Guy M.CA
Some courses just review information. This one reveals it. Eye opening and ground breaking
2h 17min · about 18,100 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00If you've been in an auto accident, you turn it over to your insurance company and expect them to do two things for you. One is hire a competent, ethical lawyer to guide you through the judicial process. And to, you'd expect them to find a settlement or judgment. But suppose that the driver of the other car died and turned out to be your spouse's lover. So the when you get slapped with a complaint, it accuses you of murder, that changes everything with the insurance company. And that's what this course is all about. In most auto accidents, there are two ways the case can come out. Either you're innocent, and you don't have any money to the other driver, or you're negligent. And you do owe money to the other driver, which the insurance company will pay. But if you're accused of being a felon, the insurance company doesn't have to pay for that. And that makes sense. But it creates a conflict of interest between you and your insurance company. And it also creates a different but related conflict of interest between you and the lawyer that your insurance company wants to hire. This presentation, I assume will be viewed by people in many different categories. There will be some insurance industry people, there will be some insurance defense lawyers. And I want to make it clear, I'm not talking to you. There will be some policyholder lawyers, and some plaintiffs lawyers. Hopefully, there'll be some policyholders themselves and some plaintiffs themselves. That is my audience here today, everyone is welcome. But those who are the
2:07insurance industry will have little to gain from hearing this presentation except to Know thy enemy. The rest of you, I hope, we'll be able to take away from this course, an intimate knowledge of the rules of professional conduct in every state, and how they apply to a very specific situation, which occurs hundreds of 1000s of times a year, if not millions of times a year, I will be providing two kinds of information. One is strictly objective statements of the law that you can independently verify by reading the authorities that I present to you. But the other and very important element of what I hope to present clearly will be entirely subjective on my part, and in some instances, downright speculative. And when I'm saying that I will endeavor to make it clear to you that that is what I'm doing. The goal of this presentation are several The first is for policyholders and plaintiffs and their lawyers to foster prompt settlement of a liability dispute at no cost to the policyholder. That's one of the goals. The other goal is to pressure the insurance company to pay for independent counsel rather than panel counsel. Both of those are huge wins, if the policyholder can achieve it.
3:53Because one, if they get to appoint their own lawyer, they get to control the conduct of the defense, and two of the case can be settled at no cost to them. That is a fabulous outcome. This course will focus upon non litigation solutions. Perhaps another course in the future will focus on litigation solutions. But that's just too complicated for the two hours that we have here. The goals will also include goals for the insurance industry, that is insurance companies and their panel counsel. And I'm about to make the first of many subjective, even speculative statements based upon my experience. And that is that the insurance industry in the very narrow situation that my hypothetical poses are often not always but often in systemic violation of the law. Well, that's a huge statement. So big threat. And I can't prove it, because they're not talking about what they're actually thinking. But based upon my experience, I believe, and I hope you will come to believe you being the audience, I have identified that this systemic violation of law does in fact occur. And even if it doesn't occur, that doesn't matter, because the behavior of the insurance industry will be reliable. But if it is true that the insurance industry is in systemic violation of law, then when the policyholder pushes back against those violations, the best cure for the insurance company and their panel counsel, is to eliminate exposure for breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty, bad faith liability. How do they do that? They do it by eliminating causation for
6:04damage. Every civil lawsuit for damage has elements of causation and damage. So how can the insurance industry if they are in systemic violation of the law? How can they avoid that face liability and frankly, terrible embarrassment about their systemic violations? Well, it is to have to pay for everything that the policyholder is entitled to. And that is a wonderful solution. But how do you achieve that solution? This course will focus upon practical steps that policyholders can take and that plaintiffs and plaintiffs lawyers can also participate in to push back. This can be done in as little as two weeks. My record is eight days. But it could be pushed out to as much as six weeks but need not go any longer than that. by which the policyholder not policyholder counsel, not any lawyer on behalf of the policyholder, but the policyholder him or herself engages in a communication campaign to develop admissible evidence about what the insurance industry is up to. Now, you're probably thinking, I don't know what to ask for. I wouldn't know where to begin in terms of trying to participate in such a communication campaign. But that's what this course is for. I will have for you what I call a delivery package, which has most of what needs to be communicated from the policyholder to panel Council and the insurance company specific documents in your course recourse materials that the policyholder needs to put into the hands over the course of two weeks or so put into the hands of the panel counsel and the claims
8:13agent, you're gonna get two hours worth of ethics, credit for your MC le obligation, because ethics is at the very core of everything I have to say today. Those rules of professional conduct that we will focus upon our 1.4 1.6 1.7 1.8 and the definition of informed written consent. Those rules are the root source of a lawyer's obligation to a client of disclosure, undivided loyalty, confidentiality, and a prohibition on accepting compensation from one other than the client. And the overriding theme of today's presentation will be to accept Nancy Reagan's catchphrase I'm old enough to remember that many of you may not. But she had a campaign to help children where the catchphrase was just say no, in her case was just say no. For drugs and sex, drugs and sex will not be a part of this presentation, although that may might make it a lot more interesting. But just say no means that the policyholder should just say no to the panel counsel and the insurance company in the very narrow situation, that our hypothetical raises
10:00Now, my name is Steve Thomas. I've been at this field of law for a long time. In California, where I practice, there's a famous case called cumulus that many of you may be familiar with. And then we'll be talking about, I started working in this field years before the cubes case. And the cube this case, in fact, cites a case I had
10:27several years earlier from 1981 Give us was in 1984, I believe, when I represented the insurance industry, that's where I got my background in this subject matter. And I will be peppering you with my experiences in providing the kind of information I told you about that will be entirely subjective. But before I go further, I want to introduce you to my fellow panelist. Here is my feral fellow panelist. This is my granddaughter's chair, and you'll notice that this empty, why is it empty? Why is there no debate going on here today? Well, I have invited many, many members of the insurance industry in the insurance defense industry to join me in any kind of presentation like this, and none of them accepted the challenge. But if there are any of you out there listening, who are insurance, defense lawyers, or insurance claims handlers, and you would like to have a debate with me, I invite you to contact me, we'll get a hold of the producer will put on another presentation, when we can both present our differing points of view.
11:56Nonetheless, today, that other chair is empty, and I will be presenting to you the primary defensives, which the insurance industry puts up to the kind of situation which my hypothetical raises. You all should have. And let me just emphasize when I say you from now on, I'm talking to policyholders counsel, policyholders plaintiffs and plaintiff's counsel. You should have before you two primary sources of additional information additional to my talking to you. One of them are the course materials. They're 69 pages long. And I will be referencing those course materials as I go through the presentation. The other is that you should have access to a PowerPoint presentation that has 25 slides. I'm on slide number one right now. This is David versus Goliath, you or David, the insurance industry is Goliath. They're big, they're powerful, they're wealthy, they're threatening, and it's all very real. But I believe with the law that is before you in the course materials. And hopefully, the experience I would like to share with you today, you will come to recognize the policyholders and planners and their lawyers can be David and overcome defeat that Goliath by a very specific means of loading this lengthy shock and killing the giant. policyholders hold great power when insurers issue reservations, right. And their panel counsel failed to obey ethical rules.
13:54That is this course. In a nutshell. Slide two has some definitions. I'm going to stop using the word panel counsel and instead talk about dependent counsel. Dependent counsel is the opposite of independent counsel. Dependent counsel always represents the insurance company and always represents the policyholder and the insurance company. Turn to page two of your course materials. And you will find a definition of dependent counsel including authorities that describe that dependent counsel relationship. That same page will also describe and give you authorities to to understand the difference between dependent counsel and independent counsel. Independent Counsel is chosen only by the insurance of the policyholder but must be painful. work by the insurance company.
15:02Technically, under the contract. This series of contracts, the insurance company will owe the policyholder the costs of defense incurred by independent counsel. And they'll be the policyholder that pays independent counsel. Now as an accounting convenience checks can go directly to independent counsel. But the it is very important to keep in mind the relationships such the independent counsel does not represent the insurer does not represent the insurance interests, and is free to work on behalf of the policyholder to try to win the liability suit, but also to try to defeat the reservation of rights and to try to secure coverage. Why? Because independent counsel represents only the policyholder dependent counsel represents both the policyholder and the insurer. And because defendant counsel represents to duel clients. The rules of professional ethics come into play in a big way. I'll be using the term disqualifying conflict of interest. And that is going to be difficult to ascertain under many circumstances. But fundamentally it means then dependent counsel has a conflict of interest, which prohibits dependent counsel from representing the policyholder without informed written consent. Informed consent is a defined term under Rule one of the rules of professional conduct. And we will be discussing those apps on length during the presentation today. Moving on to slide number three, and page three of the course materials. This is the very narrow situation to which this presentation applies. First, a
16:51plaintiff sues a policyholder. Second, the policyholder has insurance notifies the insurer asks for defense and indemnification. And the insurer responds by reserving its rights. The insurer always conducts a coverage analysis before accepting any defense. And basically it has three choices, to deny all coverage to accept all coverage, or a little bit of both. And a little bit of both is when they issue a reservation of rights. As I mentioned right off the bat, the things a policyholder is entitled to when sued is for the insurance company to appoint ethical competent counsel to take you through the judicial process. And to to fund the resolution of that. It reservation of rights throws a monkey wrench into that situation. Because when there's a reservation of rights, the insurer says yes, we will provide you with the defense. But no, not necessarily will we pay for the outcome. They defer to some future date, any decision about whether or not they will deny coverage, so that the policyholder will be in limbo the whole time the liability dispute is pending. That's the neurosis situation. In addition to that, the insurer will appoint dependent counsel to represent the policyholder. Now, the insurance company has a policy, which for all intents and purposes, they're ways to fight this, but this is the time to fight it. The insurance company has the contractual right to control the defense. Some policies are specific and say we have the right to choose counsel. And for our purposes, we're going to just accept that as gospel. So when you the
18:56policyholder, notify the insurer, I've been sued, please protect me. The insurance company has the contractual right to control the defense. So they're perfectly entitled to send the defense to their dependent counsel. But that's not the end of the analysis. Because when the matter is referred to dependent counsel, the lawyer then has to qualify to accept the representation of both the policyholder and the insurance company. And that is independent of the contract, right that the insurer has to appoint counsel. Dependent counsel does not have that contract. The pennant counsel is not governed by that contract. It's not a party to that contract. Instead dependent counsels obligations to the policyholder arise from the attorney client relationship, which is in part contractual, but it's also controlled by the State Bar Act and the rules of visual conduct that we will be just looking into the intimate detail on during this brief dictation. So let me just summarize. The narrow situation is you got sued, the insurance company issued a reservation of rights. They sent it to defendant counsel to represent you. And something has to happen next, in order for defendant counsel to ethically represent you. Now, the reservation of rights always create some kind of conflict of interest. Why? Because by its nature, the reservation of Rights says the insurance company says, I'm the insurance company, you're the policyholder, I'm slapping you in the face to wake you up to the fact that I am your enemy. I don't want to pay for the
20:46outcome of this lawsuit. I want you to pay for the outcome of this lawsuit. And you should do something to push back against me to protect your interests from me. i The insurance company and the enemy of you might policyholder. So watch out. That's what a reservation of Rights says. But not all reservations or rights necessarily disqualify dependent counsel from representing the policyholder, we're going to get into that in some detail. But not now. Now, there are three purposes and insurer has for issuing a reservation of rights. The first is the one I've already described, they defer to some later date, a decision to deny or accept coverage for the lawsuit. The second is to put pressure on the policyholder, to contribute to a settlement or a judgment or to pay the whole thing. That is a very powerful purpose. And one that arises frequently in liability disputes when it comes to settlement time. The third purpose is to pressure the plaintiff's lawyer into accepting less than the case is worth under this threat. You go into a mediation, they say, Yeah, your case is worth a million bucks. But we're only going to pay 500,000 Because we don't have any coverage. And if you want to collect your million bucks, you're gonna have to sue us and wait five years. Ha ha ha. Well, that's why this course has been given so that the policyholder counsel and the plaintiff's counsel can lawfully and properly cooperate with each other, not in resolving the liability dispute, but rather, in working together
22:50against the insurance company and is dependent counsel to achieve a mutual goal. And those are the goals I've already announced one, that the insurance company will agree to pay for independent counsel rather than dependent counsel. And to that the insurance company will fully fund a prompt and equitable settlement. Moving on to slide four big categories go to page four, the situation I've described does not always happen. Sometimes the insurance company behaves properly, and sometimes dependent counsel also behave properly. But we're going to ignore all of that for the rest of this presentation. Because this presentation focuses upon only a very narrow situation, this still happens hundreds of 1000s or millions of times a year. So that the insurers and dependent counsel will, in my opinion, be systemically violating the law firm of which I will be explaining to you today. Next slide number five. This is my description of how independent counsel often behave. And for purposes of this presentation, always behave because I just excluded from the subject matter of this presentation in those instances where the insurer and the dependent counsel behave properly. There are 100 ways they could go around this and you may be very happy that and you should be happy that they're behaving properly. But that's not the focus of this presentation from now on. So how do dependent counsel often behave? They do not ask for and they do not ask whether or not a reservation or rights has been issued at all. They do not
24:53ask for a copy of the reservation of rights. If they get it they don't read it. If they read it, they don't analyze it. And if they analyze it, they don't disclose their analysis to the policyholder, or the insurance company, to they will not respond to questions about the reservation of rights. It's simply off the table. They say, No, we don't get involved in coverage. We have been asked to defend the lawsuit only. So we're not interested in whether there's a reservation of rights, or what it says or anything else about it, we're just going to ignore it. The dependent counsel will refer the policyholder their client, to the insurer for all issues about coverage, including whether or not dependent counsel has a disqualifying conflict of interest. This one really bugs me, because the lawyer has no right to delegate a non delegable duty to clear conflicts of interest with a client. And they certainly have no right to delegate that duty to one of two clients they represent that have the conflict of interest that needs to be resolved. But nonetheless, dependent counsel in this situation, I'm just driving will say to the client, though, talk to the insurer, don't talk to me. Next, defendant counsel will represent to the policyholder, to not worry about the reservation of rights. But that representation will be oral only. We're going to focus heavily in this presentation on how to overcome that problem. But the policyholder will be Flipside. On the one hand, the insurance company's gonna say we
26:58got a reservation of rights, we're sticking by it. But in oral communications, it'll be difficult to prove in the future, they'll say, Oh, don't worry about it. Usually, this comes out just fine. It doesn't create a disqualifying conflict of interest, go to sleep. The reservation of rights really isn't important. You shouldn't worry about it, come take a nap. And that one bugs me to the final thing in our situation will be the dependent counsel will simply not comply with the rules that are the primary focus of this presentation. Now, I've just leveled a terrible indictment of the insurance defense industry. That indictment is based upon my experience, anybody who's had psych one knows that human behavior usually falls into a bell shaped curve. And some people on that bell shaped curve will do different kinds of things. And so a great variety of behavior could be expected in any category. But in this field, that has simply not been my experience. Instead, rather than a bell shaped curve, there is a single line at the at one extreme from the possibilities of behavior that always occurs. By I don't know, why don't I know? Because the insurance industry and the insurance, defense industry aren't talking. If you ask them why they do it, they won't tell you. So instead of trying to discern what their motives may be, which we'll never know, instead, this course will focus upon watching their behavior, not what they're thinking here, but what they're doing with their mouths and in their action. That behavior has to be determined before the
29:02liability dispute is over. But it is behavior that we will focus upon and try to create evidence so that the policyholder can protect herself from the reserving insurance company and it's unethical, dependent counsel. Slide six, it's amazingly simple to achieve that. Just say no, Nancy Reagan's catchphrase policyholders should expressly not impliedly withhold consent to representation by independent counsel until independent counsel comply with the numerous Rules of Professional Conduct that we'll be going over in great detail in this the rest of this course. Slide seven, at the end of page four, go take a look at that now and follow along that kind of repeated here. Here are the items that may need to be delivered into the possession of dependent counsel and the insurance company as a delivery package. Getting these items into their hands is the point of the two to six week communication campaign. Some of these will vary from case to case. For example, the reservation of rights will always be unique. The policy not quite so unique, but nonetheless peculiar to your policyholder, the last two are a complaint to the state bar and a complaint to the Department of Insurance. Those have to be developed by the policyholder in the course of these two weeks. The remaining items are part of what I call the delivery package that is in your course materials. These will include a number of model emails, as I've mentioned already, is the policyholder who alone should be in contact with dependent counsel and the insurance representative. And the
31:19policyholder who has come to you for help, is going to say, I don't want to do this. I want you to do it. But you can't do it for reasons that I will explain. Instead, the policyholder has to do it. And the policyholder is best equipped to do it. Because the policyholder is not a lawyer and doesn't know what's going on. These model emails are a guide for the policyholder to send a series of messages to dependent counsel and the insurance representative to start a conversation about conflicts of interest. And proper disclosure into the hands of the enemy should be put excerpts from the rules we're talking about today. And that's part of the physical package PDFs that can be supplied to them. We will go in later to deep detail about rule 1.7. That's the rule that establishes the duty of undivided loyalty. There are some differences between the ABA rules and the California Rules. But there's they still go to the same place. And rule 1.7 has six gallon six separate prongs, each of which must be satisfied in order to comply with rule 1.7. Next, your delivery package includes two one page questionnaires.
32:50One coverage questionnaire goes to the insurance company and the other ethical compliance questionnaire goes to independent counsel. Neither the insurance company nor independent counsel will ever complete these questionnaires. So part of the communications campaign will lead to include that the policyholder talks to the insurance company representative goes through the coverage questionnaire herself, completes the questionnaire herself, sends it to the insurance company saying this is what I understand. You told me if I'm wrong in any respect, write me back and correct the record. And please do explain all of your answers. Same thing for independent counsel, send them the ethical compliance questionnaire, they won't complete it.
33:43Instead, the policyholder is going to have to call it the lawyer and say, Look, I need answers to these questionnaire. Please answer them and then just go through one by one. The questionnaires have boxes, check the box, send it in an email to independent counsel saying this is what I understand. You told me and please get back to me with any corrections. And please explain your whatever it is you're talking about. Another item in the delivery package is a model disclosure letter. The model disclosure letter answers the question that inevitably comes up. Well, Steve, what in the world do you really expect a candidate counsel to do? This is the answer. This is a several page letter that goes through or prompts intended counsel to go through the particulars of the reservation of rights, the particulars of this policy, the particulars of this particular complaint, and to analyze all of the grounds upon which the insurer has reserved its rights. The next five minutes the last item in your course materials is a memorandum of law. All, I challenge any of you to dispute any of the law that is stated there. And particularly Let me listen to my friends on the other side of the eye. If anybody from the insurance industry, or from the insurance defense industry wants to take me on in a debate, fill this chair, my grand daughter right here. Happy to do it. But you must you, the policyholder must put this memorandum of law into the hands of the defendant counsel and the insurance company. Why? Because one of the things that both are afraid of is civil
35:44liability for violating the law. And if you the policyholder didn't know anything about the law delivers to them somebody else's Memorandum of law, and you asked him, please tell me if this isn't the truth, then both the insurance company and the pendant counsel will be in a position, at least there'll be an evidentiary basis to make an accusation that their violation of the law was knowing and was systemic. Slide eight. Ethical compliance is hard for defendant counsel. Suppose all the lawyers out there, you had a client and the client came in and said, Susie, I think you're unethical. And I want to talk about it. What would you do? You say, Wait a minute. What are your concerns? Let's sit down. Let's work this way, work our way through this because that's a serious charge.
36:47And it is my obligation to convince you that I am not on ethical rules of ethics apply to me, the lawyer, not you, my client. So let's work this out. And it's hard to do. Now, rule 1.7 compels undivided loyalty and has the six proms that we will go into in detail in a moment. Rule 1.4 is a a an obligation of disclosure by the lawyer to the client. There's no parallel obligation by the client to make disclosure to the lawyer. And it will turn out if you believe my opinion, that I'll be describing the what's left in the next two hours, that this rule 1.4 is the most powerful in terms of developing admissible evidence to bring the goals of this course to fruition. Rule 1.6 of the State Bar Act require protection of confidentiality. This too, is a very powerful rule, but one that's hard to develop admissible evidence on at least in early stages, at least without litigation. And then rule 1.8 is independently other rules. And it does require consent by the policyholder for the insurer paid and counsel. This is another one where the insurance company is simply going to pay independent counsel, notwithstanding the absence of the policyholders informed written consent, so that not a lot can be done about it in in this two week communication campaign. But it will hang like the sword of Damocles over dependent counsel, who have to be asking himself, why do I want to represent this plaintiff in this case where I may not get paid, or I may have to discourage the fees that I earn? Very, very powerful tool for the policyholder.
38:59Now, as hard as it is for dependent counsel to comply with the rules of professional ethics because they're so complex, so confusing, and so strict. The reverse side of that, here on slide nine, is that it's very, very easy for the policyholder to obtain admissible evidence about dependent counsels compliance or non compliance with the same rules we just went through. All the policy holder has to do is say No, I do not consent to you representing me. I do not consent to you appearing in court on my behalf until you have complied with the rules of professional conduct. And I will work with you closely to achieve your compliance with those rules. But I don't know what's going on. And I want you to explain it to me. The burden will be on the lawyer, not the client to comply with the rules. And as long as the policyholder without any lawyer being inside, and engages dependent counsel and the insurance company, about the specifics of these rules, and how the lawyer plans to comply with them, under the limited situation I've described. And as long as those communications are recorded, somehow, usually by letters saying, we talk on such a day, this, this confirms what we talked about, if I got it wrong, please correct it. But also through possibly through recorded zoom calls to which everyone consents. All right. Well, well in to this presentation already. And for the first time, we're going to take a good hard look at the goals that I mentioned before. One of the goals of this procedure and enforcing the rules of professional conduct is to limit or
41:16eliminate insurer reservation rights, one of the solutions to the conflict of interest is to simply put the reservation of rights into the garbage can, or at least to limit it sufficiently that it doesn't create a disqualifying conflict of interest. That does happen on occasion. And it's a very good outcome. It's reasonable enough all by itself to push back. If the insurance company's response is alright, you got me, we're going to limit the reservation of rights. That's a huge win, a really big accomplishment. The next is to achieve prompt settlement and no policyholder cost. That's a that's a big word. But in my experience, this is a uniform outcome of pushing back by delivering the delivery package to the enemy. Why? Because if I'm correct in my speculation that the insurance industry and the insurance defenses in the insurance defense industry are in cahoots with each other about systemically violating the rules of professional conduct, and insurance law. If I'm right about that, which we're going to assume for purposes of the limited situation we're describing here. Then when you push back and you catch them in the violations, as I mentioned briefly before, you gotta buy the short hairs.
42:44They're caught in the violation. And one of the best ways they can avoid liability for getting caught is to make sure that the policyholder suffers no damage, really powerful outcome. And other goals and pressure dependent counsel, the quick, we're gonna discuss some of the specific ways of going about that. But one of them is the one I just described. Hey, I think you're unethical. I want to accept you as my lawyer, but you got to explain to me why I should. What about this reservation of rights? Let's dig into the details. Many lawyers will quit. They won't as long as the insurance company is paying the bill. They won't want to at least, but if you put enough pressure on them through this communication campaign, very, very often, they will quit. One of the ways to bring that to fruition is for the policyholder, to bring a motion in the liability dispute to disqualify their own lawyer. What? Yes, exactly that you'll be watching your dirty laundry in front of the plaintiff and the plaintiff's lawyer. But my experience has been that the defendant counsel will join in the motion. If dependent counsel does not join in the motion, then the policyholder can ask the trial judge in the liability dispute to decide the issue of whether or not the reservation of rights creates a disqualifying conflict of interest. It's a very difficult question to answer and in my experience, the trial judge won't even try to answer it because it's just too complex. But we'll grant the motion to disqualify dependent counsel under the
44:31circumstances that are the core of this presentation. The next goal will be to urge plaintiffs and policyholders to cooperate to enforce their rights to their mutual benefit. Now, this deserves some attention. The plaintiffs in the policyholder cannot cooperate with respect to prosecuting and defending the liability dispute. In my opinion. You can't make the Next up. And that's also true with respect to the coverage dispute, you can't make things up. But the policy holder and the plaintiff and their counsel can, I believe, properly cooperate with each other, to try to achieve a common goal that they have, almost independently of liability dispute, but a common goal they have of getting the policyholder to have trustworthy counsel, and to put pressure on the insurance company to bring the entire dispute to a resolution at no cost to the policyholder in the near future. Next, a goal will be to avoid, but prepare for covered litigation. Again, this presentation is only for the non litigation option. Perhaps a future presentation will address the litigation option. But we just can't go there. Next, this entire procedure should be completed in a very short period of time. And during that very short period of time, there should be very little contact between the policyholder and the policyholder counsel who can introduce the subject matter of this course to the policyholder, to pick up and run with independently of any council for this period of time. The next slide 11. are the principles that inform achievement of
46:38these goals? First is power. Where does the power come from? Well, it comes from the rules of professional conduct which empower the policyholder to say, no, no, I don't give me my consent. I don't give you my authority. I want to I sincerely want to. But you have to comply with the rules before I will give you my consent or my authority to represent you. Whose burden is it to resolve conflicts of interest? The lawyer only the lawyer, not the insurance company and not the policy. Because the lawyer represent the defendant counsel represents both the policyholder and the insurance company. So is the lawyer who has the burden of clearing potential. But certainly actual conflicts of interest. And dependent Council has very little time to do it. Because there's a sum as to which a response must be given in short period of time. What is another principle while it's a principle of proof, policyholders should develop admissible evidence. I am so arrogant as to say that I've read all the cases in this field possibly be true. And from time to time someone who says Steve, you haven't read the ABC case? Because I've read an old case it'll say you write and read that. Okay, so I'll go read it that has nothing to do with the subject.
48:07Having read those cases, there are a number of cases where the policyholder loses. And in those cases, the policyholder failed to present any evidence to the court in a coverage contest, that dependent counsels had any conflict of interest. Why? Because they didn't deliver the delivery package. They didn't test the defendant counsel's conduct, and instead had to rely upon after the fact kind hindsight analysis by the insurance company, an independent counsel of to the effect of well, you know, if you had asked me to read the reservation of rights, and to analyze it and explain it to you, of course, I would have done so. But now that I don't represent you anymore, I don't have to. So that's the end of it. You don't have any evidence that I did anything wrong, saw ha ha. The next principle is one of timing. And I've already introduced the subject, all of this evidence. Accumulation has to occur right away. It cannot be deferred until after the relationship with the lawyer and the insurance company has ended, because then they don't owe any obligation whatsoever. It has to be done right off the bat and should be done before dependent counsel accepts the representation. So when and we'll go over the defenses later at the end. When the defendant counsel and the insurance companies say hold your horses. What are you so excited about? It's just a reservation of rights. We haven't denied coverage. We're just going to defer that to the end. So let's sweep this under the rug. And when the whole case is over, we'll address it again. Well, you've been
49:56slapped in the face Mr. policyholder, don't take ate that kind of information from the enemy. And let them do that to you get the thing resolved. Now, in all likelihood the two weeks will be spent. Aster dependent counsels already made an appearance in the action. After dependent counsels already accepted representation, why? Because they are under the gun to respond to the complaint and the summons. Next, a principle that informs these goals is what I mentioned before, and that is the uniformity of behavior. By the end the council and the insurance industry, they're all of one end of the bell shaped curve, the whole thing is collapsed. Why would that be? The Cubans case in California came down and 84, a Cuba statue came down 87. And the industry has had 37 or eight years to figure out what they're going to do about that holding and the statute and the rules of professional conduct. And in my experience, for the limited situation that we described here, were all of the exceptions to the rule have been filtered out. Everybody in our situation behaves uniformly. And I'll describe that in further detail as we continue this course. Another principle is protection. The policyholder should take prompt steps to protect themselves from the reserving insurer and their lawyers. Take them on, push back, insist upon full disclosure. So how do you do that? I don't understand Insurance Law. Many of you are saying I don't know how to do this. I need some guidance. And your course materials will have most of the guidance that you will need.
52:04Specifically, it will include putting the delivery package into the hands of dependent counsel and the insurance company and put into their hands a completed coverage questionnaire and ethical compliance questionnaire. So let's go through this slide number 12. The policyholder not any lawyer, the policyholder alone must ask questions. The policyholder again will be afraid to do that. You're throwing me into the lion's den. I don't know what to do. With that not knowing what to do is exactly what qualifies the policyholder to be asking the questions. Often in the cases where I have advise policyholders to go through this process. The companies we select as a spokesperson to be the liaison with independent counsel and the insurance companies. And very often that person is someone close to the CEO but not the CEO. Very often, that that is a very personable, very smart, very, very articulate person who has no legal background. And who can honestly say, Look, I'm a complete neophyte in this stuff. Never been involved in a lawsuit before. I don't know what's going on. But my boss wants an explanation.
53:36And that's my job. So I need you dependent counsel and you insurance company, to explain it to me clearly to explain it in writing. So I could take it to my boss, and try to explain it to him and get a decision. I don't have any authority to make decisions. But I do have authority to get the information for my boss that he or she will need in order to make informed decisions about how to go about this lawsuit. Only the policyholder can ask those questions. If a lawyer for the policyholder comes forward and says here I am. This communication campaign will come to an end, in my experience. Why? Because this is a powerful argument. You independent counsel are here to do that for me take the ball and run. And many courts will accept that as a perfectly satisfactory solution.
54:32But if you don't exist, you panel counsel do not exist. No one even knows that you're there and you're not even participating in the evidence gathering process, then that can't happen. The insurance industry is going to do the same thing. They're gonna say, well, all right. I don't have to explain anything to the policyholder anymore. You Mr. Lawyer, thank you for coming on board. You've just relieved me of any obligation I have to explain anything to the policyholders. You're here to do that for me. Thank you very much. Really appreciate that. I am mom. I'm not going to answer any of your questions, Mr. Lawyer, because I only have to answer questions from the policyholder, same for dependent counsel. They have to answer the clients question. They don't have to answer questions from lawyers. Even though the lawyer represents the policyholder.
55:29There's just a filter there. Moreover, the evidence that's developed between lawyers bickering with each other, could very well be excluded from admission at a trial and litigation. Why because it's argumentative. It's it's mirrored colloquy of counsel, having esoteric debates about fine points of law. It just isn't interesting isn't powerful, and it may not be admissible. So lawyers stay out of the discovery development process. That goes only to the policyholder. Now, the policyholder should expressly withhold consent. And the questionnaires I've developed do that, but the policyholder should also say these communicators said, Look, I want you to represent me, I want a lawyer who won't cost me any money, I want a lawyer I can trust. But until you explain these things to me, under Rule 1.4 1.7, until you explain this, to me, I do not consent.
56:31And I do not authorize you to appear in court for me. Next, report dependent counsels will the state bar and report the insurer to the Department of Insurance, in a moment, we'll get to a principle of law that undermines this, I can assure you that neither regulatory body will do anything about it. But it's still an important step to take. Why? Because the insurance industry hates it, when they're reported to the Department of Insurance, or insurance keeps track because that requires them to respond to such complaints. And their licenses can be influenced by the number of complaints they get. Same thing with a report to the State Bar love dependent counsel really common but what they do, they're really good lawyers in many respect, except for compliance with these rules. And they've never been reported to the bar in most cases. So if you report them to the bar, that's going to put them on notice that you're angry, it's going to sour the relationship, and it's going to encourage that lawyer to quit. Next, do not negotiate a compromise. If I'm right, and I believe I am, that the the way you catch him in the act, the insurance company decides to offer independent counsel, then they're going to want to start negotiating a bunch of things. All right, we're gonna give it to you, but only on those terms. Do not negotiate do not compromise. Why? Because the contract you're operating under is the insurance contract, and the contract of engagement, establishing an attorney client relationship with dependent counsel, that's implied or oral,
58:14but nonetheless, it's a contractual relationship. If you cut a new deal with a lawyer or the insurance companies, then you run the risk of abrogating those very powerful rights that the insured has under the insurance policy and that the client has with the conflicted lawyer. So whenever the insurance company or the lawyer comes to you and say, Okay, you caught me, why don't we work things out? US lawyers out there, I'm gonna say, Well, of course, that's what we do. We negotiate, we compromise, not here. Do not compromise. I have a case, I'm going to give you a very brief, very complex area of substantive law, insurance companies said we want to have a lawyer. We talked to the lawyer, the lawyer said, We don't know anything about that. So we asked the insurance company, do you have any lawyers qualified in this field? And they didn't. So they said, Alright, we will pay for independent counsel, but only on our terms.
59:19And we said no, we have the policyholder has a contract with lawyers who are competent to do this. You Mr. Insurance Company don't have any borders who can qualify. So you have to pay their fee, and they did. So don't negotiate don't compromise. I know that's a big ask. But you'll be rewarded. If you accept my subjective point of view. Next, I'm the plaintiff. Here's it. Here's information for you plaintiffs lawyers out there, and the plaintiffs themselves. Now, we all know that a plaintiff's lawyer cannot talk to the defense And who's represented by counsel, except in the presence of the lawyer representing that client. But there is no prohibition upon the plaintiff and the defendant as parties to continue talking to each other. Oftentimes, they know each other, you know, their daughters are on the same soccer team, they go to the same church, they play golf together, whatever it may be, they have a continuing relationship. Now, they should not be talking about the merits or lack of merits of the liability dispute. But in my opinion, they are entitled to talk to each other about matters of mutual interest in terms of getting the insurance company to do what they both want to do. And that is to bring the dispute to a close in the near future. So you're gonna have to look at the particular circumstances. But I believe that it is possible for a plan to take these these course materials, and give a copy of it to the defendant to read if they want, they may or may not do it, the defendant will certainly take that back to independent
1:01:12counsel, who will be shocked and appalled. But at least the policyholder will be informed of what you're informed of. And it may spark a discourse between the client and dependent counsel in the presence of a reservation of rights. There's one other thing that I have seen done, and it's worked very well, you plaintiff's lawyer is going to take the deposition of the defendant. And that will be in front of the defendants lawyer. What I like to do and I urge you to consider is to take the entire package, of course materials have three sets. One at the end of the deposition, say I have one last exhibit to attach to the deposition, identify it, give it to the court reporter, then give another copy to defendant counsel and give another copy to the policyholder and say, I'm done, you're not going to be able to ask any questions about it. Independent Counsel is going to be apoplectic, the defendant isn't gonna know what to do with it, but at least he's on. And one thing I've already mentioned as a technique, which is very, very effective, is that if nothing else gets rid of dependent counsel, after this communication campaigns, a motion to recuse will do so. Let me just give you one instance. You know, emotion of recusal usually require some lawyer to come in on as especially basis and just make the motion to recuse the lawyer. But in one instance, literally a little old lady in Pasadena appeared in court in Procore, even though she was represented by a lawyer on a motion by the insurance company to intervene in the
1:03:10liability disputes for the purpose of having a voice in selecting the wording of jury instructions, and especially derogatory is to the jury, which would determine coverage issues in the liability dispute. The little old lady from Pasadena asked her insurance defense lawyer to resist that motion. He refused on the grounds that he doesn't get involved in coverage. So the little old lady showed up in court, because there was no opposition to the motion for the insurance company to intervene. The tentative was to permit the insurance company to intervene. The little old lady said, Your Honor, this is not my lawyer. This is my insurance company's lawyer. There's a reservation, right. He refuses to get involved and instruct you to resist the motion, he wouldn't do it due to this liability dispute to try to decide insurance issues in this action, where their lawyer represents the policyholder and the insurance company is clearly accusing the insurance company over me and I have not authorized this lawyer to to appear in this action for me, nor do I consent to his representation. And the judge said literally Wow, motion denied. Dependent counsel discharged. Great result little lady from Pasadena she didn't know what was going on said she read these materials.
1:04:43So she won. Next item. How do you gather the information? Um There are two elements to this. One is that the policyholder really needs to complete the questionnaires. And the independent counsel and claims representatives are unlikely to participate in any oral communication that is recorded in any fashion. So there will need to be some communications that are not recorded by. But once the delivery package is in the hands of the enemy, and the questionnaires have been completed with the enemy, given the opportunity to correct any errors in the way that the policyholder completes it, then one way for the policyholder, to make sure that all evidence from then on is admissible evidence is to insist that all communications with independent counsel and with the claims route be by zoom that is recorded. Now, they're not going to want to do that. And so they will not consent to such a recording. And therefore, the policyholder cannot record it without their consent without risk of violating wiretapping laws. Nobody can listen in, nobody can record a conversation under those circumstances, which is fine. But if they won't participate in oral communications that are being recorded, then they must communicate if at all, in writing, and that creates a better record. One of these techniques which the insurance industry uses is to whipsaw the policyholder, on the one hand, they have a written record while the reservation of rights. On the other hand, they have an opportunity to have oral communications, which oral communication can
1:07:03contradict the written record, a reason I believe they don't want to go on the record with respect to oral oral communications. And one of the reasons they want to have all communications is so that there is not a body of admissible evidence to contradict what is already in the written record. Instead, you get into what will necessarily be a trial about who said that too. So my recommendation is when the policyholder gets into these communications, to try to get consent to record in a zoom call all of the communications invariably, they will say, hell no, we don't consent, we won't do it.
1:07:53That conversation shouldn't be recorded. And the refusal to participate in a discussion that is being recorded, followed is being recorded and they know it's being recorded, I believe will be admissible evidence, because when they speak, knowing that they're recorded, they're consenting to being recorded. It's just like, leave a voicemail. And what will result will be a great piece of theater, the policyholder can say, why don't you want to record it? Are you planning on lying to me? If you're going to tell me the truth? Why not record it? Well, all right, that piece of theater will come to a close in pretty short. So you turn it off, you make a copy of what was recorded, you send it to whoever was on the call. So they've got a copy of it, too. They can sit down and look at what they've done. And then the communications will have to be non recorded.
1:08:54Nobody listening in nobody recording it. But the policyholder can instead ask the questions, complete the questionnaires. And follow up with a confirming letter, in always inviting the defendant counsel and policyholder to correct any error in the record. Now a moment ago talking about regulatory entities. I said we'd get to this later. And here it is. There is such a thing as a primary jurisdiction doctrine, at least in California, and I would imagine elsewhere as well. And the primary jurisdiction doctrine says that a court does not necessarily have to resolve a problem. If there is an administrative process that would resolve the problem instead. In under this doctrine, the court will sometimes dismiss a civil action but will instead often defer to regulatory bodies, to see if the regulatory body can find a solution. So one of the reasons to report dependent counsel after a failed communications campaign report dependent counsel to the State Bar is that if this lease litigation, you can truthfully say, Your Honor, we tried the State Bar, nothing happened. So don't invoke the preliminary jurisdiction doctor. Same thing for the insurance company, report, the insurer to the Department of Insurance, Department of Insurance will do it. A an investigation, they won't tell you what the outcome is, in all likelihood, neither regulatory vital, is going to do anything. But you've achieved very, very simply some important information, that if you go to litigation, the regulatory bodies are not
1:10:57going to be any help. And therefore, the court has to decide what's happening. Slide 13 In order to put the rules of professional conduct in the context, I think you listeners other than the enemy that I've already identified, need a little bit of background in just a few basic insurance defense principles. So the you put implementation of the rules of professional ethics into context and and apply them knowingly, turn to page eight of your materials here, and you can kind of read along. One basic insurance principle is that the insurance company will accept the duty to defend because of a potential for indemnity coverage. Right off the bat I mentioned, you expect the lawyer to take you through the process and expect the insurance companies to pay for the outcome.
1:11:53Those describe what we defend in coverage lawyers call the duty to defend that is pay for a lawyer to go through the defense and the duty to indemnify that is fun to settlement or judgment. Though those two duties are governed by different standards, the duty to indemnify is only right if after the fact all of the complicated language of the insurance policy is satisfied. And there can be hundreds if not 1000s of bases upon which the insurance company could deny indemnity coverage. But none of that complicated analysis is necessary for the duty to defend to be triggered. Why? Because the duty to defend has to be discharged from the beginning of the lawsuit, the duty to indemnify can only be discharged at the end of the lawsuit. And therefore, the duty to defend is triggered in full. If there's any possibility that there might be some small portion of a judgment that is covered by the policy. The insurance industry knows this, they adhere to it very carefully. And therefore they will often instead of denying coverage, agree to provide an offense under reservation rights. That means there can they are going to try to fulfill the duty to defend and then defer until the end of the case the decision whether or not to indemnify leaving the policyholder in limbo for the entire period. That is a very fundamental concept that you need to understand that is working upon the insurance industry. In the situation we've described. We're on slide 15, item number two.
1:13:47Another basic insurance concept that you should be familiar with is that if the insurance company fails to defend all together, it may be required to pay a non covered judgment. That's a huge concept. And a huge subject matter. To try to explain that in detail would take me two hours. We don't have time for that. But what you should take away from this presentation is if the insurance company is afraid to fail to defend because a breach of one of the two primary promises of the policy. The duty to defend that alone may require the insurer to pay a judgment without regard to whether or not all the complicated elements of the duty to indemnify are satisfied. This is a hugely powerful stick to hold over the head of the insurance company. They're very very aware of it. They're very, very afraid of it and therefore they tend to offer to provide a defense while reserving their rights to later deny coverage. One of the whole themes of this brief entation is includes however, that it may constitute a failure to defend, to appoint a lawyer who is not ethically qualified to conduct the defense. It may even race rise to the level of denying the policyholder procedural due process of law to go through a liability dispute with a lawyer cannot be trusted to have protected the policyholders interests. Item number three on slide 15, is a failure to reserve rights may result in a forfeiture of coverage defenses. The reason liability insurers issue so many hundreds of 1000s, if not millions, of reservations or rights per year, is that
1:15:48they're afraid not to, they are permitted to do so quite liberally. Because all they're doing really is saying we don't know if there's coverage is legitimate is permitted. I don't blame insurance companies for issuing referees, right? It's just that when they do so they incur certain obligations arising out of the fact that they have reserved rights. And they, in our situation, routinely fail to accept the consequences of issuing a reservation of rights. But they know that if they don't issue the reservation of rights, they can forfeit coverage defenses. What does that mean? Well, it means the same thing as the last one. That is if they don't have any contractual defenses, because they forfeited them, then any judgment entered against the policyholder will be covered, because they can't rely on any of the bases that they have under the duty to indemnify. They just can't rely on them anymore. They can't enforce. And therefore they have to pay the judgment, whether it's covered or not. Really, really powerful stuff. Number four, on slide 15, dependent counsel owes the policyholders duties of undivided loyalty, disclosure and confidentiality. We've been through that before, we're about to get into the nitty gritty of the language of the rules themselves. As to these three, but first, let me just mention this, there is a fourth primary duty that lawyers owe to their clients. And that is a duty of competent representation. And invariably, in my experience, dependent counsel are incredibly competent at their fields. Why? Because the
1:17:37insurance industry says have hundreds if not 1000s, of cases of the same sort. Why? Because certain different kinds of policies covers certain different kinds of situations. So an insurer that issues a kind of policy will send to dependent counsel much of their word for those kinds of policies. So a law firm can develop a whole department where they do nothing but the subject matter this lawsuit, and they do it really, really well. They know how to go about it, they know the ins and outs of it. So they have a great deal to offer in terms of competent representation. And I take nothing away from them for that. But instead, we will be focusing upon what I have experienced to be systemic failure to adhere to the duties of undivided loyalty, disclosure and confidentiality. And those are undivided loyalty 1.7, disclosure 1.4 and confidentiality 1.6 and the State Bar. Another thing you need to understand, and this is well developed in California, and frankly, I don't know it exists anywhere else. But in California, insurers have a right to reimbursement. That is an insurance company can say, all right, we got a conflict of interest. we're reserving our rights.
1:19:04We're going to pay all the costs of defense, we're independent counsel, we're going to pay all the costs of settlement. But when it's all over, we get to sue the insurance company that had no we get to sue the policyholder, to get all the costs of defense back or something. All of a sudden, or something, but And believe it or not. In California, there's a case that the insurance company can sue independent counsel for unreasonable charges in conducting the defense. The course materials have a detail some details, a very brief description of what those rates of reimbursement car, but I want you to know that they exist. And I want to mention it because this will be folded into what's left of the presentation, that this rights of reimbursement can make very complex. The whole question of whether or not an insurer is providing enough hedge or is paying for settlement. For example, if an insurance company says they frequently do, yes, we agree to provide a defense. Yes, we will pay independent counsel. But we reserve the right to get money back. does that constitute a fulfillment of the duty event or not? And in California, there's a statute that this impacts, does that qualify to trigger the application of the statute? More about that? Later? Slide 16. All right. So now policyholder, what do you do next? So far? We've been talking about mostly principals during the page 10 of your materials. Some of this was redundant, but I cannot drive it home clearly enough. Where's the power come from? The policyholder has the power comes
1:20:59from the ability to say no. And the ability to say no, come from two sources. One is as two independent counsel, you come from the Rules of Professional Conduct after the insurance company, the ability to say no comes from insurance statutes and regulations. Let me elaborate on that. The insurance industry itself came up with what is known as the NS unfair policyholder insurance issue, unfair insurance Practices Act UEBA. And California and some states have adopted it. And those states that have adopted it and probably also implemented regulations. California is very well developed on it. And it creates obligations of the insurer to explain what the insurer is doing. Explain that to the policyholder, uniform insurance company does not do that.
1:22:07And therefore, is in breach of its of its regulatory obligation to explain to the policyholder what's going on? And that creates a very powerful tool that the policyholder can use against the insurance company to place upon the insurance company that burden to tell me what's going on. It's very similar to the burden the insurance the defense counsel has, but the source of power is different. As to the lawyer rules. Special conduct, as to the insurance company is the concept of of good faith, but also insurance statutes and insurance regulations in those states that happen. Next, what? How should the policyholder be guided? Again, it is to developing proof. Again, I've read all cases.
1:23:01And you can go to my website duty to defend.com and download a very lengthy survey of all of the American jurisdictions. In a moment, we'll be discussing the differences among those jurisdictions. But for our purposes now. There are many cases out there where the policyholder lost the conflict of interest issue. And in those cases, I believe the loss is primarily due to the failure of the policyholder to present any proof of any violations of the rules of professional conduct. And that is because the policyholder didn't sue the lawyers, and didn't develop admissible evidence before the underlying case was over. So they were empty handed. And when they were empty handed they lost that can be overcome by going through the procedure that I'm urging in this process. Finally, bring up timing again, do not delay getting this evidence on the record. Dependent counsel has to clear conflict, before they even make an appearance and 99% of the time, they they just don't have time to to clear those conflicts because a responsive cleaning is done. And my interpretation of the California Rules of Professional Ethics permits that frankly, in an emergency if there is a need to clear conflicts and need to comply with approval of the with the rules of professional ethics. The lawyer can go to the client and say, look, we've got a problem here with my ethics. And I want to get it cleared out. And I want to work with you to make sure that you're happy with my representation. But it's going to take us a while to do that. In the meantime, we've got to file an answer. So I'd
1:24:53like your permission to file the answer. And then very soon, we'll get back to clearing and go conflicts of interest that's permitted and is permitted, in my opinion, under the circumstances zoom thing it makes sense. But still, the timing is very, very important. And so, GIF as often happens, dependent counsel makes an appearance and accepts the representation and does so with your limited consent. This is an emergency step, then, then that's okay. But dependent counsel has to come back promptly and resolve the conflicts of interest in some fashion or another. What are the principles? Slide number 17? What are the principles for developing this evidence? First, dependent counsel has a fiduciary relationship with all of their clients. And that fiduciary relationship includes an obligation to educate the client. We'll get into rule 1.4 and detail in a moment, and that's part of it. But this obligation to teach the client to be able to make informed decisions about the lawsuit is also well developed in California law, even independently of the Rules of Professional Conduct, and I suspect that's true in other jurisdictions as well. The claims agent must answer questions from the policyholder. Why, because of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing bad faith. Also, in those states that have the statutes and regulations, California regulations make it explicit. I don't know what the regulations in other states say. But I urge you in those states to see if there's a statute to see if there are regulations,
1:26:52read them carefully and see if those obligations are supported by the regulations. Next, a principle. So let me just finish up on one. The policyholder has depended counsel and the insurance company under the thumb. If they ask questions, they got to answer very important principle to recorded conduct reveals actual violations of law. Now, I recorded I mean, some, you know, Zoom recordings, Zoom meetings, if that doesn't work out, then reported means while confirming letters and completing the questionnaires, but to make some record of what the conduct is of the insurance company and the independent counsel, while the underlying case is still going on, if by asking the questions and requiring responses, and making a record of what the question is in responses are, often by confirming letters, we will know what the conduct is of the insurance company and dependent counsel and that conduct be establishes whether or not they're violations of the law. If they behave ethically Great, then then you want if they don't behave ethically and lawfully, then you have evidence of a violation. So making a record establishing this admissible evidence through use of the delivery package, and the questionnaires is very, very important as a principle for developing the evidence. Third, the policyholder alone should have the direct content. I've emphasized that before and can't emphasize it enough. You as the lawyer, take this course a maybe I'll give it a try. You get a client come in, you give them a copy of the course
1:28:52materials, you talk it through you say lie away, go do what it says. Leave me out of it. Let me know what happens. And then we'll talk it through. It may be that the client hasn't gotten enough information so he can say all right, come into the office. Let's discuss it again. Go back and continue the development of of evidence. You know, you play it by ear. But lawyers stand for the development of evidence. And again, you shouldn't even we don't do exist. Five, policyholder should offer to accept any ethical independent counsel, never, never never demand independent counsel. Now, however critical is that, for me to say that one of the goals is to get independent counsel, but don't ask for it. Not hypocritical at all. Why? Because if Particularly the lawyer comes in and says, You gotta pay me I'm greedy, money, money, money, money, I want your money. It's a terrible life. Moreover, it misses a very fundamental achievement that is possible if you don't do that. Never demand independent counsel, wait for the insurance company to say, we're going to do you a favor and pay for independent counsel. And the way to do that is for the policyholder, dealing with the first lawyer who quits using the techniques we're going to continue talking about. The response to that should be by the policyholder, it'd be somebody else. This lawyer didn't work out that maybe you have somebody else who does work out. And I've had clients. I've consulted in situations where the policyholder, considered four or 567 other different law firms, contacted every
1:31:00one of them. Many of them smell a rat and say I'm not interested, many of them who are not panel counsel say not being paid enough. I'm not interesting. But some panel counsel will come forward and say, Sure, I'll take the business, in which case you just go through the same routine with the next lawyer, maybe the lawyer will respond ethically. And if the lawyer does respond ethically, frankly, what I do in those situations is a great, we consent to you representing us. What we're trying to achieve here is not dealing with lawyers who don't understand what the what the coverage issues are. And there's no and is therefore not in a position to be able to protect the policyholder with respect to coverage. But if that happens, then great, except Except dependent counsel. That that's generally my advice. But in all likelihood, because of the narrow situation that that we're addressing here. None of the other lawyers that the insurance company has to offer will qualify either. And it is very, very important to establish that fact. In California, there's a statute that says the insurance company does not have to pay any more than his normal hourly rate to the to Panama Council. They don't have to pay that to independent counsel. But if it turns out that nobody on the insurance companies panel can ethically represent the policyholder, because of violations 1.4, not necessarily 1.7, then a very good argument can be made that there is no standard by this insurance company, they do not regularly hire lawyers to handle a case like yours, because nobody
1:32:54on their panel could qualify. And therefore the rate limitation of this is Civil Code section 2016. That doesn't apply, the insurance company has to pay full rates to independent counsel. Okay, the guide to the delivery package. Let's turn to the delivery package in your course materials.
1:33:28And you will find there the ethical compliance questionnaire on page 23 and coverage questionnaire on page 24, the model disclosure letter on page 25. And then the memorandum law starting on page 32. excerpts and the six prongs of rule 1.7 are back on starting on page 12. So please, you know, thumbed through those as we go through this next section. Among the things in your packages are the model emails. Um, and these are just suggestions. They're things that have worked for me, you'll want to adapt them for no conditions on the ground. But they're a good series. I think they're good series of emails starting off soft, getting stricter and stricter, starting off essentially saying, Welcome aboard. Looking forward to working with you. I don't understand the reservation rights. Do you have a copy of it, and then start the dialogue? Usually, and always in our limited situation. Here dependent counsel doesn't have the reservation rights, didn't ask for it. Didn't want a copy of it didn't want to read it didn't want to analyze it. But it's important to establish that all of that is true. Next, the delivery package the process, the guide to do this must result in accurately don't make anything up accurately making a record of what actually happened. It doesn't matter what the other side says. But matters is to create a record of what they said. What they say may be wonderful for you, and you don't have to go through this, they may qualify.
1:35:30That's great. But if they don't do what they're supposed to, you still need to make the record. If you're making a record of them behaving beautifully. That's great. If you're making a record that they're not behaving beautifully, that's also great. Just the the policyholder should be nothing more than a Scrivener. Barnaby Scrivener, ask questions because you don't know what's going on. Write down what is said who said what? Try to make sense of it. Send out confirming letters. Nothing creative about the process. Don't put words in their mouths. Don't reach conclusions, just just be a Scrivener. But confirm all oral contact. And then again, once this process is over in a couple of weeks, insist on recording zoom calls, or requiring insurance company independent counsel to write to you, whatever it is they want to know. Great. I'm asked for detailed explanation of the coverage defenses. What does that mean? Go through the reservation, right? Go through the complaint, go through the policy and say okay, you've reserve your right and based upon such and such language, let's turn to that language. Please explain it to me. For example, a frequent subject matter of a reservation of rights is that the policyholders not may not suffer defined loss LSS a defined term that that means certain kinds of damages are covered, certain kinds of damages are not covered, and then go through it line by line. Usually, exclusions for certain kinds of loss are long and complicated. They talk about what at this kind of damage, we won't pay for that kind of
1:37:30damage, and so on and so on. Like, it's a long, complicated process. But it's a process that the insurance company has to respond to, the independent counsel has to respond to, and that the policyholder only has to ask about, so in these oral communications, go through that stuff in detail word by word, item by item and ask, though the insurance company on the one hand, and the lawyer on the other hand to say Help me understand.
1:38:01They will have never done that before. Never been required to do it. Probably won't do it. And in my opinion, if that's what happens, that will be a basis upon which the policyholder can reject dependent counsel, whether or not the reservation of rights creates a disqualifying conflict of interest, or breach rule 1.4 alone. There's a strong basis upon which to not consent to representation by a lawyer who won't army to make intelligent decisions about how to conduct the defense. And number three, ask Oh, yeah, we just did that for sand and complete the questionnaires. This is a two step process. After learning that the defendant counsel doesn't know and doesn't want to know anything about a reservation rights, he doesn't get involved coverage, send them the questionnaires and say, Please complete this. We're gonna go through the questionnaires, not completely because of lack of time, but in part. The questionnaire says you you don't have my consent, or my authority represent me until you complete and return this questionnaire. But when you send it to them first time, they're gonna say, We've never been required to do this before and we're not going to do it now. That will be a violation. In my opinion, rule 1.4 for the policyholder makes a reasonable request for information, and the lawyer doesn't get it. So what do you do? I think you still need answers to the question. So we've been through this already. The policyholder should call up not recorded because the other side won't answer the question Is it while they're
1:39:43being recorded? Complete the questionnaire. The policyholder should complete the questionnaire dependent counsel will be very reluctant to hang up on the client. The insurance company representative be very lucky to hang up on their own clients. And so the If the policyholder can just read question by question, and then check the yes or no box. And then when completed, send the completed questionnaire to the lawyer and the insurance company with a cover letter that says, This is what I understood, you said, if I'm wrong, then please correct me, and give me an explanation for why I'm wrong. Very, very powerful piece of evidence. Next, just make sure you deliver the entire package, there are going to be emails back and forth. But before you're done, make sure that everything in the package is in their hands. And next report to the regulatory authorities. We've talked about that in some detail. But here's a slide at least and it's and it's more lengthy in the course materials. But these are the things this is a slide that you give to the policyholder to say, All right, this is what you're trying to do here, it is a one page there six items, you're not going to have to do any of them. I know you're going to be confused about how to complete the emails, but let this be your guide. All right. This one is going to take a while on slide number 19. While we are on slide number 19. Please be thumbing through the extremes of rules starting on page 16. On this slide 19, I have put the I paraphrase because the rules are longer and more
1:41:36complex. But this is in my opinion, the gist of what both the ABA rules and the California Rules. Say. Let me just take a moment to emphasize that the California Rules use the word and AMD that they make it explicit that each of these six elements are conjunctive. The ABA rules don't use that word, but it's still implied because they the ABA rules, say under Rule 1.7, the lawyer has to do 12345 each of those must be satisfied. Okay, so the question under one one question under 1.7. is, are the clients directly adverse? Or the insurance company in the policyholder, directly adverse? Neither set of rules defines directly adverse? So how's the lawyer supposed to explain that clearly, very difficult task? In my opinion, that is simply another way of saying Does the reservation of rights create an actual or potential merely potential conflict of interest? And that requires a thorough analysis of the reservation of rights in order to answer that question, next, Will 1.7 prohibits representation, if there's a significant risk that as a lawyer being materially limited by the relationship with the insurer.
1:43:16What does that mean? Well, that also requires a complex analysis. The dependent counsel has a relationship with the insurer, they dependent on this and other issuers for virtually all of their income. That's an important important relationship. The rule also describes a responsibility to the insurer, the lawyer often has to follow billing guidelines and litigation guidelines that are imposed upon the lawyer by the insurer. The litigation guidelines often say you can't hire an expert or take a deposition without our consent, that limits the independence of dependent counsel in exercising their free judgment about how best to defend the policyholder, that's a problem.
1:44:03So is the lawyer limited by these impositions placed upon the lawyer by the insurer? Maybe are those limitations material? Maybe? That's a hard question to ask. Easy question to ask a hard question to answer. But the policyholder is in a position to say, keep explaining because I don't get it. And I need an explanation of what is material, how the limitations apply. What are your responsibilities to the insurer? What is your relationship with the insurer? I want details and I want them in writing. Three. The lawyer can't take the representation if the representation would be materially limited by the lawyer's own interest. So what are the lawyers interest? Well, the lawyers interest Aren't pleasing the insurance company. So the insurance company will keep sending business.
1:45:05The lawyer has no interest except those ethical obligations to represent or to please the policyholder, because the policyholder isn't going to pay the lawyer any money in this case, or any other case, this the only time this lawyer is going to engage this policy will occur. So the economic forces working on the border are huge. And those can be exploited, the policyholder should say, so how much money do you get from this insurer? How much money do you get from other insurers? How much money do you get from people other than insurers? Are you completely dependent upon insurers? The lawyer is not going to answer any of those questions, and probably doesn't have to, but they're very challenging questions. They're perfectly good questions. Why should I trust you when your economic motive is to protect somebody other than me? Powerful stuff? The lawyer doesn't answer adequately. And frankly, they'll probably get angry and refuse to do so. You've got a great piece of evidence by confirming whatever the lawyer says. The next is a little bit tricky. A lawyer reasonably believes that you can do a good job that the lawyer can represent the policyholder and the insurance company competently and diligently. And the dependent counsel will almost invariably say, I think I can do a job. I'm perfectly comfortable doing this is that expression of a belief reasonable or unreasonable? depends upon the circumstances. But it is very difficult for the policyholder, to answer the question whether that belief is reasonable or not. So
1:46:54it is one of the bases upon which you're really not going to be able to develop much, much evidence. Because the lawyer will routinely will say, unnecessarily believe it all likelihood that they could do a good job. The next item is that the representation is not prohibited by law. Well, so what law are we looking at? in California and elsewhere? There's a well developed body of law, including the humans case that says that the lawyer cannot represent the policyholder, without complying with the rest of the rules of professional ethics, not just rule 1.7, but the entire set of rules. And so if that representation is prohibited by not only the rules themselves, but by the cases interpreting the rules and lawyer obligations, then the lawyer has failed to satisfy rule 1.7. Next, and I just love this one, because it's so confusing, but so obvious that the lawyer is permitted to accept the representation. If if the representation does not involve the assertion of any adverse claims. That is, does the defense of the liability suit involve an undefined term? In rules? You'll find a definition in the dictionary, which is very broad. Does it involve the assertion by the insurance company of a claim against the policyholder? Is anything going to come up in the defense of the liability suit? Which might determine any issue upon which the insurance company has reserved its rights? If so, then the representation does involve the assertion of the insurance company of a claim against the policyholder that we're not going
1:48:52to cover with this kind of damage. We're not going to cover this cause of action and we're not going to cover whatever it is they said in the reservation of rights they're not going to cover. So I think the policyholder just has a rich Goldmine to dig by looking at these six prong and taking the lawyer on the one hand and the insurance company on the other hand, through each of them, and demanding detailed explanations, which are recorded in writing. This item can certainly be evidenced by confirming letter, but I think the policyholder is entitled to require defendant counsel to develop their own written explanation. This is a little bit complicated. I interpret rule 1.7 I think many do that adherence to rule 1.7 is does not require the informed written consent of the client unless there's a disqualifying conflict of interests. And that's a very difficult thing to determine. Without litigation, and the insurance company and counsel invariably say, No, we don't have a disqualifying conflict. And there's no way of resolving that except by going to litigation. But independently of rule 1.7 rule 1.4, the disclosure rule does require independent counsel to respond to inquiry. So it is appropriate, I believe, for the lawyer or the cert or the policyholder client under these circumstances to say, All right, we've gone through and 47 You've told me certain things, but under Rule 1.8, I want a written disclosure of your explanation of rule 1.7.
1:50:43That puts the defendant counsel between a rock and a hard spot. All right, so let's take a look at 1.4. I'm not going to read that language to you. But I do ask you as you go through it under the excerpts, as as I'm discussing this very briefly, the excerpts starting on page 16. What is rule 1.4 all about? It is described as requiring communications between the lawyer and the client. I call that the source of the duty of disclosure. The disclosure doesn't necessarily have to be written it can be oral. But if the policyholder asks for a written explanation, I think that is a request that falls under the terms of rule 1.4. And should require independent counsel to comply with that request to make a written disclosure or explain why not. If they don't comply, then I think the independent counsel as a witness become very weak. Why wouldn't you put it in writing? Did you want to lie to your own client? Why wouldn't you make it clear? Okay, so the gist of rule 1.4 Is that the lawyer shall promptly comply with reasonable requests or information, copies of significant documents. And when, when necessary to keep the client informed in order to make informed decisions about achieving the goals of the policyholder in the lawsuit. The Cumans case, and this whole conflict of interest field focuses upon rule 1.7. But in my opinion, the way to implement rule 1.7 is through rule 1.6 1.4. That's the one that can be controlled. That's the one where evidence can be developed. Very often, the ultimate decision of whether one rule 1.7
1:53:10applies or not required through the gation. We're not focusing upon that in this presentation. So 1.4 becomes hugely important. The next slide 1.6 requires protection of confidential information. In addition to this rule, the California rule and I suspect other states, it simply incorporates the State Bar Act, which which very, very strictly enforces the obligation of a lawyer to not share confidential information with anybody else which can be harmful to the to the client, the policyholder client. Now, this is another rule of wild strictly enforced, it's really difficult to develop admissible evidence with respect to whether or not the lawyer is adhering to it. Why? Given you know, going back to our hypothetical, suppose the policyholder goes in and sees the lawyer and said, Yeah, I've murdered the son of a bitch. Well, what is the lawyer view with that? All right. The fact is that the policyholder is a felon and an admitted felon, but that communication was given to the lawyer in confidence. Now, if the lawyer doesn't know what the reservation of Rights says, and that a basis for a reservation of rights either was or is about to become that the conduct of the policyholder was willful, therefore not covered. Well, the lawyer is it a disadvantage if they don't know what the reservation rights is? So what is the lawyer do about having this information that the client is a felon after all, Clearly, the lawyer cannot tell the insurance company. But on the other hand, if they pick up the phone, and the lawyer says a march, you know, the
1:55:12Jones case, the guy just walked into my office and told me that he did it on purpose. What do we do about that? And Mark says, Thanks for the information, but keep it off the books. That's a problem, you're not going to know that they're going to keep it on the Qt won't come into the record. But it can be very damaging. And that is an example of why it is that the policyholder should not trust a dependent counsel who does not know what the basis of the reservation of rights are. Because if he doesn't know he can't possibly comply with the rule of confidentiality. Now, that may help to protect the lawyer, the lawyer who later say, sorry, I didn't do it on purpose. I just didn't know the clients were conflicted. Well, that just begs the question, why didn't you know, why didn't you find out? You know, you're representing two clients. You know, that in under the circumstances, liability policies, reservation rights are often issued. Why didn't you find out? Okay, maybe the lawyer won't be disbarred. And we'll just be disciplined. And maybe the lawyer will have civil liability, maybe not. But we don't want to go there. You want to you want to prevent this problem from occurring in the in the first place, which reminds me that the Rules of Professional Conduct are prophylactic, they're designed to prevent harm from occurring in the first place, they're not remedial, they are declared not to be a single basis upon which you could sue the lawyer for malpractice. Instead, they state the standards by which the lawyer should
1:56:55conduct himself. But and so if those standards are violated, that may invite civil liability, but the purpose of the primary purpose of the of the rules is to not get into the situation in the first place, that could lead to these kinds of liability problems. All right, rule 1.8 in California is rule one, point 8.6. We're now on slide 22, of only 25. And we don't have a whole lot of time left. But I'm just going to keep going if you don't mind listening to me drone on. Rule 1.8 has three requirements. And let me just state that I have no problem with the insurance company paying for defendant counsel when there's no conflict of interest as just 1.8 is off the table. But when there is a conflict of interest, I believe this rule does come into play. And so the insurance company cannot interfere with the independence of the lawyer exercising judgment. They have to protect confidential information, and they have to obtain informed consent of the policyholder in order for the insurance company to pay dependent counsel.
1:58:11This is independent, in my opinion of all the other rules and hangs, as I said, as the sword of Damocles over dependent counsel. Now, onto Slide number 23, I'm going to have to make this very short, I think is a fascinating subject matter. And again, the survey at duty to defend.com will go into this and I don't know 80 or 90 pages, reviewing every not every case, but every jurisdiction. There are kind of three rules that come out. The most common rule is the per se rule. And it says they're up to 3035 jurisdictions that have had this issue come before them. And the judge in line or two, maybe a paragraph of the Court of Appeal has said surance Company issued reservation right, that creates a conflict of interest. surance company has to pay for an independent counsel, move on to the next issue. Interestingly, none of those opinions identify their decision as following the per se rule. Instead, the only cases discussing the per se rule are those that depart from and California is among those emerging cases that quite uniformly now adopt what is also the Restatement rule and that is a modified per se rule. Not all reservations of range create a disqualifying conflict of interest.
1:59:38For example, a breach of conditions under the policy didn't pay the premium. He didn't tell us about the lawsuit, things like that errors by the policyholders that have nothing to do with the substance of the lawsuit. And that is what I believe should be the uniform rule. But there are a few states that depart even from that. And in those five six states, they have developed what they call the enhanced duties rule. And in those cases, one, the lawyers were not super sued to the policyholder failed to present any evidence of any violation of any rules. Three, the insurance company paid for the resolution of the lawsuit for the insurance company paid for the complete defense by independent counsel. And five, therefore, the insurance company does not have to pay for an independent counsel. But in with those back situations in those several jurisdictions, those courts have concluded No, there is no obligation to pay for independent counsel, in addition to dependent counsels and reaching those conclusions, those courts say, in reaching these this ruling, we are going to comment on the nature of the rules and emphasize that the Rules of Professional Conduct and the rules of good faith and fair dealing merge so that the insurance company and indeed counsel share each other's obligations mutually to the policyholder, under enhanced duties, mostly of disclosure to the policyholder. So those cases that follow the Restatement rule and the has duties rule refer to a rejection of the per se rule for the reasons that they stayed, in
2:01:41my opinion, because rule 1.7 1.4 are universal. Throughout all the jurisdictions, the judicial results of the situation we're discussing should also be exactly the same. That just makes sense to me. But the decisions are not. And one of the reasons that the decisions are not is because not because the rules are different, not because the insurance company's obligations are different, but because the evidence was different. And therefore we get what are recognized often as disparate outcomes, pursuing two disparate rules, where in fact, the rules is the same, and therefore, the judicial analysis of the outcome should be the same. Here is a brief statement of the Restatement. And because I'm running out of time, I'm just not going to spend any time want it. You can read it for yourself. And we're going to move on to slide number 25, which is the last one.
2:02:53Now, I've already mentioned, what kind of qualifies as the insurance industry's defenses to being caught red handed systemically violating the law with respect to unconflicted representation. The most powerful of those is that the insurance company wants to protect itself from civil liability by making sure that the policyholder suffers no damage. That's a great defense. And it's a great outcome for the policyholder. And it's one of the goals you're trying to achieve. But it's not included here among these industry defenses. So let's turn to the first one and turn to page 28 of the course materials to try to follow along with these various things, the tripartite relationship. What is that? That means simply that when there is no conflict of interest, the there are three parties on the defense team. The insurance company is a financier the policyholders a witness and dependent counsel is a harmonious lawyer who can ethically represent both of their interests in resisting the merits of the liability claim. That's the tripartite relationship. And it always applies to the effort to defeat or minimize the the plaintiffs claim. But that's all that it does. The harmonious tripartite relationship evaporates when there is a conflict of interest in device the policyholder from the insurance company. Now, they still want to defend the liability dispute and they want to work together to minimize it, but conflicted defendant counsel, when there is a conflict of interest, no longer gets to be part of
2:04:55that relationship. And instead, defendant counsel gets replaced by independent counsel who have kind of a modified bipartite relationship, to not only resist the merits of the liability dispute, but for independent counsel to also simultaneously protect the interests of the policyholder against the insurance company, and to do that ethically, because independent counsel, by definition, does not represent the insurance company. So we're on slide number 25. Item number two insurance company defenses. Defendant counsel does not represent the insurer, you're gonna hear that all the time, the lawyer will say, I don't have a conflict of interest, because I don't represent the insurance company. And there are some states, particularly those that follow the Enhance duties rule that say, That's right, the lawyer does not represent the insurance company because the insurance company is not a party to the lawsuit. But that is, in my opinion, flawed reasoning for the following reasons. The insurance company is the indemnify tour of the policyholder, of course, the insurance company has interests to protect in conducting the defense of the liability dispute. Why? Because they pay for it, when there's no conflict of interest, you know, they're gonna pay for it. But when there is a conflict of interest, there's still the possibility that they're going to have to pay for it. So whether given that the insurer is usually not a party, to the liabilities to the lawyer nonetheless represents the interests of the insurance company in conducting the defense. And always
2:06:47the insurance company has interest to protect thought with respect to that defense. Sometimes they'll deny it, they'll say we're angels, the only thing we want to do is to represent the interests of the policyholder that that just doesn't hold up under scrutiny, in my opinion, and particularly take a look at rule 1.7. Those extra tips, and you will find a provision in certainly the California rule. And I think the ABA rule that says that the lawyer cannot represent the interests of clients, former clients or others, which would include the Insurance insurance company that certainly has an interest in the outcome and loss of the next defense is that dependent counsel does not get involved in coverage. This is absolutely uniform in the bell shaped curve that has collapsed to align. Always say this, we don't get involved in coverage. We have been hired to conduct the defense. We don't know about we don't want to know about coverage. We're not being paid to advise anybody about coverage and impliedly but never spoken out.
2:08:02Explicitly, we're not going to analyze our conflicts of interest based upon the coverage dispute held by our two clients. And therein lies a very principal flaw of this defense. The question is not one of whether or not dependent counsel is going to advise one party or the other against the other. The question that needs to be answered here under Rule 1.7. Is does that admitted conflict of interest between the two clients disqualify the lawyer and uniform independent counsel act urges that they're relieved of the duty of resolving conflicts of interest simply because the clients have a conflict? And that logic just doesn't hold up? Whenever you represent dual clients that they have a conflict? The lawyer needs to know about it, and analyze it address whether or not that disqualifies the lawyer if it does, or it could obtain to the clients informed written consent, whereupon the lawyer can ethically move forward. But the fact that the two clients have a conflict of interest is not a fact that relieves dependent counsel from analyzing the conflict of interests. But that is the essence of this defense, which frankly, I find to be ridiculous. Next, the policyholder has the burden of bribery.
2:09:40That's what it says. And that's wrong. The possible the defendant counsel has the burden of conflict resolution. And I'm going to fix that before you get your final stuff. The policyholder has no burden of conflict resolution. So it is the lawyer that has to fix this stuff. But what they do under these circumstances is that defendant counsel on the one hand and the insurance company representative on the other will say we don't see a conflict of interest. Why don't you the policyholder, tell us what the conflict of interest is. Well, that policyholder has no such burden. And that's the end of the analysis. What could occur is that once you get to litigation, the policyholders and plaintiff will have an obligation to satisfy each of the elements have a cause of action, which could include that the lawyer had a disqualifying conflict of interest. But we're not in litigation. This is the conflict resolution stage. And the duty to analyze and find and resolve conflict never falls upon the policyholder at this stage. The next defense is one that I've mentioned before, and that is a deadlock on rule 1.7 violation may require litigation. And this is one that always comes up no matter what communication is occurred between the policyholder dependent counsel and the insurance company rely on dependent counsel and the insurance company will say we don't see a conflict. So we're just going to keep going along. Happy as a clam here. All right, we're on slide 25.
2:11:35Item number four. One of the defenses that the enemy will approach is to say that the policyholder has the burden of conflict resolution. That, of course is ridiculous at this stage. It is they who have the is the lawyer who has the duty of conflict resolution. But if you're in litigation, the policyholder will have an obligation to prove each element of a cause of action, which could include that there was a disqualifying conflict of interest. But at this stage, the policyholder should simply say, No, I don't have the burden to analyze conflicts the lawyer does. And that would be the end of that defense. Number five, there is frequently a deadlock with respect to whether there's a violation of rule 1.7. And the enemy can do that simply by saying we don't see the conflict what what you see is the conflict. Whereupon the only way to resolve that is to go to litigation. And this presentation focuses only upon upon resolving conflict short of litigation, but going to litigation is long, hard, complex, expensive, and should be avoided. Um, the next defense number six is that is a violation of the cooperation clause for the policyholder to insist upon ethical counsel. There are literally hundreds of cases in California that mentioned the cooperation clause, there is a cooperation clause in virtually all liability policies. And it says in effect that the policyholder must show up and testify truthfully, in discovery and at trial. In my opinion, that is the extent of the cooperation obligation that the
2:13:34policyholder has. So in my opinion, it is not a violation of the cooperation clause for the policyholder to insist upon ethical counsel, which is at the very root of the Rules of Professional Conduct and that humans decision. Next, insurers steadfastly handed lawyers steadfastly insist that Civil Code section 2016 California limits to conflicts of interest that disqualify a dependent counsel, and limited only to those instances where dependent counsel can influence the outcome of a coverage dispute. There are no cases in California or elsewhere that I know of that endorse that position, nor does proper statutory interpretation permit that interpretation from the statute, but there are no cases on and the final defense that the insurance industry puts up is a more complex one. There is case law, which says that the defendant counsel has a duty when there is a coverage contest to favor the policyholder over the insurance company with respect to the content The coverage issues. And there's a piece of me that likes that body of law. But on the face of it, if dependent counsel is to favor one client over the other, then the dependent counsel cannot do that without the informed written consent of both clients. And I have never seen a dependent counsel try to obtain informed written consent from both clients under those circumstances. But absent that informed consent, the duty to favor the policyholder is the duty that dependent counsel cannot discharge when they are ignorant of what the bases are in the reservation of rights on
2:15:48which the insurance company would seek to deny coverage. So the duty to favor the policyholder is one that cannot be discharged by the insurance company, unless the defendant counsel is up to speed with respect to what those issues are. The final slide is this. I hope you can tell that this subject matter interests me greatly. And I hope that you have found this presentation to be helpful. If you stumbled somewhere along the line, I would love to hear from that if you decide to do this at all. And you get confused. Here's my contact information. And I won't charge it to listen to your story and and try to help you out whether I can help you out or not. I would love to hear any feedback. You've got to tell me that this works. That didn't work. Because perhaps the the approach of the documents I have prepared can be greatly improved upon with your feedback. And with that, I conclude I thank you for your attention. And I apologize for going over the two hours by
Guy M.CA
Some courses just review information. This one reveals it. Eye opening and ground breaking
Diana G.TN
Very enthusiastic and interesting speaker- an admirable advocate for the client who is up against the powerful insurance industry.
Maxine A.OH
Excellent presentation! I loved the explanation of terms and real-life industry actions of some insurance providers. My "what does this mean?" questions were answered as the presentation went forward (without assuming listeners had the same level of expertise as the Presenter himself). Bravo!!
David L.TX
I really appreciated the details of this presentation. The speaker was very knowledgeable and gave examples that I found very helpful in understanding the subject matter. This course provided me with information that I can start putting to use right away.