Richard Brian G.NY
Very interesting.
54min · about 10,400 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello, my name is Mike Moyer, on the inventor of slicing pie. And I'm with the number one slicing pie attorney in the United States, Matthew rosette, he Hi, Matt, thanks for coming on board with us today. Thank you, nice to meet everybody. Always good to do a webinar with you. Today we're gonna talk about perfect equity splits for early stage bootstrap startups. Lawyer edition. So this is a model for producing a perfectly fair equity split with your founder clients. So you have clients come to you, and they want to form a new company. And the first deal they normally do is what their equity splits going to be. So they sit down and try to hash out what their shares gonna be. And they usually kind of try to do something along these lines, they figure their share should be the value their contribution divided by the total value of the firm. The problem with this logical equation is we don't know these things, we don't know what the valued firm is, you don't know what someone's going to do, the future is unknowable. So because of this usually winds up in discussion about the promises of the employee or the co founder, divided by the dreams of the founder. So I'm going to come on board, and I'm going to say, Gosh, I'm going to work really hard and be your marketing person and, you know, work for five years straight and no salary. And you say to me, we're gonna be a billion dollar company in five years, and we're going to sell out and I'll give you point zero 1%, you'll be rich beyond your wildest dreams. The
1:33conversations get pretty ridiculous pretty fast. And I'm sure as a startup lawyer, you can you can relate to that. Unfortunately, we go talk to lawyers and advisors and professors and people who are smart and experienced and well meaning and have your best interest in mind. And they tell you to keep guessing is what you know, what are the estimates for marketing person? Or what are the estimates for a technology person? Or what's the rule of thumb? And what's your financial projection? What are you gonna look like? All of these things are based on future events, you're basically just guessing. So you got to ask yourself, can you predict future events? If you can, then there's no problem. But most of us can't, most mortal men can't do that. So we wind up with what's called a fixed equity split. A fixed equity split is one that looks like this, it's 6040.
2:20Or maybe it's 5149. Maybe it was kind of my idea. So I get 51%. So I can maintain control. Or maybe we just did some random split. And usually people say screw it, let's keep it simple. We'll go 5050 Or a third, a third, a third, and lots of startup startup, doing equal splits. As I'm sure in your experience, you can you can attest to, what if we're 5050 and you do all the work. So I own half your company, and you're doing all the work. Now you got to get rid of me? Well, what if we're 5050, and you want to bring in a third person. So I'm a marketing person you bring in a marketing person doesn't help you, it helps me just to come out of my share, just come on to your share, who shares come out, or what if your partner wants to quit? Does he get to take his percentage share with or percent share whether or if your CTO gets hit by a bus, I was once working with a company CTO, built half the software and got hit by a bus and subsequently died of his injuries. And his wife inherited his half of the business which she should have. And the founders of the living founders said, this woman can't code a software package is this mean not to give her half my profit. So and indeed, it does mean you have to give her half the profits. And he didn't want to do that. And I don't blame them. But she didn't want to do it for sure. And I don't blame her. So they're stuck. And this company ultimately went out of business because they couldn't figure this out. So when something changes, as it inevitably will, one of these things is going to be true. The first one is
3:46the the greatest and symbol, you're gonna have more than your fair share. And some people are okay having more than their fair share. But the other thing that can happen is to have less than their fair share, and no one's come from unless their fair share, no one wants to get screwed. I call these alligator pit negotiations. So when people go into the negotiation using a fixed equity split, their goal is self preservation to get as much as they can for themselves get in there, negotiate as hard as they can get what they want, get it all written in their contracts they can then they can't get it taken away, secure as tight as they can. And they're not very nice places to be, there's not the kind of negotiations you want to go into as your partners. So I call this the fix and fight method. You fix the split. With folks dressing fixed percentages, and you fight about it later. And many lawyers that I talked to including man on the phone, do this all the time, we were people will have to come back and renegotiate their split. And a big percentage of them requires legal intervention, which means you spend time that could be better spent on other things in the company rather than fixing founder disputes.
4:53Because if it's not fair, it won't be fun. So startup should be fair, and they should be fun. So the best way to understand The slicing pie model and the best negotiation strategy for this kind of thing is the game of blackjack. Now, Maddie on the phone with us still? Yes, I am. You know how to play blackjack? Right? Yep. So we're gonna agree to play blackjack together as a team, not opponents, but as a team. And we're gonna split the winnings. 5050 That sound, Okay. Sounds good to me. So we're gonna do air fist bump to agree on it. You're my lawyer, we're going to, we're going to document it, and then you do the deal. And we're gonna go to Las Vegas. And I put a chip down, and you put a chip down. Now, we don't know if we're gonna win. We don't know how much we're gonna win. We don't know how long it's going to take you in the future is unknowable, we can't predict the future. What we know for certain, though, is that we each bet one chip, it's the dealer deals an ace, and another day. We're gonna split the aces.
5:52Okay. Sounds good to me. But I'm out of money, and you're not. So you put two more chips down to cover our bets. Now you've bet three chips, and I've bet one chip. Now, we still don't know if we're gonna win, or how much we're gonna win or how long it's going to take to win. What we know for certain, though, is that you bet three? And I bet one, if we win, is our 5050 Deal. Sound fair? It does not, does not it shouldn't be 75% for you, and 25% for me, and we had a deal for 5050. You can I can sue you and probably win because you're a good lawyer, you documented it properly. Right? Correct. But just because we agreed to it, just because our lawyer wrote a contract. Just because we shook hands doesn't make it fair.
6:36What's fair is that our share the winnings should reflect our share of the bets. And it's exactly the same thing for startups, except we're betting on ideas instead of cards. And we bet time and money and relationships and facilities and supplies and equipment. And every time we bet something, we're betting exactly the unpaid portion of the fair market value. So if you're worth $500, an hour's lawyer, and I, you work for me for five hours, and I don't pay you 500 bucks an hour, you are betting the fair market value of your contribution. If I'm worth $100,000 a year, the startup doesn't pay me $100,000 A year, I'm betting $100,000. In unpaid compensation, I can't bet more than that, I can't magically bet more than that, that's my fair market is I can't bet less than that, because I'm only worth what I'm worth. If I bet a piece of equipment that cost 20 bucks, and I'm not reimbursed, I'm betting $20. In expenses that are not reimbursed. With that in mind, a person share the equity should always be based on that person's share the bets. So slicing pie does is simply observes the bets on the table keeps track of who made what bet converges to what's called a slice. A slice is a fictional unit of risk, like a poker chip is keeps track of who bet what and divided equity based on the bets. So that's the basic premise, the whole idea is that whatever you're betting is what you should receive out of the out of the business. Now, a common question is is some kind of legal agreements. So Matt, is there some kind of legal remedy
8:11they can they can write for this? Yes, there is, on what Entity Framework they're going to use. And what's your favorite? I prefer all C's. But we can make it work with a C Corp, we could have done some partnerships as well. What's nice about this is I've been doing this for about 10 years, and I've seen I work with lawyers all over the world. And in every culture, every tech system, every kind of economic system, it's always there's always been a solution. That's because the logic behind the model is logical. It's the logic of fairness. What I've noticed over the years is fairness is not a matter of opinions. It's a matter of facts. If I think something's fair, and you have a different opinion was fair, one of us or both of us has to be wrong. But when you can observe the facts, you can only know what's fair. And in business. Everything is quantifiable in terms of dollars and cents. Everything can be expressed in fair market value, literally everything you contribute to your business can be expressed in dollars and cents. And you can observe the facts as they happen.
9:12Because you can do this, you can always calculate, there's a great deal of accuracy, what's fair and what's not. You can't do this to other parts of your business. You can't do this. And it was fair in your civil trial, for instance, or murder trial friends, you can't you can't do that. Because what's fair, that situation isn't always clear. But in business, everything is quantifiable. So in the slicing pie model, there's two pieces of this. First is the allocation framework. The second is the recovery framework. This animal is called a grunt, you might hear it referred to as a grunt fund sometimes, and it is a universal one size fits all solution to the allocation and equity and recovery of equity and an early stage bootstrap startup. So what that means is that it works for the bootstrapping stage, it gets it from concept creation. to your first major round of funding, and we'll talk about that more in a minute. But this is not a long term solution doesn't work forever, it only works for the bootstrap returns when your share values, in fact zero. So the allocation from four remembers the first part I mentioned earlier, slice is a fictional unit of risk called that kind of a poker chip, it marks the fact that it read that a bet took place. It doesn't, it's not worth anything, you can't buy anything with it, it just marks the fact that a bet took place. So the fictional unit of risk. So the allocation framework is you convert your contributions are slices. You divide your slice at any given time, your shares, your slices, divided by all the
10:44slices, just like in poker, your share was 75% of your three year three chips divided by the four chips that were bet, and it'll self adjust over time to stay fair. So as people come and go, people change their commitment levels as the needs of companies change, they will self adjust. So one common question at this point is, isn't it easier just do a fixed split? And yes, it is. It's easier just to divide up 5050. That's an easy, easy deal to do. It's easy contract to write. The problem is it will backfire. Because it's gonna be renegotiated. How often you see a fix that we negotiated that for most companies, it comes up on an annual basis, and they're always gonna come back. So you know, Joe didn't do he said he was going to do his market and say, or this person quit early and took how many 10 years ago, and they just sold out. And she got a big check in the mail. But she was disappointed because she didn't feel she got she got enough. So you know, one thing I tell people is your equity split. Most importantly, split is how you experience success. So if you're actually putting stuff is there, you'll experience success in a positive way. If it's unfair, you'll experience either in a very positive way, because you've got more than your fair share, or very negative way, because you got less than your fair share. I was with a company wants to wear one of the co founders walked away with $5 million, which was more money than he ever thought he had. And the rest of the rest of his life was a huge
12:13amount of money. But he was irate because his co founder got $300 million. So relatively speaking, he was rich beyond his wildest dreams. But when he looked at an equity stake, he saw the injustice because he worked just as hard as his co founder did. So it's as much as easy to just do a fixed split, it's Uncharted online to fix that once it goes wrong. And the way people experience their success will be very different. So here's the first step, you convert to slices, there's two kinds of contributions, you can make your startup company, there are non cash contributions, which are things like ideas, time, relationships, certain facilities, things that don't require cash out of pocket to acquire. And there are cash contributions, which are unreimbursed expenses. So let's say I buy a plane ticket for $1,000. If I don't get reimbursed, then I'm betting the cost of that plane ticket. And some things are kind of in between. So maybe I have a truck in my back yard that I don't use anymore. That's a non cash contribution. If I buy the truck for the company, then it's a cash contribution. Guys got to ask yourself, did I take cash out of my pocket? Or was it did I just not get paid for my time and my ideas. So you take the fair market value, which is always observable. Now we may not know right off the bat, what you what it's worth, so that the truck in my backyard, it'll be worth the blue book value, for instance, or I may not know what my celebrity status is worth is, but somewhat somewhere out there, there's a there's an answer to what something's worth.
13:38We're fair markets for fair market value standpoint. So to convert to slices, we have to account for the risk associated with each type of contribution. So to do that, we get two slices for every dollar and non cash you contribute, and four slices of every dollar in cash we contribute. That's because when I consume cash, there's a different way that I consume non cash. If, for instance, if I paid you 50 bucks an hour to work for me, and you want to buy a thing that costs $50, it would take you more than an hour to buy there enough money because when you when I paid you, I pay employment taxes and Social Security taxes, when you receive the money, you pay income taxes, when you bought the thing you pay sales tax or bad tax. So it may take you two hours to earn enough money versus time value of money and all kinds of things that go into it. So we have to wait it more heavily. So I waited twice what I tried to wait a non cash dollar, it just smooths out the volatility in the two different choices of contribution. So again, to the two sides for every dollar non cash and $1 in cash gets four slices. So for instance, for time time is the most common contribution people make to startup companies. You take the fair market salary, whatever it happens to be, you subtract cash compensation, because if you're paid, it's not a bet. So for instance, if I paid your entire salary, you're not betting anything, so there's no equity do at all, if I pay you less than your fair market salary or nothing, then what's left over the unpaid portion is your bet. So
15:07for instance, that I multiply by two to get my grunt, hourly resource rate or GRE sound and making them harder work with my company. So let's say you're worth $100,000 year, which is 50 bucks an hour, even 2000 hours in a year. So that's 100 slices for hours, every hour that I worked with a company and I'm not paid, I'm contributing embedding 100 slices of that pie. If I get paid 10 bucks out of that 50 bucks, then I'm only getting $40 an hour. So my group my risk goes down to add slices per hour. So cash them out, when I buy something for company or I invest cash when it's consumed, I multiply by four to get my slices per hour. So money is not at risk if it's not consumed. Once it becomes consumed, it comes at risk. Equipment, I talked about the truck earlier, if it's if you pay cash for it, it's times four, or a cash contribution. If it's less than a year old, it's non cash contribution. If it's more than a year old, I use a blue book value.
16:03Literally everything has a fair market value. So for instance, relationships are really important as they should be. So someone who has a lot of relationships can convert into sales, for instance. So if I am a salesperson that convert my relationship to sales, I'm dual commission, I can either get that commission paid to me in cash, or I can contribute slices in the pie as a non cash contribution. My ideas I was all gung ho about that idea has been so important. And they are important. If their idea exists in fixed in space and a patent or copyright, then I'd be doing royalty on my idea, I get paid for my royalty in cash, or I can get slices in the pie. So office supplies and things like that unreimbursed expenses are times for. You might be saying, gee, Mike, that sounds like a lot of work and track, which can be confusing. Most companies track their payrolls, most companies track their expenses. Most companies do this just as a matter of fact, doing business is just part of businesses tracking these things. There's nothing new to track here and Slice the Pie. The difference is, we're tracking things we're not spending versus things we are spending. But if you're in a business, and you're not capable of tracking your payroll expenses, you're not off to a good start anyway. So I always tell people, the tracking seems like it might be a big deal. But it's not really a big deal, because it's just interesting people during the course of doing business, and there's tools that can help you track this, check the contributions. So here
17:28we are some grant funds in action. This is a herd of grants milling around and startup incubator. This grant has an idea. She recruits a team. She's got her junior developer, she, she's the founder, and she's got a rich uncle. She puts in time and some equipment and some ideas, or junior developer puts in some time only developing websites and apps. And a rich uncle bankroll is a thing. It makes important relationships. All you can, all you do is take the fair market value these contributions, convert into slices, SHABOOM, add them all up, and divide each person's share, just like we did in poker. So there's one, two and three, analysis that looks like this. This is a logical split, given the contributions made to date. It makes sense, the algo has more who bankroll this thing because the founder, the junior developer, and we're working very much the junior developer was just out of college and she didn't get she didn't bet very much compared to the founder. So this gave him this point in time. This is a fair split. And let's add somebody we're gonna add this guy's name is Barry. He's a sales guy, put in some relationships and put some time in big Rolodex variants. So we convert his stuff to slices SHABOOM there it is, we add it to the total slices of the pie that given time. Now we're going to pretend no one else does any more work. But in reality, I wouldn't be adding slices to the biome time. And we divide each person share again, there's number 123. And now we have a new split. Now as you can see, the sales guy
19:02Barry has 13%. If the rich uncle was unwilling to budge on his split, then the founder and the developer would have gave him various share of his share, they would have to fight about it, the jungle would have to be a good record to hire lawyer got to be drafted agreements they got to fight about it maybe Barry didn't want to do on a commercial of fighters. So at this given time, at this point, given them the contributions made the fair market value compared to each other, just like in poker, we adjusted the split. Now that we've allocated shares, sometimes we're going to get shares back. Getting shares back is called the recovery framework, and recovering equity when people leave some of the signs those disruptive to the most destructive part of the company. I hate hearing about a founder who gets paid off early on in the company, they buy back shares, and he winds up being the only person who ever makes any money in the company. Or she walks away with a chunk of shares and she didn't really deserve. So there's four reasons that someone can be fired and you might wreck it Diocese's as an attorney from employment contracts the first way you can be fired for good reason. And use the logic of fairness I always say you got to fire someone with two warnings, Warning, warning fire, before you can fire them, you gotta get some chance to correct their behavior before you fire them. Unless anything so negligent that it's clearly shoot fire, like sexual harassment or bringing a gun to work or embezzlement, there's there's no warning, you
20:24just fired most of the cases performance related WARNING WARNING fired, they can also be fired for no good reasons meaning it's they just got fired one day and I want to work with you, the boss just fired you which is which is fine. You can also resign for good reason. Resigning for good reason implies that your treatment or was horrible or your promises are made, they weren't kept. So for instance, if you're sexually harassed on the job, you have good reasons to resign. Or if the job was changed your title or your compensation or the location, the job has changed fundamentally, and you have good reason to resign.
21:01So startups are notorious for making promises they can't keep you know, we're gonna have million dollars in the bank by next summer, you may or may not happen. So if that doesn't happen, then make that promise, you have good reasons resign. You can also resign for no good reason box D here. This means you just resigned for your own reasons. Maybe you didn't like the company more, or you don't believe in the vision anymore. Whatever your own reasons are resigned for no good reason. In situations a and d y for good reason or resigned for no good reason. You're essentially walking away from your bet. So imagine the blackjack table, you just get up and walk away, I'm not going to chase you down and give your money back. You've walked away from your bet you're quitting. So you lose your slices for non cash contributions. And your cash contributions basically turned into a loan and you paid back later. So you basically lose your rights to equity. It's painful to leave on these circumstances as it shouldn't be. If you want to play the game, don't quit, don't get fired, don't underperform. On the flip side, if you're fired for no good reason, or you resigned for good reason, you keep your slices in the pie, they stay on the table and convert to equity later on with everybody else. So here's an example. Here we are back at our team. The junior developer stopped showing up at work one week, we gave her a warning and she's got to come to work. Second time, she doesn't warn number 2/3 time she's fired. All she had was non cash contributions on the tables. So
22:24we simply subtract your stuff from the from the pie, recalculate the remaining grunt shares, there's two, three, and four. And now the pie is automatically naturally recalibrated itself to stay fair. So no matter what changes no matter who joins the company, who leaves the company, and our commitment levels change slightly by natural to what was what's logical and fair based on the fair market value of the contributions. So eventually, you want to bake the pie. Baking the pie means you terminate the slicing pie agreement, and it turns a crisp, golden brown and tasty, delicious. So there's two times this can happen. The first is breakeven, meaning the company now has doesn't have enough money to pay all his expenses, or series A investment, which is the first major price round of funding, not an angel round, but a price round of funding.
23:17So here's the breakeven example. So let's say you're worth 50 bucks an hour and you get paid $0. Now, that's 100 slices per hour. So every hour you're working, you bet on your slices, now they're coming to get some revenue in the door, guests are paying you 10 bucks an hour. So your equity goes your bets going forward, go down and febbraio the more the company can pay you this 20 bucks, 30 bucks, 40 bucks, 50 bucks, when it's paying you in full for your contributions, you're no longer making any bets. And the pie naturally stops human beings license, you're paying your expenses, you're paying your salaries and everything out of your revenues. And the pie stops fluctuating and it freezes and your your common shares your your your shares, issuance is triggered. And now what's left over is profits. And you can either keep the profits as retained earnings are distributed in shareholders, and this is the bet paying off that pays off according to size you buy or if you sell the company, you'd better pay off that way. So this is the bed paying off just like in blackjack and get two thirds 1/3 split or 7525 split. The other way is a negotiated Series A round we raise enough money to cover your expenses in the foreseeable future. So let's say we negotiate a $900,000 pre money valuation, you want to raise a million dollars. A common question here is what's the relationship between the slicing pie model and the company's underlying valuation? And the answer is there is not. We're not what do you tell people when they ask this question? It's correct.
24:48I literally tell them if you remember nothing else from a free consultation or discussion on it. The underlying valuation of the company has no relationship whatsoever to the Hi framework. Now, a really easy example this came up during COVID, where we had clients who are opened brick and mortar stores or shops right? Under the guidelines issued, whether it be by the mayor or the legislator, whoever would be, you know, there's usually some kind of disinfectant requirements, right. So if Mike and I start a bakery during COVID, and I clean the place and completely disinfect everything, and Lee, we just assume that mike doesn't have a cell phones can't get all to me, he does it again, we both put time in. And we get credit into the slicing pie framework for performing those services.
25:39But we certainly did not increase the value of the company. And I think a really easy way to understand this. And that's one of the reasons I use the term slices instead of dollars, because I want to obscure the underlying value of the contributions, and then recognize their way so you can look at them or slices of pie and say, there's a million slices in our pie. So worth a million dollars, it's just not not related to one another. You can spend your wheels for six months and creating zero value and most companies do that. And what's what's valuable is your ability to negotiate your pre money valuation by showing customers and revenues and sales and things like that. So let's go back to our example. So we've raised a million dollars, and we are a lot of post money valuation is $1.9 million. We've been effects sold 53% of our company, we use that money to pay salaries and expenses and things like that. And now that person is part of our bet. So the bet pays off that person gets to this year too. So common question here is what's the preferable structure now LLC or C Corp Matt.
26:46An LLC allows us to implement the model as true as possible to the terms of the actual book slicing pie. C Corp is process possible, there are some issues that we have to navigate in, particularly Q SBS on but you know, both are possible LLC simpler, it's also going to be more preferable for your early stage companies that are on a really strict budget because a C Corp is usually a little bit more expensive. And I like LLC is because they often that's the point of analysis used to offer a lot of flexibility and how they allocate shares and losses and things like that. All right, one other thought on that it's really affordable and pretty easy to convert an LLC to a C Corp doing the opposite is much more difficult and expensive.
27:33Yeah, some people use C Corp and use siteadvisor besting mechanism. That being said, in every country I've worked with, they've all found solutions for this. And I'm always looking for attorneys who can come up with creative solutions. But literally all over the world is even a feisty play out in Iran. So even in Iran, they've created legal contracts that work in Iran, which is very different economy and culture. And so it always works. But so I'm always looking for ways to make this process easier. And you already mentioned it, but did you know how difficult it is to convert the C Corp process with an LLC.
28:11not difficult at all. converting an LLC to C Corp is relatively simple, it is a little bit of an expensive process. But generally speaking, when we get to that point, the teams are either pretty well capitalized or so have a round of fundraising. Right? They're doing it in anticipation. And in anticipation is important part, you don't want to convert your your slices to shares after the company's already had a round of funding. You want to do it beforehand when the share values essentially zero. Right. Now, can I ask and decisive like I'm gonna be an escort? No. The issue with US corporations is that that they require both the payment of a reasonable salary. And number two, we have to know exactly what the equity split is when we filed form 2553 with the IRS. So we always want these to be there if it's an individual just hiring you know, non member participants, disregarded entity, sole proprietorship or a partnership.
29:15Got it. So steer clear of s corpse. Correct. So when you implement slicing pie, you get a perfectly fair models, not based on guesses about future events. It's based on the actual facts of what happens. You're rewarding the actual contributions, people may ignore what they say they're going to do or hope they're going to do what you hope they're going to do. They're doing your own rewards, their actual contributions. It's providing ongoing motivation to stay involved. Unlike vesting, I can just wait wait, wait, wait to clock out and just quit whenever I want and just keep my shares invested. It's accommodating teach team changes. I showed you how to subtract somebody that somebody is placed ducks on the face of rapid change and no point you have to redraft our contracts in order to make this work. And it gets rid of the Gators no means fighting about equity splits. Now what I tell them was there are three reasons why you would not want to use slicing pie why someone will not want to use slicing pie. The first reason is, he or she just doesn't get it.
30:12It's been explained that kind of get the head around it. You know, the conventional wisdom is a hard thing to overcome in life. And I trust me, I've been in this for 10 years and breaking through the ice of traditional wisdom is always tough to crack. But if someone doesn't get it, there's plenty of resources online to figure it out. I've read a number of books about this one, the supply handbook is the most common one I suggest will work for PI's goes into more detail about compensation. It's been translated in languages all over the world. I offer software online, a calculator online that helps people calculate it's after all, you can do all this stuff for free. But there's optional tracking tools. There's Excel spreadsheets, there's lectures online, there's all kinds of there's even a slicing pie game. So my goal in life is to train the world and how this works. So people will see that that works. Once people get their head around how it works, it becomes just logical and obvious. Until that day dawns, they might struggle with it. The second reason they wouldn't want to do slicing pie is not willing to learn it. And this comes up a lot, he will say, people say I just want my 1%.
31:18And I don't want to bother with this new contract this new way of thinking. And that's fine. But I always recommend to steer clear people who aren't willing to learn new skills. And the third reason someone will not want to use this is because he or she does get it does not want to play fair. And unfortunately, this is kind of a popular thing that people who you know, angel investors, for instance, who can smell desperation, I always tell founders that if your deal is good, you'll find other options for investments, you have someone who doesn't want to play fair, just steer clear of them. For the most part, the biggest problem is people don't understand slicing pie. And once they get it, they'll see that it works. And in my experience, it always works. I've never seen a deal. I've seen 1000s I've seen by companies that have been formed a nursing a single deal that falls apart because of Slice the Pie as long as putting in place properly.
32:08But I hear all the time of people who fall apart because of their equity splits. In fact, a large majority will come to me find me after they are done a fixed equity split. And they use SICP to unwind directly with equities, but make it make it right. So that's the basic overview. I got some other questions, I want to go over with Matt, that they commonly come up in presentations like this. The first one is the long term or a solution for a company. As I said before, it goes from series A from concept to series A now once you've been your experience, people want to use this long term, long term is not a smart idea, right? Because the underlying company will end up developing some value and there could be significant tax consequences. Other common question that I get is whether or not this is a substitution for minimum wage, as every lawyer is watching this knowledge, it is not right. I think functionally, though, the biggest issue with using it's super long term, removing taxes and sort of liability concerns, right, because you can't have somebody working forever for free. And on the promise that they're gonna get paid someday, you know, one of the biggest limitations is really just going to be that the founders are going to get tired of tracking their time. And when I actually represent our firm represents several law firms, attorneys, etc. And the biggest thing we all laugh about when we implement this model for them is that we as attorneys generally log in our time. But if you're using for five years, and Mike and I
33:39are working on the same business, and it's profitable, it stops making sense for us to sit and track every single input that we put into the business. And what I tell people is you can track and whatever level of granularity you're comfortable with, so if you don't like talking about our or you can track by the week of the month, you know, most of us get paid every two weeks, whatever, you can just simply observe that check event, the check is full fair market value, there's no tracking if it's less than fair market value, you attract that check. So you're not shocked by our use checking the granular that makes sense for your business. And once you pass decisive pi phase once you pass a series a investment or past breakeven, your company becomes valuable and the underlying share price becomes the price you traded not slicing pie model. So if I give you $1,000 The shares worth $1,000 per share, I buy one share. So you can use that that the share value is the trading price. So this doesn't preempt you know, subsequent later, you know, stock option programs or equity grants to do officers out of the company raises money and indeed, series A investors often do reverse vesting and stock option pools and things like that. None of that goes away. Besides the five stops when that gets a vote all the founders to the the funding event and the break even event without killing each other So another question comes up is how to determine my fair market value. Fair market value isn't always obvious, but it usually is
35:10obvious. So you approach for fair market value. Like any negotiation, taking a job, you look at the salary and benefits usually, instead of the r&d benefits, because it's a startup, you look at the salary that you can make somewhere else, or what the job requirements are negotiating a fair market salary is much easier than negotiating the future events that may or may not happen. So always think about, you know, look, look at what your fair market value would be. If you're flipping hamburgers, you probably worth 15 bucks an hour, if you're a neurosurgeon, you might be worth 500 bucks. Now, if your company needs a hamburger flipper pay 15 bucks an hour don't pay neurosurgeon prices for flipping burgers. So just didn't negotiate like you would anything else. One thing that I often get comes across the table, as you know what if it's like a celebrity, or an advisor that has a big Rolodex? Well, they too have a fair market value, you got to determine what their fair market value is, what you would you pay them if you were paying them cash, you always approach it the same way. If I was paying for this contribution, what would I pay, and then you pay it if you can't pay us slices, because eventually, like you said that people aren't gonna work for free forever, eventually, they're gonna want to get paid, and they're gonna want to know what they're gonna get paid. So when you can start paying them, you start paying them.
36:25One quick comment on that. Over the years of doing this, we've been working with Mike basically, since day one. You know, the biggest thing about when you determine someone's fair market value is you don't want to allow one participant to calculate theirs based on say what their actual going rate is. So if you're a lawyer, you make $500 an hour, that's going to be your hourly rate. If you're going to add other people, and you're going to say, Okay, well, you're located out of the country, we're going to use payscale.com, to figure out what that software engineers hourly rate is, in a given jurisdiction, everything should be normalized. The goal here in this model is fairness. We don't want anybody gaming the system. And the only thing that matters when you're determining fair market values, is making sure that the way you arrive at that fair market value is the same for everybody.
37:21So just to clarify that. If someone's working on a country, and they're good, they get five bucks an hour, we're the same person in San Francisco might get 25 bucks an hour, are you suggesting to us 25 bucks an hour or five bucks? No, I would go with a $25 an hour because it should go by what their market rate would be in the location where they would be working. On the contrary, if everybody on the team is going by wherever they're geographically located, and lawyers will know this term, right? You get to a meeting of the minds where everybody agrees that that's acceptable. It's all subjective. Yes, but you all know, my my my advice always is determine what you would pay if you were going to pay cash. And sometimes, you know, you do find people that have pretty big disparity with similar similar skill sets. And the reason you go overseas offices is to save money. That's the point of going overseas. One thing I find is, let's say you do a $500 an hour lawyer that's willing to work under the slicing pie rules that most lawyers don't use usually work for equity, but some do. Well, let's say you have a 500 hour an hour consultant. If that's the only resources available to you, you use that resource. If you find a resource that's less expensive, you can fire that person for no good reason they would keep their sizes and hire somebody else at a lower rate. There's no hard feelings, they're keeping their bed on the table, just say found a replacement for a better rake. So you're always going to be making decisions, good financial decisions
39:00based on your company. So if you're if you find a better source somewhere else, it's a no problem to to trade it off for for lower cost if you find that resource. And that's just good business. So but you do you want to make sure that you're negotiating salaries that will be paid if they were paid. Another question I get is what do investors to get slicing pie? This is a common question. People are going to think gosh, are they going to be turned off by the flexibility of the model? In my experience, slicing pie and then to do with investors because investors come with a price round all they want to see is a clean conflict free cap table, which is exactly what slides to my delivers. So you don't have to involve investors. decision in the discussion, they might ask how you got your cap table and you can tell them but it doesn't really affect them going forward.
39:48There's basically three types of investors that I break it down for people one are contributors to your company who are putting personal things at risk, time and money and materials and things. Those are grunts in your pie. They use slicing pie. The second type are people who invest their own money in amounts that are too small to fund your operation, which I call angel investors, they should always get a convertible note or safe note, which we'll learn which would be state outstanding until sizes by terminates the third type of investor, professional investors who invest other people's money in amounts that are larger than your operation, which are called VCS and they get the price round. Have you had any pushback from investors, man?
40:26In the beginning, you know, about nine years ago, I can say confidently No, you know, we've done 1000s of these slicing pie agreements, once the investors understand what they're looking at, they actually when you go through the due diligence process, prefer it to a standard sort of cap table tracking system, right? Because what happens is, we're able to go in very nuanced and see who did what, when and why they're on the cap table. Instead of seeing, you know, that mat me I'm on the cap table for 5%. And they see like a Legal Zoom operating agreement, like, Well, that's all he did to earn that how do we buy him out? How do we get rid of this guy, right? Whereas with slicing pie, it is very detailed as to who did what and when they did it, and what really what the value was.
41:12And that is one a nice byproducts of tracking. So you can see who's who is very rarely what are called Dead equity on a slice of pie cap table. Because you don't have disgruntled employees that have left everyone leaves for reasonable if they've left it, the treatment is reasonable. And I wanted to state a little bit earlier out of the 1000s of agreements that we've done using any permutation or variation of this model, we have had zero instances of arbitration mediation litigation, 99.999, continuing decimal percent of the time, we're able to meet with the teams and come to amicably come to a resolution with no problem.
41:53Yeah, and I'll share a personal experience years ago, before I embedded in slicing pie, I did a similar model for one of my startups wasn't the same, but it's very similar. And I had an employee show up for stop coming to work. I showed up for two weeks, and then just stop showing up for work. And then he sent me a bill for $8,000. And I didn't pay him good and having $1,000 spam, and he took it to you sued me through state of Illinois, to collect that those wages and went to an arbitrator. And she looked at the plan over for 10 minutes, she said this is clear what it says and I was off the hook for it.
42:26Because we had agreed that you wouldn't get paid if you quit under the circumstances. So that's the only time I've ever personally tested anything like slicing by an arbitration. You know, if you go to a to a judge with with logic on how things were changed in logic guy, you can't do it. In my opinion, there's no reason they wouldn't see the formula making sense. Most of the time, you're just arguing and most, you know, who did what, and pointing the finger to one another. And there's movies about this kind of disagreement. So ideas get pretty stressful but dicey by should, should help you navigate the split. Another question I get a lot is how to get buy in from others.
43:07You know, there's a lot of free tools online. How do you get buy in from others? Did you struggle with this with your practice? Not too bad, everyone, we're dealing with one right now actually, generally speaking, the folks who are reluctant to buy in are probably not going to be people that you would want to work with even on a static equity split. The goal is to be rest invest from those folks, and really overvaluing right, what they're gonna do. I mean, when you read the book, and you look over any sort of legal agreement that would implement the model, it's as fair as it can possibly get. If somebody loves him like that, you need to ask your client whether or not it's a good idea to work with that person. And it comes down to this, those three reasons either don't get it, they don't want to learn it, or they want take advantage of you. And so, I have quick 10 Page guides, five page guide, one page on site supply, anytime you have struggled this, people can come to me or and plenty of resources online to get it. This is a common question. Does this mean someone can pad their hours to get more slices? This is a great question because it shows the the Unbreak ability of slicing pie. If you have an employee who comes in and starts saying hey, all I do is add hours to my to my my timesheet, and I can give him free equity. Well, they can go of course do that. But when you notice they're doing that you will give them a warning for taking too long to do certain tasks. Let's say that a
44:40designer took 65 hours to design a logo. You might say, Gosh, that seems kind of high. You need to do this quicker. And if you footbed do better management and so they do it again. That'd be warning too and then we get fired for not being effective on the job. So spy spy always has a catch for those kinds. One thing so people can't gain the system without risking getting fired. So just be like, if someone lied on their their real time card or their real expense report, you can, you can certainly lie on your expense report. But if you get caught, you'll get get fired. So people can try to have their hours but it'd be grounds for dismissal if they did. Have you ever had this experience at all? Man?
45:18Shockingly, no, we have not had anybody pad their hours or you know, lie about contributions or anything like that, which is very surprising. One thing, though, is that this does get gamified. Right. So you may have a founder who goes in and you know, hire somebody in a, they got their team going, and I have had calls where they're like, Hey, we didn't put like, all the maximum amount of time that somebody can put into this per week. And so and so is working, you know, nonstop. And I don't really know if the business needs that. So you know, through through well drafted contracts, you can prevent these sorts of issues. And the same question, by the way, comes up with cash, I don't know if that's going to come up later. But you know, this doesn't replace good management, if you have someone that's you know, shooting from the hip and not going off on tangents and doing work is unnecessary.
46:08That's a management issue. It's almost like a supply issue. If you don't, you know, set parameters for expenses and approvals for expenses. That's a management issue. It's not a slicing pie issue. So nothing replaces good management. So you still have to manage your employees and see what they're doing and monitor what's going on just like you would if you're paying in cash. Now, the question that I kind of get a lot is What if I already have a fixed split agreement with my partners, this is very common people come to me and say, you know, I got into business with a partner, he's not doing any work, or she's slacking off. What do I do? This is very common. I've been I do 1000s of phone calls every year, this type of person. And you can use slicing pie to what I call it, do a retrofit, which is to go back in time and recalculate where the share should be and then just make adjustments going forward. Do you this college is very common in your practice, all the time. Now, once someone is faced with what the reality of fairness is, in my experience, they rarely argue whether this is a yes, I see that I have too much. What I say is if you have fixed that agreement, and someone has more than they deserve, it doesn't make it fair just because the legal right to be a jerk. And sometimes they'll be jerks. And you got to deal with it precisely if I can help you unwind to do prevent that. What if my advisor doesn't want to track his or her hours. So just like I said, before, Matt, no one likes
47:36to do track hours, I don't want to track hours later, just like tracking hours. And you don't have to track hours, you can track you know, weekly or bi weekly or monthly, whatever the payment that makes sense for you would be with advisors, advisors is often this kind of default setting, which I'll get an advisor or advisory board, I'll give them each point 5%. And this is a rule of thumb out there you have revisers, just a mini employee. And you should treat them just like everybody else. And basically, what I always recommend is with an advisor or even a board of directors, for instance, give them a monthly retainer doesn't say $2,000, say you're worth 200 bucks an hour, I'll call you 10 hours a month, that's $2,000 a month. And every month that goes by you're not tracking hours, you just get a $2,000 retainer, if I'm getting value out of your relationship, or we'll stick with it or not, we won't. So you can you can negotiate anything that makes sense for that relationships. You know, like for instance, a celebrity may not track hours and advisement may not track hours, different things, it comes in different ways. He's got to be sensitive to how they're, how they're compensated. How much of my idea worth is, is a common thing. I always tell people that ideas by themselves are not worth much, they're usually worth zero. If the idea was developed on the job, meaning your time you spent on the job was developing the news worth your time. So for this, I used to be the head of marketing for a company called planing. Now that makes fishing tackle boxes.
49:11It was my job as vice president of marketing, they have great ideas for new products. So I invented new products for them. That was me just doing my job so I don't get royalties on those ideas. I just get my salary. Now if I hadn't invented products before I joined the company and I want to call fix them in space and you know trademark copyright patents is trade secrets. And I brought that idea to them I might be able to negotiate a royalty and that royalty can be paid in cash when sales happen or can be paid in slices of the cash isn't available. So ideas are only worth that can be traded on the on the fair market.
49:47So if you want to work to know how much it is worth, go out and try to sell to somebody. If you can't sell it, it's either worthless or it's priceless. It's probably worthless. So everything has a fair market price. You just got to determine what that is. Do you? Have you ever had any conflicts over ID value? That not too bad, right? Once you explain the model to folks, I mean, if it's not a patent that's already registered or anything like that, we usually don't have that much of an issue. On as everybody knows the name of the game is execution, right? It's easy to convince clients. Another common question is, how do you maintain control? What do you tell people that want to maintain control, man, I mean, that's a tough one, usually, we would do it through maybe separate classes of individuals worked into the agreements, through drafting customs, traffic, group drafting of the agreements, where the manager has certain control, etc. There are multiple ways to handle voting, which is kind of handled on a case by case basis with each each client, but we can always address it right. Just at the end of the day, though, if somebody controls, you know, puts in the effort at a time and ends up controlling, you know, 90% of the cap table, you're probably going to lose some control there, right?
51:06Naturally, yeah, that's what I try to do is just talk people down from that tree, it's, you know, maintaining control means putting the effort forward, and then taking the risks necessary. If you have to contractually maintain control or consolidate control, that becomes more problematic. And if your decisions are made by vote during the bootstrap stage, you're probably not very cohesive team in the first place. So if you think about it, you think it through sort of objectively, even the person who has the most slices should be able to be fired. Because if that person is not performing as expected, the other team members should be able to get rid of that person. And I've actually had experience with this where we're founder got fired from their own team. And the team members went on to create a great company, and the co founder was that he was upset at first the founder, but he wouldn't join a new company. And they did a similar idea, and they flourished. So being fired even as a as a controlling interest holder, could be a possibility. And you always gotta remember, no matter what happens, you're always protected. So if you're like, oh, for no reason, you still maintain your shares. Your risk and reward are always perfectly in balance. But of course, I tell people, if there really is an issue for them, they can legally consolidate control in different ways. Which book should I buy? So there's a number of books out there is a lawyer, you've got a copy the book for free, I'll send it to you. I'm happy to share it with you and all the materials you need.
52:31But the slicing pie handbook is the one that I most commonly promote. It's newer than the slicing pie, original slicing pie book and just explained better. My most recent book is called will work for pie and it goes into more detail about how to pay advisors how to determine fair market values, how to pay salespeople, for instance, how to put together their bonus program. So covers a little bit of slice of pie, and more in depth for slices going beyond how to pay people and how to get more help. I'm always available to help people as much as I can. I'm build on my phone, through my website and emails that go through website will trickle up to me if they need to. It's my mission in life to make sure everyone knows how this works. And I'm sure Matt, you help a lot of lawyers too, right?
53:14Absolutely. Tons of law firms, lawyers, etc. We do offer you know, affordable packages, etc to help out lawyers and the good thing is once you learn this once, generally you could scale your practice with it. Yeah, so you can use over and over again because it works for every every type of startup no matter what it is, no matter where it is, no matter what kind of tech what they're doing. It always works no matter what. I even had someone do a prenuptial agreement using slicing pie. It's always fair. So thank you very much for watching. I really appreciate it please reach out to me or Matt if you have any questions or comments or concerns or spiritual observations, I'm happy to talk to you about how it works and I hope you can use this in your practice and, and and eliminate founder disputes forever.
Richard Brian G.NY
Very interesting.
Chelsea S.NY
Really well done CLE. Informative and interesting.
Charles F.OH
Best CLE I have watched.
Matthew K.AZ
The most interesting video I've watched on LexVid.