0:01Hello, and thank you for joining me for a two hour seminar regarding compliance with the Medicare secondary payer act. What's new for 2023? My name is Christine Hummel, and I am with Hummel consultation services. Even though this is an on demand program, please know that I am available to you for questions or concerns. This is my email address and my phone number. If you have any questions about the data being presented in the course of this seminar, please feel free to give me a call or shoot me off an email. I am a specialist in compliance with the Medicare secondary payer act. Our firm is 20 years old, we'll be 21. A little bit later this year, we work with both defense firms and plaintiffs firms as well as the insurance companies directly sometimes were engaged directly by the insurance provider or the self insured corporate entity. So regardless of what side you find yourself on the plaintiff side, or the defense side, if you are struggling with Medicare, and how to comply with the Medicare secondary payer act, whether that's a lien issue, drafting settlement language, or working on a future medical allocation, please know that our firm is available. If you don't want to work with us, that's fine. There are other experts out there that you can also work with. But this is an area of the law, where if you feel yourself struggling or you feel like you're in over your head a little bit, definitely reach out to someone and get some assistance.
1:40Because if you if you mess up with Medicare, it can have some fairly dire consequences. And nobody wants that. And nobody wants a case to come back six months or a year after you think it's settled and fully resolved. And suddenly, the client calls and says, Hey, I've got this letter from Medicare, and I don't know what to do about it. So if you have questions or concerns about the seminar, call me if you have questions or concerns about Medicare in your case, call or email me as well. With that, just to give you some structure for how this is going to go. Today, we're going to start with just some basics about Medicare, and how people become eligible for Medicare. And then I'm going to walk you through the three elements within the statute, the requirement to do your section 111 reporting, if you're on the defense side, the requirement to reimburse the Medicare lien or their subrogation interest, and then the statutes requirement to keep Medicare secondary to your settlement. If the plaintiff continues to require medical care for the specific injury or disease process, that's the subject matter of your case post settlement. So with that, we're going to jump right in with Medicare eligibility. A lot of people think of the Medicare program as a senior citizen program or an elderly program, because the most common way that people become eligible for Medicare is to age onto the program. And on your 65th birthday, you automatically become eligible for Medicare, so long as you have been working and paying into the system
3:18through payroll withholdings. When you pay into the system, and they take that deduction out of your paycheck, you are earning what's called credits, or quarters of coverage, you can earn a maximum of four quarters per year. And if you are 65, at the time you become eligible for Medicare, you need to have 40 quarters to be considered fully insured and eligible for the program. So essentially, if you're working full time, for 10 years, by the time you hit 65, you will have your 40 quarters you'll have more than your 40 quarters actually and be fully insured and eligible for the program. So that is the most common way people age on to Medicare on their 65th birthday. But younger folks can also become eligible for Medicare through the Social Security Disability Program. If a person becomes disabled prior to the age of 65, and they qualify for Social Security disability, once they've received that benefit program for 24 consecutive months, they will automatically become eligible for Medicare. Social Security Disability also has a quarters or credits of coverage requirements, but it is a sliding scale. The younger the person is at their time of their disability, the fewer quarters of coverage they require. So you could have someone in their 20s or 30s. And they may need as little as four or six quarters to be considered fully insured and eligible for the disability program. And then it gradually goes up all the way to that maximum of 40 quarters of coverage for folks who are in there you late 50s, early 60s, once a person receives
5:05disability benefits, they will become automatically eligible for Medicare on the 24th month. Now, it's important to realize that the Social Security Administration or an Al j, if the administration denies an application, the applicant has the right to appeal that denial and request a hearing before an Al j. So either process, whether it's through the agency or via the Al J hearing, a person can be awarded a back award of benefits, the back award count towards their 24 months. So in addition to keeping track of a person's disability status, once you find out they're on disability, you want to find out if they were given a back award of benefits. And then how much was it six months was it a year, and that counts towards their 24 months. So you may have less than two years front, once they begin receiving disability before they trigger Medicare, it just depends upon how their application was processed. And if a backup award was granted, if you have someone who is relatively young, and by that I mean 64, or younger, and relatively healthy, so they were, you know, participating in the workforce, or they're in school full time, no major health issues or crises in their life at the time of their accident, you most likely have a person who was not on disability or Medicare at that time. So if the only time you ask the the plaintiff or if you're on defense side that you ask the plaintiff or plaintiff's counsel if they are represented about their social security disability, and their Medicare status is at the initial file intake. And you
6:49never circle back and ask them if there's been a change in that benefit status, you will miss it when they go out and apply for disability. Kind of keep track of it. If the case is taking a long time to resolve, you know, it's six months, it's a year, it's two years out, and it still hasn't settled. The plaintiff has struggled to resume work or resume their normal activities of daily living. You'll want to check back with them or their attorney and see what's what's their status now, have they applied for benefits? are they receiving Medicare? What's the change because you don't want to miss it once they get onto the disability program, that just starts the clock ticking for Medicare, and it triggers the statute. So you want to be aware of that. There's nothing worse than sitting down in your mediation or arbitration and having the mediator ask the plaintiff about what benefit programs that are on and having them say, Oh, I'm on Medicare, I have been free for a year now. And nobody in the room had any idea and you didn't reach out for a lien amount, you didn't look into the necessity for future medical allocation. You know, everybody was just caught completely off guard. And that can really up end your settlement negotiations and make things more difficult than they would have been had you known about that in advance, they could have planned ahead for that particular lien holder. And the final group of people will talk about in terms of triggering Medicare or becoming eligible for Medicare, our young adults and minor children. So these are, you
8:18know, 19 and 18 year old adults and then children under the age of 18. Because of that work requirement that you work in the system, and through that payroll deduction from your wages, you are earning those credits or quarters have covered the gut reaction is there's no way a minor child would ever be eligible for disability or the Medicare program because they don't have a work history. But there is a system in place that will allow that minor child or very young adult to piggyback on a parent's work history and through the parent receive disability and Medicare benefits. So while it's very unlikely, like you know, one in 1000 cases is going to have a young person on the Medicare program, it is still possible. So if you have a case involving a disabled child, from time to time, check in with the parents to see what benefit program the child is enrolled in at that time. Are they working on additional benefit programs such as social security disability? And you know, if they say yes, we are removed it all, kind of jot that down and check back and see, you know, what, were they successful in getting the child on disability because then the child will also become eligible for Medicare and that same 24 month window, so you want to keep you want to keep that in mind. You can confirm a person's Medicare status A couple of different ways. If you are on the defense side of the case, the defendant insurance company is called a responsible reporting entity for Medicare purposes, and specifically for something called the section 111 reporting requirements, which we will
10:20talk about a little later on in this seminar. The sexual 111 reporting requirement is the defense only requirement, and it requires the defendant to report any settlement that involves a Medicare beneficiary that is greater than $750. And if the entity fails to report timely, they could be subject to a financial penalty. Because of that, because of that risk of a financial penalty. CMS has granted access to the social security database to these insurance providers, these these corporate entities, and once per month, they can query that database to determine if someone is or is not on Medicare, they can query up to 500 people per month. And you can query a person as many times as you'd like.
11:11So you can query them every month until the case is resolved. Or in some other frequency that seems to work out best for you. And the query system is very limited. I don't want to get your hopes up about all this information that you'll get when they when they do that query search. It simply returns a Y for yes, and N for no meaning Yes, this person is on Medicare or N no, this person is not on Medicare, it will not tell you if they have an application pending for social security disability, it will not tell you if they will be on Medicare soon, like it may be that their birthday is coming up in six months.
11:49And so that will trigger Medicare, it won't give you any information like that. It's just strictly Are you on Medicare right now, today, yes or no? The system has been known to return false positives and false negatives. So I always encourage my defense clients to query someone at least twice. Particularly if you do get a result that seems strange to you, you know, you were definitely expecting them to be Medicare eligible and the system returns a no, definitely query them again in the next month just to see if you get the same result. on the plaintiff side, you do not have access to the social security database, you know, the government figures, it's your client, you know, potentially the Medicare beneficiaries, your client, it should be easier for you to figure out your client status, because you can simply ask them and hopefully they'll tell you the truth. But if there's any doubt on on your side, or the defendant has some concerns about information being provided by the plaintiff, the plaintiff can sign up for what's called a My Account on the Social Security Administration website. Once the My Account is established, they can request a benefits verification statement, the statement is exactly what it sounds like. It just simply verifies the Social Security and Medicare benefits that the person is presently receiving, will also let you know about past benefits and applications that are currently pending for benefits. It's a very helpful letter. It's on Social Security letterhead. So it's very official. If you
13:31have a defendant who is concerned about some of the information being provided on the plaintiff side, the social security verification letters should reassure them and calm any of those concerns that they may be having. And you can update the letter whenever you'd like so you know, every six months or once a year, until the case is resolved. If you want, you can get an update of benefits verification statement. Likewise, with query query, this person regularly doesn't have to be monthly, like I said before, but every six months or once a year until the case is fully resolved, or until their status changes. I mean, once they're on Medicare, you can document that in the system and you can plan accordingly for compliance with the Medicare secondary payer act. So the act itself was passed on December 5 of 1980. It has three basic requirements, the section 111 reporting requirement, which we've sort of kind of touched on just a little bit. The requirements remain Medicare secondary post settlement if there is an ongoing need for medical treatment, and then the conditional reimbursement payment, which is Medicare's lien, so reimbursement of that conditional payment amount. The only reason December 5 of 1980 should be a meaningful date to any of you is if you have an exposure case or an injury case where all of your damages that you are seeking financial reimbursement for is prior to December 5 1980. The statute does not apply to you or your settlement. Because the statute didn't exist at the time of the injury. But if the exposure to asbestos or
15:15mold or some other chemical contaminant even has just one day beyond December 5 of 1980, or the damages you are seeking extend beyond December 5 of 1980, then you will trigger the statute and you do have to comply, there aren't a whole lot of cases still around that would meet those requirements. It was a big deal for the asbestos cases. And in the class action, asbestos cases from, you know, 1520 years ago, they were they were kind of all ramping up a little bit, but they most of those have been settled now. And a lot of those folks, unfortunately, just due to age, they've passed away. So there aren't a ton of cases anymore where you could argue we don't need to comply with the statute because all of our damages are pre December 1980. But I throw it out there just in case you find yourself in one of those scenarios. What question I received the most when a client calls or an attorney calls me and it doesn't matter if they're on the defense or the plaintiff side of the case is can I completely avoid the Medicare secondary payer statute? And the answer to that question is yes, so long as your settlement is $750 or less, this is the 2023 threshold every year at the at the end of the year, usually sometime between the first of December and between, like by Christmas. So almost always, before the end of the year, we get the updated threshold amount for the next year.
16:55And I think it's been since 2018, it's been 750. It's either 2018 or 2019. They set it at $750. And they've left it there. So it's been at 750 for quite a while now. But they could always change it. So next year, for 2024. It could be a completely different number. Also, there wasn't that long ago where they had two threshold amounts, one for workers compensation claims, and then one for all other injury claims. And they could bifurcated again, at some point in the future, you could see them go back to that two threshold amount system. So if that happens, don't let it throw you off. They've done it before. But for right now, for all you need to know for 2023, it's $750. This threshold amount does not apply to cases of ingestion, exposure, or implementation. So if you have a case of mold exposure, and you settle it for $1, you still need to report that case, comply with the statute, do a lien search, all of those things are still applicable because it's an exposure case. If you have a medical malpractice case involving the malfunction or improper implantation of a pacemaker as an example, that would be an implantation case. And again, the threshold amount does not apply to you. So the first big topic, if you will, for the compliance of the statute that we're going to tackle will be the Medicare conditional payment amount. We're going to talk about Medicare's recovery rights for all four programs, all four plans Medicare's part, ABC and D. Now a and b are together. There's a there are two national contractors that do national lien searches
18:46for both A and B you will sometimes hear people refer to Medicare Parts A and B as Original Medicare for traditional Medicare because those are the two Medicare programs that were developed back in the 60s when Congress first drafted and enacted the statute creating the Medicare program. Part C came along in the mid 90s. And Part D the drug plans are the baby of the family and they came around in 2005 2006. The policy plans are the Medicare Advantage plans you hear a lot about them right now and they're very popular. A lot of people are opting into the Advantage plans. And the critical thing for you to know about the Advantage plans and the Part D plans are that they admitted they are administered by independent companies. So when you get a letter from the National contractors for Medicare, the bcrc and CRC you will only see payments made by a and b part A and B you will need to do separate Unique lien searches for Part C and Part D payments. And we'll talk more about that in a few slides. As you can see from this slide, I think it's slide number eight. There are a number of CFR Sections that Congress enacted regarding conditional payments and reimbursement of conditional payments. This should show you that Congress is very serious about making sure Medicare gets its money back. And they have given you a lot of guidance on how that works and what your obligations are to protect the program. Medicare just like any other lien holder, or most lien holders, I guess, I should say, is entitled to
20:49reimbursement for any payment made by the program from the date of injury to the date of your settlement. For Medicare purposes, the date of settlement is the date on which a legal obligation to pay has been created. So if you are in a state where your mediation or arbitration agreement does not create a legal obligation to pay does not trigger a payment obligation on the part of the defendant. That date, the date of your mediation or arbitration agreement is not an appropriate date of settlement to provide to Medicare to obtain a final demand or final lien amount, you must provide the date on which you executed the actual release document that did create that legal obligation to pay. And that is your settlement date. And that is what is binding to Medicare. If it is your practice to give them an arbitration date or mediation date, I would encourage you to please stop, because it's not a valid date of settlement. And it could be defrauding the government of several weeks, maybe even months, if it takes you a while to hammer out the fine details of a settlement agreement. Sometimes that takes a while. All during all that time in between the arbitration and the time, it's taking you to finalize and execute that settlement document, the plaintiff could still be treating and racking up bills to Medicare, and Medicare is entitled to recovery for that. So you need to make sure that you're giving Medicare a valid date of settlement. So that way, they are calculating your lien appropriately. As I said earlier, there are two national contractors for AB lien
22:39recovery, the benefits coordination and Recovery Center, the BC RC and the commercial repayment center, the CRC we'll talk about each of those recovery contractors in just a few moments. We kind of touched on this already. But I want to make you aware of before we go too much further is date of injury. And I know it sounds a little ridiculous to say you don't know when your date of injury is or make sure both put both sides, you know all all parties to the agreement. Far away aware of what the date of injuries, but everything Medicare does is date of injury specific so if there's any controversy or dispute about what is your actual date of injury, before anyone contacts Medicare, whether it's plaintiff side defense side or a contractor, like myself, a vendor compliance specialist that you're contracting with to do the work on your behalf. Before anybody contacts Medicare for any reason, the parties need to come to an agreement on a date of injury. This comes up most often in automobile cases where the accident happens close to or at midnight. Sometimes there can be a disagreement about which side of midnight you were on. So which date is your date of injury and malpractice cases where the question is, is your date of injury, the date the malpractice occurred, or the date the malpractice was discovered by the patient. And some cases the the time period between those two dates when the malpractice allegedly occurred and when it was actually discovered by the patient could be several weeks, months, or even years in between and
24:30you can see how picking one date over the other could really impact a lien search and the amount of time that a lien holder would be searching their payments database to see if they made any payments related to the alleged injury or illness. So keeping everybody on the same page will ensure that you don't have a duplicate payment, or duplicate lien file opened if somebody inadvertently reports a different date of injury We'll talk about section 111. I know we keep saying we're going to do that, but we will. When the defendant does that section 111 report, there's a number of data fields that they need to fill in, but one of them is the date of injury. And if the date of field, the date in the date of injury data field is different than the date of injury reported for conditional payment purposes, when those two databases are synced up, so CMS will sync up the conditional payment database and the and the sexual 111 database about once a quarter. And if there's a discrepancy, if they can't find a lien file for a reported date of injury in the 111 reporting system, then in the conditional payment reporting system, they will automatically open a file. So that is why you want plaintiff and defendant on the same page, and be very consistent about the date of injury that you are reporting. So that way, whoever does the conditional payment reporting reports, the same date of injury that the defendant intends to report, when they do their section 111 reporting, so everything syncs up and there's no discrepancies in the system. And
26:14you don't end up with the duplicate lien recovery file being opened for the exact same settlement. Plan ahead. With this particular agency, they are slow moving, some things will take as little as 21 days, maybe even 14 days to get a response to other things will take 45 to 60 days, make sure both the plaintiff and the defendant are aware of the time periods involved. And you don't set them up for failure, you know, don't tell them, Oh, I'm going to get a response in two weeks, tell them it's going to be 45 to 60 days, if you get a response in two weeks, you tell the client, you look like a hero, everybody's happy. If you take the full 60 days, the client was already prepared for that. So they're not going to be upset, maybe a little bit frustrated, but they won't be surprised or upset by it.
27:08Medicare has the right to recover for any payment made by the program with a date of service prior to your date of settlement. Even if the bill is paid after your settlement, medical providers have one year from the date of service to bill Medicare. So it is possible that you could settle your case before all of the bills have been submitted to and paid by Medicare. And Medicare can audit their system and look for those additional bills. And if they find them, they will send out a revised final demand seeking that additional payment. So if something is missing, and I'm talking about big ticket items, a surgery and inpatient rehab stay a very expensive diagnostic test.
27:57Things that are rather expensive, not just an office visit or physical therapy visit. But if those big ticket expensive items aren't showing up on a lien somewhere, whether it's a Medicare lien, Medicaid lien the VA and ERISA plan, if you can't account for that big ticket item somewhere, you want to go hunted down, because the last thing you want is for you to settle your case, think it's done, you know, you've closed it out. And then six months later, you get a call from the client saying, Hey, I just got a letter from Medicare, they're asking for more money, I thought this was resolved. Or worse, the client gets the letter from Medicare thinks it must just be a duplicate or that it was sent an error because the attorney told them all of Medicare's interests have been accounted for. So they do nothing with it, they ignore the letter, the new amount that's being demanded goes into a final demand status that gets ignored, interest begins to accrue. And eventually it ends up at the Department of Treasury and the client is being garnished because they didn't pay the lien timely, and by then they call you. And now a lot of time has gone by. And it could be very difficult to appeal that at that point, because there are deadlines and time periods in place. That if you miss them, you have waived your right to appeal. So you want to look for anything that's big and expensive that's missing that could get attention of Medicare finds it at a later date in the system, and then track it down and find out who paid it and if you know is it on a
29:29different lien, maybe Medicare didn't pay it, maybe private health insurance plan paid it, but you want to make sure that all of those big ticket items are accounted for. So that way there's no surprises in the future. Unless you're utilizing what's called the final CPE process. You cannot obtain obtain a final demand amount from Medicare until you have settled the case. Signed your legally binding settlement document and provided that date of settlement to Medicare. Just as a reminder, you Mediation and arbitration date is not illegal date of settlement for Medicare purposes, if your state requires execution of a settlement agreement to trigger that obligation to pay on the part of the defendant. The bcrc, the benefits coordination and Recovery Center. So this contractor, again, only doing Medicare AB lien recovery, you're not going to see any parts to your Part D payments from any letter generated by the bcrc. They are the recovery contractor for bodily injury human UI M and men male cases, when a file is open and active at the bcrc. That means that the Medicare beneficiary has been deemed the primary Debtor or debtor of record, the entity or party to the case that is deemed the debtor of record or primary debtor is the entity that gets to control the case, they get to do everything on the case, they will decide if an appeal is filed a dispute a waiver a compromise request, that entity is the one that has that power, and that is the entity that can assign an agent to work with that lien on their behalf. The Medicare
31:21beneficiary can sign those various releases to appoint an agent to work on their behalf. And when we get to the CRC of just the very next slide, you'll see that the the corporate entity can also assign an agent to work on their behalf. The commercial repayment center the CRC, they are the lien recovery agent for PIP or medpay lien. So the no fault coverage on an auto policy or premises liability policy, and also workers compensation claims, the CRC will only work with the responsible reporting entity. So that's going to be the defendant insurance provider for their designated recovery agent. The CRC only took over doing ab lien recovery work for hip Med Pay and Work Comp in October of 2015. Almost every case, older case has now transitioned into the CRC system, but you may still run across an old case from 2012 or something like that, that hasn't settled, it's still open and active. And it's still at the old contract or it hasn't transitioned over to the CRC. And if that happens, you can you can try to get it into the CRC and then they'll seek recovery from the insurance provider rather than the injured party. Or you can leave it where it is. But just keep that in mind, you might still find some very old, particularly old work comp files that are still the older contractor but almost all of them have been transitioned to the CRC. So how does the CRC get a file? When an insurance company receives notice of a compensable claim for work comp, Pip, or med pay, they will file their section 111 report that gives notice to Medicare, that they have
33:13an ongoing responsibility for MediCal. So they are telling the federal government, this is my injury. This is my body part. I'm going to make these payments, and Medicare should flag that in their system and hopefully they don't pay anything. Hopefully, a provider bills Medicare, Medicare will just say no, we're not primary bill, the insurance company whoever that might be, but if something slips through the system, the CRC is allowed to audit their file a minimum of one time per year and a maximum of four times per year. And if they find any payments in the system, that could be for the reported compensable accident, they can seek recovery of that amount immediately. They do not need to wait for a settlement. They do not need to wait for a payment of any kind they can immediately go to that insurance provider and say we made these payments, the Medicare program should be reimbursed and the and the provider needs to do it at that time because they are the responsible medical entity. They were the responsible entity for payment of that bill. This will continue this continuous audit review process will continue until there is a section 111 report notifying Medicare that the ongoing responsibility for medicals the O R M obligation has been terminated. So disputes and appeals. If a file is in its tentative status, it hasn't gone into a final demand yet. You're going to file a dispute. Once a final demand has been issued. You're going to file an appeal. You could file a dispute or an appeal for a number of different reasons the most common
35:00It is for unrelated body parts. So your accident involves the right knee. And when you get the Lean notification statement from the bcrc, or the CRC, you, you find that there are a number of payments that have nothing to deal with your right knee injury. They have all sorts of body parts in there and other disease processes like diabetes and hypertension, a cardiac problem, all this stuff that has nothing to do with your accident. And you can dispute those out as being unrelated to the reported claim. Or there may be other reasons for you to file disputes and appeals, but that is the most common once you get a final demand, and you appeal that final demand, if your appeal is not successful, you will be able to dispute that or continue the appellate process to the second level of appeal. You can eventually it's there's a few steps, three steps or so you can eventually exhaust your administrative remedies and get yourself into the district court. If you are going to follow that process that appellate process and exhaust your internal rights agency rights and then get yourself into the District Court. Enter all of your evidence supporting your position into the record as soon as possible as soon as you have it available. If you fail to put evidence into the record, when it's available, you may be barred are prohibited from admitting it or having it admitted into the record at a later appellate phase. So unless you can show good cause why you didn't enter something into the record at an earlier appellate phase, you
36:45could be prohibited from doing it at a later appellate phase. So don't hold on to it thinking well, if this fails, I'll try this, put all of your evidence forward, make your best case right away at the you know, earlier appellate stage. And then you can continue to make those arguments and build on those arguments as you go through the appellate process if you if you need to if you're not getting the result that you want.
37:10Once a final demand has been issued, a final demand must be paid within 60 days to avoid interest. Medicare is statutorily entitled to its interest, beginning on the 61st day. If you have an appeal, compromise our waiver request pending pending review, that will not hold the interest, interest will still accrue even while your request is under review. You can pay the final demand while your appeal, waiver or compromise is being reviewed. In theory, payment does not impact your likelihood of success. CMS understands that there's a financial benefit to paying the demand amount to avoid interest, it does pay payment of the final demand amount does not necessarily mean, you have agreed that the lien amount is correct. It just simply indicates that you are trying to avoid additional financial hardship to the client by making the payment. Now, look, keep in mind that sometimes payment of the lien could be of concern, you know if your argument is that you want a full waiver of the lien amount, because it would be an exceptional financial hardship to the plaintiff to have to pay it. They really need the money and then you go ahead and pay it. Technically, they're not supposed to take that into account. But you have to think at some point in their heads, they're thinking well, it couldn't have been that much of a hardship because you paid it. I'm not saying you know, don't pay it if you have a waiver pending, I'm just saying, you know, strategy, there could be reasons why you pay, pay the final demand to avoid the interest. There could be
39:11reasons why you don't pay the demand. Because you think perhaps it makes it a stronger argument. Every case is going to be different. There is no black and white. There's no you know, broad based rule where you know, if you meet these three criteria, pay the lien. If you meet these three criteria, you know, let it ride and see how it goes. Every case will be unique and every case will require some some independent thought to decide what is best and when you should pay or not paid the lien will be up to each individual person to make that decision. Let's talk about waiver requests in a little bit more detail. There are pros and cons with both a waiver request and a compromise request. The biggest negative probably aid for the waiver is that you can only file a waiver once a final demand has been issued. And it always seems to take the contractor at least 55 to 60 days to review your waiver request and issue a decision or sometimes longer. So you always kind of feel like if I'm doing a waiver request, I'm going to run right up against that interest wall. And, you know, that's always a concern. So that makes it a more challenging process in some ways. But the benefits to a waiver are, you can ask the agency to waive their conditional payment amount in full 100%, you can also ask for a smaller amount, so you could ask them to wait half of it or you know, 25%, whatever the case may be, but you can have the option of waiving it 100%. And that is very attractive to some people. And it's sometimes very necessary, depending upon the facts of the
40:57case, there's just no money there to pay that lien with. And the decision is appealable. So the waiver request is reviewed by that contractor by the bcrc. And if you disagree with the bcrc decision, you will be allowed to do a second level appeal. And if you disagree with that you can request an HJ hearing, and so on and so forth up into the point where you get to the district court level. So a waiver is appealable, which is also a benefit in my opinion. Your comp will contrast that now with compromises so compromise requests. The biggest benefit to me when when I'm trying to decide you know what to do waiver versus compromise. I like the compromise request, because you can do it when the file is at a tentative status. So you don't have to wait for that final demand to be issued. You don't have to worry about interest accruing if it takes the regional office a long time to review your compromise request. You can do it you know at that earlier stage, but it is dependent on review, or is issuing your settlement amount or not issuing it but notifying CMS of what your settlement amount is. That is one of the factors, the settlement amount is a factor that CMS will review when determining if it will be compromising the lien. So if you disclose or indicate your settlement will be $100,000. And based on that plus other factors, the agency agrees to reduce the lien. If you then actually settle for 125,000, you will nullify that compromise, because now you have $25,000 more to work with more to potentially reimburse Medicare
42:45with than what was given consideration at the compromise level. So if you want us they have no clue what the case will settle for. Don't do a compromise request, don't try to guess wait until you're a little bit closer to settlement, when the parties have a better idea or understanding of what the claim will actually settle for, then do a compromise when you can give a more accurate number about the settlement amount, you have to be willing to pay something so for some people, this is a negative to the compromise, you cannot compromise all the way down to zero, you have to give them something. The final potential negative is a compromise request is reviewed by the regional office with jurisdiction over the Medicare beneficiary. And the decision of the regional office is final, it cannot be appealed. So if you disagree with the decision of the regional office, you have nowhere to go, there's no exhausting your administrative remedies to get to the District Court. There's there's nothing you can still file a waiver request if you haven't already done so you can file an appeal. And if you if you found a basis where you think an appeal might be successful, you could also revise your compromise request. If you think there was a real error made at the regional office level and resubmit it. There's nothing that says you can't resubmit your compromise request.
44:20But you need to realize that I mean, once the regional office has looked at it, unless in the new revised compromise request, you have new evidence and it's quite substantial new evidence that would really be impactful on the decision of the regional office. The likelihood of them changing their minds is very slim. I mean, it could happen but it's it's slim. So you know there There you go there the pros and cons of waivers and compromise request. And now we're going to shift to talking about Part C and D payments, our plans and their recovery rights. So I'm on slide 24, you're going to see the CFR Sections that give the Part C and Part D providers their recovery rights that link it back to the Medicare secondary payer right payer act and gives them those recovery rights. Even if someone is on a Part C Medicare Advantage plan, you still have to do traditional AB lien search, because of open enrollment. Open enrollment is a period of time every year where a beneficiary can change their Medicare plan. And during open enrollment, they are allowed to opt into or out of any plan that they would like, including going back to traditional AB Medicare. So because of open enrollment, and it's possible that at some point they were in traditional AV Medicare while treating for your accident, you will always do an ad lien search plus the Part C OR Part D. Lien search if necessary. If you have information that indicates participation in a Medicare Advantage Plan, or a Medicare Part D drug plan. If the AB lien search returns a
46:26conditional payment amount of zero, this could be an indicator that the Medicare beneficiary or the plaintiff is participating in a Part C plan. The Part C plans pay everything that a B Medicare would have paid. And they usually offer additional benefits that Medicare Parts A and B do not provide such as covering prescription drugs, they may also cover some transportation services, some additional home health benefits, there's a lot of things that Part C plans may provide that A B doesn't. But the most popular reason to get a Part C plan is you get all of your benefits in one card, including your prescription drugs.
47:09So if someone's on a C plan, parts A and B pay nothing, it kind of passes through, he will add to that Part C plan. And they will make all of the accident related medical payments. So if you know someone's on Medicare, and you're pretty confident Medicare paid the bills, and you do that Medicare AB lien search and it comes back zero, that is a huge indicator to you that there is a Part C plan. If you're having trouble kind of communicating this to the planet, because it can be confusing. You're going to then say I want your Medicare card, I want all of your Medicare cards and they give you the AB the red, white and blue Medicare card. And then when you come back and say well, I need your your Medicare card and they're thinking, I already gave you my Medicare card, what are you talking about? So a different way to approach it with the plaintiff may be to ask them for the card. They gave their pharmacy, when they had to get medications refilled it, it's pretty rare. When someone gets into an accident, they go to the hospital, and they leave the hospital without a prescription. Almost everybody walks out of the hospital with a prescription for something whether it's a pain medication, an anti inflammatory, a muscle relaxer, and then they go to their you know, their pharmacy, and they get that filled. When you get an outpatient drug filled, you can't give the pharmacist your red, white and blue Medicare card because that benefit program doesn't cover outpatient medications, you have to give the pharmacist
48:46a different card, are you paying cash. But if you're using insurance, you're giving them a different card, not your ab Medicare card. So sometimes if you go to the plaintiff and you ask for the card that they give to the pharmacist that can help you at least it's a starting point to figuring out what other health plans or health benefit programs they are participating in. And then you can use that to figure out what additional liens may be out there. And then you know, kind of start that process of getting the lien searches going. If you don't believe that the CD plants have a right to recovery and you're going to fight them, you need to know that they win almost all the time when they go to court if if a of a Medicare Advantage Plan decides that they need to sue you to recover their payment to recover their lien amount. Know that that plan is very confident they win pretty much all the time. You will probably not be that confident. So just keep that in mind. They may not be plans that you want to push too far. They will negotiate with you they will try to work with you on lead NGS and lien reductions. But if you just flat out denied their recovery rights, they will certainly not hesitate to file suit.
50:08Because it can be difficult to determine liens and Part C and Part D plan participation. And because the Parsee V plants have a direct right to recovery against the insurance providers, insurance providers were very concerned that they were settling cases and they didn't know about a Part C OR Part D plan that could have had a lien. And then they find out about it later after the fact. And that can cause all kinds of trouble. So Congress passed the paid Act, which is the provide accurate information directly act in December of 2020. It became a law a year later in December of 2021, or became inactive. And what it does is it requires Medicare to provide to the defendant. So it's made available through the section 111 portal plan identifying information for the most recent three year period of time. All it provides is the name of the plan. It will not give you contact information for the plan, it will not tell you if the plans have made any payments related to your accident, but will not even tell you if the plan uses a third party subrogation firm to do their lien work on their behalf, they will just simply give you the name of the plan. And it will only show you plans for the pub lap most recent three year window of time. So if you have an older case, that's five years old, or six years old, or something beyond three years, you're not going to see all plan information for the entire case, you're only going to see that the limited three year window. So while this is helpful, you know, could be more helpful
51:57in some ways, but at least it does allow the defendants to know that they need to get more than just the AB lien amount when they're getting ready to resolve and settle the case. Plaintiffs plaintiffs attorneys, you do not have access to the paid act information for right now. It is only on the section 111 portal, there is no way for plaintiffs firms to tap into that data. So on the defense side, be professionally polite. And if your client comes back and tells you we have paid act information from the portal, here are the plans that are have been identified, as you know, the plaintiff has participated in, pass that information along to plaintiff, they may already know, you know, their client may have already given them the cards and plan information for the plans showing up in the portal. But they may not know they may have asked for the Medicare ID card may note of that in the file. And you know, when they asked the client, are you on anything other than Medicare? The client said no. And that was the end of it. And again, that can be confusing. So you asked the client, are you receiving health benefits from any other program other than Medicare? And they say no, and you've got the AB Medicare card in the system. So you're like, Okay, we're good to go. It's not going to trigger with the plaintiff to say, or not now with most plaintiffs to say, I also have an advantage plan, my get my Medicare through UnitedHealthcare gold or you know, Medicare, complete Blue Cross and Blue Shield, Medicare, whatever it might be. They're just
53:46going to ask you the question, and you ask, is Medicare your only health care provider? Yes, Medicare is my only health care provider. And if you don't kind of poke them a little bit about, have you participated in an advantage plan? Have you added on a Part D drug plan to your ad Medicare to help pay for drug benefits, they're probably not going to think to just volunteer it. So don't assume on the defense side when your client comes back and says, Oh, we've got our plan information for C and D we you know, we got that off the portal through the paid act. Don't just assume that opposing counsel on the plaintiff side knows all of this information, go ahead and let them know what you found out and make sure that they're aware that there are additional lien holders and you will need additional lien search data. The final CPE process so this is a very specific final demand process. It is also the only way you can obtain a final demand amount from Medicare prior to finalizing your settlement. So this was the most asked for change to the conditional pay. programs, so many attorneys found themselves involved in cases where you had a tentative lien amount, it seemed relatively reasonable. You don't really question it too much. You settled the case on that basis that you know, you pay your $5,000, Medicare lien, and then wood you gave notice of settlement. The lien wasn't $5,000 anymore, it was 15,000, or some some significant number, it had gone up quite a bit, and now the settlement is in jeopardy, you don't have enough money to pay the lien,
55:34or other factors might be at odds with each other. As you thought you had a $5,000 lien turned out it was $15,000 lien. And so yeah, that's a problem. So attorneys kept asking through lobbying groups and you know, direct conversations with senators etc. Can we please have a way to get the final demand amount for Medicare before we actually settled, so in January of 2016 42, CFR 411 point 39 became effective, and it allows you to request the final demand amount, up to three days before you start off. So here's how it works. When you request this process once you request it, so I should back up just a little bit. The other name for this so it is officially the final CPE process. But the other name for this process is the 120 day process. Because once you go into the Medicare secondary payer portal recovery portal, and click the little button to start this process, you must settle your case within 120 days. Once you start the process, you will get an updated lien letter a conditional payment letter, you can appeal each line item on that letter one time and you will get an expedited review. Once all of those appeals have been processed, go ahead and settle the case. Go right up to the point like get the get everything worked out documents are drafted, everybody's confirmed the language is appropriate. Get everything worked out. But don't sign anything. The person who's doing the final CP process at that point, should go back into the system and click another button for the final demand amount. The final demand amount will literally show up on the screen, it's
57:34like a screenshot, you can print it out you can do whatever you want with it. And that amount will not change, or at least it will not go any higher. critical for you to know is that amount that shows up on the screen will not have been reduced for fees and cost which you are statutorily entitled to. So you will technically have to appeal to get the fee and cost reduction. But that amount will not go up. When you get that amount, right, so you click the little button you ask for the final demand, you'd have your screenshot, you then must execute your settlement document within three business days after the final demand was requested. If you sign your settlement document on the same day that you request the final demand amount, you will nullify the process. If you sign it before you ask for the final demand amount, you will nullify the process. And if you sign your your release document on day four, instead of day three, you will nullify the process. It's very easy to nullify this process. And because you only have that three day window to get the document fully executed. It means it doesn't work for all cases. If you have out of state parties and everybody needs to sign it, it could be difficult to get the document signed and fully executed within that three day window. If you have someone with cognitive difficulties, and they sunset and sun rise, so they have periods during the day where they're fully competent and Lucent and could definitely signed that settlement document and periods during the day where their competency would be questioned and they
59:20could not legally sign the document. You need to be able to coordinate with the family and medical practitioners. So you have a witness that when they signed the document, they were fully competent and loosened. You need to be able to get that oh coordinator within that three day window. Sometimes that's easy to do and sometimes it's very difficult to do. And finally, some cases involve minors or other persons who might be competently challenged were in a probate court is required to review and approve the settlement to ensure it's in the best interest of the minor or incapacity. spectated person, and it may be very difficult if not impossible to get that probate court review set up and established and completed within that three day window. So, the final CPE process does not work for everyone, it is not appropriate for all cases.
1:00:25The final CP process may be available for work comp and liability, it is not available for no fault settlement. Most people, it doesn't work for work comp, either. It's basically just liability. I do want to point out 42 CFR 411, point 39 subsection D obligations with respect to future medical. So this is written into the statute, right. And it just reads, final conditional payments obtained via the web portal represent Medicare covered and otherwise reimbursable items and services related to the beneficiary settlement judgment award or other payment. There's never been any case law on this. CMS has never used this section yet to deny coverage, or denied payment for something in the future. But what it essentially means is if you pay a conditional payment for an unrelated injury or body parts, so let's go back to our hypothetical example, with our right knee injury. And you're doing this process or you're doing you can actually obtain a final demand amount off the portal without doing the final CPE process. But so you're you've got your final demand amount, and your you it's a number you can live with.
1:01:45And you decided to just pay it rather than dispute off charges. And one of those, or maybe a handful of those charges are for diabetes, something wholly unrelated to your right knee, but you just went ahead and paid that conditional payment amount, you didn't dispute off that condition as unrelated. This CFR Section essentially says, If you paid it, it's because it's related to the accident. And that means Medicare doesn't have to pay for it in the future, the settlement is primary. And anything related to the settlement in terms of a medical condition should be paid for from the settlement proceeds. If you are going to use the final CPE process, you need to be mindful of this subsection of the law. And if you are going to pay a lien without disputing or making any effort to dispute off unrelated body parts or conditions, it is possible. Medicare is going to utilize the CFR Section in the future as a basis to deny payment to deny coverage for that unrelated body part. So we're almost done with the conditional payment section.
1:02:59But before we move on to the other segments to Section 111 reporting and the and the future medical obligation that the statute requires I did want to make you aware of for actions by US Attorney's Offices. There were four cases filed against plaintiffs law firms between June of 2018 and January of 2020. All four cases were settled, none of them went to trial. All four were for failure to reimburse conditional payments. The these were fairly large law firms in their areas, they had been monitored for a while and had a history or pattern of accepting settlement proceeds and failing to pay the Medicare conditional payment amount. And therefore, these actions were brought against them. And two of the settlement so all four settled, but in two of the four settlements, the law firms were required to acknowledge that they they have violated the False Claims Act. The False Claims Act essentially means you are in possession of government property illegally.
1:04:18And for each violation of the False Claims Act. There is a financial penalty. And then on top of that financial penalty, the government can ask for treble damages. So it is a significant law with a significant penalty if you are found to have violated it. And the fact that they are trying to sort of marry violation of the Medicare secondary payer act, with a violation of the False Claims Act shows you that the government takes this exceptionally seriously. You really need to pay attention to the liens. You do not want to be the next law firm to get a notice from the US Attorney's office that you We're being sued for failure to comply with the act. Just because these four cases were targeting plaintiffs firms, it doesn't mean that there couldn't be similar cases in the future brought against insurance providers for their failures to fully comply with the Medicare secondary payer act. So, defense counsel, I don't want you to think you and your clients are off the hook here. These were targeted to plaintiffs firms. But it doesn't mean that in the future, the US Attorney's Offices couldn't target the defendants in the case for similar violations and failures to comply with the law. So at this point, I want to just to make sure that we have enough time and we do cover all elements of the of the act. There are there there, you know, look at the slides are definitely a few things that we're going to kind of skip over that are in the slides, but not not going to actually cover them. But I do want to pick up now with slide 45, we're
1:06:09going to start our conversation about the section 111 reporting requirements and give you more details about what that is. As I've said a couple of different times, the section 111 reporting requirement is a defense only requirement. If you only do plaintiffs work, you will never have to worry about section 111 or any of the penalties that come with it. And you know, come with that failure to comply with that reporting obligation. If you are a defense attorney, you want to check in with your clients if you haven't already, to make sure that they are fully in compliance and that their systems are updated. And they are doing all that they need to do to ensure that they are reporting accurately and timely. Because failure, failure to report accurately and timely could result in a financial penalty. And we'll talk about that in a little bit. There are basically two groups of of entities. So there are no fault and liability cases for Section 111 reporting and no fault cases are going to be pit medpay. And workers comp. And these are cases where the insurance provider is required to pay for medical treatment as long as the terms of the policy are met. So you've got a compensable claim that is covered under the terms and conditions of the policy. And you are required to make those payments until your obligation under the policy is terminated. For those for these types of cases, there's going to be two section 111 reports. The first report will be made when the insurance provider is notified of a compensable claim. So not when you get a
1:08:12bill. But when you are notified of the compensable claim, you're going to report right away, and you're going to notify Medicare of your fo RM obligation you're on going responsibility for medicals obligation. That's report number one. The second report will happen when the O RM obligation is terminated. There are a few ways you can terminate for PIP and medpay. The most common termination of or terminating event would be the exhaustion of policy limits by payment to medical providers. So that is critical. If you make the payment for let's say a $5,000 Pip policy, or PIP coverage on an auto policy. If you pay that $5,000 directly to medical providers, you have exhausted your policy limits, you have not shifted the burden of payment to Medicare, and there is no lien.
1:09:16If you pay the policy limits or the balance, so let's say you pay $2,500 to medical providers, there are still $2,500 of PIP coverage left and you pay that balance to directly to the Medicare beneficiary that is treated as a settlement and essentially as a settlement. Medicare can assert a lien against that payment because now you didn't fully exhaust by paying medical providers. You only exhausted partially by paying medical providers and the remaining balance who pay directly to the beneficiary and when that happens, that is a payment to the beneficiary that will trigger the Medicare secondary payer act and Medicare's recovery rights against that payment. So if Medicare finds on their system that they paid for $700 worth of benefits, or medical bills, they get to have that $700 reimbursed out of that $2,500 payment that you made to the Medicare beneficiary. And then finally, your responsibilities for our EMS is terminated by statute for settlement or judgment. So in some states, particularly with Pippa medpay, on an auto policy, the injured person has so many months to file bills, essentially, it might be 24 months, it might be 36 months. But essentially, after that statutory window has elapsed, the Pippa Med Pay provider is not responsible for payment of any additional bills, even if there's still benefits available, even if they haven't exhausted benefits. If that window has closed, you know, the 24 month window is over. And by statute, your legal obligation to pay that medical bill has terminated, you can then
1:11:13file your lrm termination report based on that statute. If you settle, you file it as a settlement. If you go to court, and there's a judgment that terminates your responsibility for medicals, then you would report that judgment. So four cases involving compensable claims where medical benefits are going to be paid. You will have two section 111 reports when you first notified of the case. And then the second report when your responsibility for medical benefits is terminated or straight up liability cases. So just bodily injury UNM UI M, you know your your basic tort type scenarios, you're going to have just one section 111 report, and that will be when the case is resolved. Either you settled the case, or you went to court and there was a judgment against you and you ended up making a payment. But there's just going to be that one section 111 report and it will come at the time. At the end of the case when the case is resolved. Generally speaking in a liability case, there is no or an obligation, which is why there's only the one section 111 report not to back in 90, no 99 ish back when well, no 2007. My apologies back in 2007, when the section 111 reporting requirement was created now it it didn't go into effect until 2010 2011. But it was passed by Congress much earlier than that and just took a long time for it to be implemented. But the original codifying statute for the reporting requirement had within it a built in financial penalty, wherein if the reporting entity failed to report timely, they would be assessed a fine or penalty. And that final
1:13:18penalty would be a per day per claim penalty. However, there were no parameters as to how or when the final penalty would be assessed. And there was also nothing built in that might waive the final penalty if the reporting entity should could show good faith efforts. A good faith effort to determine the Medicare status of the plaintiff. So to this very day, CMS has not collected a single penny of their civil money penalty associated with section 111 Because they never promulgated the rules that they were required to promulgate by Congress to enforce and effectuate the collection of the penalty. In February of 2020, CMS did publish a proposed rule in the Federal Registered had a 60 day public comment period, which has long since closed and that was the end of it. They have not yet published the proposed rule. The final version of the rule, rumor has it sort of rumblings that it could be published by February of 2023. But that is a rumor and a rumbling. Not necessarily something you should rely on. It could be very well that you know February of 2023 comes and goes and we have no final penalty published or final rule published. So what I'm going to walk you through is the proposed rule that was published in 2020. Keep in mind that the final version may be different than what they proposed back in 2020. So the proposed rule was that a civil money penalty would be assessed against an RR E, that's the reporting entity. When the AR, he has an error reporting amount above the reporting threshold of 20%. What that means is, so it's
1:15:3020 20% error reporting rate in four out of the last eight consecutive reporting periods. So I will put that in some sort of English for you that makes sense. Most large insurance companies report their our report their section 111 reporting quarterly. So what this is saying is, if in four, out of the last eight consecutive reporting periods, there is a finding of an error rate of 20% or more, then the entity will be assessed a penalty. If the error rate is less than 20%, or two occurs only three times instead of four times out of the most recent eight consecutive reporting periods, then no fine or penalty would be assessed. There is a tiered system for penalties being proposed, the first offense would be $250 per day per claim, that's an error. And then it gradually increases up to the maximum of $1,000 per day per claim. For the fourth offense. No civil money penalty will be assessed if the RR E can show or document all of the following.
1:16:52The ar e has communicated the need for identifying information to the Medicare beneficiary or their attorney. This is identifying information that will allow them to use that social security database, that query function that we talked about way back at the very beginning of this program, where you need to input data fields social security number, first and last name, proper date of birth. And if you don't have all of those data fields, the correct data fields, then your query search will be less effective, and it may turn up you know, a result that doesn't make any sense or you may not find the person in the system at all. So they have to communicate to the beneficiary or their attorney, what they still need to effectuate a query search so that they can determine the Medicare status of the person, they must make at least two written request and one phone call or email request for the necessary information. They are already must certify that despite these requests, the information was never provided. And they must document all other subsequent efforts to determine the Medicare status of the person that would be needed to facilitate their section 111 reporting. If you can show all of that you're fine or penalty will be waived. The statute is also proposing a statute of limitations of five years from the date of when the non compliance was identified by Medicare.
1:18:28If there's going to be a change from the proposed rule to the final rule, this is where it's going to happen. Because I think a lot of people raise some eyebrows. First Five years is a long time anyways, but five years from the date when the non compliance was identified. So not what the non compliance happened. But when it's identified by Medicare. So what if it takes them three years to figure out that you have a reporting non compliance issue, then they would have five years after that, to assess the fine or penalty, so be eight years total? That's a long period of time. So this was where I think a lot of the public commenting came in people were indicating that the period of time was was too long. And to have it be from the day when the non compliance was identified without information about, you know how or what Medicare would do to try to identify the non compliance or how timely they have to be with identifying noncompliance was of great concern to a number of people. So I can't guarantee you that it's going to change when a final rule eventually gets published. But this definitely got a lot of conversation and a lot of people were not real excited about it.
1:19:43We have no case law, because we have no law. But we do have one case that kind of speaks to what could be deemed reasonable or more than reasonable efforts on the part of an RR E to verify the Medicare lol The ability status of a plaintiff. This case was published two months after the proposed rule was published. It comes from us. To us from Rhode Island. It's a liability case, the state of Rhode Island was the defendant. The case settled with no specific requirements in the release agreement that the plaintiff had to provide the data necessary to verify his Medicare status. Specifically, the plaintiff refused to provide his social security number. The State of Rhode Island had a partial of the social security number, but they did not have the full number. And they made according to the judge, the state made over 100 queries to try to identify his Medicare status. But the results were inconclusive, and therefore the state was refusing to pay out the settlement proceeds, because they didn't want to be hit with a civil money penalty in the future. The state was very concerned about this. And eventually, plaintiff brought a motion to compel compliance with the settlement agreement and have the settlement proceeds paid out. The judge determined that the 100 queries and other efforts made by the state to verify the plaintiff's Medicare status was sufficient and should be enough to have any potential penalty waived. So while the case is interesting, and somewhat informative as to what might be considered reasonable
1:21:37efforts to ensure that our civil money penalty would be waived. The case speaks more strongly to just simply drafting your settlement documents more effectively. If the defense attorney had simply drafted in a couple of sentences into that release document that would have required the plaintiff to provide the data necessary to determine his Medicare status and fully comply with the section 111 reporting requirement. All of this would have been avoided. Because it would have been a term and condition of settlement, that would have been enforceable against the plaintiff, if he failed to fully comply. That that's the end of the settlement. So presumably, if he had signed the release document with that requirement in it, plaintiff would have been comfortable providing that information to effectuate the settlement. So, look at your release documents, make sure that you have the necessary data in there that you you know, just drafted in and say we, you know, plaintiff agrees to provide the necessary identifying information to verify his Medicare status or to facilitate the defendant section 111 reporting. There's a few different ways you can go about it. But it should definitely be included in your in your release document. If you have, you know, questions or concerns about that, you know, reach out to me, I'm happy to review draft settlement language and give you some guidance on where I think it could be modified or tweaked a little bit, if you if you have those sorts of questions or
1:23:19concerns. And with that, we are going to turn to the final topic for this CLE section, the future medical requirements. So the requirement that Medicare is secondary to your settlement proceeds and does not allow to make a payment for the injury or illness for which the settlement has been paid. So this is this is always a little bit of a tricky topic. It can get some people kind of emotional. So I'm going to try to walk you through it and help you navigate what is sometimes a rather contentious part of the statute. A key difference the requirement to keep Medicare secondary is really only referenced in the Medicare secondary payer act itself. So that is the statute referenced on slide 51. And the requirement specifically says what the what the statute says is that Medicare is prohibited from making a payment when payment can be made or has been made by workers compensation, an auto policy, a liability policy, a no fault policy, and it includes self insured plans. So that's it. That's the entire statute. And there's no other specific requirements. What what trips people up a lot Out of Time, is that the magical phrase Medicare set aside, isn't in the actual statute itself. And a lot of people get concerned that when, let's say, defense counsel goes to plaintiff's counsel and says, You made a claim for future medical damages, it appears your client is still treating for the alleged accident related injuries. Therefore, we think a set aside is required. We want to see your MSA report, we want to draft in settlement language that
1:25:38says you're going to fully comply with the statute and you're going to take care of all of these various elements. plaintiffs attorneys get very nervous about that, because they go back to the statute, and they look for that phrase Medicare set aside, and it's not in there. All the statute says is Medicare is prohibited from making a payment, Medicare is essentially secondary to your settlement proceeds. And the settlement proceeds now kind of step up into that primary payer position, and they have to be exhausted and utilized first. And Medicare is prohibited by law from making a payment for that same accident or injury until that primary payment or settlement amount is exhausted on medical expenses for the injury. The Medicare set aside is a tool to help you comply with that requirement. So while it's not in the statute, specifically, the fact that it's not there doesn't mean that it's not appropriate for your case. It is important to know that the set aside is CMS is preferred tool for compliance with the statute. But even CMS has acknowledged that there may be other ways to comply with the statute, other than a set aside. But to date, CMS has never approved anything else. And believe me, people have tried all kinds of financial schemes and wizardry has been put forward to the regional offices at one point or another. And they've been asked to approve it. And they have hands down rejected pretty much everything that they have seen, except for the set aside. Because of that. It's the go to tool. We know it works. We know the
1:27:52federal government likes it. And in a lot of cases, it's fine. It you know that there's nothing overly alarming or problematic about using it. So why is there so much contention about it? I think it's partly because it isn't directly in the statute. Another reason I think, at least for liability cases why there is a lot of pushback about doing it is because initially, while it's been in the statute the whole time. So statute was drafted in 1980. And this requirement to keep Medicare secondary has been there the whole time. There's no change. With CMS didn't do anything. As matter of fact, way back in the day CMS was with HCA, the Health Care Financing agency. And they didn't do much with it either. Until the late 90s. And then CMS published the memos and I, they they worked out on the workers comp side of it first. Why they chose work comp, I'm not 100% Sure, except for maybe it was just easier that most of the work comp laws in the 50 states are relatively similar. There aren't a lot of uniquenesses. There are a few holdout states that do things kind of uniquely, but there's a relative uniformity, if you will, and the way work comp is administered across the country. So that made it fairly easy for CMS to develop policies and procedures that were going to work fairly well in most of the country. And so they started making sure kind of reminding insurance companies that the statute existed and that they had this obligation to protect Medicare in 9798. In 2001, they published their first policy memo addressing the
1:29:55statute and how to comply with the statute in your setup When it was a very work comp, geared oriented policy memo, and CMS didn't shift their attention to non work comp, settlements until 2009 2010, kind of in that time period. And they still, even though it's been over a decade now that they have been steadily ramping up enforcement of the statute and steadily educating both the legal community and the medical community about compliance with the statute, their feedback could be better their information and instruction could be better. And because of that, there's still a ton of pushback in the liability community about protecting Medicare and fully complying with the statute. I think it's getting better. I certainly, you know, have have far less angry, contentious conversations with attorneys who really don't want to do this element of the statute, you know, they're fine paying back a lien. So that part of the statute is fine. But the other part of the statute that keeps Medicare secondary, that's the problem. I have far fewer calls now with very, very angry attorneys saying that this is just silly and hogwash, and they don't need to comply with it. So I do think it's getting better. I do think CMS is education efforts. Well, maybe they could be improved upon I do think the agency is trying to be communicative to the best of their abilities to the best of any government agency, I think we could say almost every government agency could communicate better. And I think CMS is trying. So back to the set aside and kind of
1:31:45out you know, more practical, outside of that sort of theoretical type period, you have to remember that your settlement is primary to Medicare, if you made any type of claim for future medical damages permanent damages, Lifetime Medical, and that claim, so the plaintiff makes this claim for medical damages future medical damages. And if that claim is being released as part of the settlement agreement, and remember, this goes back to our conversation about drafting and being consistent with your settlement language. If you if you're trying to draft settlement language that is narrowly tailoring the recovery, you'll have to be consistent all the way through. If you have a very broad damages release clause or paragraph in your release document that essentially says this is releasing any and all claims that could have been brought, whether they were or were not. CMS is going to look at that and say that includes medical, any and all claims medical is a claim that could have been brought. And that's going to rope in your settlement. So keep in mind, the plaintiff is going to control the scope of the injuries that are going to control the scope of the damages.
1:33:04The broader the brush you paint with on the plaintiff side. So the more body parts, the more injuries the more aggravated underlying conditions you bring in to try to advocate for your client and maximize their recovery. The more body parts and injuries and aggravated underlying conditions you have brought in for Medicare as well. And Medicare has every right to seek recovery for payments they made for those injuries and conditions. And they have the right to deny coverage going forward in the future for those same injuries and conditions, because the plaintiff has received financial compensation for them. And you made a claim for future medical damages. Is there any way to avoid an MSA or future medical allocation if a claim for future medical damages was made at some point in the history of the case? And the answer is yes. CMS issued a policy memo on September 29 of 2011. That indicated if the treating physician for the patient provides a statement indicating that the patient has been discharged from all treatment. And there is no future care required for the accident related injury. No MSA will be required. This is called a certification of no treatment statement. That has to be on physician letterhead, dated, physically signed by the physician. It should reference your date of injury and the name of the plaintiff. And it should also be specific as to the injuries or body parts. If there's any ambiguity or vagueness in the statement, CMS will not find it compelling to avoid a set aside, and will require an MSA. So if there's language such
1:35:11as the patient may return as needed, the patient can return if their symptoms flare up, the patient can return if they deem it appropriate. These are not major requirements for future care. They're not overly aggressive in any way, shape, or form, but they do indicate the potential for future as needed, or symptomatic treatment. And with that simple return as needed phrase, CMS will discount everything else in the letter no matter how well worded it might be. And they will require a fully funded MSA for that potential as needed symptomatic treatment. So when you are reviewing these statements from treating physicians, you need to be exceptionally critical of them. Any potential ambiguity, any inconsistency if in one part of the letter, they say, the patient is continuing to complain of pain or soreness or something and then they ended with what they're doing great and they don't need any treatment, that's inconsistent. You want to look for anything like that, that CMS could kind of pick apart. Also, it has to be a treating physician. If you get this type of statement from an IMD doctor, a second opinion doctor, even if they're a highly qualified physician, no tops in this area, you know, the best backs specialist in town kind of thing. If they weren't this person's back treatment provider, it doesn't matter, you need to get the certification of no treatment statement from the treating physician. And if the treating physician won't provide it, then you're stuck doing some type of future medical allocation for
1:37:13whatever treatment might be required in the future. If you can't get the doctor statement, I get asked about case law a lot. And there really isn't any. It hasn't come up in a while. But I used to get case calls all the time about the Iran key case out of Arizona in 2015. And the duff case out of Massachusetts and 2016. Trying to argue that these two cases stood for the principle that the secondary payer Act didn't apply to liability cases that the secondary payer Act didn't require our mandate to set aside and liability cases. And you could essentially shift that burden of payment. No judge in either case, or in any case has ever said that the secondary payer Act does not apply to liability cases. It definitely applies to liability cases. And in most of the cases that have been published, the judges went out of their way to make that clear. However, both of the cases referenced in the slide had a very narrowly tailored question to the court. And that very narrowly tailored question was
1:38:32does the secondary payer act mandate us a of a set aside? And you know, because we have already gone over it, that the statute does not mandate use of a set aside. Even CMS has indicated that they would be open to reviewing other financial tools or schemes that could be in compliance with the statute. So if even CMS is saying there might be something else out there that would be effective at complying with the requirements of the statute, then you can't say that the statute mandates a set aside. So that was all that those judges were asked. Right. If they weren't gonna go any farther than what they were asked the question. Was that, does the statute mandate a set aside? The answer is no, that's it. They did not say the statute doesn't apply to liability. They did not say that a liability settlement wasn't primary to Medicare. They didn't say any of those things. They answered the highly highly narrowly tailored question, and that was it.
1:39:38And I don't really blame them. It's a difficult question. What because CMS is silent on it, and the statute is silent on how to comply and how to keep Medicare secondary. If I were a judge, I would just volunteer my opinion on how to go about that either. So that's where we kind of circle back to the set aside if you You can't get your certification of no treatment statement to be in compliance with the September 2011 memo from CMS. There's no case law that you can fall back on to help you. So now you're you're in that position where you have to do some type of future medical allocation. What do you put in it? What medical care does it set aside accommodate or account for? A set aside is required to account for Medicare medical treatment that would be otherwise covered by the Medicare program that is reasonably foreseeable and related to your injury. So it's reasonably foreseeable future treatment related to your injury or illness that would otherwise have been covered by the Medicare program. This will include office visits, diagnostic imaging studies, physical therapy, lab work, such as blood draws, and urine drug screens, medications, replacement and maintenance on durable medical equipment.
1:41:11It will also include allocations for treatment that have been recommended, but that treatment has not yet occurred. This may include surgeries, pain management treatments, including injections and ablation procedures, and implantable devices such as use of an intrathecal pain pump, and a spinal cord stimulator. All of this will be reasonably foreseeable if it is referenced, particularly in a clinic notes of the treating physician. So if the treating physician indicates a need for three medications, and quarterly office visits, the set aside should account for three medications and quarterly office visits. If it is the type of injury that would benefit from periodic X rays, maybe an x ray every five years, then the NSA should accommodate periodic X rays, and so on and so forth. There are ways to reduce your MSA exposure, the rated age is probably the most commonly used, it's also probably the easiest to be perfectly honest, rated ages are an assessment by life companies. So those are life insurance companies such as New York Life MetLife, Pacific life, those those sorts of entities, they will evaluate the medical records, usually you give them 10 to 20 pages of relatively current medical records for the injured party. And they will evaluate how that medical treatment or how that medical those medical conditions impact life expectancy. The great thing with rated ages is the life companies can look at the whole person. So they're not just limited to your injury, they can look to the whole person and
1:43:17what's going on with them. So they can take into account the hypertension and the diabetes, and other diagnoses that have nothing to do with your accident, and then determine how that may impact and shorten their life expectancies. I forgot to mention, the life companies are generally going to be contacted by structure broker. So you're gonna go through, you're gonna contact a structure broker, you're gonna give them the 10 to 20 pages of medical records, they're going to give it to the life companies, and they're going to filter back the range of ages. So in an example, let's say we have someone who is chronologically 50. And after a review of their medical records, the rate of ages returned are 455. That means when I do my analysis for future medical allocation, I can use the life expectancy for a 55 year old rather than the life expectancy for a 50 year old. So that's going to shorten the number of years that I'm accounting for, which is in turn going to lessen the overall MSA allocation. The the next place to kind of look around to see if you can reduce your set aside is with medication costs. If a person is not a surgical candidate, medications are probably the number one cost driver of your set aside allocation. So review their medications and see if it might be possible to transition them from brand name drugs to generic or if they're getting duplicative drugs. Let's say they're taking three muscle relaxers Maybe the prescribing physician could whittle that down. And they might be okay with just one or two muscle relaxers
1:45:07rather than taking all three, we don't want to do anything to harm the patient to impact their quality of life, increase their symptoms, just for you know, the, just just to save some money, like that's not the goal here. But if we could modify their pharmacy still maintain their quality of life, it's, it's a win win, they're taking less medications, it's less expensive, they're still getting a good quality of life. So you can look into that and see if that's a possibility. The third bullet point there, surgery and implantable device statements, you can get a statement from either the doctor who was recommending the procedure, or the plaintiff, the doctor, it kind of can go two different ways. You know, maybe it's been a long time, maybe it's been five years since they recommended surgery. And now the patient's condition has changed, and they no longer consider them a surgical candidate. And the doctor might be willing to provide a statement, kind of confirming that and saying, hey, they're no longer a surgical candidate. I'm not recommending that for them, or they still think they're a surgical candidate. But the patient has said, I don't want surgery, I'm never going to authorize that I want to be treated conservatively. Some doctors might be willing to put into writing a statement to that effect, essentially saying, I discussed surgery as a treatment option for the patient. The patient has indicated they do not want to proceed with that option, they want to be treated conservatively. Therefore, I will continue to
1:46:46treat the patient conservatively. That it's a way to support why you didn't fund a surgery cost and set aside. You can also get a similar statement from the plaintiff saying, I know I've been recommended for surgery, I've weighed the pros and cons, I don't want surgery now or in the future. Neither statement is legally binding on CMS, CMS can still look to the whole of the medical evidence in a case and make a determination that it's more likely than not that the person, you know is or will be a surgical candidate and therefore the set asides should have included funding for that surgery. So that's important to know that even if you get one of these statements, it's not binding on CMS and CMS can disagree. That doesn't mean that you have to fund the surgery. What it means is everybody involved in the case needs to be educated, that surgery costs weren't included. This was why we didn't include it. You know, we had this doctor statement, we had a plaintiff statement. But there was a possibility of CMS disagreeing, and we requiring additional funding. You can also try to obtain a treatment plan or a treatment statement. Be careful about getting treatment plans or treatment statements. I've seen these go wrong, more often than I can count where an attorney called and said, Oh, don't worry, you know, I know Dr. so and so and I'm sure I can get them to put in writing that they just need to see the plaintiff once a year and an x ray every five years. And we'll you know, that'll that'll help minimize the satisfied, it's going to be great, don't worry about it. So
1:48:34they talked to the doctor, the doctor says sure, sure, I can provide the letter, they get the letter back and it's not so great. Suddenly, the doctors throwing in all kinds of treatment, they want to try pain management injections, they want to send a send the patient for a surgical consult. And so now here I have this really current letter from the treating physician specifically addressing future medical needs for this accident. And it's got all of this treatment in it that was technically not in any of the clinic notes. And had I not received this letter, I would not have that to include an insecticide. But now I have this really extensive really aggressive treatment plan.
1:49:14And there's really no way I can justify excluding this treatment I have to put it in. So now the set asides going to be larger than it would have been had I just gone off of the clinic notes that we not asked for the treatment plan or the attorney had not asked for it. I want to draw your attention to 42 CFR 411 point 47. If you look at this CFR Section, you will find that there is a mathematical equation and a number of vendors utilize this math mathematical calculation to support reducing their set aside allocations and it generally results in a very nominal set aside really Low. And when you first read the report, it sounds exceptionally persuasive because they're quoting the CFR Section in there says, the fancy schmancy equation, it's, you know, very, very delicate, complicated mathematical equation. And it just, you know, looks great, right?
1:50:16But this has been around a long time this this CFR Section has been around a long time. And people have been trying this for years, going all the way back to 2001 2002. There was even a case brought on it that got dismissed for failure to state a claim. And in July of 2005, so, quite a while ago, CMS issued a policy memo that indicated you cannot use this CFR Section for future medical allocations ever. They have also memorialized that 2005 memo and their work comp MSA reference guide. And if you have one of these reports, if you have a report, wherein the MSA is very low, and a bases for that very low calculation is this CFR Section, do you need to go back to the entity that provided you with that report, and talk to them about the CMS policy memo and the work comp Reference Guide, and ask them why they are utilizing a CFR Section for a future medical allocation? When CMS has made it clear, you cannot utilize that CFR Section for that particular purpose. I would not rely on that set aside. Based on the writings from the federal government, the basis for that set aside is not appropriate. And I don't think it's something that you should be relying on. Evidence based and essays. What are they? They are also sometimes called non submit MSA is and the word called Community.
1:51:58You'll hear that term non submit MSA more frequently. I think in the liability community, they probably call it evidence based more often. That's primarily because there's no formal review process for liability MSA. But we do have a formal review process for work comment essays. So an evidence based MSA or a non submit an essay is a set aside that was calculated not on the clinic notes from the actual treating physician for the injured individual. But instead, it's based on journals and blogs, and website databases to reduce a set aside. That's the goal, the goal is that these evidence based mshs are going to be significantly lower than a traditional MSA calculation. But they're still supportable because they're still evidence based. And
1:53:05companies like mine, people like me that don't do this, and try to come up with numbers that would actually be reviewed and approved by the federal government have always, you know, raised an eyebrow to this and wonder, you know, is that really appropriate to to be calculating a set aside based on journals and other such evidence when it's not really based on or supported by the clinic notes for that actual patient. And the reason they were called non submit essays or you had to agree not to submit them to the federal government is because the vendors who were providing them knew or were fairly confident that if they did come under scrutiny and review of CMS, they would likely not be approved. So you have to agree if you were going to do this program or, you know, participate with this, with this product that they were offering, that it would not be submitted or reviewed by CMS. And finally, in January and March of 2022, CMS addressed this concern and indicated that they do have concerns about these products and these LSAS.
1:54:17It is possible that they will be deemed burden shifting, and if they are deemed to be burden shifting to the Medicare program, the CMS agency will basically deny coverage for medical services related to the injury until proof is shown that an amount equal to the total settlement less procurement costs. So that's attorneys fees and costs only has been spent on medical care related to the injury. Presumably this amount at the settlement minus procurement costs will be significantly larger than the calculated NSA that was relied upon for the case. So CMS is not saying In that all evidence based NSA is our problem. They are saying that these products will probably be given a higher level of scrutiny should they come under review. And it is possible, they want to essentially people to be aware that some of the techniques used to calculate these mshs were not appropriate. And the MSA is were so low that, essentially, they were shifting that burden of payment to the Medicare program. And that would be inappropriate. So you do want to be mindful, if you're going to use an evidence based MSA, you really need to have a comfort level with how it's been calculated, and the actual evidence used. We just I just sort of touched on on CMS review. If you have a worker's comp claim, there is a formal CMS review process. If your case is a liability case, only. For now, there is no review process for your set aside allocation. However, CMS has promised that they've actually been promising for a while that they plan to expand the formal review process so
1:56:13that at some point in the future, it will fail we will accommodate mshs that are not work based. So for now, liability LSAS are not formally reviewed, work comp are if you need the review criteria. So if you don't have this review process, right, how does CMS know that there is an MSA and how do they know what what is primary? There are a couple of ways. First off, they're going to know that your settlement happened because that section 111 report is going to come in from the defendant and the defendant is going to say we settled with this Medicare beneficiary for X amount of dollars. In October of 2017, CMS made changes to what is called the common working file. The common working file is not a file that's available to the public. It is an internal file, wherein Medicare reviews data on a particular Medicare beneficiary to determine for our purposes, the most important thing that they determine is when to pay a bill. It specifically alerts the billing people at Medicare that there's been a liability settlement, that that settlement is primary to Medicare and that coverage for certain treatment. The section 111 report will include ICD nine or 10 codes for the injuries that are allegedly related to the accident. If they get a bill for those matching ICD nine or 10 codes, the common working file will direct the billing department to deny coverage on the basis that the liability settlement is primary to Medicare.
1:58:05Also, in 2017, CMS issued a medical network learning bulletin and educational bulletin for the medical community to educate them on the Medicare secondary payer act. And it's specifically educated them the medical providers that Medicare is always second always the secondary payer to liability insurance, no fault insurance and workers compensation. So you were all again lumped together in this bulletin. And that once physician is made aware that the claim has settled the liability claim the work comp claim the no fault claim has settled, the provider should look to the patient for payment. Medicare should no longer be billed. This is good and some fluff around around the country in December of 2018. It was widely reported and public or it wasn't published.
1:59:09But there was a notification issued by CMS that they were going to publish a proposed rule to help explain the requirements of the statute and specifically the future medical aspects of the statute and how to comply with it. It wasn't creating new law or new rules. It was just essentially going to be informative on in providing additional information on how to comply with the requirements of the secondary payer act. But that is all that happened. This notice that they planned to probably maybe publish a proposed rule was published in 20, December of 2018. And nothing ever happened with it and in October of 2022 it was formally withdrawn. But, as I said, this doesn't change the statute even though they have formally withdrawn the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking. It does not change the parties the defense and the plaintiffs obligations to fully comply with the with the statute. If you have a companion worker's compensation claim, keep track of it. If the work comp claim is settling, and they're closing out medical in addition to the wage reimbursement reimbursement portion of the comp claim, they've they're doing the set aside, not every claim needs to do the set aside, you know, if you're all set only together in or do a global settlement of the liability claim and the comp claim, if comp is already going to do is set aside, then they're going to get it approved through CMS because you can for comp, let them do the set aside, because for compensation claims, you can use the word con fee schedule. So it's going to be a little
2:00:56bit lower set aside, then on the liability side where you're using actual charges or the private pay rates. If they're leaving medical open on them, work comp claim, see if the comp carrier is going to exercise a holiday or credit, if they are exercising their holiday or credit period, that means then compensation available to the worker during that time period, then they usually have to spend a portion or percentage of the liability settlement once that liability amount has been fully exhausted, comprehensive primary payer status. So during that window of time, where a comp is not available, because the holiday period is being exercised, you will need some type of set aside or future medical allocation to ensure that you don't shift the burden of paying it to Medicare. While comp is on holiday, when comm presumes its primary payer status, then you're good to go. So you don't necessarily need a lifetime MSA or something you know, that's fully funded for the life of the person, you just need a set aside that accommodates that holiday or credit period. Sometimes, you can get the comp provider to waive the holiday or credit period and continue or agree to continue to pay medical benefits, even after your liability settlement uninterrupted. And if that's going to happen, then the comp carrier will remain primary. So they're going to keep paying uninterrupted. And that means your liability settlement does not need to do is set aside because now your liability settlement isn't burden shifting, you're not shifting that
2:02:38burden of payment, because comp is still there, and that primary payer status, so you don't need to set aside, you do still need to reimburse the lien, you do still need to report under Section 111. So there's a lot of elements to a comp claim. They may need to approve your liability settlement before you can proceed with it or finalize it. So don't lose track of it and stay in good communication with the Workers Compensation provider. I've kind of touched on it the MSA is going to be funded at actual charges. For liability cases, you can use a work concrete schedule if you're in a state that has one there's a couple of states where there isn't a work comp fee schedule. You can never use the Medicare fee schedule when you are calculating a set aside. Medical billers are not required to take the Medicare fee schedule from any entity except for Medicare.
2:03:34So therefore, you cannot utilize the Medicare Fee Schedule ever. Medical bills from the set aside must be paid utilizing the fee schedule used to calculate it, which means if you are doing over comp, MSA and you use the work comp fee schedule, the person administering the set aside must continue to pay the providers at the work on fee schedule. And if the providers want payment above and beyond the work complete schedule, you cannot use the set aside for that you have to that amount above and beyond the work coffee schedule has to be paid from other financial resources. A lot of people don't realize that. So I throw that in when I can when I have time. Speaking of time, we are pretty much at that at the two hour window. So there are a few things that we did not get to some practice tips, slides and things of that nature that we did not get to in our two hour time. But I think we got through quite a lot of it. And I'm hopeful that it answered a lot of your questions about the Medicare secondary payer act and how to fully comply with it within your settlements. As I said at the beginning of the presentation, if you do have questions or concerns, don't hesitate to call or email me. I'm always happy to take your questions and lend assistance where where I can and with that I'm going to conclude your seminar thank you so much for your time and I hope whatever you're doing for the rest of your day that you have a wonderful day thank you so much