0:00Good morning. My name is JJ Abrams. And I'm here to present my lecture the body and soul of business valuation. And thank you for spending your time with me today. A little bit about my background, and I'll announce the slides that we're we're now on slide number two. So my background is I I'm the Business appraiser. I've worked in it since 1983. When I started with Arthur D, little valuation. Previous to that I ran, founded and ran a two way radio sales and service business with my brother that still lives in existence. And before that, I was a CPA with Arthur Andersen and Company. To the right in the slide, you'll see picture files for pictures of the covers of my books, quantitative business valuation published in its first edition by McGraw Hill and second edition by Wiley and Sons 2002 1010 copyrights and how to value your business and increase its potential. The first book, quantitative business valuation is something like business, valuation 501 Very heavy mathematical tome, I would say, hands down the most mathematical treatise in our field. It is used in graduate schools and undergraduate schools, not only in the US, but also throughout the world, Russia, Germany, India, etc.
1:41And how to value your business and increase its potential is a book for the lay business business owner, and they're professionals. They're attorneys and accountants. And then I have a fourth book, which is mostly written but not yet published, called how to value S corporations, and pass through entities, an extremely mathematical tome on valuation of pass through entities. I received my MBA from University of Chicago in 1982. And I also had graduate work in the Department of Economics at the same university. And I've invented over 150 mathematical formulas in my field, as well as quite a number of models and algorithms, etc.
2:30That covers slides two, and three. And pretty much slide number four. Okay, slide number five. My goals for you today are the following. One is to provide you with a working understanding of business valuation, which hopefully should enable you to help ensure that the appraiser correctly defines the valuation assignment. Even correctly, measuring the wrong value can make it can spell disaster for your client. To help provide important information that the appraiser needs to know, and ask for to help you to be able to ask good questions and be an active participant in the valuation process, and possibly affect the outcome for the better.
3:21Basically, appraisers know the numbers well, and you know the client usually better than we do. And you also know the law, well, much better than we do. And some of the danger points occur when you know something that we need to know, but you don't know that we need to know it. So the more you understand about business valuation, the better you'll be at sensing what we need to know. Okay, slide number six, to help you do your own quick and dirty valuation. So even before you bring an appraiser in at this, after taking this course, today, I would hope that you could get to a rough order of magnitude of value, and maybe b plus or minus a third or plus or minus a half.
4:15Also to help you select the right appraiser, we'll talk about what what elements go into that choice. And to help you develop the intuition whether or not your appraiser or you're the one you're considering has the critical insight necessary to do the work right. Okay, next slide number seven. Here's some examples of being an active participant in the valuation process. The first was my own unfortunate experience in the cancer world. My my late wife was who passed away 19 years ago, in 1990s. Seven was diagnosed with metastatic breast cancer in 1991. And I plunged myself into the medical world and did quite a lot of research.
5:19We had been told by five doctors, three surgeons, a radiation oncologist, and a medic, and a medical oncologist that she needed radical mastectomy right away. I asked our medical oncologist for, for articles on breast cancer, and she had her secretary give, prepare a handful of journal articles, which I read. And one of them was an article that she herself probably didn't read, I don't really know for sure, but I'm surmising it was by the doctors at the MD Anderson Clinic at the University of Texas. And this article said, Don't do surgery first, do chemotherapy first to shrink the tumor before you do any surgery. So I read and reread the article, and then I called up doctors at the MD Anderson Hospital, actually, I I prepared a fax to send to them with medical information about her case, all the data. And I said, I read your article. And it seems to me that it would apply to her. Yet all our doctors are telling us to do radical mastectomy, just not even a simple mastectomy. And they.
6:47So I would like to know, if you feel given the fact that I've given you that, that she should have chemotherapy first, they agreed with that. And I use that as you can only fight fire with bigger fire. I'm not a doctor, and I don't have a science undergraduate. But the doctors at MD Anderson agreed that that we should do it that way. And I got our doctors to agree to it. Although I had to let our radio radiation oncologist go, because she screamed at me for having the hutzpah to interfere with the medical process. So I had to have her removed from the case and get somebody who was a little more user friendly on the case.
7:33And it turned out the chemotherapy was so successful that, that my that that she didn't have any surgery at all. And the cancer never returned to the breast. So I know that that prolonged her life. And as well as the increased the quality of her life, compared to what she would it would have been had, she had a radical mastectomy. So so my my boys were nine and six when she passed away, and I'm sure that if she had that surgery, she would have passed away at least two or three years earlier. And that made a huge difference in the lives of my son's who are now almost 26 and 29 years old. So that's an example of a non expert acquiring some expertise in a field that's not his own, and making a meaningful difference in the process. Similarly, I would like you as attorneys to be able to be knowledgeable enough in appraisal, that you can ask intelligent questions, and you can be an active participant in the process. The second bullet point on slide number seven is about a Doctor Joseph Stein in San Diego, who was a client of mine on a construction defect case. I believe this was in the late 1980s. So it's a long time ago.
9:10And I just remember him as being very smart, asking really good questions. And one of the questions that he asked actually got me to rethink one of my calculations, and it made a significant change in the numbers. So we're not perfect. Everybody makes mistakes, has blind spots. And it's not what I did was wrong, but just he saw something that was better, better thought out. So there's another example. There is an example of a doctor becoming, you know, meaningfully affecting the appraisal process. And then, then there's the attorneys who question me, and unfortunately, there's too few of them. I would say probably not more than 5% of the The attorneys whom I work for, ask any difficult questions of me.
10:06And while it sometimes can be annoying, honestly, to have to go the extra miles to answer the questions, I actually really respect that that the attorneys are paying very close attention. On the other hand, I also appreciate sometimes being able to breathe through without without too much question. So it's ultimately up to you. But you can decide to be one of those active participants in valuation. That's what another one of my goals for today. Okay, and again, slide number eight attorney as an active participant, our expertise is in the number, the numbers and hopefully, the conception of the numbers.
10:50How we approach the problem, your expertise is in the law, and also in the facts of the case. And you also have a perspective of some distance from the numbers, sometimes we're so close to them, that sometimes we can't see something that's right in front of us, usually we can. But again, you as an active participant can meaningfully and positively affect our work. Alright, we're now in slide nine, we're going to do an overview of what we're what we're going to be covering today. The first item was goals, which we've already done. The second bullet point is the power of metaphor, I'm going to be talking about different metaphors, and I'm going to use a few of them to help explain the not only what we do, but why we do it and the and the importance of
11:50being as right as we can and
11:55and the importance of the help of the attorney in the process. Third, sorry, the third bullet point is the body and soul of evaluation, just like people have bought and sold, valuations also have the same and we'll talk about what that means. Number four, we'll talk about the right paradigm, which is the winning or the losing insight. Moving to slide number 10. We're going to do talk about the infrastructure evaluation, which I likened to the concrete slab underneath the house. It's not the house, but what if you don't have the infrastructure than the house is going to tip over and collapse. So the infrastructure consists of the premise of value standard of value and valuation approaches.
12:48Then we go to the structure of valuation. And the structure of valuation is basically evaluate that valuation methods which are the techniques as well as the adjustments, the premiums or discounts for the degree of control and marketability of the interest that we're valuing. Okay, and in slide 11, we will be talking about reconciling the DCF, which is discounted cash flow method and the market methods. We'll talk about valuing S corporations and pass through entities and probabilistic valuation models. Slide 12 We'll talk about demonstrating expert bias. We'll talk about how value grows, how accurate our evaluations choosing an appraiser, how attorneys can help appraiser and common valuation errors.
13:44We're now at slide number 13, which is model paradigms. And we're going to talk about the Black Scholes model.
14:00The Black Scholes model is that for bidding looking equation on the top, P stands for price is the expected value and as a cumulative normal density function D one and D two are these parameters that consist of the other the other variables below. I don't expect to I don't expect you to memorize it or to even understand it. It's, it's enough for appraisers to understand it and a lot of us don't.
14:37The importance of the Black Scholes model is as follows This is a
14:43this is a model for calculating the value of a stock option. Interestingly enough, the same equation if you translate the variables into physical quantities, not only explains The the way stock options are priced. But it also explains the way that heat moves through a thin wire. It's called the heat exchange equation in physics. And it also explains the distribution of galaxies to the universe. So I'm told by a cosmologists
15:25so and that that covers slide 14 as well. So one single equation explains three such diverse phenomena. Obviously, there's something common to all of that. A radiation physicist friend of mine thinks that it's probably the mathematics of randomness. And randomness affects all three different phenomenon. So just as there are physical metaphor there are than an equation can be a metaphor for measuring different phenomenon. So there are also physical metaphors for valuation. And I want to, and I want to demonstrate that with a physical demonstration because people relate to physical things more easily than two conceptual items. Hi, we're back here with a neighbor of mine from down the hall. gentleman named Elliot Wedeman, who's 27 years old, and about six foot four, I'm 64 years old.
16:29And I used to be five, nine, and we're now there's the Incredible Shrinking Man is down to about five, seven and a half. Okay, and maybe 161 pounds or so. So he's got the advantage of size and age over me. But we're going to, I'm going to show you a little bit about from I have 43 years of martial arts training. So I'm going to show you a couple of interesting things from martial arts, which will serve as a metaphor for evaluation, again, the body and the soul of the techniques and as well as the body and the soul of evaluation. So the first thing I'd like to demonstrate is what makes for a good stance.
17:15The first thing I teach anybody, when someone comes into our karate dojo, which is in place of training is how to make a good stance. So there's different types of stances. Also, two of them, one is front stance, and one is back stance. So front stance is basically like this. Now, the elements that make a good front stance is that my body needs to be sort of this way and not to not to, with my trunk turned in very much, should be more this way. My back foot should be in my knee should be low, and it should be over this way and not collapsed in this direction. And no, no upper body power, just relaxed and breathing through. So now, it's Elliott, who's, how much do you weigh up to 20 to 20. And I'm 160. So he's got, he's got about 60 pounds on me. Okay, he pushes and I want you to push through not not sort of up or down. Okay, pushes on me my stance, my stance holds. Now, if he does the same thing, he does the same thing. But I have my hips back like this. Okay.
18:28So yeah,
18:31no chance against the guy who's much bigger than I am. Also, if I, if my front knee is sort of lazy and a little bit collapsed, even if my hips are in when he pushes on me, and go ahead, I can't I can't hold if my back foot is pointing out, and everything else is right. And he pushes on me, I still, I still can't hold. All right. Now basically, we can do the same thing with back stance. back stance is a little more the way it's more on the back foot. And it's kind of 90 degree angle. But I'm showing my side edge of my body. So again, when he pushes straight on me, my stance, my stance, more or less hold. Okay, if I if my if my knee collapses a little bit
19:30Not a chance. If if my hips are back,
19:36not a chance.
19:39If my if this knee if this knee is lazy over here, and then even if everything else is right, he pushes me back. So there's there's lots of little subtle things. Oh and the other. The other thing too is if everything else is just right, but my body my trunk is turned in a little too much And he pushes, what happens is that his energy goes into me and it looks for a weak point to escape. And if it finds one, then my stance doesn't work. If it doesn't find one, his energy goes into me, it goes right back to him. No point of escape. And we'll see that valuations are like that. Okay, the next next demonstration I'd like to make is about the the body and the soul of a technique. Okay, so we have a technique that we call the unbendable arm.
20:39First, I'm going to have Elliot tried to bend my bend my elbow back. And at first, I'm going to resist him with just my conscious power, just pure muscle power, which is mainly going to be upper body power. So go ahead
21:05he's not totally overwhelming me. But I'm sort of fighting a losing game. And eventually, his youth will overwhelm me at my age. So we got to get older guys have to work a little smarter than that. So they the second, the real l essence of the unbendable arm, is instead of resisting him with my conscious power, I do it with unconscious power, focusing on my breathing going through, going from my navel through my arm through him, and no upper body power at all. So go ahead again.
21:57Yeah, what do you got to iron sleeve. So that's what I call the soul of a technique. The body of the technique is just putting my arm out there with some reasonable form and no upper body power. The soul of the technique is the breathing, going through, focusing on the breathing going through me through him through the wall, forever. It's interesting. I'm an Orthodox Jew, the Hebrew language. The there are three languages for for levels of different levels of the soul, called Rua nephesh. And the Shama. And all three are related to breathing. Rua, not only means the crude animal spirit, but it also means wind. And it also means a part of our sort of like a lower part of our soul. nephesh is related to the word vagina. fosh Shabbat Vina frosh, also a level of breathing. And the Shama is the third level of soul, the highest level of soul is related to the word and the Shema, which is, which is breathing. So, there's a, there's an obvious structural connection in the Hebrew language between breathing in the soul. And you can see how breathing is also the interface of the mind in the body. And the, the different levels of soul exists in the blood and in the brain. So that's basically sort of like the mind and the body.
23:40The way the way you can think of it as this, what is your breathing, like, when you are tense and angry, your breathing is going to be fast and shallow.
23:53What is your breathing like when you're relaxed, it's slow and deep. So your breathing is a result of your mental and emotional state. On the other hand, if we take conscious control of our breathing, we can reverse the direction of causation. And that is that if you're tense and angry, and you catch yourself being tense and angry, and you know your breathing is short and shallow, and you feel lousy, you can just stop and say 10 deep breaths, I don't accept this.
24:30Very slow breathing in one breath, I can change my mental state and 10 I can completely transform and everybody can do that. So we can see the connection of the mind and the body. So the breathing is the interface between the mind and the body, and the emotions and it's also really our interface with this level of soul. So we're going to use that as a metaphor for business valuation because evaluation has its body, which are its techniques. But it also has a soul which has to do with the inspiration of the appraiser, the, the conception of what this is all about the left, the right left brain connection, all of that has to do with the soul of the valuation beyond just the pure techniques and mathematics which make up the body of the valuation. Now that that concludes this little section, the physical demonstration of metaphor. And we're gonna take a short break just to reassemble the camera in and go back to my original position. Catch you in a minute. Okay, we're back.
25:46We're at the bottom of slide number 15. So, just as we have power beyond our physical strength, the soul of the valuation goes beyond the sum of its technical components. Slide 16. Now let's talk about the body of valuation. The body of valuation is the models, the techniques, the methods and the formulas. A bad assumption is or a technique etc, is like hips out in the stance, the opponent can push you over. Opposing expert will demolish you. And opposing counsel will demolish one who's got a bad assumption. So a series of good assumptions might make a good stance, but it's still kind of lacks that the force, the force, as, as we, as you saw from the unbendable arm technique is something is there's something in the soul of the valuation that goes beyond just the pure physical and scientific. Slide 17. So what is that that's the imagination in the creativity, intuition, the passion, the critical insight, and the integrity of the appraiser.
27:01My latest published article and called and how does value grow. Chasing short term income destroys long term value published in business valuation review in October 2015. That article inside me is a living breathing entity, I conceived it from the beginning, it took me months to write to a lot of mathematics in it, some pretty complicated mathematics. It's, it exists as a living entity within me, and it, in a certain sense possessed me. Unlike somebody who reads it, I lived it for months before submitting it for publication, can can't quite get the same passion of from reading something as creating it from nothing.
27:53Slide number 18. All right, the soul of evaluation is a fusion of the right and the left brain. So the left brain should have critical insight in Jewish mysticism, in Hasidic philosophy, the the right side I'm doing mirror image for you the right side represents the side of kindness, which is also the side of openness. And the left side represents the side of restriction boundary, it's called, it's called strength Gore in Hebrew hesed is the left side, sorry, the right side before the left sign. And the left side is has to do with drawing boundaries between you and others. The right side is openness. So the left side, the left side is this critical insight, which requires being discerning requires mental probity.
28:58Being able to logically justify every single step along the way to whereas the right side is the creative the creativity and the inspiration. Right side is is about being open the left side is about being close. First, you have the first you have the flash of inspiration, thinking uncritically until you until one finds the the right, the right paradigm, the right metaphor for the valuation assignment, and then the left brain takes over being very critical scrutinize scrutinizing everything closely, being very detailed in the calculations etc. But a right a left brain without a right brain is still lacking something it may do all the it may do a lot of correct calculations, but it may miss the point entirely. It requires one Having that, that inspiration, creativity and passion that comes from the, the comes from the right side. So the left side also, besides critical insight has the organization and the integrity.
30:15Slide number 19.
30:19The fusion of the right and left side is a difficult achievement. It's a, it's essentially achieving the 710 split and rolling the fusion of opposites. And it's much easier to be strictly technical, or to be strictly inspirational. Being strictly inspirational doesn't really work well in valuation, it can work a lot better in art. But even art requires some technical skill and really a lot of technical skill. But valuation is much too mathematical to survive strictly on inspiration. But if there's no inspiration, all the all the techniques and the calculations and the models and the formulas and the footnotes and everything else is may still entirely missed the point, because maybe that appraiser just sees the wrong paradigm to begin with, and goes about making lots of correct calculations for the whole wrong concept.
31:27Okay, so technique without inspiration is lifeless and lacks impact on the reader of the report or the jury who's listening to the jury and the judge is listening to testimony. But inspiration without discernment, discipline and organization leads to muddle headed drivel. Slide 20. Here's some quotes from quotes for some great physicists. So from first from Einstein, Imagination is more important than knowledge. As knowledge is limited to all that we know and understand, while imagination embraces the entire world, and all there ever will be to know and understand. He's a pretty good authority.
32:12And then Richard Feynman Fineman in 1965, he was a Nobel Prize winning physicist, said, a new idea is extremely difficult to think of it takes a fantastic imagination, from the book, the character of physical law.
32:32And my own quote is that a scientist has to be a great artist. Otherwise, he's just a technician.
32:42We're now on slide 23. The right paradigm. Basically, we appraisers win or lose a valuation based on whether we choose the right paradigm or not. This requires creativity, critical insight, technical mastery and cool under pressure. Something I learned as a graduate student in the Department of Economics at University of Chicago, and something that they didn't really teach so much in the MBA program, was the importance of understanding the intuition of any mathematical model. We start with usually one or a series of assumptions, which we then translate into mathematical formulas. And we work the math until we come to a solution.
33:35But our professors always taught us what's trying to understand what's the intuition of your final solution, that final formula doesn't make sense in your gut? Or does it not make sense and if it doesn't make sense, you should be disturbed about it. And keep going until it does make sense.
33:58So let's take a look at a at a at sort of the paradigm valuation model. It's called the Gordon model multiple. It was
34:11actually developed by John burr Williams in 1939. But somehow, it was later repackaged, and somehow became known as the Gordon model after Eli Gordon. And if, if Gordon's PR guy is still around, I would really like to hire your services because that's, that's a real accomplishment to get your name on somebody else's model. Anyway, the Gordon growth model for valuing a mature firm that has constant growth and cash flows, he actually used it for for valuing and based on his dividends. So that model is the multiple have cash flow is one over r minus g, where r is the discount rate that we use the investment rate of return that we use to discount future cash flows to present value. And g is the constant growth rate and cash flows.
35:18Now, even if they're even if the growth rates are not constant, if let's say, instead of being a mature firm, if it's an early stage firm, there is in my article, how does value grow, there is a rate called G star, which is the basically weighted average present value of
35:44a present value weighted average of, of the future growth rates of the firm, there is a unique g star that will act just just the same income to the same value as if the firm had constant growth. And we can calculate that g star, that's part of my article, how does value grow. So one over r minus g, this is assuming what we call and your cash flows, which is not the most accurate for businesses, it's good for valuing bonds, business's cash flows occur evenly throughout the year. So the mid year Gordon model, which is the square root of one plus r over r minus g is actually more accurate, but let's just stick with the simpler model for intuition sake.
36:32So let's assume that a small business has a discount rate of 25%. That means it's kind of risky, it's quite risky. And the buyer of such a business would want to have a 25% rate of return to compensate him or her for the risk that they're undertaking in buying such a small risky business. And let's assume that the constant growth rate of cash flows is 5% a year. So the Gordon model would be one over point 25 minus point oh five, which is equal to one over point two, which equals five. So we're at the bottom of 24. Moving on to slide 25.
37:18So that's we're willing to pay $5 Today, for each dollar of cash flow that we're forecasting to receive one year from now, and which will grow at 5% a year. So we're expecting then $1 of cash flow in year one, $1.05, in year, two $1.10, and a quarter, in the year three, et cetera, et cetera. So we're, the investor would be willing to pay $5 Today, for each dollar of cash flow next year. And if we're forecasting $10 million of cash flow next year, then the valuation of this firm would be 10 million times five, or $50 million. As a starting point, before we make any adjustments for differences in marketability or control of the interest that we're valuing.
38:15And the publicly held firms from which we calculated this 25% rate of return. Now, let's go to slide 26. If we let g decrease to 0%, that means now instead of expecting cash flows to grow at 5% a year they we expect them not to grow at all, in nominal terms, which means if there is positive inflation, which there always has been in my lifetime so far, then that's actually a real decline in in cash flow. So the Gordon model multiple will now change to one over point 25 minus zero, which is one over point 25, which is a multiple of four. So now the valuation of the firm goes down from $50 million to $40 million. So that is a 20. To 20% decline in the value of the business from this change from from going from a firm that has the 5% of your growth to zero growth. And that makes sense, you would rather buy a firm that has growth rather than the firm that has no growth. So therefore the value goes down when the growth disappears.
39:38If we make a different change, and we change the discount rate the our if it decreases from 25% to 20%.
39:48So one over point two minus point oh five back to the 5% of your growth
39:56which is one over point 15 equals A 6.6666 forever or rounded 6.7. So the valuation would increase from $50 million to $67 million, that's 6.7 times 10,000,060 7 million. So the value increased big because the, somehow we have judged that the risk of the firm has decreased. And that makes sense. The higher the risk, the lower the value, the lower the risk, the higher the value. So we're testing out the intuition of the primary valuation model that we use. Now, when we get later on to business cash flows. And business valuation, we will find that there, there can be more complications in the process, if we're valuing each year's cash flow separately for a while. But ultimately, all valuations eventually settle down to constant growth forever, at some point. And I'm just showing how the intuition behind this model makes sense. Okay, that's part of, I guess, you could say it's a little bit both right brain and left brain because it takes left brain activity to do the math and to change the things around, but it's a little bit right brain to be looking for the intuition behind the math.
41:40Okay, we're on slide 27. I'd like to give some
41:47some examples of winning and losing paradigms that, that I've seen and experienced in my career.
41:58About a year ago, one of our clients was audited by the IRS, which in this was a valuation of a receivable from a private split dollar contract. The IRS has gotten very active in auditing this particular asset. In business valuation, we've actually had very few audits. But the IRS now routinely audits, virtually all of these private split dollar valuations. And the IRS appraiser chosen appraiser
42:39conceived, he chose the paradigm of a bond, valuation bond bond like risk of, of the receivable. And the way it works is this is the these, the structure is is that usually grandparents will take out a life insurance policy, perhaps they'll they'll take out a five or $10 million life insurance policy, sorry, they'll pay 5 million or $10 million for a policy on the lives of their children, with their grandchildren has beneficiaries and it and so they'll get usually some sort of universal universal life insurance. And this is a technique for the very wealthy, it's not for not for most people.
43:40And the the grandparent by the split dollar agreement, usually the grandparents estate, upon the death of their children is due the greater of the the premium that the grandparents put out for the policy of the children and the cash surrender value of the life insurance policy. Now life insurance policies generally come with a enforced illustration from the insurance company and we will get the information illustration on the valuation data as close as possible to it. And And usually, it comes in two forms, one is the non guaranteed values and the second are the guaranteed values. The non guaranteed values are based on historical performance, and often are in the five and a half to 6% annual rate of return. And those are the cash flows that we use. In forecasting the cash surrender value of the policy.
44:49The guaranteed values are usually much lower and maybe two and a half or 3% growth and those often will last apps before, they'll often lapse by the time the children are in their, let's say, 60s or 70s. So that it means that there's a substantial probability that the children will out live the life of the policy. The IRS appraiser said, well, the the life insurance contract is from this big life in a huge life insurance company. And we'll use their their bond rates, the rates that they pay on the bonds that when they're borrowing money, we'll use that rate is mainly V rate that maybe they'll make a slight adjustment upwards, but pretty much these are bond rates. So it might be, they might be discounting cash flows at a six and a half to seven and a half percent discount rate. And we were using in the old days, we would use 30 or 35%. And since then it's kind of calmed down to about a 15% discount rate is sort of our usual discount rate. The IRS appraiser attacked us saying that this is this is crazy, this this, the series of cash flows are is based on a life insurance policy, we use the bond rate, we countered and explained, I'd say the main thrust of our reasoning for using the higher discount rate is that bonds are a contract that fixed when somebody borrow when a company borrows money, let's say it issues $1,000 Bond and is going to pay, let's say a 5% rate of interest on that bond or 7% rate of interest.
46:54Those interest payments and the repayment of principal are fixed by contract. Unless the borrower is going to default which has its own severe consequences to it, the borrower has to pay that amount. However, the we cannot use a bond type discount rate on these non guaranteed values because there's a probability of something like usually half to two thirds, that the policy will lapse while the while the insured is still alive, and therefore the insured would pass away. And Oh, for sure, for sure, would owe only the the $10 million, let's say paid for the premium, but they won't have a policy to collect the $10 million since the policy lapse. So they'll end up paying back nothing. So the investor in this asset would has a substantial probability of getting nothing. So there's an example of the right paradigm versus the wrong paradigm. The IRS appraiser made all the correct calculations, but his conception of what this is all about was wrong. So that's an example of what I would call missing the soul of the valuation and just having a lifeless body.
48:27Number two, on page 27, the subterfuge increase the risk of their business. This was a case where I had valued a client a couple of times for gift tax purposes. And then some years later, a big box wholesaler wanted to sell their product and my clients a manufacturer of sporting goods sold very high end product that 1000s of dollars for a unit and the big box wholesaler wanted to buy and and keep their product in their stores. And they said no, we use a dealer network. It requires a lot of training. You have to have a service department. The salespeople have to be very well trained to be able to sell it and a big box wholesalers just the wrong kind of place to show our product so no we can't sell it to you.
49:24Big Box wholesaler initiates a subterfuge and
49:31and obtains about 100 units of my clients product. When their dealer network found out about it, they went wild because the big box wholesaler is selling the product a lot cheaper than they are. It really rankled their dealer network. They had to have their dealers buy back the buy back the units at at the big box store. stores retail price. And they had to reimburse them for it. And then they initiated a lawsuit against the wholesaler.
50:13So the attorney there, their litigation attorney called me and explained all of this and said, Can you calculate damages for us? So I said, Well, have sales declined since this tort. No sales are up is net income down. No net income is up. That's it is not going to be so not so easy. It's one thing to say that they did. They did us wrong. It's another thing to be able to prove damages and quantify them credibly. It took me about probably 20 seconds of extreme right brain activity to finally for the the right paradigm to pop into my head. And that is even though we can't show that there's any current loss of sales or income.
51:16This tort increased the risk of their business. And just like Arthur Andersen, which is one of my business, alma mater's,
51:28it was the largest CPA firm in its time 85,000 professionals, I believe, it's either 85,000 professionals or 85,000 total employees.
51:41The after the Enron scandal broke, the firm had a big black eye. But it survived. But then when Worldcom happened, that was the end, the first trauma weakened the company. And the second second one was a death blow to a weakened firm. So I use that as metaphor here, that this is the first blow. And you've weaken the firm, you've made it riskier. So what what we did was to forecast a probability distribution of the effect of this tort on the discount rate that an investor would require. Now, we don't know the exact rate that any one investor would require, is nobody can know that with exactness. But we made a probability distribution saying we believe that there's perhaps a 3% or 5% probability that there's no effect, that there's maybe a 20% probability that it will increase the discount rate more than zero, and let's say up to a half a percent. So one quarter of a percent as the midpoint, another percentage probability that will increase somewhere between half a percent and 1%. So there's average of point 75%, etc. And we came to a weighted average increase in the discount rate of I believe it was either 1% or 2%. Reasonable calculation. And we just did a valuation of the firm, actually discounted profits of the firm without the tort, and then with the tort using the same forecast sales and net income. I did not fight about sales or profits, not going down. As a matter of fact, we did it. I did a calculation to see i forecast how much sales and net income should have been up, which was about 15%. Since
54:02the start, and they were right on target. So my forecast shows that the that there was no immediate effect whatsoever on sales or net income. I did not fight about that. And the opposing counsel in in my deposition was so astonished that I didn't fight about that. He must have asked me the question eight or 10 times the same question over and over again. And I finally said, I've already answered this question. Many times and the answer is always the same. I'm not I'm not saying there's any effect on current profits and current sales. There is a probability that the firm is more vulnerable now.
54:49That if something significant happens, something significantly negative happens in the future, that this first blow weaken them and will and then there will be an effect at some future time, hard to forecast what it is impossible to forecast when it will be, or even if it will be. But we can measure this by an increase in the rate of return that a rational investor would require. If you had two identical firms, one is my client. And second one is twin brother of my client. And the difference is twin brother didn't have this tort against them. Well, any rational investor would would want to invest in twin brother, and would require a discount in order to invest in my client. Similarly, and I use this metaphor, I said, Imagine yourself, test driving a new Mercedes.
55:53You love the car, it's beautiful. You come, you stopped at a red light, and somebody comes from behind and hits your car at 10 or 15 miles an hour. You're kind of shaken.
56:10This the sales, the salesman, sales agents, they're with you in the car, get back to the agency.
56:19And you see there's like, you know, there's some paint, there's some looks like a little bit of bumper damage, etc. Nothing doesn't look like anything's major. But you never know what goes on inside the car. So the salesman says, Well, you liked the car. I said, I love it. Would you like to buy it? Yes, I'd like one just like this. All sorry. This is the only one that we've got right now. But we we can fix this up? You will not know that there was anything ever happened? Yeah, but I'd really like one that hasn't been hit. Yeah, but we don't have one that hasn't been hit, it'll take us a month to get the next one in in this color.
57:04Are you going to buy that car at retail? Are you going to insist on some discount? May okay, maybe they can make it look like nothing happened. But that doesn't mean that there wasn't any impact on the structure of the car, or any of its components, maybe it's been weakened. And you don't know, if you don't know, you maybe just go walk down the street and buy some other dealers, new Mercedes that hasn't had a collision. So if you're going to buy that one, you're going to insist on a discount any rational person would that that was the paradigm that I used that that I think made sense in. In this case, I like to use physical paradigms, because people relate to physical things more easily.
57:54The third, the third example of winning and losing paradigms. This was a case probably about 15 years ago or so. There was a transaction of a sale and leaseback of agricultural property in Florida. Now, I'm not a real estate appraiser. I'm a Business appraiser. And I don't value whole interest in real estate. But this but there was a lease on this property that was a 60 year lease of 15 years plus three renewal periods of 15 years each. And so one party sold the sold the land to the buyer and then leased it back. But there was a buyback provision and the the seller who now wants to be the buyer wants to buy it for cheap. And he had, he had three, he had two Real Estate Appraisers on the other side had one real estate appraiser value, the remaining 45 years lease fees, lease fee interest in the property. One side came to a valuation of $10 million. That's the original seller who wants to be the buyer. And the other side had a valuation of $20 million.
59:15And it turns out, the only thing that they disagreed about was the right discount rate. So now the original seller, now the buyer hired two business appraisers and they did evaluation and they did an excellent valuation. A lot of very impressive research. When I first read through it, I said, Wow, these guys did a really good job. And they hired me to look at the discount rate and see is this is this a reasonable discount rate or not?
59:54So I read through the lease, and one thing just popped out at me right away A is that there was no cost of living adjustments in the leaf, which is a usual provision, but it was missing here. So I said to retaining counsel, what would happen if the, if the original seller, now the buyer defaulted on the lease, they said, well, it cost us $50,000.06 months later, we would have the property back. And we could lease it out at market rates, which are, he gave me a new market rate with cost of living adjustments. So, I ran a discounted cash flow, assuming that the buyer default and
1:00:53I mean, the original seller, now the new buyer defaulted. And lo and behold, the valuation was still very high. So I what I found was, my valuation came to something like 22 and a half million dollars. So all the risk that these other business appraisers were asserting, is there for all these various reasons. just disappeared. Because the best thing that could happen to the original buyer is that the seller would would default on the lease. So that's another example of having a body of valuation that's missing a soul is missing a key point.
1:01:46Is that just purely a technical matter? Like the equivalent of having hips out? No, it's not really a technical matter, because these guys did a great job of, of showing their paradigms of various different bond rates, et cetera, et cetera. But in the end, it meant nothing, it really was kind of missing, missing the soul of the valuation. Okay, now let's go to slide number 28.
1:02:21Some great paradigms that are true in the law.
1:02:26So I asked the question, what makes Clarence Darrow, Oliver Wendell Holmes, Alan Dershowitz, and Richard Posner, whose son actually was a martial arts student of mine at the University of Chicago. What makes them a cut or several cuts above the average rank and file in in the legal profession? I don't think it's just because they had a better memory than everyone else. I don't think it was only about just say raw memory power or something purely technical. Could it be superior delivery? And if so, do they have better acting skills? Are they more genuine? In which case then maybe, maybe former actors should all become attorneys?
1:03:16Or is there something beyond that some sort of genius, some sort of mastery, passion and conviction? Or is it all of it? So I asked the question, I don't give an answer. That's for you to figure out. And now that concludes the introductory section of the lecture. And we're now at slide number 30. We begin what I call the infrastructure of valuation. It's not the structure, it's the concrete slab under the structure, so that we start the infrastructure with the premise of value, which are these, which is the assumptions in the value valuation scenario? So there's basically two premises of value that we have to deal with. One is, are we valuing a going concern? Or are we using liquidation value? In other words, is the business worth more dead or alive?
1:04:11Slide number 32. Now the answer to that is if the going concern value that's a GCV is greater than liquidation value, then we use the going concern value. If it's worth more alive, there's no question we use the valuation alive. However, if it's worth more dead than alive, then we have to ask a second question. Are we valuing a control interest or are we valuing a minority interest? Control interest has the power to liquidate the firm so it's usually reasonable to value it at liquidation value for someone because an arm's length buyer who would come in and has no emotional attachment to the business would just liquidate it and would achieve liquidation value On the other hand, a minority interest doesn't have the power to force the liquidation of the firm. So therefore, we might use we as a starting point, we would probably use the lower going concern value. However, we also might use a weighted average. So as an example of that, that I have on the bottom of slide 32, I once did a valuation for an estate tax attorney who happened to be a minority interest owner in in a family firm. And his mother had just passed away owning 48% of the firm, and his father own half of the firm.
1:05:48So the question is, what's this 48% worth? Well,
1:05:56the farm was just basically breaking even, but it owned the real estate and the corporation itself owned the real estate, out of which it operated. That obtained a real estate appraiser appraisal for $2 million of the property. And so they, and they, they had hired an appraiser before me, and actually met me at a bar association lecture that I did, and then hired me to defend them in audit, their appraiser had taken a 40% discount, combined discount for lack of marketability, lack of control off the $2 million and valued the firm at 1.2. But
1:06:45the IRS said, Well, you can't have that discount, you didn't do anything to justify it, you just said I'm taking it, no reasoning whatsoever. So we'll even though we really can argue with the $2 million valuation of the real estate, and we think it's really higher, we'll let you get away with that if you accept our valuation of $2 million. With that means no discounts. So the attorney hired us to defend him an audit. And the the paradigm ran as follows I read the real estate appraisal, and the real estate appraiser had assumed that the the the arm's length landlord would be getting $300,000 a year for the property.
1:07:36So but the firm wasn't paying anything for it because it owns the building and the land on which out of which it was operating. So if we're valuing the $2 million real estate as a non operating asset, the valuation of the business itself must then presume that the business is paying arm's length rent, to an arm's length landlord. So the arm's length rent was $300,000 a year. So now all of a sudden his business that was breaking, breaking even is really in a true economic sense is really losing $300,000 a year. So what's the value of a business that has net income of minus $300,000 a year, well apply a Gordon model multiple, and it's probably somewhere between minus 1.2 and minus $1.6 million, which is a whole lot better as as far as paying taxes on it than having a valuation of $2 million.
1:08:42Then we did a little bit of kind of game game theory thinking, which is, well, a 48% owner could try to convince dad to sell the business, to liquidate the firm and just rent it out to somebody else, rent out the land to someone else. What would it what's the probability of convincing dead? Well, Dad was going to, he had run this company for 50 years. And he was absolutely committed to running it until the day you could no longer run it. So we did some different scenarios and came to a valuation of something like minus $1.2 million. And our client got a very nice settlement with the IRS and was very happy. So there's another case of what is what paradigm are we using what what the IRS didn't realize is that the real estate appraisal presumed that this business was paying $300,000 to an arm's length landlord, so that that created a loss company. So it's really about the big thing, the big picture right? When we do when we measure liquidation value we start with, usually book values in the balance sheet and then we we calculate the percentage sorry. So we're still really at the bottom of 33. We make a fair market value balance sheet with the percentage realizable values for each one. So, typically inventory, work in progress have very low realizable values. Accounts receivable might also have low realizable values. If customers know that the company is going out of business, maybe they really won't pay. So we show book value and then we have a percentage Realizable Value column next to it, we multiply the two to estimate the dollar
1:10:48amount realized from each asset and then from each liability, okay. The liquidation value also needs to include liabilities for severance pay cost of the skeleton crew for three to 12 months to wind down the business, legal accounting and admin costs. Okay. The second premise of value is are we talking about value and exchange or value to the holder.
1:11:19We're now in slide 36. Value and exchange is what this business would sell for what this intangible asset would sell for in the marketplace. We try to simulate the thinking of buyers and sellers in the market. It's an objective concept of value, usually independent of the specific buyer or seller. Sometimes, if we're if we're valuing a minority interest, it may take into account who the existing seller is. But usually for a control interest, it's independent of the identity of buyer or seller unless there unless for example, it could be that if there was a personal guarantee on on a on a loan than then that may not be true. Okay, valuation premiums and discounts apply in value and exchange value to the holder slide 37 is more subjective. An example is a medical license has no market value, can't the doctor can't sell his or her license to someone else, but it has value to the holder valuation discounts might not apply.
1:12:37So slide 38, which of the two is best? Well, that's basically usually an irrelevant question. Usually, civil law case law or regulation specifies which we have to use. So somehow law usually determines how we what are the rules of the game per se? What are the rules of calculation and we have to run with that the standard of value determines the rules of the game and affects the value outcome. And the first recorded debate in history of what is the right premise of value and standard of value actually occurs in the Toleman. Now, it's like 39, a standard of value as a definition of value or business damages, that determines the rules by which we measure value, are we measuring value or loss profits, we which valuation discounts apply and which ones do not apply.
1:13:43The most common standard of value in the US is, is fair market value. It's used for all tax purposes in the US. We're now at slide 41. So definition of fair market value is the selling price in cash or cash equivalents.
1:14:04As a starting point, if the seller of the business accepts a below market interest rate on a note, so in other words, the buyer is not paying all cash, but instead is paying a down payment and then the seller takes a note upon which the buyer pays if that note is at a below market rate of interest, which they often are, then fair market value is actually less than the face value of of the note of the note plus the down payment.
1:14:39market interest is usually very high for privately held firms, and especially if there's a lot of debt on it. Also, the fair market value of contingent payments is less than the face value of the contingent payments. Slide number 42
1:15:00fair market value also presupposes generally a hypothetical willing buyer and seller. So you see all those faceless people doesn't matter who their identity is usually, although it does matter in as I said earlier in the minority interest, for example, in the case of that firm were mom passed with 48% of the firm. It didn't matter who was controlling the firm in the buyer didn't matter. The buyer is a faceless, nameless, financial buyer, but the financial buyer was going to face that controlling the firm, or at least with veto power over the firm. And, and is the son really going to crosses his age father?
1:15:47Probably not. So basically, he's got control of the firm. So then it doesn't matter. Okay, fair market value is also an arm's length transaction. So when we use paradigms, we use guideline companies we have to find or guideline transactions, we have to find out are they arm's length transactions. If they weren't arm's length, then that doesn't count for fair market value. Also, fair market value presupposes an open and unrestricted market. We're now on on slide number 44. So any restrictions on transfer of the interest decreased fair market value. Now this is typical in privately held firms. Often, the shareholders agreement will put rights of first refusal and will not allow any of the existing shareholders to sell to whomever they want without approval. So these restrictions on transfer, do reduce the fair market value compared to having no restrictions.
1:16:59Slide number 45. Fair market value also presupposes there's no compulsion to buy or sell. A fire sale is not fair market value. And I recently just read literature on from Jewish law. From the code of Jewish law of the Rabbi Schneur, Zalman Eliade, who wrote it about 200 years ago, he talked about essentially not using the terminology fire sale, but essentially he talked about fire sales versus ordinary sales. So and he's not making this up himself. This, this is just a later codification of Jewish law that comes from the Talmud, so 1000s of years old laws that recognize the difference between fire sales and No, no compulsion to buy or sell. Fair market value on slide 46, also presupposes the both buyer and seller have reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts.
1:18:07This can be tricky. So basically what is either known or reasonably knowable on the valuation date? So we're often using?
1:18:19We're often using data from public sources, and sometimes the public sources are after the valuation date, but we use them for the valuation date, because perhaps the perhaps this was knowable on the valuation date. If it's definitely not knowable, then we'd better use last year's financial publication, because that would be the latest information available to hypothetical buyer and seller. So sometimes these little details of what data sources are we using and when was it published? And when was it available? And when was it knowable, is very important and can affect the outcome of our evaluation.
1:19:06The US Tax Court does allow sometimes as a sanity check subsequent data and that that can be a bit of a an explosive issue, it can create a wedge between the two sides as to whether it should be admissible or not, but it is what it is in theoretically, it should not be admissible.
1:19:35But theory in $1 will buy you a cup of coffee in some restaurants sometimes. Okay, page, slide number 47, fair market value the minority if for minority interest, actual owners matter, and we covered that with dad and then slide 48 When does fair market value not exist again the example of the medical license
1:20:02There was a, there was another example where fair market value doesn't exist. Another one of my war stories, we were valuing this is now slide 49, we were valuing a pipe manufacturer who, who made a deal with their management, that management would get a certain amount of stock in the firm. And according to their stock holdings, they would get some sort of profit sharing from it. But upon retirement, they would have to sell back at book value. Now, the problem with this is that that means that the value of even though it's stock, and we had to value it, the value of this depends on the age, the age and the probable length of service of the member management. So there were some there were some members of management who were already in their 60s, there were others who are in their 30s, say a 30 year old would expect to work at the farm at least another 35 years.
1:21:16So 35 years of superior returns, could be worth a lot to that person. Yet the for the one who's in the 60s, maybe only expecting two or three years of the the profit sharing wouldn't be worth very much. And we're supposed to for fair market value, we're supposed to
1:21:41assume hypothetical buyer and hypothetical seller? Well, there is no one hypothetical.
1:21:51Buyer, in this case, it has to do with the value of this stock dependent on the age of the person buying it. So we had to make a compromise and just assume an average age and let investment value. pinch hit for fair market value. I talked this over with quite a number of people, and there was no great solution. But on the other hand, the IRS wasn't exactly going to like the answer, well, there is no fair market value. So therefore, zero, they wouldn't like that either. So we picked an average age of those members of management and ran with that. Even though technically there was no fair market value.
1:22:34investment value value is value to a specific buyer. That's slide number 50. And slide 51, where their synergies investment value is often 20 to 50%, or more higher than fair market value. And an example of that I did the valuation of pure X Corporation in 1985, maybe 84. But I think 85 It was acquired by armor dial, which has since split up into three different companies, one of the excellent one being the the dial Corporation.
1:23:16Armor dial was a manufacturer of a wide range of high end specialty cleaning products. Pure X was a manufacturer of a relatively small line of
1:23:32lower priced cleaning products that were high quality, but they didn't put much into marketing. So it's sold for lower prices. Armour dial was excited about the the acquisition because they had the same customer base. So now pure X who had been selling their product and shipping in carload quantities by railroad could now piggyback the armor dial shipment to the same customer also by rail thereby. So armor dial which was the bigger firm was going to be able to lower their their transportation costs their shipping costs on all of their products just by tagging it along with the periodic shipments to the same people. So they were figuring that this was going to add a lot to armor dials bottom line. So that's a that's a real life example of the synergy. And in this case, the synergy was worth something like I don't remember exactly, but I believe it was either two or three times as much as the actual standalone value of pure X at the time. That's that's the most likely win win scenario in an acquisition. Unfortunately, most acquisitions are not that good, but that was a very successful one. And I ended up speaking with a fella named, I believe Dave Riddiford and one of are one other fellow at the successor dial Corporation. I spoke to them probably in about the year 2004. And they were still very happy with their acquisition 20 years later.
1:25:16Okay investment value page 52. What if the database of private transactions is all investment values and not really fair market values? So contrary to intuition, a recent research shows that strategic buyers do not pay more than financial buyers do. That was a surprise to us. Okay, slide 53 fair value, which is used in shareholder oppression suits. Does Bernie Madoff the shareholder oppressor? Slide 54. For shareholder oppression and corporate dissolution suits, the standard of value is generally defined in case law, it varies by state that may or may not allow valuation discounts, as case law follows value and exchange or value to the holder and it can vary from one state to the next.
1:26:14So in California, California may not allow either discount for lack of marketability or lack of control and a different state can have total can allow both of them or may allow one and not the other, and vice versa. Slide 55 fair value for financial reporting, even though this standard of value has the same name as fair value for for purposes of shareholder oppression suits, corporate dissolution, it's not the same, even though it has the same name, it's not the same standard of value has definitely different definition, in its definition actually happens to be similar but not identical to fair market value.
1:27:03Fair Value for financial reporting specifies the exit price, which differs than with fair market value when there are wholesale and retail prices. Fair market value requires the average of wholesale and resale whereas fair value requires the exit price. So it's very important. That's why I'm spending so much time on standard of value. It's really important for you as the attorney to understand the standard of value that applies, because the appraiser the appraiser often knows but sometimes we don't know. And this is this is something that you as the attorney really need to take the lead here to make sure that you understand what is the proper proper standard of value to follow. And if we get the standard of value run, we will we can do all the calculations properly and still end up with the wrong value and irrelevant value.
1:27:59Okay.
1:28:02Also, unlike fair market value, fair value for financial reporting may allow the synergy with the buyer. And it is value in exchange. Slide 56 Marital value in San Diego, it's a mix of value to the holder and value and exchange. It forbids discount for lack of marketability, but does permit permit the discount for lack of control. Slide 57. Now we're going to come to the oldest written standard of value of which I'm aware, which is the standard of value in the Talmud. And it's based on the biblical passages have an eye for an eye tooth for tooth stripe for stripe wound for wound bruising for bruising, there's five languages used. And and from that we get that there's five categories of damages.
1:28:59First, okay, we'll move to page 58. The the Talmud is composed of two parts, the older part, they both comprise the Oral Law, the written laws, the Bible. The Oral Law was transmitted orally, to Moses on Mount Sinai and it was transmitted from Moses to Joshua to the elders, the prophets, etc, and comes down to this day, the Oral Law was forbidden to be written down unless there was a danger of forgetting it in its entirety. Or substantively, and in about the year 200. That happened, the first stage of that happen, which resulted in the Mishnah which is a short recitation of laws, but the Mishnah is very terse, and it lacks any of the discussion and reasoning about why the case ruling is what It is.
1:30:01So the mission is the older part of the Tolman, the Gemara. There's actually two of them. There's what's known as the Jerusalem Talmud, which was about around the year 350, I believe, and the Babylonian Talmud about the ir 505. That's known as the Gomorrah. But both existed orally, over 3300 years ago about 30 320 2728, something like that years ago. So when he puts out BSI, there's these five categories of damages from the language used in the in the Bible. And there's five categories of damages that are listed in the Mishnah. And by the way, when it says an eye for an eye, the Gomorrah in the tractate of Bava, kama, which I have learned, some 10s of pages of it I'm not finished with it yet.
1:31:05Does goes through what we call two full pages, or four, we would call them four pages, really the each page is two sides of Talmud, it takes two full pages or four real pages of analysis. Finally, to prove that it doesn't mean literally that you if a puts out beside that you then put out a sigh as retribution for that carelessness or for that maliciousness. Instead, it means the economic damage for the loss of the eye. You could say, well, then why doesn't it just say so straight on? And the answer is, is that in a certain way? It's sort of like saying, you deserve to have your AI put out, but what good is that going to do? So somebody might just say, I don't care him, I've got plenty of money, I'll pay him for the value of AI. So what? No, you really deserve to have your eye put out, but that's not going to do anybody any good. So now you owe him for the the the damages for the loss and vet his loss and value as a human being because of the loss of his eye. So the how do we measure that? Simple, you go to the slave market, and you see what a fully what fully sighted slaves sell for?
1:32:29And what what one eyed slave sell for and the difference between them is the loss of the value of the eye pain and suffering. Do a market research, we can go to the people in the market and say I can the duck the government has decreed that you're going to lose your eye. There's two ways to do it. The standard version is we'll just stick a knife in your eye. And that's free. If you want the deluxe version, we can give you a poison which will make you go blind, but it'll be painless. How much are you willing to pay for it? And the result of that market research is the value of the pain and suffering have to pay for medical expenses, unemployment and finally, embarrassment for being disfigured and having to wear an eyepatch the rest of his life.
1:33:21Slide number 60. That's the mission. And the mission says in valuing the damages for embarrassment. It all goes according to who is the perpetrator and who's the victim. There's three opinions of who the victim is in the Gomorrah, where the mayor says we treat the victim as a former aristocrat who lost most of his wealth. Basically, we're all children of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob one size fits all. It's just like fair market value. It's like value in exchange. Rabbi Yehuda, the damage is unique to the fight financial position of the victim and the perpetrator. It's unique, it's like investment value. And finally, Rabbi Shimon has a dual class where he treats the rich victim like ribeye mayor, the former aristocrat who lost his wealth and the poor, we treat as the poorest of the poor for valuing damages. That's like a more sophisticated view of fair market value that has a size effect to it. Now we start the next segment of the lecture, that is valuation approaches, we're still in the infrastructure, but we're getting a little closer to structure as the asset income and market approaches.
1:34:41Number 62. A valuation approach is a general way of looking at value. It's not a specific technique and itself. The asset approach is value of assets minus the value of liabilities. Well, there's three versions of that. There's the accounting historical cost base values of assets and liabilities. There's liquidation value, there's market value, we can make different choices in there. So we had the liquidation value is the good one for valuing the firm debt. And that's the that is usually the most important use of the asset approach.
1:35:25When we value a, let's say a family limited partnership or a family LLC that owns say real estate, and maybe stocks and bonds, then we're using market values. Usually, book value is not a good choice. But it can be, it can be a good shortcut, when we're if the book value is less than, than the than the value of the firm alive by the by the income approach or the market approach, then we can pretty much say liquidation value would be even less than that. And we know that our valuation is going to be based on a going concern value rather than liquidation value, or book value. For that matter. The income approach, we're usually using discounted cash flow, but it's basically what is the value of the cash flows the business produces above and beyond arm's length compensation for the owners who work in it.
1:36:24And then the market approach, we're developing mathematical relationships between the selling price of businesses, or between the trading price of a publicly traded firm, and that is its market, market cap, trading price times shares outstanding and the underlying independent variables that tend to drive value, which would be sales, net income, profit margins, etc. Cash Flow. Slide number 63.
1:36:58Now let's we're going to synthesize valuation premise and approach. This is a little bit of a complicated table, but I find it to be very useful. So the first row, left column says the we're talking about the time orientation. The asset approach, which is balance sheet based is present orientation is present time, what's the value of assets minus the value of liabilities today, on the valuation date, discounted cash flow or the income approach in general, discounted future net income is a future time orientation, we forecast future results and discount them back to the present time. And the market approach is a mix of the present and the past the stock price in the present.
1:37:53If it's a publicly traded firm, or the present meaning on the valuation date, and usually some past measure of net income or sales, something like that, that's usually the past year's sales, or net income might be more than one year. So the market approach is a mix of the present in the past, so we have present future and present and past. The strengths of each approach. The asset approach value is dust at valuing the company dead using liquidation value. It's also good for valuing the holding company using fair market values of let's say, if it's mainly made of real estate, you can get real estate appraisals on that good for that. It's otherwise not not good and useful in valuing most operating firms other than just to establish a value dead.
1:38:52The income approach its strengths are that it's custom tailored to the firm. It's a real rifle shot. It's also the only method available for valuing startups usually.
1:39:09Finally, the market approach. It strengths are that it's objective because we're looking at other firms that are trading in the same industry. It's not a subjective look within it's an objective look without and if we have enough data to use regression analysis that can give us some very useful statistical feedback on how reliable our forecasts are. Valuation is the weaknesses of each approach on the bottom row of the table. The asset approach often ignores intangible values in the business. The income approach has many subjective sometimes subjective assumptions in the forecasting and A an appraiser, who is being unscrupulous and wants to tilt the valuation result in one direction can do so by making a series of small biased assumptions. And the impact of several small bias assumptions is can be a large difference in value tilted in one direction or the other.
1:40:30And the weakness in the market approach is that it's their data issues. The
1:40:38these, these databases have flaws in them, they have mistakes in them. There are all kinds of issues with the data, that there's not enough time to go into it and would probably bore most of you. But it's a can be a real significant issue. It's something that we cannot use in valuing startup firms. And there's often an issue of selection bias and that is certainly the small and medium size businesses that business appraisers are usually valuing, are generally much less valuable and have much lower expected growth in the future than the certainly the publicly traded firms. But often even the privately traded firms that populate a database like Pratt stance, generally, those sale of mom and pop businesses don't usually show up in press stats, although some do but the majority of the firms in that database are firms with more size and substance.
1:41:48And if we are applying it to a smaller firm, or even a firm of the same size that has lower expected growth, there will there will tend to be a selection bias that will lead to an overvaluation of the business. Let's move to slide number 64.
1:42:09I call it synthesizing valuation premise and approach these digital qualities zero or one, we could also call them binary qualities, there are a whole bunch of them and again, this this goes back to the some Jewish mysticism and Hasidic philosophy about the right side and the left side.
1:42:32The right side again is the site of kindness, the left side is the site of the site of strength and severity and judgment. So, and this is not a perfect categorization by all means, but there is some there is some practical use in in understanding how this works. And it actually can be practical in your law practice. Okay, so on the side, on the left side, we have risk people fear risk. On the right side, we love return. So the higher the expected return of the business, the more we're willing to pay for it. But the higher the risk of the business and the left hand side, the less we're willing to pay for it. Okay, so there's risk and return are the two big principles. They basically correspond to the biblical commandments of love and fear. We love returns we love profits, we we fear risk, we fear failure Okay. On the right side, we have macro the holistic view of things, the left side is micro, the atomistic look the right side with God extrovert concern with others, left side introvert concern boundaries and self oriented right side is subjective.
1:44:05Left side objective, right side is feeling. So here's your right side, left side is thinking
1:44:15right side fairness and the results. Okay. A kind judge is going to be concerned with the fairness of the results. A more stern and impersonal an objective judge is going to be more concerned with the fairness of the process and is not is going to be less concerned with the fairness of the results. On the right hand side we have the concept of equity, which is related to fairness and results. And the left hand side is the law which is more related to the fairness and the process. The right side would be related to share value as a standard of value, the left side would be related to fair market value.
1:45:06The right side would be discounted cash flow.
1:45:11Left side, which is more, a little more inward looking and this is it's more unique to the firm. The left side is mainly concerned with what's going on the market, I don't care what you think. You think sales are gonna be this much in that my you think the relationship, the Gordon model multiples is going to be this for this. And the other reason, I just want to look at what's going on the market, forget what you think about the firm, what's happening out there in the market value in exchange, that's more related to the right side. Sorry, to the left side. Okay, so the importance of the digital qualities, and that it has to do with the marketing appeal to a judge or a jury.
1:45:57So it's good to know who your audience is, and what kind of what kind of personality the judge tends to have, you know, you would emphasize that which appeals to that judge. So again, a kind judge is more concerned with favorable do an argument that the final result is unfair. Whereas a stern judge is not going to be is going to be much less open to that sort of an argument, who's more concerned with the fairness of the process, not the fairness of the final result. Okay, new topic. Slide number 66. The elements of an engagement letter in an engagement letter, and this is engagement letters are very important, because it defines our contractual arrangement between often is the attorney who's retaining the appraiser, sometimes it's the client. But but with the attorney supervision, often though it is the attorney. So engagement letters need to identify who the client is.
1:47:03There should be a clear recital of facts so that it gives context to the assignment has to identify the purpose of the valuation. And it's critical to identify all purposes of the valuation. One of my not so happy war stories was probably about 25 years ago, and attorney told me that there were two purposes evaluation, I put that in an engagement letter. When we were done with our numerical results, or we thought we were done, we presented our results to the attorney and he said, Oh, I'm sorry, I forgot to tell you, there really is a third purpose of your valuation I needed also for X, whatever that was. And that required another $20,000, about a $25,000 worth of work, which had we known from the outset, we could have structured or analysis differently, we probably could have done that $25,000 for 5000. So it caused an extra 25 $20,000 worth of work that was really unnecessary. Had the attorney told us upfront, all the purposes of the valuation assignment. So really, lack of doing that can lead to some train wrecks.
1:48:26The engagement letter should specify the standard of value, the interest that we're valuing the valuation date. Now we're on slide 67, the intended users of the appraisal, identify if this is an appraisal, which is the higher end service or calculations, which is a lower end service.
1:48:52Calculations may be just some number crunching without any due diligence where appraisal is higher with due diligence market research sometimes or it may not be there, but generally more more more quantity of work and usually more quality of work. engagement letter should identify the timing and should identify any critical dates by which the numbers are due by which the draft report is due by which the final report is due. should specify the fees and that is ordinary fees. And what happens if there are data errors or there's an expansion of the scope of the assignment and it should have dispute resolution and jurisdiction.
1:49:39Okay, now we're at slide number 69, which is the title slide regression analysis, a general tool. I wasn't quite sure where to put this, whether to put this in the infrastructure evaluation of the structure. I decided to put it in the infrastructure because it's a general tool that can be used in many So many parts of the, of the of a discounted cash flow method or in the market approach, since it's a general tool, I decided to put it as the in the infrastructure of valuation as a tool rather than something specific to the, to the DCF or the market methods. Okay, what is regression analysis? It's a statistical technique that estimates the mathematical relationship between the dependent variable and one or more independent variables.
1:50:45In the, in the DCF, that is the discounted cash flow. And by the way, we're on we're on slide number 70. We can use it for forecast sales is a function of time. And perhaps other variables too. I think I once had a client who had something like 25 years of sales history. And that client was in the it was a wholesaler and a high end wholesaler have
1:51:19engineering parts for process plants like like oil refineries, and paper mills. So when one of these in a when an oil factory shuts down is very expensive. This client did not only supply the parts, but also they they provided engineering assistance, as well. So since a lot of their business was related to selling to oil refineries, I decided to see what was the relationship of their sales over time as a function of time. And in other words, its function of the passage of time, that generally there's an upward trend, usually, for growing businesses at least. And I tried oil, the price per barrel of oil, and I even tried the price squared for oil barrel. And I found that actually, the price squared was a better predictor.
1:52:20So it turned out that that time and oil prices did did an excellent job of being able to forecast sales in in that for that client. We can also use regression to forecast the relationship of costs and expenses as a function of sales. In the market approach, we can use the regression tool as a way of we're trying to explain the mathematical relationship between the value of the firm that is the selling price, and and sales, net income, cash flow, etc. Okay. Slide number 71. So why why use regression? I like to explain everything with the people can relate to physical quantities more easily than two conceptual ideas. So, we're talking in terms of sales, variable costs, fixed costs.
1:53:33More people can relate to how could I use this tool to forecasts somebody's weight. Now on I'm about five, seven and a half, or maybe a squished five, nine, and I weigh about 161 and say, 160. If we were to just imagine a graph over here, with a with an X axis and the Y axis, if we make this panel over here, the x axis that's weight and the Y, sorry, x axis is height, the independent variable, and the y axis is weight because height causes weight. Weight does not cause height, although there is a relationship, but height generally causes weight. Okay, so we would go out to let's say, 68 inches on the x axis, and 161 pounds up on the y axis, and you could plot my height and weight as one single point on that graph. Then we could take the height and weight of say 99 other men, we would not want might want to mix men and women in the same populations for for forecasting weights because they're two totally separate populations.
1:55:05So I'd have 99 other points on the graph, so we'd have 100 points on the graph. Okay, now what would want to do is to draw the best line through those points. Now you would expect that line to be an upward sloping line, because the, the taller we are on average, the more we weigh, yes, there are short men who are very stout and are heavy, and there's tall, tall men who are like skinny poles. But on average, the taller one is, the more the more he weighs. Okay, so we would, we would like to fit the best line through these points. That's called the regression line. Slide 71 says, This is our starting point, if we, if we did not use the regression technique, the best we could do is if you want to forecast somebody's weight, and you don't know anything about him, you don't know his height, you don't know anything? Well, you would just then take the average of these 100 men a sample of 100 men, and hope that it wasn't a sample of 100 basketball players or 100 football players. Whereas if you want to use that to forecast the weight of an average man or a, say the weight of a midget, obviously, it's, it's a poor application of statistics.
1:56:32So our starting point is, in the absence of a regression, we would just use the mean weight of the population of the sample population. That's that vertical line, going through the points, sorry, the horizontal line going through the points on slide number 71. And slide 72, shows that there's a large, a large forecasting error, because obviously not not everybody is the average weight there, some guy who's a linebacker for for the Packers is, is going to be way off the average weight of the average population. So there'll be a large forecasting error there. Slide 73 shows how we, we draw the regression line through those points, here, we're just showing six points on it on a graph, be nice to have 100. But we rarely get that we draw the line that minimizes the sum of the squares of the distances of each point from the regression line. And using a little bit of calculus tells us what the y intercept and what the slope of this line is. So the slope of the line of the weight line would be for every additional inch of height, how much more would a man weigh?
1:58:04And maybe that answer is four pounds. Maybe it's three pounds, two and a half pounds, whatever it happens to be, the slope of that line tells us how weight changes as height changes. The y intercept tells us theoretically, what would a man of zero height weigh? Obviously, in reality, it should be zero. But oftentimes, our data have their own measurement errors and flaws and, and we probably would get a positive or negative number for a y intercept.
1:58:45Slide 74, to see how the regression reduces the error, because now, instead of if somebody is, let's say, seven feet tall,
1:58:58we're not going to, we're not going to just say, Well, this guy, you know, we're using the average of the population. So we're using 165 pounds as our forecast for the seven foot men, I mean, that that's obviously gonna be way way off. But if we have a regression line, we can take it out to set seven feet is at four inches, we'd go out at four inches on the x axis, up to the regression line on the y axis, and then read, then go, then go over here on the y axis, and read off how much this guy weighs. And we're probably going to get an estimate of 240 260 pounds, and it's not going to be perfect, but it's going to be a whole lot better than then saying the seven foot guy is going to be 165 pounds.
1:59:51Slide number 75 If we want to get a little more accurate, yeah, or even a lot more accurate, instead of using it Single varial variable regression, we can expand it to be multivariate. And now, we will not only what I like to know, what is what is this man's height, but if you also give me his waist, measure his waistline, I know both. Now instead of plotting points in two dimensional space on a flat space, we're now pointing we're plotting lines in three dimensional space. Sorry, we're plotting points in three dimensional space, there's a point here a point there. So there's, there's height, sorry, yeah, there's, there's a height, height dimension, a waistline dimension. And then there's the weight, the weight would be vertical height. So we'd have a point up here and other point there, another point there, another point there, and we would fit the best regression plane through these points and three space. And we would get a regression with a y intercept and then 2x coefficients, which tell us how, how does weight change for every additional increase in height and for every additional inch in waistline, that then we can get much more accurate in forecasting weight. Now, obviously, business appraisers and I running around forecasting Wait, we're going around forecasting value generally, sometimes we're forecasting total costs and expenses, but it's just easier to explain the concept of regression using physical examples first, and then that again serves as the metaphor for the more conceptual variables.
2:01:54Okay, we have now completed the infrastructure of value