1h 6min · about 10,400 words
0:01Hi, my name is Russell petty, and our class today is going to be about the fundamentals of ERISA litigation. We're going to start at the top how you recognize the case is governed by ERISA walkthrough. exhausting your administrative remedies. Now, what causes of action may exist? What evidence is allowed or received trials? motions for attorney fees from pretty much from soup to nuts? So if, if you're somebody who's inexperienced that or receive cases or who has never done one, and is thinking that you'd like to try this, this is the course for you now. What if you're not one of those people? Why are you continuing to, to listen to this instead of, you know, turning the sound down so you can get your MC le credits and doing useful work? Well, I could give you three reasons. Why, even if you're not planning on being an Ursa practitioner, even if you're never going to handle Ursa cases, this is still probably a good lecture to listen to. And, and the first is, well, if you're never going to handle Arista cases, how are you going to know if you can't recognize an Ursa case? The the time to learn that your case is governed by ERISA is not after you've filed a lawsuit. It's before you file a lawsuit. And I could I can tell you, from my experience over on the defense side, I do mostly plaintiffs work now, but I, you know, learned Russ on the defense side, I can tell you my experience on the defense side is there's a lot of guys out there that don't think they handle Arista cases and find out they do when the notice of removal and the
1:39motion to dismiss based on a risk of preemption comes in the door. And those guys are generally sad when that happens. And so you people don't be sad, learn in advance if your case is governed by a Rison, you know, if it is either learn how to do an Ursa case or find some guy with low social skills, who's who's willing to take it off your hand for you. Another reason is why you're you're looking for that guy, to take the case off your hands have a recess has got some very aggressive and very dangerous statute of limitations. The there are three and maybe four statutes that that you need to worry about. I use statute loosely because they're not all statutes, but they accrue at different times, and some of them could be wickedly short. And so you need to hear what I have to say. But protecting yourself. While that case, you never get a handle is sitting on your desk until you've figured out some other place to put it. And finally, in a lot of cases, a risk of loss spills off into other areas of law. And one of the things that's going to be particularly useful to you personal injury specialists is here's a case, which is probably come up with most of you you've mail your client injured in a in a traffic accident, and you I've just gotten a nice settlement on his behalf from the other side. And just as the as the money hits your trust account, you get a notice from this guy's your clients health plan that says hi, we we'd like all of that money, please.
3:18Thanks very much. Can they do that? Well, yeah, they turn I'll let you know. In all cases, the the first issue is always going to be Is there a risk? Is this case governed by ERISA? And you know, there's a number of factors that play into that. Is there a plan, the plan established and maintained by an employer, employee organization? Is the employer the right kind of employer? Are their employees in the plan? And does it provide the right kind of benefits? And let me you know, back off for just a second, you know, I'm not going to cover you're getting a very comprehensive outline with this course.
4:03And so I'm not going to cover everything in detail. There's some stuff that's fairly self explanatory. And I'm going to sometimes rush over that and focus more on the stuff that that I think is interesting. Interesting, being a relative term, given that we're, we're talking about a risk of here. Is there a plan? What do you need to have a plan? Well, you know, you don't need much, you need to have a writing, it's got to be in writing. It's got to be a document that identifies who your beneficiaries are, you know, who's entitled to get benefits, and under what circumstances they're going to get benefits and how the benefits are, are going to be paid. And if you've got that document, you know, people say you can have a you can have a risk plan written on a cocktail napkin, although I bet I've never seen that but I guess that's possible.
4:55The there are some limits, though as to what what constitutes a plan, because a plan sort of, you know, denotes ongoing administrative activity. And if you haven't got ongoing administrative activity, then you you may not have a have a plan, for example, in the fort Halifax case, the, the government of Maine, state of Maine required employers who were leaving the state to provide one time severance pay to their to their employees and the employer, one of the employers complained and said, Well, you know, it's preempted by by ERISA, and the Supreme Court said, No, a one time payment does not constitute sufficient ongoing administrative activity in order to in order to constitute a plan. And sort of a related front. We have what are known as payroll practices. payroll practices are basically carve outs from Marisa that are set out in the Department of Labor regulations. And the Ninth Circuit has said, yeah, that that's okay. These these claims aren't governed by by ERISA, a lot of them are sort of things you think of payroll practice, you know, overtime, pay vacation, pay the, you know, pay while you're on a on a sabbatical, but there's one area where the payroll practice looks an awful lot like an ERISA plan. And that's a, when you're dealing with a self funded plan for short term disability benefits. I just use the term, you may not all understand some of these sort of backup for a second, and talk about what I mean by self funded plan. We talked earlier about how a plan has got to have a funding source. Okay. Now, there's two funding
6:51sources that are generally used for an ERISA plan. One is where the employer pays the benefits out of its own pocket. And that's called a self funded plan, or self explanatory, it's funded by the by the employer. The other is where the employer goes out and buys a policy of insurance, that group policy of insurance to cover the employees. And that's called an insured plan. So you've got a situation where the employer has an agreement with the the employees, you, you become disabled from your job, I'll continue your salary for 26 weeks, pick a number of random, that kind of looks like self funded ERISA plan. Under the do well, regulations, it's going to be a payroll practice. If, and here's the big if this is determinative, what's the funding source, if the funding source is the same funding source that the employer uses to pay regular salary, ie, you know, the same same checking account, then it's going to be found to be a payroll practice. On the other hand, if the employer has set up a trust of some kind, where parks the money in advance to be used to pay the, the short term disability, then what you're gonna have is you're gonna have an actual ERISA plan. So that's something that that you're just gonna have to look at when that case comes in the door. Okay, the next question we have is, if you've got a plan, is it established or maintained by an employer or an employee organization? What does that mean established or maintained? Well, you know, the, and this is set out in the course materials, there's, you know, Department of
8:36Labor, safe harbor regulations that sort of set out the things that an employer is allowed to do without establishing or maintaining the plan subject to to a risk, but the bottom line answer is the employer doesn't have to do very much to have established or maintained an ERISA plan. The employers allowed to allow the insurance company guy to come in and sell his product to the employees to sign them up. And also to do the premium check offs. In other words, taking the premium out of the employees paychecks and forwarding them to the insurance company. If that's all the employer does, then it's not the employer is not established or maintained the plan. Subject to ERISA. If the employer does anything else puts its name on a summary plan description sends out a brochure advertising the benefits of this plan, then at that point, that's endorsement. And at that point, you have a you have an ERISA plan. The
9:44sub not all employers are equal when it comes to to ERISA, the when the government in its infinite wisdom decided to pass a risk, of course it exempted itself. And so if it's a quote, government plan, ie A plan that established or maintained by a governmental entity, then it's not subject to ERISA. Church plans are the same. If it's a plan established or maintained by a church, then it's not going to be subject to ERISA. Is it a governmental entity? Well, you know, most of the time, what is the government allowance? This time? It's pretty easy. You know, it's the FBI, the Department of Defense, the Internal Revenue Service, okay. Sometimes it gets a little more esoteric when you've got a government agencies. Sometimes it's it's, I once had a case with the West Los Angeles regional center, that a governmental entity or not, well, you know, you had to do a lot of research and digging in order to establish this happens with respect to hospitals all the time. Sometimes a hospital is a governmental entity.
10:53Sometimes it's not, sometimes it's sort of on the border. And there's a complicated test in Arista, which set out in the case law, and I've provided that in the course materials, if you ever have a situation like that. One caveat, by the way. The you know, your client is a school teacher who works for local school district, and you're saying to yourself, okay, you know, governmental, governmental entity. So Arista doesn't apply. But you need to look at, not who the employer is, but who sponsors the plan. It's entirely possible the plan is sponsored by the local teachers union, which is an employee organization. And so therefore, you're you're sort of backed into a Risa ERISA coverage.
11:42The church plans, church plans are easy. The, for once there's a simple answer, the the IRS thinks it's a church, then for our purposes, it's a church. And if the IRS doesn't think it's a church, then for for risk purposes, it's not so that, you know, your client is employed by the Lutheran Church, then it's going to be exempt from ERISA. If employed by the Church of Satan, I didn't know the Church of Satan was, you know, giving disability benefits. But you know, you'd have to look and see what the IRS has to say about that. about that. The, okay, the, here's an issue that comes up, comes up a fair bit, which is whether the plan covers employees, the because it's the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, and so if you have a plan that doesn't have any employees in it, then it's not governed by by ERISA. So if, for example, you know, you've got a, you know, a small accounting firm, and the three partners get together and they, you know, take a disability group disability policy out on, you know, covers all three of them, that's not going to be covered by ERISA, because none of them are employees, they're owners of the business, but not so fast. The case, ninth circuit case, Peterson, involved a small business just like that with some, some partners, and some, some employees, you know, secretarial staff and that sort of thing, and they had one health plan that covered everybody covered by ERISA. Right, then what happened is they found a better deal for a health plan. And so they all changed to a different health plan, except for one of the
13:42partners, Mr. Peterson, who had a pre existing condition, they wouldn't let him in that health plan. So he had to stand with the old plan. So now you've got two health plans. Mr. Peterson's is just, it's just partners, no, no employees at all. And, you know, their insurance company doesn't want to pay and he makes a claim. Is it covered by ERISA? Well, you know, the Ninth Circuit said, Well, you know, you have to look at the employer's plans as a whole. And while this particular plan just has partners or other plans that have partners and employees, and so looking at it as a whole, we've got sort of one great big happy Ursa family. That case might have made sense in that context. But you know,
14:32people get greedy, you know, you know, pigs get fat and hogs get slaughtered. And so the next case to come along, involved a
14:41situation where the, the owner of the business, got a disability policy on himself. You know, he was the only person covered, you know, but, you know, the insurance company looks through its file and read realizes that he's he's making payments for this policy from, from a business account. Why? I don't know, maybe he was he was taking the the tax deductions and why not the. But anyway, when he makes a claim, they say, Well, this is governed by ERISA. Because you know, your plan, you're the only person in this disability plan, but you also maintain a health plan for your employees and under Peterson, we have to look at the scope of the employee plans as a whole. And, you know, the Ninth Circuit says not so fast, and said there has to be some sort of relationship between the two plans before we're going to consider them together and determining whether Arista coverage exists. And so this is an area where, you know, you could count on people who represent insurance companies and plans, being aggressive, and attempting to take your state law insurance coverage and turn it into an ERISA plan. And, you know, if you're on the other side, you have to be just as aggressive in defending the lack of ERISA coverage.
16:04The Okay, the right kind of benefits, we're talking about payroll practices, the, you know, the garden variety or receive benefits or things like, you know, life insurance, accidental death, health, disability, pension, the technically the statute covers vacation, pay, but the, you know, the ninth step, courts have said, No, we're not gonna, we're not going to look at you know, vacation pay is a subset of Ursa. The. So anyway, those are the factors that make up whether a plan is governed by ERISA. And, you know, the good news is most of the time, it's really pretty simple. Most of the time, it's fairly obvious, you know, the guy is employed by XYZ widget company, and it's clearly a private employer and XYZ widget has contracted with the ABC insurance company and purchased a group policy that it pays premiums on for its employees. And that's the paradigm plan. And so that's what you've got 95% of the time, it's, you know, the 5% is on the margin where where maybe you need to, you need to call somebody if you're unsure.
17:15The okay. I, I told you folks that at the beginning that we would be talking about some very dangerous and sometimes very short limitation periods that did that exist with respect to Ursa. And so that's what we're going to talk about next. The Arista, at least with respect to benefit claims, which is what we're focused on here today doesn't contain an internal statute of limitations. And so the courts have said, we're going to borrow from the most closely related state statute limitations, which here in California is the the four year statute limitations for breach of contract. And so that's pretty good, got four years from the breach, to to file a lawsuit now, the ones that statute start to accrue. There's been some fits and starts with respect to that. But eventually, the Ninth Circuit settled on a rule that again, makes sense. At the time of the final denial.
18:25We're going to talk about exhaustion of remedies in a little bit. The but you're going to go through two and sometimes maybe three denials, before your administrative remedies are exhausted, and you get to file a lawsuit. And the ninth circuit is essentially said that four year statute of limitations starts to accrue, that the time you have the right to file a lawsuit, which kind of makes sense. The that's where pretty much starts making sense the because with respect to that four year statute of limitations, that's assuming there's not a shorter limitation period that's contained somewhere in the plan, which the court is going to uphold the
19:09some of the shorter limitation periods could be wickedly short. I had one case where it was six months, I've seen another case where it was three months, that the courts held to be a reasonable limitation period. And remember, you're not going to get a notice of this. There's no requirement, at least with respect to a self funded plan that they tell you in the final denial letter. Oh, by the way, three months from now, and you're out of court. Hey, so so you need to find the plan, the summary plan description or the plan right away and look at it and see if you've got one of these shortened periods limitations that sometimes that could be tough. I mean, some of these are, there is one of these cases involving a shortened limitation period where the district judge himself in refusing to uphold The limitation said, You know, I looked through the plan myself, I couldn't find the limitation period until one of the lawyers pointed out to me where it was. But the Ninth Circuit has taken that exact same plan. But that exact same confusing language and in the shark case held that the the insured was on notice that the, of the shortened limitation period, so you've got your four year and then it could be shorter. Okay. That's your first problem. Your second problem is, with respect to administrative appeal rights, the courts have said you've got to appeal before you can bring the matter to court. And the regulations say that the plan is allowed to put a minimum time period for the appeal. Basically, that minimum time period is 60
20:56days, generally, in the case of disability plans, 180 days, that's the minimum, that's the floor. But of course, that's the number all the plans have adopted. So, you know, you can be sure that they're not, you know, they're not given any help to the insurance, and they're taking the lowest possible figure. And so those are the numbers that should stick in your head 60 days for wife and adnd, and health benefits, and 180 days for, for disability. You let that time period lapse, and you're done. So, when you have a case that you suspect is Arista, you have to get right away a copy of the most recent denial letter. And fortunately, they are required to put the appeal rights and the time period for the appeal right in the denial letter. And so you get yourself right off the bat a copy of the denial letter, and you'll look at it and it's gonna either be a final denial, in which case, you know, the appeal rights have been exhausted, you've got the right to file a lawsuit, and then it's going to be either four years or the shortened period that we just talked about, or else you're in the process of the appellate procedure. And they're going to say, you know, you have 60 or 180 days to file an appeal from the date of this letter, and you calendar that date, and that's a drop dead date that you make sure that you've got to that you've got to meet the so what happens, as happens, the
22:29where the insured shows up, and the date has already been blown. I mean, you know, 60 days is not a lot of time, the what happens if the, you know, took took two months for the for the person to find the lawyer. Well, you know, all it's not necessarily lost, could be not necessarily the one of the things you need to look for is to see if that limitation on the time to appeal is contained in the actual plan itself. I'd say about half the times it's not, you know, basically the the person who wrote the denial letter, put that in the denial letter, but you can't create plan terms by writing them in the denial letter.
23:13It's got to be actually in the plan itself. And so take a look at the plan that may give you a that may give you an out. Okay, I mentioned Another problem with the statute of limitations. And that's the, you know, the Supreme Court serve, you know, parachutes into the world of ERISA about once a year and then generally, you know, muddles things up, and they certainly did. So with respect to the statute of limitations. They did so by interpreting a decade's old pre Orissa piece of model insurance code, which because it's part of a model insurance code has been adopted by most state legislators, without anybody really understanding what it means and just sort of plug randomly into into insurance policies, again, without necessarily anybody understanding what it means. And the what this provision says, in effect is that you've got that no legal action could be brought. After three years, from the time proof of claim is required.
24:26What does that mean?
24:29Most of have these insurance policies have a section on when proof of claim is required. And it's generally you know, 20 to 60 days or, you know, two months or, you know, some fairly short period from when the Disability Claim begins. So, what does that mean exactly? Well, you know, read literally in courts have been reluctant to sort of read that literally, you know, because most long term to Ability policies, for example, have a, you know, 180 day elimination period, no benefits are paid for the first 180 days? Well, you know, you're not going to get a decision from, you know, the insurance company within two months or three months, it's probably going to take more like about six months or nine months or sometimes a year, before they actually get around to denying your clients claim, which means red literally, this statute will allow the statute of limitations is three years statute of limitations to begin running, before there's actually been a denial. So not only do you not have the president right to take the case to court, the claim hasn't even been denied yet, and your limitations period is running? Well, no one would would would dream of interpreting the statute in that fashion until the Supreme Court did just that. Thank you, justice.
25:52Thomas, under haima shop, that's another period, you have to look at, you've got to look at when the policy says, proof of claim is required. Take three years from there, that's when you have to, that's when you have to make sure the claim is on file. Now. One of the reasons why the high mashrafe decision was, in my humble opinion, very badly thought out, is it didn't take into consideration the fact that sometimes the insurer or the ERISA plan is going to pay benefits for a while before it denies the claim. And that under the reasoning of heimish off the that period, when it's been paying benefits, is the statute limitations is going to be accruing that entire time, even though the insurance company's paying benefits. And so let me give you, you know, sort of a sort of a hypothetical, the now the claimant makes a claim for for disability benefits, most policies and this one does most policies that group policies have two definitions of disability, the first 24 months, it's if you're disabled from your own occupation, beyond that, if you're disabled from any occupation for which you're reasonably fitted by training experience, and what have you, the so the insurance company as oftentimes they do pays for the first 24 months, and then denies. So you've got the six month elimination period, and let's say, for those months, or after the time when proof of claim has to be received, and then you've got the 24 months that it paid benefits. And so now we're talking about two years and four months. And then after the denial of the own
27:39occupation, the the client does perone appeal, and C six takes them six months to to handle the the appeal, well take another couple of months to find a lawyer. And so when that claimant is sitting across the desk from you, and hand you a denial letter that may just be a couple of months old and says, you know, help me Obi Wan, you're my only hope. You know, you just haven't been handed a denial letter even handed a hand grenade, because you've got sitting there a claim that looks like it's brand new, and the statute of limitations is going to run in a couple of months. So, you know, you need to look at these need to look at them right away in order to protect yourself. The okay.
28:32In the previous section, we talked about exhausting admin administrative remedies, and the law here is all fairly settled. And so I'm going to cover this relatively briefly. Basically, you know, the court has got discretion to allow a lawsuit without, without exhausting, but they rarely exercise that discretion. So go ahead and exhaust do whatever it is the plan tells you you need to do you know, if they say you've got to appeal appeal, sometimes you have to do two appeals. Sometimes they say they want another appeal, but plan only allows one I mean, you can you can live with whatever it is the plan tells you to, to do. And so, you know, you need to do that in order so that the district judge will will keep your case but you know, really appeals are your friend. Okay, and the reason why appeals are your friend is and we're going to talk about this in in a later section. For the most part, once you're in litigation, you're not allowed to introduce evidence, which is not in the quote, administrative record the administrative record being a sort of a fancy name for, you know, the insurance company's claim file. So if it's not in the claim file, the judge isn't going to look at it. So the appeal is your opportunity to lard up the record with all the good stuff, you know, the medical records statements by the doctors, you know, the declaration by your clients, sort of whatever It'll be helpful in, you know, whatever you're gonna want the judge to look at later. So you've got to exhaust in order to keep the judge happy, make sure that he or
30:08she'll take your case. And of course, the appeal process is the process in which you're allowed to, to get the get the evidence that you need to proceed to trial. Okay, when it does come to now got a letter from the insurance company or from the plan that says your your appeals are exhausted, and you could file a lawsuit? Well, with that, let's talk real briefly about about parties. This is an issue that that was subject to some confusion back in the back in the day, although it's, it's sort of gotten sorted out a little bit now. And I'm just going to tell you sort of the bottom line, the used to be, you have to sue the plan entity. What does that mean, exactly? That means, you know, you've got the XYZ widget company, if it's a disability case, you would sue. You know, just kind of make up the name. I mean, literally, that that's that's kind of what you do the XYZ widget company, Long Term Disability plan, and yeah, that's who you put on the caption, and there'll be a lawyer actually shows up to defend the even though he just made up that name. You know, Your Honor, this is, you know, Joe, defense lawyer representing the XYZ company, which had company Long Term Disability plan, the. So that's what you used to do. And you could still do that. The, but in a fairly recent, on bunk decision, the Ninth Circuit decided that, that Now, if you've got an insured plan, and if the funding is from the insurance company, and the insurance company, made the decision, all by its lonesome without any input from the employer, you can
31:56just go ahead and sue the the the insurance company. And so that's, that simplifies things. But here's the caution, I would only do that, if you're sure that it's an insured plan. Because, you know, what happens in a lot of these self funded plans, is the employer is going to, you know, pay the benefits, but doesn't want to have to decide whether benefits are payable. And so it's going to hire a insurance company, to be what we call a TPA, or third party administrator. So you know, you look through the file, and you see, you know, the denial letter, and all the other letters were, you know, came from an insurance company, and you say to yourself, aha, it's a, it's an insured plan, I could just sue the insurance company. And then when you sue the insurance company, you get a, you know, 12 b six motion, because, you know, not so fast, it turns out that it's a self funded plan, with a third party administrator, when in doubt, just sue the plan entity. And, you know, the look, the other side, sort out who the who the proper, proper defendant is the talk about what claims you bring a risk of causes of action are purely statutory and nature. And if the cause of action that you're seeking to bring is not contained, within 29, United States Code, section 1132, which is where the limitations period are located, then, from a risk point of view, it doesn't exist, it's preempted by ERISA, and you can't bring it with interested because it's not one of the enumerated causes of action. The,
33:38we're going to talk about three today of those, those causes of action, the one of them, because it's the one that you're going to use all the time, and irisa benefits cases. Another one be, it's not going to, you know, be used very often, but it might be important to at some point. And so I'm just going to point out the fact that it exists. And then the third, which is an area where there's been a lot of legal activity, and the law has been changing, changing about once every couple of years or so in. So I'm going to, and this is one of these areas, it's interesting of interest to you, personal injury guys. And so I'm going to spend a little time talking about that. The first we're going to talk about the, you know, the workhorse of a risk of litigation, which is
34:2929, United States Code Section 1132 a one B, that's the claim by a participant or beneficiary to recover benefits under the plan to enforce his rights under the plan, or to clarify his rights with respect to the plan. Got a claimant who's been denied benefits 9095 99% of the time, that's the cause of action that that you're going to want to Web being on a brain, the that's where you can force the plan to pay benefits that it doesn't want to pay. That's kind of mentioned early to soul exclusive remedy, breach of contract, bad faith, all those things are are preempted by ERISA. So if you want the plan to pay benefits, you bring a claim under 1132 a one B. What are you entitled to? In a claim for 1132? a, one B? Well, you're entitled to the benefits that should have been paid, but weren't. And a reasonable attorney fee, which we're going to talk about a little bit a little bit later.
35:44The what Aren't you entitled to? And the answer is pretty much anything else. consequential damages aren't allowed in Ursa cases. If you're going to be an aggressive practitioner, you get good at given this speech, because pretty much all your clients say You mean, you know, I lost my house? Because the because the they wouldn't pay my disability benefits? Or, you know, I? Because they wouldn't pay for the hospitalization? I got way sicker. And can we recover for that? And the answer is always No, you just can't. smarter lawyers and I have been trying for decades to figure out some way around the bar on consequential or punitive damages that are really the case with with very limited success. Okay, the second risk claim for relief I'm going to talk about is a fiduciary duty claim under 1132. A to that's a claim for breach of fiduciary duty. And so you say, Well, that sounds okay, breach of fiduciary duty sounds fairly, fairly broad, we should be able to shoehorn all sorts of stuff into that. problem being that the courts have held, that the relief allowed under an 1132 A to claim is limited to relief that enters to the plan itself, meaning your client doesn't get anything other than what he or she would be entitled to get as a participant or beneficiary in a plan. So what good is it well, in many respects, not very, the where you would use this claim, the paradigm cases, you know, your small employer, who rather than putting the money into the trust to fund benefits, decides to keep it for himself. At
37:34that point, you'd have a claim for you know, a to breach of fiduciary duty, and make him pay the money back into the back into the plan so that it can be distributed to the to the employers, employees, I'm sorry, the the growth area that we talked about is claims for appropriate equitable relief under Section 1132. A three, the scope of 1132 a three at this point is somewhat uncertain. There's been a lot of judicial decisions with respect to this. The and both plans and participants IE claimants have been using this section in order to attempt to fill some of the gaps in in ERISA remedies. But what 1130 283 provides, it allows a claim for, as I say, appropriate, equitable relief, to remedy a violation of the plan or to enforce a provision of the plan. So what you've got to have is you've gotta have a violation of the plan, somebody who's doing something other than what the plan says or refusing to do with the plan says, and you've got to have equitable relief, that somehow could could correct that, that problem more or enforce the plan. The now where we're seeing this statute, most of the the case law is with respect to plans, attempting to use this provision to recover overpayments. Now, you know, people, you know, your see the case all the time, how comprehensive and reticular whatever, whatever the heck that means, and well thought out. Risk is and that's what the case is, say. And anybody who practices interest and knows that it's something which is very badly thought out and then hastily thrown together and filled with gaps and
39:41errors. And, and one of those errors is with respect to a plans right to recover. overpayment, you know, the plan paid too much in benefits for some reason or other and now it wants the overpayment back. Well, you know, you would think that there'd be some some remedy For doing that, but the rating one, you look down the list of remedies and 1130 1132. And there isn't one for a plan or an insurer to recover, overpayments may do a claimant or or beneficiary, it was just, it's just absent from the statute. And of course, what we talked about earlier, those remedies are exclusive. So, you know, you can have some state law claim for restitution or unjust enrichment, because those would be preempted by ERISA. So the plans are kind of stuck, or we're stuck until they recently got tossed a bone the these overpayments, they show up in into all kinds of areas. But you know, there, there are two situations where they show up all the time. One of them is with respect to disability plans, the most group disability plans call for a percentage of benefits, you know, 60%, or, you know, 65%, and then allow for offsets for other benefits, such as, for example, Social Security or workers compensation that the claimant is entitled to receive. So the insurance company has been paying the full freight on the insured for a couple of years, and all of a sudden, the insured is granted Social Security retroactive back to the date of disability. And so now, it turns out that the insurance company has been overpaying,
41:22and once has a big overpayment that it wants to to collect now, if it's still paying benefits, it could just, you know, take that out of, you know, future benefits until it gets caught up. And that's generally what it will do. But, you know, a lot of times it's it's terminated benefits, and and so now, it needs a cause of action. So that's one situation. The other situation, which is even more common, is where you've got a guy who's injured by a third party tortfeasor. His medical plan or medical insurer pays for his medical bills as it's required to do. And then later on the his, his lawyer is able to get a nice settlement from the third party tortfeasor. And the the plan has got a subrogation provision in it. And the plan is saying we're entitled to those funds, and it may be entitled to those funds, but for the longest time, it had no legal mechanism for getting those funds. The are the plans attempted to use 1132 a three for appropriate equitable relief in order to recover those, those overpayments. The problem is, is that the initially the Supreme Court bought in great West versus Knutson, which is a case that we provided in the notes. The Justice Scalia wrote that the look, the statute is limited to appropriate equitable relief. equitable relief has to mean something what the planet here it's seeking money damages. And so you know, whatever, you know, that is it's not appropriate equitable relief. And so plan, you can't use a three to recover this overpayment. Then inexplicably, inexplicably and explicit explicitly they say that right
43:19that time Okay, good. Yeah, the explicitly in Sarah Boff, about four years later, the Supreme Court changed its mind. And I think the reasoning of Sarah Boff is so weak that the Roberts Court was now just recognize they had a problem here. And they're not going to say, Well, you know, we think that Congress screwed up, and we're going to sort of fix Congress's problems. But I think that's what they did. What they did was they reached back over a century to a precedent that said that when someone receives a fund money with an immediate obligation to pay it to this other guy, there's a lien by agreement, which is created which can be enforced in equity. And so the and so as a result, when there is a promise to repay an overpayment contained in the plan language, then the at that point, as soon as the money comes in and hits the the personal injury lawyers trust account, that promise to repay kicks in and the you can now that plan could now get that money, some of it perhaps all of it, the UN a three claim for appropriate equitable relief. Now. Let's stop right there for a second. What does that mean? It means that you need the look the person you need to look at the plan language, because not all plans have a specific promise to repay contained and I'm familiar with one plan. For example, we litigated this issue where the what was contained in the plan was a four For the trustees to to recover overpayments authority for the trustees to recover overpayments is not the same thing as
45:12the beneficiary or participant promising to repay. So you need to look at that. The a couple years, then a couple years, six, seven years after Sarah ball, the Supreme Court made things worse. In the US Airways vs McCutcheon case, Supreme Court, again, a ruling that surprised a lot of people decided that in spite of the fact that the claim allowed for recovery, this overpayment was an equitable claim that equitable defenses would not be allowed, meaning that doctrines like unjust enrichment or make whole a common fund doctrines which which would normally, you know, limit, you know, somebody's ability to obtain equitable relief doesn't apply here. So you can have a situation where again, depending on the plan language, where the plant could come in with a claim for the entire amount of the settlement, and basically leave the you know, the claimant with nothing, and even take that portion of the settlement, which is used to what was supposed to be used to pay the pay the attorney fee. So but the very unfortunate and counterproductive ruling and the Fortunately, the the Supreme Court has just this year, come out with a new case. monta Niall is probably how it's pronounced. The the. And in Montana, well, the the money came in, and it was sitting in the out of personal injury lawyers, drunk driving cases, a lot of these are sitting in the personal injury lawyers trust account. And he attempted to negotiate with the plan and is sometimes the case the plan was playing hardball and they
47:10weren't able to reach a settlement. And so the the lawyer sent out a letter that says, Well, no, we're not able to reach an agreement unless there's some objection. In 14 days, I'm going to distribute the funds. And the plan did nothing distributed the funds six months later, the plan filed filed suit under under eight three, and the Supreme Court Justice Thomas channelling judge Scalia said no. And the reason why is because the money is not in that account anymore. Okay, it's been moved. It's now part of the claimants, General assets, and the law firms general assets. And, you know, in equity, you're allowed to proceed against a specific race, a specific piece of property, a specific sum of money, that you can be traced as belonging to you. But once you get past that, and are attempting to collect a debt from someone's general assets, you've transmuted from equitable relief to legal relief. And that's not within the scope of what ERISA allows. So I mean, take some comfort, in that, in my opinion, most, most medical plans, health plans are not the most well organized shops in the world. And I'm willing to bet that, you know, the lawyer letter saying 14 days and I'm going to distribute the funds, if there's not some objection, there's a reasonable chance it's going to be ignored for more than 14 days. And I would, you know, you take your opportunities where you get your opportunities, of course, it's just better to try to try to settle and know in advance that that's something you're going to have to do
48:52when you perform the settlement. The plaintiffs have been using attempting to use a three as a as a means to expand the remedies allowed under under ERISA. And in 2011, the Supreme Court came out with the ammara case, which those of us on the plaintiffs bar thought was a big deal that said new equitable remedies and scope of equitable relief and surcharge and reformation. And unfortunately, the Ninth Circuit didn't see it that way, in a couple of very restrictive cases, Skinner, and Gabriel imposed some restrictions well beyond what I think the Supreme Court intended. And so in many respects, Tamara has made the situation for plaintiffs attempting to seek some sort of remedy outside the specific terms of the plan harder evidence and discovery. The very limited evidence in interesting cases, as we talked about earlier. Generally speaking, you're limited to the, to the evidence that was in the record. At the time the final denial letter came in. There are three recognized exceptions. And let me just sort of briefly touch on those. And I've got more detail about all three of them in the course materials. One of them pursuant to monga.
50:22Lusa was when you have the novo review evidence, which is quote necessary for adequate de novo review, close quote. What does that mean? Well, in that case, laws have fleshed it out a little bit, you know, cases involving, you know, credibility of medical experts where there's complicated medical issues where there's the use to be an insured plan. Prior to prior to Arista, there's a whole set of factors set out in the the case law. Obviously, you don't want to count on Mangala. So you want to get your evidence in before you know your file. But to the extent something good comes along afterwards, that's your avenue to get it in a de novo case, in a abuse of discretion case, you're allowed to get in evidence showing a conflict between the you know, but you're showing a conflicted fiduciary I mean, you get a situation like in the typical insurance company case where the insurance company is paying benefits out of its own pocket as it typically does when it when it decides to pay benefits. The we all know the name of that song, the and the obviously it's the one deciding whether to pay benefits. And it's the one that's making decision whether benefits are doing knowing and that sort of an obvious conflict. And so if you could develop evidence of self interest on behalf of the disher insurance company showing that it's allowing this conflict to overwhelm its fiduciary obligations, that's something we're going to talk about this a little bit, the court can use to lower the standard of review from abuse of discretion to not quite so, so
52:00bad. Now I'm going to talk about standard review. And in just a little bit, so so so bear with me, the the third exception comes into play, where there's been some sort of procedural default, caused by the plan, fiduciary plan fiduciary forgot to send out a denial letter, the plan fiduciary changed the reason for the denial between the initial denial letter and the final denial letter. In cases like that the Supreme, the Ninth Circuit has held that the claimant has an absolute right, to expand the record to what it would have been had the plan, the plan acted, acted properly. discovery in arrested cases, you know, I'm kind of a, there's some limited discovery allowed. I rarely take any I have could probably, you know, and I've done, I don't know, excess of 100 risk cases, I could probably count on the fingers of one hand, were discovered it was conducted with any use whatsoever. Interest may be a little too too extreme. I mean, you know, you'll want to look at it on a case by case basis. And if there's a situation where there's something you don't know, that could potentially be useful, then you know, the discovery may may well be an order. But anyway, I've set out the standard for when you're allowed to take the discovery. I'm not sure if that's still good law, because they've recently changed. Rule 26 and the language from rule 26. And a lot of the cases keyed on whether discovery is reasonably calculated to obtain admissible evidence isn't in the statute anymore. And so that would just change this last year. And so
53:40we're gonna have to wait and see how the case law shakes down. I just got done talking about the standard review. And I'm going to spend most of the balance of my time talking about this because it's an important subject, the there's two possible standards of review and a risk of cases. One is de novo, and one is abuse of discretion. De Novo sounds just like what it what you would think it means the judge is going to decide whether your client is entitled to benefits without regard to what the insurance company or plan decided. That's what you want. The other standard is abuse of discretion. And under the abuse of discretion standard, the judge has got to uphold with the insurance company or plan did unless its plan interpretations are unreasonable as a matter of law, or its findings are not supported by the record findings not supported by a record that's a very, very high bar to have to get over as a plaintiff. And so you don't want abuse of discretion review and so you want to try to figure out how to get to the novo review. And and I'm going to tell you how to get to de novo review First, California has made the situation a lot easier, at least with respect to insured plans involving health and disability. They passed the statute, California insurance Code Section 1011 0.6.
55:19That essentially outlaws discretionary clauses in all insured plans. The, of course, the, you know, the insurance, people, you know, hated that statute. And, you know, you've been awful lot of litigation, when it first passed is to is to just what it what it meant. And the Fortunately, the district courts have upheld the that statute in very broad terms, given a very broad application, you know, for example, the insurance companies would say, Well, you know, that only applies to policies in here are granted discretion isn't a different document. The end? Oh, let me back up for a second. The, cuz I didn't really explain how to tell what a grant of discretion looks like. And the problem some folks may be wondering if a grant of discretion basically is language in the plan or in the policy that says that the insurance company or fiduciary has discretion to decide, you know, all matters of factor policy interpretation, and its determination will be final and binding or upheld or language sort of like that. The Ninth Circuit says it can't be uncertain language, it's got to be language, which explicitly grants discretion. If it doesn't explicitly grant discretion, then there is no discretion. But anyway, the the the insurance companies tried to take the position of well, you know, it's in a different plan document. It's not in the policy itself. And, you know, the statute only governs the policy and the, the courts have rejected that broadly. And uniformly the district courts the there's one outlier,
57:02which is which is, which is Cowie, which is which is actually going to be argued in the ninth circuit in the next couple of next couple of months. And so hopefully, we'll get a decision from the Ninth Circuit that says these, these statutes are saved from ERISA preemption, and broadly applicable to all ERISA insured plans. But we'll say we'll know when a couple couple of months from when the swell six months made, because they got to write the decision from when this this taping is being is being done. The Okay.
57:46What else have you got? You know, one of the, let's say to self funded plan, that statute isn't going to apply to self funded plans. Let's say you're not in California, let's say the Ninth Circuit does something stupid. But one of the things and this happens all the time is the
58:06the grant of discretion is not in the plan or the policy, but in a document called a summary, plan description, summary plan description is sort of a handout given by the employer that's supposed to, you know, state what your benefits are, and sort of layman's language. And a lot of times, that's where they put the, where they put the grant of discretion. The courts, including the Supreme Court, and the Ninth Circuit of hell, that's not good enough, it's got to be in the plan itself, because the summary plan description only describes the plan can't be used to commodify the plan. And other issues at the discretion, there could be a grant of discretion in the plan, which is binding, but only if the right entity exercises that, that discretion. And you see that happen a lot more often than you would think. For example of the case I had a few years back against the against the university disability plan. And the ad had a grant of discretion. But the grant had discretion said, you know, the University takes the head said we have discretion to decide claims. And then we was defined to be the university. The problem is here with the university did is it got tired of deciding these things itself and went hired a third party administrator to decided and so the argument could be successfully made, hey, the this is the not the university does the university decided would have been plenty of discretion, but unfortunately, it was a third party administrator, there's no granted discretion to the third party administrator. So look, and see exactly who
59:47discretion was granted to and make sure it's the same as is the entity that actually issued the final decision. The venue got the argument that the The grant of discretion is an illegal plan amendment. How does this come up? The this comes up when the Oh, what happens though there is no grant of discretion in the plan document. And it's just too hard to amend the plan. And so what happens is the insurer that wants this discretion kind of puts together like another document, you know, but just as an example, you've got a company, let's just call it visa. And it hires a third party administrator, let's just call it Cigna to to maintain its its health plan. And the health plan doesn't have a grant of discretion, but Cigna kind of wants one. And so it puts the language in the contract between it and visa, under which it's going to be the third party administrator, and to say, Well, you know, that's there for, you know, plan language, which is binding on the plan, because it's in this this binding contract between us. And so, you know, your first stop looking at that argument is to say, well, I'll bet the plan, as all these plans do, has got language limiting, what can be done to constitute an amendment because the employers are all scared stiff, that you know, somebody's going to say something stupid, or write a letter, and they're going to argue, well, this constitutes an amendment. So there's always an integration clause that said, in order to have an amendment, you've got to have a document got to be signed by this guy and
1:01:34signed by this guy and approved by this third person over here. And so look to see as to whether that document that the lawyer from Cigna is waving around, complies with the plans, amendment procedure. And then you could use evidence of conflict to reduce the extent of discretion, we already kind of already kind of talked about that some and that's all in the in the course materials. Arrested trials, the section is going to be short, because the rest of trials are short, the sometimes non existent. I, I lost the case recently, in Arizona, where I went through the entire case, from the filing of the complaint to the trial, it's now up on appeal. I never even saw the judge. Okay, this guy ruled against me, I have no idea what he looks like. So that's what happens.
1:02:25Sometimes they decide these cases on the papers, sometimes you're bought in for for half an hour of argument. Sometimes if the judge is being real decent, he or she will give you a couple of hours. So So yeah, you don't do this kind of work, unless you're good on the papers, because that's where you win or lose these cases is by, you know, how persuasively you argue that the record is in your favor, don't count on, you know, on being able to sort of well, well just pay that short shrift. And I'll you know, I'll convince the judge when I'm in trial, because you may never even see the judge, and he's going to likely decide the case mostly based on or entirely on your your papers. The good news in a recent case is a plaintiff achieving success on the merits, is presumptively entitled to attorney fees. The there's a test that and you know, the way the statute is worded, it's it's equal between plans and, and claimants. But the way it's been applied by the Ninth Circuit bless them is that claimants are almost always entitled to fees and plans are almost never entitled to the fees. The test for the you know, for for, you know, attorney fees is contained in the lecture materials, and it's I'm not going to I'm not going to spend a lot of time talking about that, the, what I am, I'm just going to touch on a couple of issues that you need to, you probably need to keep in mind.
1:04:06One of them is with respect to timekeeping. You know, a lot of planet floors, they're not used to writing down there time. And then so all of a sudden, they've won an Ursa case. And now they're entitled to put in, you know, for for a fee claim, and the judge is going to expect time records, showing the date that work was done, how much time was expended, who did it, and what was done. And, you know, we having to recreate that over, you know, the two and a half year case is going to be is going to be difficult. So you've gotten the rest of case, you're hoping that at the end of the day, you're going to be able to put in a claim for attorney fees. Write down your time of write down your time in such a way that the judge looking at it can understand what it is you did with that, that 1.2 hours. And remember the only purpose is going to be to give this to the jury And opposing counsel and so you should when you're writing the description of the work done you know make sure you don't say things that would be you know subject to the privilege or or otherwise just just dump things to you know to put in the in the time records for the for the judge to see if you could redact you know them but you know, when you've got you know, 15 pages of time records sometimes it's easy to you know, to miss something and so you know, you don't want to write down and your time record you know, 1.5 explaining to the client it's okay for him to lie in his declaration because the judges too stupid to figure it out, okay, that but just don't put that down there and a conversation
1:05:42with client regarding contents of declaration. The other issue is there's no fees for administrative appeal, you know, all that stuff that I told you how to do about sending in the letter and putting in your evidence and you know, all that good stuff. You're not going to get paid for that, at least in terms of the fee motion for a recipe. That's the that ladies and gentlemen is the is the soup to nuts of, of original litigation. And hopefully you found this this lecture useful and good luck here.