55min · about 10,100 wordsDownload Transcript
0:16Hello everyone and welcome to today's seminar. I know there was a little confusion on time. It was scheduled out to everyone here at 3:00pm Eastern Standard Time, but on my end it was scheduled for 4:00pm Eastern Standard Time. So thank you for being flexible and coming back at 4pm to accommodate schedules and everything else with that. Just some housekeeping items as everyone gets settled and everyone gets connected here today. If you want to know when you get that CLE code for CLE credit, that comes at the end of today's seminar. Not at the beginning, not at the middle, but at the end within the last 10 to 15 minutes of the hour.
0:57So about 10 till 5 or you know, towards that end of the seminar time, that code will automatically be populated into the chat feature here on Zoom and so you will see it put in there by lexfin. I will also copy and paste that so you have it in there a second time as well as announce it verbally. You will want to write down that code and then once the seminar is over today, you will exit out of today's seminar and enter into your individual lexfed account online. Go to the seminars you signed up for. There should be a place to put that code on your individual LexVid page and then you'd submit it back to LexFed.
1:36LexFed then has 30 days to turn that around to your respective jurisdictions reporting your attendance. Your jurisdictions then credit your account or put it on your audit report that they have held for you within the state or however they handle those. Now obviously Lexvid has 30 days to report your attendance to your jurisdiction, so it's not instantaneous. It's not going to be on there tomorrow or maybe even by the end of the week. So please do give LexVid some time to get that turned around. If you don't see it within your jurisdiction on your audit reports within 30 to 45 days, please do reach out to LexVid or your jurisdiction to see where it's at in the process if you if it's been reported or where the holdup is and they can help you.
2:20Your attendance here is recorded today, so lexvig can always go back and verify that as well. If there's any question or discrepancy on how long you've attended the seminar or if you were even on it today. So just know that can be verified. If you have any additional questions or any questions throughout today's seminar, you can obviously put those in the chat feature here on Zoom. I will try to monitor that as I'm speaking, but I may not get to those questions until the end of the seminar. I may try to answer some as I'm speaking to you if they're relevant to the topic and I see them and can fit them in, but otherwise they'll be answered at the end of today's seminar. If you're not comfortable submitting them here, you can always email me separately or email lexeded and they turn around and submit the questions to me to respond to. So you can also do that as well. Anything else, just again put it in the chat and we will try to answer any questions or any concerns you have throughout the presentation. With that, if you've not taken a seminar from me before, My name is Carrie Sheehan. I'm assistant General Counsel of Taft, Stentenius and Hollister law firm located in their Indianapolis, Indiana location. Within my role as assistant General counsel, I work with the firm, attorneys and the firm itself on compliance and ethics, responding to any disciplinary commission, things filed against our attorneys, any malpractice suits, just compliance in general and and making sure that our attorneys stay compliant with
3:50the rules of ethics and whatever they're doing for their clients. So again, please ask any question. I deal with ethics all day, every day and happy to answer those questions. Today we are focusing our topic here on ethics and evidence. So we are going to be talking about some of the ethical rules that are implicated when you are collecting evidence, say, in a litigation, presenting evidence in a court, or just handling it in a client matter or a client case. And this can be very important because in this process of dealing with evidence, you can have missteps. And those missteps can lead to violations of the rules of professional conduct.
4:32And when we get into the throes, say, of discovery, when we get into the throes of just defending our client or even putting a trial together, sometimes that ethics hat goes out the window, meaning we are so in this zealous advocacy mindset, meaning advancing our client's position, pushing it forward, trying to get that foot ahead or that advantage over your opponent or defendant or opposing counsel. And we forget that we're bound or still have parameters, including the rules of professional conduct. And these rules include things like being honest, correcting misstatements of the record, not prejudicing or not doing things unfair to opposing counsel or third parties.
5:21And we're going to go through all these. But if you think about it, especially if you're a trial attorney, when you're preparing for a case, is the first thing you're thinking about ethics? Probably not. It's the first Thing. Your client's thinking about ethics, probably not. They're thinking about winning the case. They're thinking about, you know, how do we get that advantage, how do we outsmart our opponent and, you know, what do we do in that context? So we have to be the ones to push that. We do have ethical parameters around what we do as litigators or as lawyers, especially when it comes to presenting evidence and presenting our client's case. And with this, too, we have to manage our client's expectations because our client, again, wants to win, and sometimes at any cost. And so we have to alert them that we do have rules of ethics that we as lawyers have to comply with, and that we can't lie, cheat and steal. We can't hide stuff from the other side. We can't mysteriously make that piece of evidence disappear. That's going to hurt them. That we have to first, first and foremost, be fair and try to, I guess, adhere to the rules of evidence, adhere to our rules of ethics, and then two, remind them that first and foremost, we're officers of the court, meaning our first duty as judicial officers is to be honest with the court. So we can't lie to the court. We can't counsel others to lie to the court. We can't do certain things.
6:56And we do need to remind our clients of this, particularly every. If you're in areas that involve high emotions, such as family law, child custody cases, criminal defense cases, those types of things, those are going to spark emotions, and they're going to spark what clients want as that bulldog or that bulldozer type of lawyer who just goes in there and is just rude and just abrasive and just does everything and doesn't care, takes no mercy. But sometimes we cannot do that as lawyers. So we have to find that balance between zealous advocacy and ethics. And that comes with, you know, knowing that sometimes with the rules of ethics, what we can do under the rules may not be always ethical. So conduct that's admissible can still be unethical. They don't always go hand in hand, just like if we have laws or just like out in general society. A lot of stuff as humans we can do as human beings, but they're not ethical to do so. So we do have to balance those two things when we are representing clients as well, handling evidence, collecting evidence, and then presenting it to the court. Because the rules of professional conduct govern us 24 hours a day, seven days a week, personally and professionally, and we cannot forget them. We can never take that ethical hat off. We always have to think with our ethics hat and know that we are bound by those rules of ethics.
8:28So we are going to go over some of the core ethical duties regarding litigation and evidence. And these are just ones that pop out in this general area. Now, there are tons of rules of ethics, and they all apply to you, whether you're litigating, doing a transactional matter, or just something personal. But these are just ones that stand out more, that can be more highly implicated when we're handling evidence or when we're presenting stuff to the court or representing that client in litigation. The first two rules kind of go hand in hand. Rules 1.1, competence and 1.3 diligence. Under rule 1.1, competence, we have a duty to be competent in our representation of the client, including the requisite legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation for the client's case. This also means that we have to be competent in relevant technology and anything that touches and concerns the client's case. And that is a big thing, because nowadays technology is advancing so much and there's so much stuff out there, especially regarding different types of evidence that can be collected. And if we don't stay competent in all these new developments, then we're not going to be able to assist our clients effectively. For instance, how many of you remember when we started getting interrogatories and requests for productions for Facebook passwords or content on Facebook, and then that ballooned into all social media posts or different messaging through social media?
10:07And now there's actually a case out of New York that says, and this is new, this is just this past February 2026, there's a case out of New York that says if a client uses a generative AI like a ChatGPT or, you know, one of the large language models inserts into it, you know, the attorney's legal advice, or ask the ChatGPT force to generate something on a legal case that's not protected by the attorney client privilege and, and that's not protected by confidentiality because the ChatGPT is not the attorney. And so anything that a client inputs into these large language models could be discoverable by opposing counsel.
10:53Now, that's huge. New York is the first place that I've seen a case like this come down in response to generative AI and what's out there. But this is really going to affect our evidence collection, what we can and cannot do, and how we handle that evidence and maintaining our competency, especially if we're litigating. Now, we may want to include in those Interrogatories or requests for production of documents, asking for the client's genii or the opposing parties gen AI prompts. And the thing is, if they're using ChatGPT or any of these large language models, those programs save the prompts. They save them. And you can now, based on this New York opinion, at least in New York, try to get at those. So maintaining competency in what we can request.
11:45Maintaining competency in different types of evidence is going to be crucial because if we don't maintain that competency, even if we don't like the new technology coming out, it can hurt our client's case and it can hurt us, because if we're not competent, we violate Rule 1.1. So we do have to look at that competency too, in just the collection of evidence, how it's treated by the courts, and what that looks like. Otherwise, we can be hit with a competency violation. We also have to Remember too Rule 1.3, our diligence rule states that a lawyer shall act with reasonable diligence and promptness. And in representing a client, this means that we cannot procrastinate. And even the comments to Rule 1.3 tell us that we cannot procrastinate. It uses the word procrastinate in the comments. This also means that we have to control our caseloads, that we have to, you know, not cause unreasonable delay. We have to, you know, file stuff on time. Motions for extension of time that are excessive or missing deadlines is a violation of Rule 1.3.
12:53So in the evidence collection or as relating to evidence, you can violate Rule 1.3 and not conducting discovery promptly, and not responding to discovery promptly, or doing those different things, the procrastination, the excessive motions for extension of time, moving depositions, or just delaying the process can potentially be that Rule 1.3 violation. So we also need to think about that in our evidence collection, just especially in that discovery phase, but also in the entire litigation phase as well, where we could have this violation under Rule 1.3. In addition to those just general competency and diligence, we also have to make sure we put forth meritorious claims and contentions. This means as we get evidence in, if the evidence is not supporting the contentions we put in the complaint, or we get evidence in before we file the complaint, and we realize that the claims are not grounded in fact in law and that we shouldn't advance them. This rule specifically states that a lawyer shall not mandatory standard, bring or defend a proceeding or assert or controvert an issue. Therein unless there is a basis in law and fact for doing so that is not frivolous. I call this kind of the laugh test too.
14:16If you can go in front of a judge and have enough case law or have enough foundation in the law or, or the statutes or the rules to advance the position with a straight face and not laugh about it with your colleagues in the background saying, I can't believe the judge fell for that, then you probably have a meritorious claim or one that would pass muster. If you can't do that or can't do that reasonably, then you probably have an unmeritorious claim. A lot of times we can think of some famous cases where the evidence really didn't support a meritorious claim, or it did support it, but to the outside world it looked like it didn't.
14:56One of the ones that comes to mind is the McDonald's hot coffee case. This was the case where the lady spilled coffee on her leg sued McDonald's, actually ended up in a settlement for a sizable amount of money. But the basis of this was that the coffee of McDonald's was hotter than industry standards, meaning other fast food chains or other places that serve that to go coffee, and that McDonald's intentionally did that to have a hotter version of coffee because it said customers liked it, but the temperature of their coffee was above what industry standard was, which is kind of what grounded it in that law or fact to have a meritorious claim.
15:37But there was a lot of people that thought it was an unmeritorious claim and that everyone should have known coffee is hot, don't spill it, it's going to burn you, kind of common sense thing. But it was that fact of the industry standard was lower and McDonald's was higher. If you read a lot of the briefings, you kind of pull from those cases and the settlement that came forward. Other cases, one that was not meritorious, and this one was actually taught in a paralegal studies textbook that I used to teach from when I taught paralegal studies in the mid 2000s there in the earlier years. And this was a case regarding jelly, but it was not the kind of jelly you think that you put on bread, but it was like contraceptive jelly that's supposed to stop you from getting pregnant that a girl should use, you know, before they have intercourse. And so this plaintiff bought this jelly, went home, spread it on toast and ate it, and then sued the manufacturer of the jelly when she got pregnant and said, you know, there was nothing on the jelly to state that it shouldn't be taken Orally and that you had to, you know, use it elsewhere to stop from getting pregnant. That was kicked out of court as an unmeritorious claim. It was a frivolous claim.
16:57You know, common sense should have prevailed there. There's no law in flat in fact or any warnings that this, you know, contraceptive jelly company could have put on the bottle for that or they said that that would been frivolous and, you know, it wasn't necessary. So that is one too, where even the evidence coming in they tried to do like a failure to warn or failure to put warnings wasn't enough to get past 3.1. So we do have to collect evidence. We have to think about the stuff that's coming in, make sure it's grounded in law and fact as we're collecting that evidence. Otherwise we could violate Rule 3.1. Now, if you want to have another case like the jelly case, all open to outrageous cases, I just don't want to be the culprit of putting them across. So please do for more content.
17:43Another rule that we could potentially violate if we have when we're dealing with evidence is candor to the tribunal. We cannot present false evidence, we cannot make a false statement of fact or law to the tribunal or fail to correct one that we've made in the past. We also, as you can see here in 3.3 A2, if there is a controlling case in our jurisdiction, even if that controlling case is adverse to our client, if opposing counsel does not disclose it and we know about it, we have to disclose it even if it's adverse to our client. This is the one that really gets lawyers up in arms because it's like doing your opposing counsel's job for them and disclosing the case when it's controlling. But controlling, adverse to your client kind of puts your client at a disadvantage and you're helping out an opposing counsel who wasn't smart enough to even find it. But the thing is, when you look at the basis behind this rule or the reasoning behind it, the judiciary is a truth seeking function. It's there for fairness, justice, to examine the truth or to find the truth. And it needs the information, the controlling information, to make that fair determination.
19:00So it's putting that onus on us, the lawyers, to make sure we give it the information that we know about, even if it's adverse to the client and it's controlling on the subject matter of our client's case. Now, obviously, if this does affect you or you are put in this position where you have to do this, you would want to distinguish that case right out the gate to make sure that you know you can overcome it. But just know you are under an ethical obligation to disclose those, even if they do hurt your client's case. So, something to think about there. And that's what lawyers tend to forget about too, because how many of us want to do our opposing counsel's job for them?
19:40Not many of us. And so we do have to think about that, and that our first obligations are candor to that tribunal. And that even trumps confidentiality, which you can see if you jump down there to 3.3 C. The duties in this paragraph A and B continue to the conclusion of the proceedings, so all the way out through the proceedings, and apply if compliance requires disclosure of information otherwise protected by Rule 1.6. Meaning our duty of candor to the court trumps confidentiality to our client. This means in instances where you know your client has perjured themselves, or you know your clients lied, or you know something's false on the record, your duty to correct it, even that client's false testimony trumps confidentiality to your client, because normally you couldn't disclose that they lied because it would hurt your client. But this trumps it is paramount, and the rules make it paramount, that we first owe our duties of candor and truthfulness to the tribunal over even our confidentiality to clients in some circumstances. So we have to take this very seriously, because a lot of lawyers do get dinged for this, especially when it comes to evidence production or disclosing certain things, or even putting certain witnesses or their own clients on the stand and then suborning perjury. So we need to make sure we're honest.
21:08And everything we present to the court and everything we present to the court, we're basically stating it's true and accurate to the best of our knowledge. So we need to really take it seriously when we do this. That, excuse me, 3.3 talks about offering evidence that the lawyer knows to be false if it's a client or a witness called, and that you've offered evidence that's a falsity. We shall take reasonable remedial measures, including, if necessary, disclosure to the tribunal before you disclose to the tribunal. Some other remedial measures could include talking with the client, having them correct it, going about it a different way. But again, ultimately, your duty of candor is to the tribunal. And so we have to make that disclosure.
21:54Do not forget that. So don't present false evidence, don't lie, and don't do anything like that to the tribunal because they don't like being lied to, just like you don't like being lied to. A judge probably hates it even more. And so make sure that we follow that disclosure to the tribunal and candor to the tribunal. Another one that can come up with evidence production is fairness to third parties. This one states that a lawyer shall not, shall not mandatory standard, not discretionary, mandatory standard, unlawfully obstruct another party's access to evidence or unlawfully alter case, destroy, conceal a document or other material having potential evidentiary value. We also cannot counsel or assist others to do so.
22:40This means if your client gives you a document that is very damning to their case, that it's, you know, the thing that's going to basically be their downfall. You can't say, oh, that just fell in the shredder. Or you can't say, oh, just don't give me that. If I don't know about it, I don't know about it. We need to be able to take evidence that may be harmful and be able to distinguish it or rehabilitate from it. But we cannot counsel our client to destroy it. We cannot counsel them to do something else with it. And we cannot do that ourselves either. You need to actually advise the client to put legal holds on stuff that would be relating to the litigation, especially, especially if it's pre litigation, and then tell them that they cannot destroy stuff. This includes social media posts, which is a big one that's had trouble over the years because a lot of clients, especially if they're on social media a lot, they want to post their entire day, week, year, down to the minute. And so when they get in, say like a car accident or they get in trouble, they post about it on social media. Then they come to you, the lawyer, and you say, don't post about this on social media. It's discoverable. Because that never crossed their mind. And they're like, okay, so they go delete it.
23:56You need to counsel the client. You cannot delete these things if you've already done them. Okay, save them, print them, give them to me so we can see what's out there, but don't destroy it. Or that's a violation. Spoliation of evidence and other things. It can also be a violation if they think you counsel them to delete it. Violation ethically for you under 3.4. And we'll also see here in a minute 4.1 and other rules. So we need to make sure that we talk to our clients about the truthfulness, obligation and that that extends to them too, because if they're lying and we know they're lying, then we're in trouble. So we need to make sure that we counsel them as well, especially with that evidence or falsifying or testifying falsely or anything like that that they normally tend to do.
24:46Also too, you can just read down further in the rule, it talks about like at trial, we can't allude to any matter that the lawyer knows, not what reasonably believe relevant. So this also goes to things that are, you know, kept out, or if something's not relevant to a case, you can't bring it up just to inflame like a jury or, you know, something like that unless it's allowed under some exception to the rules. So you have to remember those things as well. We also can't request a person other than a client refrain from voluntarily giving relevant information. So we can't threaten witnesses. We can't, you know, say, don't give the information or, you know, those different things. We have to let the fairness and justice system play out. And you have to be a good lawyer. Be a good lawyer means no matter what they throw at you, you rehabilitate it, you try to distinguish it. You say, oh, that's not a problem.
25:39We'll use this to counter it. Don't try to kill it, don't try to destroy it. Don't try to do something unethical. Play fair and play smart. Use the skills you learned, the critical thinking you learned in law school and since then, and be the better lawyer and do it ethically. Because at the end of the day, even though you feel like it doesn't win all the time to be the ethical lawyer, you're going to win in the end. The ones that are unethical, they may win here and there. They may get away with it for a year case or a few years or, you know, whatever part of their career. But ultimately it will also be their downfall. And it will affect their reputation.
26:19Because even if they don't get turned into the disciplinary commission or don't get in trouble with the disciplinary commission, everyone in the community normally knows who are the good ethical lawyers and who are the ones that lie, that destroy things, that cheat in court or that do those things, and the judges aren't oblivious to this either. So over time, your reputation will be what you make it. And so you need to make sure that that's on the ethical side, not the unethical side of things. We also have Rule 4.1, truthfulness in statements to others. This one states that in the course of representing a client, a lawyer shall not knowingly make a false statement of material fact or law to a third person or fail to disclose a material fact to a third person when disclosure is necessary to avoid a criminal or fraudulent act by a client unless prohibited by Rule 1.6.
27:12So this means we can't lie to third parties. We can't take on alter egos or alter identities like a lot of people or the public can. This includes on social media. When social media started coming out, lawyers got some lawyers got these grand ideas that they can make these fake profiles like, you know, teenagers and kids do, and have like five fake Instagrams or five fake accounts and then one real account. And then they're going to use those five fake accounts or one fake account to go befriend witnesses who they can't otherwise talk to, maybe, or befriend the opposing party to try to get in the scoop and see the stuff behind the scenes to where they're, you know, they can see the private stuff, not just the public stuff that's making a false statement. You're lying about who you are. Us as lawyers, we always have to be honest, especially when we're acting in our legal capacity.
28:08But anytime, really, because the rules apply to us 24 7. And we can't say we're disinterested or we can't claim to be someone we're not. If we call someone to talk to them about the case and they ask who you are, you can't say, oh, I'm just a friend of Joe's. Joe, being your client, you have to say, I'm a lawyer representing Joe. We have to be honest. We can't, you know, hide that fact because that's relevant, it's material because they may tell, you know, friend of Joe something that they wouldn't tell attorney of Joe. But we still can't lie about our identity. So we need to make sure we do that, too. Especially when trying to collect statements or different stuff in the background or anything like that on that evidence front. And then we do have to as well. If our client is assisting or using our services to assist them in committing a crime or fraud, we normally have to disclose that to a third party. Unless we can't for some reason.
29:09But we don't want to transform ourselves into an accomplice or being part of, you know, like that mob or that, you know, gang or whatever. We have to use our services for good. We can't counsel on anything that's against State or Federal law, that's 1.2 D as in dog in most jurisdictions. And so we do have that disclosure and being truthful to others in that respect as well. We also have. If that's not enough, we can violate Rule 4.4 with our honesty and ethics and just evidence collection and our rights to third parties. This one states that we shall not use means that have no substantial purpose other than to embarrass, delay, or burden a third person or use methods of obtaining evidence that violate the legal rights of that person. So this one always comes into mind when we're collecting evidence or during discovery, and you are asked to produce documents, or you're asked to produce something, or you just want to make it difficult on the other side. So you make your discovery quest so broad and not defined to a certain term or timeline, and then the other side is trying to produce 50 years of documents, or that's what the request entails because you didn't define it. Just because you want to run cost up in litigation or just because you want to give them a lot of work to do. And so you're using these tactics to embarrass, delay, or burden a third person. This can also mean you have that one document, and we've seen this done before in cases, and it's this, the key document, and the other side knows you have
30:46it, and they ask for it in production. But you take that one document, you put it in a file bin of thousand documents, then on top of that you stack about 20 other file bins of a thousand documents, and you produce it, and you say, oh, I produced it. Is that for the purpose of delaying, embarrassing, or burdening the third person, potentially, or another case here in evidence collection, if you have a request for production that's not even relevant, or an interrogatory that's not relevant to the proceeding, or you call a witness that's not relevant, has no relevancy. You're on a fishing expedition that can meet under this rule, too. So we need to be very careful on the strategic tactics, as we call them, that we use in evidence collection and in discovery, because it can violate the rules. Attorneys tend to forget that they always couch them as strategic tactics. This is how we play the game.
31:44And using those phraseology like strategic tactics, this is an advantage. This is how the game is played. Takes ethics out of their mind or is an excuse not to follow the fine line or black and white letter of our ethics rules. We do have to remember that sometimes those strategic advantages can lead to violations when it comes to it, one of the ones that comes to mind, just personally is when I was a young attorney, I was out of law school maybe a year or two. I was working for a partner at the time. And we had a deposition that day and I was going with the partner to the deposition, just a shadow to see, you know, what it was, you know, to learn. And I was waiting in our office lobby because the partner and I were going to drive over together to the deposition.
32:32And I notice it's five till, you know, one, the deposition's at one. Then I notice it's one o' clock and the partner's still in his office. So I go down to the office and say, hey, you know, the deposition is getting ready to start, we need to go. It's, you know, 10 minute drive. And the partner looks at me and says, nope, this is my advantage. I like to delay and be late because it pisses them off. And then maybe they're a little nicer, you know, they're a little more frazzled. Would that be a violation of Rule 4 4a potentially he's doing it on purpose to delay, embarrass or burden a third party. They're wasting their time. We had a set time. There was no reason we couldn't be there at that set time. Just depends on how you define it.
33:16So those things, and even there, the partner couched it as strategic advantage, or this is just a tactic to use to get under their skin, we could be violating the rules. So we need to be very careful on those things that we do under the guise of strategic advantage or tactfulness, when we are litigating our cases and getting evidence or collecting evidence or anything in between. We also too, the Last part of 4 4B actually deals with inadvertent disclosures. And so this would mean
33:53if you have a document that's considered privileged or confidential and say you're sending it, someone internally in your firm or your assistant is, and they inadvertently put the wrong email up there. We've all probably sent an inadvertent email or knowing someone that has. And then the privilege or confidential document goes to say, opposing counsel or a third party that it's not meant to go to, that's an inadvertent disclosure. So how do we rectify that? Because now that opposing party or that opposing counsel or has a document that they weren't supposed to get ever, and it could be something very disadvantaged to your client. And so the rule, this is the model rule, states that, you know, when those inadvertently Sent shall promptly notify the sender. So basically just says, if you receive something that you think is inadvertently sent or confidential, like you shouldn't have received it, you, as the recipient, has to contact the sender and basically say, hey, I think I received this in error. Now, the rule in the comments is different in every jurisdiction. Sometimes the comments to this rule go into what you should do from there, like, can you use it now? Can you use it against the person who sent it to you? Do you have to return it? Do you have to destroy it? Can you motion the court to use it? Like, what can you do now as the recipient of this inadvertent disclosure?
35:19And each jurisdiction is different. Some jurisdictions say you have to follow the instructions of the sender who inadvertently send it, meaning destroy it, not use it, those things. Other jurisdictions say it's free game. It's not your fault you received it, it's the person who sent its fault. They should have been more careful. So then they allow the recipient to use it as free game. Other jurisdictions say you can potentially use it, but only upon motion to the court and with leave of the court. And so you do have to look at your specific jurisdiction on what you do with those inadvertent disclosures. If you're the recipient of one or you're the sender of one. I'd rather be the recipient than the sender because the recipient at least gets to figure out if they can use it or not.
36:04The sender is just out of luck sometimes. So that too, when it's on evidence collection and what we're doing, just make sure we get, you know, those email addresses right or those things right, and that we don't inadvertently send evidence to the wrong party. Or we could have a 4.4 B violation, other things that we could have violations on. 8.4 is the big one. 8.4 A. We can't counsel others to do what we can't do, basically, or assist others in doing that. So if we can't do it under the rules, our assistants can't do it on the rules. If we can't have the fake identities to snoop on opposing parties, they can't have those either. So again, we can't counsel others to do it. We also cannot do anything. If we commit a criminal act that reflects adversely on our honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness, then we violate that rule.
36:55This can be anything from violating the rules, from lying that also kind of correlates into 8.4 C, engaging in conduct that's dishonest, fraud, or deceitful, and then to anything prejudicial to the administration of justice. They don't define prejudicial to the administration of justice in the rules or in the comments to this rule. So that is a very broad one, kind of like the kitchen sink. Catch all one. And so again, if you have any violations, especially for that trustworthiness, truthfulness, honesty, diligence, anything that we've talked about, or anything really in the rules, you could have a potential tack on violation here under Rule 8.4. So numerous things that you could violate in the evidence production. And then we also can't remember some of the last rules that we're going to point out here today. 5.1, 5.2 and 5.3. If you are a supervising attorney, mentor or someone in that supervisory role or manager role over other attorneys or non legal assistants, if they violate the rules, you violate the rules.
37:59So you need to make sure you train them, you need to make sure you supervise their conduct and, and you need to make sure that they are in adherence with these rules of truthfulness, honesty and all the things we've talked about with evidence. Because if they violate the rules, you as their supervisor, mentor, manager, you know, partner over them, violate the rules too. Even if it's not at your direct, explicit direction, you can still violate the rules because you have a duty to supervise, train and make sure they understand their obligations. So whoever you're supervising, mentoring, you know, reeducating them on the rules, on what is required with evidence collection, on their duties of honesty, and all those things are going to be paramount because it can affect your law license at the end of the day.
38:47So when we do these things, we need to make sure that we make ethical decisions in any type of evidence. The collection, the production, you know, putting stuff in front of the tribunal. We need to put ethics first. Now the ethics hat, like I said earlier, kind of tends to go to the wayside, we tend to forget about it, but we need to put it first. So before making any decision regarding evidence collection, evidence production, or anything with evidence, or just anything in general in a litigation or in a case you're working on, we need to pause and think. We need to think about the applicable rules. We need to consider what rules of ethics come into play, what rules of evidence come into play, and then make the best decision, taking both into consideration.
39:33Because sometimes, like I said earlier, what you can do that's admissible is not always ethical. So you need to just figure out what type of lawyer you want to be or how you're going to balance those decisions and it could be a case by case determination. Maybe sometimes you'll go with what's more admissible than ethical. Other times you'll go with what's more ethical than admissible. And so it just depends on what your decision is. And we're allowed that discretion. And whichever discretion you make, it's the reputation you're going to be building for yourself. So you need to make that determination for yourself what that's going to look like.
40:13That also means balancing our zealous advocacy, like we've kind of talked about too. Zealous advocacy is not gamesmanship. It's not, you know, being the best hunter, always taking ever every advantage. It doesn't necessarily mean winning at all cost. It means having a good strategy, which includes an ethics into that strategy. Credibility can also be more valuable than a single ruling too. So play the long game. Zealous advocacy is kind of an intelligence or even almost an emotional intelligence, or just like a professional intelligence of knowing when to pull back and knowing when to push forward or press a point.
41:02Pressing every point is not zealous advocacy. That's really called, you know, not very good lawyering sometimes, because sometimes we want to press things and sometimes we're like, we can let that slide. That really doesn't affect us. Let's let that one go. That's not worth our time. It's being able to decipher between those two things what is worth your time of pushing forward, especially when it comes to evidence and discovery and what is not worth your time. The lawyers that press everything and make a big deal out of everything get that reputation and they usually tend to violate the rules of ethics because they're not thinking, they're not figuring out what's best for that client. And sometimes it's best for one client's case is, is not best for another client's case. So you really have to look at both every client individually and every section and not just say, oh, we fight everything. Everything's a fight, everything's an argument. We don't want that. We want to make sure that we press the right advantages and that we don't press the other ones to make sure we stay within our ethical limits.
42:10We also too, remember I said initially we have to manage our client's expectations or what our client wants. A lot of times clients, clients want or perceive that a good lawyer is one who presses every advantage, who pushes every boundary, who is that person who's confrontational all the time. And that's what they want or that's what they expect. And counseling the client that that's not what real law is. That's maybe what they see in movies, but that's not what real law is. And advocating, you know, every day, we have to manage those expectations. We have to say no. We have to tell the client we're controlled by rules of professional conduct and that if they're going to insist upon certain conduct, we can't represent them because it's going to violate our rules.
42:58I don't know about you, but I'm not willing to lose my license for pretty much any client, maybe my husband or child, if it ever came down to that. But you worked hard for it. And is it worth losing for one client? Is it worth losing for taking the guess direction from a client who's asking you to do stuff that's going to violate the rules? If it is, then that's your decision. If it's not, then managing those expectations, making sure you tell clients that we are bound by rules of ethics and that some of the stuff that they ask us to do may not be in compliance with those and that we have to say no for that.
43:38So we need to also educate our clients and educate them on what we can and cannot do. One of those big areas, like we've briefly talked about already, is that preservation of evidence, you know, not destroying stuff. Remember that ethics rule? Clients, like I said then too, when we're discussing that ethics rule, like to destroy stuff that's going to hurt them because in their mind, they're like, well, no one's going to know I destroyed it. Well, no one's going to know it was there. No one's going to know I deleted that email. No one's going to know. That's kind of what they always say. And the thing is, there's metadata, people know there's witnesses.
44:17And if it comes out later, it's going to be way worse than if we would have just had that evidence up front, distinguish it, used it, you know, in a way that could be advantageous to us, then it would have been way better. And now we're going to be hit with potential ethical violations, foliation of evidence, and all kinds of other things. Kinds of things. Because of that, oh, they'll never know. Let's just delete this. Let's just, you know, lie about this. And so we do need to think about those things and counsel the client on them and make sure they know of their duty to preserve evidence, especially when litigation is foreseeable. Those Are those litigation holds that we can put into place, because otherwise we are going to run into spoliation claims and that. So make sure, especially if you represent companies and corporations, that they put those litigation holds out there. And also to include in their informal communication, such as text messages and, you know, Slack messages, that's like an online instant messenger.
45:21Different things. Because a lot of litigation holds that I've seen don't include those things. They just include emails or documents. But sometimes the substance of what you're looking for, the substance of what's going to be pertinent to the case, came across through maybe a Slack message or a Zoom chat message or something like that. And so if you don't. And those don't stay for a long period of time, I know, like on Zoom, sometimes the chat feature only lasts, you know, 48 hours, or you can program it to last longer, and it may be saved somewhere else too. But they have a very short retention of certain things. So we need to make sure that we have those, especially in our litigation, hold for that too.
46:03Otherwise we could be hit with a violation that we weren't expecting or an ethics complaint that we weren't expecting. So making sure we have this oversight of our clients, making sure they understand it, and then two, don't ignore client misconduct. Don't ignore it when it goes wrong. Talk to them about it. Try to rectify the situation, because you don't want your license jeopardized and you don't want to be in a situation to where you're going to have to go to the tribunal to disclose something the client did because they won't correct it themselves. And you have that obligation, or 3.3, not to lie to the tribunal and to correct any misstatements. So we want to try to keep them in this position where we don't have to breach. 1.6. They understand their duties. They understand our duties of ethics and what trumps what and that we're all on the same page now when it comes to introducing evidence at trial.
46:57Obviously, evidence has to be truthful, honest, just like testimony, real evidence, those different things. It cannot mislead the tribunal. Make sure it is accurate. Not just technically accurate, but accurate information. A lot of times attorneys will say, well, it's, it's accurate. I just left this off. You know, that lie by omission or that white lie, or you just glaze it over and summarize it, and then next thing we know, it sounds like the opposite of what it really was supposed to be. So we do have to look at our wording, phraseology, lies by omission, white lies, lies or lies. Whether it's lie by omission or white lie, lies or lies, and dishonesty is dishonesty. So we need to make sure we do the right thing when presenting evidence.
47:41Now there's different kinds of evidence that can be implicated, you know, when we're presenting it. And the rules that we've talked about can come into play here if we're presenting that real evidence, the hard evidence like our fingerprints, footprints, DNA, you know, stuff that we can feel, touch or, you know, that's there, camera footage, stuff that's, you know, showing the facts of the case or showing different things. We obviously don't want to manipulate it, we don't want to destroy it. We, we don't want to lie about results or fudge results or change results. Those are all implicated in those truth rules. We can violate the rules of ethics there.
48:16We just need to present and distinguish or, you know, have rebuttal for what's presented. If it hurts your client, be a lawyer. That's why you critically think, you're like, okay, we have this bad information, how do we pivot from it? How do we, how do we justify it? How do we get a rebuttal in here? We shouldn't go straight to, well, how do we get rid of it, how do we destroy it, how do we change it, how do we manipulate it? We don't want to do that. That's going to be violating those truth seeking functions and we want to stay away from that. We also have improperly obtained evidence that could come in. We don't want to lie about where it came from. If it's something that's illegally obtained, then we probably in most instances can't use it in court unless, you know, you have an exception or something else applies. You don't misuse your subpoena power either to subpoena things that you know you're not supposed to be getting or inadvertently disclose things. Watch out for illegal wiretaps. We can't use that evidence in court in most cases. Or stealing documents from employer. If there's an employer and client situation involved, just make sure you know the origins of where your evidence because you've got to obviously give it a foundation in court to get it into court. And if you can't say where it came from and lay that foundation, then you're going to have a problem.
49:40And so again, just watch out for that. Again, truth seeking function of the court. We have to be Honest in what we put forward. Same thing with our testimonial evidence. Like I said, we can't counsel our clients or witnesses to lie. We have to correct misstatements on the record. We want to make sure that they give the truth. Now, with testimonial evidence, there is the thing where we have witness preparation. We need to tell witnesses to tell the truth. There's a difference between preparing a witness and scripting a witness. We want to prepare them for the kinds of questions we're going to ask. We want to hear their responses. We don't want to give them a script, we don't want to feed them information, and we don't want to recreate memories or create memories that they don't have. There's a difference between refreshing the recollection, meaning showing them something and then in their mind they remember it, or altering a memory. Say if you show them something, you're like, I don't remember that. You say, yeah, you do. And you try to, you know, alter it. You try to tell them the facts, and they're like, oh, yeah, you're probably right. And so then they create this memory that they don't really remember. So we have to find this fine line between truth telling, obviously, first and foremost.
50:50But we cannot script. We. We cannot alter memories. We can refresh, but we can't alter. We're stuck with what we're stuck with, and we need to work with what we have. And don't cross that ethical line. Don't be the scripter. Don't tell them to say a certain thing. Just prepare them, give them direct questions so they're used to them and their responses and how they're going to phrase it and tell the truth, and then cross examine them and teach them how to answer questions. Just the question asked. But don't script it. Don't tell them to lie. So there's this fine line on the witness preparation that we need to be aware of, too, and that we need to be cognizant of. We also have demonstrative evidence that can be presented in court. This is evidence. Normally I call it evidence, but it's demonstrative things that we create ourselves based on real evidence or based on timelines or factual situations to aid the jury and the judge in understanding the facts. This can be maps, this can be timelines, diagrams, graphs, charts, all kinds of things that we create. We need to make sure anything we create is honest, is truthful, is not misleading.
51:55And also remember too, with demonstrative evidence, if you create something, it can be used against you by opposing counsel. So if you're dishonest in whatever evidence map or whatever you've created or recreation, they can pull it apart and show where you didn't show it correctly or didn't have the proper timeline. And, and so again, we need to be honest and present things forward or demonstrative evidence. Why you think it's going to help you with the jury and the judge and explain things better can actually harm you if you've done it so bad and so wrong that opposing counsel now uses it against you.
52:31So we need to make sure that the demonstrative or the monstrous are fairly represented by the evidence that they're accurate. It's visual persuasion. We don't want to distort, sort things with it, otherwise it can hurt us. Some other evidence to consider. Evidentiary evidence. Letters, contracts, newspapers, Bibles. These things normally speak for themselves. So don't alter them, don't do different things. Just let them speak for themselves. Let them present, you know, as they are, read passages out of them, do what you need. But again, they normally speak for themselves. We just need to be honest in that production or in that use of the documentary evidence with it. Some red flags in presentation. If you're presenting something in evidence in court or otherwise, don't omit key facts, don't overstate your conclusions.
53:21Present disputed facts. Presenting disputed facts as settled is also another red flag. If it's disputed, it's disputed. If it's settled, it's a settled fact that's uncontested. Don't exaggerate, don't try to elude something's one thing when it's really another. Just be honest. Like that is what is lacking. A lot of times where lawyers get in trouble is they think they have to lie to win. Just be honest and play an honest proceeding. The seek the truth seeking function, the justice function, fairness function. We have to remember that is the backbone of the judicial system. And what we are here to do is that truth seeking function. We're not here as lawyers for gamesmanship or to annihilate our opponent, or we're here to seek the truth, to seek compromises, to seek resolution of matters. So again, we have to remember our purpose in the law. Yes, we want to win for our client, we want to do the best. But our ultimate purpose is that justice, that truth seeking function too. Just like the judiciary, be careful with lately or late discovered evidence.
54:28Timing of disclosures does matter. You do have a duty to supplement throughout the discovery phase and thereafter, strategic Delays can create ethical exposure. Kind of like the deposition thing I told you about when I was a young lawyer. Strategic delays can be dishonest. They can be that embarrassment, harassment, or delay we talked about in the rules. So if you're delaying turning over evidence, you're delaying not disclosing a witness until, you know, pops up in court to surprise the opponent. You could have some ethical violations come your way. So again, those strategic advantages or what we coin is, that can be ethical violations. So make sure we look at what we're doing and how we're litigating and advocating for our clients. We also need to use ethical objections, or use of objections ethically, better phrase. That way.
55:21Objections are not weapons. They are there to reinforce evidentiary rules and keep good faith, legal basis. Make sure they have that. But objections are there to keep fairness in the proceedings and parties in check of what should be the basis or what is allowed under the rules and evidence. And not going beyond it, not expanding it, just bringing it back to, you know, what's relevant and what is there. They're not there for abuse. They're not there to delay the proceeding or, you know, not turn over anything. It's like, oh, we'll just object. We won't to turn over anything. That's not what they're there for. They're there to keep the evidentiary rules in check so that people don't try to expand them.
56:01But you still have to respond to things, so use them ethically. Objections used to delay or harass can be ethical violations. Pattern for baseless objections can be an ethical violation. Coaching witnesses through objections, meaning if someone is testifying and you object and then your objection's long and in that you're kind of signaling to the deponent or the witness how to answer the question that can be unethical because now you're feeding them or scripting them testimony. Be very careful with your objections because they can lead to ethical violations, which is what something we don't want to do. We also need to make sure we have candor in our evidentiary arguments. Make sure they're accurate, basis of law and fact, not selective or misleading in our citations or what we put in there.
56:50And we have again, that duty to correct any false statements. So in arguments and evidence production, in witnesses and objections, this duty of truthfulness carries throughout everything. So we often, because we can have sanctions, discipline, or other things brought against us if we don't act in accordance with the rules of professional conduct. And two, professionalism can also be a violation. How you act when you present stuff different things like that can also har. And professionalism is one of the biggest downfalls of lawyers because we get in this mind that we have to be these zealous advocates, press every advantage, yell, scream, act mean in court, act like we hate the other person or even believe we hate the other person when the opposing counsel could be your best friend if you just act civilly with them. And so that professionalism too, in exchanging evidence, presenting evidence, can lead to also ethical violations that we want to shy away from with that. We are coming here at the end of the hour. We have about one minute left, a little under one minute. So I want to give you that code verbally. It is D as in dog, Q as in Queen, J as in jack, the number 7 and n as in Nancy. Again, that's D as in dog, Q as in Queen, J as in Jack, the number 7 and n is in Nancy. Make sure you write that down. Exit out of today's seminar, go to your LexFit account. Enter it where prompted to get your CLE credit. I thank everyone again for your cooperation and patience regarding the wrong times or the time change. And I hope
58:31everyone has a wonderful afternoon. Thank you.