Anna M.CA
good overview of PR in a law practice. Covered many issues that come up in a law office crisis and how to use a PR firm to assist and minimize unforeseen problems.
59min · about 10,100 wordsDownload Transcript
0:01Hi, everyone, welcome to principles of crisis communications, a, a continuing legal education workshop. My name is Nate Miller, I run a strategic and crisis communications firm headquartered in Los Angeles, with offices in San Francisco, and New York. I've been doing this work for almost 20 years, I spent a number of years working in Washington, in Europe, you know, and also three years as Israel's chief speechwriter, admission to the United Nations, and for the last 11 years, I've run our firm. And we've worked with a wide range of different types of clients and their attorneys on high profile cases, that, you know, where the media result is sometimes even more important than the result in the court of law. And, you know, through that process, I've learned quite a few tips and tricks on how to think about communications. You know, and many of these principles apply, whether you are a lawyer in a courtroom, an advocate, you know, trying to make the case for the hot button, political issue. A business owner, trying to clear your name, or, you know, share your message with a with a with a target audience, or just a person walking through the world. So today, we'll try to distill all of that down into an hour and give you some key principles that we that I think are important for you as an attorney. And here we go. So, today, we're going to talk about first we're going to cover some, you know, some pillars of strategic communications and some of the basics, then we're going to talk a little bit about crisis, you know, what, how do crises
1:54often appear? What's sort of the anatomy of a crisis, I'm gonna offer some specific tips for attorneys. And then I'll give you some background on how to think about hiring folks like myself, as a lawyer, we're going to cover some basics of doing interviews with attorneys we're going to, and then we're gonna talk about some new, you know, new pieces of our communications field, including search engine optimization, and others. And then, at the end, we'll do we'll do a quick crisis simulation. All right, let's get started. So, we're gonna have a slide three pillars of strategic communications. This for every new associate that starts at our firm, and every client, I always say I start, there's three key pillars to running an effective strategic communications program.
2:46And if you remember nothing else from this lecture, I really want you to remember these three pillars. The first is objective, you want to have an objective that's clear, specific and ideally measurable. And objective can't be we want to get good PR and objective is, what do you want your communications program to? Do? We want more sales. We want you know, this specific audience to think about us in this way. We want to position our CEO as a thought leader in this field. We do or don't want the judge to think about this in this way. There's so many different objectives. But you know, too often people don't take the time at the front end of every good strategic communications program to define what is your objective? The second key pillar is audience. Who are you trying to reach? Great communication strategists can inhabit the mind of their target audience. As attorneys, you do this as well, whether you're speaking to a client to a jury, to a judge to opposing counsel. But when you when you when you're thinking about developing good strategic communications programs, you want to understand, what does my audience believe? What are their perceptions and misperceptions? If I say this to them, how will they hear it? In great communications is the act of translating what's in your mind and putting it into the mind of the audience? They'll really understand it. And a final piece of a effective strategic communications program is message. You want your your message to be clear, concise, and compelling. We'll talk
4:36about that a little bit. We talked about the three C's. But to boil it down a good strategic communications program has a clear objective, a targeted audience, you know, in a compelling and clear message, and ideally, the message is aligning your audience with your objective. I don't know how many of you are Netflix fans, but there was a great show on TV a few years back called Stranger Things and in Stranger Things. There was this concept of the upside down the upside, and was this crazy sort of mysterious in some ways grotesque world where in the show there was in the 1980s, as science fiction, the US and the Soviet Union, were battling the upside down this other dimension, and then whatever happened to the upside down kind of reflected back into the real world that we live in. I often joke that as a communication strategist, particularly a crisis communication strategist, I have to understand how to operate in the upside down.
5:38And in this sort of shadow world, to shape the perceptions that exist in our real world today. And this is particularly true in the new communications environment that we exist in, and we'll talk more about what that environment is. But when you think about this, this world, you know, I think the key takeaway here is things are not always as they seem, and getting from A to B, in terms of communications is not always linear, you want to think about how do you use the different tools at your disposal to navigate the upside down to drive your objective in the right way. So now I want to, I want to talk a little about how the communications environment is shifting, you know, and how to think about the upside out in this shifting communications landscape. So first of all, journalism has been transformed. It's totally different from anything that I can remember when I first started in this business. There's been a tremendous gutting of journalism, sort of, particularly at the regional and local level, where, you know, in the early 2000s, you could go to any major American community, and you'd see a thriving local newspaper, or two or three. Today, those local papers have, you know, many of them have disappeared, although there's been a lot of consolidation and, you know, one or two or three major outlets, places like the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times The Washington Post, and everyone else is really like, you know, they'd have their lunch eat.
7:01There's fewer journalists, you know, in the traditional sense, you know, covering fewer stories, so it's so the ability to reach the public through journalists is harder. And every journalist has a lot more on their plate. And it's harder to get your story out into the media. But as sort of the traditional ways that we thought about reaching the public has declined as journalists, journalism has changed. There's been a tremendous rise and another way to reach directly to your audience, social media, the internet. And as a result, every single person has the ability to be their own publisher, you no longer have to rely on this mediated model where you go through other gatekeepers to reach your target audience, today, you have the power, all you need is an internet connection, and a good idea and a good message. And you can reach directly to an audience. So we'd like to say at our firm, everyone has a publisher, everyone has the ability to get your message directly to an audience. And that creates tremendous power creates great challenges for us as a society that we all we all I think many of us are aware of. But it's an opportunity for you and your clients to be a publisher and to use your to build a platform where you can reach directly to your target audience. The third major shift is disinformation. I've seen over the years. Just a frightening growth of the ability of people who are malignant, malignant, who want to spread, you know, lies or half truths, and use the the the tools that we have given that everyone has a
8:41publisher to spread disinformation. And this, this creates an imperative for attorneys to help protect our clients from the dangers of disinformation and misinformation. And you know, given the fact that everyone has a publisher. And it also creates necessity for you to think about understanding what's real and what's not. You know, we'll talk more about this later in the presentation. But you know, sometimes people I often see in our cases, you know, a journalist will approach a client and people will assume that he's just a, he or she is just a normal, regular journalist like they're used to dealing with.
9:19But sometimes these are not real journalists. They're paid advocates that are posing as journalists. Or they'll see a piece of content online that they believe reflects this, the, you know, the truth, but in fact, the the document can be altered or forged, especially with new AI tools and everything else. So it's really important to understand that disinformation is out there, that it may target you or your clients and you have to understand how to identify disinformation and develop tools to respond and approaches. The final major trend that I want to address is that advertisers have more power than ever before. It used to knew that you could take an ad in a newspaper or put something up on television or on the radio, and put that ad out. And you'd have to reach a lot of people who would maybe you weren't trying to target the same kind of way. With digital advertising, you can slice and dice in such a specific way that it gives advertisers tremendous power. The other thing is, with the decline of journalism, we've seen a huge rise in what we call native content, where, you know, almost every major paper today, or news outlet has a sort of Brand Studio where they will create content that looks just like what you would read as news. And sometimes it's not even labeled as such. So it creates an opportunity for people to spread messages good and bad. And you know, when you're thinking about your clients, you have to be aware that people can pay to specifically influence your audience in a way that they've never been able to do
10:53before. So you want to use those tools for good for your clients, and you want to understand how to safeguard them, from others abusing them. I want to mention, I want to give an example of, of how our information environment has changed dramatically and how they were often living in the upside down. So now I'm gonna go to a screenshot from my phone from this is now about the from about a year old. If you went into your iPhone a year and a half ago, and you said, Hey, Siri, who's the president of Israel? And just asked it that question. This is what would have come up. Now, of course, you know, Apple, the probably no more powerful source of information for, for millions, billions of people around the world, then going into Apple and just asking it, Siri pulls all of its information from a website called Wikipedia that many of you may be familiar with. And Wikipedia is sort of our crowd sourced encyclopedia that anybody can contribute to. The problem is that because anybody can contribute to Wikipedia, people can manipulate the system to, to shape the way that information comes to all of us. So there was a group of editors on Wikipedia that weren't so friendly to Israel, they got together and, you know, change the name of Israel to the Zionist occupation state. So if you had just gotten to Syria, anybody around the world and you asked, you know, who is the president Israel, you would get this answer that Reuven Rivlin is the president of the Zionist occupation state. So you can see here that a group of editors are actually able to
12:34shape the way the basic information architecture in which millions, billions of people are understanding the world can be shaped through this new upside down world of you know, that we're all living in. So it's very important understand this is a small thing, but Wikipedia can be manipulated, to change the way that businesses are perceived to change the way that public figures are perceived to change the way that your law firm is perceived. And that information gets pushed out not just through your iPhone, but through many, many other channels through Wikipedia, and it has a huge impact on the way that people understand and see the world around them. And the traditional model where we had gatekeepers, you know, sort of putting guardrails around how this information was great, created and distributed, those guardrails have been eliminated. So when I say we're living in the upside down, this is kind of what I mean. Okay, so I've now described the, the crazy changes in our information environment that we see. What can you do? How can you think about being successful in this new communications environment? So I want to give four tips that everyone should think about as, as communicators in this world. So the first is deploying an integrated strategy. I talked about this a little earlier, but you want to think how to work across earned media meaning, you know, going through that old mediated model going to, to, to traditional reporters, maybe bloggers, maybe influencers online, but going to that, that media, where
14:06you have to earn the coverage. So you're reaching out directly to them, owned media, meaning you're the platforms that you actually own your website, your blog, your email, the your YouTube channel, any of your social media channels, and, you know, speaking through them, and then your paid media, the advertising that you do, and you know, as I said, advertisers have more power than ever were before it. So if you want to work, you want to work across earned, owned and paid media to develop a strategy that works in sync. You don't want to have those channels working in silos or different people on your team working, you know, across each of those channels, you want to work, you want to bring them all together into one effective cohesive, integrated strategy. Second, you want to know how to tell a story. With the decline of the mediated model, it's it's more incumbent on individuals, or you know those who who worked with them to want to tell a story to tell it themselves, we can no longer just rely on journalists to tell our story for us, we have to understand what is our story, how to make it really compelling and how to make it stand out from the information overload the content overload that we all have every day. To really make to make it powerful and compelling. You want to be nimble and proactive. You want to you have to understand how to navigate in a, in a world that is rapidly changing. Every month, there's a major new development, the communications department that we live in. So you want to hire people around you. And you
15:38want to also yourself be nimble and proactive to understand what are the changes that are going on, and quickly respond so that you're not behind the curve, what worked yet, what worked last year is probably not going to work this year, there are changes constantly happening in terms of how we are, how we're thinking about this. And don't take anything on its face. You want to understand that the world like I said, the world is never necessarily as it appears, and you want to always go a level deeper to understand how the communications environment is, you know, maybe manipulated or, or, you know, skewed in some way, you know, and you want to always investigate one step further, is this reporter. What is what is his angle? What is his agenda? Is he really reporter? Is this information truly accurate? We've it's never been more important to really be dubious of everything that comes your way and really be thoughtful about understanding that some of this information not be may not be accurate, or maybe the person who's sharing it may not be totally forthright about how about the agenda that they're pursuing? Okay, I want to speak about in our, in our firm, we think about the three C's, the three C's are key to developing an effective message. An effective message is clear. It's concise, and it's compelling. Let me say that, again, it's clear, meaning that you can understand it.
17:10It's not full of jargon. That any person who it's intended for will clearly and immediately understand what the message that the information that you're trying to convey. It's concise, you want to make it as short as possible, particularly in this era of declining attention spans, you want to really shrink down that content to just as as athletic a sentence as it possibly can be. I often give my team members Ernest Hemingway to read because I think his sentence structure is great for this. It's obviously, the ethos is very different than legal writing. But when you're thinking about communicating in this immediate environment, in this information environment, think about how to make sentences as concise as possible. And compelling, you really want to make the sentence fly off, flying off the page, and how do you make it compelling. Go to the next slide, we think about the three S's storytelling statistic, and sound bites. So
18:08the way we tell stories is, is so important, since man was living in caves, without enough to eat, you know, you know, in prehistoric times, they were still telling stories to each other, they were painting on those caves to try to create an image and it shows that goes to show that we all have this innate need to tell and hear stories, through stories, we understand the world we can put ourselves in other people's shoes. And it's really important that you understand that your job as an attorney, as an advocate is also to be a storyteller. And it also is to be a storyteller when you're when your work extends outside of the courtroom for your client. So you want to think about those compelling stories are those that touch people emotionally, that help them put themselves in somebody else's shoes. Statistics, another really key tool in your tool belt, when you're trying to make a message compelling. statistics can be incredibly powerful and incredibly boring. The key to great great statistics is to to really figure out how to put them in human terms that people can understand. Instead of you know saying that this plant will reduce our carbon footprint footprint by 30% say
19:28this change in the plant will take 1000 will be the equivalent of taking 1000 cars off the road. Take those statistics and quantify them in a way that the the audience that you're trying to speak to will be able to relate to will be able to understand and will immediately move and motivate them and then soundbites. Again, this is often not an ethos within legal writing, necessarily, but creating those short sentences that somebody's going to quote that somebody will repeat it somebody will remember it You can use humor, you can use rhyme, you can use metaphor. But think about how you how you really crystallized down the core point that you wanted to make into something that's, that's really memorable, short, and that will make someone think about your message long after you've said it. Okay. That's my crash course on the sort of the key principles of effective communication. I want to talk now about a crisis. So we do a tremendous amount of crisis communications, crisis management work. Every crisis is different, but every crisis is also the same. And that there's, there's a, there's a period before the crisis, there's a period during the crisis, and there's a period after the crisis, and there's key principles you want to think about at each stage of that crisis. So before a crisis hits, there's a lot of things that you can do as attorneys to help your client prepare for a crisis. I often say that when someone's making a decision, during a crisis, it's the equivalent of driving 100 miles an
21:05hour on the freeway, weaving in and out of traffic, smoking a cigar and then being asked to make the most important decisions about your company, or your family, or your life, you know, in that environment was so much pressure, and so you know, so the more that you can prepare ahead of a crisis, the better off you're going to be, the better decisions you'll make, the better the outcome that will be for your client. So what are some things you can do before a crisis hits? First, you can train your staff. What do I mean by that? You may want to train, you may want to train your your your frontline staff and how to answer a media call. And that can be as simple as just explaining to them if a reporter calls, answer the phone, get down there and information, let the reporter know that you're not an authorized spokesperson or that someone will get back to you. So often I go to a client you go I meet with clients where they that message was never delivered to their frontline staff. And as a result, when a reporter called the message was never translated. Or even worse, somebody from the company just decided to talk to the reporter, because why not no one ever told them not to. So really important to train your staff on, you know, the most likely situations that could occur including press calls, or influencer calls or public calls, think about what the potential liabilities could be for your client and train your staff, anybody who could be involved to deal with that ahead of time. Practice makes preparation, don't just tell your staff, the policy, actually do a
22:38drill with them. In the example I just gave, you know, pretend to be a reporter calling and see how they handle it. You know, as part of an exercise with your team, so everybody else can understand, okay, that's the way I answer their phone. And in that environment. There's so many other scenarios, whether it's, you know, emergency planning. You know, depending on the nature of your client's business, there's so many different potential scenarios, but you want to really not just tell the team what to do when actually practice with them before the event so that they're they've already sort of have the muscle memory of, of responding to the crisis. Third, you want to create a crisis plan? That is a formal document that lays out who is who, what's the chain of command? Who are the decision makers during the crisis? What needs to happen to make those decisions?
23:27What are your preliminary responses depending on the crisis, if there's a fire, if there's a the shooting, if there's a HR complaint, if there is unauthorized disclosure of information, you know, depending on your client and the potential exposure, you want to think through all those different likely scenarios, and outline on paper ahead of time, what will be the appropriate response, you also want to think about who your potential spokespeople will be. And if possible, get them media trained ahead of time so that they're ready to go in the event that there's a crisis. The more that you can go into detail as to how you're going to respond ahead of time again, you're going to be so much better off once you get into that crisis. And the final thing that I can't emphasize enough is get your digital house in order. What do I mean by that? You want to have really great cybersecurity protocols, you want to train your staff on how to respond to potential hacking attempts, which is which happens to all of us every single day, unfortunately. And you want to have a really, really, really good digital security protocol to ensure that you don't come become victim to a hack or a leak or something like that. during a crisis, something that I always talk about with our clients are the principles of incoming outbound and alignment. You want to have a clear chain of command for decision making. And that revolves around getting these three principles, right. So what do I mean by incoming? You want to be able to get all
24:55incoming information up the chain of command to your decision makers in a very time The manner so that means training everyone on your team, everyone on your clients team to collect that information transmitted to whoever needs to receive it, so that they can immediately understand what's happening, whether that's something happening at a property you own, or you know, in your organization or a media enquiry or somebody posting on social media, the more that you can have as much visibility and get all that incoming information. It's extremely important because when you have that information in real time, you can make better decisions quicker and offensive the difference between success and failure, you want to have clearer, outgoing information, you know, from one person. So often, a challenge that I see with organizations during crisis is they have multiple people communicating to different constituencies, not in coordination, you want to have one decision maker deciding, here's all the information that we are going to release as an organization. And this is how the how it will be released. When you have different centers or different decision makers with an organization that are giving different messages. It's a recipe for disaster. So one spokesperson or if there's there's multiple spokespeople, one decision maker about what the message or messages will be. And then alignment. During the crisis people often are, you know, there's internal politics in organizations, there's confusion, there's,
26:25there's just incomplete information, you want to really have clear alignment all the way through the organization so that everybody knows, this is my role. This is who decides this is how they decide. And everybody understands what the plan is very important.
26:44during a crisis, you want to have the right spokesperson with the right message for the right moment. You can't always rely on the same person, it may be different people are the appropriate spokespeople for different moments for different messages. So it's important to always think about the dynamics of the situation. What is the person who speakings expertise on a subject? Do they have any any baggage on a subject that's going to make them less credible? In the eyes of the target audience? Does the person are they a good speaker? Are they a comfortable speaker, all of those things should be factored in, when you're thinking about who you put forward to deliver a message. And sometimes it's really important to have an attorney deliver the message on behalf of the client. And in other cases, you know, it's not a good idea to have the attorney because sometimes when you put an attorney forward, it really it makes it seem as if a client, you know is guilty, or you know, or is bullying someone on the other side. So you want to really think about is the attorney, the right person to speak is the client the right person to speak and who within the client should be the spokesperson, and that's a really important principle during a crisis is putting the right person forward. Another important principle that I often share the cover up is often worse than the crime, there is a natural human tendency to want to make, to not want to face the music in the moment to make a situation not as bad as it actually is to not share the all the all the truth
28:19that you can share because it's uncomfortable, or doubt, right. Like there's also that sometimes that instinct that people have. But I always tell clients when I start working with them during the crisis, the cover up is often worse than the crime and the thing that you're ultimately going to get maybe gonna get in trouble for more is trying to obfuscate and not come clean with whatever information you need to during a moment of crisis. So people don't always cover up things intentionally, either. Sometimes it's just a lack of information, or a feeling to you know, the feeling that they have to say something. And that instinct during the class crisis is often wrong. The truth is, you're better off saying nothing than saying something that's inaccurate or false or misleading. So what can you do during a crisis to ensure that you're not seen as covering up one is get your facts straight, make sure that you understand exactly what's happened, you know, within your organization, so you're not relying on inaccurate or incomplete information in formulating your communication to the public or even worse, your strategy for how you're gonna respond. Timing is everything to help get get in front of an issue whenever you can. It's important to share what you can when you can, but not before that. I know that sounds a little paradoxical. But you know, the sooner you can get out in front of an issue, the better but you don't want to go out to the public until you have all the information that you really need. ask the hard questions. Yes, man will
29:45bury you in a crisis. You want people giving you feedback as to how your target audience will perceive what you're saying how they'll see the situation. And your job often as an attorney is to ask your client those hard questions. And don't make them feel better in a moment. Exclusively, your job is also to help them avoid additional damage to their company, or organization or themselves. Don't make promises you can't keep this is another important point, never go out, you know, promising to do something with no intention to actually follow through with that, because it will almost always come back to heart to hurt you later. Okay, and I'm gonna move to after crisis. So here's some key principles to think about. Once a crisis is complete, always important to do the post mortem, examine what happens, try to learn from it, and grow. Too many clients over the years I've watched make the same mistake again and again, and again. You know, when that executive posted something on Twitter that they shouldn't have posted, that, you know, after the first time it happened, maybe that was the time to go sit them down and say, Hey, these are the guidelines that we have for social media. And you really shouldn't do that again. Or maybe you should have a different team member working with you to ensure that we're, you know, we're more in line, do the post mortem after the crisis and insist on it. And, you know, when you're an attorney, advising a client, it's even more important to tell them listen, we've got to, we've got to learn for next time. Follow
31:22through on your promises. I said, Don't make promises you can't keep. We live in an era when people are. The people are held accountable in a way that they never were before. And I see that often get them into trouble. There is an army of people online looking to understand that you follow through on that promise that you made. And so So, so keep the promises you made. And don't make promises you can't keep. After a crisis, you want to communicate what you can, but you don't want to overshare some people feel a need to be, it's not your responsibility to be that totally open book after the crisis.
32:01But it's important that you don't that you that you that you share with your target audience what you can to help them understand what happened, what you've learned, and what's going to what's what's the plan going to be moving forward. And if you made mistakes, to understand what you've learned from that process, and how you're going to not repeat the mistakes again. Okay, that's my crash course on crisis communications. Now we're going to talk a little bit about your role as attorneys working with public relations and communications professional. So, here are my four top tips for engaging PR firms and working with communications professionals. So the first is train your frontline staff. I talked about that a little bit earlier. Make sure that everybody at your law firm, your paralegals, your receptionist, your attorneys understands how to receive immediate call. And what do I mean by that they should understand that when a reporter calls, how to get all the information they need, meaning the reporters name, number, email and deadline and the outlet they write for. To get that quickly and to have a protocol in place at your firm. So that information can be sent to the partner and or to the client and or the PR firm. So often, I see that there's not a protocol in place for attorneys when it comes to media or dealing with inquiries like this. And what happens is, reporters call, someone answers the phone, they just sort of ignore it, and the client loses the opportunity to respond, and to shape the story. And that's that sounds
33:43can be catastrophic. So you want to have a protocol in place so that everybody understands on your team, what to do, if a reporter calls, you should put this protocol into your employee handbook, you should train on it once a year. And it should be something that's just part of your, your your training as a team. Timing is everything. To the extent that you can prepare ahead of a big complaint being released or settlement being announced. Or when you know, when you know ahead of time and you can prepare for something coming out you want to get ahead of it. Because whoever gets the information out to the press first is gonna be able to really shape the story. And when you're playing defense and somebody else is shaping the story instead of you, you lose a huge strategic advantage. So timing is everything. Get out in front of stories, prepare and think about the PR. There's a great line from the State Department, someone I worked with for many years who was a public diplomacy expert at the State Department of the US State Department and he said, Too often they bring in the communications folks only for the crash landings and not for the takeoffs. So bring in your PR people for the takeoffs as well. Think about the timing and get them engaged so that they can craft the strategy ahead. of time. Another thing that I encounter often with my legal colleagues is, it's just a natural tendency to say it's easier, let's just no comment. Now, sometimes you can't comment because there's active litigation, and you don't want to be seen by
35:17the court, as you know, engaging in the court of public opinion instead of the court of law. And I get that, and sometimes you really do have to know common situation, but often that gets extended into situations where we really do you really should comment. And there's a cost, there's an implicit cost every time you know, communist story, because it allows a, maybe someone who's adverse, or the other side to put their narrative out there. Or at the very least, you know, the public may, or your target audience may may think, well, they have something to hide if they're not commenting. So again, sometimes you have to no comment, because you really have nothing to say, and that's okay. But I wouldn't make that the default. Understand that there's an implicit cost every time you know, comment a story and ask yourself and the client, well, maybe there is something that we could say, and you know, consider that don't handle the PR yourself. This is something that I see again, and again, attorneys are brilliant people, you know, you've you've spent your life working with words and, and concepts. But I so often see, attorneys and their clients get in trouble when they don't have an outside professional coming in to help provide guidance. It may seem like our work is intuitive and easy. And sometimes it is, but sometimes it's not. And I would just say, you know, in all my years of working in this field, I've seen huge changes. And often my legal colleagues, you know, haven't been working as closely with it. And they don't necessarily understand how
36:43the field has evolved. Or, you know, they may not have all the background on the reporter or the outlet or the strategy. And then the really, the smart attorneys are finding PR communications professionals to work with and handle the PR and not handle it themselves. Okay, so there's some questions now, some person, some slides now about engaging a PR firm for your client. So this is a conversation I have almost daily. Does attorney client PR firm privilege exist? There's a there's an open to debate. So the jury is out on this? Sometimes it does. Sometimes it doesn't, but the safest answer is no. And the US risk capital. It was it was decided that information protected by attorney client privilege can be given to a non legal professional, who is retained by counsel to deliver legal advice or services to the client. So if the if the non legal professional is retained is delivering legal advice or services to the client, then that communication is privileged. I guess that's that's very vague, though. But not limited.
37:51legal professionals can only use the privilege information to help counsel deliver legal advice to the client to develop or develop a legal strategy. The very few exceptions are narrowly construed in general No, attorney client PR privilege exists. This is this is really important. So the bottom line, when you're engaging a PR firm, you want to be very thoughtful and careful about what you share if the information that you're sharing is something you want to keep privilege. Another situation that I do quite often with, with with, with attorneys that we work with is, you know, the question, can we sue for defamation, people will say, you know, my client got that negative press, they're really upset, and they want to sue. They want to they want to see the outlet. So often when I get that request, I immediately understand that in fact, there is no debt defamation suit to be had, but that the the standard has not been reached, at least in the United States. Around the world. There are different standards for defamation. But in the US, we have the First Amendment and it's a very clear and specific standard. The standard is one a false statement was made to the false statement was published or divulged to a third party. Three the statement was made negligently or intentionally and for the statement caused damage, you need to have all four of those facts lined up in order to pursue a defamation case. Some just some q&a on what is defamation. So is it slander or libel? And what's the difference? Slander is
39:34spoken or broadcast on libel is print or written communication? Do you always have to prove damages? Sometimes you don't need to prove damages. defamation per se applies to statements that are inherently damaging. So that's the case. And what are common defenses against defamation charges. So what is the statement was true. Second is is the statement was privileged. So absolute privilege is that the statement is protected or qualified privileges mean the statement may be protected. So if it was true or privileged, those are defenses against defamation charges. Another question that I often get that we deal with with our clients is can the media report on stolen documents, communications tapes, etc? If someone hacks your client sends that information to the New York Times, does the New York Times have the legal right to publish that stolen material?
40:34The short answer is yes, most of the time. In Carnegie versus Viper, there was a landmark Supreme Court case where it said that media outlets can publish stolen information on matters of public concern. As long as they themselves were not the party to stolen the information. So one party's crime theft does not abrogate another party's first amendment rights. So something that's a matter of public concern is, you know, generally is the kind of information that someone will want to publish in the newspaper anyways. Now, you can say that, you know, that the information doesn't rise to that standard, and argue for stricter scrutiny. However, you know, most editorial standards, most things that people would want to publish rise to the standard. So it's a really high standard, it's very hard to prove it. So in general, unfortunately, if your client is hacked, or information is leaked, or somebody shares something on authorized the the outlet, the platform has the legal right to publish that material, which is a really big bummer for those of us in this business, but it is what it is. So see my affirmation comment on digital security really important to make sure that this information does not leak in the first place. I get another another question I get often from journalists is how, you know sort of the jargon of journalists, if I'm going to give an interview. How does this work? So I'm gonna go through just the common sort of jargon of journalists. So you can understand how what what are some of the rules of engagement. Now, obviously, these
42:08rules are not legally binding, unlike in court, right. But if someone is a reputable journalist, they will usually adhere to these rules. And if and if you're concerned that they won't adhere to these rules, you probably shouldn't be on the phone with them in the first place. So so when you're when you're engaging, before you have an interview, we want to you want to decide with the journalist is, is the interview going to be on the record? Now, if an interview is on the record, it means every word you say, can be published as a quote, with your name in the story. So if I say the sky is red, today, the reporter can write, Nathan Miller said the sky is red today. That's on the record.
43:00Off the record means that nothing I say can be used for the reporting, even even as just like, you know, the corpus for material. So if if, if I say to the to the reporter, the sky is red today. But that's off the record, then they would have to find somebody else. To tell them the sky is red, in order to even include that fact, in their story. If something is off the record, it means that you can't use it for reporting, I'm just giving you information for your own awareness as a reporter to help guide you in your reporting, and find somebody else to tell you that fact or confirm it elsewhere. Not for attribution means that you have a piece of information, you want to get it into a story but but but but, but your name cannot be associated with it and the the reporter off to paraphrase or you know, give information that so if I said the sky is red today, and it's not for attribution, the reporter can say can write in the story, the sky was red today, but it can't quote me or attributed in any way on background means that I give a quote, we negotiate ahead of time how I will be characterized, and then they can put that quote in the story. So a background quote on this would be, you know, the sky was red today. According to a source familiar with the matter for according to a meteorologist meteorologists with knowledge of the matter how you it's important when you're doing a background quote, to negotiate ahead of time, how you will be described in the story.
44:48Really, really important. When I'm dealing with a journalist on a sensitive story, I'm very careful about either going on record, you know, just in on the phone Interview or putting my client on the phone, for an on Record interview, the safest way to go is to either have a background conversation or not for attribution conversation so that the the, or an off record conversation for the journalist can gain a flavor for what you really think. And then to provide your actual comments in writing. Or if someone has really like, you're really not sure that you can trust that the journalist is going to adhere to the standard that we just described, or you're just you think it's particularly hostile Johnson situation, then you want to just get those questions in writing? Who should speak to the media, the attorney or the client? It's always a question. If something is a legal matter in general, and you know, you need somebody to speak to the specifics of the case, I like to have an attorney. Or if I don't want to put the client out into the media, it's the middle of a crisis, and it's not going to look good for them. Or there's many different reasons why I might not put a client in front of the cameras or you know, in front of a journalist and I can have an attorney speak. But know that when the attorney speaks it out, you know, there are downsides to that as well, they're less you know, and they're less close to the matter. Sometimes it feels like somebody is sort of putting a layer and you're not being as vulnerable. The other
46:14thing that you can always do is put someone like me, have someone like me deal directly with the reporter and then provide quotes in writing from the the attorney or the client. And that's something that you want to think about as well, if you have a PR team working with you. Okay, another question I get quite often when to respond, and when to ignore press increase. We talked about the upside down. There's so many more media outlets today that are sorry about that. There's so many more media outlets today that are online. So it's hard to know exactly who the reporter is or what their angle is. The first thing I always do when when we're when we're considering whether to when to ignore an inquiry is to look at the outlet itself, evaluate the source. Is the outlet. credible?
47:08Well known objective FAT, FAT fact based? Ai, have you heard of it? Have others in your office heard about it? Is it highly biased against your client? Does it does is the editorial line that it's taken, so hostile to your interests? That it might not make sense to even engage? If the answer is yes to this question, you might want to ignore it. If you don't have a good answer to the question without line, it there's nothing you can say at that moment. That will that will that will help be exculpatory, for your client or you know, helpful to them. If you're forced to live, and then that's when you want to No comment. And if there's no answer that advances your narrative, maybe you're waiting for information to come in. There are plenty of reasons why do we ignore our press inquiry? So that's, that's one thing to consider.
48:03Then, once you decided if you do want to engage, the question is, how do you how do you want to respond? So you might want to respond with a written statement, like I said, which is a narrow and precise response to a specific scope. This is the safest way, it leaves little room for the reporter to misinterpret or quote you out of context. Again, just because you provide a written statement doesn't mean that they will run the whole written statement, but it's the most conservative thing. My advice always on written statements is to make them as short as possible people often give me, you know, wanna write paragraph long responses. And that's usually a bad idea. Because it gives, you're basically taking the choice away from yourself about what the core message you want to put into the story. And giving that choice over the reporter who can chop it up and sort of frame it however they want. So you want to have a short, concise, powerful, written statement. Maybe you want to do a phone interview. So the good thing about a phone interview is that it allows you to clarify and elaborate. And if you think the reporter is friendly or open minded, so knows the phone interview is a good idea, because it allows them to ask questions on the spot and create sort of a report a dialogue, I will say there's significant liability to a phone interview, especially for somebody who hasn't doesn't have much experience talking to media. There's a lot of room for something to go wrong. You can you can get quoted out of context, you can, you know, by just by asking
49:24you a question, the reporter can force a framing of an issue and then just take that response, you know, as his responses or her response for the story. So, you want to think about can I really trust this reporter? And is the downside risk worth it in order to you know, be able to have this more open dialogue? Do you want to send a legal letter? This is a question I get all the time. We talked about defamation so often clients, they get frustrated with how a story turned out. And they want to send a legal letter threatening, you know, to sue the publication. Um, I will say, nine times out of 10. This is a bad idea. A because most of the time that there's not really the the, you know, writing a bad story often doesn't meet the standard for defamation that we described earlier. It often just antagonizes the publication and makes you a bigger target for future stories, you know, media, they have a barrel of ink that they can continue to spill, if they decide that they want to come after you, they'll keep coming after you. So it eliminates your ability to have sort of a productive dialogue. That being said, if somebody is truly writing defamatory things about you or your client, you may want to consider a legal matter. And, and, you know, I've sent my fair share of legal letters over the years. And I will say that, you know, sometimes it can be really effective in getting something clarified or deterring bad behavior in the future. So nine times out of 10, it's a bad idea. But occasionally, it is, it is a good idea. And you and you want to
51:01and you want to, you want to do it. So the next thing I want to talk about is a new concept that many people consider when they haven't necessarily understood or considered, and that is the concept of search engine optimization. So search engine optimization, to put it you know, in terms of most people understand is when you Google something on something or someone, you know, a person's name their business, what comes up. And this is really the new, what are the new core ways that we evaluate each other, as you know, you know, goes to the heart of our credibility. And it's a new concept that's extremely important. So if you have a negative news article, it's a flash in the pan. And you know, maybe people see it at one moment in a specific time. But, but if that news article lives high on your search results for years and years and years afterwards, then everybody who you may do business with or meet, or, you know, Will, Will will then see that article again, and again and again. So the search engine, the SEO value, they call it of, of a particular article, or piece of content, or tweet, or, you know, anything on the internet, that's negative can be extremely damaging. And malignant actors or people who want to harm, you may, may use this to their advantage. So there's, there's often seen many strategies in place where someone gets a negative article placed about somebody. And then they use tools of search engine optimization, and there's there's different techniques that people can use to push content up. To really to, to increase
53:02include a lot of negative information about somebody, and it goes to the top of the search results. So that's a big problem. So when you're when you're dealing with sort of negative influence campaigns against you, you're dealing with spam and fake accounts you're dealing with, you can deal with people who are paid influencers, from from your, your adversaries, you can deal with pay to play websites, where people actually pay to put negative content up about you, all of that adversarial content, and then that gets fed into an SEO strategy where that content gets pushed to the top of the search results.
53:34And that can be a big problem. So what what tools do you have at your disposal to deal with SEO? It's one of the new core concepts that I've witnessed in my career evolve over time. So what is it you can work to get down fake stories, you know, stories that are that are clearly defamatory, posted on our website, so that they were somebody clearly paid for them to be put up. And there's a legal strategy for that, you can, you know, you can go after the website itself, you can go after that websites, host provider. There's, there's a, you know, there's a clear way to take down story stories that are on sort of, we'll call them fake news, or, you know, maybe less than reputable news websites, you can get those stories D indexed on Google, they're super certain ways through SEO vendor, you should find someone where that you can actually go and get the story removed from the Google search results. So you want to get it taken off the internet, but you can get it actually taken off off Google and legal options. You know, maybe you sue for defamation, or maybe you know, there's different ways with every one of these different situations that comes that comes up on SEO to pursue legal options in terms of getting content down. The other thing you can do is go on offense. I tell every client they should have an SEO strategy for themselves. A because you want to cure write the story that comes up when somebody Google's you, you want to really help shape their opinion. And because it's also, it's a prophylactic strategy if somebody ever does
55:12read a damaging article about you or wants to put something negative, so think about your own SEO. And lawyers should think about this for their law firms as well. What What's the positive content that you can go put out into the world that will rank well on Google that will help to curate the information environment, which people learn about you and understand who you are. And you know, so that might be putting out press releases about yourself that may be getting earned media content that may be creating really active and strong social media accounts or videos about yourself or appearing on other websites. There's so many different ways to curate positive content about you, your company, your brand, and you want to think about that actively having a positive, proactive SEO strategy is extremely important. I want to talk a little bit now also about implicit bias. So implicit unconscious bias are attitudes or stereotypes that unconsciously affect our understanding actions or decisions. So, you know, every one of us has our own set of unconscious bias, biases. And when you're going into a crisis situation, you want to be able to understand this is how I'm maybe seeing a situation that's filtered through that lens. You have to want us to be able to effectively communicate and advocate for clients for many different diverse backgrounds. And so you want to be able to understand what is my bias going into the situation? How can I? How can I limit that bias? How can I address it and and ensure that you are sort of mentally
56:57prepared to navigate that that important truth about all of us. There's a, you know, this is a this is also important for lawyers, because it's you know, it's an ABA rule, that's professional misconduct for a lawyer to engage in conduct that lawyer knows or reasonably should know is harassment or discrimination on the basis of race, sex, religion, national origin, ethnicity, disability, age, sexual orientation, gender identity, marital status, or socioeconomic status and conduct related to the practice of law. So if you if you don't navigate your implicit bias, it can lead to unethical behavior that violates your duty as an attorney. I just want to close with a few words about the importance of integrating these concepts into your your practice, I've seen so many incredible attorneys who are fantastic at their narrow practice of the law, but they don't always think about the broader context in which they're operating, and how their work. May you know how having a good PR resource, you know, and a good fundamental understanding of the way that the information environment exists today, they don't understand how important that can be for their clients success. So I would really encourage you study up on how communications is changing, study up on how people are changing, like how their opinions are being formed, the information they're receiving is changing.
58:26And find a great PR partner that can work with you. You want someone who's really good, who's not conducting a legacy strategy for a legacy environment that no longer exists, you want someone who's on the cutting edge of this work, who understands how media and communications is changing, and who has a lot of experience working with attorneys on this specific matters that you handle. And that's my best advice for every attorney is, you know, build a strong relationship with an external communications partner that has experienced in the work that you do. And, and, and cultivate that relationship over time so that you can bring them in in the event that you do need that strategic communications crisis communication support. So with that, I thank you for your attention.
59:08And wish you a good day. Thanks so much.
Anna M.CA
good overview of PR in a law practice. Covered many issues that come up in a law office crisis and how to use a PR firm to assist and minimize unforeseen problems.