Douglas C.TX
I found this and the preceding two courses taught by the presenter to be rewarding in all aspects.
1h 0min · about 8,700 wordsDownload Transcript
0:01Hey everyone, this is Mike to Bliss. And we have arrived at part three of storytelling in the courtroom. This has been a three part series. And we've definitely done a deep dive into some topics that I feel are very relevant to trying a case. We spent a lot of time on storytelling, we've spent time on opening statements. And now we've arrived at the part of the presentation where I'll introduce you to one way of brainstorming a case, I have to give credit where credit is due for this section. This is not something that I just happen to learn. On my own. I was taught this way of brainstorming a case at the National Criminal Defense College in Macon, Georgia. The this was a culmination of many attorneys, you know, giving advice and feedback on how they try a criminal case. And basically, I tied up the loose ends. And this is what I came up with. And this is a system that I continue to use today, when I'm prepping a case for trial. Before we jump into how I brainstorm a case, I want to loop back to to the voice because I spent a lot of time in his presentation talking about the voice. And so I just want to summarize where we've come. And you know what, where I stand on, on voice practice. So the sound of your voice is a complex and multifaceted expression of your inner self. It can convey a wealth of information about your personality, emotions and intentions, from the tone and pitch to the pace and rhythm. Every aspect of your vocalizations can reveal something about who you are and your feelings. So for example, a calm and even
2:09tone like a measure tone might suggest that you're feeling relaxed and competent. A lifted or uneven tone could indicate uncertainty or looking for approval. The pitch of your voice can also be telling with higher pictures or pitches often associated with excitement, or enthusiasm and lower pitches conveying seriousness or authority. We saw a demonstration of that by one of these by the actor who was reading young adults story, I think I played that for you in the second part of the presentation. In addition to these more obvious aspects of your voice, there are countless subtleties and nuances that can reveal even more about your character and personality. For instance, the way you pause between words or phrases, or the specific inflection that you use on certain syllables can all contribute to a unique vocal fingerprint that is entirely your own. Overall, your voice is a powerful tool that can be used to express yourself in a variety of contexts. From casual conversation to public speaking and beyond. I feel like we need to pay more attention to our voices. Because today, I feel as if we are all in this hour, we're all in this age of sending text messages with breviary patients and with emojis. And we're kind of losing, you know, we're losing our language.
3:50And I feel like it's the right time to harken back to real conversation, and to invest in that because it's a lost art. And it's all we have when we're standing in front of a jury and we're trying to communicate to them. I'd also argue, however, that body language plays just as important if not more important than the voice. So by paying attention to the various elements of your vocalizations, you can gain a deeper understanding of yourself and the messages you're conveying to others. And so my advice is to keep learning and keep studying, never give up on yourself and never stop learning. And we can always work on our voices. I gave out the name of a studio named the Linklater voice center that offers voice classes for actors as well as individuals that are not actors, because everybody needs a rich and vibrant voice. Especially lawyers because when we're in trial, our boy CES are being exercised to the limit. I mean, we're talking from, you know, almost seven, eight hours a day, and our voices have to be heard by the jury. And, you know, we have to be able to communicate precisely and concisely, various things. And we also have to include emotion, when it's when it's necessary. So all of these variables go into the necessity of having a vibrant voice. So now we can jump into brainstorming a case, I brainstorm my cases using the steps below. This is merely one way of brainstorming a case, there are many different ways to brainstorm a case is there are lawyers who try them. I brainstorm
5:46my cases, according to steps. In a chronological order, I sometimes go out of order, depending on the type of case. And let's see what we've got here. The Blueprint should be viewed through the lens of a criminal defense attorney, this blueprint, I should say. So it doesn't mean that if you don't try criminal cases, that this won't be relevant to you, it just means that the blueprint is for a criminal defense attorney. But these are some of the same issues that you would be looking for if you were trying a civil case, personal injury case, for example. I always start backwards by asking myself the question, what facts must I established during the course of the trial, in order to make the kinds of arguments that I need to make a closing to support my clients innocence, or to win the case? So specifically, what facts do I need to establish in order to advance my defense defense and get an acquittal? Brainstorming requires a lot of free association, I, I found myself at times in my, in my life, as I was trying cases at a stumbling point or at the fork in the road, as Yogi Berra might call it. And I realized that the type of free association that's necessary to brainstorm a case requires requires that you're relaxed.
7:27And it requires that you're not under a lot of tension and a lot of pressure, I don't do my best work when I have a gun to my head. And I've waited until the 11th hour to prep a case. It's simple, it's simply that there's too much running through my mind that I can't, I don't have the luxury of letting thoughts float in and float out, like the waves of the sea. And that is the place that I need to be and to have some of my best, my bet, my my bread, my best thoughts. So it's a process. It's a spiraling process, not every thought that comes into your mind is going to be a keeper. And I have to tell you, there are times when I've really invested a great deal of time into brainstorming, and I've come up with ideas that I thought were slam dunks, and were great for the case, only to find out a couple of days later that they were no longer relevant or no longer useful.
8:32And letting go of those thoughts and those ideas was difficult. My ego wanted me to hold on to them, because I had spent so much time coming up with them. And they seem so clever at the time. But sometimes, as I said, you know, when you're brainstorming a case, it's a spiraling process. And you realize as you get deeper into the case, that an idea that you had in the beginning may not necessarily be relevant any longer. So you really want to plunge yourself in and just really just go in headfirst. You know, it's like being afraid of heights, but finding the courage to bungee jump off of the steepest cliff. In other words, you have to let go and give yourself permission to think outside of the box. And tell yourself that there's no such thing as a bad idea. Of course, it doesn't mean that every thought that comes out of the deep recesses of your mind is going to be brilliant, much less than it will be a keeper. Like minnows swimming upstream only a few ideas will actually survive. But the only way to realize these ideas is by allowing your imagination to run wild and not to self edit or censor yourself. So step one, list the date and time of the incident. Again, I start with the very basic bare bones. Step two, I make a list of the witnesses distinguishing Whether they are state's witnesses or defense witnesses, I further break them down according to whether they are lay witnesses are met or members of law enforcement. Step three, I make a list of the names of any witness or victim who gave a statement. I indicate how the statement was
10:18made, when it was made, and how long it lasted. And this is these are sub points under Step three, was a statement made to a police officer at the scene is so does it appear as a summary in the narrative of the officers report? was a statement made to a detective at the police station? If the suspect was the one being questioned? Was you read his Miranda warnings before being questioned at the scene or at the police station? If taken at the police station? Was the statement video recorded? Or was it transcribed by a stenographer? We have strict rules in New Jersey that require most felony offenses to be video taped. I believe, however, that our fourth and third degree offenses can be recorded vs demographer without being video recorded. But anything second degree or higher, I believe has to be video recorded. On what date and at what time was a statement made? How much time elapsed between the incident and the taking of the statement? That's critical. And it actually brings into play rules of evidence as well.
11:35If you might remember the excited utterance and the present sense impression. The difference between the two of them was how long or how much time elapsed between the time of the incident and the time that the statement was made by the by the speaker. How long did the questioning last? If it was typed up by his demographer? In real time at the police station? How long did it go on for was it 20 minutes? Was it one hour? What was the start time? What was the end time? How many pages does a transcript consist of was an interpreter needed if the client was was not a native English speaker? If so, was one obtained? What we see happening all too frequently today is that the police officers are the ones that are interpreting. They the the various police departments employ many bilingual officers, but they are not official translators. So how does that play into the credibility of the translation when they're not a certified translator? Step four, I create a three column chart called bad facts. I labeled the far left column bad facts. In that column, I list all of the bad facts, no matter how obvious they might be. So these are the facts that you know that are really detrimental to your case. And they're the ones that your clients have typically don't like to hear you talk about when you are having an open and frank discussion with them about taking a plea deal. But they are there the inconvenient truths that are that had been established by one way or another. Don't worry about what is admissible and what is not admissible. When making the chart. Just
13:45try to list everything you can think of. Then I have a middle column. And in that middle column is the heading source of bad fact. I cite the source for each bad back. For example, if it was a police officers report, I write the name of the police officer and the page on which it can be found. If it was testimony given at a grand jury hearing. I reference Grand Jury transcript and the page on which it can be found. The bad facts can be a work in progress through the case. Sample bad facts include one defendant has criminal record to defend and fled the scene. Three defendant admitted crime to witness for defendant assaulted victim in the past. Fifth defendant was arrested in clothing that matches the description provided by an eyewitness six no coercion on behalf of police during defendants interrogation. Step five. I create I then move on to creating a three column chart called good facts. I label the far left column good facts in that column. I list all of the good facts and they're not Always blatantly obvious, I will say that sometimes, to find the good facts, you have to probe a lot deeper than the bad facts because the bad facts are blatantly staring out at you or blinking like the proverbial neon sign in, in the window of a shop. So you do have to dig deep sometimes to find good facts, but they're there. If you exist, don't be afraid to reach. For example, John did not make an incriminating statement. Name, the middle column source of good fact cite the source for each good fact don't worry about what is admissible and what is
15:39not admissible. When making the charge. Just try to list everything you can think of. The good facts can be a work in progress throughout the case. Sample good facts include no fingerprints on gun, if the state had actually attempted to take fingerprints. And that's a whole nother issue because if they didn't attempt to lift fingerprints from a gun, then you might want to put things not done in the investigation that could have been helpful to determining the truth and getting to the bottom of this case, second, defend and consented to a DNA test. Third, no DNA found for law enforcement never recorded the defendant statement. Fifth, the defendant had no motive six, it was dark out if it's a mistake and identification case. Step six.
16:38State your defense as shallow as it might be, for example, mistaken identification, don't worry about if it's too broad. We're going to drill down as we as we go through this process. Step seven. I then returned to my bad facts chart. I labeled the far right column neutralizing bad facts. For each bad fact, I present the state's argument, for example, how you expect the prosecutor to use that damaging fact in closing argument to smoke your client and supportive guilt directly underneath it. I provide a rebuttal. Are there any pretrial motions? You should file? Is there any supplement of Why dear, you would like to submit to the court. Your goal is that by the time you do your summation, you either have a good explanation for every bad back, or you have suppressed it or kept it out of evidence. I also might I'd also add the following. Neutralizing a bad back you don't necessarily have to be able to take every bad back because it's impossible to take every bad back and somehow make a positive spin to it. But there are ways you can neutralize bad backs. Step eight. I then returned to the good fax chart, I labeled the far right column defense's argument for each good fact I write out the argument how that fax supports a vital point that you want to make during your closing argument. In supportive Jon's innocence. Are there any pretrial motions, you should file? Is there any supplement of what dear, you would like to submit to the court, your goal is to ensure that every good fact has been presented during the course of trial, so that
18:32you have a legal basis for making the kind of arguments that are consistent with innocence at closing. So just to summarize, going back to the bad facts chart, what we attempt to do in in this order, is when we have our list of bad facts, we attempt to determine whether there are any pre trial motions that would allow us to keep those bad backs out of evidence. If there isn't, step two becomes one of doing damage control. Is there any way that we can take that bad fact and put a positive spin on it? Generally there isn't. So then the third thing to do is to ask yourself, all right, I've got a bad I've got this bad fact, I can't keep it out via a pre trial motion. I can't put a positive spin on it, can I neutralize it? And if the answer to that is no, then you basically want to think about conceding it because as we've discussed in this presentation by conceding even bad facts, you gain points with the jury because the jury sees you as being super credible, somebody that they can look to to help guide them through this maze of a trial and they can trust you because you're even introducing something that is potentially damaging to your client. What type of example would I give? For this? Let's say, for example, that you represent Johnny. And Johnny has numerous felony convictions. You've had a Sans Bronson motion to sanitize those felony convictions, that's what we call it in the state of New Jersey. So now the jury won't hear the type of convictions that they were, but the jury
20:32will hear what the sentence that was associated with those felony convictions was. So an argument can be made that sometimes sanitizing them is worse than the jury hearing what the actual nature of the charge itself was because potentially their mind could be could run wild. And they could think that you know, your client was a sexual predator when he wasn't. So that's an argument for another day. But let's assume that you have a client with felony convictions that you can't keep off of the stand. You've had the, the sands Bronson motion to sanitize the convictions, the client is now on the stand, you do you are performing your direct examination, you've tried every which way to keep the convictions out of evidence, and you've lost. So what are you going to do, you're going to concede them, and you're going to have, you're going to bring them out on your direct examination. And by doing so, you're going to the jury is going to see you as being credible, like you're not trying to hide anything from them that you're the truth finder. And you're going to at the same time, give your client the opportunity to explain that he or she has changed their, the way they live. And as a result of these convictions and as a new person now, and that the person that they that is sitting before the jury today is different than the man or woman that had committed those offenses back how many years ago. So that's a way to neutralize a bad fact. But again, you want to go through the sequence of trying to keep it out of evidence
22:15with a pre trial motion. If that fails, try to put a positive spin on the bad back. And if that doesn't work, try to neutralize it.
22:28Good facts, again, you want to get them in the end, and get them in and remember, in keeping with this idea that we've been taught in law school, by our evidence professors, consider this everything is inadmissible unless you point to a rule of evidence that allows it to be admissible. I find that helpful for defense counsel, more so than the prosecutor because the prosecutor has to work a lot harder to bring in these bad facts, but sometimes they get lazy thinking that something should automatically be admissible, but it's not. So put their feet to the fire and insist that they that they find a way under Rule of evidence to bring a bad fact in and fight like hell to argue that it should not be admissible. So in Step nine, look at the bad facts, look at the good facts and determine if there are any pretrial motions you should file. And then I I basically provided a list of potential pretrial motions. Dismiss the indictment suppress physical evidence suppress statements suppress identification, prevent the state from introducing 404 B other crimes evidence sans Bronson hearing to sanitize the convictions, prevent irrelevant or unduly prejudicial evidence of admissibility of expert testimony or scientific evidence prevent hearsay admissibility of evidence of third party guilt, identity of confidential informant disclosure of police surveillance, post admissibility of victims prior sexual conduct, a driver hearing that that deals with admissibility of tape recordings, prevent fresh complaint evidence, prevent
24:21tender years hearsay evidence, prevent excited utterance, a Michaels hearing, which has to do with coaching child sexual abuse. Witnesses, severance of CO defendants, we call that a Bruton issue in New Jersey severance of counts of the indictment prevent the state from relying on lab reports. redacted inadmissible portions of a tape recording of the defendants statement. When you have a statement that goes on and on and on for a lengthy period of time. inevitably there's going to be portions of the statement that are Are that have that bear no relevance on the charges and that are extremely prejudicial to your client. So you want to make sure that you go through the statement and isolate or identify parts of the statement that are potentially prejudicial to your client, and argue that they should be redacted. Step 10. Examine the good facts and the bad facts and determine if there is any supplemental voir, dear that you would like to submit to the court. If so submits a supplemental voir, dear questions regarding these areas in a supplement of why deer brief. Also for voir dear, I recommend constructing a chart with the seating positions for each of the jurors, the court will usually provide one, right the jurors name and the information about that juror inside the rectangle that corresponds to that juror in the chart. Insert a mark for how you feel about that juror. For example, you might draw an upward arrow for jurors, you like a downward arrow for jurors you don't like and a straight line or no mark at all. For
26:14jurors, you feel neutral about how the small pad of sticky paper available, so you can create a clean space in your chart over any jurors that were struck. And alternative is to write all the information on a pad. But that can get confusing. Be sure to keep track of how many peremptory challenges you have used and how many the prosecutor has used. Remember that there's a limit on the peremptory ease, as is the for cause challenges. But if you see that you're eating up your challenges for peremptory reasons, then you might want to try to make motions to have the challenge be made for cause instead.
26:57Step 11. What are the underlying dominant emotions that you expect the jury to feel after hearing the prosecutors opening statement? For example, sympathy for the victim? disgust for your client? Step 12. What are some things that law enforcement should have done? But didn't? Did they neglect to take fingerprints? Did they fail to take a statement from a key witness? Did they forget to cordon off the crime scene with yellow tape to protect it from contamination and to prevent nosy people from traipsing through all of these things you want to you want to list? And I find that there's a lot of fertile for a lot of fodder, I should say, in this category for what law enforcement should have done but didn't. Step 13. What questions is the jury likely to ask after hearing the state's case? For example, if Bill is truly innocent? Why would he have confessed to a crime that he didn't commit? This question will need to be answered directly during closing argument. And yes, I do believe that while the defense can, theoretically sit on their hands and coast throughout the whole trial, and do nothing, I do believe that if you want to win your case, you have to answer the questions that the jury is going to be forced to decide. And if you don't, then the jury will very likely find the answers. Find the answers completely opposite to the way you want them to find the answers. So for example, if you know if you're arguing that bill is innocent, and he didn't do it, but he's given an elaborate statement to the police, you know that when
28:56that went on for a lengthy period of time, but he was offered water and food and, and and bathroom breaks during that statement, then this question is extremely relevant, and you're going to need to address it, because it's going to be front and foremost for the jury. If Bill is truly innocence was innocent, why would he have confessed to a crime that he didn't commit? Step 14. Write out the theory of your defense in a short sentence or to an example. When the pivotal question is why would an innocent man confessed to committing a crime that he didn't do? John took responsibility for a bank robbery that he didn't commit in order to protect the love of his life from going to prison. If he is guilty of anything, he is guilty of loving Vanessa too much and of using poor judgment. So what does this tell tell you about the theory of my case?
29:56I'm arguing that John took the app for his girlfriend to protect her and from going to prison. So basically, John, you know, stood up. And while he wasn't guilty of the offense, in order to protect the love of his life from going to prison, he accepted responsibility for something he didn't do. Is that Is that something that's within the realm of possibility? Sure, so long as inferences from the facts that have been introduced at trial can bear that out. You can, of course, put that into play in a trial. If there are if there aren't facts that suggest that or reasonable inferences taken from those facts that could suggest this type of theory. But I will let you know that I used this exact theory, in a case back when I was a public defender, and we did obtain an acquittal for the defendant, and he had been charged with a very serious robbery.
31:06And we had alibi and we had a lot to work with. But again, we had to answer the question, Why would an innocent man confessed to committing a crime that he didn't do? Well, he did so because he was protecting the love of his life from going to prison because she had been the one to have to have committed at it. So I did have to throw another person under the bus. But again, my loyalty was to my client, and not to any love interest of his step 15 Come up with some themes. For a false confession case, he was as desperate as a bear who chewed off his paw paw off after getting caught in a hunter's trap. trilogies are great for a battered women's case, battered, beaten, and abused.
31:57So this idea of false confession comes up so much that I do tell a story about a mother bear that, you know, had to chew off her paw in order to save her baby bear from an oncoming lion. And that basically goes hand in hand with the theory of a man doing a you know, doing a heroic thing by stepping up to take responsibility for a crime he didn't commit. And so in that same in the same way that the mother bear shoot off her paws off to get to her cub before the lion could eat her cub. So too, did my client take responsibility for a crime that he committed to prevent the love of his life from going to prison? So these are rich themes that resonate with jurors, and yes, they do get results. Step 16. Tie it together and start writing out your closing argument. Why would an innocent man admit to committing a crime they didn't do? Why would a bear to off his bull his paw when he is in a helpless situation? And so this expands on my story of the bear Papa Bear and his cub were out foraging for parrot for berries. Papa bears Paul became ensnared in a hunters trap. The cub doesn't realize that his father's in trouble and full of curiosity drifts away from his father, a hungry lion perched on top of a cliff sees the wandering cub, seizing the opportunity to catch the cub off guard.
33:37And in a vulnerable state. The lion takes off like the speed of light from his perch. The papa bear sees a lion out of the corner of his eye racing towards his cup. He knew all too well what was going to happen, and he knew what he had to do. With no time to spare the FATHER BEAR chewed off his trap, Paul. limping, the bear rush to his cub as fast as he could, and it wasn't a minute too soon. The lion had already closed in and was eyeing his prey, summoning up all of his strength that he had the FATHER BEAR stood between his cub and the lion stood up on his hind legs and raised his paws up in the air showing his menacing claws. The lion stopped dead in his tracks, turned around and retreated like a hyena with its tail between his legs back into the forest. Just like the father bear sacrificed his poor to save his cub from the lion. John sacrificed his liberty protect to protect the love of his life from going to prison. As John testified, the detectives told him that Jessica had been arrested and charged with being in possession of heroin.
34:43On the way to the police station. When John was alone in the car with detective Jacobs, Detective Jacobs made John a promise if Shawn confessed to committing the robbery that detective Jacobs would talk to the prosecutor and see to it that Jessica didn't Go to jail. Detective Jacobs exploited the vulnerability of John His unconditional love for Jessica. He knew that John was in a relationship with Jessica. And he dangled Jennifer's bait in front of him like a hunter dangling a piece of raw meat in front of a lion. Why did John admit to committing a crime they even do to protect his love from going to prison, he couldn't bear the thought of seeing someone as naive and innocent as his girlfriend rotting away in a cold, dank jail cell where her safety would be at risk every day, you may not have believed what John believed or done what he did. But it doesn't make him a criminal for exercising poor judgment, it only makes him a criminal if he violates the law. And that, that basically, it was a theory and a theme that I used in a recent trial. And again, it was a successful theory and theme. Now, I realized that we still have some time here. So what I would like to do in the time that I have left is quickly transition to one to give you a preview of one of my upcoming presentations, then, and this also is on storytelling. So I'm just going to ask for your indulgence for a minute or two while I switch my slides. In the meanwhile, if anybody has any questions, I am happy to take any questions, I realized that this was an ambitious three part
36:49presentation, and I didn't give any time in the first two parts for taking questions. So if there are on Feel free, verbally, or you can shoot me a message via the chat. Okay, I think where I want to go next with this is to give you a little preview of an upcoming presentation that I'm really stoked about presenting. It's on. It's on movement psychology. And just to give you some background about me, I am not a psychologist, nor am I a psychiatrist. I was a psychology minor in college. But I'm fascinated with this area of psychology. And I've been introduced to a very special form of psychology course called movement psychology via my acting training. And I have found it very useful in when I am selecting jurors during voir, dear, as well as when I am prepping my witness for testifying, as well as prepping other witnesses for trial and then cross examining the state's witnesses. So this topic is a fascinating, fascinating topic. And I want to give you a sneak peek at what to expect in the full blown course.
38:27Because I think that you might find this relevant to your trying cases. Okay, I just have to get to my Presenter View. All right. Nonverbal communication. I talked a little bit in this storytelling presentation about how incredibly important it is for our bodies, movements, to be communicating what our words are communicating. And the reason why I said that was because when they when the body is out of alignment with what the with what's coming out of your mouth, it's usually the nonverbal communication through the body, and through the movements that the body makes, that will win the day. And so this statistic reveals that as much as 93% of what we communicate is nonverbal. And so it's it's critical that as lawyers, if we are zealously advocating for our clients and trying to persuade the jury that our clients are innocent, if it's a criminal case, then we want to make sure that everything that our gestures and our bodies are, you know, communicating the very same thing that our words are communicating, because if there is a slightest doubt in our minds of what we you're advocating, and it could be as subtle as scratching your head or your temple. When you're arguing passionately about your client's innocence, that subtle movement could betray your words. And the inconsistency is always going to fall on the side of nonverbal because the statistics should have borne out time and time again, that 93% of what we communicate is nonverbal.
40:30So nonverbal communication in the courtroom is deafening. If you're arguing that John is innocent during your closing argument. While your hand is scratching the back of your head or your temples, the jury will instantly read this contradiction as uncertainty. In other words, when there's a contradiction between verbal and nonverbal communication, nonverbal will always prevail. The danger this poses is that it causes the jury to question the lawyer's credibility. And again, that's the most important thing that we possess. The jury can see your whole body in the courtroom, so you might as well be aware of what it's doing, and use it to say everything that you mean it to say, a rule to live by is that one cannot expect to persuade others of that which one does not believe in himself.
41:18When the lawyers body and words are out of alignment, the jury will instantly view the lawyer as an imposter. Ironically, because we as humans are so complicated, these contradictions can sometimes become our norm, without us even being aware of them. In the same vein, we don't always say what we mean or mean what we say. There's an expression for this in the theatre world, and that's called unity of opposites. Because the characters that actors play are messy, inherently flawed, and full of baggage actors go in just the opposite direction, leaning into the inconsistencies between the nonverbal and verbal to create a rich, multi dimensional character. But for us as lawyers looking to persuade jurors, we have to make sure that both our nonverbal and verbal communication are in sync. So as simple as this might sound, one of the biggest reasons why lawyers nonverbal language and gestures are out of sync is because the lawyer himself has not convinced himself of his clients innocence. When defending a person accused of a crime, we must convince ourselves lock, stock and barrel, that our clients are innocent. And the reason why we do that is to make sure that subconsciously, there's not another story that's playing out in our subconscious that could betray our words.
42:53Here, I would like to take the opportunity to talk a little bit about a concept called economy of movement. And it's, it deals with two questions. First, we the first question that we ask is, must you be doing anything? Or is your movement distracting from the truth and meaning of your words, the movement doesn't necessarily have to be a big gesture like flailing your arms about in order to be distracting, it could be as subtle as balling your hand up in a fist. The general rule of thumb is to fit the movement to the Word and the Word to the movement. A good question to ask yourself is whether this movement is 100% needed. If you can't take your eyes off of an actor, if you've been moved to tears by an actor, or if you've been pulled to the edge of your seat, chances are that the actor's actions fit their words and their words fit their actions. That was actually that comes actually right out of Hamlet. That phrase. On the other hand, if your mind begins to drift, and you reach over to grab your smartphone, one of the reasons might be that the actor is indicating or what we might call it gesticulating in a way that distracts from the experience of their inner life. The ladder is far more interesting for an audience to watch, but for far more revealing for the actor to show. The second part of economy of movement is that once you've decided that this movement really is needed, which muscles do you actually need to make that movement, for example, in order to raise your arm, you don't need to attend to your leg or your neck, your neck muscles don't
44:36move your arm. This is an example of what's called parasitic movement. And so there's a number of somatic practices that help to train artists from all different disciplines to only use those muscles that are absolutely needed for certain types. Some movement, but this takes time to correct habits that have evolved over the years. And a lot of these a lot of times these habits have been formed as defense mechanisms and way we protect ourselves from the shocks from the shocks and arrows of everyday life. So it's not that we should look at our habits as a hindrance, or as being something bad, because they've actually protected our our bodies and they've been like a cloak to us. But essentially, if we misuse our body, then we are setting ourselves up for, you know, for future physical ailments as well. So it's, it's in our best interest to, you know, try to use our bodies to the best way the best way we can, and, and to make sure that our gestures and our movements are always consistent and in line with what we are arguing, and that we are using our body efficiently so that we are not causing any potential physical damage to ourselves, maybe not now, but later on down the line. And so I I often encourage lawyers to pay attention to the gestures and movements that they use in everyday life when they're in conversations with other people that will help them to identify which movements are natural, and organic, versus those which are nothing more than window dressing, or a mask that covers up their true self.
46:44This gets a little bit more into specifics about movement, physical movement in the courtroom. And I I do like to tackle this in the in another presentation. But because we have the time, I do want to talk a little bit about using your body and in the courtroom. Actors never wander around stage. Every move has been choreographed and is done with purposeful intention to emphasize, draw attention to or offer subtext to the script or content. When an actor moves from place to place on stage is called a cross crosses are precise, clear movements from one place to another. Each movement is done with purpose.
47:37at a specific point, wandering pacing or even unconscious weight shifting is distracting and takes your attention away from where it should be the jury, it weakens the impact of your speech. When I first began to learn these techniques, it was brought to my attention that I had a habit of pacing. And I still to this day prepare for a trial. When I'm practicing my opening statement. I walk around in a distracted way sometimes. But I paced and I try to get comfortable with this idea of rooting myself into one point. And I've realized how important that is for the jury to follow my thoughts. If I'm moving around aimlessly, then it distracts the jury. From the words that I'm speaking they become more interested in where my body is going to be next than what I'm saying next. By moving to a specific point in the courtroom. You can punctuate a point. If you want to make a strong point for example, taking three steps forward will alert the jury you are about to say something important. You just as the director looks at the stage to see the areas of strongest impact for the audience and sets the stage for the scene. So should you when it comes to the courtroom, you should always think about the courtroom from the jurors point of view, keeping it balanced and visually interesting. Look at general areas of the courtroom as points to reach your jury on as many levels as you can. For example, you may move closer to the jury box to get closer to one or two of them or keep your distance in order to take in all of them. Look carefully at the placement of furniture
49:30in relation to you and where you are in the jury's view. Make sure you are not upstage by an unnecessary piece of large furniture, which unconsciously draws the jury's attention away from you. The following theatrical techniques will help you stage your opening and closing in a way that uses movement to enhance content. upstage and downstage directors block the movements of actors to emphasize dramatic meaning and to maintain Clear sightlines. The downstage area closest to the audience is a strong position and is the best place to present the most important content of your speech. However, you don't want to live there. In fact, if you meander too close to the jury in this area, you will be entering the dreaded zone of the pathetic upstage, away from the audience is less powerful, but can be used effectively for reflective pauses. But be careful. If you meander too far away from the jury in this area, you will be entering the dreaded zone of the tragic where intense scenes are played out with extraordinary consequences such as a battle between the hero and his arch nemesis. Moving from upstage downstage in order to make an important point is highly effective. And here's a little visual of, of how this would have would appear before an audience but you can substitute the jury for the audience and see that when you're at the point closest to the jury, the jury box, you're downstage when you're halfway between upstage and downstage, you're at center stage. When you're at the left, you're at stage left. When you're at the right, you're
51:20at Stage Right. upstage is the farthest point from the jury. And remember what we've talked about upstage, is considered when you're at the far or extreme end of upstage, you're in the zone of the tragic, but when you are at the foremost part of downstage, you are at the zone of the pathetic, that's when you can literally touch the jury, you got to be careful because if you decide to meander all the way to the for most points of downstage then you could be making the jury uncomfortable by by being that close to them. And what I what I tried to do is to keep a safe distance from the jury because I don't want to be inside their bubble and make them uncomfortable. And I don't want them I don't want to be spitting on them, either. So you want to you know, use the courtroom to the, to the advantages that I talked about, based on what we've learned from psychology in the theater. But again, you don't want to mosey around or meander around haphazardly without purpose, your movement should have purpose when you are in before the jury. Stage Right stage left and American and British theatre stage right and stage left refer to the actors or speakers point of view. The position downstage right is perceived by Western audiences as having intimacy and importance, perhaps because we read from left to right. In theater love scenes, monologues and narration are usually performed down right. public speakers use his position for their most important content, or for stories that have a strong emotional effect. Downstage left traditionally has a
53:13conspiratorial feel to it a place for plots and discussions in the theater. Umer in a speech is often very effective when delivered from downstage left. Tips follow your instincts be led by those jurors who seem to back in your attention. You'll see it you'll feel it, but never leave anyone out. I always encourage this idea of making eye contact with the jury with each juror acknowledging each juror one by one, and again, not leaving any one juror out. Now, I do see that there was some questions in the chat. So I would like to just address how do you link the stories and an opening and closing? How do you link to stories and an opening and closing of civil cases? Well, again, you're using, you're using storytelling in opening in your opening statement in a civil case, just as you would in the opening statement for a criminal case, storytelling runs through and you're using. You're using the narrative framework that I've introduced in the presentation. So you want to have a theory and you want to have a theme. Remember that themes are best remembered in threes, because we tend to remember themes and we tend to remember lists in threes more than we remember. fours or fives. So for example, in a battered women's case it might be she was battered up and abused. And that theme might help would help your theory of self defense in that instance. So you are always going to have a theory and a theme, even in a civil case, in your opening statement. What are you doing in closing argument in a civil case that might be different than what you're
55:24doing in closing argument in a criminal case? Well, you are, you're arguing that the defendant was liable. So you want to bring into play some of the examples that I talked about earlier in the presentation. And I can harken back to them in the slideshow. I'm going to take one second to do just that. Okay, just give me one second, and I'm going to do, I gave an example from a case where the plaintiff had a broken leg and was suing the defendant. The the plaintiff, in the example I had given, was in a cast, and had been hospitalized for approximately a week or two. And I attempted to use that example, for the specificity that you want to get into when you are representing a client like that, who has been so severely injured, that his or her life may forever be different, as a result, but we started in the hospital, in that example, by disgust by, by by stressing the hardship that the plaintiff went through while in the hospital and how he had a cast up to his genitals and how he was in traction, and how he needed to be, you know, fed by somebody, perhaps a loved one, or were nurses while he was there. And so I used the I use that as the example of make them see it, make them feel it. Don't just argue that the plaintiff suffered a serious injury. You want to get into specifics and details so that the jury can feel what your client went through, so that they can empathize. Here it is. I use it in the context of stick with the action avoid abstractions. This statement, my client suffered a broken leg tells us nothing. Tell them what it felt like for Johnny to have a
57:54broken leg with the bone sticking through the flesh. Tell them how excruciating the pain was, how John couldn't make it through the night without being sedated. How He clenched his teeth so much that he grinded them down to their gums. Tell them how John was confined to a bed for two weeks, with a solid case extending up from his ankles, and how he needed to use a bedpan to urinate and defecate, make the jury see it, make them feel that now, if these facts haven't been brought into evidence, and they're not logical inferences that can be taken from the facts and from the evidence themselves, then the then the defense is going to object at your close during your closing argument to to to talking in these terms. But more times than not, these details have come into evidence, at least, you know, by your client testifying or by a doctor who treated your client testifying. But again, they're going to be very clinical, the doctors are going to be very clinical. And this this type of detail is only going to come out if your client takes the stand and talks about them. But you really want to be able to milk, the milk the cow, so to speak and to you know, and to get these details in so that you can argue them strenuously during closing argument. So I see that we have arrived at time. I tried to give you a little bit of a preview of what's to come and one of the future programs on movement in the courtroom and a little bit of nonverbal, nonverbal communication that I think you might be helpful to you next time you are in the
59:46courtroom making an argument. But I really hope that this series was helpful to you and that there's a couple of things that you might be able to bring into your own practice. You know, as a result of this presentation, As I said in the past if you have any questions whatsoever my doors always open I welcome email I welcome calls and I'm always happy to brainstorm cases so I wish you the very very best and look forward to seeing you at a future presentation
Douglas C.TX
I found this and the preceding two courses taught by the presenter to be rewarding in all aspects.
Robert L.CA
A likable, unpretentious lawyer who has a serious intention of helping the viewer with important information