1h 4min · about 9,400 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, this is Neil Roberts. I'm a managing partner of Protectus law. And this program that you've selected is the IR's whistleblower Cle 1 hour credit. The purpose of today is to tell you, oh, that's me, only a little younger in a hat. The purpose of this educational hour is to train lawyers or other professionals who are interested in whistleblowing on how you could submit a whistleblower claim to the United States Internal Revenue Service. I might add that this is designed for representing whistleblowers, but if those of you in the defense industry want to know how it works, that'd be great.
0:47And on the other hand, almost any lawyer might stumble upon a case of tax fraudhouse or government contracting fraud, or, who knows, sec fraud. And so it pays to understand whistleblowing because it's a wonderful area of the law and it helps the country and it helps the clients, and it can work out quite well for the lawyers too, I might add. We prepared at protectus law four of these hour long presentations, and each one is somewhat integrated with the other. So if this is your first, you might be interested in taking the others. The idea is that there's a whole constellation now, interrelated whistleblowing laws, perhaps not as well coordinated as you might hope, stemming from some historical matters that started in 1986. So we've prepared one for filing a case under the United States False Claims act that tells you about fraud in the government and how to bring an actual complaint, which you write as the lawyer on behalf of the client, which is both your client, the relator, and the government, because they're the real party party in interest. The second matter that we did prepare was how to prepare a TCR for the SEC. It's reporting corporate fraud and foreign corruption. This is not fraud on the government and a government contract, but rather a fraud on the investors or violations of the securities law, which endanger investors.
2:28And what's really unique about that is that as they wove together this quilt of whistleblowing laws, they decided that the DOJ and the SEC should be in charge of foreign bribery. So if an american reporting company hires a consultant in Peru or Gabon or wherever, they might hire it, and that consultant walks down the street to a government official, say the one in charge of hospitals in Cyprus, for instance, and that firm is something like, say, Siemens, if you find out about that and then file a TCR on behalf of your client, that has to be secret. Obviously, you have to find still read in the paper, then there is a fine against that corporation, because it's a books and records violation. They're supposed to say in their books and records and their filings, money spent on bribe.
3:29And of course, they don't do that. There is a reward. I might mention that in the FCA, it's 15% to 30% of what the government gets. The tcasec. Again, it's 15% to 30%. And some of these actions can be quite large. The take every year by the government on the FCA world is around three to 6 billion a year. The sec goes up and down, but it's in the hundreds of millions. The third one that we prepared, which is a brand new area of the law, is that the treasury saw that the other arms of government, investigative arms of government, were doing so well with insiders walking in with fully prepared cases by logical minded lawyers like yourself, as opposed to, you know, random thoughts stuck to the wall that they have now, just in the last year, established a mandatory payment system for rewards.
4:39If you bring a money laundering case. Now, what's interesting there is that the case is really about a bank. A bank who doesn't know its customers and allows the customers to set up accounts, which are in turn, they don't know who they are. They might be the proceeds of crime. They certainly aren't paying their taxes. And that is a significant note, because the way you penalize the bank, if you're a treasury, these banks couldn't easily be in Europe or anywhere all over the world, because they all use the facilities of the US treasury, because the dollar obviously is the global exchange. They get very big fines.
5:23So I think last year the treasury, without whistleblowers, brought in 9 billion. The whistleblower schemes usually are a factor of something like ten of what used to happen. So I've prepared presentations like this for other governments who are considering it. And in Canada, I did a royal commission presentation and of course, the government folks came in and said, oh, we can do this very well. They were the mounties, in fact, in that case, and I will mention that when they, when the original FCA case was act was put together in 86, and John was up in front of Congress again, that the FBI and the attorney general said, we can handle all this, they were only getting in something like $87,000 a year, a million dollars a year out of a trillion, and now it's 3 billion. So there you go.
6:22What's interesting about the treasury program is that the sanctions OFAC, that is trading with the enemy type things, Russia and Iran and the like, are administered by treasury. FinCEN is the agency, OFAC is the sub agency. And again, if you find out someone trading with enemy or trading with Russia or trading with any of them, you can file it with treasury in it. And again, a TCR. And finally, we get to submitting a whistleblower came to the United States Internal Revenue. I mentioned all those in some detail because as you can imagine, if you're filing a money laundering case, you'd want to let the IR's know that the clients of those banks may be evading taxes. Or if you're filing a TCR about books and records because of bribery, you may want to tell the IR's that they've, in effect, fraudulently filed their income taxes. So each one of these situations may give rise to a tax fraud.
7:28So that's the setting. I'll mention that we're going to monitor how many of you lawyers watch these, and if there's an interest, if there's a fair number of people watching them. There's a couple of other programs that I might do later in the year that are rather recent. There's a FTC commodities future exchange CFTC program, which mirrors the SEC. If you know how to do an SEc one, you know how to do a CFTC one. And there's also a brand new meaning, August 1, 2024, program from the Department of justice to give rewards out of criminal forfeitures, which is not possible under the four programs I just described. That is a temporary trial program for three years.
8:20But if it seems to be valid, I'll probably do a program on that too. I might mention that we co counsel and assist in all sorts of these cases. And so we're here to help in any way possible. And we have been doing this for 20 years. So there you go.
8:40Here's the history, the framework, and the form of how to file an IR's claim. I might mention that the. If I just back up for a second, you can file a SEc anonymously. TCR, you can file a treasury anonymously. It might come up if they need to. I mean, it has to come up when they give you the money, money at the end. And you can file a false claims act case under seal, and it'll only your name, your client's name only comes up. Then in the case of the IR's, this is your client's name on it. It won't come up because you can never find anything out from the IR's, which is part of what we're going to describe as part of the problem. Here.
9:30But basically what we have here is a layout of what's going to happen in the next hour. First, the history of this, the Revenue act. The commissioner of revenue, which became the general revenue service in 1862, appointed a fellow in charge of it. And the first act in 1867 gave that secretary wide berth because they'd seen in the Civil War that you had to have a false claims act to get anyone to come forward. And they believed that if they were going to be taxing people, that unless there was some thought they might get caught, they'd never pay their taxes. So he had the right to pay out payments. And one of the things that's interesting is in the hundred years in the previous century, very few payments were made. And one of the interesting things about the revolution and whistleblowing act legislation since 1986 is that even if the bureaucracy has a discretionary power to give rewards, these are civil servants. The job is to save public money and they just don't give it out. If it's a discretionary matter, the amounts of money given are tiny. Okay? Non existent. And that was the same case with the IR's. So here's what happened in 1986.
11:03John Phillips, who I went to law school at Berkeley with, was a public interest lawyer. And he had read up on the civil war history of how corrupt secretary of war Seward was. And some of those folks and I, the Congress, in what became to be known as AIDS law in effect, appointed a whole country full of private attorney generals to bring their own cases against anybody who was stealing from the government. And John brilliantly first resuscitated the act with real teeth in California and then went to Washington and he met with Howard Berman and Senator Grassley. Grassley is still there 35 years later and still a major proponent of whistleblowing legislation. And so he's been the sponsor of most of the acts that have come since then. The act has been a fantastic success in both recovering $18 billion, but also to deterrence. Because if you know, if you're a corporate, these are corporations, right? That's what they do.
12:18If you know that your secretary or your vice president can report a fraudulent scheme, you're just much less likely to do it. So based on that, in 2006, a set of senators and congressmen with Mister Grassley in the lead, established a whistleblower office in the IR's and established the head of the whistleblower office and a new form. And we'll get into how the actual act works and the form works. But what's amazing is the numbers and the opportunity here. So I'm going to lay out the numbers. You'll see what the opportunity is. And it's your job as a lawyer. And every time you talk to anyone to kind of mention that there are whistleblowing laws, because it's out there, you stumble upon fraud. I mean, human beings are the way they are, and it's just finding out about it. So here's kind of an interesting set of things. This is what the taxes collected by the service, okay, over the last ten years, we're now up to pushing $5 trillion.
13:35They have to make a report every year to Congress, they being the service, as to what they think they're collecting and what they think the gap of what they're not collecting. So they estimate that and send a report to Congress. This is the numbers, okay? So that number there, out of that 7 trillion, the service itself thinks that they're not collecting. In 2001, 345 billion, and by 2021, 688 billion. So more or less a trillion of uncollected taxes by the time you get to 2024. Then on the other side, you see enforced and other late payments. That's what they collect. So out of the 688 billion, they basically collected 63 or 10% by running around and auditing taxes and sending out IRA agents and having DOJ bring big cases and all that sort of thing.
14:39So obviously that means that there is some version of, let's estimate $900 billion of fraud, which you can bring forward as a client for your client of fraud and then collect with your client a contingency fee of his reward. The tax gap,
15:08which I just described, is that trillion dollars and there's fair number don't file and there's fair number underpaying, and there's a big chunk that just don't report it. Okay? If they can get away with not telling people they've made money, the taxpayers tend not to do that. And as we'll see in this hour, often that's done abroad. If you make quite a lot of money, you'd like to get away from the IR's and there's perfectly wonderful schemes to, I mean, jurisdictional outreach to capture those american taxpayers.
15:51There's the picture of the opportunity. If you collect 100 billion and you have 900 billion left, you can go find more cases. 926 is the exact number of guests there. Now here's the whistleblower claims. The form we're going to take you through and the process we're taking you through produces a bit of paper. Okay? And anyone can do it. You can go online and do it. Probably you wouldn't do it right. If you're not a lawyer, you might if you're careful and a good accountant. And it's archaic. It's not the other. The, the FCA is a regular sealed filing. You walk into a federal court, the SEC and the CFTC and the treasury are all portals that you send a TCR in electronically. The IR's doesn't work that way. What they like is they like paper.
16:52So when they started, they didn't have practically any. And it just keeps going up. So last year there were 30,000 forms manually put in the mail and sent to Ogden, Utah. And so you go, well, that's big. Now remember that part of the problem that we have, the IR's, which I don't want to take the air out of the balloon in the party, is they just don't have enough resources. There's a movement from one political party that I won't mention that they think the solution, since everyone hates paying their taxes, is to underfund the service. And obviously the more funding it have, the more money it collects. So it's a good investment if you could do it. But the problem is whether how to get noticed. Right now they do have very able people.
17:46They do look at everything and they do send you a note. They've looked, but as we'll see, they don't necessarily bring a lot of actions based on it.
17:57These are tax fraud offenders in the hundreds, okay. Not in the hundreds of thousands. These are in the hundreds.
18:07Here's the awards distributed out of those 30,000. Okay.
18:18The totals are there and you'll see this number goes down. The number recoveries goes down in 2022. That's just a resource issue. Have time to investigate it. They don't collect the money and then they don't pay the rewards. It's not because they've decided they don't like doing it, they just don't get it. And then what happens is those annual reports go to Congress, then Congress has a hearing, then they bring forward the whistleblowing and the head of the commission, and then it goes back up again. So that's sort of routine. Average whistleblower award and Washington
19:01a 20% reward on the base. Total amount the IR's gets. Based on the form. They don't quite tell you how they think. So they might have gotten more, but they give you an explanation. And so if they were to get $100 million reward, they give away 20 million. They're big numbers, as you can see. And that's why we're in this business. All right, so now, now that you see the opportunity, a $900 billion market, a set of individuals across the world and the country who might know about this chicanery and the ability to represent them, have a contingent fee and file a mere form, but do it in such a way that you get noticed because it's significant impact.
20:02That means big money, significant bad actions, that means criminality, and the actual how it's done. And I might add that one of the secrets of this, that's why I mentioned all the programs, is that if you file a treasury about money laundering, and then you file a sec about the traded company, bank, that's a traded company that's doing the money laundering, and then you file the IR's, you have three or four different parts of the government that might be investigating this, and you then find the right people in the Department of Justice that you make sure it's sent to, and that a certain art to that, and you might get some synergy, you might not.
20:53They sometimes don't talk to each other. But anyway, that's the hope. So now let's, let's look at the law here. Basic section 7623, sub b, sub five. It only comes into play if you send in the form, they do an investigation, you don't hear anything for a while. They decide they're going to collect a penalty, and they collect a penalty which can be unpaid taxes. It could be penalties, it can be fee bar, daily penalties for having a foreign account. It can be any number of things, but it has to exceed $2 million. Okay, so it doesn't. The first thing to note is that if your client comes in and says, I know my neighbor, or I, my ex wife's husband, or whoever it is, is cheating on taxes, it has to be a large amount of money because obviously $2 million means they didn't declare at least four or $5 million, which means it probably you wouldn't bother if it wasn't ten or $20 million, because they're not going to wake up for that small amount of money.
22:05So don't waste your time on small ones because you can't get an award and you're not going to get noticed generally, unless it's a real high profile person or politician, and the news alone would make the service wake up. But it's still got to be over $2 million.
22:26Here's the statutory section of what your client gets. He gets an award between 15 and 30% of the collected proceeds, and it lays them out penalties, interest, additions to tax, additional amounts resulting from the action. The action is defined as the 211 action, but the other related actions would be the treasury or the SEC or whatever else. And it doesn't have to be judgment. It can be settled. Okay. And it says the substantial contribution to such action. Now, since they often don't talk to you, they'll have a hearing, they'll have an interview sometimes, and sometimes they don't. But when they do, what they're really talking about is how good a presentation have you made in the paper? As well as how good a presentation you make in person. And that's why it pays to be a good lawyer and do this, right? Because that's how you get larger amounts from them.
23:27On this scale,
23:30there's also a 10% situation that comes in play when it was slightly public, right. It comes from information disclosures outside that, administrative hearings, audits, investigation, news media. But you put a case together based that. Your client comes in and says, well, I figured this out. And you say, do you have inside information? They say no. Do you have specific documents from the company? They say no. Well, then you say, you probably can't do a 211 and expect to receive the award of 15% to 30%. But that's a really interesting ten page or 200 page description of how you figure this out. And in that situation, you again get 10% instead of the higher percentage. But if it's a large amount of money, it's still a great thing for your client and yourself. Now here's the good news. So your client comes in, you fill this out, you are one of the lucky ones. The few out of those 30,000, it's over $2 million. You get 20%, it's sent to your client and he gets to deduct your attorney's fees. In the old days, I remember that other than personal injury, pain and suffering, you can't deduct attorney's fees as an expense in one of these situations. And ironically, that whistleblower would have gotten zero. So they had to fix that early on in the FCA world. And then they know enough to fix it in this world. The next thing is we now have the setting.
25:12So we know that there's a lot of people illegally evading taxes out of our 350 million or whatever. We are another 25 million abroad who should be paying the taxes. And we know that there's a robust reward system, and we know that there's a bureaucracy that does, depending on the year, pay attention or not pay attention. But what else can you rope in. Well, as I said, a lot of the people that evade taxes,
25:44when I was younger, it was, you'd have a, they'd all have a swiss bank account and the Swiss would never let anyone know. So the Swiss was really the banking for the world, world criminals, right? And you literally, in the 1970s, could walk into a swiss bank and not show your id. And just like in one of those movies, right, starring Steve McQueen, and set up an account. Anyway, they've roped that in. So one of the, that is, they've created a legislative network to try to stop thwart that kind of thing. And what's great about the criminals and this and the legislation is that every time there's a new law to crack down on new problems, then they figure out a way to go around it. And then there's another law. And the ones that come to mind is that money laundering used to be just against a bank. And then people said, well, oh, good, well, I'll go do it using check cashers. Or there might be one that comes along and they include check cashers.
26:59And then somebody else comes along and says, prepaid cards. And they sort of have to keep expanding that. The same thing goes for, obviously, lots of other things. So the foreign bank account reporting fbar rule is if you're an american citizen and you have a foreign bank account, you have to file a form and you file it with FinCEn. There's a 20% compliance. That means 80% of the people with foreign bank accounts don't file it. Now, a lot of those people just don't know about this, right? They happen to have a grandmother. They set up an account for ingest Ireland, and they don't know about the rule and they don't file the form.
27:36That would be a problem because any us citizen, us person, which includes citizens, residents, corporations, or anybody else that actually is subject to the us tax laws, must file an fiber report in any account exceeding $10,000 during the calendar year. And if you have a grandmother in Ireland, you know that's not a lot of money that you put aside for to live on in the year. And you might well forget. On the other hand, if your name was some long italian name from a movie and you have 100 million, you're not forgetting, you're just keeping it there and not telling anybody. And why would you be doing that? Because the interest earned on that, or the original earning of that probably didn't get reported to the service.
28:24There's all kinds of interesting ways that people do this. There's credit card transaction, batching. One credit card processes the other credit card. And that credit card allows people to come in with $10,000 and get cards. All kinds of ways people dream up to take illicitly gotten money and turn it into money. They can live in Miami with or wherever.
28:53So under the Bank Secrecy act, which is over in the treasury,
29:00they said, here's how you file your FBR. Cause this is a bank secrecy rule, but it has to do with tax paying, right? So you're a taxpayer, you file online and you submit it, and this is how you do it. By going to Fincen and doing it. You may, in normal case, some of you who have nothing to do with whistleblowing may go, whoops, I got clients that have accounts for their grandmothers in Ireland. So there you go. That's what it looks like at Fincen. This is how you fill it out. This is the filing name and you should do it. And this is how you can find it. That's the form, not very long. And luckily this one, because it's Fincen, is electronic, as opposed to the 211s, which aren't ize.
29:48Here's the financial account, here's the amount of money, here's your name and how to find you, and here's the owner's information and all that sort of thing. So it's a lot. The reason 80% of the people haven't don't fill it out. It's a pain in the ass and they don't get around to it. On the other hand, they probably should.
30:08One account, okay,
30:12is $10,000 fine, or we'll get to it, 50% of the amount of the money in the account. And they have an exception since most people's grandmothers, they get irate about this. They're just trying to take care of grandmother. That's why it's not enforced very much, but it's really enforced if it's a big tax evader, and that's the beauty of this,
30:38if it's willful, that is, if it's not just the grandmother and you made a mistake, or you had an account because you worked there on a job for a month and wanted to set up an account and cash the check somehow or something. But if it's a large amount of money and it's part of a tax evasion scheme, then it's the greater of $100,000 or 50% of the amount in the account. You're talking real money. If it's a multimillion dollar tax evasion scheme. And this just says in the report they keep reporting to Congress, which is how that service occasionally changes. The great ship's direction is this is the 20% compliance.
31:26The swiss bank scandal, which I'm going to get into a little more later in the presentation, changed the law a great deal. And it was because of whistleblower. And the whistleblower's name is Birkenfeld. And this is why I'm just saying it's such an interesting part of the law. This gentleman is an american financial advisor. At the beginning of this century, he went to. Hed been working in Wall street for various private banks, handling family accounts and the like. And he went to work in Europe because hed worked with an american offshoot of a european bank which was based in Switzerland. So he goes to Switzerland and he uncovers the not unusual, if you'd seen the movies again, fact that the whole idea was to get the world's criminal tax evaders to be your client. And he came back and went to the IR's because he knew even then that they had a discretion to pay him.
32:45The act was in. The timing was at about the time in the news when the act was coming in, mandatory procedure. So he went back to the service and he said, well, I've got this big bank called UBS, and here's the list of all the Americans that have set up accounts with multimillion dollars in it. And this is how the whole swiss banking system works. And for reasons unknown, the service and the DOJ put a whole team together and said, and partly was because you have so much pressure coming along with terrorists, right. That it's not just criminals, but it's some of the legislation we'll see is called narcotics, right?
33:31It's narcotics money, which is obviously causing a really big problem domestically. And it's terrorism, which is causing the twin towers to come down. And it's all based on money. And unless you can find the money and chase it, therefore you can't have one of the sweetest, nicest countries in the world being the bank for all the terrorists and criminals. So they made a change of policy. They went in and did the following. First, when he came back from Switzerland, they arrested him. Now, that's because one of the clients that he was working for, and he'd been working for that client in America, he had continued to work for. So he reported UBS in the net account. And then he continued to work for one of his clients and help that client set up a foreign account and evade taxes.
34:26So he landed at the airport, and he was arrested. He went to jail. Four years in jail. Jail, real jail. Because he'd been complicit in designing an international tax evasion scheme. He'd also been more than complicit in disclosing it. I mean, it's just fantastic. But when he got back out, he got $104 million. $104 million, because the IR's does not have the rules that the false claims act or the SEC or the treasury has. They don't have the rule that you can't be part of it. They just want to collect their money. So it's an interesting story. And it changed swiss bank completely. I was talking to a accountant who'd worked at one of the big firms I've worked at who's based in Switzerland. And he said that since he's arrived in this century, the swiss bank system is an entirely different animal.
35:28And they do know their customers. And that's all because of one whistleblower who happened to be a criminal who walked in to with counsel, I might add, and got this reward. The lawyers probably did all right, too.
35:43That's his client. So his client was fined $780 million for working out with our friend Brad, working out a scheme. And Brad got 104 of the 780. Not a big number, but big enough.
36:05So they. The service then decided, well, since no one's complying with fBar, why don't we, in fact, change the rules and have a safe harbor day? Okay. It's like, bring your library book back. And they told all the folks had a big announcement, and they said, if you come in and tell us you have a foreign account, and the people who come in, obviously are the honest ones that weren't trying to do anything except help, grandma will waive the penalties and you can start fresh and start filing the fbar. So that worked very well. And that compliance went up from like 20% to like 30% or some such thing. I think they've done it twice. Okay, the next thing I want to talk about is transfer pricing. So what we have now is we have a whistleblowing office in the IR's. We have a program that means that you're going to be filing that often when you're filing other whistleblower rewards.
37:12It allows you to also bring in foreign tax evasion, and it allows an award, which is not necessarily your client could have been complicit in it. Now, I will say, in terms of representing that kind of client, and I've come across this on occasion with our clients, not many of them. But the first rule there is, if you're a whistleblowing lawyer, you are by definition not a criminal defense lawyer. The first thing you do when a client walks in with that story is you say, we need a second lawyer here, because you're going to want, you can imagine Brad had someone to help him with the IR's and he had someone else to help him to go to jail.
38:02Not for 200 years, but only for four. So the first word of caution is always worry about whether your client committed, had any crimes of his own. And if he did, it doesn't mean he's necessarily precluded from being a certain kind of whistleblower, the one I just mentioned being the IR's. But what you do want to do is get criminal counsel, put that on them, and then coordinate the civil side. This is a civil action, obviously, to go forward. All right, so now we, we now are at the point of the program where I'm going to talk about something which will just make your mind boggle. What we've been thinking about so far are either individuals or corporations that set up some sort of scheme and don't pay their taxes. And you think of the famous entertainers, right, who just failed to file. And suddenly when their manager nailed them, right, and they had to pay $14 million, a famous country singer had to pay back, I think it was $78 million, right? He just didn't file his taxes.
39:11And he went on tour and didn't file his taxes. You find out about that, you file a 211. Perfect. Okay, again, there's somebody else goes abroad, does lots of criminal activity. You find out about it. You file that and that so forth. But now let's talk about corporations. The other four entities, other four whistleblowing programs, almost always those are large, well run criminal corporations. I mean, sorry, just corporations.
39:46And they can't seem to help themselves. There's something about the e suite that makes them want to make even more money. And so that you're dealing with completely lawyered up and accountant up, um, targets. And yet there are areas where those corporations in the tax sphere have done things, just ridiculous things. Okay, so if you start with the false Claims act area, it's often a company that, that only does 10% or less with the government. And they just don't quite understand. Government contracting is very precise. You have to do what you say you're going to do. And the fact that some official of the government waved their hand doesn't get you off. Okay.
40:36Similarly, the SEC, you'd say they cook the books. And you would think the accountants would find the fraud, but they don't. That's Enron and all the rest of them. Because they hide it from the accountants. It's a fraud. Right. And they have a whole second set of books. And why are they doing that? Make bigger bonuses, make their stock go up. Who the heck knows? It boggles the mind. You're president of a big pharmaceutical company and you decide you're going to design the whole marketing scheme in violation of the FDA so you can make even more money. I mean, astounding. I might mention the F false Claims act. World is predominantly medical fraud, 80% or something, because we have such a disparately decision making medical scheme that that's how it works.
41:31And they don't pay their taxes either. So now we get to those international global corporations who might have done the bribery I mentioned, which would be an SEC problem. They might have traded oil. There's one.
41:49The british tobacco company decided that it liked North Korea, so it continued to supply tobacco in violations of the sanctions for years and years and years. And it was just right there in public. They're a big traded company, and they decided, what we want to do is make sure the North Koreans have cigarettes. They paid several hundred million dollars in penalties. Um, so now let's go to the one that's large and interesting. If you're a multinational corporation and you start off making a widget, and the widget consists of some stuff, okay, make it a. Make an electronic widget. It has some aluminum, it has some plastic, it has some chips that you get somewhere, little electronic chips and some wire, and then it has some big design lab somewhere, and then it has a bunch of patents, and then it has an assembly plan or more than one or ten, right? And they're all over the globe.
43:00Okay? And then in United States, you have a whole bunch of shops in the mall that sells the widget, and you have a whole bunch of branding. This is the equivalent of the Prada widget or the whatever old spice widget. And you get a product and you start off the various pieces, the chip in Taiwan and aluminum in Chile and the copper wire, I guess it's chile. And it all hits the global supply chain and the assembly chain, and it ends up on our shores. And you sell the widget for $100. The cost of those original bits and pieces might have been a lot to develop. The patent, I might add, probably isn't $100. Or we can make it $1,000 and you can look at the markup now, some things have markups, like groceries, they say is five, or I think Costco is a 14% markup. I think the grocery stores pretend it's only five.
44:16But you look at widgets like Apple and their 25 or 30% margin, right? So the question is, where did you make that money? You transferred the aluminum to the wire, and then you transferred the wire to the widget, and then you got the patent, and then you got. So you have to have a way to pricing. And the theory of this is that if you were buying those in each of the countries where they were made, there would be a third party transaction which would say, well, copper's $22 an ounce, and there you go.
44:55But that doesn't cover brands and patents. So the answer is that the big corporations just hoodwinked the IR's for years and years. And finally, about 15 years ago, 20 years ago, there was a case called Glaxo. Now, Glaxos, perfect because it was, I think, swiss, but european based, maybe swiss pharmaceutical company. It had all these patents, but it sold all its stuff in America because we paid for the same item about three times what anybody else does for reasons that would take too long for me to even understand. And this hour. So that case lasted nine years, okay? And the IR's wonde and they got $1.6 billion.
45:46And they decided, well, this is good. And how do. And so each, if you can look up transfer pricing for any of the big four accounting firms, and you can look it up, and they have whole units that go through this exercise of saying, well, what would the copper cost in Chile and what would the whatever? And the answer is that with all those lawyers and all those accountants, they still play fast and loose and they still have second sets of books because the difference of paying taxes makes a tremendous difference on your stock price, right? If you can take a third of your income and jam it into, lets say, Singapore or Ireland.
46:33Singapore and Ireland pretend to have rates, but then they give, I mean, corporate tax rates. We have 28, 23% some places. Europe has 20, France has 25 to 28, depending on the year. Ireland ends up being zero because they have a special set of rules for foreign companies that have a certain domiciliary blah, blah, blah. Same goes for Singapore. And they use it to attract capital and professional jobs. Right? One of my, I was a professor along the way, and one of my fine friends, son manages a big blue white shoe firm in Singapore. And I'm sure they have some interest in some of these matters. But the answer is that you can take a third or a half of your income that you earn in the United States that you'd have to pay tax on at 23%, and you send it to whatever.
47:32And some of them have been legal, and then they had to change the rules. There was something called a double Dutch Irish, which meant that you had the patents go back and forth between Holland and Ireland and a series of things. So in any event, the IR's keeps trying to catch up with them. And I've just explained what transfer pricing is. And there's the 3.4 billion from galaxy. Oh, I got it wrong. It was 3.4 billion. That's real money. And if you could have a, you know, file a form 211 and maybe even a billion, it'd be a nice contingent fee. You'd have to know a lot about transfer pricing. But the great thing is that the professionals inside the firm right now, there's some rules along the way about what they're supposed to do. The lawyers can't violate their legal ethics, and the SEC frowns on. The audit team doesn't give rewards to the. To the outside auditors, but the IR's doesn't care. They just want to get their money. Okay, so this is transfer pricing.
48:37And it's rather exciting when you think about the fact that if you could figure out a way to find those professionals and they're out there, they're all, remember the. We have global trade, and then we have global labor force, and we have global professionals. And clearly the big four accounting firms are there. And right now, all the big Wall street law firms or Los Angeles, Gibson and the like, all have offices, right? So they all go back and forth. So they could easily be your client even if you were in wherever, Idaho, where they retired. Who knows?
49:19So here's an article from 2024, and the IR's, it says, has woken up a new enforcement environment. This is a warning to corporations. But I'm telling you, there's a huge opportunity. We're in the middle of a series of cases. We have sort of a european outpost. It is a little like buying a lottery ticket that you might not win. On the other hand, if you have a conduit of professionals that are walking through your office all the time, some have been in Europe, and some may be having been fired or used to work at a company they don't like, there may be a story to tell. And the IR's, it says, is woken up. I'll believe that when I see the awards, but you never know.
50:19All right, now let's talk about something else. There's one of the great ways that you can set up this,
50:28in effect, transfer your profits to a country with no tax system is you put, you lodge the patents that obviously take a lot of effort to build in a country with low tax like Ireland or Singapore, and then you pay the patent license fees all to that country. And then by the time the widget arrives in America, it's only $98. You only made $2. You only have to sell, pay taxes on the $2, not the $70. So the service, realizing how difficult this all was, said, why don't we pre negotiate this? So with the largest companies, they put in an advanced pricing agreement. What that means is that the accountants and the lawyers come forward and say from the company, say, well this is how we file it. We check out the Fairmark pricing and where we get the copper and then we check it out here. And then in patents, we look at the global price of patents. And so the service then says, well, let's negotiate this right now and we'll give you an agreement that you can file under these license tariffs for this period of time under the APA.
51:45And then there's no fight, there's no audit and you don't sneak off and not pay your taxes. So I think there's now among the global hundred, probably 80 of them have these. They're quite large and quite elaborate documents, but they basically have a list of patents at the end of them and they have a list of payments and they have a list of years. If it's going to be changed. That's all well and good, but guess what? Once they have that, then they figure out, at least in some of the cases we're dealing with a way to have a second set of books and not quite follow it. So then you have a great case because then you have a breach, the APA, and intentional violation. And it in some ways makes it easier to prove the case because they knew what they were supposed to do and they didn't. All right, now let's turn to the form. We're getting well into the time.
52:44This is the form and this is how to file it. And you go to the whistleblowing office, internal revenue, and it describes exactly who should file it, who should do it. Okay, it has to be an actual whistleblower. You can't be. And he has to sign it in ink and you have to mail it. See that? Mail it. Mail it. US post office return requested to Ogden, Utah. The form, which is called an application for award for original information looks like this. And you fill it out. And what I strongly suggest is that it becomes an odd circumstance because just like owning the department of vehicles, it's supposed to be a form, right? You put it in and it's going to go to an office, it's going to go in the mail. But if you're describing any of the kind of big elaborate schemes I've mentioned, it takes a legal brief, right? So basically you fill this out, you check the various boxes and under eleven you say see attached narrative. And the narrative is as good a complaint as you can write in narrative form. Okay?
53:56The who, why, where, what, when people, dates, attachments, exhibits exactly what you'd like to do to survive. A nine b, you don't want to have it. Anything but the most complete story you can make. Now whats interesting is that, and you want to say right up front in eleven, you want to say this is a tax fraud, failure to pay approximately. And put the number as bold as you can get because remember theres 30,000 of these coming in. I said that. Right. 30,000 are on the way in over the course of the year. And if you think about it, it's, you know,
54:41800 a week, I mean 100 a day. Right. And just to get noticed is the problem. So make sure you say tax fraud. Make sure you say the millions involved. Make sure you have a narrative. And make the narrative in the beginning of it. Explain it to someone who is not a lawyer and is a clerk in the IR's searching through this paper. And this is things you can't be, but you notice it doesn't say you can't be involved in it. So one of the things I want to mention is that if you took thirty thousand two hundred eleven s and you only attached to them ten pages of the narrative and then you printed them and then you stack them up, it's a hundred feet tall piece of paper, pile of paper. Right. It's just do the numbers.
55:38So it's a huge problem to get noticed and I'm not.
55:44What we'd love to do is help you. If you, anytime you want to think this through, you really want to make sure that you have it dead to rights. What they did wrong, that you have the actual primary documents. It's not, I think they didn't pay their taxes. It's, here's the bank account, here's a picture of the person going whatever, whatever the heck it is. And if it's inside a corporation there, it's great because there are documents after documents. Remember that when the client walks in, one of the things he says is, well, I have these documents as part of my employment and I don't. But I signed this document saying I can never give them to anybody.
56:26What's great is that the rule is that any citizen who finds what they believe and reasonably believe is illegal activity have the right to take those documents to the authorities, which means take them to their attorney and give them to the authorities, and they cannot be subject to theft or violations of the nondisclosure. In addition, if the non disclosure says do not give this to the government, that itself is a violation that you can file a whistleblower form on because it says you may go every confidential agreement written with any lawyer attached to it. You may, of course, go to the various authorities, including the Security and savings Commission. That's part of how Dodd Frank works. So the answer is the original document, copies of them that prove the fraud. And then your job as an attorney is to distill it into the essence on the form.
57:36Failure to pay $200 million in taxes in these years pursuant to a transfer pricing fraud, deliberately executed in the executive suite with the same set of books. That's one sentence, right? See? Narrative. And then laid out just like a complaint. Don't. I think it's important, don't take this because it's just a form as having any less quality than the finest complaint you've ever written. Because if you get their attention, it is that right? It is a complaint. The same as that false claims complaint or any other complaints you've ever written. And unless it works, you're not going to succeed.
58:18So that's the form. Whoops, I went backwards. I've mentioned that there's going to be multiple tcrs and multiple attacks. If you do any whistleblowing practice, you have to know how to do the IR's one. And it's a big pain in the ass to figure it out. Go figure it out, because every time you file any of the others, you're going to have to avoid malpractice. You should file an IR's because what if there was a tax evasion and there was multi agency investigation and there was an award, but you didn't get award because you didn't send a form in, right? Okay. This is how the treasury one works. This is how the SEC one works. It's in the, incidentally, the.
59:04This hour is yours now. It's in your machine, but if you want the actual PowerPoint, we can send it to you and they have it and the vendor has it. And now let's talk about, we have almost used up the hour, but let's talk about some of these. We have a few cases here. One of the things that you'll find, and this is sort of the, the disappointing thing about this, you get an exciting case, you drill into it. The whistleblower doesn't quite understand it, you don't understand it. You go to other law firms that know this stuff, like us, which we're happy to Coventure with you. You figure out an exciting fraud.
59:51You figure out that the smoking gun documents to prove it. Remember, frauds are by definition hidden, right? So finding anything that proves it is very difficult. They've been hiding it from their own accountants. You write it all up, you file the form, then you don't hear anything for a long time. And then they may say, we'd like to interview your whistleblower. And then they interview them and they seem to ask the right questions, and then they disappear.
1:00:24You might know some people or have some people in your constellation that know how to call the whistleblowing office and or the transfer pricing office. Incidentally, the head of the whistling office is formerly head of the transfer pricing. So you know where their, where their focus is. But there'll just be a lot of silence and then you may end up making your client a lot of money or it may just disappear. Because they don't think it was a tax fraud. They did their investigations. There was an alternative universe created by the professionals or whatever, and that's it. But every once in a while, they'll then do a press release. So you just kind of watch. And there it is,
1:01:0529 billion. I'm just mentioning that even if they collected like 10% of that and you had a whistleblowing claim that knew what they were doing, that would be good. These are just horrendously huge possibilities. But remember, it's within 30,000 different claims, 100ft of paper. And your job, or you and accountants, we bring in and everybody else is to get it noticed. And again, what's the secret of this is that you're also sending it to the right tax guy at the DOJ who's in charge of large tax frauds, along with the TCR from Treasury, because it's also money laundering, along with the other guy at the DOJ that does securities fraud because they didn't put it in there in their annual report. So anyway, huge numbers. Okay. The funny thing is, I add this at the end of our hour, is that perfectly normal people making millions of dollars decide they want to make even more and cheat the government on the taxes that, you know, the taxes is why we have roads and we're not being invaded and stuff. So it just boggles the mind. Almost every whistleblowing case, including I was whistleblower too along the way and brought in half a billion dollars.
1:02:21It just, you go, well, what were they thinking? And I always say to my kids, now they're grown up, say to my kids, kids, whatever you do, always picture it printed on the front page. And they used to have things called newspapers printed on the front page of Google and as long as you can print it, you're fine. So what this CEO thought is beyond me, right? They go to prison for billion dollar biofuel tax fraud scheme. This is a deliberate tax credit scheme that they dreamed up. They knew it was illegal. They had to go to prison. Just astounding. So that's the end of the hour. If you'd like to expand your practice to include whistleblowing cases, particularly an IR's one like we discussed, you can be part of our whistleblowing network. You email me and I keep a set of interested lawyers. I'll let you know if we do a new program and basically we're here. I've had a wonderful career in the law. I just loved it. And I was a law professor and then I was actually in the trenches and in both the worlds of law firms and accounting.
1:03:30But at about the turn of the century when I was whistleblower, I've now been doing for almost 25 years, which a good chunk of my career, whistleblowing. And it's just the most fun and the most rewarding and it does good and you can make a lot of money. So we'd love to help you. Here's how you contact me. Get on my mailing list and I'll keep you informed. And mostly what I do is just talk to people to see if there's something there. And you kiss, I might add, you kiss a lot of frogs. And they're not princes, they're just frogs. But I'm happy to do such and help you out anytime you want. Hope you get interested in this. It's a great part of the law and it does do some good and make us have a better world to live in. Thank you very much.
1:04:19I quite enjoy this hour. Thanks so much. Bye. That's me.