Lori A. D.CA
A very thorough and entertaining review of the issues that make each of the big four professional leagues unique and explains why they are treated uniquely from other corporations. I really enjoyed it.
1h 1min · about 10,500 words
0:00Hi, my name is Brandon Leopold us and I'm a sports and business lawyer here in Los Angeles. And I'd like to welcome you to our presentation today on Sports law, the business structure of professional sports, focusing in on the leagues and member franchises. Again, my name is Brandon Leopold us and I am a attorney for private clients, including a lot of athletes and businesses here in Southern California. Welcome to beautiful Los Angeles. And it's a great place to practice sports law as well as business law because there's a lot going on most of the regional captain of the sports Lawyers Association, the largest collection of sports lawyers in the world, you can check more out about them at sports law.org. I got my start with sports as a professional baseball umpire. And I figured once that career was over, if I was gonna argue for a living, I might as well make a few dollars and I decided to go into law. So want to jump right into it. So the business structure is something that you need to take your fan hat off and kind of put your lawyer hat on for a while. And the principles and things that we'll be going over today will be easy to understand, because it's from a sports perspective, oftentimes, sports can be used, because people are familiar with some of the names that are involved in the structure of it. So while some of this might get a little complex, you'll if you're a sports fan, and I assume you are tuning into a sports law CLE, that you'll be able to understand a little bit about what's going on here. And it might
1:31make a little more sense than if we just covered it from a textbook perspective. So let's start with the leagues. Now the leagues are those governing bodies over the teams, right. And today, we're going to be talking really about those big four leagues Major League Baseball, the National Basketball Association, the National Football League, and the National Hockey League. Now, these principles do apply to those other sports, whether it's Major League Soccer, or the W NBA, Arena Football, any of those other leagues, including like the national lacrosse League, or some of the startup leagues, whether it's involving extreme sports or other traditional sports, some of these principles can apply. So if you represent any of those organizations, or you're looking to base, your business model, or that of a client off of these leagues, these are some good takeaways. So we'll go through these as we move along. Starting with the leagues, they're based and they were based, and they're starting to move away from this a little bit. But they're based on a 501 c six structure, meaning that they're a nonprofit, but not a 501 c three, like a traditional nonprofit. This is a special provision that the sports leagues have figured out worked for them, and continue to work for them. So there's an element, there's an element to that 501, c six, you have to have at number one, that has to be an association of persons having a common business interest, number two, a purpose of which is to promote the common interest. And number three, it's not
3:02to engage in a regular business of a kind ordinarily carried out for profit. Now, let's go through each one of these. Because when I first read through 501, c six, I thought there was no way that leads could actually properly be classified under 501, c six. Now, the association does have a common business interest for sports. If you think about it, the common interest of these franchise owners and of the league is to promote the sport. And even though that's to generate money for those member teams, it's not for to raise money for the league, it's really to promote the individual team members. The purpose, again, is to promote that common interest to promote the sport and those businesses that are member of the league. Number three, the league is not engaged in a interest to cause a profit, right, the league is not the profit center, the individual teams are the profit center, the league just does some administrative duties, and helps set some of the guidelines. And we'll talk more about that here shortly. Now, the leads are set up as trade associations and under 501, c six, they have to have some requirements, just like any other IRF section. Number one, they have to have a business that activity must be devoted to improving the business conditions of one or more lines of business. Number two, they're the they're not performing a particular service for an individual. Number three, and no part of the net earnings may be for the benefit of a private shareholder. And number four, they may not be organized for profit, engaging activity. And so we've
4:45already covered that one. But let's go back through these elements as well very quickly. There, it has to be set up to improve the business conditions of one or more lines of business and really, if you think about say Major League Baseball for example, that's What they do, so the lines of business, whether it's an entertainment product or those venues, or even licensing and merchandise, they're there to set specific sand standards. So if you have a client that's dealing with Major League Baseball, for instance, if you have a represent a company that's supplying the turf, or specific products, they have certain standards that have to be met on each and every line of that. And so that would be something more for the team anyway. They're setting standards, and improving those business conditions for the member teams, and those franchises. And so at number two, it's not performing a particular service for an individual, again, it's for the collective whole of those members, not just say, the owner of the New York Giants, they are the NFL anyway, is acting in the best interest of all of those member teams, not just the giants, but the Jets, the Denver Broncos, the new Los Angeles Rams, all of the teams that are involved with the league. And finally, they can't be engaged in a generally profit business. Now remember, the league is not the profit center, that's really important to remember, as we go throughout this presentation. For 501 c six, the league is not the profit center. The individual
6:22franchises are the profit center, and they help the league be successful. But remember, the league is just covering some certain duties. Now 501 c six if you weren't convinced that a sports league was covered under 501, c six quite yet. And that's okay. There's been numerous panels and discussions, especially at the sports Lawyers Association events on whether or not they should be a nonprofit, or covered under 501. c six, there is a special provision for boards of trade and professional football leagues, that's pretty much a slam dunk for sports being able to be covered under 501. c six. Let's talk about some of those benefits. I had mentioned them throughout that first part about what the benefits are from a league perspective to those member clubs. Number one, they're able to set up exhibitions between the member teams, right. So if you own the Philadelphia Eagles, you don't have to worry about trying to set your own schedule and figure out what member teams you have, the league will let you use the league actually sets the schedule for those teams. And they make sure that the Philadelphia Eagles aren't going to be playing a local Semi Pro team. There are certain standards that the League has, and only the member teams can play in a in a league game. Now, some of these are different. You see, sometimes with the NBA, or Major League Baseball, especially during the exhibition season, they may play outside of their league for a game or two, that's usually set up by the teams. But those are under very specific provisions within the
7:57bylaws and collective bargaining agreements for each league. Now, the not just the league doesn't just set the schedule, but they also handle some disciplinary issues. And this is something that we see in the news quite a bit, just using the National Football League, for example. They're involved with the discipline for Tom Brady for deflate gate, or for Ray Rice for violating the domestic abuse provisions that the League has. You also have situations where they're going after and disciplining players such as Josh Gordon for repeated abuse of the the drug and alcohol provisions that the National Football League is set up. So discipline is something that doesn't just cover the players, it covers any employee of any league team. So you occasionally will see an assistant coach or a front office personnel member that gets picked up for a DUI and they're probably going to get suspended and or fined by the league, not just a team, although the team can also take action as well. Generally, though, most of those things are covered by the league because they're able to conduct investigations a little bit easier than the teams are.
9:07So other things that they're able to do, are they cover collective bargaining on behalf of the teams. Otherwise, if you think about it, it would be difficult for not just the individual team teams to negotiate a collective bargaining agreement with the players associations, but also it's difficult for the the union to negotiate with 30 or 32 different teams as well. So it's a benefit across the board that they're able to handle the collective bargaining for all of the member teams. They license intellectual property for the teams, and we'll talk a little bit more about antitrust implications. But oftentimes, if you're here in Los Angeles and you're looking to get the intellectual property rights to have, you know, National Basketball Association logos and venues on in your movie, you would go to the National Basketball League, you wouldn't just go to say the one Angeles Lakers, you would go through the league office. Now they're able to negotiate league wide sponsorships, but pay into the NBA. And then those pay out to their member teams. So for example, Coca Cola is a sponsor of I think just about every sports league. And it's for a certain set of time, you see the same thing with uniforms.
10:20Generally, in most sports, at least, the major sports, you're going to have all of the team uniforms manufactured by the same company. So Nike or Adidas, or Reebok, those are three big ones are CCM with the National Hockey League, you're going to see those logos across the board on their team uniforms, you're not going to have Wilson make one uniform for three or four teams and Adidas make uniforms for three or four, you're generally going to have one body that makes all of the uniforms for those member teams. Other benefits, right? they govern the league. So they set the rules and regulations of the league. So that way, it's across the board. Well, the Green Bay Packers may have their individual team policies, the legal habits, league policy, so it's standard across the board, you're going to have the league set up a pension retirement program, this is a benefit for everybody involved, including the players associations and their members. But also for those people that are working for the teams as well. They're going to set up health insurance and for and other benefits. That's always a benefit. When you have a bigger pool of people, especially when they're young adults, with the athletic prowess that they have. The league handles dispute resolution in a lot of different matters that we don't hear about on television, whether it's between a player and its team, or it's between two team owners, or some other situations where licensing may get involved.
11:49All of those things, the league handles a lot of dispute resolution. It also makes loans right, so next time you hear about an arena being built, and the team contributing several 100 million dollars, oftentimes the team owners don't have that pre capital. So they're going to have to get capital from somewhere and the league is able to loan that out to the owners at a reasonable rate, as well as being able to collect it because they're able to really have that team as leverage. So they do some marketing efforts, right. So you see that the league market that's players, they market individual matchups, and they market those special events, such as the Super Bowl that is a league event, with a Super Bowl if it's hosted in Dallas, for example, Jerry Jones and the Dallas Cowboys are not responsible for marketing that Super Bowl, that's what the league office will do. They also do some international events, and it would be difficult to delegate that or leave it up to just the team owners, but the league and go and market occur overseas and into new markets on behalf of the member clubs. And finally they handle officiating right, as a former Empire. This is one of my favorite topics, but the league is the one that sets your officials. Otherwise, you can imagine the scenario when the Chicago White Sox have to get local umpires to, to officiate the White Sox games against, say a team from Florida. And now we have all sorts of issues.
13:17And so the league is able to hire, train and evaluate their own officials and have a standardized process across the board. They're keeping the integrity of the sport intact. Now, one thing that the League has that the leagues have, that most businesses do not, are is an antitrust exemption, which is huge. And we see a lot of issues come up around antitrust throughout the years. And it's really something an area of law that's moving a little bit and it's nuanced now about how antitrust works with the leaks. But really it allows the league's the antitrust exemption allows the league's, to operate as a single entity. Even though it crosses state lines, you have member teams and generally more than 20 states, it's considered that the a single entity because the league, usually based in New York, is going to be really the governing body. And so they can collectively pool the things that they're doing and have it under one entity. Now that came out of a case in 1922. And you'll see this in your materials. And with those materials, I just want to make the caveat that all of the materials have links to internet sites with all of this information. So I just gave a rough footnote at the end of everything to to those materials. So you can go ahead and read these yourself. We're not going to do full case briefs on these because we have a lot of information to get to today. And I want to go over just the importance of all of this. Now, that first case that we're going to talk about is the federal baseball club versus the National League Baseball case from 1922. And
14:56one thing you need to understand when you have sports and the court is that some times the court makes irrational decisions and decisions that you would not otherwise expect if these were two non sports businesses, just like with fans, that people aren't sitting on the bench also like sports. And so sometimes, some rulings will get a little creative in order to allow or disallow sports to do certain things. And this is really one of those early sports cases, that left people scratching their heads a little bit. Justice Holmes ruled that baseball was not interstate commerce. It said that interstate travel in order to participate in baseball was not an essential thing at the major league level, which is interesting considering that back in the 20s, teams would be taking trains across state lines to play their baseball game. So the White Sox would travel by train to Boston, Boston, would travel by train to New York, so on and so forth. But yet, that was not considered to be an essential thing, even though those teams were not going to compete with our local pony league team or something like that. He also said that the American and national leagues were merely umbrella organizations for their member teams, they, these a outlaid it that the league's only set the schedules and the rules, and the actual business operations of the team were local, which you can understand that some of those things are very true. But otherwise, it gets into an area where it may not necessarily hold up anymore, because number three that he said was that there was no revenue sharing in
16:37professional baseball, and that there were no pool licensing revenues that we've seen in the fairly recent past, but those last two are no longer applicable. Now there are there is some revenue sharing going on. And there are pooled licensing revenues for all sorts of things. And so really, when you look at this case, you have to look at it from the perspective of 1922, rather than, say, 2022, where, but right now we have licensing pools with all of the major sports. And there's a lot of revenue sharing going on. In fact, that's a word that's used throughout sports. And so we're through this case that baseball is exempt from antitrust law. And so they were really able to put their foot down and the federal league is no longer. But for some of you baseball historians, there are some really interesting things that went on with the federal League, much like some other defunct leagues, where they had to try some creative, creative marketing efforts and creative business ploys to try and keep that league afloat. That just didn't work out for them. Another case that I want to talk about is brown versus pro football link. And this is a case where it held that labor relations at the major league levels were exempt from antitrust regulations. This was a big issue on whether or not this was going to be held up. But it really prohibited the players unions from filing antitrust lawsuits. Without decertifying a union. The court reasoned that it's in a public policy interest, that people are able to collectively bargain on equal footing. And so with the players
18:12associations, they figured that that was the case, rather than individual players negotiating with a league better with a team within a league on their own behalf that the union provides them equal footing. And so antitrust law would take a backseat to collective bargaining. And so the only way that antitrust would kick in is if they decertify, the union. Now, we saw this not too long ago with the National Football League in their last collective bargaining agreement, they actually did decertify, the union, and there was some turmoil on whether or not that antitrust case would work, really, it was a negotiating strategy. But they were ready to litigate that as well. And so you're going to see antitrust come up in a sports context, on a fairly regular basis, it doesn't always mean that these cases are going to succeed. But all of the major sports are very protective over this antitrust exemption, and they want to keep it intact.
19:11So be on the lookout for that after you finish the CLE. Certainly, take a look. If you just type in antitrust and sports into Google searching under the news, you'll find plenty about it. A couple things that the league's can do that other other industries really can't do because of the antitrust exemption. They can block franchises removing right weed now we've seen some other cases about this on whether or not it is completely legal. And we've seen it turned out in two or three different ways. But often, they can block those moves because they have to be approved by the member by the members of the of the league. And so these committees that are actually voting on it are comprised of Either the owners or somebody that's appointed by the owner. And so just recently with the Rams moved to Los Angeles, they had to get so many votes of owners. And it was really difficult and a lot of horse trading going on and a lot of politics being played.
20:14But if they don't reach that vote, they might file an antitrust case. But it also takes time, money, effort and uncertainty on whether or not that'll go through. So with those politics and personalities, it doesn't mean that teams can't move. And since 1971, and this is recorded in 20 2016, there's been a lot since 1971. Right? So we've seen eight NFL franchises move, we've seen seven NBA franchises, nine NHL franchises, and one major league baseball franchise move. So you can see that there's a lot of movement going around. But now, I think owners realize that more than an antitrust case and determining whether or not that exists that should exist or what the parameters are, they're realizing that they have a financial motive to not even test it, then instead work with the other owners. For example, if the Montreal Expos did not move to Washington, we probably have fewer fans, when the Washington Nationals or previously the Montreal Expos go into, say, New York to play the Mets. That rivalry wasn't very big. Because you didn't have a lot of people from Montreal living in New York or say even the expos going to Denver to play the Colorado Rockies. However, you do have more transplants from Washington DC living across the country. And so it creates a larger ticket base for those franchises to sell tickets into market their product to. And so I think owners have really started to take a look at that. Now there may be ebbs and flows in the future. But that is certainly a motivation. Anytime you can put millions of dollars into anybody's pocket, they're
21:55probably going to start listening to that a little bit more than they would a legal principle to see how it would get tested in court. And so leaks can also block the sale of franchises, right, so a sale to a certain party has to also be approved. And so we recently saw that, again, here in Los Angeles, with the sale of the Clippers from Donald Sterling. Now, the owners didn't like Donald Sterling, and they were going to have him removed. And so that sale, it was really something that had to have some horse trading going on with dad that play that politic game, and make sure that all the personalities were satisfied as well. And so that's really one of those key takeaways.
22:34It's not always just about the law, it's about how you're able to get the business done. And then there's always some legal ramifications with that. So broadcasting is another area where there was a lot of turmoil and uncertainty, but that led to a specific antitrust exemption for broadcasting. And that was a sports broadcasting act of 1961. Really, it allowed teams to pool their broadcasting rights and sell those rights nationally. We all are probably familiar with that. If you're a football fan, American football fan, you see that on Sundays, the National Football League has nationwide television. And so if the part depending on what part of the country you're in, you might see certain teams more than others. Here in Los Angeles, while we get the Raiders or San Diego quite a bit. And this is before the Rams move, we would also get a random game, perhaps it was Philadelphia and Dallas. Well, that's not in the local territory. But these teams can sell the national package. And so that way, they're able to negotiate those rights and really maximize that and then the broadcasters have the right to figure out where they want to broadcast those. Now, the revenue model for this is that the broadcaster say it CBS pays the National Football League in this case for those rights. And then remember the money that goes into the league, all the profit gets split between those member teams. Those franchise owners all benefit from the large contracts that they have for broadcasting with the league. As I mentioned, antitrust you have a
24:10lot of litigation with and some of the time it's for a ploy, some of its posturing, but you can see a number of cases and there's some footnotes here we see al Davis and the Oakland, Los Angeles, Oakland Raiders. Al Davis was the owner of the Raiders. He recently departed us and Mr. Davis didn't really care what the league charter said he was going to take the league to court on moving his team and he was successful. So it was a long drawn out battle. He faced a lot of ramifications for doing so. But he was able to test the boundary of just how much the league could do when it came to franchise moves. You also see some other cases where you have Tolson versus the New York Yankees and this was a Yankees minor league player who still sued over what's called the reserve clause. And what the reserve clause binds a player to, it's to the parent organization, really for the lifetime of the player. And remember, in the minor leagues, the reserve clause exists. And the reserve clause is just a form contract that says you don't have a right to become a free agent after a while, if you get drafted by the St. Louis Cardinals, you are playing for the St. Louis Cardinals, and or you're just going to go get a different job. Now, that's not necessarily the case anymore. There's some internal bylaws from Major League Baseball that allow for what's called a rule five draft free baseball nuts, you already know what it is for others that don't understand what that means. You can feel free to look it up. But
25:44it really, this was an interesting case. But the Supreme Court said that the Sherman act, antitrust was not drafted for baseball, that wasn't the original intent. But rather it was set up for large industry. So it shouldn't really, it shouldn't really matter. And so that was really an interesting take on things, because you would think that antitrust would apply to any large business like that. But they decided against that. And I think this was another decision that if it was something other than sports, it might have come out differently. And so the most recently, a big antitrust case was called American needle versus the National Football League. And several years ago, the National Football League granted Reebok an exclusive license to produce all apparel, not just the onfield apparel, but sweatshirts, t shirts, hats, only Reebok was allowed to make that all the smaller companies that also made anything with a team logo on it was barred from doing so they weren't going to license it outside up to that one company. And what that case ended up holding was that, well, let's back up American needle was one of those companies that used to have a license for it right, they'd make some t shirts, they'd make some hats. And it was non exclusive license. There were many companies that were licensing this out. But in a unanimous Supreme Court and imagine how hard that was to do. In this day and age, they ruled that each team, each team is a substantial, independently owned and independently managed business. As you can
27:24imagine, that was difficult. But even in the oral arguments of the Supreme Court, which are really interesting to listen to, if you're into that sort of thing. The oral arguments, it was hard for the NFL to say that they weren't individual interests. So that was difficult. So NFL properties. While NFL properties is the licensing arm of the NFL, its actions were not considered a concerted activity, but the decisions about the licensing are considered a concerted activity, and therefore it's covered under the Sherman act and antitrust. And so if you think about it, this was a very rational decision, it was very, very well written. And so I recommend that you take a look at that, and the link is in the materials. So let's also talk about the business structure of the league. It starts with the franchise owners, and goes down to the NFL Executive Committee, right. And these are the people that really make the decisions on how the NFL is going to operate. That third layer down is the Commissioner's Office and the Commissioner of the particular sport. And on each side, you have that administrative arm with the Secretary and the treasurer, and some of those other people that work directly for the commissioner. And then it branches off into some different categories. So you usually have one arm that's communication and Public Affairs. And that covers a wide variety of topics. But this is just within the league here. You have the league administration, that's including business and legal affairs, and the football operations and development
29:05arms of the league. You also have the labor relations or a Management Council, something like that with the National Football League, they have a league Management Council and say you're going to have that's going to do the collective bargaining part of it. They're really going to that's their primary focus is really the football operations the player personnel, player and employee development, that type of thing. You have a financial arm, right? So you're gonna have the accountants, you're gonna have the strategic transactions, that type of thing. With each league also, now they all own their own network. So with the NFL, you're gonna have the NFL Network or Major League Baseball, you're going to have the MLB network, and you're going to usually have some sub sections there, whether it's the marketing part of that the distribution arm, those type of things, you're going to have now have an international arm For each sport, now, hockey is a little different, as is baseball because you have these teams in different countries, then NBA also has some teams in Canada. But we're talking overseas, we're looking at China and Europe is two really big areas for development for each of these leagues, and so they have their whole entire international arm.
30:21But then you're going to have the sales and marketing as well. And all of these business departments tie into one another. And so while you may classify somebody as marketing, they may, another lawyer may classify them in the international market, it really depends on each League, and really each commissioner and how the executive committee is set up in order to determine just who is where, but you can see those different departments, there's quite a number of them. Just in the league office here, we're not talking about the teams yet. But in the league office, there's quite a number of different departments, and they interplay between each other. There's several 100 people that work in each league office. And with varying roles, you also have a large, new media presence and digital marketing and that type of thing. And if you're really interested, check out Major League Baseball, advanced media, or NFL bam, they're really a trendsetter, that leading to a lot of revenue for Major League Baseball owners. And this was set up well in advance of the other leagues, and their digital arm. And so they're not just doing the games online for the major league baseball teams, but they're also handling content for content and some of the video stuff for a wide variety of other organizations that are some involved in sports, others are not. But it's another business model. It's not just about putting on baseball games anymore. It's about creating revenue. Now, we see that with the the leagues. But now let's talk about the franchises, right, these are the teams that
32:00you're all familiar with. And so keep your local team or your favorite team in mind when we're talking about this now, with one exception, and that's the Green Bay Packers, these franchises are privately held. And even with the Packers, it's on the stock exchange. But it's you really want to remember that these are privately held companies with a vast public interest in them. Not a legal interest, but certainly an emotional interest. And generally, they're held in either an LLC or some sort of partnership. Really, it depends on what's best for that ownership group. And I say ownership group, because oftentimes, there are majority and minority owners, these franchises are valued in the billions of dollars. And even the cheaper franchises are hundreds of millions of dollars. And so oftentimes, you're going to need somebody with some very deep pockets or group of people with deep pockets in order to purchase these. Now, as I said, very few of these are individually owned. But that's not the case. For the minor league franchises with, say the NHL, or minor league baseball, those are often valued in the millions of dollars. And you can often have a single owner for some of those. But you can also take a look at Major League Soccer, the National lacrosse League, these other smaller leagues. And if you're interested in getting into ownership, there are certainly some availability for those. Now when they're doing that, and when you're looking if you're working with an individual or an ownership group, or a partnership, or for one of the
33:37franchises themselves, they're oftentimes estate and succession planning issues that come up that often are not adequately addressed. And I bring this up because for those estate planning attorneys, this is something where if you have a high net worth, client, whether it's a sports business or not, these are some questions you're going to need to ask because we've seen some some of these issues come into play with the Buffalo Bills recently. And if we can use a baseball example, I think everybody will understand or is the Steinbrenner family. When George Steinbrenner owner of the Yankees passed away, he had a succession plan to give that team to his kids with who also some direction on who was able, who should be managing each part of the business. And that seemed to go a little bit more smoothly than what's going on in Buffalo right now. Or with the Denver Broncos. Now, the Denver Broncos owners name is Pat Bowlen, who's owned the team for more than a it's close to 30 something years, and he has Alzheimer's. He has advanced Alzheimer's. And so there's some succession issues there. And they're trying to determine which of his kids is going to be able to take over that franchise. And while we don't know the details of exactly how that succession is planned out, we can certainly see just by what's going on that some of these issues have Not quite come to fruition with anybody being able to make a claim for that team. And so it's really important that if you are counseling anybody in this area, that you have the succession plan worked out well in
35:13advance and continually update that, as the ownership continues. So the franchises have a lot of abilities, apart from just making money from being a member of these leagues that they have. They agree to the league rules, right. And they also share in the benefits. So while they have to abide by certain things, they get to share in the benefits. And the leagues are managed by a committee of League members, right. So that's a benefit that if you own a franchise, you're going to be on one of these committees. So you can help steer the direction of the league, whether it's in broadcasting or licensing, or venues or special events or anything like that, you're going to have that opportunity to really have some direction. And it's really similar to owning a team in one of the major sports is similar in structure to owning any other franchise. It's not, it's a lot like owning the McDonald's clearly with a lot more money involved and different business, but you still have to abide by certain things. So for example, if you on the Cincinnati Bengals, you're probably not going to be able to change the look of the NFL logo for the outside of the stadium, because it clashes with your colors. Certainly all of that type of thing, you have to abide by those league policies, just like with a McDonald's, your restaurant has to look a certain way. If you own an NBA franchise, your arena has to meet certain specifications as well. And so it's really important to keep that in mind. So those of you that work with
36:40franchise owners, you'll really understand some of this. Some of the upcoming material here a lot better than, say, if you're just the wills and trust attorney. And some other things that teams can do really on their own. And they don't need too much legal oversight, although there are some are number one that you can sell local sponsorships right now, they can't clash with the league sponsorships. So for instance, if I'm in Texas, and I want Dr. Pepper a Texas company, to be my local soft drink sponsor, it's probably going to clash with a Coca Cola or Pepsi, that is a sponsor that's league wide.
37:23And so you with these teams, they always want to make sure that those exclusive categories are kept exclusive, and all the sponsors are kept happy. But local sponsorships are, are really invaluable. And often, really the best sponsorships that individual teams have. So for example, if you are the owner of the Dallas Stars in the National Hockey League, you may get the biggest car dealer in the area to be one of your sponsors and have their logo put on the ice or on the boards and have in venue signage, and also probably luxury suite or some sort of ticket package. And so these local sponsorships are always good because it gets the players out into the community and really gets these local businesses that are influential to be invested in the team. And so these local sponsorships are something that teams can certainly handle on their own. One thing with the teams is they also have exclusive categories, right? I mentioned that with the soft drink category. But the link in there will show you that there are exclusive categories all over the place for all sorts of things. And so teams can certainly do the same thing. While there may be waqia is the official vehicle sponsor of the NBA, you may be able to get a car dealer that sells to usually, as a local sponsor, it really depends on the the terms of each deal. But really something you want to take a look at those exclusive rights are certainly more valuable than if they were non exclusive for each product category. They could also these individual teams can set the ticket price and
39:03sell tickets for their games. If that if the Boston Bruins wants to set their ticket price at a minimum of $1,000. They can certainly do that. The National Hockey League may not like it, but they can certainly do that. Or they can set their ticket price at a penny apiece. They have a wide range and being able to sell their tickets and create different tiered packages. Oftentimes, you'll see some teams with numerous games, whether it's the NHL, the NBA, or Major League Baseball, sell packages of tickets, because it's sometimes burdensome to buy 40 or 80 games at a time. But buying 12 or 16 may be more worthwhile depending on what the market can bear. And so they can sell those tickets. And also they can control the venues depending on if they own the venue themselves privately or if it's through a municipality partner. They oftentimes get to manage that venue. And even though there are some minimum standards that the league's require the individual teams generally not always, but generally get to manage the venue and take care of the venue as they see fit. And so that's always a benefit for these teams, where they have the ability to control not just the playing surface, but also all of the marketing and advertising opportunities and licensing it out for special events and that type of thing. And so, you know, another thing I want to talk about are some of the departments that are involved with the franchises now the franchise is really different, because there's not nearly as many people working for each franchise as
40:43there is with the league. Generally, you have a managing partner of an ownership group, it may be the majority shareholder, in a be the president or the CEO of that company. Or it could just be the single owner, depending on what the how the ownership looks like, then you're going to have those other ownership interests, right. A minority shareholder is a stakeholder in the team, limited partner, something like that, then you're going to be named, you're going to name a president or a CEO of a team, and they're really going to oversee everything, you're going to have the CFO, and usually a chief baseball officer, Chief basketball officer that really oversees the sport side of it. The on field product or on ice product or on court product is very specific. And it takes it's it's not just understanding how the sport is played, but also understanding the entire dynamic of that industry. And so it really takes a specialist to have that chief sports officer in a franchise. Again, there's typical categories and departments for each one of these areas.
41:50And it really depends on the individual and the lawyer and the owner, and the president ceo, and where they want to place each person in a department. So with accounting, right, this is a really big one with these franchises, they need to figure out who's in charge of financial management, accounts receivable, you know, you have ticket accounting, which is completely different than just the regular accounting, you have General Accounting stuff. And then you have foundation accounting, usually there's a nonprofit sector to each team. And really, it's a good community effort. And oftentimes, the owner will have some sort of personal attachment to a certain cause. So you have ticket sales and marketing, they always throw these two in together. And sometimes they put advertising in there. And I always like to do that as well. But you have those corporate partnership, people that focus in on just creating those court, corporate partnerships, you have the guest services, right? These are people that answer the phone. These are the people that reach out to certain clients. These are the people that you have answer questions when your fans are looking for their questions answered at the venue, you have somebody handling special events, these aren't just the all star games in the Super Bowl type things. These are also those special events when you have a meet and greet with the players. When you have that special kid's day when you have a camp out in the outfield. Some of those other special events that are ancillary to the actual sport
43:18themselves. Like I said, you have the the advertising gifts and inside salespeople, those soft leads, you have some hospitality folks that handle some of the VIPs and that the club level seating and those sweet holders. And but with along with that you have those people that are selling those premium seats, the legal arm of it. Most teams now have in House Counsel, if not more, oftentimes, they have an AGC as well. But some teams still don't. Sometimes they're just using outside counsel. And so that's something that I think will be coming to a close where most teams will or I guess all teams, I would think within the next few years we'll have inside counsel because it's really important to have somebody for the day to day as well. You're going to have the communications arm where you have everything from player and media relations, the publications with your programs and your scorecards, the corporate communications where you're dealing with your corporate partners and creating content. So they have branded media, you're gonna have social media, and this is an area that some teams are getting in trouble with. But now it seems to be that teams have somebody Manning their Twitter account 24 seven, or their Facebook account or their Snapchat account, but somebody is usually in charge of the social media. And of course, you have the photographer and the community affairs person. You're going to have the human resource department that looks almost identical to every other human resource
44:44department. In any corporate setting in America, you're going to have some business operations, right. So this is a sector that you're going to cover some facilities, you're going to cover the security, probably the housekeeping groundskeeping and maybe it depends on whether or not you consider it a whole separate category. Now, let's talk about the sports side of it right? This is the front part, where when we're talking about the operations of the sport itself and the on field product, this is where a general manager of a team usually sets, while the president and CEO often comes from this role and gets promoted out of it. Generally, the general manager is under the operation side of things. Now, they're going to lead it. But they're also going to oversee the scouting department, right? The professional and the amateur scouting, they're going to oversee the player development, they're going to oversee the analytics department, right, with all the new data that's coming in with wearable devices, as well as statistical analysis, they're going to oversee all of that, including the video operations. So that general manager role even though it's one small piece on a on a map, you'll see on the PowerPoint, it is a critical role, because that on field product is what drives the revenue of the team. And then of course, you're gonna have broadcasting some teams just license this out to their media partners, others do it in house, depending on how the company is set up. But you have the on air talent, you have the engineers, the
46:20managers, the producers, the directors, all of that type of thing, if they're handling broadcasting, it's just like any other news or live TV show that they're going to have to deal with. So as you can see, there are a number of departments that are involved with just having a team also want to talk about some of the philanthropy efforts and why that's important. It's not just important, because it's giving back to the community. But with the leagues and the teams, it's really important when you're with any company that has billions of dollars in revenue, think about each of these major sports is approaching at least $5 billion in revenue annually over their member teams, it's a lot of money. And everybody is aware of the type of money that these companies or are these franchise owners are bringing in as well as the league.
47:14It's important to get back to the community, not just because it's doing something nice in a good PR battle. But it's also helping people understand what your sport is about an end to putting a face to a lot of the teams that are out there with the National Football League, your players wear helmets, so they're outside of being great big men, oftentimes, some of the smaller players go on notice when they're walking around the street, it really helps your players, it really helps your team and helps the people that are in your office connect with the community. And so while it's a great tax deduction as well, it's also important because it will help generate revenue later on, and makes you feel good too. One thing that I do want to bring up, before we go to some of the takeaways are why the the structure of the leagues really through some of the pressure of their teams is changing. The 501 c six structure was preferred for a really long time. But now, the leagues are realizing that they don't necessarily need to have a non profit status.
48:19Even though they save some money on taxes. It's estimated that the NFL, which has recently abandoned the 501 c six structure to a taxable entity structure, they might pay $10 million in taxes this upcoming year. And while that's certainly a lot of money, it's not that big of a check for the National Football League to write with the pressure of the public where you have commissioners making, at least with Roger Goodell, the Commissioner of the of the National Football League, he was making $44 million, which is higher than many fortune 500 CEOs. And so that certainly had Congress, a little upset and people outraged that a commissioner of the sport was making that kind of money, it was important for the National Football League to really evaluate what they needed to do in order to change things up a little bit to not just take the public pressure off of them, but also to get some of the regulator's off of them, because of course, they were threatening the antitrust exemption that the sports have. And so that was important. And so you're going to see some leagues go away from that. But really, each individual league is different. And just because one league is going to do it doesn't mean that that's maybe the right way, or the appropriate way for each individually to act. It depends on each organization. And so, if you're working with any of these organizations, it's always important to know what the landscape looks like, but also be ready to adapt and change if necessary. It's important to look through those things. And even though nobody likes
49:55being the first one to say that something should be done it Maybe important that somebody steps up and says 501 c six, no longer should apply to us, let's abandon that and go somewhere else, you can always go back and forth. And so that's always something that I look at when I'm dealing with clients is that if we pick a structure, and that needs to change, that can certainly happen. And so that's something I want to take a look at. But also with the antitrust exemption. That's another area where sports remember, it's an emotional business. And even when the courts make decisions in favor of or to the detriment of sports based on some emotions that play in and they, the sports, the sports cases vary widely on their application, it's important to realize that Congress hears from their constituents. So if you own the Atlanta Hawks, right and NBA franchise, and they decide they want to move, you can guarantee the congressman from that area, and the senators are going to get a lot of phone calls. And so if the Congresswoman from Atlanta hears about that, she may very well start calling the league office to discuss antitrust if her constituents put up enough of a fight. So keep that in mind that these are companies with a lot of public public perception issues, when they fall slightly out of touch, or if the public just doesn't like what they're doing, because it might result in a negative consequence for their team. So for example, you just saw with the Rams moving back to LA, all sorts of issues going on. And so you want to keep that in
51:42mind. With the businesses you're handling, though. So let's talk about some of the big takeaways that we have here in the last few minutes. Number one, you can learn a lot from sports and the things that is going on in the sports business to apply to your clients. Or maybe it's your farm or your outside business as well. So use a structure a corporate structure that fits your client's needs. We talked about how ownership groups vary from partnerships to LLCs. Use the one that works for your clients, there's no one right way to do things, it's important to do it the right way for your clients. And so while a general partnership may be just fine for you, the next door neighbor, they might want a limited partnership, or the neighbor next to them might want the LLC, it's completely okay, if you have different structures. Or if you see that a client needs something, it's not just about how, say the Miami Dolphins are structured, it's important about what your client needs. You also want to make sure that you maximize the asset of your clients, right. So and you want to make sure that you're able to maximize that asset to get the best returns and streamline the work, we see that with the leaks for the National Hockey League can help streamline some of the work by licensing their individual members. Intellectual property. Now, you may not have a league or a team that can do that. But the businesses that you represent, they may license their intellectual property. And there may be ways to help streamline that
53:24process. But there's also important ways to package that material, right. So we talked about how teams can provide exclusive categories for some of their sponsors and advertisers, it's important to realize that your business can do the same. And you can get products to exclusivity, if you are working with a business that is in negotiations with a team for those advertising rights. So if you're representing a local business that's going to advertise that a minor league baseball team, maybe you try and get that exclusive category for, say, a car dealership, maybe they won't offer that. And so you should decrease the actual value of that, that deal. And really just try and maximize what your clients are able to get out of it. You also, right along with that is figuring out how to leverage things in what to leverage with sports, they're able to leverage that public pressure and they're the public engagement with their team, right, that emotional part of people cheering for their teams to get the best benefit. I don't know that a lot of municipalities would build billion dollar football stadiums if it wasn't for the emotional attachment that people have towards their teams. And so the teams have certainly learned how to leverage that. They've also learned how to leverage that VIP experience. So those luxury suites I don't know anybody that thinks watching a football game or a basketball game is worth several $1,000 a ticket. It's that overall experience. And so these teams have been able to leverage Just the luxury, the access, and
55:03really the ease of getting to a game, and really making it a worthwhile experience. So people pay extra money, nobody wants to pay $6 for a hotdog that cost 35 cents. But if you can leverage that cost into the actual experience, now, that revenue can certainly work for a team. And it can work in your work as well. While you're not probably not setting hot dog prices, you're certainly setting some of the parameters of contracts. And if you can leverage those assets within a contract, you can certainly generate more revenue or decrease the revenue your client has to pay out. So the other thing is really develop good working relationships with in with those in your industry. So we saw with the move of the Rams out here to Los Angeles, that there was a lot of jockeying, there was a lot of politics that had to be played. And it's important that those relationships are maintained. If the if you don't have a good relationship with the other owners, it's really going to be hard to push your agenda, just like anything in politics. Or if you're a part of the any other business association, you're going to understand this very well, you need to have those good business relationships within your industry. It's also important that you leverage some of the associations and groups that you belong to.
56:25And it could be for your advantage, it could be for your clients, just like these member teams, really lean on the National Football League to do a lot of things, you can lean on some of those organizations, oftentimes they're underutilized by people, including myself, for example, with the sports Lawyers Association, you have a vast member directory that you can reach out to is that you're going to be able to find out the latest happenings in sports law. And some other organizations have formed documents. So if you have something that comes across your desk, that you've never seen before, instead of just trying to get a PDF from Google, you might want to try starting out with one of your associations that you belong with to see if they actually have that document and save yourself a lot of work and help your client because they're going to be able to at least start you out with those basic terms that you're going to need in those contracts. And they're used in your industry. So really, it's important. Also, if you're trying to hold an event, a lot of times local bar associations, just like some of these leagues will allow you to utilize their spaces, though their resources in order to help make your event a success, though, or your clients event a success, it's really important that those associations aren't just another check that you write throughout the year. But it's a source that you can use to really leverage what you have. Another thing is be prepared to adapt, as things have changed in sports, the antitrust exemption things, some of the
57:59requirements of the leagues, with a tax status, it's really important to be adaptable, and find more than just one way to get things done. As my dad always said, if there's only one way to get things done, it's probably not going to end up well for you anyway, if you can find one or two ways to get things done, you can always leverage if they've cut off one of the ways now you have a second way to attack a problem. So really important to be adaptable with your strategies. And, you know, one of the last things here is prepare for unexpected court rulings, like we've seen it sports is an emotional issue. And so even though you can have the best jurists in the world on a bench, oftentimes, that emotional part of it will be in the back of their mind.
58:48And even though we already know that some lawyers and some judges will try and reach a conclusion, in order to do really the right thing. Oftentimes, in sports, you get an emotional ruling, that has some legal basis for it. But if it was any other industry, that may come out differently. And so it just helps everybody realize that sometimes you're not going to be able to fully predict what's going to happen at the court. So really, just be aware of that and understand that you may have to prepare for some unexpected court rulings. And finally, if you need a specialist, or you need help, or you need more understanding in a certain area, get it go hire somebody that all the sports leagues do that. They hire lobbyists, they hire lawyers, they have accountants, they really delegated their tasks. And even though commissioner and their staff are very capable of handling a multitude of issues, they have really handled a they've really done a good job of handling those issues off to other people that can handle it a little bit better and more efficiently. And so it's important for your clients as well.
59:54If you see a client struggling with something, you may want to refer them to somebody that can help them out. Do it just a little bit better than they could if they were on their own. There's always information that you can find out about whether it's sports law in general, whether it's another CLE video, or just if you're looking for more examples that you can use in the business world. Feel free to check out some of the resources here on the PowerPoint slides with the sports Lawyers Association, a great place to start and a great organization be a member of but also, you know, check out some other things that may be beneficial for you if you're part of a Business Alliance or a business networking group. They also have those four sports. I'm a member of one and oftentimes we have non sports business that gets referred out to one another. And you can also check out my web page for the business practice that I have.
1:00:48And I try and update that pretty regularly. Again, my name is Brandon Leopold us and I'm a sports and business attorney here in beautiful Los Angeles, California. And I welcome any questions or comments you may have and if you want any more information about this or any other topic that I may be able to help you with, feel free to reach out to me and my contact information is on the materials. Thanks
Lori A. D.CA
A very thorough and entertaining review of the issues that make each of the big four professional leagues unique and explains why they are treated uniquely from other corporations. I really enjoyed it.
Stanley B.PA
Excellent presentation as an introduction to the sports content field of law.