Clarence L.MS
Wow, that was fantastic! An awesome comprehensive overview of critical issues.
1h 52min · about 9,700 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Good morning. Good afternoon, wherever you may be. This is Bob Fitzpatrick, and I'm your presenter today. And we're going to talk about the settlement of individual. Okay, emphasis on that employment disputes, we're not going to discuss settlement of class or collective actions, we ought to have a totally separate program that discusses that topic. So we're going to concentrate on individual employment settlements. I'm Bob Fitzpatrick, and as you'll see, when you get the written materials, about settlement that have been written by me, you'll see my bio in there, suffice it to say that I've been around the block quite a few times have settled, hundreds, probably 1000s of employment disputes have written extensively on the subject have a chapter in a book on settlement of disputes. And many, many other webinars, presentations and papers on this subject. Okay. Let me issue my verbally what will also be in the written materials, my disclaimer of any derivative responsibility or any responsibility at all for that matter?
1:46Suffice it to say in in simple terms, they disclaimer is if you rely upon something that I say here today, and it blows up in your face, it's blown up in your face, I have no responsibility for it. I think everything else say here today is based upon my very substantial experience in settling employment cases. But some of my ideas, some of my experiences might not work perfectly for you or your client. So make sure you've thought it through. To the extent there's any law involved, make sure you've researched your local law, the bottom line is, I can make mistakes just like anybody else. And I'm not responsible for any mistake, or a miss reading on your part of what I have to say here today. Okay. Before we get into a discussion of some of the terms that you would normally see being negotiated in a settlement agreement, let's talk about what I think is quite frankly, more important than the settlement negotiations themselves. And that is the pre settlement, discussions, arrangements agreements between you and your client. And if what I'm about to say shows a little bit of a tilt in the direction of employees understand that my background in practice is not exclusively representing employees and executives. But certainly, if you counted up the number of cases, compared to my management experience, the employee experience would outweigh it. Having said that, understand that for Oh, seems like 15 years or so. I represented one of our major employers 20 Some 1000 employees here in the Washington DC area. So I think I bring some
4:54balance to the program because I do have not a whole employee perspective on this. But I understand that I have a management perspective on some of these issues. So let's start with first principles. Number one, most sane in quotes, clients want a reasonably expeditious settlement. And most sane clients do not want to go to court, or, as is now the case, to arbitration. And I think this applies to both sides, arbitration has become very, very expensive. And that expense may be borne entirely by management. So I think it is fair to say that both sides would like to say a fair and reasonable expeditious resolution of the dispute that avoids proceedings at an EEOC or your local anti discrimination agency here in DC, the DC Office of Human Rights, that avoids the administrative proceedings that avoids court and avoids arbitration. And for that matter, also avoids mediation, mediation, while is a useful vehicle to get to settlement, understand from the perspective of both sides, like arbitration, mediation is very expensive these days, some of these mediators are charging up to 1000 bucks. For their time, I'm seeing substantial bills from mediators, which typically have to be borne by the employer, that's part of the deal. If you get to a settlement, you know, maybe the employee picks up five 10%. But the lion's share of the mediation fee is picked up by the employer. And if you're representing the employee, understand that that outlay of money for the mediator potentially depreciates the amount of money that's
8:03available for settlement. So a smart, sophisticated sane client wants to avoid all of these and has hired counsel for themselves. To try to effectuate a fair and reasonable and quick, expeditious resolution of the dispute. That can't happen all the time. But I've certainly had a lot of success in doing so and being able to avoid litigation for my clients. And I think one of the reasons that I have been successful is the work that I put into a client's case prior to the initiation of settlement discussions. Okay. And the first thing that I do and the first thing I think that you should be doing, regardless of which side you're on, but most particularly if you're the on the employees side, and you're gonna be in discussions asserting some sort of claim, common law or statutory or both.
9:44You need to do your due diligence. And, you know, due diligence can be very sloppy and is going to come back to bite you I spend a lot of time at the front end, in learning from my client. What are the facts? And what are the critical documents, some of which my client may have? Many of which my client may not have? And who are the key witnesses? Can we talk to them or not? Cannot? Can my client talk to them or not? And typically, what I do is I will send written questions to the potential client. And I want answers. And I want detailed answers to those questions. And I will get answers to that first set of questions. I'm a detail oriented guy. I think that's one reason I've been successful. I can spot issues and spot problems and spot pluses and claims that maybe no one else has yet seen, I will get that set of answers to my first set of questions. And probably in 100% of cases, that will then precipitate by sending out to the potential client to the PC, a second set of questions that follows up on the first and I may go through multiple sets of questions. To get all of the facts and test the correctness the veracity of the answers I'm getting? Are these answers that are pure speculation? Are these answers that are Forgive me Looney Tunes? Or are these answers that are anchored in hard facts? And then with that intake, and very early on, you need to raise this issue. I try to raise it in one of the very early communications with the client. And that is, what documents does the client have? You don't want in my judgment, you don't want the client to send
13:07you any document until you have approved that it's okay for the client to send it to you. It may be a document that the client is not supposed to have. It may be a privileged communication between the employer as counsel with you know, somehow the client got the document. These may be documents that the client took in so called self help discovery and from the management's perspective documents that the client stole. During typically, the last few days, when the client was working for the employer. They're going to know that they're gonna seize in most cases, a sensible employer is going to seize your clients desktop laptop, and is going to review it to see was there any suspicious activity or a series of documents downloaded onto an external hard drive for example, in the last few days, were a cache of documents sent by the client to himself, his spouse, his kids, you know, to some sort of a home to Computer, they're going to know, typically, that your client has documents that they say your client ought not to have. And, as you probably know, the courts are, I think it's fair to say deeply divided on the issue of self help discovery, some self help discovery, for example, under the False Claims Act, is probably permissible, some health, self help discovery is gonna get not only your client, but you potentially in substantial trouble. And I'm not going to name any names, but suffice it to say, there are some employee lawyers out there who have had to pay dearly, because they took from the client documents that the client stole, okay.
16:18And used the documents, use them to evaluate, use them to assert claims, even use them in court proceedings. And there are cases out there, some reported, many not reported, where employee lawyers have paid dearly for that. And there may be sanctions against the employee. They may be sanctions in terms of instructions that can be given to a jury evidence that may be offered at trial. And they may also be monetary sanctions. So you need to be very aggressive at the outset about what documents does your client have? And how did your client obtain my own personal video? There is Danzel disagreement amongst employee lawyers about this. Okay, so I'm not saying I'm the font of you know, wisdom on this, but this is my personal view. If my client has documents, that in my judgment, the client ought not to have a, I wanna, okay, B, I want my client to return them lickety split. To management, I couldn't go into great detail, I don't think this is the appropriate setting, because we're talking about settlement. But I think that can be done, where you and your client, get as close to the high road, if you will, and that's where you want to get on these issues about. purloining is the word that you often see documents from the employer. Okay. Next very early on, you want to get a reading on client expectations. In my experience, most clients are not, you know, on the moon or off in some galaxy that will never be discovered by astronomers. Some are and if they are rock solid on ridiculous expectations of the value of their claims.
19:34And you can't readily convince him otherwise. My own personal view is by by those of the clients to say sorry, but I'm not willing to represent you. I never give clients the my reasoning as to why I have declined to represent them, that seems to me only to be an invitation to debate and potential trouble down the stream. Okay. I also have a conversation with clients. And I think this is a conversation that both sides ought to have. And that is the word principal is spelled two different ways, PLA and P Al. And I tell my clients 99.999% of cases, and your case is about principles spelled pa L, this is about money. Okay, and forget about, you know, you're gonna write this book, and you're gonna write this magazine article, and you're gonna go on TV, and et cetera, et cetera. If that's the route you're going to take on, if that's what they're stuck in, and it's not a high are a number of high profile cases, these days, particularly sex harassment cases, were using that as a lever, or being able to do that, even after a settlement is a seen a quinnen for the client, that's fine. There are there is a small subset of such cases. But if you're not in that small subset, and normally or not, if the client is stuck on, you're gonna write this book and expose these people, etc. I'm gonna go on Glassdoor and anonymously, you know, trash them. Once again, in my judgment, this is a client, you do not walk, you'll want a client who is oriented on typically a monetary settlement. And as you'll see when we get into details of settlement agreements,
22:45and obviously there are non monetary provisions that can have a substantial impact on an employee's work life going forward into the future. I know, when we get into a discussion of the terms of a settlement agreement, obviously, one of the things that management wants is confidentiality. I understand I will discuss that. My practice is I have actually entered into written agreements with the other side to this effect. But typically, it's not reflected in in a agreement with the other side. It's just a an agreement between myself and my client. And that is confidentiality starts right now. starts before there is any discussion about settlement much less, there is the settlement agreement. And I want that confidentiality, to apply to particularly co workers who may be spies. Here, just you know, no. And if your client is talking with a co worker, and talking about what their expert you know what they actually really want in dollars to settle a case. Poof there, there goes your leverage to probably get what your client wants your clients bottom line is, much less be a hero and do better than that. So you want to carefully modulate, monitor your clients communications with other people. You may want your client talking with potential witnesses, as long as you know you've not crossed the ex parte communication ethical line. And that's for a whole nother program.
25:20But co workers, former employees, and understand I don't like collateral damage. Understand that many former employees have signed some sort of a severance agreement that may have a confidentiality non disclosure clause, which may be enforceable might not be but maybe enforceable, and your client by talking to them, maybe asking them in effect to violate that agreement. They may violate it without giving any thought to the fact that they're in violation of the agreement. And then the case doesn't sell goes to litigation. And one typically, one of the questions to your client in interlocutory deposition is, you know, disclose everyone that you've communicated with about this matter, bango discloses the former employee, and management and maybe pursues some sort of revocation issue with the former employee for violating that.
26:53valuation. This goes back to my principles spelled two different ways. You need to pick the client's gonna have, this is the classic that always gets talked about a newspaper article that shows that attorney Joe or Jane schmo just got a verdict for 3 million bucks Sena, some other employment case. So the client is going to have potentially elevated expectations, you need to take the client through one of their hard damages in terms of lost pay and benefits. One of the hard damages looking forward into the future. And punitive damages rarely happens. I uncertain that, in some cases, forgive me. I've negotiated on punitive damages in settlement negotiations, but 99% of the time, the subject simply does not come up is not a value value on the table, in terms of determining what the opening demand may be. Where we are seeing right now, the big big verdicts being returned, putting aside back pay and front pay, where we're seeing the big verdicts right now. And the exposure that management has is emotional distress damages.
29:04And I think in this for the discussion before, there's a demand letter, whatever. You need to have a conversation with the client in terms of how severe is the emotional distress? Do you have a diagnosis? Are you in treatment? Are we going to if it goes to it add command letter, a mediation letter? complaint, if it goes to litigation, are we going to be alleging severe emotional distress? I'm making this simple. I've written extensive worry about this. You're welcome to send you materials if you email me. Rule 35 mental exams. I'm not afraid of them. I don't think the client properly prepared should necessarily be afraid of them. But they are a reality. They are a tool, they're to be used by management. And if you are alleging severe emotional distress, if you're going to put an expert witness on, on the subject, if you have highfalutin diagnosis, if you will have severe emotional distress, substantial likelihood, then that management is under Rule 35. The federal rules. And pretty much I think every state has a state a now analogy to rule 35 mental exams. Your client has put himself herself at risk of a mental exam. And, you know, some clients may get the heebie jeebies. And simply, you know, you didn't tell me. I had you told me I wouldn't have gone down this road. So you need to make that disclosure, it seems to me at the front end. This is my own personal opinion, substantial disagreement amongst lawyers about this. It seems to me if you're not going that road, and you're going this so
31:57called garden variety, emotional distress road, that I think eventually the law is not there yet. But I think eventually, there is the potential the law is going to evolve to if you have run your case with garden variety, emotional distress, which means, you know, the courts have said this, it's the distress that the ordinary person incurs when they get fired, which means that just about everybody who gets fired from their job has this level garden variety of emotional distress. And then the jury returns a whopping award of emotional distress damages. Is the law going to evolve to the point where the courts then at remitter reduce that award? Because the allegation was garden variety, emotional distress. I think you just have to have these conversations with the client, so that the client can attack you later for failure to make these disclosures.
33:35Next. First, put in writing. Secondly, say to your client repeat after me. Bob Fitzpatrick is not a tax lawyer. Bob Fitzpatrick is not a tax lawyer. Bob Fitzpatrick is not a tax lawyer. Thank you. Okay. Then it's now clear it's in writing. You've said it three times, you will understand. I'm not a tax lawyer. I'm not giving you tax advice. You need to know for talking substantial money. You may need to be talking to a tax lawyer or a CPA and accountant somebody who is familiar with the tax implications and can answer sometimes very difficult tax questions arise in these cases. In my experience, in a small percentile of cases, difficult tax issues arise, but they do. And if you're not a tax lawyer, you don't want It'll be held responsible for giving that advice I would share with the client I R S documents and arrows series of good IRS documents that explain the typical taxation, issues that arise in employment cases. The client, many clients think it's not taxable. All of the money or some of the money, they need to know early on that in all likelihood, this is something you'll need to talk to your tax lawyer. But in all likelihood, all the money is taxable. One way there may be w 210 99. Or part w two part 1099. But understand that, also, I think early on, you need to make sure the client knows that your fee that there are 1099 May Issue if it settles, and there's payment of fees to you. There may be a 1099 issue to you, the lawyer and the client.
36:39That's IRS has position, the client gets a 1099 for your fee and kind of Holy Toledo. I gotta pay fees on fees. That's crazy. And then there's discord with the client. Client needs to have been explained early on that that 1099 fees of your fee is a total wash for them. Excuse me in terms of tax liability. Your retainer should address as much of this as sensible. Certainly your retainer should say you're not a tax lawyer. Your retainer also may want to address who is responsible? And how do you get paid? If there are counterclaims, okay. You may want in these pre negotiation discussions with the client explained to the client what a tolling agreement is, and you should have a form ready. This is many, many times one of the first things you want to assist you in settlement negotiations. Otherwise, you may be under time limits, statute of limitations wise to file with court or to assert a claim in arbitration, or to file a charge with EEOC or your local agency. You need to be certain that your tolling agreement is going to be respected by the courts, administrative agencies and so totally in agreement, for those of you who don't know, freezes the clock and says no longer is the statute of limitations, the time limits whatever they may be not on our running anymore. While we are attempting to settle this matter, and we have to give notice to one another that the clock is now rerunning and the clock doesn't start to rerun for X number of days after such notice is given you've got sufficient
39:48time to do whatever needs to be done in terms of timely filing. Another thing that I explore carefully with clients, because is an issue that seems to come up. And a huge percentage of cases, and that is exhaustion of administrative remedies. And not a lot of be one of the first, you know, when you're doing your due diligence, your fact analysis. What if they filed with the EEOC or federal government, which is, you know, this is DC, then will to the counselor, the EEO complaint, did they allege everything that is now being raised? If they did not exhaust their administrative remedies? You just need to be aware of that. And take it into account. You also need to look at this the client have a 401 K. What's the match? And to the extent you're into it, look at the recent Supreme Court decisions US versus Northwest on retirement plan options. If the client has stock options, you need to have the stock option plan. Know what the strike price is the market price vesting basically need to be able to value what's what is the loss, if any, as a result of termination before stock options have a vested? If your client is a salesperson Commission's you need to look at the plan. And bonuses. You need to look hard at many issues. But one is paramount, it seems to be a NAT is is the bonus discretionary. And as you probably know, the law is not good. In most jurisdictions in most settings for him, or he's if the bonus is discretionary. Okay. a demand letter. And
42:57I guess I put it this way I am of two minds about this. When I was a young lawyer, and nobody knew me, and I had no reputation. I wrote all Boreas demand letters that you know, laid out the facts laid out the law. And I don't do that anymore. Most of my demand letters now and I'm not saying you can, okay. But my demand letter, typically to the General Counsel, whomever it just says, I've been retained by so and so blah, you know, whatever. And let's schedule a time for you or your counsel and I talk period. That's it plain vanila. No assertions of claims, no assertions of fact, I haven't given them a target to shoot at. And I can't think of an exception I'm sure there has been. But for the most part, that then starts a discussion between my office and counsel on the other side.
44:44That is, in part, probably because I've been around forever. And I have I'm known and I have a reputation. So I'm not suggesting that that's what everyone Who is listening to this can necessarily do. But understand that that fact base claim based demand letter is a fixed target for them to shoot at one. But I think another concern you need to have is a number of courts recently have said, well, you obtained in litigation X. But in your command letter, you asked for Y, way above x, so you didn't achieve your goal. And therefore, I judge am going to reduce your legal fee for failure to totally succeed. So I would be very careful with the demand letter. I also try to send out at that point in time, and maybe early or at that point in time, a preservation letter, but I don't just send it to management. And that's why he said maybe at an earlier time, I also send it to my client. You know, what I'm representing an employee, and I tell the employee client, you're not to delete, destroy, make more difficult to access. You're not taking to take that hard hammer to that hard drive, I've had that happen. You're not to take that hard drive and throw it in the trash. So I've seen in numerable, employee II, deletion destruction of evidence. Okay, so this is a two way street, and you need to be very much aware of that. And that's what it seems to me. I can't cite you chapter and verse ethical decisions. But it seems to me that may be in the area of legal responsibilities, ethical responsibilities we have. So record preservation. There are a number, you know,
48:01you have a template of form. And then make sure your template is also addressed to the particular circumstance of this case. You know, they're all the people who you want specific people who need to be told by counsel on the other side, to preserve their documents, you may want to send the record preservation letter to a number of third parties. There may be people who no longer work for the employer. There may be people who never worked for the employer, but are key to this dispute. You don't want to send them a record preservation letter, that they may or may not have obligations to preserve.
49:05There's a lot of dispute about third party social media discovery. But, you know, step one seems to me is record preservation, you want to be looking at and probably in your decisional process as to whether you're going to take clients case, you want to be looking at their Facebook, their Instagram, you want to be looking at all of their social media. The other side may not get access to it. The courts are trying to find a role. And I think the role they're moving towards is is that at issue Is there some evidence that suggests that there is a likelihood there's something in the employees, Facebook, whatever social media that may be relevant to this dispute, then and only then I think, are most courts allowing this sort of pretty intrusive discovery, and this social media, but you at the outset, need DUIs. So all this is gonna get out there. And you need to see it first.
50:40And, you know, can we deal with this? Or is this just going to be a killer, and therefore a reason excuse me not to take the client's case, I have actually in a few cases, but in
51:05to be significant, I have actually said the clients, I am going to take possession of your cell phone, and you just go buy a new one. And I'm gonna put this you know, in safekeeping safety deposit box, whatever. Maybe only two people, you know, can even access it in a safety deposit box. So that we have preserved everything. Nothing has been deleted or destroyed. And you really can't delete everything. Well, you know, that turns it you ediscovery it just becomes more expensive to retrieve it. But I may actually seize that evidence, if you will, of for safekeeping, so there never can be any suggestion that the client mucked around with it. Okay. You've now started to talk with the other side. And let me just quickly jump to mediation because that seems like so many matters now do go to mediation.
52:45As I expressed at the beginning, it's expensive and it may depreciate the money that's on the table for your client. But among the things you need to be thinking about is who's going to pay and the other side, and I want my client to have, quote, skin in the game, maybe five 10% of the mediation fees, but you want your client not to be a free rider on this. Preparation for mediation is crucial preparation of the mediation statement, typically, in my experience, it is ex parte only goes to the mediator. And then with a good mediator, you want to be able to have an understand the other side will to have conversations with the mediator about what's the mediators reaction to your mediation statement? What does he or she feel is missing? What problems does the mediator as the mediator identified? What issues can the mediator discuss with you that the mediator has learned as a result of the other side's mediation? You want to have that kind of dialogue with the mediator before the day of mediation and and going way back to the beginning on mediation, obviously, the choice of the mediator is huge. I personally dunk, like, most not all, former judges as mediator. If they've been away from judging and have been mediating for a long period of time, then my view may be different. But if they are just off the bench, and have flipped over to now being a mediator, they still maybe, and I emphasize maybe they're former judge mediators and their former and judge me years, but they may be still not so much oriented to how do I
56:07settle this mess? Because I don't want to be the orientation of the mediator as the job of the mediator is to facilitate mediation, but they may still be in kind of a black robe, Judge mode of what's right and wrong, what's the decision? Now, who wins who loses? And that's the kind of mediator you do not want. The other side, May will, okay. But the choice of a mediator is huge. Most, maybe all, don't do it anymore. But I had success with you are a mediator until four o'clock in the afternoon, hypothetical. At four o'clock in the afternoon, if we haven't been able to settle this mess, bango, you're taking mediator hat off, you put your arbiter had on. And on a single piece of paper, you just write a number that's in case over the arbiter decided that the award is whatever.
57:43As I say, I don't think very many of the mediators provided by Jehanne was AAA, the major ADR providers, I don't think that they will do that anymore. Okay. As I said at the start another tax lawyer, but most of my settlements, I don't personally like the single check settlement, where then the money has to be divvied up between the client and the lawyer. I think that is an invitation to potential disputes with the client, even though you've got a rock solid representation agreement, or you're on hourly basis, or whatever it may be. So my settlements are typically a check to the lawyer, and then a check or checks and typically, it's checks to the client. The check to the lawyer is my fee. It results in the issuance of a 1099 to me, and if management is doing it, right, same 1099 goes to my client and as they said, You need to explain to the client they're not going to get hit with tax on tax. Then there are checker checks and typically it's checks to the client and typically there will be a web to check that is we settled half for this month. Hey, let's just hypothetically say is wages and therefore w two issues there's withholding. So we settled for 50,000 in wages and there's you know withholdings on that. I like to try to monitor what the withholdings are gonna be. Sometimes it's difficult for the other side, because now it involves their payroll people, so on. But I want to make sure there isn't some big surprise for my client in terms of the withholding is from the W two money. And then the other check is what I call a 1099. Check.
1:01:03And there's no withholding, but it's going to be an all likelihood, taxable in the next tax season. Okay. And the client needs to understand that tax bump relief. And an increasing number of jurisdictions have come around to recognize tax bump relief. NLRB has added a number of courts, the devil is in the details on this one. And, you know, it may be a great card to play in settlement negotiations. You know, my client has been unemployed since you terminated my client five years ago and has back pay, you know, of, let's say 200k per year times five. And, you know, so is, let's say a million in back pay on the table. Yeah, we're gonna settle for something less than that. But the clients gonna pay mightily tax wise. And you, too, use say, Well, you know, Judge, if the client had been paid this year by year by year rather than all or a lump sum for five year period, taxation would have been dramatically different. And your judge may say, intuitively, I agree, but you know, the proofs in the pudding, I want to see some tax calculations presented and probably presented by an expert, so you may need it. Tax bump relief is a significant issue for negotiations, significant issue with mediator and mediation, you may need an affidavit from a CPA what have you that calculates what the tax bump is for your client Okay.
1:03:59When is the money to be paid? Big, big deal for the employee. Man management in some instances would love to delay as long as it can. So you want in your settlement agreement to have a line that says payment of the fee payment of the w into that 10 Nail whatever it may be to your employee is to be made on her before X date. And a failure to pay by x date is a material breach of the agreement and A some sort of penalty kicks in for a veil interest, liquidated, whatever liquidated, it's tough. And once you start to go down that road, as an employee, you know, it's a two way highway, liquidated damages are kind of come back at your client in other instances under the Settlement Agreement, and
1:05:32speaking provides help speaking for employee lawyers. They don't like liquidated damages, but some sort of sanction for not paying on time. You know, maybe the sanction is rescission. Although, you know, rescission can be a dangerous game. And if you're management, you don't want that payday to be shorter than the older worker benefit Protection Act. Lemon Law date, under the LW BPA. The employee can reject the settlement for seven calendar days after the agreement. So and, you know, lots of controversy about you know, does a revocation only revoke the ad at age discrimination? So, or does it revoke the entire agreement? We don't need to get into that here today. Suffice it to say that pay date needs to be more than seven days after the agreement is entered. So there's no there'll be a BPA issue. Health insurance oftentimes is an issue in settlement negotiations. Typically a cobra CLDR a notice of the employees health care continuation rights will issue in a substantial number of settlements, management is agreeable to pay the premium on health insurance for some number of the 18 months that typically the COBRA coverage is available. The premium in the experience of most of my clients is so high that most clients can't afford it. If the spouse has insurance coverage, and they're already on it, then it's not an issue if they're not on it. Now, when's the next enrollment period that they can get on? So you need in doing your due diligence to know the facts about health insurance also. And the issues that
1:08:53now comes up with frequency is the lien lie and clause that management is putting in settlements. And I understand their perspective. You know, if your client has been, you know, we could go home away from all the employment benefits in DC. We have a statute that, in effect says that out of the settlement that was on the employment benefits that were paid by DC have to be repaid. There's some nuance about the statute. You know, if you're in a jurisdiction where there is such a provision like DC you know, this is very then this is a very state specific matter. and you need to be aware of, you know, what is the state law and state interpretation of the administrator interpretation of that statute. The client may have Medicaid, Medicare, X expenses, and maybe inextricably tied to the case and the settlement payment, and therefore, there's a possibility of a lien by CMS. Hence, management wants to clarify that before payment is made, because bottom line, data will end up holding the bag and being responsible for that. Non disparagement this sometimes is a very difficult clause to negotiate. I like to negotiate it as a mutual clause. And initially, I got a lot of resistance to mutuality, I get little or none. Now. The argument is that he is the language management will make its best efforts Not to disparage or management will not disparage and dance where there's an area for dispute and settlement negotiations, if your client has a concern about Joe or Jane blow, has a real burn on about your client.
1:12:13And your client is legitimately concerned that that individual is going to trash them in some setting that may do harm to them. And you ought to be fighting hard in the settlement negotiations. For Yes, other people in management only have, you know, a best efforts Not to disparage responsibility, but this particular person is not to disparage your client. That's a very, very difficult negotiation. And part of the flip side of that is, what can your client say and not say? And does that apply to the clients family? And does that apply to the clients use of social media? Does that apply to the anonymous use by your client of social media? Now what can or cannot be in your clients LinkedIn profile? And, you know, maybe I'm being super cautious, but I try to get the other side to bless my clients social media, LinkedIn profile as not being in any way. Violating confidentiality non disclosure for non disparagement glass door has is a real concern for many, many companies, people can go on Glassdoor, and big time trash and employer anonymously. So the Settlement Agreement will prohibit the employee, former employee from disparaging even anonymously.
1:15:15How that get I have yet to ever have a case where there's ever been an allegation that anonymity provision has been violated. But I can only assume how messy that could be.
1:15:40Still on the non disparagement, moving back to management, I basically one HR, you know, name rank and serial number. Everybody now seems to be comfortable with neutral job references. You know, nobody can get a good reference, but nobody can get a bad reference anymore. It's kind of a stupid situation that the lawyers have taken us to, but it is what it is. So then the issue becomes, why did the employee leave? And the job application is in many circumstances now. Ask the prospective employee, your client. You know, have you been terminated? From a job in the last years? Have you negotiated the settlement or have you know, lotto? You know, very difficult questions. And I think it's fair to say, at the end of the day, I just kind of wash my hands of it. I do a punches pilot.
1:17:18I'm not, I cannot, and I am not counseling you, as your lawyer to lie. Okay. You do what you do. Understand, if you lie on a future job application, they may not get you
1:17:45immediately because of the neutral JOB reference and they can't get any meaningful information. But if they later discover, somehow that you lied on your application that could come back big time to haunt you. If you put on the and particularly in the federal government's very difficult situation and a lot of back and forth recently about
1:18:27clean records settlements and what the position was under the previous administration, what the position is, under this administration, that's an arcane but important issue in federal government settlements. of return of documents, both electronic and hardcopy. And I used to spend countless time on this with particularly with management who thought some years ago that you know, this. They discovered the answer to all their problems by raising this return of documents issue. I get at that early on with the client. And as I said, I want to know what they have. They may have the circumstance that exists now the technology is catching up with the problem. And I'm seeing employers now with you know, you have Your laptop, desktop, whatever provided by the company. And there's now technology that prevents the employee from downloading anything from that device, hallelujah. So it is a real impediment to the self help discovery. And I think that's, from my perspective, I know there's disagreement about this. From my perspective, I think that's good. Because then my client simply can't get and has no documents that he or she shouldn't have. But that technology is not widespread yet. It will be I think. So I have clients who have devices. Sometimes it's you know, bring your own device to work. They have devices that are a mixture of business documents, and personal documents. So that just used to be a nightmare a couple of years ago, in terms of how to you return. Maybe the device because maybe it's the companies and
1:21:49only the business documents, extracting the personal documents. And I had cases, thankfully, I think they're in the rearview mirror, where you know, it people external internal, would come to my office and sit with my client in a conference room for hours, going through the devices and separating out the business from the personal. I think we've now moved to the stage where that can be done by certification by the employee that all that had had has been done. Confidentiality, we're now at confidentiality in a settlement agreement. And you know, manchmal will have a long clause about you know, keeping everything confidential. I like having a simple sentence in the agreement that says that, at every one who is asked about the matter, their response is to be in so many words, quote, The matter has been resolved, period, close quote, nothing more, nothing less, not even resolved to my satisfaction, which if I'm management, lets the employees suggest with a wink and a nod. Boy, am I happy with the money I got this settlement. This matter has been resolved
1:24:01says absolutely nothing about who got what.
1:24:12No rehire clauses. First of all, kind of a word of warning. I think that with the new admin, administer stration. Now are getting control, if you will, at E or C. You think we may see some guidance? Maybe even some rulemaking on no rehire clauses in settlement agreements. I understand management's perspective. I don't want to settle with you. And then the eighth day after settlement, the effective date of the agreement. You knock on my door and apply for a job. And no way in hell are we going to hire you? Of course. I mean, we all know that. And so the individual doesn't get hired, and then files a retaliation claim.
1:25:43And here we go again. And so, that's the management's concern. And, you know, I don't think it is completely completely ill legitimate concern. So then the flip side of that is I have a no rehire. No, ever apply again, Claus with ABC Company. You know, ABC is a big company, national. Does this mean I can't you know, I live in work in DC. And I worked for ABC in DC. But, you know, five years from now, I may move to Seattle. And I can't work for ADC and Cl. So is there are no rehires, you may want to look at a geographic limit. You may want to also look at a time limit on this. And then the issue that comes up all the time in these discussions is, well, what if ABC, you know, what if okay, I go to work with XYZ and XYZ acquires ABC or ABC acquires XYZ. What's the impact on me in terms of the no rehire clause? So you need to in settlement discussions on the no rehire address that kind of merger acquisition issue that may arise? The release of claims. First of all, you as the lawyer, because this issue has come up in a number of cases, you as counsel need to, in writing, in my judgment, put your authority that has been conferred upon you by your client to settle, you know, dear client, this will confirm that, you know, I am authorized to offer blah, blah. But your bottom line that you're prepared to accept in a settlement is blah, blah, I have authority, if in my judgment, I can settle for anywhere between this number and this number. I don't need to come back to you for any further afar, and that gives you some modicum of protection against a client who
1:29:18says, you know, you settled my case, and you didn't have authority to do so. I'll sign settlements agreements. I don't make myself a party, I might sign you know, reviewed as to have approved as to form whatever, but I am not a signatory. Who has any responsibility for the terms of settlement my client does. I have authority written authority to enter into this and if it gets into a dispute at a significant dispute I've got that to show to a judge. In terms of the release, you need to understand that there are some claims that can't be released in this manner. And some claims that may be limited in terms of the the scope of the release the FLSA, there's case law out there that says, you can in an FLSA settlement settle 10 million other claims. Okay. It's an F L S, a settlement.
1:30:55Okay. And that you, you may know, there's no dispute as to whether an individual FLSA settlement has to be reviewed by a court or the Department of Labor or not. And just ask yourself, practically you've settled an FLSA claim. No, nowhere near litigation, you're nowhere near a court. Do you really either side, see any positivity in taking that individual claim to a chord for approval, or forgive me, DOL, God forbid, to the DOL. Particularly the DOL under sorry, but under this administration, I don't think you want to. So those courts that say you don't have to take an individual settlement to either quarter DOL, to me, makes a heck of a lot of sense. Claims that cannot be so worker comp,
1:32:34unemployment and a hill RV. And then when we get to the FLSA, I'm not going to discuss that. Suffice it to say there's a fair amount of case law about settlements out there and what effect settlement may or may not have an FLSA claim. Next withdrawal of the administrative charge many times your client will have filed with your state or local anti discrimination agency or will have filed when he was here. Both. Management wants all this to go away. You go as employee want to wait on one of these agencies say we've actually withdrawn and so the issue is they want a withdrawal. You want you have submitted in proper form a request for withdrawal of a subsidiary issue that comes up is
1:34:03Can someone disclose to the agency how much money past pains or disclose the actual agreement, but it's typically the dough. Why do they want it? Because they put it on their list as you know, they got a settlement in his case for X amount of body and they try to put it on their rap sheet to take responsibility for in terms of you know, hey, congressional appropriator, here's how much money we got for employees in the last fiscal year. So they're gonna want to know a lot of times how much money past hands so you want to give them Someone the latitude to make that disclosure. I have no difficulty at all in the management lawyer carrying that burden and not being mine. If you're actually in court and have settled, then needed the settlement agreement needs to have a dismissal, or and sometimes is, in a few cases, there is an issue as to whether the court is going to retain jurisdiction or not, in most cases, not so. And therefore. Any breach litigation May and in state court, federal court in light of the Sixth Circuit has a last year or so a tender back decision where simple turns I think they held that tender back does not apply in I think it's titled seven cases. I don't know if there was a petition for certain that case, but I think long enough time has gone by that if there was cert was denied. So you may want to address in the settlement agreement, the tender back issue. Know management's gonna want if there's a breach, you've got to tender back. You know, take a look at the Sixth Circuit opinion. You may want the
1:37:09country I don't know how you get term sheets. I hate them. My dad taught me never to say, hey, but you know, I hate term sheets. How many mediations have I been in or just one on one negotiations with the other side where you know, okay, everybody's tired, we got to catch a plane, whatever. So we take out a single sheet of paper, and we write what the terms of the settlement were. My worst example of that is my client flow in from wherever they had, their lawyer flew in from Chicago, one of their guys flew in from Atlanta, another guy flew in from Switzerland. And we negotiated all that we had a term sheet at the end of the day, six months later, six months later, a term sheet was finally converted into a settlement agreement. So when I go into serious negotiations, take your template of your settlement agreement, take this settlement agreement with all your clauses. And ideally, you'll want to come out at the end of the day with a signed settlement agreement, no term sheet, but certainly at a minimum, you want an agreement on the language of some of the key clauses. And then you want a potential I think, you want a good faith clause in the term sheet that you know, we will take this from term to a final agreement and resolve that expeditiously and in good faith. You may want to put a time limit on it. But I'm not a big fan of term sheets. Unemployment comp. We touched on that a little bit. Typically, the employer will say, No, we're not going to oppose a claim for unemployment. As I discussed, there may be a refund issue in
1:40:19some jurisdictions like DC, future cooperation, and transitional help. If you're a client, Sonya unusual, but it happens. Your client has been told on X day, your last day is going to be a month from now, I understand you're gonna go into negotiations, and you want to be on the high road, and you want your client to be well respected. Therefore, I advise my clients in those circumstances, that during that last few weeks at the employer, I want you to be the best employee that you can conceive of. And I want you to take the initiative to put together a transition plan, I want you to take the initiative, and let them know everything that's in your pipeline, et cetera. If you're being asked for after you've been let go for this boiler plate future cooperation clause, if it's only a few minutes, short period of time, you talking to maybe the company's lawyer about some other deal, whatever that you're involved in now as gotten in controversy, that's fine. But if a substantial amount of your time your clients time, is going to be involved in future cooperation, you want your client to be paid for that time, and for any expenses, travel or otherwise. Then there is the future not none cooperation clauses. And you know, to get to Solomon, I can go there, as long as my client understands. When you get a phone call from another lawyer who represents another employee of the company, and asked for your help, you basically have to say, sorry, I'm gonna have to subpoena me under compulsion of law, you know, you can be required to
1:43:20cooperate, it seems to me, the future non cooperation clause has to interact with the future cooperation clause and play off the two against one another. Let's talk about
1:43:44see, we got a few minutes left here. One last thing before I get to ethical issues, you know,
1:44:00much of this is not state specific, but you still need to be familiar with your state law. I noticed the other day that Washington state has a new law that prohibits settlement agreements that have a nondisclosure or non disparagement clause. I know nothing more than that, about that law. But certainly, if you are in Washington State, you need to be familiar with dispute resolution. Knock on wood, I don't think I have had a settlement that's ever gotten into any significant dispute resolution. System situations, but there always will be a clause in most agreements. Choice A lot choice of four And, you know, if your client worked in DC and headquarters and the company is in Seattle, they're gonna try to say, the law Washington state. And the form for fr un for dispute resolution is some court in Seattle. And that's going to be an issue in dispute. In these dispute resolutions, clauses, I like to have a cure permission, you've got to give, I've got to give you a written notice of what the breach is, what the violation is, and X number of days to cure. There may be a subset of some issues that simply I don't care if you you're, you know, it's a material breach, and you know, a, if I can prove it, you're gonna pay the price. But most breaches can be quickly cured. Then, if we do have a breach situation, maybe you want to have a mandatory mediation provision in before it goes either to arbitration, or back to a judge. Other agreements, always keep this in mind, both sides. What other agreements? are there out there? Is there a non compete agreement that
1:47:00your side good client signed early on? Do you want to renegotiate that? Do you want that to go away? Is there a non solicitation agreement? And do you want to walk it back? And maybe make changes? There's a probably a trade secret agreement. Just checking out to see if that presents any problems for you? The inventions agreement. We have started here in DC to have some very significant litigation, over inventions agreements. So you know, be sure you're familiar with it. And does it present any problems for your client? Then ethical issues? Oh. Hey, in settlement negotiations in discussions with opposing counsel, we are supposed to be ethically honest. Where is the line between fluffer theory and dishonesty? And I'm not going to try to draw that line for you. But certainly, you ought to know when you or your client are just flat out why you're not puffing. You're lying. And that's not ethical. civility, being courteous with one another. Many of our ethical codes fail. say that's a requirement of life. You know, this is this is about your client, not about you. So I mean, you may be angry, you may have your baggage, don't bring it to the client's case. Your job is to try to settle this. And regardless of what your feelings may be about opposing counsel, and you know, you may think the lawyer on the other side, the employee, lawyer, the management lawyer, you may think, here's the seeds, the schmuck don't bring that to the table. Turn the other cheek. It has no mileage whatsoever in my judgment. I and allowing it to get ongoing threats of
1:50:07criminal prosecution, et cetera, was simply not permissible requests that the employee lawyer never take another case against your company. verboten to absolutely unethical. Self Help discovery there are ethical issues there. And we'll leave it at that. I hope I've been helpful. I know it's been a long, two hours, a lot to digest. There's a lot in the written materials that you will get with this. If you have any questions, concerns, suggestions, criticisms, please feel free to contact me by email only at our Fitzpatrick at Robert B. Fitzpatrick. Don't forget that be Robert B. fitzpatrick.com. Please don't hesitate to email me with your comments, suggestions, so on. And so I say I hope I'm better with some little help to you here today. Enjoy the rest of your day. Bye bye
Clarence L.MS
Wow, that was fantastic! An awesome comprehensive overview of critical issues.