Judith G.NJ
This was excellent! The presentation was clear and engaging. Very informative
1h 12min · about 12,700 wordsDownload Transcript
0:01Welcome to our LexVid presentation today this will be litigating sexual harassment attacking an old problem using creative approaches. In parentheses with the Illinois gender violence act as a model for a new approach. I am Max Berek one of the two principals of the Garfinkel group, we are a plaintiff side civil rights and employment law firm. And I'll be talking about that mouthful of a topic today. Because this is a legal presentation, I have to give the proverbial disclaimer. This is just to touch on these issues, there is so much more to cover, we're really just going to barely be scratching the surface of these topics. It's just to give you a general overview of worker rights on these topics, how to attack these cases, how to approach them to understand generally what the law is, and then to give some theoretical state law examples for what to do when you run into certain problems with the federal law claims primarily statutes of limitations, but some other topics as well. Keep in mind, there are a lot of other rights, I'm going to plug a lot of free resources throughout this presentation. To that end, the EEOC or Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. And depending on what state you're in, if it has an agency in Illinois, the Department of Human Rights have lots of free resources, and user friendly fact sheets and guides that folks can use and should use. To that and so with that said, let's dive in. Going to do another brief overview. I'm going to focus a little bit on the Illinois in seventh circuit areas, but
1:39it's not going to be an Illinois or seventh circuit specific presentation, I understand this as a national bent to it, we'll be doing that. It's going to be a crash course in federal discrimination laws to give everybody a base of knowledge, I am going to touch on different circuits throughout the presentation. We'll then move into federally recognized causes of action for sex harassment, spoilers, there are largely two. But it's important that we bought them those out, we're gonna do a brief overview just to touch on it of what companion state laws exist, that are akin to Title Seven of the Civil Rights Act, but not the same. And then we'll get to the meat of it. What I wanted to talk about today, in most detail, which is the Illinois gender violence act, and how even though it only exists here in Illinois, it can act as a model for how other states are folks practicing and other states might attack some of these issues, largely related to statutes of limitations, delayed outcry, sex harassment claims. And just when the federal remedies are really not adequate. There are some other states with similar laws. I'm going to touch on New York's law today, because that was the closest I was able to find, but no, and I will mention that California may have a companion law that's somewhat similar. Once again, this is just a framework, it's not exhaustive, do feel free to reach out for clarification or follow up questions stops me from having to do real work, and lets me keep being a nerd about these topics. Just a warning, you know, the
3:11gender violence act isn't the title of the presentation, it's going to take us some time to get there. And lastly, I don't know if I need to do a trigger warning. But I am just going to mention, we're going to touch on some tough topics today. There are going to be mentions of sexual violence at times. And I just want to give folks a fair warning about that. Okay, so this is the obligatory I'm doing an employment law CLE. So I have to just mention at will employment, I like to do this as a start because it just gives us a solid playing field to start from just means that an employer can terminate an employee's employment at any time for any reason, except the illegal ones we're going to talk about today without incurring legal liability. By extension, it gives employers quite a bit of leeway to manage and navigate and control the workplace. But that is not unlimited. And this is 49 out of 50 states have this. Okay, so let's start working our way through the federal anti discrimination statutes. So in as much as that will is the baseline. It's not the only thing. Not everything is legal discrimination, obviously, is prohibited by federal statute. Not every form of discrimination is prohibited. I've had people call my office and say they were victims of discrimination based on an inability to find parking, because that led them to be late to work quite a bit. And so that was discriminatory. It might be, but not in any way that is recognized that I'm aware of under any state or federal law. So we're really going based on what are protected
4:35characteristics or categories under the Civil Rights statutes, once again, not an exhaustive list. Title Seven of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which I am going to refer to as Title Seven today prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex and national origin. This has been expanded over time, race and national origin claims are now Our focus today but know that they often operate interchangeably or very similarly, and are often hard to separate. And sex no longer just covers I'm female or a male and somebody of the same or opposite sex harasses or discriminates against me. It now covers gender identity and sexual orientation explicitly. Those developments come out of the 2020 decisions the Bostock decision, addressing sexual orientation and the RG and GNR, Harris funeral homes case that dealt with gender identity. So those are now protected categories. And if there's a sex harassment claim that arises that like what we're going to talk about today. Those categories are covered. Just touching on the other statutes that exist there section 1981 of the Civil Rights Act of 1991. This forbids race discrimination and contractual relationships.
5:54The hostile work environment tests we're going to cover today do apply to that statute some of the time, when you bring a claim under that statute as a vehicle, you can bring that hostile work environment claim in a similar way to how you would a Title Seven claim. There's also the Age Discrimination and Employment Act the a DEA prohibiting age discrimination though of note, because I do get calls on this. It's not younger folks, it's got to be over the age of 40. Being young and not taken seriously is for better or for worse, not a form of protected discrimination under the ADEA. I'm going to mention the ADA, Americans with Disabilities Act cannot discriminate in employment or in public accommodations against people on the basis of their disability. ADEA also gives the right to seek a reasonable accommodation and employment, among many, many other things. There's the genetic information, non discrimination act of 2008, and the Equal Pay Act of 1963. These are just some of the federal laws that exist, there are more, this is not exhaustive. And also remember there are various state laws that touch on these topics. What do we mean by discrimination? Let's start with the baseline. So Title Seven, as discussed earlier makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer to discriminate against any individual with respect to their terms of compensation, terms, conditions or privileges of employment, because of such individuals race, color, religion, sex or national origin. That comes out of the Meritor savings Savings Bank
7:26decision, which is an important Supreme Court case we are going to spend some time with today. So there are different types of recognized or actionable forms of unlawful discrimination. It's not everything, but it's a lot. So there's what we often think of most colloquially, disparate treatment. Basically, you and I go out for a job, one of us gets the job, the other does not. So it's essentially disparate treatment or different terms or conditions of employment. There are a lot of different ways this can manifest. Like I said, the promotion or hiring or in firing, job assignments, discipline, pay, pay claims are a little different when litigating under the Equal Pay Act, and they would be under Title Seven, just to make this extra exciting and complicated. But know that those options are there. Another way this will sometimes present because it is rare that companies are at this point. short sighted enough to say out loud, if they're going to do something discriminatory, they will usually point to what we call a pretext or an excuse for what they did. Rather than saying out loud, yeah, I didn't promote you, because you're female, I don't want a woman in this job. So one of the ways that disparate treatment will present that I want to flag because it does typically show up in a gender context is stereotyping cases. So it's not the traditional, hey, I'm not promoting you because you're female or because you're a person of color or LGBTQ. It is based largely on like euphemisms. And, like I said, stereotypes. So there's a Price Waterhouse
9:00versus Hopkins decision that holds that a form of gender discrimination can be gender stereotyping, so that particular case involves a female employee who hit the proverbial glass ceiling, because she did not fit what that employer felt a woman should be in the workplace. She was too aggressive or abrasive, basically was not feminine or Meek enough. And the court held that those sorts of stereotypes are unacceptable, and do constitute a form of discrimination. I see this in a lot of different settings if you extrapolate it outwards. So it's not just hey, this woman is not feminine or Meek enough. One case I had that involved a situation like this involved a 50 year old female employee at a large financial institution who made the mistake of telling her male supervisor No, that's an inappropriate interview question to a female employee or would be employee who was younger and was being asked about like her personal and dating lives and sex life and that's just wildly inappropriate and My client at the time then started to get feedback of, well, you're abrasive, you don't play well with others. You've burned bridges here.
10:07We're we're concerned, you don't know how to get along with your co workers, mind you, all she had done was say, no, she just didn't curtsy meekly and say oh, yes, of course, go ahead, continue to ask those improper questions. So just know that it's out there and is one of the ways these things sometimes present. I've also seen it in race and national origin context as well. Another form of discrimination is retaliation. Basically, I'm not going to read all of the definitions. This is a text heavy presentation because I can't help myself. So just know. It is essentially opposing an improper employment practice, or taking what we call protected activity. in furtherance of that, it can be simply saying no, opposing it, filing a charge of discrimination, reporting or complaining about a practice that you perceived to be discriminatory or harassing.
10:56And you actually don't have to be right, it's got to be reasonable. In that belief, you can't say everything that ever happens is discrimination, or it loses its meaning. But there it is common that folks will complain about harassment or discrimination, disparate treatment, will sometimes lose those claims in the course of the litigation, but we'll be able to move forward with a colorable retaliation claim, because even if what they were reporting was not held to be legally actionable, it was a legitimate protected complaint that resulted in the second part of this, which is an adverse employment action, essentially, something that would make the reasonable person less likely to complain.
11:33Now, a lot of really most courts will treat that as there's got to be some tangible employment action, a discipline or right up a firing a fine a suspension, something concrete that has a tangible effect. I have seen some decisions. And I have argued that it's not always that way that there is a form of retaliatory harassment, a lot of courts. In fact, most may not tolerate that. So no, you're usually looking for something more concrete there, and a causal link between those things. So then we get to what we really want to talk about today, harassment. It's got to be based on race, sex, religion, national origin, and more recently, a age like I said, Sorry, and disability status, gender identity and sexual orientation. And then if you bring it as a state law claim, depending on what state you're in one of the other protected categories that is permitted as a form of harassment, or to bring a claim of harassment in that state. So I mentioned the Meritor case, that's where we first get this Supreme Court held that sexual harassment creates a hostile or abusive work environment, and that that act or those acts constitute a form of sex discrimination under Title Seven. And by extension, the Court held that an employer couldn't be liable for sexual harassment perpetrated by its employees under some circumstances. So what do we mean by harassment? Well, there's two typical types where we would see this, there's quid pro quo, which I always thought of as the more traditional way, it wasn't until I got to law school or started
13:02practicing that I understood that it's not always quite so obvious. But that occurs, what we think of a supervisor or somebody else with authority demands something sexually inappropriate or sexual favors in exchange for job benefits, or threatened some negative consequence if the employee does not comply with those demands. That comes that definition comes from the murder case. And I have a local Northern District of Illinois decision that talks about what that can look like. Cases where I've seen that it believe it or not, it does happen. I have one right now. I had one recently where a young immigrant woman was cleaning for, let's call it a hotel, didn't like that job, told the owner, the owner said, well, I need a personal assistant, it pays a salary. She was like, great, he goes, Yeah, you just have to massage me occasionally have sex with me. So it does still happen. And then there is a hostile work environment claim, which is what we're going to spend our time on today and what is going to give rise to our gender violence information down the road. This is yet another disclaimer know that. I'm going to primarily focus on sex harassment today, because I can't help myself I am at times going to mention race. cases I have dealt with or how this might apply in a race case just in passing, but I'm not going to focus on it. Just know that with some nuances. Most of the tests we touch on today are going to apply in those contexts as well, when you have a hostile work environment claim based on something other than sex harassment, okay,
14:33so as I mentioned, we first get sex harassment or hostile work environment in the Meritor Savings Bank case. So the test that gets articulated in the holding is essentially sexual harassment, which creates a hostile or offensive environment for members of a sex is every bit the arbitrary barrier to sexual equality at the workplace, that racial harassment is to racial equality. Surely a requirement that a man or woman run a gauntlet of sexual abuse and return for The privilege of being allowed to work and make a living can be as demeaning and disconcerting as the hardest or harshest of racial epithets. I would agree. So here's our first but not all harassment is going to be actionable. We're going to spend a lot of time talking about looser strike comments or just mentioning that concept. So keep in mind, if you have a couple of one off remarks that are off color or inappropriate, it's probably not going to be enough. Returning the Meritor, I'm going to only focus on the emphasized or highlighted text for sex harassment to be actionable, it must be sufficiently severe or pervasive to alter the conditions of the victims employment, excuse me and create an abusive working environment.
15:48So severe pervasive is a term we're going to use quite a bit or a phrase we're going to use a bit because that is the operative definition here. Take away no loose or straight comments giving rise to harassment, there are single comment instances that have given rise to I've seen racial harassment claims. Its use of certain epithets, where once you use it, there's sort of no going back. I'm not going to repeat them. But those are hard cases. And there is starting to be a body of bad case law. That is, undercutting the argument that even use of that particular slur on its own is enough. The same test was then later clarified in Harris versus forklift systems. Another important the hostile work environment Supreme Court decision, there were quite a few over a 10 or 15 year period, about a 15 year period that we're going to mention at least in passing today. Harris is one of them. Whether an environment is hostile or abusive can only be looked at by a determined by looking at all of the circumstances. These may include the frequency of the discriminatory conduct its severity, whether it is physically threatening or humiliating or a mere offensive utterance, and whether it unreasonably interferes with an employee's work performance. It doesn't require actual psychological or dime, documented medical or psychological harm. That is a factor. But it's not the only factor. That 12 years later, 12 years from merit or less after Harris, we get the oncology decision, which recognizes same sex sexual harassment claims
17:21as actionable seems obvious, but it doesn't always have to just be you know, man and woman, right? I have worked on female and male cases, it does happen. It's a thing. And we need to take it seriously. But same sex harassment is a problem as well and is actionable. So what is this good is because it's good to know that there is this severe pervasive concept, but what does it really mean in practice, I am going to pull here from an old Seventh Circuit decision that is largely still good law, because this is the test that is used locally, for establishing a hostile work environment claim to slay the summary judgment Dragon, plead the case and eventually get to trial and hopefully prevail. And that is that a plaintiff must show that she was an I'm saying she'd but it can be they them he anybody really can can do this was subjected to sexual harassment in the form of sexual advances, requests for favors, or other verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature. More on that in a moment. The nature of the advances were unwelcome, the harassment was based on sex. The harassment had the effect of unreasonably interfering with the plaintiffs work performance in creating an intimidating, hostile or offensive work environment that affected the psychological seriously affected the psychological well being of the plaintiff. And not or there is a basis for employer liability. So you see the elements coming out of the Meritor and Harris versus forklift systems cases, taking shape, and forming into a multi prong or multi component
18:50test that you have to satisfy. So it's helpful at least you have a roadmap. So I'm going to start, what I'm going to do now is work my way through these five part tests, I'm not going to go through all of them in detail. But actually, I might take that back, we are going to go through them all in detail, but in varying levels of detail. I'm gonna start out of order, however, with number two, that the advances run welcome. And I put fun in quotes here, because I think this shouldn't need to be said, but it's what we got. So for sex, harassment, hostile work environment claims in a way that is not present for others typically. In a sexual harassment claim, you have to show that the advances were unwelcome, with the unspoken bit being I guess, at times that might be welcomed conduct. So just keep in mind, that's going to be part of it. So when you have a case, and I've seen this where there is a to the extent these relationships can be consensual, consensual workplace relationship, that stops being that you might run into some trouble there and you need to contemplate that element.
19:58And, and just stay with that for one more month. but you can show that a lot of different ways I think somebody's complaining or reporting their harassment is pretty obvious that it's not telling somebody to stop. I think you look for common sense elements there. We're going to spend a lot more time on fair girl Earth, but I'm going to mention that there were two other seminar it seems like these cases come in the same year. There's 219 86 cases, there's like 390 98 cases, two of them are right here. Faragher versus City, a book written and Burlington industries incorporated versus Ellsworth Faragher and Elric cases they make up a test. They are seminal cases to liability for supervisor harassment, and for honing that test, just know that they happened. Those cases reaffirm the severe pervasive test. What they did do, we're gonna get to the affirmative defense component. But in terms of establishing the claim, you want to be careful about pre 1998 decisions, because the language they use about how you establish employer liability differs. Also, they're more than 25 year old cases, depending on when you watch this video. So that has its own other pitfalls and risks that might come from using a case of that age. But previously, to circle up to what this is to establish such a claim your hand to show what we've discussed that remember a protected class, that there was the unwelcome sex harassment that it was based on sex that had created a hostile work environment, but also that the harassing actions were
21:26foreseeable or fell within the scope of employment, and also that the employer had failed to adequately to respond adequately and effectively. So basically, you have this pre harassment notice element, or just showing that it was a foreseeable outcome, which is challenging if there's no prior reports, or that it fell within the scope of employment, which I still have yet to find a case where I can show that her engaging in sex harassment falls within the scope of employment. So you can see how pre fair girl Ruth, we have some limitations to the test as it existed. So after, it's no longer enough to just correct promptly once that happens, employers now have an affirmative duty to prevent sex harassment, in particular, when a supervisor is involved, because once an employee has established actionable harassment involving no tangible employment action, the only way out with an affirmative defense for the employer is that they had taken reasonable care to prevent and correct any of such behavior. But as we're going to cover supervisory harassment is quite often strict liability. So that was an important change there. So backing up, let's get into the actual language, so courts determine whether harassment is based on sex. By examining the nature of the conduct and the context in which it occurred. The harassment must be shown to be not merely tinged with offensive sexual connotations, but to actually constitute discrimination because of sex. So to determine that courts look to whether it was sex specific and derogatory,
22:59indicating that the harasser was motivated by a general hostility to the presence of a particular sex in the workplace. So that can be that the it's not always just another words that Oh, you are asking for sexual favors, or groping or asking somebody out or pressuring him to date you. There is a General Hostility option here as well. So for example, that a harasser is treating members of one sex differently from others can be used to show that the harassment was based on sex. So for example, if the women are the primary target of harassment, it could indicate that it was based on sex if there aren't sexual favors or sexual like explicitly or obviously sexual elements involved. So to that end, sometimes you have somebody who's just hostile to the opposite sex in the workplace. I'm going to paint with a broad brush for a moment and say it's typically men being hostile to women or struggling with interacting, like normal people with women in the workplace. So I've had a lot of cases for example, where it's not obviously sexual, you have a harasser who is constantly insulting women calling them slurs, that I won't repeat or calling them the B word a bitch, calling them gender specific insults, or anything euphemisms for things that are not obvious, but that they have morphed to mean something improper. So I had a case, for example, where a harasser wasn't asking women out, but he would go around referring to them as a one or a zero, meaning whether or not he would sleep with them with the binary scale. It wasn't obvious
24:32in the same way that a sexually explicit comment would be or calling someone the B word. But in that context, so you look to the context, it's a really inappropriate and offensive course of action. So you want to think about these claims, not just in the obvious, where you pressuring the client to go in and date. Were you in a quid pro quo context, right? Leveraging that against some tangible employment action, where you may Making sexually explicit remarks. Those are pretty obvious. But if somebody is really verbally abusive based on gender, and not treating men or people of the same sex the same way, that is an example. Other things are the euphemisms or sort of less obvious things that I described. I mentioned not treating people of the opposite sex the same way. Because in some circuits, there is still recognized a defense called the Equal Opportunity harasser defense, I have another word for harasser that I like to use. That's not as clean, equal opportunity as holder jerk defense. And that is a defense that, Your Honor, I couldn't have been harassing based on gender, because I'm in short to everybody. And it's so weird scenario where you find these cases where witnesses are actually, whereas you normally see in these cases and employers seek witness statements about how wonderful they're harassing employee was and how nobody would ever dream that he would have done that sort of thing, and that they can't believe that it happened.
25:56You actually have something of the opposite where you're seeking witness statements. That yeah, no, my boss was a real jerk. He's really unpleasant. But he's like that to everybody creates a weird dynamic. So I'll give you one other in terms in the realm of it's not always obvious or the opposite sex, keeping on calling in mind this Nichols versus as tech a decision out of the Ninth Circuit. Think back to the Pricewaterhouse decision I mentioned towards the beginning and gender stereotyping. Sometimes it's none of the things I've talked about earlier. It's not like an obvious hostility to women or men or, or trans folks or gender non binary or LGBTQ folks. It may not be sexually explicit or solicitous. Right, it might just be mistreating somebody because of how they present. So I think you'll see this more in a gender identity and LGBTQ context these days, but not exclusively. So this Nichols decision refers to situations where it is based on an a perception that the man was not strong enough, he was too effeminate for what his harasser determined men ought to be. And in that context, he was harassed because he failed to conform to a male stereotype that is a form of actionable gender based harassment or sex, sex harassment to create a hostile work environment. And I've seen that I had a case where an employee who was LGBTQ got into an argument on the floor with some co workers of a factory. They called him some homophobic slurs, and he was kicked in in the groin, which we're going to talk about the GVA later. So these things do happen. So
27:36staying with this topic of the harassment being based on sex, we look to all circumstances, circumstantial evidence, even if the harassing and conduct and statements is facially neutral can be used to show that it was on the basis of sex. So like what I was talking about. I'm not going to read through all of this, just know that this is one of the tests, I provided a couple examples, this Alabama case out of the out of the Northern District of Alabama, that's about eight, nine years old. You look to a host of factors, including the immediately surrounding context, prior course of dealings, local customs, and store practices. So this was in the context of a race harassment case. But like I said, these tests tend to be largely interchangeable when jumping between race, sex, or any other type of hostile work environment claim. Okay, so let's go back to slide 20. For just a moment, we've covered the unwelcome component, we've covered harassment based on sex. And I think, just because I couldn't help myself, I sort of talked about the harassment in the form of sex advances, requests for favors or other conduct of a sexual nature or of a gender motivated nature of a sex motivated nature. I think we've probably covered that. So I want to talk more now about the next component, severe or pervasive. And this goes to the bit about affecting the terms and conditions of employment. Loose or straight remarks. The case law is really consistent even in cases where you have summary judgment or some kind of a decision favorable to the plaintiff
29:15being rendered. Pretty much every decision will start with offhand comments, isolated incidents, and like simple teasing, does not cover it. That's not going to cut it. We're not here to police the workplace. We're not here to police bullying, and we're not here to police. Just one off incidents that are not that serious. It's not to say they're okay. And they should be dealt with in the context of the employer. But it's not our job to police it. It doesn't have to reach the level of helplessness. So if we're looking at this local Seventh Circuit decision from about four or five years ago, there are some bad decisions out there that are not great law that say, well, it's got to be hellish to really be actionable. That's not it. But it's got to be severe pervasive as to affect the terms and conditions of employment, we keep going back to Harris, even though it's now a 30 year old case, it's just got to be enough to affect their terms and conditions of employment and really mess with somebody. So what do we mean that? Okay, we have a general idea of it's got to be really serious. But what does that look like in practice? So, and I'm going to highlight one word here, sexual harassment, which is so severe or pervasive as to alter the terms, the conditions of the victims employment and create an abusive work environment violates Title Seven. So that's this Perkins decision that I flagged before quoting Meritor again and Faragher. So I want to point to one operative word here, however,
30:37severe or pervasive, there are, the road is littered with reversed decisions, where they hold where a judge holds, that the claim is defeated, because it is not severe and pervasive. That is not the test. It is an either or, it can be both, but it needn't be severe, I think is a pretty obvious term, we're going to go through what that looks like in practice, but pervasive means different things to different people. So what you're thinking about here is, in terms of, it means pervasive, it means essentially, it's got to be happening a lot, it's got to be consistent. If it's not real serious, it's going to have to be constant. So this is just a couple more examples of how the Supreme Court decisions do that. Look to these tests. So once again, you look to all circumstances frequency. So going back to Harris, this is what you look to frequency of conduct, whether it is its severity, whether it is physically threatening or humiliating or in your offensive utterance, and whether it unreasonably interferes with an employee's work performance. psychological well being component is helpful, but it's not. It's not on its own dispositive in either direction. This is also the case law will tell you typically a fact question, it's gotta be pretty obvious. There's nothing there for summary judgment to actually be a proper outcome in these claims. Okay. So in the spirit of trying to make sure every circuit wherever you're watching this in the US or abroad, I guess, if you're working remote is covered, I walked through circuit by circuit,
32:11how those circuits just provide this test and how they articulate it. So that you have those examples. So I'm not going to read all of them. But know that they're there. And they're all largely using the same type of language. They're all citing back to Harris, to merit or to ferret, Grinnell Earth, or on Kali, or anything that's come in between or after this Second Circuit decision, I'm just going to stay here for one moment and point out, this is the same in Illinois, that with some nuances, title 719 81, or any other type of hostile work environment claim. And the state law claims are typically assessed using the same standards, with some exceptions. And that you looked at the totality of circumstances and then those factors articulated in the Harris case. Once again, as you see in this cruise decision, isolated incidents typically don't rise to that level.
33:10My experience and I have litigated these cases I most of my career has been spent in Illinois doing northern district and state law claims of this nature, but I did it the very beginning of my career, get the opportunity to work on these cases out of the Ninth Circuit in Vegas, and handle some as well in Florida, New York and North Carolina. So I have some sense of the lay of the land on these. And you will you will see different iterations of this test and what have you, but they all still continue to operate largely the same way. Um, so again, I'm not going to read through all these I think it's kind of a time suck and distracts what we're really here for today. Just know that we're always operating off of the Harris decisions. Okay, so I want to give some examples of severe or pervasive see here, we've got this 10 Circuit decision rounds, pointing out that proof of severity or pervasiveness, conservative independent grounds to sustain a hostile work environment claim, kind of nice when you have both and quite often they do go hand in hand. But as we're going to get to in a moment, there are sometimes really severe one off incidents where where the claims are actionable. There is you will see in some of these decisions, I'm going to pause here and the Throup decision. We assess this element severe pervasive based on both subjective and objective criteria. So it's not enough that you subjectively proceed conduct to be severe pervasive, you have to show that a rational jury would also find that the workplace is permeated with discriminatory intimidation,
34:48ridicule, and insult. So again, when we go to the bullying or stray, inappropriate remarks, the run of the mill, boorish, juvenile or annoying behavior that is not uncommon in the American workplace is not the stuff of its Title Seven hostile work environment claim. I want to pause here for a moment. I handled a case early in my career like given these horror stories, because I think they give some color to this and make it make more sense, handled a case against let's call it a gaming establishment in the desert, if you will I out of the Ninth Circuit, many, many years ago, and it was a race and sex claim.
35:24And our client was African American. And there was pervasive use of the N word in that case by coworkers. I, as an aside, I think even one use of that word is not okay. And there, at least at the time was some pretty good case law saying one use of that word would be a problem. This was not a one off, it happened a lot. Our client was African American. Now the defense is a tax strategy, not something I would have anticipated was our clients had not had not locked down in social media and had a rap career he was trying to get going. We were unaware of this or would have prepared for it. And during our clients deposition, he got the joy of we all got the joy of being blindsided by getting a projector brought in midway through the day. And defense counsel essentially walking through all of his rap videos in which he did swear and use some use a particular racial slur, but it wasn't the white harasser using it, it was him using it in the context of race of his songs, I am not here to to litigate that issue, other than to say the argument that was brought up on summary judgment was that he could not possibly have been subjectively or objectively offended based on these videos. Thankfully, the district court saw through that argument for what it was and rejected it but that is sometimes how that aspect of this can get litigated. So just be aware of it. Um, so Okay, a couple examples we've got. More than just off color jokes are teasing. In the Ellsworth case at a Tennessee plaintiff was repeatedly proposition for sex, and there
37:00were frequent open speculations about his genitalia and sexual performance. The court held that under those the totality of the circumstances that was enough to get a hostile work environment through summary judgment or pleading stage, the beta decision out of the Sixth Circuit, ongoing sexual comments over a seven year period were sufficient to support the claim. They were commonplace, ongoing and continual establishing a pervasive component, the Beatty case at a Kansas very old one. It was sufficiently pervasive and hostile. Even though there was no touching, or graffiti. It was just a regular, numerous string of comments that were sexual and demeaning. I want to focus on the demeaning component, I'm going to give another race example. So I gave the binary one zero case. One other one was a case where an African American woman worked at a fast food establishment. And she heard co workers frequently saying the phrase grape jelly and she didn't put two and two together right away and really notice much after a few weeks, she goes a Why is everybody yelling that out? And the coworker because she was the only African American employee in the store goes, Oh, well, every time you people come in, you put grape jelly on all your food. So what essentially these people were doing was screaming out their euphemism for a slur about black people every time somebody came in. So on its face, that's not an obvious slur that creates a pervasive hostile work environment. But over time, understanding that the joke's on you the
38:27whole time. Suddenly, that took on a very different meaning to our client with real severe consequences. So a couple more examples that we provide. Okay, so I've alluded to the mythical single incident hostile work environment case. So let's just take a quick pause here on that some circuit court divergence here, but different circuits do give some examples where a single instance of sexual harassment was enough to meet the severe pervasive Well, the severe test. It's got to be really bad, though. So it's not one example of asking somebody out on a date and rubbing their arm. I'm not saying that's not a big deal at work. But that's just not going to cut it, you've really got to have something serious. So this is that moment where I say we're going to cover something a little sensitive. There's a Ninth Circuit decision that's about 20 years old, talking about a plaintiff being drugged, kidnapped and raped repeatedly during one night. So it's a one off incident, or a one off event was extremely severe. I don't think that should have been controversial, but it met the criteria. There's some Seventh Circuit case law as well discussing the same you're talking about a sexual assault her and attempt sexual assault, though, for that really to to satisfy the test.
39:36There were obviously other horrific things that happened in this particular case. That helped that that were not maybe on their own explicitly sexual. But again, if you take it in the context of everything that happened, there clearly severe incidents that speak to a hostile work environment. You have this Guadalajara decision out of the Fifth Circuit giving some examples of where this could be a problem as well that are not nearly as bad as those seventh and ninth circuit decisions I just described, you have the worst case where the employer stroked the plaintiff's face and buttocks, put his hand down her shirt and touched her breast for several seconds. That on its own was enough to get the case over the finish line there. So it's not just even one unwanted touching, because unwanted touching takes on a lot of different meanings. I have another northern district and Mississippi case that I flagged here. But be mindful, though not every circuit does this. I don't believe the 11th circuit has an absolute ban on these claims, but they are pretty hostile to a one off incident from what I have uncovered. So let's go back very, very briefly to slide 20. The test, so we've covered that you reform you were subjected to sexual harassment, whether it is the abusive or inappropriate or gender motivated language, or the sexual advances, and sexually explicit conduct we described at the beginning, that it was unwelcome, we covered how we can describe that it's based on sex.
41:05And we've now covered the severe pervasive component that had had the effect of unreasonably interfering with work performance. So now we get to the little bit more complicated part, establishing employer liability. And through that, we're going to cover the fair gorilla with affirmative defense. So it depends on who does it. If it's a coworker, we're really operating from a negligence standard. If you can show that the employer was negligent in permitting the harassment to occur, then the jury should be instructed that the nature and degree of authority wielded by the harasser is a factor to be considered in determining the negligence. But basically, what we're covering here is that the employer knew or should have known, failed to act in the face of complaints, or failed to act in the face of this stuff is happening right in front of you constantly or happened in front of you, and you're not handling it appropriately, you're going to have a showing of negligence, where a supervisor gets involved changes the calculus a bit, I'm going to bring back up quid pro quo and point out that under Burlington, or under the Fair Grinnell Earth cases, you've got strict liability for quid pro quo harassment, which because the supervisor is involved makes sense. Where you have a hostile work environment, it is still sometimes strict liability for supervisors If so, okay, where there is a tangible employment action that is the culminating act of harassment. So essentially, at the end of it, you fire them, it is strict liability. So
42:31there is no negligence it is they are strictly liable, where it culminates in that tangible employment action. You're going to have to show something concrete most of the time to establish that but that's the test where there is no tangible employment action. So essentially, it doesn't culminate in a firing a suspension and demotion or something. It is strict liability unless the employer can satisfy the fair girl or if affirmative defense, which we will now cover. I'm sorry, before we do that, I want to mention what mean what supervisory means, because until 2013, that was an open question. And then we get another one of the seminal cases bans versus Ball State. And in that decision, the Supreme Court clarified that not all supervisors are, you know, big, so if you will, supervisors and employees, a supervisor for purposes of these vicarious liability analyses, if they are empowered by the employer to take that tangible employment action. Pay attention to your state laws on this topic. I'm going to use Illinois as an example here to say, Illinois Human Rights Act, the Illinois Human Rights Act, which is Illinois, what I like to call baby Title Seven law, even though it's actually much broader, define supervisory much more broadly. And there's a fair amount of state Supreme Court and state appellate court case law in our state holding that you do not have to have this measure of authority. So team leads are low level supervisors with some clear type of authority will meet the standard under federal law higher standard.
44:02So here's one place where state and federal law can diverge. Okay, so here we go to the fair gorilla test. This is a little bit more case law. I'm not going to run through this slide too much. This is sort of expounding on what I was just talking about. I want to talk about the defense itself. So the employer is subject to vicarious liability under strict liability unless you've got this affirmative defense. So there are two elements that the employer exercise reasonable care to prevent and correct promptly any sexually harassing behavior, and not or that the plaintiff unreasonably failed to take advantage of any preventative or corrective opportunities provided by the employer to avoid otherwise harm. promulgating an anti harassment policy can be a component to this, there is some good case law that the absence of a policy or clear reporting mechanism prevents your ability to assert this defense, or certainly limits it. You're also not typically limited to the quote unquote designated complaint procedures. So one of the strategies They will often see management take in defending these cases that yeah, you complained. But you didn't use the right complaint procedure, or what you said to trigger the investigation did not give the employer enough information to determine that this is sexual harassment.
45:16There's mixed case law on these topics. Usually you can overcome that. But not all complaints are going to do the job as with retaliation, there's going to have to be some industry, even if it doesn't use the word sexual harassment, or describe, you know, the legal terminology, it's got to give the employer some indication of what they're looking into. So that's that defense, it is sometimes available where you have supervisory harassment. Okay, so that was a very long sprint, if you will, through how to establish a hostile work environment claim based on sex or sexual harassment claim at the federal level, what elements you'll have to meat and some nuances to those claims. And as well, what are some of the affirmative defenses you may have to grapple with? I'll just mention before we move on entirely from defenses, that's not the only way these cases are defended. defense counsel will often very successfully attack the different elements from slide 20, that it was not predicated on sex, or whatever category, you're bringing the claim for. That there, you know, you can attack different elements to the employer liability issue, you can attack that it was severe, pervasive. There's a lot of that that goes on. So let's just touch on state companion statutes or state sort of equivalent statutes. I'm going to use Illinois as the example primarily just because it's where I practice, but I am going to mention other states here too. So in Illinois, we have the Human Rights Act, which is essentially a catch all to the myriad
46:48federal anti discrimination statutes that I mentioned at the beginning, are for most at least. So it covers race, color, religion, sex, national origin, citizenship status, ancestry age, we get way broader coverage now order of protection status, marital status, familial status as to housing, physical or mental disability, arrest, record, military status, sexual orientation, and unfavorable discharged from military service, there may be some new elements to this as well, I believe hair discrimination is now covered in Illinois. And in our state as of about four or five years ago, it used to be 15 employees was the minimum definition to meet an employer. Now it's as long as somebody with one employee is covered. One other minor nuance to this law, not so minor is damages.
47:34There is no cap on damages, like you have under Title Seven, but there is no punitive damages available, so you have uncapped compensatory damages. You have similar though not exactly the same administrative exhaustion requirements. For example, in Illinois, you have 60 days from the time you filed a charge or when it's accepted to opt out. Otherwise, you're bound to the investigation for some period of time. They have to complete the investigation within one year absent an agreed extension by the parties, and what have you. But just know that those exist. It is my understanding that there are largely three and a half states I say Georgia, because I think there is protection for public employees, that these states tend not to have any other state laws, at least according to workplace fairness.org. One of the free resources, I will plug everybody else has at least some state civil rights equivalent, even if it doesn't operate the same or cover everything. This is that moment where I will plug workplace fairness.
48:32It's a great free resource. It has answers to a lot of these questions, and it has a lot of free, useful materials for employers, employees and attorneys alike as to how they can contemplate these issues and navigate the workplace ethically. I want to touch on administrative exhaustion because it's going to give us a nice dovetail into the gender violence act. So you have an administrative exhaustion requirement that I mentioned before you with the exception of certain race claims primarily under Section 1981. You have to file a charge of discrimination with the government before you can bring a discrimination or harassment lawsuit. Usually that involves filing with the EEOC or some equivalent state agency, most will have crossed filing agreements. But I'm not sure that that's true everywhere. So what that would mean essentially is if you protect your statute of limitations and file a charge with one, you have covered your state or federal law claims with the other.
49:24Be mindful of the substance and form of the charge because in Illinois, for example, the IDA char has really really formulaic and specific requirements for what a charge has to look like that are not present for EEOC claims. And that may, depending on how you file those charges, if you're not broad enough, or you're too specific, or you don't cover enough, you can sometimes lose claims. I'm not here to cover that in detail today. Just know that there's a relation back issue. Some states have shorter statute of limitations when Illinois amended the Human Rights Act Four or five years ago um There was up until that time, 180 days statute of limitations, I believe California has a three year statute. So that before we move on from an entirely, that doesn't mean you got to capture the whole hostile work environment within the 300 days. So think back to one of those decisions where you had like seven years of ongoing comments or conduct, it would have been impossible, because you would have had to have the charge on file within the first year of it happening, to even cover it all, not the requirement. So in the Morgan decision, the Supreme Court and other Seminole Supreme Court decision on hostile environment, you're not time barred, as long as everything is part of the same ongoing unlawful employment practice, and at least one act falls within the 300 days. So if you leave the job for a year, and you come back, you're probably out of luck. But if this just goes on forever, as long as you work there, you get to keep capturing it. But that
50:58doesn't help everybody. So here we get to the GBA. What do you do if somebody's not ready to move forward within 300 days, or just something happened, where they were not in a position to do anything until after that deadline passes. And we don't have to think too hard about what gets us there. survivors of sexual assault in particular, but other forms of trauma are often not prepared to address what happened to them from a civil or criminal legal context. For a long time, we actually as a firm just handled a case where somebody waited five years to come forward about an ongoing hostile work environment.
51:34Just because they weren't ready yet. And luckily, we're going to cover now, not for everybody, not for race claims and not for all sex harassment survivors. But for some there, at least in Illinois is one other option. And some other states have equivalent laws or similar laws met equivalent. So we have a solution, but a limited one. So let's go to the Illinois gender violence act. So where you have some unwanted touching or gender violence, in my state, there is an option. So this is about a 20 year old law, it is not heavily litigated, so the decisions on it are rather sparse. And it clarified a few things. This is not germane to today, but I'll just mention to clarify that domestic violence is a form of gender related violence, that gender related violence is a form of sex discrimination. And it recognizes that the 300 day statute of limitations issued deprive survivors of time to heal before they're ready to pursue and is just, frankly, draconian, in short. So I'm pulling this language straight from the statute. What is this law do? Any person who has been subjected to gender related violence as defined in Section Five of the Act can bring a civil cause of action for damages, injunctive relief or other appropriate relief against a person or persons perpetrating that gender related violence for purposes of this section, perpetrating means either personally committing the gender related violence or personally encouraging or assisting the acts of gender related violence? What are the remedies, so you get really what you get a
53:00lot of other places damages injunctive relief or other appropriate relief can be actual damages, emotional distress, or peonies, as well as attorneys fees and costs. So like the rest of the Civil Rights statutes I mentioned today, it is what we call a fee shifting statute. So if you prevail, as a contingency lawyer or hourly, you have the right to have your fees paid by the other side of your client does. So we talked about section 10 Just now. Okay, so definitions, this is important. What is gender related violence. In Illinois, that means one or more act of violence or aggression, satisfying the elements of battery under the laws of Illinois, that has at least in part committed on the basis of the person's sex, regardless of whether there's a criminal component, it can also be a physical intrusion, or physical invasion of a sexual nature under coercive conditions. So think of a less obvious, not just forcible sex, but there's other forms of unwanted sexual touching, or sex acts that can be coerced, again, whether or not there's prosecution or convictions, or a threat that causes a realistic apprehension that they mean it. So essentially, almost an assault there. So going back to this definition, it doesn't have to be a criminal battery, it doesn't even have to be a full hostile work environment. If you have an act of gender related violence that at least meets the common law, criminal or civil statutory definitions of a battery, and you can tether it to somebody's sex. You have a viable course cause of action. So backing up, what
54:35does that mean? I'm going to give a couple examples of how our firm has approached it means a lot of things. So I described. I'll give a few different examples, one, a hostile work environment case where we were within our statute, and we're able to bring a hostile work environment case that we brought in state court in Illinois under the Human Rights Act that satisfies all the same elements that we've talked about under Title Seven. Were at a car dealership, the client and harass her basically cornered or came up from behind, pressed himself and himself if you will up against her and tried to push her into the bathroom to have sex with him she fled. We brought a gender violence claim for that. We've had cases where a CEO type basically leverages the client's job into an unwanted he might call it a fair, I didn't think it I thought it was a course of sexual dynamic. I won't dignify it by calling it a relationship, where he made he hired this person as a backup secretary or executive assistant, there was no job description. And basically her job was follow his orders, traveled with him at a state and basically agree or not really egregious and not feel like she could fight back when he pushed for sex. And then, you know, made comments like, Well, I wouldn't worry about your job, we know we both want this. Or don't worry, you know, your job is safe, things like that, that had a real menacing feel to them when you consider the context. Another couple examples, I'm going to give touch on what I talked about earlier, where it's not
56:09explicitly sexual, like the two examples I've given. So the first one was more prong one, you've got an unwanted touching and physical aggression, that very clearly is sex motivated, the second being more of the coercive, sexual dynamic and acts. The third and fourth examples I'm going to give are more the first but not in the same way. One is the case I described earlier, we represented somebody who identified as gay, worked on a factory floor that was a hard blue collar environment that wasn't exactly very forgiving for this sort of thing was called a bunch of homophobic epithets, and at one point was kicked in the testicles. Not an attempted sexual assault, not attempted rape, not not coercing him into sex, but it is attacking him because of his sexual orientation physically. It clearly was a battery. So our our position was that was a gender violence violation. The other example that I can give that's more akin to that was where we represented an LGBTQ employee whose summer job was with somebody who was a neo Nazi. And he came out to this person for some reason. And this person started getting really violent with him and calling him a series of homophobic slurs that I do not repeat. Again, not beating this person, but for his gender, to bring it completely full circle and go to the very beginning and the Bostock decision. In pleading the case, we pleated it in a way where we tethered it to the dicta and holding of the Bostock decision, that sexual that sexual orientation is sex for purposes of sex harassment, or
57:50discrimination, in terms of how we pleaded the gender motivated violence in that claim. So these are just a few different ways we as a firm have brought it. But it has a lot of different options, again, for Illinois specific gender violence. So now we get to one of the nuances to the statute, which is vicarious liability, because the way the statute reads If you'll recall, any person
58:19can bring a claim against person or persons who perpetrate the gender related violence or assist or encourage it. So you can probably guess what the conundrum is because a person is not a corporation, except I guess, under the Supreme Court's Citizens United decision. So Illinois had and I say had because it's about to be mood, a split between state and federal courts. And that split came from in 2019, the gay Sikh versus Marquette decision in which the Illinois appellate court held in circumstances they declined to provide that employers could be held liable for the actions of their employees who commit gender motivated violence or sexual assault. That constitutes gender violence, under some unspecified circumstances, they were kind enough not to provide that particular case I'll just mention was not an employment case. So it made it a little bit easier in involved. And why it applied in that case, makes sense. It was somebody like the maintenance worker, having a history of complaints of sexual misconduct, but the management company not doing anything about that. And as you might predict, giving this guy keys to somebody's apartment or access led to a really bad outcome and in a sexual assault. There were very clear reasons why there should have been vicarious liability there. That has been up until now, what most attorneys in Illinois will do is look for that kind of notice to justify the claim to establish that kind of vicarious liability, you look to sort of simple principles and negligence to tethered to the employer. I
59:52never tried doing it on a strict liability basis based on a supervisor but I suppose that might be one other creative way to attack it. I can't promise it will be success. basketball but it's a theory. But what this did was it created a split between state and federal courts because district courts in the area, with the exception, I think one Southern District of Illinois decision that gave a nod to gay sick, all the Northern District decisions in Illinois, held that person did not mean a corporate entity or they didn't establish vicarious liability. I am unaware of how Illinois Central district handled it. So you have this split that existed. This is not a shameless plug, I'll just mention I helped author and advocate the amendments that I'm about to describe. So Illinois test up until now is about to change. This law does not take effect until the amendments to this law will not take effect until January. So for claims that accrue before January, you're going to be operating under the old regime, the basic world if you will, but for new GTA claims, the amendments that we worked on, clarify that an employer can be held liable for gender related violence committed in the workplace, under some circumstances that you can read here when there's a failure to supervise trainer monitor, failure to investigate complaints or reports, and to take remedial measures. And if the gender violence is the proximate cause of the injury, it reiterates the GVS original legislative intent. I know this is not a
1:01:18domestic violence presentation, but I'll just mention, there were Circuit Court judges locally not paying attention to the preamble to the statutes. So this way domestic violence is at least covered. There was a compromise that was negotiated, however. So going back to why do we need this? You have this 300 Day statute of limitations? Well, the GBA has a seven year statute of limitations in this moment. I believe it's two years for the prong C or prong three violations the realistic apprehension, the assault version, but for actual gender violence claims, you had a seven year statute of limitations that is still there for claims against individuals. So to the extent you sue somebody individually, or bring a claim against an individual who is solvent and able to, to provide a recovery, you still have seven years to do that. However, for employers, the compromise was a four year statute of limitations to bring a claim for gender violence. So it's not seven, but it's still for more than four times what you would have at most states, and at the federal level to bring a discrimination claim of any kind.
1:02:26I'm just going to mention I'm not going to read through it in detail, just know that the GVA looks to the Illinois Human Rights Act for its definition of employer and reiterates the same definitions of gender related violence. It also defines the workplace. So one of the concerns in crafting the bill was, Well, are we going to now be held responsible for domestic violence that occurs at home or domestic or gender violence that is perpetrated by an employee, but unrelated to the workplace like in your free time, and I can certainly see why an employer would not want to be held liable for that. And so it clarifies that you are not responsible for an employer is not responsible for something that has nothing essentially to do with work. And a workplace can also include activities occurring off premises and employer sponsored events. So think work trips, work events, you know, like a happy hour, what have you. We are not performing your normal duties. So okay, you're not, you know, you're not selling at the sales event, but you're there at a work event for work reasons. We also define what a workplace means geographically.
1:03:39And the new provision that gives rise to employer liability is that the employer is only liable for gender related violence committed in the workplace. When it arises out of it in the course of scope of employment with the employer, it only extends to violent gender violence that occurs while the employee is directly performing their job duties. And the injury is the proximate ID that gender violence is the proximate cause of the injury or the agent of the employer was directly involved in the gender violence and the performance of the contracted work was the proximate cause of the injury. And proximate cause exists when the actions of the employee or the agent of the employer were the substantial factor in causing the injury. You have kind of a negligence standard here. If it is predicated on a failure to train the claim, Illinois passed the workplace Transparency Act, which took effect in 2020. So doing the sex harassment training promulgated by the IAT through the HRA is an affirmative defense to that sort of claim. And if an employer fails to investigate the claims, that can give rise to liability. You also we were careful not to preempt common law causes of action or any other form of gender related violence that might be covered under the GBA. So I think I already touched on this, what this might look like in practice, but basically considered the logic behind what you couch is gender related violence, same sex gender related violence that hey, crimes cases that I described earlier, attempted or unfortunately
1:05:03successful sexual assaults, delayed outcry cases. So think I mean, nothing stops you from bringing a GBA claim if somebody has a timely charge, but it never hurts. You know, if you're a couple years out, this is a great vehicle. If you've got an individual defendant, and you don't want to mess with administrative exhaustion, or you just think it's a weird fit for an employment, administrative agency case, or domestic violence. So none of the obvious great that helps some people in Illinois, but what about everybody else? Some states, though, by no means all have similar statutes. The one that I was able to locate that comes closest is this New York City Law. It's not a state, I think it's a city law, victims of gender motivated violence protection law. There is a state decision in New York, this brief decision that I found that discusses the viability and sort of pleading bases of such a cause of action, you can see, it does give a civil cause of actions for some kinds of gender violence. And it allows them to sue for money damages, in addition to other civil claims for sexual harassment, or assault and battery. This is the closest I came to the GBA. There was a temporary extension to this law recently, so you've seen some states do this in minor sex abuse contexts. But essentially creating a window when survivors can come forward, even if they're otherwise time barred to bring a claim. I believe California may have a state civil rights statute that touches on some of this, but I'm not. I'm not positive on that. So just, you
1:06:43know, whatever state you're in, this is what you're looking for. Not every state has a GVA. But if you live somewhere that has something similar, these are some angles you can take. There are tort claims as well, that might have a longer statute of limitations. So some ways you might bring that up that come to mind. Think like an eavesdropping or secret recording case that's not gender violence, but it still can be really sexually inappropriate. I've had some cases recently where somebody installs and this is disgusting, but a camera or recording device in like a bathroom or changing room. You know, there are state tort claims that that might be covered by in Illinois, we have invasion of privacy torts, the one that we felt was most actionable there is something called intrusion upon seclusion within the invasion of privacy context, you may run into the vicarious liability liability issue in a different way there. And by that, I mean, you may run into different states have different rules for when you can impute tort liability to a corporate entity or establish vicarious liability. So just be aware that there may be some hindrances on bringing that sort of claim straight up. If it's just a low level employee, and there's no notice to the company.
1:08:05There are also preemption issues that may come up so Illinois has Human Rights Act preemption and Workers Compensation Act preemption. In our case, if it's a negl, if it's a physical injury, which can include psychic injury, and it sounds in negligence, you are going to be preempted from bringing that claim based on a theory of negligent hiring, retention and supervision, because the theory is the workers comp act and Illinois preempts all negligence based forms of causes of action for employment, such that comp is the remedy for that. I HRA preemption conceptually, and I'm paraphrasing and glossing over it in Illinois is, let's say you have a sex harassment case. And you also bring a claim for intentional infliction of emotional distress and battery. If the claim essentially can't stand on its own. If it's just well, you made a series of sexually inappropriate comments which which amounts to intentional infliction of emotional distress, you're probably going to get that claim knocked out as being preempted, because essentially, it is just parroting the same conduct that gave rise to the sexual harassment claim such that it can't stand on its own. However, I also mentioned battery, because if there is an unwanted touching, like with the GVA, that would be improper anyway. So you may run into the vicarious liability issue, again, depending on how your state addresses that. But it does give you a couple of other tools. Illinois also has a hate crime statute that you can sometimes employ. It's not a one to one I don't recall
1:09:47specifically if it's going to apply in a sec context. So there are other avenues you have you it does you well to know what offensive weapons exist in your state. You now have a good survey of what After a while looks like and also just pay attention to when states create these windows for you to bring a claim well after the statute, because it may give you options you wouldn't otherwise have, even if only temporarily. So we'll finish with the same disclaimer, this is just tip of the iceberg. There are obviously quite a few nuances to these sex harassment cases. They are very time intensive, they are very labor intensive, they're emotional, and they're challenging. And there are a lot of moving pieces. So spend some time with them know the case law in your circuit as to each of the elements I've walked through today. But this should at least give you an overview of what you're looking for. I'm going to include in the next slide, some free resources folks can touch on if you're a survivor, or you need funding to defend a defamation case, countersuit or or retaliatory suit. In a sex harassment case. The time's up legal defense fund a National Women's Law Center have some wonderful resources, as well as for survivors of sexual violence and harassment, who need help, both legal and psychological, National Employment Lawyers Association Neela has a national organization that's wonderful. Check your state most states also a Neela. equivalent, we have Neil, Illinois here, the EEOC, federal agency that investigates and just addresses discrimination has incredible
1:11:21guidelines. And just sort of packets of information on how the case law plays out best practices and how to pursue these cases and just think about them. And then I've mentioned that a couple of times, workplace fairness or workplace fairness.org has a lot of really good national resources. There is a list of that did not print to PDF Well, or I would have included it in the materials of states, state specific state civil rights laws and ones that do not exist. That's where I got the four states that don't really have great options for that. And we'll also tell you the various administrative exhaustion, statutory statute of limitations requirements and what have you, among many, many, many other things. Then finally, if you have any questions, you can always call or email me, excuse me, saves me from having to do real work, and I always like talking about these things. Thank you so much for watching at home please feel free to reach out with questions. And I hope this has been informative.
Judith G.NJ
This was excellent! The presentation was clear and engaging. Very informative
Alexander C.NY
This was one of the best CLE courses I ever watched. Thank you
Noah M.IL
Extremely well-done. Highly informative. This is the best lecture I've watched of all of them. Great work, Max.
Christina J.MN
This was honestly an phenomenal training. Even though this isn't my practice area I felt this was really valuable!!!