0:02Hi, everybody. This is Mike Debliss. This presentation is titled beyond a shadow of a harnessing the power of psychology in the courtroom to win your client's case. The first question that I usually get when I present on this topic is, why? How, you know, did you come up with a topic like this? And so I'll just give you a brief background. I got my start in the public defender's office and began trying cases very early in my career. I quickly realized that the tools that I learned in law school, namely the knowledge of evidence and the rules of criminal procedure, as well as all of the reasoning skills that we picked up along the way, while they were enormously crucial in trying a case, there were also what I might label or what others might label, soft skills that were not emphasized so much that I felt was lacking. And those soft skills are what really create a connection between the attorney and the jury.
1:27So I embarked on a self journey of sorts, and I began taking whatever classes I could in the area of litigation to help enhance my trial skills and my ability to connect with a jury and essentially, my ability to be more human.
1:53So much of our humanity, it seems like, was lost in those three years of law school, because everything, the way the legal curriculum is structured is that we are very goal oriented. We are looking for the issue. We're looking for the facts. We're looking for the analysis, the rule, and everything else kind of gets thrown out the window. It's kind of like the baby with the bath water. But these same skills that, you know, that aren't, you know, these same, you know, things that we may not consider to be relevant when we are studying the law are ever so relevant when we get into a courtroom. And when we are, we are trying to persuade a jury. And so a lot of my presentations have focused exclusively on delivery.
2:51We've talked a lot about storytelling, and, you know, this presentation, to give you an overview, is going to begin with looking a little bit deeper at a criminal defendant. A criminal defendant. You know, a client. So I should back up and tell you that my background is as a criminal defense attorney. I did branch out to doing white collar criminal defense after leaving the public defender's office, thanks in part to having earned a master's in tax law. I do handle a great deal of civil tax matters as well, such as audits and things of that nature. But for the most part, my Balliwick is in the area of criminal defense.
3:44And in the last 15 years that I've been practicing criminal law, I've really developed an interest in my clients well beyond just the attorney client relationship. I really like to get to know my clients on a personal level so that I can tell their story in a way that is going to fit the narrative and be consistent with innocence, as well as really understand them as a person, not just a defendant in a criminal case. And I found that by digging deep like that, I'm able to uncover theories and themes that I didn't even know were there. And again, it's really just about listening. It's about.
4:38About asking some questions that even might surprise your client, because they're not expecting their attorney to ask questions like that. But again, not personal, but in an effort to get more information about them, to make their stories come alive, and to paint them as a human being with the same hopes, dreams, desires as every other human being. And this dovetails into the first part of the presentation so many ways. I believe that there is an equivalency that is made between a criminal defendant in a criminal trial and that of a villain. And that is what has inspired the first part of this presentation. So, without further ado, I want to jump right in here.
5:38This presentation I've dedicated to my dad. He was the best father, law partner, and role model a son could have. He fought a long, hard battle with cancer a couple of years ago and, sadly, is no longer with us. But I've got his heart beating in my chest, as I'm constantly reminded every day. Bye. By some dear family members. And I really try to live out the work that he did. He was an attorney like me, and he fought zealously for his clients, whether they be criminal defendants or civil clients. He fought like no other lawyer I know, and I'm just so lucky to have had a father like him and a role model early in my career. I'm a criminal defense attorney, so this presentation is heavily skewed towards defending those accused of committing serious crimes. We are all they've got.
6:42At the same time, just because, you know, I'm a criminal defense attorney, and, you know, it's skewed towards a criminal defendant. So many things that I'm going to talk about in this presentation cross over to the civil arena as well. So if you are representing a plaintiff in a personal injury action, I think that you will see parallels as well. I come from the perspective that the more you know about human nature and human expression, the better an advocate you will be for your client. After all, the work we do is centered around helping people who have been wronged in some way or who have been charged with committing a criminal offense and face the loss of their liberty.
7:28An uncanny similarity between the job of an actor and the job of a trial attorney. Just like an actor gathers background information about the character they're portraying in order to bring him or her to life on stage, an attorney also must gather background information about the client they are representing in order to reveal the human element to the jury and to help them understand why the only just verdict is one in your favorite don't be afraid to tell the jury what you want them to do. In my view, it's not pandering. I will state explicitly what verdict I want them to return in my closing argument.
8:07The imagination. The imagination is so.
8:13It's so underplayed, but it undergirds everything. We learn to be human through the imagination. It's the imagination that distinguishes us from every other species. Sure, a beaver can build a dam, but can a beaver build a skyscraper, write a novel, sing a ballad, or launch a rocket into outer space? Of course not. As humans, we have an enormous capacity to imagine what if. And this allows for empathy,
8:43performance, or taking a pass. When I hear the word performance, I don't know about you, but I cringe, because I feel as though I now have everybody's eyes on me. So they've gone from looking in other places to everybody, all eyes on me, and I freeze a lot. And that was my response early on in my career, when I got very nervous in front of a jury. I oftentimes would freeze like a deer in headlights. So the word performance for me immediately induces fear and creates tension. My mind begins racing with thoughts of, I've got to be good. What will other people think of me? Am I going to fall flat on my face? Will I freeze up and forget what I was going to say? You can replace this toxic self talk with. With stating, with saying to yourself, I'm right where I am. I'll admit it.
9:47I'll work from where I am, even if it's nerves instead of where I wish I was. After all, nerves are just energy and nerves. And so energy can turn from being anxious to being splendid and to being magnificent. It's also another way of looking at this. I've had instructors tell me, which I found to be very helpful, is that the reason why you're nervous is because you care, you take pride in what you do, and you want to be the advocate that your client needs. In their darkest hour, you want to get them a just result. It shows your humanity. It reveals your empathy for the cause. And for the client and for your reputation. So this is all human stuff that we're talking about and looking at it from the perspective that everybody experiences this to some degree. And, of course, we don't want the fear to be paralyzing that we freeze like a deer in headlights, but we want to acknowledge it and make friends with it in a way. And at the same time, you know, at the same time, at the same time, calm ourself and soothe ourselves into knowing that nervousness is just energy that is going to flow through the body and will, you know, will change and transform to something else. So it's just a temporary state that we find ourselves in. Instead of looking at what you do in a courtroom as having to hit a bullseye because the stakes are very high, how about changing your mindset to let me just take a pass at this? And if that, you know, is a little bit too, you know, too low stakes for you or, you know, too informal
11:54for a courtroom, then maybe when you're rehearsing, you want to change your perspective on things and say, let me just take a pass at this. Geez, I've never made an argument like this one before. Let me just hear how it would sound in the privacy of my own home. As my instructor so elegantly stated, this is where all of the Easter eggs or golden nuggets lie. When you're in a low stakes situation and you're just spitfiring, if you will, and trying out new things, sometimes that can be when you find the best fodder and the best, and you can find the golden nuggets. In other words, it's born. Some of the best arguments and some of the most persuasive arguments are born in just, you know, in just, you know, low stakes, you know, informally and casually, you know, brainstorming ideas and talking them out loud so that you can hear how they vibrate in the.
13:04In the air. In other words, just see what's there before you have an obligation to make a wedding cake out of it. In fact, going back to Shakespeare's day, they had these wordplay gyms, just like we go to the gym to work out today. Well, back in Shakespeare's era, they went to a different kind of gym. And in the gym that they went to, they would actually, you know, they rhyme. They would rhyme, they would speak. They would create, you know, narratives that they would put into verse, which is the structure that Shakespeare's plays are written in, or iambic pentameter. And this was how they became so masterful in stringing words together and thoughts together, because that era honed the craft of the spoken word.
14:02Fear. Fear looms large in the courtroom. And again, it's because the stakes could not be higher. You're representing a client if it's a criminal defendant that could spend the rest of their life in jail if they're found guilty of the offense. Similarly, you might be representing a personal injury plaintiff in a serious accident where they've been maimed or disabled or where they've been disfigured, and the rest of their life will never be the same again. The stakes could not be any higher. So no wonder why we carry the weight of the world on our shoulders. And no wonder why we put so much pressure on ourselves to be perfect. That is another theme that comes up so frequently, even with artists. This idea or this goal of being perfect takes all of the fun out of the art.
15:11And I would dare say that this idea of being perfect can be very debilitating to lawyers as well. The reason why, and I'll speak from personal experience, is that perfection creates tension in the body. And when there's tension in the body, the body's unable to freely express itself the way it wants to. So, for example, when you are amongst friends in a very relaxed environment, you're watching the game, you're at dinner, you're unguarded in many ways, and you're in conversation with those that you know and that accept you and that you feel comfortable around, and you are your most beautiful self in that environment. Take a person out of that environment and put them in on a stage in front of 500 spectators, or take that person out of that environment and put them in a courtroom, which is a roman coliseum of sorts, where they are charged with defending somebody who's been accused of committing a serious crime. Then that all changes. We instantly get tense. And once we get tense, that tension murders the vibrations that our body is used to from being loose and free.
16:46It also stifles creativity. So if you find that thoughts that come to you easily when you're preparing a case aren't there as readily to access when you're on your feet in a courtroom, you're no different than anybody else. There's an element, there's a performative element where, you know, you've got eyes watching on you. You know that you are in a very tense environment, one that I would. That I would describe as, you know, fierce in many ways. You don't know from second to from moment to moment whether your adversary is going to jump up and object to something, and then everything will cease. And you'll have to answer that objection. You are, in your mind, doubting your own self, because we all do that, wondering, oh, my gosh, these eyes of the jury, they're on me, and I feel like they're undressing me. What are they thinking?
17:53Do they dislike me because I'm representing a genghis Khan, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. So there's just so many moving parts. And what we need to try to do is not try to conquer everything all at once, because it's impossible. Even for the seasoned attorney like the Jerry Spence. The Jerry Spencers that have been doing this for time immemorial, they are still. They're not impervious to judgment. They're not impervious to this self talk that goes on. But if we can, in a way, try to silence some of that and not view the jury as perhaps intimidating figures, but actually view them as people like ourselves that don't want to see us fail, but that are rooting for us. They may not be our best friends, but looking at them from the perspective that they are more than just complete strangers, they are now my jury. I've heard a lot of lawyers use that pronoun my in front of jury. And I can tell you that that does wonders when you look at the jury from that perspective.
19:13I turn to Shakespeare for inspiration, especially when it comes to this idea of fear and the stakes being so high in representing a client charged with a heinous offense. Shakespeare walked down the street and tried not to lie about what he saw. He dealt with the theme of fear over and over again in his plays, none more poignant than in Macbeth. And this is going into this idea that as trial attorneys, we have to be warriors. And that there is no room for fear and no room to even acknowledge that we are experiencing fear. When fear is a basic human emotion that every human being experiences. And this is why I am specifically relying upon or bringing to light Macbeth.
20:11Because Macbeth, even if you haven't really studied the play, you might have heard some things about it. Macbeth was a warrior himself. And what's so interesting is that he shows fear. He shows fear when he is beginning to waver on whether or not to kill King Duncan. As you might recall, the three witches give him the prophecy. When at the opening of the play that he is going to be named a general based on the victory that he led his troops to and that he will soon be king. Well, Macbeth's mind immediately turns to regicide, which is the killing of king. And he and Lady Macbeth begin to conspire. But at one point in the play, he wavers. And what's so interesting here is that when he begins to waver about killing King Duncan, Lady M began to consider whether or not to stay in this relationship. She was trying to determine what the cause of her husband's hesitation was.
21:23In so many words. She was saying, if you mean that you can't commit the act out of moral consequences, I can't stay in this relationship. But if you're afraid, I can deal with that. I'm a powerful woman, and I can work with your fears. I'm afraid is hard for any man to admit, much less a ruthless warrior like Macbeth. It's such a human thing that we all deal with. And Macbeth is no exception. Lady M asks Macbeth, Beth, are you afraid? And like a shrink, she begins to work on his fear. Reflections on opening statements and closing arguments. So I am moving around a lot here, and there's just so much that I really want to share with you. But we are going to get into the substance here. During opening and closing, your access to the jury is immediate and complete.
22:15Engage the jury. You must be in conversation with them. The best closing arguments are those where there is a seduction of logic that invites the jury to listen and not to judge. They should be hanging on your every word. And remember, when you have nothing, you still have your sense of humor. Sir Anthony Hopkins is someone who I absolutely love. I have watched all of his movies, and I've actually been trained in many of the specific technique that he was trained in when he was in England, training as an actor. So he has been very influential to me in my life. And a lot of the stuff that he talks about outside of acting I find to be incredibly relevant to this job that I am called to do every day when I walk into the courtroom and I have a client to defend. So I got this excerpt that I want to share with you, and it's very short, but I would like to play it for you.
23:30Have any regrets? No, don't have to regret. We move on because we are acceptable for what we are, not what we think we should be. I am accepted in myself by what I am, but not as I think I should be, because that's a lie. I'm a sinner. I'm an old sinner. I've done some bad things. I've done some good things. So, you know, you just forgive yourself and move on. To add on later in that interview, he said something just as profound. He said that he carries a picture of himself from when he was eight years old in his wallet. And from time to time, he'll open up the wallet, take out the picture and look at it, and he'll smirk a little bit or smile at the picture and say, hey, kid, we didn't do bad.
24:25Or something to that effect. And so, you know, I think that that's. I think that that's really beautiful. Have any. There's a profound quote from Anthony Hopkins that I would like to share. My philosophy is what people say about me is none of my business. I am who I am and do what I do. I expect nothing and accept everything. And what. And that makes life easier. We live in a world where funerals are more important than the deceased. Marriage is more important than love. Looks are more important than the soul. We live in a packaging culture that despises content.
25:04My further inspiration for this program was none other than the one person show performed by Patrick Page and called all the Devils are here. It played at the Dr. Two theater, I believe, in New York up until a few weeks ago. And essentially, Patrick Page is an american actor who is probably the best american actor we have today living that has portrayed Shakespeare's characters. He's been doing so ever since the time he was a tyke. And in this one person play, he took on all of the villains, or I would say most of the villains, not all of them. And essentially what he did was take an excerpt from each of the plays with these villains and play the role of that villain for a couple of minutes.
26:03And he also made it very educational in the sense that he began to trace the evolution of Shakespeare's writing of the villain from his very first villain to his very last villain. And as you see the evolution unfold, you begin to see how Shakespeare learns so much about human nature and writing these villains, and how he initially starts with perhaps a one dimensional person and then creates a multidimensional person that is so real and so true to how we might label a villain in modern culture today. And I think that that's the beauty of this, because the thing that I hearken back to is this idea, this label that a criminal defendant carries.
27:11From the moment a jury lays eyes on them in a courtroom,
27:18there is a label of that of a villain, and obviously nobody utters that word or that label. However, at the beginning of the case, the jury is read the bare bones indictment, which consists of the allegations as highlighted in the indictment. And there could be nothing more prejudicial in my mind, than for a jury to hear about the alleged offense that was committed by this person who was sitting next to me at counsel table.
28:03For that reason, you know, it's so important to humanize the client from the very beginning, because instantly the jury is, you know, through the reading of the bare bones indictment, instantly, the jury is getting a picture of this person as being Genghis Khan. And so that's why I'm approaching. I'm integrating this theme of villains and citing this beautiful one person play. So this is just one person, one man show. These are some of the reviews, which were magnificent. And if I can play this for you, I think I will come. Vic Knight, Paul the dungeon, smoke of hell. Some people have no conscience whatsoever.
29:05My words fly up. My thoughts remain below. And from this torment, I will free myself or hew my way out with a bloody axe.
29:28Come. And this is, in his own words. He makes some very good points here. So I might fast forward this a little bit. We're not going to watch a whole clip, but I want you to get a sense of where he was coming from here. And I'm going to, I promise you, show you the relevance, as I've been doing up until now, between this idea or this theme of a villain and that of a defendant. And once we acknowledge this inconvenient truth that, you know, a jury in so many ways is being led towards the conclusion before we've even had the opportunity to address the jury in opening that the client or that the defendant is a villain, we can then we then have deeper insight on how we are going to. How we are going to approach the defense of this person.
30:33I heart radio Broadway driven by Mercedes Benz all the devils are here is a one man show. Well, it's called a one man show, but really it's a 101 person show, because I play the Darrell Roth Theater, which has 100 seats, and Shakespeare's soliloquies are interactions with the audience. So I use the audience as my acting partner, and every night is different. So it is an exploration of how Shakespeare developed the character of the villainous. The character we call the villain of a play didn't exist when Shakespeare started writing. In fact, the word villain actually didn't mean back then what it means today.
31:18Shakespeare created the villain, and he starts with this tradition that he's handed by these old medieval morality plays of this character called the vice, who wasn't even a person. He was kind of a personified sin. And slowly, over time, Shakespeare keeps making these characters more and more and more human over a period of 20 years. And it's his investigation of why we do terrible things to one another. So he starts off with these great characters like Richard III. He has this breakthrough with the character of Shylock in Merchant of Venice and Falstaff in Henry IV. He has hilarious characters like Malvolio in 12th night. And then later on, he realizes that people who do bad things also have a conscience. Many times with Claudius and Hamlet, sometimes have no conscience at all. That's the psychopath, which is Iago. And then he goes very deep and dark, of course, with Macbeth, which is the darkest play, I think, ever written by anyone. I started with this show because I was. I had this sort of idea in my mind that it might be something fun to explore.
32:32And it was there for a long time, and it sort of sat in my mind until I came up with the idea, why don't I do it chronologically from the beginning of Shakespeare's career to the end? So the audience has the thrill of the development of these characters, how they grew and became more and more and more human, from those one dimensional comic vices at the beginning of his career to these fully three dimensional human beings at the end of his career. Not only that, but you get to see how his writing becomes more and more conversational and rich and idiosyncratic. So that was the initial idea. I then called a friend out in Utah, at the Utah Shakespeare festival, and said, can I come and do it for you? I wanted to do it for high school students, because high school students will give you a real reaction. They were having a conference of all these high school students. So I did it for a thousand high school students, because they will tell you, through their boredom, through their rustling, through their laughter, what's good and what isn't.
33:32So I thought, okay, good. It plays for high school students. Now, who do I need? So the next stop was Prague, because there was a Shakespeare conference of all these people who ran Shakespeare festivals and Shakespeare. All right, we can stop it there. I heart radio your client, the villain. As difficult as this might be to accept, the first impression that a jury makes of a client charged with a criminal offense is that of a villain. This is because the first thing that they hear about the case is what's contained in the indictment, and that would sully anyone's reputation. After trying some serious cases, I got to thinking a lot about this label.
34:11It impacts me not just as a criminal defense attorney, but also as an actor. As an actor, I've played my share of shakespearean villains. I've always been fascinated by antisocial behavior, behavior where people cause harm to one another, to wit, what villains do. Some of the questions that arose in my exploration of villains was why do we harm one another? Why do we love one another when it can be torturous?
34:40With everything going on in the world today, there can be no better time to address this question head on. According to Patrick Page, people do bad things when they feel like they are justified in doing them. The quote hurt people, hurt people could not be more true. Shakespeare wrestled with the idea of what we should do to break this vicious cycle of I've been injured, now I want to injure back. What I love about Shakespeare is that he refuses to write people off. When others get judgmental. He instead gets curious. He wonders very deeply, why might that person behave that way? Under what circumstances might he behave in that way? He seeks to understand, and that brings you one step closer to empathizing with the person.
35:36Villains are complicated. As ashamed as I am to admit this, when I first tackled villains, I painted them with a broad stroke, like the vice, as Patrick alluded to. By broad stroke I mean a scheming, plotting, conniving, machiavellian types, not unlike the Sesame street character Count von Count, complete with this iconic ahahahaha staccato laugh. And you can already tell it. So put on and you can tell I am playing a caricature, and a very poor caricature at that. There's a common thread among villains. I've learned over the years that a villain is anything but, that they're far from being one dimensional and static. Indeed, villains are dynamic human beings with backstories just like everyone else, according to Shakespeare. A common thread that seems to connect all villains, from those with a conscience to those without a conscience, that is, psychopaths, is that they view life as a game and they are playing it to win.
36:43It's only when we dig into these backstories that we discover the hidden story that explains why this person behaves the way they do today. Villains are broken at their very core. In playing them, I've learned to connect with this brokenness, both their physical and psychological brokenness. In playing these characters, the actor must engage as deeply as he can with those same questions that Shakespeare wrestled with, or he won't be able to lift them out of the text. In all the instances where I've played bad people who have done bad things, I've had to find that in myself, its empathy on a level unlike any other.
37:27When asked how do you prepare yourself to play a villain? Patrick Page answered, if you can't love the character, you can't play him. Geoffrey Dahmer was one of the most infamous serial killers of all time. In one of the most exquisite displays of paternal love, Jeffrey's father loved his son to the very end.
37:51When I tackled the role of Richard III, I knew that if I was going to portray as realistic a Richard III as I possibly could, as opposed to a caricature, I'd have to find a Richard III in myself. My way in was that I knew that there was a part of me that was ambitious, like Richard himself, obviously, I went to law school, and I was very motivated and very driven when it came to academics. Similarly, there was a part of me that might not have been as easy for me to acknowledge as the ambitious part of me, and that was a self righteousness. Like Brutus in Julius Caesar, I have all of these things burning inside me like a raging inferno, based on the simple fact that I am human.
38:49It's developing or acknowledging that they are there and that they come out, and that those might very well be the shadows part of me, the side of me that I don't like to put on public display for fear of what others might think. Empathy for your client. Unless I could look at these shadows, I believe that I was in great danger of projecting them onto other people, perhaps unknowingly, and behaving in ways that I would be ashamed of. There is something about being able to be the advocate for that man, being able to stand in his shoes, being able to look through his eyes. That always appeals to me, not just when I take on a character of that, like that of a villain, but also when I'm defending a client charged with a heinous offense.
39:46And although the audience would see a man who did terrible things, as you know, when I'm portraying the character, they might also see why that man did terrible things, not to excuse those terrible things. And again, this is me in a role of an actor, not me in the role of a criminal defense attorney. Now, because obviously, I want the jury to excuse those terrible things. I want the audience to understand why he behaved that way and feel a little bit of empathy along the way. Humanizing the villainous, humanizing the villain only heightens the tragedy or the drama. Looking at the nuances of a person's life, looking at the causes of what we might call evil, is important because we're living in a time when intolerance, impatience, and hostility have replaced tolerance, kindness, and civility.
40:46Lucky for us, popular culture has a love affair with the antihero. I think this has a lot to do with popular culture's love affair with the antihero, who reigned supreme in modern day television. The person who does things that are morally wrong, but who we nevertheless root for. Who might this be? Look no further than Tony Soprano, Walter White in Breaking Bad, and Marty bird in Ozark. Sheer irony. It's ironic how, on the one hand, there is this character on television who helps us to understand how otherwise good people might do bad things. And then on the other hand, in our public life, we copy it to a t when we go off or, you know, classify people as being good or bad based on nothing more than their political beliefs or what part of the world they come from, we all do this.
41:43The good news again, for us is that it's not enough for a villain to simply be bad in the eyes of the audience. When we see a villain nowadays, even in Marvel comics, especially in Marvel comics, look no further than the Joker. The fan base expects them to be complicated. Look no further than Joaquin Phoenix's portrayal of Joker. We, as the audience, expected or expect him to have a motivation. We expect him to have a backstory. That's what the whole movie is about. And we are witnessing the man transform, in a sense, to joker from the human being and from the everyday fellow that he once was. And isn't that magnificent, that transformation, to say that that's something that popular culture isn't interested in? I would argue to the contrary, as that was one of the highest grossing Marvel Comics films of all time.
42:50And there's a sequel coming out as well. So that speaks to how audiences crave knowing the backstory and knowing what transformed this innocent child into the person they are today. And we need to. We need to exploit that, that interest and that desire on the part of a jury to know more. They're not going to be satisfied by just hearing the bare bone allegations of the offense and what your defense to it is. They want to know more. They're curious. They have an insatiable desire for it, and so let's meet them on their turf. That gives us hope when we are defending a person accused of committing a heinous offense. I love this quote by Patrick Page. I think I am a little terrified of people who identify too much with the hero because to me, it indicates a kind of shunning of their darker side, which we all inevitably have. And it is only in exploring that darker side of ourselves that we can find any light. We have to know the monster within us very thoroughly, and then we can go out and we can do good things. But if we think that monster doesn't exist inside us, I think we're in deep trouble.
44:15I'd agree. Self awareness, the magic sauce. In order to be the advocate that our client so desperately needs his time of crisis, we as lawyers, must know ourselves on a deep and intimate level. What comes from that level of awareness is a compassionate, empathetic, and caring lawyer who puts his client first and who fights relentlessly for justice in the courtroom. He or she is not afraid to show their own humanity and to reveal their own vulnerability. When making passionate pleas to the jury on behalf of their client, they are client centered. This is the hallmark of a great lawyer, Jerry Spence.
45:01Through a deep sense of self awareness, we will be better equipped to do something that Jerry Spence called crawl inside the hide of the client. He uses this phrase as a metaphor for tapping into another person's experience in order to see things the way he saw them and feel them as he felt them. Another way of saying this is walk a mile in his shoes. To me, this means putting ourselves in our clients shoes and entering the matrix, the very strange and unfamiliar world that our client inhabits. Once we slip into our client's shoes or into their skin, we can see, hear and feel the world from their point of view. So, in other words, instead of looking at them from on top of, from inside an ivory tower and judging what we see, we can do, we can be more. We can be more intimate in the sense that we share the emotion of the client.
46:06Bye. By getting into his or her shoes. Doing so fosters a deeper understanding of what formed this once bright eyed and bushy tailed child into the man he is today and why he now stands before a criminal judge dressed in an orange jumpsuit and restrained in shackles. Understanding who your client is and his history is the master key for unlocking your client's door. Where has he come from? What has he done? What has he endured? Now, there's going to be some logical things that come into play here. The first question being, how do we get things about prior good things, if you will, about our client into evidence?
46:56And I will say that that's not a topic for this presentation. I do talk about these evidential issues in the evidence program, which is actually we're doing at the same time, and it's overlapping this program as well. So I'm not going to take the time to get into what rules of evidence can be relied upon to bring in good acts, if you will, of your client. Suffice to say, there's a price or cost to doing so in the sense that if your client has skeletons in his closet, they can then be presented by your adversary, the prosecutor, on rebuttal. But there are always ways to merge the good things of your client with the defense, and it does require thinking outside of the box. But we're going to focus right now on talking about the client and really knowing where they come from so that we can tell their story in a compelling way. And I believe that in order to do so, though, we also have to get in touch with those sides of ourselves that we might not be so proud of in an effort to tell our client story in a meaningful way that is at the same time compassionate and at the same time causes the jury to lean in a little bit more and keeps them on the edge of their seats. Slowly, we begin to care.
48:37And as we do, we acquire the power to cause others to care. As challenging as this might be, it's not the hardest part. The hardest part, in my view, is shouting out to the world, the jury, from this dark and frightening place of where your client's shadows lie, what you see, a disclaimer is in order. The hide of a defendant in a criminal case is not a warm and cozy chalet located on the foot of the Swiss Alps. As Jerry Spence so eloquently says, there is wretchedness there, not to mention pain and sorrow. There are always the scars of injustice and the evil mangling of the mind of the once innocent.
49:23A great. I love this as a metaphor for what you might find when you go deeper and to understand where your client has come and what he's endured. When I think of shouting out to a jury the wretchedness I see in the dark underbelly of my client, the first image that comes to mind is the mangled body of Hayden Christensen's character, Anakin Skywalker, being engulfed by lava and bursting into flames on the edge of an embankment on Mustafar. This disturbing scene teaches a valuable lesson. Hayden's heart wrenching cries and agonizing pain can be understood as his argument. By arguing out of his own sorrow, the audience was instantly able to relate to Anakin for the simple reason that we have all experienced sorrow before. It's universal.
50:18And this is what's so beautiful about, you know, understanding your client's story and what they've been through. Especially, you know, when we talk about the wretchedness that is in the dark underbelly. We, a jury, will be able to understand these things because they themselves have experienced them firsthand, or they have very close family or friends who have experienced these things. Now, of course, you know, a jury will not have experienced what it's like to be a criminal defendant in a trial, but there are still common themes experienced by your client that might be their shadows that the jury will be able to relate to. They might not be able to acknowledge these things in themselves, and they probably won't. They'll be quick to say, oh, I. You know, I can understand that. That is something I see in Aunt Grace or Uncle Fred or, you know, my sister in law, my brother in law. We're not always so keen in acknowledging that they exist in us as well. It's kind of like when other people point out your flaws, you're quick to deny it, and, you know, you might very well have a blind spot and truthfully, you know, be denying it. Yet, you know, the other person will chuckle because they can see it. It's so obvious that they can see it. But, you know, we are slow to the party and slow to acknowledge that shadow in ourselves.
52:04And again, the beauty of this is that we are. Is that these feelings, these shadows, are all universal. By the virtue of being human. We are not immune to these things. We can try to live as best a life as we can. We can try to live according to an ideal religion, if you are religiously oriented and try to be the best versions of ourselves as we possibly can, but we're human. And all of these vices, we are tempted in all of these ways. And so it's uncomfortable and awkward to acknowledge and to accept sometimes what other people might point out are flaws. But I feel that that gives you strength by knowing where your shortcomings are. And you are able, if you accept them and you are into self improvement, you know, you can work on them, and at the same time, you know, realize that they're there. And perhaps, you know, they could be useful to you in the.
53:21In your courtroom, you know, in your advocacy of your client. Who knows? It doesn't always a shadow doesn't always mean it's a bad thing. You know, it's just. It's a part of being human. And we need to be very compassionate when we go to these places.
53:42In this, I find the inspiration to never allow a client that I am representing to be judged on the bare fact of committing the crime that he has killed or raped or maimed. The danger this poses is that a person who commits a heinous crime is hard to care about, and it's far too easy to judge and to criticize a person on the bare fact that he committed a crime. Why? Because it relieves the jury of the responsibility of understanding why. To me, there is never such thing as a set of bare facts that tell the whole story. As my grandfather once said, there are always three sides to a story. Yours, mine and the truth. The same applies in a trial.
54:29There's always another side to the state story. The other side is the world we don't see. A world that is personal, perhaps one that is as secret as a forbidden forest. The forbidden forest is the world that our clients inhabit. It is that part of the iceberg that remains hidden underneath the water, despite dwarfing the apex 100 times over. As lawyers, if we concern ourselves with nothing more than the bare facts, the trial becomes nothing more than a long guilty plea. But mitigating facts always lie beneath the surface. It takes time, though, to mind them. They are not readily transparent. It takes time and brainstorming and going back to the table and rereading the facts and seeing them in a new light or a new context. So the challenge, in many ways, is finding them. And that takes time and effort.
55:30For those willing to take this risk, there is no greater reward. By the time the jury begins their deliberations, they'll have no choice but to see your client as a son, a father, a brother, an uncle, a nephew, endowed with the same rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness as every other human being on this planet. Not to mention all the hopes, dreams, and ambitions that burn like a fire in the human soul. I realize that this all sounds idealistic, but this is ideally how we want a jury to view our client, despite how heinous the offense might be. A little tip, and this was given to me by an experienced criminal defense attorney, attorney who talked to me a lot about humanizing my client. And he often would say that if a jury, if the jury had a question, and they wrote that question on a piece of paper, as they normally would be instructed to do so, that the judge would read it, the question, if it started out with them referring to your client as the defendant, and not by the person's first name, by the defendant's first name, then that was never a good sign. But if they referred to your client by his first name, John, then that was always a good sign, at least in this attorney's experience, that the juror that you had done an admirable job in humanizing him, caring as schmolzy as this sounds, caring is at the core of every case. The first thing to ask yourself is, do I really care? We have to find the humanity in our client before we can ask the jurors to see it.
57:25If you don't care, then imagine the audacity of, you know, of trying to ask a jury to care. As Jerry Spence put it, it's like saying to the jury, I want you to do what I can't do myself. Apathy has no place in the courtroom. Caring is the first step in transforming the client from a defendant to a person. Jerry Spence asks the provocative question, how does one care for someone who has committed a heinous act? How can you care for someone who is accused of raping a little girl and killing her? How can you care for a serial killer? We've all been ambushed by this question at some point in our careers, by family and friends, if we do this work.
58:1215 years of being a defense attorney has helped me to reflect on this question. Too often, the person that is before the jury is the first victim. Of course, a crime has been committed, and there is a victim of that crime. But what about the first victim, the defendant, the person for whom you're defending? Was he the victim of a mother who didn't care or a father who abandoned him? Was he raped or abused as a child? A twist of fate, in Jerry Spence's words, could have changed his circumstances dramatically. For example, had he been raised by a loving and nurturing family, would he have dropped out of school, pledged his allegiance to a gang, and turned to a life of crime?
58:58Or would he have gone to college and become a successful businessman, a doctor, or a lawyer? Are we condemning this person for what he did or because of the cards that he has been dealt in life? Jerry Spence uses a metaphor around a dog, and I realize that this part can be very touchy. So I apologize, because I know we all love animals so dearly. I'm an animal lover myself, and this metaphor really struck a chord with me. You can take a little sweet, wiggly tailed spaniard pup and put the pup in a cage with bars and never pet the pup and never love the pup. This little pup who loves you dearly and wiggles its tail and wants to be petted and accepted, you can stick it with sticks and refuse to feed it when it is hungry. You can put it in with other vicious, vicious dogs. And then one day, you go to pet the dog, and you stick your finger in that cage, and the pup will bite you.
1:00:08That sweet, gentle, innocent puppy who wanted so much to be. To be cuddled by you and that licked you so much when you first got it, that sweet, gentle, innocent pup is now biting you. Well, Jerry asks the question, should we kill the pup? He's only entitled to one dog bite, and he is bitten twice. So it's a rhetorical question, of course, and it really teaches us that there's so much more to a person who comes to us accused of a crime. And it is incumbent upon us to understand more of their backstory, and that is going to help us to tell the client story in a way that is full of compassion and in a way that is going to dovetail into the defense. And I do.
1:01:11Later in the program, I do present you with some examples of how, knowing the client's backstory, I was able to create defenses that were successful at trial. And I can only believe that it resonated with the jury in the sense that the verdict came back not guilty. Keys for caring. Understand who your client is and know his history. Where has he come from? What has he done? What has he endured? What formed this little puppy into the person he is today? The journey. Let's begin the journey into ourselves and see what we learn.
1:01:58There is a beautiful book, and this is called the little book on the Human shadow. It's by Robert Bly. I haven't read it yet, but there were some excerpts that were highlighted by many instructors that I've worked with over the years. And I have to tell you, so much of what Robert Bly writes about is apropos to what we are called to do every day in a courtroom. And this is a direct quote. When we were one or two years old, we had what we might visualize as a 360 panoramic degree personality. Energy radiated out from all parts of our body and all parts of our psyche. A child running is a living globe of energy. We had a ball of energy, all right.
1:02:54I. But one day, we noticed that our parents didn't like certain parts of that ball. They said things like, can't you be still? Or it isn't nice to try and kill your brother. Behind us, we have an invisible bag that we carry. And the part of us our parents don't like, we to keep our parents love put inside the bag.
1:03:20We spend our life until we're 20 deciding what parts of ourselves to put inside the bag, and we spend the rest of our lives trying to get them out again.
1:03:33The story says then that when we put a part of ourselves in the bag, it regresses, it devolves toward barbarism. Suppose a young man seals a bag at 20 and then waits 15 or 20 years before he opens it again. What will he find? Sadly, the sexuality, the wildness, the impulsiveness, the anger, the freedom he put in have all regressed. They are not only primitive in mood, they are hostile to the person who opens the bag. The man who opens his bag at 45, or the woman who opens her bag rightly feels fear. She glances up, and what does she see? She sees the shadow of an ape passing along the alley wall. Anyone seeing that would be frightened. Every part of our personality that we do not love will become hostile to us.
1:04:31Carl Jung. Carl Jung was a swiss psychiatrist and psychoanalyst who founded analytical psychology. He was a prolific author and illustrator and correspondent.
1:04:45I'm going to introduce you to many quotes by Carl Jung in this presentation as we begin to delve now into shadow, this theme of shadow. And so this is a good place to start. A good Carl Jung quote to start with. A man who is unconscious of himself, acts in a blind, instinctive way, and is, in addition, fooled by all the illusions that arise when he sees everything that he is not conscious of in himself coming to meet him from outside as projections upon his neighbor. So this encapsulates everything, everything that you know, basically all of Carl Jung's findings. And essentially what this says is that those parts of you that you remain unconscious of, and they tend to be the qualities that you may not be proud of because, for example, those qualities that you are very proud of. For example, your ability to. To be persuasive, your ability to be convincing, your ability to be commanding in a courtroom, your ability to win cases that nobody thought you would win. Those things we are very conscious of, and to different degrees, to varying degrees, of course, there are people with low self esteem that have accomplished incredible things in their life, but aren't aware of those things and still might consider themselves to be unsuccessful.
1:06:35But for the most part, for healthy people, we tend to be very aware of the things that we do well and that, you know, and we've perhaps been told that. And those are things that we stored within us. Or perhaps we have developed a self awareness upon around the things that we do well. And they are immediately accessible to us. And we are aware that we are good at those things. The things that we may not be too proud of oftentimes get relegated to the subconscious, and they are not conscious in us because, of course, we are very selective in choosing what things, you know, we want to bring to the surface, and we want to be conscious of. But what Carl Jung is saying is that if we don't meet face to face, those parts of ourselves that we may be ashamed of or those parts of ourselves that we are extremely self conscious of, we are going to run the risk of projecting those things onto other people as judgments and criticisms of them. So, for example, I've been in this. I've been in this training for a while now, and the mirror has certainly been held up to me on many an occasion. And I've learned through this journey, and again, there's always compassion as we.
1:08:18As we, you know, begin this journey. But I've learned that there was a part of me that was very judgmental of other people that was. That were frugal and that were, you know, were. Were not generous. My acting instructor told me that that was something that I should investigate because it could be a potential shadow in the sense that I was essentially casting onto other people something that existed inside me that I didn't want to confront head on. And I have to admit, as I went, as I went deeper into this work, I had to come to the realization that there was a part of me that was very frugal and that was not as generous as I would have liked it to be. And so by not coming face to face with that, I was consistently projecting that onto other people and judging other people because, you know, in my opinion, I felt that they were not generous and that they were very tight with their money. I oftentimes had an expression, short arms and deep pockets. And so the sense of looking at that definitely caused me to internally make fast friends with that part of me that was frugal. And now it's something that I. Because I've been. I put some awareness on.
1:10:08I've, over time, tried to change. I've tried to become more generous. I've tried to become less tight with my money and giving more to charities. And I am so. I'm so delighted in a way, as difficult as this was to confront, you know, several years later now, I am so grateful for, you know, having this be brought to my attention, and I'm so proud of myself for, you know, for accepting it and for not fighting it and denying it, which is the first reaction that we oftentimes do when we hear of these parts of ourselves that we don't think we embody. So that's just one example. These are some more quotes from Carl Jung and the shadow self. One does not become enlightened by imagining figures of light, but by making the darkness conscious. The latter procedure, however, is disagreeable and therefore not popular. A key part of this transformation process is for an individual to confront their shadow, a term originated by Jung in relation to analytical psychology. The darkness, the greed, the envy, the aggression, the lust, all of that. And we say, not me, no, I can see that in him and her, but me? No, no, no, I don't possess any shadows. Jamie Mears, who is a brilliant, brilliant, classically trained actor, taught a workshop a while ago, and she brought this theme of shadow in because she felt that this was incredible fodder for getting into character work, especially since most of the characters that we, as actors, love to play are those that have a myriad of shadows.
1:12:12And so she recognized that one way into playing some of these characters is to become more conscious of what shadows lurk inside us so that we can bring them to the surface in playing the characters that possess these shadows. And for purposes of our exploration, I bring this to light because I think that, you know, our client, shadows are so readily apparent to us, you know, because, you know, naturally, we've been doing this for a while. And when you are. When you are responsible for defending a person charged with a heinous crime, the crime itself, you know, lends itself well to the shadows that are underlying it. And so right away, you know, that your client, you know, based on, you know, simple one on one initial meeting with them, you know that they are, you know that they are obsessive compulsive. You know that they are full of anxiety. You know that they are.
1:13:23You know that they might have greed, you know that they might be aggressive. You know that they might shoot from the hip. You know that they might judge you right away and begin to throw darts at you because you're not doing your job or you're not representing their interest to the best because you're not a paid lawyer. In my world, that comes up a lot. And so those shadows of others we can see are readily apparent, especially with someone in the criminal justice system who is incarcerated and fighting for their life to get out from under this or to strike the best deal possible to limit their time in jail. So Jamie talks about the nine primary demons that often are, you know, often labeled the shadows. The perfectionist, the insatiable to do list addict. What we must not forget control freak, for example. This archetype is moving against.
1:14:41It's all about passive aggression. I will be the first one to admit I am a perfectionist. It rears its ugly head. Even in presentations like this, I don't want to leave anything out. I am so, you know, focused on the minutiae of everything and that I sometimes lose sight of the forest from the trees. When I go to the supermarket, I always have a list. That list might not be written down, it might be a mental checklist. And as I'm going through the aisle, I'm checking off what items I've got, and same thing in the dead during the day. I'm task oriented. I like to be able to say I'm done reading this discovery and I've accomplished this. Now I'm going to move on to this task. If I haven't accomplished x, Y and z by a certain hour, I get very upset at myself.
1:15:34So a part of me is very goal and task oriented. And if work isn't being done in the time that I expect it to be done, you know, I kind of give myself a kick in the behind. Second, the attention seeker, the needy one. You can choose, for example, an overbearing and resentful mother, a jealous lover. Archetype. It's all about conditional love. Look how much I love you. But there is a big payment. This archetype is something about vanity driven by an insatiable desire for love, attention. Third, the strategizing mask wearer, the entrepreneur, the used car salesman that is trying to get you to buy a lemon. Anything to get to the top, to win, to make the sale. Fourth, the melancholic artist, the individualist, the ever suffering woe is me. You know, the world is against me.
1:16:35I'm a victim. That would be number four. Number five, the arrogant, know it all, the scientist.
1:16:44Six, the paranoid or hypochondriac, the complete pessimist, imagining the worst, seeing shadows in the dark, being negative, the voice of doom. Seven, the innocent, naive child. This time it will be different. I can't wait. Let's have fun. The glutton. It's going to be so good. When I can't wait until eight. The tyrant. Vengeance is mine. Kill. Revenge. They've got it coming. You could go from perfectionist to raging tyrant in seconds. Nine, the indifferent, detached, the apathetic sleepwalker, chronic fence sitter. Everyone's right. I mean, I can see both sides to the point where you can't stand for anything because you are able to see both sides so well that you can't come down on one. It's really bad. But, you know, we're here, they're there, the list goes on.
1:17:42All humans have shadows. This list represents part of ourselves that drive us consciously and unconsciously, we will find that and that on certain days, or just in tight moments, one of these, or to take over. And so there's a raging inner life happening that drives all of our outer behavior.
1:18:04I deeply admire the person who says, I am a cranky old sinner, but I try to do my best. That quote actually comes directly from Anthony Hopkins that I played for you earlier. That shows a sense of awareness that he has about himself, the courage to acknowledge that he can be cranky at times, and at the same time, that he strives to do his best to me, that awareness and that admission makes me feel, brings me to a level of synchrony with Anthony Hopkins, that he would be courageous enough to acknowledge something as unbecoming as the fact that he's cranky and he's old and he's a sinner. But the fact that he says he tries to do his best, isn't that what we all try to do? We try to do our best.
1:19:09That acknowledgement makes me feel his humanity and makeshi me and makes me connect with him on a deeper and more intimate level than the person who might say. Who might say, I've got this whole thing solved. I've got it licked. Okay? And so what I'm really honing in on here is this idea that when we can be. When we can have the humility to acknowledge something as deep as this, and it doesn't have to be as deep as standing in front of a jury and saying, I'm cranky and I'm getting on in years, obviously, no. But if we can stand up in front of a jury and impassionately make the plea for our client, and perhaps even in a light moment, say, you know, I am trying to do my best and my worst, my worst,
1:20:27my worst fear in this trial is that I won't be able to present Johnny in the light that I want to present him, that shows humility, that shows courage, that really speaks to what is going on inside that attorney. And I will tell you, you will gain more jurors that will connect you and will connect to the humanity behind such a courageous and sweeping statement than you will with any legal argument that you can possibly weave together. In fact, going the opposite can be a big turn off. Now, that's not to say that we're not going to be in our left brains making the type of legal arguments that we need to make. Of course we're doing that. But there can also be softer moments where we expose the heart chakra a little bit more and again, it doesn't have to be something as intimate as acknowledging that I'm cranky and I'm a sinner. That has no relevance, and we wouldn't go there anyway.
1:21:52But something that speaks to what is really going on in this moment, the truth that that carries and the ring of truth that that carries is so powerful in a courtroom where the jury is expecting everything that comes out of your mouth to be eloquent and to be a pre pre written, you know, argument. But if you were to stand in front of the jury and announce to them that you're experiencing fear because you feel you might not be able to live up to the. To the expectation that you have for yourself as the attorney for your client and how, you know, you are so, you know, determined to, you know, to tell your client's story and to do the best you can, and you're worried about falling short. That's really what I'm about to say. That's really what I'm trying to say. Sherry Spence, of course, is able to speak to this topic so eloquently, but he himself acknowledges that the acknowledgement of fear in the courtroom has such power and is so underused in this day of, you know, wanting to appeal to the, you know, appeal to the masculine parts of ourselves, which, you know, and the powerful part of ourselves. But what if we were to reveal something that is really truthfully going through everybody in that moment? There's not a person in this, in this world who cannot say at some point or another in their argument before a jury that they're not experiencing some fear, but those that are brave enough to acknowledge it and to do it in a way that's sincere and that really speaks to what is underlying
1:24:00what's going through, what's coursing through their veins in that moment, that type of connection with a jury, that type of connection will, that will create the type of connection with the jury that will bring them closer and closer to your side. And so to get back to what, I went off on a tangent on this idea of a person who says, and I deeply admire the person who says, I'm a convicted felon who's been locked up in prison for a long time, but I won't let that stop me from my dream of finishing college, getting a stable job, and starting a family. I have to tell you, the client that utters words similar to those and acknowledges that they've done bad in the past, I have to tell you, I want to fight harder for them, and I would like to think that I fight just as hard for every client, but the ones that will come right out of the gate and make a sweeping admission, I feel, have such humility and courage and self insight that.
1:25:09That arouses sympathy and empathy on my part. And because you don't hear that often, and you usually hear, you know, the clients that are saying, get me out of here, it's all your fault, I didn't do this. But the ones that can have the deep insight to acknowledge that they've done wrong in the past, but how they're not going to let that stop them reach their dreams, and how they're relying upon you to do the best you can for them, boy, that makes me want to do everything humanly possible. And those, those, more often or not, are the cases that I really dig my heels in. And of course, you know, we do it for all of the clients, and sometimes grudgingly, when they're difficult. But, man, when you have a client who you care about so much because of this connection,
1:26:13you'll cross the seas for them. They're not saying, I've got it solved. When I meet someone who identifies themselves as virtuous, that's when I get most frightened. So hopefully you've gotten some tips out of this, or I've encouraged you to think in ways that you might not otherwise think. I've always thought of art and acting in particular, as teaching me to think in a way that is very independent and to make my own and to come up with my own ideas and to really look at many different sides to an issue. And so that's what I come with. I try to come with a blank slate and an open mind whenever I am defending a person. I try not to.
1:27:11To put on the client any biases that I might have or preconceived notions, if you will. I really try to come to it with a blank slate by treating each client as if they are unique and their case is unique. And it's not easy, especially when you've been doing this for a while and you have a number of clients. But this idea of thinking in a free way and allowing yourself to think outside of the box will help you in brainstorming theories and themes to your case that, you know, that might help turn bad facts into good facts, or at least neutralize them, as well as helping, you know, come up with powerful themes and theories that will resonate with a jury. So we're just getting into this, and I've got tons more to share with you in part two. In parts two and three. And I really hope that you'll join me in the next few parts to this presentation.
1:28:14I wish you the very best and see you at part two. Take care.