Danielle F.NY
Honestly one of the best CLE classes that I have watched in a while! Excellent speaker. Content was extremely relevant to my practice. Thanks!
2h 3min · about 9,700 wordsDownload Transcript
0:00Hello out there. whatever time of day, it may be for you. It's hot here. This is Bob Fitzpatrick. And today we're going to talk about non competes. And let me say at the outset that the issue, surprisingly, I think too many of us, as bubbled up to the federal level. And we'll discuss near the back end of this presentation, what what's going on, particularly, under this Biden administration, and most particularly, a little bit about what's happening at the Federal Trade Commission. For you employment lawyers out there, who traditionally have been either prosecuting or defending these non compete cases, typically in state court or in diversity and federal court, you now need to take into consideration some of the developments that are taking place at the federal level, and we'll get to that. And particularly if you represent medical groups, you need to be very aware of what is going on most particularly at the FTC Yes, but also at the Department of Justice DOJ, in the antitrust division, and watching what the so called no poach lawyers in the antitrust division are now doing with medical group, non competes or no poach agreements. But first and foremost, because still, most of these controversies regarding non competes are battles in state court, and very few of them so far, are at the federal level. I'm going to try to issue spot for you all, in terms of non compete controversies at the state level. And then, at the tail end of the program, we'll discuss quickly some of the state statutory developments and spent a lot
2:54of activity at the state legislative level and more to come in the current 2023. And going forward legislative years. This is not only in terms of the common law on noncompetes is very much a local state matter, and sometimes is very much what's the thinking of your judge, what's the disposition of your judge? So you need to be familiar with your state law. And increasingly, you need to be familiar with changes, revisions that either have taken place are about to take effect, or maybe passed by your state legislature. The uniform state law commissioners have waded into the fray, if you will. And they have issued a proposed uniform state law on so called Low wage employees, as you know, and many so called I don't like the terminology, but everybody uses that. In the so called blue states, the Democratic states. There's been a lot of activity over the last few years in the legislatures in terms of low wage worker non compete legislation. And the uniform state law commissioners not only weighed in on that issue, but also waited in on what had I think originally been limited to Aragon. It has now On and enacted by a number of states and that is a requirement that some form of notice be given during the recruitment process to let prospective employees know that they will be expected to sign a non compete agreement. Okay, that's kind of the scope of what I'm gonna try to cover here. In the time that we have. And the written materials that you get, they'll probably be a fairly fulsome biography of may suffice it to
5:46say that I've been practicing employment law, non compete non solicit trade secret, defend, Trade Secret Act, and now FTC cases for decades, if you will. So, I hope I'm in my wheelhouse, I hope I will be of help and assistance to you all during this program. If you want to contact me by the after the program, contact me online by email at our Fitzpatrick at Robert B. Fitzpatrick. Don't forget to be here, you won't get to me Robert V. fitzpatrick.com. I welcome your comments, your curse isms, suggestions on how we might improve this program or mistakes. misstatements Scott I've made. And that says good enough a segue into a quick, simple recap of the there ought to be a written disclaimer of any derivative responsibility in your written materials. Suffice it to say, I like all of us make mistakes. I like all of us and not 100% up to date, on everything non compete wise, taking place in every one of the 50 states much less the legislature's mad even at their FTC. So I may make mistakes, I may make misstatements I may even give you some bomber advice. If you rely upon my statements, my misstatements, my bum advice, whatever it may be, it's on you, not on me, I have no responsibility whatsoever. You need if you say to yourself, hey, that's a brilliant idea that Fitzpatrick just suggested, you need to run it to ground at your state level, and you may even need to run it to ground with your particular state or local judge. Okay. With that long intro, let's do some issue spotting. And then the first problem that looms in these non compete
8:51cases is my client can't find the damn document. And don't laugh. This happens with great frequency that the document as signed by both parties cannot be found is an unsigned agreement enforceable and typically, like any contract to any agreement, there will be signature lines. There will be excuse me, there will be execution lines on the template on the proposed agreement. And if you don't have a copy with signatures there, you may have a problem.
9:58One of the written materials that you will receive, discusses that issue with respect to a Louisiana case, Louisiana being one of those jurisdictions that is not friendly to non competes. So in the onboarding process for you management lawyers out there, and the onboarding process, you need to be sure that your clients are getting signed agreements, your clients are co signing or already have signed it in advance. And that a fully executed copy is being retained safely, somewhere, presumably, and HR, so that if a controversy arises in the future, and you get contacted, your client can quickly access a fully executed copy. And even if it doesn't go to litigation, many of these cases don't, the non compete agreement ought to and will almost 100% Certainty gets sent to the departing employee to remind that individual of his or her responsibilities under the non compete agreement. And it may be in terms of a severance agreement, you need to be very careful in the language in your severance agreement. That says typically near the end, there are no other agreements. This is it. This is the only agreement that potentially in the hands of some judges who could say, well, in the severance agreement, you'd say this is the only agreement. So even though you have a fully executed non compete, it's not enforceable because you in effect, voided it in your severance agreement. So you need to be very careful in constructing your severance agreements with respect to that particular clause, so that it doesn't come back to bite you.
12:45Excuse me, there'll be times during the program when I hesitate to look at my notes to just make sure that I'm staying on track here. What if this is second in issues spotting? What to have? This is a no cause termination. And what if this is not only a no cause termination? But it doesn't smell right. It doesn't look right. It doesn't feel right. It feels like the person's been if you will, shafted by the employer. And now the employer is saying, No, I let you go, I didn't need you. You're not important enough to us to retain you. It's not important enough to have just cause good cause to terminate you. But nonetheless, you're important enough that we're going to seek to enforce the non compete agreement that you signed during the onboarding process. And there are some states and some judges that will take into account the circumstance of Yeah, if it's a good cause termination, then there shouldn't be pregnant. That shouldn't be a problem in terms of the enforceability beat. There may be other issues, but at least that's not an issue. But for many judges in a number of states, if you've got a no cause termination, and particularly as I put it, it just doesn't smell right If it doesn't sit well with the judge, then the non compete may not be enforceable. And you need to keep your eye out for that potential problem, certainly need to make your client aware that it depending upon your jurisdiction, it might be better to have documented good cause for the termination so that that's not an issue in terms of the enforceability of your non
15:43compete. What if after onboarding and after the execution of the non compete, there are, quote, material changes in the circumstance of that employee's job. The person is demoted, the person is promoted. There are material changes. Does that affect enforceability? And Massachusetts is so far the New Hampshire is blast hide check. I think I'm right. It hasn't enacted it. And there's substantial opposition in the New Hampshire legislature, New Hampshire is considering what maths Associates has done. New Hampshire being doing it potentially by statute, maths has done it by its interpretation of its common law. And it has determined in some cases, that the change is material, and therefore the non compete is not enforceable. There is certainly I think, is correct to say, the advice in maths is that you put a clause in your non compete agreement that says it is enforceable change or no change. And you might want to spell out some of the change compensation, compensation, changed duties and responsibilities so on and have a clause in the agreement that says despite those changes, they that this agreement is enforceable, that may give you a leg up to get around the difficulty that many have in maths with material changes. The language that I've seen, that suggested the parties here to understand this agreement shall remain in effect, notwithstanding any job changes or job assignments by the employee within blah, blah company or its organization will language like that in mass and if it
18:38happens in New Hampshire, it seems increasingly unlikely it will, but this material change doctrine may spread to other states certainly in mass, you ought to have some sort of disclaimer Kotori language like what I just read to you. An issue obviously, that comes up over and over in these non compete cases is the the adequacy of the consideration being given by the employer, many states a hold that employment is the consideration that you in the onboarding process signed is non compete. In the consideration we are giving you is that we are employing you that consideration also maybe that we are allowing you to see and work with cars confidential, proprietary trade secrets materials. If the individual is let go very shortly after entering into, excuse me, the non compete agreement, there may be an issue regarding the adequacy of the consideration. This issue has arisen in a number of states you'll see in the written materials. Vermont, Minnesota, you need to run this to ground in whatever state you're dealing with. What if the individual doesn't sign the agreement during the onboarding process, but signs it either before or after? Commencement of employment? You'll see in the written materials, there is case law that saying I think this I have a question, the correctness of the holding, but there is case law that says if you signed it before your employment started, then there's an adequacy of consideration issue, you were not yet an employee. Also, if you sign it, particularly substantially after employment begins, there
22:01may be issues regarding adequacy of consideration. And the written materials discuss some of the case law on this. As you know, and I think this increasingly will be the case in non compete litigation as this has seen become a bit of a political football, if you will. This is a big issue on the political divide, if you will.
22:47And the issue that comes up in almost every case, is there a protectable legitimate employer business interest being if you will, protected by the non compete agreement. And there may be instances where you're caught clients simply cannot articulate a legitimate business interest, particularly in those states that are not friendly to non competes. If it is ancillary, to the sale of a business, rather than what we see typically being contained in the onboarding stack of documents that the new employee is expected to sign, then a non compete that his if you will, ancillary to the sale of a business seems to me is is less heavily scrutinized. Less disfavored, if you will by the courts, and may not be subject to quite the same stringent legitimate business interests. And I think that basically has to do with bargaining power employer employee where it's just in the onboarding process. I think many judges view that as there being unequal bargaining power, whereas in this say A lot of business. The bargaining power is more equal
25:16excuse me, if they non compete in terms of legitimate business interests, attempts to carve out to an excessively large geographic area. There will potentially be legitimate business interest concerns. I'm jumping a little ahead of myself here. But you in drafting these agreements, I guess, two suggestions. One, a general suggestion. And that is, I would not just take something off the shelf that may have worked a year ago may have worked with another employer. I think every one of these needs to be particularized, individualized to your employers situation, there may be circumstances where it makes all the sense in the world for the noncompete to be planet wide worldwide. And then there may be circumstances where it makes no sense whatsoever, and is going to get knocked out as not being enforceable. And then the second thing is watch out for the phrase in any capacity. I call this the janitor rule. The non compete says you can't work for a competitor defined or not defined, and hopefully we'll get to that in any capacity. That means to one court said that you can't work as a janitor. You can't work in Zimbabwe. And those courts, particularly those that are unfriendly to non compete, seized on that in any capacity language. To say the agreement is not enforceable, we'll get to Blue penciling red penciling in a while which may be depending upon your jurisdiction will address the problem.
28:15Virginia for example, which is not a blue pencilling state has consistently knocked out the in any capacity agreements okay
28:41excuse me just skipping over some material to cover Okay. Your client says
29:03I have a legitimate business interest in keeping that particular employee on on the shelf off the market in non competitive circumstance for 12 months, for a year. Okay, sounds okay. Both states would enforce a one year non compete. And that comes out in the discovery process in the case that your client maybe unbeknownst to you, has done deals with other employees where they they've reduced the one year to five months what say
29:59say In Job, same employer, not 12 months for this person, we negotiated it down to five months, your court where you're seeking to enforce your 12 month agreement saying you've named this may look at how others were treated, and may look at the circumstance where hey, now I person got it negotiated five, five months deal. I don't think you have met your burden, to show me that you have a legitimate interest in a 12 month prohibition. In the written materials. I'm just gonna say this over and over probably just assume, pretty much everything I have discussed, is also covered to some extent, not necessarily every single case from every court in the country, as of yesterday, okay.
31:12So you need as I've said repeatedly, to go to ground in your own jurisdiction on these issues, I'm just trying to issue spot for you all. geographic scope, is big deal, as we've discussed, and the what I will describe as shelf life and the shelf life the person's ability to effectively compete against you the shelf life of the skills, the shelf life of the knowledge that has been imparted to your departing employee may be a significant factor in terms of how long a court is going to allow an individual to be no pun intended, put on the shelf put on the bench, not allowed to be non in a competitive situation to it. It's been a lot of non compete litigation in the Northern District of Illinois, you know, which encompasses Chicago and other parts of State and the Seventh Circuit and this shelf life issue. This competitive edge AI issue has been addressed by courts there, okay.
33:24What if your departing employee is caught red handed. And let's say here, she has a one year non compete. And a couple of months, a couple of weeks, couple of days in a row, your client discovers that the departed employee is engaging in competitive activity in violation of the agreement. And your client takes quick action with respect to that delay. may come back to bite you on this bun tags quick action, and after a year. But now, the one year period has passed. And a year later, a judge concludes Yes. That individual was in violation of the One Year non compete and the proof that was put The front of the court was that a day and a weekend, a month, whatever, very soon after the individual departed, maybe immediately they began competitive activity and violation of the agreement. The issue then is what what what's the scope of relief that you can obtain? Can you get, let's say, three months into the one year you filed suit, can you get nine more months of an injunction that prohibits the employee from for the now nine months going way beyond the one year period, but for that nine month period can be prohibited from engaging and competitive activity. In other words, here or she violated the agreement, week after week, month after month while his case was being litigated. And then the non compete ran out, cannot be effectively extended by the court for the period of violation. And those cases that address that issue, are some of them at least are discussed in the written materials. Certainly, you should give some thought to
36:55having in your non compete agreement, a clause that empowers the court to in effect extend the non compete period, if there is a proven violation of the agreement. That certainly a clause like that would give you a leg up in terms of enforcement of it. I talked about the janitor role and the NA capacity language, also words to be careful about and that some courts have found I've seized upon of us to deny enforcement have met with disfavor are the indirect and similar? Okay. And you see in many of these agreements, is shall not compete against XYZ company directly or indirectly. Okay. I always ask myself, at least, what the heck does indirectly mean? I'll know. I think it is ambiguous. And therefore, I can't properly advise you on firing advising a departing employee? How the heck do I tell an employee what might constitute indirect competition against his or her prior employer? I think that's a tough advice situation for me. And hence, may lead to enforcement problems for management. You'll also see in many of these non compete agreements, you may not compete against XYZ company in blah, blah, industry, or similar enterprises. What to similar enterprise same problem with direct indirect language, and that may create enforcement problems for your client if you're representing man Richmont
40:05can a non compete, be forced as a violation against an individual who may be competing against you, but is not hired by a subsequent employer as an employee, but is legitimately an independent contractor. And suffice it to say, that could be a potential problem. You know, contract is words. And we are wordsmiths when it comes particularly to these types of agreements. And if it just talks about competing and employment status and doesn't address the independent contractors, situation, maybe you got a problem, medical practice, huge area of I think, Ken, your written materials, you'll get one of my papers on the enforceability of medical professionals non compete agreements, a lot of litigation and almost probably every jurisdiction on this issue. Excuse me.
42:03If you are representing the physician who has left the practice and you I think the first issues fact issues that you need to discuss with your client is what's the geographic scope to hear? Yeah, it'll be you know, you cannot practice. Another medical group within X number of miles of your employer. The questions you want to focus on, I think, in that initial discussion with your FAS physician client is what type of medicine dental care do you practice and if it is a particularly a very niche, discreet group, and there are a few if any other doctors within that, let's say 25 mile radius, then you may have a very strong public interest argument to knock out the non compete. And I've seen even dental groups. Now it is the dentists just don't practice dentistry anymore. There are now and maybe have been for a long time as far as I know. Some specialties in dental practice, just like there are many, many sub specialties and medical practice. You need to zone in on that and determine whether you've got a public interest argument. The American Medical Association has been pretty dramatic on this issue, and has said that such a non compete agreements in medical groups can be unethical if excessive in scope So they jumping ahead for a moment. The AMA American Medical Association also has gone to the FTC on that non compete group. And my understanding is they basically asked the FTC not to take right yellow Tory action. That's my understanding of the have anaise position with the Federal Trade Commission.
45:46Oh, ah, online broadcasting industry. And this is, I think, a product of lobbying that started many, many years ago. And a number of states quite some time back, I believe, passed legislation prohibiting non compete agreements in the online broadcasting industry, Arizona, Illinois, Massachusetts, Maine, are just some of the jurisdictions that have enacted such laws. In our industry, US lawyers, they partnership agreement may say, you know, you, you can leave anytime you want to, but you can't take clients with you, you can't compete against us. I think I'm probably correct in saying ethically, every state ethics committee a non compete in that, you know, such a crude if you will, non compete in the legal industry is not enforceable, where the rubber meets the road and where there is some disagreement is what if there is a financial penalty, the departing legal partner forfeits certain compensation of if he or she began there takes clients competes against the firm DC I think I'm correct, has held in most circumstances not enforceable, but that's an issue. A controversial issue in some jurisdictions, once again, the written materials address that. A bit of an esoteric issue, I guess, if you jumped the gun, so to speak too quickly, and seek to enjoin seek action against someone who is preparing to compete, but is not yet competing against your client preparing to compete is that's okay. That's not a violation of the non compete agreement. It may be a shot across the bow from the employer to the employee,
49:34but it may not constitute a violation of the non compete. Okay, blue penciling and I think we can break this down in two separate parts if you will. There are Some jurisdictions, and I call them freedom of contract jurisdictions that simply will not. If your oil blue pencil, a single solitary word comma semicolon, what have you in an agreement? If the agreement as written is unenforceable even know with blue pencilling, one could take out the offensive clause. There are a few jurisdictions. And I believe I'm correct Wyoming, as either enacted or is considering enacting legislation that by statute would prohibit blue penciling period. So there are those jurisdictions, either by statute, or by common law, that are what I call freedom of contract states that just say you live or die with whatever agreement you wrote, I'm not a Scrivener. I'm not here to rewrite your agreement, then there are those jurisdictions, that blue pencil to some extent, and that is, if I can. Extract excuse me a phrase, or let's just say an example, in any capacity. And if by taking those three words out, I make what was otherwise unenforceable, a perfectly enforceable agreement. And those states that approve of such blue penciling, would take that in any capacity, take that offending language out to make an uninformed and otherwise unenforceable agreement enforceable, then there is the circumstance where the court to make it an enforceable agreement has to do more than just take the offending phrase out. The court actually has to, to some extent,
53:16rewrite the agreement. Maryland, for example, has said we won't permit blue penciling, where there will be supplementation or rearrangement of the language of the agreement. Those courts that permit this are to those freedom of contract cases they are the antithesis of freedom of contract situation. The judge is writing a new agreement for the parties. There are a few situations a few circumstances out there where that is permitted. But those are few and far between. It seems to me the real issue is can you know are you in a blue pencil jurisdiction or not to start with some courts just won't permit bloom penciling under any circumstance. But that if you're Antoine is can you make enforceable by taking the language out Virginia being a perfect example of a no blue penciling The State long, long history of declining to enforce blue penciling, even if and there may be exceptions. But even if you have a excuse me clause in the non compete that authorizes the court to blue pencil the agreement. Certainly that is an issue to be considered and discussed with your client.
55:47Your client may not want management may not want a blue penciling claws. I think in most circumstances they will.
56:13US assignment much controversy. The majority rule of course, is that restrictive covenants are typically viewed as personal services agreements and are not assignable. But in the sale of a business, they clash question that you need to ask is Is this a stock sale? Or is this an asset sale? If it's a stock sale, then typically there would be no issue in terms of assignability to noncompete can be assigned if it is an asset sale then an assignment is necessary and typically you would need some sort of proof of assent agreement by the so called asked an ad and fully to the agreement.
57:48New York is I think New you unique in that it has the employee choice doctrine. I don't know of any other jurisdictions that do under the employee choice doctrine. If the employee chooses to leave and go into a competitive circumstance, the employee can forfeit otherwise deferred earned compensation and forfeiture will be enforced as you know you employee had a choice as to whether to accept your deferred comp or forfeit same um
59:03one thing to be very careful about and to be on your checklist both sides in terms of enforceability is has there been a prior material breach of the employment agreement?
59:35If the employer has not timely paid employees that may constitute a material breach and if there is a pre material breach, by one One party that then excuses non performance on the part of the non breaching party. In other words, if the employer engages in some sort of activity, that is considered to be a breach and a material breach, then in some jurisdictions, the employee is excused if you're will, from being accused of violating the contract because the contract is otherwise null and void because of the early material breach by the employer. So if you're on the employee side, this is something that you want to watch for. choice of law and choice of form fo r u m. can be a very substantial and important issue. I've just gone through a situation where we had the law of Virginia, New York, California, and Nevada. At least those jurisdictions laws, potentially being involved. And the issue that had to be sorted out is what law of what state applies to particular controversy. And in the situation I'm talking about, without naming names, suffice it to say to actually two jurisdictions applied one on one claim one on another. So the choice of law is, and choice of form a for both sides is a huge issue. If I am representing a company whose headquarters is in Seattle, and I'm dealing with an employee who works, let's say, in the Commonwealth of Virginia, and I have a choice of law that says Washington state, and I have a choice of form that says, state Circuit Court, whatever in Seattle, or if there is jurisdiction, the federal district court in
1:03:25Washington State. And the law of Washington and the law of the Commonwealth of Virginia are in if you will, in conflict. And Virginia is more favorable to my client. Now switching hats, the employee, and the law of Washington is much more favorable to management. It's also home court, it's 3000 Miles journey, etc. That day difference in the substantive law may resolve the dispute and it may be that Virginia wins out. This is a battle that goes on in jurisdiction after jurisdiction. Excuse me, part of this is first to file you know, if you get you the employee, get sued by the employer and a A state or federal court in Washington state and by a hypothetical, then seems to me, the management's got a leg up in terms of, and this is where the agreement said we're supposed to be. And this is a law, which you're familiar with judge that is to be enforced. And then there was a subsequent litigation in Virginia and gets really dicey in terms of, you know, what power visa vie does the court in Washington have visa vie the court in Virginia, etc. There is much litigation around the these choice of law and choice of form, that's a good place to switch. If I can, folks, forgive me, I'm writing my notes here to talk about some of the state statutory changes that have been taking place recently. Illinois, as of early this year, they Illinois Freedom to Work Act, took effect or was amended and now prohibits non competes based upon this is one of these low wage, so called Low wage, jurisdictions, if you make 75,000 or less, and Illinois,
1:07:19then a non compete as of this year, cannot be enforced against you. Excuse me. If you make 45,000 or last in Illinois, a non solicit cannot be enforced against you. We haven't talked about non solicits typically, a non solicit is twofold you may not solicit our employees to leave and go elsewhere. And you may not solicit some set of clients. Typically, clients that you work with are clients of the company for some discreet period of time. They amendment to the Illinois statute also requires that there be consultation with an attorney before entering into such an agreement. And there is a 14 day consideration period Oregon effective this year, amended is noncompete laws to provide that you've got 12 months post termination is the outside limit on a non compete agreement and has so called Low wage provisions. Employees who are classified as non exempt are not you may not enforce against and those who earn $100,533 or less per year. The non compete may not be enforced unless there is an agreement in writing. And as I recall, I think they are I got an agreement each year for the next five years, the dollar amount gets increased. Nevada, in 2021, amended is non compete law to provide that non competes are not enforceable against hourly employees.
1:10:40And we've had huge controversy here in the District of Columbia. We have a probably the broadest, most substantial non compete statute law in the country. Its effective date has been deferred and deferred. I think it's not I know it's on the shelf. Now. I forget what the latest date is. It's changed. There is a lot of pushback from employers in terms of the breadth of the DC non compete, and we'll see how all that shakes out. I think I mentioned earlier that New Hampshire is considering is the legislature is considering adopting the material change doctrine that, to my knowledge is so far limited to Massachusetts, Washington State. Recently, I think the Governor signed it. The silence, no more Act, which prohibits non disclosure clauses and non disparagement clauses in employment agreements. Colorado is criminalizing some non compete violations.
1:12:49This low wage, statutory bands that I mentioned much, much earlier in this discussion. There are such laws in Illinois, Maryland, Maine, mas, a two sets are Oregon, Nevada, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Virginia and Washington state. The Uniform Law Commission, as I mentioned at the outset, in July of 2021, they issued their report and the proposed uniform statute that I discussed that has been adopted in a number of jurisdictions. Why don't we take a five minute break at this point? Welcome back. We took a short break. And I'm now going to turn to some cases that I would hope will illustrate some of the points I've been making. And that at the end of our discussion, are taught talk briefly about the FTC, the Department of Justice, and the Congress of the United States. But let's first jump in to a few cases that I think help illustrate some of the points I tried to make. And the first part of this presentation. We talked about sick gonna choose. And my emphasis was, make sure you have a document that has been signed by at least the employee, hopefully, counters signed by your client, the employer also and of course of your employees Council, this is something you'll want to look for right at the start demanding that the other side produce a signed copy of the agreement. Because it's a real problem. Okay. There is a fairly recent 2022 decision, Barrows versus brankin Retire retirement group out of the Second Circuit. And I'll just say at the outset, kind of seriously question whether
1:16:09this case is correctly decided. And whether even if correctly decided, its resolution is a sensible way that people can really proceed. This deals with electronic signatures. This isn't the future, this is now, okay. Ah, wet signatures, where I sign with a pen is a thing of the past. And here, the company said that it had a uniform policy that required you to, at the restaurant, use your password and access into the computer that was made available to you. And then review these onboarding documents. One of which would have compelled arbitration doesn't make any difference could have been a non compete. Okay. And you then had to input as I recall four chunks of information about yourself, including the last four numbers of your social security number. And then you electronically signed the agreement. And the company sought to enforce that. And the Second Circuit held that the employer had failed to demonstrate sufficiently that the onboarding employee indeed access the document and had electronically signed it.
1:18:53And one of the facts that they took into account which, to me is pretty inconsequential. Is that one other employee, maybe more than one but they only heard one, signed the agreement with a wet signature, did it the traditional way. Therefore, Second Circuit in essence said you didn't have a uniform policy. Why is that fact would bear on the accuracy of their revenue the the evidence showed somebody went into this individual's computer, so use the password. Second Circuit suggested Well, others could have had her pen password. And then somebody also input what I believe was the four chunks of data, including the four last numbers such security. And also so suggesting that it is possible in this scenario, that someone other than Barrows actually electronically accessed and signed the agreement. The suggestion being that it was management that did it, management had access to I believe it was an i nine form, which would have had all of those four chunks of data that I've talked about. So the court said, Didn't sufficiently establish the electronic signature. And we, and I guess it's a recommendation for the future, that you have a uniform policy, but more importantly, that you have a two factor verification. The second factor being and this is what I came Kise somewhat unrealistic. Have the employee after the employee has done going through these steps, and as electronically signed, have the employee verify by an email from the employee's personal email account, that they have electronically signed and agreed to the
1:22:06agreement in hand. Eyes variously question whether that is realistic, is seriously question whether that's necessary. And I seriously question whether based on these facts, these guesses there's no proof that the manager did what is suggested the manager did it seems to me in an adversarial summary judgment type proceeding guessing that someone could have done it just doesn't cut it for me. I would not have moved in the way the court did. But it's there. It's the second circuit I don't know whether it's going to go up on bonk. I don't know whether other courts are going to follow it. But these electronic signatures are something that this is certainly a shot across the bow a warning to advise your clients that like let's get a step ahead of the Second Circuit and let's be able to prove that the person did in the electronically sign seems to be and I'll shut up on this. But it seems to me this is kind of almost antithetical to the whole idea of electronic signature that this notion Okay, now email using non your office email, but your personal I guess you could from your office email, you can access your personal email I guess. But using your personal email confirm that to seems too complex, too convoluted, anti sense circle. And I guess I've gone on and on about I don't like this case, you can tell all right. Being penciling, we talked about that. Wyoming for years and followed the blue pencil in rule. And its pencil case in that regard was a 1993. Excuse me decision Hopper versus all pet American I think is the name of the
1:25:22defendant. Hopper is now over ruled by the Wyoming Supreme Court in Hassler versus Circle C resources. And hear the lower court following Hopper, the 1993 case had written blue pen sold the agreement from 24 months to 12 months and had blue pencil the agreement or maybe gone a step beyond you know, there's this kind of subset, if you will, of bloop penciling, which is reformation, where you're not just bingo. severing a clause from the agreement like you know, taking 24 out and not substituting something here, the lower court substituted 12 months for 24 months and then substituted for a geographic scope. That was, excuse me anywhere. The employer ad marketed its services or was marketing its services. And rewrote that. So this just ain't severing that this is a reformation type deal. rewrote that to explicitly refer to two counties only as the geographic scope that now the 12 to 24 month, non compete and the Wyoming Supreme, then use that as the basis to overrule hopper and reject the blue pencil and roll query in a state like Wyoming, spend some legislative activity out there also Solage state step out of Wyoming and just go to one hypothetical one of the 50 states. Now there's blue penciling, which is severability, and there's reformation seems to me. Hasler was a reformation case, more so than just a blue penciling case. And in maybe that jurisdiction or in some other jurisdiction, there still would be room for severability, but a rejection of reformation.
1:28:44If you're at a state, you got to look at your statute, you got to look at your law. If you're in a state, that's still seems to permit some level of blue penciling, I would put a if I'm management, I will put a severability clause in my agreement that says, you know, the court is authorized to seven. And you know, if you want to go the road of reformation, I think court after court is going to reject reformation, as in essence, delegating to the courts. The role of lawyers in our clients to write agreements, and also allows employers to and this is what really sticks in the craw of a lot of courts on this issue allows employers to write overly broad temporal or geographic Fake scope, knowing that if they get it, you know that that may intimidate a lot of people don't challenge it. And if it does get challenged, well, heck, we got to several more in a severability state. Or maybe we're even in a reformation state. If I'm in a pure reformation state, and there ain't many of them. But if I am, maybe in addition to a severability clause, I want to write in a reformation clause. This is, excuse me, once again, very state specific. You need to be watching your statutes, you need to be watching your legislature what's going on. And you need to know your case law. And, frankly, I think, in many of these cases, you need to know your judges, because a lot of this if there's elbow room, as there is this is really judged to judge. Okay, we talked in the early session about attorney non competes. I just call your attention to 2020
1:31:29opinion from the Ohio Board of Professional Conduct construing it's rule 5.6. And I think in most states 5.6 is the rule in your code of professional responsibility that you want to look at it basically prohibits restricting a lawyer in his or her practice of law. There was a non compete applicable to an in house attorney in this Ohio 2020 matter. So Pinyon 2020 Dash Oh, one. And of course, the Ohio court held that the non compete violated rule 5.6 I think you will probably find that is universal. The real issue, as we discussed earlier is forfeiture of money or clients if you compete against the firm. Okay, we talked at the start, briefly about the shelf, what I will call the shelf life issue. And if you're on the employees side, this is something you should have in your quiver. Something that you should think about long and hard to recent cases on the shelf life issue, CDs holding versus Hedden, which is how the Northern District of Texas A march 2 2021 decision, and then a case out of the Tennessee Court of Appeals, get men associates versus armor a m o u r. It's reported in the IE our publication by BNA.
1:33:51It's probably out there also Lexus or Westlaw, but I only have the eye er sight. The issue here is this. You know, we take we talked a lot about legitimate business interest of the employer. And so the employer says, I have a legitimate business interest. And I taught him or her XYZ, okay. And let's just assume that's a legitimate business interest that justifies some sort of non compete. The issue then, if your employees Council is okay, those skills, how long are they really a threat to the employer? How long are they competitive? What is their shelf life? How long Oh, do they have value to the employee departing employee and competing against the employer? This may require expert testimony. But it's a terrific issue for the employees side, and one not to be ignored. Okay, some venue issues. First of all, many of us think JF the word shall, is in the venue provision, that must be mandatory, not discretionary. A lot of cases out there. Hunt Wesson Wesson foods versus Spence oil, a ninth circuit, pretty old case 1987. But the number of courts have said, depending upon the fact situation, that putting the word shall, in the venue provision doesn't necessarily make it a mandatory and you if you're management, want your venue provision, presumably 99 times out of London, to be mandatory. So the suggestion has been that in your venue clause you put in, you know, is the exclusive venue, it is the sole venue, it's the only place that you can sue and you know, blah, blah, state court, or federal court if there's diversity
1:37:04jurisdiction, still on these forum selection clauses, you're familiar with the Supreme Court's decision in Atlantic marine that basically says, whaling look at the Public Interest considerations. The courts have not yet conclusively dealt with does that, in essence, preempt those state statutes that say, for cars, particularly cars, state statutes that say, construction disputes, cannot have a venue clause in the agreement? Other than the place where the construction is taking place? Does is is are those statutes? The miller Act, also construction related federal statute? Are those statutes, in essence, since preempted, and no longer of force and effect in light of Atlantic Marine, I think that's still an open issue. So if you're in the construction industry, you probably know more than I do about this. But if you're in construction, take a careful look at that issue.
1:38:45There are a number of state statutes California, Washington, Colorado being examples that have passed the state laws that prohibit the use of choice of form venue clauses. Virginia has no such statute. And the audit take a look at he'll be here if I'm pronouncing it right hai lb group of New England versus la page. What page worked exclusively in Massachusetts. But the suit was in Virginia. And the Virginia court
1:39:40upheld it even though there was an argument made that there was a strong Massachusetts public policy that was rejected and if I'm pronouncing correctly they will be case solicitation I got an inquiry. The last time I did a non compete for LexVid. On this subject, I got a nice inquiry from another lawyer saying this is really the courser split, this is a tough issue. And the courts are split and this split as simple terms is, did the employee the departing employee, initiate the contact with the customer? Or did the customer initiate the con contact? And it's not quite that simple, because in a lot of cases, it's very fact specific as to what lead first part of this analysis would be? What led the customer to initiate contact? It could be LinkedIn, it could have been word of mouth. And then what happened when that first contact was made? Was it did the customer contact you and say, I just want to do business with you, your money, you're my person. I'll warn you want nobody else that you know, no initiation of discussion by the departing employee, courts are deeply split on this issue, very fact specific. Just as an example, there are many many cases out there on this issue and just as an example, excuse me as a reason 2022 A Why have I Supreme Court decision, Prudential locations versus gagged on jiejie n o n. And the court held that and a antis Solis solicitation, covenant of restraint requires active initiation of contact, and then remanded the case back for further summary judgment proceedings. So it's fair to say that Hawaii
1:42:51is active initiation state. But as I say, this whole dispute it seems to me is very, very fact specific. If you are advising a departing employee who has an anti solicitation clause, you need to know your once again Your statutes to the center already and your case law and your judges and to walk very carefully and give good advice to your client about initiation of contact Okay. advance notice that the employee will be expected to sign a non compete agreement. This has become the rage in the States. So I think it is smart practice for management to the think the longest. Elon, Illinois and Colorado are 14 days before the person accepts or starts employment. And I find the statutes quite frankly, have been kind of a pain in the backside for management. Okay, that's good. They have to give notice, but it may be inconsequential in most cases, because the employee has already resigned for from their prior employment, and if they've resigned in anticipation, Yeah, boy, it really sounds good that I'm gonna get this job. And they're not in the 1014. Two weeks. One, main is three days. If they're not in that time period, then the employer hasn't violated the advanced notice statute. But the employee is kind of out of luck. Cuz you don't have a job anymore. So if I'm management trying to get ahead of this issue. Yeah, it's a hard road walk. Because you want to don't want to discourage a job applicant. But there may be instances where you want to say, do you still have a job do you still work for ABC Company? If and I emphasize if
1:46:20we make an offer to you understand that one of our onboarding requirements is the execution of our non compete and you're welcome to review it. Okay. Now a lot of people management won't do that because a my state law doesn't require me to do that. And be Yeah, I don't care about that. I want to get up on the high road as high as we can get to defend our non compete and defend how we'll fairway But the second reason that management probably doesn't like the advice I've just given is, am I going to discourage this person from coming to work for us? noncompetes are almost universally these days in many industries comes as no great surprise to my employee clients when they're asked told that they have to sign it a non compete so I'm not so sure that the concern you're gonna scare people away is really that realistic. Okay. When does the non compete gets signed? Okay. As it gets signed, the for the person has actually started employment.
1:48:11And I think that happens with some frequency Rolex company versus tells Dan's tram I take it is Pennsylvania Supreme Court 2020.
1:48:33Excuse me, I'm talking about execution after mixing my cases up so forget about Pennsylvania Supreme Court. I want to talk first about somebody has signed the non compete before their official first day of employment rouses Are you SCS enterprises LLC versus klamp, Fifth Circuit 2020 to a firm as a Louisiana decision that says, not enforceable. You weren't an employee, when you signed the non compete, therefore, the non compete is unenforceable. Our other jurisdictions kind of follow Louisiana. I kind of doubt it. Okay, but it's out there. And, you know, employees Council are gonna use it in other states and other cases. Now. The ROLAGS case that I referred to, is the execution after employment has started and here ROLAGS vs tells Stram Pennsylvania Supreme Court 2020 is execution some two months after employment started once again very very fact specific is was just you know, we talked about the non compete and we forgot to get you to sign it in USA verbally assented to it agreed to it, you know, two months ago bah bah probably not a big deal here. As I recall, in this case, the employee think English was a second language red flag and had been given it and told think about it, take this under consideration and then some months in signs that no consideration given for the non compete and to other non consideration cases.
1:51:45Big case out of Kentucky spring quarter Kentucky employee had been with the company for eight teen years and was told you need to sign the non compete to get the owner's daughter off my back. And so, there was a signature court in Kentucky in the Creech care ch case. Charles T Creech vs. Brown said no consideration continued at will employment was not sufficient. In contrast, Colorado's supreme in loops. Concrete versus Horner. held that continued at will employment was sufficient consideration. I just suggest for your reading. Okay. Very complicated case. potentially important case in certain industries, is the second circuit's fairly recent. J L n coutry. And for this yo you tre vs Getman. This is a fashion industry case and goes off on the issue of uniqueness. And I'm really distilling that very complex and important case down by just saying goes off on uniqueness. Okay, in the few minutes we have left here. Let's talk quickly about the FTC. The Federal Trade Commission and particularly on the employees side. For years have done noncompete work. They're kind of the FTC. Hmm, okay. There was a two two Democrat Republicans split. That was just resolved quite recently. There's now a three to the dems, got the FTC. And they seem to be over time ready to use rulemaking in some way to prohibit non co competes. It appears that that is in the works, it appears that the Democratic majority wants to move in that direction. Needless to say, this is going to result in a spate of litigation dealing with the statute and the Administrative Procedure
1:55:31Act. No, I'm not an FTC lawyer, I am learning this stuff just like you all. But is this an unfair and deceptive act and practice? Or is this an unfair methods of competition, which seemed to be the two bases under the Federal Trade Commission wall that you can proceed
1:56:13at don't want to appear to sound more conversant with FTC law than I really am. But you might want to take a look at DC circuit National Petroleum Refiners Association for a two bed second 676, a 1973. Case, which two years later, the Congress adds to Section seven teen the substantive provisions, the argument now being the National Petroleum refiners, which permitted substantive and just not just procedural provisions under the act. Maybe the act by the Congress two years later, dilutes the significance of National Petroleum. That is a huge issue out there amongst the FTC bar. Then still on the FTC, if you're doing mergers and acquisitions, you need to watch the non competes, that one typically has in a sale of business. And take a look at the recent settlement. I think it was five zip all five commissioners at the FTC were on board with his his the a CRO a K aro deal. Take a look at that, and start to learn your FTC law, have your employees side on employees side.
1:58:37It's a lever to use in negotiations. And it may be a place to file a complaint if you have no other recourse. But certainly the threat of bubbling it up to the FTC, I think is increasingly going to have leverage in settlement negotiations over non competes as is what I'll just call and it's now become very complicated. No poach agreements. The Department of Justice has become fairly aggressive on no punches. Take a look at their statement of interest. It's really not an amicus brief they call it a statement of interest in Bakke vs. Picard Medical Group have filed in a state court I think in Nevada as Ira Call, take a peek at that title to show you. And in your written materials, you'll have my no poach PowerPoint, which has many of the cases many of them. In Washington State, the Attorney General of Washington has been very aggressive on this issue. But, again, that may be if you can talk the talk, no poach agreements, and look for them in your conversations with clients. They were. And hopefully it's past tense, very common in many, many industries. And the DOJ seems to be focused on medical groups. Lastly, we'll close with this. There are a spate of proposed federal laws though Workforce Mobility Act, the freedom of freedom to compete act, and I'm sure others that have been working their way through the House or the Senate. Realistically, I don't think any federal legislation is going to go any place anytime soon. I think the action at the federal level is that the FTC and the antitrust division of the United States
2:01:58Department of Justice. Well, I hope this has been helpful. As I said at the start, please feel free to email me at our Fitzpatrick at Robert D. fitzpatrick.com. Are Fitzpatrick at Robert P. fitzpatrick.com. I hope I've been of some little help to you all today. Thank you, and have a wonderful day. Take care. Bye bye.
Danielle F.NY
Honestly one of the best CLE classes that I have watched in a while! Excellent speaker. Content was extremely relevant to my practice. Thanks!
Philip S.MN
Very good course.
Carol M.PA
Excellent presentation of a complex subject. Thanks!