1h 23min · about 12,200 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hi, everyone, this is Mike to Bliss. And we are in part two of Shakespeare for lawyers make your words dance. One thing that I wanted to mention at the top is something that doesn't really get spoken about a lot for lawyers, and that is that I really encourage lawyers to take voice classes. And I encourage it for a myriad of reasons. But the main, the main reason is because we use our voices as much if not more than actors, I'd even go so far as to say we use our voices as much as Broadway actors who are doing two shows a day, six days a week, for a total of 12 shows every week, we need to be ready at any time for, you know, a trial or for pre trial litigation. And as you all know, you know, a trial can go on for weeks upon weeks, and even if you're only sitting three days a week, you're up on your feet, you're arguing, you're cross examining witnesses, you're doing direct examinations. So you're speaking from, you know, as many as sometimes eight hours, maybe even nine hours a day. And we don't always know when our next trial is is going to be is is is going to be there. You know, we might, you know, at the beginning of the month think that we have a light month, and then lo and behold, we wind up on trial two weeks later. So I really encourage lawyers to consider taking voice classes. For the speaking voice. I'm not, I'm not referring to singing classes or anything of that nature. But class is geared towards towards the speaking voice for public, for people who do public presentations, and public speakers, and storytellers and I'm
2:05happy to provide you with a few voice centers that are doing their sessions online. And that you can just join for as little as $20 for an hour session, and that'll help keep your voice in shape so that it's ready for the demands of the courtroom. So we left off on mono syllabic lines. A monosyllabic phrase is, among other things, a verbal stage direction to the reader or the actor to slow down. This way, Shakespeare forces the reader to bring attention to the words which are intended to be read in an uneven deliberate tone. When it comes to speaking monosyllabic lines, a good practice is to slow down. Here are a few of my favorite monosyllabic phrases, from Hamlet to be or not to be from a fellow, oh, my souls joy from Julius Caesar, lend me your ears from Henry the Fifth, O for a muse of fire. Now, if characters, I want to talk a little bit about Shakespeare, and the construction of thoughts, and the reason why I think this is relevant, as you can tell, I'm I really attempt to make connections between Shakespeare and the courtroom. When I bring these themes up, and these topics up.
3:37Sometimes there is a direct relationship and other times it's indirect. But I really, really try to show the connections between Shakespeare in the courtroom. I like the approach that Shakespeare has taken to constructing thoughts for his characters. I basically think of thoughts as, you know, long ideas that we are that are that we're processing through our minds. And as I mentioned in yesterday's presentation, when a lawyer can stand up in front of the jury, and make the thoughts appear as if they are happening, you know, in that moment, and that they are literally coming off of the top of their head. It's, it's it's most it's mostly because they're so well prepared, and that they've been brainstorming these ideas, and they've been talking out loud. And so when an idea pours out of them, that sounds like gold. And it sounds as if it just, you know, came out of that moment. It's because they've rehearsed a lot. If characters are what they think and I would go so far as to say that people are what they think, then how they think is very important to get to know who they are. Shakespeare was clever about making the characters thoughts. Dynamic. Every character in Shakespeare is a dynamic thinker. And I would go so far as to say that every lawyer is a dynamic thinker. That's how we've been trained thoughts are very physical in Shakespeare's world. What I mean by that is that the thought is always the thing that moves the character. This is so in everyday life to, for example, when a person has an exciting thought he might leap for joy or
5:27high five a friend. We are all characterized by our thought process. Therefore, it's useful to examine a character's rhythm of thought, by finding ways to physicalize that thought process. Let's begin in the simplest place by asking the question, how do we construct our thoughts, Shakespeare relied heavily upon a recognizable thought pattern of lift, balance and parentheses to make a character's thought process. So dynamic look no further than the measured thought process of Hamlet. When you launch off on a thought, you have an agility to thinking and you have an idea of where you are going to end it. The thought starts and travels over several lines, the longer the thought, the more likely it is connected to feeling very simply, when we allow our thoughts to flow, emotion automatically attaches to them. Short thoughts, on the other hand, contain little feeling. For example, Hamlet has five thoughts to navigate through in the opening question to be or not to be. As a general rule, in life, when we're expressing ourselves, each new thought that we have is better than our previous thought. Shakespeare knew this all too well, every new thought that a character had was better than the previous one. Each thought got more specific, you'll never find a thought that gets more general, Shakespeare does this in every speech. And it makes sense. We don't want to watch Hamlet get more confused and the To be or not to be speech, we want him we want to see him get more clarity of thought and arrive at a conclusion. So while the
7:15beginning thoughts might be muddied and juxtapose now, as the thoughts unravel, they get more specific. And the more specific they become, the closer we get to a conclusion. Versus speaking in court. Recall that when we argue we speak in rhythm, therefore, it follows that we must have a concrete relationship to rhythm in order to inspire and persuade. And by the way, everybody has their own unique rhythm. I'm speaking to you right now in a rhythm that is very unique to myself. When I'm in the courtroom, arguing, I'm also speaking in a rhythm that's unique to myself, everybody. Everybody's unique rhythm of the spoken word is as unique as their fingerprint is. I'd argue that verse speaking is one of the most potent linguistic rhythms for oral argument in the courtroom. I think that there are opportunities for us to be just as creative with breaking verse as Shakespeare was in order to stress how important something is to a jury or to add further emphasis to a point during cross examination or closing argument. Here's a summary of the benefits derived by actors who work with iambic pentameter. That is just as relevant to us as lawyers. First, it's easier to learn lines that are written in iambic pentameter. And I think it's necessary just to back up for a second, I know that there are as many different schools of thought about, about writing out an opening statement and how it's delivered as there are lawyers who write them out and deliver them. I'm going to go out on a limb to say that, I find it I find it very helpful to have notes that
9:17you can refer to when you're doing your opening and your and your closing argument. I do not advocate that you write verbatim ly word for word, your opening statements and closing argument out. Because what that does is that acts as a crutch. And lo and behold, you'll find that you're reading the words verbatim ly off of the page instead of instead of speaking them from openly and transparently from the heart. And so I think it's very important that the notepad or your your notes doesn't form a wedge or put a wedge between you and the jury. You want to be able to speak to them openly and transparently. And, you know, and of course, it goes without question that you need to rely on notes to make sure that you've covered what you need to cover. But you don't want to lose, you don't want to verbatim Lee speak directly from the page, it makes it too impersonal. And the jury will instantly feel that, that there isn't a connection between them and you. And so, with iambic pentameter, it's actually easier to learn lines that are written in iambic pentameter. Because when the beat is off, and your ear is trained to that we're accustomed to hear the beat going to dum dum de dum de dum de dum. And if it goes off, then you know that you might have missed, you know, a syllable or you might have missed a word in, you know, in speaking the words that you had committed to memory.
11:11So, again, just to back up once more, I do advocate memorizing the opening and the closing argument. I am a big advocate, however, of having a checklist of your main main points, that is on counsel table that you can refer to at all times, but you never want the notepad to act as a crutch or to be a wedge between you and the jury. Second, because blank verse approximates more closely than any other verse form to our natural everyday speech, it makes a pattern on the page which is easier for the mind to absorb. Third, it's full of directorial hints. Fourth, because verses more economical than prose, it's likely to be more concise and particular and exact. Fifth, because verse has a rhythm and a flow, it's more attractive to the jury to listen to, and helps the lawyer to hold the jurors attention. Six is a subtle but important page that we can take out of Shakespeare's playbook. In American culture, the vast majority of people unconsciously allow their voices to trail down and dwindle at the end of a line. The harsh reality of this is that when all of the energy and vitality pours out at the end of a line, the voice droops and the audience falls asleep. And that might happen on perhaps one of the one of the biggest points that the lawyer wants to make. In Shakespeare's writing the end of a line is where the juicy is fruits lie hidden. As such Shakespearean actors are trained to sustain a line by pushing the intensity of thought right through to the end, tending almost to an upward inflection, if a natural one can be
13:03found. Now, don't think that you have to do this for every point that you make. In fact, if you were to do this, then it would probably be unnatural, and a little offsetting to the jury. But when you do make your when you do make main points, you don't want to trail off at the end of those points, because the jury will, you know, the, the intention that that or the the way the the jury will think of that as if it's not important if you're trailing off at the end of the line. But if you fail to finish with an upward inflection, then you're indicating to the jury that you've made an important point. But fear not this is one of the slowest and most challenging processes to learn for actors. So as lawyers is going to take some time to learn how to verse speak. I have witnessed firsthand lawyers with incredibly impactful endings to their thoughts and arguments, allow their voices to trail off or to swallow their words, as if they're uncertain of what they just said. The result is that the remark is lost on the jury. Finally, don't forget to take a breath, I realized that that sounds you know, pretty obvious. But it's very easy to get stuck in a in a cycle where you're holding your breath, or not taking in enough breath to sustain the thoughts that you're speaking. And when that happens. You'll normally feel tightness in your throat, and your voice will not project as as much as you'd like it to. And the jury may even have difficulty hearing you. So breath is everything breath is life. It's a very first thing that we do. When we come out
15:00of the womb, and it's necessary to sustain these thoughts that we and these arguments that we're making when we get up before a jury, taking a breath helps to stay present in your words and think them through, it helps to keep your presentation fresh, and alive and real. Just like Shakespearean actors, lawyers have to be quick on their feet and think with great alacrity. It is a thorough brain workout. After having spent so much time talking about verse, for those who wish to play with it, I'm asked how conscious one should be a bit went up on your feet before a jury. My advice is to be conscious of it during preparation, but to throw it away on game night. At the same time, totally ignoring it is not a good practice. Even if you choose not to follow it, you should at least be conscious of when some of your arguments follow iambic pentameter. And once you identify lines like that, in your argument, you might find creative ways of breaking the iambic pentameter, like Shakespeare did in order to emphasize to the jury how important what you just said is, so yeah, I'd say, walk a fine line, you don't want to, you know, be totally focused on iambic pentameter. But at the same time, you don't want to disregard it altogether. I like to always say, once you do your homework, you then throw it away. And you let your argument live in the moment. Varying up the length of your sentences, that's very important. And I often encourage lawyers to tend strongly towards short sentences, written sentences are normally longer clunkier and more complex
16:55and sentences delivered orally. Again, the most important pack or truth, truth that we have with the jury is that they understand us and that, you know, we lead them, we lead them down this path towards the acquittal of our client, if it's a criminal case or towards the defendant being liable in a civil case, we always need to make sure that we have the jury that the jury is following us, we never want to lose the jury. If we lose the jury, you know, for obvious reasons, that's not good because they, they'll be lost and not know, you know, what's going on. But secondly, if we lose a jury, they're less apt to, you know, they're less apt to view us as the, as the rock star that we want them that we want to be seen as they won't, they won't be able to trust us as the person that's going to help them separate the wheat from the chaff. So you always do have that pack you you have that truth that you owe the jury to, to be as open and transparent as you possibly can. And we talked about that in in terms of credibility, but also in terms of comprehensibility. And we do this by tending towards shorter sentences, and easing the legalese and trying more and more to be more specific than general, when we speak to the jury. Use powerful imagery, we may have to take the jury to the streets of an inner city like Newark or Camden, without ever leaving the courtroom in order to draw them into the reconstructed reality of a new and unfamiliar world. Why might we have to do this? Well, very simply, perhaps this is where our where the crime occurred. Or perhaps this is where
19:01our client grew up. And if this is the world that our client grew up in, then it's important that the jury know this, and know that, you know, his, the way he views the world is filtered through his youth and through the environment that he was raised in.
19:24The words we use can help the jury picture and the streets of New York action verbs paint vivid pictures in our minds, and avoid dull and empty abstractions. Paint vivid word pictures by visualizing the scene in your mind, and then describing it in exquisite detail so that the jury can see it in theirs. Again, this sounds very basic, but it works. You really have to have a specific image in your mind before you try to describe what you're seeing. But when you can do that You know, you're working on all cylinders when you can, you know, go in and out of your argument. And you know, at the same time paint the scene of perhaps the crime where it occurred, or perhaps where your client grew up with such exquisite detail that the jury can see it in their minds. And at the same time, you're walking a fine line that you don't give too much detail because as we discussed, in yesterday's presentation, we would risk doing what flow bear did and Madame Bovary. And that is going on for 20 pages to describe a living room. We don't want to describe, we don't want to over describe and get too flowery or ornate in our descriptions. But we also want to be specific enough that the jury, you know can see the the scene in their minds. There's great power that comes from being able to see an event in detail. The famous author Ray Bradbury recommends reading poetry, essays, novels and comic books, anything that will touch us viscerally. The more you read, the more you can draw from use of word pictures must be learned. Lawyers intuitively speak in
21:15abstract in general terms. This was not lost on Aristotle, who said, when a speaker describes an event so vividly in such detail that it seems as though the event is happening right in front of them. Stick with the action, avoid abstraction, active or passive words tell very different stories. For example, Johnny fired, the gun tells a radically different story, then the gun went off in John's hands, decide which which story you want to tell and then use the appropriate active or passive tense. And just so that we're also keeping in mind personal injury cases. And abstraction from a personal injury case where you're representing the plaintiff might be that my clients suffered a broken leg. Well, while that might be factually true, and that might, you know, condensed be a summary of what the client what the client suffered. We don't want to use that in our opening or closing we want to, it tells us nothing. We want the jury to know what it felt like for John to have a broken leg with a bone sticking through the flesh. How can we do that? Well, we do it with our words, and we go into specifics of the ordeal that client went through after breaking his leg. You want to tell the jury how excruciating the pain was, how John couldn't make it through the night without being heavily sedated. How He clenched his teeth so much that he grinded two teeth down to the gums.
22:59Tell them how John was confined to a bed for two weeks with a solid cast, extending up from the ankle, from his ankle to his genitals, how he couldn't walk for two weeks and how he had to use a bedpan to urinate and defecate, make the jury see it, make the jury feel it, make them understand, make them care. Now, I realized that this can be crass. And I realized that, you know, it's, you know, we're throwing manners out the window. But our our loyalty is to our client. And in a personal injury case, where, you know, the client has been seriously injured, and the medical bills are through the roof. You know, and there might be a defendant who is, you know, who is who's, you know, culpable for and responsible for the circumstances that led to the client's injury, we need to paint the picture in this level of detail in this amount of detail. Emphasis and impact devices, there must be emphasis to the extent that your points will dominate the conversation during deliberations cases are lost because the jury doesn't know how important something is and doesn't remember the point. Just to give you a little bit of background information, I like to start the brainstorming process by writing out the type of arguments that I would like to be able to make at closing, and then I start backwards.
24:31So once I know the type of arguments that I want to make at closing, in order to in order for my client in order for the jury to return a not guilty verdict or an order for the jury to return a verdict against the against the defendant in a personal injury action. I I need to know what arguments I want to make at the very end and then that way, I know what evidence I need due to, I need to, I need to introduce during the trial, and what inferences from that evidence need, I need the jury to make. And that really helps to hone in on what's important versus what is unimportant. And it helps to focus and channel my attention as the lawyer who is not just the actor, but also the director and the producer and the writer of this event. But again, emphasizing to the jury, how some how important something is, might seem like it's obvious, but a lot of times points, you know, fail to get emphasized. And as a result, the jury doesn't remember them.
25:51As lawyers, we're good at emphasizing the written word in our briefs through a variety of literary and stylistic devices like italics, boldface, font, and underlining. However, we sometimes struggle to do with the spoken word, what we do with the written word, we must emphasize important points orally, in the same way that we emphasize written words. The challenge always is how do we do orally what we do with the stroke of the pen, or keyboard. From day one of my acting training, I learned that an actor is like a composer, that what you read in the script is only the merest indication of what you have to do, when you really act the part. After all, anybody can read lines, emphasis may be gained in a number of ways, from outright telling the jury how important something is, to harnessing the power of your voice. After all, you are your voice and your voice is you, I do have a personal story to tell on you know, on on this issue of the voice. I, I had been told from the time I started acting training that you know, of this beautiful quote that, you know, you are your voice and your voice is you. And I never really, truly processed it until after I lost my father two years ago to a really strong battle with pancreatic cancer. And I remember, several months afterwards, you know, watching a video of him. And instantly when I heard his voice, I felt as if he was in the same room with me again. And I was instantly reminded in that moment of the quote that my acting instructor had given me some years back that we are our voices. And
27:43it's, it's like when you're walking down the hallway in the courtroom, and somebody yells your name, instantly, you know who that person is. And when you look back, you see them waving at you or you know, walking towards you. And so, you know, we are our voice, that's the single biggest thing that identifies who we are, it's our voice is as unique as our fingerprint, as our fingerprints are. But, you know, recognizing this, I think that there are so many possibilities for us to develop our voices and to use tone, voice, inflection, pace and silence as our tools. And again, I don't think that lawyers are situated any differently than actors are the lawyer. The demand on the voice of a lawyer is every bit as demanding as the demand on the voice of an actor who is doing two shows a day, six days a week. And so we have to keep our voices in tip top shape. And to the extent that we can take some voice classes that might bring in some yoga, and help, you know, engage the breath, and bring in, you know, some vocal techniques that will help the voice to stay strong. During a prolonged trial. I think that could be helpful to all of us. The starting point, of course, is to have a strong point of view when you're drafting your arguments, but that's only the tip of the iceberg. It's your point of view that makes you who you are. For example, I always ask the question, what do you love? What do you hate when I'm working with young attorneys? These things engender strong feelings. I could sit here and I could
29:38probably talk to you about the law of the Lord of the Rings for the next two hours. And it would feel like five minutes i That's one of my favorite movies. I can watch it six more times. Similarly, I could tell you how. Last month when I was prepping for it or two months ago when I was prepping for a trial. I indulged in Ben and Jerry's Heath Bar crunch. I'm at night, I'm much to my, much to my stomach's chagrin because I would oftentimes go to bed way too late, after having devoured a pint of Ben and Jerry's Heath Bar crunch, but it's my favorite ice cream and it makes me happy. And especially during times of stress, at the same time, I there's things I hate, while while I love my dog, I hate it when she barks in the middle of the night. We're all human. So we, you know, we don't just love things, we also hate things. Now, if you're anything like me, your voice might need some work. One thing that I've learned over the years about my voice, is that I tend to be slow and steady, taking my time to emphasize certain words and to be precise, methodical, and accurate. I reason and I use logic, this translated into a voice that was monotone and devoid of emotion, I was told that I can wring meaning out of words easier than poets could infuse feeling into theirs. But there's always a reason for this. And that's why it's always important to look at your habits through a prism of patience and compassion. Why would Why was my voice a little dull? Well, it was it evolved as a result of my need to be clear and precise when explaining things to my clients. I was a
31:29public defender for many years, and I would have as many as 10 to 15 cases on a day. And so I had to be economical in the use of my words. And I had to make sure that I was understood the first time so that I didn't have to keep repeating myself over and over again. However, this was a turn off to the jury. And the last thing I wanted was to put my jury to sleep, especially when there are important things that I wanted them to hear. It also prevented me from playing some of the characters that I had always dreamed of playing from the world of Shakespeare. So what did I do, I should, I shook things up, so that I wouldn't be boxed into one way of speaking and expressing myself. In drama school, we receive loads of training, there are some exercises that I'm going to introduce you to that will help you to expand your vocal range, the more expansive your vocal palate is, the more interesting and persuasive you'll be. And I would even go so far as to say, when we talked about the last seven minutes at the beginning of part one of this presentation, how to get the jury how to how to cast the jury in a spell, and to be able to have them, you know, literally hanging on every single word that you say, well, there's, there's a lot that goes into that. But one, very interesting, or one very important aspect is your voice. And this is this is the genesis of the whole presentation that as lawyers, it's our bodies, our voices, our manners are our gestures, our physical, you know, mannerisms. These are all things that are on show. And these are this is
33:22everything that we have when we're attempting to persuade them to our position. And in the same way. Back in Shakespeare's day, Shakespeare's actors had only their bodies, their voices and their mannerisms and their gestures to act out some of the greatest plays in human history. So this is why there's a striking comparison between lawyers of today and the Shakespeare actors of yesteryear. Step one in the process is to have a self awareness of what your habitual patterns and natural tendencies are. Before you can effectuate change, you need to know what you're already doing well, only then will you know what needs work. Of course, what comes easy to you should remain untouched. Instead focus on those areas that are underdeveloped and that need practice.
34:17For example, I learned that by quickening the tempo of my speech, resulted in more urgency in my delivery. And that urgency instantly raised the stakes and infused my arguments with more passion, which has always been there but had never been expressed in quite that way. Step two is reigniting your imagination. I can't emphasize enough the power of the imagination. It's limitless. No matter what occupation you're in from advertising to practicing law, your imagination is your strongest ally. It's your birthright as a human being. As Emily Dickinson once said, I dwell in possibility. What a beautiful way to capture the essence Imagination. How do we develop our imaginations? Well, you can do this through daydreaming, reading a good book, a poem or meditating. I, for me, I love daydreaming, it allows me to tap into subconscious images and bring them up into consciousness. Just as if I had awoken from a dream that was still fresh in my mind. This allows you to tap into that wealth of the mind without walls without boundaries, and to fertilize your creative work.
35:30For me, I like to go to the first image that pops into my head that catapults my imagination into far deeper and richer places than if I were to try and control the direction of it. The idea is to let images flood into your mind without censoring anything, like a trailer to a James Bond film. When I'm in the state, when I'm in a state of free flow, images of my childhood begin to emerge. But if you would prefer to read a book or a poem, take a few lines and read them out loud. The benefits of for forget about, you know, a book or a poem. But the benefits of reading out loud is that you exercise your voice, and you get your voice used to, you know, speaking for long periods of time, and you'll find that the voice will strengthen the voice and it'll be less likely to, you know, it'll be less likely to get dry, your throat will be less likely to get dry, and you'll be less likely to you to lose your stamina quickly. So it's all about you know, making sure that your voice is ready for the demands of the courtroom. But on another level, reading a book or a poem also helps in brainstorming, because it gets your creative juices flowing. And what thoughts and images come into your mind when you're reading a book or a poem? Let the words come out, however they want surprise yourself.
37:02Were there specific images that stirred something up inside of you. One thing that I become acutely aware of is that whenever I'm stressed out or carrying tension, my imagination is usually blocked. So it's oftentimes helpful to take a few deep breaths before you get started in order to ground yourself. And the breath. Once again, I can't emphasize how important and vital the breath is. When we come into this world, it's the first thing we do so should come No, it should come as no surprise that the breath is a vital component of our speaking voice. Kristin Linklater, who is one of the great voice instructors, and who developed a methodology for teaching voice to actors, as well as to public speakers and storytellers put it like this. She said, quote, there's a desire to speak. It's an impulse, it runs down the spinal column and through the central nervous system, galvanizing simultaneously the breathing mechanism, and the laryngeal mechanism into an activity that creates a vibration, which is immediately amplified by surrounding resonating surfaces into voice. At the same time, the impulse activates movements of lips and tongue that deliver words. In fact, the vibration, actually, the vibe, there's vibration in the cheeks, with the bony hollow of the cheekbones. There's vibration that happens in the throat area, there's vibration that happens in the skull. And the beauty of taking voice classes is that you begin to work on your voice and you begin to create an increase the amount of vibrations and your
38:55voice becomes more resonant. She would say let go of the result. Commit yourself to the feeling of what you want to say, feed in the desire to communicate that feeling. Release the desire into your breath, and the vibration of your voice. See what happens. This is a commitment to causal thought, voice and speech are the result of that causal impulse. Communication is a byproduct of desire and freedom. There's a beautiful exercise that we do in acting to demonstrate the connection between the desire to speak and the delivery of words. We're told to close our eyes and the instructor will ring a bell and when the bell rings we open our eyes. And what we're staring at is a physical object or a picture that hadn't been there before. It might be a piece of fruit like an orange or pineapple, or a picture like the sun setting over the beach, or a tiger in the wilderness or a wolf howling at the moon upon opening Our eyes were told to feed in or take in that image, and let it feed in an impulse to speak, and then to name, what we are seeing, and that what's right in front of us. And we're taught to let whatever we're feeling, and what whatever we've been inspired to feel, by that picture, come out through the words of how we label the object. So for example, if the object was a wolf, and a picture of a wolf, that was howling at the moon, you know, and upon opening my eyes, I saw that picture, I would let that lie, I would let myself be inspired by what I saw.
40:47And then label whatever the way I labeled the picture in whatever words I used, such as lone wolf. And what this exercise demonstrates is how it's the sound of words that convey more meaning than the actual words themselves. And so when words are coming at a jury Fast and Furious in the courtroom, it's a human, it's very human, for people to listen to the sounds that those that utter those words. So the underlying sound, the underlying sound, of the words connotes more feeling than the actual words themselves. So for example, you could say I love you in about 12 different ways. You can say, I love you, in a way that's that seething with sarcasm, or you can say I love you in a way that is that it seems like you're proposing to the, to the love of your life, or you can say I love you in a way that scornful. So that's why it's a sound that underlies the words that actually connotes more meaning than the actual words themselves. Why is this important? Well, again, I, I just stressed that when a jury is, you know, has been sworn in. And when they have evidence coming at them, in the form of oral testimony exhibits, written exhibits, excused, being excused from the courtroom, while objections are ruled upon by the judge and argued upon by the attorneys, it's, you know, their ear, you know, is is programmed to, as any human beings ear is for the sound and the tone and the quality. So, for example, you know, if you're, if you get home late from work, and, you know, your, your significant other is cooking dinner,
42:52and, and your significant others says, you know, how was work and you, you've walked in late, and, you know, and that sentence is uttered in a in an accusatory tone of, why are you so late, you're going to pick up on that right away, you're not going to have to intuit your way through it, it's going to innately come to you that, you know, your significant other is, is peeved over the fact that you're late, and you've come home late, and that sometimes leads to argument. But these are all human things that, you know, that are subtle, but, you know, but our have had, you know, have ripple effects in relationships that we have. So we would then close our eyes again, and wait until prompted to reopen them again for the next object or image. So here are some tips. There's music and speech and don't let anybody tell you that there isn't. Don't let anybody ever tell you that your speed that your voice isn't beautiful, or that it doesn't carry with it a musicality, we all possess this. Some of our some of us, however, needs some work. And I'll be the first one to admit that when I first began my acting training, I needed a lot of work with voice, my voice didn't have much stamina, and it would it was weak, and it would wear out very quickly. So I went to the gym for training my voice. And to this day, I am committed to taking voice classes at the rate of once, sometimes twice a week to keep my voice in tip top shape. For whenever I'm going to be called into the trenches again for my next trial by adjusting the pitch and vocal inflection of certain
44:44syllables and important words, shortening your sentences slowing down the pace, pausing to allow for important points to sink in. You'll draw the listener in. Don't overlook the mannerisms and phrases that you use to come in to convince people In everyday life, this will bring you closer to the goal of being real and natural in front of the jury. There's a social influencer named Sally Hogshead, who says, quote, to become more successful, you don't have to change who you are, you have to become more of who you are. So in essentially, what she's saying is you have to reveal more of who you are, you don't have to change who you are by trying to be like somebody else, you just have to really dig in more to who you are, and reveal those beautiful sides of you that may, that may be embarrassing, but that will build a sense of camaraderie with the jury. Here's a short story from my personal life. To underscore this, I was asked to give a cold read and the script contain the line. Oh, I forgot. I gave a straightforward but on an uninteresting reading of these words. But when I thought about it, I realized that that was not how I would personally react to forgetting something, especially if it was important. I then put my trust in my body since it never lies. Instantly, my fists went to my temples in a moment of painful recollection, like I'm doing now. And I began a horizontal gaze, looking into what might look like no man's land, or, you know, looking out into space, a long pause, followed during wish, I realized
46:32that it was too late now. And then I must make the best of it. Finally, almost with a shrug of my shoulders, I casually said, I forgot. Well, the instantly the casting director said that that was a true authentic moment, and one that they hadn't seen in other actors. So again, drawing upon the gestures, and the body language that you use in everyday life, bringing that part of you into a courtroom, that is going to build rapport with the jury. Number three, voice work is an often overlooked, but invaluable tool. And I've been emphasizing this since we started this presentation. But once again, the benefits far outweigh the time commitment. It'll help free your breath, develop resonance, loosen jaw and tongue tensions, and wake up your full vocal range.
47:28When this happens, your voice will drop into your body. A tip here is that relaxation and release is essential to opening freeing and ultimately strengthening your voice, the power of silence, I really feel that silence is under used, especially in a courtroom, where you know where there's so much words that are, you know, that are, you know, words and words and, you know, talk and talk and talk and talk and talk that sometimes the best way to emphasize something is by incorporating silence. Now, there's no such thing as nothing. Even when we talk about silence, there's always something even if it's as subtle as the sound of breath going in and out. Silence has a myriad of meanings.
48:20In theater, silence is an absence of words, but never an absence of meaning. A word can be emphasized and a thought underlined by silence. It has a certain energy to it like no other energy source. It has the power to get people to think and to act, it can help slow the mind down. There's also a certain intimacy that surrounds silence. In fact, if you think about it, it's a type of intimacy that is shared between two people who have a very deep and meaningful relationship. That might explain why they need only look at one another and glance and see their facial expressions in order to and then no words need to be need to be said. The couple already knows what you know what the other was thinking. Sandy Meisner, a famous acting instructor of the 20th century, had a beautiful quote when it came to silence. He said, quote, silence has a myriad of meanings. I already mentioned this quote, but he gave an example of a student that he was working with in his book. And Sandy said a moment Sandy was instructing his class and said, a moment of silence is something to let me prove it to you asked me whether I think you have talent. So of course, the student turns to Mr. Meisner and asks Mr. Meisner, do you think, do you think I have talent? Well, Sandy didn't respond. Instead, he let his head caulk away from the student and he maintained complete silence. The class began to laugh. And then Sandy's said that was silence wasn't it, but that my silence was very expressive. The trouble with silence these days is that it can make people feel
50:09uncomfortable and alone. That's why the world is filled with TVs that have been left on when nobody's watching for background noise. Because of how comfortable or uncomfortable rather silence can be, many people feel the need to fill the void of silence with needless chatter. We all do this, even the most experienced. actors do this as well, whenever whenever it feels like the atmosphere could be tense. You know, people just start chattering and chit chat, you know, fills the uncomfortableness of the void of silence. The rapid, close unbroken delivery of words, cause ideas causes ideas to become blurred and to recede into common noise. Returning to the voice, either.
50:59Another way of expanding your vocal palate is through movement. Everything in life is movement. This is not just a slogan for somatic practices, or yoga, even something as small as the flutter of an eye, or an incoming breath involves movement. This could not be any more true than theatre or film, when someone acts in theatre or film, because it's a visual medium, they're being seen and heard by an audience, just like a lawyer is in the courtroom. As such, their physicality reveals so much, especially when they're in extreme states. But even when someone is still, that stillness communicates something to an audience. In fact, I would go so far as to say that stillness communicates something even more significant than a large physical gesture. And that's why I try to get lawyers to stay away from large gestures in the courtroom, or gesticulating, you know, sometimes it's really do sometimes it can be due to the passion. And in other times, it's just big, and, and pompous. And I think we need to be careful of that, because the jurors come in sometimes with the impression of jurors as attorneys as being arrogant and pompous. And we don't want to do anything to reinforce that notion, which in my opinion, is, is is false. But again, that's the impression that some jurors come into the courtroom thinking. And I always encourage lawyers to speak with the same gestures that they might use when they're in a conversation with a friend or a family member. We're really trying to, we're aiming for conversational reality, and a tone and a
52:56conversational tone with the jury that that keeps them hanging on every single word that we say, that doesn't mean, however, that we're going to be a wallflower. That doesn't mean that we're not going to be animated or passionate. When we're making a plea to the jury. I am not advocating that one iota. What a conversational tone sets up is a connection with a jury and a trust with the jury. But when there are times to be passionate, of course, you know, your voice, there will be voice inflection, of course, there will be your heart will begin to start pounding, of course, there will be you know, you'll get read, you know, on the outside, these are all normal things that happen when you know, when a human being is, you know, compelled to speak and when the stakes are as high as they are as in a trial. Okay, so we've come to the end of this slide set. And we have some more time together. So I'm actually going to jump into a little more of a discussion surrounding surrounding body language and nonverbal communication. So I'm just going to ask you for a second while I fire up this next slide set. This is actually can serve as a preview for a next one of my future presentations called silence in court movement psychology and vocal dynamics for lawyers. So I'm going to just fast forward a little bit here and take you to some concepts that I'd like to introduce you to. This is actually a very fun presentation.
54:59That At talks about movement psychology, I am not a psychologist, I do, however, have a minor in psychology. And I've been exposed to this through my acting training. And it's, it's the work. It's a great work of Carl Jung and Rudolf Lavon, who both lived in the 20th century, and one was a movement specialists, the other was a psychiatrist. And the two got together and created a fascinating body of work. That is known as that is known as movement, psychology. And we're going to take a look at that in that in the standalone course on a later day. But I do want to talk about nonverbal communication. And this importance of, you know, always making sure that our outward the outward expression of ourselves through our gestures is consistent with the words that we speak. And the reason why is because as much as 93% of what we communicate is non verbal, nonverbal communication in the courtroom is deafening. If you're arguing that John is innocent during your closing argument, while your hand is scratching the back of your head, the jury will instantly read this contradiction as an uncertainty. In other words, when there's a contradiction between the verbal and the nonverbal, the nonverbal will always prevail.
56:37The danger this poses is that it causes the jury to question the lawyer's credibility. And as we've talked about, lawyers, credibility is the most important asset that they have, the jury can see your whole body in the courtroom. So you might as well be aware of what it's doing and use it to say everything that you mean it to say, a rule to live by is that one cannot expect to persuade others of that which one doesn't believe himself. So the rule of thumb here is that when the lawyers body and words are out of alignment, the jury will instantly view the lawyer as an imposter, someone who can't be trusted. There's this theory called unity of opposites. It, I don't want to confuse you with anything, but because we as humans are so complicated. We are, we are contradictions, we're walking contradictions. And sometimes this can become our norm, even without being aware of them. So for example, you know, when I, the person I am when I wake up in the morning, and then stumbling out of bed into the bathroom to brush my teeth, is a radically different person than I am, when I'm sitting in a conference room, speaking with a client in the middle of the afternoon, so, you know, my wants and my needs are radically different. At the point when I'm, you know, at the point when, in the morning, when I've just woken up out of a sound asleep than they are when I'm sitting, you know, across from a client in the courthouse, six hours later. So we call this unity of opposites. And, ironically enough, through my learning through the education I've had in
58:30movement psychology, I've learned that, you know, once we get what we want, we want something new and different. And I guess an argument can be made, that we see this through people who have won the lottery, you know, they've won the lottery, sometimes they exhaust all their money. And, you know, while they said before they had the winning lottery ticket that if they won the lottery, their life would be complete. Well, now they're looking for the next source of money, because they've won, they've gone through all of that cash. So yeah, I mean, we are inherently contradictory. Because the characters that actors play are messy, inherently flawed, and full of baggage actors go in just the opposite direction, leaning into the inconsistencies between the nonverbal and verbal to create rich multi dimensional characters. But for the lawyer looking to persuade jurors, both the nonverbal and verbal must always be in sync. So as simple as this might sound, one of the biggest reasons why lawyers nonverbal language and gestures are out of sync is because the lawyer himself has not convinced himself of his clients in a sense if he's defending a client charged with a crime when defending a person accused of a crime. If you haven't convinced yourself locked lock, stock and barrel of your clients innocence, your nonverbal communication will reveal the uncertainty, economy of movement, this This is a beautiful, I've given you some background information about over using your, your body to, you know, to, you know, to use
1:00:13too much gesture in the courtroom. I like I like it to be scaled down. And I like this idea of economy of movement which gets us back to using the gestures and movements that we use in everyday life when we're having conversations with our loved ones and our friends. So first, you know, you must you be you the question you might be asking yourself if, if you find that you're, if you've been told, you know that your gestures might be a little bit too distracting to what you're actually saying. You might ask yourself the question must I be doing what I'm doing now? Or is my movement distracting from the truth and meaning of my words, the movement doesn't necessarily have to be a big gesture like flailing your arms about in order to be distracting, it could be as subtle as bawling your hand up in a fest. The general rule of thumb is to fit the movement to the word or the action to the Word and the Word to the action. A good question to ask yourself is whether the movement is 100% needed. If you can't take your eyes off of an actor, if you've been moved to tears by an actor, or if you've been pulled to the edge of your seat, chances are that the actor's actions fit their words and their words fit their actions, a good actor to watch his Marlon Brando, he only used the the minimal amount of movement that was necessary for the scene. On the other hand, if your mind begins to drift, and you reach over to grab your smartphone, One reason might be not always but might be that the actor is indicating, or what we call gesticulating in a way that
1:02:01distracts from the experience of their inner life, their inner life is what's far more interesting for an audience to watch. But far more revealing for the actor to show. The second part of economy of movement is a once you've decided that this movement really is needed, which muscles do you actually need to make that movement, for example, in order to raise your arm, I don't need to tense my leg or my neck, my neck muscles don't move my arm. If we're using other muscles that aren't necessary, then what we call that is parasitic movement. If you want to turn your head do you need to tense your shoulders Of course not. And this is all part of somatic practices. One technique is called Alexander technique. This training takes a lot of time. But the beauty of this training is that not all is that it helps to avoid, you know, bone problems later on in life like osteoporosis.
1:03:03And, you know, and the weakening of bones because you only begin to use the absolute, the minimal, the minimal amount of movement that's necessary, so you don't over exert muscles that aren't needed. And therefore you won't, you know, be prone to the types of bone, you know, bone density issues that older folks are prone to. If you have a habit for a year from years and years of raising your shoulder, every time you turn your head, that habit of course isn't going to disappear overnight. So I like I advocated earlier, you want to pay attention to the gestures and movements that you use in everyday life, when you're in conversations with other people that'll help to identify which movements are natural and organic to you, versus those which are nothing more than window dressing, or a mask that covers up your true self expression. movement in the courtroom. I'm just going to grab a quick sip of water and then we'll jump into this topic.
1:04:16So we start with the premise that wandering around the courtroom, like want like an actor wandering around the stage isn't helpful to an audience. The reason why is that audiences find it distracting, and I can tell you for a fact that jurors find it distracting when a lawyer walks around without purpose. If they're walking around aimlessly or wandering around the courtroom, chances are that it's going to distract from the message that the lawyer wants to convey to the jury. And so when an actor moves from place to place on stage, it's called a crime OS crosses are precise clear movements from one place to another. Each movement should be done with purpose at a specific point in your presentation. Wandering pacing or even unconscious weight shifting is distracting and takes your attention away from where it should be. The jury in weakens the impact of your speech. By moving to a specific point in the courtroom, you can punctuate a point. If you want to make a strong point, taking three steps forward will alert the jury you are about to say something important. Think like a director, just as a director looks at the stage to see the areas of strongest impact for the audience and sets the stage for the scene. So should you when it comes to the courtroom, you should always think about the courtroom from the jurors point of view, keeping it balanced and visually interesting.
1:05:57I just want to make sure.
1:06:03And I just want to make sure that my screen is showing everything that I'm seeing right now. So this is just a precaution. Okay, good. Great, we're on track. So this beauty of being able to think not just as the actor but also as a director and as the playwright has so much as so much significance. Just as a director looks at the stage to see the areas of strongest impact for the audience, and sets the stage for the scene. So should you when it comes to the courtroom, you should always think about the courtroom from the jurors point of view, keeping it balanced and visually interesting. Look at the general areas of the courtroom as points to reach your jury on as many levels as you can. For example, you may move closer to the jury box to get closer to one or two of them or keep your distance in order to take in all of them. Look carefully at the placement of furniture such as lecterns tables and projectors in relation to you and where you are in the juries view. Make sure you are not upstaged by an unnecessary piece of large furniture, which unconsciously draws the jury's attention away from you. The following techniques will help you stage your opening and closing in a way that uses movement to enhance content. Directors blocked the movements of actors to emphasize dramatic meaning and to maintain clear slight sightlines. There's what's called the downstage area and the upstage area. The downstage area is the area closest to your jury. It's a strong position, and is the best place to present the most important content
1:08:04of your speech. However, you don't want to live there. In fact, if you meander too close to the jury, in this area, you'll be entering the dreaded zone of the pathetic. That's when you're literally standing in front of one juror, that's a little bit too uncomfortable for the jury. And you'll even notice through their body language that they'll probably inch backwards in their chair or their chest might cave into a concave shape. That's because they're uncomfortable. You're you've basically, you're in their bubble, and nobody likes to that to happen and the jury is no different. upstage or away from the audience is less powerful but can be used effectively for reflective pauses. But be careful. If you meander too far away from the jury in this area, you will be entering the dreaded zone of the tragic where intense scenes are played out with with extraordinary consequences, such as the battle between the hero and his arch nemesis moving from upstage to downstage in order to make an important point is highly effective. And this is just a diagram you see now the stage you can just superimpose the jury for where the audience is in this picture. And then you you see that downstage is the area closest to the jury, upstage is the area farthest away from the jury and then you have stage right stage left, you have center stage, which is a happy medium between upstage and downstage in American and British theatre stage right in stage left refer to the actors or speakers point of view. The
1:09:58position downstage Right is perceived by Western audiences as having intimacy and importance, probably because we read from left to right. In theater love scenes, monologues and narration are usually performed down right. public speakers use this position for their most important content, or for stories that have a strong emotional effect. Downstage left traditionally has a conspiratorial feel to it, a place for plots and discussions in the theater. Umer in his speech is often very effective when delivered from downstage left. And so these are the tips that I give for moving in the courtroom. Follow your instincts be led by those jurors who seem to back in for your attention, you'll see it, you'll feel it, but never leave anyone out.
1:10:50An exercise that we did when I was a student at the National Criminal Defense College, is when we were practicing our opening and closing, we made it a point of making eye contact with every juror. And because that was hard to do. As an exercise, the actors who worked with us would sit in the jury box, and we would be forced to shake the hand of every every one of the 12 jurors that sat in the box, even reaching over the ones that were in the front row in order to in order to reach the hand of the jurors that were in the back row. And that always taught us never to forget to make eye contact with everyone.
1:11:35Because at the end of the day, you don't know which ones are going to be pulling for you in the in the in the deliberation room. And sometimes it may come down to one juror, one juror only. That's a holdout that that that turns that that results in a mistrial. And maybe that Miss trial gets your client a better plea deal if it's a if it's a criminal case. So now I'm going to X out of this set of slides. You might recall that I talked about this idea of the five senses when I was giving you a preview of this presentation.
1:12:27And so I feel compelled to chat with you briefly about the five senses. And this discussion actually comes out of my storytelling in the courtroom presentation which you might be interested in viewing if you weren't in the live in the Live Set of that presentation.
1:13:02See, I share some of the same information as I did in the Shakespeare for lawyers presentation.
1:13:18We talked about pausing, we talked about the power of silence. We have five senses not one. Don't forget to actively engage the five senses. The easiest way to get vivid cinematic and sensual details into your story is to think in terms of the five senses. If your story can enter the listener through this senses, the listener can experience the story in real time, and as if it were happening to them. And so what are the five senses they are sound, smell, touch, taste and sight. Remembering sounds can help to access the emotions they trigger inside of you. Does the ringing of a classroom Bell bring back feelings of being out of place and alienated such as when you were in middle school? As the sound of an ambulance sirens scare you, causing you to remember the day that your grandmother died? Does the sound of a Brook running make you feel peaceful? An example might be one where you are you have to bring the jury you have to give the jury a glimpse of the neighborhood that your client grew up in or of where the event where the alleged crime occurred. And so you might say he heard a loud pop like a muffler backfiring and took cover on the ground. However in John's neighborhood, you could never be sure more often than not a loud pop meant that someone was firing shots and and that it wasn't just the muffler. smell the smell can help you can help open up the personal emotions you Need to feel the stench of garbage might make you feel nauseous. But the fragrance of lilacs or roses can make you feel the first stirrings of romance. Touch.
1:15:11Does sand trickling through your fingers transport you to a beach, does a touch, affirm, make you feel romantic? Does a cool breeze blowing through your hair remind you of the day when your husband proposed to you? The five senses. This is something that I learned from one of my acting instructors that was so deeply profound, that I couldn't help but want to share it with you. My acting instructor said that the five senses are one big super sense. And it wasn't just mentioned by the instructor, but she actually had an article written by a psychologist who had done research and supported this, the five senses are once again touch their one big super sense called touch. Now we've already covered physical touch, but how is touch triggered in the context of the other four senses. The other four senses being sight, smell. Sorry, sight, smell, taste, and sound.
1:16:23This is fascinating. Well.
1:16:33Okay, so again, how is touched triggered in the context of these other four senses? Well, when we taste something, it touches our taste buds. When we smell something, the molecules penetrate our nose. When we look at something, the color or the light touches the back of our cornea. And that's how we see it. In what might be surprising, and even a little bit creepy. Sound waves are touching us all the time. Even now, as I speak to you, I'm touching you with the sound of my voice. And what's what's beautiful about this is that my voice is probably touching you in some way. You're you're having some type of visceral reaction to the to my words, and guess what isn't that what's happening, we're in the courtroom. And we're speaking and addressing the jury, our voice through sound waves is touching the jury. And those sound waves are giving the jury impressions of things that are happening happening in nanoseconds. And those things are it's almost as if our eyes almost as if we have tentacles inside us and that those tentacles through our sound waves are like probing and palpating, the the members of the jury, and you know, we can't No matter how hard we try, we can't escape our voice and the fact that our sound waves are coming through our voice and touching others, whether they be through a computer or in person, you know, directly. So I think it's just fascinating that looking at this from from this perspective teaches us that touch is a super sense. And so again, I send out sound waves that travel through my mic into the computer out of your speakers
1:18:32and hit your eardrums causing inner vibrations. The vibrations that I'm sending here, are literally touching you there and are leaving you with a feeling of me as a person even though we're not physically, you know, sitting opposite one another in person in this room. I'm fascinated with this idea of how our words and sounds are always touching people. Indeed, the sounds of people's voices by themselves trigger certain sensations inside us. Look no further than some of your favorite narrators on Audible. I use the example and from the storytelling in the courtroom class of a very famous actor niam Liam Neeson who was narrating on Audible book for a young audience of high schoolers, and he did such a beautiful job in in his pace and his tone, his voice inflection using pause and silence. And I'd love to share it with you. I don't have time now. But look no further than some of your favorite narrators on Audible. Some of the things that some of the very techniques that they're using are what we've talked about in this presentation, and are what lawyers use all the time when they're addressing a jury. Recognizing the sheer power of our voice. We We should exploit it for the good of our clients when we're speaking to the jury. I'm also fascinated with the power of touch through sight when we're speaking to the jury. I can think of times in my life when another person shot daggers at me from across the room. It felt as if they had touched me when they looked at me. Indeed, it felt as if the person had stripped me naked with their eyes.
1:20:23How might that relate to the to an argument in court, you might say that the officer's grip on John's arm was so tight that the imprint it left it left was still there more than two hours later, talk about you know, viscerally you know, getting through to a jury that is sure to leave an indelible imprint almost on their arm. When they hear how tight the grip was that it was there more than two hours later on your clients are, taste does a taste of a bitter pill, rancid mill, or liver make you want to throw up, perhaps a taste of the nella icing makes you feel loved and special, as you did when your mother would make a birthday cake for you with her special vanilla icing? Or maybe this is the sensation of a dark piece of chocolate melting in your mouth creates primal sensual feelings. How might that relate to the courtroom? Well, you might say in a case of self defense, where you're defending your client, that as he lay on the ground, John could taste the blood that was dripping out of his nose and onto his lips. You know, and again, that brings it to life in a more visceral way for the jury to to literally be in John's shoes. To know that he was tasting his own blood site, a Hawaiian sunset and abandoned house, a dead carcass on the highway and intimate candlelit room or a flag draped coffin. What visuals create a response in you explore different images to see which ones move you chances are they will move the jury to and examples for the courtroom with cite. His palms were shaking and soaked in sweat. The room looked like it hadn't been
1:22:12cleaned in months, he could tell that she was holding back tears. And that's going to do it for us folks. We've made it to the end of Shakespeare. For lawyers part one, make your words dance. This was actually two volumes. Volume One was in two parts. There is a second volume called Shakespeare for lawyers rhetorical power in the courtroom. And that's where I will go through all the rhetorical devices that Shakespeare used and which we as lawyers can use in our closing primarily in our closing arguments, but as well as an as an other aspects of trial. So it's been an absolute pleasure presenting this topic to you and hope to see you at a future program.