1h 11min · about 11,100 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, my name is Peter Lupo, I'm the head attorney for Haply Communications. We specialize in rights of way management, telecommunications law 5G. So everything to do with FCC, any kind of updates and modifications to telecommunication facilities, either on the streets and sidewalks or rooftops or towers, that is our bailiwick and that's what we specialize in. Today I'm here to discuss the broadband equity access and deployment. It's called bead, part of the ija, which was a bipartisan bill under President Biden. And we're going to talk today about different aspects of bridging digital divide. We'll talk about what the digital divide is, but very briefly.
0:43It really talks about households that have no or very little bandwidth and if they have none at all, it's pretty self explanatory. But if they have very little, it amounts to effectively not having it because it doesn't allow for basic functionality, zoom calls. Many of you might be on that right now watching this video. Insufficient bandwidth to really function in the modern age. So let's go over the course agenda a little bit. We'll talk a little about the overview of the BREB program, how it functions, how it works. We'll talk a little about the legal framework in which it operates. We'll talk a little bit about the regulatory, contractual litigation issues and broadband deployment.
1:21And then of course some ethical consumer protection and future legal challenges, things that may crop up as a practitioner if you're representing a municipality or county or state in deploying this speed money. So let's do a little bit of an overview.
1:39So just keep in mind that due to the different policies and priorities of the current presidential administration, things have changed quite a bit. You don't need to really go too far to see that different priorities, different presidential administration, things are changed very, very rapidly. So, so every aspect of the B program is subject to change and maybe drastic change in real time evolution. So I really kind of foresee an update to this slide presentation because I imagine there'll be quite a bit of changes over time.
2:12So let's go over a little bit about broadband access and deployment program. So it's a federal program, as I mentioned before, it fell under the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act. And you see that it's a federal program which funded a little over 42 and a half billion dollars to close the digital divide. The National Telecommunications and Information Agency, the NTIA administrators bead so that the ones that will be on the federal government that'll be issuing the money out creating guidelines and these guidelines As I mentioned before are rapidly changing and each state will have required who's going to participate in the BID program. That's to set up their own administrative agency.
2:58Many states including State of New Jersey. I'll use that frequently because this is where I practice in New York State. Give you a good example here. New Jersey OVC so Office of Broadband Connectivity. And they have the primary responsibility to disperse the money. So they get the NTI guidance and they then use NTI guidance and then make it state specific for some of the rules and regulations regarding perhaps public private partnerships, perhaps the RFP process. Every state has their own type of unique way so it kind of bridges the federal guidelines requirements with that of the state. As I mentioned before, the primary objective is to bring 100Mbps download and 20Mbps upload broadband service to unserved underserved areas. So that's the minimum thresholds if you're a state accepting this money in which you have to provide to currently unserved and underserved communities. Secondary objective is going to be symmetrical gigabit speeds to community anchor institutions CAIs so things things like libraries. Think about hospitals, high schools, universities. These are areas that are capable of serving multiple people. You know in the case of a library it could be up to 100 people. So you want to have symmetrical gigabyte speeds up and down download and upload speeds which is very important.
4:21And then some of the tertiary objectives is going to be digital equity. So that's making sure that people not only have the service to the house but they could either afford the service or afford the devices that you would need. So things like laptops, tablets, phones and the like keeping that affordable. So that is a tertiary objective. And if you have any money left over after meeting the primary secondary then this is the focus and very interesting. Lots of programs currently going on in the states, many states to ensure people have money money to afford the service and have access to things like tablets. And this could be used to those ends. The purpose behind the B funding was created under the Infrastructure Investment jobs Act in 2021. Closes the digital divide which funding broadband infrastructure in unserved unserved areas across the US and we just talked about those thresholds ensures equitable access to high speed Internet for all communities especially in rural low income and tribal populations. Think about what happened just before this is 2019 to 2020. We had Covid and a lot of people who were able to at least who were in the service sector where they had to fiscally be there, call it a janitor, call it a doorman.
5:37We had to fiscally be there. It allowed people to work remotely. So many attorneys were able to work remotely. Courts were closed, but life still went on. And what they determined was that lower income communities, areas that were underserved or unserved, especially with children, were unable to participate in school, which of course is a big issue. So you had this wealth gap. So you found areas that didn't have sufficient broadband were usually areas that were already underinvested in. So this is going back, not to give too much of a history lesson into redlining, but this goes back many, many years into racial discrimination redlining.
6:14Areas that were historically received very little way of institutional investment through electrical, cable companies, telephone lines and the like continue on to this day. And this is meant to cure some of those histor injustices. It's supposed to promote competition, affordability, which by encouraging participation range of providers which will include things like municipal networks, not for profits and co ops. We'll get into this a little bit about different using municipal networks. These are networks already built for municipal purposes. And the BEAD program does encourage use of very existing networks, either not being used in some cases dark fiber, fiber that was forgotten about or unused.
6:57Another purpose of BEAT funding is to support workforce development, digital literacy and device access. This whole holistic approach to broadband adoption. We know that just having service your house is not enough. You have people who may know how to use, how to use into the Internet. So think of people have people who are in their 70s, 80s and 90s, people who didn't grow up with it, who are kind of scared of it or hostile to it. So that's one part of it, being able to afford it, afford devices. This is a holistic thing. So in order to have somebody to be able to order something through whatever it is, have a telemedicine appointment if you're an 85 year old man. It's not just having affordable, having Internet access and broadband to the home. It's being able to know how to use it and be able to afford it. So that's kind of the approach of eid.
7:44The idea too is strengthen US infrastructure. The idea is to have future proof technology so that whatever you put in today doesn't become outmoded in a short period of time. So you want to make sure that this technology is something that can be built on, that either meets current functions and immediately recognizable uses and needs in terms of data bandwidth and then also allows future upgrades so allowing sufficient room for Additional fiber for example to be pulled through a conduit. These are the types of things that you could do. Another part of strengthening US infrastructure which I've listed here is weatherproofing.
8:20So in many cases where you live in flood prone areas, you may or wind high wind areas, sometimes you might want this to be put into waterproof types of trenching or infrastructure and the like and kind of take into effect increased climatic violence. What I call that. It is the largest federal investment in broadband in the United States history. So again, 42.45 billion allocated natural nationwide. So many people are already comparing bead to New deal under Roosevelt. Think of the Tennessee Valley Authority bringing power to rural areas of Tennessee, the Carolinas and Georgia. All this money was spent to kind of take these rural areas, areas that are very remote areas where you have very little return on investment because you have to put a lot of capital infrastructure into building out into rocky remote areas. You don't have much of a way of road to get to. So this is part of the other reason that be around. But again a lot of people comparing this to a new deal like investment in the United States infrastructure.
9:23So some of the federal laws and guidelines, these are the rules and the architecture of how things to be spent and was to be used. You have the IIJA itself and you see the reference here to that. You have nofo, you have notice of issuance of availability. Recent indications indicate a shift in fiber preference. So right now fiber preference is something that they prefer but that is evolving. And things like fixed warehouse access, things like satellite. These are all things that are being considered right now. As a result of the foregoing, states have been granted 90 day extension by the NTIA to submit their final boardband equity access deployment proposals pushing a deadline to 12-27-2025.
10:13Again because of different changes in the way things are being approached. So everyone's giving a little opportunity to update themselves. You have a five year action plan which is submitted by all states who are participating. Notice of funding opportunity. That's the NOFO I mentioned before. Detailed responses to NOFO questions. We'll go over that in a little bit. So here are some of the NOFO requirements that I alluded to before. You see over here, one of the requirements is the use of government owned networks of gons. NTIA believes that they want encouraged inclusion of municipal, tribal and other government owned networks and B proposals to promote competition and coverage.
10:52Again, this is kind of very important to allow use of these because a lot of these are underutilized networks and Promotes competition and coverage stretches dollars of the B money. So if you have a network that's being underutilized, it allows the monies distributed for the federal government to go further perhaps for secondary those tertiary needs that I mentioned before. So New Jersey's response to this this is plucked directly from their from the notice of funding opportunities is the OVC Incorporated Strategies. This is the New Jersey Office of Broadband Connectivity incorporating strategies to leverage Gons where appropriate. Aligning with NTIA's guidance to enhance broadband infrastructure Another one with challenge process. The NTIA requirement states must establish a process allowing stakeholders to challenge accuracy of broadband coverage to ensure precise identification of unserved underserved areas.
11:43In most states that area is already passed. Right now the way we establish unserved unserved areas for broadband coverage data is from the FCC and many cases is that accurate. So this allows local states who may have more accurate information from their Internet service providers or their own data sets to challenge a process. So in this case New Jersey responded. The OVC implemented a comprehensive challenge process enabling local governments, nonprofits and other stakeholders to contest reported service availability, thereby refining the state's broadband deployment strategy. Who can be a B subrecipient?
12:22So again the grantor in this case is the federal government, the grantee is a state and then the sub grantee or sub recipient would be whoever winds up getting the award of the money. So it could be a public private partnership. For example, it could be one that truly traditional ISPs so you see traditional ISPs are up here. So your incumbent telecoms such as Verizon, AT&T and Frontier, all types of people who might be interested in getting some bead money. Your cable providers such as Comcast and charter, your wireless ISPs or WISPs or other potential sub recipients. You have your non traditional nonprofit providers so electric cooperatives.
13:01So you have the example of Tri county emc Bourabin in Georgia. I try to be as broad as possible. So that kind of applies to everyone in the United States. Listening to this non profit broadband cooperatives and community based providers, educational institutions especially in anchor tenant or middle mile roles. So middle mile rows is a. Is the typical, you have your major cable runs, fiber runs and then the middle mile is what brings you to local streets and local streets is the, the fiber to the curve to home type of thing. So you have who can be a bead subrecipient again at the state level government owned entities, for example municipalities and counties. Here in New Jersey, many municipalities have decided to build their own fiber network so they could potentially be a subrecipient public utilities.
13:53Utility authorities like think of municipal electric companies. My own town in Madison, New Jersey has its own electrical generating facility. Tribal governments and tribal telecommunications providers. And then as I mentioned before, public private partnerships or P3s, which of course is a joint venture between public entities, say a town or a country, a county and private ISPs. And these structures allow local ownership of assets while leveraging private operational expertise. Here in New Jersey, I have two counties that are opting to this so they'll effectively compete against the ISPs and cable companies for this money. And in many states that they usually like public private partnerships, they're preferred because it allows direct intervention with the counties if people become unserved or there's some sort of anomaly. When you're an owner, you're an owner of an entity. It allows for more say in what's getting done.
14:49So B no formal encouragement. They encourage NTI encourages participation Municipalities, co ops and other public entities mentioned before, that was the P3. You have the government of networks. They comply directly or partnership with ISPs provided they meet eligibility performance requirements. This is set by the nti, these minimum thresholds. And the NTI requires states to explain how universal service will be achieved. So if you accept this money, you have to have that five year plan in which you roll it out. That means not a single unserved or underserved home in the state that is a sub grantee that receives this B money. So some of the keys over here that comply with open access affordability performance standards.
15:33So open access obligations. It doesn't mandate open access networks. That means that other competitors could use it or allow other competitors to use the infrastructure that's being built. The NTI strongly encourages network operators to offer open access on a voluntary basis, especially if it's municipally or state owned or governmentally owned. Open access refers to allowing multiple providers to use the same infrastructure. So fiber towers and poles to offer competing services. Open access can improve consumer choice and align with the NTIA goals of market competition cost transparency. Because when you have consumer choice, obviously that forces the competition improve service. You don't want to fall behind because people who are paying will migrate to other services. If there's only one service, a monopoly in effect, then there's little motivation. But if people are picking up, leaving their service because of lack of performance or bandwidth, that'd be a message for the other lagging carrier to start approving government owned Networks must also be prepared to offer reasonable wholesale rates. That's to their competitors. They choose lease access to other providers. Most states have board of Public Utilities which usually sets these wholesale rates.
16:49So let's talk about complying with open access affordability and performance standards. Performance standards. Again as I mentioned before, government owned networks must meet the same minimum service thresholds as primary providers. So that's 100Mbps download, 40Mbps upload. Talk a little bit about latency. So you want the time that it takes for a device to connect with their service ISP to be as low as possible. So think of things like self autopilot cars or video conferencing. So you want to have something that's low enough to support real time applications. You want reliability so capable of scalable upgrades to meet long term needs. So again we all know that data in our Americas and the world's hunger for data is only going to increase. Especially with you know, 5G. You know 5G, which is very, very data hungry TVs and the like that use a lot of data to really have this crystal clear displays we have. Government networks must be capable of maintaining and operating the network over time, not just building it so they care about again sustainability and be able to last generations ideally. Let's talk a little about legal and statutory considerations.
18:03State law preemption as of 2024, just something as a practitioner should be aware of. Sixteen states have laws restricting municipal broadband. So again a lot of states will not allow municipalities go into broadband. So North Carolina, Texas, Tennessee for any of those states. And I happen to reference the Tennessee code here. But obviously if any of these other jurisdictions go ahead and take a look at that, the NTIA will scrutinize how these restrictions impact universal coverage goals under bead FCC versus Missouri Municipal League. So this is an instance where the Supreme Court ruled that the FC can't preempt the state laws that prohibit municipal broadband to express congressional authority.
18:46So this is if you're familiar with the Chevron doctrine, this is again saying that the local, that local, sorry, local courts, FCC have limited ability to intercede on laws pass in states unless Congress has given express authority to do so. Again, Chevron doctrine gave significant amount of deference to federal agencies like the FCC to go ahead and fill in the blank if it was ambiguous or was silenced. Something that's kind of changed quite a bit now with the Chevron doctrine which is still playing out in the courts to see what extent the SEC could rule on things that are not clearly delegated to them under congressional authority. So just something as practitioners should be aware of steadily evolving attorneys must review state enabling statutes before proposing government owned network participation. So as I mentioned many states have their own unique approach to it. Just be mindful of that.
19:48So we'll talk a little bit about the Supreme Court United States. We'll talk about Chevron Memorial and the implications for B deployment. I kind of mentioned before 1984, the famous Chevron doctrine. Courts deferred to reasonable agency interpretations of ambiguous statutes or even where they were silent for federal agencies like the NTIA discretion to interpret terms and laws such as the Infrastructure Investment and Job Settings act, the IIJA Lopea Bright versus Raymondo just last year. So the Supreme Court ruled Chevron stated that the courts must interpret federal statutes independently without deferring to agencies interpretation. So it was ambiguous or silent. Then it has to go to court for it to be determined there rather than the federal agency.
20:31So again it shows power from federal agencies to the judiciary which increases legal scrutiny of agency rules, guidance and policy decisions. So there was the CARS ruling going back in the about five years ago a lot of this which puts a cap on the amount of money that local municipality could cover to pay for 5G small cell site in their public rights of way that may change that was not expressly put in any of the underlying acts. That Delt was entirely created by the fcc. May or may not have been, you know best interests of all parties. But again wasn't expressly enumerated to the FCC and that may be coming under review. It's called the Safe harbor with 5G deployment. So some of the impacts the NTA guidance is now more legally vulnerable as I mentioned because of the reversal of the Sherman doctrine. The B NOFO and scoring rubrics and subgranting guidance are rooted in this interpretation the IIJA.
21:26So you may have to first May 2 guess NTI interpretations. So think of unserved versus underserved areas, technologically neutral, eligible entity, open access and low cost plan. This may be challenged in the courts. And as a lawyer I just want to kind of point out to the other attorneys on this, on this video that there's going to be potential increase for increased litigation. You have private ISPs or exclude advocates being challenged. So some of the things may challenge is the state you subgranting decision based on NTI guidance, scoring systems or eligibility rules imposed by states based on NTI templates, affordability or rate setting mandates that exceed the plain text of IIJA and you can expect for sure lawsuits to arise under the APA or the Administrative Procedure act or constitutional grounds such as the 10th Amendment and Commerce Clause. So these are all things to be mindful of if you represent a municipality working with B money Practical Guidance for attorneys Advising clients on bid so we'll talk a little bit about post shove run bid implementation. Make face more litigation narrow judicial interpretations less deference to NTI guidance so one thing you should take as a practitioner look at is to scrutinize statutory language directly. Shouldn't rely solely on ti interpretation when advising municipalities ISPs or non profits flag areas where NTI guidance may not be legally contestable.
22:55Build stronger factual legal records for bead subgrant applications and for you litigators participate in more judicial review opportunities of agency decisions at both state and federal levels. Some of the key legal and strategic considerations for attorneys State laws and municipal broadband let's talk about this briefly. Some other things as I mentioned before they restrict or prohibit local government participation board based services and as I mentioned before you have to make sure that the state B plan allows for government owned networks.
23:31So some of the key legal and strategic considerations for attorneys Federal grant compliance is a uniform guidance Governor Networks and nonprofits may be unfamiliar with federal grant compliance rules. Attorney should advise on procurement standards Some of these things are always tricky tones that really deal with procurement standards. Somewhat mind boggling in some ways and could definitely make you pull your hair out. Financial Tracking make sure you're keeping accountability of the money is being spent that it closely hues to your five year plan. Make sure there's some if you're audited that you have some sort of good financial tracking method to justify the money that you spent.
24:10Some property and asset management audit readiness Again make sure your accountant everything is closely aligned for the purposes that the money was given to you and that you have good documentation for it. Contractual structuring for public private partnerships. You want to make sure you draft joint venture agreements, shared asset agreements and indefensible rights of use contracts which is critical. Clearly defined roles, ownership liabilities and exit strategies. All types of things you should take into consideration. And we'll talk a bit about Colorado as an example for drafting a scoring matrix. This is from last year. Some of the key criteria we're talking about cost effectiveness. You want to talk about points for lowest cost per location. So if you're if you were able to do it in a cheaper way than other competitors you get points for that.
25:01Digital equity measures so if you have emphasis on workforce development Outreach to marginalized groups, you get credit for that as well as redundancy. Overbuilding penalizes proposals in already served areas. Less justified sustainability. Again, points for business plans that show multi year financial viability. Again, everything you could do to reduce costs, increase the life lifespan of the of the infrastructure being put in as well as cost effectiveness. These are all things again that's within there that are very important. So drafting a scoring matrix, they make sure that if accurate reflects the scoring. It'd be very important.
25:42So some common scoring themes emerge across the states. Give you a little bit of aggregation. Here you have a fiber preference that's not exclusive even as direct right now it's a preference, it's not an absolute need. But fiber generally is a lot more quick and reliable and scalable but also very expensive. And particularly talking about travel areas, remote rural locations and a lot of times, especially when you're in a city with complex rules of getting access to the building. Fiber can be prohibitively expensive. Which is why other alternate measures are being introduced now and be discussed. We'll talk a little bit about low cost service plan requirements.
26:20That's going to be one of the things to be also included that they're going to that whoever is the winning party that they're going to have a low cost service plan that's being offered for a period of years. Won't be indefinite, but it will be for a certain period of time. Usually about 10 years or so, maybe a little less. Public private partnership incentives. Again, this allows local municipalities and counties to be able to earn some small amount of revenue for it. I love this idea and again I definitely encourage all of my county clients to go with this route. I think it allows again one in a cash starved environment with inflation, people trying to avoid raising taxes. But you'll find that taxes are going up regularly because expenses are going up. And public private partnerships do allow some revenue helps offset some of those costs. Use of local labor, apprenticeships. Again, you want to go ahead and encourage buying locally. Let us support from local entities that usually is very helpful. And sustainability of the business models. We spoke before very important in coming up with a scoring because again you want to build this as responsibly and show fiscal and leadership sustainability.
27:34Let's talk a little bit about examples of government network asset leverage. So we'll talk about Santa Monica, California's example. They have CityNet to leverage City owned fiber that offers gigabit service to anchor institutions. Generated recurring lease revenue by selling excess capacity. Chattanooga, Tennessee had EPB fiber. The example here is a municipal utility launched fiber network, became a national model. Survived legal challenge from Comcast and later received Covid broadband funds. So this allowed for economic growth, improved education, digital inclusion. So again this is a good case study. Fair law in Ohio and you have fair law and gig. It used public private partnership to deploy gigabit citywide which was very successful. Created clear policies on access used to city owned conduit and revenue sharing.
28:30We'll zoom in a little bit on Chattanooga EPB fiber. It illustrates administrative complexity of bead rollout. So Chattanooga Tennessee Electrical Power Board operates one of the nation's most advanced municipal broadband networks. It offers gigabit Speed Internet since 2010 and it's been incredible with attracting major employers like Amazon and Volkswagen to the region. Again, having it nicely developed reliable infrastructure brings in a big players like that. Especially like Amazon which as you imagine everything is online with order fulfillment or placement. Order fulfillment, everything. A lot of things are automated on Amazon's distribution hub Volkswagen also the same thing relies quite a bit on automation. Of course there are people building cars, but a lot of it is automated. Does rely quite a bit on broadband, especially with ordering materials.
29:21And you'll find that EPB sought to expand its high speed Internet services beyond its existing electoral service area to neighboring communities lacking broadband access. They want to build on success. But Tennessee state law prohibited municipal utilities from offering broadband services. So they designated electrical service area. So it restricted them to operate only where they had existing electrical service in those areas and they were going beyond that. So the EPB petitioned the broadband the FCC to preempt the restrictive state law. They argued that it hindered broadband deployment in underserved areas.
29:55And 2015 FCC ruled in favor of EPB asserting that the section 706 of the Telecommunications act of 96. This is a bit of Clinton era legislation. Notice the TCA empowered the FCC to remove barriers to broadband investment competition. Then the state in Tennessee challenged the FCC's decision saying that the FCC overstepped its authority by interfering with the state's governance of its municipalities. Again 10th amendment issue the case escalating to the US court of appeals, the 6th circuit. In the end, the 6th circuit rule against the FCC said that the TCA did not provide a clear mandate for the FCC to override state laws governing municipal broadband. So as a result EPB remains restricted from expanding its broadband services beyond its current electrical service area, leaving neighboring communities without access to its high speed Internet offerings. Again, great idea. It's one of those types of things that would have worked in expanding their Business model which showed a great bit of technological thinking ahead stewardship. But in the end we have constitutional construct and in this case the FCC overstepped its constitutional construct and allowing the states to manage its own local municipality. So again, bear this case study in mind. So let's talk a little bit about some key legal drafting tips for attorneys. You want to make sure you include clear grant of authority to build and operate broadband local ordinances or charters. So you need some sort of enabling language.
31:25You want to draft interlocal agreements or MOUs if infrastructure crosses jurisdictions. So for example, if you're talking about two local municipalities that have governmental networks and you want to connect them as part of a larger thing, larger network as you say, you would have to make sure you have interlocal agreements. You want to ensure governmental networks have appropriate procedural procedures. So make sure you have competitive RFPs versus sole source for bill outs. Obviously you want to have transparency and competition. Establish rate setting guideline to protect against claims of unfair competition, which you may find these are very large contracts being given out across the states and you're going to find, you know, people who have sour grapes who don't get the actual award. They might go ahead and contest things and challenge it in court. Let's say that there's a unfair competition.
32:16Want to make sure you draft lease and license agreements for third party access to public infrastructure so you make sure it's compliant with these open access expectations. As I mentioned before,
32:30some policy recommendations for fellow legal professionals. We want to make sure you have legal clarity in subgranting rules. So encourage state broadband offices to adopt transparent appeal process for contestant beat awards. Push for clear definitions of scoring criteria and publicly posting reward rationales. Again, people understand it's just not just the applicants and potential sub grantees who are looking to looking for these awards, but allows members of the public to understand how you reach this conclusion. And you always see that it's very, very important to have a little transparency. People like to understand the rationale and it also shows good governance a lot of people to understand that hey, the municipality really thought to sink through. So it was a good way of communicating to your to the constituents of any kind of state or municipality that the government was thinking ahead. You want to make sure you help clients build resilient partnerships. So you make sure you have MOUs, IRUs and governance structures that account for lifestyle obligations. So the deployment of the infrastructure itself, maintenance of it.
33:37Maintenance can be expensive fiber usually once it's laid that much in the way of maintenance. But other Forms of infrastructure may require maintenance and then sustainability. You know what? How can it last longer? You want to make sure you vet your partners again your ISPs or whoever you want to be using for fiscal soundness, regulatory compliance and long term viability. Usually the major players you can take a quick look, but any of the ones you know, like Verizon for example, know they're going to be a sound player. But again if you're someone you know less of or less familiar with check into financial stability.
34:17You want to monitor and respond to emerging federal policy. So you want to track National Telecommunications Infrastructure Act FAQs, FCC orders and congressional reauthorizations affecting broadband funding. So again one of the types of things is going to be rapidly evolving. Again people thinking of different ways of doing things. Technology changes. So just be prepared to constantly check bulletins, prepare to challenge or defend interpretations and litigation. Particularly with NTIA's authority weakening post Chevron lead on digital equity compliance. So some attorneys advising B recipients should ensure digital equity players are legally defensible, inclusive and performance driven.
35:00And you want to make sure you build policies that support accessibility, things like affordability, vice access and digital literacy training,
35:08some risk management, due diligence. In light of everything we just discussed, you want to perform tile search and verify municipal ownership control of assets used in build out. So again you want to make sure that if you're using any municipally owned land that it is in fact owned by the municipality so you don't later on find out you're squatting effectively. Environmental and zoning compliance must be documented for each construction zone. So nepa, SHPO local zoning codes. You want to develop a cyber security plan complying with the NIST guidelines B requirements. Again we always everyone's very familiar with attacks on our infrastructure and we want to make sure cybersecurity plans are in place and again is up to date with federal guidelines.
35:53Ensure insurance and indemnification provisions for subcontracts of partners in case there's a mishap, someone gets hurt or injured, material or other things get damaged. You want to make sure you have proper insurance indemnification to protect your client.
36:09One thing I want to kind of go over again in light of stretching federal dollars and an idea of governmental networks, talk a little bit about asset mapping. Asset mapping is a process of identifying, cataloging and leveraging publicly owned infrastructure support broadband deployment. Now think for example over the last 30 years there are a lot of companies that build out fiber and what happened over time is a lot of these businesses early on weren't successful. They either sold the business, the emergent of the company, or they just might have went out of business and kind of abandoned their fiber. They were already broke and didn't have the money at that point to spend the millions of dollars it takes to pull the fiber out. So what you have in many cases is fiber gold underneath your feet in many ways in the public grades away. If you're able to go ahead and identify this mapping of fiber, you get to decide, you get to leverage that and use it. And, and given the fact that most of the money spent in deploying it usually is on the fiber, if you're able to find substantial amounts of dark fiber, unused fiber, abandoned fiber, this could be a substantial benefit in protecting that need money to do your secondary and tertiary goals of affordability to local residents.
37:29So really you find this to be efficient, critical for efficient planning and cost reduction. And board band expansion of the BA program encourages the use of government owned networks where feasible, making asset mapping a key component of the state's B proposal. I would definitely identify that as something you're going to do. Of course, finding abandoned fibers not always easy. Takes a little bit of sleuthing around to kind of figure out what was abandoned. You have to look at potentially agreements, newspaper articles, look at some archived permits, if those still exist. I'm not sure what everyone's local municipal requirements to maintain documents are. There might be 10 years, 15 years, 20 years. So a lot of that might be gone. So a lot of it may require like talking to your local utility company to see if they know of any unmarked or unknown fiber that's there that wasn't probably marked out. So a little bit, it takes a little bit to find out. But if you're able to find it out, you can find literally millions of dollars worth of unused fiber.
38:32So let's talk a little more. In the government owned networks with a deed NOFO context, government owned assets for broadband expansion. Asset mapping helps identify existing private sector infrastructure that can be leveraged for broadband deployment. So think of things like private optic networks, state, county, municipally owned rights of way, so RRWs along highways, railroads and utility corridors. That's principally where most of this infrastructure is built. Fiber, electric cable, all that goes along the rights way for the most part, public safety networks, utility poles and condo by the municipalities. Think of water towers, rooftops and other vertical assets.
39:14So traditionally you can start building fixed wireless assets and small cells on top of water towers and rooftops. These are all potential locations to build infrastructure. Public buildings, they can also serve as broadband HUDs or data centers. So these are very useful. A lot of public buildings are not fully utilized and they have room to serve as a hu by reducing costs. You don't have to go to a private landlord and pay rent for it. Let's talk a little about asset mapping for government owned networks in the b NOFO context. Strategic benefits of asset mapping reduces deployment costs by utilizing existing infrastructure instead of building new facilities from scratch. Improves broadband equity by ensuring public assets are used to serve unserved and unserved populations.
40:04It also accelerates network deployment by streamlining access to government owned assets, which minimizes permitting delays. Again, permitting is, you know, one of the big things. I could take quite a bit of time if you submit a permit. Some municipalities take a long while. So when you have when you streamline the access to government owned assets by communicating with the mitzvah beforehand, you speed up the time to implement and deploy your bead money. Implementing asset mapping and bead projects should conduct a standalone audit of public assets suitable for broadband expansion. A bit of a project. It's a bit time consuming. If it's done well, it's done thoroughly. You could discover you have quite a bit of infrastructure that's already available and either not used or underutilized or never thought to be used in a certain way. Rooftop might be a good example of something that you don't think of as a vertical structure because it's a rooftop in fact can be used for fixed wireless things like fixed wireless access and 5G antennas. Good idea is the best practice is to develop a centralized database or GIS mapping system to track assets of facility planning. Creates a bit of knowledge management as well for future people and know what's actually in there right away. To date I don't know anyone who's got a fully developed database of all assets access on GIS mapping. Definitely see some of it on GIS which is a great tool for it but again it's data in and who's who's managing it and a lot of this stuff takes a great great deal climb that a
41:30lot of mispronounce don't have to put into it but variable do that that would definitely help with your bead project. You should integrate asset mapping to public private partnerships to maximize the value of public investment which is always a good practice. So let's talk a little bit about asset management considerations for government networks. So types of assets are conduit, dark fiber towers, poles, real estate, rights of way, utilities and really if you can ensure compliance with uniform guidance for federal grants. Again mentioned before regarding asset tracking, depreciation and disposition. All this is a great best practice.
42:09Expect there to be audits prepared asset management plans say you want to do inventory of physical broadband infrastructure, meeting schedule and depreciation, accounting and policies of sharing or leasing assets. For this example would be to private ISPs. Let's talk a little bit about regulatory, contractual and litigation issues and broadband deployment. So let's get into a little bit about defining the digital vibe, also known as a broadband divide. So what we see over here is Congressional findings under the IIJA that there's a persistent digital divide in the United States. It's a barrier to our economic competitiveness.
42:48Obviously we have talent and ideas and industry we brought from all segments of our society. We solely restricted to the more affluent towns and affluent cities. It's effectively not using the whole of our nation's great gifts of thinking, of ingenuity, of entrepreneurship. So we find that there's a barrier to equitable distribution of essential public services. You think about healthcare, education, particularly if you're talking about people working remotely for whatever reason. We had a pandemic not too long ago. This gives a good example of that disproportionately affects communities of color, low income areas and rural areas for many reasons. Part of it was our nation's history with segregation, lower income areas, poverty. Usually people might come with fiber because of the low return on investment roi.
43:41Low income areas generally can't afford it. And if you don't want to build a network to an area where people are going to use it because you never make your return and rural areas typically because they're so remote and so far away and so few people, it's very expensive building. You also have the ROI issue with rural areas. So the benefits of broadband should be enjoyed by all. Recent coronavirus pandemic unscored importance of affordable might speed broadband for individuals, families, communities allowed many of us to work home and to school from home and remotely. But we found that poorer areas and rural areas fell behind significantly from middle class and upper class areas that had good infrastructure didn't have a issue with sufficient broadband.
44:27So again, we know now that to be able to work, learn and connect remotely is one of becoming a essential need for many Americans. So why does it exist to venture? Four traditional financial metrics discourage advancement infrastructure in the poor remote areas. It had the low ROI for broadband infrastructure and deployment costs. High deployment costs and low expected revenues usually amounts to discouragement from billing that in the first place. Which brings us to the IIJA and the BE funds. Let's talk the difference between underserved and unserved areas. We have the FCC definition here. Unserved unserved areas based on bourbon speeds thresholds, primarily using the fixed bourbon definition. So unserved areas, you see 25Mbps download and 3Mbps upload. This is a long standing broadband benchmark and anything less than that would be unserved.
45:23Underserved is again anything under 100Mbps download and under 20Mbps upload. So that would be underserved.
45:38High cost areas, you have additional B criteria. The B program also designates some regions as high cost areas which may receive special funding. And we'll get into that a little bit. Places like Brooklyn, Chicago, rural areas, high cost areas because of unionization and assisted building by landlords. So all things that contribute to higher cost, these are generally rural, remote areas where deploying broadband is more expensive due to terrain, infrastructure costs or population density.
46:10So some of the areas that qualify, as I mentioned before, remote rural locations, sparse population leads to high per capita infrastructure costs. Large distances between homes, increasing need for more fiber per user. So some examples here is part of Appalachia, Rocky Mountains, Alaska, Western Plains, Mountains of default. Difficult terrain, so requires expensive trenching, drilling or aerial deployment. Very expensive aero deployment, usually by helicopter. Think of rocky soil, elevation changes, forest, complicated fiber deployment. And we look at places like West Virginia, Colorado, parts of California, Sierra Nevada mountain range and Montana as good examples.
46:52So high cost areas again, wetlands, swamps and flood prone areas, kind of alluded to that before. Fiber deployment is challenging due to unstable ground and environmental regulations. Often requires special construction techniques or aerial solutions. So Florida, Everglades, Louisiana Bayou, Mississippi Delta. Again, think of water and watery types of environments. Very difficult to deploy and keep it, you know, in areas where they're able to be serviced and upgraded extreme climate regions. So think of places like the Arctic and subarctic areas which require specialized trenching, high heat or desert areas.
47:29It could cause equipment overheating, dust related types of failures. So let's talk about some urban pockets of high deployment costs. Think as I mentioned before, New York City, Detroit, Chicago, Baltimore, New Orleans. A lot of the things revolve around expensive building access costs. So we'll talk a little bit about digital divide and redlining. So we'll talk historic redlining and discriminating investment pattern. I mentioned this earlier at the very top of the hour. Redlining was a government backed at private lending practice as everybody knows since the 1930s, it actually began began during Hulk, the homeowners loaners corporation. And they denied mortgages, business loans and infrastructure investment to minority neighborhoods. It's not no longer legal. Obviously since the 60s it's not been legal. But some of the legacy of it still, some still remains. So ISPs historically under invested in fiber or cable upgrades in red line neighborhoods.
48:30They were deemed to be low return on investment areas. Might have been racial reasons for it, but it was financial. But again, it relates back to earlier practice of discrimination leading to slower speeds and fewer provider choices denied. So some of the places are impacted by this. Think of places like affected cities like Detroit, Baltimore, St. Louis, New York and parts of Bronx and Brooklyn. Let's do a little bit of a case study. Expensive building access. So multiple dwelling units. What it is is deploying broadband to these buildings requires negotiations with property owners permits and physical access to the sites. So some of the barriers for ISP is exclusive wire yields. They only allow when ISP provided the building high rate of entry fees. ROEs. They may charge a lot of money for ISPs to come in a building that make it unprofitable older infrastructure. So a lot of buildings don't have modern wiring. They will have conduits and core drilling throughout the building to allow for easy rollout. So a lot of the times have the core drill between floors.
49:37A lot of the time they have environmental issues like asbestos in a building which requires additional environmental mitigation and for workers to work to have certain equipment on union labor rules. So you have places like New York, Chicago, strict legal agreements that raise deployment costs because you have to go through unions. So think of places like New York City, Washington D.C. san Francisco and Chicago. Some of the solutions to high deployment costs. Open access requirements require apartment billings and loanlines to allow multiple ISPs instead of granting exclusivity to a single provider. That's something they can do from a regulatory standpoint. That way, once you have multiple ISPs in there, increase competition. You want to maybe perhaps lower permit fees and faster approvals for projects to show that the municipality is receptive and willing to work with you. And also again allows for these ISPs to reach their deployment goals right away. Reforms make it easier for ISPs delay fiber public streets without excessive fees. Again, lower costs, lower time, allowing that b money to be deployed and reach more people.
50:44So here's a little example of here in New Jersey, you see over here, according to the fcc, you See the different areas I have Middlesex county red, it's one of the counties represent as well as Bergen county. And you see the different disparities between population and percentage of unserved and unserved people.
51:06So let's consider technology preferences, technology preference indeed fibers prefer technology. But this may change the new administration funding prioritization for future proof solutions. Again, the whole idea is you want to make sure you spend all this money that it is going to be something that's going to survive and be able to last for 50 years or maybe longer if it's properly planned out. Allowances for fixed warehouse access and satellite as lesser solutions depending on cost calculation outcomes. I actually have an algorithm that kind of comes up with the potential deployment depending on the geography and population size, which is kind of a fascinating, you know, look at things to really optimize be money, deployment, legal implications of technology preferences and funding applications. Again, that's keeping track with NTIA guidance.
51:58And as I mentioned before, fiber is tops, but it's not by any means unchallenged.
52:04Fiber is the gold standard and prioritizes farming to the premises FTTP because it does have incredibly high speeds, low latency and long term scalability. But it does allow for alternative technologies such as fixed wireless access and low earth orbitals. They're committed to generally see as secondary options for area where fibers are practical. Think of the single farmhouse in Montana, you know, far away maybe next next location might be 20 miles away. Next home or residence is 20 miles away. Putting fiber would be prohibitive, especially sensor for one single person. So a low earth orbital may be the best way or a fixed wireless access might be another way of doing it. Potentially cost versus deployment speed.
52:48While fiber offers superior performance, fixed wireless and satellite can be deployed faster and at lower costs, especially again in rural remote areas. Maintenance and infrastructure challenges. Fiber requires extensive underground or aerial installation, making it costly regions with rocky terrain, flood zones or extremely extreme weather risks. Here are some other examples. Again, these are emerging technologies. These are not by any means being actively used for sustainable long term use for remote locations unserved communities. But they're UAVs. They have solar panels that allow them to stay much longer for months in many cases last. For persistent broadband relays, UAVs, beam Internet using millimeter wave or free space optional communications links. It's ideal for military emergency response and rural connectivity. Again, usually best usage right here is short term use, not for anything that you know for year round use for a residence, but potentially as the technology increases and these become more Reliable and able to keep up longer. Could be a potential solution.
53:57Here I have a picture of a Zephyr. It's a high altitude platform station or haps. It's kind of cool. It looks like almost like a condor. Here we have a high altitude balloon here. This is nice examples of an airship which is operating low earth orbital. So some of the operational advantages cost effectiveness can present a more affordable alternative to traditional satellites for specific uses. Extended mission duration. Designed for autonomous missions lasting up to one year. It offers persistent coverage for applications like border surveillance, maritime monitoring and communication services in rural areas.
54:38Geostationing positioning operating at 20 km altitude maintains a stationary position relative to the earth's surface providing consistent coverage over a designated area. So other potential applications Telecommunications providing to unserved regions. Environmental monitoring. Measuring air quality, detecting greenhouse gases, monitoring marine pollution and observing forest fires. Surveillance security. Think border surveillance.
55:13So let's talk a little bit about regulatory application. In the US FCC has designated specific frequency bans for HAPs that's been allocated. Licensing framework is flexible has been established for these bands allowing entities to obtain non exclusive nature Y licenses. License holders must register individual links with third party databases. So here's another thing here. A stratospheric balloon using helium or hydrogen operates in the stratosphere. So you can see what they operate at the extreme, you know, level of the between earth atmosphere and out of space. It looks pretty, pretty futuristic. I think it looks pretty cool.
55:55So let's do a little bit of a summary of technology overview. We'll talk about fiber. Fiber to the home, fiber to the premises. We see broadband delivery wired broadband with fiber optic cables. Pros are fast ease. It's future proof reliable has very low latency. Cons is very expensive deploying it. A fixed wireless access is a wireless cellular network. It's lower cost and fiber faster deployment and can serve rural areas effectively but limited by spectrum and network congestion. So this has a great reliability and broadband capability. Fiber does. Then of course the non terrestrial networks which you just covered satellite haps to high altitude platforms. It does allow for wide coverage for remote rural areas.
56:38So again, that farmhouse that's 50 miles away from the nearest closest other residents and doesn't require any ground infrastructure needed. So no trenching. They'll go over these difficult terrains. You have the high latency except for the leos. Not really optimal when you want to use autopilot cars or you want to do zoom calls. It's expensive and dependent on satellite capacity. So let's talk about identifying unserved locations. Ntifc data sources are synergistic but not entirely consistent and there's also risk of misrepresented broadband coverage. So sometimes we either don't really capture unserved or unserved areas.
57:20So that was the discussion we had before. So we'll talk a little bit about mechanisms to dispute broadband availability data Step to submit a challenge. You have individual government challenges through FCCC BDC portal. FCC reviews the challenges. The ISB has 60 days to respond State led challenges on the bead State agencies collect data from residents, local governments and organizations and they are then reviewed and resolved by the state broadband office. Final broadband availability maps are then submitted to the NDI for funding approval, which in most states has already happened already. So let's talk a little bit about regulatory compliance Substantial bureaucratic hurdles State and local government obligations I mentioned before that you're going to have the NTI requirements but you also have local public contract law which would have to be complied with. Each state has their own version of it ensuring compliance with NTI guidelines Potential legal penalties for misuse of funds. So make sure you have a very good accountant making sure that the money is being used for its appropriate use.
58:20Contractual obligations of public private partnerships those were discussed before. That'll be put in the partnership agreement itself. All stakeholders must be on board for the bid program to work. That's very key to have communication everyone to be somewhat enthusiastic about it. So you have to have adherence to NTI rules Build out of performance obligations Projects must meet minimum speed and reliability standards. So again it's 100 download sorry 100 upload sorry 100 download 40Mbps for unserved areas Financial accountability the strict auditing and financial reporting that we discussed Transparency oversight tracking progress you want to make sure you're preventing fraud Ensure open competition with potential federal oversight if discrepancies arise.
59:08Public private partnerships alluded to this before. Advantages of P3 models are things like P3s can combine local capital with private investment to meet these 25% leverage strengths of both sectors. Again, public access to right of ways community trust low cost capital private has detectable expertise, scalability and customer service infrastructure. It's an ideal marriage in many cases Expanded coverage of local buy in local governments bring community insight Private partners provide execution efficiency financial sustainability As I mentioned before joint revenue sharing models and use asset strategies improve long term viability Provides a steady revenue source for many counties and municipalities.
59:53So let's go over some risk mitigation. 1. Include identification, insurance and bonding requirements very key Define responses for Environmental review Bacon compliance and vendor sourcing Again by America requirements in Section 889 Community broadband need identified make sure you have a local government identifies unserved and unserved areas Initial market assessment and asset inventory. We spoke about asset mapping before partner identification engagement public issues RFI RFP seeking private isp, co op and nonprofit and partner may Involve pre negotiation MOUs or non binding expressions of interest.
1:00:36P3 structure defined select the legal structure IRU Agreement Concession Contract joint venture these are the very very common typical ways of arranging for everything grafting the agreement itself. These are very complicated. Make sure you try to keep as much in mind as possible. Some of the real big things are affordability, cybersecurity very key and procurement It's a B sub grant application New Jersey Office broadband connectivity releases subgrant NOFO NOSO funding opportunity Every state will do something version of that public private partnerships application scoring awarding we spoke about this before.
1:01:15We have the NTI approved rubric project implementation Construction begins private part of bills network using B funds measured contributions public part overseas compliance financial tracking, community engagement operation service launch. So at the end of it all you ideally have an actual operating service and then after that you have the ongoing oversight compliance, regular audits, pre informed guidance compliance with affordability, cyber security and digital equity requirements. Which is why I said before it's great to have a P3 because you have the municipality itself overseeing these aspects of it to make sure the constituents are getting the benefits of the bean money.
1:01:52We'll touch a little bit about environmental zoning laws. Again, when you're trenching or digging to put in poles, there might be other things that come up such as wetlands, regional health spaces or historic districts. So some of the things to be mindful of is nepa, your National Historic Preservation act, the Endangered Species act, the ESA Clean Water act and tribal consultation requirements. Again very critical when you're dealing with tribal lands. Practical practice tips Environmental risk mitigation conduct environmental due diligence early because those are very time consuming. If you need to get environmental approvals include environmental review clauses and agreements. Use construction methods that minimize impact Again hurts under directional drilling reduces the amount of surface trenching. Very good practice New Jersey specific environmental rules but similar rules likely apply in other states like permitting may be required for disturbance with regulated wetlands or transition areas Green acres encumbrance reviews, fibroids or tariff siding on publicly preservable spaces Highlands act and Pineapple Pinelands Commission review these are unique to New Jersey. I think other states have similar acts but again very time consuming types of types of processes to go through broadband Rights of way and easements Legal requires for accessing public private lands State and federally Regulation Rights of way Legal requirements for accessing public and private land Think of things like easements
1:03:23and right of ways. Written access agreements should define scope, duration, means, responsibilities, dedication, title searches. Kind of alluded to that before as well. And land use diligence are essential to avoid disputes with property ownerships, owners or utilities. Legal requirements for accessing public and private land Continued you have section 253 of the Telecom act prohibits local or state governments from unreasonable prohibiting broadband deployment of rights of way requirements. States must streamline permitting and access process for public right of ways in the B plans. So let's talk a little bit about CLE practice.
1:04:03Tips for attorneys to draft a model right away agreement for clients that address B compliance, restoration obligations and indemnity. Advise clients to coordinate early with local governments, utilities and property owners to avoid project delays. Encourage clients to document right away negotiations and file permits and access rights to avoid future title or easement disputes. We'll go over briefly ethical consumer protection future legal challenges Deploying broadband and the Broadband Equity Access and Deployment Program involves several legal risks that could lead to litigation. These risks primarily arise from procurement disputes, permitting challenges, environmental regulations and here are some areas of potential litigation bid protests and challenges. Again, lots of money will be on the line. ISP can, you know, get quite a significant grant? They win. So be prepared to make sure that your procurement process is very transparent and follows the rules. The scoring rules Dispute over challenge processes allows providers and stakeholders to contest the coverage maps. So we've discussed that before.
1:05:05Permitting and right of way disputes Municipal state right of way restrictions some place may pose stranger and inconsistent right of way fees and conditions leading disputes between broadband providers and local governments. Expect that poll attachment and infrastructure access broadband providers may sue utility poll owners if they're denied access to polls conduits to terrorists at reasonable rates. So make ready work disputes who bears the cost of restriction modifications could also lead to litigation.
1:05:34So proactive legal and regulatory compliance Ensure strict adherence to NTIA rules state and permitting processes to avoid disputes Transparent fair challenge process Environmental tribal consultations early on that's having your reaching out to your key stakeholders. Open town halls these are always best practices clear right away and poll attachment agreements avoid disputes by negotiating standardized access terms for infrastructure use.
1:06:05So let's talk a little bit about cyber security and supply chain rules. This is very very important. You have certain requirements to keep up with cybersecurity. Very complex and then supply chain rules especially becoming prominent. You don't want to have any potentially adverse near peer competitors like China for example providing key aspects of supply chains you want to make sure it's sourced in approved locations ideal in the United States. Your plans must demonstrate compliance with the National Institute Standards of Technology framework for security protection of networks from intrusion, data loss and malicious activity procedures for incident detection response reporting Again cybersecurity framework training should ensure clients align with NISP depending on systems classification so identification, protection, detect, detect, respond recover all parts of the NIST functions Supply chain risk management behavior service must address prohibited vendors potentially supply chain vulnerabilities. So think of companies like Hawaii, zte, Dahua. These are all companies you know that you would definitely want to avoid.
1:07:15Legal counsel should council should help clients Vend vendors for Section 889 compliance use flow down clauses to ensure subcontractor supply compliance and implement protocols Offender risk assessment equipment origin tracing legal exposure enforcement risk non compliance can result in grant clawbacks or termination of funding State ag enforcement and data breach notification laws that's New Jersey, New York, California then federal investigation if B funded systems are breached and data is compromised so consumer challenges B Program Many such states and subgrantees prioritize equity affordability, inclusion and broader deployment States must enforce anti digital redlining policies to prevent discriminatory deployment that excludes minority communities. Community engagement Stakeholder input Mentioned that before. Very important States must engage local governments, community organizations and marginalized groups the Broadband Planning process Ensuring affordable and sustainable broadband services Low cost subscription plans Municipal private partnerships encourages cooperative and municipal broadband models in areas where private investment is sufficient and develop P3s to leverage public infrastructure. We talked a little bit about the challenge process mecms Dispute Broadband availability data Legal framework for submitting challenges well as a state of municipalities early Every house has categories but not always accurately.
1:08:35And as I mentioned before, there's a program relies on acroborbit availability data and just sometimes inaccuracies in the FCC's program maps, which is why you have a chance to challenge it. The mechanisms Dispute Broadband and availability data FCC's BDC map serves as a primary data source of B funding and there's different types of challenges. There's the location challenges and then feasibility challenges and then the speed challenges. Those are three broad categories. B Specific Challenges Process entities eligible to file challenges local governments, nonprofits, ISPs, residents and affected areas themselves tribal entities and then some of the ethical considerations Broadband policy Fair distribution of beat funding Some examples Transparency and broadband mapping and data accuracy Ethical obligation Ensuring data transparency so unserved, underserved areas receive appropriate funding. Again, we'll go over some of these points. Ethical designations and Broadband Policy Community Involvement in broadband Planning Ethical Broadband policy should prioritize local input rather than relying solely on corporate interests, long term viability, avoiding waste and ensuring that taxpayer funded broadband projects are built for long term success.
1:09:49So let's go to conclusions and takeaways. So the B would be the most substantial public telecommunications infrastructure project in a generation. I mentioned before about this being the modern day equivalent of the New deal from the 1930s and 40s. Best practice practices for ensuring B compliance is Public private partnerships, smart rights based stewardship, sensible technology preferences and future proofing Legal challenges to watch Abroad deployment program continue to evolve in real time due to the evolution of technologies, the new presidential administration, SCOs decisions and other gatekeepers and stakeholders. So with that I'm going to conclude my presentation.
1:10:26Here's my contact information if you'd like to reach me. If any questions regarding bead funding, public private partnerships and the like. Always happy to share best practices with fellow practicing attorneys. Thank you.