0:00Good evening, my name is Marc silver. And this evening, I'm going to be presenting a CLE, which is completely new to me. I've presented dozens of CLE to literally 1000s and 1000s of lawyers throughout the United States. But this is the first time I'm presenting to CLE, specifically on the subject, which is the pre sentence investigation, and how to critique it. This, of course, pertains to our clients who are defendants in criminal cases. And before they have the opportunity to plead guilty, before they have the opportunity to be sentenced, of course, there is the opportunity by the probation department to interview these clients as a means to better understand their needs and who they are. Many times these pre sentence investigation reports are just inadequate, and they do not adequately represent or reflect our client's needs, their histories, background, mental health, family issues, and so on. And for that reason, I developed the CLE specifically for criminal defense lawyers, so that the criminal defense lawyer can better understand where the weaknesses are in these psi eyes, and how to critique them. But more importantly, what essential tools are available strategic tools are available for the criminal defense lawyer in understanding these psi eyes, to better grasp nuances about our client's background, mental health, family, and so on, so that the criminal defense lawyer can better advocate for the client for pre sentence purposes, for pre sentence purposes with the prosecutor, Judge,
1:41and so on. I've been working in forensics since 2002. I've done well over 2000 cases now, for criminal and immigration lawyers, although also a few cases for family and personal injury lawyers. As I said, I've been fortunate to present dozens of CLE to perhaps 10,000 lawyers at this point, I work in New York City in Manhattan. And today, I think I presented at something which is relevant for all of us. It's particularly relevant on this particular day, it's November 13 2018, when this is being recorded, because there's now very serious talk about sentence reform, and whether or not will be passed specifically with regard to how our clients are sentenced, particularly with regard to allowing judges a greater sense of freedom. It's all the more relevant therefore, that we have a better understanding of how these psi are assembled, but more importantly, how to critique them how to present to the judge who has more freedom these days, especially in the post Booker era, so that the judge himself has a much better grasp and a more complete grasp of who our clients are. Therefore, you know, the title of today's CLE is pre sentence investigation report, critique its critique of the psi eyes, and specifically mitigation as counter strategy in a child pornography case. I wanted to really rather than just talk theory to also apply how these peace sentence reports are used and how they're at times inadequately prepared for specific kinds of cases in the case I'd like to look at today is a child pornography case. Although I have it on a later slide, I really
3:32want to emphasize I try as best as possible to integrate theory and practice. And therefore, any criminal defense lawyers who are interested in sample reports, sample mitigation reports of child pornography case have to in particular here, please, after the seminar or at another time, do not hesitate to email me with your full information just so I know it's not spam, of course, put your name, title where you work address and so on, and request one of these cases, they are of course, fully redacted. So there's no personal information and no identifying information. But I think it really helps to integrate theory and practice. The outline of the seminar today will be a general introduction. I'm then going to try and provide some explanation of why this CLE is so important right now. I want to give a general overview of what the pre sentence investigation looks like that is the criteria what it entails a psi by the government, then specifically, and the next two sections are really crucial specifically to look at what is missing from the psi to really critique it. Then I'd like to look at evaluation tools that can be used by the criminal defense lawyer strategically to better understand the client to critique the psi, and cumulatively to better advocate for For the client in a more complete way, because I truly believe as a mitigation expert that mitigation is the best way to counter a psi, I will then look at mitigation challenges, specifically in this area. So let's really get to the heart of it. First,
5:16the introduction. mitigation is absolutely crucial, crucial as a means to counter psi is for many reasons. And what I focused on in my own work really breaks down to a few central areas. I do work in sex crimes, for example, pornography, and so on. And the case we're looking at today is exactly that. I've done a lot of Adam Walsh Act cases in the context of immigration, defense work, white collar work, specifically for individuals in the financial sector, but really white collar in a much broader sense in individuals working in the business world, corporations and so on, not simply at a high level, but also mid management, fraud, embezzlement and so on. I do a lot of complex trauma cases that is, particularly with individuals from from lower socio economic backgrounds with traumas not just from a specific individual such as physical or sexual abuse, but the individual has suffered trauma in different contexts of their life because of abuse or neglect by other caregivers because of crime and drugs in the community and so on. I give a separate CLE On another subject called borderline personality disorder. I do work with criminal immigration matters for both criminal defense lawyers who have clients with very serious immigration problems, but also immigration defense lawyers who have clients with serious criminal problems. And lastly, I do a lot of work with very difficult clients, or clients who really tend to jeopardize the criminal defense lawyers work, they tend to undermine
6:55the best advice given to them by even very experienced criminal defense lawyers. And as a result, they tend to really jeopardize their entire litigation. As I mentioned early, please do not hesitate for a case sample. The books I have, as recommendation are my Handbook, its Handbook of mitigation and criminal and immigration forensics. The subtitle of the book is humanizing the client towards better legal outcome. And I mean that very sincerely. And this is such a crucial issue in the psi are so many of them are very concrete and black and white, we want to move away from that. And a central part of the critique of the psi is to humanize the client to show a real sense of who the client is and show where they have had terrible challenges and traumas, you know, where the client has really stumbled like all humans, like all people stumble. And that's a crucial part of the book to understand how to advocate for the client in a humanistic manner given criteria and given the challenges that we have in our kind of work. I also have a case study book, which is now being revised called criminal mitigation case studies for criminal defense lawyers, which is also recommended.
8:09But the first book in particular, I think, has the crux of what I try to do in mitigation as it means to counter the psi s, which I find to be weak. And I'll say at the very outset, I have never seen a psi given to me by a criminal defense lawyer in a mitigation case that is complete. That is, I always find major areas that are missing, including mental health issues, medical, physical problems, family dynamics, even financial issues, a wide range of matters that are really crucial to helping to understand our client and which in turn, is crucial so that the judge and prosecutor can better understand who this individual is, who is going to be judged and whose life is going to be changed irrevocably, by whatever the judge gives out as a sentence. So why is the CLE important now, there has been a huge shift in power. There has been a major shift in power from the tripartite system of Judge, prosecutor and defense lawyer to really a unilateral system in which the prosecutor acts as prosecutor, of course, but also judge and jury, while the judge twiddle systems board, sometimes in an empty courtroom for weeks and months on end. This has had a major impact on evidence, right in law school, we required an entire course on evidence for very good reason. However, today, evidence cannot be fairly examined in a court of law, because the cost and risk of going to court is just too high for the criminal defendant. So paradoxically, hearsay evidence found in the psi and mitigation reports have become crucial sources of information for
9:50determining sentences. In fact, this was a major criticism by the late Justice Scalia from the Supreme Court who said mitigation reports are very much To hearsay. But understanding the shift in power, I think is absolutely crucial because it really helps us to understand that where our focus strategically needs to be within the realm of criminal defense, it needs to be directly in understanding our client's background, their needs, family dynamics, and so on to best advocate for them, because so many cases now are being really dealt with directly with the prosecutor. And because of the shift in power, that individual now has an incredible amount of decision making regarding our client's future. And of course, the case itself. There is something called now a trial penalty, the criminal justice system has been turned into a guilty plea factory. So powerful is this penalty that even innocent persons will succumb to the threat of a worse outcome if they dare to risk the fundamental, Sixth Amendment right to a trial. The National Registry of exonerations has now identified for 404 out of 20 2200 cases in which individuals later determined to have been innocent, had entered a guilty plea, rather than take the risk of going to trial, which is extremely embarrassing, extremely lengthy, extremely expensive, and so on. And of course, the risk of going to trial for these individuals brings the threat of a far greater sentence for incarceration. So this is this is an extremely timely, extremely relevant topic, I think, for all of us in
11:34this field. My own background, I will tell you, is a mix of both law and mental health. I came out of law school in 2001. I've been a mitigation expert since then, really since 2002. But I've really seen the shift even while in law school. But I've also seen a shift slowly, slowly towards a much better understanding by criminal defense lawyers in general, as a strategic need to look towards mitigation as a tool to critique the psi. This is particularly important in the kinds of cases we're dealing with today, specifically child pornography cases. And I'll tell you about one or two of them very quickly as a introduction. The first one was an individual who is viewing child pornography, he had a state charge against him, he served about 18 months he came out.
12:25And then about eight months later, he went back to it, he was arrested at the federal level, and he ended up being sentenced to just under 20 years. The second case involves an individual who really became involved in this through a chatroom, in which he took on the identity himself as a 36 year old male, the time I met him, but he started in his early 20s, he took on the identity view of identity of a male adolescent and encouraged under aged girls, mostly ages 15 1617, and so on, to also perform some kind of sexual act or take off their clothes and so on. So these were two cases in which the PSSA found, at some level did a good job in a concrete way. But of course, the nuances of who these individuals were their background, their needs. So much was missing. And I found through the mitigation and interviewing and so on, that a completely different perspective on who this individual emerged in a way that I think was ultimately quite beneficial, not only to the client, but it provides the lawyer a much greater understanding about the insights as to the psychological needs and background for this client. So very quickly, what is the psi, of course it after defendant please enters a plea of guilty to a federal offense or is convicted by trial. He or she will meet with a probation officer typically at the initial meeting, their probation officer from the Federal Bureau of Prisons will conduct an interview with the defendant to gather a wide range of information including family history, community ties, background,
14:04employment history, physical health, mental health, substance abuse, history, financial conditions, and of course, the individual's willingness to accept responsibility for his or her offenses. There's a wide range of psi supporting evidence during the pre sentence investigation. a probation officer will interview other persons who can provide pertinent information, including the prosecutor, law enforcement agents, victims, Mental Health and Family substance abuse treatment providers, and the defendant, family members, associates and employers. The officer will also review documents which may include court dockets, indictments, plea agreements, trial transcripts, investigative reports from other law enforcement agencies, criminal history records, counseling and substance abuse treatment records, scholastic records, employment records and of course financial records. There may be a home visit where the individual probation officer actually goes to the home and investigates the residents regarding safety quality of life during the visit the officer May interview family members and assess living conditions in general and of course, the suitability for potential supervision conditions, such as location monitoring. Then, of course, there's a pre sentence report. It is the responsibility of the probation officer assigned to the pre sentence investigation to assist the court by verifying, evaluating and interpreting the information gathered, and to present the information to the court in an organized
15:26objective pre sentence report. Another important part of the preparation of the pre sentence report involves the probation officers investigation into the offense of conviction, including the defendants involvement in any similar or uncharged criminal conduct, the impact of the offense on the victims, the sentencing options under the applicable federal guidelines and so on. Really, the pre sentence report helps the court fashion appropriate and fair sentences and is used by probation officers later assigned to supervise the offender. The supervision officer uses the information contained in the pre sentence report, as part of a comprehensive approach to assess risks posed by and the needs of offenders under supervision. The report is also disclosed to the defendant, defense attorney and prosecutor who have the opportunity to make objections or seek changes to the pre sentence report through a formal process established by the Federal Rules of criminal procedure.
16:27Act sentences of course, it's crucial that the probation officer conduct a pre sentence investigation and prepare the report in a way that can actually be be quite integral for the sentencing itself. Although practices differ among various districts, usually a probation probation officer may at the conclusion of pre sentence investigation work with his or her supervisor to formulate an appropriate sentencing recommendation that will be provided to the court. The officer must be prepared to discuss the case with the sentencing judge to answer questions about the report that may arise during sentencing hearing, and on rare occasions to testify in court as to the basis of the factual findings and guideline application set forth in the pre sentence report. So that's really, you know, the heart and soul of what the psi is. And really what I wanted to do is spend the rest of the time a critiquing the report, critiquing the psi and second, looking at alternative strategies to better understand who our client is to essentially balanced the psi, with, frankly, more insightful and more complete information. As I said before, I have to say that after all these years, I've never seen a complete psi. I've never seen a psi that truly reflects the client in all his subtleties and nuances. There's a dearth of information missing. And on this slide, I have, you know, a general outline, there is misleading, incomplete information. There's a lack of empathy in these reports, the psi misses out on good deeds by our clients. psychosocial information may be missing.
18:08General, mental health information is generally omitted. family issues are neglected. Environmental and community ties are just not there. Sometimes. There's cultural sensitivity issues, which are often absent. Very often our clients are willing to accept responsibility, and that's not clearly included. And of course, mitigation is not included. I want to go through each one quickly. First, misleading, incomplete, insufficient sections on the psi, half truth is no truth at all. I sometimes look back at mitigation report that is incomplete. I gotta tell you, I just stare in disbelief that the person who I've interviewed for the mitigation is the same person that was interviewed for the purpose of the psi, the misleading the incomplete information really, ultimately provides something that is a terrible disservice to the client. And I'm not suggesting that the officer who undertakes the psi is trying to be misleading, please don't misunderstand me. But I am saying that I think some of these officers just don't have sufficient clinical training, or just don't have sufficient training as to how to undertake a clinical evaluation. And in a sense, the psi is are really clinical evaluations understanding, health, mental health, family background and so on, in a way that provides a clear picture for the prosecutor and for the judge. Next is really a lack of empathy. The omission of empathy is also the omission of humanization.
19:43That is, it is crucial to humanize the client to explain various aspects of the client's psychosocial background so the judge or prosecutor will be able to identify with the major challenges, traumas and stressors that the individual has encountered. is not easy to accomplish and requires a combination of objective information. subjective perspective and clinical know how the child pornography case I was mentioning before the second one where the individual got into child pornography through chat rooms with other individuals pretending to be an adolescent boy, and then enticing girls to take off their clothes and to engage in sexual acts. This was an individual who's really quite accomplished, he went to undergraduate he completed an executive MBA MBA program, and had really moved up in the executive world in a major corporation. And this was an individual who you really didn't naturally have a lot of empathy for. The idea was, well, this is a guy who's had every opportunity to go to good schools, he had a good family. And I could see from the psi, there was no empathy, there was no ability to really identify with those challenges and problems that the client had. And for example, in this case, this was an individual who grew up in a family where the parents had divorced, the father had previously been quite abusive in different ways. And the divorce, even though his parents each provided appropriate care and support to him, nonetheless, yielded a terrible trauma for this individual. And he ended up with a
21:20severe eating disorder, very poor self esteem. He had terrible interpersonal problems with women, and it fed into this really pathological need for him to only connect with women through the internet. In fact, he had very healthy relationships with his family healthy relationships, in his workplace, and even social relationships in general. But there was just a complete lack of empathy for the trauma that this particular person experienced in his, uh, in his own idiosyncratic way, it was just missing from the psi altogether. And when I did the case, it was essential focus, quite frankly, for me, to be able to humanize the individual and really explain who he was. And this is an example of what I meant in the previous slide of misleading or insufficient, you know, the psi for this client was, in a sense, complete, you know, it explained who he was and where he came from. But that information is very concrete. And it leaves out a whole dearth of topics and, and subtleties and all sorts of things about what makes this person tick. And in particular, the empathy that is needed so that we can identify with the person identify with this client's challenges and problems and so on.
22:41Next slide is about good deeds. This is very important. I have so many clients who have done such terrible things. And yet in many ways, they have led very praiseworthy lives in the community. They have been volunteers, they have contributed in charitable ways. They have helped develop organizations, they have been very good participants in their places of worship, and so on. And I sometimes find that the clients community connections within their community, through good deeds through community, volunteer and charitable work is omitted. Sometimes these clients when they go to the psi, they're embarrassed, they know they've done something terribly wrong. And sometimes they don't want to, in a sense, put themselves on a pedestal. And I saw that with this client who really had done wonderful work through his university to develop chapters, for fundraising purposes for academics, scholarships for needy individuals and social services program, I mean, really wonderful work. But because he was accused of this terrible crime, and he faced such a serious penalty, he was very reluctant in the interview to speak honestly of his accomplishments, and the positive aspects aspects of his life, for many reasons, including the fact that he was ashamed, including the fact that he feared that he just wouldn't be believed, at times, he thought it was not relevant, and so on.
24:04And so ultimately, the psi reflected the information that he gave, which was incomplete. It's also very interesting to note that I found this with the lawyer, that the lawyer after he received my mitigation report called me and said, You know, I found out a whole, a whole array of information regarding this person's personal life, social life, the sexual development, interpersonal needs, and so on. But he didn't tell me about the client either thought it wasn't relevant legally, the client perhaps didn't have a complete sense of trust with the lawyer because, you know, the interview is, of course, a legal one by the lawyer and not one that is clinically based. But you know, it shows you that a clinical expert can sometimes extract from an individual through with a trusting almost therapeutic relationship, all kinds of information that can be helpful and not just to counter the psi, but also to assist lawyer to better understand Who the client is and this really dovetails to the next slide. The next slide looks at psychosocial information.
25:13Sometimes the psi looks like a background check for a job interview rather than really psychosocial history. The psychosocial history is absolutely crucial and uncovering any and all background information that better explains how the client got to be in his or her current position. In a sense, psychosocial information is mitigation in and of itself, because it better explains the client's decision making thoughts, feelings and so on. The psychosocial information is not supposed to be solely concrete in nature, but rather individual nature and we want to really investigate through a psychosocial information, the idiosyncrasies of the individual that is what makes this person make his particular decision. What makes him you know, attracted to this kind of hobby or interest, or engage in this kind of conduct, or have him interested in certain proclivities. psychosocial information often gathered by a social worker is thought to be very concrete. And we see that with psi is at least I do all the time. But really, psychosocial information is psycho social. It really is the intersection between psychological issues and social issues, so that it better informs the lawyer is going to better inform the mitigation report and counters the psi in a way to really explain how both meet and give better insight into how our client got to be where he is. In the first pornography case that I was telling you about, where the client was much younger, I think he was in his early 20s, when he was first arrested. He had come from a family a
26:57first generation family from Mexico, his parents had suffered terrible extreme hardships in Mexico, including poverty abuses, and their relocation to the United States was quite desperate to explain to escape. You know, living in a small village where many basic necessities were quite frankly unavailable. These issues were completely omitted from the piece psi. It said, of course, that the client had been born to an immigrant family from Mexico. But that is nearly explained the kinds of challenges that his parents had, and how his parents as a first generation immigrant family didn't always have the wherewithal to provide the care, love and support to the client in this child pornography case. And you got a much better sense when that information was included to understand how this client in some ways had to raise himself. He didn't have the guidance that was needed. He didn't have older siblings to turn to, and therefore better explains how his poor decision making developmentally really fed into his poor decision making as a young adult. The next area is general, General mental health. This is absolutely crucial. I have never seen a criminal case without mental health issues period. I know criminal defense lawyers like to use mental health in a very considered a strategic way. And I understand that particularly with regard to psychosis for pleas of not guilty by reason of insanity.
28:23But mental health is not just about individual diagnoses, although that's crucial. It's more broadly about mental health functioning, it's about how people make decisions and how they live their lives. So for example, a person can have a serious mental health problem, including depression, and not necessarily have a diagnosis. But there may be aspects and symptoms or criteria of depression, or trauma or anxiety, that can be very relevant and helpful to understanding how our clients makes decisions and how this client got into so much trouble and their mental health history. Even though there's no formal diagnosis. The other thing is many of our clients don't see mental health experts for many years, or sometimes ever psychiatric care, but may be anathema to their cultural background. Mental health diagnoses may be stigmatized. And so when they, you know, see the officer for the psi, the client may be very honest and saying, you know, I've never had any mental health problems, but the client is really saying is, I've never been formally diagnosed, I've never had the opportunity to really sit down for two or three hours, and speak with someone who has clinical expertise, a social worker, a psychologist, whatever. And therefore the client doesn't relate very important information, which quite frankly, the omission of such really, really robs us of a complete understanding of the client. mental health issues could be overt, it could be settled, they could be chronic, they can be acute, and the criteria and the symptoms of
29:46each one need to be explained within the context of the case and how it pertains to the client's legal problem at the time. Some of these mental health issues may be very old and the client himself may not be aware. So the information from parents older siblings and so on, to understand about the client's mental health development early in life, and so on. emotional health is also important. It's not just psychiatric diagnoses, clients often have industry mental health problems that existed at one point and do not exist now. For example, I had a client just the other day, who suffered rather serious traumas and losses. And I was speaking to her and she was perfectly fine. She she had no depression or anxiety, she was functioning very well. She was in a very loving, committed marriage, she was working and so on. And yet she had many years before significant trauma and mental health problems. From you know, her early 20s. That information needs to be included, and sometimes the client because they're feeling psychiatrically stable, and they do not exhibit mental health problems of the moment, omit serious problems that they had for many years before. One very huge example. And I have a completely separate CLE on this is borderline personality disorder. It's missed all the time. And I know, because borderlines make up a significant portion of our mental health population, make up perhaps several percent of the population in general. And yet it's very rare for me to see a criminal defense lawyer saying, you know, I have a
31:18client with borderline personality disorder, it really needs to be fleshed out. And the diagnostics he was playing within the context of this person's criminal problem. And I've never, ever heard of it and on a psi, in general, personality disorders and borderline personality is a type of personality disorder are in general omitted, they're omitted, because there's an assumption that if the person's committed these crimes, they're they have an anti social personality sorter they're a psychopath or whatever. And yet, it's far more nuanced than that. There's all sorts of personality disorders that may be really very relevant for different reasons for the clients that are not considered by the psi officer undertaking the examination. family issues are often omitted, Family Development, context, familial contacts, dependence, hardship issues, and so on. You know, I see as much as possible, immediate relatives of our clients who provide sometimes crucial insights into the client's development in life. But I also have to tell you, I gain a crucial understanding about how these family members are dependent on our clients who risk incarceration and I often include dependency issues, how the client may be providing physical, emotional, psychological, instrumental financial supports, to a spouse, to one or more children and so on, and how in this person's absence of these family members could suffer, no profound hardships and their educations could be completely derailed. His children's educations could be derailed, there could be
32:59profound familial detachment and that I really tried to explain as much as possible how these healthy bonds have really been beneficial to the family members.
33:11I have to tell you, I haven't completely different CLE on borderline personality disorder, as I mentioned, but I had in that case, and I have a redacted example, also there that lawyers are certainly welcome to how a client in that case was the second generation survivors of the Holocaust in Europe during the World during World War Two, and how she had suffered profound trauma growing up in a home of survivors and how it fantastically impacted her development, her self concept, her dysfunctional interaction with family members, and so much more in her life. So family is extremely complicated, as we all know, because we have families and so much is dependent on families that it's almost overlooked as so obvious by the psi, Officer, environment and communities absolutely crucial. So many of our clients have grown up in deprived socio economic neighborhoods with violence, poverty, racism, and systemic abuses. I have clients that I've interviewed from these kinds of neighborhoods, and the abuses and systemic violence and abuses are so sometimes ever present, there's so ubiquitous, that the client views these problems as normative. That is an individual who suffered abuse in a very constrained or particular way. While growing up, we'll understand how that abuse really exists in contrast to what is normal, but if you grew up in a home in a community where there's only pathology where there's only violence and abuses and drugs and so on, that for you is going to be normal. And so sometimes the client cannot order have the
35:00capacity to really explain that to the psi officer. clients who've really enjoyed a strong middle class background who do not have their environments investigated fully for the possibility of unseen trauma or also problem. And I see this a lot in white collar cases where the individual really has grown up in a home where, you know, it's considered a white picket fence home, and everybody has a middle class income, everybody goes to high school, and they have a college education. And it's assumed that when the client comes for psi, that this person has grown up with all the privileges and everything is perfect.
35:40And of course, you lift up any home and you look inside, and you see that there are problems and challenges. And it doesn't matter how much money you have, or how little money you have, it doesn't matter if you have both parents with you, or just you grew up in a single family home. Everybody in their own particular way have challenges. And I see this in white collar cases, where there's quite frankly, a sort of bias thinking that you know, this is a person who necessarily probably had all the benefits living in a middle class or upper middle class neighborhood. And in fact, they those are the clients who the most need to have a very detailed psychosocial history to counter the psi. I will tell you the second pornography case that I described before, the guy who worked for a major corporation and you know, even completed an executive MBA program had also grown up even after his parents divorce in two very healthy homes. His father remarried a wonderful woman who had the opportunity to meet when I was doing the mitigation report who is very educated. And you know, she really directed my clients father in a way that he became a better father and so on. But it didn't mean that my client because of the divorce didn't suffer trauma. It didn't mean that even though he didn't have wonderful summer vacations and his father didn't come to his Eagle Scouts and his mother wasn't there in a supportive way, he did have his own serious mental health problems separate and apart from other family members. Another major issue is cultural sensitivity
37:08sensitivity. cultural sensitivity considers how individuals within a family within a community and within an ethnicity, and sometimes in various ways, all three, are shaped how these influences are shaped, and how the individuals is shaped by them. But more importantly, considers how us as professionals need cultural sensitivity, how we need to think of individuals, given their own particular context, their own particular development, so that we have an understanding clearly of who these people are separate and apart from what we consider mainstream, perhaps, willingness to accept responsibility, often I see in psi is, there's not enough willingness reflected, I see so many of my clients who really feel a deep sense of remorse and regret, I speak to them often for three, four days for many hours a day when I'm doing these investigations. And what comes out is a deep sense of contrition. And they really do accept full responsibility. But more importantly, they explain why they accept responsibility. My client in the second pornography case, again, this executive with really all sorts of accomplishments of his life within the corporation explain how he felt terrible about the harm that he had caused these teenage girls and how his own deeply damaged self esteem throughout his adolescence and young adulthood contributed to decision making this area and how he understood through the through his own psychological harm, his emotional dysfunction, how he also heard other people, and not only these girls, but you know, obviously, their families, and so on. And it
38:49was really very heartfelt and I found this was really missing. In the psi. I found this for the other pornography cases. Well, this guy, as I said, was much younger. His name has been 20s. He was not educated, he was not articulate. He had a very difficult time, explaining in simple words, his remorse and regret, but it existed it was there was just underneath the surface. You just needed to speak to this person for several hours to have it come out. Finally, mitigation mitigation. I have obviously separate CLE is on it. I'm going to talk about it here. But it's so often missed from psi is that is mitigation, explanation, context background, a more detailed understanding and more nuanced understanding about how this person got to be where they are. And of course mitigation for the purpose of pre sentence for the prosecutor pre sentence in front of the judge. It's absolutely crucial. I mentioned in another CLE that, you know, mitigation is almost becoming the new Gideon v. Wainwright, which of course, the famous Supreme Court case that mandated for felonies that criminal defense criminal defendants have a criminal defense Lawyer that you know, perhaps for serious cases or felony cases or whatnot, that perhaps we really need for these criminal defendants mitigation experts to help explain who they are their background, mental health problems, psychiatric issues, family, remorse, regret and so on. So that we have the proper representation at a psychosocial level so that we can fairly move forward in the
40:25criminal defense system understanding who this individual is.
40:35What I'd like to look at now are the tools for evaluation to counter the psi, we first looked at the psi itself. We then looked at the major critiques of the psi given what information may be absent and now I want to look at what value what evaluation tools are available. And on this slide I have a whole bunch neuropsychological evaluations psychosexual psychosexual evaluations, psychological evaluation, psychiatric, Social Work evaluations, medical evaluation, psychodynamic and mitigation evaluations, I just want to spend one or two minutes on each one. I think it's absolutely crucial for criminal defense lawyers to be aware of them I'm sure almost everybody is but I think crucial for review, and also crucial for understanding how to use them as a means to critique the psi. The neuropsychological event neuropsychological evaluations may be based on a wide range of investigative tools that provide an objective sense of the issues. They are crucial because they can help to possibly rule out organic problems.
41:41And if there's any sense from the cycles from the neuropsychological evaluation that there are organic or organic problems, the client could be referred to a neurologist or another expert just to understand the difference and neuropsychological evaluation is done by a psychologist who specializes in neuro psychology and neurologist is a physician who really doesn't do too much a neurologist most often or almost always, if he suspects some kind of brain problem or cognitive problem, there may be history of brain damage, or whatnot. The neurologist will then refer the client for a scan a CAT scan or MRI or whatnot. The CAT scan or MRI does not go back to the neurologists it is read by a radiologist who gives an impression and a possible explanation of what they see on the scan and it is then referred back to the neurologist who makes a diagnosis and recommendation. The limitation of the neuropsychological evaluation is that the questionnaires and the research tools used to evaluate the client often miss nuanced mental health issues, and psychosocial background subtleties. I have to tell you as a mitigation expert, overall from all these evaluations, I like the neuropsychological evaluation the most because it gets psychological information it does neurological testing, it considers the client in a way that I think is quite helpful. And I often ask criminal defense lawyers if it's possible to get a neuropsychological evaluation before I go into the do the mitigation evaluation as as background and of
43:18course again to rule out any other problems. psychosocial psychosexual evaluations are also very important. The advantage is that sexual development is often relegated to the back bench so that psychosexual evaluation to examine specific issues can be quite helpful, particularly if there has been turmoil in the individual's early childhood or adolescence. Obviously, for child pornography cases, we always consider psychosexual development to consider if there's been early trauma, abuse, neglect, but also medical or physical problems and so on. Sometimes we see clients that have actually rather a normal sexual developments, and they develop a sexual problems or issues as young adults are even in their early 20s. And sometimes, of course, we see clients with very serious problems very early on. The limitation is that a normal developmental phenomenon is often mistakenly pathologized by the judge or prosecutor. Remember how the case many years ago where I think he was about 11 year old a client was experimenting sexually with a cousin who was probably a year or two younger, and the family was very upset and it went to the police and the prosecutor's office. And the pay havior was quite frankly, normative sexual play sexual experimentation, touching, questioning looking through books, this is all part of normal development. Of course there are appropriate and there are initial appropriate behaviors even for children. And there are appropriate and inappropriate questions even for children, depending on who they are, where they develop
45:07their context and so on. But it's very important to understand what is normal, what is not normal, and where the lines blur and where of course, there are red flags. The next are psychological evaluations. psychological evaluations tend to focus on conscious behavior. Generally. As I said, I like neuropsychological evaluations the most as a background psychological evaluations are second best, but they're also very good. It's also very good to have a another clinical expert and I am a clinical expert to go in and evaluate the individual. The limitations that psychological evaluations may omit a fuller consideration of emotional issues, as understood in the context of development, family, environment and community that may exist below the level of consciousness. Of course, every expert thinks that their evaluation is complete, that their evaluation is the bee's knees, and it has everything. But of course, there are advantages to every kind of evaluation. And I think every evaluation will always add something to our knowledge base for the client. At the same time, we have to be very humble as experts and know where our limitations are, and I certainly know are minor and I know when to get help.
46:24Next are psychiatric evaluations. psychiatric evaluations are great. It's really a mental health evaluation by a physician. It's best done, of course, when the psychiatrist has a forensic background, but the advantage is that the psychiatrist knows medicine, or at least should know medicine from his days in medical school, so that there could be important medical issues that dovetail with the psychiatric problems, or compliments psychiatric problems that psychiatrists may pick up as quite new ones. This is particularly true with somatic disorders, which are really undervalued and under considered in mental health in general, but really exists for so many of our clients.
47:08These are disorders where the person has reacted over the years to anxiety or, or mental health problems. And they're sort of defending themselves against these mental health issues. somatically that is through their body, they may develop chronic headaches, neurological symptomatology, such as dizziness, or gastrointestinal problems. We see this with many clients who develop compulsive behaviors with regard to their body such as continually picking their skin, which is called dermatillomania, or taking off their hair and other sorts of behaviors. And you know, psychiatrists can be particularly good at picking these up, when would hope. It's also very important to understand that we're looking always for both individual issues of mental health, but also patterns of pathology, which psychiatrists in theory should be good at picking up patterns of pathology really give insights into this person's problem, not just today, not just this month, but over long periods of time. And it helps to sometimes fill in more meaning with regard to their behavior over years and decades. It's particularly important for personality disorder issues, because as I said, so often personality disorder issues are missed or relegated to the side in, in part because I think sometimes people are concerned about bringing up psychopathy and bringing up the issue of antisocial personality disorder. But in fact, exploring those criteria can yield really very insightful information as to who our clients are. Many of our clients have
48:48paranoid conditions and delusional systems that may be undetected, they may be very subtle. hallucinations are false sensations, or delusions or false beliefs. hallucinations are tend to be more exact and easier to pick up such as hearing things that aren't real, you hear a voice telling you that you're terrible, you hear your grandmother's voice from 20 years ago, since since her death you you may see things such as strange objects or shadows at night. They tend they tend to be more concrete, as opposed to delusions. delusions, can be very subtle delusions involve false beliefs. There could be all sorts of idiosyncratic delusions regarding one's identity regarding one's personality, paranoid delusions, so that people may be very guarded and suspicious, and they may have a very low sense of trust. So they don't want to really work with a clinical expert or their lawyer, other people and psychiatrists can be good at picking that stuff up. I must say again, mitigation tries to bring all this together. That's why the mitigation expert is also a clinical expert. The limitation here is that sometimes psychiatric evaluations Miss or undervalue social and community ties that are so crucial for explain who our clients are. And that's why frankly, holistic evaluations are so crucial. You should also know in the United States that psychiatrists today are very different than psychiatrists, 30 and 40 years ago, psychiatrists today of course, do psychiatry, that's their specialty. But in the United States, about two thirds, two thirds of all psych meds
50:28especially for depression, anxiety, insomnia, and so on, are prescribed by non psychiatrists. And the vast majority of talk therapy is done by non psychiatrists. So when we evaluate our clients, and this is why mitigation experts with clinical backgrounds are so important you want really want to bring in the clients access to community mental health, primary care physicians, for women, gynecologist and so on. Because the gynecologist primary care visit care physician and these other health care connections may be substituting for what was formal psychiatric care 2030 and 40 years ago. Social Work evaluations, you know, my background is in psychology, law and social work. So of course, I have a bias towards social work evaluations. They're great because they're holistic. They are systemic BIOS, bio psychosocial evaluations, and they're integrative. They take psychiatric issues, they take social family issues, background developmental issues, they're integrative. And they're best in a sense to counter the BS the psi because the psi is kind of like a social work evaluation in a very real sense. Plus social workers have cultural sensitivity, they have greater sensitivity to the person's ethnicity, ethnicity, family, and their background situation. But there is a limitation in many social work evaluations to be quite frank psychopathology, which I think is absolutely crucial. psychopathology is relegated as secondary to the client's family and community context. And to me, you know, no
52:03one issue should ever be missed a no one issue should ever be paramount, we have to have an integrative bio psychosocial evaluation. Next, we have medical evaluations themselves. Medical evaluations are supposed to be holistic, considering every aspect of healthcare, it's particularly important because sometimes their pathologies, especially the endocrine system, that can cause aberrant behavior, lupus, thyroid dysfunction, hypothyroidism, and so on undetected brain tumors. And again, this is particularly relevant if we have a client who has chronic dizziness, headaches, they're unbalanced, nausea, gastrointestinal problems, and so on. I've had many clients who have had depression, who have exhibited something very similar to bipolar disorder and chronic issues with anxiety because of hypothyroidism, which is often maintained through medications such as Synthroid, but the truth is, a medical evaluation should, in theory, cover all the bases within medicine and be completely holistic. Again, this is one of the advantages of a psychiatrist who in theory knows both medicine and also mental health as a specialty within medicine, I have to tell you, the limitation is there's a high rate of air in the United States with our physicians is simply reality. There's a wide range of research on this, it was my main interest before he went to law school I've published on this. And it's a very serious point of consideration so that we really want to have the client not only a general examination, but is any suspicion of any
53:49specialty issues that the client has also spent sent to a specialist to understand those more thoroughly. The next is a psychodynamic evaluation, such psychodynamic evaluations, really look at unconscious motivation. There was a time when psychiatrists very frequently went for psychoanalytic training. Today, extremely few psychiatrists go for this kind of training, psychodynamic training and understanding of the individual is crucial. It can be extremely helpful in providing a humanistic understanding about feelings, privations, traumas, thoughts, aspirations, hopes, dreams, frustrations, life challenges for the client, personal obstacles, stressors, ideals, values, confusion, disappointments that the client has had resentment losses and so on, he can give a much better understanding about why our client at times has felt very unsafe or very secure. Why our client has felt very stable or unstable at different points in his or her life. It can really provide core insights and deeper, more comprehensive understanding about our clients. And it can tell us about our clients judgment and decision making. I love psychodynamics I always use it as a mitigator. Whenever I evaluate clients, I always think in the back of my mind, about social work about psychological issues, psychiatric issues, developmental issues, I think about what's in the psi. But I think psychodynamics I think what, what has brought this person to this place given unconscious decision making, that is things that they're
55:22not even aware of, because of traumas they've had, or things that are simply too threatening to think about or talk about ideas or, or experiences in their lives that can be quite embarrassing or overwhelming, this can be a source of wonderful information to understand our clients. One of the limitations here is that sometimes it's a bit of a blur between the normative and psychopathology within psychodynamics. And it's clearly not mainstream anymore. Nonetheless, it provides wonderful information to me as a mitigation expert. Then, of course, we just have a mitigation evaluation, which, you know, I have a bias as a mitigation evaluator, but I believe that they are just crucial. They really exist in a way that serves to undercover in a systemic, holistic manner, wide range of issues that can be extremely helpful. In the memorandum of law, presented by the lawyer for sentencing purposes, it is crucial to interweave the criteria of 18 USC 3553, a into key mitigation factors outlined in the mitigation report. This will afford the prosecutor judge to consider and understand the client's psychosocial issues as legal mitigating factors rather than simply background information established for the sake of general argument. So that is, you know, criminal mitigation is not simply an effective tool for the sake of argument. But it's a necessary factual underpinning to support the factors of 18 USC 3553, a and other relevant case law. And quite frankly, in the post Booker age, and that's where we are now, the court now has unfettered
57:05discretion, to consider any and all mitigating evidence and to understand the client, and given his own particular idiosyncrasies and understand him as an individual with his own needs, and whatever challenges he's experienced in his life. So with mitigation, it's really possible to show the signs development and even symptoms of psychopathology, without the diagnosis itself. And that's also very important because sometimes our clients, in fact, do have an antisocial personality disorder. In fact, sometimes our clients do present with psychopathy. And of course, those are very damaging, and stigmatizing diagnoses. And sometimes it's better to tease out those particular criteria to understand who our clients are, and present our clients and get a better understanding of their decision making given these criteria, rather than simply labeling them without a complete understanding of how they got to be where they are. The disadvantage of mitigation I try to be fair, is that its does not seem to be widely widely used. I think, criminal mitigate criminal defense lawyers would probably say they use criminal mitigation and they have criminal mitigation experts come in where they feel it's appropriate, I certainly understand that I would never second guess, the criminal defense lawyer in any case. My sense is, it's probably not used nearly as much as it could be used. There's some sense, obviously about the cost of criminal mitigation, especially if it's a CGA case to have it approved, because it's almost a week
58:42worth of work to do a particular case, especially if the individuals incarcerated, interviewing family members and so on. And yet, it can sometimes provide just a wonderful range of information to counter the psi is really the most effective and strategic tool for the criminal defense lawyer and of course, ultimately, to the clients benefit. So I just want to say a little bit about mitigation. We don't have that much time. mitigation is of course, a bio psychosocial evaluation of the client's social and psychological history, informed by the facts of the criminal case with appropriate recommendations as a means to minimize the negative legal outcome either in court or of course with the prosecutor is so relevant now, as I mentioned the beginning because the prosecutors have so much power given the shift in the court system. mitigating circumstances reduces the grip the degree of moral culpability or blame which in fairness, sympathy or mercy may lead to a more favorable outcome for the defendant. It's interesting that in 2012, the American Bar Association House of Delegates adopted Resolution 107 C, which open quotes, formally urges criminal defense attorneys to address client civil, legal and non legal problems to link Is with other service providers. The report accompany the resolution makes it clear that all defense lawyers are required to provide comprehensive representation, including using other service providers, such as social workers, mitigation experts, and so on. I'm a lawyer myself. And one of the
1:00:18things, you know, I really saw in contrast between law school and psychology and social work was that one of the first things they tell you in social work, graduate school is not just how you can help your client because obviously, you can help your client as professional but to know what resources apart from your own expertise can help you understand your client and can help your client better with their needs. And I found that was a little bit missing when I was in law school that we were sort of being taught that we need to become experts in a particular area after law school and to help our clients in the most competent manner possible, of course, but that I think, for many of us, having come out of law school, or maybe even while we were in law school, it seemed that we needed help ourselves, we needed to know what other resources could best, explain who our clients are and what their needs are. On the next slide, explain that sometimes using two experts is very important. And this is specifically important in child pornography cases. And I've done many of these cases where they've been bifurcated. I'm not sure if you're familiar with it, but it means basically having someone like myself do a mitigation evaluation, a holistic psychosocial report, but having also a psychological expert come in to use a standardized investigative tool such as the sv 20, to determine the risk that that individual may pose to others in the community or to other family members. Having the mitigation expert and having the outside
1:01:54expert, use a standardized tool tend to have these two reports complement and balance one another one that is much more investigative and background driven with clinical expertise. And the other one, the tool which is really seem to be objective in in nature, I think can sometimes help these clients to great deal, and I've used them in several Adam Walsh Act cases. It's never too early obviously, to get a mitigation expert, it should be done as early as possible, especially before the psi is undertaken. The state, the same strategy can be employed with regard to the prosecutor that is before the prosecutor forms, biases and prejudices against the client, the prosecutor can read the mitigation report and become disabused of assumptions that may be false or not fully held. In fact, it's really never too late. It's never too early to get a report like this, as they say in Chicago, you know, vote early vote often for mitigation as well really try to undertake a mitigation report as early as possible, not just to get the information for the mitigation report itself and to count to the psi so that the lawyer, himself or herself can gain a broader and more detailed understanding, given the mitigation expertise clinically, as to how to proceed and if there are any red flags, or maybe any areas that seem quite positive, strategically to work with. The purpose of the mitigation report ultimately is to humanize the client through a systemic narrative, induce empathy for the reader, document the client's life history.
1:03:33contextualize the client's conduct. Explain if there's any family issues, dependencies, interpersonal issues, illustrate the client's community involvement educational employment eyes, split the client explain the client's remorse and regret his contrition, it's important to really understand that professional expression can replace self expression that the mitigation report allows a professional to express mitigating factors on behalf of the client in a way that can really replace the client's own thoughts and feelings because the client just does not have the education or the emotional wherewithal or the general ability to convey those on his own. mitigation is not just a mental health report, countering the psi is a strategic tool. It's a strategic tool, as a mental health report that looks very broadly at the person's psychosocial background.
1:04:31It is there to dispel abuses and biases and perceived patterns of behavior that may not be real. This is particularly important for our clients who have committed crimes with regard to child pornography, because it's so often assumed that their clients are monsters that they've done something that is reprehensibly wrong. We really want to explain as much as possible, in context what the client has done. Sometimes the mitigation report can be a peace offering can counter the government's pre sentence report, of course. And sometimes it can just be used as a strategic consulting tool for the criminal defense lawyers. Psi officers are not clinical experts, they don't have that clinical expertise and a clinical expert, I think, through the mitigation report, assuming that, you know, the mitigation expert has clinical expertise, as I assume he or she does, can find all sorts of issues that the psi officer simply would not know about, not because they're doing anything wrong, but just because they don't have the training, or the mental health background. This is, again, so crucial in child pornography cases, where we really want to understand this individual because so often, you can't argue that the person did something that was aberrant, because many of these child pornography cases the individual individual has been looking at this pornography for years and, and years at a time and they've looked at different kinds of pornography, they are often they've downloaded it, they have shared it with other
1:06:02individuals in the community. And you really want to explain how this person sometimes is not a monster does not have terrible animus towards other people, but is simply misguided, how the person has made terrible mis judgment, and how that person has made such terrible decisions that has impacted their life. And how they have proceeded to where they are today. As I said, this is very similar to white collar cases, where because the person has a $3,000 suit on and they went to good schools, they had a good education, they had a good professional career, an intact family and so on. It's assumed that they're monsters, because they've had all the privileges and yet they did something so bad.
1:06:39And it's just the opposite, you need to pick up the home, you can look inside and understand who the individual is, given any non mitigating mitigating issues. Clearly the clients need to be be prepared early, they need to be the right frame of mind. You need to eliminate anger and defensiveness, they must show contrition, there must be an opportunity for them to gain trust with me with a mitigation expert, I find so often the most basic problem with the psi officer is that the client just doesn't feel trust, they feel like you're not on my side, you're working for the government. And the person is guarded, the person is reluctantly suspicious to really sometimes reveal the most important information that could be to their benefit. And finally, the clients who benefit the most from this, I find that those clients with clear mental health issues, but also subtle mental health issues or recurrent mental health problems, those clients who have suffered extreme hardships, those clients who have suffered childhood traumas or history of abuse, clients who have inter family dependency issues, clients with poor language skills that cannot advocate for themselves in a clear manner or with poor executive skills related to decision making. clients who fear authority may even fear their own lawyer to times because their lawyer is very educated and knowledgeable. And they may be embarrassed given their own lack of education or given the crimes that they've committed because they're so embarrassed by them. Very often, there's a confluence of mental health
1:08:05and social deficits. And because of this, the mitigation again, could really help counter the psi, I'm not here, to really say the psi needs to be put aside, what I need to really get across throughout this seminar, as I conclude is to say, the psi needs to be critiqued, we need to understand the strength, the psi and what is true and real. And we need to understand the deficits of the psi, and where it's misleading in a sense, or where it's incomplete regarding family mental health or whatnot. It's very similar to our own clients that have suffered challenges. And we have an incomplete understanding about themselves. So we have a times an incomplete understanding about the psi. And I've tried to show what is the best way to critique it? What are the major problems with the psi? And of course, what are the major strategic tools by clinical experts to help understand our client in a way separate from the psi and separate from what the criminal defense attorney has gained through his or her own work? Again, I thank you very, very much for listening today. I hope this has been informative. And I hope it's really provided you a much greater sense and a much greater understanding about strategic thinking going forward as a criminal defense lawyer, what tools to use, when to use them, and hopefully not only for your own benefit, but obviously for the benefit of our clients. Thank you.