0:01Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's seminar. With that, I'll introduce myself too. If you have not taken one of my seminars. My name is Carrie Sheham. I'm assistant general counsel with Taft, Centennius and Hollister law firm. I'm located in its Indianapolis, Indiana office. Within my role as assistant general counsel, I do anything, ethics compliance or anything internal that is needed to be done within the firm that falls within those parameters. So you can see I practice ethics all day, every day. But I also touch on things like HR issues, just things that can lead to malpractice of attorneys, malpractice of our patern, our attorneys specifically, and helping guard against those, and helping educate attorneys and internal staff regarding some of the pitfalls of working in the legal profession. And that is kind of where this seminar comes in play today. The Vicarious Trauma.
1:07Protecting yourself and advocating for others. And that is because as lawyers, we are advocating for people, laypersons, companies, corporations, and they are putting their stress and their traumas on us and asking us to fix the problems for them. And we get all of our clients, our motions, we get all of that residual, you know, anger sometimes, or just not knowing where to turn or what to do or who to trust. We talk to clients sometimes in their most vulnerable states, in the worst moments of their life, and they are wanting us to help them. And with that, even as much as we try, can sometimes come a price. The price is that we take on their traumas as our own traumas. And we're just going to here in a few minutes go through that definition of what vicarious trauma means.
2:15But if you boil it down, it really does mean just taking on the traumas of someone else. And we are one of the most highly high stress positions where that can occur or careers in that way. So we need to learn to recognize the signs of it, recognize the symptoms, how to prevent it, how to recover from it, and then also understand how it can affect you in a professional ethics liability standpoint. Meaning can vicarious trauma lead to disciplinary complaints, to malpractice claims, and to making you a less effective lawyer? And so we're going to talk about all that here today. If you have any questions throughout the seminar, please go ahead and put those again in that chat feature.
3:08I will try to monitor it while I'm speaking, but if I don't get to your question right away, I will try to get to it at the end of today's seminar, if time allows, or respond to you offline once the seminar is over. So the first thing here, and just to kind of get our framework is what is vicarious trauma? And like I said, just the short definition is it's the emotional residue from exposure to clients, trauma experiences, often through empathetic engagement. Over time, it can also develop and have an emotional, psychological, and even physical impact on how we think and what we do. And this can happen whether we are cognizant of it or not. Now, just think about this, and maybe you've seen a lot of lawyer shows, maybe you haven't. But if you've ever seen the shows where the lawyer is really working, really working hard for the client, and the lawyer kind of takes on the stress, takes on the feeling that this is them, they're putting themselves in the client's shoes.
4:24And a lot of times litigators do that so that they can get into kind of that mindset of how to convince the jury and convey to the jury what's happened. But the risk of that is, is you're going to be more empathetic than you need to be. You're going to take on more trauma, more stress of the clients than you should. And it may start to cloud your judgment, as we'll see here in a couple minutes. It can also lead to other things as well. But vicarious trauma is really having a repeated exposure to someone else that's had a traumatic event, and then us empathizing with them and taking on as if we were the person with that traumatic experience, that we were the person, you know, living it with them, and we feel their pain. It's like it happened to us. And as a lawyer, while it's good to have empathy, we still need to have a disconnect or a space between us and the client, because we need to think with the business mind and not the emotional mind that the client is thinking with. Because that's come.
5:44Excuse me, that's where the old adage comes in. If you have a. If you represent yourself, you have a fool for a client. And that is because if you are too connected to something, you're not going to see all sides of it. You're going to potentially have that tunnel vision and to where you're going to harm yourself. Hence, if you represent yourself, you have a fool for a client because you're in that tunnel vision of emotions, tunnel vision of feeling, the personal nature of what's going on. And when we hire someone, that outside counsel, that attorney, or our clients hire us, we are there to think with that business mind, to think, you know, without the emotions necessarily attached to it while we still may have empathy for it, we need to think more clearly when our clients cannot.
6:40But if we have it, if we start having vicarious trauma, then that starts to blur those lines. Now, vicarious trauma is different than burnout or compassion fatigue, if you've ever heard those phrases. Burnout is chronic stress. That is chronic workplace stress which lead to the condition called burnout. You we can all have stress that comes and goes, but if it's a chronic stress, eventually you are just going to burn out to where you're not going to want to engage. You're just going to be more disassociated. You're not going to kind of have a feeling for anything anymore. You're kind of going to have that numb effect.
7:25And that is just constant chronic workplace stress over repeating itself and over and over and over again to where you just don't care anymore. They have stressed you out so much that you don't care anymore. And that's what burnout is, that chronic workplace stress. Now some of you may have felt it, and I'm actually given a seminar on chronic workplace stress versus fatigue. So if you have not seen that one, try to catch it here on LexFit at some point. But again, that is a different condition than vicarious trauma, the repeated stress. And I can say I've been through the repeated stress too, to where at some point you're just saying, I don't care.
8:13They can fire me, I don't care. I don't like my job anymore. I don't care. And that's kind of where it comes in. Now, compassion fatigue is emotional depletion kind of going hand in hand with that where you just don't care anymore. Your emotions and your stress and you're feeling anxious and, you know, happy for your client. You're like, I just have nothing left to give. That's kind of the compassion fatigue. You put so much passion into something that you're just again, maybe that burnt out. So vicarious liability, as I was saying, is different. It is that internal transformation of constant exposure and taking on our clients traumas as our own. And we are internally transforming the way we think, the way we feel, the way we react. Maybe we start getting the victim mentality. Maybe we have the trauma response even though it didn't happen to us. We internally change because we're internalizing our clients problems. And this is very common in the legal profession. And we are at a high risk for this just because of what we do and how often we interact and take on other people's problems and listen to them. We have that frequent exposure to distressing client narratives. We have high workloads and emotional investment because if we don't win sometimes, if you're a contingency fee lawyer, then you're not getting paid sometimes. So we have an emotional investment into it, a personal investment sometimes into our clients cases and what we do.
10:05We also too have lack of training on how to have remote emotional resilience. Meaning how do we separate ourselves from our clients traumas? How do we separate ourselves and still be a good advocate and a good lawyer for our clients? There is no class in law school on emotional protection, emotional resilience, or how do we learn how to manage our own feelings in high stress situations over and over and over again. Now you will say there's a. Well, you could hear, I would say say too, there are many lawyers that say they could never do certain cases and that's because maybe of the constant exposure to something bad, to something negative, to where they just start internalizing that trauma as their own. They become the victim and they can't move forward. Or sometimes people can't take on certain cases because of the burnout or the compassion fatigue where they just don't care anymore. And that's where we can see it too. Now there are certain types of cases, certain practice areas where this can be more prevalent. And if you start to think about those which types of cases have more of a high emotional response, have more of a high emotional involvement of people that we're representing, Maybe it's family law, maybe it's criminal like public defenders in a lot of cases, maybe sometimes it's that social justice or those limited means, advocacy. We could see it there too because a lot of people with limited means, we feel we empathize with them, we want to help them, but they can't afford our
12:09help or you know, they need more than we can give. You can see it there too. There's all types of areas where you can see it. I will say one of the areas that kind of affected me in my career was I was a young lawyer, I wanted project to do and I wouldn't say it maybe as a project. That's kind of a harsh word to put it like. But I wanted an extracurricular. I was single young lawyer, you know, in the first three, five years of my practice and I wanted to give back. I was doing insurance defense litigation. So I was an insurance defense litigator, which wasn't necessarily as fulfilling as I was hoping it would be. Or as fulfilling as I needed for myself. And I had wanted to help people.
13:00So I became a guardian ad litem, which is something you can do as a layperson or even as an attorney. Where I was the guardian ad litem for different children that were entering foster care or in a situation where they had to be removed from the parents home. And then to see every unification was a possibility. And I remember going through, and sitting through the trainings, I was like, I can do this. I have the emotional resilience to do this. I can do all these things, things, you know, disconnect myself. Because some of the rules that were there, which are similar rules to lawyers, you can't provide the children that you are visiting with financial assistance or give them gifts or presents, just like we can't provide clients with financial assistance, aside from, you know, the court fees and that. That's allowed in the rules.
13:53And we can't do certain things. We have to keep that professional boundary to avoid the conflicts of interest. So with similar rules, being a guardian ad litem, going in, meeting with a child, meeting with them and advocating one way or another for reunification or up for adoption or what was going to be the path forward for this child. And I thought, okay, I can do this. This is just like the law. Just like, you know, working with clients, you meet with people, you make a recommendation, sometimes you have to go in here and testify, no problem. The problem was that I wasn't ready for was the working with children part.
14:38And that's why sometimes cases like family law, for ones that can really pull, I'd say your heartstrings or that empathy side or that empathetic side of us as human beings are going to be harder. And you may have that trauma response to it. Because I remember going into a home and it was two, it was, it was two children, they were twins. And I was like, okay, I'll just go visit them. They were staying with grandma. I guess maybe I was overly privileged or I don't know what it was. I just didn't expect what I was about to walk into. And I had to meet with the children, I played with the children. And I was like, I said young lawyer, you know, mid, late 20s, they're very young. And I just remember walking out and feeling like, I want to buy them shoes, I want to buy them clothes, they need more food, like just different things. And in my, I wanted to. So I was kind of taking on their trauma as my own.
15:43But I could not let that cloud the recommendation either because in my Mind maybe because then I had to go meet with the parents that could potentially have reunification. And they didn't have a lot of means either. And so but I couldn't necessarily, as long as they provided like the basics or the criteria that had to be meet, be met, then reunification was a possibility. But it was in my mind stepping into that mindset of a child feeling that child's pain and trauma, feeling the child needs XYZ because I want them to need XYZ or I need this and just feeling it was kind of taking on that trauma, vicarious trauma type response. With that story though, it kind of leads into. In family law, we see the worst of the worst sometimes and immigration attorneys also can see the worst of the worst, really wanting to step in and help because a lot of times they're people of low means or if they don't have low means, just a bad situation where potentially, you know, families could be split apart or you know, people deported.
16:53Like it's more life and not like life in jail, but life like you're going to be taken away into a different country, may never return type of stress on there. But we tend to take on certain types of clients, pain or vicarious trauma as our own. Same thing with public defenders, especially if you feel like you have the innocent client, the one wrongfully accused, you may take on their trauma as your own. And then same thing with like legal aid, social justice lawyers. Now if the type of law you do is not listed up here, it doesn't mean you're not susceptible to vicarious trauma. These are just more the most highly affected areas within the legal profession by statistics and that. But again, it is hard.
17:47It is a hard thing to do. And a lot of lawyers, I mean, I'll tell you flat out, I've never done a family law case, aside from those guardian of items, never done one. And I'm not cut out to be a family law lawyer. I always think it takes a special kind of lawyer and a special kind of person who can have that emotional resilience, who can do it without becoming jaded over time or feel the stress and trauma of it. Same thing with immigration, same thing with public defenders. It takes a special kind of person and a special kind of lawyer to see those stresses day in and day out, client after client, and sometimes feel that now they're your own and you can't do anything about it. And so it is a very high stressed area or high stress areas in the legal profession. Those ones that were just on the screen where we See most of the vicarious trauma coming through. Now, how do we know if vicarious trauma is coming for us or we haven't?
18:56Or maybe you're like, oh my gosh, I have this already. Well, here are just some of the signs, some of the things that you can look out for. Now obviously these are very general signs to recognize. These can also be signs of burnout, of high chronic stress, which leads to the burnout of even that, compassion fatigue. These can also be signs of that. And these can also be signs of illnesses, like medical illnesses that you may need to have checked out by a doctor on top of, you know, just the stress and that as well. But some of the signs are the anxiety. You're sad, you're anxious, you're irritable.
19:37All right, I meet that criteria, at least the irritable one, you know, here and there. But again, think of why you are, think of what is causing it. And if it is the stories of your clients, if you feel like their pain as your pain all the time and you're becoming that victim and internally changing in that way, then maybe it is vicarious trauma. Another one too is fatigue, headaches, sleep problems. Well, again, I have fatigue, but I also have a six year old child that I chase around all the time. I have headaches. But again, there's other factors too. So just because you have some of these signs doesn't mean you necessarily have vicarious trauma. It is just something to look out for when it comes about or, you know, just to be cognizant of when it comes around that way too. And maybe it's something if you're not feeling better, the medical doctors have nothing wrong, saw nothing wrong with you.
20:42Maybe then you kind of, you know, start to think, well, maybe it's something with stress, maybe it's something with, you know, the vicarious trauma or some other area like that, too behavioral, you come, withdrawn, you're very cynic, cynicism, you're overworked, you just feel that, you know, you just maybe don't want to be around people again. You can have this in any professions and you can be like, I don't have vicarious trauma, I get it. But when you start to see the fatigue, when you start to feel the pain of your clients over again, even when you're not thinking about the cases, even when you're not working, you feel like that victim.
21:33Now we're getting more into that vicarious trauma stage where we may need to stop, figure out and maybe it means a change of pace. I know I was working with one lawyer once and I wasn't working with him in a legal capacity, it was actually on my side job, I guess you could say as an adjunct professor. And this was years ago when I first started adjunct teaching. And I remember talking to him and we were both teaching paralegal studies at IB Tech at the time. And he was telling me how he also taught at Butler University. And I was like, oh, I'd love to adjunct at Butler University too. And so he made the connection for me.
22:18But then I asked him, you know, why are you a full time lawyer? And he said no. And I said, oh, so you just adjunct teach at different places? He said yes. And then I also work for my church, you know, had a, held a position as church, a paying position. I said, oh, what made you transition out of the law? Because he wasn't old, he wasn't like retirement age, like a relatively, you know, midlife lawyer or midlife person. And he said chronic fatigue, stress that led to burnout and that he just couldn't do it anymore because he just felt the pain of his clients that his doctor told him if he didn't switch, he was going to have a heart attack. So sometimes when we don't address these symptoms soon enough and care for ourselves and take the time we need, we can get to serious medical conditions and we can get to places where we don't even recognize ourselves anymore.
23:22And so we do need to step back. Especially if you're internally changing to where you're taking on those traumas of your client and you feel like the victim when you're really not the victim, you're supposed to be the advocate for the victim, then maybe it's time to take a step back. Maybe it's time not necessarily for a huge career shift if you don't want to like get out of the law completely. But maybe it's time for a different area of law. Maybe if you're in those high risk areas, and maybe that's why a lot of public defenders and prosecutors aren't career public defenders or prosecutors. A lot of people do it for years, get some experience and maybe move on to something else. Some stay for years and hopefully they get the mental health and the emotional resilience they need. But again, if they don't, it can lead to serious health conditions potentially in the long run.
24:24It can also have a cognitive and spiritual impact on your well being. If you take on the traumas of our clients and it can disrupt your own belief system, it can make you lose safety A feeling of safety, control or trust, and you kind of get that jaded perspective. How many of you have ever caught yourself saying, oh, they're an old time practitioner, they're just jaded. They've seen this too often. That's because they've taken on those feelings, those emotions of their client. They've seen everything and they just are like, if this is just how it is, there's no there anymore. There's no passion to fight, you know, against certain things. They just kind of give up.
25:15And even if they were passionate before, held beliefs, now they've been trampled on by everything. They've seen that trauma from their clients. So sometimes that can have an impact too. If you start to see yourself changing in that way and, and not because it's just changing as a growth or you're growing into who you're supposed to be, but changing based on others impacting you, specifically our clients, then that could be a concern as well and a flag for you to know. Maybe it's time to take a step back. You start questioning your own values or you have reduced empathy or increased hopelessness. Again, that could be that jaded response. How many of you have ever sat across the table from your client? Maybe it's an initial consultation. So a prospective client, they're telling you their trauma, they're, they're crying, they're emotional and all you can say is, yeah, it happens. You're not the only one.
26:18You know, this is just how it is with no emotion, you don't have any empathy anymore for anyone because you're like, you know what, I'm a victim too. I've had this happen to all my clients. Why is this one crying? When you start to get to that place, we need to stop and think how we got there, because it is internally changes. Especially if you weren't in that place to begin with, where you were like, oh my gosh, let me help you. This is horrible. You know, everyone's circumstances are different. You know, you want to have that empathy. We want some empathy. We just don't want to over empathize with our clients to where we get to that jaded spot, to where we get to that reduced empathy or that increased, nothing's going to get better hopelessness, we can't do anything about it. You might as well just, you know, give in type of deal. And so we want to stop it. And if you see yourself cognitively or spiritually changing what you believe, changing how you advocate, changing how you put that stuff forward, it may be a yellow flag just to take a step back and figure out what's going on and if something can be done to change it. Because if you don't, it can impact your legal practice and it can impact it very dramatically.
27:47It can impair your decision making, reduce your client engagement and higher risk of ethical missteps can happen as well, meaning disciplinary complaints, malpractice claims, a combination of those things and could potentially lead up to disbarment.
28:10So when we take on that empathy, we take on those factors, it can have grave consequences in what we do. And so we really again need to take an assessment of what we're doing. Now some of this impaired decision making again goes back to that if you represent yourself, you have a fool for a client. Well, if you've vicariously taken on the emotions of your client, it's like you're the client, so you're going to have a fool for a client because you're making decisions based on your feelings of empathy. Not a sound business legal mind. There's a difference between a legal mind and an emotional mind. There is a difference. One may be a little more petty. The other one may be like, okay, we can give here but not here. Let's think strategically.
29:05Let's you know what's going to get us the best results. And so we need to keep those things separate. And we can't if we're in a trauma response or a vicarious trauma with our clients. We also too probably don't want to talk to our clients as much, which would lead to a communication problem under Rule 1.4. We probably don't want to talk to them because we're feeling our own emotional drainage, we're feeling our own emotional response. And we don't want to take on any more from our clients. We don't want to take on anymore from new perspective clients. We just want to be left alone, withdraw into our own little retreat space and kind of wallow in our self pity and our victim mindset.
29:57And when we get to that point of withdrawing, that is a problem, like we said earlier and can lead to not communicating with clients, missing deadlines, you know, not pressing the advantages you need to, not advocating for the client where we need to impairing that decision making. And eventually it could lead to even more serious things. Because when a lot of people get into these kind of depression holes or these withdrawal states, what do they start doing? Not all of them, but some of them do start drinking or turning to drugs, which then we have an even bigger problem that could get you disciplined, disbarred, or at a least into counseling through any judges, lawyers assistance program that your jurisdiction may have. So we need to stop and think of what are we taking on of our clients and how can we kind of put this. A little barrier between. It doesn't have to be a Can't feel anything. You got to stay over there, but just that. Right. Emotional resilience.
31:07So here's kind of an example case, which I know we've. I've given some, you know, just in my own experiences here already, but Jane is a child advocate attorney, begins to lose sleep and feel emotionally numb after several years of high caseloads and traumatic cases. This is a sign that she's internally changed. She's. Her sleep's off. She just feels numb to everything. Nothing. Jaded. Numb feeling. That's a. That's a problem. That's something that we can't just shrug off as lawyers. It is from what we do and the work we do is difficult. How many other people can you say, maybe aside from doctors, you take on people's medical problems, take on people's problems in the worst days of their life and try to make it better and if they lose, could get sued for losing because now your client's mad.
32:07It's a hard profession to be in. It's a lot of stress. There's money, there's life, there's liberty, there's freedom, there's, you know, citizenship in this country at stake. Those are high at state cost, and we have to stay that business. Sharp mind. So if we do start feeling emotionally numb, if we do start seeing any of those signs and symptoms we talked about, we need to seek help. We need to seek help maybe through therapy, through, you know, friends and family, through some type of means to stop what is going on and to really feel or recognize that, hey, this may not be the best. Maybe we need a break. Maybe we need a change in, you know, what we practice or, you know, the different areas that we practice in. We just need some changes that come about. Now. There are also two.
33:09It's not just clients that can put these traumatic stresses on us or have that traumatic response that we are looking for, that trauma, organizational factors can contribute to it, too. High caseloads, limited supervision or support, toxic workplace environments. You can also start feeling like the traumas of that high caseloads, the traumas you can feel, or the vicarious trauma is really from the stress, which can again, lead to burnout, which is different. But if you have lots and lots of cases, it Means you're interacting with lots and lots of people and you're taking on lots and lots of emotions all at once.
33:52And so high caseloads can be a factor or a contributing factor to where we can't regulate ourselves and that emotional resilience to not get the vicarious trauma. So if you are a volume based attorney with high volumes, like our public defenders, potentially our family law or immigration law right now, or any of those areas, or even the legal aid society types of lawyers, if you are high volume and high stressful volume, meaning high emotional volume, you're probably going to be more at risk too because of just the nature of what that is. Not just necessarily stories, it's just the cases are so voluminous because maybe you can handle one or two public defender cases, you know, a month or year, and not get vicarious trauma, not cross that line. But then I say you're going to take on 40 in a month and you're going to feel all those emotions from each client. And so that can really intensify in a vicarious trauma too.
35:00Limited supervision or support. We do need to talk to our co workers. We do need to talk to people or have conversations, especially if we think we have vicarious trauma or if we think a co worker or someone has vicarious trauma. And some of the notes I made, which I'm just going to read them because I was kind of writing down and preparing for this. If you believe a co worker might be experiencing vicarious trauma or you see kind of that withdrawing factor, you see some of the signs that we've talked about, consider reaching out to them individually, maybe privately about the impact of their work, seeing how it's making them feel. What can you maybe do to help them to take some of that off of them? If you are in a place yourself to do that, we need to think of ourselves too.
35:56You can also potentially help or have the organization help them establish a more of a consistent work to home type of transition. Setting boundaries. Maybe we leave stuff at work and we don't do stuff at home. How many of us have great work life boundaries? That's a bigger question. Setting some of those work life boundaries can help stay off some of this stuff with emotion or, excuse me, vicarious trauma and that lack of support. So we need the support in there to make sure those boundaries are clear. Obviously encourage them on good sleeping habits, good eating habits, good exercise. Again, that work life balance.
36:42Maybe it's time if you're in a public defender or some high stress where you can see this Bay Area trauma coming through for yourself or for others, maybe implement. Everyone stops work for an hour and actually takes lunch. That's crazy, right? In a law firm, not eating at your desk, going out to lunch every day. I know when I was a younger lawyer, one of the ways I combated probably vicarious trauma, even though I didn't think about it at the time, because I was a plaintiff's lawyer, I was defense lawyer for a while, then I switched to plaintiff's lawyer. Was I every day at noon or in the evenings? If I didn't get the noon one, one of the times noon or 5:45, I would either go running at noon if I could, or I would definitely. If I didn't make the noon run, I had a standing appointment at 5:45 for yoga.
37:37So incorporating something in there to just kind of take my mind off things, to relieve some stress and to not take on all the emotions or to filter them out and kind of be able to think through it with the volume of the work I was having, with the stories and the traumatic experiences of the clients really did help too. Some other things you can do is maybe institute. If they're your employees or your attorneys, you're working for your supervising capacity or. Or if you just want to ask for it for yourself. Flexible work schedules, staying attuned, you know, to people who are withdrawing or isolating, maybe they need a little more flexibility on, you know, to get them motivated to work again, to get out of that victim, that trauma mindset that they've taken on reflection. Maybe maybe have meditation rooms in the office, maybe have quiet rooms in the office, maybe have different things like that. Maybe encourage them through the EAPs, if your firm has that, to seek counseling or therapy or work with them on daily routines with family, friends, and just things to kind of, hopefully kind of pull out or help with the trauma that they have vicariously taken on. It's like with any other victim, if you're counseling a victim of what to do maybe to get over an assault or maybe to get over whatever happened to them, what. What are you going to be telling them? You're going to tell them to go to therapy, you're going to tell them to exercise, you're going to tell them to engage in family, to talk about their problems, to journal.
39:20And so if we have vicarious trauma, that advice we give others, our clients, we need to turn it around on ourselves, and we need to take care of ourselves. And we need to make sure we remove any toxicity from our cultures and our law firms and be more supportive of these mental health things and these because it's not just mental health, but it can also affect the physical and our physical health and well being. So we need to be supportive of those things. So through that peer support, through that supervision, mentoring, cutting down on caseloads, making sure caseloads are evened out. I know if you're a solo practitioner or small firm, that's hard to do. But I'm going to tell you a little secret. Lawyers can turn down cases. We can say no to potential clients.
40:16Isn't that crazy that we actually get to say no to a client or a potential client and we can just wait for it, withdraw from cases too for any reason at any time, so long as we meet the requirements of any local jurisdiction or state jurisdiction, especially if you're in front of a judge or a litigator, you may have notice requirements. You can't prejudice the claim client. You may have to, you know, petition the judge to be let out of the case. But so long as you meet those requirements, you don't have to have a certain reason to fire a client. The ABA formal, the ABA Commission came out with ABA formal opinion. I think it's 516 maybe or 514, I can't remember which number which talked about that is rule 1.16. We can fire clients for any reason at any time so long as we follow the state, local or jurisdictional rules of withdrawal and we don't prejudice the client. So guess what? You can turn down cases to help those reasonable caseloads and you can fire clients. My suggestion is fire the clients you don't like or the ones that are causing the trauma or the ones that are causing, you know, that emotional dependence or stress coming on.
41:51Because if we don't, as I was saying earlier, it's going to potentially affect our practice and it's going to potentially lead us into ethical violations. Some of the ethical violations I know we've mentioned some in passing could include competence. Rule 1.1. When our emotions start to take over, if you've ever been really emotional and then you think, oh, I'm so emotional, I'm not thinking straight, I'm not thinking clearly. Just think about that. If you're trying to make decisions as a lawyer for a client's case and you're emotional, and you're emotional because you take in on the trauma of your client and so you're not thinking straight, well, that's a competence issue.
42:39Rule 1.1 says we have to be competent to represent Our client not only in how to put a case together and the law behind it and any updates, but also in like technology and anything that touches, concerns and affects the client's case. But if we cannot think with a clear mind, if we are now having cognitive changes because of the trauma that we've taken on, if we're now having cognitive changes because of, you know, the victim mindset that we've put ourselves into by taking on our clients traumas, we're going to have competence violations because we're going to make mistakes. We're going to make the wrong decision. We are going to lead with emotion and irrational ability and not being rational and business and legal minded. So we can have a Rule 1.1 violation. We can also have a diligence violation because if you are withdrawn, you're not going to act promptly. Rule 1.3, diligence.
43:46Even in the comments of it, it says lawyers shall not procrastinate. How many of you procrastinate? Even without maybe a withdrawal mindset. So we have to act with diligence on our clients matters. But if we're withdrawn and we're not being attentive, then we're not going to act with diligence. Another one is communication. If we're withdrawn and we're isolating and we're not going to want to talk to clients or we just don't want to run stuff by them, or we're like, oh, I can't talk to them, I can't take on any more of their emotions today. I have all my own. Then we're going to have a communication problem because we have to communicate with clients.
44:32We have to give them a chance to reasonably participate in their prosecution or defense of the case, to run certain decisions by them to make sure they're informed and all of those things. If not, we can have a rule of 1.4 violation. So vicarious trauma and how we internally change can cause these violations leading to disciplinary complaints and malpractice. And we're not done. What I call the kitchen sink rule is 8.4 D as in dog. It says anything that is prejudicial to the administration of justice is a violation of the rules of ethics. That's very broad. They try to define it in the comments, but there is not a black and white list of what is prejudicial to the administration of justice. If you're not communicating with your client, if you're not acting with diligence and competence, then you're probably prejudicial to the Administration of justice.
45:34So that it's why I call it the kitchen sink, because it can be tacked on to almost any conduct that violates the rules of ethics. So something to consider there, too, impairment and self care are our responsibilities as lawyers to make sure we give good client service, that we stay competent, that we remain diligent, that we communicate, and that we put our best foot forward to not do anything to prejudice the justice system. Again, we have to care for ourselves before we can care for others. And I know a lot of us that is a hard standard to think of. I will say it's a hard standard for me to think of too, because maybe as a mother, maybe as a wife, maybe just, you know, in my different roles in life, in those roles, sometimes my job is to care for others first and myself second. But we've got to remember as a lawyer, we need to care for ourselves first and our clients second.
46:49Because if we don't care for ourselves first, then we're going to not have competence and not meet our ethics. We need to take care of ourselves. There is several bar guidance and if you go out to like the ABA website, they do have an entire kind of wellness section, different resources that you can find on these topics and different things that you should just kind of look out for. A lot of also different platforms give cles on this too. I know here in Indiana we have what's called the Indiana Judges and Lawyers Assistance Program, to where if you're feeling the burnouts, if you're feeling the stress, if you're feeling the vicarious emotional traumas, you can go there to get free counseling, be part of support groups to have, you know, a safe space to go where you're not with the general public. The Judges, Lawyers and Assistance Program here in Indiana is only for, guess what, judges and lawyers. And it's entirely confidential.
47:57But it is a safe space for lawyers to go when they know they need help, don't really want to face it publicly, but they know if they don't, they're going to get those disciplinary complaints about practice. And a lot of times when a disciplinary complaint is put across for someone, they work with the Judges and Lawyers Assistance Program to get the treatments and counseling and different things they need without losing their license. So seek out those different things to help you, specifically in your jurisdiction, if they are available. And it's okay. It's not a weakness to say you need help. It's not a weakness to say I have vicarious trauma. I need to work on myself because I've changed because of the impact of the client's traumas on me. And so you need to take care of yourself there too.
48:56Some things to advocate for, just for, you know, yourself, your other lawyers in your firm, your employees. Model boundaries yourself. If you are a supervisor of a firm or a partner in a firm, or an owner of a firm, or just a solo practitioner, set boundaries so that your lower associates and staff can see you setting boundaries and know it's okay for them to set boundaries, to know it's okay to have that work life balance. Because I will tell you someone who I teach, I adjunct teach over at the law school here in Indianapolis, a lot of young lawyers are of the mindset that they have to arrive to the law office before the partner and leave after the partner. If you, the partner, don't have work life boundaries, what do you think you're doing to those associates? What do you think you're doing to their work life boundaries and their emotional resilience and burnout and stress and victims, vicarious trauma that could be coming on depending on where you're working.
50:06So set your own boundaries and talk about emotional resilience with young associates, with staff and with yourself too. And know it's okay to recognize those signs. And if you see them in colleagues, you know, recognize them and try to help them. Don't put a stigma on it. Don't tell them it's a weakness to have that. You need to have the confidence in that to make sure that we have that. We talk about this in our profession. Some tools for resilience, those mindful practices we've kind of talked about throughout the seminar today. Supervisions, consultations, setting boundaries with clients, setting boundaries with others and yourselves.
50:52Maybe every day you stop work at 6. No phone calls and emails. You have kind of like a dead period. Maybe you implement that dead period on your whole firm, saying you can't email after this time unless it's an emergency. This is what constitutes an emergency. Or I know a lot of emails have, that you're about to send this after hours. Do you want to schedule it? To not send, you know, till the office opens in the morning? Set different boundaries. Also have different, maybe quality of life protocols and traumatic stress scales and do self assessments or trainings within your firm to see who's stressed out. There's these different tools. If you just Google Secondary Traumatic Stress Scale or Professional Quality of Life Scale on Google, there's going to be different kind of tests or studies or different things where you can give a seminar within your firm. You Know, test yourself to see are you on this traumatic scale, are you internalizing that vicarious trauma or do you have just burnout or high chronic stress?
52:00Where are you at on this scale and what do you need to do for your own emotional resilience and your own health and well being? Again, like I've said before, normalize, offer mental health re resources, reduce isolation to. If we isolate people and don't make people collaborate and work as teams, it's easier to become withdrawn, it's easier to pull back into those little rabbit holes that we have and take on stuff of our own and feel like we have no one else to share it with or unload it. Sometimes half the battle is just talking to someone else. And I will say even my husband works in a very high stress environment. He is a detective with our local police department. And I remember sitting through when they have to go through the academy and this was many years ago when he first became a police officer. We were younger when we first got married, a lot younger. And I remember sitting there because they invited the family to come to the police academy when they were in their training phases and the family members who showed up were sat through a trauma type of seminar. And the trauma type of seminar we had to sit through was them outlining if we saw certain signs and our significant others or loved ones, like you know, the withdrawn nature, they come home, they go sit in front of like a mind numbing game or they don't talk to you anymore or they're just, you know, start to withdraw or have that motions or those irritabilities, those signs. We've seen police officers are one of those high stress environments where they can really have
53:48vicarious trauma. But we were told if we see any of these signs we need to talk to them and if they won't talk to us, we need to reach out to a certain person because if they are not mentally fit, then they shouldn't be on the street because then they're going to make mistakes as police officers. So I actually had to sit through a vicarious trauma class for my husband's profession. And at the time I didn't even think of how it impacted lawyers until, you know, really looking into it. And it does. And so especially if you have a significant other spouse or loved one in a similar area, really look for those signs, really create kind of a trauma informed legal practice where you can screen for it, know the signs for it and just ask the questions. Maybe it's not vicarious trauma, maybe it's just burnout Maybe it's something else, but asking a question and figuring it out and showing that you care and not stigmatizing it.
54:53Having that creative, supportive environment and training people on it is going to be half of our battle to catch it. And having those support systems that we need in place, whether it be peer groups or networks, clinical supervision, using those EAPs as employees assistance programs that we have through work or legal, professional wellness. I know a lot of big law firms like your big law. Then you have wellness programs, wellness initiatives, wellness weeks, all these things to push out wellness. Now you can have all those colorful things, but unless people use it and you really put, you know, feed into the program, it's not going to be worth anything. So make sure if you're going to offer something, you offer it in a way that it can be utilized to help people within your company.
55:47Exercise nutrition can be a great work, life balance thing too. I remember I worked at a law firm once where they had free yoga classes at lunch, like a yoga for employees. Or they had, you know, people come in in the evenings for yoga classes at first in the conference rooms and then they built like a little gym in the office. So having those things too, just in your place can help with some of the stress burnout, but also vicarious liability by giving us that fresh mindset, putting those boundaries in. Because all those things together, you know, how we deal with stress, chronic stress, burnout and vicarious trauma, how we deal with them is all similar. And how we're going to seek help or seek, you know, those consultations with others and set our boundaries is going to be very important. And like we've already talked about this too, setting those boundaries, clarifying our roles, don't over identify, don't over empathize, empathize, structure communications, keep those healthy distance and boundaries, maybe not become best friends with your trauma traumatized clients.
56:58Maybe because there's a friend listening here and there's a lawyer, we want to be the lawyer. We also want to say we're the friend, someone who'll listen. But we need a healthy boundary in there to not be the one who's at their house at midnight all the time. And so setting that healthy boundary, setting that can help. But if it is to the point where peers can't help, you can't help, is management or friends and family, then seek help outside of that, if you have the judges and lawyers assistance programs, if you have a comparable thing or just go get help, because that persistent dysfunction, those impaired relationships can lead to greater problems again, counseling, therapy, Professional coaching, bar associations have support. This is just another example.
57:54Jane sought counseling, adjusted her caseload, joined a peer supervision group, and eventually regained empathy and clarity to the level she needed it to be a great lawyer. So you can recover from these things, but you do need to take the actions. Look at the wellness programs. Look at the resources out there for, you know, there are helplines. If it's gotten to the points of such withdrawal, such isolation that you're going to do something to harm yourself, then you need to seek those things as well. Again, let's not stigmatize it. Let's make it something that people are okay to talk about. These are just. I know I'm going through these pretty quickly here, but we've talked about all these. It's just some material so you can kind of see it and just kind of rethink and, you know, how to set those boundaries, how to reflect, how to have that resilience and identify your different support networks that you need.
58:57With that. We are at the end of today's seminar. Thank you, everyone, for joining this afternoon or this evening, and I hope everyone has a wonderful weekend. Thank you.