54min · about 9,500 wordsDownload Transcript
0:01Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's presentation. First, today's seminar is on rule 8.4 g, antidiscrimination. And I will say some jurisdictions do not have 8.4 g. So if you're looking at the screen and you're thinking, wait a second, I've pulled out my local jurisdictional rules and I don't see an 8.4 g. Well, that's because some jurisdictions have not fully adopted it, but it is in the model rules, and the jurisdictions that have not adopted it specifically go under rule 8.4 d, as in dog, which is the one that says prejudicial to the administration of justice, which they lump into anti discrimination. So if you are in a jurisdiction, if you're looking at your specific rules and don't see 8.4 g, do not worry, they will still get you under 8.4 d, as in dog. And we will talk about those differences between the two rules. A little bit about myself here today, too. My name is Kerry Sheehandhennae.
1:00I'm an assistant clinical professor of business law and ethics at the IU Kelley School of Business in Indianapolis, Indiana. I am also a conflicts and ethics attorney with Scopolitis, Garvin, Light, Hansen and Fury in Indianapolis, Indiana, where I practice internal attorney ethics, advise the attorneys and the firm on ethical compliance and other compliance issues and conflicts issues and anything that can arise in that arena. So you can say I practice ethics every day, all day in both my teaching and professional capacity. And 8.4 g antidiscrimination is one of the new ones that is emerging and getting a little more visibility than it used to, used to not have in the past. So we're just going to talk, though, a little bit about first just professionalism and civility, because that's what 8.4 g really goes to. It is basically saying that we need to be professional and civil during the practice of law.
1:58Now, this shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone. We all know we need to treat each other with respect. But if you think about lawyers conduct, do we actually do that? Do you actually treat your opposing counsel with respect? Do you actually treat the court with respect and your clients with respect? And then on top of that, too, can you say that the practice of law and your practice of law is 100% free of bias? Most of us would initially say, yes, I'm not biased. I don't stereotype. I'm civil, I'm professional. But there is a thing called unconscious bias, and unconscious bias are those things that we don't realize we're doing or we don't realize that we hold a belief that can have a stereotypical connotation or a bias connotation, and then we act upon that, you know, what belief we have, thinking it's completely normal and there's nothing wrong with it, when in reality it is treating someone differently, it is treating them with disrespect or it is discriminating against them. And that's what the unconscious bias does. And if you have a brain, you have a bias.
3:07And that is a quote from Doctor Jennifer Eberhardt at Stanford University, excuse me, Princeton University, where she did a study on the brain. And there's a part of our brain, which we'll get to in a few slides here, too, that we hold bias. It's not intentional. It's a part of all of our brains. So if we have a brain, we have a bias. And if we have a brain, if you take that over into legal context, we are going to have unconscious bias within the profession, sometimes not act professional and not act civil. And as I was saying and on the screen in front of you, what is professionalism in general, is the competence and skill expected to act as a professional or to be a professional. Civility is exhibiting good behavior for the good of the community or a professional code of decency that characterizes a civil society. That's the key thing. A civilized society. If you think about the wild, wild west or the crazy area of lawyers, sometimes you're like, oh, my goodness, they're not civil. We need to have a civilized society.
4:11It doesn't mean agreeing with everyone all the time. It doesn't mean not agreeing or the absence of criticism. And it doesn't mean you have to like everyone in the legal profession. I guarantee you don't like half your clients. I also guarantee you don't like half your opposing counsel or maybe even half your partners or people in your firm. But that's okay, so long as you can treat them with professionalism and civility, then it's okay. I can say the meanest thing, but say it very politely with good manners, and it doesn't make me civil, and it doesn't make me professional. We have to find that balance, and it is a very fine line to walk. And you may think, well, I'm always professional. I'm always civil. But I guarantee you there's a time when you haven't been.
4:59And if we really dig into the rules of professional conduct, the preamble particularly, it tells us that the rules apply to our professional and our personal lives. So this civility concept, this professionalism concept also applies in a, or in your personal lives. So we need to think about those things as well. Some civility initiatives that have gone through the legal profession. Civil contact is a condition of lawyer licensing. It's. It is kind of, you know, we are that self governing profession. Rule 8.3 tells us that, that we have a duty to report the misconduct of our fellow attorneys, of our fellow lawyers when we know they violated the rules of professional conduct. So we really need to look at, you know, what they're doing, what we're doing, our own conduct as well, cause of that self reporting profession. 8.3 is the rule that goes into that, and we need to take that into consideration.
5:59We also see the civility come through because most bar associations and most jurisdictions have what are called fitness and character examinations. This is when you went and applied for the bar exam. They maybe have made you sat through a fitness and character examination. This is where, as in Indiana here, you got assigned to a local lawyer. When you submitted your bar application to become a lawyer, you had to set up a meeting with that local lawyer in town. The local lawyer met with you, had your bar application, could ask you all types of questions and scenarios, or they could just take you to coffee, drink, or lunch and call it a day. It was completely up to the local lawyer. But what they were doing was assessing your character, seeing if you are who you say you are, trying to test if you're going to be a good person and a good lawyer and uphold the standards of the legal profession. Now, again, some lawyers took this responsibility when they were tasked with doing these interviews very seriously. Other lawyers just said, hey, let's go out for a drink, and didn't even talk about character and fitness or civility or professionalism. But the standard is there, and there is different things like that that come into play in our profession to where we like professionalism and civility.
7:12So it does make it a qualification or requirement of our law licensure, meaning, you know, we need this in order to become a lawyer, you had to pass that character and fitness exam. You had to pass that section of the application process to become a lawyer. And then they carry it through in our oath of attorneys. Now, here in Indiana, when we raised our right hand and we set our oath, you know, we sort of uphold the constitution, represent our clients zealously, you know, defend and protect all of those different things in the very middle of the oath. It's actually administrative rule 22. In the very middle of it, it says, between upholding the constitution and zealously defending the client almost, that we will abstain from offensive personality. Now, if you remember something I said a little earlier in the seminar, I said the rules of professional conduct applied to us personally and professionally, and so does that oath.
8:10So we raised our right hand and swore that we would abstain from offensive personality in our personal and professional lives, 24 hours a day, seven days a week. That is crazy, because we all know that does not happen with most lawyers. So we need to look back to and look at the different things that we swore to and the rules and where we are really breaking down, too, because this idea of professionalism, civility, comes through in a lot of the things in which we do as lawyers and the requirements that we're sought to uphold. Lawyers, too. We have to remember we are public servants. We have to be civil and professional in our court dealings. We have to resolve issues maintaining courtesy and professionalism. It is a profession. We should not take it personally. And where this really comes down and into play is between opposing counsel.
9:06It's not always a lawyer being unprofessional or civil to his client or his law partners or her law partners, but it's to the opposing counsel. And judges are really getting fed up with it. In 2002, there's what is called the Sedona conference, which is a conference that was launched as a think tank to confront some of the most challenging issues facing the legal system. One of those challenging issues facing the legal system was the animosity and the uncooperative behavior between opposing counsels, particularly during the phase of discovery in cases. And so a lot of times now, judges who've signed on to this proclamation, it's a Sedona conference proclamation, require attorneys, when they go into their courtroom, to take oaths that they will try to resolve stuff face to face in consultations and resolve disputes prior to airing their grievances with the court. Courts are really putting it back on the lawyers to be civil and not come tattling or not come trying to fight it out in court, wasting court recesses, wasting client money and time, wasting all of these things. And so we've got to really think about that and how that affects us, because how many of you have been in the throes of a deposition or in the throes of discovery, and you just want to wrangle the opposing counsel's throat? Now, you may be laughing, you may be chuckling, you may be thinking, oh, my gosh, that is so me. And it's all happened to us at one point, because when opposing counsel starts objecting, not turning
10:48over documents, not doing XYZ, we get upset. We get so emotional, we get so inflamed and inspired by it, and we just want to do something. But we've got to step back and realize that we need to be professional. We need to act with civility, and we need to try to resolve it in a cooperative manner. It doesn't mean don't zealously advocate. It doesn't mean don't do what's best for your clients. It doesn't mean give in to the other side. It just means be professional. Remember, this is a business decision, not personal to you, and you've got to work through those issues. Another example, too, of civility and professionalism through the legal system itself. In 2005, the Illinois Supreme Court established the Commission of Professionalism under Supreme Court Rule 799 C. This is known as to civility. It promotes the culture of civility and inclusion of Illinois lawyers and judges, embodying the ideals of the legal profession and how we should have a democratic, basically civil society. Illinois has also taken this professionalism and intertwined it into its law schools. Getting law students at very young ages and having them take oaths, having them realize those different things and having them know that things are good professionalism codes and the american bar also really intertwine those different things there. Now, if we do act uncivil, can incivility equal professional discipline?
12:20The answer to that is yes. First, we have that rule, which almost every jurisdiction has, that 8.4 d. If a professional misconduct for. It is professional misconduct for a lawyer to engage in conduct that is prejudicial to the administration of justice. This is the one that every jurisdiction has. And it kind of goes hand in hand with 8.4 g. G, as in girl. If the jurisdiction has that, too. This one I call the kitchen sink rule 8.4 d, and I call it the kitchen sink rule, is because prejudicial to the administration of justice is so broad, how do you really define it? How do you really get into what is prejudicial to the administration of justice and what is not prejudicial to the administration of justice? What does that look like?
13:10And so when you think about those different things, it's really hard. And so anything that could be uncivil behavior, unprofessionalism, could be prejudicial to the administration of justice. It doesn't have to mean hiding evidence or yelling at opposing counsel. It can be discrimination. It can be bias. It can be lying. It can be anything, anything at all that affects the process of law and the administration of justice. Another one that we see is that 8.4 g, if your jurisdiction has it, probably going to be similar to the rules set in front of you. Now, the one difference that a lot of jurisdictions who have adopted this rule do is they change that wording that's highlighted in red on your screen.
13:54They either add more protected classes or they take protected classes away, but they change that red font that's on your screen to different protected classes. So 8.4 g says that an attorney shall not, skipped ahead a little too far, shall not engage in conduct that the lawyer knows or reasonably should know is harassment or discrimination on the basis of sex, race, religion, national origin, ethnicity, disability, age, sexual orientation, gender identity, marital status, or socioeconomic status in the conduct related to the practice of law. So let's kind of break this down, because this is one of those rules that's unique at first. It's unique because it only pertains to when we're practicing law. And you can see that in that first line, a lawyer shall not engage in conduct. The lawyer knows it's harassment while practicing law, basically.
14:50And so it is limited to that area. Now, that's one of the only rules that is limited to that area. The second thing that's unique about this rule, too, is that it is so many protected classes and so many things that go into it and that vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. Some jurisdictions don't include, say, marital status, socioeconomic status. Others do. It just depends on where you're at. But all can be incorporated or included under d. 8.4 d, as in dog, prejudicial to the administration of justice. So you don't just get away with it thinking, oh, my, 8.4 g didn't include gender identity, so now I can discriminate against them.
15:33You still get 8.4 d out there, and so you're not going to get away just because it wasn't specifically stated necessarily. So with this, it is kind of interesting, and it has to be related to the practice of law. And so what is the practice of law? This doesn't apply in our personal lives, just our professional. So what does the practice of law include? And the rule in the comments have given some guidance on that, which we'll get to in just a second. But it can include things such as, you know, after work events, cocktails, managing a law office, talking with the client, litigating a case in court.
16:09Anything of those natures really can be the practice of law. We can see here, too, that the classifications or the protected classes under 8.4 g are way broader than title vii as well, which is way different, way broader. So you can see that the law profession, legal profession, is really trying to combat discrimination and bias and really trying to hone those things up in that area. It can include anything from discrimination, verbal conduct that manifests in bias, harassment, that aggressive, intimidating behavior. It can be sexual harassment, too. Anything that it can be included in, it can be within this definition. Getting to that, what does the practice of law mean? Comment four tells us it means interacting with witnesses, coworkers, court personnel, lawyers, and others engaged in the practice of law, operating or managing a law firm or law practice, participating in bar association or business or social activities in connection with the practice of law.
17:11It can mean basically anything that touches and concerns the legal practice. So while it is limited, it doesn't apply to us in our personal lives. It is also very broad when it comes to what does the practice of law mean? And that phrase, practice of law, is kind of like prejudicial to the administration of justice. A little hard to define. Could mean almost anything, depending on how you phrase it or how you talk about it or if you can get it within that definition. So something to really be aware of there regarding that anti bias, anti discrimination. Now, it was actually John Gleason, the then chair of the ABA center of Professional Responsibility when this rule was adopted by the model rules in 2018, said that, you know, he thinks 8.4 g is going to be dead in the water. There was a lot of opposition to adopting this rule. So let's go back and kind of look at the rule. Why do you think there was a lot of opposition adopting this rule? Well, one, a lot of attorneys thought and infringed upon their freedom of speech, meaning you're now telling me what I can and cannot talk about, what I can and cannot do. And so the bar association and the jurisdictions heard that, and that's why they only parsed it down to related to the practice of law, meaning those areas in which, you know, we were practicing law. So then that's where they put in that comment for definition of what it means.
18:37So that was kind of their fix for, you know, the argument that it infringes upon our freedom of speech. But again, still, jurisdictions didn't like it. Texas didn't like it. Connecticut didn't like it. A lot of people really came out and spoke about how this was too far, that the rules and profession were going too far in governing lawyers behavior, but the majority have adopted it in some version, and the model rules have it on their books now. Since 2018, I will say Indiana has had it on its books pre 2018. It had a version of it even before the model rules formally adopted it themselves. And so some jurisdictions have had it for years, others have had it more recently. But it's really getting more attention, especially within the wake of what's going on in society since the pandemic in 2020 and just everything like that and just how society progresses. This rule is becoming more and more important and more and more talked about in a lot of ways.
19:39And so you may think to yourself, well, I don't have to worry about this rule. I don't have a bias. I don't discriminate. But if, do you remember I said, if you have a brain, you have a bias? Because there's part of our brain that holds that bias feature and that we all hold stereotypes. Unconscious ones, mainly, can be intentional and conscious. But normally the unconscious bias when it comes to it, and a lot of times, too, we don't realize it. One of the one things we don't realize is known as the other race effect. This is one where if I put pictures up in front of you, pictures of different people, well, actually, let's just start with a picture of one person. Say I put my face in front of you, a caucasian female with brown hair, and then I was talking about myself, and then my picture went off the screen.
20:27Then all of a sudden, a picture of eight faces come up, all caucasian women with brown hair. The other race effect tells us that the people who are most like me would be able to pick me out in that eight person lineup. The people who are less like me in characteristics, features, would not be able to. That's the other race effect. This really comes into play, say, with lineups in criminal cases, you know, picking out the false people. If someone says, well, it's an african american man, well, can you pick him up a lineup? I have heard people say, no, they all look the same. That is the most discriminatory thing ever. But it's part of this other race effect, too, and potentially an unconscious bias or an unconscious thing that that person holds. And it's hard for them to distinguish characteristics of other races. Now, you may think, why is that?
21:16Why does our brain do that? And it's because we have a part of our brain called the FFA, the fusifasiform. It sits in the lower back part, and it lights up like in, releases neurons, releases those endorphins, when we see things similar to us, it says, this is good, this is happy, this is my childhood, this is what I'm used to seeing. This is my familiar. And when we see something unfamiliar, the other races, the other things that we're not used to seeing, you know, growing up, it doesn't light up. We don't get that warm, fuzzy feeling. We don't get that, you know, hey, this is awesome. Great thing, you know, this is a good thing feeling in our. In us. And so it's our brain telling us now, this isn't technically a bad part of the brain. It is when we use it in the way I just described it. But it's not a bad part of the brain in a context. It's also the same part of the brain that tells us, hey, lion, different scary, run for the hills, you know, the fight or flight response, it gives us that. It gives us that momentum to either flee or stay. It tells us what's good and what's bad.
22:28Now, the part of that is it takes it to this other race effect, or it takes it into an unconscious discrimination. And if we don't recognize that and work against it and try to retrain our brain out of those patterns, then that's when we have bias come about. And like I said, that fusive face area, that FFA fusifasiform of the brain is in that lower back quadrant. There's two, one on each side, and they're going to light up with those neurons. They're going to light up. When things are good, it's going to tell us, this is like me, this is good. This is what I want. This is, you know, what I've known. This is everything.
23:05And it's going to help us distinguish that familiar from the unfamiliar, but it's also going to give us that us versus them effect does not stop at the physical face identification, but can expand to other areas, other beliefs, other feelings, other social groups and other people. Us versus them, discrimination versus not, stereotype versus non stereotype, unconscious bias versus none, us versus them. And so we've got to know this is there. We've got to stay in tune with it and know that it's okay. It's okay. If I would have said, do you hold a bias? Every single one of your hands should have gone up. You would have said, yes, I do, because I have a brain. If you have a brain, you have a bias.
23:50That's what we. Dean and Doctor Jennifer Everhart, in a lecture she gave to a bunch of psychologists professors stated that normally that unconscious, that Ffa part of our brain is an unconscious bias, an unintentional stereotype is just something we're used to seeing, something more familiar to us. It's not intentional, but it can lead into intentional. Intentional is the mean part of our brain saying, oh, I don't like you because of XYZ. It's not thinking things like, oh, you're a male, maybe you're a policeman. Simple as that. Oh, you're, you say you work a law firm, are you the receptionist and the person's a female.
24:29That is an unconscious bias stereotype because maybe you're used to seeing a female in those positions or a male in those positions. And so you've got to really work against those things as well. And so where can an attorney violate the rule of 8.4 g in the practice of law? Let's look at some of those different areas. It can happen in recruiting of staff and attorneys, screening and hiring, work promotion, allocation discharging, interacting with coworkers, attending social events, correspondence with opposing counsel, third parties, employees, company policies and manuals, interacting with the judiciary, other things, work advice, decisions, choices. It can happen anywhere in the practice of law. Today we are going to go through some more of the ones that we don't think about as the practice of law, through the recruiting, screening, hiring of employees and staff, and even to a job posting. And we're going to look at some job postings. They're not all law or legal related, but we're going to see some phraseology that some people have used in their job postings and then we're going to see why maybe that was not the best choice for them.
25:35So let's start with some of those job postings. The first one here, this is for a full service web design company specializing in industrial and commercial clientele. So they want someone to be a content writer, SEO specialist and join the dynamic team. Now, they note that filling of this position, it has responsibility as a receptionist. So female candidates are preferred. That's that bias, that stereotype coming through. Now, they may think, well, it's always had a female there, we want a female there, we want that there. And why do you think a lot of businesses, companies, and even law firms may want a female as a receptionist? Think about your receptionist.
26:12Think about who sits at your front desk. Have you ever had a non female or a non identifying female in that role? Think about it. Some of you may say, oh, no, we haven't. Some of you say, well, ours has been there 30 40 years and so. But is it a female? If you think about those things now, why do most companies want receptionists to be females? There are some reasons, and they've actually tried to justify this bias, the stereotype, with these reasons. They say that, you know, when someone calls, if they call and, you know, the person on the receptionist picks up the phone, they say, hi, welcome to you know so and so. How can I direct your call, or what can I do for you today? Nice, sweet voice, caring, reminds you of your grandmother, reminds you of your mother. Warm, embracing, makes you love the company. Now think of that. Same caller called and someone answered the phone in a lower, deep, gruff voice and was not, didn't give the other person that calling, that warm, fuzzy, oh, this is family feeling. Some companies try to justify it in that context, that, you know, females are just more caring and have that feeling in their voice and better for clientele and personnel. But again, it's hard. And so we cannot do that, though. We cannot just do it based on customer preference. We cannot discriminate, we cannot do those things. So this would be one, which would be a flag and a bias stereotype. Coming through. Here is another one. This is for a documentation invoice processor.
27:42Must be female, not above 29 years old, single. So we have gender, we have age, and for some reason we have marital status in there, which is 8.4 g violation. We cannot discriminate on marital status. But again, very odd document processor. What did these qualifications have to do with that job? That's, you know, to be seen. Accounting assistant. Again, female graduate, 21 to 28, single age gender, and we have marital status, which 8.4 g talks about. Again, these aren't necessarily for a legal job, but again, you can see where it comes through. Some of you may have accounting assistance in your firm, some of you may not.
28:24Just depends on the size of your firm. Executive driver, must be male, ages 30 to 35. Again, we have some age and gender. This is one to kind of look out for two. Customer service fun young team. Dynamic young entrepreneurial culture based in Surrey Hills. Learn and growth company age fun young team. I think I'm young. You may think I'm old. You may be like, oh, my gosh, she's so young. I think I'm fun. You may think she studies ethics and does ethics for a living. She's boring. Do we really want to put that in a job advertisement? We can get into some trouble with bias and stereotype when it comes to those areas. Here's another one, too. It's nice to be one of the good guys. Gender pronouns. We really need to think about those things when we are posting something. Working and training HR hiring managers, the one who are tasked with writing these descriptions for your firm, that's what you really need to look at.
29:19Gender pronouns, gender neutral, any unconscious or stereotypical biases that can be coming through. Here's for a director of operations. We are particularly interested in receiving applications from candidates who identify as female. I understand what they're trying to go here, probably to promote diversity, that diverse candidate, but it's still a stereotype or a gender bias coming through that, you know, they want identify as female or they want females in the role. So again, we really have to look what we're posting and where we're posting it. Store requires no Indians or Asians, please. Must speak English.
29:56Ethnicity, race, background, those things we do not. Now, speaking English can be discriminatory if it does not relate to the job qualifications. But if you need to be able to speak English to communicate or to do the job effectively, or to do the job at all, then you could have that potentially as a qualification. But if you're just putting it on there, say, if I wanted someone to move bricks from here to here, and they could understand that concept without being fluent in English, then me saying fluent in English would have no bearing on the job itself or the qualifications needed to complete the job. And so if I put that on there, then obviously it could lead to a unintentional stereotype or unintentional bias discrimination, trying to weed out a certain group of people just because I wanted to, but I did it in a non or a neutral way, kind of.
30:47So you've got to watch those things as well. Here's one. The mission covenant church, Sister Ann's kindergarten and nursery. They want an english teacher, part time loving, kind hearted teaching experience. And caucasian race can never be a qualification for a job. Never. Customer preference is not enough to make it a qualification for a job. Maybe their student body is primarily caucasian. That doesn't matter. It can never be a qualification for a job. So we need to get that through our minds. We need to make sure it does not come through in our advertisements and in our job postings. This one I find is fun. Now, I really want you as lawyers to kind of look at this one and kind of dissect it and think to yourself, is there any stereotype here? Any bias that would trigger that 8.4 g those classifications, prejudicial, maybe to the administration of justice or just title seven in general? Like, do we see anything triggered or wrong with this because this one's kind of funny and I'm going to read it to you.
31:47Please do not apply if you oversleep. Have no alarm clock, have no car, have court, often, have no babysitter every day. Have to give friends rides to work later than we start work experience flat tires every week. Have to hold on to your cell phone all day or become an expert at your job with no need to learn or take advice after the first day. Must be able to talk and work at the same time. Must be able to remember to come back to work after lunch. Should not expect to receive purple ribbons or gold stars for showing up to work on time. Now, I find this funny. I find that they've probably been burned several times and they are, you know, catering to hopefully finding a good, reliable employee.
32:30But is there a discrimination here? Is there a bias here? Is there a stereotype you see here? And if you start to dissect it, maybe if you want to go kind of deep diving in the phrase have no babysitter every day. Could be a family stereotype, single mom stereotype or single dad stereotype. You could start maybe see that, or an economic stereotype, not having a car so you could really delve into it and maybe get to those points, but maybe not. And so it could kind of be one of those borderline things. How many of you are going to use this later on? I don't know, but it is kind of something interesting to see. The other area where we see discrimination and bias in any job, particularly even in the legal profession, is through the resume and application process. Now this is where we see it in this area.
33:22Because if you think about it in the resume application process, what is the first thing you see when you get someone's resume? You see their name. When you see someone's name, your mind already starts to form an image of what that person looks like. They've identified them by their gender or alleged gender. They've identified what they're wearing with a picture of a person based on the name alone. Now, say that person gets an interview, walks into the door, and the person interviewing says back, says, oh, you're not what I expected. Your stereotype, your whole image of this person just got burned. And if you only wanted to hire this person based on that image, now you're like, eh, you're not as great as I thought you were, or, oh, maybe you're even better than I thought you were. I don't know. But again, discrimination, bias, stereotypes start with the resume, too. When those applications come in and just reading the name of the person, and this is something, an exercise you can actually do in your firms or to help train people, is if you have a list of names, resumes on a name, then a list of jobs. Ask your employees or whoever you're training to pair them up. You may think, but we need more qualifications.
34:37Just say they're all qualified for every single one of these jobs. They only can put them in a job based on their name. This is what we do with resumes and don't even realize it. We look at the person's name, most people immediately stereotype them, get the image in their head, have already said, eh, they don't sound like a CEO, eh, they don't sound like that. Or, oh, I knew someone by that name. She was a receptionist. She'd be a great one, just like the other person I know. You are going to start to see trends. A lot of the trends I start to see when I do this in a, like a hands on workshop or an in class type of activity.
35:11The Linda Allen, the let's see, Emily Johnson tend to be more stay at home parents receptionist. And when I pull people to say, why did you put them in those roles? Sometimes Betty Jones, too, they say, well, they're old, traditional female names. And that's what, you know, we're used to seeing. Or I had a teacher by that name, or my mom's that name, or you start to see those things. Your Fortune 500 CEO is going to be someone like Brad Williams. Sometimes I put on here, John Smith is on here. You're going to see him come through in that, too. And so you're going to see more traditional names, going to traditional roles that we're used to seeping that is that FFA working, that stereotype, that unconscious bias coming through. And we do it in the legal profession, too.
35:57We see a name, we think, oh, I had a teacher by that name, or, you know, oh, that's a weird name for a lawyer. What's that going to look like? And so we start to put them in those roles. So if we go back to that brain, we are trained to think of certain things. We're trained by pictures on media, we're trained by pictures on social media and tv and over time and learning and books, that these are the traditional roles, females receptionist, female teachers, male cops, male doctors, male lawyers, different things like that, females more the homemaker. And we've been seeing these images since childhood, some of us. And so retraining that FFA part of our brain can be very hard and we not even realize it.
36:37We can also see discrimination and the bias unconscious conscious come through through screening and hiring tests. I remember even as an associate, I was straight out of law school, this was early, two thousands. And a law firm to hire me as a law clerk or first year associate wanted me to take an aptitude test. They wanted me to take a typing test, writing test, and do like a little problem. And that was kind of interesting. It's only one law firm that I've ever had to ever do that with. But some people use these as way to weed out applicants. And intelligence and aptitude tests can be biased towards one culture. So if you have someone of a different race or background, they may not pass it as well. And it can also be biased towards males or females, requiring things that aren't really necessary for the performance of the job. So you've got to be very careful in those screening and hiring processes as well.
37:30We can also see it through promotion. And one exercise to really test if you have it in promotion within your company or firm or within yourself, is this exercise here in front of of you. And this is something you can do with your firm or take back and educate and train as well. So here I'm going to task you. We're not going to necessarily do it today. You can, if you want to, write down the top five to ten people that you trust cannot be family members. Avoid listing family members only. List friends, classmates, and coworkers. Some of you may not even get to five. I can get to maybe two or three. Because this inner circle of trust are the people that you would share your diary secrets with that you would let into your bedroom the most intimate details of your life. These are the people you would share it with. Only naming friends, classmates, and coworkers.
38:16Once you get that list together, maybe two, three, maybe the five to ten. If you have that many, then next to those people, list out their gender, race, age, sexual orientation, education, disability, and other characteristics. Once you list those out, next to the people you trust with your diary secrets, your ride or die, you're sitting in jail by each other type of people, see if their characteristics are the same as yours. Are they caucasian? Are they african american like you? Are they hispanic like you? Are they female? Are they male? Or are they some other gender like you? Most likely yes. Usually 80% to 90% of the time, the answer to that question is yes, they are. Now take this into business.
39:01Those lists of people are your friends, classmates, coworkers. Sometimes you're a manager of them. Sometimes you help aid in their promotion, give them referrals. You want to foster those relationships because they're your ride or die. They're your tight knit group. They know everything about you. So you're going to put them up for promotion. You're going to want them to succeed. You're going to push them forward over everyone else. Even those candidates may be as deserving, if not more deserving, but they're not your ride or die. And so then we start to see bias and stereotype here, because again, those ride or die people usually have the same characteristics as you have. And if you're in the majority and not the minority, or even vice versa, you can have discrimination.
39:45Now to take that exercise even further, list out your middle ring, the ones you'd invite over for a picnic at your house. Keep them outside, little arms distance, a little like, oh, I'll tell you a little bit of stuff, but you're very, you're guarded with what you tell them. List out their characteristics. Maybe your pool gets a little bigger. Go to the third wing, the acquaintance wing, the one where we're like, hey, how you doing? How's so and so? Great. See you later. That rings a little bigger when you do that exercise, too. But the thing is that inner circle, that trust zone in business and in life, those are the ones we want to promote. Those are the ones we want to propel forward, and those are the ones that we want to make sure succeed. And that is where you can get your discrimination in your bias through those exercises.
40:31Work allocation plays hand in hand with that, just like in promotion, we want to make sure we're not going to give our trust circle the worst projects or anything. And so we've got, we can see it through there as well. In addition, discharge, when, you know, you fire people, sometimes it's your system, policies, women, those different things are less likely to discharge individuals that we have that affinity with or that we have that trust circle. And also, too, if it's last in, first out, if you have a history of discrimination in the firm or history of, you know, a certain race or gender, and then you start firing people, let them go. If the last people in are the minority, then you can see it through there as well.
41:14So you've got to be careful in that discharge. We can also see bias, discrimination and unprofessionalism through communications with clients, especially difficult clients. And so we've got to maintain civility and decency in what we do. If people are making unreasonable demands know when to say, enough is enough. And this is what I mean by that. We can fire clients. Clients can fire us. But going back to that first one, we can fire clients. We do not have to go down to meet the incivility of a client or to act like that client. You know, we can say, enough's enough and be done with it. And so we've got to think of those things as well. In dealing with uncivil opposing counsel here, again, we just have to watch for, you know, what we're doing, know what we're up against, some helpful hints in dealing with uncivil opposing counselor lawyers, if they get to you, then they win. We need to maintain our own composure, our own civility. We're only responsible for ourselves.
42:20We're not responsible for other people. We cannot control how other people act towards us. And so we've got to consider that, too. We need to smile, be better, or ignore them. Just need to not let it faze us. Not engage. Fight up. Don't fight down. Have compassion. Believe in professionalism. Believe karma comes around. Karma can be a bitch, as we all know. And so the good part about karma is if you're the person on the outside hoping karma on someone else or saying, oh, the karma is going to get them, it's a good day when you actually get to see it come back around, because not a lot of us get to see that. But believe in that professionalism, karma.
42:58Believe in those things and believe that you doing the right thing. If you control your behaviors and your actions, that's all you can ask for. Keep communication open. Talk to composing counsel. Face to face conversations can go such a long way. I know a lot of people who, in email, they are the worst human beings ever. But when you get them face to face, they're the nicest people, and that's one they may not like. Face to face confrontation. They feel empowered behind a screen or their tone. And how they write just comes across in a rude and insolent manner. And so there's still value in picking up the phone. There's still value in those face to face conversations.
43:38You also need to outsmart. See ahead. Prepare, prepare, prepare. All communications need to be placed in writing, because if you need to prove something, you need a writing or something of that nature. Kill people with kindness. Play the waiting game. No one. Follow the rules. Check your own attitude. Routinely stand up to bullying in a professional manner. Do not stoop to the level of a bully. Do not stoop down. Always play up. When it comes to certain things, proving incivility. If a lawyer does not provide a request to document, document their contact, say, I've called you five times, you've not returned my calls. You know, now I'm taking these steps.
44:18These are things that you've tried to resolve things amicably, especially with opposing counsel, before you seek court intervention. If they're doing tactics such as late night faxes, different things, obviously document it down in an email. I love it when I have a conversation with someone and then I send them confirming email and they get mad. I send them a confirming email about our verbal conversation. It's like, you didn't want it in writing. Why not? Are you going to lie about it later? If something's inaccurate, then change it or email me back saying, no, that's not what we talked about.
44:49But it is kind of amazing how many lawyers really don't like stuff in writing all the time. Now, some stuff's great in writing. Some stuff you're like, yeah, let's not put that in writing. But again, these things we really need to think about when it comes to just documentation and knowing civility and knowing how we can document stuff to, if we do have to go to court, prove to the court that happening at that point. Let's look at some examples here. We've got about 14 minutes left in our seminar here today. So let's look at some examples of just incivility and unprofessionalism. The first one is Glenn. Excuse me.
45:29Robinson engaged in sexual behavior with a current and former clients. Some areas of the sexual behavior created that hostile work environment tan about to sexual harassment. Some of the things also that Mister Robinson did was quid pro quo sex for, you know, conditioned offers of employment, different things like that. This was 8.4 d violation and g violation. Suspended for two years for the practice of law. Not professional, not civil. And triggered that 8.4 g bias rule. Robert E. Abrams represented a married couple to file a construction lawsuit against a former builder. Abrams developed a negative opinion of the judge presiding over the case. In an email to his clients, Abrams referred to the judge using derogatory slur that exhibited bias or prejudice based on sexual orientation. What he said was he thought the judge had been bullied as a kid, that he had feminine features, that he was, you know, the whiny kid. And he was telling this to his clients.
46:27The client's case was in front of this judge who their own attorney was badmouthing. Clients fired the attorney, turned him into the disciplinary board. The attorney got suspended for three years for the conduct bias conduct 2020 is when this happened. Prejudicial to the administration of justice. 8.4 djdehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe 8.4 g as in girl. We had violations there. This was one. Stacey l. Kelly claimed to be her husband's attorney, so she's putting herself into that practice of law category.
46:58When she called a telemarketer who had been trying to reach someone by her husband's name, well, on the phone with a telemarketer, she asked the representative he was gay or sweet because she thought the male representative had a feminine sounding voice. That is biased determination. Indiana's had 8.4 g or similar rule in the book, way before the model rules adopted it. Prejudicial to the administration of justice. This was one by her saying, I'm my husband's attorney. She's now practicing law. She put herself into that category. She put it in there. So that is why this is another one out of here. In indiana in 2011, lawyer mccarthy represented a title company, was involved in a dispute regarding a cloud of title of property.
47:42The agent representing the seller of that property had his secretary send Anhe an email to Mister McCarthy to arrange a meeting of all involved. So the secretary sent over an email saying, hey, can you have a meeting with, you know, my partner here? Mister McCarthy's response to that email, just requesting a time to meet, was, I know you must do your boss's bidding at his direction, but I'm here to tell you that neither you nor, you know, neither you or I am, neither you or his. And then he said, a very derogatory inward. You do not tell me what to do. You ask if you ever act like that again, it will be the last time I give any thought to your existence, and your boss will have to talk to me. Do we understand each other? The Supreme Court here said there was no use for the word, the n word used in this context. It was not a historical reference, but outright racial bias. He was suspended for 30 days without automatic reinstatement, which means he had to reapply and go through the screening process and bar application process all over again if he wanted to get his law license back. So that 30 days really turns into a year or more suspension because the bar application process is not short and not swift. And I'm sure he would have to go through several different things to get that law license back.
49:02This is another one which actually, if you google this, you just google twerking lawyer, you'll see all kinds of articles about it. This was during a mediation, a lead defense counsel for a large company shook his butt at plaintiffs counsel uttering profanity such as do you want to ask me? You have a ponytail haircut. I figured you'd wanted to ask me. This is during a deposition with the people there. The conduct in a brief was described as a lavacious gyrating of the lower flesh or fleshy extremities. Plaintiff filed sanctions. Defense counsel new defense counsel defended in a brief or response back saying, let's put this unfortunate event in our episode in our rearview mirror. Probably not the right words to use when we're talking about rear end shaking up and down. But in this case, the judge found no sanctions. He felt that the attorney had suffered enough due to the public national attention. Texas is one of the states that did not initially or has ever adopted 8.4 g as in girl. But they do have 8.044 prejudicial to the administration of justice, which this can fall under for an ethical rule violation.
50:12This is where a plaintiff's lawyer stopped a deposition to duck her head under the conference table. So she what she did is she stopped, she grabbed the table, stuck her head underneath that table. When opposing counsel asked what she was doing, she said, looking to see if there's anything between your legs misses Lionheart. The attorney that did this apologized for her conduct and stated she lost her composure from being chronically and persistently exposed to condescending behavior. 8.4 g if they had it, yes, potentially. But Connecticut again, was one of the ones that did not originally, if at all, adopt 8.4 g as in girl. But we may have an 8.4 d as in dog violation. They are prejudicial to the administration of justice.
50:54Dorothy J. Thompson son represented a husband in a divorce proceeding in 23. The wife had a friend that was african american. During the bench trial, Miss Thompson referred to him as the black man, the black guy. The person's race was irrelevant to the case. She got a public reprimand for this. We do not bring in race if it's not relevant to the case. We need to remember that same thing with any other of the protected classes. Here was another one, Vincent Kempetti representative father at a child support hearing he repeatedly disparate made disparaging references to the mother's United States citizenship and different things, which is irrelevant to the hearing. Again, again. Another public reprimand in Indiana in 2009.
51:36You can see these throughout various jurisdictions and states. Similar conduct using phrases, phraseology, bringing in religion, bringing in ethnicity, bringing in national origin, bringing in race. You're going to get in trouble ten out of ten times for this type of conduct, you need to leave it out. It is not professional, it is not civil. So how do you combat this in your law firm? Obviously, have company policies and initiatives go through those different processes we've talked about here today, through the limit, creating, excuse me, recruiting, screening, you know, different areas to training them. Use the exercises I had when it comes to the courtroom. Have policies on conduct and what's good and what's bad. Have partners double check associates.
52:18Have partners, double check. Partners have, like, more than one attorney on things to make sure that bias and stereotypes stays out of the different areas of practicing law and what you're doing. So we need to have those different policies and initiatives put through. We need to stay aware and accept that if we have a brain, we have a bias, which means all of your employees and all of your lawyers have biases. We need to develop awareness, we need to slow down in our work. We are not, should not be on 24/7 we're not meant to work that much. We need to turn off, we need to slow down, and we need to check our own biases and attitudes out the door and not lower ourselves to the level of others. We need to remove bias from decision making, speak up who we notice in the workplace, and just be accountable for ourselves. We can only combat unconscious bias if we are honest about it. And does social unrest play into this? Probably. It does affect companies, what's happening out there, socially, economically, this, you know, even politically, in certain political years, it does affect it. So we've got to watch all those things as well, because it's going to come into play. If you have any questions after the seminar or anything, please reach out to the platform or myself directly.
53:34I'm happy to answer them and I hope everyone has a wonderful day.