0:00Hello, this is Colleen Quinn. I'm coming to you from Richmond, Virginia. And I'm really happy today to do this program for LexVid. On introduction to assisted reproductive technology, we finally referred to as RT AR T, although it's not what hangs on the wall. So we're going to talk about art law and also drafting assisted reproductive technology contracts. today. I'm based out of Richmond, Virginia and I have been doing adoption and surrogacy work for over 32 years. I went way marry undergrad UVA law school. And I belong to a number of organizations been president of the Academy of adoption and assisted reproduction attorneys and also served on the Board of Trustees for a long period of time.
0:43Also, other organizations, the ABA art committee and the American Society for Reproductive Medicine also are organizations that are really critical to being in this area of the law. We'll talk a little bit about more, a little bit more about those organizations as we go along. Alright, so what are we going to plan to cover today, we're going to talk about the terminology and different types of assisted reproductive technologies. We're going to talk about some of the prerequisites that need to be met prior to contract drafting. We're gonna talk about drafting basic basics and provisions to include really important legal issues. And we're going to kind of hit upon some of the unique issues that are out there, such as divorce and frozen embryo issues, abortion and selective reduction provisions in contracts, a choice of law and conflict of law issues. And then some unique issues that affect same sex couples, international intended parents and unmarried couples, we're just going to briefly hit upon those. So this is intended to be a pretty introductory program, just giving a lot of the basics not really doing a super deep dive, a deeper dive would be probably one of my programs on advanced surrogacy contracts, which would be kind of a part two to this program. So when we look at what is our law? Well, first of all, it's a constantly evolving area of the law, because it's so tied to medicine and medical advancements, it's just, it's really hard to stay on top of the medicine sometimes. But that's what makes it really
2:28exciting and challenging also. So our law is most closely tied to adoption law, because it's family formation, it's family building, or helping families grow, or we're helping people to have children. But also, it's really largely rooted in contract law as well. So we have clients that basically are looking to do some sort of family building. And they usually want to look at either assisted reproductive technologies, or they're turning to adoption, mainly because of infertility issues. Of course, their goal is to have children be parents. And a lot of these clients have really struggled when they typically come to you as their attorney. A lot of them have been through infertility treatments, they've spent a lot of money on trying to figure out what their fertility issues are. Now some might know right, when they get married, then there might be medical issues that they knew about before, if they're a couple coming together, could be a single person as well, having a child, but typically, they're going to come with some sort of story. And it's important to be compassionate with these clients that come to us, because typically, they have already encountered a number of issues with having children and also usually have spent a lot of money on fertility doctors. And so we also know now that there are 1000s and 1000s of embryos in storage. And so we are starting to see more and more folks use donated embryos on as part of this process. So we're going to talk about that a little bit as well. So we've got just lots of embryos now that are
4:26in storage. And in fact, we were able to get Virginia law changed in 2019 to allow a single person or couples to use donor embryos. And we actually package it as a pro life on Bill, given the number of embryos that are in storage so that we could bring those embryos to life. And so we were able to navigate on both sides, both political sides of the of the Virginia General Assembly, and able to get that legislation passed. So, of course all of these embryos all day One is a womb somewhere, so that they can develop. So when we look at the new world of family creation options, there are so many different variables, folks could be using donor egg, it can be known or anonymous donor sperm known or anonymous. Donor embryo, typically known less frequently anonymous. And by the way, we always tell folks that there's no such thing as total anonymity. Since 23, me ancestry.com and other ways of doing genetic testing, there really is no way that every single situation is going to be able to be kept anonymous anymore. Of course, we have clients that are looking to use a gestational carrier. And they might be using that gestational carrier with a combination of their own egg and sperm, they might be using their own sperm donor egg, they might be using their own egg and donor sperm, or they might be using that donor embryo as well. And then we still do see couples that or single people that are using traditional surrogates, as well, less frequently than a gestational surrogate or gestational carrier, but we also have traditional surrogates. So we've got
6:18lots of different combinations going on. And that might include actually having somebody of the opposite race, there might be a white gestational carrier, Caucasian gestational carrier, carrying Asian donor parts, and have Asian twins delivered for an Asian couple, or we might have an African American carrier caring for a Caucasian family. So there really is a lot of cross culture going on here. And because of the cross cultures, we just also need to make sure that people's religious and ideological views also mesh in these arrangements as well. But there really are no color or race barriers. I'm in the whole world of assisted reproductive technologies. So when we look at the most common agreements that we might be working on as lawyers, we might be working on an egg donor agreement. And that could be where an egg donor donates directly to the intended parents. Or it could be a clinic document where the donor is signing an agreement with the clinic, and the donor is anonymous. And it could also be where the donor is donating her her eggs to a cryo preservation bank, and she intends to be anonymous. And then we might be reviewing the recipients agreements with that clinic. Or we might have a direct egg donor agreement between the donor and the recipients. Um, same thing with the sperm donor agreements, we might be reviewing a direct agreement or drafting a direct agreement between the male egg donor and the recipient, or it could be we're reviewing clinic releases or documents. On behalf of folks that are purchasing sperm either known
8:15or anonymous from a cryobank. They thing with embryo donation agreements. Typically, the embryo donation agreements are direct agreements between the donors and their recipients. But now we're seeing all sorts of different kinds of embryo donation agreements, it might be between a couple that formed their embryos together, and now they're divorcing and now one spouse wants to donate the embryos to the other spouse. And we are also seeing embryo donation agreements get more complicated with regard to it could be a couple that's donating 10 embryos, and they're donating them out to three different sets of recipients. Or it can be folks that already have received donated embryos that are now turning around and re donating them to somebody else. So the complexity of these arrangements is starting to get a little bit crazier, and making sure that we follow the prior agreements. And we look at the prior agreements and make sure any current agreements are consistent on with those prior agreements becomes more important. Of course, we've got surrogacy and gestational carrier agreements, and then the agreements with the fertility clinics can encompass a number of things that could be the informed consent forms, the financial agreements, that could be the cryopreservation agreements for the cryopreservation of the eggs or the sperm or the embryos. And so looking at those agreements, becomes more and more critical as well, including making sure any agreement that we are drafting or reviewing is going to be consistent with the clinic documents. So
9:53by way of example, I had a couple come to me the other day on married couple, but very committed to each other. And the clinic document that they were about to sign basically said that if they split up, that the embryos that they were about to create, the disposition of the embryos would be governed by any divorce decree or a Separation Agreement. And so they came to me and they were like, this is kind of crazy, because this is saying that our disposition of our embryos is going to have to depend on something down the road. And I said, Well, what we need to do is we need to do an embryo disposition agreement between you now, I'm going into this so that we know in advance and then I had a nice conversation with the fertility doctors said that they changed their forms, to now provide that folks going into forming their embryos in advance can do that embryo disposition agreement in the event of death, or disability or divorce and separation. So that's just an example of that interaction between the clinic documents and then some of the documents that we would be working on as the lawyers on behalf of our clients. So what are the typical roles for the lawyer will of course to review the agreement on behalf of a party to draft the agreement to draft and negotiate and negotiate the agreement to review those fertility clinic documents, in some cases to actually request changes to the fertility clinic documents. Now, we're also looking at surrogacy program documents, and whether any negotiation can occur with the surrogacy
11:40program. So we've got more and more clients where I'm looking at the surrogacy programs, documents and advising them as to whether it makes sense for them to go with this program or whether they need to ask for some some of the terms to be changed. Also, the lawyer will handle the birth certificate amendment process or the parentage order or the pre or post birth order, or whatever proceedings are necessary to resolve the parentage issues, less often now actually doing an adoption. But in some cases, adoption is still still may be necessary in some states. Alright, so the key thing for the lawyer is to watch out for not practicing law in a state in which we're not licensed, that can get us into some some trouble. And then also watching out for dual representation. And so, you know, try to represent the both the clinic and the intended parents or the clinic and the donor or trying to represent surrogacy program or agency, and one of the parties working with the agency. And so it's it's not a good practice, because of the conflicts that can develop. The Academy of adoption assisted reproduction attorneys has a really good code of ethics that governs ensuring that there's not dual representation and that we're not getting into conflict situations. All right, so pretty much all states now allow for some sort of surrogacy or we're gestational carrier arrangements. But we still have to be careful about different state laws. For example, Michigan still forbids getting people put together to do compensated CEREC. And we just have to make sure that we are
13:35following the laws of each individual state. Some states like Virginia do not expressly allow for compensation, but they allow for reimbursements for reasonable household and living expenses. And so oftentimes, we get to some of the same payment amounts that are being paid in other states, that we have to be really careful about how the payments might be characterized. And so one of the things that we're also looking at typically is what is going to be the governing law of the contract, which state law are we going to pick? And why does it make sense to pick that state's law? All right, so my colleague in the Academy of adoption assisted reproduction attorneys, Diane Henson has a lovely map of the surrogacy laws on her website, which is helpful, but that said, you want to always check with lawyers in that state with experienced counsel. And sometimes there are actual ly kind of particular localities like county to county or region to region within that state differences that might occur. By way of example, I have a colleague in Indiana, who is able to get now a pre birth order, but it would be using a very Jenya contracts, and it's with the particular judge that he is educated. And basically, I just have to do an opinion letter that says that the contracts perfectly legal under Virginia law, etc. And then he's been able to work with this particular judge in this particular county to be able to get that pre birth order. So they can be kind of locality dependent. And we always want to check with local counsel in that regard. All right, so
15:29let's go through the terminology. It's kind of this alphabet soup of acronyms in the assisted reproductive technology world. But knowing the basic terms and the proper use of them is crucial. Some of the clients are going to come to you really knowing the medical terminology, others are not. But a lot of this terminology gets put into the contracts. And so we have to become familiar with these terms. So the term just you know, assisted reproductive technology just generally refers to all fertility treatment in which eggs and sperm or embryos are handled outside of the body. And the purpose is to facilitate the conception of a child. And the assistant part is typically, but not always, medical providers assisting with the conception of the child. So artificial insemination, of course, is when a female is artificially inseminated, meaning sperm is injected via some artificial means, into her uterus. Does that include home insemination kits? It can depending on state law, it might. We have an interesting case out of Roanoke, Virginia that went up to our Virginia Court of Appeals, where the female getting pregnant, she had a friend that she thought was a donor, they used a turkey baster. The initial trial court judge said that the turkey baster was a kitchen instrument and it did not qualify as an intervening medical technology. Our Virginia Court of Appeals agreed with that. On that case, the donor turned out to be a dad, not a donor, of course, they didn't have a donor agreement between their donor agreement
17:23between the two of them either, in addition to using the turkey baster. And so in our contracts, we want to make sure that we clearly define what the parties intend to be intervening medical technology. Do they intend that a home insemination kit, that that qualifies as an intervening medical technology? So and we need to be careful about if a medical provider is not being used? Is there going to be a third party witness, we just have to be careful about being able to prove that the conception did in fact occur with a medical intervening technology if it's not being done at a fertility clinic or a doctor's office. So I've included a slide in there on artificial insemination. And versus IU i, which is inter uterine insemination. It's it's very technical in nature, but I've included it so that you could understand the technical difference. And so feel free to read that slide. I'm not going to feel like I need to read it for you. But just in case it comes up, you'll know the difference between the two IVF. Of course, it means in vitro fertilization, commonly referred to as like the test tube, baby. But what happens is the ovaries are medically hyperstimulated. The eggs are then surgically removed. Those eggs are then fertilized with sperm in a laboratory and then the result an embryo is implanted into a uterus. And so that's IVF. At its kind of basic, best. Eggs we typically refer to an unfertilized female gamete as eggs, they also might be called oocytes, or obem or ova. I kind of like sometimes rather than call it a feline called a cat, we typically just call
19:28them eggs, and that just keeps things simple. Same thing sperm, it's just the male reproductive gamete. And there is a lot of debate about the use of testicular sperm as opposed to ejaculated sperm, testicular sperm, meaning that it has to be surgically retrieved from the testicles. There's a lot of debate about which is better. And men typically can have their sperm checked for motility and sperm count or When I have clients come in, when they're looking at potentially doing a sperm donor agreement or they're looking at using a gestational carrier, one of the basic questions I ask is, have you had your sperm checked? Have you had your eggs checked, and those of us in the art field kind of throw these terms around loosely, but it's really important if people are going down this path that they know that the quality of their eggs or the quality of their sperm is going to be high enough and that they're not going to run into issues where they may have needed to consider donor egg or donor sperm instead. All right, moving along with the terminology, IX C i C S I stands for intra cytoplasmic sperm injection.
20:49And that is where the little sperm is basically shot into the nucleus of an egg in the hopes of a cheese being fertilization. One of the fertility Doc's I work with, told me then, that so that little sperm doesn't go too far in the egg, they actually lock the little fellows end of this tail off, so that he doesn't wiggle too far in which I thought was a very interesting, but I've included a little slide there showing what that looks like. It's revolutionized the treatment of male infertility allowing men with extremely low sperm counts. The ability to conceive a child which was nearly impossible before this technique, some people would argue it's messing with mother nature, and that you know that the strongest sperm should be able to make it rather than helping a weaker sperm along and injecting. That said, it's revolutionized the ability for people to have children. So regardless which side of the fence you fall on in terms of whether it's messing with mother nature or not. It's the salvation of a lot of my clients who are now able to have children. And I showed you a little, another little slide there of that IXI, sperm injection and what it looks like. All right, so donor conception, you might hear that term, it basically refers to any conception via donor part. So that could be via donor egg donor sperm or donor embryo. Note that banked eggs and embryos, those that are already frozen are less expensive than eggs that need to be retrieved from a donor or embryos that still have yet to be formed. I've included a slide there on gift versus
22:35ZIFT. Versus bros. Again, I'm not going to read this slide. It's just for your benefit, in case this terminology comes up. But gift G I F T stands for gamete intrafallopian transfer ZIFT Zi F T stands for zygote intrafallopian transfer, and then post refers to pronuclear stage to both transfer. They're just different methods of IVF. And so I've included that slide. Usually we don't get down in the weeds that much with those terms, but in case they come up, you know you've got them there. cryopreservation is a term used a lot and that's just freezing. In arch, we've got sperm eggs, and embryos and now even tissues. Basically, can can be cryopreserved or frozen. Alright, so surrogacy is a kind of loose term that just generally refers to the process of one woman carrying a pregnancy for somebody else. And it's a we use that term kind of loosely, although a true surrogate is one that contributes her own eggs or genetics. So there's basically two types of surrogate, the one is a traditional or true surrogate, who becomes pregnant using her own eggs. And typically with the sperm of the intended father or donor sperm. And in those situations where we have true or traditional surrogacy, it's a lot riskier because the in most jurisdictions if the true surrogate changes her mind, she very well may have claim to the child under Virginia's statute, a true or traditional surrogate is the only one that can avoid or vacate that will basically void the contract and to keep the child and that's that's the case in a number of states. So it's a risky proposition. That
24:53said, I've done lots of a true or traditional surrogacies Even between six stirrers, which is been pretty interesting. And so they they do work out in many events. But clients do need to know that it's unless much riskier venture to have a carrier who's also genetically connected to the child. I slide mentions that an adoption may have to occur. And that's been evolving pretty rapidly, where most jurisdictions are now eliminating the necessity for an adoption. But it's I just looked into like Nebraska where I had two intended fathers that were going to use a sister Sister in law as a surrogate, and we were still bumping up upon the need for them to have to do adoption. Alright, so the other type of surrogate of course, is the gestational carrier, or we call her gestational surrogate, and that is the carrier who is not genetically related to the child. And that is typically an arrangement that is honored in most states now, without the risk of the carrier if she changed her mind in in those situations. Typically, the intended parents now are going to prevail in that regard. In all of these arrangements, though, the carriers are usually psychologically heavily screened, and a lot of thought goes into the arrangement beforehand, so it would be pretty rare to see those situations where a carrier or even a true surrogate would try to keep the child.
26:39Alright, so when we look at cost estimates for art IVF itself can range a lot from 15,000 to 45,000. There are a lot of regional variations that might include just one single embryo transfer, it might include several transfers, there might be a package deal up to six embryo transfers for a certain amount of money. So the medical costs can vary pretty widely. The cost of donor a bag, on average, about 5000 to 15,000, it really varies a lot. Some banked a bag can be purchased for as low as 3000. Sometimes they're bundled a package of already banked eggs. If the donor needs to actually be paid and have her eggs retrieved from her then it's going to be more expensive than already having the cryobank to cryopreserved a egg that's that's already there. Also the bank egg, there's, there's more certainty that the eggs or egg is there already. And the quality of the egg as opposed to picking a donor, who they expect to be retrieved from, there's more uncertainty about how many eggs are going to be retrieved, and what's the quality of the eggs going to be gestational carriers, typically. So if they're fully compassionate, they just don't come out of pocket. And then there's something called quasi compassionate, which is where they get maybe 10 to 15, or 10, to $20,000 as a quasi compassionate carrier, but most outright, kind of paid carriers so to speak. I'm typically now on a minimum about 25,000. And I'm even seeing numbers up as high as 75,000. But right now, it's probably about 25 to
28:3750,000, average. And of course, second time carriers are getting more than first time carriers. I would say most of the contracts that I'm doing right now, the carrier, the base fee, we call it that's over a 10 month period, is typically running about 25 to 45. And then I'm seeing some of them bumping up to the 50,000 we've started seeing a bit of an increase in what the carriers have been paid over the last few years. Alright, and then we talked about IXXI. The interest said plasmic, sperm injection at intracytoplasmic sperm injection, and that usually runs about 2000 for each attempt, but again, there are regional variations and clinics may bundle several attempts for a certain amount. So again, these are just general cost estimates. Medical Insurance for art. Most health insurance policies don't cover the cost of fertility procedures, or may only cover certain types of procedures. And there are some mandated states now that do require that there be coverage for infertility issues. But it's really important to review clients policy to use to see what is covered what's not covered with gestational carriers, we need to make sure that we're looking at their health insurance policies to make sure they're not excluded for being a surrogate. So usually, most policies, at least the policies I see and review on the East Coast, I would say about 80% Very clearly are going to cover the carrier's maternity care for acting as a surrogate, we might see about 10 to 15% of the policies with some murky language. But typically, it's language that
30:38is construed in favor of coverage for the carrier. And then there might be about 5%, where we will see some just absolutely clear exceptions that say that the carrier is not going to be covered for her maternity care if she's acting as a surrogate. There is the ability oftentimes through three different companies to get coverage under the Affordable Care Act, or sometimes some independent insurance brokers. But if a couple is looking specifically just for servicing insurance, it can run $24,000 and on up, so it's really important to make sure that the carrier does have that health insurance coverage and are no exclusions. So I've included on the next slide some helpful information for clients, some of the patient client support groups, the American Society for Reproductive Medicine, the SART society for assisted reproductive technology. And of course, the Academy of adoption and assisted reproduction attorneys all have good websites. ASRM has on the mental health professional group site, they've got really good books, including children's books for clients. So knowing about those resources is important. Alright, we're gonna dive into some of the prerequisites prior to contract drafting because we really do want to make sure that clients have already thought about all the things that need to go into the contract drafting and we don't have a contract blow up in the middle of the drafting process. So first of all, I mentioned earlier coordinating with the fertility clinic and the surrogacy program if
32:27a surrogacy program is being used. If a surrogacy programs not being used, we typically call it an independent journey. I help guide folks a lot through with independent journeys simply because Virginia has got an anti surrogacy broker statute. So which prohibits surrogacy programs from operating in Virginia, we figured out we've got some workarounds in terms of revising their program language, which I've done with a number of programs. But we do have a lot of folks that engage in an independent journey that are not using a surrogacy program. So we do need to still though interact with the fertility clinic and we want to find out what what counseling is being done or has been done, what medical screening has been done, what psychological screening has been done, have the American Society for Reproductive Medicine recommendations for utilizing a gestational carrier have been followed? Is the clinic following them? Or is the clinic not following them? What background data has been gathered, including medical data on the carrier on which medical professionals or clinics are involved? What contracts have the parties already executed with those clinics? Do those contracts potentially conflict with the contract? You're about to draft? Have you gotten copies of those contracts? have you reviewed them. And you also want to get to know your fertility clinics and your medical providers, you want to be able to interact with them. As I just mentioned earlier in the program, I had a really good conversation with one of our local fertility clinics, the
34:02doctors there with regard to revising that embryo cryopreservation agreement for that couple and making some changes, and then also just making sure that they knew to send those couples to me or another lawyer to make sure we get that embryo disposition agreement drafted in advance of the couple forming their embryos. So I've included some fact sheets here that you could find on reproductive facts.org. Um, these are great sheets to give to your clients when they have an initial consult or if it's a zoom consult, email them the PDFs, but being able to provide this sort of information to our clients also shows that we're really invested in educating them and also that we're on top of our game with regard to the information that's out there. So I mentioned the recommendations for practices utilizing gestational carrier. The most recent version is May of 2022. You want to make sure you get a copy of that I recommend you join ASRM if you're going into this area of the law, um, they also have an older document. It's third party reproduction a guide for patients, but it's still a pretty informative document to be able to provide to our clients. Also just be aware of some of the ASRM guidelines that are out there. For example, the quarantining of embryos. So typically, there's a concern about the transmission of any contagious diseases, HPV, HIV, Hep C. So oftentimes, a donor egg or sperm donor will be tested, a gestational carrier and her spouse or partner will be tested just to make sure that there are nobodies carrying any contagious
35:56diseases, in fact, something that they don't even know that they're carrying. But this concept of quarantining, that is freezing the egg or sperm of the embryos for six months, is something that helps with negating the transmission of any contagious diseases. So oftentimes, somebody will be tested and then their gametes or embryos frozen and then retested after six months, and it's just a precautionary measure. Also, the ASRM guidelines typically recommend out just one single embryo transfer at a time. It's no longer the day of the Octomom, you know, where she supposedly may have had as many as six of those embryos put into her. And in the past, there used to be this concept of well, the more embryos we put in, the more probability that one will take. Now there's a reversal of that there's more information about potential competition in the womb, I carry twins, they're now 31 years old that I broke 200 pounds it was taxi mix, so the carrying multiples, what that can do in terms of complications, the health of the fetuses, the health issues on the carrier, we have a lot more information. So one angle one single embryo transfer is what is now recommended. Alright, moving right along here. Be aware of the ethical guidance that's out there. I mentioned the Academy's ethics code, but you also have the ASRM guidance and the ABA model act as well. And then all parties in these arrangements should have separate and independent legal counsel, even if it's just an egg or sperm donor agreement.
37:39Right, we're going to talk about some issues that are unique to surrogacy contracts, the parties views on abortion and selective reduction, whether the intended parents are willing to have their estate documents prepared at the proximity of the parties is important. The medical instructions that go into the contract are important, what level of contact are they going to have during the arrangement? And then how are the parentage issues going to be addressed? So you want to know all of the primary prerequisite issues? You want to know what screening has to be done both the physical and mental screening, have criminal and CPS background checks been done? Has a financial credit check been done?
38:22Is one going to be done? Are they going to be waived? Through the parties already have background checks because of the nature of their employment? We want to make sure all the monetary and financial issues are agreed upon before we start drafting contracts. We want to make sure there's insurance coverage. We want to know what's the applicable law of the contract going to be? And then what is there going to be any continued contact. After the arrangement and donation situations, we want to make sure there's a duty to report back the birth of any children and also any medical issues. We want to look at the confidentiality issues. And we also need to have the parties understand what the breach provisions would be what would be the consequences for a breach. So I've basically put together a quick checklist. It's not exhaustive, but it's just a quick checklist that I have my clients give to me before I start contract drafting to make sure that they've either done it, or they for whatever reason are knowingly waiving doing it. And I use that in conjunction with the ASRM guidelines for guidance. I've got a copy of the quick checklist there for you. It includes the parties filling out background forms, the medical clearances, the mental health clearances, the group counseling, those background checks, so they're going to be done. And then what I find in most gestational carrier arrangements is that the parties really have to be aligned on their religious or abortion or selective reduction issues. We need to match pro life with pro
40:01life and pro choice was pro choice. And I'll tell you a quick story. I had a match sent to me by a surrogacy program with my Asian intended parents who resided over in China. And they had been matched with a very, very, very, right, religious conservative carrier, who, basically her beliefs were that she would not abort a selector, reduce a child for any reason whatsoever, even if the child had no meaningful chance of existence. And, you know, basically, she was of the mindset of it'll be God's will. And I never presume to judge any people that are anywhere on this spectrum. My job is just to make sure that folks are understand each other's views, and they are aligned with each other. So I told the surrogacy program, I said, I'm not sure that I don't think this arrangement is going to work. I just don't think my clients are going to want to go forward with this particular carrier on the program. So well, you know, why don't you look this look into it a little bit more. So I get on the phone with my clients who are in China, and we're going through the Mandarin translator, and I said, You've been matched with a very religious carrier. And if something was determined to be wrong with a child, she's not, she's not going to reduce, you're not going to abort for her any reason, even if it's really something severe. And the phonies, intendant mother, not even through the Mandarin translators. She says no bad baby, we know take no bad baby. And I'm like, that's kind of what I thought. So I called the program and I said, I just there's no way
41:47there's no drafting that I can do to make this situation work. It's just, these folks just are of different mindsets. So we need to make sure that that's been flushed out on that's normally more important than the financial terms. We also want to talk about the level of confidentiality between the parties is superior going to be blogging on Facebook about her surrogacy journey? Do the attentive parents want to keep this more under wraps and confidential, we want to talk about the level of contact during the arrangement. And after the arrangement, I recommend that the attendant parents do a home visit of the carrier. These arrangements typically don't require home studies, although a couple of surrogacy programs, our home study kind of based, but we do want the attendant parents to go see the environment in which their child's going to incubate. And so I always say it's on college checklist. And so you have to get it done. But folks can learn a lot from a home visit. And I usually tell them to do that first because it's free.
42:52Before we get into paying for psychological evaluations, etc, you want to go ahead and check out that home environment and the carrier likewise, can go see how you can have parents live because of course she's carrying this child for them. She wants to make sure that they live in an acceptable environment for this child that she's going to bring into the world for them. All right. So ways we can address these different prerequisites I use, I've got background forms for the kind of social medical background pregnancy history of the carrier. And then I've got written questionnaires that it used for the actual contract drafting. Of course, folks can do that whole visit. We also have the mental health provider evaluations and clearance. And then we have the mental health provider counseling, it's usually strongly recommended that all the parties to the arrangement have a group counseling session. So in my questionnaires for contract drafting, there are things that I make sure are addressed the exact financial terms, even down to like the dollar amount of the mileage, is it going to be set amount, or is it going to vary based on the current IRS business rate? What are the number of embryos to be transferred per attempt? What are the number of transfer attempts? How long is the carrier going to be under contract? What's the number a maximum number of fetuses the carriers willing to carry to term? And then other issues that we're going to cover? Right, so one unique aspect of art contracts is is that in this area, we typically, you wouldn't want to ask
44:30another attorney purchased a copy of their contract. First of all, the law varies from state to state. So the contract is going to vary from state to state. Um, second, there are malpractice implications of using on someone else's contract that may not apply to your state law. And just knowing what the law is. You also might be asking someone for what might be years and years of their work product. And each contract is unique to that arrangement. I've had clients say, Oh, well, don't you just have a template? I'm like, No, you be surprised. It's our mind's a 60 page double space contract. And there are so many things that change from a range of it to arrangement, depending on the situation. All right, that said, there might be situations, for example, my friend, Melissa Briskman, who runs reproductive possibilities early on, when we were going back forth reviewing contracts, I said, Hey, Willis, I really like your copyright section. Can I steal your copyright section that I want to make some additions and changes to it, revisions to it?
45:33And she's like, Yeah, absolutely. Just send me back your more improved version. So we do have a lot of that that goes along with that happens among the art attorneys. It's just, it's a courtesy, though, of saying, Hey, I like the way you've worded this, or this, this, I like this section better than what I have. Can I take it but I'm gonna send you back how I've revised it, that sort of thing. Alright, let's talk about gestational carrier screening. Typically, I require that she has an OBGYN note that says she's cleared to get pregnant. I had a situation where the carrier said she had gotten the note, I'd never looked at the note. And then she got pregnant. And then my intended mother went with her to the first doctor visit and the OBGYN told her that she was a high risk pregnancy and she hadn't agreed to be her doctor. And of course, my intended mother freaked out. So now I make sure I actually get the note.
46:29We also want to know if site clearance at a minimum has been done on the carrier. Um, usually it should be done on all the parties. But definitely the carrier. We want to know things like does the carrier enjoy being pregnant and have easy pregnancies? Ideally, she should have no more than five prior pregnancies and three prior C sections according to the ASRS guidance. However, I have seen exceptions to that. Um, does the carrier have a supportive spouse or partner? She can't be in the middle of a divorce. If she's not in a relationship, does she have supportive family? I had a program simio match. My intended parents were matched with a carrier who lived in a two bedroom apartment with her five children with no family support anywhere in the area. And so you know, I tell my clients, if she's put on bed rest, you are caring, not just for her, but her five children, and she's going to be out of work. And it just wasn't a workable situation. We do want to dive into what is the household environment of that carrier? We want to make sure the carrier has had at least one prior child. And is she done having children? Or is she taking a break from having children? Is her job conducive to being pregnant? She can't be in the military subject to deployment. The Navy will not allow anyone in active duty Navy to be a carrier. We want to make sure they're not a firefighter than an elite athlete. Not a skydiver, horseback riding instructor, etc.
47:57So even housecleaning bartending we want to wait waiting tables, we want to look at what is the nature of their employment? And is that going to pose any issues? We want to check with the carrier on any restrictions. Is the carrier willing to adhere to all the physical activity restrictions? No scuba diving, no triathlons, no skydiving, no water or snow skiing, no racing, horseback riding no tubing, there's just so many restrictions. It's no longer just no drugs, alcohol, tobacco, but it's also avoiding too much raw seafood that might have mercury in it. Avoiding body piercings, tattoos, henna, even certain hair dyes, not willing to be around. You don't want to be around toxic solvents or cleaning products. Not changing kitty litter avoiding secondhand smoke. Is the carrier agreeable to all the travel restrictions? Because typically, the carrier can't travel out of the country during these arrangements? Are they agreeable to getting the COVID vaccine are agreeable to the COVID guidance, the CDC guidance that's out there. And then of course, I mentioned the home visit. So a couple of just red flags. If the carrier is not fully divorced and in the middle of separation and doesn't want their spouse to be part of the agreement. That's a red flag. If they're single and older and never had any children, that's an enormous nono. If the intended parents want to micromanage the pregnancy, that's another red flag if the parties don't get adequate medical psychological background clearances, particularly on the carrier that can prompt
49:38some issues if either party doesn't want representation, and I said, the carrier not wanting representation or the parties trying to use joint representation, but really both sides have to have independent legal counsel. And then if the parties haven't had that, that joint group counseling session, I find that a arrangements sometimes tend to get a little stickier if that has not occurred as well. Alright, so if you are starting to get into this field and you want to get into contract drafting, um, the first thing to do is to basically let folks know that you know, you're getting involved in this field. And typically, as I mentioned before, you will not ask other attorneys for a copy of their contracts to use. But typically, you start into this field by reviewing the contracts as opposed to drafting them. And I've got a little kind of Calvin Hobbes thing that I use sometimes where they're kind of recklessly going along in this little red wagon, and, but not really knowing what they're doing in terms of going down this steep hill. And I use the cartoon to basically say that, if you're embarking on this adventure, for the first time, find yourself an experienced partner and let them steer that little red wagon that is they dropped the contract and represent one party while you kind of go along for the ride and help navigate the trip. And even then you may not know 100%, where you ended up as you are going along for the ride. But hopefully you enjoy the ride.
51:19And you also will have learned a fair amount from that other attorney who has been steering that little red wagon, which is actually doing the contract drafting piece itself. So you do want to attend a lot of art sessions on contract drafting, either through the academy or ASRM or the ABA. And you want to just get out there and network and start to let folks know that you are interested in this field. I do have a little kind of cheat sheet outline I give people because I get asked a lot of time, how do you get into this field. So I have a little outline that I put together that I'm more than happy to send as well. email to you if you're interested in getting into this field. Oftentimes, if you're representing someone in a donor agreement or sperm donor agreement, that's, that's kind of a lower barrier to entry in terms of getting into this field, as opposed to representing someone in gestational carrier agreement. So just keep that in mind.
52:24All right, and I've mentioned there, some of the different assisted reproductive technology sessions that are out there, including LexVid sessions. I'll be doing a one later on advanced con, surrogacy, contract drafting as well. Alright, so we're just going to really briefly hit upon some contract drafting basics. And some a lot of these slides I'm just going to reference not really read in any detail. But the first thing is you do want to have a table of contents. So demystify your contract, make it easy to read, make it easy for your clients to find things. If you don't make it easy for them to find things, then they're going to be calling you during the arrangement and asking you a lot of questions. So we want to make sure our clients can easily read these contracts, whether it's a surrogacy agreement, egg donor agreement embryo donation agreement, we want to have a table of contents. We also saw I've given you some sample table of contents for gestational carrier agreement, I've given you another sample table of contents for an egg donor contract. But the next thing about any contract is we want to have section headings, so you could have your table of contents, and then you don't have section headings, it just makes that much easier to find that particular provisions. Then the next thing, the third thing and demystifying your contract is have it in a logical order and chronological is best. So we want the intent and purpose the representations, the definitions, the choice of law at the
53:54beginning, then we want to cover the preliminary matters, we want to cover medical and conception instructions. We want to cover potential events during the pregnancy. And then we want to cover the breach provisions. And then we want to include those boilerplate provisions at the end of the contract. And I've given you some example there as the boilerplate provisions, which are the provisions that you would find in almost any contract, even a real estate agreement or even the purchase of a car contractual obligations. Notice several ability, acknowledgement of the advice of counsel modification, revision or amendment changing or evolving law, original agreement, entire agreement and how many copies of the agreement copyright provision. All of those would be those boilerplate provisions. I even included a picture of a boilerplate there for you because I was really curious about where the term came from. So you've got a picture of a boiler plate there. Alright, so all of those tables of contents that I've included, kind of include do the basic contract terms or areas that have to be covered in either an egg donor agreement or a surrogacy agreement. Um, the next thing we want to be really careful of is, before we start contract drafting, we want to start with the end in sight. So we want to look down the road before this child before the this embryo might even be made. How are we going to make sure this child is legally the child of these intended parents? So we want to look at where's the birth or the donation taking
55:31place? Where is any medical procedure occurring? Where did the parties live? What law is going to apply? And how are we going to get these attendant parents to ultimately be recognized as the legal parents. So I call that contract drafting starting with the end in sight. So start at the beginning and map out the entire process. Typically, you're going to want to contact an attorney in another state, who practices aren't law in that state, in order to make sure that, for example, I have an arrangement right now, where the carrier lives in Delaware, but she's right next to the Maryland line. And so the plan is that her and her doctors right there in Maryland, and the hospitals right there in Maryland. And so the clinics, actually in Virginia, we're actually doing the contract under Virginia law, but we've got a Maryland attorney who's going to be able to get a pre birth order. And then there's a backup plan if for some reason, somehow she lives in Delaware. But the hope is, is that she's so close to the hospital and her doctor in Maryland, that that's where she's going to deliver. But typically, we want to make sure we always have a contingency plan to if if things don't go to plan. All right. So ways that we address parentage can vary from state to state, some states allow for a pre birth order. Virginia doesn't allow for a pre birth order in its status of children and assisted conception statute. It allows for a post birth administrative birth certificates to be amended after the birth. But we also have our
57:13parentage acts that we can use to get a post birth order. And then interestingly enough, if I get a pre birth order from another state, I can have the pre birth order domesticated and given full faith and credit prior to the birth in Virginia, because we've got such good Full Faith and Credit law. So we just want to make sure that we've mapped out how is this parentage going to happen? Does the State allow for a birth order? Does it allow for a post birth order? Do we just need a birth certificate and not an order? Is there an administrative birth certificate amendment process? And in those lesser cases, are we going to have to default to an adoption given this particular situation? So I've included some sample contract provisions on parentage options. This particular one note that I've got here, actually involved a crazy situation where my clients lived in Massachusetts, they were using a Virginia clinic, they had a carrier who was in Florida, but the carrier was probably going to move to Arizona during the arrangement. So we had to involve lawyers in all four states, in order to make sure that we've mapped everything out well enough. All right, so what can happen if somebody fails to consult with another attorney and the other state and just kind of blindly goes into the situation?
58:38Well, I had that happen. I had an attorney in Washington State, supposedly draft a contract that was under Virginia law, but never checked with a Virginia lawyer to make sure that the contract was in fact, under Virginia law. The contract had words like fee and bonus and compensation to out the contract, which is a voidable contract in Virginia, he can't play compensation, it all has to be in the guise of household living expenses. And in Virginia, when we go through that post birth, administrative birth certificate process, the that process depends on the contract, being on a proper contract under Virginia law. So it can't be a voidable contract. And when I got that contract and was asked to do the birth certificate amendment process, I had to inform the lawyer in Washington state that the contract even though it said it was written under Virginia law, was not written under Virginia law, and no Virginia lawyer had been involved. And so we ended up having to rewrite that contract before we could submit it. So what could happen in some cases is that the parties might spend more money, time and effort when an easier procedure could have been followed from the beginning. Had the Washington State lawyers simply add a Virginia lawyer in volved either representing the carrier or just reviewing the contract and making it comport with Virginia law, then the parties would have spent a lot less time money and effort and also been a little less frustrated. In some cases, the parties might avoid more adverse tax treatment. And in some
1:00:20cases, the other state might fail to give full faith and credit to a contractor pre birth order. Or the parties might think, for example, if they get a pre birth order, from another state that Virginia vital records is going to honor the pre birth order, but they're not. They won't honor it unless I get that pre birth order domesticated by a court in Virginia. So we want to make sure that we've mapped it all out. We also want to map out what payments are lawful, and are the payments going to be taxed? Are they going to be paid as an escrow agent? Did we used? Is it going to be direct pay? And what are the amounts of the payments? And if there's going to be a tax consequence, then which party is going to bear the liability of any possible taxation by the IRS? How are the payments to be established? Is there going to be the necessity for showing receipts or proof of payment? How's the peer you're gonna know that the money is there? If it's in an escrow account, of course, the money will be there. But if it's not being put in escrow account, will the carrier otherwise get monthly statements showing that the money is there?
1:01:27And then how exactly are the payments going to be made? Are there going to be made by cheque a lot of electronic bank transfers l Venmo. PayPal, they want to map that out for the parties as well. We talked about the health insurance coverage issues. Not only do we want to make sure that the carrier has coverage and no exclusion, but we also want to make sure that if she loses her job or if she's on her spouse's coverage and the spouse loses their job, that she's going to be able to go on COBRA, what are the options there, we'll make sure we draft for that. We want to make sure that we draft so that the intended parents are not viewed as guarantors or insurers and the insurance company can't seek subrogation against them. We want to make sure that the carrier is not liable for the baby and the baby's medical costs the tenant parents or parents need to be responsible.
1:02:19And then there are special TRICARE and Medicaid issues are most of the time we recommend not having a carrier that's on Medicaid, but in some compassionate situations, even quasi compassionate, it might be doable. And then TRICARE typically just requires that there be an allowance that's put in the contract to repay TRICARE, if they ever asked for the repayment, which that that involves like another whole half hour lecture. But just be aware of special issues with TRICARE, we could devote an entire day just to contract drafting. And as I already mentioned, I'll be doing a program on advanced surrogacy contract drafting for LexVid. But here are other sticky issues that we will address in more detail in that program. And that includes the conception of medical instructions regarding the conception, the carrier's management of the pregnancy, there's confidentiality issues. What about death separation, divorce is appearance. What happens if the intended parents are in a car crash happens if the carrier is in a car crash and in a coma? I had one client asked if I sat around and drank wine coolers and thought of all sorts of morbid scenarios to put in my contract.
1:03:30And I said, Yes, that's exactly what we do. We sit around and drink wine coolers, and think of every possible thing that could go wrong and put it in there. But seriously, a lot of the evolution of the contract. And the changes come from real life scenarios. Either they've happened in my practice, or I'm aware of what's happened in my colleagues practices. And so we just learn as we go about some of the things that can happen. I'm aware of several cases now where the intended parents died. I'm aware of one case where the intended father committed suicide while his carrier was carrying his child. And nobody even put the names of the Guardians in the contract and our contact information, much less required him to have a will in place. I've had situations where there's been third party medical negligence or third party negligence, a drunk driver hitting the carrier. So as things go along, we start to make more and more changes to the contracts to address these contingencies. The breach provisions and contracts can get more complex, cover those in that advanced surrogacy contracting program and also what happens if the lab screws up like what happens if they transferred the wrong embryo.
1:04:51So just briefly on abortion and selective reduction issues, I just we learned a lot from the crystal Kelly case. She was offered $10,000 to abort that child that she's holding in the, in the photo there. What happened in the case was the Connecticut couple learned that the fetus had developmental disabilities and they offered her $10,000 To have the abortion. She turned around and asked for 15,000 Saying that she didn't want to undergo a procedure that went against her religious beliefs. It started to get into a legal skirmish. And then Kelly fled Connecticut from Michigan, who are under state law, the surrogacy contract will be disregarded and she'd be recognized as the legal guardian, she gave birth in Ann Arbor to a child with some severe medical conditions. She eventually placed that child for adoption. And the child, as far as I know, is alive and doing quite well today. And we learned a lot from that we learned that any carrier at anytime, can simply move to another state. Of course, a lot of states now actually, Virginia has a provision that says any any provision in a contract that says the carrier must abort or not abort will be unenforceable. But that's just kind of what we've also known all along is that we're not going to get a judge to make a woman do with her body. What she doesn't want to do even with the the United States Supreme Court ruling in the Dobbs decision, which now draws into question whether a woman has a constitutional right to abort, there's still recognize that she's got
1:06:39a constitutional right of autonomy over her body. So that's where the screening upfront becomes really critical. And that's where this matching of pro life with pro life and pro choice with pro choice really becomes relevant. And this is also where the pre genetic testing now that we've done on embryos factors, and as well on because it, it has dramatically reduced the issues with significant developmental deformities or problems with the fetus. So I've included and a sample abortion selective reduction provision, this is a really quickly changing area of the law given states that are putting into place provisions that say that, you know, a woman can't afford after a certain number of weeks, or states like Virginia that say that any sort of provision that says that a carrier can or can't afford to selectively reduce will be unenforceable. And so I've got some additional provisions in there. Usually, if the carrier's life is in danger, her life always takes priority over the fetus. Now, most of the more and more of these contracts are just simply saying it's going to be up to the carrier, because that's just where the law is moving. I've got a provision in there on selective reduction. Again, we want to have some understanding of how many fetuses a carrier is willing to carry or carry on must be willing to carry three if you want to carry too, but the reality is, it's ultimately going to be up to her. So just be aware of state law and coverage issues, especially if you're doing a contract that crosses state lines. So it may be that a
1:08:22Virginia contract can be used in Texas to get a pre birth order. But it's also going to have to comport with Texas provisions, which are like Virginia, Texas has a provision that says abortion clauses and surrogacy contracts are unenforceable. So we just want to make sure that in some states actually criminalized abortions after a certain number of weeks, we just want to be aware of that issue. I always do a retainer letter with my clients that or a separate document that explains to them that we're not going to get a judge to make the carrier do something with her body that she doesn't want to do, we're not going to get a judge to make her award or not award. And we also have always the risks of the carrier moving to another state like crystal Kelly did. So I'm just going to touch upon just a couple more issues as we kind of start to close out the program in the next five minutes. But we do need to think about identity issues for the children of art.
1:09:18should be should they be told that gestational carrier was use. Of course, there are great children's books out there about my apostle mommy and my kangaroo mommy and oftentimes if it's a good arrangement, we'll even know who their their carrier was, and still have some ongoing information about the carrier. In some cases, I even have clients, they all take their kids to the park together and get together because they've had such a wonderful arrangement. Typically, in a surrogacy contract, there's no provision for ongoing contact. But so normally it'll be left up to the parties, but in donor arrangements, there normally is reporting back provision so that folks do no other half siblings or full siblings have been born. We can avoid the inconsequential continuity of siblings or half siblings and updating each other. But also that reporting back of meant mental health and medical conditions, that reporting information becomes critical. So in those donor arrangements, we typically do have enforceable ongoing contract provisions.
1:10:33What sort of search options are these children going to have, they already have the ability to hop on 23andme ancestry.com, the prediction is more registries will start to evolve. And so we really have to address these things. With our clients from the beginning. Not only are these potential terms that go into the contracts were drafting, but I like to provide my clients with this list of children's books. Hey, it'd be great for you just like in the adoption world, having a my birth story book for your child that shows the placing mother that placed the child for adoption and here's more information about that family having a my birth story book, you know, with their gestational carrier, explaining of donor egg or donor sperm are used, and they're great little children's books to talk about, you know how what we had to borrow and acorn from another tree, you know, this mommy tree, this daddy tree had to borrow an acorn from another tree that introduce these concepts to children from a very early age. All right. So just if you're working, especially with same sex couples, just in arrangements where they might be using donor sperm, we're continuing to make sure that same sex couples get a either an adoption order or a parentage order. In addition to being on the birth certificate, a birth certificate is not proof of parentage. There's an Arizona case that specifically says the birth certificates, not proof of parentage, we do have the US Supreme Court decision of VL vs. Eel that basically says that all states have to give full faith and
1:12:16credit to an adoption decree. So we don't have a decision that says all states have to give full faith and credit to a birth certificate of birth certificate set administrative document, it there's not case law that says that it's it's a definitive like a court order, and it can be subject to challenge. So we do want to just make sure that our families understand that they should take that added step. I recommend for my single parents using a gestational carrier. And for example, donor sperm recommend that they also get a court order just because now we have a court order that definitively terminates the gestational carrier carriers rights, but also definitively terminates that sperm donors rights. Interestingly enough, I couple months ago, I had a case with a sperm donor clinic in another state, where my client came to me and she asked if she was protected from the donor ever coming back was a single mom, and we were looking at her estate documents. And at the time, I learned that that particular state did not have a donor statute like Virginia has a donor statute that says a donor is not a parent.
1:13:40And that state had no statute and they had no governing case law. So the release is being signed by the sperm donors in that particular state actually had no basis in the law. And so that was a situation where it became even more abundantly clear that we wanted to get a court order definitively terminating that sperm donors rights since there was no clear governing law that said that his that the release would have been valid. Alright, so just be aware of that issue. Also issues unique to unmarried couples. If like in Virginia, they use their own egg and sperm our surrogacy statutes still says that they have to be married or single, but we're still doing gestational carrier agreements for unmarried couples. And if they use their own egg and sperm, I can get them a post birth order parentage under our parentage statutes, but if they use a donor apart, then I'm still going to have to do a parentage action as to one in conjunction with a stepparent adoption as to the other. So we just want to be aware of some of the unique issues and look at the law. Have each state's, actually in Virginia I can do, they don't have to, I can do a second parent adoption and not to be married. But I still have to do that parentage action as to the one in conjunction with the second parent adoption as to the other, and clients can get a little they can get a little sensitive. So if you're telling a couple that they're actually going to have to adopt, we want to make sure that they understand the legal process and that they just understand in advance that this is the way we're gonna
1:15:36have to do it. And in some cases, I've had to say, folks, hey, if you if you want to get married, then I can get you both on the birth certificate right away with the order parentage, but if you're not gonna be married, we're gonna have to do this parentage action as to genetic parent in conjunction with the second parent adoption as to the other parent, and I'm sorry that we're using the term adoption, but it's just the only way legally, that we're gonna be able to get this done. Alright, couples that are international, a lot of additional issues involved there. That includes coordination with, you know, immigration attorneys with attorneys in the other state, excuse me in the other country, you might need the use of a translator, or you need to watch out for cultural differences, obtaining criminal record and background checks of intended parents from another country can be more difficult. And the support of the carrier the communication between the parties can be trickier. This could be the case to in long distance arrangements where if the gestational carrier is in Virginia, and the intended parents are in California, or vice versa, you know, the intended parents aren't gonna be able to come to all the medical visits. So it's medical provider going to be willing to do virtual calls with the intended parents during the medical visits. So we want to make sure that we map out what's the level of communication going to be, especially if there's a language barrier, how are the parties are they're going to use some sort of
1:17:07a translation software program. Also, for international families, oftentimes getting any sort of newborn insurance coverage is about impossible, or they have to look at doing self pay. So oftentimes, if we use some of the insurance providers that are out there aren't risk new life, I FYI, we can use those companies to also help us navigate some of those issues are typically in all international cases, all the money is going to be put into a trust or escrow account to make sure the money is there. Especially with COVID, we had a lot of issues with international families being able to get into the states, we had one a woman for a surrogacy program end up having to care for the child for six months. While the international internet parents tried to navigate getting back to the States, and not enough money had been put in escrow, so the poor woman caring for the child that was coming out of pocket to care for the child at that point. Of course, with the international families, oftentimes we're trying to expedite the birth certificate, letting them know about passport assistance, we're trying to get APA Steel's and certified translations. In some cases, they might have to make an appointment with their embassy. So just recognize there are a lot of additional issues with international families. All right, so just briefly commenting on divorce and frozen embryos. I mentioned before the couple that had gone to a local clinic that were about to form their embryos. And your the clinic document said that if there was
1:18:51any divorce or separation, that the disposition of embryos will be determined via their divorce decree or separation agreement. We want to be more proactive about these couples that are going into the formation of embryos. And it's not just heterosexual couples, if a same sex couple, if they use the sperm or egg of one and they use a donor sperm or egg that they purchased together, they both jointly now own those embryos. They use marital property to the purchase of the donor parts and now merging that with the genetic gametes of one of the two. Now that these become property owned by both of them, so we do want to try to map out those things in advance and say in advance, hey, if you guys divorce, or if one of you dies or disappears, what's going to be the disposition of those embryos? All right. And we also need to educate some of the general Family Law lawyers that are out there, that general separation agreement or equitable distribution, document governing the disposition of experiment embryos, very well may not be upheld. embryos and eggs and sperm oftentimes are deemed to be special property.
1:20:16Again, we've got to look at state laws, individual state laws, but typically these will be donated, as opposed to just a simple transfer. So we want to make sure that the correct language is being used, and that we've got a proper donation agreement and release. And then also that we look at some of those. Are there going to be any issues of is there going to be the need for any reporting back at all? What if a couple use embryos to have the first child you know, basically, we want to make sure that if they divorce, and then one of the couple than that, no longer a couple, that that person then decides to have a second child. And we want to make sure that we've got a clear donation agreement that says that, hey, if dad who had the first child who's now divorced, is donating the embryos to the ex wife, that he's clearly off the hook for any child support, anything like that, we're going to make sure that we've got that provision in there. But on the other hand, we might have some sort of a communication agreement that's agreed to, because if dad's still going to be a dad to the one child, you know, what is his relationship going to be with the other child that's later formed, that's created from the one of those embryos, all sorts of kind of thorny issues that we need to think about in terms of the best interests of the children that are involved here as well. So I am at the end of the program, and I will leave you with just that kind of philosophical thought about some of the thorny situations that we can get into
1:22:08with divorce and the frozen embryos. And we just want to make sure that people think about all of the different possibilities down the road with regard to these children that ultimately might be formed from these embryos that are being created and then being donated to each other. So I've enjoyed my time with you. Hopefully, you've enjoyed the program, you've learned a lot. And my final slide is adios amigos.