48min · about 8,500 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's seminar. With that, just a little bit about myself, too, before we get started. My name is Carrie Sheehan. I'm assistant general counsel at Taft, Stentinius Hollister Law Firm. I'm located in Indianapolis, Indiana. In my role as general assistant general counsel, I work with internal ethics and compliance. So anything that really touches the rules of professional conduct or compliance for the law firm which operates as a corporation do, comes through my office or general counsel's office and myself to make sure that we are compliant and that we stay upright with our ethics. So if any of our attorneys get sued, if Taft gets sued or anything like that, those are the types of things I deal with on a regular basis. And then I'm there for that. Loss prevention and risk management.
0:52With that, we're going to get started here today. Today's seminar is Lawyers Role and the Law. And we play many different roles as lawyers. There's many different types out there, too. Now, if you think back to the days in which you were a law clerk or a summer clerk, now some of you, that's a lot longer ago than others. But just think to the different colleagues that you interact with and the different people you interact with on a daily basis, maybe they're partners, maybe they're opposing counsel. Maybe they're just members of the bar association that you go to events with. Think about their conduct, think about their demeanor, and think about, too. Have any of them ever left an impression on you, either good or bad?
1:39Now, if you're a younger lawyer and you really think about that, like what lawyers have left an impression on you, you probably start to frame or think about what type of lawyer you want to be. And this usually has to deal with the reputation of the other lawyers you see in the community. There are some lawyers in the community where I practice that I'm like, oh my gosh, they have this reputation, or I've been up against them and they are rude, they're loud, they're, you know, just every turn and corner, they're going to throw something that's just unnecessary. And so you start to see those things. And so then you have to ask yourself, do you want to be that kind of lawyer with the bullying reputation or the reputation that has more of an uncivil, unprofessional, or do you want to be the type of lawyer that is professional?
2:28Sometimes they don't press every argument. Maybe they're not known as aggressive or bullheaded, but they're effective or, you know, they've done something to help. And so you have to look at the different lawyers out there and see what type of lawyer you want to be or you want to change into if you're already into your practice. And it was actually a professor of mine way back when I was in law school that said if you wake up and look at yourself in the mirror and don't like who you see looking back at you, or can't look at the person with a good conscience and they're proud of who you become, then maybe you need to change. And when I teach legal ethics in the law school, I always ask law students at the time who are going through the clerkships, who are going through the summer associate programs, and I ask him those questions we saw on the first screen. And. And every single law student usually has a story. And the ones that really stick out in their mind are the lawyers that they don't want to be like. And a lot of times it's the ones that are very argumentative, that are rude, that are insolent, that are, you know, just uncivil and unprofessional, or have an arrogance about them to where it's off putting. Young lawyers are really pushed off by that. They don't want to be that lawyer, and they see it, and they're turned off by the legal profession.
3:47But then I get the stories of the lawyer who helped them, who mentored them, who went out of their way to try to make, you know, their experience worthwhile and try to educate them on how to become a lawyer. And then they saw the respect that that lawyer got from other colleagues, from other, you know, people in the community, not just from clients, not just from, you know, the partners within the firm, but from everywhere. And a lot of our younger lawyers gravitate towards those lawyers. So what type of lawyer do you want to be? Whether you're a first year out, 20, 30, 40 years out, it's never too late to change and know what type you want to be. So I do encourage you to think about that, especially in the context of civility and just professionalism within the legal roles. Now, lawyers also have other roles. We are obviously client advisors.
4:39We have client relationships. You know, it always starts there. And in that role as an advisor for a client or the attorney client relationship, what do you think or believe your specific role is? Is it to be the dictator, the one who calls and makes all the decisions? Is it to push every advantage? Is it to be rude and insolent, just to try to let your client win at, you know, whatever cost it comes at or is your role in that attorney client relationship to be an advisor, to be a kind of a alongside colleague of the client, meaning you work with the client to achieve those objectives, that it's okay not to press every advantage, that it's okay to let stuff go or to counsel on, you know, yes, we have this legal argument, but it's in your best interest or best business decision to maybe let that go and compromise here and there.
5:38What is the role? Well, if we look at the rules of Professional conduct, particularly Rule 1.2, it states that the client controls the objectives of the representation and the lawyer controls the means of how to get to those objectives. But Rule 1.2 has to be read in conjunction with Rule 1.4, our communication rule. So as the attorney is communicating the means to get to those client objectives, they do have a duty under Rule 1.4, Communication, to consult with the client. And ultimately the client is the boss. If the client says no, they don't want to pursue a certain means to get to those ultimate objectives, then the answer is no.
6:25If the client wants to press certain things, the lawyer can push back about those means being used, especially if they find them pugnant or, you know, not going to be in the best interest, they can say, no, I'm not going to push that objective. No, I'm not going to do that. Will the client get mad? Maybe, maybe not. Maybe you can reason with them to say why this route's better than that route. But if they do get mad, guess what? They have the right to fire you. And you have the right to fire them. You do not have to stick an attorney client relationship in which the client is taking pass and conduct that is objectively unreasonable to you or against what you believe your role as a lawyer is. And if the client is also taking steps or doing things that is adverse to the rules of professional conduct, meaning that they're violating them or they're asking you to violate the rules, then the rules tell us that we must withdraw from that representation because we cannot do anything that's fraudulent or criminal or, or we cannot do anything against the rules of professional conduct. And if we do, we are up for that disciplinary complaint and we could lose our license, be suspended, be publicly reprimanded, or whatever types of punishments are within the jurisdiction with your practicing.
7:47So we do have to have that attorney client relationship. And yes, while the client controls those objectives and is technically the boss, we control the means within the bounds of the rules of professional conduct. And we just have to know when to say enough is enough, and when to step back and step aside and say, no, I'm not going to push that. I'm not going to be that kind of lawyer. The kind of lawyer that, you know, is the puppet to the client. I do everything the client says without independently thinking. There are lawyers like that, they just do whatever the client says because the client's paying them and they want paid and they don't care about anything else. Then there's the lawyers who say, no, I work with my client, I counsel them. We're a team, we're a partnership, we work together. That's usually the best kind of lawyer. There's also the other lawyer who tries to dominate the client, meaning that lawyer thinks he's or she's the boss and not the client, which is completely contrary to the rules of ethics. So think to yourself. When you're dealing with clients, those client interactions, which category do you fit into? Are you the puppet and the client the puppet master? Are you the one that's more collaborative, you know, the joining together in the attorney client relationship to get to that common goal in the most ethical, reasonable manner with, you know, sound business mind?
9:08Or are you the one that wants to be the dictator? The one that wants to call all the shots because you went to law school after all? Right, they didn't. So are you that one? What role do you want to be and how does that affect your reputation? How does that affect your effectiveness in court and for your clients? And these are all considerations that you need to think about. And we do study ethics, and we do study the rules of ethics to really see how far we should go. How far should we go into that puppet, puppet master type scenario where the client is controlling the strings? How far should we go and compromise before we have to step up and be more that boss?
9:51How far should we go and what is the right path? And a lot of attorneys think, well, I can't be a good lawyer if I'm going to be this pushover or always be the nice person or do the right thing. And I would ask if I could see you, which I know you can. I'm not asking you to turn on your camera, but just think about that. Have you ever in your practice or career thought, well, you know, this is what it really should do, you know, ethically, morally, but I'm not going to win, so I'm going to do the opposite. How far do we go and do we have to have. Do we have to compromise being that good, moral person in the interest of Legal, you know, winning or legal justifications or can we incorporate it all together? And it is kind of an interesting question to ask too, because if you look at the different corporate scandals throughout the country and throughout history dating back to Enron and even before that, there's always lawyers involved in those corrupt scandals. Lawyers in house and the corporations, maybe outside counsel too. And so why is it that we always see lawyers getting sanctioned, getting criminal charges brought against them whenever there's a big scandal, when we have the rules of professional conduct here that are supposed to guard us or keep us morally right, so we don't get into those situations.
11:15The only question that really, or the only answer that can really come from that is the fact that lawyers just discard the rules of professional conduct or don't think they're always relevant or think, well, if I follow them, I'm not going to win or get ahead or make that million dollars, not have that mansion, you know, or live in that upscale neighborhood. And so they just can't coincide being a good person and following the rules and, you know, having all those material things that they want and that power and prestige, that, that comes at a cost. And normally that cost is morality, the rules of professional conduct, and not doing what we're supposed to be doing as lawyers.
11:57But we do really have to think and stop and step back and that going even back to our oath as an attorneys, we were there to uphold the profession, uphold the integrity of it, uphold the Constitution and our justice system and, and give society confidence in our justice system. We are the gatekeepers to the courts. We're the gatekeepers to, you know, the scales of justice and everything. And so our conduct, whether we want to believe it or not, is viewed by public and society as being what the legal profession is. And that's why we have all the lawyer jokes. That's why we have all those things. Because over time it has just come about because you always hear that case blowing up of the lawyer who stole money, or this lazy lawyer that did XYZ or didn't follow the rules.
12:45And then, you know, it causes a joke or it goes, now it goes viral. And so you've got to look at all those different things. So some tips to thinking about your ethics and really having that attorney client relationship which the rules of professional conduct envisioned, where that client controls the objectives, you advise, you counsel on the means, but you're not the dictator. It's a partnership between you and your client. These are some things that you can ask yourself throughout the representation to make sure you're still on that partnership track with the client, really trying to achieve those objectives.
13:22You can ask, you know, are you furthering your client's interest and what they want? Are you pursuing something out of a grudge or vendetta? Is it objectionable to your morals or what you believe is right and wrong? Now, obviously, if you're trying to pursue a personal vendetta or a grudge or something's adverse to your morals and judgment, then you're probably not doing the right thing as a lawyer. If you're furthering your client's interest in the best way possible, taking out any grudges or vendettas or anything like that, then you're more on the right track. Are you working as that partnership and as that team. Those something to really consider there too. We also have to remember too, that a lot of people or a lot of lawyers just think that they only have to be nice in litigation because that's where, you know, there's the most adversary or adversarial component or opponents. And so you always think of litigation lawyers as being the most mean, the most, you know, unprofessional. But I have met some transactional lawyers that far outweigh personality wise, meaning very vindictive, very grudge holding those vendettas that they have, and just very forceful in their nature. I've met some transactional lawyers that can basically wipe out any litigation lawyer any day. And that's because there's this misconception that transactional lawyers, in most transaction, everything's friendly or there's no adversary, it's just a contract. But if you think of a contract, it's about money normally and getting what you want and making sure, like,
14:56if something goes wrong, you're covered. And that can actually be more confrontational than a blowout fight in a courtroom. It's just, it's more done on paper and it's more done in a backstabbing, vindictive way. And so even like the transactional lawyers and not just our litigators, they can have, you know, these grudges and this discord and that vendetta is just going to come through on paper. We also have to remember too, when we're in those heated, contentious situations, that sometimes it's just best to bite our tongue or to walk away or say, nope, I'm not going to represent this person. We always have to know that that is an option. You can fire a client almost at any time. Now, I say almost at any time because in most jurisdictions, if you're in the throes of a litigation, and maybe it's a week out till trial, and now you want to withdraw from the client representation, you're usually going to have to file a motion with the court requesting leave to withdraw and get the court to agree.
15:56Now, a week before trial starts, that's probably not going to happen. Maybe it is, depending on the reason, but this. But it's getting slimmer. And if the judge is going to grant that. Now, obviously a client can fire you at any time, even that week before trial, because again, the client has the right to choose the lawyer they want. And if they don't want you, then they don't have to have you as a lawyer. Now, a judge could say, you know, even if you do fire a lawyer, are you prepared to move ahead pro se? Who's your new attorney? We're not going to delay this proceeding. So there's all those little caveats, too, that can come into play. But sometimes it is best to file that motion to withdraw or just walk away when something's going to get contentious, uncivil and unprofessional. Because again, what is your role? You're there as an advisor, not as a dictator.
16:47You're there to help the client achieve those objectives. And if there's a breakdown in the communications, if there is an uncivil nature, an unprofessional nature, then maybe it's time to walk away. At that point. You also need to remember to never put money above your morals and obligations. And that is sometimes a really hard thing to think about. Because how do lawyers get paid? We get paid when clients pay us. There is no money tree. There's no corporate backing or investors propping up the law firm. We get paid when our clients pay us. If we don't have money in, we can't have money going out to pay us or our staff. So a lot of times, especially if you're in a smaller, excuse me, if you're a solo practitioner in a smaller firm or maybe even a midsize firm, if there's no money coming in, then you can't maintain the practice. So a lot of times attorneys will do things, even unethical or against what their role is just to keep the money coming in from the clients.
17:51They're not going to want to fire that client for, you know, a breakdown in communication. They're not going to want to fire the client. If the client asks them to do something repugnant or in violation of the rules, they're going to do it. So that they get paid. And that is one of the things we really have to separate. And always, always, always remember this. Never put money above those morals and ethical obligations that we have to uphold as lawyers. Because the minute you do that, it gets easier and easier until you're up for discipline or disciplinary complaint, and then you're defending your conduct, conduct and potentially could lose your law license. So we always need to think about that.
18:35And if you have ever a question about, you know, what are the Rules of Professional Conduct, I know I'm up here, you know, saying the Rules of Professional Conduct, I've said the model rules. And so if you want to know where they're located, if you, you've forgotten that class in law school, Here are some URLs or some different websites you can visit. Now, there are different levels of rules. The ABA has the Model Rules of Professional Conduct. This is just the model standard. These are put out there so that each certain jurisdiction or state can decide, do we want to follow the model rules, do we want to revise them? Do we want to write our own rules? And so it's just a model. So when you're listening to seminars like the one I'm giving, or it's more of a general class, when we have multiple people on the line from multiple jurisdictions, a lot of times, like I'm doing, the speaker will cite to the model rules because those could apply universally. But each jurisdiction has their own set of rules that they've adopted for ethics knowing as basically the jurisdictional set. In Indiana, they're called the Indiana Rules of Professional Conduct, and there's the website for it.
19:46If you're in California, you have your own Rules of Professional Conduct just for lawyers in California. Same with New York, Florida or any other jurisdiction. So while the model Rules is great as a model and a starting point, depending on what jurisdiction you're located in, you're going to have to review the, the specific jurisdictions model Rules to figure out if you violated them. So say, for instance, I'm located here in Indiana. If I do something that's unethical, it will fall under the Indiana Rules of Professional Conduct, since that's where I'm located and that's where the case probably is. And so I'd have to look to see if it's wrong in those rules.
20:27Now, the thing is, sometimes your jurisdictional specific rules may differ from the model rules and differ from jurisdiction jurisdiction. So each jurisdiction you practice in, you need to make sure you're in line with those rules for that particular jurisdiction because if you get disciplined in one jurisdiction you're licensed in, excuse me, you could have a reciprocal discipline in all jurisdictions you're licensed in, even if the conduct only happened in one jurisdiction. So make sure you go out and take a look at your specific jurisdictional rules and then the model rules too. I always like to use the model rules as a stepping off point of just how to do an analysis. Sometimes the state specific jurisdictions, because they give guidance, they give say we're going to apply it this way or this was the intent behind it. So then when you get to the specific jurisdictional rules, you kind of have that language, that backing to know, you know what, how it's going to play out. Plus, the ABA offers formal and informal opinions on how rules should be interpreted, which are some great guidance. Recently, over the past month, it came out with formal opinion 514 regarding in house counsel. And you know, who is the client, is it the individuals, is it the corporation?
21:46And how all that should be treated and communicated across. So there's no discrepancy on who is the client. And so it's good there for those ABA rules because they always follow the model rules when they write those opinions to really see the rules come into action and come into play and understand how they're going to play out specifically. Then if you go to your specific jurisdiction, they have the same rule as the model rules, then you're going to know how it's going to play out or should play out. You can also look at other sources too. There is actually a Restatement Third of Law Governing Lawyers, which covers more in depth ethical topics regarding the Rules of Professional Conduct.
22:26It also covers some agencies civility privilege questions and has some great resources for that too. So there are different places where you can find your ethical obligations and look for them. Now, I know this is kind of going back to law school, but you would be surprised how many lawyers have not read their Rules of Professional Conduct since law school. And when you're reading the rules, it's always good to remember that any shall or must in the phrase, like if it says an attorney shall or an attorney must, you know, and then it tells you what you shall or must do is a mandatory standard, meaning we don't have any discretion, we have to do that. If it says an attorney may, that means we can use our professional discretionary judgment and decide if we want to follow the rule or not based on the circumstances.
23:14So there is a difference. And you really do need to get down to the language of your specific rules. And jurisdiction to know which ones are mandatory standards and which ones are discretionary standards so that you know what you have to follow and what you have the option or professional judgment to follow in certain circumstances. Now, when you are reading the rules and kind of setting them and looking for the different scenarios, do not forget about the comments. I have memorized the comments here to the rules. If you are studying for an MPRE or for an ethics exam, then obviously you really do need to memorize them, but you also need to memorize them for legal practice, because those comments are, is actually giving you how the rules are going to be applied. They're giving you examples, they're giving you scenarios, they're giving you different things like that. And so it really does go back to knowing what the comments say. You can't just rely on the face of the rule. The comments interpret the rule and give you the scenario.
24:15So that is why I say memorize it. If you're taking the NPR like you're a new lawyer or, or if you're an older lawyer just learning the rules, memorize them. The, the meat is in those comments. You cannot skip the comments to the rules. We also have to remember to read the preamble to the rules so that we know our role as lawyers and we know what we're supposed to do. We have to know that we have to respond with competent diligence, promptness, and conduct ourselves honorably. Also, too, this number five here in the preamble states that a lawyer's conduct shall conform to requirements of law both in their professional service and business and personal affairs.
24:58This means that the rules of professional conduct apply to us 24 hours a day, seven days a week in our personal and professional capacities. Now you can think, okay, we all know this. It's been ingrained in us since law school. It's, you know, it's always been there. But if you think about some of the things that the rules of professional conduct say that we have to do, like conducting ourselves honorably, acting with competence, promptness, diligence, and then it says that we have to conform or meet these requirements in our professional, business, and personal capacities. Have you done that? You may think, well, yeah, I always have. Can I ask your spouse, can I ask your significant other, your partner, your colleagues, would they say the same thing? Would they say that 24 hours a day, seven days a week, no matter in what capacity you're in, either acting as a lawyer, acting as a business person, acting in your personal affairs, that you have complied with all of the rules of professional conduct in every situation, as well as the oath and the preamble and the requirements of them. And most people would still say, yeah, yeah, I think I have. The ones who say, nope, don't think I can say that, are probably the ones being the most honest with themselves.
26:21Because a lot of jurisdictions, and I put Indiana's up here on the screen just as an example, have a little phrase or have a little oath or part of the oath just thrown in and buried in the middle. Now, if you're in Indiana like I am, you may not remember this oath because we stated this oath or said this oath when we got licensed. So it was at that swearing in ceremony. Most of us, that's the last time we've ever read that oath or looked at it or thought of its existence. But I encourage you, no matter what jurisdiction you're in, to look up the oath you took when you became a lawyer, the oath you took when you raised your right hand and got sworn in. Because I guarantee you, most of us have forgotten what that O said. Because it's a whirlwind that day. You're a new lawyer, you pass the bar, you've got the job, you're going to get more money.
27:13There's all kinds of things going on. You got Supreme Court justices up there talking, you've got your classmates. And so it's just a whirlwind. And we don't focus on the words. But when you really get down to the words, we swore to uphold everything in this oath here in Indiana. Look up your specific jurisdiction. And one of those things in the yellow font, which is underlined there in the middle, we said that we would abstain from offensive personality. Abstaining from offensive personality. Now you take that, you couple it with the preamble where, you know, it's housed in, and that applies to us 24 hours a day, seven days a week in our legal, professional, business and personal affairs.
28:00So then I asked the question again. If you were in Indiana, whatever your jurisdiction says, because Indiana is not the only one that has the something like this buried in its oath. Have you abstained from offensive personality 24 hours a day, seven days a week in your personal, professional, business, or whatever capacity you're acting in, I guarantee you most of us, if not 99.9 or almost 100%, would put our hands down right now and we would say, nope, we can't swear to say that because that is a very high standard. And a lot of us too, when we're maybe out for cocktails, with friends, when we're tired, when we're in an argument with our spouse. We're not acting in an un. In a nice personality.
28:48We have an offensive personality. Maybe you said something the wrong way. Maybe you yelled at someone because it was the wrong moment. Maybe you're frustrated. This is a very high standard that they want us lawyers to meet, and no lawyer is perfect. But we do have to keep it in the back of our minds that we are held to higher standards and that we should really strive to achieve the oath we took. We should strive to achieve. To be that lawyer that law students or people working for us find to be impressive and memorable, the lawyer that they want to be like when they become a lawyer or work for a lawyer. We need to strive to have those personalities and to have that role in and to think about our conduct. And it's also ingrained not only in the oath, but everywhere in bar admissions. When we took the bar, when we're admitting new applicants, most jurisdictions, if not all, have a maintaining integrity of the profession provision.
29:49And it basically says to be an applicant for the bar. And this was probably the same for you when you applied. Maybe it was a little different, depending on how many years you've been practicing, but it's very similar. And so with this, too, this maintaining integrity, we don't want lawyers to enter our bar. So think about all your law clerks out there right now, your summer associates. I want to be lawyers. And if they lie or make false statements to the commission, if they disclose, if they forget to disclose something necessary in their application to make a good determination, they're not going to become lawyers and they could be disciplined. Same thing for existing lawyers.
30:29If we lie, we violate the rules. It's rules like 3.4, 3.6, and so forth and so on. If we do not have good integrity, you know, in what we do, then we can be disciplined. For the new lawyers coming in, your law clerks, new associates, if they lie on their bar materials, if they lied in that law school application or the two don't coincide, then they can be in trouble and not become a lawyer. We want to try to protect the integrity of our legal profession. And it starts with those incoming lawyers. And it starts with, you know, just making sure that they fully understand that oath they're about to take, that they fully understand the rules of professional conduct.
31:12And the way they're going to fully understand that is us, seasoned lawyers, leading by example and being that lawyer. We want to be being that role model we want to see there, because again, Admission into our bar includes that criteria of good moral character or fitness to practice law. It also includes the other things you see on the screen, like age, education, examination, oath, but that fitness to practice law and be of good moral character. This means acting honestly, the ability to act professionally in a manner that endangers respect for the law and the profession. When we turned in those bar applications, we, you know, gave over our criminal records or academic histories, you know, anything like that, even stuff that could be mismanagement of personal affairs, like maybe you didn't pay child support. Well, how can you handle clients money or how can you advocate for someone else to pay your client child support when you didn't even do it yourself? So those are things that kind of play into a good moral character of a lawyer that we really have to stop and think about and know that that is going to be how we're assessed 24 hours a day, seven days a week on our personal, business and professional capacities.
32:24We have to have conduct that exudes public trust, that makes clients in the relationship want to trust us and come to us with their legal problems. It's a very high standard to meet. And a lot of times too, and this is almost in any profession, if you've done something in your past before you were a lawyer or while you were a lawyer, now you know, you're, you know, you've gone a few years and not done it again. But a lot of times, jurisdictions and courts, that minute you get in trouble again, they're going to take that past conduct into consideration. Because a lot of bar associations think that past conduct indicates future performance. Especially if you've done it once, you'll do it twice, you've done it twice, you'll do it three times. And so if that does come about, whether you're in front of a disciplinary commission or whether you have a new lawyer that's trying to enter the bar, you have to prove that you can be rehabilitated. You have to prove that you know you can do better and why did you mess up again? Or you know you're not going to mess up in the future. The disciplinary commission. Bar associations love to see that rehabilitation. If they feel like that rehabilitation is not there after you've been done something against the rules of professional conduct, you're probably not going to get readmitted or you're going to have a har har, harsher sanction. Rehabilitation is one of the key hallmarks that disciplinary commissions and bar associations really want to see. When lawyers have been in trouble in the Past are
33:57in trouble again or it's even a first time offense. They do, they want to see a rehabilitation so they're not going to have a repeat offender because of repeat offenders harm the public impression of what lawyers are and the hallmark of our profession, you know, having being that honest, upright attorney. Now a lot of times too when it comes to these things, a lot of attorneys and even law students are applying for admission to the bar if you're going back that far as well again, they feel that they shouldn't have to give over their past criminal histories or talk about stuff that's happened in the past or not have it reincarnated again if they do something else wrong. And they do claim kind of first Amendment rights too. It's like, why should you make, you know, something in the past come up now or you know, why do I have to give over my mental health records? Why do you care about the fact I didn't pay child support? That's private. And a lot of attorneys and law students in different contexts have tried to make these arguments and they failed every time. Because when we take the oath and we raise our right hand, we oh say that, swear that we will uphold the legal profession and that even our first amendment rights take a curb or a seat next to the rules of professional conduct. Because to hold a law license is a privilege. It's not a right. There is no right to be a lawyer. It's not in the first Amendment, it's not anywhere. So if you want to be a lawyer and practice law, then you have to agree to
35:24abide by the oath and what that means to practice law. And so again it takes that backseat to it. There is a case and the page references throughout are for my reference, not yours. I have a text back book that I sometimes pull examples from and this one is the case is in re application of converse. Citation is 602 Northwest 2nd 500 Nebraska 1999. This is actually a student. It's a 48 year old student at the McGrath for Nebraska who's applying to the Nebraska, Nebraska State Bar Commission who denied its bar examination application. And in this case the Converse, the person completed law school had checked. Yes, when asked whether the bar examiners could inquire regarding his moral character. So he checked the appropriate box.
36:21And when they started inquiring they found several things. They found that Mr. Converse had sent a letter to the then assistant dean about issues he had with first semester fall classes. Closing out the letter with I hope we get a full body tan in Costa Rica, meaning You're not here to help. Converse also wrote letters to the dean and assistant dean complaining about his grade for appellate advocacy course, but never filled out a formal grade appeal that was established through the university. He also sent a letter to South Dakota Supreme Court criticizing an appellant advocacy professor and and sent copies of the letter to two well known federal appeals judges. Converse, the student also displayed a photograph of the backside of a nude female in his study Carol at the law library. The picture was removed by a law librarian and returned to Converse who redisplayed the photograph. The Dean received several complaints about the photograph, classifying the behavior as unprofessional and inappropriate. He redisplayed the photo alleging First Amendment rights. Converse also attempted to obtain an internship from the U.S. attorney's office in South Dakota, but his efforts were subsequently rejected by the law school because he failed to comply with the school's procedures for internships. Converse then complained to the chairperson of the Law School committee of South Dakota Bar association referring to the Dean as being arrogant. Converse threatened various litigation against the Dean for alleged violations of his First Amendment
37:59rights and against other students with whom he had disputes with throughout his legal education. The he did not formally file the suits, just threaten them. He also posted signs around the law school denouncing a professor in response to the way in which the parking appeal a parking appeal was handled and went to the student newspaper criticizing all those who are involved. He produced marketed a Dini has a weenie campaign against the dean of the law school with the dean sitting astride what appears to be a long hot dog and posted those posters around the school in his capacity as landlord at a prior law school. So this is a second law school. Converse sued a tenant for non payment of rent and referred to the tenant as a effing welfare bitch. This guy's not even a lawyer yet. Mind you. At the bar admission hearing, Converse testified at great length as how he tends to personally attack individuals when he finds himself embroiled in confrontation and controversy when he becomes a lawyer.
39:11And this person petitioned and surprisingly sued to try to become a lawyer when he was denied admission. And they go back inside. All these things that we want to uphold in the profession, the integrity, the honesty, the good moral conduct, you know, the consciousness, you know, all of these things, this character, this good moral character and past things, these past experiences with this person who's now sitting in front of the commission saying he's going to be a good moral lawyer and uphold the rules of professional conduct, uphold the oath. But all of those eight Circumstances are more that I listed off and prove otherwise.
39:49So going back to that past conduct indicates future performance. And when a commission trying to let a new lawyer in seize this in someone's past, they're going to deny it. If you became a lawyer, then you start doing these things, then you get in trouble. They're going to see this stuff in your past and you're going to get disciplined for it. So we really have to do look at our conduct and how we conduct ourselves and make sure it's with good professionalism and civility in our profession. Because again, as I was saying earlier, holding a law license is a privilege. It is not a right. Not everyone can do it and we should feel privileged to do it. But know that that comes with a little bit of price, that we have to uphold the rules of professional conduct, that we have to do the right thing and hold ourselves to a higher standard than maybe laypersons in society. So we really have to look at that. And if you want to know what this privilege gives you.
40:43I know, it's so glamorous, the privilege we have to be a lawyer. We can initiate that attorney client relationship, we can provide legal advice, we can sign pleadings and papers on behalf of our client, we can carry out legal proceedings in the court of law for a third person. Otherwise you can only represent yourself and we can charge fees. This is so glamorous. These are the five things our privilege gets us. But something about the law and having the knowledge and helping people is a lot of times why people do it. Aside from the money, if you get paid a lot, I get that. But again, those are the things.
41:19If you do have a non lawyer working with you, they have to uphold the rules as well. It's the rule of Supervision under Rule 5.3, you also have to make sure they don't commit the unauthorized practice of law or do any of these five things that only lawyers can do. If they don't, or if they act uncivil and professional or you don't supervise them properly and they violate the rules, you violate the rules. So we are also held to the standard of making sure those who work for us, lawyers or non lawyers, that they uphold the rules of professional conduct, just like we have to uphold the rules of professional conduct. If they don't, we don't. But they don't hold a law license, we do.
42:02So we would be the ones to get in trouble for that. Now what happens when someone wants to take the privilege away from a lawyer? Meaning what does a disciplinary complaint process look like and it's different from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. So please check your jurisdiction. But this is kind of the basic or model that most jurisdictions follow. When a disciplinary complaint is filed, who can file it? Well, anyone can file it. It could be a client, a judge, a lawyer, a third party. It's not really a criminal process. It's not really a civil process. It's due process in a way because they file it with the disciplinary commission. The disciplinary commission reviews it. The other, whoever the complaints filed against gets to respond to, you know, the complaint that was filed, disciplinary commission reviews it.
42:52If there's enough evidence there they want to move forward with a formal complaint, then a formal complaint is filed by the disciplinary, disciplinary commission against the lawyer in court. So it's not really a civil proceeding, it's not a criminal proceeding. It's a licensure type of proceeding where we can have our license, our legal license taken away from us. The burden of proof of proving someone violated the rules of professional conduct is clear and convincing evidence. And again, it's adjudicated by a judge or other lawyers, not a jury. You go in front of the supreme court of the state, state you're in, or the disciplinary commission, if you're going to try to settle, or you know, some type of pseudo adjudicated body to get it settled, at that point you can appeal the committee's decision. Obviously that goes again to the supreme court of the jurisdiction you're in.
43:40So what happens here? I kind of said it, but just to kind of lay it out for you, the grievance is filed, which triggers the due process. Right. Disciplinary commission reviews the grievance and can either dismiss it, not raise the misconduct, or find potential misconduct. If potential misconduct is found, the lawyer that it was filed against is notified and a grievance investigation has started. This is still a, not normally a public process, meaning it's not going to be on any docket. The lawyer must respond to the disciplinary commission. The fastest way to get disbarred or disciplined is to not respond to the disciplinary commission. If they send you a letter or grievances filed against you respond, put it on the top of your priority list, get it done.
44:25Lawyer gets to respond to the grievance in a time allotted investigation, concludes additional review by full disciplinary commission, and then they can either dismiss it or start that formal complaint process. If the formal complaint process is started at that point, that's when it is public and that's when it's filed on a docket again. The worst thing you can do is not respond to the disciplinary commission, you will get a violation of non responsiveness which is not a good violation to have. Again though too, if the formal complaint then is filed like they do, find misconduct and want to start the public formal complaint process, you will be notified. The complaint is normally filed with the supreme clerk of the Supreme Court of the state or jurisdiction you're residing in.
45:11A hearing officer is appointed by the Supreme Court to hear the evidence. You do have a right to a lawyer if you have a disciplinary complaint filed against you and you should hire one either at the initial non public phase where you're just responding on paper, or you definitely should hire one at this phase when it's more of a formal proceeding. Hearing officer hears the evidence report, gives a report to the Supreme Court regarding if there's a plea or a final determination. Supreme court does get the final overall say and any basically review of the evidence. All orders, opinion or discipline can be located on disciplinary websites.
45:50So if it goes through this formal process here, as this screen in front of us says, then you may have a disciplinary complaint that anyone can find and locate on the commission's website at that point. This is why you need a lawyer if you want to stop it before the formal complaint comes through. You may need a lawyer at that beginning informal process and get a plea or head it off at the beginning. This is the formal one. If it doesn't reach this formal one, it doesn't go public. So there's a lot. Sometimes lawyers reprimanded or discipline maybe in a plea agreement or something like that before it ever goes formal. So you've got to really look at that. But if you do get a disciplinary complaint filed against you, just know that is the normal or general process. But check your specific jurisdiction.
46:36Certain violations, private reprimands can also be public reprimand, pay fines or money. You can get an interim suspense suspension immediately loss of license pending subsequent hearing. Interm suspension means if they file the former complaint, they're going to suspend your license. Now you may say but I haven't had due process. Well, this is usually when it's a very serious crime or the evidence is so strong and you're a risk to the public. Otherwise you will not get a suspension sanctioned against you until after you know the Supreme Court or whoever comes down with their decision that hearing officer.
47:13You can also get a disbarment which is permanent, you know you can't come back in. Or you can get a temporary disbarment with, with or without automatic reinstatement, meaning you have to reapply or you don't have to reapply to become a lawyer again. And if you're disciplined in one jurisdiction you're licensed in, you can receive reciprocal discipline in every jurisdiction you're licensed in. So something to consider. You can also face malpractice, civil, criminal or other penalties depending on what your conduct was. I do encourage you to find your commission's disciplinary website. This is the Indiana one, but make sure you go out and find the one specific to your jurisdiction. They will have information on there. Sometimes you can even see that a lot of it's done online, like the filing of the complaint, the response is done online.
48:03All of those things can be done online. So really do go find your specific jurisdiction and make sure you understand the procedure for where you're located. With that, we will conclude today's seminar here. This is a great stopping point for that. If you have any additional questions or anything, please do not hesitate to reach out. And thank you for joining us today.