55min · about 10,000 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's seminar. Just a little bit about myself. My name is Carrie Sheehan, and I'm an assistant clinical professor of law and ethics at IU Kelley School of Business in Indianapolis, Indiana. I am also a practicing conflicts ethics attorney with Scopolitis, Garvin, Light, Hanson, and fury in Indianapolis, Indiana as well. And I do a lot of study and a lot of research in the area of AI, social media, lawyer ethics, and how everything kind of coincides with each other. Because whether we like it or not, technology is part of the legal practice, AI is part of the legal practice nowadays, and we really have to watch out for where it's going to cause intersections where we could run afoul with the rules of professional conduct and how do we handle those situations when they arise.
0:53But some other questions we may want to answer, too, is how do we prevent certain situations from arising and what is the best policies and the best things we should do from a standpoint of just being lawyers in general. So before we get started, though, just in the main material of what we're going to be talking about today, I really do love this picture because it kind of encompasses stuff that is happening and we don't realize it. We all sit on our computers all day. We're at our computers now. We all think we're protected, safe in our offices, safe in our home. But while work laptop is up, while our computer is on, there is stuff coming at us all the time. Now, whether your security system is preventing it from actually breaching your system, whether you have, you know, a full it department helping stop these things from coming in, we have things coming at us 24 hours a day, seven days a week. It can be from trojans to viruses to worms to spyware to bugs to different, different toy kids, different things that are coming at us. Hackers, cybercriminals, or sometimes it's just people experimenting, trying to figure out if they know how to hack something or not.
2:07Now, what do we do about it? Well, we can take cover. That's the one thing we can do, meaning we can educate ourselves, stay up on what we need to do when it comes to cybersecurity and different things and how to protect ourselves in the IT world. And we can kind of fight back with that. But we do have to remember that we have to still stay in line with the rules of professional conduct. Unlike businesses, we do have to abide by them because we are lawyers. It was actually Robert Mueller of the FBI director in 2012 that said, I am convinced that there are only two types of companies, and this could be law firms, too. Those that have been hacked and those that will be. And even those are converging into one category, companies that have been hacked and will be hacked again.
2:56And this is very true. And that was back in 2012. If you can just think of today, think of all the notices you get from major companies like Target, Walmart, at, and T being one of the most recent ones where they say, hey, we've had a data breach. Here's some 30 day, you know, credit monitoring protection. They've been hacked, they've been breached. They didn't use reasonable precautions, or maybe they did and they still got breach to protect their customer consumer information. Well, us as lawyers were held to a little higher standard, too, because not only do we have to protect our information just in general, just as being a company or, you know, operating in that space, we are also obligated to protect it under rule 1.6, confidentiality, part of the rules of professional conduct, and we have to take all reasonable means and precautions. Now, what the word reasonable is, we're going to look at a little bit of that and see what that means, but we have to take reasonable means to protect our client data and information. And you may think, well, why does it matter? We're not an at and t.
4:05We're not a Walmart. We're not a big box store that has tons and tons of credit card information and other things like that. But then when you stop and think about it, we do. We not only have employee confidential information talking about Social Security numbers, addresses, phone numbers, bank accounts for direct deposits. We also have client information, bank accounts, Social Security numbers, HIPAA information, private data, addresses, anything that a cyber criminal could be able to use to steal an identity, to defraud, to steal money. We have that information on our systems as lawyers. So we are still prime targets, just like the AT and T's, just like the Walmart, just like the big stores and companies, we are prime targets. We obtain, store, and use highly sensitive information almost entirely throughout the day during a law practice.
5:08And our rules of professional conduct say that not only those things that just are inherent to businesses like Social Security numbers, bank accounts, we also have to keep confidential anything we learn in the representation with the client. So if the hacker, whoever comes in, doesn't maybe get a Social Security number, maybe they don't get a bank account information, maybe they don't get any kind of that information, but they get your client's file, so they get to learn your strategies, they get to learn, you know, who your witnesses are going to be, the ins and outs of your investigation and research. And you may think, well, that's not going to be too bad, but it's still a breach of 1.6. So we've got the security portion, just like any business. And then we have the ethics portion, 1.6, where we cannot divulge client confidential information or anything we learn in the course of the representation to a third party. So a breach would be that. And the thing is, too, we have volumes of it. We have voluminous past clients, current clients, you know, prospective clients. We have a lot of this information that is right for hacking that hackers really want to get at because they can use to their advantage some of the major threats that we see. And we'll go through each of these a little bit more in detail and go through some examples, ransom attacks such as your phishing and social engineering.
6:36When you think of the ransom attacks, how many of you this morning or this week or this month, or even this year, if you want to go out that far, have got an email in your inbox and it says something like, click this link or your Amazon order is coming, click below. And it's really, you didn't order anything. You don't know where it's from. It's just, you know, a phishing with a ph email trying to get you to click a link. Now, when you click that link, usually a virus, a Trojan horse, a worm or something deploys on your system. You open up like a portal for them to worm their way into your computer to try to steal your data, to try to take over.
7:18And if you don't have the proper security things in place, they can't. I will say that I've known several law firms, several businesses, and just individuals who have clicked on those links, and then they realize their entire system is breached. You may not know it right away, but eventually, if you do have an IT department or some type of security data protocol in place, you would be able to see, you know, when it happens. Now you, like I said, you may not notice it right away, but when you start to see red flags go off or your system alerts go off, then you've got to figure out where was the breach, how do we stop the breach and what damage has it done up until this point? And those are big questions to answer, especially if what damage hasn't done involves tens of thousands of client files. Because now if that happens, not only do we have a breach, a potential rule 1.6 violation, we also now have to communicate with the clients about the breach, stop the breach, figure out how to make it not happen again, and then potentially defend any malpractice suit if it gets to that extreme.
8:32So ransom attacks, phishing, social engineering, those things where we want to click links or we get those random emails or those random encounters that just don't feel right, those are things we really need to look out for. Another one of the scams coming through. It's not really an email. It kind of is. It starts with an email, I guess you could say, but it starts with that email. And as you're doing the email or seeing the email, it's not for you to click a link, but it's someone saying, I need your services, I want to hire a lawyer, will you help me? They don't call you normally. Some have, some normally don't. But they send an email and the email looks halfway legit and, you know, just like a prospective client. And you say, yeah, I'm happy to talk, or, yeah, let's, you know, let me see about the case. And then all of a sudden they say, I'm sending you a check. It's for this amount.
9:22Just deposit it and send me this back. I know it's more than any retainer should be. That's the red flag, because then all of a sudden, within 24 hours, or sometimes 48, you get this random check in the mail from this person who's now kind of ghosting you. And it's for a huge amount. And what they're asking is you deposit it and then refund them some of the money. So one, you're either laundering money at this point, we don't know where this money's from. Two, it's a bad fake check that's going to bounce. And then you're going, you're, you know, going to get hit with a lot of fees and different things. Something is wrong with it.
9:57They're fake. And I have caught some of these before in different law firms, but at the same. And it's hard to catch. But you can usually see something like the check looks off, the background's not the right color for the bank, maybe the logo, the bank's just a little off or something, or just the whole situation does not feel right. And when you have that, where the whole situation does not feel right, then that is the problem. And you need to go with that gut instinct and make sure that, you know, you stop it before it starts. And with those two, you can take those types of checks to the bank, which they're potentially drawn from or to the bank that's on the check. You take it in, you ask them, is this real? And they run the routing numbers, they run the account numbers, and everyone that I caught or, you know, we've had to take in or test has been fake and the bank is actually thankful. They usually want to keep it or take a picture of it so that they can try to stop people from writing fake checks out of their bank. And so with those things, you've got to be very vigilant and there's usually some little yellow red flags that you'll see, like the spelling, the logos off.
11:04But it's that paying attention to detail that's really going to catch the ransom attacks. Phishing and social engineering emails. Now, the hard thing about these is with AI, those are going to get more sophisticated and harder to catch because not only can cybercriminals use AI and have access to it, it's going to help them be more, you know, proficient in what they do. They're going to be able to take that email, put it into AI. AI is going to rewrite it like a chat GPT or something, take out all the spelling errors or those red flags that we normally saw to tip us off, and then we're going to have a hard, harder trouble finding these. Same thing with, say, the checks. Maybe now they're going to have an AI program that can draft a better fake check or you're not going to have the issues that we spotted in the past. And so AI is really going to help cyber criminals and help the hackers that are coming for us, which is very scary. We can also see cybersecurity alerts through social media.
12:06This can be, again, through those chat programs, people reaching out the different scams that come through, or just trusting people. I don't know why we are so trusting online. We don't even know the person. We have no idea who's sitting on the other side of that computer. Maybe it's just the hope or the thought that this is good, or it feels nice, or our luck is turning around in certain situations. But why we're so trusting with social media is beyond me. You can have facial filters, you can change me to look like someone I'm completely not. I can say anything I want and no one knows who I am because I'm behind a computer screen. But that is the kind of things, too. This trust that we have or this need for that connection that maybe we're not getting in person now is going to breed trust where we shouldn't have trust, and we're going to have different cyber events. We're going to let people in that we shouldn't. And so we've got to watch for those things as well, and then just watch for suspicious links on social media, kind of like the phishing emails, different links that say, click here, click here. And if you don't trust the website, don't click the link, especially when it's on your work computer.
13:18So we need to remember those as well. You can also have cybersecurity events, and this is one that we don't really think about as a cybersecurity event, but it is a breach of rule 1.6. This is the misdirected email. Say, for instance, you're writing an email to opposing, to not opposing counsel, but someone in your firm, and they have a similar name to opposing counsel. The autofill feature never fails. Autofills that name. You hit send before realizing that you just sent your entire strategy, not to your colleague down the hallway, but to your opposing counsel. That's the misdirected email. This can cause problems with rule 1.6 confidentiality. Another issue with misdirected emails, or just emails in general, for the cybersecurity part of it is interception, hacking into the emails, meaning when you send something out there via online, via social media, via emails, or anything like that, it has the chance to be intercepted and it can be intercepted, and then you're going to have a cyber security event that you need to, you know, handle or deal with in those certain situations. So you've got to watch those misdirected emails.
14:32Now, if you're the recipient of a misdirected email, not the cybersecurity event where you hacked in and stole it, you know, as it was sent, but one where opposing counselor, someone who's not supposed to send you information that you're not supposed to have and you know you're not supposed to have it because it's confidential. Rule 4.1 does tell us that we need to reach out or we don't have to reach out. We have to follow the direction normally of the person who misdirected it. Now, most jurisdictions say that, meaning if they say delete it, then we need to delete it. If they say don't use it, then we don't need to use it. Now, a lot of jurisdictions say it's not the fault of the receiver, it's the fault of the sender. And so sometimes in those, you can do whatever you want with it if you're the receiver, but you've got to read your specific jurisdiction because each one is different. On that inadvertent disclosure rule, make sure you take a look at that rule. If you are the recipient or sender of one of those misdirected emails, and how to protect confidentiality, or how to correct the mistake, or if you're on the recipient side, can you use it in your case or do you have to disregard it? Those are all important questions when it comes to those misdirected emails.
15:46We also have different cybersecurity events with stolen or lost portable devices. Obviously, we all are connected with cell phones, laptops all the time. If you're out and in your pocket, it falls out or someone steals it, you may think, well, how is this a cybersecurity event? How is this a breach of confidentiality? Well, what do you have on your cell phone? Do you have client emails? Do you have client contact information, the contents of all those emails? Maybe you've even downloaded and saved client files to your phone to send them to someone else. If your phone is not password protected, if your phone does not have the security features on it, this is a huge breach. Same thing with a computer. If you lose it, you break it, you do those things or you don't protect it, then whoever gets it can, you know, access the information. So you've got to watch out for those situations as well. Always use passwords, always protect your information. Use reasonable means. That's what the rule says. Reasonable means to protect the information.
16:47Protecting is reasonable means kind of, you know, making sure it's secured. If you leave it in your car, reasonable means. Now, the one thing people forget when it comes to the portable devices, too, there can be a breach, and maybe not a big cybersecurity event, but a breach of rule 1.6 confidentiality. If you share a cell phone with a spouse or children, they do not fall under the same privilege or protections, and they're not part of that. So why we think that there are kids, they're not going to say anything if they read my email. But that's not, that's not the analysis. The analysis is, did you share it with a third party? If the answer is yes, then it's breach of rule 1.6.
17:27Whether that third party be your spouse, your significant other, your, you know, relationship partner, your kids, your friends, whoever that is, that's a breach. And you may say, well, they just got on it. They were just using my phone. Don't let them use your phone, keep them out of the email, get them their own phone. Otherwise, we could have a breach of rule 1.6. We can also have those HIPAA violations like I talked about, too. If someone hacks in, they can still HIPAA information, which is a whole nother ballgame, a whole nother security breach. You've got to watch out for that as well. And then improper disposal of information. This is one, again, that not a lot of people think about. But how many of you at your office have a shred box? That shred box is where maybe your assistant, maybe you, throws documents you want to shred because, one, you need to dispose of them in a manner not to breach confidentiality. And so you put box, you put papers in there. Well, then you don't really don't want those steps on your.
18:27I watch. You don't care about that. You want to sit and get work done. And so you don't take your shred box or empty it out into the actual shred by bin, the one that's secure, that just has the little slot where you can't even shove all your papers in at one time until every Friday. And then on every Friday, you take it down there out from under your desk, or your assistant takes hers out from under her desk or his desk and takes it down to the bin. Now, the problem with this is for that entire week, that shred bin has been sitting under your desk for anyone to pull the papers out of, read them, or do different things.
19:02Now, you may think, but it's in my office. It's secured. Do you have a cleaning person at night? Did someone mistake the shred documents for trash and throw the shred in the general trash can and threw it in the dumpster out back of your building? Now, did someone in the dumpster out back go dumpster diving, get into the client files, and there goes all the confidential information. There goes all the cybersecurity things, too. Because maybe there was HIPAA, maybe there was bank accounts, maybe there was Social Security numbers. What was in the shred box? You wanted it shredded. So why are we throwing it out back in a dumpster? Why are we leaving it under our desk for some cleaning person at night to mistake it for trash or just to rifle through it? That can also be the improper disposal, creating a cybersecurity event, creating a rule 1.6 violation that we have to watch out for.
19:55This can also be data breaches, insider trading, apts, which is known as advanced persistent threats. That's people coming at you, coming at you for information supply chain attacks, where they, if you have vendors you use, they come after or hack your vendors, not you directly, but the vendor has your confidence information or your clients confidential information. So you've got to also look at the security of your vendors. Say you use investigators or third parties, or you send stuff out to an expert to be analyzed. That's a supply chain attack. If they attack that person, then it attacks your confidentiality for your clients. You've got to look at those things as well.
20:37A lot of us use cloud storage. Now, cloud storage does have vulnerabilities and hacking capabilities. Some law firms I know hate cloud storage and refuse to use it because of the security risk associated with it, because of the cybersecurity and hacking that could be involved. So you've got to watch out for those things as well. Jumping back up to those insider threats if you don't know what that is. Sometimes people you work with are not there for great reasons. Maybe the attorney is looking to go to another firm. Maybe that's just a bad apple, or someone, you know, just was like, I'm going to steal this. And they had the this side, second life, you don't know about of hacking and cyber threats. And so they steal information.
21:20They use the information they learn while employed at the law firm and then steal it for their own benefit or to release out to third parties. So you can have those insider threats, too. And you may think this only happens in movies. This only happens in big Walmarts or companies or corporations, but it can happen in law firms, too. You can happen because, again, we have client information. It's not always just bank accounts. It's not always just after the Social Security numbers. It could also be after details, names. Think of like Ashley Madison and the list and all of those things. That could be a security and a breach, especially under rule 1.6, because we have a duty to keep everything confidential that is pertaining to the nature of the representation. So we have to watch out for those things as well, which just keeps our list growing and growing and growing again, just reinforcing it. Those client files, information, that financial stuff. Human resource records, too. We haven't really as much talked about that one, but it's not just our client data, but also the information we keep on our employees. Think about everything we have to give on the first day of a job. We have to give our name, our bank account, those different things, those human resources is what is important to hand over. And we've always got to think of that as well. The hackers that we have. They're faceless. Attackers are hacktivists. They are criminals, insiders, nation states, terrorists. Call them what you
22:54want. They are coming at us like that first photo. They're coming in worms, intro gems in different areas are coming for us and coming for us, and we've got to be ready for them. Got to look at the rules. We've got to know all those different areas we just talked about, too, and be able to guard against them, not only to protect ourselves, but to protect our clients, which is our duty and obligation to do so. We've got to remember that. And you may think, well, wait a second, do I really have to? What if I just use paper files? What if I go back to the old school typewriter and the snail mail and all those different things? And that's great, you can, but it doesn't negate your responsibility to learn about the technology, to learn about protecting your clients against cybersecurity threats, to learn about, you know, all the ins and outs that we need to do because row 1.1 says we have to stay competent. Competent in our representation requires the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness and preparation necessary for the representation. So we have to maintain that requisite knowledge and skill. We have to stay abreast of changes in the law, and that includes the risk and benefits associated with relevant technology.
24:11So it even spells out in the comments to rule 1.1 that we have to stay informed. I don't care if you never have an electronically stored file, if you have email, use your phone, anything, it's risk and benefits associated with relevant technology. Rule 1.1 tells us we have to stay competent, so we have to learn how to protect ourselves, protect our clients, and make those reasonable decisions to protect their information. And so when you read rule 1.1 in conjunction with rule 1.6 c, which is at the bottom of your screen in front of you, which says that we have to make those reasonable efforts to prevent the inadvertent and unauthorized disclosure or unauthorized access to information relating to the representation of a client. So all of all these phishing emails, all these different data breaches, if we go back in that list, the ransomwares, the social media, the misdirected emails, the stolen portable devices, the HIPAA improper disposal, data breaches, supply chain, all those things, we have to make reasonable efforts to protect against those things. Now, what does reasonable efforts mean? That's a great question. And that's a question we can't have a black and white answer to because each of your law firms and how you're practicing and what area you're practicing in is different.
25:32Certain areas are at higher risk, certain areas at lower risk. Some of you have a very voluminous practice. Some of you have one to five clients at a time. It just depends on where you're at. So these are things that we have to take into consideration in addition to that, too, what just is confidential information? 1.6 c says anything relating to the representation of the client, and that is true. It's everything there in that big red circle. Some people mistake that confidentiality for the attorney client privilege, but the attorney client privilege is actually a very small subsection of the broad concept of confidentiality. Attorney client privilege is a communications directly between me or you or, excuse me, you and your clients, or me and my clients. You know, those verbal ones, those emails where no other third party is present, minus a few limited exceptions in that area. But it's the direct communications between the attorney and the client that is attorney client privilege protection.
26:36Confidentiality is everything else that touches or concerns the representation. So we have to remember how broad confidentiality is and how small that tiny subsection of the attorney client privilege is as well. And we have a duty to keep this broader confidentiality secured and free from cybersecurity and cyber hacking and cyber events. So when we combine those rules, like I was just saying, I just want to give you a slide so you can see it for yourself, too. A lawyer must act competently to preserve safeguard confidential client information against unauthorized disclosure to any lawyer or persons under his or her supervision. Safe harboring.
27:21Obviously, there's no violation if we use reasonable efforts. But what is reasonable efforts? What does it take to guard against? So we don't have these rule violations. And as I said, it's not a one size fits all. It's actually ABA formal opinion 477 R, which is really great for you to go to read. It talks about some guidance on how we can take reasonable measures, especially when it comes to email traffic, social media, just all those different cybersecurity events that we talked about. 477, are that ABA formal opinion. Give some great advice. And again, it is not a one size fits all. It depends on multifactors. The information you have, the security level you want, it could be too. Do you need additional things that other people would not need based on your practice? What is the cost?
28:14Are you a two person firm? You can afford maybe a million dollar security feature or security setting where a big law firm or an AmLa 100 law firm could and probably should, just because they have multiple offices and multiple data points that could be breached and multiple attorneys and staff over into the thousands and thousands. And so maybe they need that more robust us, more expensive one. But that cost is also going to be, you know, part of it because we can't tell solar practitioners by this million dollar policy and they say, no, I can't afford it, I'm going to go bankrupt. And then you make them go bankrupt. You have to do it based on, you know, the size and nature of your firm. It can also have issues with difficulty and implementation. Meaning how hard is it to implement? Do you need training on it? Daily maintenance? Do you have to hire a whole it department? Because it just something like McAfee where you can put it on your computer, update it, pay the update fee every, you know, year and call it a day. What is the difficulty? Again, that's not a one size fits all either.
29:20It's going to be based on your firm size, your needs, your clients, the work you do. All those multiple factors are going to come into play again. And then two, we need to look at the adverse effect of safeguards vis a vis your ability to represent your client. Too much security is not a good thing because then how can you adequately represent your client if you have so much security on your email where you can't even get an email from your clients in a kind of almost simultaneous without it going through 500 different checkpoints, or you can't get that court docket, or the court can't even email you because you have so many security settings on, then that's too much.
29:59We need to take that and balance it with security versus our ability to do our job. And we want to make sure we have the ability to do our job are the things we really need to look at when it comes to it. Common 18 give some guidance to enroll 1.6 but that formal opinion 477 r, I recommend pulling that down. If you have access to it, you can google it. And if you have an ABA subscription or you're a member of the ABA, you can obviously get it from there as well. Some other guidance from that opinion, though, just to kind of summarize them here for you. Obviously we need to understand the nature of the threat, how it impacts our client confidential data, where and when, and, you know, how those different things, if we have certain threats we're looking at, we need to understand and use reasonable electronic security features where we can, where cheap determine how to communicate with our clients. If a breach does happen, that communication has to happen. You can't try to sweep it under the rug. You can't try to pretend it never happened. If a client status breached, you owe a duty under rule one, communication, to communicate that breach back to the client. Tell them how you're resolving it, tell them the impact, and then maybe offer them security features if you have them, or, you know, how are you going to make this up? What are you going to do? Have that plan put in place. But we need to understand what the threat is, what the threats are potentially or were, if we already had the breach and then how are we going to communicate?
31:31We got to communicate back with the client. We've also got to communicate too. How are we going to change things in the future? Some other things you can do, especially with those misdirected emails, label emails, client confidential information when they are now, if you overuse that, courts are going to go, are not going to put any credence to it. You've got to be limited in its use, make sure it's relevant, make sure it's real. But you can also do that as an added layer that this is meant to be confident. We also have to look out too, for supervision. If we're using all these features. But no one else in our company is, such as our subordinate lawyers, our subordinate, like our non attorney assistants, then we have an issue there as well. And so because we are responsible for them under rules 5.1, that's, you know, when we're supervising subordinate lawyers, or 5.3, when we're supervising our non attorney staff. So we've got to watch out for those areas as well.
32:23So if we're doing training and encryption and all this confidentiality, they need to listen to this too. They need to know, because if they violate the rules, you violate the rules. So we've got to watch that as well. And then conduct with vendors. Again, we need to watch our vendors. Who are we using? What are we doing watching those vendors and making sure that they're using proper security protocols to protect our client data. If they're not, or they don't have the systems put in place, then maybe we shouldn't use that vendor. Maybe we shouldn't use that third party to help us with the case. We need to ask those questions and be able to communicate so that we can again communicate back with our clients.
33:05Here's that communication rule, rule 1.4, just for your reference, if you didn't know you had a duty to talk to your own clients, this is a rule that says we have to talk to our clients and it says Justin is short it's a short one. A lawyer shall promptly inform the client of any decision or circumstance stance with respect to which the client's informed consent is required, reasonably consult with the client about the means to accomplish the objectives, keep the client informed of the status of the matter, respond to requests for information, and consult on any relevant limitation of the lawyer's conduct. So again, that communication needs to be there. We do have a duty to disclose the risk to our clients and disclose any breaches thereafter that occurred.
33:50If we found a breach, or if we clicked on a link or we've got a trojan or something, or we know we've been hacked, you need to contact your general counsel, if you have one, immediately, or whoever is in charge of the firm. Now that if you're a solo practitioner, you're contacting yourself and maybe your malpractice carrier. But you need to contact internally and have procedures in place for what people are to do if a cybersecurity event happens to if there is a breach, we need to be able to know who to contact and we have our incident response plan starting to form and starting to come in place.
34:27We also have to advise the clients of any potential or breach that has occurred, and then we should also communicate with them, too. The risk upfront regarding any potential breaches, meaning if they use email, it's always the potential of being hacked. This is, you know, potential. These are these different risks that you're taking on by hiring us. Tell them that upfront. Maybe they'll say, I don't want to use email, or don't send me things over the phone, or don't do XYZ. You have to communicate the risk and then let them decide, the client decide what risk they're willing to take on regarding your representation of them. So we need to start looking at these things too, and making sure we make those communications.
35:13If a breach does occur, we have an obligation to monitor it, to try to stop it. Obviously, we don't want to keep it running rapid, restore our systems to working order. And with higher protections, that may mean determining what, excuse me, what actually did occur, because we have to know what occurred to stop what occurred, and then we have to provide notice to any client that's affected. Again, rule 1.4, but also, formal ABA opinion 483 walks through these steps of what we need to do and how we need to protect ourselves and our clients. So what can you do? Well, you need to make up an instant response plan, meaning this is how our firm is going to handle if a cybersecurity event happens.
35:59If a, you know, unintended disclosure happens or misdirected email happens, this is the plan. And make sure everyone in your company knows the plan and follows the plan. First, you need to assign responsibility. I'm not saying to whose fault it was to let the cybersecurity person in. I'm saying to whoever's going to take charge of the situation and make sure the steps of the incident response plan are followed. So you need to appoint someone as the person or team to be the overview of the cybersecurity events. You need to have those internal reporting procedures laid out for all employees. Lawyers and non lawyers like to know what to do if something happens. And you may need to make them feel comfortable in reporting. If they're scared you're going to retaliate because they caused the breach, or fire them because they caused the breach, they're not going to report it. So you want to have a sense of trust and a sense of communication. Open honesty, transparency.
36:55When it comes to internal reporting procedures, you also need criteria for activating the plan. Like when do they reach out? When do they nothing. You need internal personnel and other resources as well to manage it. Because once they report up, then what happens? Who takes the lead? Who takes the reins? Who figures out with it what went wrong? How do you plug those holes? What do you do? Do you need to hire someone outside to do it? If you're a smaller company, you need to think of all those things. You also need to think, too. If you're. Excuse me, I'm tired this morning. You also need to think, too. Alternative ways to communicate if your email has been hacked, you're not going to want to communicate via email.
37:36If your phones have been hacked, you're not going to communicate via phones. So how are you going to communicate? You need to have an alternative step in there. In the incident response plan, you also need to think too. We've had a report now, who do we notify? Do we need to notify insurance? You know, hr? Think about labor, employment laws, credit monitoring. What are we going to do to resolve this? Who do we need to conjure? What procedures do we need to put in place? What crisis management needs to be there? The flexibility to plan for the unknown. You may think you have the greatest cybersecurity policy ever, and it'd be terrible because it's something you never thought of. So plan to be in. Plan to be flexible. Plan to know that the plan may not work. Plan to know that you may be taking plan B, C, D, e, or f plan for the unknown, communicate, give that notice. Keep records of your activities, what you do, how you handle it, who you contacted, who you've not contacted, what data was breached, what data wasn't. Keep those records, preserve it, either digital or paper form or both.
38:41Have backups to your backups. Restore your systems back to where they were. In part this incident response plan and do periodic review and training, and know that it's not going to be perfect every time, but having something in place shows that you thought about it, that you're using those reasonable measures, which is what the rule states and what the, what is required by the ABA. So we need to think about how are we going to do this and do it effectively. Core functions, any plan, if you're thinking of writing one or don't, or, you know, want to write one, identify the potential threats and issues.
39:18Now you're not going to be able to identify all them, but start to think about what those are, what protections are you going to put in place, how are you going to do maybe annual detection, training, different things like that to make sure that you get catch everything because you can have systems in place, but it doesn't, if it doesn't have a trigger, meaning, you know, when a breach occurs, something triggers you, that a breach, then it's not going to be effective. So how are you going to detect them, how are you going to respond and how are you going to recover? So any great plan for a cybersecurity or event or any breach event, identify, protect, detect, respond and recover.
39:56Those are the core functions that we would need to have. Let's look at some common scenarios here. This is going back to that fission social engineering. This again is one that we talked about earlier when I was going through the list. Here we have John. He's working at a large law firm. He clicks on a link, link, you know, to reset his username and password. It came via email to him. Did it? Excuse me, that was not what it was for. It was actually a virus coming into his computer. The next day, the managing partner of the firm calls stating that the organization has experienced a significant breach of over 3000 client files which has been traced back to John's computer.
40:36Yes, what John has done, John admitted that he clicked on the user thing, which was a fake one. It was someone just trying to hack in. And so then now they have to trigger any incident response plan. What are they going to do? Can they stop it? What client files are, you know, compromised? Make those notification notifications out to those clients. How are they going to recover, then they also probably need to get John some more training. So this is a common scenario you see within law firms is these phishing emails that come across another one we've already talked about a little bit, too. I gave kind of the over general example. Betty apparently regularly handles medical records and sensitive information.
41:18Occasionally, she has to dispose of the printed protected health information. So she puts in the shred receptacle underneath her desk before taking it to the big bin in the hallway. The shred box. But this morning, she arrived to work and noticed that her box on her desk was empty. So the night crew, cleaning crew had emptied it for, but not in the shred box. Now it's in the dumpster out back in the regular trash. This is that example of improper disposal that could implicate a breach or an event. And we'd have to trigger that incident response plan here, too. We, even though it's not online, we still have to recover. We still have to disclose, we still have to talk to clients. Like this would trigger that incident response plan, too. Betty probably needs some more training, and so we need to think of those things. Breach of confidentiality.
42:05Linda is a law partner at her law firm. One day, she receives a phone call from a client, Bob, who is very tearful and clearly upset. At the time of the call, Linda was waiting for a doctor's appointment in a public place. However, Linda proceeded to take the call from Bob and even put it on speakerphone to hear him better. During the call, Linda repeated out loud back to Bob the facts of his case and gave him legal advice. The other persons in the waiting room overheard the conversation. They also read her laptop, or the person sitting behind her read her laptop, which also had client confidential information. This is a cybersecurity or another breach event as well. We cannot be talking about client information in public places where people can overhear us or see the content on our computer screens. If we were all in person here and you were in rows in front of me, how many of you would have your laptops up working on client files?
42:57When the person immediately behind you can read your screen, that's a breach of row 1.6. That could be an inadvertent disclosure. That could be a breach of confidentiality. That could be a malpractice claim. So again, we have to watch here. This would trigger the incident response plan. What are we going to do? Well, stopping. It's easy. We talk to Linda, we educate her on why this is not good, but we still have to make that communication out to the clients put proper procedures and protocol in place so this doesn't happen again. We still have to follow that incident response plan. The misdirected email scenario we talked about quite a bit, actually, so far up to this point. This is Todd at a large law firm.
43:40He was in a hurry and didn't properly look at the autofill address, and it populated the email that he was drafting to his client, populated it out to opposing counsel, and email contained case strategy and evidence that Todd had successfully kept out a discovery and now, inadvertently, he's sending them over. So what did he do wrong? One, use the auto fill feature. Didn't check. His work was being too much in haste. So we need to slow down, we need to stop, and we really need to think now. What should Tom do, Todd do here? Well, incident response plan is triggered here. We'd want to reach out to the opposing counselor who received the email, try to intercept it, recall it back, but reach out to them saying it was sent inadvertently.
44:21Please do not continue to read it. Please disregard it. Please throw it away. Please. You know, go forth. Now, depending on the jurisdiction, depends on what opposing counsel can do with it. Opposing counsel could use it for a motion, could argue that, you know, since it was inadvertently disclosed. Now it's his to use for whatever means and reason he wants to. It depends on the jurisdiction. Hopefully, the jurisdiction in which this occurs to is more the ones that say, nope, you can't use it. Sorry. You know, you need to follow his direction. Disregard it like you never got it. That's really hard to do if you've already read it.
44:57But some jurisdictions say that because if you can prove it's misdirected, then it wasn't intentional. And they don't want to punish people for unintentional actions. But at the same time, it's carelessness, and we shouldn't be careless as lawyers. So that's why other jurisdictions go that different direction, too, when it comes to deciding what to do with inadvertent disclosures. Going on to another example here, portable devices. This is, again, where we have information on our phones. We talked about this earlier. Here we have Dan, who leaves his laptop in a taxi that dropped him off from the airport to his hotel, his contacts through the taxi service. But several customers have been in the captivity calls to try to get his laptop back.
45:41Can't find it. Can't find it. Now we have a breach. Someone has this laptop. Hopefully his password protected. That's a reasonable measure. Hopefully, they can't get into it. What should Dan do here immediately, notify, trigger that incident response plan, whoever he's supposed to notify. Maybe your firm has a way to remote detonate, or I say detonate, but turn off a phone, turn off a computer or. So no one can get into it, even with password. Maybe they can, you know, contact the service provider. Maybe they can do different things. We also need to know, okay, now we need to up security internally too, because what else is on that, the emails? Can they hack into it now is I'll put up additional security features as well, because Dan has, you know, kind of handed over a big gift to someone who found his laptop. Hopefully not, but maybe so. So again, that incident response plan is triggered there. Well, some other things to think about, too. The impact of AI just a little bit, you know, emerging impacts of emerging technologies on law firm cybersecurity. This is mainly AI. How is AI going to affect all these different categories we talked about, particularly chat GPT and other chat bots out there and what they're going to do if you don't know what chat GPT is, it is powered and run by OpenAI, so you can go to OpenAI.com to find it. But chat GPT is a generative, pre trained transformer. So it's a language model that is programmed to respond to any question or query like a human being. So it generates
47:18out those human like responses in a text based format. It is not, right now, verbally talks to you, but maybe in the future will. But it will. You can ask it a query, it will respond. You can ask another question, it will respond. There are different versions of it. There's actually three versions now. I know there's only. Well, there's three on the screen, but. So four, if you count their picture version, four versions now. One of the most recent ones just came out within the last month or so. So this has not been updated since then. But the first version is chat GPT 3.5. This is the free version. You can go to chat GPT OpenAI dot, sign up with an email password, use the free version. There's chat GPT four, which is more enhanced, safer, pulls from a bigger data pool, has more programmed information into it.
48:09It's more reliable, but it costs $20 a month. And so you've got to think, do you want more reliable, up to date information with the four, or do you not care and just want to use 3.5? Because you're just doing general stuff? You got to make that call for your cell. Now there is a chat GPT 40 or lower case letter O. So four o, but the o is in the lowercase letters, and that one is even more reliable, produces safer, more accurate results than the regular four. And it just pulls, again from a bigger subset of information. You may think, well, what do you mean pulls from an information? When you have a pre prone transformer, it just, it can't think on its own. It can't draw on past experience. It can't draw, draw on different things like that. So you have to program it to pull its knowledge from certain sources.
48:59And it's not just the entire World Wide Web with no parameters. 3.5 think of it as a hot tub pulling from think of four as a swimming pool. Think of four o, the new one as maybe an Olympic sized pool or maybe your town, like the size of your town. So the data it pulls from gets bigger and bigger with each version. So that's why it gets more react, accurate and more reliable with each version. Upper ones are paid. The one that small pulls from the hot tub, not paid or, excuse me, not no service fee. You don't do a paid subscription. There's also dolly, which creates images and art that works on like credits online.
49:39So you pay for those credits. But all these things combined can do language generation, answer questions, text completion, they can do text summarization, translation. They can feel, you can say, tone this down for me, make this sound more forceful, make this apology sound like I mean it. Maybe some of our TikTokers out there should use AI to write their apology letters. But it can show tone, it can show sentiment, it can show those different things within the program itself. It can chat with you, you can say, hi, how are you doing? And it will answer the question. Say, I'm good today. How are you? How was your day? If you're alone at night, chat with it, talk to chat. There's the free version. It's a free conversation and it doesn't, it talks back, but it doesn't talk back with unwanted opinions because you're asking it the questions you want it to respond to. So think about it that way as well. If you want to talk to it, it can also do different things, such as explain stocks, design data, scan, brainstorm recommend activities, ideas for things. It does a whole host of things, but it can also breach a lot of our rules. It can breach that confidentiality because anything you put into it does nothing remain confidential.
50:50We have no control over what chaptpt does with the information we put into it. So if we have client names, client data, client different things that we put into it, we cannot guarantee that they will remain confidential. We also communication. We would need to let our clients know we're using it because that confidentiality concern, because we would need their consent to use it and it could be a breach or a security event in and of its itself. We also need to know how to charge for it. It does stuff within seconds, which would take us hours to do. And then we need to supervise our staff. The other thing with chat, GPT and different language models is they pull from the Internet. The Internet is not unbiased, so it could pull in bias content as well.
51:31So in and of itself has problems. But why should we use it? We can use it to help us. We can use it to help us write a data security plan, something very general, no client confidential information. We can use it to give us recommendations on a data security plan. We can use it to help us figure out where to even start. It can give us a form template. It can do that again, don't put in client confidential information, but you can get a generic template and then modify it past there. It can help you with your advertising, your blog posts, your YouTube, your social media, youre networks. But we have to watch these rules, especially confidentiality. Otherwise, using these AI programs is a cybersecurity event in and of itself. It's not going to be helpful to you anymore. It's going to be a cybersecurity event that you're going to have to now trigger your policy, now trigger, you know, going through and contacting your clients of why you decide to use this, what happened, and that you have no way to even stop the bleeding because you have no control over what chat tb does with their information. So while it can be helpful in some instances by creating generic content where we're not putting in confidential information, it can also, on the flip side, create another type of cybersecurity event, confidentiality breach and data security breach as well.
52:57So we need to watch AI. AI can be great, or it can really harm us in our law practice, and that's something we need to watch out for. We need to think too, using those reasonable measures. Encryption is one of the them. If you don't know what encryption is, encryption is the process of converting information or data into code, especially to prevent unauthorized access, protect sensitive information. So you can encrypt your emails through Microsoft. You can encrypt files where only if you have a certain password or code can you open it. This is good. If you're transmitting, say, HIPAA information from point a to b or if you're transporting, you know, different stuff, you just don't want people to access from point a to b. This would be something you would really want to look for different types of encryption to think about. There's symmetric, which is same key to use, is used for both encryption decryption, meaning I have a code that's going to unlock this email.
53:56This file attached to the email, I use it to lock it. Recipient uses that same code to open it. You send the encryption separate from the other thing. So sender and receiver have the same code. There's also asymmetric, which is there's two different codes. I have one code to lock it, they have one code to unlock it that's a little higher level, so you can do that too. But when you're sending emails with sensitive information or files attached, encryption is a great way to protect those as well. Law firms really do really use this because it's cheap. It's part of usually Microsoft. You don't have to do anything, you just have to, you know, include it on there, send the password separate, do different things. But for regulatory and compliance requirements, HIPAA, GDPR, it should be required almost protecting our information, mitigating risk and different security events. We can use encryption to help with this. Five tips for evaluating your cybersecurity and software just go down the list. I'm not going to read them all to you because we're winding down here on our time. But prioritize compliance, evaluate your data, security features, access vendor experience, check the scalability, understand and support an instant response. Get those plans and policies in place. That is going to be key.
55:09That is something you're going to want to do in those areas. And with that, I hope everyone has a wonderful day. Thank you.