Jim D.PA
The instructor's knowledge and passion for this topic really came through in her presentation!
1h 1min · about 8,900 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, my name is Colleen Quinn and I'm an attorney in Richmond, Virginia. I practice in a variety of areas, including employment, which we're going to focus on today, as well as adoption, surrogacy, personal injury, and also estate planning. And a big component of my practice is serving the LGBTQ plus community. And so today we're going to talk about gender identity and sexual orientation discrimination in the workplace. We're going to go through several parts. Part one is basically knowing the terminology, it's critical to understand the terminology in order to understand what gender identity and sexual orientation discrimination means, and being able to recognize it in the workplace.
0:50So we're going to kind of zip through these slides today on my PowerPoint presentation. I am located out of out of Richmond, Virginia, and I've been practicing here for just over 32 years after I finished getting my law degree at UVA, I clerked on the Virginia Supreme Court for Chief Justice Kericho. And then I launched out into private practice, and I've been in private practice ever since. So, we're going to talk about LGBTQI cultural competency, and the thing is to be educated, but also educate your team that's going to be part one, part two is going to be addressing the case law on gender identity and sexual orientation discrimination. So launching into part one, really, what it boils down to is respecting your clients, your customers and employees, as well as your prospective clients, customers and employees, by knowing and also using proper and respectful terminology. I've got this great slide here, which is basically the rainbow flag on the first one says we are all the same inside. On the second one says I'm gay and lesbian, I am bisexual, I am transgender. I am like you, I'm human. The key thing is we are all human beings on this planet. And we might have different orientations different paradigms, but we all have feelings inside. And so it's critical to be respectful of other people's feelings. So you really want to know the letters. Most people know that L stands for lesbian. G stands for gay B stands for bisexual and T stands for transgender. And then we have these other letters that have popped up over the years we've got Q for
2:34queer and questioning I for intersex, GNC for gender nonconforming and a for asexual. Now let's talk about sexual orientation versus gender identity because they are two different concepts. And it's important to know the difference between the two. Sexual orientation is who you go home to gender identity is who you go home as well. So I'm not going to read every single slide in this presentation. In fact, some of the words are just dirty and I want to clean my mouth out with soap. So some of them I'm just going to leave on this slide, and we won't actually say it out loud. Those are the words that you want to avoid using. But let's first talk about gender identity and the different types of gender identity I already mentioned GNC gender non conforming. That's basically a term for individuals whose gender expression or behavior is different from societal expectations or societal stereotypes related to gender. Gender queer is a term which generally refers to a person who does not accept a gender binary world and refuses to conform their behavior to any any gender stereotypical behaviors, gender identity, that's your sense deep Lee felt psychological identification as whether you are male or female, somewhere in between, they are not really sure. And it may not correspond to the external body, or the sign or the sex assigned at birth. Gender expression is the external manifestation of a person's gender identity, which again may not may or may not conform to society defined behaviors. Right? So a crossdresser is a term for people who
4:28dress in clothing not typically worn by their assigned birth sex, but who generally don't desire to live full time as the other sex. So you might think about going to say a dry clean breakfast, where you know, there might be some guys who love dressing up as a Dr. King's queen, singing etc. But that doesn't necessarily mean that they want to be viewed as female, when they're not performing, and then intersex biologically That is a person who was born with both female and male or in descript sexual genitalia or some chromosomal differences that create a secondary sexual character. There is a huge myth about a famous actress Jamie Lee Curtis. And for the longest time, I heard this rumor that she was intersex. Apparently that is a rumor. But that is something that people identify with in terms of, of acknowledging and what that means what that concept means. All right. So transgender people, um, transgender is an umbrella term for people whose gender identity or gender expression differs from their assigned sex at birth. But not all transgender people want to live as the sex opposite of the one they were assigned at birth. We talked about, you know, cross dressers or somebody that acts as a drag queen, that doesn't necessarily mean that they are transgender. A transgender man is a term for a transgender individual who was assigned female at birth, and currently identifies as a man, a transgender woman is basically a term for a transgender individual who's assigned male at birth. Think of Caitlyn Jenner, and currently identifies as a
6:24woman. Now it's better to not say transgender man or transgender woman, unless there's some legal reason why you have to, it's just man or woman, Caitlyn Jenner is a woman, we don't need to say that she's a transgender woman necessarily, that would be a little bit offensive to her, she's a woman in her mind, okay. And then her body. Transsexual are people whose gender identity differs from their assigned sex at birth. And they may often on a full time basis or part time basis, live as a member of the sex opposite their birth. But they may not necessarily identify as transgender, that term transsexual is kind of a hotly debated term, it's, it's better just to not use it, there's really not much reason to use it anyways. So just recognize that some of these terms are just for educational purposes, that doesn't mean that you really necessarily need to use them at any given time. All right. So with transgender folks, usually there's initially a gender affirmation or transition when the person begins to live as a sex opposite of they're the one assigned at birth. And that process is referred to as a transitioning are going to be gender affirmation process. Please don't use don't say somebody's transgender in, okay. It's transitioning. I hear that that misused quite a bit. Also, they go through a process of self authorization, there are three phases of transition, there's really the social, the legal, and then the medical as well. There's something called from the medical psychological standpoint, gender dysphoria,
8:13that's a DSM five diagnosis. It's not a term of general usage that describes a strong and persistent cross gender identification and persistent discomfort with one's sex. Some, but not all, transgender individuals have gender dysphoria. It's again, kind of a controversial concept. In some literature, it's still referred to as gender identity disorder. However, many in the community consider the use of the term disorder to be offensive, and even gender dysphoria. While it's now the preferred technical term, again, there's not really many times that you have to actually use that term unless it's for some specific legal reason. So with transgender people, oftentimes, they may go through a gender reassignment surgery, but other times, they may just go through hormone therapy, and different ways, different modalities of actually going through the transitioning process. You don't have to actually have to have surgery to to identify as transgender or, or to transition from one sex to the other, it often can be done just with hormone therapy as well.
9:38So I'm not gonna talk too much about some of the controversies about children and the use of Lupron to suppress suppress puberty and the development of secondary sex characteristics. Just be aware that there is a lot of controversy about how children arm transgender children are managed in the medical In psychological community, a lot of debate currently, basically, the general thought is to just allow children to be without any sort of inner medical interference, interference with drugs or anything like that. And and as time goes by, they will figure things out for themselves. Just be aware, too, that there is a organization called W path. It's the World Professional Association for Transgender Health. And there's a lot of debate there on the issues of hormone therapy and surgery for minors. So we're going to talk about respect again, our ESP EC T, right. So we're going to not just necessarily sing the song, but we're going to talk about how to show respect. And this is where I start to feel like I kind of have potty mouth and I don't want to say all of these terms. So I'm just gonna mention some of them. But they are outdated and they are offensive. So words like tranny shemale, he she transvestite sex change, sex change operation, those are all outdated terms. They are offensive, please don't use them. And whenever possible, use a transgenders person's chosen name, even if it's not their legal name. We will have a client right now who's transgender identifies male. I think it's basically on his birth certificate that
11:34goes by Joe. And it's interesting because, you know, we've we've explained to Jim, we, we deal with Joan as a woman and, and call her Joan. But for some legal reasons. For the case that we're involved in, we have to use Jones assign name at birth and assigned sex at birth on which are male. But out of respect, whenever we're dealing directly with Joan, she is Joan and she is female. All right, it's not possible to ask a transgender person which pronoun they prefer, go with the pronoun that's consistent with their appearance and their gender expression. But most of the time, you can just say, Hey, what's your preferred pronoun? Nowadays, most people put their preferred pronoun, you know, in their signature blocks, etc, which I definitely recommend doing. recently got my hair done. And it was with a new hairdresser, who was substituting for my regular hairdresser and went by Taylor and and I really could not tell if Taylor identified male, female, or they and so I just said, Hey, Kelly, what's your preferred pronoun?
12:48And they said they. And so, you know, that explained to me right off the bat that Taylor was transgender. So most folks will respect the fact that you asked them what was their preferred pronoun. Like term, they has gone through different morphs over time. They're originally in the 1850s. It was ZZ E and fi, pH E and X, E. And even back in the 1850s. And 1884. You had different you had recognition of transgender folks moved on to the use of MX instead of Mr. Ramirez, it was Miss pronounce MCs. And now the conventional way to address transgender folks is the use of the term de now I'm an I was an English philosophy major. So wrapping my head around the day when I had my first trans or gender client about 20 years ago, was was kind of difficult. But if you think about it, if somebody leaves a pen on a table, oftentimes somebody will say, hey, they left their pen here, okay. And we say they because we don't know if that was male, female, female, are they? But I oftentimes refer to that concept when I'm trying to address the word gay.
14:19There's a really great TV show billions and the transgender. One of the main characters Taylor in that program, is they and all of the characters do a phenomenal job of the use of that terminology. So my first transgender person I mentioned was about 20 years ago, I had the case of Betsy and beau, coming into my office and it was almost like an Elvis an Abbott and Costello routine. Because I would say to Betsy, Betsy was lesbian Bo was they and I would say well, Betsy, who was in the in the car when the accident happened. And that didn't say they were and I would say you mean bow and she was a yes. And we say, that's who you live with. And she says, I live with them. And I said, You mean bow or do you mean bow in anybody else i She goes, just them and I'd be like, You mean bow right only bow and she was. So it gets a little comical at times. But now we're going to switch over to sexual orientation. That term describes a person's attraction to members of the same gender or different gender. So of course, gay is typically refers to describe a male who's attracted emotionally and sexually to other males. Sometimes, gay is also used to refer to lesbians, but most lesbians actually prefer you to use the term lesbian, as opposed to gay. Lesbian, of course, is a female who sexually emotionally attracted other females. Bisexual is a term to describe a male or female sexually emotionally attracted to both sexes. Questioning is a term used to decide a person who's unsure and they're just questioning their sexual orientation. Heterosexual or straight, of
16:11course, applies to persons who are attracted to the opposite sex genderqueer or are people who do not ascribe to a binary notion of sex or gender. And then as we mentioned before, asexual is a person with no desire for a sexual relationship with anyone. Alright, so now we're gonna go to again, some of those words that you do not want to use. The term homosexual is offensive, um, please try to stay away from that term. It's better just to say gay, or bi or bisexual. In my outline, I have, say gay person or gay man. You don't really need to qualify it with that you could say gay or lesbian for the most part. Also, another offensive term is sexual preference or sexual. What is preferred is sexual orientation or just orientation. The term sexual preference is typically used to suggest that being lesbian, gay or bisexual is a choice and therefore can and should be cured. Whereas sexual orientation is more accurate description of an individual's kind of enduring physical, romantic or emotional attraction to members of the same or opposite sex. And so it's really it's not a preference, it's an orientation. Again, more it's not to use homosexual relations or homosexual relationship or homosexual couple of homosexual sex. Instead, you can just say relationship or a couple. If you have to say same sex couple for legal reasons. For example, when we're doing step parent or second parent adoptions, we will in my office, we will oftentimes say that it's a same sex couple because the pleadings are different that we use in that regard. And
18:05they're the oftentimes especially a lesbian couple will be using a sperm donor and doing a second parent or stepparent adoption. And so it's actually legally a different type of pleading that we write for them as opposed to a stepparent adoption where we're having to have a biological parent get that consent. So oftentimes, we will use a term a same sex stepparent adoption, or second parent adoption, just legally so that in my office, we can identify that particular type of case, but otherwise, we would just simply say adoption if we didn't have a specific need for per se, and that it was a same sex couple. Alright, so again, words not to use it's offensive to say gay lifestyle or homosexual lifestyle is preferred to say gay lives or gay and lesbian lives. There. There is no single lesbian, gay or bisexual lifestyle Okay? Lesbians gay men and bisexuals are diverse in the way they live their lives, just like heterosexual folks are by saying gay lifestyle. It's used to denigrate lesbians, gay men and bisexuals suggesting that their orientation is a choice and therefore it can be can be cured.
19:23Gay people live the same as heterosexual people we all live on we don't have to like specify, it's a heterosexual lifestyle. We wouldn't go around say, Oh, they're living a heterosexual lifestyle. So just stay away from from those terms. Also offensive admitted homosexual or about homosexual. It's preferred to say openly lesbian or openly gay or openly bisexual or simply out. Ricky Martin is an out pop star from Puerto Rico. And so you know, a lot of folks will say I just came out. So that's that's pretty common terminology, more terrible term. arms, five fagot. And you don't need to refer to a faggot or pile of sticks as as fagot. Just stay away from that term completely and just nobody. Nobody uses that term to refer to a pile of sticks anyway. Whereas like diet como sauna, my similar epithets just, they're very derogatory. They're vulgar and their offensive arm so please stay away. And if you hear anybody using those terms, tell them that that's that's not really showing respect. That's that's, that's not really cool. Other words to avoid are deviant disorder, dysfunctional disease. The notion that being gay or lesbian, bisexual as a psychological disorder was discredited by the American Psychological Association and the American Psychiatric Association in the 1970s. That was more than 50 years ago. Terms like deviant disease and disordered are oftentimes used to portray LGBT folks as less than human mentally ill or as a danger to society. So it's all of that terminology we want to clearly stay away from. All right.
21:10And then of course, people know not to associate LGBT individuals with all these other things I've got listed on this side, which are it's just with pedophilia, or child abuse, or any deviant other type of social behavior. That's just extremely offensive. As I said before, we are all human beings. So let's talk about polyamory. That's a form of relationship that involves more than two people. Their relationships might be symmetrical like a triangle or something more complex. A purely heterosexual form of polyamorous marriage just wants to practice upon the Tibetans on each man had many wives and each woman had many husbands, that raised the possibility of your brother also be in your husband in law and law. So diagram that out for some fun. So I got the definition from Wikipedia of polyamory and there, it may not be the best definition. But we do want to recognize that polyamory is a way of life that that many that many people have embraced. And I even wrote an article my mommy and daddy and dad, daddy and mommy, for the American for the for am LA, the American matrimonial Academy. And it basically focuses on try parenting and quadruple parenting, either by design or by default. But there are cases out there there's more and more recognition of more than two parents. More and more states are beginning to enact the uniform parenthood Jackson, the most recent version of that to recognize more than the two parents, including even the ability to put more than two parents on a birth certificate. And then I've got a cute little
23:12slide in there where the one little boy is saying to the other showing them that pictures of his genetic Mama's biological mom and his social monad says have you met my mother's. But but we are seeing all sorts of different connections, we can have the gestational mother, who carries a child who is formed from the egg of the genetic mother. And then they might also have a de facto mother involved, who's also co parenting with gestational mother and genetic mother, a family of three mothers. So of course since America fell, which is Hodges the 2015 SCOTUS opinion, which hopefully is not going to be overturned on with the current composition of the United States Supreme Court, but with America fell. Finally all married couples were entitled to have their marriage recognized. However, some LGBT couples were still encountering issues with being recognized as legitimate parents. And so I've got some cases in there. The eel versus BL case is a really important case, because in that case, the the biological mom essentially moved to Alabama. She had done a stepparent adoption with her wife, and in Georgia, and then she moved to Alabama, because Alabama did not recognize same sex adoption at that time. Um, she tried to say, Oh, my ex wife is no longer the child's mom. And the Alabama Supreme Court agreed that went up to the United States Supreme Court and they said, no, no, no, no. All states have to give full faith and credit to adoption orders throughout the land. And so one thing that is a standard protocol is for We're same sex
25:00couples to make sure that they do a second parent or stepparent adoption, in order to make sure they secure their parentage in that regard. And then I've got a cute little cartoon in there where the female officiant is wedding two guys, she says you may now kiss the Supreme Court. And I think that's how a lot of LGBT folks felt once the other fellas decision came down. So we do want to talk about relationship building, we want to ensure that you have an LGBTQI friendly work environment and what are some ways that you can do that? Look at your intake forms do they ask for a person sex or marital status and is that really necessary we can take if it is necessary to the intake is your wording appropriate. Upon presentation, we talked about this with an individual whose sexual identity is not clear. But it's not germane to the relationship. Simply just ask them for their name and call the client or customer by their name. If for legal reasons, you have to know what their assigned sex is at birth? You can you can ask those questions. So you can ask how do you identify in terms of your gender? Or what are your preferred pronouns as we talked about before, and then if you need to know for legal reasons, what their assigned your sex was at birth, you can say is that the same gender that's on your identification documents. And don't hesitate to explain why proper gender identification is necessary. In some cases, it's proof of gender identification might be necessary to the legal processes, the insurance forms or the statutory requirements, when I first had
26:44the auto accident case with Boeing, but Betsy, some 20 years ago, I had to explain to bow that when we put together the claim package, on those case, that it was going to be difficult, especially 20 years ago for the adjuster to understand why on the claim package, I might be referring to bow as Bay, especially because all of those treatment in Virginia had been as female, and that was in the records. And then when Bo moved to Colorado, though, change the treatment there to as male. And so I explained to Bo, that, actually, the having to include these aspects in his claim package and including the terminology, they at that time, might actually devalue the case and confuse the adjuster? And would it be okay, if we simply referred to bow as female, because both primarily treated as female for the auto accident and well understood and as I was being respectful, and explaining that to bow and bows like sure, Colleen I get it, we can we can go with that I'm fine with that.
28:05So you do want to make sure your company or office is LGBTQI friendly, you want to include magazines, or articles. I've got articles on this wonderful story on Jacobs law, which is the whole story where I hope to have my clients helped reform Virginia's assisted reproductive technology statute to allow for the use of the donor embryo. Jacob was a donor embryo baby through a surrogate. It's a wonderful story. And I love putting their article out in the front lobby. So when people come in, they can see that story that immediately suggests that our office is LGBTQI friendly. And I've got some pictures here in your sides of a kind of an all gender restroom as well. Which again, shows that your office is LGBT friendly. On my signature block, I have the quality Virginia logo that says All are welcome here. I also have my preferred pronouns in my signature block. And then I also try to stay educated I belong to the LGBT Bar Association the Virginia quality bar association and quality Virginia and gay RBA I'm so make sure that I follow and stay informed and updated in terms of knowing that I know the right terminology and I'm keeping my office LGBTQI friendly. All right, so we've gone for about half an hour and that was part one. Now we're going to totally switch gears and now that you know the terminology you understand the terms, we're going to talk about gender identity and sexual orientation discrimination in the workplace, part two, and I've got a nice treat for you because we have a little video clip of a TV news pass that was done On one
30:00of my clients, Dena persico, a case that we brought before the Supreme Court ruling that we're going to talk about coming down recognizing gender identity and sexual orientation discrimination in the workplace. So we talked about what was gender identity, remember, that's one innermost concept of their self as who they are, okay, who you go home, as all right. And we also talked about sexual orientation, who you are romantically or physically emotionally sexually attracted to, that is who you go home to. So gender identity is who you go to bed as, and sexual orientation is who you go, who you go to bed with, quoted by Sam Kellerman. And then I've also given you an illustration of the gingerbread person, which actually shows the spectrums of gender identities, the spectrum of gender expression, the gender, the spectrum of sexual orientation, and so the gingerbread man is oftentimes used to kind of help better illustrate these concepts. So how did sexual orientation and gender identity discrimination become protected? How did that happen? It happened with the United States Supreme Court ruling of Bostick versus Clayton County. I just had one of my interns this summer, help work on an article that we're putting in the VTL, a journal that basically talks about the Bostick versus Clayton County rulings. And it's really fun to actually get to know the characters, because it was a combination of three different cases on appeal. And so we're gonna look at each case, and what was the ruling and what what led up to that. So in addition
31:56to the Bostick versus Clayton, the Boston versus Clayton County case, the other two cases were altitude Express, versus Melissa Zarda. And William Alan Moore, Jr, who were the executors of the estate of Donald sarta, who unfortunately passed away before he got to see that this ruling came down. And then the third case was RG Mgr. Harris funeral homes versus the EEOC. And unfortunately, the plaintiffs in that case also passed before the ruling came down. And one of the things that we've tried to feature in the article that we've just written, is just how long it takes for these cases to finally get up to the United States Supreme Court 10 years easily from the start of filing the initial charge with the EEOC and to get to that point. So these cases really require a lot of persistence. And it's very noble and admirable that these three petitioners and then subsequently their families carried on these cases for them. So the Supreme Court accepted the three cases, because they all had similar issues involve a two of the cases, Bostick versus Clayton County and the altitude Express versus Czarna cases were consolidated because both involve claims that employers discriminate on the basis of sexual orientation. And then the third case, RG and gr Harris Funeral Home case about the question of whether existing discrimination laws applied to transgender workers. So in this historic decision, the US Supreme Court ruled that the 1964 Civil Rights Act, which we refer to as Title Seven, protects gay lesbian and transgender employees from
33:55discrimination based on sex. The ruling was six to three with Justice Neil Gorsuch, who was President Trump's first appointee to the court writing the majority opinion, which was kind of surprising. That opinion was joined in by Chief Justice John Roberts and the courts for liberal justices, which also include it included. I've got Ruth Bader Ginsburg little ornament hanging behind me. And so RG RBG was part of that decision before she passed away. Gorsuch found that discrimination was barred by the language in Title Seven that bans discrimination based on race, religion, national origin, sex as well.
34:40And this was a great quote, and I'm going to quote it from the opinion. But Gorsuch wrote, quote, in our time, few pieces of federal legislation rank and significance with the Civil Rights Act of 1964. They're in Title Seven Congress outlawed discrimination In the workplace on the basis of race, color, religion, sex or national origin. Today, we must decide whether an employer can fire someone simply for being homosexual or transgender. The answer is clear. An employer who fires an individual for being homosexual or transgender fires that person for traits or actions it would not have questioned if members of a different sex, sex plays a necessary and undescribable role in the decision exactly what Title Seven four bits. So let's talk about Gerald Bostick. The first case, Gerald Bostick, this case came out of the 11th circuit, Bostick versus Clayton County, Georgia. Joe Bostick was a gay man who began working for Clayton County in Georgia as a child welfare services coordinator in 2003. During his 10 year career with Clayton County, he received positive performance evaluations and numerous accolades. In 2013 10 years later, he began participating in a gay recreational softball league. Shortly thereafter, he started getting criticism for his participation in the league and for his sexual orientation and his identity generally, on during and during one meeting, in which Bostic supervisor was present at least one individual openly made disparaging remark remarks about his sexual orientation and his participation in the gay
36:28softball league. And then in your materials, I've included a picture of Gerald Bostick to better humanize this for you a handsome, smiling looking guy. So, around the same time that Gerald comes out, starts playing for this gay League. Clayton County starts to inform him that we're going to be conducting an internal audit of the program funds he managed. And then shortly afterwards, they terminated him, allegedly for conduct unbecoming of its employees, even though they found they didn't find that he'd done anything wrong. Within months of his termination, he filed his charge of discrimination with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, which we refer to as the EEOC note that in most states, if they don't have a parallel state statute or Human Rights Office, you only these folks only have 180 days to file their EEOC charge or they're out of luck. Now, if there is a parallel state statute or State Human Rights Office, then oftentimes that is extended to 300 days, but it's a pretty narrow window to go ahead and make that charge, or else you can't bring that cause of action. And then in most states, like Virginia, the EEOC has another mandatory 180 days to process that charge. So you've already got now you know, 360 days before you could even get to the point where you might be able to get your 90 day right to sue letter and go ahead and file in the initial federal district court. So in Gerald's case, it was three years later in 2016, that you filed a pro se lawsuit, meaning that he did
38:19it without a lawyer against Clayton County alleging discrimination based on sexual orientation a violation of Title Seven. And what happened was the district court dismissed his lawsuit for failure to state a claim finding that Title Seven did not discriminating. prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex did not include sexual orientation, even though there was a 1979 decision out of this same circuit. They live in circuit, I'm saying otherwise. So Bostick appeals and he goes up to the 11th circuit. And the 11th circuit affirms of lower court, meaning they say, Yep, you're out. Title Seven doesn't protect you. And then Bostick then appealed that decision up to the US Supreme Court. So let's talk about the second case. The altitude Express case. So Don Zarda, was a gay skydiving instructor and he was fired because of his sexual orientation.
39:24And so he basically, again, proceeded with his his claim. And we've got pictures of Don there he looks like he was quite a dynamics. skydiver looks like kind of fun guy to go skydiving with. I only did it once for like 50th birthday. And I think that was enough for me, but it looks like Don enjoyed skydiving and was good at it. And so basically, he was terminated because of his sexual orientation. And then the third case, basically and At case any Stevens and I've got a picture of her there for you. She worked at RG and gr Harris funeral homes for six years. And she was terminated two weeks after she told her employers that she planned to transition to become a woman. And her employer specifically said he fired me because she would no longer dress or represent herself as a man. So, in that case, which came out of the Sixth Circuit, the EEOC investigated and actually brought charges for her termination, which is really unusual.
40:32Most charges that go before the EEOC do not result in the EEOC saying that yes, there is a case here and we are going to go ahead and take it on your behalf. So unlike Gerald Bostick, who went without a lawyer and and proceeded to say, at least Amy had the EEOC on her side. And so the EEOC went ahead and proceeded to take the case for her. The the district court granted summary judgment for the funeral home on both counts that were advanced using the Religious Freedom Restoration Act as their reasoning. So in other words, the district court said, No, this funeral home is protected because this was a religious issue. And because for religious reasons, they could not have a AMI working there as a transgender female. And then the Sixth Circuit reverse that discrimination saying no, no, no. Title Seven trumps the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, and so protection over folks and prohibiting this discrimination, Trump's your claim that you're you get to do this because of religious preferences. And so basically, the Sixth Circuit stated that Title Seven was intended to strike at the entire spectrum of disparate treatment of men and women resulting from sex stereotypes, which included any discrimination based on gender or perceived gender. And again, I quote from that opinion, discrimination based on the failure to conform to stereotypical gender norms was no different under Title Seven, than discrimination based on the biological differences between men and women. And then finally, this I love this quote from the
42:26Sixth Circuit, it said, quote, It is analytically impossible to fire an employee based on that employee's status as a transgender person without being motivated, at least in part by the employee's sex. So those were the three cases that went up to the United States Supreme Court. And those are the three cases that resulted in the decision. Now, there were other cases that led up to that ruling that were kind of precursors predecessors. And not all of them relied on just Title Seven, some of them relied on the Equal Protection Clause and constitutional arguments. Now, the concern, especially by the LGBT community, with the current composition of the United States Supreme Court, and with the current decision, that's at hand with regard to abortion, is that if the US Supreme Court rules that is a state issue, that state should decide, you know, whether we're going to be printed or permitted or not, that then that might be a slide toward a decision down the road that that states can then decide whether sexual orientation and gender identity are protected. It's, it's a way far off. I know that a lot of my LGBT clients are concerned about it. But But what happens down the road?
43:52We don't really know. What we do know is that there were some really good decisions that led up to this SCOTUS ruling, and that we can make these discrimination claims not just under Title Seven, but there are also constitutional arguments as well, that can help with some of these these claims. So we're just gonna briefly kind of talk about some of the other decisions that were out there, and there really was a split in the Federal Circuit Courts on this issue. All right, so the case of Glenn versus Brumby came out of the 11th circuit that was a gender identity case. And in that case, basically, the Court held that the termination of an employee based on their gender transition, transition, transgender status or bathroom concerns constituted sex based discrimination. I'm on the board of the Girl Scouts and that was one of the issues we had were the bathroom concerns when we had a
44:58a transgender In the female with male sexual parts, joining the Girl Scouts, it's like okay, what are we gonna do about the bathroom situation and we were able to work work around that. But in this case Vandy, Beth Glen, I worked as an editor for the Georgia General Assembly, when she notified her boss that she was going to transition to becoming a woman. She was terminated because her boss thought it was inappropriate and would be disruptive to the workplace. And there were the issues of which bathroom were which she used as well. Now, she sued for discrimination under the equal protection clause, stating she was discriminated against because of her sex, female gender identity and failure to conform to sexual stereotypes on the district court granted summary judgment in favor of her an 11th circuit affirmed. And in that case, the courts looked at the Price Waterhouse and US versus Virginia decisions, and basically said that I'm linking discrimination based on transitioning or being transgender, or to discrimination on the basis of gender based behavioral norms. The court ruled that, quote, an individual cannot be punished because of his or her perceived gender nonconformity, because these protections are afforded to everyone that cannot be denied to a transgender individual. So that case relied then upon the Equal Protection Clause and also other arguments that had been advanced, which will still remain out there. If for some reason, something if there's a reversal of the Title Seven rolling another case of
46:40Barnes versus City of Cincinnati case. That case was based on sex based discrimination under Title Seven, Felicia got a picture of Felicia there was transitioning from male to female while working for the Cincinnati police department. She lived as a man on duty and a woman while off duty, and she was told that she did not appear masculine enough at work and she lacked a command presence. And the Sixth Circuit held that determination of her based on her gender transition was six days discrimination under Title Seven. In that case, she passed a promotional test to become sergeant and began a probationary period. And then once it was, she came out as being transgender. She was demoted at the end of the probationary period. And now she challenged the demotion under both Title Seven and the equal protection clause and the jury ended up awarding her $320,000 $511 in damages, which is pretty good for an employment case judgment. And the Sixth Circuit upheld the ruling under Title Seven. But in that case, she did advance both arguments and then in the Smith versus City of Salem case also out of the Sixth Circuit.
47:54The court held that termination of an employee based on her gender transition also constituted sex based discrimination under Title Seven. Smith in that case was a firefighter who was born male but started to identify and express herself as female. Her co workers and supervisors stated that her actions and mannerisms weren't masculine enough and she was suspended for an alleged infraction of policy. The district court dismissed her claim saying Transgender Discrimination was not available under Title Seven. But then the Sixth Circuit reversed them and said, Oh, no, yes, it is. And basically, that was the first time that was in 2004. That the Sixth Circuit or any circuit actually hinted that gender identity discrimination can be claimed as sex discrimination. Again, the court lifted the Price Waterhouse pay state sexual stereotypes are considered discrimination under Title Seven. And in that case, the quote was, quote employers to discriminate against men because they wear dresses and makeup, or otherwise act femininely are also engaging in sex discrimination because the discrimination would not occur, but for the victims sex actually use the term victim. So that was a way back to 2004. So now we're going to bring you up to right before Bostick versus Clayton County ruling came down. I brought this case on behalf of Dina persico, who was a Chesterfield County school teacher, and she was lesbian. Her wife was also a school teacher and her wife presented on dressed very feminine in accordance with our normal
49:28societal kind of stereotypes for women, while Dina preferred to dress more masculine. And so we're going to look at a little film clip here of Dena persico and learn a little bit more about her and her situation. County wore pants and upset the entire education system. That former teacher says she was told she was too masculine and needed to be more feminine. Now she's filed a lawsuit against Chesterfield Public Schools alleging gender discrimination. She spoke one on one with a who's investigating Kerry O'Brien, a story you'll see only on eight.
50:06If you just are a skirt on once in a while we wouldn't have any of these problems. Harassment, flamboyant was our favorite term or if there's intolerance, your appearance is too flamboyant. Your arm movements are too flamboyant. It said with intent. And that intent is to say that you're gay and repeated reprimands about her appearance. It was suggested that if I seemed more feminine, I would be less intimidating. They use those words to seem more feminine. Yes, Dina persico, a former Chesterfield civics teacher who is a lesbian alleges in a federal lawsuit against Chesterfield public schools, she faced constant sexual discrimination.
50:49There were some jokes made like Oh, should we call her Mr. Prosecco. She tells us she was once banned from the ladies room. I went to put my hand on the door and he actually blocked me and he was like, No, that's not really appropriate. You going in there with all those, you know, with the young female students, I felt really humiliated. It was an assault on my person. And then it was like your basic human dignity. I just need to use the restroom. That's all you need to do. This is gender discrimination person who is attorney Coleen Quinn tells us the harassment was initiated by administrators and other staff at Providence Middle School, and intensified at Midlothian High School.
51:24Just this ongoing barrage of criticism directed at her because of how she dresses simple shirt. I put on a second layer because it gets cold button downs a sweater or fleece pants and athletic shoes. That was her typical teaching attire. I'm not a fashion like person at all. Her employee handbook only a few lines on dress code calling for a professional look seems like they would just kind of find a piece of my outfit to have an issue with that day. But you said other teachers had fleeces on Oh yeah, there was a I mean, one guy that he was an English teacher. He lived in his gray fleece. I mean it was every day he wore that thing. And no one said anything to him. No one said. So why do you think they were saying something to you?
52:10Because I'm a girl who was wearing a fleece purse a co taught in another Virginia district for 10 years without issue and has piles of notes from students praising her work in Chesterfield. And if you ask her about teaching civics, something she dreamed of doing since she was a kid, she lights up, and I absolutely loved it. If you get to teach the kids, you know what it means to be a citizen and how they can participate in the government. The constant badgering she says started when the principal at Providence, learn she is gay and married to a fellow teacher. It's very clear to me that my wife was discriminated against because of the way that she expresses her gender. So I think I'm given and when women like me are given more of a pass because we appear more feminine. I was actually in the meeting where the assistant principal told her to change her hairstyle. And they suggested that if I got bangs, it makes soft. Your employer, yes. suggested I got bangs I got. Eventually it took its toll person who suffered a mini stroke. What did the doctor think that stem from she said it was 100% related to stress. It's been devastating. She's lost her entire sense of self identity and who she is her doctor advised her not to return to work. I just felt like this was a case that cried out for awareness. Now person whose final lesson, a lawsuit she and her attorney hope leads to change. Number one, they get some training. And they understand that what they did to me is wildly inappropriate.
53:47We really wanted to talk to Chesterfield, school leaders about the teachers allegations. But we were told Chesterfield schools does not comment on pending litigation. Kerry O'Brien, eight news. You can hear more of our conversation with that former teacher on our website, w ric.com. Okay, so having watched that film clip of Dina I'm hopefully that brought this, this discussion a little bit more to life for you, so that you could see how she was persecuted on including, I'm not going to be able to use the ladies room. So that eventually led to that many stroke on that continued harrassment against her because mainly of the way that she dressed. In that case, we we settled that case. Part of this it wasn't for the money, we got a lot of publicity and one of the things that was part of the settlement was to have county wide training for all the teachers and students etc. on LGBT cultural competency, pretty much kind of like the first part of this, of this presentation. on educating folks on being showing respect, being more sensitive to LGBT cute issues. So we have a few more cases just to kind of zip through before we close out the hour. If we look at some other cases that were out there, there was an EEOC opinion in 2013. The Baldwin versus Fox case, that was the first time the EEOC itself so that sexual orientation discrimination could be seen as sex discrimination. And then that case, was taken up by the EEOC and a 2015 decision came down involving an air traffic controller who
55:48was not promoted to a permanent position because he was gay. And the EEOC said that an allegation of discrimination based on sexual orientation is necessarily an allegation of sex discrimination under Title Seven. We also had a case out of the Seventh Circuit, the highly versus Tech Community College case. And that case involving a lesbian part time adjunct professor who was repeatedly denied promotions, which she believed was related to her sexual orientation. In that case, the Seventh Circuit upheld the district court and how that sexual orientation was a subset of sex discrimination. They actually relied upon an interesting Fourth Circuit case, out of my neck of the woods, the on call case, which was a much earlier case that involved male on male sexual harrassment to show that sex could be interpreted to mean sexual orientation. And then you've got a picture of Kimberly Hyde Hively there so you could see for yourself. The Franks versus Santa Ana case was one out of the Ninth Circuit and 2018 Again, these cases leading up to the SCOTUS ruling that involved a levy lesbian police officer who was forced out of her job because of her sexual orientation. And the Ninth Circuit said that the lower court was wrong, not allowing her case to proceed to a jury and send it back down. And in that case, you can see there is Tammy Frank's the former Santa Ana police chief, that was the plaintiff in that case. Alright, so in light of the SCOTUS rolling on what we want to if anybody on that either runs a business owns a business, um, does employment law, we want to
57:45make sure that all of our handbooks, our employee handbooks, and our policies are revised to ensure that sex is more broadly defined to prohibit discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and gender identity. And then employers need to be mindful of training supervisors and employees to understand the distinctions as well as how to be culturally competent and LGBTQI terminology. So it's very important to educate folks in the workplace, and to make sure that we've put in place materials that help with that education. We also want to make sure that any required EEO postings and break rooms or similar areas are the most up to date ones and include gender identity and sexual orientation as subsets of sex discrimination. So if you haven't updated your posters, you want to make sure you get updated ones in that regard. And we want to send a message from the top down that that, as an employer, we accept persons from all walks of life and have a zero tolerance policy for any acts or words of discrimination, or harassment or hostility. And so that messaging really has to come from the top and bring it all down throughout the organization. And again, having materials in the lobby that are LGBT friendly, as I mentioned before, um, can help with that messaging, to make sure that that all are welcome. Just like the equality Virginia little badge that I put at the bottom of my signature block. Before I leave you, I'm just going to tell you a quick little fun story. I've tried to say harrassment instead of
59:26harassment. So I had this wonderful 11th grade English teacher well in Connolly God rest her soul, she's she's now passed, she was very matronly, very southern, very proper. You'd never hear Miss Connelly ever say a cuss word. And she says class class. You know it is Harris, for one never talks about harass. So just a little tip to leave you on. Try to say harrassment but A lot of people do say the word harassment, but remember Llewellyn Connolly whenever you refer to that term. And remember now that, given the SCOTUS ruling that any hostile work environment, any type of harrassment is now it's now directed at somebody because of their sexual orientation or their gender identity. Well, that was not part of the Bostick versus Clayton County ruling. Those cases all involve termination cases. However, that ruling does include hostile environment harrassment that is directed at somebody because of their sexual orientation or gender identity. So great spending the time with you today. Hope you learn something. And if you have any questions, shoot me an email. Thanks
Jim D.PA
The instructor's knowledge and passion for this topic really came through in her presentation!
Van W.NY
Very informative and inspirational CLE. In that regard, Congratulations on that case. Well done!!!
Mary K.IL
Very informative and effective. I like how she went through all the terminology, the dos and don'ts, and just generally explained how to make potentional clients and coworkers feel more comfortable and welcomed.
David L.AZ
Excellent presentation.