0:02Hello, everyone. Today's seminar is on ethics and data security. My name is Carrie Sheehan, and I will be your speaker here today. A little bit about myself. So you know, who's talking at you or to you during this seminar, but I'm an assistant clinical professor of law and ethics at IU Kelley School of Business in Indianapolis, Indiana. In addition to that, I'm also an ethics conflict attorney with a law firm of scopolitis, Garvin Light, Hansen and Fury in Indianapolis, Indiana. They do trucking, transportation, mainly. Anything in the trucking or transportation industry, that's what they do. And internally with their firm, I help them resolve conflicts, do ethical compliance, anything that touches the rules of professional conduct. That is what I do on a day to day basis. That's also what I teach over at the Kelley school and at the Robert H. McKinney School of Law.
0:57I also adjunct there as well. So let's get started here today, and let's talk about the fun world of ethics and data security. How many of you and I can't see your hands, work at a law firm or have it or different things, and you're worried about security? Normally, I would probably see all of your hands, and that is because we all have data security concerns. We all have data security, you know, just in our lives we have to think about it, especially being lawyers. We have client confidential information. We have Social Security numbers. We have HR stuff. We have banking accounts and banking records, not only of our clients, but also of our employees. And so we are prime targets for being hacked, for spyware, bugs, worms, viruses. And so I always say just everyone just needs to take cover because it's coming at us.
1:51In today's digital age, especially with AI, artificial intelligence, it is going to be more prevalent, and we are going to have to really buff up our security in our law firms and on our systems because AI can now code. It can create malware. Those phishing emails, which we'll talk about a little later, too, aren't going to be as easy to spot because now with AI, a hacker can throw those into chat, GPT or another AI program, and it correct their English, their spelling mistakes, their errors, their spacing to make it look like it came from you or me, someone more highly educated. And so then it comes across to your system. You're like, oh, this looks real. I don't see those miss things that, you know, I'm used to spotting. So we are going to be under attack, and it's starting to come, in addition to that, with AI, too, which we'll get to hopefully at the end of the seminar.
2:46There's also voice cloning. There's also face cloning or deep fakes and different things that can affect our data security as well. So we have to be vigilant. It was actually Robert Mueller of the FBI, an FBI director in 2012 said, I am convinced there are only two types of companies, those that have been hacked and those that will be hacked in the future. And even those are converging to one category, the companies that are hacked and will be hacked again. So, meaning every company at some point is going to be hacked or have a security or data breach at some point, your law firm may have already had one.
3:22I worked with law firms that have had them before to counsel them and advise them on what to do and take those steps moving forward. So you've got to really be cognizant of these things, especially in your firm. And as I said, we are targets because we store, we maintain, we have the highly sensitive information. We also probably have details about clients and cases. This is not just financial stuff, but those details that someone wants to take and expose. Think of like the Ashley Madison situation that occurred with releasing the names and different things like that, or the people going in to try to find data and try to find that information to become popular on TikTok or become popular on the news or sell it to the tabloids.
4:07Some lawyers will have that type of information about their clients. And so we really need to think about that and we need to protect the information. We have some common security threats that we can see throughout firms especially, that are more prevalent than others. Ransom attacks. This is phishing and social engineering emails. So phishing and social engineering emails, as I was briefly talking about before, this is where you get an email and it may say external in the subject line. It may not, but you read it and it says something like, please click on the link below to change your password. Thanks, it department. And you may think, okay, we have an IT department. I know I have to change my password every so often. Let me just click on that link. You click on that link. Well, it's not really from your IT department. It's actually, if you would have looked at kind of the email address it came from, really analyze, the email itself was from an outside hacker. So when you clicked on that link, guess what happens? You just opened up your entire system, your entire thing, and now they're worming their way through all of your network to try to steal data from you.
5:17That happens more than you think. The biggest one which catches a lot of people. It has not caught me yet because a lot of firms send these out. You know, the robo ones, the fake ones, to see if you fall for them is Amazon. If you use your work email for your Amazon account, you will see several Amazon phishing emails saying, hey, click here to see your recent order. You're like, well, what do I order? Or what did my spouse, significant other, or my kids order? How many of you have that problem? Your kids order something on Amazon and you no idea what they ordered. You get that random email and you're like, let's see what they ordered and what they spent my money on. So you click on that account and guess what? It's a hacker, it's someone else. That's that ransom attack, that phishing, that social engineering type of email we need to watch out for. The biggest ones are Amazon.
6:05That you'll see fake ones come through because everyone, particularly majority of people, use Amazon, also fake ones from it departments. Some are like, you want a contest? Click here to gain your prize. You'll see those as well. Other ones can be such emails as, and this is a big one with law firms. I've caught several of these internally within firms is you get an email from a potential client. They say, hey, I want to hire you to do XYZ. You email them back. You said, great, happy to chat with you. Let's set up a time. Then all of a sudden, you get a check. You get a check physical check into your office, and it's for, say, $200,000 or $275,000.
6:50Then you get an email back from that person you were emailing with, even though you've never met them, don't know them or anything, and they say, hey, I just sent over a check for, you know, our retainer or deposit. Go ahead and cash that, but then send me back XYZ money. Or, you know, we only are going to put $100,000 down, but deposit it all and then send me back money. That's probably a scam. You may be money laundering at that point. If you deposited it, it could be to where you deposited and the check bounces, you know, and different things like that could happen, too. And a lot of times when we've seen those, it's usually a really big check from someone who we've never met, some random email we've gotten saying they want our representation. And then if you actually take that check and look at what bank it's potentially drawn from, it's usually fake, not the bank. Name, just the check. And I've actually taken those types of checks to the banks, like, say, to chase or first merchants or Citibank or wherever it says it's potentially, you know, written from.
7:51And I have the bank run the numbers, the routing and account numbers, and every single time they're like, no, this is fake. This is counterfeit. This isn't real. This isn't something in our system. So you can actually take those if you're suspicious and have someone go verify those at banks before you actually cash them. If it's. If you get that gut feeling, it's going to be a suspicious security type of thing that you need to take care of. And I've done that. And the banks actually are like, can we keep this or keep a copy of it? Because they want to turn it in, they want to seek who's doing it, because they're using that bank's name to write false checks on.
8:28So then you have this whole other layer there, too. So you can actually do that. And if you live, or, excuse me, if you work or your office is next to the banks, that's great, because I just normally walk, you know, anywhere downtown Indianapolis because there's all the banks down there and say, hey, can you tell me if this check is real or nothing? And they're more than willing to do that because they want to catch the people doing it just as much as you do. So those are some of those ransomware attacks that we can see coming through. Social media is another huge one, too. Social media, again, you can get those phishing social engineering type of things coming through, too. And also you need to realize that anything you put online, anything you talk about, anything you post, any information, anything you link up to it, it's not private.
9:12So if you put information online somewhere via TikTok, LinkedIn, Facebook, MySpace, if they still have that, I'm probably dating myself with that one. Any of those social media type of platforms, it is not private. There are confidentiality concerns there. Even if you say, well, it's my personal account with only my family and friends on it, it's still not private. Those family and friends could screenshot it. They could do different things, like repost it, resave it, take a picture with their cell phone and send it out via an instant or text message. Nothing you put online is private, ever. Never think it is. And never also think that your friends and family will hold your deepest, darkest secrets if you post it to them on Facebook. Guess what? They won't. Our family and friends usually are the first ones sometimes to stab us in the back.
10:06And everyone always asks me why I say that. And I say, because they know we love them and that we're going to forgive them eventually, because that's what family does. Friends sometimes don't forgive. They split ways. They move on. Family, you're connected for life, basically, is how I view it. So it is always the family members to say, oh, their family, they won't care. Oh, their family, they'll get over it. Their family, they'll do this. So never, ever, ever think just because you send it out just to family and friends, that it's going to be private. Because it's not. Nothing on social media, nothing on the Internet is ever private. We need to get that conception out of our head. Another area where we see a lot of common security threats. And we'll go through some examples of these as well in the next couple of slides. Misdirected emails.
10:50How many of you like the reply all feature? I don't. I've been caught in that one too many times, especially on my cell phone, because my thumbs and fingers are bigger than the screen of my cell phone or I'm driving. Don't turn me in for that one. And I try to reply or something. And so reply all feature can be a terrible, terrible thing. We've got to really look out for that, too. And then to not just the reply all feature, but the auto fill feature. How many of you started to type a name in your email, say John or Michael or anything common, and it auto populates. You don't really look at it because we're mind numbingly going through our tasks. We've got 100 other things to do in the day. And so we just auto fill, right, the email hit send.
11:35Well, maybe it auto filled the wrong person. Maybe you hit reply all when you shouldn't have. And so that can be lead to data security breaches too, because if you had confidential information in that email or an attachment and you just sent it out to someone who shouldn't have it, or out to a broad range of people, we have an issue. I will say one of the ones that was now, looking back in hindsight, it's funny, but at the time was not very funny. I was working internally at a firm, not the firm. I'm with one in the past. And an email went out to the entire attorneys, like the entire law firm, everyone, staff, everyone. And then an attorney decided he didn't like the contents of the email and so wanted to complain about it to a partner or to the management. But instead of just sending his email directly to that person, he hit reply all and started talking about coworkers and other attorneys in the firm.
12:27That was a big misdirected email. Now, it wasn't necessarily a security data breach, but it was something that really got him in trouble, got a lot of people upset. But it could have been even worse too, if there was external people on that email communication. Luckily, it stayed internally. Just had a lot of hostile feelings after that from some people towards this person. But again, it could have been even worse if there was external people on that as well. So we need to really watch those. Another type of data concern is portable devices, making sure if you have them stolen or lose them, you report them immediately to your firm, remote disconnect them if possible.
13:11Also too, you've got to think about if it's not password protected or there's a chance that client confidential information got let out. You need to have a plan in place to alert those clients. Kind of having that, you know, what do we do if this happens scenario. So you need to think about those things as well. A lot of times this happens when we set stuff down at places or different areas and we just forget about it. Another thing too, lost or stolen devices. It's not really lost or stolen, but how many of you let your kids on your cell phone? Does your cell phone have client emails on it? Does it have client confidential information on it? You need to think about that. Even if you think, well, it's my kid, but if you read rule 1.6, confidentiality, there is no exception for family, friends, or significant others or spouses.
13:59Under the rules of confidentiality, we still cannot tell them or allow them access to our client confidential information. So we need to think about those things as well. HIPAA violations. If you receive or send HIPAA information, encryption is always good. You need to think about that as well. Encrypting emails to certain people, doing different things like that. When you send them via online or find the safest ways to get them or to send the information and receive it, encryption is a good one. It's easy. You can do it straight from your email. Different areas like that, improper disposal of information. This is where we don't take our client files and go put them in the dumpster out back behind our building.
14:41We need to shred them, we need to burn them, have a bonfire, you know, do something like that as well, because again, someone could go dumpster diving, or someone could go do something like that and then get the client files. Another area with this is to, I know a lot of us have shred boxes probably around our office and different things. And so the shred box is, you know, we put the paper in there, maybe they come once a month or whenever to shred everything. Well, problem comes in is when you have like a shred box in your like under your desk. And I'm not saying the box that sealed, you know, just with the little thing in it, but like a paper cardboard box, so it's open on the top, sits under your desk, you just throw your files in it. Then once a month or once a week, you take it down to the main shred box that the company comes and picks up. The problem with that is it is open and exposed under your desk. Yes, you're in your law firm.
15:34Yes, it should be confidential. You know, everyone's bound by the same rules. But what about if the cleaning staff at night comes through, picks up that shred box thinking it's trash because it's sitting right next to your trash can and then just throws it in the dumpster out back. Now we've had improper disposal, so you really should get your shred papers and get your client files down to the main shred box as soon as possible. Don't leave them sitting under your desk. Type of scenario. Also need to think about too. When you're cleaning out files or destroying them, you destroy them properly.
16:07E files, paper files. Let's just not take it to the dumpster out back. There has been some questions come across the chat. They've been more about logistics. Your CLE code will be at the end of the presentation. You will get it in the last five or ten minutes of the presentation. So you need to hang around to the end to wait for that. And then too, if the CLE materials PowerPoints are available, you can contact the platform after the seminar. And I think they are available to you at that point. So those were some of the questions I saw coming through the chat just now. Some other things to think about too. Going back one slide here, types of protected information. We've talked about client files a little bit. HIPAA sensitive information, Social Security numbers, trade secrets, analysis strategies, financial information of the firm and clients, human resource records. These should all be common sense. Everything we do for our clients is confidential. And everything, you know, we keep and save within the firm is confidential. So we need to think about that as well. But if you think about it, your law firm has your Social Security number, your bank account for your direct deposit, then your address, everything that is right for someone to steal your identity, it's not just client information we're protecting, but it's also our own personal human resource records that we need to protect. And so if you think, oh, it's just my client stuff, I don't care. No, it's your stuff, too. If someone gets into your system, if someone hacks your
17:30files in your records, that is your personal data as well. Are lawyers subject to HIPAA? Yes. We have to keep HIPAA information and data private. Now, how does that come about? Well, obviously, when we collect the HIPAA information or medical records, especially if you're a plaintiff's attorney, you normally have your client sign an authorization for you to get that. When you get those records in, you can't just go disclose them to any Joe schmo on the street or throw them in the back dumpster just at your win. You shouldn't just email them or forward them out to people without encrypting them or taking what we call reasonable precautions to protect the information. Reasonable precautions are things like the encryption, maybe sending the records in one way with a password and then sending the code or calling and giving the opposing counsel the code in another way. When you file them with court, if it's something highly sensitive, try to redact them or try to file them under seal, or, you know, on here, it's like the green paper. That means confidential. It doesn't go on the public docket. So we have to take reasonable steps and reasonable precautions to protect HIPAA data.
18:41Personal health information, Social Security numbers, trade secrets, analysis strategies, everything with the clients. And that comes with our obligations under rule 1.6, confidentiality. And we've got to think about those things because we have hacktivists, criminals, insiders, nation states, terrorists, military. It's like a war out there. All these faceless attackers coming at us 24/7 trying to not only get our data, but the data of our clients as well. So we have to remain competent. Getting into some of the rules, specifically here, competent. And our duties and competence means a reasonable level of knowledge. So we don't want to be experts in everything we do. We have to remain competent or requisite knowledge and skill that we should have to stay abreast of the law and its practices, including the risk and benefits associated therewith.
19:36And one of those is that duty of confidentiality. Confidentiality is where we have to prevent the inadvertent or unreathered disclosure or access to information, including that HIPAA information, private health information. We cannot go out and tell the secrets of our clients. We cannot go out and even give other people our client's name without our clients consent confirmed in writing. We have a strict duty of confidentiality to all of our clients, and we have to maintain that. We do have a question coming in, so I will skip to it here real quick. What about AI making encryption essentially worthless? What methods are considered reasonable when we aren't able to protect against AI decryption technology?
20:20Reasonable efforts is not really defined in the rules, and it's not even defined in the ABA yet reasonable efforts are. We have to do what a reasonable person in our situation would. If that's encryption, then we encrypt it. If there's an AI technology out there that can decrypt it, we can't necessarily fight against everything out there. We can't fight against all hackers and everything. You can train, you can send out fake phishing emails within your firm, and you're going to have probably one or two people still click on them. No matter how much training you give, nothing is going to be perfect. But we still have to take those reasonable steps, those reasonable precautions, to try to make it perfect again. It's a practice of law.
21:02We can't just turn a blind eye and say, oh, well, they have decrypting stuff now, so I'm not gonna encrypt anything. Cause it's not worth my time. We still have to take the steps to try to encrypt it. We still have to take the steps to try to protect the information. That is what we are supposed to do under our rules of competence, under rules of confidentiality, and just our loyalty to our clients. Think about it. If you went to a lawyer and the lawyer said to you, well, I'm not gonna take any efforts to maintain your confidentiality or your secrets or anything, because you know there's someone out there who can probably hack into it anyway, so why waste my time? Would you wanna hire that person?
21:39I wouldn't. I'd say I'm turning you into the disciplinary commission is what I would say. So you need to take those reasonable steps to protect client information. Another comment that came in to HIPAA applies to health plans, healthcare clearing houses, and any healthcare provider who transmits health information, electronic form. So law firms are not subject to HIPAA, but we are same types of responsibility of confidential obligations? That is correct. We have to keep the information confidential. That's our rule 1.6. We cannot disseminate out our clients information. So we need to make sure we do that.
22:18Any other questions, please keep them coming in, they were kind of the same questions about the course materials and that that have come in since then. So please keep those. But going back to our duties of confidentiality, we have a duty to remain confidence. And this is one of the graphs that I like to use. Confidentiality is huge. It pertains to anything that touches and concerns the representation. So any stuff we learned during the course, any documents received, any of those HIPAA records, any of those things, that is all confidential. In rule 1.6 that is way broader than the attorney client privilege, which we normally just think about.
22:52The attorney client privilege is the direct communications between the attorney and the client. That is a small subsect of confidentiality. You can see that in the graph there. So we've got to stop thinking about just confidentiality between what we say directly to and from the client. But confidentiality is everything that touches and concerns, or you learn in the course of the representation pertaining to that client. So, and that is what we have a duty to take reasonable precautions to protect, to have data security protocols in place to make sure that that information does not get out. So everything in that big red circle under rule 1.6 is what we're really looking for.
23:33So when we combine kind of our duty to keep stuff safe and our duty of confidentiality, this duty of reasonableness that I've been kind of talking about, it boils down to that a lawyer must act competently to preserve safeguard confidential client information against unauthorized disclosure by the lawyer or persons under his or her supervision. ABA Rule 1.6 common 18. The unauthorized access is not a violation when lawyers make reasonable efforts, we just have to make reasonable efforts. If we don't take those reasonable efforts, like encryption, if it's easy and different things, then we're not doing our job, and we can get in trouble for that under the rules of professional conduct. And so what is reasonable, too, is sometimes also balanced. Are you a solo practitioner or are you a big firm with 20 to 50 offices across the country, across the globe?
24:25That data security for a big firm is going to look way different than the data security plan in place for a small firm. So that duty of reasonableness, that duty of, you know, trying to take the reasonable precautions is going to look different depending on what size firm you're in and also, too, depending on what practice area you're in. If you just do say something, wills, trust in estates, it may be a little different than someone who's representing China or doing something high level security for the federal government, the data plans or the data security plans are going to look different based on the size of your firm and the practice area in which you're engaging.
25:05So you need to always consider that as well. Reasonable efforts. Again, not a one size fits all. And I would direct everyone to ABA Formal Opinion 477 R revised in May of 2017, which talks specifically to that email encryption that I've been talking about and other guidance just on data security, and you can google that, pull down the PDF. If you're a member of the ABA, you can obviously go on their website and get it through your members access as well. But ABA formal Opinion 477 R talks about what our duties are and what is reasonable or considered reasonable for data security, data encryption, and the parameters that we have there, too, and also to what reasonable efforts mean. Again, reasonable efforts, like I said, is not a one size fits all. It's that multifactor analysis.
25:56What is the information? What safeguards do we have in place? Is someone going to be coming at it? Someone's going to be coming at something more if I work for the federal government than if I just represent little old people in nursing homes writing wills for them. It's a different level of security for each type of practice, the cost associated with it. If the cost is going to be a million dollars and you're a solar practitioner, that may not be reasonable. If the cost of data security is a million dollars and you're a huge global law firm, it may be reasonable. At that point. You've got to look at those multi factor situations also too. Difficulty of implementation.
26:32Solo practitioners, you're one man or one woman or person. Shop big law firms, you may have an entirely robust it department of 50 employees or more that all they do. Is it data security? It's a little different there. It's easier to implement when you have a team on it than if you're a solo practitioner looking at it that way as well. Another thing too, that you should consider, obviously, ability to represent different safeguards, any adverse things that come into play as well. And so you've got to look at those. One question that just came in was, should we encrypt email communications between the attorney and client beyond the point of a regular email program? Normally, no. Unless that email between the attorney client includes some other information that you want to protect in a higher level, such as you're emailing medical records back and forth, then maybe we should encrypt the sending of those medical records or, you know, some other highly sensitive document or attachment, then you may want to consider it. It's not just based on a one size fits all, if it's just a general communication with the client saying, hey, we have a meeting, XYZ, or here's a summary of what's going on. You probably don't need a second level of encryption, but if you're sending HIPAA records, if you're sending protected health information, if you're sending something else more, then maybe we need to encrypt it, then we need to look at it as, you know, different situational basis, and not just a one size fits all basis in every scenario.
28:06Another question coming in. What is your opinion about state bars and courts requiring attorneys to employ all the latest computers and technologies in their firm? Isn't there something to said for retro security? Or all paper offices that literally cannot be hacked or infiltrated if they simply don't use these vulnerable new technologies? Or even that it. Again, in my opinion, it depends on what you're doing and what the firm is. Yes, some of the new technologies are more able to be hacked and it's a little higher security risk. And I understand why people are going paperless, but going paperless comes with infiltration, comes with hackers, comes with that. It does streamline processes, make stuff cheaper, all those things.
28:50But again, you've got to balance it. Should we keep it just in paper for security reasons, or should we keep it to where we can be hacked? The more stuff we put online, the more security I need to put in place. There are some firms and attorneys who I know who hate using the cloud. They don't want any of their client stuff in the cloud. And there was this big controversy over if lawyers should even use cloud service at one point, just because of the potential of it being hacked, the potential of it not being confidential or not having enough security around it. So you really have to analyze the technology that your firm wants to employ to see if it's worth the risk. If it's worth the risk, then you should do it. But no, you may have to have more protections in place. If it's nothing, then stay the old way, stay the paper way, stay something else. And it could be too. Maybe you'll use the cloud for this, but not for this.
29:43Maybe you'll use online for this, but not for this. Again, very situational, case by case basis. When you look at that as well, and like I said, I know some firms who won't use the cloud. I know some firms that still do everything in paper. I know some that go paperless. I know some too, that use the cloud, use email use everything out there. But they tell their clients that up front in that engagement letter. They say, hey, client, we store our documents in the cloud. We're going to communicate with you via email. Here is the risk associated with that. Here are the protections we have in place. If you're okay with this or by signing this engagement letter, you are giving your consent to us doing these certain procedures.
30:26Then they're aware of what you're doing. So then if there's a breach, they're not like, oh my gosh, you didn't tell me you were using the cloud. I would have told you not to do that. Telling your client the technology you're using, telling your client the risk associated there with, and giving them the opportunity to say, no, I don't want you to communicate with me via email because I'm scared of email. No, I don't want you to use subcloud because I've heard bad things about it. And then you having an alternative plan and working that out with them kind of protects you too, as a law firm if something happens, because then the client's not shocked when a breach happens. You reach out to them and say, hey, we had a breach. Here's what we're doing to resolve it. They're not like, well, you didn't get my permission to use that communication. Rule 1.4 of the rules of professional conduct says we have to communicate with our clients.
31:14A lot of law firms, especially big law firms, will put that in their engagement letter or standard terms, advising the client of the technology they're using, how they're going to communicate with that client, and then getting their clients consent to the same. Now, this is easier if you have more sophisticated clients, such as companies or corporations. It's a little harder if you're on the plaintiff side of things and dealing with laypersons who don't understand the technology or the business world. So you've got to tailor that communication down to the sophistication of your clients. But that is one way to come at it too, is under that rule 1.4, communication.
31:52Communicate with your client and let them know. Let them sign off on it. If you have standard terms that go out with every single engagement letter, drop a paragraph in there about it. If you don't and you just write up an engagement letter for every single thing, or it's a shorter one, drop a paragraph in there about it or have an entirely outside separate agreement, separate from the engagement letter that you send with it and have the client sign both. You should always communicate with the client, especially if you're using cutting edge technology, AI in doing something or something where you're like, well, some people may like this, some may not, or there's risk associated with it or more risk than before. Get the client's consent, confirm it in writing to protect yourself from the firm. Another question coming in. Are certain emails ranked higher for security purposes?
32:43There's not really a ranking system necessarily. You really have to look at the content of the email or content of the communication. I would say ones that if you wanted to rank something that may be higher on the scale where we need encryption or something a little more if they contain privileged protected information, trade secrets, health information, something beyond the normal course of you just talking with the client or you just talking with someone generally about the case, but a little more than that. But then when you get to that information too, you've got to assess, is this something that if it gets out, will turn like really hurt the client, or is this something that if it gets out, okay, that's terrible, but, you know, we can make do with it. So again, situational basis, but I would say if it's more than just a normal communications with someone regarding the case, then we need to put a little more encryption on it. Debt is security programs for small firms depends on the small firm.
33:41You can contact it people. There are third party vendors that can help you figure out what your firm needs and do that. I'm not going to recommend or endorse any one over the other. I worked at big firms, I've worked at small firms, and I know it's different levels of different things. And so sometimes if you're a bigger firm, or normally if you're a bigger firm, you probably need an onsite it person or department to deal with all your data, secure security concerns on a normal, everyday basis. If you're a smaller firm, you probably don't need an on site person all the time. You may maybe just peace of mind, but you can also contract out with a third party or a vendor to do that for you and not have someone you know on your staff or payroll as an employee to do it, like maybe a bigger firm would another. And then is necessary warrants if the information is of a confidential nature and comes through a firm's website. So this is, I'm assuming, where I know a lot of firms have, where clients or potential clients can say, hey, here's my name, here's my information, you know, and then it sends through a general website submission form with those two.
34:51Obviously you want it to go to maybe one person, one department have security protocols on that. On those two, I would probably drop a disclaimer saying anything you put in, this is confidential. However, please note, this is like an email communication subject to being hacked. We will do everything we can to make sure it doesn't, you know, some disclaimer on it too, so that the person knows that's sending it. The risk associated. I've also seen on those types of submissions too, some law firms saying, don't put confidential information in here. Don't attach confidential information to this email or to this communication.
35:24Only give us the basics, XYZ. We'll talk about it more in person once you receive your information at your initial consultation. So again, a disclaimer. Clear instructions can really help with those two suggested website disclaimers can be anything, but normally I would just say, especially if it's something for advertising, completely different than data security. But for advertising, obviously you put your advertising disclaimers, this is an advertisement. This does not create attorney client relationship. This should not be construed as legal advice, vice versa for data security, for those things. This is, you know, not creating attorney client relationship. We'll review your information. Please do not attach confidential information. This is subject, you know, to normal hacking things of emails, you know, and going through those things, those risks associated with it. That's the type of suggested disclaimer. I would put on a lot of those, especially if you have those portals coming in where clients can put information, or prospective clients for you to know what, to know what the initial consultation. Some other reasonable efforts here, too. Four seven r. I just kind of wanted to outline them for you. It talked about understanding the nature of the threat, understanding how the client information is transmitted and stored. So we got to have a little working knowledge of technology, understanding what's reasonable electronic measures could be determining how the communications labeling, too. This is something I haven't talked about.
36:55If you're sending emails of highly sensitive information, or just any email to your client, you can put in there confidential information or attorney client privilege in the subject line at the start of the email. Is that an end all, be all security fail safe? No, but it kind of flags it as this is confidential. So if there's ever an argument in court, you could say the intent of this communication was to be confidential, as said here, you know, upfront in the email. So that is just another protection you can put on there just in case, you know, that excuse comes to court. Sorry, I thought I was going to sneeze.
37:32Also, training your lower level staff, not attorneys and associates on technology too. Because we can learn all this. We can be knowledgeable as attorneys. But rule 5.1 and 5.3 tell us that we have to train and supervise subordinate lawyers. Meaning if you're a partner, the associates underneath you, and train and supervise non lawyer staff. Again, the associates underneath is 5.3, because if they violate the rules, they violate data security or confidentiality. Then we violate the rules and we hold the law license. We're going to be the one up in front of the disciplinary commission. We're going to be the one facing them. A practice lawsuit. It is going to be us.
38:12So we need to remember we do have those duties to train under rule 5.1 and 5.3. And what is training? It could be this right here. Giving a seminar, giving a CLe, giving an informal, you know, going to the staff meeting whenever it is, and talking for 10, 15, 20 minutes on it, or five minutes just running through things like, here are our firm policies. Remember to encrypt these emails. Remember to put confidential information on top of these. Remember to do XYZ. That's kind of the training, just so they know the importance of that confidentiality and data security. This is that duty to communicate, like I was talking about when I was answering the questions. We have a duty to communicate and consult with our clients about what we're doing.
38:56Doing that with technology can save you a lot of headache and trouble as well. So make sure you consider that. If you do have a cybersecurity breach, obviously, formal opinion, Aba tells us we need to disclose it. If you work in a bigger firm, disclose it internally, up the chain of command, up the lawyer chain. If you have a management committee, general counsel, if you're a one or two person shop, then obviously just hold down the hallway at your partner and say, hey, we have a data security concern. And then after that point, you've got to take steps. You need to have a plan of action put into place. Plan of action is going to include things like, okay, whose confidential information was breached, what client information, or which clients were affected.
39:41We need to start parsing that out. We also need to, if the breach is continuing, like a worm or a hacker got in and is looking through your files, let's get that cut off, let's get that out of there. If that remains contacting your internal it department or a third party vendor or a third party, you need to get that cut off. You need to get the hacking out done. If it was just a grab and like a grab job and leave type of breach, then obviously that's cut off. Let's seal the hole where they came into on the internal it department. Let's get that sealed off and taken care of, then assessing whose data was taken, what was viewed. If you don't know, then you've got a broad stroke of all your client information that could personally be hacked.
40:25If it is something to, if you're working of something of high level national security in your firm, I don't know what all of you do, but if you're doing something for the government and that there may be a whole other level of reporting you have to report to if government information was stolen, because some attorneys do work for the government and federal government with highly sensitive information. So you need to make sure you get those things figured out. Seal off the hacks, seal off the breach, figure out what client information was taken and what clients affected, and then we have that duty to communicate. We have a duty to communicate and disclose. So that means we've got to now tell the clients whose information was seen, hacked or taken about the breach and determine what we're going to do from there.
41:12When you do contact those clients, if they have what are called outside counsel guidelines, and if you know what that is, you just know in those, normally there will be a provision, and these are terms and conditions from the client to the attorney. Like this is the client's own terms and conditions. Usually in those, there's a paragraph or there is a section saying, you know, if a data breach occurs, you need to go back to those for the clients who are affected and figure out what you, how you need to report for that client's procedures. Sometimes it is reported immediately, sometimes it is report only if XYZ occurred.
41:49So you look at those procedures too, to figure out how that communication is going to go back to the client. Once you figure out what information was hacked, what information was done, determining what occurred, my recommendation is when you go back to that client, have a plan of action in place. Tell the client, yes, this occurred. We know, we duly apologize. We sealed it off. We're working on it. This is what we're doing. So this never happens again. In the future, have that next step ready for that client saying, we are owning up to this. Here's what we're doing. Here's what we can do to try to help you. Here's what we're doing.
42:22So this never occurs again or hopefully never occurs again in our firm with your information. So having all that in place, when you go back to the client is going to go a long way because bad news, one does not get better with time, so don't procrastinate. But two, if someone came to me and says, yeah, we've been hacked, and I say, well, what are you doing? So it doesn't happen again, you're like, well, I don't know yet. That's not very confident. I'm not going to keep that attorney. That doesn't give me confidence, that doesn't bode well. So we need to think about those things as well. Let's go through a few common scenarios here. We've talked about a lot of these already, so we'll just kind of go through them real quick and do a little bit with AI here at the end of the seminar. John works at a large firm. His one afternoon he notices an email from his is so his information systems. The message states that his email has been compromised and instructs him to immediately set his username and password. Same scenario I was saying earlier, John clicks on it, next day comes in, 3000 client files have been stolen because he clicked on that email.
43:22They trace it back to his terminal where it happened. What did he do wrong? He blindly clicked on it. Ethical response? Obviously we need to stop the breach. We need to figure out whose client information was affected. We need to make our notifications and figure out a plan so it doesn't happen again. We need to have that plan in place for John. He made to go, need to go through some IT security training. Maybe he needs to go through a class, a seminar up those things. Maybe the whole firm needs more IT security training also too. With that, just know this does happen. The bigger firm you are, the more often it's going to happen. And sometimes it doesn't happen with the lawyers, but with your staff because the staff aren't thinking like us, thinking of confidentiality, that hackers are coming at us 24/7 so training your staff and making sure they don't click on these links, they're not susceptible to these ploys of hackers.
44:14Is going to be half of your battle, if not the whole battle. Improper disposal. I've kind of already gone through this one too. Betty is a paralegal at Mickey Mouse LLP. She regularly handles client medical records and sensitive data, so protected health information. Occasionally Betty must dispose of the health information the printed versions of. She understands the information is sensitive, so the nearest receptacle though is all the way down the hall. So she wants to keep a cardboard box and just throw them in there, only walk down the hall once a week or, you know, once every so many days, three days or so, because it's just too many steps for her fitbit. She doesn't want that many steps per day, and so she just throws them in the bin under her desk, like I was talking about earlier.
44:54Well, again, custodial staff at night, pick them up, throw them in the dumpster out back. We have an improper disposal situation. So again, it's not always the attorneys. It is the staff, too. What did Betty do wrong? She didn't take those extra steps to dispose of the information properly as it was coming up. Day to day ethical obligations of the supervising attorney. Train her, correct the situation, make sure there's new protocol in place where Betty takes him down every day, or move the receptacle closer to her desk. If Betty doesn't want to walk that far, let's make those accommodations there. Also, too, if it was dumpster diving, stolen, whatever information was in there, we need to make that notification, let the clients know, figure out what we're going to do moving forward, if we have to do a triage situation or what that's going to look like, depending on what information was taken.
45:47Breach of confidentiality. Linda is a law partner at her law firm. One day she receives a phone call from client Bob, who was tearful and careful and clearly upset when the call came in. Linda was actually in a doctor's office, and so there was other people in the waiting room around her. However, she still took the call, was talking out loud, repeating facts about the case, repeating Bob's information, and this is a verbal conversation that other people can hear after the call, too. Linda opened up her laptop as she was sitting in the office, but there was people sitting behind her who were looking over her shoulder, looking at her computer screen, which, again, high client confidential information on it.
46:21What did she do wrong? This is a breach of confidentiality. It's not the data security hacker situation, but we cannot disclose client confidential information in any context here. Linda should have taken the call later, outside the earshot of third parties, because now she's in inadvertently waived confidentiality, and she shouldn't have been working on her computer if other people could see the screen at the time. We've got to protect. So if this was a live seminar where we're all in the same room and all of you whipped open your computers and started working, and the next person is only like 3ft behind you and can see your computer screen, we'd have a lot of real 1.6 violations going on right now because I guarantee you probably about 80 90% of you have your computer. Obviously it's open, you're online, they have client files up on your desktop right now working as I'm talking, just saying.
47:11And, you know, if someone's sitting behind you, they can probably see your screen, which could be a breach of confidentiality. So that's also how data security links come out too, is where people can see the different things that we have on our screens, can hear the conversations we have. And so that's something we want to guard against. The misdirected email scenario, like we talked about before hitting that autofill reply all feature, not a good situation. What should he do? Wait, do it later. Disable those features. You can disable them through Microsoft and different apps. So just knowing that as well, lost or stolen devices. This is where you're traveling out of town, leaving a taxicab, on a train, on an airplane, wherever you're going.
47:54Don't have it password protected. What did you do wrong? One, not have it password protected. We should password protect everything. Two, we just need to keep track of our belongings. But what should you do after those situations? Obviously, report it to your firm, your it. Hopefully they can remote disconnect it. Figure out if it'd been accessed during that time of period of being lost. Think about what's on the phone or if you can figure out what data and what clients are affected. And then do your reporting obligations, making sure you go through, you know, everything that you need to at that point. Some other common elements for response plan. Some of you may ask, well, what do I need in my response plan? You should have, like, if a data breach happens, that's the response plan. Like, what do we do next?
48:40Assign responsibility. Who's going to do what? Don't think your partner is doing something when they think you're doing something, who is doing what? What steps are being taken? What are those internal reporting procedures, the criteria for activating the plan, internal personal resources, communications, external resources needed. Do we need vendors, third parties to help us? Notification, mitigation, restoration, training, and periodic reviews. These are things you should think about in any data security or data response plan. These are things you really need to consider putting in. There it is. Again, not a one size fits all. We have to consider all these things. If you break it down, you need to identify the harms, protect against them, detect them when they happen, respond to them and recover, identify, protect, detect, respond, recover. Those are the core five steps that you need in any response plan or any data security plan to make sure you have things covered. Identify, protect, detect, respond, recover. Think about those things. Maybe have that as the motto of your plan. Put it at the top where you say this plan is to identify, protect, detect, respond, recover, and then go through each one in turn. And you should be okay as long as you have those reasonable procedures. If something does happen again, just know.
50:02Inadvertent disclosures. Now, if you inadvertently disclose something to opposing counsel, and opposing counsel gets it and knows it was an inadvertent disclosure or they weren't meant to receive it, depending on what your jurisdiction you're in, they have different requirements. Some jurisdictions say that that attorney receiving inadvertent disclosure has a duty to immediately stop reading it and notify the opposing counsel. Other jurisdictions say they can read it all they want, but then they have to follow the direction of opposing counsel once they get noticed it was formerly inadvertent.
50:35Others say you're out of luck. The opposing counselor can use it for whatever they want, anything they want. They don't have to do anything you say, depending on what jurisdiction you're in, depending on how, if you get something inadvertently from opposing counsel that you know is confidential and that you should not have received, how you should respond. So you really need to look, I think it's rule 4.4, your obligations in your specific jurisdiction, because jurisdictions are all across the board on that issue. So I would really counsel you. If that does occur, read your rule, contact your local attorneys that do professional ethics or your local bar association, if they have an ethics hotline and figure out what needs to be done. So again, stop reading do memos, do different things. You need to look at all those things.
51:23When that happens, make sure you do it promptly. If you send something inadvertently, notify whoever you send it to inadvertently properly, so that you can hopefully stop the damage or stop the bleeding before it gets too severe. Know that sanctions can come occur too. If you are the receiver of inadvertent information and you don't comply with the rule, you can be sanctioned. So just keep that in mind as well. I know we have only like five, six minutes left, but I did want to kind of talk about just AI a little bit here on data security, since it's such a big thing with AI, we have obviously concerns about privacy. We have cookies, the right to be forgotten laws in the UE if you're a global thing, that we have to comply with general data protections, the GDPR children, online privacy. So a lot of online stuff and AI stuff, we have privacy concerns. We also have surveillance concerns, surveillance concerns can be anything. Do you have cameras in your office?
52:17Do you use AI and programs to track your employees keystrokes on their computer? Technology, facial recognitions? Those things can also be a concern when it comes to AI data privacy. AI is also affecting copyrights, trademarks, infringements, too, because we can now create things and you cannot copyright or trademark anything that AI created, so you can't trademark it as your own. So it's going to be also affecting a lot of practices. Cybercrime, which is more what we're going to focus on here, that's that malware, that fraud, those fishing, those deep spaces, voice cloning, these are things you need to consider, too. And the risk of a cyber event happening is grave.
52:58And the cost of it can be devastating because it's going to cost to fix things. Loss of revenue, breach, notifications, all different things. So let's take a look at some of the AI stuff that can happen that's really going to affect your practice. And this one, hopefully you can hear it through the system. I'm going to play a little video. Let's see if I can get this to place.
53:26This is a video regarding scamming and AI.
53:31Maybe not, but what it is is like I said, I don't think everyone can hear it, but I will have the Lexbid can get the link to the YouTube video, but it goes through. The difference between voice cloning and deepfake is where all you need is a snippet of someone's voice. So say, for instance, you were recording my voice, and then you take my voice, you put it into an AI program, and then you can tell the AI program, make this voice say XYz. And it does in my voice. And I never said it. That's voice cloning. And all you need is a snippet. Just like 30 seconds to a minute of recording. The other one that it talks about is deep fake or facial cloning. So you could actually take my voice, do the voice cloning, take my face, and AI can make my lips move and say what you want me to say as if I was saying it in my own face and in my own body. And so with that too, this is going to be huge for security because you could think you're getting instructions from, say, a boss or someone and it not really be from that person. So there is voice cloning things out there, deepfakes, that are going to really have an effect on everything. Some other things to think about, too, is technology. The more technology you use in the firm or your law firm, you've got to think, too. Okay. So if you employ that, you have to have a QR code or that your clients do the encryptions or different things, and they don't have access to that, maybe they don't have a smartphone, they don't have things. That's called the
55:06digital dividend. What we have is, you know, probably the cutting edge technology, but a lot of our clients will not have cutting edge technology. And so we have this digital divide where not everyone, geographically or economically, has the same things that everyone else does. And so we've also got to tailor what we do in our firms to what our clients have in the sophistication. Now, there are benefits to using technology, but again, you need to tailor it to sophistication. Improved legal research, streamlined contract review. These are all things that can come with AI and different things, but they all come with security concerns as well.
55:44So we just have to think about that when we're doing stuff. And so, and also think of where do you stand with the use of AI platforms, the use of AI, this advanced technology with all the data, security risk, and you need to make a determination for your firm what that's going to look like and what you're going to do. And so, too, with that, have policies and procedures in place, have trainings in place, have those things there to help your firm and do all of those things that come with it. And I hope everyone has a great day.