Alexander C.NY
This is an excellent course. There was lots of useful information. Thank you very much
1h 6min · about 8,500 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Evan Stewart. I'm a partner Cohen and Gresser here in Manhattan. So my presentation today is dealing with internal investigations, The Good, the Bad, and the ugly of that subject. And this is a very important subject, because lawyers often get involved in in corporate investigations. And oftentimes, they've not gotten gone so well. So knowing how to do these right, and to avoid the problems that some people have fallen into. It's, we're going to go into some detail on that today. So what are the goods of investigations? There, in fact, many reasons for doing internal investigation for public companies include, to find out what the facts are so that you and your client can make informed legal and business decisions. The seminal case in the Supreme Court of John versus the United States, really is a touchstone of this, as many important lessons that can be learned on how to do this right. But that's sort of the godfather of internal investigations from an illegal legal opinion.
1:16Also to fulfill obligations or responsibilities and duties of care to the corporation. This mid versus working case sort of lays that point out. There's a New York City Bar Association opinion and probably about five years ago, that says, there's actually an ethical duty to do these investigations. To find out whether client has done something wrong. Then another reason to do investigations is to avoid the risks of doing nothing. The Salomon Brothers case where the firm essentially blew up because they didn't do an internal investigation certainly makes that point pretty clear. Now the reason to do with them is to be able if an investigation uncovers mistakes, wrongdoings, and worse, to take corrective action, to both address past conduct, but also with respect to prophylactic action. Another reason to do them is to buy again, hopefully, the public can accompany some goodwill and or leniency by self reporting to government, governmental or regulatory agencies. Now, the reason is to get ahead of the public relations curve. And another very important reason is to hopefully shore up the company's stock price. But their bads to investigations just like they're always goods, there's some Bad's, there's a so called silver platter doctrine. When you pull together all these facts, oftentimes you make them available to regulators. Well, that then, is a silver platter to the private plaintiffs who will invariably wait in line soon your client after the after, after the commencement of the government's
3:07investigation or after the completion of the government's investigation. So they're doing these you have to be very careful about what it is you actually put down in writing, and especially what it is you give to the government. Then there's the issue about giving stuff to the government. In various iterations of memos by Deputy Attorney General's name Thompson, McNulty gates, where the government has set forth the Justice Department set forth, what is deemed to be cooperative activity, or behavior by private public companies. are you expected to give over all your work papers of the investigation, breach attorney client privilege, etc. Some people had thought that I don't actually give any report or work papers. I can just give the SEC or the Justice Department an oral download of the investigation. J. Stein in Florida six years ago, the Herrera case that didn't work so well. So be very careful about what orally download to the government. The Selective waiver work. In other words, can you selectively waive privilege materials to the government and then attempt to prevent private plaintiffs from getting? The answer is in the Eighth Circuit? Yes. Everywhere else? No. So unless your client is going to be sued in the Eighth Circuit, that does not work. And it's very important from a legal standpoint, and from your own relationship with your client, that your client understands the implications of handing over an internal investigation or the work papers there. Or whatever it is you gonna hand over
5:00the government, because of the silver platter doctrine, you're really going to be paying for their clients green paying twice. You're not resolving everything. When you resolve things with the government, you have a second sector, right? When you resolve things with the private plaintiffs, for the client really needs to understand when you're trying to resolve things with the government, that there's a second act to follow with the private plaintiffs. Then another bad investigations is have some disclosure obligations with respect to these investigations in your SEC filings. And I'll come back to that with a real life example a little bit later. Then, of course, there are risks to the corporate personality individuals at your client. When you do one of these things, you're increasing the risks to them personally suspected criminal, regulatory, civil, and of course, reputational issues. Then there's the issue about disclosure of the investigation to auditors. Auditors are very, very interested to put it mildly, in these investigations, and lawyers need to understand that there's a difference about what you share with regulators. Sorry, if you share it with your auditors, if you share with your auditors, your company's auditors, your attorney client privilege materials, that's a waiver of the privilege. However, if you share your attorney work product materials, with your auditors become these auditors. That is not a waiver. So be very selective as to what you're showing the auditors you can show them
6:55your attorney work product materials, but you can't show them privileged materials, whether that's a waiver. And then there's a failure to disclose to auditors, which is highlighted in a case just a couple of years ago, and evolving General Motors, General Motors took a huge hit when they failed to disclose certain issues from internal investigation to their auditors. And the flip side of what some of the goods of investigations and when you do one of these investigations, it can often have a very adverse impact to the public relations from the client and the stock price. another bout of investigations is what is often called the bloodhound factor. And Enron is a classic example of this. When you do an investigation, you have to tell the client that you are going to follow the facts wherever they lead. In other words, you can't take a directive from the client, only look at x. And once you've looked at x, look at nothing more. You can't take
8:08any barriers or any restrictions on your ability to follow where the facts lead you. If if that guidance is given to you, a you really have to not take on the representation. Or if the client says I only want to spend 50,000 or $100,000, during this investigation, you probably shouldn't define because that investigations I can be worth the paper it's written on number one. But also you're gonna run the risk that Enron ran, which didn't didn't follow where the facts lead. And of course, that led to the destruction of the company, terrible impact to lawyers, and others involved including the auditor. So that's something that the client has to understand, has to go forward. And then as I mentioned earlier, the whole issue about what do you create? What don't you keep? These are very important issues, ethical rules about 3.4 A very important for understanding what it is you can create. Because, again, the government's gonna probably want to see that private players are gonna want to see it. You've got to be very careful with restricted privilege and work product materials here. And then with destroying documents, be very careful that again, the Enron case is a classic example that that did not end well, for the lawyers that were involved in that. Then there's the issue about the loss of confidentiality. There have been some prominent cases where investigations have been done undertaken and there have been leaks in the media. And CBS movies case is a classic example of that where there's huge reputational damage to the
10:13law firms and lawyers involved. And in fact, later found out that one of the lawyers at one of the two firms that was doing the investigation, had they uncovered who the lawyer was who leaked, and she has lost her law license. So huge, not just reputational damage, but career damage. If that takes place, then there's the additional litigation risk, where the individuals affected by the investigation may turn around and bring libel suits or wrongful discharge cases. Again, the CVS moonbeams case as an example of that. And then, if lawyers don't handle these investigations, that can sometimes lead to the settlement with the government being torn up, because they government finds out later that they were lying on what the lawyers did. In that did not turn out to be in the government side is completely accurate. And that, of course, has huge reputational damage to the lawyers when that happens. And this recently happened in a case involving Ericsson SA. Then the uglies investigations. If the bads weren't bad enough, then they're the ugliest. The first is the so called Corporate Miranda warning. What are these?
11:46These are sometimes miss properly, called Upjohn warnings. I mentioned the Upjohn warning before. People who call them that really don't understand what they're talking about. An Upjohn warning up, John is a case, as I mentioned before, a similar decision by the Supreme Court. That said for purposes of an internal investigation, generally purposes, individuals are covered by the corporate attorney privilege. This is something very different. This is a obligation that arises under the ethics rules, ethics rule 1.13. And this is a duty to advise individuals, when you're doing an investigation, that the corporate attorney client privilege belongs to the company. And while their conversations with you are privileged, under the company's attorney, client privilege, the company has the discretion at some point, at any point in the future, to waive that privilege with respect to what the individual is telling the lawyer, the company's lawyer. And of course, that can be a pretty chilling thing to do. And it's a lot of lawyers don't haven't handled this exam, this ethical obligation very well, I've given you three exams of the rule case that quite matter involving Mr. Quite thrown, the Stanford financial. Penn State and other case where it's not handled well. When you're representing a company, oftentimes, you are in this odd situation where individually the general counsel or the CEO they're looking to you is to be their lawyer, but your job is to tell them, actually, I'm not your lawyer. And under certain circumstances, you really need
13:59to be aware of that. So question is, when do you have to give this morning? And the answer to that is depends on what state you're in? Because different states have different standards. States that follow the American Bar Association, rule 1.13 have to give this warning. At the point, when it is clear that the interests of the individual are different than that of the company, lawyers in New York state. On the other hand, you have to give this warning when it appears that the individual's interests may differ from that of the companies. So obviously, from a time standpoint, this warning has to be given much earlier in an investigation than states like Delaware, for example that follow you ABS model. So real world implications again, lawyers in rule case Blacktron case the Stanford financial ends and state case. All have had very significant career setbacks, put it mildly, for not handling this. One, one important practical tip is, it would be useful to have some written documentation in the form of an interview memo or some other
15:33written memorialization, this warning is actually been given, because this comes a point of some contention later, whether this is this warning was given or not. And to be able to point to the person sign this document saying they got the warning for my associates put up an interview memo that memorialized that I gave a warning that goes a long way to proving that you gave this warning. Another terrible ugly about this is this computer associates real life case to case where a prominent firm in Manhattan here was doing an investigation for computer associates. And it made clear that the roots of the investigation will be handed over to the government that was bootstrapped into the lawyers being made, considered to be agents of the government for purposes of these discussions with individuals and computer associates. So when it was determined that some of the individuals that computer associates had not been truthful, to the private lawyers representing computer associates, those lawyers were deemed to be essentially deputized agents of the federal government. And so for purposes of 18 USC 1001, which says anyone who makes a material lie to an agent of the government, or government official, these people were prosecuted and found guilty of lying to the government for having discussions with private lawyers. I don't think that's a quick statement of law. But those people are now judged to be criminals, who've had these discussions with private lawyers. So it can be very dangerous, tricky situations. Lastly,
17:40I'll highlight is internal investigations and advocacy. A lot of lawyers treat these investigations as advocates, and interact with regulators in social and civil litigation, as if, when they're doing these investigations. They were zealously representing the interests of the client in trying to defeat claims by the government or others. This has real dangers to lawyers, because regulators really don't like it. And some have, and some very adverse situations where lawyers have paid millions and millions of dollars, because they've been advocates, during the course of these investigations, not nearly objective seekers of the truth. And then their clients dangerous to clients, where lawyers have tried to use the investigation to their benefit with respect to regulators, but then to shield themselves in their work product and their privileged materials in the private plaintiffs. And that's so called sword in the shield approach, has not found a very favorable reaction in the courts. The Kidder Peabody not heard from several years ago, classic example that and then lastly, sometimes the government really doesn't like these investigations to examples of the world calm and marsh and McLennan where the government just did not believe the law firms in the lawyers involved. Really, truly objective, objective facts seekers, but we're really trying to position the client. Those are three different ways to look at these investigations. Now, I'd like to highlight some recent investigations as they've been
19:56reviewed by the courts. In this go over three important decisions I think it will be of use to all of you. I frequently caution, litigating attorney client privilege and work product issues is tricky enough. When you handle the process correctly, handling the process incorrectly then expecting the court to do somersaults to miss apply the law to help you and your client out of some self imposed jam is likely to be asking too much. And these three decisions that I'm going to review now should should highlight that point, I think pretty well. In 2016, the SEC sued RPM International and a general counsel in federal court in the district Columbia for failing to accrue and disclose properly for a DOJ a False Claims Act investigation. Six years earlier in 2010, an individual had filed a sealed return complaint against rpm. In March of 2011, the Department of Justice told RPM about the complaint, and sent along a copy of it and advise the company to treat the matter confidentially out confidentially. Over the course of the next year, RPM attempted to resolve the matter with the Justice Department in January of 2013 RPM offered $28.3 million to settle. Two months later, DOJ countered with $71 million on April 1 2013 RPM for the first time recorded on its books, a contingency Reserve of $68.8 million to cover the matter. In three days later, RPM disclosed publicly the Justice investigation in the company's financial group on January 27 2014. The SEC informed our pm that it had begun an investigation into the timing of RPMs accrual and
22:05disclosure. Until July of that same year, the company's outside auditor Ernst and Young informed RPM that it would not sign off on an upcoming 10k audit committee hired an independent law firm to investigate the matter. As a result, the committee hired Jones Day, which then proceeded to conduct 19 interviews of in house and outside lawyers, RPM executives, and three Ernst and Young auditors. On August 10 2014, Jones Day made an oral presentation of his findings and conclusions to Ernst and Young. Thereafter, the lead Ernst and Young partner prepared a written memo summarizing Jones day's presentation. Jones Day also provided updates to against neon over the course of its investigation. And that same Ernst and Young partner wrote memoranda on those updates. In addition, Jones Day lawyers prepared 19 memoranda 19 draft memoranda, covering the interviews. On August 21, Jones Day provided to the SEC an oral summary of its investigation subjected to a non waiver agreement. Later in 2014, Ernst and Young in response to an SEC document request, produced among other things, lead partners memoranda reflecting Jones days presentations before they were sent to the SEC. RPM reviewed those documents, and requested limited redactions. It did not object to Ernst and Young producing the materials. More than four years later, as the SEC was about to conclude, discovery in federal court, commissioned demanded disclosure of the Jones Day interview memoranda. RPM resisted citing attorney client privilege and work product.
24:05On February 12 2020, Judge Amy Berman granted the SEC has motion to compel. With respect to the work product argument, Judge Berman rejected on two separate grounds. First, the memoranda were not prepared, both because of litigation. Rather, they were part of the effort to satisfy Ernst and Young in order to get an approved 10k. Second, the documents did not constitute opinion, work product, because they were completely devoid of legal opinions, thoughts or mental impressions, and, quote, contained no analysis whatsoever, close quote. As to any company claim attorney client privilege, the judge ruled the RPM and waive the privilege by orally sharing the contents of the memoranda with a third party.
24:58Judge Berman in my view, got it right. The hiring of Jones Day by the audit committee had no contemporaneous recordings of litigation, anticipated or otherwise, having anything to do with the law firms mandate. That was a big mistake. An interview memos by lawyers that are nearly verbatim recounting of what wins witnesses said are by definition, not opinion work product. Another big mistake as far as waiver by Jones Day disclosing actual witness statements and quotes to Ernst and Young Lawyers need to remember that this is an area where there's a key difference. I've mentioned this before, between privilege and work product. Lawyers can share work products with third parties like accountants working in unison with we're under the direction of lawyers that sharing client competences with the same third parties kill the privilege. And of course, here RPM went one waiver bridge further, it approved the Ernst and Young documents with the privilege quotes going over to the SEC. All I can say to that is Yikes.
26:14Second, relatively recent opinion, will be helpful to cover the case involving floor international 2017 floor instituted an internal investigation growing out of the conduct of an employee perspective military related contracts in Afghanistan. The matter was handled by inside counsel and ultimately led to the one the employee being terminated and to the company reporting the investigations findings to the government, as is required when a governmental contractor has quote, credible evidence, close quote, that certain federal laws have been violated, including the False Claims Act. Employee thereafter brought suit against Florida in federal court asserting multiple claims, including wrongful termination, defamation, and negligence, resulting from floors investigation and disclosure thereof to the government. The employee sought floors, investigatory files and discovery, which the company resisted citing attorney client privilege and work product. The magistrate cited wood floor, but the federal judge disagreed. The judge ruled that four statements in the disclosure made to the government revealed, quote, legal conclusions which characterize the employee's conduct in a way that reveals attorney client communications was as a result, there had been a waiver of the privilege as to those statements. Other communications on the same matters, as well as factual work product relating to, with disclosure mandated by the court floor brought on a petition for a writ of mandamus to the Fourth Circuit on March
28:012 2020. That petition was granted on March 13. The appellate court ruled on March 25, in an unpublished opinion. From a procedural standpoint, this is a troubling from problematic ruling. The Fourth Circuit clearly in Bolden by a demonstrably wrongly decided set of earlier decisions by the DC Circuit, which I'll get to later, when against directly on point precedent by the Supreme Court in granting the writ of mandamus. As the Supreme Court has made crystal clear, I thought anyway, but an interlocutory appeal is not available, and attorney attorney client privilege cases. Say that again, an interlocutory appeal is not available in attorney client privilege cases.
28:57The only mechanism to take an attorney client ruling on appeal is to take a contempt citation. law that is crystal clear, but even come back to that when we get to the DC Circuit decisions and the assumption inside decision bears better. The district court focused on four statements as constituting a waiver. One, the plaintiff both appears to have inappropriately assisted was clearly to quote Florida considers that a violation close quote three, the plaintiff quote, use his position to pursue improper opportunities and obtain an improperly disclosed nonpublic information, close quote and floorplan for floor estimates that there may have been a financial impact as a result of improper conduct was according to the district judge, because those four statements were conclusions which only a lawyer is qualified to make those work. They revealed privilege communications, and thereby the privilege had been waived. The circuit found that determination to be clear error ruling, both the fact that floors disclosure cover the same topic as the internal investigation, or that it was made pursuant to the advice of counsel, excuse me, doesn't mean that privileged communications themselves were disclosed because that was a correct determination of privilege law. The Fourth Circuit also rejected the district courts Imagine if argument regarding quote, legal conclusions that only a lawyer could make close quote. That is not the not the standard whether a waiver has occurred. Rather, to find waiver, quote, a court must conclude
30:55that there has been disclosure of protected communications close quote, A.
31:06Third case I'd like to talk about is the San Mina case in the ninth circuit. This litigation arose from a $503 million stock to duck and claim made by San Marino, a claim that was challenged by the IRS in support of its claim, San Mina had provided the tax agency with a evaluation report prepared by a law firm DLA Piper at the time at the time that deduction was asserted in the DLA Piper report, there was a footnote referencing to memoranda, prepared by the company's in house tax counsel, without revealing the contents of those documents. And DLA Piper representative had relied upon the in house counsels work in reaching its conclusions. San Mina also share the in house counsels documents with two accounting firms, both of which have weighed in on the deduction. Not surprisingly, the IRS demanded that the in house documents be turned over. Equally not surprising, San Mina refused, citing privilege and work product. After an in camera review, the district court found the memoranda were privilege and work product, but rejected San meanness arguments for confidentiality. Finding the waiver by the company's conduct in sharing the documents with DLA Piper. The district court as an alternative justification for its ruling found the DLA Piper report that reports citation to and reliance upon the documents constituted a waiver under the quote fairness close quote, considerations under rope underlying Rule five of underlying section 502 of the Federal Rules of Evidence. On appeal to the ninth circuit, that Court
33:09affirmed the lower court in part and reversed in part, finding a waiver of the privilege but not a waiver of work product. To as to privilege the Ninth Circuit ruled that DLA Piper had not been retained for purposes of getting legal assistance, and thus the law firm should be deemed a third party with any privileged information conveyed there too, as being waived. According to the Daily bring the Ninth Circuit DLA Piper's role was to prepare non legal valuation analysis. And the presumption that a high a person hires a lawyer or legal advice is rebutted when the lawyer is, quote, employed without reference to his knowledge and descript minimal law post quote, notwithstanding substantial evidence in the record that San Mina and its law firm, DLA Piper, obviously thought they had a client attorney relationship. The Ninth Circuit differed to the district court's determination that the DLA Piper's role or purpose was non legal binding the determination was not quote, clearly erroneous, because it was not, quote, logical, implausible or without support in the record post. Admittedly, the retention agreement and DLA Piper's report could have been better written to address this issue, especially given the obvious likelihood of the IRS is unfavorable reaction to the report and to Sam mean as deduction. But this ends oriented opposite ends oriented outcomes, of course, with well established privilege law. Moreover, clearly, moreover, clearly sharing really, the sharing of the in house memo with the two accounting firms did constitute a
34:58waiver of the privilege but for some reason that evident, self imposed blunder by sand Mina went without mentioned. With respect to work product, the Ninth Circuit got to the right result by a extremely curious route. First off, the court looked at whether there's further disclosure the in house documents to the companies law firm, DLA Piper constituted, quote, disclosure to an adversary was quote, while I concluded it did not. We require the court even went there. Indeed, the Court acknowledged that the IRS was not contending that there was such an internship report next discuss whether there was an attempt to selectively disclose to DLA Piper but not the government, but then deflected that issue. By amusing that obviously San Mina intended for DLA Piper to assist the company in its anticipate anticipated litigation with the IRS, thereby undermining the courts earlier quote, analysis, close quote, of the law firms role or purpose in the privilege as a final matter, the Ninth Circuit turned to whether giving the IRS the DLA Piper report with a footnote reference to in house memoranda created a subject matter waiver visa vie those two documents. This part of the decision was primarily addressing the lower courts alternative concern about quote, fairness, close quote. Ultimately, because the IRS based upon the same facts that San Mina and DLA Piper possessed, could reach its own conclusions regarding the claim deduction. There was no basis for providing the mental impressions, conclusions, opinions
36:44or legal theories of Sammy as in House lawyers, as such fairness only mandated the production of those portions of the in house documents with factual non opinion of work product. These three decisions demonstrate the principle concerns expressed when I started out on this subject. Lawyers still do not always correctly handle privilege and work product issues. And certainly, neither dashboards, so be careful with this. Now, importantly, how we deal with investigations here in America. We talked about the Seminole decision about Upjohn. giving you three examples of how lawyers not really followed it too well in this country sometimes. But the rules in Europe are very, very different, very different. And these two decisions, the RBS rights decision, and the ESA SFO decision from 2016 and 2017. really point out that thinking isn't apply. And think that privilege and work product are going to be protected by the EU, certainly by the English boards, you're going to be very, very unhappy and find that they have very different news under the so called legal advice, privilege standard, their workpapers standard. And just a very different way of looking at the world.
38:37Court has moved a little bit better in England on the litigation privilege. But English as I say English standards on legal advice, privilege and work papers privilege are really in direct conflict with American standards. So lawyers need to be very careful about how an investigation is structured. Involve multinational companies, where the investigation where the investigation was place, and who controls those work papers? Are they control of American lawyers on American soil in the London office of American law firm, where are those documents can be located. Because we have so many other things to get to. Let me just say, these matters are dealt with in greater detail. An article I wrote in the New York Business Law Journal, December 2017, Mad Dogs and Englishmen part and do which you can find on my law firms website. Now, now, we come to
39:43these two district DC circuit opinions, which I referenced earlier, which constitute almost seminal things on how not to do like corporate investigation. These are two to two decisions involving the same company, Kellogg, brown and root. And you see that the two sides take the four citations to District Court opinions and do further appeals decisions. This is really an amazing, amazing
40:27everything that could go wrong went wrong here. So, this litigation arose out of allegations the major defense contractors employees are given preferential treatment to a subcontract or exchange for bribes. Prior to the litigation, and on its own initiative, defense contractor employing its Code of Business Conduct those code protocols, in SP initiated an internal investigation. Critically and unfortunately, this was an investigation conducted by non lawyers. Those non lawyer employees interviewed personnel with potential knowledge of the allegations, review documents and obtain witness statements. on completing their investigation, the non lawyers wrote up seven reports, which were then forwarded to defense contractors internal legal department.
41:26Thereafter in subsequent CUI Tom litigation, the plaintiff sought seven reports in discovery. Kellogg, brown and root cited the attorney client privilege and work product doctrine, posing them upon a motion to compel the district court conducted an in camera review of the materials and then held neither position held water. The district court and its ruling here got one right and got one wrong. As to the work product argument, the district court observed both one that the investigation was conducted by non lawyers not at the direction of counsel and to investigation was not undertaken in anticipation of litigation. That analysis was clearly correct, and proved to be not controversial. And the attorney client privileges you, the district court ruled that a party invoking the privilege must show that a party invoking must show that the communication would not have been made. But for that the legal advice was sought. Saying citing Defense Department of requirements of self disclosure of improper conduct, the court found that the Butch four standard and not been met. The court also noted that the employees were interviewed, were never informed that the purpose of the interview was to assist the defense contractor in obtaining legal advice to that the employees certainly would not have been able to infer the legal of the legal nature of the inquiry by virtue of the fact that the interviewers were non lawyers. defense contractor, Kellogg Brown and root was extremely unhappy with that ladder ruling and asked for the district
43:21court for an interlocutory appeal on the privilege issue. Only on the on the privilege issue did not seek mandamus. On the court product issue. Very important point. Court rejected that. Then petition the DC circuit for mandamus on the attorney client privilege issue, and the district court, DC Circuit Court granted that rip. Obviously, the grant of mandamus was a sure sign that district courts privilege ruling was not long for the rule. We're long for the world, but with a dis DC circuit get it right. But the DC Circuit got one thing, right. I have things wrong.
44:22Fact, one of the reasons that they got all this wrong was the DC circuit's view that the lower court's opinion had the potential to, quote, disable most public companies from undertaking confidential internal investigations. That was with Molly gross overstatement. But it also said that the rule is so misunderstood and misinterpreted the Upjohn decision. The lower court's decision, quote, threatened to vastly diminished the attorney client privilege and the business setting was Not only those dire consequences not well founded, but the mystery of the DC circuit's analysis and justifying reversal was completely wide of the mark, again, with one exception. So what did the what did this DC Circuit Court get right? The only thing we got right was in rejecting the district courts but for testing. And Circuit Court was completely correct in observing that such a test is not appropriate for an attorney client privilege analysis. And the court was also right that there's no Supreme Court or court of appeals decision that is adopted a test of this kind in this context. But that is all it says that is all the DC Circuit.
45:42Right? What did the DC Circuit miss? Not much, only that one, it did not understand the basic and fundamental precepts underlying the attorney client privilege did misapplied of John. They confuse the attorney client privilege with the attorney work product doctrine. It did not understand lawyers, ethics duties in the circumstances, and it flouted the law. These are the interlocutory appeals. Those are great insubstantial mistakes. So first, it's axiomatic that client communications with non lawyers, especially non lawyers, not acting under the specific guidance of lawyers pursuant to rule 26 p three of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Those communications are not confidential, privileged and protected from discovery that is just axiomatic. Thus, when the DC Circuit wrote that the case before it was, quote, materially indistinguishable close quote from Upjohn, it was simply wrong. In the court's own words, quote, in Upjohn, the communications were made by the company employees, the company attorneys, during an attorney led internal investigation, close quote. Well, that's true. That's not the situation in the case before the DC Circuit, communication made with company employees, by non attorneys. So tell them out of invoking the policy can change the structural factual problem as compliance personnel and internal auditors are regularly told, even those who are licensed lawyers, this privilege does not apply to them or their communication period.
47:27And by its frequent, you can always tell in a judicial opinion, when you see a lot of CF citations, something something not so good is going on. And there are a lot of CF citations, particularly the seminal case IpMan versus Taylor, which is the Seminole Supreme Court decision underpinning the attorney work product doctrine and Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 26 V three. By frequently invoking I kicked in V. Taylor with CSI motions, it's quite apparent that the DC Circuit was confusing the attorney client privilege with the attorney work product doctrine. If in fact, the defense contractors legal department had established the internal investigation in anticipation of litigation, and had specifically designated non lawyer personnel as agents to assist the lawyers in the investigation, then the work product would have been protected, not under the privilege, but under the work product doctrine. It's indisputable however, that is not what happened in the case. And remember, the work product decision by the DC Circuit was not on appeal before the DC Circuit Court of Appeals. With respect to the failure to inform employees that the interviews were of a legal nature, circuit courts, ethical antennae were clearly turned off. The court was simply wrong and stating, quote, nothing in Upjohn requires a company to use magic words to its employees in order to gain the benefit of the privilege for an internal invasion investigation. Here as an Upjohn, employees knew the company's legal department was conducting an investigation of a
49:19sensitive nature, and the evidence they disclosed would be protected, close quote. But unlikely, not John K. KB ours, employees certainly did not not know the legal department's role or involvement. And as for the interviewees confidentiality expectations, how could or would they have had any informed view on that subject? lawyers were not conducting the interviews, and thus we're not giving the employees the magic words required by the canons of ethics. ie the corporate Miranda warning that I went over For under Rule 1.13, warning them that in fact the information they're posing might well not be confidential or protected. Compliance officials or audit officials have no ethical duty to make such warning. That's our obligation. So these people had no, there were no magic words involved here. So again, further evidencing this misunderstanding when people talking about Upjohn warnings, they don't arise from the Upjohn decision for the antithesis of the John decision, where everyone's protected by the attorney client privilege that's owned by the corporation. When you give this warning, you're telling them that's true, but company may at some point, waive the privilege as to what you're telling them. You're the individual. As if that were not bad enough. The circuit court then correctly cited two binding Supreme Court precedent, which I cited you before that an interlocutory appeal is not available in attorney client privilege cases. They cited those two binding cases. And it also properly noted that taking a contempt
51:18citation is the only appropriate means to get an interlocutory appeal. Nonetheless, leaving long leave it had had to step in because the DC circuit's lower court's decision had the potential to work a quote sea change in the well settled rules governing and controlling corporate investigations. The court convinced itself that there's going flat out long against binding Supreme Court decision was necessary and appropriate under the circumstances. Well, that's a lot to get wrong. Little did I think that the DC Circuit would compound those errors in the same case, just 14 months later. On August 11 2018, the same appellate court will be a different panel. Click on a later facet and KBR Sega, and this time drove the car into a different ditch on a second writ of mandamus from an adverse ruling from the district court, the defense contract contractor was again able to get the higher court to block discovery into obviously damaging materials relating to alleged wrongdoing. On February 2014, one one month at the original district court decision and five months before the first opinion of the DC Circuit, defense contractor had put forward for a rule 30 B six deposition, a lawyer in its internal legal department.
52:53Among the topics the internal lawyer was to testify about as a corporate officer on behalf of the company. For rule 3636 was, quote, any investigation or inquiry, internal or external formal, informed of the KBR employee and subcontractor at the center of the alleged fraud, or any of the matters identified in the above listed topics. The scope shall include knowledge of everyone who participated in investigation, close quote, and is a deposition that KPR internal lawyer acknowledged that in preparation for his testimony, he had reviewed the documents prepared by the KBR non lawyers in their investigation, which were the subject of both appeals in the DC Circuit. Notwithstanding that preparation, incredibly, there are material differences between the lawyers testimony and the contents of those investigatory materials for the hard to believe. Five days thereafter, KBR moved for summary judgment, and in its motion in a footnote JPR put forward the following piece of the advocacy. Quoting KBR has an internal Code of Business Conduct investigatory mechanism that provides a means of identifying any potential illegal activities within the company.
54:17When a code investigation reveals reasonable grounds to believe that a violation of the anti kickback Act may have occurred, requiring disclosure to the government, KBR makes such disclosures. KBR has made reports to the government when it had reasonable grounds to believe that the violation of the anti kickback Act had occurred. KBR intends for these investigations to be protected by the attorney client privilege and attorney work product privilege. Indeed, they're not even given to the government as part of disclosures, but as not asserted privilege over the fact that such investigations occurred, or the fact that whether Kvr made a display issue the government based on investigation. Therefore, with respect to the allegations raised by the plaintiff, KBR represents that it did perform a code invest, did perform code investigations relating to the Kvr subcontractor and the employee at the center of the fraud alleged by the plaintiff, and made no reports to the government following those investigations. Close quote.
55:29This motion practice led to two decisions by the District Court. On November 20 2014, the court ruled that there was an implied waiver of the attorney client privilege and work product doctrine, because Kbra puts the Imperials issue. But KBR has actively sought a positive inference in his favor based upon what a Kvr names document show. In other words, what about the court? KBR carefully use the inference to decode documents do not support any reasonable belief that fraud or kickbacks may have occurred. KBR has on multiple occasions advanced a chain of reasoning. First, when KBR has a reasonable, reasonable grounds to believe that a kickback of fraud has occurred. It's contracts and federal regulation required to report the possible violation. Second, KBR abides by this obligation and reports possible violations. Third, KBR investigated the alleged kickbacks that are part of the plaintiffs complaint forth after the investigation of the allegations. In this case, KBR made no report to government about an alleged kickback or fraud. Court. The district court also ruled that Federal Rules of Evidence 612 further mandated waiver because the internal KBR lawyer had used the contestant materials to prepare for his deposition.
57:02And the balancing test into that rule, the so called fairness considerations that under advisor will require disclosure, especially given the fact that the lawyer necessarily relied on the documents for his testimony, because he had no personal first hand knowledge of whether the fraud or team facts occurred, and two, major discrepancies exist between the lawyers testimony and the contents of the writing that lawyer had received. On December 17 2014, the district court issued a separate opinion finding the disclosure was justified under a third basis that this disputed materials were discoverable work product, and the plaintiff shows substantial need. Thereafter, almost immediately, KBR sought mandamus to the DC Circuit, which was promptly granted. And what the DC Circuit do this time, again, unfortunately, they got it wrong on a lot of levels. But even before we get to that, the district courts to decisions separate from the basic depths of that helped ensure the appellate court even more off the track. The district court had correctly determined in March 2014 letter the decision that the investigatory materials were not attorney work product investigation was not conducted by lawyers that done it direction of lawyers were not done in anticipation of litigation.
58:32And that lawyer was not that ruling was not appealed to the DC Circuit. That was that's the law the case. But the district courts more recent decision did complete 180 degrees and now labeled materials as work product, notwithstanding they were in the exact same documents, which the court had they were previously we're not worried about it. That's the entire basis for the district court's December 14 substantial league decision was completely wrong. And the November 24. November 2014 waiver decision was also loan six that was equally premised on the privilege and work product. That's that's the DC Circuit District Court. The DC Circuit Court first took on the waiver decision to this district court with respect to the 612 issue. The appellate court determined that as a threshold matter, the district courts use of the balancing test was inappropriate and clear error. And even using the balancing test scales were weighed in indisputably in favor of non disclosure. Both prongs of that decision were unfortunately wrong. For its initial proposition. The DC circuit cited judge Weinstein's famous treatise on Evans, but that that treatise and the rules stand for completely opposite proposition. First off most courts that have looked at the use of written materials to refresh a witness's memory pretty privileged materials have ruled over for likes to believe that the materials are fair game under Rule six. Well, second, the leading case on this ordered did not dispositive not helpful and did not help. The circuit's opinion. That's assuming that
1:00:18circuits sport versus appeal. Third is the fact that Judge Weinstein is himself a major proponent of the balancing test. Thus, the DC circuit's out of hand disposal that's useful citing was quite bizarre. Furthermore, Judge Weinstein is also on record as urging lawyers not to show witnesses privileged materials or work product because of this concern under 612. Finally, the DC Circuit zones sort of APT on sort of application of the balancing test was wrong. Did the writing influence that? witness's testimony judge Weinstein's death? The answer is obviously yes. Unless one use of the word use takes the word view that Dr. Lloyd inconsistent testimony meant encompassed by the writing. That was not even the rationale offered by the DC Circuit in support of its no answer. Instead, the appellate courts take was at the case that KBR having chosen the in house lawyer to be the 36th witness on the steak in and of itself, the lawyer had no choice but to review the investigatory materials, then resolve the matter by labeling the plaintiffs material on waiver as absurd. As such, the court did not even have to confront the influence issue, or just the fact that all of this could have been avoided by Kba, putting up corporate first hand knowledge and investigation in the first place, as opposed to the lawyer. Having neatly disposed of the 612 issue that DC circuit then moved on to the issue waiver, the rising from the fact that KBR had argued in his summary judgment papers. Remember the footnote that they put in there? The first glance wrote the board
1:02:00for this appeared to present a quote more difficult question, let's quote that the appellate court was undeterred, finding the seemingly obvious influenced by the district court, ie JPR is contending that they'll always self report to the government when they're dealing with illegality, that it did not do that here. Thus, there must not be any evidence, evidence, privilege or otherwise that occasion any illegality, that's not good in the DC Circuit. That's not what the JBR meant at all. Instead, DC circuit says we have an alternative inference. The KBR was really confessing, quote, that the investigation showed wrongdoing, but the Kvr nonetheless made no report to the government.
1:02:41In my, in my margin notes, the court's opinion on this point, I wrote palm with question mark in about 17 exclamation points, because that obviously makes absolutely no sense. The appellate court then tried to support its alternative inference, aka alternative universe by further noting the Kvr and tried this advocacy for only in a footnote, and that in any event, all inferences should have been drawn against KBR And in summary judgment motion, and a district court should have adopted the appellate court's alternative inference. Course such reasoning and analysis are bizarre. Then the DC Circuit was not completed yet said let's look at the substantial need decision by the lower court. Incredibly and notwithstanding discussion above on that subject. The appellate court determined that the lower courts 180 degree turn on work product was correct. We think the district court got the law right. But then will the lower court misapplied the law the documents that are disclosed to support those Miss judgments? The DC circuit made numerous additional errors. First of all, it continued is blurring of the lines between attorney client privilege and work product.
1:04:00Missing cited and misapplied the so called Cobell exception, as well as what's called the DC Circuit. So the Delta street rule of ethics. As a final matter that the DC Circuit then faulted the lower court's failure to delineate between opinion work product and work backward product, and thus still justified not even reaching the question of whether the lower court had determined that erred in its determination of substantial deem that the disputed materials were neither opinion work product nor work product was of no importance. So this is a incredibly sorry history by the two panels of one of the most important ports in America. And if you want further clarity on this, you can see an article I've written in the New York Business Law Journal of winter of 2015 DC should fit Long and longer. But it really highlights that these issues are very. They seem pretty simple to me. But companies that various examples I've given you today, often get these wrong. And incredibly, courts often get them wrong. Sometimes they get them wrong to your detriment, incredibly KBR, they got them wrong to save, save the company from disclosure, when there should have been complete disclosure of these materials. So getting these issues right, to protect these materials can be really important if you handle these things wrong. Remember, under most circumstances, there is no interlocutory appeal, unless you could take a contempt citation. So unlike the KBR examples, and unlike some of these other cases, where the courts improvidently, granted, writs of
1:05:54mandamus, you're stuck with what the court has ruled that the district court will be very, very careful in in handling these matters. Try to do them on the ways that we've discussed today. Not not the way KV certainly not the way KBR has handled them. And I will stop there. Thank you for your attention. And I hope this has been helpful.
Alexander C.NY
This is an excellent course. There was lots of useful information. Thank you very much