Roger R.CA
The course makes clear the rule about the need to keep the client informed and that the client makes some of the important decisions but could be clearer about which decisions the lawyer can make.
55min · about 9,500 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's seminar. I know everyone's getting connected, getting settled, and is probably very excited to talk about control and communication when it comes to attorneys and when it comes to our responsibilities with our clients. Today is kind of part two of a little series. However, you can jump in anytime in the series you want. We're just talking about the attorney client relationship and different aspects of it. Last time we talked more about the attorney client relationship in the context of, you know, how do we create attorney client relationships? Why is it important to document those attorney client relationships?
0:40And today we're going to talk about basically communication and control. Who has the duty to communicate? I'll give you a hint. It's probably the lawyer. And who has the duty to control the representation or be the boss? I'll give you a hint on that. It's not the lawyer. Lawyers are advisors. We are not bosses or dictators when it comes to that attorney client relationship. So we really need to know the dynamics of the attorney client relationship and what our duties are as lawyers within that dynamic to make sure we don't run afoul with the rules of professional conduct. And this is one rule that is sometimes hard to understand by lawyers because we all go to law school, and we all probably have more dominant personalities or personalities that kind of say, hey, you know, I have confidence. I have these different attributes which make me a good lawyer.
1:37But sometimes those attributes can also be a detriment because we really have to sometimes set our ego inside a pride, or, excuse me, pride aside for the betterment of our client and for what the client wants. Because there are some times when the client makes a decision. And we'll take an example, for instance, say you're working on a civil case and there's an offer of settlement that comes in. The settlement offer, in your mind is low. They only offer like 15,000 or 10,000 or something where, you know, if you go to trial or you push it a little further towards mediation or, you know, you at least get through more of the discovery phase and up to that trial date, you know, you can probably get that settlement offer bumped up another maybe 25, 30, 50,000. But the client is very stressed.
2:28The client does not like the litigation. The client can't handle the pressure of it. And so you have a duty to obviously communicate any settlement offer back to your client. So you take that offer, you communicate it back to the client, and the client says, yes, take it. I want to be done. I want to be done. You're like, but wait A second. There is all this money left on the table. There's all this money that we could potentially get if we just go a little further. A little further. But the client says, no, I want to take this now and be done with it. You, as attorney have a duty to follow the client's wishes regarding settlement, regarding anything, because they control those objectives. You control the means of how to get to the objectives, or you don't really control the means. You advise on what means are going to be needed to reach those objectives.
3:16Now, if at any time the client doesn't like the means you are using to control to get to those objectives, the client can say no. Another example, too. Take, for instance, you need an expert witness. You have an expert witness, but they're going to cost $15,000 to take the deposition and testify. But you know, this expert is gold. This expert is amazing at testimony. This expert is what the client needs. But the client also knows that that $15,000 towards that expert is going to come out of any settlement at the end or any reward from the jury at the end as an expense. And the client says, no, find another expert. That's cheaper. I don't want to pay that bill or that's excessive. Well, you as the attorney, you have to listen to the client. You're going to be finding another expert. Again, we make recommendations. They may have the objectives to reach. If they don't like our recommendations or don't agree with our recommendations, even if it's against our sound legal advice, that's their right to make the decision, and we have to abide by it. Now, there are ways to protect yourself, because in either of those scenarios, the client could come back later and say, well, you didn't tell me this. I'm suing you for malpractice. And so that's a scenario that is all too common, unfortunately, and one that we would like to prevent.
4:44So how do we prevent such a scenario? Well, we write down, if a client does not follow the means or the recommendations we're giving to them, then we can document that. We either document it to be a letter to the client, we can document it via email the client. But we document in some fashion so that when we send it back now we have a written record. So if the client comes back and says, you didn't tell me this. You didn't tell me. I would lose if I didn't use that expert, otherwise I would have done it, or, you didn't tell me xyz, then you have something to show. Yes, I Did. And that, yes, I did. Piece of paper or that yes, I did tell you this writing is going to be huge in any defense to a malpractice claim. So we want to make sure that we get that into place, especially if we're going to protect ourselves. Because while we might not be, excuse me, while we are not the boss, we're just the advisor.
5:46That boss role can try to push the blame back down on us. And we want to protect ourselves as lawyers from malpractice and we want to make sure that all that is in place now as part of this role. Remembering who is the boss, the client is the boss. As you can see from the examples I've given, we also have duties of communication. Obviously we have to let the client know what's going on so they can make those decisions. And we have to do it in a prompt manner. We cannot procrastinate. And we'll see those rules here in just a second as well. But that golden rule is if you always keep that focus on the client is the boss. So whenever you have to make a big decision or play with someone's money or play with, you know, your client's freedom, in some instances, if you're in the criminal context, you don't get to make those big decisions.
6:39You get to make recommendations for the outcome of those big decisions. But your client has the final say and authority to say yes or no to those big decisions. So that is something really important to remember that we have to think of the client as the boss. Never forget that rule. And that any big decisions or anything that needs a decision made needs to be communicated to the client. And then the client has the right to make that decision. Now again, sometimes that is hard because there's only so many hours in a day. And it's hard if you have a volume book of business to always constantly be communicating with every single client. But there are ways to manage that.
7:25Some of those ways to manage that is obviously utilizing your assistance. Your staff, your law clerks, your paralegals, they can relay messages to the client for you. They can help prompt up emails for you to send. They can, you know, make those communications. So long as they're not giving legal advice, so long as they're not doing the work, they're just relaying a message, a legal advice from you to the client, then that's fine. Now if you're relying on your paralegals or non attorney assistants to actually give legal advice and answer those clients questions or advise them on stuff without consulting you, then that could be a violation of Rule 5.5, the unauthorized practice of law. But your non attorney assistance can help with communications of keeping the client informed so that they can participate and be that boss in the representation. But you just have to make sure you give clear direct guidance that your non attorney assistants know where and when not to cross the boundaries. Because again we don't want to venture in into the unauthorized practice of law.
8:33We want to stay on the other side of that so we don't get in trouble. Because if your non attorney assistance are committing the unauthorized practice of law, you're committing the unauthorized practice of law. Because they don't have a license, you do. So the disciplinary commission is going to come after you because you have a duty to supervise, educate, train your staff. And if they're not doing what they're supposed to, you're not doing what you're supposed to. But you can use them in helping with communication, helping uphold this client is the boss in a representation and they are a vital part of that success.
9:12It's really good to utilize them in that manner too because then again it helps and it takes alleviates a lot of stress and burden off your plate too as you're trying to manage everything else. Now this is just the rule that really goes through. This is the model rule too. So please check your local jurisdictions to make sure you comply with any local requirements. But this just outlines the scope of representation and allocation of authority between the client and the lawyer. And that is basically saying the client is the boss. And we can read here because I know probably some of you have not read this rule in quite a long time, maybe all the way back into law school.
9:53But a lawyer shall shall. That means a mandatory standard abide by clients decisions concerning the objectives of the representation. So the end goal, like where they want to get what their wanting out of it as required by Rule 1.4, which is our rule for communication. So lawyers have a duty to communicate. They shall again another mandatory standard, consult with the client as to the means by which to get to those objectives or the means of which to be pursued. So it says here in that very first sentence, the lawyer shall abide by the client's decisions. The client controls those objectives or set them. Lawyer must communicate regarding the means or those recommendations of how to get to those objectives. So it's right there in our rule 1, 2A. Now we can take action on behalf of the client when it's implied by the representation.
10:53Obviously if we're in a court hearing and have to respond to a Judge or certain request. We're going to, you know, do what we need to do as a lawyer and use our legal judgment. But if we have that time to communicate and come back and make recommendations for the next step in a proceeding, then obviously we need to do that and abide by the client's decision. The rule continues on to say that a lawyer shall abide by a client's decision to settle a matter in a criminal case. They shall abide by a client's decision after consultation with the lawyer to take a plea. So anything there, or whether to waive a jury or, or you know, have an a bench trial, that's all. The client's decision. We get to advise on our recommendation. And a lot of times the clients say, just do what you say, you're the expert, I'm not. But again, it's the client's decision. So we need to make sure we have that there. The rule goes on too, that we do have the right to limit the scope of representation and other things. But that first paragraph there is really what we were focusing on here with the client being the boss, setting forth those objectives, the lawyer making those recommendations or means to get there. But again, the client is the boss. This is just a breakdown of that rule to see it a little more in a digestible format, because I know sometimes the rules can be very hard to digest when you're reading these long, drawn out sentences and the rules all crammed into one page real succinctly. So it just goes out to say, again, client controls those objectives. The client
12:26is the boss. Lawyer shall consult rule 1.4, our communication rule. And then we get back, you know, what we're supposed to do from there forward. Now, the communication with a client, that's an important thing because yes, we can say we communicated. I called them, I sent them the motion I was going to file. They didn't say anything. So I filed it. When we communicate with the client, Rule 1.4, which I know is not on your screen right now, but it is down there referenced at the bottom of your screen. But Rule 1.4 tells us we have a duty to communicate. But it also tells us that we have to tailor our communication to fit what the client can understand and digest.
13:12So that means if you have a client who has an 8th grade education, then you have to communicate in a way that the client will understand the eighth grade education or understand with their eighth grade education. So probably in that scenario you shouldn't be using words like pro hoc viche or motions in limine or motion for summary judgment. Because unless you've gone to law school or unless you're in tune with what the legal profession is, how it operates, the procedures, or taking a class to understand what those terms mean, they're not going to know. It's going to go over their head. So this duty to communicate, this duty to make recommendations, has to be tailored to the client's sophistication. And that means you've got to understand your client, how to communicate best with the client on how they'll understand things and tailor your approach to that. Now, that's the hard part, especially if you have a volume book of business.
14:14Sometimes I've seen in court, prosecutors come in, or criminal defense attorneys, that's a better example. So we have public defenders come in. They always come into the back of the courtroom, sometimes here in Marion county, or they used to before the pandemic, and they call out a name. They're meeting their client for the first time, they're in court. And that's kind of the nature of a lot of big cities, especially in that criminal defense realm, or being a criminal defense attorney or public defender. Sometimes you are meeting your client the day you have a hearing. The day the first hearing is where the plea gets entered. There's usually a quick communication.
14:54There's usually an entry, and then hopefully after that, the attorney talks more in depth with the client or the assigned client that they were given, because they have to explain the process to them. They have to explain if there's been a plea, what that means. Is the person going to take it? They have to explain, you know, what pleading not guilty is, or guilty. There's all these types of things. And they have to understand how the client is best going to comprehend. Does the client need an interpreter? Does the client need things broken down more on an elementary level? What are those needs so that communication, so that the client can be the boss, has to be tailored to the sophistication of the client. So that is something very important to remember. It's also one of the hardest parts, because unfortunately, lawyers are not always good communicators. I know that may surprise you to think, oh, my gosh. But all we do is advocate. All we do is talk. Yes, we argue motions. We talk to people who have our same education, who understand the legalese and the acronyms and the language that we're speaking. Speaking. Because to the layperson, sometimes the legal world and what we reference can be a foreign language to them. If you think about. If you go around saying msj Motion for Summary judgment. Abbreviation or if you remember, and some of you might in law school. I remember when I was way back when in law school, several. Several years ago, there was the capital letter K stood for contract.
16:30Well, I used to write that in shorthand. No one knew what I was doing. Maybe it was just my law school or how we wrote shorthand. But those different things that are specific to our profession, we have to stop ourselves from using them when we talk to clients because they're not going to understand them. So that is part of that communication and having that skill and having that ability to work with your clients, and so they understand you. Now, there is also what is called implied authority. So let's kind of look at the difference of that. You know, we always ask for permission for things, then we get actual authority, which is that express authority that we're given.
17:13But again, there's implied authority. Implied authority is when we are in situations where we can act on the client's behalf, knowing their objectives, knowing our guidelines of what we've been, you know, given, and not have to always say, let me talk to the client. I can't respond to that motion. I can't respond to that argument until I talk to the client. There are certain things we do as lawyers where it's implied, it's okay to move forward. Now you can have kind of an actual express authority and an applied authority kind of all in the same scenario, too. For instance, maybe you've talked with your client already, so we're getting actual, you know, express authority from them about a settlement range, you know, what they're willing to accept.
17:56And now opposing counsel comes to you and says, hey, will you accept this offer? And you know, it's in the range, or you know, it's above the range, and you know, if you can accept it or not. Or you could just say, well, let me take that back to my client, you know, I'll confirm one way or another. And so it just depends on that communication with the client up front. If they said, if they offer this accepted on the spot, so then you already have authority to do it. And then when it comes up, you have that authority. But if they say, this is my range, and you know, they fell within the range, obviously, take it back to the client, make sure they haven't changed their mind. Unless there's that definitive, you know, except on the spot authority given, and then you can go back.
18:40Some other implied authority too, is when we're, are you in a court, are in a hearing or conference, or talking to Opposing counsel about different issues or discovery or different things. Our client's not always there and present, but we don't have to stop a conversation all the time. So long as we stay within the bounds of the legal profession and the bounds of what we need to on making those legal decisions, then we're okay. And that's kind of that implied authority when acting. There's also authority, especially if special authority, especially if you are representing an organization or company. So a lawyer employed or retained by an organization represents the organization through its constituents or through its leaders, the chief, the C suite, if you will, you know, those top executives. So with this, though, obviously there is different ways that we have to protect the company. With a company, there's no real person in time sometimes that we can go back to and say, hey, you know, what do you want to do with this? Who do we communicate to? We have to communicate, communicate with the full board or the chief executive officers or that C suite.
19:49And so it's not as if it. Our boss is another human being. Our boss is an entity. An entity. It's not a living, breathing thing, but it's made up of different constituents. But we have to remember too, even with an organization, our implied authority comes from doing what's best in our legal skill and knowledge for that organization, always protecting the organization's interests first and foremost, even if it means the CEO in there is doing something wrong. If you're the attorney for the organization, you're protecting the organization and may have to report it. So we always have to keep in mind, you know, who our client is when it's represented an organization and where our authority comes from, our authority comes from the board or the CEO constituents. But again, if one of those are doing something to hurt the organization, then we have a duty to the organization to report that or try to stop that conduct. And so you will see some examples here. And those are for my reference, just so I know to kind of go through them. But here is kind of a scenario of this. Plaintiff retained Fox in a personal injury case.
20:59A few weeks later, Fox proudly informed plaintiff the case had been settled for a tidy sum higher than the agreed amount. Plaintiff replied, if I would have known how much the defendant offered, I would have never have settled for that amount and refused to sign a release. Why should fo. What should Fox do? Does it matter if Fox agreed to the settlement during a mandatory court annex mediation? So here we have a scenario where plaintiff retained Fox as an attorney. Fox proudly informed the plaintiff that they have a settlement offer higher than what plaintiff, you know, originally agreed to and that.
21:42And now the plaintiff's like, well, if I would have known that, you know, I wouldn't have agreed to this, or, you know, I would have done differently. So did Fox do anything wrong here? That's kind of the question. And depends. Depends on when Plana had settled the case or whatever, or different errors. And when it was given, did the lawyer have another chance to give another communication or was there bad advice given? Probably not, because we make those recommendations based on, you know, what facts are in front of us at the time. So we always have to look at what was there at the time, not what we find, you know, a day or two down the road. I know hindsight's 20 20, but again, if it's what is in front of us at the time, that's what we're really looking for and looking at, and then we can backfit it past there, too. If we are representing clients with a diminished capacity, we still have that duty to communicate. We still have that duty to let the person with diminished capacity be the boss. But again, we have to tailor our communications to their sophistication.
22:48Now, sometimes this can mean having a guardian ad litem appointed or someone there to help in the communications. If the diminished capacity is more of a minor child situation, then obviously maybe having an adult there or maybe having someone there to help in those communications. If it is someone more with Alzheimer's or dementia or other mental instability, then maybe we do need an official guardian ad litem or family member assigned to be that so that we can have someone to fully communicate with. Now, with diminished capacity, it does not mean that we don't represent them. It does not mean that we have. We stop, you know, representing them at all or stop communicating with them.
23:33We still have to communicate with them, and we still have to show them that respect of being the boss, if we can. So again, we still have those duties of communication. Even a person with diminished capacity is still our client, still the boss. We just have to figure out how to communicate with them effectively and whether that means having someone step in as a guardian, invite them, or petitioning the court for one, if it's so necessitated, or working through an adult, if it's a minor child, someone looking after the best interest of that child or that minor individual, then that's what we need to do, too. Kind of taking all these concepts together, we can do kind of a little another scenario here and kind of walk through it together. This one is.
24:18Martin has just been appointed by court to Represent Pop Star, who was placed under a full guardianship 10 years ago after suffering from a public mental health crisis. When the guardianship began, Pop Star's father was named as her guardian and was granted sole decision making authority over Pop Star's finances and personal life. Sound a little bit like Britney Spears, maybe? Or the pop Singer. In the past 10 years, Father has overseen pop Star's return to touring where she earns millions of dollars annually for herself and father as guardian. Prior to Martin's first meeting with Pop Star, Father tells Martin pop Star is still not stable enough to make her own decisions. When Martin meets the pop Star, Martin determines that Pop Star has a much higher capacity to make decisions than the father had indicated. Pop Star expresses her desire to get out of the guardianship because she wants to tour less and spend more time with her children. As the attorney for pop Star, what do you do? Well, Pop Star is your client, not the father. Pop Star is.
25:29And so you have to look after the best interest of Pop Star. Now, in this scenario, and you can kind of think to yourself what you would do. Maybe you can drop it in the chat if you want to be active participation. But in this scenario, maybe we have a mental capacity test given, or maybe we have the court determine if pop star further needs a guardianship or maybe helps Pop Star get it removed. But we still have to treat pop Star as our client because Pop star is our client. That means we have to communicate them. We have to let them participate in their own defense. We have to really assess that. Now, as lawyers, we think maybe we can assess someone's mental capacity or make those determinations on our own, but we really shouldn't. We can do the basics to see if someone's competent. You know, a basics test like, you know, ask him certain questions that, you know, almost any person would know the answer to. But to really get something like this and have maybe the father removed as guardian or help our client, because our client is the boss and our client here is Pop Star, not the father, then we have to take maybe affirmative steps to help, maybe getting that mental evaluation again, maybe seeing if you can undo what is needed. But again, the client is Pop Star. So when we have these situations with someone mentally incapacitated and we have like a guardian, Adam, or a guardian or a power of attorney or someone appointed, yes, that makes it easier. But we still have to think
27:02to ourselves, can our client actually communicate or is this person essential? If the person is not essential, then we don't need them. Our duties of loyalty still go to that client. So some of those situations can be very hard to determine. And us as lawyers, we didn't go through psychiatry school, we didn't go through counseling school or psychologist school. We probably should have. That probably should have been a class in law school, but we didn't. So we need to start having other experts in the areas get evaluations, but listen to our client and communicate with our client. Because ultimately the client is the boss. No matter if they see guardians or anything around, we still have that duty of communication with the client and listening to the client on the yes, no, controlling the objectives. And then we advise on the means for them to accept or reject based on, you know, what they want to do. So communication is the key. Learning how to do that and do that effectively is what we really need to do. And finally, we get the look at the rule of communication. I know I've been talking about it up to this point, but Rule 1.4 is that foundation to our communication. We shall promptly inform the client of any decision or circumstance with respect to which the client needs to give informed consent. We should reasonably consult with the client by the means by which the client's objectives are to be accomplished.
28:32We need to keep the client reasonably informed about the status of the matter. We need to promptly comply with reasonable requests for information. We need to consult with the client about any relevant limitation on the lawyer's conduct when the lawyer knows that the client expects assistance not permitted by the rules of professional conduct. And a lawyer shall explain a matter to the extent reasonably necessary to permit the client to make informed decisions regarding the representation. So we have all of these duties and that top yellow font. A lawyer shall. Shall. Is that mandatory standard? It's not discretionary.
29:15We do not have any discretion. We have to follow these five things, including the subpart on number five, to comply with our rules and duties of communication to our clients. A very strict standard, one that's often violated because lawyers do get very overwhelmed. We have volume businesses sometimes and we just don't stop and think about our duties and obligations of communication. So we really need to stop and think of those different areas. Again, just think about this too, if you have something to tell the client. Some people don't like to communicate because they're afraid. They're afraid of bad news. They're afraid of disappointing the client. They're afraid of something, some emotion that that news is going to spark in the client. Maybe they're afraid of losing the client. The bad news does not get better with time or with age. And so making the prompt communications, doing what is necessary is always a good thing for that client communication and relationship. To really allow the client to be the Boss Under Rule 1.2, we also need to make sure these are just again, summary points of what we've already talked about. Give the client sufficient information to intelligently make decisions and then gear, like I said, our communications to the client sophistication so that the client understands and can make the informed decisions and provide us with what we need to move forward on behalf of the client. Always meet clients expectations. Some expect more communication than others.
30:52Again, take the client as you find them. I had a client every single week he would call when an update on every Friday. Finally I had to kind of temper down those expectations saying hey, how about this? I will send you an email, I'll have my assistant call you, you will have an update. Because it was a litigation, I go, there's not always something new every Friday, but when we have updates, we will update you on those immediately. However, if there's parts of a lull time every two weeks or every three weeks, you'll just get a letter saying there's been nothing new, like just a touch to make the client feel that they're being appreciated for being your client, that you're listening to their needs and that your case is important to them. So making that communication, even on a regular routine basis, even with nothing new, just saying there's nothing's changed, nothing's new, but this is what we're waiting on still can go a long way for that attorney client relationship. So we need to make sure we think about how do we make the client feel appreciated, how do we make the client feel listened to and how do we make the client feel that their case is important to us. And so communication is one of those ways. But again, we have to keep our sanity.
32:07So we need to make sure we temper clients expectations that they're not expecting a communication daily or weekly, depending on the nature of the case and the matter. Maybe in a criminal case they do need that. Maybe you're in trial and it is a daily communication. But there are certain parts of litigation, or there are certain parts of cases and transactions as we know where it's kind of quiet, like we're just waiting on stuff. And so just kind of creating that expectation with them, communicating with them would be the key to keep those expectations in check. These are just nine triggering events just to kind of put in your mind if you're like, well when do I communicate? What's over Communication, or what areas should I always remember to communicate? And what's more, discretionary, these nine things on the screen in front of you are taught in law school too, in the professional responsibility class, because I also teach out of The Robert H.
33:03McKinney School of Law, where we do teach communication to law students, which is surprising. I know when they get out in practice, they usually forget. But these are what we call our nine triggering events for communication. So the first one here is fee arrangements. Obviously we need to tell the client what we're charging them. And this is best done through an engagement letter. Although engagement letter is not always required, but it is highly recommended. It is required under Rule 1.5 in most jurisdictions. If you have a contingency fee case, then the contingency fee needs to be communicated in writing to the client and agreed to and signed off on. Otherwise, most jurisdictions, engagement letter is not necessary, but highly recommended. But you do need to communicate your fees and the scope of your engagement, including who is your client, what we talked about in the first series of this lectures, and make sure that's communicated to the client. We also need to communicate things that requires the client's consent. So decisions like to waive a privilege to, you know, object to something or to file a certain motion that's going to cost money or hire an expert. If we need the client's consent for something, then we need to obviously communicate that. So that's another triggering event that we've kind of already talked about. We also have situations that require clients consent no matter what conflicts of interest. If we have one arise, we need that client consent confirmed in writing.
34:31That's under rule 1.7, conflicts of interest rule, and 1.8, and 1.9. So take a look at those rules regarding conflicts limiting the scope, limiting our fiduciary obligations, or waiver of confidentiality. Those are all things requiring client consent, all things requiring a communication consultation regarding the means of representation to accomplish the objectives. Do they want to go to mediation? Do they want to settle? Do they want to litigate? Do they want to say, you know, take them for all they're worth? Do they want to take the plea? Do they want to take a risk of going to jail? Those are required client consent.
35:07Periodic updates are good for that communication. So again, like I was saying, either send something on a regular basis, even if there's nothing new, or have the understanding you'll only send new stuff, then you just have to remember that. But there will may be long lulls depending on what type of litigation or what type of matter you have if you make a mistake again that goes back to that. Bad news does not get better with time. We need to make that communication. Client request information. We need to make that communication. Law requires limits on the conduct that a client requests. We need to make that communication as well.
35:43Reasonably necessary to permit a client to make an informed decision. So that is that if there's a decision to be made, we need to give them enough information and at their sophistication level to make sure that they can make that decision. So again these are just seem like common sense things. But if you would have asked me, well how do I know when to make the communication? These are those nine triggering areas when we should make that communication, when we should bring it down to that and when we should talk to the client. Now obviously there's other situations that are ancillary to these nine, but these are the main nine that we really need to focus on.
36:25And so just kind of a summary. A lawyer must initiate those conversations with the client to give the client that, you know, the client is the boss. Communication consultation and lawyer must provide the client with the necessary insights to effectuate those goals, those objectives that they set for us. Because the client controls those objectives. We the lawyer control the means. Discipline if not communicate to if you don't communicate you can be up for disbarment. You can get a disciplinary complaint filed against you. It's probably going to fall under the terms ineffective assistance of counsel.
37:01But you can be sanctioned for not communicating. And it's such an easy thing to do. Send an email, have your assistant's help, have your non attorney law clerk's help. Just make a communication, make it routine. Just know the client's the boss and that we have that duty to communicate. Some best practices here that I would recommend and these are kind of easy to employ but kind of hard to remember sometimes. Unfortunately one of the first one is return client calls and messages within 24 hours or acknowledge the call at least. So if a client calls, either return the call or send an acknowledgement email saying I received your call, I'm busy at trial this week.
37:47Return your call next day, the next time. Now if you're like well that's a lot of work for me. Respond to emails. Great. Give your assistant access. Tell them to respond with attorney. So and so is out at trial. They'll be back on this date. I've set up a call on his calendar with you at this date and time. Thank you for the communication. We'll get back to you then. Guess what? You've responded. The client feels that they're appreciated. They feel like they're heard. They feel like you have attention to their case, and now you've got a specific calendar invite to remind you to call them back. As long as you follow up with the calendar invite, then that's good. Now, if you need to remove the calendar invite or, you know, reschedule it, that's another touch of communication.
38:30Your assistant can say, it's so sorry. Attorney so and so has had something emergent come up. I just need to move your call with him back a couple days. Here's your next date. So you're constantly communicating so that everyone's aware what's going on. No one's ghosting each other. No one feels like they're not appreciated. And that's the ultimate goal for those client communications. You can also, if you have a more sophisticated client, and the client drafts once a week or as you draft motions so they can review them. Some clients, corporate clients, actually require this. They want to see the drafts before they're filed with the court. And that's another way they can make decisions on if they agree with the arguments you're making or if they want to take a different approach. And it's also those touches on communication. Bad news does not get better with time. So if you have bad news, you better be picking up that phone. And it may be okay to wait a day, maybe a week. But if you're stretching it past that and you haven't told the client you've lost emotion or you know, something else has come up, we could be in a bit of a pickle.
39:33So we need to make sure we communicate. We need to make sure that, you know, even if it's bad news, we need to take the heat. Now, if it is bad news, I would recommend delivering the bad news in a way that's honest, truthful, and that the client can digest it, but then also offering simultaneously a solution of how you are going to fix or overcome the bad news. And if you don't have a solution, then maybe you can brainstorm with the client saying, here's what the law says, here are some of our options. None are the best, but this is what we can do, or we can just do nothing. What do you prefer? But you need to have some type of solution, some type of way to counteract the bad news. Hopefully that you can communicate with the client in that context as well. Now, all these things, client is the boss, communication and how we respond to clients and, you know, giving them the information they need.
40:30Consulting with them has to be done with diligence. Another one of our rules, Rule 1.3, diligence, says that a lawyer shall act with reasonable diligence and promptness in representing a client. We must control our workload. We must, you know, say no to clients when we have too much to do and can't, you know, work on clients cases expeditiously. We don't want to miss deadlines, we don't want to procrastinate. Even comment 3 says perhaps no professional shortcoming is more widely resented than procrastination. So a client's interest can be adversely affected if we delay or we procrastinate. And I wish I could see a lot of your faces here, but I'm not going to ask you to turn your cameras, don't worry.
41:16But again, if I would take a poll saying who here has a problem procrastinating or who is a chronic procrastinator, I'm probably going to get a lot of hands. Because at some point in time, a lot of us procrastinate. And a lot of laypersons don't understand why attorneys procrastinate. They're like, you had 30 days to respond, why didn't you respond? And we all know 30 days in lawyer world is a very short period of time. It is very short. You are putting out fires here. You have other cases, you have a trial, you have a hearing, you have a deposition, you're prepping, you're doing law firm management stuff, you're attending CLES. 30 days goes by very quickly. There is not enough hours in the day, especially if you have a high volume caseload.
42:04And so that is why the rules say, and the comments say workload must be controlled. And we have to start learning to say the word no when we have too much volume, when we have too much of a workload, where we're forgetting deadlines, when we, where we're not calling clients back, when we're not, you know, making the client the boss like we're supposed to. But we're making decisions fast because we don't have time to stop and communicate. We need to control our workload. Our rule of diligence says we have to, we have to apply this. And this is one of the hardest rules for lawyers to follow. Because if I would pull laypersons, I'd be like, do you like lawyers? They half of them say, my lawyer never calls me back.
42:50I call him, I leave messages, he never communicates. Hard to get a hold of Them never available. We shouldn't have that. Yes, we don't have to be available every second of every day for clients. But we have to act with community promptness, diligence, communicate. And if you do those simple things that I was talking about, like the 24 hour response rule, utilizing your non attorney staff, then you can really uphold this rule and not get those comments or lead into those professional stereotypes which we're used to hearing. So we've really got to think about that. We also too have to think about, you know, our own health and our fatigue.
43:32Are we out sick? Are we, you know, tending to personal matters? And sometimes we need to withdraw from cases, find another attorney, pass it off if we cannot. But a lot of us don't like to give up work. And that's expected because work is money, time is money. But we need to think about those things too and how that's going to affect our clients because ultimately the clients are who we should be protecting and we need to hold ourselves accountable. And these are rules that are forgotten. These are like the rules, like that doesn't matter. I know I need to talk to my clients. I know I need to not miss any deadlines, but the rules are really more than that.
44:06They're more than just missing deadlines. They are having that prompt communication, they're letting the client be the boss. They're having that communication skill so that the client understands what you're talking about in a prompt manner. And we've got to really hold ourselves to that higher standard, not just the watered down version that most lawyers do. So too, lawyers have abandoned clients ways that they have with no diligence. This is just a list of ways where we can abandon clients when we really shouldn't recognize. We have to recognize that a client relies on us. Were there access to the legal system, they are going through probably one of the worst times in their lives, especially if it's a criminal matter or even a civil matter, when maybe their financial means are at stake or some finances are. And we have to recognize that we have to really stop and think, how is this affecting my client?
45:00Because we lay persons are relying on us, they're relying on us to that access to justice. We have to understand that it's difficult. They don't understand the legal process, they don't deal with it 24 hours a day, seven days a week like we do. So it's all foreign to them, it's stressful to them. And if they can't communicate with you, then it's even a bigger Problem also too when a client stops paying or has an inability to pay, sometimes lawyers start to not call back or not work on cases which is, I get it, they're non paying client but you need to take the appropriate steps to terminate them. Then if you're not going to be working on their case, don't just ghost them, don't just stop, but actually terminate them at that point if you leave a firm or assume other responsibilities, that is too when sometimes that diligence and communication can fall off because we just get busier when we join a new firm. It's a frenzy. It's a frenzy of getting client files moved over. You're worried about making deadlines, getting all your cases in, getting all the permissions in new environment, new things and stuff starts to fall off.
46:03Communicate, still rely on your non attorney staff to help you with these tasks. Don't try to take it all on yourself. We need to have that help and recognize we can't do everything. This is just some examples here. This is a criminal defense example. Client per accused of a crime has the right to retain or appointed counsel at the critical stages of proceeding. Right to counsel for capital sentencing hearings and appeal. Okay, we know that clients get that competence says that we have to be there, we have to represent the client in a reasonable standard and do those things now to commit malpractice for not community communicating, for not working with diligence, promptness and for not letting client be the boss. It is the case of Strickland vs. Washington, which normally comes under in a malpractice suit where they claim ineffective assistance of counsel. And you may have heard this case before, it's studied in law schools, it's a famous case. But the two things they work for, which can be in here, lack of communication, lack of diligence, you know, not letting the client control the objectives.
47:11All those three rules combined together. Ineffective assistance of counsel can amount to performance, requires the defendant to show counsel's representation fell below an objective standard of reasonableness. So meaning you didn't communicate at all, you had too much of a caseload, you forgot to call the client back, you didn't file the motions, you missed deadlines. That's that diligence, promptness, that's below a reasonable standard. Reasonable standards. Kind of what I've been preaching today in this lecture and kind of what's on the screen. Maybe a 24, 36, 48 hour rule to communicate back. You know, taking your communications down to the intelligence of your client. That's a reasonableness. Those Things are reasonable.
47:51They're not a high overarching gold standard. That is just the basic bare bones of the rule that we have to remember. And then the second prong is prejudice requires the defendant to show. But for counsel's errors, the results in the proceeding would have been different if we show that. But for your procrastination, this would have been filed and I would have won. You've committed malpractice. But for your lack of communication about the adverse ruling, I would have made a different decision and could have made revive this. But for this, your actions as an attorney breaking these rules, I would have won.
48:31That's how we get an effective assistance of counsel. That's how we get them all practice suit. And they're going to say and these are diligence communication. But for those things, if you have not done them is an easy standard to meet. Because a lot of lawyers fall down on communication and diligence for some reason. Even though you think it would be the easiest rules to follow, but we are thinking more complex rules. We're like, oh, those are, those are rules no one gets disciplined under. People do people get sued for malpractice? If you get sued for malpractice, there's probably going to be a corollary disciplinary complaint filed against you.
49:06So you need to start thinking in those terms and upholding these standards.
49:13Communication. We do need to make sure we communicate. Again, this is just going through that criminal defense example. We've already talked about about this through this seminar too. Communicate anything with a plea agreement. Be open and honest with the, with the tribunal and with your client and with opposing parties too. That candor is very important and we do need to avoid conflicts of interest in anything. Just reminders. We're going to talk about conflicts in the next session tomorrow to follow up. Tomorrow is session three of three of this attorney client relationship series. But again, we need to make sure that we avoid those conflicts of interest.
49:49So we don't really have a lot of time left. We have about eight minutes left. And so we're not going to go through the case examples that I have for you regarding diligence communication and the attorney being controlling the means, the client of controlling the objectives. But these are some cases and you can google them or put them into Westlaw, which I would really recommend you taking a look at just to see how the courts apply these rules and grievances, disciplinary complaints and malpractice suits. The first one is Monchado versus Statewide and if you want the citation for it, it is 890 A.2d 622, Connecticut Appellate Court, 2006, and this case is regarding.
50:32Plaintiff is an attorney licensed in Connecticut and was retained by complainant John Adams to represent him in a bankruptcy proceeding. The plaintiff, which was an attorney, initially met with Adams in January 2000 while Adams was in prison. At the meeting, Adams instructed the plaintiff to communicate with Kendra because as a prisoner, Adams had limited means of communication. Subsequent to the meeting, kinder delivered an $850 check to the defendant as the retainer for Adam's bankruptcy. Kendra instructed the plaintiff, which was the attorney, to obtain the release of the sales tax lien and then place the business owned by Adams and Kendra jointly. The plaintiff provided legal services in connection with the removal of sales tax lien and in doing so, depleted the entire retainer that was paid.
51:23Shortly after Kendra picked up the file from the plaintiff's office and retain new counsel, no funds were left to pursue Adam's bankruptcy, which is what Adam had initially retained the attorney to do. He just said communicate with Kendra about the bankruptcy. But what he did in depleting the bankruptcy or depleting the funds had nothing to do with the bankruptcy, but he was taking direction from Kendra. Plaintiff took no further action on the bankruptcy, which is what he was initially hired to do by his client, Adam, who was in jail. The plaintiff did not inform Adam of anything and did not inform Adam that he was no longer pursuing the bankruptcy. He didn't talk to Adam.
52:02Adam just had instructed the plaintiff to communicate with Kendra but never said never communicate with him. And the attorney basically forgot who his client was. So we had failed communication here. We had violations of Rule 1.2. You know, who is the boss? It wasn't Kendra. Kendra was an agent of Adam, but Adam was still the boss. Failed communication did not keep Adam reasonably informed with who he was supposed to. He needed to either make sure his communications were getting back to Adam or send him directly. You know, he had to keep Adam in the loop even though Kendra was the outside person.
52:38So we had violations of Rule 1.2, violations of Rule 1.4, and he was sanctioned for it. And so we really need to stop and think who is our client. It may not be the person who we got the check from. It may not be the person who know is the agent or that guardian situation that we talked about a little bit today. But we have to remember who our client is or we can be sanctioned. And here in this Connecticut appellate court in 2006, the plaintiff Machado was sanctioned for it. So we still need to think of who is our client. And the court just really rimmed into the rule 1.2, who is the boss, and 1.4, communication, and said that this was a breach of the rules. And even though the plaintiff's intent was not sinister, it was still a breach of the rules. So we need to make sure we really look at who is our client and making sure we follow those rules.
53:38The next case I recommend, which we kind of went over that first one, there's three here total. The next one I recommend is this 1, the Pape vs Trinity Health Systems. The citation for it is 242 Federal Supplement 2d 585, Northern District, Iowa, 2003. This is regarding an HB1 visa, an engagement letter, and some different things that went wrong. Again, really thinking no communication, who is the client. Again, I'll let you look that one up on your own because we're running short on time. And then the last one, too, is Maples versus Thomas. This is another case really encompassing those rules. Its citation is 565 US 266, 2012. And this was a capital murder case where Maples was charged with murder, sued an attorney for it, just for conduct, during it, during the case. Again, going back to communication, who is the boss, those different things, abandonment, these are issues that you need to think about.
54:46Please let me know you can reach out anytime if there are questions. So I hope everyone had a great seminar and thank you for joining.
Roger R.CA
The course makes clear the rule about the need to keep the client informed and that the client makes some of the important decisions but could be clearer about which decisions the lawyer can make.