Kathleen O.NC
Enjoyed the program and format; the presenters complemented each other. Nicely done.
1h 0min · about 8,900 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, how are you? My name is Vincent Syracuse. And they found the important Tannenbaum helpern, Syracuse in her Street, where my practice is in the litigation and dispute resolution area, as well as professional responsibility and legal ethics. We're here today to talk about hot topics, and legal ethics in the mind lawyer. I'm joined by Elissa gold rich, was one of my colleagues in our firm, and also works with me, the ethics of professional responsibility area. Melissa, how are you? Hi, how are you? So we're gonna try to do in the next hour is talk about legal ethics. Try to make it enjoyable, try to give you some practical hints and tips on how to handle issues we face in everyday practice. And the first topic we're going to talk about is something called virtual, Laurie. Melissa was you saw it. So, um, as Lynn said, we're going to try to make this enjoyable for you. Also, instead of reading a bunch of rules, we put together some fact patterns of some hot button issues that have arisen either in our practice or people that we've discussed with so the first one is, um, regarding virtual lawyering. Most days I work from home, using my laptop and cell phone, I have a private password protected Wi Fi connection. However, occasionally, I like to get a change of scenery, and we'll go sit outside at a local coffee shop and use the shops public Wi Fi, or at a park and use the hotspot on my phone to do work. Is that an issue? Am I required to do anything differently while practicing from home as
2:00opposed to the office? Are there any obligations that are heightened in a remote environment? Or do my obligations remain the same as if I was physically in the office? So the answer to this question I'm gonna work backwards is yes, absolutely. Your obligations are high end in a remote environment. As opposed to if you're in the office, the issue and the key here when we're working remotely or even in the office, but especially when working remotely is protecting client confidences, whether that client confidence by the way of documentary evidence or document you receive or conversations you're having with a client, the key is always to make sure that you are protecting the clients competences to the best that you can, um, using a public Wi Fi is never recommended. I don't think by any of the of the ethical guidelines not especially not in New York, there are significant cyber security threats that can come along with using a public Wi Fi connection. It's just never recommended. And same with using the hotspot on your phone. While that's more secure and protected, it is still not recommended, it is recommended that you use a Wi Fi router, something stationary, that is password protected, and you have a unique passcode that you can use, if you must use that if you're working outside of the office. And aside from that, the other things that you should be concerned about when working in a public setting such as a Parker coffee shop. And you want to make sure that if you're taking any client calls, that nobody
3:38is in the vicinity that they can hear you I think we often overlook how easy it is to inadvertently disclose protected client information by just a phone call. Or the key. The key here is to be smart and Be careful. And at the same time be practical. Because it's everything works very smoothly. When there's no problem with an adversary or a client, when there's a problem and having lots of explain. And the more you have to explain, the more people will not likely to believe you. So be smart. The fact that you've worked practicing or virtually working and not in the office doesn't mean that you should ignore certain basic protocols like confidentiality, like keeping score as secure way workplace, things like that. Listen. Sure and and and as Ben said, Don't ignore basic points such as confidentiality but competence as well. I know here in New York, the ethical rules require that you be competent in any technology use. It should never be lost. I knew that at home, you likely don't have access to your IP expert that you would at your your firm so make sure that if you're choosing to work from home You must work from home.
5:02And I can't I can't emphasize one episode the importance. Recently here in New York, there was a case, we all know about Microsoft Teams. The courts in New York use Microsoft Teams. We all we had a situation, there was a situation where we were involved in a situation where a lawyer had trouble using Microsoft Teams. And he was really faulted for not being responsible in the technological areas. And the the judge when they get into this later on, but the judge felt that his inability to fuse teams was a strategy to potentially disrupt the proceeding, think about them. So you know, it's worth the time to the matter, you're as young as Alyssa, or as old as I am, is worth the time to learn about the technology, and learn the use of technology. And if you have an IT professional, when you're in the office, or we're on call these you know, they're there to help make moves. So make no mistake about that.
6:12That's exactly right. And then on the topic of Microsoft Teams, or zoom, the next question is, what is the protocol for dress when appearing on Zoom or Microsoft Teams for work meeting? And while I don't know that you need to wear a full Su, I think this one is pretty self explanatory in that you should always make sure you're dressed appropriately. If you're appearing before the tribunal. I would recommend, you know, a jacket. It's out of respect for the tribunal respect for the profession. I think it goes without saying that over the course of the pandemic, we've read about certain instances where attorneys really skirted the line between what was appropriate and what wasn't, then do you want to take that one?
7:00I think we can debate we listen, I write something called the attorney professionalism Forum, which is in the New York State Bar journal. And we've addressed some of these issues in that forum. And I can give you a commercial later on, for the folks that we have out on this. But basically, I think when you're appearing virtually, it's the same thing should be the same thing as being in the courtroom. That means you have to dress professionally. There are examples, some terrible things going on. People early in the pandemic, taking court appearances by virtual court appearances in dead are in their bathing suits, poolside, vases, poolside. And there was even a situation where I rec read or read about whether it was some kind of doctor doing some kind of surgery. And guess what? He was a witness of a proceeding. And he was one hand had the scalpel of one hand at the zoom. Well, that's that's ridiculous. It's not a question simply for you, as Warren. So see, friends, if you're going to have a hearing, or something like that dress professionally, dressed in a manner that doesn't call attention to yourself. That's no different. In my view, if you're in a courtroom, or you're in a Zoom Room, you dress your dress in a T shirt, you're going to call attention to yourself, you're going to distract from the argument you're going to make that you spent a lot of time preparing for and charging money to your clients to do and all of a sudden you want to dress like you're in bed or something like that. That's that's it's use common sense. Exactly right.
8:52So the next fact pattern we have is called the Living Room lawyer. I live in apartment with my wife and toddler because we have limited space, my home office is the living room. This does not pose a problem for most of the day. However, when my wife and toddler get home around 5pm, I have to work in their presence. In addition, I keep all my client files in my desk in the living room, but it doesn't have a lot. My family knows lead by work papers along but is there something else I am required to do? How else can I make my home office ethically compliant? I think the key here and Dennis and I have had multiple conversations about this and that the key here is that you have to be reasonable there.
9:32Everybody has different circumstances. Now while I think everyone would love to have a separate home office with five locked file storage, that's just not everybody's circumstance. So you have to do the best that you can do. But be reasonable take the proper precautions because, again, as Ben said, you don't want to be standing on the carpet having to justify something that happened that could have been easily avoidable. So if you don't have The ability to have a separate standalone office away from everything and you have to work in your living room, you need to set very clear boundaries with your family or anybody who lives with you to let them know that you know, your workspace is your workspace and it should not be interfered with at all. And make sure that you to the best of your ability protect any information that would be sensitive to the client. And it's not something that you want, you know, laying around, it should be put away in a file folder that's not easily accessible to family, or anybody actually entering you know that space is yours, she was lawyer have responsibility to maintain client security. Now, you don't have to be necessarily crazy about that. You can be passive about that. But think about the fact what would what would a client walk into the door as your office and says, By the way, I had a lawyer representing me, and all of a sudden all my documents come up on the internet with somebody or something like that? How would you explain that? That's, that's, that's the issue here. So that does that mean, you got to be practical. Ideally,
11:16you have the dedicated ones in your home or corner of a room where you can talk privately without having your family or your kids involved. Now, that may, if so in certain instances that may be unavoidable. And then you have to explain that. But treat your home office as if it was your office, not virtual things, consider things like having a shred of things, having some kind of earphone so that people don't hear your conversations. certain basic things. Another issue that arose a lot during the pandemic and still fairly new issue is that, um, attorneys working from home forgot about their listening devices, whether that be Google or Amazon or whatnot. And they have them on in these workspaces. And they were either chiming in during zoom calls or on oral arguments, or, you know, if you have a client's name is very similar to Alexa, for example, once the listening device starts, picks up that it's being spoken to, it starts recording the real issue there with disclosing client confidences because you don't know where that information is being stored. So it's best practice, unplug them, remove them from your workspace, and just avoid an issue before it's an issue.
12:46There used to be a law professor in New York, his name was David Siegel. And do seven expressions. He said follow the SEC Rule in all situations, meaning, have these issues decided in someone else's case. Right. That's being spied. That's being careful. Because if you end up you know, I learned that those of us who've tried cases now that have a witness has to explain too many things. After a while, the explanation is irrelevant. And all the findings of fact finds here is the dead the need to explain something. So that's the practice with being careful. Carlos Famo has of being practical and careful. Our next fact pattern is called the personal email problems. My client recently sent me a zip file containing highly sensitive financial information to review. I really prefer to review documents in hardcopy form, so I decided to print them off. However, I've been working from home and my printer doesn't have capacity to print large files. I decided to forward the zip file to my personal email address and go to Staples to use their industrial printer. Staples is a large company so I'm sure their networks are protected. Should I be aware of any ethical concerns in printing the clients documents at Staples? The answer to this is absolutely yes. First of all, it does matter what type of documents you are printing, whether it's you know, if you're going to print it the entire public record or docket and then the files case that may be a different situation. But if the client is sending you highly
14:32sensitive financial documents that you want to review in hardcopy. It is not best practice to use staples and server to print them in a public setting. First of all, you're not you don't know if staples retains copies, Staples or any company really or somewhere it's best practice to if you can print them at the office and if you must bring them home And, and do that or have them sent to you, I would not go to a large big box store and print highly sensitive client information, unless you want to take a lot of risk. Right? That's that's the issue here. And you know, I've had an expression called Syracuse's spectrum of risk, on one side of the spectrum is no risk.
15:21And the other side, it's absolute risk. So how much risk do you want to take, you know, I can understand there might be a need for these documents, they may have no choice, and therefore you have to make that decision. Is it worth taking the risk? If you have a little time, and you're working at home, maybe there's gonna be someone in the office who could print out the document for you, and send it to you by Federal Express. Now, there's another issue here. He said, Listen, you said something about forwarding your email to personal email account, edits at Gmail as a data problem. I think when we don't want to get into anything controversial about Google, Google's a great.
16:03It's a great, wonderful thing. But yeah, well, whether it's Gmail, Yahoo, AOL, whatever the case may be, I don't think it'll come as a surprise to anyone that your firm email is likely more secure than any Gmail or personal email device that you you may use. So we always recommend against forwarding client confidences to your personal emails, God forbid it gets compromised. It's not only your information that's out there, it's now the client. And And another important point is, is it's the disclosure or the inadvertent disclosure, which we will talk about next of client confidences, it's not only the judge, you will have to explain that to the client as well. So if you're, if you have the potential to inadvertently disclose highly sensitive business information that would detrimentally affect your business, that's not a conversation I don't want to be a part of with the client, especially where that can be avoided. Or many people have VPNs, or virtual protected network, on their on their office, domain emails, you know, and that protects you from someone who may be stupid. Some people practice all with use Citrix, and not all Citrix Systems are some Citrix Systems allow you to go on the internet, some dos. So some people think that they are only choice. If they want to get an email, or get on the internet, there's an internet, link in the email, send it to Gmail, once you do that, the cats out of the bed. And it may very well be that nothing bad will happen. Or something could happen. I mean, one of the things you
17:57can do is send a link, do you have a link in the email instead of going into Gmail? Because I'm told that there's a place in your where all these emails are being monitored. So you know, paranoids have real enemies too.
18:15So on that note, we are going to move to the topic of inadvertent disclosure, which is a very hot button issue in the law right now, especially with everybody working remotely. So I will turn it over to Vince. Okay. Disclosure.
18:43I'm sorry, didn't you I'm gonna read the fact pattern. Read the fact pattern yet please. Okay, so we recently received a large document production and a hotly contested business divorce matter. As my associate was reviewing defendants production, she noticed that three privileged communications were produced with the production. What is the associates obligation with respect to the privilege communication, a stop breathing and alert opposing counsel of the inadvertent disclosure and delete the documents? Be read the document to clarify whether it is privileged and alert, opposing counsel of the inadvertent disclosure? See, send the documents to your client and let them decide, or D nothing. It's not your fault opposing counsel made the mistake?
19:29Well, this is one of the most subject we've written on. And it's one of the most controversial and my opinion misunderstood issues of all time, and it varies from state to state. The opera role in most jurisdictions is rule 4.4 D. and New York, Pennsylvania Rules of Professional Responsibility. The ABA has a similar row rule. And the question is, what do you do and In New York, and in many jurisdictions, the only ethical obligation that one might have is to properly notify the center. I got this email from there on, what do you do? It's almost overseas. Not a province here, the site, the various jurisdictions, but in some jurisdictions, you have an obligation not only notify the sender, stop reading some jurisdictions, you may have an obligation to give it back.
20:35You have to also decide, or now, what context was this disclosure? Is it in the context of a litigation? Is it in the context of a corporate transaction? And what you know, what's the cat is out of the bag, so to speak, it could put great, huge problems for you as a recipient. So for example, you're in a corporate transaction. And all of a sudden you get an email, you copied an email from the opposing counsel in the transaction that says, you know, what, Syracuse doesn't know, that, just as soon as we signed the deal, we intend to breach it. You know, and that, that is the war is writing that because break give rise to cause of action against the lawyer. But what what what series has got the email?
21:26What do you do now? I now know that this person has no obligation of performing, they got the contract, and we've been negotiated. Okay, what do I do that? Do I tell my client? Should I tell my client? Must I tell my client, these are all judgment issues. I mean, the extreme example that I've given, if you saw an email, to the opposing counsel, saying, The mercy of words in substance, the effect that they don't intend to have won the deal, in my opinion, smart lawyer would tell his client, SWAT lawyer, my calls the deal, the ways of doing, and it's very different. If you're in a corporate transaction, or business transaction, this was a litigation. Because obviously, in the litigation, you have a judge in the stress corporate transaction, you don't have a judge. And most litigations, place here in New York, I think all over the country. People negotiate complex litigation, fallback positions, sort of the delivered disclosure, you have a lot of stipulation or whatever whatever protocol might exist, or will say, I get the court back and get to take it back. Once you tell me that I didn't hurt that produces. I get to take it back, you know. But there's also something beauties in United we hold one person's inadvertent disclosure might very well be a strategy. And as strange as that might seem, and all of a sudden, the strategy backfired. And the inadvertent disclosure is is what's the attorney says? Let's try to get the document back. And that's not necessarily going to be very easy. So it's so it's, it's yes, and no, the rules understand the rules.
23:22And many jurisdictions, I think, most jurisdictions, the obligation is simply to give it back that the vector to notify the inside. And there have been various proposals in many jurisdictions, where people have been trying to impose an ethical responsibility on a lawyer to do more than to simply notify, like, give it back, or stop reading. And that's, it's such a judgmental listen, I also think there's a practical component to it as well, in that, you know, barring the the extreme circumstances that Vince mentions where you get an E, a privileged email saying that, you know, the client doesn't intend to proceed with the contract or intends to breach it. And I think that that's a different circumstance, but oftentimes, on when you get when you get information that has been inadvertently disclosed by live privilege communications, it, at least in my practice, has not risen to that extreme level. And under those circumstances, you want to just take a look and say, Okay, well, even if there is no clawback provision, you know, if they're asking me to destroy the document, do you really care that much, right. And do you do you want to pick a fight over something that, you know, a judge would probably my say, depending on the judge, you know, you really should delete this information, it was inadvertently disclosed. That's exactly that's right. This is beyond the area of Professional athletes, I think maybe it's maybe you want to call it civility, you know, maybe you want to call it
25:07goes around comes around. We were all capable of pressing the wrong button and copying an adversary on an email. And they drop these drop down menus, on emails, relief. So it comes around, namely that you want to be a lawyer who takes advantage of an adversary that way. And God forbid you made a mistake, the same mistake when you want that lawyer to give it back. So that's, that's the absolutely and I so the, the question here is, is really a trick question because as Ben mentioned, on, the only real obligation is to promptly notify the sender. The ABA rule as in this, promptly notify them to allow them to take protective measures. So that's probably exactly what we said that fallback provision, destroying the document, etc. But even with that, once it whatever the lawyer has already read, you can call back the document, you can delete it from your database, you can't delete it from your mind.
26:18So diligence is always very key in this regard, and the next step pattern we have is called review before you regret. As you are packing up to leave the office after another long day jam packed with calls and meetings, you realize that you forgot to provide your client with an update regarding a deposition you recently took, which the client has been requesting for some time. The client Holly Walsh has an easy email address, h walsh@yahoo.com, which are mounted Microsoft Outlook program recognizes and anticipates with every keystroke you make in the two lines. This auto population feature pops up H Walsh at Bradford law.com. In a hurry, you fail to double check the email and hit the send key to check your final tasks of the day often to do lists. After hitting send, you get the fleeting sense that perhaps the email is going to the wrong person. You check your sent box and your heart thing.
27:20What do you do?
27:24So I know that there are a number of Microsoft Outlook at least has a clawback of its own option where you can try to stop or retract the email before the other party opens. But let's assume for this for the purposes of this fast pattern that you were too late to do that. The opposing counsel, who you've now sent this email to is extremely diligent and opened your email immediately. Is the Cavs admin favor? Well, they may very well be.
28:04I agree. I think that in that case, I I don't know whether the opposing counsel would have an obligation to stop reading the other lawyers perception of how a deposition went?
28:22What do you think? It my answer depends on the person's revealing, in the most once again. What would you want to do? What would you want? What would you want to be done to you? Right? If you know someone made a mistake, the civil thing to do in fact, some I'd say, professional thing to stop reading the documents or send it back. So I know you didn't intend to send this to me. So we'll send it back. Right, I agree with you. I think that, again, much of this is is practical, and what you give is what you're gonna get. And even the most diligent and perfect lawyer will likely find themselves in a circumstance where they they're on the wrong and inadvertent disclosure. And when that happens, you want to make sure that you know you, your adversary would do for you what you've done for them. So I agree with Vince, I would tend to err on the side of sending an email back to opposing counsel. It looks like this email wasn't meant for me.
29:41I'm going to delete it and let them know that I'm and it sounds like Vinci you tend to be in agreement on that. I do. But the question is now another question. So I'm going to show you tell your client Do you have an obligation tell us what you have have an obligation to say to your client, at least I got this email. I'm gonna give it back. I was telling you I stopped reading it.
30:11Well, I actually thought that your question was more so just the lawyer who inadvertently send the email have an obligation to tell our clients that they did. So that's another issue.
30:24That would tell you, in my opinion, probably 10 Boys might say no, because they don't want to admit that was a mistake. And that might depend also, on the relationship work with your client. So I think the point of this is that there is no such thing as too much diligence, when you're sending and receiving anything that would be considered attorney client privilege, protected information from a client, you want to track, you want to double check, and you want to make sure that you're preserving client competences, where, wherever possible things, mistakes, like this may seem small, but depending on what is inadvertently disclosed, it can have a really large consequence. And as Ben said, you don't want to be the lawyer standing on the carpet in front of the judge explaining this, where it's such an easy thing to avoid.
31:22What about things like metadata?
31:26So metadata is a really interesting point, because I think it is not that new, but still a fairly unique concept to many lawyers. And I'm always surprised when we get a document production, and it doesn't have any metadata, because we always make sure to put it in our ESI protocols, that that's not something you want, however, you learn how to be okay. That's a document production issue. That's a litigation issue. Yeah. What about metadata, and communications with your client with your opposing counsel? documents like that? Should you scrub the metadata, you should all I'm of the belief, you should always scrub the metadata, I think metadata can come back to bite you in, in certain circumstances it the metadata, I we always scrub, in fact, our system prompts us to do so before we send an outside email.
32:25What does it does it prompts and you can skip it or not skip it. And most of the times, you don't skip it. But what happens when you're working at home, is your home system has the same automatic scrubbing, and mine, most systems don't happen. So that's something you have to think about when you're exchanging documents, with the opposing party, from working from home, that's another area of security, you might both have, a lot of times without a doubt, it's just nonsense, negotiated an agreement, who cares? Who's on your office, whether it was illicit Vince or somebody else made a change? Don't really care about that. So it's a question of thinking and thinking about the fact you might want to have that email sent all the time, none of us have a sewer system in the office. You may be working at home with those offices have incompetent staff. So I used to do that. So ediscovery vendors can do that as well. Right? That's right. Phrases a good point.
33:39If you're negotiating a contract, for example, and you're working from home, you know who whether you suggested this revision i That comment might be on the document. So so the answer is you don't want that. And if you care about that, just take it out and take a step to protect it. That's right. Yes.
34:02So staying with our theme, what you give is what you get, we are going to move on to a very hot topic and legal ethics these days, civility, professionalism and decorum.
34:19So what do you do the fact that? Sure, I was defending my client at a deposition last week where I felt the attorney taking the deposition was intentionally trying to trick my client by asking confusing questions. And an effort to zealously advocate for my client. I adjusted to every single question that I thought was confusing and made sure to stay on the record why I thought the question was improper. For example, the attorney asked my client how many times my client had personally met her client in the month of May. I knew that was a trick question because I believed her clients would be traveling abroad for that entire month before my client could answer the question And I made sure to let the record reflect that her client was abroad during that period. So there were no meeting. When the attorney taking the deposition status outline Jessen were improper, I further Let the record reflect that she had no idea what she was talking about. And she needed to stop asking my clients silly question. When she continued to make an issue out of my objections, and my instructions to the client not to answer her ridiculous questions. I told her she was being obnoxious. She later made a motion for sanctions against me, which I also believe was improper, was I wrong?
35:38Short answer is that the speaking objections are improper, and could be a violation of rules. So those of you in other jurisdictions, any jurisdiction and litigation, when you have a deposition, obviously, you need to know what the rules are. In New York, you can make speaking objections. And that makes it challenging. So this is the defendant deposition, because you think a client is going off the reservation, and the lawyer is doing things that he or she shouldn't be doing. So for your own, I mean, I think that the very judges will say, you may speaking objectives, and you shouldn't be that doing that, and you shouldn't be interfering with deposition. Now, as a practical matter, you might have no choice, you might have had no choice. But to make the speaking objections. That's, you know, that's, that's a litigation, one point of five type of thing.
36:51I think what the issue here is that, for some reason, it seems that during the pandemic, the line between zealous advocacy and being overly aggressive, have got an unnecessarily aggressive have gotten extremely blurred. Now, I don't know if that's because everyone's comfortable at home or what the case is. But I think I know this specific fact pattern, it's safe to say that the attorney in the spirit of zealous advocacy, took it a bit too far to name call your adversary to to, you know, call question her competence on the record at a deposition, I'd be hard pressed to find a judge that finds that behavior to be civil, ethical, and in the spirit of, you know, keeping up with the are perfect the dignity of our profession. And so, as been said, most most jurisdictions, I think on state that speaking objections are improper, but I don't even know that that's the biggest issue. This fact pattern, it's also it's also behaving okay. The New York State, we have civility guidelines, not least in New York, not ethical prescriptions. That's important that we have civility guidelines, that lawyers are expected to fall forth in litigation and transactions that affect all settings. Plus, they are not ethical, a violation of the rule. These rules, at least in New York is not an ethical violation, not part of the rules, professional responsibility. Other jurisdictions may be differences. I think he you have to know what the rules are. And in particular jurisdiction, having said that, it goes back to the Civility guidelines, go back to the days of revvo litigation, where some
38:56of us actually carried money in our pockets, they fail. In the event the judge wanted to sanction. So the answer is supposed to be a visa was did not interfere with the deposition. But business lawyer, the lawyer taking a deposition as an obligation to be civil as well. And what I find with Zoom depositions, and you can do this, I think so much during the deposition, because like this, and that can make the client even the defending warrior. totally nuts. So we have to be careful with that as well. But and the other thing is, if you mentioned illicit zealous advocacy, the word zealous advocacy, you will not find any place and the rules of professional responsibilities here in New York, was taken out a long time ago. A lot of lawyers don't know that. But you should be an advocate but you'll also deal with the address the the arguments of deposition in a professional way. I mean, I was in a deposition with someone said that someone taking a deposition, obviously is your first deposition because you, you haven't resolved the first sentence because you don't know what you're doing. That's a terrible than say, you should never say that shouldn't get away with that. The question is, if you have all these abuses or sanctions in the courts, should your view the victim of this move for sanctions? Or should you just suck it up and move on? What do you think Alyssa? Well, I think that's one the client calls, how aggressive the client wants to be, um, regarding the, you know, with the lawyers. Counsel, I think that would be a client call.
40:44You know, I think it really depends. There's a line where if the lawyer acts somewhat improperly, somewhat on civil, whether it's worth it to make the motion. But I think under a fact pattern like this, it would be worth it to make the motion if for no other reason to set the stage for the sanctity of our profession, you want a lawyer should not be acting in this manner, especially on the record at a deposition, you will find cases, I will say that this lack of civility is not an independent basis for a scientist application. And I think you have to be careful of frivolous sanctions applications, let's say this application should you choose to make it would be frivolous. What I am saying is that if you gotta do this, build the record, create a record on the deposition, maybe do a couple of timeouts, let the adversary lose his or her coal, not you. And if it happens over a period of time, and repeat it happen, then you come over sanctions, and said it's unprofessional behavior, not because it's a violation of the Civility guidelines. Because it's improper behavior. And personas. This is not a star chamber, where you have someone underneath a stool underneath us, like you might see NCIS like that. We all have that. But we have to we have an obligation to ourselves to our clients for a system. That could be goody two shoes that talking about that. That's a be professional. Three people who step three to process and respect. As you take the high road. In my view, it's going to come back to you and help you with this case,
42:43because the judge will monitor the situation. When I used to have someone tell me, every lawyer starts off with 100 points in every case, and the end of the day when it's over the last person standing with the same number of points, the most vulgar points, if one is every time you do something, you might think it's a great idea. It may be a great idea, maybe the greatest strategy in the world, but it might backfire face. So my view, build a record and was Mohan. Great.
43:21All right. So our next fact pattern is one that may be all super familiar is dealing with an adversary who just can't tell the truth. I have always tried to be civil and to a certain extent friendly with opposing counsel, employers are hired to achieve a positive result for their clients. I have always found that working together with an adversary is far more effective than it is harmful. I recently got involved in a few very contentious litigation where my adversaries have been keen on bending or fabricating the facts and misstating. The law, whether it be on the record ended deposition during oral argument or even in briefs submitted to the court. I have recently experienced attorneys who blatantly lie to the court concerning the facts of the case, and make misrepresentations about relevant documents. Some of these lawyers are from large big law firm. My guess was that they're counting on their adversaries being poorly prepared to recognize and raise their misrepresentations to the core. How should I handle adversaries who just can't tell the truth? goes a record.
44:27Hill the record, a lot of times, judges will think that it's proper advocacy. But if someone makes misrepresentations to the court, held the record, notify that person and indeed consider making your sanctions application that happens too often. So the other question is back kind of dances though. Do I run the risk of annoying the court by raising numerous misrepresentations made by counsel? Yes, you do. You do. So you have to, again, it's a question of risk, what you want to do, and what judgments and being smart, that's very, very important, because if someone said, repeatedly said, the evidence shows the light was red, when in fact, it was green all the time, and you can prove that that person is going to be really in deep trouble. When the judge he is the judges, in my opinion, I've worked with work with judges, for judges, in my career, the judges. See, a lot of this is noise. Because someone is trying to be used where we use before a zealous advocate a proper advocate, by taking a position. That's a they view, as a fair reading of the law. But there are people who just don't get don't get it. And they and they constantly misrepresent. And we've all seen that as the most frustrating thing in the world, how do you explain it to your client, that this person is saying, you know, that there was a conversation a certain day was suddenly was said, think about that. So you what you what you want to do is keep your powder dry, I hate to use that kind of expression, keep your powder dry, and be
46:36ready to move. And if someone is characteristically, continually misrepresenting the facts, then you build the record. And this is and if need be, get in front of the judge. And as with your client, there are these motions, your motions you did very often. It's a summary judgment motion or something like that, or trial issue. You should have the ammunition that you need to prove that this person is misrepresenting. There are always going to be people with this represent. That's unfortunately a fact of life. And dealing with them, this is the issue. And if you need to bring it to the attention of a judge, so explain to your client, make sure you quite understand that these types of motions, or have costs associated. And if the person if it's a motion, and you're responding to the motion, and the adversary made these lies in the moving papers, we're going to brief you on the next word. And you have an ample opportunity without involving the judge to just explain it. And say, he said this person's he or she said this person this, this was the effect. In fact, the evidence is to the contrary. So but then what about the concern of a court turning on the on the lawyer trying to report this misconduct and essentially finding their conduct unprofessional or uncivil for calling their adversary out as a liar?
48:13Good. This is Syracuse's risk avoidance. Yeah, if you will, if you're going to bring it to the attention. And I've discussed this many times with judges. If you're going to bring this to the attention of a judge, you better damn well be sure that you have all your ducks lined up in a row. You have all your ammunition ready to roll. And as you've explained to the client, there's a risk associated with that. And maybe you're better off just letting it be part of the buzz of litigation. If I were the judge, I'd say Oh, come on. You people always, very often say, How many times have I heard back that someone is not telling the truth? That is stretching the evidence? Yeah, this is a business about credibility, though. They've been in mine. Those of you taking this course are in different courts, different jurisdictions. And the rules, they vary from place to place.
49:16One thing is for sure, any place and I've I've tried cases, divan cases all across the country, my career judges pretty much the same they they've won. They weren't the intent the process of the process. But did you get a waste of judges time and you're gonna lose
49:43to them to this point, I think that especially now with the backlog of COVID cases and whatnot, judges are extremely busy. They you need to be sure that you got a winner here and if this is really egregious kind On that, before you make a motion for sanctions against a lawyer and or their client on it, because if you're coming with some potentially harmful conduct that you're not, it's not well supported, you really do run the risk of annoying the judge more than anything. Judges are very busy people, their clerks are very busy. They, you know, they're there to resolve the dispute, determine who's gonna win, who's not going to win resolve the issues, but there wasn't gatekeepers. And, and they're also mindful of credibility, when we sell as lawyers is our credibility. And if a person is repeatedly stating facts, they have no choice. But look, but look for the look for the right way to raise the issue. But for the right time to raise the issue. Maybe you want to send an email to your adversary, say, by the way, I noticed that you're saying this, but it's totally wrong. His his says a page 34, line 12 to 15, of the deposition of so and so where the testimony was testimony was was the opposite. And therefore, you should retract the statement may not want to retract the statement. You know, but if they did it once.
51:32Yeah, who knows, who cares? They did it twice, three, four times, I just want to know that. But they're always gonna be lawyers, just don't tell the truth. And I'm sorry to say that. But that's the fact. They think and advocacy, they have license, they really don't. And as I said, before, we market ourselves we're credible. And a while depends on the court. Because in certain places, or specialized parts, where there's a limited number of judges, think is very important. There's a limited number of judges that have to handle certain types of cases, you do commercial litigation, in New York, and something called the commercial, where various counties, you have a handful of judges, which means if you're a commercial litigator, you're going to be appearing in front of the same judges over at all, and your adversary. And your adversary has to be careful. But there's our reputation, and tarnishing that representation, that reputation. Because the judges will know. Unless you tell you the truth, inside baseball, the judges talk about us. And if they if you don't think that's true, they're nuts. They talk about us. They meet in conferences, I've been on many, many judicial panels, before the chair of the New York commercial federal litigation section of this is a chair, the Kelley boys Association, Committee on superior jurisdiction, right.
53:08And the judges talked, the judges talk about us. And, again, if you think that that's not true, maybe you ought to think of a different way of earning a living. It's very true. So you want to develop that reputation. And of course, always gonna be people don't care about their reputations for them, and sorry, to lose those law cases, they'll win in the short term in the long term.
53:36I think the real key here is that, you know, civility is is really a critical component of the standard of our profession. You need to use your better judgment and and exercise that appropriately on extension should be awarded to adversaries where necessary. I mean, there's always this circumstance where clients say, Aha, I'm not giving them an extension, and that's really a lawyer call a call for a lawyer to make civility at a deposition again, a call for a lawyer to make, you know, there are times to be zealous, zealously, zealously advocate for your client. And but But anytime that you act on behalf of your client.
54:23Listen, a lot of clients out there, expect their litigators. I apologize if this alliance program to focus on litigation. But that's was a listen, I do. And a lot of clients expect their lawyers to be pitbulls to be nasty. We had a client years ago, so Zeno saying, How can you be friendly with the opposing side? It's absolutely that it's that they they expect blood on the table. And it's your job to that as your clients, we are the captains of the ship. Our job is to steer the Profit Course. To get us to the finish line, that means winning the case. And every time you do something stupid, you run the risk of it biting me in the face. So, for example, don't give me a steal. Give me an extension of time. I mean, yeah, yeah, I can't be forced to compromise a client's rights. So there's a statute of limitations issue was things like that. Maybe asked you some judges, though, give me the extension of time. You don't really do. I want to run to the judge. And so then an ex parte order, we can do that here the jurist procedure for either the judges to file a request for detention, haste gets assigned to a judge, but the judge, I'm new kid on the block, I just started this, this guy had to represent this defendant. And I call him up. And I asked for an extension of time. You know, when he told me, he told me, I can't give an extension of time, because my client? I mean, and the other true story, oh, this is a very good story. I had a situation once where when my second son was born, there was some medical issues. And I couldn't get into
56:22answer summary judgment motion. And I made an application to the court because the court opposing side very stupidly refused to give an extension. So I made an application to the court for an extension of time. And the job, they said to the judge, I explained to someone so I had a personal issue at home. And I needed more time. And the clients and the lawyer said, I can't get my claim on. Both books had said, the judge did with a summary judgment motions a true story. The judge adjourned the summary judgment motions, nine months. Right? To punish the other side, where there's extreme example, but it's the last thing you want to be the kind of lawyer who obstructs the kind of lawyers unreasonable. It's just it's not smart. That's the thing. This might protect your client. Protect your client, do the best jobs you could possibly can. But be smart. And remember, you're the captain of the ship. And if the client wants you to steer your boat might not sail it, the client wants you to steal your boat, steer the boat onto the rocks, guess why you steer it onto the rocks? It's your fault, not your clients fault?
57:39Because you're the captain of the ship.
57:43exactly your age. So then we have a couple minutes last year. Is there anything else that you want to address?
57:53I don't think I'm running out of things to talk about. But any ideas? Listen? No, I think that, you know, we, we covered just a few topics here today. But of course, there are many other areas that arise every single day in practice, whether you're a litigator or whether you work in the corporate arena, whether you work as in house counsel, whatever the case may be, um, we frequently write on these topics. And, and we encourage you, if you're in New York, it may be more helpful to us at anything, to check out our forum articles that we post monthly, and that does address these topics. We also have a book out there is a compilation of alternative professionals forms available in USA, our website and a event. We are here to help. And we're here to try to tell you that you know, some people think that the rules of professional responsibility are hindrances. Some people think civility guidelines, hinges they're not. They're not only that, that make us behave. They certainly do that. But they set ground rules allow us to effectively represent our clients and have a something to talk to our client about when a client is unreasonable, always going to be an unreasonable client. So there's going to be a client's gonna want you to do things and then not violate any certainly that violates so that you have a you can't do it. But your client will sometimes they push you to do things, and therefore you have to make a decision and you effectively represent the client. A lot of times these issues they say
59:44this, I've said that several times in this program. It says nothing smart, is nothing effective advocate because the person in the ropes will judge in the corporate transaction, your adversary will judge. The opposing parties will judge Have you want to be judged want to be judged to be an effective lawyer? You know, the judge to be a jerk. And that's and that's the issue here. Anyway, so I think we've basically right done. Yeah. I hope you enjoyed our program. And thank you very much. Thank you
Kathleen O.NC
Enjoyed the program and format; the presenters complemented each other. Nicely done.
Greg O.GA
This course was particularly excellent in its practical approach to everyday issues faced by lawyers instead of hypotheticals that we may never come across. The two presenters were down to earth and excellent.
Sonia W.CA
The use of hypotheticals made the presentation much more interesting and with more practical benefit than if the presenters had not chosen this approach. Also, the back and forth between the two presenters with different experience levels made the presentation more enjoyable and informative as well. 5++ to this presentation and these presenters.