lawyers use, if it's a small firm use Microsoft Office 365. It may not be called it might just be called Microsoft 365. Now, I'm not sure but it permits the lawyer to keep client documents, other information, use Outlook. It's, it's essential in PowerPoint capability, it's a one stop shop for the lawyer paying a monthly amount to for that.
25:29So Microsoft obviously has assured us that that connection is is is, you know, practically speaking, is the best they can make it it's still subject, obviously to people that insist on trying to hack so that the lawyer can use that that's one example. But in Florida, back in 2000, and sic six, he's me, there was an ethics opinion 06 dash one. Lawyers may but are not required to store files electronically, unless there's a statute or rule which requires retention of an original document. The original documents of the property, the client or destruction of the paper document adversely affects the client's interests. So the lawyer can't just store a will, because that's an important original document can't store that electronically, or should say, on the cloud, and then throw away the will. So that's one example a deed things that are intrinsically valuable. If a client provides documents to the lawyer, the lawyer must preserve those as originals, but can also scan and put them on the on the server. So they must in accordance with this ethics opinion, I think this is good advice. files stored electronically must be readily reproducible and protected from an inadvertent modification degradation or destruction. So the lawyer needs to ensure that they're on a platform or on a third party vendors platform that would would guarantee or not get to the, to the extent possible, make sure that best practices are used to ensure that these documents are readily can be readily reproduced, protected
27:10from inadvertent modification degradation instruction, and I will add one more thing, the lawyer better be able to cut to to retrieve these documents. What happens if this vendor goes under and they're the documents disappear? I mean, that's been known to happen, what I've recommended is I have a an external drive, and I put documents on that external drive that I believe are important to keep in the event that my, my vendor, you know, has a problem. Hopefully, it never will. So I have those documents available in my in my, my external drive, which now nowadays, I just noticed, you can buy, what three or five terabyte terabyte, which is gigantic, external drive for 100 bucks or less. So they've gone way down in price. You can buy those and attach them right to your computer and take documents from your computer from your your document file and put it right into that external drive. Okay, what is cloud computing? It's essentially what I just said, computing. I mean, you know, having putting documents in the cloud, which is other servers, wherever they may be, Microsoft has them all over the place. So it goes to whatever wherever location is stored. And there's an ethics opinion from 2013 in Florida, 12 s3, say that states that lawyers may use cloud computing if they take reasonable precautions to ensure the confidentiality of client information is maintained. That service provider provides adequate security and that the lawyer has adequate access to the information stored or remotely, the lawyer should research the
28:47service provider to be used, as I've said in the last 10 or 20 minutes, however long it's been, that's important for the lawyer to consider. That's just one opinion. There's a New York State Bar Bar ethics opinion that it provides steps. Excuse me, there's a New York state bar, excuse me, New York state bar ethics opinion. 842 provides recommended steps to take steps to take to make sure that the the appropriate diligence is used. One is ensuring that the online data storage provider has an enforceable obligation to preserve confidentiality and security. The provider will notify the lawyer is served with process requiring the production of client information. Invest investigated the online data storage providers security measures are measures policies recoverability methods and other procedures to determine if they are adequate under the circumstances and employing available technology to guard against reasonably foreseeable attempts to infiltrate the data that is stored so that's that's New York State, which I think was around the same timeframe as the Florida one. There are others you can look check your own jurisdiction to to find guidance, but I think this is pretty good guidance right here. How about outsourcing. In Florida the issue came up back in 2008, a lawyer asked if it was a law firm, but the lawyer particularly in particular, asked if the law firm could outsource review of files to to Indian law electronically send them electronically and have effectively we have Indian lawyers who charged less than US paralegals review
30:28documents for the firm, and then have that consequence savings. And also they're they're more individuals available. I was in the on the ethics committee at the time, it's a state where that's his committee and there was a back and forth as to whether that should even be allowed and the committee came down with a point that it's done now or it was done even then were apparently Eagle may work remotely down the street from the law firm. And that's permitted. No one's ever said, the lawyer can't hire a paralegal, as you know, as a at that time, it was mostly paralegals, who were freelancing. It wasn't the actual employee, there was a who was a paralegal who was working remotely. And so it can't be prohibited. But the the committee caution in the ethics opinion that if a lawyer is going to use an outsourced, you know, outsource paralegal, for instance, that the lawyer must certainly take steps to maintain the same steps that we were just talking about as far as maintaining the cloud computing, I mean, the documents on the cloud, to ensure confidentiality, there's also additional conflict of interest issues where the two different two law firms are sending documents and ones the opposing parties getting in to get the documents. So that conflict of interest needs to be dealt with. And also the billing issue, you know, how's it going to be billed make sure confidentiality is maintained for built billing. So that that opinion recommends that contractual provisions addressing confidentiality and remedies in the event of
31:59a breach and periodic remain reminders regarding confidentiality should be used. So it's important if you're going to if we lawyers are going to outsource, for instance, paralegal work. Mostly it's gonna be paralegal work, those guidelines are important to consider. Okay, how about what are called digital storage devices in 2010, the Florida Bar looked into that you can check your jurisdiction, but digital storage devices, our computers, cell phones, iPads. Also, if we have a multi purpose copy fax scanning machine that uses a chip, that is a digital storage device. What happens with those is there's a chip inside the the machine, and then it records it all the data it keeps, that's how it works. It records the data, it takes a picture of the document, if it's going to be a scan, it takes a picture of it when it's there's a copy being made.
33:00All that information, or not much most of that information is going to be confidential. So the lawyer needs to take steps to make sure that that does not fall into the hands of someone who can improperly use it, for instance, when turning in the device at the end of the lease, so under this opinion, it's 10 dash to a lawyer who chooses devices or sorry chooses to use devices, which we all have to choose pretty much to use them that can take storage to media such as printers, copiers, scanners, facsimile machines, but must take reasonable steps to ensure the current client confidentiality is maintained.
33:34And the device is sanitized before disposition. So right now, in this opinion, they're talking only about multipurpose machines that use a chip, there has to be an identification, or there should be an identification of the potential threat to confidentiality along with the development of implementation and policies to address that threat. In inventory the devices if it's a larger firm, there may be four or five or even more devices that that are like that. And also after the inventory supervised non lawyers to obtain adequate insurance assurances of confidentiality will be maintained. And then the responsibility for the standardization device by require the lawyer must do this require meaningful assurances from the vendor at the intake of the device. The confidentiality will be maintained and also the chip will be destroyed upon turning it in and confirm or receipt or obtain a certification that sanitisation of the device at the disposition of the device. That's the recommended procedure. That's what Florida recommends. You could check your jurisdiction but that's some pretty good. At a minimum the lawyer needs to be making sure that that chip that's in that machine is going to be destroyed or sanitized as this opinion says to make sure that it doesn't fall into the hands of an individual who would use it. Use it or improper Really not use it improperly, but maybe even make threats to use it. So it's that's very important. All right, so how about metadata back in? I don't know, maybe
35:11the early 2000s Metadata became a huge deal because people were getting word documents that they could mine for information, such as revisions that were made in the document, when the documents first prepared, who revised it, what revisions that went through those types of things? Who prepared it? Who was the author? So there are a couple opinions of the ABA issued Oh, six dash 442 And oh, 5437, both formal opinions. Here's, here's the way that would work. Now, in today's world, there's less of a chance there's going to be a metadata issue. But if I were to send a Word document to the opposing lawyer, and it had a bunch of changes that were made by my clients and or other individuals, then that that opposing lawyer might be able to look at that and use means to find out and that may be helpful to that to that lawyer. Is it improper or unethical for the lawyer to to mindmap metadata? Well, Florida says no. Aba says no, it's not unethical, it may be unprofessional, or whatever word you want to use, but it's not unethical. So the sending lawyer, the lawyer who may be sending the metadata needs to keep that in mind, because they're the ones responsible for what may be in a document, he or she, the individual. And if it has metadata that is confidential that can be mined, the only duty the other side has is to send a communication saying, Hey, I received a document that has confidential information, notifying the sender, but there's no requirement that that lawyer or anybody not look at the information that can
36:53be mined. So and that includes even receiving confidential documents that actually on its on their face have confidentiality when I was practicing with a law firm a number of years ago, quite a few years ago, there was a document faxed to my office that had a, I was doing workers compensation at the time, and I was on the defense side and a claimants lawyer sent a fax erroneously to my office that was supposed to go to the client, that detailed like, basically was a confirmation of their discussion as to how the mediation was gonna work. What the what the client had approved as far as a high low settlement of the claim. I didn't know anything about it. My paralegal came in and said, Hey, we got this fax, it wasn't supposed to go to you. What do you want me to do? And at that time, there wasn't the hard and fast rules. I said, I'm not looking at it. Don't tell me anything about it, tell the other side, the other lawyer, that we received it, and then ask them what they want us to do. The lawyer said, well, thank you. Thank you very much.
37:50Please destroy it. That's what my paralegal did. I went to the mediation, it ended up being settled. And I talked to the lawyer after the mediation, and she said, obviously, he's grateful I didn't take a look at it, because it had a bunch of information I could, if I had known him, I could have used pretend, potentially, excuse me. So that's an example of where confidential information was sent directly to me, erroneously. And the rule was a little different and a little gray, more gray in Florida, at least at that time. But now it's pretty clear the only duty is to tell the other side that the sender I should say not the other side is sender that it has been received. So it's it's incumbent upon the sender of the document to ensure it goes to the right place, whether it's an email, will it be a via their backs, is are still used. The floorboard bargain amateurs still uses faxes to obtain now they're going into the electronic age now after 20 years or whatever. So they're changing the rules. So again, it's important to realize how things can can go go terribly wrong if documents are erroneously sent and that there's not an ethical duty for the person or the individual or the lawyer receiving the documents to not review those. Now, there are some federal rules that deal with that issue that don't apply it to my discussion here that requires sequestration and some other other things. So that I'm only talking about right at this point, the Florida rules and you should check your jurisdiction to determine what the rule is in your jurisdiction. It state
39:35jurisdiction as far as your bar rules are concerned and also if it's a federal case, there may be some more restrictive requirements with regard to confidentiality and receipt of documents that have that are confidential and there's an ethics opinion that I just mentioned in Florida oh six dash to a lawyer is sending an electronic document should take care of that. Through the confidentiality of all information contained in the document, including metadata. The opinion says this is a back in oh six, a lawyer receiving electronic document should not try to obtain information from edit data should not there's no prohibition, but they say should not. And then also, the requirements the notification to the sender of the receipt of it. So that is, that is what the Florida Bar opinion said in 2006, it still is valid, the lawyer should take steps to to not to send either directly a confidential documents that actually they're confidential on their on their face or medicine documents with metadata is confidential. And because that lawyer by sending it could very well be breaching confidentiality, inadvertently. So it's important to consider that. Okay, let's talk about the lovely world of social media. So all of us probably listening to this. Maybe there are some that aren't. But I would believe that most if not all of us do use social media in some way shape or form it within our, with our practice, you know, LinkedIn and social media, YouTube videos or social media. Websites can have your deal
41:19with have social media aspects to them. So what about the use of disclaimers in a profile? Well, it may be important if a lawyer is going to use, for instance, a law firm, have a law firm Facebook page, to have a disclaimer saying that, you know, don't say anything to this page, because it may or will not be kept confidential and there's no attorney client relationship. But social media is important. And I had a client unfortunately, and I'll tell you just hypothetically speaking, there was a new lawyer saw a Facebook post from an individual who that lawyer believe was an acquaintance slash friend who had been in an accident. posted, hey, you know, if anybody can help, let me know. And this lawyer said, Well, I handle that area of practice, if you need me.
42:13That was kind of an issue number one lawyer shouldn't be doing that, because that is considered potentially be solicitation. But what happened next was that individual went to another lawyer, hired that lawyer, and then was dissatisfied with that lawyer and fired that lawyer, and then hired the lawyer than it said, the initial, you know, hey, if you need some help, let me know, what happened was the lawyer who was fired, wasn't happy, and found out about that, that one response that the lawyer made to that to that now client, and found a bar complaint against the lawyer, the lawyer obviously didn't intend to be violating solicitation rules. And it was a learning learning experience.
42:56The lawyer was not ultimately discipline because it was a learning experience. But keep in mind that anything we send out anything that's sent out in social media, especially in the form of a, if it's in a form that could be considered to be solicitation is gonna be fair game. And I've found and maybe you're may or may not have found that many times that these types of complaints are generated by individuals, you know, by lawyers who are competition, because they see this and they think it's should be shut down. And they think it's improper and unethical. All those words. So just be careful out there. That's an example of where a response did it did cause that, that lawyer to have to respond and go through the whole process? It was not an easy process, obviously. So keep that in mind as well. So what about gaining trying to gain access to social media content? Can a lawyer ask a paralegal to try to friend you know, for instance, the opposing party or a witness in the case to try to get get surreptitiously get information? Well, the answer is no. There are a myriad of ethics opinions that say no, that can't happen. There's also a case called Robert roe Vitelli versus the New York New Jersey Office of Attorney ethics. It started in back in Oh, eight, believe it or not. And there was an opinion this past year. What happened was the local or regional Grievance Committee in New Jersey, throughout a complaint that was filed against a lawyer for ads asking your paralegal to send a friend request to I think it was a witness in
44:36this case, it might have been to the opposing party as actually the opposing party's Facebook page. So this went through the process the after that, that dismissal the the big Office of Attorney ethics, the statewide one petitioned the New Jersey Supreme Court to reopen the complaint and they did and then in this remember, this is 2018 and 2021. If the court finally issued an opinion saying this was a violation of the ethics rules, however, since it happened in 2008, and the rules were not as clear we're not going to sanction this lawyer, but we are saying from this point forward, if a lawyer tries to do this, or does do this or does does this through the acts of another, we're going to prosecute them. So lawyers need to be well aware of the fact that we are not permitted to use what would be considered to be surreptitious means to gain access to a Facebook page. There are other other asset ethics opinions, you knew that address this. There's one from Oregon, Oregon, Kentucky, New York State and New York City Bar Association's all of them say that lawyers not permitted either themselves or through agents to engage in false or deceptive tactics to get around to social media users privacy settings to reach nonpublic information, which would include asking the paralegal to friend an individual on Facebook. There's also a Philadelphia ethics been actually both filled up in San Diego County Bar Association, conclude that lawyers must affirmatively disclose their reasons for communicating with third parties. So there's an affirm, they say that there's
46:12an affirmative duty to disclose. So that's important for us to know as well. All right. How about if the lawyer is retained by an individual, and it's, say a criminal case or even a personal injury case, and there's some damaging documentation or information on on the clients Facebook page, can the lawyer ask, or if or if everything on the Facebook page is public, and it needs to be made product and the lawyer advise that client to do that. In Florida, there's a 2015 opinion where the where the Ethics Committee, which by the way, ethics pendants, as I'm sure we all know are not binding, but they're used for guidance, said that a lawyer could do that, as long as it wasn't going to cause a spoliation of evidence or destruction of evidence or whatever, including removing information as well. But if the lawyer is going to to recommend that to the client, then there needs to be a preservation of the pages as they were so that the lawyer if there's ever a claim, by the other side, that there was some spoliation, or destruction of evidence that the court can review that most likely in Canberra to determine whether that happens. So two things one is yes, typically, a lawyer can tell the client to increase the privacy settings and or just remove pages and from the from the Facebook page, from from their Facebook page and or other social media, you know, places but they the lawyer needs to protect him or herself by making copies of those pages first before they are removed or changed. All right. And there's also a New York City Lawyers Association
48:03ethics opinion 2013 New York has at least two different bodies that issue opinions. One is the New York City Lawyers Association, and the other is the New York state bar association. So they both issue opinions. In Florida, there's only one entity that issues opinions is the Florida Bar in most jurisdictions to just have one another. There are a while I think has multiple organizations that issue opinions. Okay, lawyers need to be careful about social media profiles, posts and blogs, because they can be advertising. I have a blog, it's called lawyer ethics, alerts, lawyer ethics alerts, you can ask for me, you can send me an email if you want to be on my list, I talk about relevant cases, bar rule changes, Bar Bar ethics, trends, those kinds of things. I've issued them periodically, I send them via email I also I actually start them out in on WordPress and then I moved them I add them to both LinkedIn into my into my Facebook page, my firm page, you can send me an email if you want to be added to it. However, blogs are going to go in to be considered to be advertising must if the lawyer is soliciting business is saying no, hire me I can do this for you that for you the in order for the blog not to be an advertisement the lawyer needs to give information only and not be trying to obtain clients or through that that vet knew that it's through that blog. Now. If the lawyer does is hired by a client because the client saw the lawyers blog, there's nothing wrong with that. Also, the blog must be truthful and not disparage you know judges
49:49over others because that can lead the lawyer to into some very serious trouble. Here's an example of an issue with a So with that, as a lawyer was blogging about an Illinois lawyer, public assistant public defender was blogging about her life as an assistant public defender and how she was overworked and underpaid and have Hey, this happened, it was kind of funny. And she blogged about a client who was put under oath on a drug charge to be taken off of probation. And the judge asked the individual, you know, are you under the influence of drugs? Are you have you had any drugs certain time, you're on probation, and the client said no, under oath, and then when they're walking out the door, the client said, I'm high right now. Haha. So this lawyer, instead of reporting it to the court or taking action, such as that made a made a joke about it in a post, in a blog post, she had a public blog, or it wasn't a joke, it was at least not minimizing the importance of it. That same lawyer was also saying disparaging things about judges and using their initials, which, you know, they can readily identify who it was. So that lawyer was found guilty. I think that that lawyer pled to the to the charges receive a 60 day suspension in Illinois, and a lawyer was also admitted in Wisconsin and the lawyer received that 90 day suspension in Wisconsin. So that's an odd that's that's an important lesson for, for bloggers to learn. And that is we're different as lawyers, we have to be very careful about what we put on our blogs. Another topic is whether we are allowed to
51:29respond with confidential information if an individual files and internet complaint against us or a bad review against us. The answer is no, we cannot, we cannot. And there's I don't believe there's any jurisdiction that has any exception to this rule that allows a lawyer to respond with confidential information to an internet complaint. Now we're permitted to respond and provide confidential information responding to a bar complaint, an ethics complaint, a malpractice claim, or if there's a dispute over our fees, or if there's some claim that we involved we're involved in a crime with the client. All those are exceptions, internet complaints are no exception, or not accepted. So there's a lawyer in New York, I'm sorry, in New York, in Georgia in 2014, who received a reprimand for including confidential information in a response to what the court called and consumer internet page. And then the New York state bar association. And that's the opinion that states that lawyers cannot reveal current client competence is solely to respond to former a former clients criticism on a lawyer rating website. So both of those are important to know. I understood or understand that, at least within this last year, there was some movement in one of the states I can't remember, it might have been Virginia, one of those states to make that into an exception to allow lawyers to respond. There was actually a discussion about that in Florida, but it never was it never, there was never a decision or an ethics being that
52:51allowed a lawyer to provide confidential information in response in general response to avoid a client's internet complaint. Except with one exception as to as to whether it's the clients alleging that the lawyer someone's alleging that lawyer was involved in in criminal acts, that that's a potential exception. All right, how about communicating that to unrepresented third parties? Week weak and we aren't permitted to try to gain access to nonpublic social media content. It's the same. It's the same deal with unrepresented third parties. It's the same rule applies if we're trying to you know, if we're we want to get find out something about a witness, we can't surreptitiously asked her to friend them to get dirt on him. That's that's not permitted the ethics opinions uniformly say that's not permitted. So we need to keep that in mind as lawyers as well.
53:47Alright, so how about email? are we permitted to use regular email for our confidential communications? Well, in Florida since about 22, the year 2000, there has been an there was an opinion saying we're allowed to use an encrypted email. And obviously, I'm sure all of us use that. The problem is it can be intercepted it can be hacked. And there's some other issues I'll talk about in a minute. So what I would say in what the ethics committee would say is if it's normal attorney client confidential communication, and there's no requirement or there's there's nothing, making it super confidential, such as, for instance, a merger of two corporations where if it gets out, it's going to be considered to be a blockbuster, you know, that kind of thing, or if the client so if it's a normal email, that's fine, but if something like that is going on, or if the client insists on having encryption or heightened security, then the lawyer has to do it, and has to has to comply with the client's wishes and or should do it if it's, if it's encrypted, super sensitive or is the type of information that needs to be protected even more than normal. And then there's the ABA has an article and I'm sure there's some ones that are more more Up to date, and maybe this one's been revised about encryption and how to use it in what time what types of situations to use it in. Okay, a practical practically speaking, when we're sending emails in, we should be very careful about a couple of things. One is, I would
55:20suggest a test that we should never copy the client on a subsequent email to the opposing counsel in a case, whether it be a straight copy or a brought blind copy ever. A couple of reasons. One is because the client may be upset about something and hit Reply All and say something that is, I'll say, stupid, something that's not smart, that the opposing party would, you know, lawyer would hear or even at admission. So it's strongly recommended, there's actually a New York state bar association ethics opinion that you can see on a slide from 2015, stating that lawyers should not copy the client, whether it be a blind copy, or a straight copy of anything sent to the opposing counsel, or anything that sends to them. The lawyer in what I do in those situations, and I'm dealing with mostly lawyer clients is I'll send that email to the opposing counsel, typically the bar in that case, and then I'll forward that email to my client and say, Here's my email. If you have any comments, let me know or if you have any questions, that kind of thing, so I forwarded it after I sent it to the to the opposing lawyer to make sure that it can't be responded to. So that's important. That another thing is that clients must should be advised that they shouldn't be forwarding confidential information to individuals who are not within the attorney client confidentiality, and privilege. So it could be that they're and I've talked to paralegals about this, and lawyers that could be privileged and confidential, do not forward to the two emails that are sent to
56:54the client. Or they should be counseled maybe in the form of communication, saying don't forward anything from us. That's, that's, it's substantive confidential, because you'll you'll you'll breach the confidentiality, aspects of our representation. So it's important for lawyers to consider that there could be something, as I said, Put on the subject line to try to ensure that the client does not do that, because it can create untold problems, if the client does that. All right, how about here's a situation if a client, and I'll just use this situation, that the client wants to sue their employer, and they're sending emails to the lawyer that they're that they're, you know, that they've retained? or are considering retaining, sending emails from their employer email address, is that is that smart or appropriate? Oh, absolutely not. Because many employers have a requirement that if an individual uses their email system, then they have a right the employer has the right to see any and all emails that that that that employee sends or receives. And sometimes it even applies to a personal email that said that that's on their system. So it's important for lawyers to realize and fines to realize that they shouldn't be sending any documents, or any information or on, you know, through email from the employers email. But here's the thing is, there are ethics beings, including this, this ABA opinion from that's 11 Dash 468, an employer's counsel who receives those emails does not have a duty to forward it to the the opposing party or his
58:46or her attorney. So that is, you know, that that that is very important to know, because that lawyer may not be required to provide that information to the unless there's there's rule there are rules or some other requirement for for revealing that which that would involve age jurisdiction. So in general, there would be no duty for that employer account employers counsel to forward those emails that talk about the case to the opposing to the, you know, the employee and or that employees attorney, and it's really important to consider that. So, in my practice, kind of doesn't happen all that often. But I've helped lawyers who were considering resigning from they're leaving their law firms. And I've told them, and I've done it enough times now in the last 25 years that that I know, and I tell them, use your personal email address, send emails from somewhere other than your employer and from the law firm for that very reason. So in especially lawyers who handle employer employment cases, where lawyers are, I mean, where employees are suing employers they should insist and in Anyone else who hires, the lawyer should be told to use an email address? That's not their employee email address, or employer's email address. It's very important. All right, so in summary, I'm going to talk about a few things, a few tips with regard to what we've just discussed, and, and a couple of things that we'll talk about. What about text messaging? Many lawyers say text me at this number, because they want to have the, you know, the clients
1:00:33have full 24/7 access at anytime. To me, that's extremely problematic. First of all, texting is femural. It's not doesn't it's not like an email where it stays there, it's, you know, it's out there, that you can buy a program, I guess, to preserve the text, so you can get them off of your phone, that kind of a thing. But it's important. In my opinion, it's also much more professional to communicate with the client in a more permanent fashion, either by phone, or through email, or through community of Britain communications, such as a letter. Because text messages, you know, there's there's all kinds of things, you know, there's there's, it can be misinterpreted. So I wanted to percent discourage lawyers from having any substantive communication with clients, or I should say, I don't, don't recommend it, not that I discourage them. But if there's going to be text communication, it should just be, you know, if the client if you have a problem, just if you want to send me a text, we can schedule a conference, you know, instead of, you know, don't send anything substantive with subsidy questions, I can't tell you how many times I've seen that turn into a big mess, because, you know, you've got the lawyer has to compile the communications, because if the client file it, for instance, files a bar might, they're only going to put their portions into the bar complaint. So the the entire context of the text messages needs to be presented. So be you know, take it for what it is. And that is they can go incredibly wrong to have too much
1:02:03communication with text messages. Make sure that the client is aware of the fact that you know that they can or cannot text you if the lawyer says please do, you do not text me my policies, no texts, that client should be aware of that. As I said, they're not permanent texts are not necessarily permanent. They're, they're hackable, all those all those issues. Emails are better, obviously, they're not perfect, but they can be sent in obviously, if a lawyer sends an email by phone, it's almost like texting, but it's not. It's different. It's a different format. How about using electronic devices in public lawyers deep in non lawyers need to be very careful not to open up the laptop and start doing confidential stuff on a Starbucks using a public, you know, public connection, where people can can look over and see their laptop, or talk on the phone to a client or to you know, talk about confidential matters on the phone. Both of those are no no's. And lawyers need to be very careful not to do that. And I know that that almost stopped during COVID Because nobody was going into Starbucks and staining around and eating. But nowadays, we're coming back and, and going into these places that have Wi Fi. So it's just an important consideration. And it's important not to use public Wi Fi in any case, because it's not it's not secure. All right, be aware of your surroundings. Don't consider using a privacy screeners and you'll see some tips on my on my PowerPoint that you can use that URL that would be important. A couple more points. The social media
1:03:41platforms can be used by lawyers. Also a paralegals listening or if there's an issue with paralegal paralegals need to be careful because the rules that apply to lawyers would pretty much pass through to the non lawyers and lawyers would be responsible for any violations of the rules, particularly if the lawyer knows about them. How about client reviews? Certainly clients and former clients can give positive reviews and testimonials there their requirements in every jurisdiction or at least in Florida I'll tell you whether there are other jurisdiction in your jurisdiction check your rules, but Florida has some requirements one is the lawyer can't write a testimonial or an endorsement has to be within the what the client can perceive it can't be that they my lawyer has the best legal mind in history of the world it can maybe mean that the law firm was very in the lawyer communicated with me properly you know kept me in the loop all that kind of stuff so that's fine lawyers can can say other lawyers are good. That's fine.
1:04:46Within the the your jurisdictions requirements, handle negative posts properly, and don't reveal client client confidential information. You know, there is there is a potential that the lawyer could file a lawsuit for libel, however, many of those are anonymous. And it's tough for the lawyer to there have been some verdicts that have been rendered where lawyers have won a lawsuit for libel. There should be a social media strategy and policy developed lawyer average sizing rules apply to all media. Now, not just to the old media like billboards. There needs to be a review of the social media accounts for the as far as the privacy is concerned, I've already talked about that.
1:05:35And be careful about the expectation of privacy versus, you know, what, somebody what, for instance, the client may want. So that those are my final tips to you. I hope you enjoyed and got some good information from this. This webinar, I really appreciate your attention, and stay safe and be careful out there and I'll see you next time. Thank you.
Sharon R.NJ
Very informative and current.
Shara B.CA
Great presentation. Learned some great stuff. Thank you.
MILES C.CA
Excellent course. Reiterated practices that I have in place or that should be updated (such as "No Text" Policy as part of retainer agreement – rubber hits the road with enforcement). Minor nit on program's reference to texting as "ephemeral messaging." I disagree that texting can be characterized as "ephemeral" because true "ephemeral" messaging disappears. Sedona Conference has an excellent paper on the topic. As to Alexa and similar devices, I don't think that those devices should be in the office at all given we know they have the ability to record whether inadvertently or otherwise. As to e-mails with opposing counsel or other third parties, great advice on forwarding those e-mails to client rather than copying the client on those e-mails. As to metadata mining, best practice is it strip it out of editable document (i.e., Word) and/or PDF image before service/filing. I think FL 062 gets it right. Regardless of the jurisdiction, it may not always be an ethics violation to dig up metadata, but it's still dirty pool. On client documents, in my humble opinion, the best policy is to instruct clients not to send originals, but instead to instruct client to e-mail PDF copies to the attorney with instructions to maintain the originals if recourse to them is needed in the future. Best practice is to send PDF copies to the client of the documents that the client has provided perhaps with internal date designations and abbreviated summary of content in the title of each document so everyone is working off the same page. As to "proper supervision" of a tech vendor, I don't know that this course did or could answer that question. It's kind of like catching the piano. Certainly one concrete step would be to download and maintain the license/contract and perhaps check for a BoM. This was a great course.
Rose M.NJ
Incredible presentation by a knowledgeable and engaging lecturer. The session demystified the ethical pitfalls of using Zoom, Teams, and Alexa as well as other digital tools in legal practice. If you are working at home, never work with Alexa on; actually, unplug the device in order to ensure maintaining confidentiality. Alexa is a home security device. Some Alexa devices and compatible smart displays (such as the Echo Show) do not continuously record or store general household video or private conversations, but we cannot take a chance. I left the video with practical insights I can use immediately. Takeaway about smart speakers and displays is spot-on for legal ethics. Even though devices like Alexa and Echo Show are designed to wait for a wake word before recording, false triggers happen. For lawyers bound by strict confidentiality rules (like ABA Model Rule 1.6), having an always-listening microphone in a home office introduces an unnecessary risk of third-party interception or cloud storage of privileged client conversations. Unplugging them—or keeping them strictly outside your workspace—is widely considered the safest best practice. NJ RPC 1.6 (Confidentiality of Information): A lawyer must not reveal information relating to representation unless the client consents or an exception applies. Under RPC 1.6(f), New Jersey lawyers are required to make "reasonable efforts" to prevent the inadvertent or unauthorized disclosure of, or unauthorized access to, client information. Video conferencing platforms like Zoom and Teams also come with their own subtle ethical traps, such as: • Unintended recording or AI transcription: Automated meeting summaries or cloud recordings can accidentally capture sensitive discussions or become discoverable if not properly managed. • Screen-sharing mishaps: Notifications, open tabs, or background windows can inadvertently expose confidential client files to other participants. • Weak access controls: Failing to use waiting rooms or meeting passcodes can allow unauthorized attendees to join a privileged call. The presentation delivered clear, practical steps that attorneys can immediately implement to safeguard sensitive client information and maintain ethical compliance. Key takeaway from today's CLE training: protecting client confidentiality doesn't always require a complete tech overhaul. We walked away with several immediate, high-impact workflows we can adopt this week.